Lessons from Dozens of Charter School Visits with Nanette Merrill
48 minAudio
Nanette Merrill, executive director of the Idaho Charter School Association, has visited close to 60 schools in her first year on the job. She tells Mike Caldwell what builds a strong school culture: a leader who knows the mission, can say it out loud, and sticks to it. Merrill's test for a good leader came from parents: "I don't know what you do in this school, but they're as happy when I drop them off as when I pick them up." She also describes the coaching program she is starting for Idaho charter leaders, with six coaches and five artifacts each school builds. What you'll learn Practice your mission until you can say it in 90 seconds to a parent or legislator who has never heard it. Get out of your office and into classrooms to check the joy factor, as Merrill urges leaders to do. Treat your school as a school of choice, whatever its type, and be ready to say why families should pick it. Practice difficult conversations at low stakes, including with an AI sparring partner, before the high-pressure ones arrive. Find a coach or mentor, whether you are aspiring, brand new or near the end of your career. Chapters 0:00 From stay-at-home mom to executive director 5:33 Rapid fire: books, advice and AI 15:17 First signs of a strong school culture 17:44 Is mission focus only for charter schools 26:26 What 60 school visits taught her 31:02 What school leaders need most right now 36:09 Idaho's new coaching program for charter leaders Questions this episode answers What are the signs of a great school when you walk in? Merrill says the strongest schools have strong leaders with a clear mission. The leaders can state it, know their students and staff by name, and the culture shows in the walls and every classroom. Students high-fiving the principal is a good sign. Do traditional public schools need a mission like charter schools have? Merrill sees it as both/and. Traditional schools have broader missions, and charters have niche ones. Host Mike Caldwell argues every school competes for families, so every leader should believe in the mission and sell it. What do school leaders need most right now? Merrill hears four needs: leadership development and coaching, board governance training for new board members, finance help when funding is thin, and training in difficult conversations. Single-site charter leaders especially want thought partners. About Nanette Merrill Executive director of the Idaho Charter School Association, a former principal and the 2013 Oregon Teacher of the Year. Working on this at your school? Get a free preview of a 10-week leadership pathway built from episodes like this one at transformativeprincipal.com/start. Thanks to our Sponsor Broadcast Made Easy who help you start a news broadcast at your school by having everything you need in one easy-to-download place. Check it out today and get your kids creating. We’re proud to be sponsored by IXL. IXL’s comprehensive teaching and learning platform for math, language arts, science, and social studies is accelerating achievement in 95 of the top 100 U.S. school districts. Loved by teachers and backed by independent research from Johns Hopkins University, IXL can help you do the following and more: Simplify and streamline technology Save teachers’ time Reliably meet Tier 1 standards Improve student performance on state assessments 🚀 Ready to see why leading districts trust IXL for their educational needs? Visit IXL.com/BE today to learn more about how IXL can elevate your school or district.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
All right. Hello, and welcome to another episode of the Transformative Principal podcast. This is Mike Caldwell, your host, still subbing for Jethro Jones. Joining me today is Nanette Merrill, executive director for the Idaho Charter School Network and a friend. Nanette, thanks for joining me. Yes. Thank you, Mike, for having me. I'm glad to be here. One quick correction, it's the Idaho Charter School Association. Thank you. Um, so I'm just really glad to be here, and thank you for inviting me. Absolutely. Well, we'll get into some rapid fire questions, but, uh, Nanette, you've worn a lot of hats in your career, teacher, principal, founding charter leader, executive director.
Why don't you give a little bit of your background, um, even though I've just kind of gave a little bit of, like, your roles, but- Mm-hmm … kind of what you're doing now and, and maybe some more detail to your background. Yeah. Well, I actually had the unique pleasure of being an at-home mom for 17 years before I went into the workforce, and sometimes I think that that's what helped me be a good school, uh, educator and, and leader because I had that mom lens, and I wanted to treat all the students how I wanted my own children to be treated. So actually being home 17 years, I think, was a great foundational, um, preparation for the work that I do in schools.
But, um, was a teacher in Oregon and administrator and navigated over to Idaho not knowing anything about charter, and my first job, administration job here in Idaho was in charter, and then I just loved it. I loved the opportunity of providing unique, you know, pathways and environments for students and having choices, um, for families to choose from, so I've stayed in that sector since I came over here. But, um, I was a teacher.
I was only actually a teacher for n- nine years before I moved into leadership. Yeah. And you were in tradit- traditional public schools in Oregon? I was, yep. I was in traducti- tr- traditional public schools. I had the unique, um, honor of being the 2013 Oregon Teacher of the Year, and that was just a whirlwind year of amazing professional development and, and connections and networking and trying to be a voice for Oregon educators. Um, but I really made some great connections through that.
And I loved, loved teaching, but I wanted to take that love beyond the four walls of my classroom, and after that experience, I was feeling, uh, very confined to the four walls of my classroom, which is then what led me into leadership and trying to have a larger impact on a student body versus a single classroom. And now I'm in a role where I get to have an impact on lots of schools instead of just one school that I was leading. So that's, um, just widening that audience, trying to make a larger impact in, in the work that I do and, and what I value- Yeah … in education for kids.
