Hugging Porcupines: Support Kids Who Struggle with Behavior with Mike Anderson
18 minAudio
Mike Anderson, author of Hugging Porcupines, joins Jethro Jones at ISTE 2026 to explain how teachers can support student behavior for kids who disengage, flare up or push adults away. His answer is a three-legged stool: engaging work, respectful and consistent discipline, and positive relationships. Anderson tells the story of Billy, who made it snow off the reading loft with the paper from his notebook. The fix was two simple consequences: clean up the mess and lose the loft for the day. Anderson delivered both warmly while following through on the rule and called them logical consequences, not punishments. What you'll learn Build classroom rules with students at the start of the year by asking what they want from the year and what rules will help them get it. Use logical consequences, not punishments: when a student makes a mess, they clean it up, and when they abuse a privilege, they lose it. Keep problem-solving conferences with the teacher instead of sending the student to the office, because that conversation is where the relationship gets built. Invite the assistant principal into the classroom to cover the class while the teacher has the conference. Give removed students a place to re-regulate first, and save the problem-solving for after they have calmed down. Chapters 0:00 Why Mike Anderson wrote Hugging Porcupines 1:32 Why kids are more disengaged since COVID 3:22 How the book walks through the school year 5:09 The three-legged stool of a good classroom 6:07 Visiting every student's home before school starts 9:23 Four traits of relationships that support discipline 13:43 Consequences versus punishments in the classroom 14:14 Why teachers should not outsource discipline to the office Questions this episode answers How do you support students who struggle with behavior? Anderson uses a three-legged stool: academic engagement, respectful and consistent discipline, and positive relationships. If one leg is missing, the stool falls. He says teachers need all three every day of the school year, not relationships in September and academics later. What is the difference between a consequence and a punishment? Anderson says punishments are designed to make kids hurt so they will not misbehave again. A logical consequence is simpler: abuse a privilege and you lose it, make a mess and you clean it up. He delivers consequences warmly while following through on the rule. Should teachers send disruptive students to the office? Anderson says teachers should keep problem-solving conferences because that is where they build relationship with the toughest kids. Sending a student away gives up that chance. Removal is for unsafe or disruptive moments, and its goal is re-regulation, not problem-solving. About Mike Anderson Mike Anderson is the author of Hugging Porcupines: Practical Strategies for Supporting Kids Who Struggle with Behavior in School. Working on this at your school? Get a free preview of a 10-week leadership pathway built from episodes like this one at transformativeprincipal.com/start. Thanks to our Sponsor Broadcast Made Easy who help you start a news broadcast at your school by having everything you need in one easy-to-download place. Check it out today and get your kids creating. We’re proud to be sponsored by IXL. IXL’s comprehensive teaching and learning platform for math, language arts, science, and social studies is accelerating achievement in 95 of the top 100 U.S. school districts. Loved by teachers and backed by independent research from Johns Hopkins University, IXL can help you do the following and more: Simplify and streamline technology Save teachers’ time Reliably meet Tier 1 standards Improve student performance on state assessments 🚀 Ready to see why leading districts trust IXL for their educational needs? Visit IXL.com/BE today to learn more about how IXL can elevate your school or district.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Pete Hall: Welcome to the Transformative Principal. I am so excited to share this interview from ISTE 2026 with you. Really fascinating things happening there. Lots of great people, and over the course of the next couple weeks, you're gonna hear some of these great interviews. Hope you enjoy, and thanks for listening to Transformative Principal Jethro D. Jones: All right. Mike Anderson at ISTE talking about his book, "Hugging Porcupines." That's my little intro. All right, Mike, welcome. So good to have you, back. I think this is our fourth time recording?
Yeah, something like that. Mike Anderson: Yeah. It's, it's been a few. It's good to see you, Jethro. Jethro D. Jones: too. so tell us about your latest book, "Hug a Porcupine"? "Hugging Porcupines"? "Hugging Porcupines." "Hugging Porcupines," thank you. Mike Anderson: Practical strategies for supporting kids who struggle with behavior in school. Yeah. Jethro D. Jones: Excellent. Mike Anderson: yeah, so the book is all about how do we support kids who have a hard time in the classroom. They might be academically disengaged. They get bored or overwhelmed, and they shut down or flare up. Mm-hmm. It could be that they're neurodivergent, and their brains aren't wired the way schools are teaching them.
