Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Time Pals

Time Pals artwork

Time Pals Do the Oscars Worst 2001-2005 Edition (Feat. "Hollywood Fringe Legend" Veronica Matthews)

Mar 28, 20251 hr 5 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail Time Pals begin their peer-reviewed and meticulously researched version of “Marry, Eff, Kill” for the Best Picture Winners and nominees of 2001 through 2005. Join co-hosts Mike Underscore, ShadoSpartan, Jon Powell, and Nickell as they venture through a special two-part episode through the Academy’s most dubious decisions, fixes film history’s wrongs, and hands the gold statues to the movies that truly deserved them. Joining the Time Pals is special guest and close friend of Nickell, “Hollywood Fringe Legend” Veronica Matthews. Matthews credits include writing, directing, and performing in multiple stage and theater shows, and her work in the transgender community has been highly praised and brings a much-needed extra voice to keep Jon Powell in line. Find all our links and episodes at: ⁠⁠⁠⁠https://beacons.ai/timepalspodcast⁠⁠⁠⁠ ⁠⁠⁠⁠https://www.instagram.com/timepalspodcast/⁠⁠⁠⁠ ⁠⁠⁠⁠https://www.youtube.com/@TimePalsPodcast/videos⁠⁠⁠⁠ Contact Us at: ⁠⁠⁠⁠Timepalspodcast@gmail.com Join us at our new home on the ⁠⁠MaydayMedia Network⁠⁠ (⁠⁠https://maydaymedianetwork.com/⁠⁠) and be sure to check out all our new Pals everywhere you get your podcasts ShadoSpartan's newest retro deep dives can be found here: https://www.youtube.com/@ShadoSpartan44 Veronica Matthews work from StageCrafts and Theatre Unleased can be found here: https://www.youtube.com/live/scsWC1Q02II?si=jC3gAwwkyy1QkCkr https://www.youtube.com/live/17pzC6uVr7k?si=vPSVL7k90vaUXOcZ #podcasts #nerdculture #timepals #timepalspodcast#maydaymedianetwork #legendarysupplements #gamers #nostalgia #throwback #podcast #Academy Awards #Oscars #Best Picture #2000s films #filmanalysis #cinematic debates #Hollywood Fringe #Veronica Matthews Chapters 00:00 Late Nights and Cheap Wine 02:20 Introducing Veronica Matthews: A Hollywood Fringe Legend 08:20 Diving into the Oscars: 2001 Best Picture Discussion 17:47 Exploring 2002 Best Picture Nominees 25:32 The Subjectivity of Film and Oscar Nominations 32:04 The Value of Comedy in Filmmaking 35:26 Animated Films and Their Impact and 2003 37:50 Best Picture Nominees: A Year in Review 46:01 Controversial Choices in Best Picture Nominations 55:00 Debating the Best Films of 2004 01:02:43 Nickell's 2005 winner is a Southern dandy Support the show

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_04This week, the Time Pals begin their peer-reviewed and meticulously researched version of F. Mary Kilt for the best picture winners and nominees of the 2000s generation. Because of the sheer number of lively cursed word-filled discussions, the episode was broken up into two parts. Part 1 focusing on the winners and nominees from 2001 to 2005, and part two focusing on the winners and nominees of 2006 to 2010. All the Time Palads are with me this week as we venture into the Academy's most dubious decisions, we fixed a few film wrongs, and had out a few gold statutes along the way.

SPEAKER_04The Time Palads also welcome special guests on the show, Hollywood fringe legend Veronica Matthews. Veronica is a highly praised stage actress, writer, and director, close friend of co-host Nickel, and someone that brings a much-needed extra voice to keep John Powell in line. So if you are just listening to us for the first time, our last episode, we went through all the best picture winners from the 90s.

SPEAKER_04So after that one, uh during our production meeting, Nickel decided he wanted to do it again because he loved calling John wrong for two hours straight. Only one of which actually made it into the episode. So imagine all the stuff you missed. Um with me for this generation, which is uh basically the early 2000s, I have Shadow Spartan.

SPEAKER_06This episode is not sponsored by Sparkling Ice, but I love that. I love that stuff, dude.

SPEAKER_04So I don't think they've ever like, I don't think they've talked to us anymore. I still talk to them. You really? Okay. It's an energy drink company, and go buy it. They don't give a shit. They're a spiritual sponsor. Yes, exactly. Uh also with me today is John Powell. Hi. That's it. Kraken energy. Oh, you were saying it's slower. Yeah. God.

SPEAKER_06Way to interrupt him, Mike.

SPEAKER_04Nickel's gonna beat the shit out of you in this episode. I can feel it. That's fine, Brilliant. I put way more effort into this one. Yes, yes, clearly. And uh also, as always, Nickel.

SPEAKER_07Yes. Uh, and uh as Mike uh is underscore said before, I'm happy to introduce the Time Pals and our listeners to a very talented writer and actress. She's written and performed Trans Setter, a one-person show, and Transpiring, a hip-hop vampire musical. You can find the links on both shows below. Uh, it's Hollywood Fringe Legend, Veronica Matthews. The thank you for joining us.

SPEAKER_07I'm excited to be finally working with you in a creative atmosphere and not just cutting and crimping.

SPEAKER_04You were so excited that you totally cut her off.

SPEAKER_02No, no, he had more to say, and I wanted to hear that. I wanted to because it was only good stuff. Yeah, which we get into the episode. So seeing more of that, like you can why did the intro have to be I I thought it was too short, but that's fine. No, two shorts from Oakland. That's true.

SPEAKER_04I'm sorry. That's true, yeah. So, Veronica, where does the Hollywood Fringe Legend nickname come from?

SPEAKER_02Um, it came from needing to have some sort of description for the show. Um but it is also true. I there if for those who don't know, there is a the Hollywood Fringe Festival is at least the largest of its kind on the West Coast, if um and one of the biggest in the country, based on the same similar uh fringe festival I have in Edinburgh, where it's a festival of self-produced projects. And so yeah, I've been doing that. I've been active with that for like the last 10 years.

SPEAKER_02I've done I've been involved with eight different projects. I've been yeah, nominated for different stuff and was one year in a show that I've done again since called The Very Die Hard Christmas that won Best Comedy. Play a lot of different stuff in that. I yeah, my solo show. I did that in 2021, got nominated for like best solo show.

SPEAKER_04And what's a very diehard Christmas?

SPEAKER_02So it's it's and I know you did a diehard episode and whether Die Hard is a Christmas movie. And this this play basically is like it is most definitely a Christmas movie, and it takes the movie of Die Hard.

SPEAKER_07I instantly regret you as having I instantly regret having you as a guest.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I don't know what you thought this was gonna be like, but it's and it combines it it combines diehard with like classic Christmas tropes movies characters like Crossy of the Snowman, Ru uh Rudolph Breno's reindeer, uh things like that, and Muppet's Christmas, like, and it's a musical, so yeah, it's a lot of fun. I just did it again this past December. We know we normally would do it at our company through in December, and this is the first time I'd done it since so I did it before I transitioned. Um, by the way, I'm transgender, blah blah blah. Let's get that elephant out there. If you didn't know, by the titles Trans Setter and Transpiring.

SPEAKER_02Um, but yeah, that was before I transitioned, then I did it again, and it was a lot of fun. Played, I did one scene where I was Catherine O'Hara as a terrorist. That was fun. So yeah, but yeah, I've done a lot of projects there and I've I've just been doing, I've been in LA for like 20 years, doing I've done stand-up, I've done improv and sketch. I just actually got invited to do my friend's show called The Late Musical Show, which is like a like a late night talk show format, but live, and it's and we do it's an improv musical as well. I've played Princess Peach before, and I played well, Moaning Myrtle in our Halloween episode, and then they're doing it like a Wizard of Oz one, so he wants me to play Glinda.

