🎬 TV RELOAD: YOU CAN SEE EVERYTHING - THE DOCUMENTARY THAT WILL MAKE YOU QUESTION EVERYTHING! What happens when a documentary becomes just as disturbing, unpredictable and manipulative as the person at the centre of it? This week on TV Reload, Benjamin Norris and film expert Brose Avard dive into You Can See Everything, a fascinating and deeply unsettling exploration of disgraced Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes. With extraordinary access to Holmes and her family in the weeks before she enters prison, filmmakers Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim set out to tell the story of one of the most notorious figures in modern business history. But what unfolds is anything but a conventional documentary. Featuring Amanda Seyfried in multiple versions of Elizabeth Holmes and Christopher Abbott as her partner Billy Evans, the film blurs the boundaries between truth, fiction and performance in ways that will leave audiences questioning everything they see. 🎙️ In this episode, Benjamin and Brose unpack: The extraordinary access granted to the filmmakers and how it changes the story. Nathan Fielder's unconventional approach to storytelling and manipulation. Amanda Seyfried's fascinating performance and the film's unusual use of reenactments. The uncomfortable relationship between documentary filmmakers and their subjects. The biggest twists, unanswered questions and moments that demand a second viewing. Is this a documentary exposing manipulation, or are we, the audience, being manipulated too? It's a film that challenges everything we think we know about truth, celebrity, storytelling and the power of perception. 🎧 Join Benjamin Norris and Brose Avard for a provocative, entertaining and thought-provoking episode of TV Reload, where the biggest question isn't what you're watching, but whether you can believe any of it. TV Reload - going behind the scenes of the biggest films and television shows.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1It's in the news today, but it was actually on TV Reload, the podcast, last week. Goodbye.
Speaker 2G'day, guys.
Speaker 1Welcome back to TV Reload, the podcast where we go behind the scenes of the biggest films and television shows. And I'm Benjamin Norris, and joining me, as always, is my favourite film expert, Brozavard, who can see everything.
Speaker 3I can see everything. I can hear everything. Unless I forget my glasses and I've still got my earbuds in, and then I can hear and see nothing.
Speaker 1It's like, put a bucket over your head. Ambrose, this week we're talking about a film that I think is going to leave audiences with more questions than answers, which isn't really how I felt I was going to feel.
Speaker 3Yeah, I thought there was going to be some questions answered here, didn't we?
Speaker 1Exactly. Well, they told us that we could see everything. Anyway, the film is called You Can See Everything, and at the center of this extraordinary documentary is Elizabeth Holmes, the disgraced founder of Theranos, whose extraordinary rise and spectacular downfall became one of the biggest corporate scandals in American history.
Speaker 3I'm pretty sure Marvel are going to do a film about Theranos. He's a giant space creature thing.
Speaker 1Yeah, you need to go on a time machine back to that. That was Thanos.
Speaker 3That was Thanos, sorry.
Speaker 1But it did make me think of that though, right?
Speaker 3Yeah, lots of them. She's a bit of a comic book fan maybe.
Speaker 1Any comic book nerd that's out there is definitely going to put those two things together.
Speaker 3I am Theranos.
Speaker 1Are you?
Speaker 3No, none.
Speaker 1I think there's a cream for that. This was a woman who convinced some of the wealthiest and most influential people in the world that she had invented technology capable of revolutionizing blood testing. He became a billionaire who was compared to Steve Jobs and was celebrated as one of Silicon Valley's brightest stars. But the technology didn't live up to the promises. Her company collapsed and Holmes was eventually convicted of fraud. Now, you might think we already know this story. After all, you know, there's books, there's documentaries, podcasts.
Speaker 1Even a brilliant TV series, The Dropout, starring Amanda Seyfried. How do you say Amanda's name, by the way?
Speaker 3Seyfried. Yeah, not Seyfried.
Speaker 1The joke is in the film, right? It is.
Speaker 3She calls you Seyfried. Also, on Wednesdays, we wear pink.
Speaker 1I love that. That's a Mean Girls reference for those people out there. And if you didn't get that reference, then stop listening to our podcast altogether. But this film takes us somewhere completely different, somewhere I didn't think it was going to go. Filmmakers Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim were given the extraordinary access to Elizabeth Holmes and her family in the weeks before she entered prison. And what begins as a documentary about a disgraced businesswoman preparing to lose her freedom becomes something far more complicated. It's a film about manipulation, perception, performance, and whether the camera can
Speaker 1ever really capture the truth. And with Nathan Fielder involved, you can probably imagine that things don't unfold quite the way that you would expect. Bros, this is one of those films where I think the people making the documentary become almost as fascinated as the person they're documenting. So before we get into our review, let's have a look at the story, this extraordinary creative team behind it, and some of the fascinating things that happen during production.
Speaker 2You really feel you did nothing wrong?
Speaker 3I did not.
Speaker 1So where did things get lost?
Speaker 2Like, how are you where you are right now?
Speaker 3I wish I knew.
Speaker 1I don't know. I don't feel like I understand that.
Speaker 2So I know you guys invited me to stay here. Does any part of you worry about me being here 24-7? I don't think so. But what if I see something that makes you look bad?
