Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
You know, CTAs are difficult to live with. You go down the stairs, come up the elevators, you might have three years with no performance. Your investment committee will look at you like an idiot. Why did you allocate this training? Welcome to Top Traders Unplugged. In markets, success doesn't come from predicting what happens next. It comes from being prepared for what you can't predict. In each episode, we go deep with some of the world's most thoughtful minds in investing, economics and beyond to understand how they
think, how they prepare and how they decide and the experiences that shaped how they see the world. No noise, no shortcuts, just real conversations to help you think better and invest with confidence. Welcome back to Top Creators Unplugged, where each week we take the pulse of the market from the perspective of a rules based investor. My name is Alan Dunn. I'm sitting in this week for Niels who is away traveling and great to have Yoav with me this week. Yoav, how are you?
Oh, pleasure, Absolutely wonderful. Actually. I'm just back from, to this country and enjoying the beautiful but very cold weather. Yes, same here in Dublin. It's gone chilly but lovely kind of winter, winter sun and, but, but definitely a bit cooler. And where, where are we on your travels? Oh, all around. I've been to the USA and then I've been to the Middle east and, and now I'm back in the UK and just preparing for Christmas. It's very exciting.
Good. So good. We the final run in already? Yeah,. Yeah. What. Is it? Five or six weeks to go. So that's, yeah, pretty, pretty crazy, but lots to talk about as ever. You know, November has kicked off. It's been an interesting month, I suppose we would say interesting and inadvertent commas for CTAs, but we'll get to that. But what's been on your radar? Oh, actually, because it's the end of the year, we, we're beginning the process of internships.
We've, we've been running internships for many, many years and we're looking for somebody in research and we're looking some for somebody in technology. We have someone already in business development and I find it really exciting. I mean in the days of AI, people kind of tend to think that investing in juniors is not something that you should do right because you can replace them with AI. But actually I think it's actually really important to develop the skills, the, the skills of using AI. I think a lot of people coming from university just, just have a
very limited experience of how to use it in certainly in a company setting. And I think it's really important in investing in the next generation. And the way you kind of do that is by giving a meaningful project. I think the like, it's very. I've been to many banks where interns, you know, get exposure to what's going on but don't are just basically shadowing somebody more senior but actually don't get to do their own work. And I think it's really important.
The value comes from giving them meaningful projects that they can do. And we've been very lucky in the past and I think, I hope that we're going to be lucky in the future. But we're just writing the spec for that and that has been keeping me busy. Great. Well, I'm sure that's a great opportunity for anybody, any young researchers or programmers or whatever out there interested in developing a career. That would be a great opportunity. Have you started the interviewing process yet or. No? No, it's just about it.
Just to go, about to go on the, on the website in applications. Very good. Yeah. Well, no doubt there will be a huge influx of applications on the back of this promotion. The problem that young people have is that unemployment, youth unemployment in this country is enormous and it's very, actually very difficult to go through the process of finding a position. You know, so the problem is not really what my problem is not lack of applications. It's actually the opposite.
I think it just reflects the sad reality is that a lot of companies are just cutting, cutting back on the hiring process and it's make it very difficult for them. Interesting. Yeah, no, definitely it's from my own experience interviewing people at that stage. They seem to have all the right credentials these days. High academics, managed funds participated in various entities
at university and done all of that. So it seems like the competition is stronger and greater than ever. But anyway, best of luck with that. So we have a great lineup. Some really interesting topics that we're going to get into around building CTA portfolios and what it can do for your overall portfolio and all of that. So maybe just to talk about performance first, I didn't mention it being an interesting month so far for cta. So it's been a tough month. Obviously we've seen the bond market sell off correcting from I
suppose from early October and that's carried forward into the early part of November and obviously we've had volatility in the equity market as well. Well after the midterms, really interesting moves after the midterms last Week abandoned kind of further weakness and obviously the likes of Nvidia with their own challenges. But yeah from a CTA perspective to the 11th of November the SoC Gen CTA index is down 3.2% still up 10.2 on the year. SoC Gen Trends down 3.9 up 9.95 on the year that's to the 11th
of November. And so yesterday was a good day for CTA so we'll probably see a little bit of a come back more. But yeah, I mean it's been a tough month. You have any observations from your side as to what's been interesting or challenging this month? Well, I think quite a few news items. Obviously the midterms have brought almost a reversal a lot in the, in the commodity market. So that, that was actually quite tough in, in the fixed income markets. I think the, the main issue, the main piece of news was actually
inflation coming out a little bit higher than expected. I think running it. I think it's about 3 per annum in the US and that, and that has caused again another reversal. So we've seen September, September we've seen sort of done very well by, by, by bonds then October was a little bit of a reversal and then, and then November is also very exciting in that respect and equities of course we are less exposed to specific risk like Nvidia but I think, but Nvidia is sufficiently large
that it is projecting on the rest of the, the rest. So equities I think equities are less of an issue. I think what has been happening is that the midterms really switched markets expectations of what's going to happen in Iran but of course the Iranians think otherwise. So that has been I think the most exciting things in November and I think that's where most CTAs are feeling the pain. Yeah. So from long energy positions basically.