SPEAKER_02So yeah, I do, you know, I just I do stuff. I've been on TV a couple times for random stuff, so I don't know. I'm no great Cummins, but yeah.

SPEAKER_05Veronica, it it seems like you mentioned several musical-related projects. And with that in mind, do you feel like you are kind of on the pulse of movie and TV musicals that have come out over the years? No, don't ask her this. Have you heard of the movie, or sorry, have you heard of the television show Gallivant?

SPEAKER_02I've heard the name. I I don't know much about it. I was really hoping shows.

SPEAKER_05It's a good show and it's a musical, and you should like it, you theatered nerd. We went through this already.

SPEAKER_04First off, as a guest. Not Veronica, you. Yeah, I know, I know, I know. Secondly, um, I know she's bragging, but trying not to, but not to be not to uh outdo you, but I am a 40-year-old father who is wearing a hat usually made for 22-year-olds, trying to relive a generation they never knew nothing about. So I have that going for me and nothing else but this show. So I'm letting you know you're overqualified and we love having you here.

SPEAKER_04Um, if there's anything you want to plug later, please do because I guarantee you I don't have the money to go see it. But you're here.

SPEAKER_05Legitimate, legitimate suggestion, though. Legitimate suggestion. I'll take all the time. I want to fucking do a road trip to Hollywood Fringe because I knew about the Edinburgh one, and I've wanted to go for so long, but like I'm poor, so not really doable. But Hollywood is just like that direction, and I can get there, and we should fucking road trip.

SPEAKER_04You're not you're not getting in free, you're not gonna be put in the play. Let it go, my friend. Yeah, make a woman.

SPEAKER_02So there's a lot of shows that do do like pay what you can, or like preview is like a dollar, and there are a lot of interactive immersive shows where you I've participated participated in shows where it's like, okay, can we get someone to come? And I've you know, I've done that. I did that a few times last year at shows that I I went and saw. So yes, you it is cheaper. You can like I the the key to seeing a lot of shows at Fringe without paying is to produce another show and then just uh like be like, hey, come see my show and I'll come see your show.

SPEAKER_02In lieu of that, though, yes, there are ways to see lots of shows for cheap, and it is much cheaper than going to Edinburgh. So awesome.

SPEAKER_04Are you happy now?

SPEAKER_05Yeah, well, I mean, it's it's it's more doable than us going to the fucking slow jamistan.

SPEAKER_04I don't know what this us thing is.

SPEAKER_05You're not gonna go. You're not allowed to go. We don't want to be seen in public with you, John. Yeah, let's do this, man. Let's do this show. Okay.

SPEAKER_07The Oscars. The Oscars.

SPEAKER_05Oscars number one, the grouch. Is he really as grouchy as he seems?

SPEAKER_07I'm already upset with John. It has begun. I know. I'm already upset with John. Go for it.

SPEAKER_05Go. Kick us off, buddy. Me or Mike?

SPEAKER_04Oh no, you. You.

SPEAKER_05You to the host. Come on now.

SPEAKER_04Yeah.

SPEAKER_05This is your I'm not the host. This is I just started saying the Oscars. I thought you were about to go into some like I swear.

SPEAKER_02It's understandable.

SPEAKER_04So we're gonna start with 2001. The film's nominated that year, Gladiator, Chocolate. Oh no, I'm sorry, that's right. That's right, right? Okay. Chocolate, Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon, Aaron Brokovich, and Traffic. And the winner that year, I believe, was Gladiator. Correct. Yeah. Um, yeah.

SPEAKER_07No argument here.

SPEAKER_05From me with Gladiator winning.

SPEAKER_07Right. I got, I got, I am so unprepared.

SPEAKER_05I I I have that notes brought up. You have no I have no issue with Gladiator winning.

SPEAKER_04It was great. I will I will help you out. I will help you out. So the first thing I'm gonna eliminate from this bullshit list is Chocolat. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. To put a better movie in there, Memento came out that year. I loved Memento. Is that yours too? I love I said Memento or Brother Wear at that. I loved Or Brother War there as well. It's I I would put if I had to only get rid of one, I would put Memento just because I loved the I basically loved the entire idea of it. Apparently, there's a on the DVD, there's actually a a secret where you can play the movie forwards, like with as if it wasn't going backwards.

SPEAKER_04And it's not as good. So we took like a basically a V minus, C plus mystery movie, and by chopping it up, they turned it into, my opinion, of an an A-level movie. I see. I see.

SPEAKER_07Yeah, I I did find my notes and I did type out 2001 is impossible. Because you had movies like The Patriot, Perfect Storm, Requiem for a Dream, Memento, Snat, American Psycho, Unbreakable, Remember the Titans, even. Okay.

SPEAKER_03Now Castaway.

SPEAKER_07And Castaway. Yeah, Castaway was dead, but I thought I I would I would agree you take out Shock a lot. But you could put any one of those movies in there. Any one of them in there to replace Shock a lot. And uh I hate to say it, but I still feel like Gladiator wins.

SPEAKER_05Yeah, from Does They were only between Gladiator and Crouching Tiger. Those were the only two competing for it. So Veronica, why are we wrong?

SPEAKER_02Um I you know, honestly, for this one, I I wouldn't say you're wrong. I Gladiator was very good, very good movie. Um I would take out Chocolat and then I would give it to like a dog I didn't like, kill two birds with one stone. Um I'm so you mentioned Memento. So this is this is a grander thing of my my research. I didn't I didn't do like years of research for this when I found out, but I I did some research and I had a very tough time because I'm like, okay, so it's 2001 to 2011.

SPEAKER_02So those are like the Oscar years. Like this was nominated in and it was um possibly a best picture nominee in the 2001 year. So that means it would have come out in 2000. Yes. Or like from Memento. So I I had to keep going back and forth because I would look up something and would say, Well, it was 2001, but no, this was 2000. And I got confused, so I would have to go and look up any movie that I thought was worth mentioning, like Memento. I would look up and see, well, was it nominated? Like if it wasn't a best picture nominee, was it nominated for something else?

SPEAKER_02So I could know what year it was a part of.

SPEAKER_07That's my fault. That's really my fault. I should have told you that ahead of time and been like, we discovered this on this last episode. Yeah. So that's my fault.

SPEAKER_02Memento came out in 2000, but it was actually nominated for um a couple Oscars in 2002 and not 2001. So does that mean we should be bringing it up for 2002 since they came out awarded?

SPEAKER_04No, I I would stick with the two if it came out in 2000. I would say it would be a good one. Yeah, I'm not sure why it had nominations in 2002. That's odd.

SPEAKER_07You know what? I don't you know what she brings up a good point because I was looking up, I was trying to do my research for 2009, and it said 2008, the Hurt Locker was released, but it didn't win. It didn't win the best picture until 2010 or 11 or something.

SPEAKER_02Really?

SPEAKER_072010.

SPEAKER_02Wow.

SPEAKER_06Well, I think it I think it gets like a select release, so it can be at that Oscars, but like the full release sometimes happens the next year. It's a weird situation.

SPEAKER_05Oh, they're doing what they need to to get double coverage.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, I basically you can release one movie for three years and be nominated every single year.

SPEAKER_07Okay, all right. But uh, you know, that and and it also depends on if James Cameron is heavily, heavily uh uh you know selling his movie to the Academy. So we'll address that when we get to uh 2010. But but Veronica, what if you had a movie for 2000 or 2001.

SPEAKER_02If we include Memento in the 2001, even though it was 2002, and when we get to 2002, I will bring up Memento again.

SPEAKER_04Uh totally fine. That's actually on on brand for the movie.

