Ripple Effects: How Might the California Fires Impact the Housing Market?
33 minAudio
Episode 5: In this episode of Trust the Process, we discuss the devastating fires in California and their far-reaching effects. From the heartbreak of loss and uncertainty faced by families and communities to the ripple effects on housing markets, migration. Join us as we navigate this complex topic with compassion and insight, shedding light on what these events could mean for the future of home building and real estate in California, Las Vegas and beyond.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Welcome to Trust the Process podcast, where we'll pull back the curtain on new home construction, the real estate market, and the trends shaping it all. Discover the stories, insights, and expertise behind the process of building a new home. Join us and let's build something great together. Welcome back to Trust the Process, a podcast where we talk about new home construction, the real estate market, and everything in between. Today we're gonna talk about the topic that's really top of mind for a lot of people right now, and it's making
dominating national headlines, would be the fires in California. Given that Nevada is so close to California as our border state, how does that influence us? What does that mean for us? What does that mean for our housing market? And some of the things that we may or may not see as we as this crisis unfolds. So I'm gonna hand it off to you. Obviously we know the tragedy that's happening there and yeah it's can't not see it. Right. So many people affected. Yeah it's a lot of it's a lot of devastation and a lot of things laid to waste and a lot of
ramifications I think that will feel for years into the future. I agree. There are just locally as a Las Vegas resident, they're a huge neighbor of ours right. I mean they're on the order of what 25, 30 times the size in terms of population. Yes. Of Nevada and sometimes I feel like Las Vegas is a suburb of Los Angeles anyway. It does sometimes feel like that. Now when they've talked a little bit about the train that's gonna go between there's almost that imagination that it is. It kind of feels like it right. It affects everyone but I do think it'll have
it'll have pressure on the entire country. You know, it's small ripples. Locally it'll affect obviously Los Angeles in terms of how that looks from a rebuilding standpoint and that's why we chose to talk about it on this episode or as part of this podcast because around 15,000 at the time of filming this we're in the last week of January 2025 and at the time of filming this it's estimated that around 15,000 structures were destroyed. The vast majority of those were residential structures. We're homes. Yeah tragic. So that is a lot of
inventory that is now out of the market a lot of devastation obviously loss of life and loss of memories and things that it's hard to seems straight to talk about in this context but it does matter and it will it will affect building policy and it will affect building practices. It will affect net migration. It just there will be people who choose not to rebuild or people that make this there. You know what? This is their line in the sand and say I was on the fence. I
was going to move in the next five years but I don't want to be the next victim. I don't want to be the next person that's affected by a natural disaster in California. It's going to be so expensive to rebuild. It was such a it's an expensive loss. It's an expensive loss in terms of where it is just geographically. It's very challenging to build in a lot of those locales and the Pacific Palisades a lot of those slopes and mountainside homes may be cost prohibitive to build. They may not even see it pencil out for many many years so
that kind of loss is really how do you even calculate it? Where do you even start? Because it wasn't just the structure that was lost. It was everything else that maybe the whole viability of that site is now no longer buildable. Now what is it worth? A vista? I mean it's you buy it to put a picnic table there. Right, and I have heard some discussions that because of the location and because the you know some of those obstacles that City County may not even allow people to build in those same locations. And what is that in itself is a migration question? That's right. I mean if you're displaced and you owned that parcel and it was
passed down especially some of the Altadena real estate that was lost a lot of those homes were handed down. Those aren't affluent people as you know in general. A lot of that that eaten fire the damage caused by the eaten fire affected more middle class and even lower middle class people that their largest asset was their home and maybe that asset was handed down over the generations and it's underinsured or not insured or now going to be in the neighborhood that is completely burned out including the commercial areas. So
who's who wants to be the first one in? And the businesses certainly don't want to be the first one in. They'll need the rooftops to support the businesses. Sure. The people don't want to live where there are no cafes and restaurants and dry cleaners and gas stations and general conveniences of modern life. So who who's going to who's going to take the investment? Who's going to take the risk? Right. And then if you look at it from the eyes of the speculative builder like our company where where is the off-ramp? How do you how do you how do you