Exactly. So yeah that has been a big reversal actually. Very good. Well it's still a positive year. It's been, I mean a lot of the gains this year have come through in the first few months of the year I think maybe to May or so and it's been up and down a bit choppy since then but net, net still a very good year you would have to say for CJ's in a year where equities have had also done well. And actually interestingly equities probably did well in the
early part of the year as well. I've been. The indices have been pretty much up and down in a range I would say for the last six months or so as well. But they are all kind of, that's all related to what we're going to talk about. And I know you've published a number of blogs of late all around, I suppose, you know, the role of CTAs in broader portfolios, convexity, you know, different types of convexity and putting all of that
together. So where do you want to start on all of this? Oh, okay. So we're just going to talk a little bit about what does CTA bring to a portfolio. And yeah, and I think what's happened is that the, this is all being precipitated essentially by discussions with clients because they've come to us. And of course, with the bond equity correlation turning positive, the. Everybody's both, is both, both concerned about inflation. People have also been concerned about stagflation. People have been concerned about like how does a CTA in, into
a 6040 portfolio and especially in this macroeconomic environment. So we started thinking about it in earnest sort of the beginning of June. And I just kind of, I think trying to put a little bit of structure over the process. And what I kind of want to talk about is a lot of the people are very happy with just having, okay, here's, here's a liquid cta. My, my consultant have recommended me that I want to have
something defensive in my portfolio. I've bought, you know, a mainstream liquid cta. Where do I go from here? Okay. And the problem is that a lot of the clients, if you look at this, how much. If you look at the total portfolio approach, everybody wants, you know, you actually want a lot of CTAs in your portfolio. You put it into your Claude, and Claude will tell you you want 20 CTAs. Okay. And people go, oh my God, this is a big number. And people are kind of afraid about what do I want to get out of
the, out of, out of the cta. And you know, not Cloud may be very clever, but it's not really attuned to what investors actually want from a CTA book. So the way we've, I view it is that there are three ways potentially that you can have from a CTA basket. The first one is that you might want to think of it as like, it's a standalone, it's a hedge fund, it's part of a hedge fund book. I just wanted to have a highest standalone alpha. You just want to have that, and that's absolutely fine.
The second view is people want to say equity convexity. We want crisis alpha. We want to support the 60% allocation to equity that we want. And of course the last, the last discussion, which is actually more recent because people have been, you know, the bond index has not been done particularly well this year. They want to say, okay, how do I protect my bond exposures because I've got 40% in my portfolio in bonds. How do I get bond convexity and bond crisis alpha? So that's the kind of question that people have been talking to us and I've published before we, I published like two blogs talking
a little bit about first of all convexity. And then, and then we can talk and try and maybe bring it all together sort of into a construction. Before we do maybe. I mean, convexity is a term that's thrown around a lot in the industry. So could we try and define that precisely before we start having a deep conversation about it? Oh, absolutely. No, no, no, you're absolutely right. So, so the way we, so essentially what we want to say is
people understand correlation. So bond positive correlation, bond negative correlation, people can understand. You know, if equities goes up, bond are likely to go up or down. Okay, that's the definition of, of correlation. Convexity is something nicer. So convexity, well, positive convexity is something nicer. It's a little bit like buying an option. It makes money both on the upside and on the downside. So the idea is, if I observe the equity market to go up 5% in expectations, what do I expect my, this asset class to do?
Like, okay, so in suppose Normally long term CTAs have got a sharp of 0.5 and they make, you know, so they make May 5% a year. If I see in the next quarter equity going up 5%, how much more do I expect equity CTAs to make? And, and that's really nice, but it's also very nice. The convexity means that it makes both on the plus side, on the negative side. So if you fit like a mod X function, it basically says, how
much more do I expect a CTA to make money? If equities goes up 5% or down 5%, how much more does CTA give us? And of course most people are concerned about the negative side. You know, what happens if my equity portfolio is going down 5%? What happens? And the problem, of course that we have is that although your book may look diversified, it is essentially a growth bet. Most of it is an essentially a growth bet. Okay, so, so a lot of the assets that you have, whether they are private equity, private credit, public credit, a lot of that
are actually very positively correlated to equity. So that means that if equity go down 5%, they will tend to go on average down as well. Not necessarily, but you kind of expect them to go down as well. Okay. And CTAs have the beautiful behavior that it actually tends to go up when equity goes down. Okay. And, and that's what we kind of define as convexity and that gradient, which is how many, you know, if it goes down, if it has a convexity
of say 15%, then for 5% drawdown in equities, we kind of expect to make an extra 75 basis points in the CTA space. Okay. For that quarter, that's kind of what we define as the convexity. And of course, the bigger the number, if it's 15%, that's good. If it's 100%, it's even better. Right. So if, okay, so we kind of want that positive convexity and by the way, zero convexity, like if I just uncorrelated to equity, that's also great.
It's already like it's already going to likely to help you because, you know, most of your assets are going down when equity is going down. Yeah, so, so that's kind of. So. I mean, in layman terms. So you obviously, you want assets and strategies that can deliver positive returns when equities are down and even better than if those returns are even bigger. The bigger the decline in equities. It's not fair to say that's capturing the idea of convexity. Yes, absolutely. But I think what is, what is important is that we should divide
convexity into two things you can achieve. Like when equity goes down, there are two ways for you to make money. Okay. The first one is you happen to have a position, say in bonds or in commodities or in an other, in a different asset class. And that asset, that position, that assets seem to have a correlation with equity and you happened to. And they happen to go in the opposite direction. So, you know, the classic example is that for many years and when inflation was low, we saw if you're holding long bonds, when
equity went down, bonded tend immediately to go up. Okay. It was a risk on, risk off trade. And actually the same one that we saw in November. And bond provided a little bit of respite to, if you were long bonds, it provided respite to the long equity position because equity going down, bonds tended to go up. Okay? So that's, that's what we call, I would call like return convexity. Now there is something like exposure convexity because a CTA provides expo Exposure convexity.
That means that when equity goes down, we will short equity in the same asset class. We will tend to become over time short that position. Okay, short that equity. And that of course essentially reduces your, your exposure. So CTAs act like as a mid midfield player, they to borrow from you. Alan and I listened to your blog, your webinar, it was really good. So you can be a midfield player and they will basically reduce,
they will go down to defense and will reduce your exposure in equity. So that's like an exposure convexity. It's almost mechanical. It will basically reduce your equity beta. It's different type of convexity. How important is that distinction? I mean ultimately people, it's returns that, that drive performance. You know, you can't as people say, you can't eat a sharp racer. You can't eat position convexity.
No, absolutely, you know, so, so, so how important is that distinction? I guess. So I think it's important in terms of understanding the dynamics of, of like the timing of when each of them come come, become, become useful. So if you're holding bonds and bond, so and the second difference is the guarantee. Okay, so with, with exposure convexity it will come, it might come later. So for example, a CTA which holds an, an exposure to equity allocation
to equity, it will go short equity, but it will take its time to actually build up this position because a drawdown by definition comes after a big rally equity rally. So a CTA will start its life actually of a crisis of a drawdown being positive equity. Okay, so it will be more painful. So actually a CTA initially will lose money from an equity exposure convexity. But after a month, or maybe a month or two depending on the speed of the, of the, of the position, it will turn negative.