Speaker 1I think this is the moment in time to capture this story before I'm gone. well bros this certainly is an unusual introduction to a documentary and I think it gives you a pretty good indication of the uncomfortable territory that audiences are headed into what did you think because you had done a lot of research I mean you've seen the TV you'd seen all of those things.
Speaker 3I've done all of them where we We did a podcast. We did the HBO documentary, The Inventor. We did The Dropout as well with Amanda Seyfried. We were all over this. And it was quite a while ago, I think maybe even lockdown, that all that stuff was kind of was, you know, hitting the zeitgeist. So it was interesting to watch this film with some distance between it. But then I did come home straight after the film and watch The Inventor on HBO again. I was just so convinced by Elizabeth Holmes in this documentary. It's like, no, no, I need to look at facts again. And one of the interesting things about this film, and I'm sure you
Speaker 3must have found this as well, this is not a fact-finding mission. This is trying to find out who the person Elizabeth Holmes is. It's really not about whether she's lying or not or whether she's guilty or not. It's more about who the hell is this person.
Speaker 1It's almost an exploitation type of film. Like this is, I mean, maybe that's not the right way to describe it, but I think you said this better before we started talking about this on the podcast where you were talking about what this film is and what it isn't. And it's interesting because it still is the documentary maker's narrative. They have final cut. So they can be incredibly exploitative if they need to be. And they can lead an audience in a completely different direction if they wanted to.
Speaker 3And a lot like Nathan Fielder's work, it goes from, let's find out who Elizabeth Holmes is as a person and why she might have done or not done the things that she's been convicted of, to let's have a look at Elizabeth Holmes and a relationship with Nathan Fielder, who allegedly, according to Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, they weren't going to be in the film, that Elizabeth Holmes drew Nathan into the film as a character. And you can see evidence of that in the documentary. But then once Nathan is allowed in, if that makes sense, once he's allowed to be a subject of the documentary along with
Speaker 3Elizabeth Holmes, he just rides it out. And Nathan Fielder is... Again, incredibly manipulative and hilarious and thoughtful. You can't think any of this happens by accident for Nathan Fielder. He knows what he's doing. I don't know if you've seen the rehearsal or Nathan, for you, some of his earlier work. Brilliant stuff. Absolutely brilliant stuff. But the whole time I'm asking myself, how much of this is set up and how much of it is naturally unfolding and what was intended and so forth. So the same thing for me with this film as well.
Speaker 1It's performative.
Speaker 3Very performative on both sides, Elizabeth Holmes and Nathan Fielder, yeah.
Speaker 1But for different reasons, though. Elizabeth Holmes is being performative because she's still trying to sell that she is innocent.
Speaker 3Innocent, yeah.
Speaker 1Even in the way in which she tries to present her case and try and make it seem as though she is oblivious to everything that's happening. And how is this happening to me? And I had the best intentions.
Speaker 3It's performative.
Speaker 1And then with Nathan Fielder, he's being performative in a way that really, this is not burying the lead with my response to this film, but it did bother me that there was a lot of him making fun of her.
Speaker 3Well, there's the third part of it too, which is harder to see, and I'm sure you're aware of this too, but Elizabeth and Nathan are being performative, but then it's edited in a way so that there are gags and laugh out loud moments. For example, when Nathan's looking a bit like a creep and watching through the window early on, and there's a few of those shots throughout where it's just Nathan watching and looking like a creep, that's edited into the film. That's not by accident. It's not necessarily something that happened organically either. It's something that they saw the shots and they thought, oh, we can edit this into the film. That's part of the construction of this narrative as well, yeah.
Speaker 1And do you think that they meant to include Billy's penis in this movie? I don't... Is that performative?
Speaker 3I don't know. He's not happy with the penis part, apparently.
Speaker 1Is he not?
Speaker 3Yeah, but if I had a dick like that and it was put on... It was a good-sized penis. And he looked fine in the shower naked.
Speaker 1He looked like he wanted us to see it.
Speaker 3And the question's got to be, what did he think the camera operator was doing?
Speaker 1I mean.
Speaker 3Just showing his head. I'm sorry, I mean his other head on his shoulders.
Speaker 1Exactly. I love that you had to remind us of that. But clearly there was a tripod with a camera on it pointed into the shower for him to go. Because I don't know about you, I never lean up against the wall like I'm in gay porn while I'm in the shower. Anyway, let's meet some of the players because I feel like introducing.
Speaker 3We already mentioned names and people need to know who they are.
Speaker 1You have no idea. So you can see everything follows the disgraced Theranos founder, Elizabeth Holmes, during the final weeks before she begins serving her prison sentence. Filmmakers Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim are invited into the private world of Holmes and her partner, Billy Evans.
Speaker 3A.K.A.
Speaker 1The Penis.
Speaker 3Oh, you've got to say that he's a bit of a dick. He's a bit of a dick. A big part of him. A big part of him. A big part of him, yes.
Speaker 1Anyway, with access to their home, I can't believe they got this, but they got access to the family home and the preparations for imprisonment. I mean, he even suggests at one point, Nathan says, you know, do you want me to leave so you can have some creep?
Speaker 3At all times?
Speaker 1At all times, yeah. Well, look, what initially appears to be an intimate portrait of a woman facing the consequences of her actions gradually becomes a much stranger investigation into truth, manipulation, and the power of storytelling. As the filmmakers question Holmes' version of events, the documentary begins examining the relationship between the people controlling the camera and those being filmed. The result is a provocative exploration of how public narratives are created and challenged and sometimes manipulated.
