Episode 19: In this episode of Trust the Process, we explore why walkability is so elusive in modern suburban development. From wide streets and single-use zoning to the psychological cues that make pedestrians feel unsafe, we unpack the design decisions that have shaped our car-centric cities. We also touch on historical context - from horse paths to high-rises - and why cities in Europe and the East Coast often get walkability right by accident, not by design. We dive into zoning complexities, and ask what it will take for walkable, mixed-use neighborhoods to become more than just a planning ideal. Whether you're in real estate, urban planning, or just curious about how we build better communities, this is a must-listen conversation.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Ever wonder what really happens behind the scenes in construction, real estate, and development? We pull back the curtain on the new home construction industry, the real estate market, and the trends shaping it all. Discover the stories, insights, and expertise behind the process of building a new home. Join us for Trust the Process podcast, and let's build something great together. Welcome back to Trust the Process podcast, where we talk about new homes, the real estate industry. construction
and everything in between. Today we are going to talk a little bit about walkability and that's something that we have touched on a few times. It comes up. I feel like it's come up enough times that it's sort of words. I think so. its own episode. So focusing on that some of the zoning, which is how we've talked about it in the past subdivision stuff, kind of how that comes into play. And there's a lot other countries that are more walkability. And so what that means older cities, cities, East Coast has a lot of
lots of walkability lifestyle. And some of that I think maybe came over. With probably and, and because some of those cities predated the car maybe. Yeah. And we, you know, when our cities are built around the car, which is kind of at odds with walkability. If you think about what's good for the car is not good for the pedestrian in general. Right. And, and we've had a push pull in the last hundred years and the car one. Right. And I think a lot of that is not just legislation or this grand conspiracy by general motors, even though they did buy all the street cars and the, and the Northeastern seaboard. between them and Bridgestone Tire Company bought
and shut down the streetcar lines. A little trivia. We only went back 100 years on that one. We usually go back a lot farther. We're always going to get that little tidbit of history where we can. Walking started about two million years ago. We came from all fours. So that's how I look at it. As a developer, I think that the car and the pedestrian are at odds with each other. And although we do our best to try to do mixed use neighborhoods or make our suburbs walkable, It's you really need a few factors. You need the pedestrian to feel safe. You need density. And then you
need a destination. So if you look at a walkability score, Zillow and this third party syndication sites have walkability scores and you'll never really see a suburb with a walkability score higher than in the 70s. Usually goes zero to 100. And in fact, a lot of them are under 10 or under 15. And I don't exactly know what goes into the formula. I don't even know if it's public information. They just kind of come up with a walkability score. But the way I look at a Michael walkability score is how is the density? So that is shorthand for what's the distances between
here and where you're walking. People are only willing to walk, you know, maybe a mile, mile or two. You might start to see resistance at a two mile because then it's a four mile round trip. It's over an hour of walking. That's a lot of walking. That's a lot. And there are times throughout the year where you just in our city here. Right, right, right. 110. Right. And a mile long walk is good. Yeah, exactly. Not good for your health. Yeah. So if you look at those things, and then you got to look at the safety of the pedestrian. And we talked about this in
one of our other episodes, we're talking about a subdivision and street widths and Minimums and you know sidewalks on both sides. So in one in one hand the city is saying put a sidewalk around your entire cul -de -sac Even though you're only 300 feet from the main roads cul -de -sac or the main streets cul -de -sac. I mean, I'm sorry the main street sidewalk We want a sidewalk to go this extra hundred and thirty feet. It's really nothing I mean, I don't even know how long it take you to walk 130 feet probably under 30 seconds, right? So I get that they're doing the walkability there great the same breath.