And it's guaranteed because it's completely mechanical. It will just take less beta, it will reduce your beta. And if it equity keeps going down, it will make money because it's going to be short equity. So, so it's one type of convexity. Whereas the convexity we get from bonds, for example, it's immediate, right? It so happens that these two asset classes during low inflation tend to be negatively correlated. So if you're long bond and long equity, when equity goes down immediately bond make money.
Exactly what we saw in November, right? It's what we call a first responder, what the consultants would like to call it. The problem with that is that it's not guaranteed. It so happens that bonds and equities happen to have low correlation at negative correlation at Times, but sometimes in different environment, some of them are like positively correlated. So, so it's immediate, but it's not 100%. Right. It really depends on the macro environment and on the nature of the crisis as it plays out. And I think the two, the two papers actually talk about that.
So let's, so that's kind of the differences between the convexities and when you build up the portfolio, you kind of want a little bit of both in terms of how do you, how do you construct a defensive basket? Yeah. So it's interesting, I mean as you say in your blogs, you talk about the. I suppose, you know, if, I suppose on a look through basis and this would have been the experience for much of the last decade. You know, if you actually, if you took money out of bonds and invested
in a cta, you probably would have ended up with more bond exposure because you're getting leveraged bond exposure in, in, in, in from the CTA side. So is that a good thing or a bad thing? Well, it's, it's about the construction. Right? It's if you understand the sizing. Yeah. You can understand what you kind of want. Yeah. Right. So, but, but the, the, the reality if, if the. I think that the first blog is talking about the. In the real market, people invest dollars, okay.
And if you, if you have 60, 40 allocation to equities and bonds, your risk allocation to equity is much higher because bonds are, let's say called 20% volatility per annum. Whereas, sorry, equity is equity. Equity. Yeah. Whereas bonds is around say 5, 6% volatility per, depending, I mean, and short term depends on which ones. It depends on which bond, depends on the duration, you know, but broadly much lower volatility, which is the right thing. So your 40% allocation to bonds doesn't actually have as much
risk as your 60% allocation to equities. Now when it comes to CTAs, CTAs basically try to get equal risk in each asset class. And most CTAs, let's call it, run at 15% volume. What they will do is they will actually delever their position in equity and lever up the exposure in bonds so that both asset class internally within the CTA are running at 15%.
Okay, what does this mean from a convexity point of view to you? It means that if I look at the exposure convexity, okay. You get a very interesting behavior. So most people think that the reason why CTAs give, give, perform well when equity goes down is because of the equity. Right. It's because of exposure convexity, the CTA will go short and therefore it will make money. And what I'm saying is that actually does, it doesn't actually
give you that much beta. So if you, because the internally the CTA levels down de leverer the equity exposure, then if you have a 10% CTA, you are basically getting plus minus three and a half percent exposure in equity. Okay. And that's relatively low. Okay. But if you are holding say but, but in terms of the bond exposure,
from your perspective, if I'm, I've got a 10% exposure to a CTA, it's almost equivalent to being plus minus 10% depending on how bonds are going. So it's a much more efficient CTA is much more capital efficient when it comes to the bond sector than it is to the equity sector. So I think the first paper was like be aware of that, right? If you're kind of relying on mechanical exposure adjustment for your equity portfolios, CTAs actually don't really offer that.
Okay. And that was the first paper is that, is that you know, if you want to adjust your bond exposure so you take your 40% and you take 10% out of your bond exposure and you put it in a cta, what you're going to get is you're going to get still, you know, when the going is good, you'll be, you'll get your original 40% exposure and when the going is bad, you get 20% exposure. So you actually get very decent mechanical sort of adaptive exposure from your CTA.
But with the same thing. If you put 10% in your CTA, you only get 60 plus minus 3% exposure. And the, the last thing in the last point in the, in the paper, which is important, which is depending on it really depends on your speed. Okay. So, so one of the things which is important is active risk management, which is what CTAs do means that we like on average we are not fully in.
Okay. You can't commit always 100% and then go minus 100%. When trend is negative, you have a very grad. You change your position gradually and that means that on average in a positive trend in equity, if you're a slow trend over the over a year, say you might get 60% exposure to equity, you give up a little bit. Okay. Which is fine because what you get is that if equity goes down over the year with a sharp one move, then you're likely to be minus
60% exposure. So that's what it gives you. Okay. With faster trend, the faster the trend, the less committing it is because it changes itself so quickly. It's sort of, it always asks itself do am I still in a trend? Am I still in a trend? Am I still in a trend? Trend Then fast trend gives you on average less exposure. It acts faster, but it gives you a less exposure. So if a fast CTA will have plus minus three and a half.
Sorry, a slow CTA must have plus minus three and a half in equity exposure. A fast CTA will only have maybe plus minus 2% exposure. So you should be aware that the speed selection also affects your convexity. This, the, it will arrive faster with a fast, with a fast trend, but overall on average it will actually be lower. So that's actually a very interesting something which comes in from the, like from the, from the mathematics. It's not, I'm not inventing the wheel here.
Yeah. And I mean, I suppose there's a question of does it matter? I mean you could say your equity positioning. Is it your equity beta though that really matters for the CTA portfolio? You know, obviously, as you say, because you're going to pick up equity beta from your bond side, your commodity side, your currency side, which all combine as well alongside maybe a smaller short in equities. So. Does it matter? Well, so in a way, no.
But I'm just going to say that it really, the type of, of protection that you're going to get from a CTA depends on the allocation to different asset classes within it. Sure. And it will play slightly differently. So and I think, I think that's kind of the, the, it's a very interesting. People fail to appreciate that actually what you, what you get is that the convex, the protection that you get from the CTA is not actually necessarily coming just from equities.