Speaker 3I think one of the things that makes this so unique too, just from listening to your little summary there, camera people, the documentary makers to a level are manipulative, right? In terms of how they pose questions, how they shoot things, but then also how they edit. They have the ultimate control. But what's brilliant about this, and there are other documentaries like it as well, The Kid Stays in the Picture is one that comes to mind. which is a Hollywood film, sorry, a Hollywood documentary. The subjects are as manipulative as the documentary filmmakers. You know, let's not think that Elizabeth and
Speaker 3her partner are being manipulative and the documentary filmmakers are innocent. There's manipulation on both sides, yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah. I mean, there are other types of people that will go and watch a movie and believe what they're seeing. Without a doubt, a percentage of the population who will go along and see this movie and feel like they've been informed. I did not feel like that. I felt horrendous with the laughing at Elizabeth Holmes, even though I always knew she was guilty. I never questioned her innocence or guilt or whatever. I just, it was so uncomfortable to me that it was being made as a joke and that I'm in a cinema eating popcorn and drinking Coke in a world that's quite sinister and I'm laughing
Speaker 1like it's a comedy.
Speaker 3That being said though it is kind of ridiculous if you if you want to put some of the blame on Elizabeth Holmes it is kind of ridiculous that she pleads her innocence and it all comes down to apparently a matter of semantics rather than fact or fiction And she's there, like, saying, oh, yeah, but, you know, maybe they didn't get that in court and, you know, that was all wrong and whatever. The law doesn't come down to semantics. The law comes down to evidence or not evidence. If they can prove it, then you did it. And the burden of proof is quite high. You know, it's up to the prosecutors to prove it for the jury
Speaker 3to convict you. So don't then turn around and go, oh, no, the whole thing was rigged and the whole thing's bullshit. They obviously met the burden of proof. You know, like... You can't argue with that part of it. But then for her to go, it comes down to this word can, which is one of the greatest conversations in the documentary. You know, our machine can do this. And by that word, she means if everything was set up that way and that we had the technology. Spoiler alert, it can't. And you're a liar.
Speaker 1Like, you're stupid.
Speaker 3And that's why I enjoyed it. I went back and rewatched, I think, 45. 50 Minutes of the Inventor on HBO and it's like, oh yeah, right, she is a complete liar and she's full of shit.
Speaker 1She's full of shit. It's funny that her setup as well for a lot of this is that she wants to tell you and thinks that she's being tricky, like even when she says.
Speaker 3Yeah, she thinks she's being smarter than everyone.
Speaker 1Yeah, she's like, I don't let myself cry because, you know... And you're like, this, what you're doing right now is bad. You are, this is the definition of gaslighting. And I eventually thought about why this film has piqued such an enormous amount of interest in the world, because this is the highest grossing movie at this point out of documentary.
Speaker 3It is a second to, isn't it the highest grossing since Fahrenheit 9-11? Or is it just beaten? I think it just beat it.
Speaker 1Oh, right. Okay. Feel free for people out there to correct me on this, but I do believe today that I read that it's now already superseded that. So, I mean, I went and saw the Michael Moore movies. I saw Supersize Me. I saw a lot of those documentaries that came out in the early 2000s, and they felt uncomfortable to me at the time. This sort of documentary still feels uncomfortable to me. But to get to my point from before, the peak of this popularity is very similar to Married at First Sight.
Speaker 3Oh, yep, yep, yep, yep.
Speaker 1And there are so many things that are so relatable. There's a human element in Married at First Sight that everyone is polarised by, and it is some disgraceful people. They obviously look for disgraceful people to be on that show for us to judge. Yes. I think the potency of this popularity comes from us as an audience judging her and knowing that she's guilty, but being fascinated by the dynamics behind the scenes. Her original dynamics with her first partner and business partner, and then to follow it
Speaker 1up by being then with Billy, who I think is equally and very similarly manipulative of Elizabeth Holmes. Yeah. Yeah, I just think a lot of those dynamics that we're getting to talk about is similar to the way that people love Merritt at first. I don't want to talk about that.
Speaker 3Yeah, and it makes sense. You're right. I think part of the appeal of this is judging her. And it surprised me there. As I said to you earlier, before we hit record, I was in a theater full, at least 70% full. And I was at a 7 p.m. screening last night. So that was the day the film was released. The 6 o'clock and the 6.30 screening had sold out. The 7 o'clock screening wasn't far behind it. And then I imagine the later screenings were probably sold out because that's always that dinner time kind of time that suffers in terms of ticket sales. So people that came after dinner, 8.30, 9 o'clock, 9.30 screenings, I'm sure
Speaker 3were sold out.
Speaker 19.30 screening, the movie would be.
Speaker 3Can you imagine? Yeah, you're leaving, getting back at 1am. But.
Speaker 1Curious, do you know, Bruce, I want to know what your take is on this, but I went and saw it in a cinema that was full of Australian comedians. Like, I'm talking.
Speaker 3Oh, really?
Speaker 1Top-tier comedians. Everyone who is a comedian that had never been on TV or done a comedy circuit was.
Speaker 3Oh, so you went to the token management screening.