It could be that these are kids with a history of trauma who are experiencing instability at home. so it's, it's kids who often struggle with behavior, but for, like, totally legit reasons. Yeah. and we've got more and more of these kids coming into classrooms, more-- We're seeing an increased number of misbehaviors in school. We're seeing an increase in the, intensity of the misbehaviors often. Mm-hmm. And teachers are really struggling. And so this book attempts to give some really practical strategies that teachers can use. Jethro D. Jones: use. Yeah. one of the things that I perceive, and I'd be curious your thoughts on this, is that when we shut down everything for COVID, we basically told kids, "All the things we told you about school that matter don't matter anymore 'cause we can just cancel it."
And I have seen since then a, a real disengagement from school from kids that I would think would be more engaged. And, is that something that you've noticed, too? How much does that play into it, and how much does just other stuff, phones and, and all that? Jonathan Haidt would say it's all the phones, right? But… Mike Anderson: Yeah. It's-- I think it's a combination of things. I- Mm-hmm. N-no doubt COVID had an impact. I mean, it was a worldwide pandemic. We were all impacted and affected by that.
But it's not like kids were skipping through hallways before COVID saying, "Yay, I love school," and teachers were like, "My job is so easy." Yeah. Like, if you could go back to two thousand nineteen, you'd still see this was Jethro D. Jones: Yes, Mike Anderson: for Jethro D. Jones: sure. Mike Anderson: so I think COVID was one thing. I think another thing that's going on is that the world is a little bit dysregulated right now. Mm-hmm. you know, when all the grown-ups are dysregulated, it would be weird if the kids weren't dysregulated. Yeah. Jethro D. Jones: very true. Mike Anderson: and then absolutely, phones and social media, we know that's having an impact on kids' emotional development, s-social skill development- Yeah on their mental health.
And so I think it's s- I don't know if it's a perfect storm or not, 'cause that makes it sound like it couldn't get worse, and I Jethro D. Jones: gonna say Mike Anderson: I kinda worry that it Jethro D. Jones: could. Yes. Mike Anderson: you know, I think it's all of those things going in together is, is what we're seeing in schools. Jethro D. Jones: in schools. Yeah. Yep. so do you feel that this is- Do you feel that this is something that is a Like, I don't know the best way to say this. Is this, is this something that schools can actually solve or, or… Okay, good. Yeah. All right. So, so how do schools solve it? What, what are your suggestions?
Mike Anderson: So the way the book is laid out, so I'm gonna answer this in two parts. Yeah. The way the book is laid out, there's a beginning section of the book, which is all about understanding our porcupines. Mm-hmm. Why do some kids break so many rules when it would just be so much easier for them and everybody else if they just did what they were supposed to do? Yeah. Like, why do they do that? Why do some kids disengage from learning even though we know and they know that the learning is what they need, but they spend more time and energy avoiding Jethro D. Jones: Yes Mike Anderson: or getting out of work than they would spend actually doing the work. Like, why do they do that? That seems weird.
Mm-hmm. And then why do they push us away? You know, very often these are kids who need strong connections and social relationships, and then when we extend a hand and we try and reach out and connect with them, they often push us away. It's like they're dying of thirst in the desert, we're offering them water, and they're pushing it Jethro D. Jones: Yep. Mike Anderson: So that's the first part of the book is why do some kids struggle so much. The rest of the book, which is really more like 75% of the book, is about, through the school year. So the organization of the book is there's a chapter about the two weeks before the school year even starts.