It comes. So the other primary source of convexity comes from the other asset classes. And there the behavior is very interesting. So what we find is that bond trend generally have positive convexity over all inflation environments. And the reason why we look at inflation environment as the explainer is because bond themselves actually are very dependent on inflation
regime. So if we look at how bond provide protection to equity downturn, it really depends on inflation. If you go back historically and you look say on the 10 most severe drawdowns in equity over the last 65 years, what you find is that when inflation is high, bonds will perform well, you get a negative correlation. When inflation is, when inflation is low, bonds will perform
well, the correlation is negative and they assist you in an equity drawdown. But when inflation is High is like what we're seeing at the moment. It's not necessarily so. I think around 4, 5% is kind of the middle ground. Above, above that level, you definitely start getting a very positive correlation between bonds and equity. So when equity goes down, bond goes down as well. And we saw that in, you know, in 2022, we saw 2 and a half like
we saw 8 and 8% inflation and we saw equity tanking, and we saw bond tanking as well. Okay. And that's, that's what it is. But, but bond trend, interestingly, is actually immune to that because CTA is kind of tend to flip their positions. So it kind of detects the change in correlation regime between bonds and equities. And by and large, even during high inflation periods, bond offers a distant positive convexity. So just in terms of numbers, equity convexity is like 40.
We say 35%. Bond convexity is around sort of 20%. So actually very, very decent. If we look at the other asset classes, if we look at commodity trend and FX trend, what we see is essentially a flat. They're actually uncorrelated. They are relatively uncorrelated to equity. So what you get is you get general alpha from commodities. So in a crisis, commodity trend is likely to work because it works all the time.
So you're likely to make money out of that, that. Not because it has positive complexity, just because it's uncorrelated. That's already better than most of your asset classes. But it's kind of flat. It's not, it's neither, it's neither positive nor negative to equity downturns. If anything, commodity is slightly negative, but, but that's kind of the interplay. So what you have is you have a CTA is built off a second responder, which at the moment, at the beginning of the, the, of the, the downturn in equity is actually likely to go down because it's the
equity exposure, because it's, it starts being positive and then after a while it will kick in and it will give you meaningful from a risk perspective. It will give you minimum, minimum performance. And we can see that because if, again, if we look at historical crisis in the past, if you sort them by the length of crisis, right, you will see that equity trend is very helpful in protracted long drawdowns because it then changes its exposure.
It is, it goes negative. It really helps sort of the, it really starts making money. But if you have very sharp drawdown followed by recovery, then it's exactly the opposite. Equity tends to suffer both directions in fact, a lot of the time. And we saw that again, we saw that in the Trump crisis, right? So we saw a little bit of that in March, we saw a little bit of that in April Liberation Day last year.
When we see a sharp crisis, the equity part of the convexity actually is just too late to the party. Okay. And most of the convexity you're getting is actually from a first responder from the bond portfolio. And that's just kind of historically how it plays out in with the CTA land. So the reason I'm saying it is because a lot of the people, you know that in our company we run sort of asset class specific
CTAs. Okay. And I just want to kind of articulate. People were going like, why would I want to tilt my allocation into one asset class or the other in terms of the CTA land? Why don't I just want to have a normal cta? And it's just in terms of understanding the properties of each asset class plays within a CTA is actually kind of important. Interesting. I mean, so obviously you have, I suppose you've got equity beta,
you've bond beta and equity trend and bond trend, and they all have a role potentially in a portfolio. So I suppose the question is how much should you be allocating to each? And obviously you can get your equity trend and bond trend via a diversified cta. Or else you can try and finesse that a little bit more by tilting up or down by selecting a manager who specializes more in a certain asset class. I guess that's what you're saying. So, yeah, so the way I see it is that if you want an equity cta,
you actually need to give it a very large allocation if you want an equity CTA in order to help with your exposure convexity. Okay. So you know, it's almost one to one if, if anything to your exposure. So if you want, if you have your 60 equity and you want to tilt it to 40 to 60, then you actually really need to have a 10% in a dedicated equity exposure CTA. And it's kind of, it's going to give you just about the, it's
a kind of expensive for me cash, cash allocation point of view in a bond, in a bond CTA allocation, you actually get your money's worth in terms of capital efficiency simply because CTAs leverage up their positions in bonds to get the risk allocation that you want. But in terms of, if you want to think about it in terms of the cross asset convexity, then you basically want to understand
that bonds give you equity. First response responsive convexity. But. Not always. Actually. Not, not obviously. Because we've seen that obviously in the last month. Yeah,. Completely not guaranteed. Actually this month has been quite good for me on the bond trend. So not too bad actually. But in terms of the. But, but we have had a situation in the last month where equities have gone down and bonds have been been going up. Trend has been going down because transfers have been short bonds. Yeah. So.
So up until the last couple days the, that kind of convexity is not guaranteed. Right. It's. It's a. In expectation and over history that's kind of the observation that we see in the same way that bonds, you know, bonds equity correlation is not guaranteed. Depends on the shape of the crisis and what, what happens. But in terms of risk allocation that's kind of the game. What is very interesting is that equities offer very little bond convexity. So what I mean if you're worried about inflation rising and
your bond portfolio doing well. Equity historically equity trend has done nothing to you. Like literally nothing. Whereas it only goes one way. Unfortunately. We would have liked equity to be a first responder to bonds and bonds to be first responder to equities. It, there is, there is an asymmetry here which is actually very interesting historically. So what. Say, I mean could you say off the top of your head like what's for a. A typical trend following program applied purely to equities
versus purely to bonds. What's the sharp ratio for each of them? So, so historically equities has been disastrous and bond has been very good. So up until, if you ask me three years ago, I would have said equity. The problem with equity is that you see a lot of value players in the market. So you tend to see, you tend to see reversals, you tend to see negative auto correlation in equity. So if equity goes down on day one, it's likely to go up actually
on day two that we're likely to see a reversal because people are kind of coming in to buy and we can talk about it. We can actually see this data in flows. So if we look at ETFs, we look at the, the performance last month and we see the flow the, the following month you actually see a slight negative correlation I. E. If equities go down, you actually see more flows, a little bit more flows a month later people are basically buying the dips.