Speaker 1I need to know more about the comedy circuit to understand that joke, but I know that Token is the management company that looks after comedians.
Speaker 3A lot of comedians, yeah.
Speaker 1Reese Nicholson.
Speaker 2Oh, nice.
Speaker 1Reese is a good bloke. Yeah, but I was really fascinating to watch those comedians because I also find that comedians don't really laugh at other comedians.
Speaker 3When they do, it can be performative as well.
Speaker 1Yeah, I was watching it and I felt like everything I was watching from, like Mel Bracewell was there, you know, like I was watching all these comedians that I'm so used to seeing on TV, watching this movie, this movie.
Speaker 3They'd all respect Nathan Fielder incredibly as well.
Speaker 1They would love to, because comedians, I'm going to get people cancelling their subscription to this podcast, but comedians love to think that they're smart. They're smart people. Yeah.
Speaker 3And a lot of comedians are quite smart, but they're also lucky they have a job where they can spend 22 hours a day thinking about things and reading and researching things.
Speaker 1Thinking about themselves, yes.
Speaker 3So they do have more time to think about things.
Speaker 1Well, I think in terms of the entire message of the mission statement of this film, that Nathan Fielder, who is the co-director, producer and on-screen participant. Yeah. You know, we have known previous work of Nathan For You, the rehearsal, which you mentioned before, The Curse, How to Win with... John Wilson. He's definitely the right person if you're going to get a comedian who's going to ingratiate himself into the life. He's a very quiet observer. I mean, they do give you a sub-storyline running about what his relationship
Speaker 1with Elizabeth is and whether he's gotten too close to the story.
Speaker 3And that was my point earlier too, sorry, just quickly. The audience I was in, a lot of them were 20 to 25. The people I spoke to sitting next to me who were younger were big up on Nathan Fielder, huge Nathan Fielder fans, didn't know anything about Elizabeth Holmes. People are going to this as Nathan Fielder fans. And all those comedians that were there in your screening were there because they're Nathan Fielder fans. But yeah, it is interesting. The true crime element of it all is also part of its success, this documentary. But definitely in my screening, I don't think that was as significant.
Speaker 1Is it fair to say that comedy right now, if you think about what defines comedy in 2026, has a lot of exploring of people's social awkwardness, the strange ways that people behave when they know they're being observed or they don't know they're being observed. I can think of so many comedians that go out and observe the world to collect their information to translate that into comedy.
Speaker 3Well, if you look at someone like Kunk in the UK, she does a lot of that kind of stuff.
Speaker 1What was she called?
Speaker 3Kunk. You know, Kunk.
Speaker 1I definitely thought you were saying * * * *, but that's definitely.
Speaker 3But yeah, she's brilliant. But she does a lot of that kind of stuff, but with experts on stuff. But it's all that hidden camera feel kind of stuff. Nathan Fielder does that. Even Adam Ray does a bit of that with his Dr. Phil kind of show. There is a lot more of that, I think. And it's also about the comedy that you can get on social media is a little more, you know, prank-based. Whereas this, yeah, this comedy is... It is a little bit more intellectual. It's something you can't just generate and put on Instagram. The Nathan Fielder comedy doesn't work in a 30-second bit necessarily. Well,
Speaker 3you sort of.
Speaker 1Touched on this before, but I mean, Nathan Fielder has built a career out of making people feel uncomfortable and exposing the absurdity of human behavior. After I saw this film, I've been watching more of his work to understand it. But the perfect person to investigate, to sort of highlight his successes in his comedy is Elizabeth Holmes. But I do think that a lot of people will walk out of this movie and feel that he might be just as manipulative when it comes to creating content as Elizabeth Holmes was manipulative in deceiving people.
Speaker 3Yeah. And look, I've watched a fair bit of Nathan Fielder's work and I admire him. I think he's fantastic. And it's One of those things where it's easy because it's not the kind of comedy I could ever do. I did a prank show once.
Speaker 1How'd that go?
Speaker 3I did not enjoy it. I did not enjoy deceiving someone who was not coping well with it.
Speaker 1You're too empathetic. You'd be halfway through apologizing.
Speaker 3I absolutely would. There's no question. I'd be great as a subject in a Fielder documentary. I'd be no good as Nathan Fielder. Well, I like to bring people along with me on the ride, you know.
Speaker 1I think what I like about your sort of comedy from what I've been able to gather is more, it's less about the making fun of people. It's more observation comedy.
Speaker 3And if I will make fun of someone, I like to make a very extreme point so that they know that I'm obviously joking, that I'm not being personal.
Speaker 1Well, you're bleeding tongue in cheek, yeah, yeah.
Speaker 3But yeah, sorry, Lance Oppenheim. Yeah, you're going to move on to him. They're the director of Primetime that we looked at last week.
Speaker 2I know.
Speaker 1After seeing Primetime and seeing this film, I just feel like Lance Oppenheim has a really clever take on social commentary and also people who do bad things.
Speaker 3The other thing too is if we look at the construction of this film a little bit, because it is an important part of the film is construction and it's not by accident. They must have spent... When did they finish filming this? 2023 or something? So they spent a long time editing and getting it ready to release. But those scenes where you've got Nathan Fielder talking to, say, Elizabeth's dad or talking to her partner or whatever separately, but then in the same time there's those, they cut it between Elizabeth Holmes finding out how strict prison's going to be and how tough prison life's going to be. Like,
Speaker 3Elizabeth Holmes, fair enough, she's an evil person and did a lot of horrible things. I still have a lot of empathy for her because prison is tough. A lot of people are out there going, oh, she only got nine years. Can you imagine suspending your life for nine years?