They're saying your street is too narrow We're not going to give you a waiver. We want you to do a 47 foot wide, not a 33. Wide streets, scientifically, are less pedestrian friendly from a psychological standpoint. When they pull pedestrians and their overall safety score of a certain route, its street width is a huge Factor and people don't even realize that they just feel it. They say why don't I don't want to walk on this road? I don't I don't want my kid riding his bike on this road. I don't like it. So you look at horizontal distance i .e. street width and then the vertical
element. So if you're hemmed in by something tall next to you and a narrow street, that's the most pedestrian friendly. And then it goes out from there. The farther out, there's actually a ratio on a YouTube channel called City Beautiful. And he's a really, really intelligent city planner. And he breaks it all down. I wish I could find a link, maybe we can embed it. He has, there's a kind of a good golden ratio. You want a certain amount of height. Now at the same time, if you go to lower Manhattan or financial district,
sometimes the height is too much. So the height. You know can be overwhelming depending on but generally speaking you're going to max out this more than you quicker than you're going to max this out. People will tolerate walking next 100 story office buildings more than all tolerate 400 foot wide Boulevard. They're just not going to walk in Houston. Let's say these big wide boulevards and they call them strode. They're not streets. They're not roads and they're First of all, the horizontal plane is so wide, you don't feel comfortable. If you think evolutionary,
ooh, we are gonna go back to two million years. Evolutionarily, I think you're more alert. You feel like you're more on a prairie. There's more threats to you. There's more that could come up on you. So that horizontal element. Then the kicker of this is, since the invention of the car, that horizontal element now involves 3 ,000 pound, 4 ,000 pound. Four -wheeled vehicles with people driving texting and going 35 45 miles an hour going faster because it's wider Those like them. Yeah, exactly. You feel like you can
I mean you're you just naturally do you go down into old East Coast cities or in Europe they have streets with trees between the street and the sidewalk then the sidewalk and then there's a Four or five -story building next to that the drivers just drive slower and then as many times there's cars parked on both sides drive slower, everything there is queuing the driver to slow down, and therefore making the pedestrian feel safer. So if you look at those factors, so you can have virtually queuing. Yeah, yeah, exactly.
Right. And it was it was a function of these were designed for horses and carriages. And now we're trying to fit cars on them. So what was a haphazard retrofit actually ended up to make some really great walkable cities. Then with that, With these roads and everything being narrower and different zoning laws or no zone zoning laws. So many of these cities were built. You stacked everything was stacked, especially after I would have invented the elevator more history. Uh, this one's full of all the ones that were our previous episodes. I've been slipping a little
bit. I think I'm trying to pack them all in here. And I did not think an episode on walkability would have so much history in it, but When Otis invented the elevator, we could start stacking up and it became a status symbol to live on the top floors versus a status symbol to live on the ground level or the mezzanine level. Penthouse is kind of an invention of the 1870s onward. The Dakota apartment building in New York City was one of the first that had a penthouse and it was planned around a square and they kind of created a park space in the middle and I don't know how tall the Dakota was. I think it was
maybe in the 20s floors. And I think it was built in the late 1890s and through the 20s was kind of a Tatey, the Gilded Age and all that in the growing 20s. And that was a status symbol to leave your uptown. Townhouse and live in a high -rise in the penthouse So anyway moral the story is you had tall buildings that hemmed in your visual cues And you didn't have minimum street widths because it just weren't designed. It was no need to conceive of it it's probably designed to be a sidewalk a market stall and wrote room
for a Horse, you know in the original lower Manhattan and Philadelphia and Boston That's kind of how they would have been laid out and most of the cities in Europe laid out that way. So it was just a recipe to be walkable because that is the default for civilization was to walk to your destination. So it's no, what we're living in now is the abomination. What we're living in now is the abnormality, right? So we're trying to correct that. That's a push, I would say from the nineties onward, maybe even later, this whole idea of mixed use, this whole idea of neighborhood
centers, you know, Green Valley Ranch has done it or Yeah, Green Valley Ranch. Yeah, they tried. Right. Even the downtown, you know, that revitalization. Yeah. And a lot of these. Yeah. Above. Right. And hope. But again, it doesn't catch because there's not enough. So what we've done here, it's been a commercial endeavor because it's easier to zone single use. So the commercial is generally highest and best use of a piece of land. If it can do it, if it can sustain it, commercials are way better return on your investment.
for the same development costs, right? Because it is a rarer zoning classification and you have to have the demand for it. So you have to have the traffic and the roads. So you get this commercial center, downtown Summerlin and parts of downtown revitalization districts nationwide, Tivoli, those kinds of places. They're commercial centers first. They're not there's not a residential component to it. Not not particularly. So that's because especially not first. It's it's just so challenging to mix that use and mix a residential
building that has a commercial component to it. East Coast, you can find that all day long. They're all grandfathered in. It's really common back there. So without that mix mixture of uses, you don't have the destinations. So why would someone go drive, park their car and then walk around the commercial under they do it, we do it all the time. But it's not full walkability. There's still a car component to it. They're still off shoot parking and parking garages and things like that. Don't get me wrong. I still think that's a better iteration of a retail center than a shopping mall in my opinion. Just my opinion.