SPEAKER_02That's true, right? I'm just gonna forget that I I already brought it up. Good. Um you mentioned, yeah, one of my absolute favorite movies of all time is American Psycho. Um that would have been one I would have maybe put in there ahead of Chocolate. Um but yeah, also there's just a bunch of like I wrote down like Requiem for a Dream was too what would have been in this one, right? Right, yes.

SPEAKER_04It was a tough year. Yeah. Almost Famous was this year too, right?

SPEAKER_05Yeah. Famous was really good. To be fair though, I would have put Emperor's new groove ahead of chocolate. So like there's a new groove in everything we do. It's an amazing movement that deserves more recognition. It does not. John. John, stop. No animated movies until 2002. That's why I'm mad because it deserved the recognition of being made a time.

SPEAKER_04It did not. Yeah, we know. Wait, wait, wait, hold on.

SPEAKER_07John. Okay, first of all, we have a guest, okay? We have a guest. Don't make me get angry with a guest. Secondly.

SPEAKER_02No, get angry.

SPEAKER_07Secondly. Secondly, that movie is garbage.

SPEAKER_04Why do you go there with him?

SPEAKER_05Why? That is offensive. That is offensive. Firstly, all John Musing voice acting performances, least of all, like the least of them was David Spade, and the best of them was Earth a Kit.

SPEAKER_07No, no. Ask yourself, ask yourself, does a movie with David Spade deserve a best picture nomination? There's your answer. More recognition. And thirdly, Dom still needs a turn. So we need to finish, we need to finish Veronica's turn and then give Dom a turn.

SPEAKER_02And you need to wait. Um, first of all, if you're saying that Joe Dirt was wasn't one of the biggest snubs of all time, I don't know what.

SPEAKER_07Oh God, again.

SPEAKER_02I are But then we're talking about the Yeah, that was in there. I forget what year that was.

SPEAKER_07But yeah, it was a tearjerker. I won't lie to you, but not best picture nod. Everything is a tearjerker team.

SPEAKER_08That's true.

SPEAKER_02Um, so Memento I would put in there. Um, American Psycho, yeah. And then yeah, A Requiem for Dream was great. Castaway was also mentioned. That was a great movie. Yeah, this was a really great year for movies. And I don't, I mean, most of the top nominees, anyways, I thought were also deserving. So there's nothing I would really eliminate from those. And yeah, I have no qualms with Gladiator.

SPEAKER_04And Gladiator still wins in your list, I'm guessing. Okay. That that's fair. Dumb.

SPEAKER_06Um, well, I still think Gladiator is definitely the winner of that one. Still a great movie. I think just as a honorable mention, uh, John, I mean, we all know Emperor's Newgrove really wasn't that great. It's all about the road to El Dorado was way better than that movie.

SPEAKER_05I mean, that did did open up my mind to the idea of of thick animated Latino women. Let's move on. Okay. That's all I wanted to say, so we can move on.

SPEAKER_04I love you, Dom. 2002. So 2002, the nominees were A Beautiful Mine, Gosford Park, In the Bedroom, the Lord of the Rings Fellowship of the Ring, and Moulin Rouge. And the winner, obviously, that year was not Lord of the Rings.

SPEAKER_07Uh, this this is another tough one. Although I will say, and this is gonna be a recurring theme, if you're going to nominate musicals. Okay, I'm just gonna leave that because that's gonna come up later. I would take I would I would take out Mulan Rouge and I would, I would hear him gasp?

SPEAKER_03Did you hear Todd gasp?

SPEAKER_05You would do that to Obi-Wan Kenobi, you bastard.

SPEAKER_07Look, look, uh this is my honest God opinion. I would take out Mulan Rouge and I would put in Blackhawk down.

SPEAKER_04Well, here's I I actually don't know if I should probably should have said it just because we were all being goofy about it. So a beautiful mind won that year. Yeah. If the last org on the planet, Lord of the Rings was gonna be that winner.

SPEAKER_07Yeah, and and and I honestly uh I probably think Lord of the Rings should have won. But if I'm all I could decide on for that year was I'm taking out Moolon Rouge and I'm putting in Blackhawk Down.

SPEAKER_05I agree with you.

SPEAKER_07Maybe, maybe.

SPEAKER_05I'm on a similar I'm on a similar path with you, Chris.

SPEAKER_07I'm not even I'm not even sure about it though. You know? Really? I'm not 100% sold, but I think if I had to make a choice, it would be take out Moulin Rouge and put in Blackhawk Down. I think Blackhawk Down was a really well-made movie. It's a war movie. Um war movie. No, but I mean it was it, it was like it I know it won a bunch of Oscars for like sound editing and video editing and stuff like that.

SPEAKER_07It was a really, really good movie. But if you're asking me, putting a gun to my head, like if I have to take out one, I would take out Moon Rouge and put in Black Hawk down. But a beautiful mind, I think, would probably still win.

SPEAKER_04Really? Even with your Lord of the Rings admission that it should have won, you would still have a beautiful mind win. Well, because that was just the first one, right?

SPEAKER_07Yeah. So that's not the best one.

SPEAKER_05Okay. I mean, it it it laid the foundation though. Like, like, I mean, we all know without a question, I was gonna say Lord of the Rings should have won. Because that's my answer for any year that Lord of the Rings is up for anything. Beautiful Mind is an amazing movie and deserved second place easily. Mulan Rouge, I fucking love Mulan Rouge. I guess I will still watch it. Gosford Park was an amazing, like, murder mystery. It's it's it it did so good. It did such a good job of keeping that genre going. In the bedroom can just go fuck off in some direction, for all I care.

SPEAKER_05But this is where I said I was on a similar path as you. If if in the bedroom can fuck off, you can easily replace it with Blackhawk Down. My next or or one of two other movies. Now I would like to say this before I say what the next movie is. Before I say the next movie that I replace in the bedroom with. That I would like to say that J.K. Rowling is the Elon Musk of authors. We were duped, bamboozled, built con, and all of the other words I wrote down from the thesaurus earlier today.

SPEAKER_05She, like Elon, is a con who needs to be headbutted. Harry Potter was a very well-made movie, and so was Super Troopers.

SPEAKER_04Um interesting. I only saw the first two Harry Potter movies. I was not a Harry Potter guy. When when those books came out, I was still in college, so I was I wasn't reading quote unquote kids' books, but it seemed like everybody on the planet was reading. Um I can see that being there. I don't think it wins. I can see that, you know.

SPEAKER_05Shouldn't win. I'm just saying it it sh it should have been nominated more. Like it was one of the movies I was able to replace in the bedroom with, but like Blackhawk Down was at the head of that listing.

SPEAKER_04See, I wasn't as big of a Blackhawk Down stand as you guys were. I I thought it was fine. I thought it was great, but I wouldn't have replaced it. May I offer two other ones? Because I've never seen In the Bedroom or Crossford Park. So if I remove those two, I would replace one with Mulholland Drive and then the other one with Donnie Darko, which is a movie that but it became a cult movie. You have to acknowledge that it became an occult movie.

SPEAKER_07Nope.

SPEAKER_04Did you forget me while you blew your nose? What the fuck was that? That was me raspbearing. He's raspbearing Donnie Darko. The only other one I could think of would be would be Ghost World, but nobody saw Ghost World.

SPEAKER_05It was such a funny fucking movie.

SPEAKER_04Such a good fucking movie. Here's the thing about Ghost World. No lasting impact. No, none.

SPEAKER_07None. No. But you know what? Underscore, yeah. I was absolutely raspberrying you. Oh no. I don't know. I'm as hard as I could about Donnie Darko.

SPEAKER_03One of my favorite movies. How dare you?

SPEAKER_04I'm gonna yell at you like I yell at John. How dare you? Let me explain. Donnie Darko, Wes Anderson's Roll Tanne Bones came out that year too. Those two movies influenced the shit out of our friends. It doesn't matter. Well, yes, it does. No, it doesn't. That doesn't make it a good movie. No, no, no. But if you're talking about what stays in the consciousness, Donnie Darko stayed in that shit for a decade. Well, sure, sure.