Absolutely. I share, share that same, uh- I guess, goal, I guess, is, you know, y- you're a school leader for so long and, and I, like you, had a g- really great experience. And now with, you know, I work with link leaders and some other stuff, is just really trying to make a greater impact and kinda give back to kind of all the things you learn and, and help other leaders along the way. Mm-hmm. Which is gonna be our big focus today, is, is leadership quality and excellence, and we'll jump into that. You know, you mentioned, it just stuck with me when you mentioned, um, parenting had, had a significant impact to you on preparing you to be probably both a teacher and a leader.
Is that- Mm-hmm … right? Yeah. Mm-hmm. You know what had the most impact on me, and I say this tongue in cheek, is being a waiter in a- restaurant. A lot of patience? No. I always use this analogy, but think about it. When you're a, when you're, uh, a… Did you ever work in food service? I just feed my children. Okay, so maybe similar. But- … I was a, I was a busser and then waiter and, and, uh, I don't think I've shared this story on the podcast, but, like, when you're a waiter, you have, let's say you have six tables going on, right?
You ha- you just had a f- a, p- people sit down that need their drinks. They need menus. You have another table that is waiting for dessert. Another table that's waiting for their check. Another table that has, you know, entrees coming out or whatever else. And you have to keep track of all those things at once. There's people involved, so there's the relational piece, right? So if you… You can't just, you can't just ignore them. You gotta know what they need and, and, and who comes first. So this, this constant prioritization, right? And then you go back to the kitchen and they, and the chef just burnt your food.
That's, that's still on you, right? Like, you still are taking the brunt of that. Mm-hmm. So you're in the middle of, of, of that war. So for all those, you're listening, skip the four-year degree. Start with food service. That's what's gonna prepare you to be a principal. Well, I think it's 'cause it's… Leadership is servitude and it's, you know, you have to wear that, that badge, I guess, if you will, with a servitude lens. Because you're exactly right.
Instead of tables that we're bussing, they're, they're either teachers or, you know, other school leaders, depending upon, you know, your role in education. And, and it's very much service, and service with a smile, even on the hard days. Even when it's not your fault. Right. Exactly. When it usually, when it's… Yeah, when it's policy or it's… Right. Exactly. Yeah. All right. I have some rapid fire questions for you. Are you ready? Yep. You warmed up? All right. Hit me. Yep. One leadership book every principal should read.
Oh, my goodness. There's so many. Um- You know, honestly, this is gonna be a silly one, but it's probably the one that I reference the most, is The Energy Bus. And it- John Gordon, I think is the author of it. Ah, it's a good one. Yep. Because school culture is so important, and you are the driver of that bus when you're a school leader. And if you've got people on your bus that don't wanna be there, they will derail your mission quickly.
And I just, it was a really easy, light read, um, but it really helped me recognize, I- y- you're gonna have some energy vampires in your school, and, and they're gonna impact it negatively. So really recognizing how to address those, um, to get them on your bus in a healthy way. So, uh, it's super easy read, and I know that there's so many other books out there that are really content heavy and great reads, but this one's a super easy one. And it will really impact how you, the culture that you have in your schools.
'Cause culture matters. Culture eats everything else. Yep. Yep. Absolutely. Yeah, it's a good one. I remember reading, listening to that one in audiobook. Um, uh, it, it's a good one. What are you reading right now? Um, actually I am part of a cohort of a leadership, and there are a lot of readings that come with that, that is taking up a lot of time. I don't know if I can say what cohort I belong to, so I'm not going to. Um, but there's just so much reading that comes with that, that that's actually lots of little things.
But it's, the whole content and premise of it is about diversity, and really accepting diversity in a leadership role, and the importance of it, and recognizing it. Um, and, and just navigating that, whether it's, you know, religion or color or race or whatever the diversity is, recognizing when you have biases and addressing those quickly. Yeah. Cool. Um, I'm reading Time for Change. Have you read this? Mm. Sorry, I forgot I'm doing rapid fire questions.
This didn't turn it into a rapid fire question. Time for Change: Four Essential Skills for Transform- Transformational School and District Leaders. Mm. Muhammad and Cruz. It's a good one, um, if you haven't picked that one up. So, all right. I wonder when you have time to read. That's my challenge. I… The time I have to read is at night, and then I'm too tired and I have to reread what I reread the night before. Truthfully, two things. One is I buy the book, but I try to listen to it in audiobook- Mm-hmm … when I'm driving or biking.
Okay. And then I'll use the hard copy to go back and highlight or whatever, whatever I listened to and maybe wanna reference. So I like having the combo. Uh, but yeah, true. Mm-hmm. And then I, I usually have one book I'm reading at my nightstand that I, that I try to get to kind of on, on the daily, and those are usually different books. Okay. Yeah. Back to the rapid fire, um, Nanette. You slowed us down. Um- Yeah. Best advice you ever received as a school leader? Hmm.