I think it feels it breathes better. It lives better. Um, it's not climatized, which is weird because you could argue that we started there and we went to malls because they're climatized, but people like outdoor shopping. So until we start mixing that, we're not going to see walkability in the suburbs. And you look, Oh, throughout the country, even in new development on the East Coast. DC is notorious for having this outside. I think it's in Arlington or maybe even a suburb of Arlington. And they've tried to catch these multi -family mixed use. Florida's big on it.
It just doesn't land. And it's not associated oddly enough with status. So I think that's part of it too. I think people see you aspire to be spread out. You aspire for low density. You start in an apartment, you end at a house. Maybe you circle back to a condo when you're old age, right? But I feel that it's culturally too. You aspire to have a home on a half acre, a quarter acre. You aspire to have that. So we don't have that aspirational aspect of it on the mixed use, which
until we do that, until we have a mixture of incomes, mixture of housing products, a mixture of uses, a mixture of intensities. You know, is this an intensely zoned? retail center is it kind of just got some retail like how you downtown Santa Barbara or something where you'd say okay there's a little shop or Sedona or something pretty low impact right but until we see that I don't think we're going to see it the market's going to have to want it before this the political pressure is going to be there to allow it so I think it's a chicken does zoning prohibit that
or does it encourage is there In our city and in most cities, you have to do an assemblage. So you have to get a big enough parcel. Usually it's around 25 acres, they have it declassified. So you can have a planning unit development as small as five acres and then 10. When you're looking at commercial would be a neighborhood center and then a power center and then, you know, you kind of go up, there's actually cutoffs for them on a parcel size. So until you get to mixed use, you really have got to get up to around that 25 to 50 acres. So now you're looking at
a developer who can take that kind of project on very capital intensive, and they're pulling in multiple specialties. So generally, you have one developer that's really great at developing office complexes, one that's really great at developing commercial neighborhood centers, power centers, and then a residential developer that's pretty good to me decently good mediocre at developing residential maybe So it's hard to get all those combined and think that where it's worked really well. There's a couple examples in Florida where
it's worked pretty well. One maybe land developer, similar to how we have a master plan here, they'll develop the idea, the parks, the other amenities, and sell the individual parcels to homebuilders. So you'll see that there's the one in DC I was mentioning, they bought the big acreage, and sold to the office to people that do offices really well sold to commercial those and so on and so forth. invented those builders to say, okay, you're going to build a multifamily product who told brothers is really good at building luxury multifamily product. KB is good at building
and when I was good at building the entry level multifamily product, and they kind of bring in that assortment of offerings and capture and lean on that builder to have a financial incentive to say, we're going to brand this as an aspirational place to be. We're going to say you can aspire for a condo because it's a $2 million condo is very luxurious. You have amenities that you're not going to get in a single family home. So I think that We're getting there and maybe maybe the future is a mixture of everything like it has been the last 20 years has been a mixture of everything predominantly single family zoning.
What do you see apartments that surround I'm thinking about summerland center in specific there's there are apartments nearby that you write it in that kind of give that it's not necessarily in the center but. That's not purchase it's not home so right purchase right so you have that community field yeah so you're you know you've got a very transient and again people look at apartments as transient and you aspire to be somewhere else so you have to build an aspirational. aspect of it so and i don't think necessarily that we have to do something i'm passionate about
but i live in the most non -walkable uh suburb that you know i could pick in an already pretty much unwalkable city so look what i chose i mean it's it's fun i mean i'm not saying everyone should live like that i just feel like it'd be neat if we saw more of it and i think it would lead to more vibrant cities and also the city that takes up a lot less land when you think about how big las vegas could get phoenix could get When, if you zoned it, even with the missing middle that we talked about in the previous podcast, you doesn't only need to be zoned downtown. But
what about that missing middle, that mid -rise, that four to eight story, a lot of mixed juice. You could fit a lot of amenities and a lot of people. And then, so let's say every morning I get up and go to Orange Theory, right? And that is a trip. But if I lived in a walkable area, I'd walk to it. So yeah, you got a lot of people and you'd say, oh, what about traffic, traffic, traffic? Yeah, but some of my trips, if there was a grocery store, a lot of my trips would be walkable. And I would have our office, which is actually really close to my home. I have to drive there. I can't I mapped I couldn't