SPEAKER_07It's a cult classic, but it's not a best movie of that year. Are you kidding me? Have to acknowledge that it's a cult classic. I will I'll tell you, I won't shit on you as hard as I like to shit on John, but I'll I'll I'll agree to disagree. Does nobody else think there was a better movie with him in it?

SPEAKER_01John. Bubble Boy. Bubble Boy's great.

SPEAKER_05Bubble Boys are great, but thank you.

SPEAKER_04So no, no, better than Donnie Dark. It's a good movie.

SPEAKER_05It's a good movie. It's just not one of the ones that I'm like, oh my god, Moholland Drive.

SPEAKER_04Moholl and Drive at least lasted with me.

SPEAKER_05Gosford Park was right in the same vein as like your murder by death, your your glass onion.

SPEAKER_04So it's it's more, it's got like that tongue-in-cheek element. I should probably watch it. I like those two. It's a good, you would definitely like it. Okay.

SPEAKER_07Fair enough. Veronica, what do you think? What do you think about that? What do you think about that year, Veronica?

SPEAKER_02About that year? I mean, I have some thoughts about what just transpired. I have more. Um, first of all, yeah, Nickel, great move without your video on to Raspberry, because that really comes across. We really get that that's thank you.

SPEAKER_07That's podcasting. That's not that's not gonna affect the editing at all.

SPEAKER_04No, not at all.

SPEAKER_07Not at all.

SPEAKER_04It's just gonna be every goddamn speaker.

SPEAKER_02We just go by that maxima, we'll fix it in post. That's right, right. Yeah, I also I'm looking at the where's um so at first they're just uh like top, like winner of beautiful mind and a lot of um I've heard, well, Lord of the Rings. Both yeah, great movies. I can't I couldn't argue with replacing Beautiful Mind with Lord of the Rings, but I I I really like Beautiful Mind. Um, so I'm not gonna just eliminate like that's that's fine if it holds that top spot. I didn't see in the bedroom. So let me I'll replace that with pretty sure this hasn't been brought up.

SPEAKER_02There was a movie that came out in 2000, but it was part of the 2002 Oscars. It was called Memento. And I think that got snubbed, but people don't remember, so that's fine.

SPEAKER_05Too sharp, too sharp well played, well played.

SPEAKER_02I said I was gonna bring it up again. And then so I went a couple movies that were thrown out there that that were talked about a little bit. I'll I'll mention just that I I I really I myself remember liking Donnie Darko a lot when I first saw it. Didn't really understand everything. I then eventually I I you know mentioned oh name dropping. I mentioned that I did a hip hop musical, and the woman who played my mom was in Donnie Darko. She's been a lot of stuff. She was on the office, and so she's great, she's amazing. And then it's funny because my my show, a lot of the themes of it, or there's a a running joke about it was about like a woman who's adopted and her parents come to find her biological mom comes to find her, but they think it's a boy and not a girl, whole trans thing.

SPEAKER_02And a whole big part of it is that the parents are really big Harry Potter fans. So with the whole J.K. Rowley stuff, like I'm very, I'm very well I'm very familiar and well-versed. And my my take on it is if you like Harry Potter, it's great. They were amaz it's amazing. Content. When I was a kid, I I didn't grow up reading Harry Potter. I was like, that's for little kids. So I only got into it later, especially when I was in a play where I played an adult Ron Weasley. It was kind of like a knockoff curse child. And that was a lot of fun. And so I started watching the movies.

SPEAKER_02I'm like, wow, these are really great movies. That was that was typecasting. It was, it was definitely type. Well, I also I did a really I do a really good British accent, so that helped. But yeah, that was it was a lot of fun. It was chaotic. Um But yeah, so I watched the movies, like two or three of them, and read a couple of the books. I'm like, yeah, okay, I get it. The Harry Potter stuff. And this was before a lot of like the really crazy J.K. Rowling trans stuff came out. Yeah. Um But I was like, Yeah, I get it.

SPEAKER_02People like this, people are really into it, you know. Like I was in a cast of the people who were really into it. So I don't need anyone for loving Harry Potter. It's you know, yeah, part of staples of many people's upbringing. But I try not to support J.K. Rowling like financially, because she has explicitly stated that if you support her works like financially and by her stuff, she takes that as like, yeah, you're cool with my use. It wasn't even that good of a movie.

SPEAKER_07Like when it came out. It was.

SPEAKER_05I mean, the I'll give you the first one. They were they were young in the first one, but like every single person in those movies was and or became a fucking great actor in their own right.

unknownRight.

SPEAKER_07Oh well, yeah. I mean, if you if you train your whole life to be an actor, you're gonna be a good one.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, the kids, the kids were they all ended up being like good at like Andrew Radcliffe, you've seen him in other stuff. Like, he's good. And Emma Watson was she hasn't really done much, but she's okay. And then she doesn't suck. She doesn't suck. And then you got Alan Rickman. Like, I love Alan Rickman. Yes, I agree on that one. So yeah, anything with him, like that's that's generally worth watching. Like, and I think what I gathered from listening to the uh last episode, and this is like a general thing too, is what is the criteria for saying like a movie should be replaced with another movie on this list?

SPEAKER_02Because obviously art is subjective and our feelings on it are subjective. However, like there seems to be an issue of like, you know, nominating, you know, Ghostbusters. Ghostbusters or like a popular movie or a blockbuster movie or a cartoon, like animated movie and stuff like that. So how much of it is like I want the movie that I like the most versus the movie I like the most that would also fit whatever hypothetical Oscar-worthy criteria is.

SPEAKER_02Like where where it's where do we it's really unobject.

SPEAKER_07I mean, it's it's it's objective.

SPEAKER_05Like and it's based on each of our own opinions. It's what we would have liked to see, which is why I put fucking Bill and Ted in there for like 1991.

SPEAKER_07Because you're an idiot. That's why you did that.

SPEAKER_02I like that because it's like this, these are the movies that like honestly, I I I didn't know what to because like, well, Nick, I don't I don't want to like draw on the ire of Nickel and have him lose respect for me all the time.

SPEAKER_05Let's do it. You have an ally, let's do this. I will be the robin to your Batman Veronica. Let's fucking get off.

SPEAKER_02But it's like I've seen a good amount of these, like the ones that were nominated for Oscars, but like I watched a lot of comedy. Like if you're talking about my favorite movies, like, and then it's like, well, yeah, what Veronica's Oscar list, not an Oscar list that I think Veronica would like. It's like, yeah, it's it's comedies.

SPEAKER_04It's it's you know, and here's here's the thing about our list, you can kind of gay uh obviously, you know, we're we're all trying to not one up each other in the sense of that pretend just like I'm trying to find a movie you've never heard of, or I'm trying to find a movie that does a thing that now I have to explain and show my English lit kind of deal. Well, for real, like the really the way I've always seen it, and just like John said with this Ghostbusters thing, it's it's the kind of movie where you're looking back on it and you're thinking to yourself, okay, what movie actually impact me and everybody else that I can think of?

SPEAKER_04You can either go broad with me not even really liking Donnie Darker that much, but going, hey, this movie had an impact, and people kept trying to remake this movie for about a decade. I think that's a good enough argument to get rid of a movie that was very good, a mystery movie that was a comedic mystery movie, I guess, but I've never really heard of it. Now, that's not good enough for some people. There's gonna be people who are gonna say, hey, if you've never heard of it doesn't mean that it's bad. But there's gonna be guys like me who go, well, if it was if it's if I gotta get rid of something, I'm gonna get rid of the one I've never heard of.