Speaker 1I think with Lance Oppenheim that from what I could see in the movies I've now seen of his and in the work that I can see, it sort of feels like this tabloid magazine, you know, like the truth magazine was here in Chicago.
Speaker 3All of those sorts of- Bit of a hard copy kind of feeling.
Speaker 1Yeah, it's like a dirty magazine where it exposes lies and truth and doesn't necessarily be needed to have been made accountable for it.
Speaker 3And Fielder and Oppenheim obviously have got no issue going in for that awkward stuff and not feeling awkward. And I think that's all getting too early. I can't go in for the awkward and not feel awkward with you. Whereas these guys just don't, obviously they just want to cover it. You know, they're mission focused.
Speaker 1There's a lot to also talk about outside of the wider creative team. But look, the cinematographer is David Bolan, who was from Some Kind of Heaven and Ren Faire. Also, I believe, the same cinematographer for Primetime.
Speaker 3Primetime, yeah, I believe so, yeah.
Speaker 1The same with the editor is Adam Locke Norton, who also worked on the rehearsal, but was a part of Primetime. And then you've got Ari Balouzian. which again was from primetime. So everyone that had just been working on primetime and maybe these projects were being made simultaneously.
Speaker 3They must have overlapped, yeah, given the timeframe they filmed this film in and then the other projects that Oppenheim and Fielder were working on separately, yeah.
Speaker 1When I was sitting in the cinema watching this movie, I felt like I was watching the start of a new dimension of cinema. I think we're going to see a lot of copycats in terms of finding subject matter like this. What was unique to this story was the fact that Elizabeth Holmes goes to jail. And then we tap in for the second half of the film with our actor, Amanda Seyfried. Oh, yeah.
Speaker 3Spectacular.
Speaker 1Which is so spectacular because a large part of it, with her being on screen after she'd played the title role, she'd played Elizabeth Holmes, and she's now back to talk about this role that she's played. There's been commentary now of the real Elizabeth Holmes of Amanda's performance.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1But then for the stuff we don't get to see, they reenact times in which she was visited in a prison with Amanda sitting there and them debating how she said things, what the turn of phrase was. Yeah. Very fascinating filmmaking. And it was like something I'd never seen before. It was like two worlds very well melded together. Yeah.
Speaker 3And the other great thing about Amanda's performance in this is she is the emotional expression that Nathan Fielder can't be. So Nathan Fielder obviously, he's got a character. He's got an on-screen character. And you've got to take that into consideration that if he's going to be drawn on screen, especially for documentaries, co-directing, he's going to maintain his, that character, right? That's, that's essential for him as his career keeps going. But, Amanda Seyfried comes in and she, I don't know, people said this as I was leaving the cinema, she says
Speaker 3the things that we're all thinking, right? That's a common phrase.
Speaker 1For you, I think it was a bit of a risk for her to be saying a lot of these things that this could affect her career. But you were sitting there going, nope, I agree.
Speaker 3I agree with her. But she was also kind of, yeah, she was the emotional response, whereas Field is, I wouldn't say the intellectual response, but he's the more measured and he's more connected to the subject kind of response. Seyfried at times, I'm like, yeah, I'm with you. You get this. But when you're talking about the phrasing, that's where it became, I think, extra fascinating because Seyfried would do a delivery of a line leaning towards the negative because she'd watched Elizabeth Holmes on video at length. She'd watched tens and
Speaker 3tens of hours of Elizabeth Holmes talking and she's made her mind up about whether Elizabeth Holmes is guilty or not and she would lean towards that guilty side whereas Fielder would then correct her like you're saying like oh it wasn't quite as negative as that or it wasn't quite that way so yeah Seyfried coming in with a bit of baggage too is just oh it's so juicy it's so so good.
Speaker 1The most creative decision I think they've made in doing all of this is bleeding these two worlds you know there is no boundary between fiction and reality yeah these two things are very much put together. Now, Christopher Abbott is playing Billy Evans in the reenactments. I don't know how much footage Christopher Abbott was able to see of Billy Evans before taking on this role, but certainly didn't look exactly like him, but did pick up similar traits. I can't imagine ever being given a role like this based on a real person and being like, delicious.
Speaker 3I think it comes down to payday. Potentially.
Speaker 1And maybe this is going to be a very noisy film. I mean, it's going to be the highest grossing documentary. It could also become the first documentary to be nominated for Best Picture.
Speaker 3Yes, that's what they're talking about as well. A lot of people are.
Speaker 1Saying, if you were Christopher Abbott, would you say yes to being weird-ass Billy Evans?
Speaker 3If you're aware of Nathan Fielder and you're aware of Oppenheim, Lance Oppenheim, yeah, I reckon I would. You're in good hands there, you know. I was going to say he's a New York actor, but he might be in Hollywood now. But obviously he was in Girls and he was great in Girls. And he's barely in it. But you're right. There are elements, whether it's in the script or otherwise... But yeah, he gets it spot on.