Um Be reflective You know, be reflective in, in decisions that you make. Was that the right decision? Was that not the right decision? Be reflective in your goals and reevaluate. Be prepared to pivot when you need to pivot. Um, I, I think sometimes, and, and I'm guilty of this even as a classroom teacher, like I have my schedule, and we have this block of time that we have to have this done, and it was really hard for me when students were not understanding something to recognize, slow down, fix it, and then it'll be, they'll be stronger for it, and, and to pivot based upon, you know, observations.
And I think school leaders need to do the same. We have these goals that we set, and yes, we need to have those targets, and we need to reach for them. But if we're not reflective about how is it going, do I need to pivot, do I need to change it 'cause that was too easy, um, and we've met that. Um, even when you have conversations with, you know, teachers or parents, always be reflective on could I have done better? You know, did that go really well, and what made it really well so I can do it again? Yeah. Indeed.
Mine is probably, what sticks out to me is people over programs. I think it's chapter three of Todd Whitaker's book of- Mm … um, eight- what is it? 18, um, what, what great 18 things that great principals do, I think it, is the book. Yeah. Or maybe it's 15 things. There's different versions of it. But, uh, people over programs, that one stuck with me the most. Uh- Mm-hmm … programs are important, but people always come first in kind of- Mm-hmm … developing your relationships and focusing on, on the people in your building. All right- And that, that complements the reflection or the, you know, be reflective because those re- relationships matter.
Yep. Absolutely. One thing every classroom should have Besides a teacher or I was gonna say, is this like a, a physical thing or… 'Cause I was gonna say love. I'll take that. I love it. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I can't top that one. Not that I'm trying to top your questions, but I can't, I, I, I ac- It kind of feels that way, Mike, a little bit. Yeah. Yeah. One up, one-upping you. That's all right. You'll always up me. That's okay. Oh, you said love.
I say more love. Okay. M- the most love. The most, the mostest love. Um- Yeah … one leadership habit you never skip. And I guess that's related to the other answer, but you could choose a different answer. Commitment. Whoa. Mm-hmm. I like it. You have to be committed to the work that you're doing, 'cause you're never gonna be adequately compensated. You're gonna work your whole life trying to find balance between work and life, and you're not gonna find it.
Just be committed to the work and, um, a- and doing what's best for students. I would say be committed until you get committed. Ooh. To the- There you go … to the funny farm or whatever. How do you know when you get, when you're there? Oh, you'll know. You'll know. All right. La- You have to be reflective. Yeah. There you go. Yeah. With love. The last q- last rapid fire question. Coolest thing you've done with AI?
Um, you know, I'll be really candid. I was very nervous about AI and it coming into the world. You know, you hear comments like almost intelligent or, you know. Um, I don't use AI a ton, but it is incredibly helpful for polishing things. So I like it to be my work, and then I like to throw it into AI and let them polish it. I really like AI to help me aggregate data as well, when I can throw in, in some data and ask some questions, and it can really-- It's a really kind of a good thought partner, actually.
But I haven't created, like, anything Worth writing home about using AI, but it's a great thought partner, and it is incredibly helpful to polish things for me. All right. I'll take it. You're much more techy, so I know you can top that one. Yeah. I, I do a lot of stuff with AI on the daily, but, uh- Mm-hmm … just building stuff, being creative. I just installed my first, like, full-scale agent that I have conversations with that's through the, through the terminal.
Wow. On a personal level, my, my father passed away last year, both my mother and my father at different times, and they have a 75-page life sketch, and I was tasked with writing their obituaries. And it was incredibly helpful to put that whole life sketch in there and ask for a 450-word obituary. Now, obviously I took it and massaged it and tweaked it till it really said what I wanted it to say, but it saved me hours of con- 'cause everything I thought in there was important in their life sketch.
So on a personal note, that was really, really helpful. Very sorry to hear about your grandfather. Oh, my dad. Yeah. Thanks. Oh, your dad. I'm sorry. Yeah. Um- I could've said grandfather, but my dad, yeah. Yeah, they, they lived a good, full life, so. Yeah. I was just gonna go something I, I, I'm not gonna go there, uh, about AI and, and past relatives, but, uh, we'll, we'll save that an- to, for another episode. Um, let's talk about kind of the work you, you, over the last year you've, you've … It's been a year and then what, a month, since you took the role as executive director for the IA, uh, the- IA … Association.
ICSA, yes. I was gonna mess up, I was gonna mess that up. I about did too. So we're talking about great schools, great, strong leadership. You've visited a lot of schools over the last year in your new role. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. When you walk into a school, what are the first signs that tell you this is going to be a great place for students? Mm-hmm. Yeah. And you can feel it. You really can feel it. Um, and it's, it gets back to that culture piece, and I think-
The strongest leaders that, or the strongest schools I've s- seen have very strong leaders. And they, they have a clear mission, you know, 'cause with charter schools we're unique by design. They all have a unique mission serving a unique set of students. They, the strongest schools and the strongest leaders know that mission. They can speak to it. They can tell you what it is. They can tell you what the value add that they bring to the charter sector is, and they stick to it.