SPEAKER_07It's totally understandable. Yeah. And and that is totally understandable because I mean, as asinine as I think Ghostbusters is, it's legitimate. If if that if it because it's all our own opinion. It it's how we want to take the list and like cut it into best picture.

SPEAKER_04And it all kind of gives you a little bit of like who we are as people. It there's no part of the reason why it's nice to have John here is because John had a lot of comedies and a lot of musicals, and Nickel told him why he was wrong every single year there was a comedy or a musical. But here's the thing you ask somebody like me who watches a lot of comedies too. I don't really do a lot of like hardcore dramas anymore. There's comedies that are so well made and and will make me laugh over and over and over again, seeing the same jokes over and over and over again. And it that to me is good filmmaking, it's good writing, but everything can't combined into one.

SPEAKER_04That also means that it's got a good performance in there. So, how is that any different for somebody like me when I'm watching and I've seen Moulin Rouge, and it's fine. It's I don't I don't disagree. It's it's very visually, it's amazing. But why is that better writing than uh than another comedy that came out that year? I I have no idea what came out. Like Monsters Inc. came out that year, right?

SPEAKER_05Yeah, but that's animated, different category, man. No, no, no, no, but let's pretend, let's pretend. But there was an animated category. I have a whole rant about that.

SPEAKER_04No, I know, and I'm trying not to get you to do it. But let's let's pretend that Monsters Inc. counts. I find it just as valid. I find the visuals just as valid, I find the writing just as good, if not better.

SPEAKER_05And you would find you would find the the visuals of Monsters Inc. valid against the fact that Shrek won best animated picture that year.

SPEAKER_04John, where's my goddamn there? So can't be heard now. It's now just us. Surprise, asshole. I'm back. No, no, no, no, no, no, no. There. Stop that. It's just it's just us four. I don't care who else here is. So let's move on. Nope. Stay dead.

SPEAKER_07So so Veronica.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, there's there's not gonna be a point in time where we're gonna think to you, if we're gonna think like, well, she should have thought of this harder.

SPEAKER_07Unless you say something like, Shrek, I won't shit on you.

SPEAKER_02That was gonna be my next one with Shrek. Oh god, okay.

SPEAKER_05Okay, let me know. Somebody once told me that the world was gonna roll me.

SPEAKER_02But that's because Shrek Shrek, like, I I love Shrek, but I I like what you said about that, Mike, or underscore however you want to be referred to as that's considering like I like the idea of considering like okay, this had a lot of like personal meaning, but also a broad sense of how did this affect the zeitgeist? How did it affect like a broader in culture in um a broader sense? Like, did it have that impact? But I do think that there are a lot of comedies that do that.

SPEAKER_02Um and so I'll bring some of those up. We'll see.

SPEAKER_07Yeah, take take take that. Don't don't be afraid of like me yelling at John like I'm gonna yell at you, okay? I promise you I'm only gonna yell at John.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_05Oh no, I'm the only one, I'm the only one who gets him hard when he does it.

SPEAKER_07So maybe, maybe yell at John, or maybe yell at Dom sometimes too.

SPEAKER_05I I do it in all seriousness, I I know it was the first year for the animated category. My only gripe with the animated category for 2002 was just the fact that Spirited Away was not included in it.

SPEAKER_07That's foreign. That's gonna be foreign. So I'm just saying.

SPEAKER_05I don't control the academy. Lord of the Rings was in New Zealand. 2003, 2003, go, go, go.

SPEAKER_06Oh, okay.

SPEAKER_05Dom, dumb, wait, dude, dumb.

SPEAKER_06Okay, cool. So, um I think the obvious answer is just the Lord of the Rings, the Fellowship of the Ring.

SPEAKER_07Right. Of course. Which is fine.

SPEAKER_06Movie theater still shows it once a year.

SPEAKER_07They'll do that way.

SPEAKER_06They'll do the extended cut five dollars, and then like two weeks later, they'll do the two towers extended cut, and then two weeks from then the return of the king extended cut. That's awesome. It's just five dollars. So that one's the obvious winner for me. Now I gotta replace the other four with movies. Sorry, Chris, but Osmosis Jones, Atlantis, The Lost Empire, and The Land Before Time 8. Right. Uh so now, no, he's trolling. He's trolling.

SPEAKER_07No, but I got one movie. No, now he's just trolling me. Yeah. Yeah. What's no, what's the last one? I gotta hear it.

SPEAKER_06Okay. Think of it. I can guess it. It features Joker from The Dark Knight working with Vision from the MCU, Robert Baratheon from Game of Rogue. Yes. And the robot from Rogue One, the Knight's Tale.

SPEAKER_05And Robert Baratheon.

SPEAKER_06Fun movie. Fun movie. Yeah. At least a nominee, I think.

SPEAKER_05Fucking love a night's tale. I made a Paul Bettany S. Chaucer in that movie DD character that I still go back to to this day. Yep. What do you do with that information?

SPEAKER_06Underscore picks speed. So those are my picks. We can move on now. Yes, yes, please, let's do.

SPEAKER_04Thank God. Okay.

SPEAKER_06The next year.

SPEAKER_04Best picture nominees were That was terrible. That was terrible, Tom. Chicago. Gangs of New York. The hours. Lord of the Rings, the Two Towers, and the pianist. I and the winner that year was Chicago.

SPEAKER_07Alright, alright. Okay. Um, take out Chicago, put in Road to Perdition.

SPEAKER_05I love you. We're back, baby. Beautiful movie. I'm back, baby. No, put it in.

SPEAKER_07That's that one. That one was the easiest year I I looked up this decade. Take out Chicago, put in Road to Perdition, which ironically is a movie about like Midwestern Chicago gangster lifestyle. But I don't want a musical. I want Tom Hanks dying in front of his kid.

SPEAKER_05Which one? Chet Hanks or Colin Hanks? Any of them. Oh, no, no.

SPEAKER_07The the the the I know I'm kidding. I'm a character kid. I know. No, but it should have been no, but it but really it should have been Chet, right? Fucking Chet. Nobody likes a Chet. Colin. Colin is dope.

SPEAKER_05Um Colin is the best.

SPEAKER_02Colin, well, yes, Colin's the talented one that like it's like a Tom Hank, you know, it's like, oh yes, that's Tom Hanks' kid. Chad is one that is nothing like uh any of them. And I won't say I don't think everybody hates him. I think he's a very decisive divisive character. Uh some people really liked it.

SPEAKER_07But everybody loves Tom and Colin. That is not true.

SPEAKER_05Tom Collins. That's not true.

SPEAKER_02Tom Collins. My my ex and her whole family hate. Why? They should burn in hell. I don't, I don't, I don't know why. I found this out when Doesn't matter. Doesn't matter.

SPEAKER_07They should burn in hell.

SPEAKER_02We were first going, like when we're first like a few months in our like going out, my ex went to the I'm telling you, they should it doesn't matter. They should burn in. I'm not disagreeing. I'm I'm telling a story. So just let me tell the story.

SPEAKER_05Tell a story, Nickel.

SPEAKER_02They um my my ex went to AFI, and you know, AFI does their like um, they you know, honor someone every year, and they were honoring John John Williams that year. And so she got tickets, and I went with her and her family. And there's a point where one of the presenters like who came up and talked was is Tom Hanks. We're like far in the back, but they all started like going.

SPEAKER_07Damn. That's white privilege. So sorry, so sorry, I assumed race. That was that wasn't right of me.

SPEAKER_02Can you say something about a John button? Is it is there a na button?

SPEAKER_04Yeah. We're gonna have we're gonna make it in post. We're gonna we're gonna bleep nickel for the first time. I'm not into leading, it's just gonna be replacing him with another track of Veronica.