Speaker 1Billy Evans is an interesting character. And I think he's going to get the lion's share of people sort of questioning how much he was involved. He didn't seem like he had the best intentions ever.
Speaker 3It's also one of the interesting things about this film, right, though, is it's not like a normal documentary where someone says something and then they go and interview three other people to confirm or deny it. Like they just believe what's being said or you only hear what's being said by the one person. And Billy does say, oh, yeah, what I'm doing is what Elizabeth wants me to do. Like, we're very close.
Speaker 1That was a lie. She was like, well.
Speaker 3Yes and no, though, right? Because when Nathan finally gets to talk to her in prison, and you'll see in the film how that all unfolds, you still don't know. You don't know if they're working symbiotically or if he is. We never get an answer to that. They make him look like a villain. They make him look like a misogynist. They make him look like an asshole, which he may well be.
Speaker 1Billy Evans is such a bad guy in this movie, in this documentary, that we actually do feel as an audience. And maybe you can speak to this, but Elizabeth Holmes is not so bad.
Speaker 3Exactly. Until I watched The Inventor again last night and went, no, no, she's a lying, evil piece of crap. We didn't mention once the fact that she basically influenced someone to commit suicide. You know, there's some serious charges against her here. And the film doesn't cover any of those. It only covers... the personalities. And it's easy to set up two personalities in contrast to each other, like Billy and Elizabeth, and not actually deal with any of the facts that got us here in the first place.
Speaker 1Well, some of those facts, by the way, that filmmakers were actually living with Elizabeth Holmes. Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim began filming 34 days before Holmes entered prison, which was in May 2023. They were given access to the rented beach house in Del Mar, California, where she lived with Billy Evans and their children. I wouldn't want to as if, look, whether I'm right or wrong or guilty or innocent, whether I've decided to, what my motivations of having a film crew come in and film stuff in my home, I would want that to happen.
Speaker 3Like people smoke. No, that's invasive. And the fact that these two people let Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim in is like the first red flag.
Speaker 1Red flag. This movie should be called Red Flags. That's what I was thinking. It's got to be Red fucking Flags in this movie.
Speaker 3Red Flags of San Diego. Yeah.
Speaker 1Well, I guess they wanted to, you know, I don't know. The film title for me is more of a tagline. I think this film could have been titled better. Yeah.
Speaker 3Well, also because it comes from Elizabeth Holmes' quote, but they didn't use the entire quote, so... The other thing I found interesting too, though, is it was a bit like watching Everybody Loves Raymond. It's like the kids were there when it was convenient for the scene, but then as soon as Elizabeth Holmes or Billy didn't want the kids around, they just disappeared. And whether there was a nanny living with them or not, we never saw a nanny. Whether there was someone else there to look after the kids when they just didn't want the kids around for whatever scene was being shot. Those kids were just gone. Like, where did the kids keep going?
Speaker 1I think whenever Nathan started having those conversations with the two of them, they were like, get these kids out of the room, big deal. Uh, mommy and daddy, uh, crazy.
Speaker 3But didn't you find that bizarre that the kids would just disappear? Like at one point they're sitting on the, the, the decking out, looking over the beach. They decided to go on the beach. The kids are gone. There's no kids. There's no kids.
Speaker 1That's very Hollywood though.
Speaker 3Oh yeah. Hollywood as.
Speaker 1Like kids are just like there as a prop and then until they're not. And then.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3Well, everybody loves Raymond. They had two sons when they were convenient to the story.
Speaker 1Only when they were convenient to the story. Yeah. While Nathan Fielder wasn't originally going to appear in the documentary, the plan was for him to actually remain behind the camera. But the interactions with Holmes and Evans became so unusual that the filmmakers decided... they belonged or he belonged in the finished film. How does that land for you?
Speaker 3They wouldn't have chosen Nathan Fielder if they didn't want him in there. And the reason that the interactions are so weird and so interesting is because ultimately Holmes and Billy wanted Nathan Fielder in there, whether he was, you know, they perceived him as a celebrity or a comedian that would, I don't know, lighten the moment a little bit. If it's not intentional by the filmmakers, it was definitely intentional by the subjects.
Speaker 1Well, they were wanting to cash in on his celebrity.
Speaker 3Yeah, exactly. Well, hence the financial thing, which we won't talk too much about, but is.
Speaker 1Yeah, a factor.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1I mean, that's the financial element of this is the backbone to sort of a large part of the storytelling and some of the twists that kind of happened to keep you ingrained and enthralled in this film for its two hours and 54 minutes.
Speaker 3Yeah, 54 minutes, yeah.
Speaker 1You know, it's a long film and you are literally being brought into this world I didn't realize that Emma Stone had helped bring Amanda Seyfried into the film.
Speaker 3Yeah, that's crazy, isn't it?
Speaker 1You know, she'd already won the Emmy for portraying Elizabeth Holmes in The Dropout, which was a hugely successful series for Hulu.
Speaker 3It's interesting because I didn't know she was going to be in it. And when they reveal, because they'd already showed Elizabeth Holmes' negative opinion of Seyfried's performance and her complications with The Dropout in general, that when she shows up, Amanda Seyfried, it was a highlight moment. Like, it was a really special moment. moment.
Speaker 1Everyone laughed in the cinema when I saw it, where I was like, yes!