They're not trying to figure out who they are. They know who they are. And so as a school of choice, when families are, you know, are choosing their school of choice, these strong leaders can speak to why choose them? What do they offer? Um, and, and that stands out for sure. So they, uh, just have a very, very intentional school culture, and it usually is around whether it's an expeditionary learning school or a college prep or, you know, um, a CTE school.
They, they, they know their mission. They stick to it, and they foster that in all that they do in their communication and all things. Um, and that comes from great leaders really knowing who they are and what their school stands for and why they were chosen. Um, because you know, Mike, you were a school leader. You have parents that, you know, they want things a certain way or they're like, "Oh, you know, gosh, if you would just do this, that would be really helpful." And when you start pivoting to please, whether it's a staff member or a parent, y- you, you start changing who you are as a school.
Now, if it's a good suggestion that supports your mission, that's a different thing. Um, but I think those leaders that are really true to, to their mission and they know it and they can speak to it and they have an allegiance to serving families within that value add that they bring. You know, um I, sometimes, I mean, the, the idea of mission-focused, you know, gets, um, I don't know, directed more towards kind of the non-traditional public education charter.
I was- I spent a lot of time in private school and, you know, we were very, very mission-focused. Yet traditional schools have missions, and many of our traditional public schools, um, I mean, they all have mission statements, right? Um, there is no reason, and I don't think it's, it's true that the, being mission-focused is something that's unique to a m- school model, right? Of a charter or a pri- public or whatever else.
I think there is a difference- Mm-hmm … between having a niche focus for a school, whether it's private where, you know, Catholic-focused or whatever else, or you're a charter that's focused on CTE or whatever else. Mm-hmm. T- push back if you disagree. A traditional public school, one, does have a mission- Mm-hmm statement, and they do have a mission, but sometimes it gets maybe too generalized and maybe not put out in front as this is our mission as a, as a, as a school, right?
Do you, do you think it's unique to charters or, or non-traditional s- schools, kind of the mission focus? You know, I was an administrator in Oregon at a traditional school, and I mean, w- w- we had a mission and it wasn't, it wasn't like a innovative or, or unique to serve a certain population of students. It was a, you know, to serve all students that walked in our doors. And, and I think charters believe that as well.
I think they wanna serve all students that walk in their doors, but as a school of choice, they were cho- they chose that school for a reason So I think that they, they have a mission. Uh, um, it's just m- maybe at a broader lens instead of, you know, a unique. But I think sometimes at a traditional school, they're also providing opportunities for students. And, and h- I think their reflection, if you will, needs to be more about how well are we delivering those opportunities.
Um, they mi- they're probably just more broad than what a charter school is, 'cause that's a very specific mission that they, that value add. And, and I, I think that's my challenge, you know, in traditional and, and, and charter school. It's not an either/or. It's a both/and. They're both serving a purpose of serving students. I'm not answering your question very well, Mike, but I, I think that they ha- in their mind they do. They do have a mission, and they wanna do what's best for students, and I really truly believe that.
I think charters wanna do what's best for student, but this is what we're offering. Right. Yeah, and I'm not so much … I'm not, I'm not challenging you per se. I think I'm challenging- Mm-hmm … the listener that if regardless of what… I think this is where my mind is on this conversation, is I don't care what school you're leading. Mm-hmm. You do have a mission. Mm-hmm. And you should lead with your mission.
And if you also don't believe, I, you know, that you have the mindset as we're also a school of choice, because if you're surrounded by other schools where students choose, that makes you a school of choice. And whether I'm a- Good point traditional, charter- Mm-hmm … private, and if there is competition in the room- Mm-hmm … I'm a school of, I'm now a school of choice. And if I'm not out there selling my mission and, and really, you know, believing in my mission, then w- why would people choose you?
Like- And- Does that make sense? Yeah. It does. And you're right. Ev- every school's a school of choice. It, because there's- Unless there's no choices. That's right. But, but even if there's- Yeah … no, no choices, parents can still say, "We're gonna homeschool. We're not gonna…" You know? So truly every school- And- … is really a school of choice. And I hope, I hope the mission of every school leader is When a parent chooses them, private, public, whatever the case may be, their mission is to provide the best, safest learning environment for every child that walks in there, because that's what matters to families.
They want to know that they've dropped off their most precious possession, and it is going to be loved and taken care of throughout the day With learning happening as well, right? They want them to learn, but ultimately they want them to be safe and they want them to be loved. And, you know, and that's one thing that meant a lot to me as a school leader when parents would say, "I don't know what you do in this school, but they're as happy when I drop them off as when I pick them up." And that was my litmus test. Was I do- Yeah … was I a good leader? Because are, are children happy while they're here?
That's what parents want to know. So every school leader's mission should be along those lines. Am I fostering an environment that's not only rigorous and academic, but learning, but do kids feel safe and loved and wanna be here? Do staff feel safe and loved and wanna be here? Yeah. Absolutely. Yeah, I was coaching some, um, a leader yesterday. It was a, he was setting goals for this next year and, um, we were talking about all these, these, these same things. And, you know, one of the things that they were struggling with and, and, and trying to focus on is attendance.