And, and that kind of, and that kind of means that inequity in general is actually makes it very fast. Trend is actually very difficult. Slow trend has worked reasonably. Sharp equity equity single just equity portfolio Sharp is, has not been great. Average market Sharp is not, has been like 0 2.2, 0.1, 0.2 in bonds. It's sort of sitting actually quite a bit higher historically. But you know, I don't want to make a claim because over time things
change. I think the, the good things about bonds is that Curry gives you a sort of a general drift that tends to, that tends to make long term trend actually perform very well. But you know, having said it, in the last four years bonds have been trading sideways and bond trend has been a disaster, like a negative one. Sharp. Okay. So nothing is guaranteed guarantees in life. And I, I wouldn't, I wouldn't advise you to go, you know, fully into just asset class.
I've just picked it. I think. Right. The way you kind of, I like to think about it is that you want to think about the cta. You know, it's a diversified program, but then you kind of want to think about what I want to achieve with it. And that means you actually want to tilt it depending on, you know, your equity bonds and, and, and, and commodities and we can come to that. Okay, well what about regimes and macro environments? I mean, because obviously this is another factor to what you've been thinking and writing about. And you know, we've obviously, as you alluded to, there had a regime
of low inflation, falling interest rates and a negative bond equity correlation in the 2000 and tens. Now we're into a positive correlation. We've had more supply shocks, et cetera, more periods of stagflationary pressures, if not maybe outright stagflation. So how does that play into it? Yes, so that's actually really interesting. So yeah, inflation going up has really changed people's perception
of where the world is going to. And of course the, the problem with the, with the fiscal situation of many, many developed markets is that, you know, debt is now sitting at 120 of GDP, 120% of GDP thereabout. And that means that there's a lot, lot less space for central banks and for governments to really provide relief in the case of an equity equity downturn. So people are kind of very rightly to be worried.
Actually I have, I think we, me and Adam wrote a paper in January this year about the combination of, about how commodity trend plays with bonds in the, in different inflationary regimes. And that's actually triggered quite a lot of conversations. So what you find with the most important variable that affects Trend
performance is actually inflation. And it plays most with commodities and it plays most with bond. With bond. It's actually an easier story to understand. If inflation starts rising, we tend to see rates rising. And what you find is that initially bonds will perform poorly. Exactly for the same reason that we discussed. There are second responders. But if we see sustained rise in yields, eventually bonds will
offer great convexity. Okay. In terms of, in terms of commodities it's actually very, it's. It's more interesting because it, it commodities in many ways is inflation. Right. The prices of commodities is the feeder to AI, the feeder to all industrial production. And you get, if you get, if you get sort of high industrial product
production, you are going to get a lot of demand to industrial commodities. You're going to get a lot of demand to energy futures and you're going to start seeing a rise in there. And that will actually be very supportive to trend. But inflation is actually the primary driver in terms of conditioning on commodity trend. And what you find is that they actually almost a mirror image of the way that long bonds exposure behave. So if you're a long bond and inflation is rising then or inflation
is high, bonds tend to perform very poorly. But commodity trend is exactly the time when commodity trend really shines. And the reason for that is because commodity has a positive convexity to inflation because it's one of the biggest drivers for commodities performance. Conversely, if inflation is really low and the economy is doing very well, then what you get to see is that bonds will do wonderfully
but commodity trend will tend to underperform. So the, the combination of commodities and bonds actually creates almost like A, an inflation plus 4% portfolio. So if you're looking for a defensive portfolio which is like you know, a lot of the, a lot of the public pension funds or the actually sovereign wealth funds have a target of inflation plus and bonds plus commodity trends are actually very good as
a. To create that sort of all weather inflation plus 4% sort of portfolio. Equities are a growth game. So what you see is when inflation is going down or inflation is low, equity will more than give you will have a very will give you inflation plus 10 or 12%. Right. So during benign economic conditions, equity seems to be able to give you not just inflation but also a great amount of growth.
And it goes like you know, 1012, that's really great. But when you think about, but when you think at a high inflation environment, equities are kind of barely are still able to give you inflation, but they're not going to give you the inflation plus. So that's kind of why I think about equities as a growth portfolio. It's inflation plus something which varies with growth. Whereas a bond plus commodity trend give you essentially inflation plus a constant number.
So these are the two things that kind of are the building blocks for I think for, for, for people who want to build an all weather portfolio. So that's the paper, that's the paper that we wrote in, in I think it was January, me and Adam pedal and a lot of the clients came back into us and talked about stagflation. Right. And they said okay, what, what happens, what happens in industrial production? What happens if the economy actually starts tanking? And that's, and that's a real concern right? Because we, if we start seeing problem in financing the capex that
we are seeing in equities, stagflation might be an issue. By the way, the AI that may not play out. Right. I'm not going to, I'm not going to like it could be that we are going to see. I'm personally quite bullish on the. I think what we've seen so far is infrastructure. I don't think about the hyperscalers as like AI the AI bet. I think what they're doing is they're laying the pipeworks, they're
laying the cables. You know that in the dot com bubble you just had to put a lot of capex in order just to set up the Internet infrastructure. By the way, they are not the beneficiary of that boom. So the people that benefited most were actually Google and Amazon and Facebook that built cash rich low capex businesses on top of those pipelines. It's the people who laid the pipelines didn't actually make that much money. Okay. What we're seeing now is we're seeing the, we're seeing the beginning
of the, the revolution in my mind. So we are seeing all of these hyperscalers actually turning into infrastructure companies. They are laying the pipes, they are laying the cables to build the, the basic unit which is called an LLM or an AI. And what you do with it right now we haven't even begun to investigate what we can do with it. So I'm actually very bullish on AI but we are like, I think we haven't even started to see the benefit in the sort of the people,
the software, the low capex companies which are just consuming AI and really improving. We haven't, I don't even know how it's going to play out, but I'm much more excited about those type of companies. I'm excited by the way on like the industrial commodities on the bottom and I'm excited by, to see what sort of applications we're going to see later on. But you know, people are rightly concerned that, you know, just like the dot com bubble, we might need to go through an adjustment
where we see a collapse in valuation and then the real economy will kick in and the real applications of the Internet or the real at the time will start kicking in and the real application in AI will start kicking in as well. So that's kind of my worldview. But clients were kind of worried about it and they said okay, what about industrial production? And we looked it at the time and it's really interesting. That trend doesn't seem to be in my mind Trond didn't seem to be
particularly affected by industrial production. The most significant impact, which is not surprising is exactly what we just discussed is that if we look at industrial commodities, if we look at energy commodities, they do well when industrial production is up. I mean that's, that's like. Sure,. Yeah, you know, it makes perfect sense. And actually it's nothing to do with inflation. You know, independently of inflation, industrial production is up, is very supportive of commodities and, and in general.