Jethro D. Jones: Good. Mike Anderson: What do you do in late summer to get ready for porcupines who are coming? Like, make a list of your kids and give yourself a tracking sheet where you're gonna start collecting all the little things you learn about Jethro D. Jones: Yeah Mike Anderson: as the year unfolds. Like they're a football fan, they like baseball, they are into horses, whatever. Yeah. then there's a chapter called The First Weeks of School, and then there's a chapter called It's October, The Honeymoon's Over. Jethro D. Jones: Yeah. Mike Anderson: Mm-hmm. November and December is handling the holidays. January is January's re-month, like we gotta re-get kids back into school. There's handling the winter, winter doldrums in February and March.
So it's, it's basically a walk through the school year. Yeah. And there are really practical strategies that teachers can do, and an image that I use that sort of runs as a theme through the whole book is to think of a great learning environment in terms of a three-legged stool. Jethro D. Jones: Mm-hmm. Mike Anderson: What I love about the image of a three-legged stool is what happens if any one leg of a three-legged stool- Jethro D. Jones: You drop. Mike Anderson: Yeah. So the three legs are academic engagement, like the work has to be worth- Jethro D. Jones: Yes … Mike Anderson: doing from kids' perspectives. Yeah. I think it would be weird if kids were motivated to do unmotivating
Jethro D. Jones: Yes. Yep. Mike Anderson: I'm not motivated to do unmotivating is. Don't you avoid it at all costs? Yes. Do the least amount possible to get through it? Yeah. Jethro D. Jones: Anytime I can. Mike Anderson: So that's one leg. Another leg is respectful, consistent discipline that creates safety in a classroom, and then the third leg is positive relationships. Mm-hmm. And there's a good bit that I go into in the book about how to build positive relationships. Like what exactly are the four characteristics of those, and how do teachers do that effectively? So that's the, that's the formula. Yeah. And what's important is I think sometimes we think of the beginning of the school year as that's when we build relationships, and we do icebreakers, and we build community, and then we can get to the academics.
That's not how a three-legged stool Jethro D. Jones: No. Mike Anderson: You gotta be doing all three all the time, all year Jethro D. Jones: Yeah. Yeah, I really appreciate that. And I, I also appreciate that you, you talk about what to do the two weeks before school. And one of the things that we did at my school that was really impactful is we went and visited every single kid's home before school started. Ooh. Even our porcupines. And, and what made that so valuable, and what was… So a little side note, what was interesting is that some people said, "Oh, I got so much empathy for where these kids live," and, and all that stuff.
And that is not the point that I was going for. N- the real point was we are leaving our ivory tower and going to where you are to show that you matter to us and that- Mm-hmm that we care and that we are part of your community also. Yes. And, and that idea of, like, w- the, the only learning that can happen is within the four walls of my classroom is just so crazy to me, but people still think that. And, and so leaving our school to go out to, to visit kids, they were like, "What are you doing here?"
Like, "Well, I came out to tell you I'm excited for you to come back to school." And it's like, "Why are you excited for me to come back to school?" And when a kid asks you that when you're on their doorstep You better have an answer. Uh-huh. 'Cause if you don't, the, "I honestly don't know why I'm excited for you to come back to school because I really, you get under my nerves." Yeah. Like, that's not the right answer. Yeah. So. Mike Anderson: better have an answer, so. No. Well, another powerful thing about what you're talking about is, like how many parents out there have had trauma in school? Jethro D. Jones: Yeah. Mike Anderson: And so that's why they're not coming to parent-teacher conferences.
Yeah. That's why they're not coming to open house, 'cause just walking through school doors elicits the fight, flight, or freeze response from Jethro D. Jones: For sure, Mike Anderson: So if we can meet parents where they're at, uh, boy, what a respectful and human thing that is to Jethro D. Jones: Yeah, absolutely. Huge. Uh, my kids actually go to the school that I, the high school that I graduated from. Mm. And even though it's been remodeled since I've been in there, walking into the gym, which was not remodeled- Mm it was, I mean, it was remodeled, but it wasn't torn down. I had these feelings come back from 20 years ago- Yeah … when I graduated. Takes you right back.