Like, their attendance was abysmal in the past. And, you know, part of the conversation got start to get hung up on initiatives like, um, you know, calling parents, set, calling, uh, at home, you know, and incentives and things like that. And, you know, as we talk through it, really the focus really is on what you just talked about, but, you know, that sense of belonging. Students- Mm-hmm … they feel like they belong and they feel valued. And same for teachers, right? Like- Mm-hmm … you're not gonna go to, want to go to a place if you don't feel like you belong there, if you don't feel this val- that there's value in, in going there, and you feel valued.
Mm-hmm. And so I absolutely agree. And that's what our- And- … what, what parents want. I mean, right? Yeah Like And that's why leaders have to be out of their offices. They have to be out and visible in the classrooms, in the school, constantly checking on that joy factor that you really want fostered. I mean, 'cause I, I tell teachers all the time, "You can have rigor, you can have difficult academics and differentiate academics," but it can all be delivered with a joy factor as well, because that's, that's when they're gonna engage and be invested in their learning, is when it's fun.
Especially in the day and age we live in now. I mean, they've got, you know, all the electronics in the world and, and fun through that. So teachers have to be providing that joy factor that really has them engaging and, and school leaders have to be out monitoring that that's happening. Mm-hmm. I was a school leader that had a cart. Like, I was mobile. I was in the hallways and I decorated and it was- Yeah … seasonal, but they knew where to find me. Now, now, now one of, there's a leader out there making his whole career TikToking on, on his, his cart.
I don't know if you know the leader I'm talking about- Mm-hmm … who I'll mention, but- I do. Yeah. Yeah That w- there was some of my best days when I was out, you know, you know- Mm-hmm … in a cart or out working, you know, in a, we had kinda different tables along in, you know, throughout our halls. So I didn't necessarily have to have a cart, but sometimes I did, but sometimes I'd just post up in particular area of the b- halls, and that'd be my office- Mm-hmm for the next few hours. I loved it. Yeah. I'd, I had a whiteboard on my cart, and I'd sometimes do, like, a happy birthday to so-and-so if it was students' birthdays, or I would, um, question of the day.
If they got it right, I had a sticker. Oh. So they would interact with me on my cart, so it was really fun to… But that allowed me to keep a pulse on the- Oh, yeah teaching and learning in the building by being out and being present. Yep. Highl- highly recommend it for those that are listening. It's a, yeah, it's a good, great practice. Well, one of the thing- things I, as I look back at my leadership, um, experience, one of the things I loved is to, to, you know, the pivot was a big pivot from going from a teacher to a school leader, is you got to go into all these different teachers' rooms and learn, you know, different strategies.
And I- Mm-hmm … learned so much about teaching when I stopped teaching. You know? Yes. And, and just to go and see all the t- all the, all the teachers in your building. And in your role, and, and in, and in, in my role in over the last few years, we both got to experience going in in a similar way into a lot of different schools, right? And, and seeing, you know, going into buildings and talking to leaders and seeing what they're doing. And over this last year in your new role, you've got to go into close to 60 different schools, probably 60 plus at this point, right?
Um- Mm-hmm … so I'm really curious about your take on that experience. What, um- Maybe start with this. What, of all the schools that you've seen, and you don't have to name schools, but what practices within those schools have you seen that made you stop and think, "More schools should be doing this"? Well, there's so many, actually. I actually, it's funny that you ask that question, 'cause I think I could go back and be a better school leader than I was because I've watched so many school leaders- Totally, yeah
over this past year. Um Ask me your question one more time, Mike. What, what have I seen that- Yeah, I s- I said what practices, but it doesn't, you, you- Oh, okay … you pick what, what, what have you seen that made you stop and think more schools should be doing this? Um, that's a- Give a few quick examples … that's a really tricky question because as I have visited charter schools, there's, like I said, so many unique pathways. There's classical, there's CTE, there's college readiness, there's at-risk, you know, students.
There's, there's just so many different ones, um, that are doing it really well that are serving the population, you know, that, that, that they need to be serving. Um- I, I think the, the most successful schools I've seen have really strong governance, great relationships with their board, support from their board. Um, they also have a culture that when you walk in, it is clear. And sometimes it's the mission.
Sometimes it's how their walls are decorated and how it's supporting their mission. You're like, "Oh, wow, they really know who they are, and that's what I see in every classroom I go in." Um, and so it really varies. I, I think the biggest thing is just that, you know, I've, I've walked around schools with school leaders that can call each student by name, and, and they, they know them. They know their staff, they know their students. Um, you can tell they care deeply about them, and the s- they're very approachable.