And by the way, we're seeing industrial production in the US up as well. So you know, it's not, it's not, it's not all doom and gloom. I think it's like 1.6 at the moment. Capacity utilization is up. I'm kind of excited by that. So it's not, it's not all doom and gloom on the industrial production side. But we didn't find anything to do with trend that was significant. And, and that's why I was quite excited. There was a paper came in October by our friends in.
In man that was a, a guy called Panashi. I hope I pronounce it correct. Panashi Bera. Yeah. Is the. And and you, I think a new strategist. Economy chief economist, I think, or chief strategies. Christina Hooper and Carnavi, who I have tremendous amount of respect to, really writes incredible papers and man wrote a paper with Otto Van Helmet a couple of years back. I think it was 2022 about inflation, the best time for inflation.
And I suspect they've been struggling with industrial production as well. Well, so, so they kind of, they probably said, okay, what happens when you try to marry industrial production with inflation? And they divided the, the data set. They go actually further back. They go all the way back to about 115 years. And, and they say, okay, can we, can we divide the history and see which, which systematic strategy does better over periods
of stagflation, over periods of an inflation runaway, overheating and you know, the rest. So that's kind of the paper. It just came up in October and I've got to say I'm, I'm not actually subscribing too much to what they came up. I mean even if you look at the, what the data. I don't think I agree with the data. I'm not sure I agree with the conclusions. Let's put this way. So, so, so what they do is they cut the, the history interest.
If you look at the high inflation periods, that gives you about 30% of the history. So let's say from 100 years we got down to 30 years. And then they kind of divided based based on stagflation overheating, based on the change in industrial production. And that kind of divides you into 15%, 15 to 15, 15 year periods roughly. Okay. And then they try to look not just at trend by the way they look at, they look at equity factors. So you know, quality versus junk.
Yeah, sort of, sort of the, the bar factors or the. Okay. And I'm not, I wasn't overwhelmed that there was actually any difference between the stagflation and the overheating. The, the main. In terms of the results or what. In terms of like how it's played historically. I mean, if you look at the, the various, you know, large, big, minor, small, whatever, all of these, all of these equity factors with the possible express exception of the betting against
beta, which is actually a very different factor from the, the rest the of of them. It's not about equity selection, it's about betting against beta is actually a diversification argument. With the exception of that pretty much they all performed pretty similarly as far as I can tell, between. It would have been nice if they put some error bars on that because then, then you'll see actually there's very little there. They come up with the same observation that commodities, and in particular industrial and energy commodities do very well in
overheating. So they do well in inflationary and in stagflationary periods. No,. No, no, no, no, no. When you look at, if you see a stagflation. Yeah. Then industrial commodities are not doing well. So. Okay,. Of course, yeah,. Yeah. Commodity trend does wonderfully because okay,. It's. Got convexity to industrial production. So commodity trend does very well either in stockflation or in other hitting okay, as long as there's good inflation, it's. Yeah, it's happy.
Right. I guess in a stagflationary environment. You know, historically they've generally been energy crises. So presumably,. Yes,. Energy prices go up, but metals, industrial commodities don't do as well. Is that the kind of how it has played out? I think as you go historically, I mean there's a lot of data management that you need to be very careful about when you go back historically. I'll just give you an example. So you know, you have the, you have the energy crisis to which really
towards the late of the, actually the, the late 70s is kind of a very interesting period that, that really affects quite a lot because you see a huge rise in yields. And following the Bretton Wood collapse, what you see is, is, is a period where there's like huge trends and you see yields going up, you see gold, you see effects. There's a lot of, there's a lot. That period is actually very, very difficult, very difficult from,
to include in a sort of stationary analysis because it tend to affect the data. If you go back, of course, the World War II, World War I will also tend to affect your data a little bit. Let's put it this way. Sure. And, and, and in terms of the amount of data that you have, right. I mean commodities, commodity futures, you start seeing sort of in the 70s, a little bit earlier than that 60s. If you start looking at tips, then tips only started trading in 1997, I think. Yeah. So like extending it backwards, it's a bit, it's a bit,
it's a bit dodgy, you know, it's, it's, it's kind of a difficult problem. There's a lot of data on, you have to be very careful about how you extend the data backwards. I know because I've gone through that process as well. So the amount of, the conclusions that you can make are kind of reduced because although you might be thinking I'm doing 115 years of data, you don't actually have that. And even the economic publication of industrial production
and inflation don't necessarily go back all that. Right. I can't remember when they started to get published. So there's a lot of back fitting of the actual economic data that you're doing. So, so it's, it's, it's, it's complicated. So the reason why I can make the claim about industrial production and industrial commodities is because you don't actually need to condition on inflation. If you don't condition inflation, that sort of Behavior is consistent historically. Okay, so good industrial activity is good for industrial commodities.