SPEAKER_05All right, I gotta say, Gangs of New York and Lord of the Rings of Two Tower retired for me because I will I will cheer for Daniel Day Lewis and anything he's in ever. I love Daniel Day-Lewis. Yes. I always still pronounce it the pianist, even though I it is it's I believe so, yeah. Like I I I love Adrian Brody. I don't know, people. That's why I said I don't know. I'm not sure. No, it's it's pianist. Yeah, the penis. Yeah, yeah, it's like you say penis. Yeah. No, no, no, no.

SPEAKER_07Penis should have won. The pianist.

SPEAKER_05No, no, I didn't say it should have won, but like this is what like the first performance I remember by Adrian Brody, and I fucking love Adrian Brody. I'm nervous for the day that we find out that he like sacrifices puppies in his basement because he's like too good, and I'm I'm I don't need another celebrity who I will then find out that I had like a misguided love for. All right, they already got me with Neo Game.

SPEAKER_02Did you see what he did you did you see when he hosted SNL and when he introduced Sean?

SPEAKER_07Yeah, as a Ross to as a Ross Safarian. Oh, that's amazing.

SPEAKER_02He's fanned from S.

SPEAKER_07Totally racially insensitive. Wow.

SPEAKER_04Just make that up to do like right then. Like, don't they like rehearse?

SPEAKER_07I think that's yeah, that was not something. He probably did make that up right at the moment.

SPEAKER_05The only other change I would make, I was I'm I'm I'm 100% with you on Road to Perdition, but for me, the hours was a great concept with poor execution, and I would remove it completely. And I think Hero, the one with Jet Lee that was in line with like your crouching tiger, hidden dragon um type cinematography, was an absolute replacement for that.

SPEAKER_04Well, I disagree. That is I wasn't a fan of Hero. Hero was fine. I think it was overhyped. It was fine. Oh, yeah, it was definitely overhyped, but it was still a great movie. Um the only one say I've never seen the hours. I actually don't mind this list, but I would replace I had forgot about Road to Perdition. Shit, that was just should have been mine. Um I would take out the hours and I would put in 20 days later. I would I loved that movie. I thought that that movie was amazing because that zombies had not been like effed out yet, and it's super low budget, had great performances, introduced the world of Danny Boyle.

SPEAKER_04Awesome movie for me. I I just took out the movie that I never saw. Again, going into like our criteria and every bit like it influence video games, influence a ton of shit. It's still one of my favorites.

SPEAKER_07Uh, what about I I've really been trying to keep this all objective, but the 25th hour was one of my favorite movies. That's right. I have not seen it. I I really like it. I really don't think it's I really don't think it's uh best picture nominee, but I gotta I gotta at least mention it. I wouldn't put it on the list, but 25th Hour came out that year. That's Edward Norton. Do you guys see Edward Norton?

SPEAKER_07It sounds like none of you know that movie. I I I saw 25 hour for sure. It's Edward Norton as like a drug dealer, you know, before he goes to jail.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think I remember seeing that.

SPEAKER_07So not a not a best picture nominee, although I'd love it to be up there.

SPEAKER_02What's Rosario Johnson in that? Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Okay.

SPEAKER_05Oh now I have to see it.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_07And then and then um the bigger black guy who always plays a cop and he's always like, oh.

SPEAKER_02Where the getting remote.

SPEAKER_05I really part of me is so curious if you're talking about Ving Rames. The the nickel button should just be him saying, Oh shit, that voice.

SPEAKER_04Oh god.

SPEAKER_07No, I'm I'm telling you, like, that's this guy's entire career.

SPEAKER_02Are you talking about Reginald Valjonson?

SPEAKER_07Like, I No, no, no, no. No, not Carl. Not Carl Winslow. Get out of here. I know his name.

SPEAKER_05Oh my god. I I know who he's talking about. And that's not who I thought he was.

SPEAKER_07No, he said it in like multiple movies or shows. I'm telling you. I'm not. Let's move on to Veronica. Move on. Move on. You're right. You're right. You're right. Sorry.

SPEAKER_02Um shit. So yeah, out of these movies, no, no significant complaints, but I I never saw the hours. Um, I know we mentioned Gangs of New York, which is I I and this was also the year Road Tradition, right? So taking uh a couple stars from each of those, uh, Leo and Tom Hang, I really liked catching it. I thought it was a a really good, fun, well-made movie, Steven Spielberg, right?

SPEAKER_02Like, yeah. It was.

SPEAKER_04It was for sure. It was very fun, I will admit. Very fun movie. And then the irony is the the dude who the movie's about the fraud guy um came out a couple years ago that he made up most of his biography. How do you not love that? To be honest with you, it's amazing.

SPEAKER_07It was a fraud about a fraud.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_02That's the ultimate. Just like Alanis Morris' ironic song is the ultimate ironic song because none of it makes actual irony.

SPEAKER_06Um, well, I don't think there was a lot of good movies that year, except for The Lord of the Rings, Two Towers. I know Star Wars Attack of the Clones isn't worthy of an Oscar nomination, or even Harry Potter in the Chamber of Secrets. Dom, I respect you for not throwing in.

SPEAKER_07But I think I see in there. Yeah. Oh, Jesus Chris. You guys are you guys are trying to piss me off, right? Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_06I'm I'm trying to throw one in there just to get a reaction out of Chris.

SPEAKER_04God damn it. God damn it, you guys. So 2003, I think, was what we're on, right? Yeah. No, okay. So 2004. Okay. Uh so the next one. Uh the nominees were Lord of the Rings, Return of the King, Lost in Translation, Master and Commander, Mystic River, and Seabiscuit. Winner that year, Lord of the Rings, Return of the King. Fuck yeah, it was. Of course.

SPEAKER_07I hated Lost in Translation, but um honestly, that year I can't find a better replacement for it.

SPEAKER_05I have one note for 2004, and that's fuck Seabiscuit. It had no business being in there. Nobody gives a shit about your stupid fucking horse. Put Old Boy in. It's the only movie that could compete with those other nominees. Old Boy was interesting as shit. Old Boy was cool.

SPEAKER_07Like honestly, if if I could take out lost in translation and not put anything else in its place, I would be happy with that. Hated Lost Translation. I thought that was the most overrated, most pretentious fucking movie.

SPEAKER_04Uh I have a confession, I never saw Lost in Translation.

SPEAKER_07That's fine.

SPEAKER_04It's fun.

SPEAKER_07You saved money. You saved money.

SPEAKER_04I never thought. You know why? Because like one of my most pretentious friends that's friends with me and nickel would not shut the fuck up about it. Yeah, and guess guess guess and guess who I went to go see it with.

SPEAKER_07Oh, I bet you of course. Of course. And I was like, this movie is fucking garbage. So I don't have any I really don't have anything I could objectively replace it with, but I just want that off the list. Interesting.

SPEAKER_04Interesting. You know, going over the list myself, I don't know if I would what I would replace stuff with. Because this was a year for me. Like, I know Don was kind of being facetious about how like the year before was the worst year. This year for me, like a lot of movies were just good movies for me, but nothing that I was like, oh my god, I gotta be. You know what I mean? Like performances were great, but I didn't really feel anything. Um like I wasn't a big Lord of the Rings guy ever. So Return of the King was just very long and it was fine, but it was like a means to an end.

SPEAKER_04And like never saw lots of translation. I liked Mystic River. I I agree with C Biscuit not really being on the list, but what would you replace them with? This is uh this is for me, like you would you replace it with like the last samurai, which was cool, but I don't know. You know what I mean? Like no, you know, like would you replace it with something like I don't even know. Like I old boy, when the moment you said old boy, I'm like, I liked Old Boy, but again, I don't think that would ever go on the list.

SPEAKER_05Because it's a foreign film, and you know how the Academy likes to keep those foreigners away.