And, and everybody has that experience. And, and going into a school, you know, as a parent could be a challenging thing. And then when they're anxious, that feeds into their kids as well, and, and they pass, pass that along as well, even in the attitude. So, so there are so many reasons why these kids may be porcupines, but the reality is, we do still need to hug them, and we do still need to do powerful things. So go back to the three-legged school, stool. Yep. It's academic, academic engagement, and the other two?
Mike Anderson: Respectful, effective discipline practices and positive teacher-student Jethro D. Jones: Okay. So it was the, the discipline interactions. Talk to us about that because, it- we, we go back and forth between this, we're just all friends, and we wanna make the kids like me, and people also miss out that kids do not like people that they don't respect. Uh-huh. And part of having good discipline is, is having expect- or not expectations, I call them standards, standards of behavior and, and helping kids see that this is how we act when we're here.
Yep. Yep. talk to us about that a little bit. Mike Anderson: Yeah. So of course, this is all bound up with relationship as well. Mm-hmm. one of the things that I learned as I was doing research for the book is it appears as though there are four key characteristics of positive teacher-student relationships- Mm-hmm … and they directly connect to discipline. So the four characteristics are: teachers need to use strategies that are warm and demanding Jethro D. Jones: Mm-hmm Mike Anderson: Supportive and empowering. Mm-hmm. So that's the key. When you're looking at discipline strategies, is this a good one or not, is look through that Jethro D. Jones: Yeah. Mike Anderson: So here are a few things we can do.
One is excuse me, at the beginning of the year, we can build rules collaboratively with our students. Mm-hmm. We can say to them, "What are the things you wanna get out of this year? What kind of community do we need to build so that we can reach for our goals this year? And what are the rules we're gonna use to take care of each other so we can work toward those important goals we have?" Mm-hmm. When the rules of the room… And I know there are some schools that don't even wanna use the word rules anymore. Yeah. I do not have a negative association with rules. Like, if I'm gonna play a board game, I need to know what the rules are- Yeah … 'cause it's the rules that allow you to have fun in the game. Jethro D. Jones: Well, and on that point, Mike, one of the things that I often said to kids is, and still say, is, "This is a game. You need to know the rules of the game and how to be successful at it." There is nothing wrong with saying that school is a game, and, and let's play the right rules to be successful in this game.
In fact, that's actually empowering because when you look at it a little bit differently, that it's not somebody saying, "You have to act this way," it's saying, "If you wanna win, here's how you win, and these are the things you need to do." Mike Anderson: And you use that word empowering. Yeah. That's one of those four characteristics. Yeah. So when we build rules collaboratively with our students, we're being supportive because we are creating rules. So there are gonna be guidelines, but it's also empowering because we're asking students to have a hand in shaping how that's gonna look. Jethro D. Jones: Yeah. Mike Anderson: Uh, and then we need to be really good as adults at actually following through when the rules aren't followed.
Yeah. And something I think we need to be really honest about with our students is that we're all gonna break rules. Jethro D. Jones: Yeah. Mike Anderson: We're all gonna have a bad day. We're gonna… Like, one of the rules we always… You know, every year when I did this in my own classroom, the rules would have some similar themes. There would always be something in there about taking care of our classroom, being responsible, and that was the one I struggled with 'cause I would always end up with piles of teacher Jethro D. Jones: Yeah. Mike Anderson: Yep. on a shelf somewhere, and it would get messy. And so I would say to my students, like, "This is one that I'm gonna struggle with. I'm gonna have to work harder at this- Mm-hmm … than I am at some of our other rules." To have open, hon- honest conversations that we're all gonna make mistakes.
and then to be able to follow through when that happens. So here's a, here's a really simple example. in my-- in one of my classrooms, I had this reading loft, which is this really cool sort of- Loft, yeah … standalone deck area where kids could go up and grab a beanbag chair and read a book or do some work. And one day I looked up, and Billy had taken all of the little bits of paper from the inside of his spiral binding on his spiral-bound notebook and was making it snow off the side of the loft. Yeah. You can picture all the little bits of paper sprinkling down. Jethro D. Jones: Yeah, I got a good story about that, too. But go ahead. Mike Anderson: So I looked up, and I was like, "Billy, that looks pretty cool, but come on down. You're all done with the loft for today, and clean up the mess."