calculate end-of-day value of a finished product? Let's say you were to pick up six or seven lots demo the homes what's left of them and rebuild with the intent to resell where's your market? Who's going to take that risk? Are you going to shoulder the risk of not only what does the home look like at the end in terms of market value but what is the process looking getting there and what kind of regulation and red tape are you going to have to fight to tear down and to rebuild to make it a commercially viable endeavor? So we have that
overlaying it and then you'll have the individual homeowners who may choose to rebuild. Did they have enough insurance? Is what they owned before even approvable with current zoning and city planning? So those are the kind of clouds that are hanging over the entire process and when you look at that times let's say 90% of the structures lost were residential and if the estimates are accurate at 15,000 and that's not more let's just take those two assumptions we're at 13,500 residences. How many of those were for family homes that like I
mentioned may be incongruent with current day zoning. Now it's one home or one home in an accessory dwelling structure we'll see a net loss of homes and then now what we're seeing is a push-pull and I feel that both sides are a little correct because there's a push to say we have to rebuild we have to cut all the regulation and red tape and then there's a push on the other side of the argument that well if we just rebuild low density suburban housing in the same like kind and quality of what was there what's to stop this from happening
again and that's not just a desirability standpoint or an intellectual argument it's an insurability argument too. What kind of insurance company is going to want to take a risk if you look at the actuarial risk of ensuring something that's the exact same product that was there before give or take at 2025 or 2026 year built but it's still in essence the same product that was there that in a one and 50 year window was annihilated and everything in an
actuarial I'm not an insurance expert but everything is about the likelihood of an event a major loss happening in X number of years over the amount of value of that loss so if a fire is an every 50 year event that property becomes insurable they're pretty much having to hit you with the 2% risk so your property is a million dollars 2% of that if you have a one in 50 year chance of a total loss just general of these are more that goes into these calculations and that but in general that's a $20,000 a year policy because
it's a 2% risk of a loss so when you couple that with other natural disasters and over other overlays and then just an overall appetite for wanting to be in that business at the end of the day insurance is a capitalist endeavor so you're going to have to have people that want to take that risk even if the map is 20,000 maybe the the market has policies priced at $40,000 and it just might be an uninsurable insurmountable hill to climb and when you look at the
affluent areas that might be okay it might the market forces might out outweigh that it'll still hold down their values in the future but when you look at the more middle-class neighborhoods in that market maybe a million dollar homes probably a middle class and a lot of Altadena 1.2 which represents maybe a 1600 square foot rambler single story on an eighth of an acre 56 in a square of a lot how does that math work out how do you hit a middle-class family with a 20,000 or $30,000 insurance premium plus their mortgage taxes and
everything else that comes with running a household so it's those types of considerations that really have a lot of people worried it's not a fair playing field exactly so there isn't and like you said they're not all affluent so so how does that look? A lot of what and I think LA is a massive wealthy city that land will be reimagined and reused but it's going to be so challenging to go through that web of problems similar to our foreclosure crisis that really had
a lot of the Sunbelt and high-growing cities it took a lot of time a lot of that land was held in bankruptcy courts or was part of a settlement or part of a company that had since gone bankrupt so you're driving through these neighborhoods with all these buildable lots and you're thinking there's still a demand for housing and the numbers still pencil in some ways why is that not being developed yet it just has to work its way through the courts and the financial systems and maybe it's wrapped up in bank like I mentioned bankruptcy courts and and other kind of barriers and hurdles that we don't even
see and aren't overtly obvious so we're going to see a push-pull and in the meantime where are those people staying exactly the displaced people that if you figure it's on the order of 50 to 100,000 people what is that what is that look like to the greater LA market what does it look like to Las Vegas there's a lot of op-eds already publishing that no 100% have knock-on effects to the Las Vegas probably rental market maybe we saw that and we'll have we have another episode on ration we saw that in COVID I mean we saw various states with their different regulations and rules around COVID that was sometimes just the line