You know, when students come up and are high-fiving a building leader that I'm with, you can tell that there's a good relationship there. And, and so I think those are kinda some of the things that I've seen that when I walk out, I would think, "Oh, man, my child would've really loved that." But it's unique, 'cause I have four grown children, and every single one of them would probably go to a different type of charter school based upon their personalities and their, and their life goals. And so I think, again, the, the schools that have stayed true to who they are and their, their mission is evident when you walk in the building, and, and the relationships that are evident that they have within that building, whether it's with staff or students, those are the ones that I walk out thinking, "That was such a good experience.
I would want my child to go to that school." And, and, and I would say it's m- probably all the schools that I have visited in some format, um, walking away thinking, "Wow, that's great." I-- Somebody asked me one day, they said, "You know, if you went back to be a school leader, would you go back to where you were or would you go somewhere different?" I'm like, I-- That was a really tough question for me. I loved where I was, but I've seen some really cool, um, charter schools that I, that are doing really cool things with kids. Yeah.
Anything that surprised you? That you didn't expect or anything like that? I don't know. I've been in administration so long, I don't think anything surprises me these days. Yeah, that's true. Yeah. Yeah. It, it just the variety. I think the variety of, of, of schools and options out there. I, I didn't know. I, I knew the charter organization that I worked for, and it has just been so inspiring to see all the options that are out there for, for students.
I, I think it's, it's amazing, and I really admire the parents that are figuring out what is best for their child, whether it's private, traditional, charter, whatever the case may be. Parents are doing their homework and trying to find the right school. Yeah. And that's commendable. Yep. Absolutely. What, what are you seeing as themes, common themes, um, for needs right now with school leaders? Um, you know, we're both working in different ways to support leaders out there. Um, you specifically in, in, in your state.
What are, what are some of the things that you're seeing as common themes? You know, leaders are asking for leadership development, and that, and that looks very different of what that development looks like. Um, the single site charters, you know, they, they operate a lot in isolation. You know that you worked with a lot of them, and they're, they're looking for thought partners. They're looking for camaraderie to grow. Um, for coaches that will help them, you know, be better in what they're doing. And, and actually, the years of experience seem really irrelevant.
You know, you've got brand new leaders and leaders that have been doing it a long time that still wanna learn and grow. I love the growth mindsets that I've, you know, encountered in this work. Um- Board governance rises to the top when I have conversations. It's either really strong or it's a challenge, and I think part of that comes from the lack of training when bringing on new board members, um, because that's important. Like, they, they join for, you know, they wanna be helpful.
They really do, but if they're not taught or trained in the roles and responsibilities of a board versus a school leader, those lines can sometimes get blurred. And so it's just a lack of training, so they're asking for, you know, help and support with that. Um, finance, which I don't deal with finance. That's, that's also, you know, trying to do more with less 'cause the funding just isn't there, and they're trying to be really creative and, and, and thoughtful in how they use those dollars. So that rises to the top.
Um, so I would say board governance, finance, um, school leadership, and, and one of the other things, and you and I have talked about this, Mike, a number of times, is really having some training in, in having difficult conversations and, and how do I handle things. You know, nobody likes those tough conversations. Nobody likes, um, gotta let a staff member go or, you know, gotta have a difficult conversation with a parent based upon a choice that their child made.
Nobody likes those conversations. Right. And, and I think the more training that they can have in how to navigate those, they're gonna go smoother. And I don't know about you, but that wasn't in my admin training, how to, how to have difficult conversations 'cause you have 'em regularly. Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. On that, on that note, I mean, I think if you're in, I think just any leadership, not just school leadership or, or whatever, if you're in leadership and if you can't, um, if you are avoidant when it comes to those difficult conversations- Mm-hmm
I don't think you're gonna last long. I mean, th- you just have to… If those aren't skills or comforts, it- those can be trained. You can, you can build those, you know? Mm-hmm. I think there, there's, there's a way to get there. No one's comfortable with it out of the gate, right? I think it's just human tendency to, to kind of stay away from that. Some people are just more naturally comfortable than others. Um, I missed your… I would love to, to hear more about, I've heard really good things about what you led in, in June with the charter leaders. But I think it's- Mm-hmm … it's really important that people go out and seek the, seek training, but then have a lot of at bats at it when you get to it.
Uh, like, before it gets super, like, you know- Yeah … high pressure, like, I think there's a w- lot of ways that you can practice these, you know, difficult conversations at lower stakes so that you can get, you know, get more muscle memory and comfortable with those types of things. I- I think there's a place for AI for that, by the way. I, I was just gonna say that. I think there's, there's your thought partner, you know, that you can spar with until you have to have that. But I think it's important for school leaders to model that for their teachers, because teachers get into parent-teacher conferences.
And again, I don't, I don't think that's in any pre-service training, you know, how to have a difficult conversation with a parent. Um, but the more training that they can have in those, the, the better the re- the resolution or the, the, the, how the con- you know, conversation ends. I always say clear is kind. You know, that being clear does not mean that you're pointing out somebody's flaws. You're, you know, it, it is kind 'cause we grow from those. I would want people to be clear with me. But there, there is training that must come with that.