Jethro D. Jones: Yeah. Mike Anderson: So there were two consequences there. He had to clean up the mess he made, and he lost the privilege of being in the loft for the rest of that day. Now, he got it back three days later when it was his turn in the rotation Jethro D. Jones: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Mike Anderson: But those are really simple, logical consequences that help give the rules, meaning- Jethro D. Jones: Yeah … Mike Anderson: and weight. Jethro D. Jones: And, and on that story, the, the consequence didn't have to be he lost the privilege up there. But in your situation, that was the right thing to do, so I'm not questioning that. Yeah. But in other situations, you could be like, "Oh-" That was actually pretty cool.
I can totally see why you wanted to do that. And when you get down, you have to clean it up. But, like, don't do that anymore 'cause it's distracting or whatever. But the thing is, like, you don't have to, you don't have to stop every behavior that may look negative either. Mm-hmm. And that's also, like, picking your battles and saying, "I- I'm going to have a boundary," but the boundary is not… Like, if you're dropping paper, you're n- you're not hurting anybody. Right. And it can be kinda cool. And if it's distracting others, that probably falls into another rule.
Mike Anderson: And it made a mess. Jethro D. Jones: And if it makes a mess, then we gotta clean it up, and we're not gonna leave it sitting there for two hours and then clean it up later. Yeah. Like, all these things you gotta be thinking about, but you don't have to… Like, as soon as a kid does one wrong thing, you don't have to come down on him. Like- Mike Anderson: Well, and there's a difference between consequences and punishments. Jethro D. Jones: Yes. Mike Anderson: So that was not a punishment. Jethro D. Jones: Yep. Mike Anderson: Punishments are designed to make kids Jethro D. Jones: Yes. Mike Anderson: Yep. idea being that if they hurt enough when we give them the punishment, then they won't misbehave again. Yeah. This was just simply a logical consequence.
Yeah. Abuse a privilege, you lose a privilege. You make a mess, you clean it up. And I delivered in, in a warm way. Yeah. So warm and demanding, like I'm following through on the rules. Yeah. We've got rules about the behavior in the loft, and you weren't following it, so you're all done. and I think that's-- those are some things that I think teachers really struggle with. Mm-hmm. In a lot of schools, teachers are very worried about letting consequences fall. Yeah. They often then, outsource their power to the office. Jethro D. Jones: Yes. Mike Anderson: So one of the things I see all the time in Jethro D. Jones: Good. I'm glad you brought it up- So- … 'cause I was gonna bring it up next. Mike Anderson: especially in middle schools, but it happens at all levels, but especially in middle school.
A kid, let's say a seventh grader, is getting dysregulated in math, getting upset, drops a swear. The teacher is like, "That's it, Jethro. I can't take anymore. Go to the office." Jethro D. Jones: Yeah. Mike Anderson: So you, you know, 12-year-old self, 13-year-old self, you go down to the office, go to the assistant principal. Assistant principal says, "Jethro, what are you doing in here? What happened?" You say, "I wasn't doing nothing. Mr. Anderson was picking on me. I w- I was just sitting there. He just kicked me out of class." Well, now, what's the assistant principal supposed to I Jethro D. Jones: know. Yep. Mike Anderson: How is he ever gonna get, or is she ever gonna get to the bottom of what actually happened? And then the idea that that assistant principal is somehow gonna help Jethro have a better time in math class next time.