in the sand that may have pushed them to a 2021 move to a different state versus what would have been maybe a 2030 move or 2025 move it just kind of read it kind of reshuffled the deck and the taxes and a lot of living all those things a lot of things right if they're 30% if they were cost of living probably depending on the city and confused and not yet exactly or three towns over was displaced but you're fine what does that look like what does that look like for just these kind of bordering cities to LA bordering states to California so it'll be
really interesting and we'll probably be talking about that that's why I said these these will have long ripples and it will affect a lot of things from a regulation standpoint when you look at what is it going to take to rebuild when I talked about that push and pull so you have existing zoning laws existing land use existing building codes that's just what's priced into it now but what and will it be politically advantageous to reimagine these things and cause more
you know more regulation and have more pushes for barriers you fire natural fire breaks more setback laws stricter setback laws and when they talk about it from an intellectual standpoint it's easy to say but in a in a country with private property who's to determine oh your street is now a boundary zone so we're not going to allow development on your street who how politically popular
is that domain right is that what it looks like I mean when you when you think about it becomes people who wouldn't want that or wouldn't be willing to give up what they do have exactly that they could come in an eminent domain now that is a very long drawn-out process that has appeals may even go to the state supreme courts maybe appeal higher than that so it's just very tricky because you're going to have an intellectual argument that's probably not wrong right they are you could steal man either side of it yes and I
think that it's going to be interesting to watch the push pull right now it's easy to get action because of cities literally still smoldering at the time we recorded this last week of January 68% contained it's a little over half contained it's still a very active and unfolding situation what does that mean how does that ripple through so right now it's very politically popular to talk about Newsome has an executive order that said the coastal Commission he basically defanged the California Coastal Commission so the California Coastal
Commission could be its own episode so what it it was sworn in in the mid-70s sworn into law and it essentially regulates the coastal zone it's 1,100 miles of California's coastal zone pretty much the entire border where it hits the Pacific Ocean and it only pertains to development okay access to the beach and overall preservation of the coast so it dictates the entirety of
the coastline but it can go as short as 3,000 feet in from the coast and as far as three miles inland depending on where you're at they have full veto proof authority to transcend city planners actions taken by local elected government officials and the ability of fine private citizens so effectively what it does yes what it does is grants one body go on governing body that was
originally voted in in the 70s that allows them pretty much full executive authority of the entire coastline and like I mentioned as short as 3,000 feet and as big as three or four miles in coastal so when you think about the kind of reach think about how far four miles from the beach would feel right you're gonna go that's not even we're not anywhere maybe we're a beach town but we're not a beach from property we're four miles in four miles in when you think people are building right up to the beach there's a lot of jurisdiction a
lot of exactly and it's by the way it is even more than residential so it act also dictates commercial but also dictates room rates and how they want a diversity of room rates along California's coastal hotels and hospitality industry in fact one hotel operator was fined 15.5 million dollars for converting his hotel to a boutique high-end luxury hotel without their approval and operated it for several several years never asked for their
permission and was slapped with a very very heavy fine for that so you can see the the far-reaching power and authority that they say that regulation you know I think a lot of what it is is that yes it encompasses a large land area but how many citizens does it truly affect and you've got a lot of these little anecdotes and these stories which I went down the rabbit hole and read and some of them are absolutely atrocious I feel that it when it's affecting on the order
of 100 people 20 people one developer one hotel owner it's just not a popular story it doesn't get brought up so now with the wildfires though and we're talking 30 to 50,000 citizens displaced I think it was smart of Newsom to say we're gonna defang this for a little bit temporarily let's get this place rebuilt because they have full authority let's say you own let's say you're in one of their zones you're two miles in from the coast and you want to pull a permit to
build a single family home they have full authority to stop it and their default generally if you talk to my architect does a lot of work over there if you talk to them their default answer is almost always no and then because it's considered an environmental agency it allows for public comment so if you're converting a rundown fourplex into a five over 100 unit apartment building every neighbor in there is going to have public comment and the ability to