Speaker 3Yeah, we had kind of an applause laugh, kind of, this is going to change things.
Speaker 1Because it would be a hard yes, I think, because Amanda ends up playing multiple versions of Elizabeth Holmes. I mean, she appears as herself in a way, which is, you know... researching Elizabeth Holmes. She's seen in footage from the dropout where she won the Emmy for playing her. And then she reprises that portrayal of Holmes in newly filmed dramatic reenactments.
Speaker 3And you can see the evolution of how Amanda makes those decisions whether to do that or not. Initially, she might not have done the reenactments. But then you can see that that would have kind of maybe organically come out of the documentary footage and then her commitment or involvement with Fielder. Yeah, it's fascinating.
Speaker 1And then a large part of their inspiration apparently came from Alfred Hitchcock, which I think when you're making a film that's this long and you want to be able to build tension and suspense, certainly for a documentary, this felt more like a psychological thriller in some way.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3This is a masterclass of manipulation. There are levels of manipulation all the way through this documentary. And look, at no stage do I want to knock this as a piece of entertainment. It is a fantastic piece of entertainment. Are documentaries true or false is a broader question that we can continue to ask for the rest of the history of cinema.
Speaker 1As an aficionado of Elizabeth Holmes and knowing that she is portrayed as.
Speaker 3I wouldn't say aficionado, but I've seen the stuff.
Speaker 1You've collected the facts. As Gina Liano would say, you've collected a dossier of information.
Speaker 3A dossier. Yeah.
Speaker 1But I mean, you would know her as a fraudster and an extraordinary manipulator. But I want to know from you, does this documentary give you more of a different perspective of her? Did it change the way that you saw her at all?
Speaker 3Not at all.
Speaker 2No.
Speaker 3And again, I think I said it at the top. I definitely said it to you off air. This film doesn't deal with facts. It's not about the law. It's not about... what's right or wrong. This is about a person and who this person was and what that person thought they had done. Once you start, and it's one of the reasons why they don't try and back anything up with any facts. It's easy to say, oh, Elizabeth Holmes was manipulated by Sonny and then she was manipulated by Billy, so we've got to feel sorry for her. She was only ever trying to achieve good for humanity
Speaker 3so you can't hold it against her. She never intended to defraud investors so you can't hold that against her. It's like, well, when it comes to the law, your intentions are not valid. What you actually did is what's valid. So if she's that naive or that self-involved that she wasn't aware that she was doing all this stuff or was a victim of any of this stuff, that's her problem because she still did it. And the court has proved that she still did it. And I think that's, I hope HBO gets a huge boost in their downloads
Speaker 3or views or streaming or whatever of the inventor, because the facts are damning. I don't know how manipulative she is or isn't, but she did all, she was convicted of all this stuff. And when you watch the docker, you can see the evidence as best, not again, not a court of law, but you can see all this evidence as to what she did. And it's, I find it hard to believe her version of events.
Speaker 1I think a lot of people do. And I think that's probably part and parcel as to why this film has so much success.
Speaker 3And what a character study. Fascinating, brilliant character study, though. I'd love to have a doco about this, about all kinds of prominent true crime figures, you know? Character study is intense in this. It's amazing.
Speaker 1Well, I also think at some point... There's going to be an undiagnosed or there's going to be a new term for this, and that is people who believe their own lies.
Speaker 3There is a term, yeah. There's a couple of terms, I think.
Speaker 1There's a couple of terms of this, but it seems to be more prevalent than ever before with people thinking that they can get away with this.
Speaker 3That's the thing that's amazing, isn't it? You know, I'm happy to lie and I've lied in the past and I'll lie in the future. How much of it do I think I'm going to get away with and how shit do I feel after I've done it are two different things. She doesn't seem to show any remorse and she seems more than happy just to carry on if it benefits. Like even the whole.
Speaker 1But she believes it though, don't you think? I actually think she's not sitting and going, I'm a nasty liar. She's moved on. She's now like, I'm innocent. I'm not guilty.
Speaker 3How do you feel about her claim that she doesn't care about money? What was your reaction to that?
Speaker 1I actually believe that part of it. I think there are a difference between notoriety and financial remuneration. And I think a lot of people who are a lot of narcissistic people in history that have followed very similar paths also weren't motivated by money. They were motivated by notoriety. I think she wanted to be the Oprah Winfrey of this field.
Speaker 3So one of the things I find interesting about her statement, I don't care about money, is she doesn't have to care about money. Her parents were wealthy and she grew up in a wealthy neighbourhood.
Speaker 1Mm-hmm.
Speaker 3Sunny, her first benefactor and boyfriend, was wealthy. Billy, her current partner and benefactor, is wealthy. I mean, you know, there are different degrees of wealth, according to Billy. But, of course, she doesn't have to worry about money. She surrounds herself with money, so she doesn't have to worry about money, you know? Like, it's convenient for her to say, I don't care about money, when she's in a position where she actually doesn't have to worry about money.
Speaker 1Yeah, it's a different world to us.
Speaker 3Completely different, right?
Speaker 1They definitely make it feel like that as well. Like, this woman is living in a different environment that she's always lived in. For us living in the real world, there's so many moments of... What? See, for me.