Like, the assistant principal can give it their best shot. They can talk to the kid, try and help him figure out some strategies for how to stay in control next time. But there are a couple of problems with this. First of all, that problem-solving con- and this is something I really go into in depth in the book. Yeah. Problem-solving conferences are gold. Yes. Teachers do not want to outsource those because that's where you build relationship And sometimes what happens is when the assistant principal or a counselor is actually good at having problem-solving conferences, you get kids who actually want to go-
Jethro D. Jones: Yeah Mike Anderson: to the office when they get dysregulated 'cause that's a person who actually listens to their side of the story- Yeah … tries to help them out. I was working with a middle school outside of Cincinnati once, and, the middle school assistant principal said, "I have the te- I have the best relationship with the 10 toughest kids in this school." Jethro D. Jones: Totally. Mike Anderson: And he said, "And that's a problem." Jethro D. Jones: Yeah. " Mike Anderson: I'm the wrong person to have the Yep. Jethro D. Jones: Yeah. So a couple strategies that I've done with that, number one is you're taking the assistant principal or the principal's time anyway. Yep. So have them come into your class- Yes … and support the kids while you go- They go
Mike Anderson: have the conference. Jethro D. Jones: Yep. exactly. Yes. That's, that's one very simple one- Yeah … that, as a principal, I was like, "Yes, please," because then I get to just hang out and do cool stuff with kids. Mm-hmm. And you can deal with the kid that's causing you trouble in a way that's actually gonna work. Because I told my teachers, "If, if you send this kid to me, you are giving up all of your power." Mike Anderson: Yeah. Your solution might not actually work for the Jethro D. Jones: Yeah, exactly. Mm-hmm. but I do have a relationship, so a l- a lot of teachers complained, "Well, all you did was talk to him, and then, and then you sent him back to class." And it's like, "Well, yeah, that's all he needed."
Mike Anderson: Yeah. " Jethro D. Jones: He just needed someone to talk to." And, like, that's it. Mike Anderson: But But the teacher wanted the kid to get in Yeah. Jethro D. Jones: See, Mike Anderson: wanted the kid coming back sniffling- Yeah … and penitent- Jethro D. Jones: Yep … Mike Anderson: when what they really needed was a chance to Jethro D. Jones: Yes, exactly. Mike Anderson: So that's, so that's something else I go into in the book, is there are times when kids should be removed from a classroom. Mm-hmm. If they are getting unsafe or if they're disrupting learning for everybody. Yeah. We gotta have a place where those kids can go and get their cool back. Yeah. But that should be the goal of that, that out of the classroom spot is re-regulation, not problem-solving.
Jethro D. Jones: Yeah. Yep, because, 'cause there's a difference between re-regulation and problem-solving. Yes. And, and if you're just focusing on the problem-solving and you don't do the re-regulation first, the problem-solving won't even work. Right. It's not even worth going down that path until they're re-regulated. And, and once they are, then you can, you can pr- solve the problem. Absolutely. And every, almost every time, if the teacher's doing the problem-solving, then it's a million times better
Mike Anderson: Because then they develop the real relationship- Yeah … with that tough kid. Yep. That's one of the ways we hug our porcupines, is by spending that time and energy trying to help that kid find a better way out of whatever's going on for them in that that Jethro D. Jones: moment. Yeah, 'cause it's very real. Mike Anderson: Yes. Jethro D. Jones: Well, Mike, this has been awesome. So good to see you again. tell us again the name of the book and where people can get it. Mike Anderson: It's "Hugging Porcupines." People can get it on the ISTE ASCD website. They can also get it on Amazon. Those are both good spots. Jethro D. Jones: Excellent. Mike, thanks again for being here. Appreciate you. Mike Anderson: Thank you, Jethro. This was awesome.
About This Episode To spot harm on a student's device, a safety tool has to look at what the student does on it. That tension is at the center of this conversation with Bella Davis, founder and CEO of Monarch AI...
A teacher improvement plan often becomes a second job for the principal, who has to follow up on everything. Jethro plays a clip from the My First Million podcast with executive coach Joe Hudson, then shows how to put...
Jethro Jones explains Project Paideia, an effort by a group of dads to give teens ages 13 to 18 a better first look at AI: build something that solves a problem instead of consuming AI slop. He separates AI in education...
Christopher Grode, Ph.D., retired after 19 years as an Illinois superintendent and wrote The Leader Within on how school leaders grow. He and host Mike Caldwell agree that principal burnout lives in days spent reacting...
Elizabeth Cushing, CEO of Playworks, tells Jethro Jones how organized recess builds belonging and emotional resilience, and why it helps student attendance. Playworks is a national nonprofit that has spent 30 years...