walk it. I have to cross have to get out of my neighborhood cross a major four lane road, then cross an eight lane inner highway. the 215. And then a bunch of other two lane streets with signalized intersections and stop signs. So just it's not it's not possible. So I think about the amount of trips I have my trips would be cut down 30, you know, they'd be 30 % of what they are. So I think that that would cut down on traffic and it'd be more sustainable. Well, we'll just see I mean, we'll see what the next gender how the
next generation Wants to live and that's gonna dictate it previous generations wanted to live that way, right? You know, so that was the norm for them. That's all they knew Yeah, maybe maybe that's why they're not away from it because it feels again. It's aspirational Yeah, my parents of this I aspire to do this So I think that if you also look at back even just a few generations ago my grandmother still going, never go to bike and never had driver's license. So she lives in New York, she, she does she walks everywhere takes the city bus, or my cousins bring her my
uncle brings her and they all take care of her. So the idea of her living out in a suburb would just be anathema to everything that she's ever grown up thinking is just No, I'm not. Why would I do that? So it's it's as crazy as putting one of us in a You know for for walk up. Yeah, just transportation and get you guys on the bus. She's 92 years old. She gets on the bus. That's not just doesn't happen much. No, it doesn't happen here as much as it does in other cities. Right. Obviously, we don't we have I mean, over the
years, they have done a lot they have to. I think a lot of suburban cities have Phoenix has tried to try and increase the different routes and then, you know, make it quicker. And it's still isn't people's go to method for transport. No, it's not. And then we weren't really ever laid out that way. So it's always going to be fitting a circle into a square because I bet you I've never done it. But I bet you to take a bus from anywhere around here to the center of town. would be a 20 mile 20 minute drive for me probably two hour bus ride multiple stops and transfers
and right you're stopping and I don't know what they express lane I don't I don't know how that works but I mean I just imagine it's not laid out like that was never designed to be that way so passionate about walkability I think a lot of our zoning laws are at odds with it minimum street widths and you think about our little subdivisions and how an extra 10 feet of street, it really adds up and it makes a city sprawl. Minimum lot sizes, it makes it sprawl and then sprawl breeds sprawl because then more people need cars. So then more people want houses that
accommodate cars and streets that accommodate cars and multigenerational living. And I love that when a builder will build a multigenerational. 4000 square foot house with a two car garage and a two car driveway. Where are the people that are living in this 4000 square foot home going to park their cars? Where are they going? Where is grandma's living with you? Where is she going to park? So it just I again, I think it's it's going to be market driven. And it's going to be maybe an evolution. And it's going to take some public policy. It's also going to
take some loaning that some changes in lending. Um, so if you think about how challenging it is to get a condo loan versus a single family home, there's so many factors that are set up for the way that we're, that we're building and built to this day. So I don't think it'll be a mile. I don't think I'll be building multifamily walkable communities. It's just not, I don't think it would take so long for the tides to change and for people to actually want that and for it to be marketable. But it is an interesting topic, and a lot of people from other cities
see it as a viable way to change things. And so you get asked, why aren't we building more of that? Why don't we have some of that in our lives anymore? So yeah, worth mentioning and a good one. And like I said, it's come up in several of the podcasting episodes that we've talked about. We touch on it here and there, but so kind of diving into it a little bit further. Thank you. Yeah, of course. It was fun to talk about. And thank you guys for joining us and we will see you next time on Trust the Process podcast. Bye bye. Thanks for tuning into the
Trust the Process podcast. Make sure to follow us on Spotify to stay in the loop with the latest insights, project updates, and everything in between. See you next time.
Trust the Process Podcast | Episode 45 You see the finished homes. We show you the steps it took to get there. Today, one of the steps nobody puts on a highlight reel. The financing. Krista and Michael sit down with...
The 2026 housing market is showing more activity, but that doesn’t necessarily mean it’s getting easier. In this episode of Trust the Process, Krista and Michael take a mid-year look at the Las Vegas housing market -...
Every community has a starting point, and often, it begins with a conversation. In this episode of Trust the Process, Michael and Krista take listeners behind the scenes of Mesa Verde Enclave, a proposed four-home...
S2 Episode 42: Trust the Process Podcast Building a home involves hundreds of decisions, and not all cost-saving choices carry the same impact. In this episode of Trust the Process Podcast, we explore the concept of...
Episode 41: In this episode of Trust the Process Podcast, we pull back the curtain on how our business actually runs day to day. From the outside, it can look like a large operation with endless resources - but in...