And, and like you said, we have a great tool right now that will help us spar back and forth when you're needing to have a difficult conversation. But avoidance is not the answer, and training needs to come from leaders to their teachers and from- You know, training for leaders, whether it's attending a conference or reaching out to, you know, you or I or those that are in the sector trying to help leaders be the best version of themselves. Yeah. Well, you, you are starting up, um, kind of some coaching, mentoring within, within the association to support leaders.
Um, with Link Leaders, that's exactly what we're doing as well. I think every school leader should have access to a mentor or for, to a coach. And I don't care if you're aspiring and not in the seat yet, you're brand new, or you're at the end of your career. I think there is… I think everyone should have one or have access to one. And it sounds like you are kind of pushing that or getting that rolling, um, in Idaho. Mm-hmm. So do you want to talk a little bit about your approach and how you're doing it, what areas you're focused on?
Well, I, yes, I do wanna talk about it. Thank you for asking. We, um, in my visitations to all the schools and really learning with school leaders what's taking up your bandwidth, what's, you know, causing some challenges, there were just some certain artifacts, whether it be a succession plan or even a job description, um, that some schools didn't have. And so really working with a group of school leaders to, um, help develop some artifacts. If they just had these in place, it'd be really helpful. So putting those in place, but then also being available for all the other stuff, for the difficult conversations, for… We've got school leaders that are possibly thinking about expanding.
Rather than figure that out by yourself, let's connect you with somebody that's done it, um, already. Or we've got some, some leaders that are struggling with academics, so I brought on a specialist that's really strong in academics that's gonna help a couple school leaders strengthen their academics. How do I look at data? How do I, you know, use that to coach teachers in the classroom? So there's, there's five artifacts that they will create, and one of them actually is that, um, instructional foundation. Who are you as a charter school, and can you speak to that?
Can you do a 90-second elevator speech of who you are, um, in a really powerful way that when a legislator or a parent or somebody walks away from you, they're like, "Wow, that's where I want my child to go"? So coaching along those lines, because those are some areas that I saw that, boy, if we could strengthen this in our charter sector, lots, lots of stakeholders would benefit from it. Yeah. But then also being, um, a thought partner for various things that they might be working on or be challenged with within their school.
So I'm really excited about it. Um, it, yeah, I've got six coaches that have, you know, proven to be very successful in their work of leadership, and pairing them with strong leaders. Some, some are, um, mentor-- or some of them are veterans and some are brand new to leadership and charter in general. And, um, partnering them, 'cause there might be something in particular that they're working on that they might need help with. So it's not like these are not successful leaders, 'cause some of them are.
But, like to your point, everybody needs a coach. I have a coach. I have a coach and, and, um, I meet with them regularly to get… You know, to grow. I think it's, like, one of the best investments anybody can make, whether it's a life coach, whether it's a professional coach, athletic coach. It, it, it makes you more efficient, because they-- Instead of you spinning your wheels and trying to figure something out, a coach can help you get there much quicker, and then you can just move on to the next thing. 100%, yep.
Especially in, you know, in positions that, of leadership and especially in, in industries or in, in, in job roles- Mm-hmm that are so compact and busy and heavy and high pressure. I believe mentorship and, and coaching, you know, provides the most, the best ROI for your time. Like you can go- Mm-hmm … and have a half an hour or an hour or whatever else with a coach, with a mentor, and zoom right into what your challenge is, where you're struggling, but it's, it's about you and getting the support that, that you need.
So I love that you're doing that- Yeah … specifically in Idaho. Yeah. It's exactly what we're trying to do with Link Leaders to connect people that maybe don't have programs like you're offering to, to others, so- Mm-hmm … very cool. Um, well wrapping up here, maybe I'd ask you, what question do you wish I asked that I didn't? Oh, that's a good question. Um- I, I would say, you know, asking me if I miss running a building or being in a teacher role and- Yeah, let's hear it … yes.
Let's hear it. Yes to, uh, both of those. I love teaching, so every opportunity I get to lead a professional development, you know, that fills my bucket along those lines. And I, I do miss being a school leader. Um, I miss the day-to-day of, you know, you never know what's gonna happen, and I miss that part of it. But I get to be in schools, and I get to, you know, try to help school leaders make their days even, even better than, you know, w- what they're making them. Um, but I really like the role that I'm in now as well, because I think it, it moved me from the dance floor up to that balcony view where I can have, you know, a, a broader lens of, you know, what the challenges are, and then hone in on those and really try to do whatever I can to, to help.
There's, I mean, Idaho's a great place to educate students. We are very fortunate. I know it's the lowest per pa- paid, um, funding for students, but I just have met so many great people that care deeply, you being one of those Mike, that care deeply about doing what's best for Idaho students. And, and I- we're fortunate. We're fortunate here in Idaho that we have so many people that care deeply about… And every state will probably say the exact same thing.
You know, you're probably gonna get somebody from a different state listening and say, "Well, we care over here, too." Um, I don't know that because I'm not in the other states, but I, I just feel really blessed to be surrounded by amazing people who care deeply about kids, and, and I believe our legislators do as well, and really wanna do what's best for kids. So I like the role that I'm in now as well, 'cause I get to interact with a variety of people who are trying to make sure that our Idaho children are having lots of options of high quality learning environments.