basically petition the California Coastal Commission to stop the project and the appeals process alone takes about nine to 11 months just the appeals process if you're told no and many times it's completely overridden really good example was were two condos in Orange County condo complexes on the water they needed a breakwater bill one condo was to save the development one condo was built in 1974 which predated the California Coastal Commission and the
guidelines in the California Coastal Commission say they may approve structures that will prevent the demolition or the loss of existing structures so the Coastal Commission had another application for a condo complex built in 1984 they're about 500 feet from each other they approved the one built 74 and denied the one in 84 leaving that condo complex completely vulnerable to erosion to loss from weather just general coastal concerns and
their argument was well you existed after the California Coastal Commission you can see the level of fury and ire that that commission draws from local residents and developers and it's funny to read the stories of the local jurisdictions like City of Newport Beach coming in to direct opposition to the California Coastal Commission for instance they sold a parcel of their wharf to a developer for several hundred million dollars which really helped the city and the California Coastal Commission blocked it saying that you're
going to cause undue strain under the local streets and traffic and people aren't going to be able to park and access the beach appropriately another great story and I won't I won't fill the podcast with anecdotes but there was a single family home owner that wanted to build an accessory dwelling unit for his disabled daughter to live in after he passed and they opposed it because the pathway he was going to plan for fund and execute to preserve beach access that
was previously through his property they said that it wasn't as good of a view for hikers when you're rerouted it 40 feet to the east so they denied his entire accessory dwelling unit even though his local jurisdiction and building department had approved it they have a lot of power and it's an entity that I didn't even know existed yeah and I guess that's because Nevada doesn't have a we don't have a real deal with you know that municipality that's right that's interesting and as mentioned it how many people does it truly affect not enough to make headlines but now it will know but it will for sure so yes so imagine
pretty much every home in the Palisades would fall into this I doubt all to Dean is probably far inland enough to not deal with the Coastal Commission but that's just one of many one of many commissions that you might have to deal with to get your projects approved but you can see just those little anecdotes of those are just layers of little stories every single home every single every single home every restaurant everything everything that story or that's right story that they're gonna battle that they will all right and the last count in the Palisades alone was about 6,500 structures so there are 6,500
potential anecdotes now like I mentioned that those have been temporarily defanged so we'll see but there that's that's popular to say and do but how is it going to look where the rubber meets the road when the headlines in six months move on to some other calamity or move on to something else what's it will that look like will it come back will will the will the Coastal Commission and it's I think 200 employees and 48 million dollar budget on the scale of the state of California is nothing but yield so much power are they
going to fight for their survival because you see something like this could this be the end of that commission could we see it realize wait this commission has no popular support and plenty of coastal states and towns manage their coastlines completely fine without some state appointed regulatory body so what I found interesting was their ability to veto state and local building departments and state and local municipalities or should say local municipalities really interesting non-elected not a single person is
elected in that office itself and before we even get to the building part so the regulatory bill portion of it what do you think that land value will be at the end of all of this you know I going to be parcel to parcel or will it overall there's some decrease or I can't see how it if for sure lost is our ability when the entire town is lost LA Metro is such a huge animal that could it easily be absorbed absolutely barring not withstanding any of the personal loss and
personal property loss that is objectively prime real estate now it has its own headwinds the insurance sure but it's desirable in its in the when you're in a city that large want to be there right where they're my choice exactly an accidental right that was right desired location and we'll talk about this in our migration episode the California is still one of the top five states for attracting new residents it's not growing net because it's losing people as fast as bringing them in but it is don't let the headlines fool you it is a dynamic economic powerhouse that pulls in a lot of people so you're in a
growing state you're in a established Metro plaques of I don't I think 13 or 14 million will put a correction if it's more than that it's a lot if you count the metro area if you run into the inland empire and you kind of how far can you drive without seeing desert if you count that the boundary you know depending I'm sure the Metropolitan statistical area by the census is one number but you look at a place like that and what a drop in the bucket 12,000 homes is it'll be nothing to find the demand but I think what is it gonna look