Speaker 3Personally, I don't think you're particularly motivated by money, but you understand how important money is for the things that you want in life. I would never say, oh, Ben's only in it for money. I would say, yeah, but he understands that he's still got to pay to live and he's still got to have money to do things he wants to do. So to that degree, he cares about money, but you're not necessarily motivated.
Speaker 1No, I think it's because I was brought up by people who believe that money is coming. Money is always there.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1So that's a different, that's a different class in itself.
Speaker 3Yeah, it is. It's an upper middle class or whatever you want to call it. But yeah, I find that interesting. And again, the movie does nothing to discuss that, which is probably one of the great things about this movie. We get to discuss it, right?
Speaker 1Well, that's what this film is all about. This film is leaning into a genre that is going to become mainstream in cinema. We're going to see a lot of documentaries being made like this with a lot of bleeding between reality, fact and fiction. I think this is the start of something. If this movie is going to make millions and billions of dollars, if this movie's Rotten Tomatoes list is now 96% and critics' approval rating is 97 out of 100, you know, the dollars won't lie and people will go and manufacture or explore new case studies that is about the human condition.
Speaker 3The other thing that's great about this is that Netflix and the other streamers have got so many production companies and so forth making true crime documentaries that we kind of already have a bunch of directors and producers that know how to make the documentaries. So if they wanted to lean into this, it's not like when animation hit big again in the early 90s, but yet Disney was the only studio that had any animation quality. This one is if documentaries boom all of a sudden, which I'm sure documentary filmmakers are hoping... there are a whole bunch of, and again, there's the greater documentary making world, but also this,
Speaker 3you know, very narrow streaming true crime documentary world that could be set up to, to do the same kind of production without a lot of effort, which is, that's kind of exciting. I'm excited for people.
Speaker 1In an era where no one has any money, bros, like this is a very cheap way of doing things.
Speaker 3It's following on after horror, isn't it? There's like make a $ 3 million film or a $ 7 million film and you might make a hundred million or you might want this.
Speaker 1We've discussed this all year. You know, people aren't necessarily wanting a blockbuster film. Rose, I'm going to go straight into this. I think that this film was brilliant. I think it could easily be a four and a half stars for me. I don't think we've given a five out to anything this year, have we?
Speaker 3I think I gave five to Spider-Man and possibly The Odyssey, but Odyssey might have been four and a half. I don't know.
Speaker 1I think I gave five stars to Spider-Man as well. So Spider-Man is leading the charge with five stars. This movie, I'm only taking off half a star for one reason. And as time has gone on and I'm reflective of it, I felt very uncomfortable at the fact that this movie is geared up for us to laugh at her expense.
Speaker 3Yeah, and look, Four and a Half is where I'm going to land as well, and my reasons are more that, look, it's a very entertaining film and it is great fun. That's not said about documentaries very often, right? But at the same time, as much as any other film you're being manipulated, it's being edited in a way to create an illicit response as well. which I appreciate. It's mastery, like the absolute mastery of direction and editing here. But don't believe that you're watching fact. Just enjoy it for what it is and then go and research some facts. I think that's a fun part too. I'm sure the dropout's going to get a bunch of new watches over the next couple of weeks and hopefully the inventor does
Speaker 3as well. And talk about people like this. Too easily these people get charged and sentenced and we forget about it. Let's talk about it. You know, let's make it prevalent. Let's make it obvious. Let's highlight these people and be more aware.
Speaker 1I think these people are making these sorts of films of talking about character studies. They're talking about the exploration of what's happening in the world right now. Next week, we're back with either The Hunger Games or Bad Apples. It'll come down to which one is more, I think, divisive or more leaning towards conversation about the actual film, which was basically how we decided on this film over Ebenezer. This film is out. Please go and see it at the cinemas. It is revolutionising the way in which we see cinema. I don't think that anyone who will go and see this won't take something out of it. And
Speaker 1You Can See Everything is out at cinemas now.
🎬 TV RELOAD: THE HUNGER GAMES - SUNRISE ON THE REAPING! TWICE THE TRIBUTES, TWICE THE DANGER… BUT IS IT TWICE AS GOOD? What happens when the Capitol doubles the number of tributes, raises the stakes and turns the...
🎙️ BIG BROTHER AUSTRALIA 2026: MARSHY BREAKS HIS SILENCE ON HIS BRUTAL EVICTION, THE TRUTH ABOUT KYRAH & WHY HE THINKS EBONY WON'T WIN! Fresh from one of the most brutal and bizarre evictions in Big Brother Australia...
🎙️ BIG BROTHER AUSTRALIA 2026: MATTHEW BREAKS HIS SILENCE ON GASLIGHTING, HIS VILLAIN REPUTATION & THE HEARTBREAK BEHIND HIS BIG PERSONALITY! Fresh from one of the most shocking evictions of Big Brother Australia 2026,...
🎙️ BIG BROTHER AUSTRALIA 2026: PHOEBE SPILLS ON HOUSE SECRETS, BETRAYALS & BEHIND-THE-SCENES DRAMA! Fresh from her dramatic eviction from the Big Brother Australia house, Phoebe joins Benjamin Norris on TV Reload for a...
TV RELOAD: WICKER - A Bizarre, Beautiful and Unconventional Love Story What happens when the perfect husband isn't a man at all, but something made entirely from wicker? This week on TV Reload, Ben Norris and Brose...