Yeah, absolutely. And I think for those that are listening that are not in Idaho, I think that, that are in education, if you're, if you're in education, if you're leading, if you're teaching, um, I'm gonna place my bets that, that you are in it for the right reasons because it's too damn hard to do otherwise, right? There's- Amen. Yes. And so I have, I have confidence that those people that are listening in whatever state they're in, if they're in education, that, that they're, they're very likely and they're in it- Yeah … for the exact right reason.
They're- 'Cause I'm pretty sure they're not in it for the money or the fame. I was gonna say, they're not in it for the money. They're not in it to get a, a night's full, you know, sleep 'cause that, those things just don't happen. Right. And they're not in it to have free time. But they really truly are in it because they care deeply about the future Yep. Yep. And, and, and kudos and thank you to all of those listeners that are doing the work, 'cause it, you're right, Mike, it is hard. And some days it feels pretty darn defeating. And then you have a kiddo that comes up and gives you a big hug and tells you they like your shoes.
And then you're like, "Yes, yes. I, I- Right … I can make it." Yep. But I, I'm glad you a- a- asked the question that I should have asked. I, I, that's, I think that's a great question, and I also, um, miss much of, of, of being a building principal. When I, when I took the role, I wasn't sure I was, you know, what, what I was expe- what to expect, and if I would love it or like it or whatever else, or I'd survive it. And, uh, I really enjoyed my time as a s- as a school leader.
I was, I loved- Mm-hmm … the, the variety of the day, the unknown, the pressure, the challenge, all those, those kind of things that come with it. Um, and it reminded me that if, uh, what it was like to be a waiter at a, at a… No, I'm just kidding. But it was- … it was, yeah, a great, great experience. So wrapping it up here, so- Did you get tips as a waiter? Yes. Yes, I did. Then you were a good waiter 'cause you got the tips.
So the, the hard part about education, nobody tips us. Nobody. Nobody tips us. In this tipping culture- But I know we're doing great work … why isn't that? Like, you tip for everything now. Like, e- you know, you, I feel like when I go to, you know, pay for my bag of chips at the convenience store, I'm, like- Mm-hmm … expected to tip a, tip now. So why not put a tip jar or a- Right you know, Venmo on the, on the whiteboard? Let's, let's, let's introduce the tipping- Let's do it. Yes … in education.
I, I think- Yes … that would require some legislative ch- legislative change, you know? Oh, heck no. There's, there's rules around those gifts- It's, it's optional. No … but, but I don't think there's anything about tipping. So maybe that's different than- I'm s- I'm starting- … you know, receiving a gift … I'm starting a- Tipping … a n- a new, a new initiative There you go. Let's figure out- Let's, uh- … how to get tips. Tips for teachers. There we go. In that- Tips for educators … in that cart you rolled around in as a principal. Oh, there you go. There's no reason you couldn't have a tip jar there. That would, that would've been a great idea.
But yeah, no, I just, our, our educators across the nation are just dedicated, committed people. And we couldn't, we couldn't do the work we do, Mike, without them. Indeed. Well, closing question. A- as we are here on the Transformative Principal podcast, what does it mean to be a transformative leader, Nanette? To be transformative, you have to have hope in our future generations, and what do we need to do to prepare them for an ever-changing world?
And that one is a tough nut to crack right now with AI, right? Oh, man It's like… Yeah. You know, I, I just really quick, 'cause I know I'm derailing us and we're out of time. I was in an AI training, and somebody there said, "We have got to focus on who our children become more than what." Because AI and the technology tools we have is going to help them be successful in any job, but how are we developing their character to be able to do any job? I thought it was just an interesting perspective to think about.
You think character is that important? I'm just kidding. Yep. That's why I hang out with you, Mike, 'cause you have good character. All right. Well, with that, Nanette, thank you so much for being a guest today. I really appreciate the conversation, the laughs, and always connecting, so. And for those of you who are listening, thanks again for listening to another episode of the Transformative Principal podcast. We'll catch you on the next one.
About This Episode To spot harm on a student's device, a safety tool has to look at what the student does on it. That tension is at the center of this conversation with Bella Davis, founder and CEO of Monarch AI...
A teacher improvement plan often becomes a second job for the principal, who has to follow up on everything. Jethro plays a clip from the My First Million podcast with executive coach Joe Hudson, then shows how to put...
Jethro Jones explains Project Paideia, an effort by a group of dads to give teens ages 13 to 18 a better first look at AI: build something that solves a problem instead of consuming AI slop. He separates AI in education...
Christopher Grode, Ph.D., retired after 19 years as an Illinois superintendent and wrote The Leader Within on how school leaders grow. He and host Mike Caldwell agree that principal burnout lives in days spent reacting...
Elizabeth Cushing, CEO of Playworks, tells Jethro Jones how organized recess builds belonging and emotional resilience, and why it helps student attendance. Playworks is a national nonprofit that has spent 30 years...