like and how is it going to collide with private property how are you going to get the 50 residents on this block to also at the same time to all have the same around this house right and burn you know they only had nominal damage right one next door that's right we lead us great it's so it's it's not it's piecemeal that's right it's not it's not 150 acres in the desert which we have the benefit and the beauty in these growing Sunbelt cities we have that kind of cohesive nature to say okay this is a big big tract of land and we can
kind of reimagine it any way we want which I guess that brings me to the next spot was do they come here I mean there are a lot of good reasons that they might consider so how what does that do to the influx here oh I think we'll definitely see it macro data I don't know if even 50,000 people and we'll talk about that in their migration episode if that how many come to Nevada how many come to purchase how many come to rent how many live a family in Stain California what what does that really look like when you look at the total numbers of people that moved to Nevada on the order of a hundred and our 360
thousand over four years it's not it's not time then even assuming every single one of those people that was that you know that are displaced come to Nevada I think it'll probably ripple out and we'll slowly kind of incrementally feel it mm-hmm and like you said it's not going to be immediate no in people have a lot to store through there yeah so I think that we're and we're also used to a lot of inbound migration from there anyway so we might not even really feel it
because we're used to ceiling I just feel that the numbers are so massive of what we're already seeing I don't know that it'll have a dramatic increase we're already a tight real estate market we're already appreciating real estate market we're already a tight city we're already seeing a lot inbound migration and growth is are those numbers going to really bear it out how many of those people moved to Austin Texas how many moved to just an inland city in California how many people moved to Seattle so there's a Arizona even further I mean exactly so I think so it's it's a scale that's unimaginable if
you try to put 50,000 people into an arena but when you spread it out over six or seven states that would be candidates for moves and relocations I think that we might not really feel it but it'll be interesting and when you look at what does it do to building industry when you have that it's not a growing city it's not used to that base of labor that we're used to in these Sunbelt cities that are growing the Phoenixes in the Las Vegas and the Charlotte they have a labor pool we have an existing labor pool so we might
feel that first before we fill anything else but I think they're they will struggle without having the housing stock for that labor force what kind of premiums will you have to pay to get the labor force out there to start rebuilding right will the regulation be a blessing in disguise because it will throttle down redevelopment and will throttle down the rebuilding process to where it is somewhat manageable imagine trying to rebuild 15,000 structures in a 12-month period we built what we say around 12,000 homes last year in Las
Vegas in addition to all the other development and growth that might happen in the city that large redevelopment things tear down stuff like that and a sparse labor force nationwide too so now are there people from Vegas that go there to to build it that's what I'm worried about kind of what you call it a brain drain but also a labor drain where we'll bear labor statistics already estimates were about two to four hundred thousand construction labor type workers short over the next so many years three or five years I definitely feel it I
definitely feel it yeah it is it is gonna be a challenge and then what does it do inflationary pressures on building materials and just logistics of all of those things that that are going to come into play and I think the biggest factor that people are glazing over is something that you brought up but what is the overall desirability of that now but well and and how does them how do we have price discovery and that's one of my favorite terms right we where's the price discovery we've never had essentially an entire city if you look
at Altadena or Palisades we've never had an entire city burnout that's part of a larger major metropolitan area where's the price discovery on what what are those parcels worth what are the homes worth when they're done where's the desirability because you could make an argument that you could see luxury homes built on every single one of those two three four million dollar homes luxury homes by most standards is there the demand there the geographic supported a lot to consider obviously it's an unfolding situation and we kind
of it's the unknowns in it are really unsettling it's very I mean and it's not even it's our neighbor it isn't even it isn't even our backyard here in Las Vegas Valley but because they're our neighbor it's you know you feel for them and you want to understand what they're gonna go through and be somehow empathetic somehow yeah maybe help in some way and you know that you are watching it like a cinema movie but it's something that is interesting to watch what it's gonna look like as as this unfolds and hard to envision I just