It's like, it's, it's a. And you can kind of understand what's happening, what's happening there with, with the, the rest, with the rest of the pack with the commodity, with the different types of trend. I don't think that there is much in there. I don't think industrial productions are actually a big and bigger factor. And with, with the equity factors, again with the possible exception of, with the, of the betting against beta, I'm not sure
that there's anything there. And then they go on and divide it to accelerating and accelerating, accelerating regimes which even divides the data even to smaller bits. And I'm not sure, I'm not sure it's, it's. I'm not sure. I read what they read into becomes very unstable from like a T stat sort of statement to make T stat statements. So from your perspective, nothing conclusive? I would say, I would say the one thing that clients should be aware is that if we are actually going to see good industrial production and we're going to see AI playing out, then you know,
a portfolio of, you know, copper, other industrial productions, other particularly in AI energy futures are going to do wonderfully. Like it's a long only exposure. Even if the AI doesn't, isn't going to play out and we're going to see stagflation, then commodity trend is going to do very well. Thank you very much. So that's kind of the conclusion I can take out of this one. So you mentioned a bunch of different papers and blogs and issues
that contribute to the kind of the overall selection and construction of your CTA portfolio. If you're like bringing that all together, what, what would you say? Oh, okay. So, so I actually have a table in front of me. Maybe I should put it afterwards, which is whatever. So it's like it, it really depends again what you want out of your portfolio. So some clients just say okay, I want the CTA portfolio that I can live with. You know, CTAs are difficult, difficult to live with. You go down the stairs, you come up the elevators, you might have three years with no performance. Your IC will look at you, sorry, investment committee will
look at you like an idiot. Why did you allocate to trend? So you kind of want to create a basket which you can live with. So you, you might want to say just I want high alpha CTA book. Okay. And for that it's actually very, very simple. What you have is your basic ingredient which is kind of liquid. Let's liquid cta, you can get it very cheaply. You can get an, you can get a index replicator, you can get an etf, you can get something with a very low fee. It's all very exciting, okay?
Balanced across all asset classes. And then you think about what can I possibly add to my portfolio that will add value to me. So there's obviously alternative CTAs okay. And alt market CTAs. Let's assume they have the same sharpest as liquid CTAs and they have historically 70%, maybe 80% really depending on the CTA. It's been going up as capacity has been constrained but somewhere
between 70 and 80% correlation. What this tells you is that if you add let's say 50% allocation to an alternative CTA that will give you, that will take you from a shop of one to shop of 1.08 say it will give you maybe 8% increase on your shop. Okay, now let's look at fast trend. Okay, so what fast trend?
A lot of fast trend program. There's the sttr, the, the SOC gen Short term trading index. And what you see is that from an alpha perspective it's actually not very conducive because historically they've had, they've really struggled because of that negative autocorrelation the short term and they still have 50, 50, 60 correlation to, to liquid trend. So the, the, they're actually sort of negatively additive from
a. If you just want a standalone sharp, okay. Just based on historical. I mean of course, maybe you know, in the next year stti you're going to kick it, you know, kick it out of the field. But I, but historically it's been very, it's a very, very tough space for them. And if you're looking just for a standalone sharp, it's very difficult. Then you have like speciality cta. So you might want to have spread cta. So you know, our friends Moritz and Moritz have got a lot of exposure there.
So shout out to them. They will have very low reasonably local relation to trend. And you might want to add that you're going to have commodity trend, so asset specific. So what you find with asset class specific is that equity trend is going to be very highly correlated to your CTA and bond trend will be very highly correlated to cta. And the reason for that is because the risk factors that they are trending, they are trading are necessarily that growth factor, that trend in growth, you know, macro trend, big factor that
all CTAs tend to over allocate to the one asset class that is very distinct because these are very distinct risk factors is exactly commodity trend. So commodity trend, if you look historically has only maybe 20, 30% correlation to, to liquid trend. So if you add it, that will bump up your performance 30%. So you're going, going from say a liquid trend 60%, you're going
to go to 80% to sorry, from a sharp of 0.6 to a sharp of 0.8. Okay. And that makes it a lot easier for you to live with. By the way, once you add commodity trend, it adds no value whatsoever. To add alternative trend. Like the additional sharp from alternative trend after you add commodity trend is like literally zero. Okay? So, so actually in terms of the. What you have is in order to add to your liquid allocation, alternative trend will add you a little bit.
It will, it will be adding a little bit of diversification and maybe, maybe bump you up from 60 to 65 basis point. Commodity trend will add you to around 80 basis points. Spread trend will add you a little bit more as well. So that's kind of the way that you kind of want to think about it. But then you might say actually what I want is equity convexity or I want bond convexity. Okay? And there you kind of have to think about what you want. So commodity trend doesn't really add you any, any equity convergence
convexity whatsoever. Okay, it will add commodity, commodity trend will add to bond convexity. But just as we discussed about bonds and commodity interaction, but very little equity convexity. You're not buying commodity trend for crisis alpha. The interesting thing actually that if you look at the analysis is that alternative trend doesn't add you equity convexity either. So if you look at alt trend historically, I looked at pretty much all the usual suspects.
You break it down essentially very little equity trend, very, very little equity convexity. And I think it's reasonable because what you find is that a lot of the allocation in alternative trend is already less in the equity space. And the reason for that is because when you look at the alternative markets, there is a little bit of credit and credit does have equity behind it, but it's very much focused in the interest rates swap market. It's very much in alternative commodities. So, so it kind of, it's, it's, it's a little bit, it's a little
bit, it doesn't seem to, to, you know, the data doesn't, doesn't give you that much. It does give you again, some bond convexity. And that's kind of to be Expected again because a lot of interest rate swaps being traded and cash bonds and whatnot. Fast trend is very exciting because a lot of people want to buy fast trend for added convexity. And I think the, what we talked about, about the exposure convexity comes to play here because what you see with fast trend
is it comes out, it's, it's more of a first responder because the position will turn very quickly but long term. You remember what we talked about in terms of the, how much committed trend is the exposure, the exposure convexity that you get. It it gets like 2% instead of 3 and a half percent. It, it, it because fast trend is less. Because it, it manages the risk so much. It is less committed on average to the full trend.
It doesn't go full latte. Like a really slow trend basically takes time to build a position but then is like I'm fully in, okay. But a fast trend is like I'm going to change my mind so often that in expectations I end up actually not having too much exposure. And this is by the way born out of if you look at the stti. So if you look at the short term trading index, if you look at the one month, one month crisis and you do the analysis and you try to fit the convexity, you get fast trend giving twice as much convexity as a normal trend program.