SPEAKER_04And the thing is, like, it's one of those foreign films where you're not gonna get it. Yeah, it's it's you know what I mean? Like it's it's like crazy violent and stuff. I can see people just immediately turning off to it. So I don't know what you would do. And then I know that year was the year where they had finding Nemo, and I almost did it, and I was like, well, I mean, it's it's a cool Pixar movie, but would would you put that somewhere? You know what I mean? Well, it already made it into the animated. Did it? Okay, so yeah, so I guess it wouldn't have bad. So I don't I don't know how to handle this year.

SPEAKER_07And you don't want to get yelled at by me.

SPEAKER_05And you don't want to incur the wrath of nickel.

SPEAKER_04And I I I guarantee you there's probably a shit ton of movies I'm missing. But when I just ran through the list, I'm like, I don't know what I would replace anything with.

SPEAKER_07No, I'm sure there's there's a few that I'm missing too, but I was like, I just want Lost in Translation off the list.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, like I said, never saw it. The person kept insisting it, and I went, well, then I'm never gonna see it. I'm fucking sticking with my gun.

SPEAKER_07It was terrible. It was a fucking god-awful movie, and it should never have belonged on the best picture nominees. So Veronica, tell us why we're wrong.

SPEAKER_02Favorite movies is Lost in Translation.

SPEAKER_04Look at her face when we were like, I don't get it. I'm never gonna see it with like, oh, oh, I've made a mistake coming here.

SPEAKER_02I remember I rented it with my my like yeah, my partner at the time. And she she she was like, I didn't, I didn't this is but I just figured it was because like she wasn't that smart. So I thought that was funny. I really liked it. I love Bill Murray. Yeah, and I get I get the pretentious stuff, but like you went and attacked like that, and then another movie that I love is Sea Biscuit. Um that has it has it had a personal relationship for me because like I was a I was a senior I think I was a senior in high school and I was running track at the time and I was coming back from injuries, and I had a teacher who's also the uh head football coach, um, and this was at Dela Salle.

SPEAKER_02So um, you know, like Bob Ladiser, top legendary high school football coach, and he told me he's like, you're coming back from your injury and you're gonna try to make you know you are your seabit. You're seabit. And I'm like, I've never seen that. It's like you need to rent that movie and watch.

SPEAKER_05Does that mean that if you didn't win, they were gonna shoot you? I was gonna say the same thing.

SPEAKER_02I didn't know that at the time when he was saying that, but probably. But but but somehow it could it could have happened. Right. Yeah, somehow I am still here. But I remember I had like a hundred degree fever before like the NCS championship, and I just watched him like I'm I am Sea Biscuit. And then like I went and ran the mile the next day, and on the last slap, I'm like, I'm seat biscuit, I'm passing them on the outside, and then I'm like, no, I'm sick, and that I I did not win. But I remember like, yeah, Sea Biscuit.

SPEAKER_02So that just has a personal um like I personally have fondness for those two movies. Um but yeah, besides that, besides defending um, you know, all the vitriol that was just faced for that. Let's see. So yeah, I don't I don't really have timeout, vitriol, like lots of vitriol.

SPEAKER_07We we we can we can disagree with Seabiscuit and uh and other movies. Like there's no vitriol there. There's vitriol for lost vitriols.

SPEAKER_02Uh I mean, yeah, maybe there was. Don't don't you know, don't don't shy away from it. Own your vitriol. The uh yeah, I don't have any problems with any uh I I never saw Master and Commander. Um the only thing is I yeah, and I and I never saw, I did not see Mystic River. And here's the thing, I don't like movies that have a title that doesn't really indicate the kind of movie that they are. Like Mystic River should be about a magical river where you're like that's what Mystic River.

SPEAKER_02So you need something more in the line of like a big nuts and tight sluts type of thing to accurately understand what just like the movie Hamburger Hill should be about like um in and out on the top of a mountain that's like having hard times. No, Mystic. No, you're right.

SPEAKER_07Mystic Mystic River is definitely a misleading title. So is Shrek. What the fuck is a Shrek? So you bring up Shrek again, John. I swear. Okay, you're right.

SPEAKER_05Right, you're right. So this year we had Shrek 2.

SPEAKER_07Don't do it.

SPEAKER_04I'll give it one of the go to Tom.

SPEAKER_06Um obviously The Lord of the Rings, the Return of the King, definitely deserved it. For sure, for sure. Yeah.

SPEAKER_07I don't deny I even though I didn't like it, I don't deny that it didn't need it. Yeah, I'm not even a huge fan of it either, but I don't deny that it deserved it. Right.

SPEAKER_06And I'd probably replace the other four again with uh how many animated movies were this year. Well, no, I I I think I would put on X-Men 2.

SPEAKER_07Underscore you gotta understand he was like 10 at this, right? So he's like, uh, Pocahontas was the best movie.

SPEAKER_06Nah, it'd be X-Men 2, The Matrix, Reloaded, and Revolutions. And then for you, Chris, Sinbad.

SPEAKER_04Revolutions and Reload were both the same year?

SPEAKER_06Yep.

SPEAKER_04I don't even remember that.

SPEAKER_05Sinbad, Legend of the Seven Seas. Yep. Oh, the animated one with yeah, the animated one. Yeah. Immediately I was like, what movies was Sinbad in that year?

SPEAKER_02House guess. House Guess.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, because that was never a Mandela effect for me. I I 100% remember seeing Shaq in the trailer being like, this is gonna be a piece of shit. 2004, let's or 2005, let's do it. All right, next one.

SPEAKER_07Let's keep the ball moving.

SPEAKER_04Nominees that year, million dollar baby, the aviator, fighting never land, Ray, and Sideways. Uh winner that year, million dollar.

SPEAKER_07Uh, I'm gonna let you guys go first, cuz I can't change I can't change best picture, but I do have something to say about a nominee that isn't best picture at this this year.

SPEAKER_05I have the most to say. Really? No way. Yes. Go. First off, Ray Prepare for another hour. Prepare for another hour. Ray should have won. The aviator did not need to be three hours. I mean, it did need to be three hours, but like it needed to be better for being three fucking hours. I personally say drop it completely. Finding Neverland. I think Finding Neverland should have been dropped because it would have been better served with just a solidly well done documentary.

SPEAKER_05Yeah. Million Dollar Baby, drop it. We do not need another We Overcame Adversity and XYZ film where we had to convince the weirdly racist, sexist, insert other prejudice coach to come back from retirement to help somebody win another sports. I would argue Linda Baby, she never comes back. I I I no I I didn't like it, but Sideways was the worst offender to me. I love Paul Giamatti. I love Thomas C. Howell.

SPEAKER_05There is no fucking way I would want to watch a I mean, I did, but a fucking pretentious wine country version of the hangover.

SPEAKER_04And that's an amazing description.

SPEAKER_07Yes!

SPEAKER_04Holy shit. That's incredible.

SPEAKER_07I love that. I love that. That's like uh that's like uh what what's his new movie out? Uh the holdovers. Right? That's like a uh oh god, damn. I had the uh analogy in my head just now, but I forgot.

SPEAKER_05But I would I would you're not gonna love my replacements, but Prisoner of Azkaban, Spider-Man 2, Sean of the Dead, and the Life Aquatic.

SPEAKER_04Here's why I don't hate I don't I wasn't a life aquatic guy. I don't hate that list. Spider-Man I don't hate it.

SPEAKER_07I don't hate it.

SPEAKER_04Um I don't know why I didn't like Sideways, but it's an amazing guy the whole time I'm like this movie is not good. And I don't know, and now that's perfect. Thank you for that. I don't even know. I I liked Eternal Sunshine. That's a I I thought that was a really fun movie. I don't know if it wins. Who won this year? Uh Million Dollar Baby. That's that's right. I don't know if it wins. But yeah, I uh I am a fan of Million Dollar Baby. It was a little more cartoony than I think people will remember. It's kind of silly for for all of like the the major traumas that occur.