can't comprehend how you know wildfires used to be wildfires just happened in the wilderness straight through town right isn't something that used to happen right here about it right suddenly this has become a thing is it the way that we're building is the way that we're living is it you know products that we're using or is there is there some other ecosystem happening that's allowing for these fires to take place you know in Maui and the one I mean there just have been a series of those situations right isn't yours is it a
numbers game is it that those areas that our fire prone didn't have the development and then the scale of geological time 50 years is a blink of an eye so if you were to look at it and a scale of a thousand years and you'd say those homes popped up and then there was literally a fire how could they not have seen that happen if you're looking at it on that scale on that scale of time so I think there's a lot of things that that come into play weather patterns and climate change I think that are affecting droughts droughts are longer harder more intense so I think that has a play in it I think there's I don't want to
pontificate but I definitely think that there was probably some mismanagement in terms of brush control and if you see the kind of way it was managed it is kind of interesting that it didn't happen sooner that there was not some sort of fire sooner you have all of those people that means there's funding of the fire department and some of the exactly right right those things too that obviously you know are all topics of discussion out in the news world but for us to kind of bring it back home and think about how that affects us right and just the
national housing market as a whole what it could potentially mean and and something that we talked about in our other episode about headwinds and things kind of affecting the market that I regret not bringing up was the insurance crisis and if you look at what it's doing to premiums in many states Florida North Carolina any hurricane prone state any seismic prone state wildfire prone state those are that could be in a you know an upcoming crisis that is not
even on our radar when you think about the actuarial math that goes into is this a one in thousand year event one in 50 year event one in 500 year event turns the math from a $20,000 premium a year to a $2,000 premium a year and categorically maybe it isn't always a fire like you're saying maybe it's the earthquake maybe it's a flood maybe it's a mudslide and there are so many other natural disasters that happen and try it nationally you know that we're not affected by here and what's right there we're weather conditions we don't have
hurricanes whatever we're grateful for some of that we do have the heat we have the heat we don't have enough vegetation for fires so that's something but yeah that'd be interesting to see how it unfolds yeah it will be an ongoing but it felt relevant to discuss it now as it's happening where we sit here you know safe and cozy there are people who've been displaced and who are suffering from this and so to look at that and think about that and how that's affecting not just them specifically but how the ripple effect as as Michael mentioned will carry out through both Las Vegas Valley and nationally so it will be interesting
to watch and we thought it was worth bringing up and and I appreciate your take on it yeah that's you know the entities that are making some decisions and well after go from here so it will remain to be seen remains to be seen I'll look forward to checking back in when it's no longer dominating that once to say how did that work out did the Coastal Commission remain defanged and did they speed up permitting it'll be interesting to watch so well we'll keep watching it with you and give you updates as time goes if there is anything
that we're noticing in the numbers here in the Las Vegas Valley or otherwise so thank you for joining us on this episode of trust the process and we will look forward to seeing you next time thanks bye bye thanks for tuning into the press the process podcast make sure to follow us on Spotify to stay in the loop with the latest insights project updates and everything in between see you next time
Trust the Process Podcast | Episode 45 You see the finished homes. We show you the steps it took to get there. Today, one of the steps nobody puts on a highlight reel. The financing. Krista and Michael sit down with...
The 2026 housing market is showing more activity, but that doesn’t necessarily mean it’s getting easier. In this episode of Trust the Process, Krista and Michael take a mid-year look at the Las Vegas housing market -...
Every community has a starting point, and often, it begins with a conversation. In this episode of Trust the Process, Michael and Krista take listeners behind the scenes of Mesa Verde Enclave, a proposed four-home...
S2 Episode 42: Trust the Process Podcast Building a home involves hundreds of decisions, and not all cost-saving choices carry the same impact. In this episode of Trust the Process Podcast, we explore the concept of...
Episode 41: In this episode of Trust the Process Podcast, we pull back the curtain on how our business actually runs day to day. From the outside, it can look like a large operation with endless resources - but in...