But if you look at quarterly crisis in equity, fast trend is already the same as a normal trend exposure. So it really depends. If you want to protect yourself against very sharp shocks like one month in, then fast trend will give you that little bit of extra. But actually from a long term perspective like quarterly drawdowns, you know, yearly drawdowns which, you know, a stagflation environment, fast trend isn't actually the one is going to give you the, the
most convexity for your money because it only gives you like 30% percent commitment rather than 60% commitment that that slow trend gives you. So that's, that's kind of the, the convexity argument. Now if you want bond convexity then you should go to bond trend. There's like, that's like that's kind of an easy, an easy and easy manager. You know, you get a little bit from commodity trend, you get a little bit from Altrand, but actually from a capacity from. So from capital efficiency point of view, like there's no nothing
to compare to it. Like nothing compares to this. So that's kind of the, the business. So if you want additive alpha, you basically just want commodity trend. If you want equity convexity then you kind of, it's very difficult in general. Bond trend will give you a little bit of first responder exposure. Equity trend, you'll just have to buy a lot of it fast trend is not going to give you as much as you like unless you really are very focused on very short term, short term crisis. I guess what you're saying is obviously, and I mean this comes
back to a theme that we touched on a lot when we did the full series back in 2023. We're talking to all of the CTAs, you know, in terms of what is your objective with a CTA portfolio? Is it absolute return which you would, I suppose you're talking about alpha or is it absolute return plus crisis alpha? Are more crisis alpha oriented? I guess what you're saying is how you think about all of that not only determines how much or maybe it should drive the nature
of your CTA exposure. And obviously you can get that if you are building a CTA or else I guess in terms of manager selection as well. Now there was another paper we were going to talk on that but I don't think we're going to have time to, to delve into that unfortunately. But maybe that's best left for, for another episode. But is it fair to say that's the natural extension of your analysis? So I think, I think there's, there's a wonderful paper. I mean we're not going to talk about it but the quantical recent
paper about, about Being Paid to Play which was part of the Quarterly Insight and what they're talking about is, is, is not actually what they, they take a different angle. But I think what is important to understand is that the way that people tend to invest what they've observed that the way that people tend to invest in trend following is basically trend following trend following. So they, they look at our performance and, and the flows that we see in the ETF and in the, in the mutual funds, they reflect
very much a trend following behavior by the way with the Same sort of 60% slow trend, 60% exposure to Delta to, to trend following. And I, I think it's, it, it's very destructive from an investor's perspective. If the investor just have one manager and he will and, and the allocator is going to change his mind and he's going to try and follow that trend follower. I think what the quantica paper demonstrated is actually how
poor destructive, how destructive it is. Right. Yeah. And I think what is important is what I wanted to talk about is like how many managers you want to have. But I suspect in order to alleviate that risk from your perspective, because if you know that you're going to try and follow performance, you can accept it, but then say, okay, let's try and create something which is more stable across managers. But we don't have time. So I think that will wait for a different for. Another. Day. Another day. Okay. Well, good stuff. Well, good to chat to you. I mean, if people want to see your table and delve into that analysis
a bit more, there are blogs that you've written under you find them on LinkedIn. So if people want to delve into them in a bit more detail and I'm sure you would welcome any feedback as well. So they're on LinkedIn LinkedIn for people to access. So next week Niels is back here. So if you have any questions, feel free to send them in for Niels. And yeah, from all of us here at Top Traders Unplugged, thanks
for tuning in. We'll be back again soon with more content. Thanks for listening to Top Traders Unplugged. If you feel you learned something of that value from today's episode, the best way to stay updated is to go on over to your favorite podcast platform and follow the show so that you'll be sure to get all the new episodes as they're released. We have some amazing guests lined up for you and to ensure our show continues to grow, please leave us an honest rating and review. It only takes a minute and it's the best way to show us you love the podcast. We'll see you next time on Top Traders Unplugged.
This podcast expresses the views of its host, hosts, and the guests appearing on the podcast as of the date of its recording, and such views are subject to change without notice. Top Traders Unplugged do not have any duty or obligation to update the information contained herein. Furthermore, Top Traders Unplugged make no representation to its accuracy and it shall not be assumed that past investment performance is an indication of future results. Moreover, wherever there is a potential for profit, there is also the possibility of loss. This content is made available for educational purposes only and should not be used for any other purpose. The information contained in this podcast does not constitute and should not be construed as investment advice or an offer to
sell or a solicitation to buy any securities or related financial instruments in any jurisdiction. Certain information contained herein concerning economic trends and performance is based on or derived from information provided by independent third party sources. Top Traders Unplugged may believe that the sources from which such information are obtained are reliable. However, Top Traders Unplugged cannot guarantee the accuracy of such information and has not independently verified the accuracy or completeness of the such information or the assumptions on which such information is based. This podcast, including the information contained herein, may not be reproduced, copied, republished, or posted in whole or
in part in any form, without the prior written consent of Top Traders Unplugged.
For decades, China's economic rise seemed unstoppable. But beneath the surface of its extraordinary growth, something has been quietly breaking down. Kevin Coldiron is joined by Logan Wright, author of Broken China, to...
What if one of the biggest misconceptions about trend following is what investors expect it to do? Niels Kaastrup-Larsen and Alan Dunne are joined by Philippe Jordan, President of CFM, for a conversation that challenges...
What happens when the system holding global markets together begins to reach its breaking point? In the wake of the US midterm elections, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen is joined by Cem Karsan for a conversation about the...
Moritz Seibert is joined by QuantEdge CEO Suhaimi Zainul-Abidin to explore how one of Singapore’s most successful systematic firms approaches risk, diversification and long-term compounding. Suhaimi explains why...
How resilient is your portfolio if stocks and bonds fall together? Alan Dunne joins Niels Kaastrup-Larsen to examine what stock-bond correlations can conceal and why owning more assets may leave investors exposed to the...