SPEAKER_04Like the the uh what's her name's family? I forget the name of the actress, but her family shows up in like Disneyland gear and stuff like that. Like it's you know, the the the the main reason why she becomes uh paraplegic, like it would never happen where somebody tries to hit her with a fucking um uh stool or she falls her down. I'm sorry, her neck falls on the stool perfectly. Like it's very it's there's a goofiness to it that when you re-watch it, if you ever do, is a parent replace her with. I really like I said I my my brain liked Spider-Man 2 a lot.

SPEAKER_04Incredibles wouldn't count, but I would throw that in there instead of a ton of other shit.

SPEAKER_05Yeah, what it won best animated though.

SPEAKER_04And it it deserved it, yeah. Right. And I'm holding my breath. Um other than that, like I don't know. I don't know what I would replace it with because it wasn't my favorite year, to be real with you. Like all those movies that you say you'd get rid of, I can see a good argument for all those.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, my the first one I thought of was um as like a a replacement would have been eternal sunshine of the smilest mind, really. I I really like that movie. I thought it was great. Um, oh by the way, yeah, Million Dollar Baby. Yeah, it could stay. Although I would maybe replace not Million Dollar Baby as a nominee, but replace yeah, like Sideways and Finding Never Wind were fine, but not great. I could just see replacing those, putting in eternal sunshine, and then maybe I would I would maybe put in eternal sunshine winning over Million Dollar Baby.

SPEAKER_02Um by the way, this is I've never done this before. This is my impression of Million Dollar Baby. Um that's my kind of humor, anyways. But this is okay, now we're getting into years where I'm like, I want to nominate a movie like Anchor Man because that is a movie uh has had a huge cultural impact. Yes, men bond over just repeating lines from that movie. Milk was a bad choice. It's just one example. So many, yeah. I mean, a glass case of emotion, so many, so many choices. And yeah, like now that if now my brain's gonna be a big thing.

SPEAKER_07I mean nerds nerds bond over quoting Monty Python movies, too. Does that make them best?

SPEAKER_04I think that comedy is hard, uh lasting comedy is hard enough that when you have something like Anchor Man that just touches on that pulse, it should be recognized. Yes.

SPEAKER_02And that same year, along the same lines, dodgeball kind of was also of that.

SPEAKER_05Oh yes.

SPEAKER_02Um but in terms of more nickel-worthy uh nominations, wasn't that 2004? Like the um that would have been the year that uh the machinist would have been eligible. Was that that year? Was it came out uh I think it should have been. Is it?

SPEAKER_06I didn't put Machinist 2004. Oh wow.

SPEAKER_07Yeah, I didn't put it on my list because I didn't see it and I didn't feel the ones that didn't make any list because it was they re-released it or something like that?

SPEAKER_04Like you'd think that would be on there.

SPEAKER_06It's probably in here. It came out January 2004, but it's possible it had an early release, maybe. Right. Interesting.

SPEAKER_07No, but I I I I think you're right, V. I think um that you know probably could have been on the list, but I didn't see it myself, so yeah. I'm always like, I wanna make it objective.

SPEAKER_02That's that's fair. And I also I love I'm um partial to movies that are driven by like great acting performances. Um so like when I was looking at like no um movies that didn't get nominated for best of picture, I'm like, okay, well, was there a movie that like someone was nominated for best actor or actress that year? Because that that always compels me. Like I I can watch a movie, like most movies that um if if they're like let's say good, maybe not great in some people's minds in terms of uh cinematography or storytelling, but if there's like a a Daniel J.

SPEAKER_02Lewis given like a hell of a performance or something like that, like yeah, that's a movie that I I could consider being like a top of me.

SPEAKER_06Well, I think I should be honest and say I haven't seen any of those five movies, so I'm gonna have to replace all of them with actual winners. So I think first pick Sean of the Dead. I still like it a lot. Yeah, it's still worth re-watching. Um I'd probably pick Hellboy. What else I got?

SPEAKER_03Hellboy was well made too. It's like these are all very well-made movies.

SPEAKER_06Right. The day after tomorrow. It's also like a cool roller coaster type experience. And then I'll go with Spider-Man too. But I think my number one pick, definitely Dawn of the Dead. Because it's Zack Snyder's first directed movie. So of course it's the winner. Snyderverse.

SPEAKER_07Snyderverse.

SPEAKER_06Snyderverse has started.

SPEAKER_04They threw out, you know, God, now I'm a nickel thing. Fuck it.

SPEAKER_05We're gonna, we're gonna, we're gonna mute me. For fuck's sake. Quickly move to 2006. We can do we can't. Wait, wait, wait, wait. Yeah, no, we're moving on. We're moving. He's not nickel that's gone yet.

SPEAKER_07I have one thing to say about that year. 2005. It was technically like what you would call a mockumentary, okay? But it should have won Best Picture for Documentary. It was called CSA, The Confederate States of America. Oh God. It was it was uh hands down, still to this day, the best fucking satire you will ever see in your life. It was hands down the best satire you'll ever see in your life.

SPEAKER_07It was a uh mockumentary about if the Confederate States won the Civil War. And so it was like like a a British documentarian was going over and seeing freed slaves in still the 2000s, and they're they're trying to you know cross the border and stuff, and it was it was so good in such a satire way.

SPEAKER_04That was a good one. I remember that one.

SPEAKER_07That was good. So it should have won, in my opinion, and I'm going completely offboard on this one. It should have won best documentary, even though it was a mockumentary.

SPEAKER_05Yeah, that's I I can stand by that, yeah.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah, I think that's fair.

SPEAKER_00This concludes the first part of this episode. Please join us next week for the conclusion of the insert nerd topic here. Wherever you get your most treasured podcasts, the time pals are the geek cornerstone of the Mayday Media Network. Check out all of the Mayday Media Podcasts at Mayday Media Network dot com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Time Pals Present: Love at First Fright! (w/Angie from The Silly Goose Society and Final Girl Kiley aka @kileythestitchmata)

    Oct 31, 202645 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail 🔪 TIME PALS PRESENT: LOVE AT FIRST FRIGHT (w/Angie from The Silly Goose Society and featuring voice actress and "Final Girl" Kiley 💘 "Nine eligible horror icons. One Lonely Survivor. Can a Final Girl...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Time Pals Interview w/Creators of Waffle and Cohen (Brian Hess and Steve Romanko)

    Oct 5, 20261 hrAudio

    Send us Fan Mail 🚨🧇 San Francisco Has Found Its New Dirty Harry. And He’s a Waffle. 🧇🚨 This week, the Time Pals interview the creators of the new online animated series WAFFLE & COHEN! From the wonderfully warped...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. From Double Dragon to Wrestlefest- Time Pals Celebrate Yoshihisa Kishimoto!

    Sep 21, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail DOUBLE DRAGON. RENEGADE WRESTLEFEST. AND THE WEIRDEST SHOOTER EVER MADE. NEXT WEEK, MrBortman (@mrbortmanttv) joins the Time Pals as we pay tribute to Yoshihisa Kishimoto, the legendary game designer...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Time Pals Interview w/Big Squid Production's Kyle Valle and Erin Aine (Zombie Con Vol.1 / Autonomous)

    Sep 1, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail THE TIME PALS ARE BACK - AND WE’RE BRINGING SPOOKY SEASON EARLY. 🎃 This week, hosts Jon Powell and Mike Underscore welcome Kyle Valle and Erin Áine, co-founders of Big Squid Films and the talented...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Time Pals Summer Rewind

    Jul 6, 202649 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail The Time Pals are kicking off their summer break by wrapping up unfinished business, reflecting on some of our favorite moments, and getting excited for even more geeky deep dives and special guest...

    Credit the people on this episode