Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Through the Line: Packaging and Processing

Through the Line: Packaging and Processing artwork

Pallet Adhesives, AI Label Checks, and Freezer Hacks: End of the Line

Nov 9, 202622 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

What do Walmart’s automated pallet-building and a string of hacked freezers mean for packaging and food plants? In this week’s End of the Line, Healthcare Packaging’s Liz Cuneo is joined by Derrick Teal, Sean Riley, and Matt Reynolds for a post-PACK EXPO roundup. Reynolds explains why Walmart’s tighter pallet specs are bringing adhesive layer-locking back, and the group looks at AI showing up inside labeling and inspection tools as a recommendation engine for humans. Teal closes with reports of hacked freezer systems and a cybersecurity expert’s advice on response plans and an “if you see something, say something” plant culture.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to Through the Line, a podcast exploring innovations and information across the packaging and processing landscape. From topics impacting consumer packaged goods and healthcare packaging to the latest technologies and food processing operations.

SPEAKER_01Hello, everybody, and thank you for joining us for another End of the Line podcast where all of us PMG editors sit down and talk about the things that have come across our desks this week. I am Liz Cuneo, editor-in-chief of Healthcare Packaging. Joined with me is Derek Thiel, editor of Pro Food World, Sean Riley from OEM magazine, and Matt Reynolds from Packaging World. And this week we are, of course, still digging out of Pac Expo stuff as we covered the show and created all of our dozens of videos.

SPEAKER_01And so, Matt, you mentioned having some Pac Expo innovations you wanted to share with us. So, what have you been seeing? What looks cool?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, these are innovations that may have been more cutting edge years ago. They just never had as much of a reason to get adopted deeply into the industry until more recently. You may you guys may remember this year and late last year, we've been covering Packaging World's been covering Walmart. And Walmart is at their distribution centers. They were taking in what they call like single palette or single SKU pallets, breaking those down, and building multi-mixed pallets that basically are pallets that are designed specifically for one aisle of a Walmart in Topeka, Kansas.

SPEAKER_03So if it's the personal care aisle, it'll have all the crest, all the Unilever products, all that kind of stuff, but in the right amounts for that specific aisle. So they're taking in full pallets, breaking them down with robotics layer by layer, and then rebuilding pallets that are designed specifically for one aisle at a time or two aisles at a time, whatever the number is. And historically they've done that. That's not particularly new. What's new is Walmart has automated that process significantly. And that puts a lot of different strains on transport packaging, really, the pallets and the secondary packaging, especially if you're removing the pallets layer by layer with compression force as opposed to human hands using with the dexterity people have versus end-of-arm effectors, that sort of thing.

SPEAKER_03So, anyways, under that kind of new regime at Walmart, and you know it's the 800-pound gorilla, when they move, everybody moves. Through the technology that we're seeing a lot more of that's coming back into the for, you may remember when you're building pallets, often people will use slip sheets in between products, keep them from moving around, protect them a little bit. More and more, companies like ankle adhesives, Robopack is another one, Joat is another. These are all at Pac Expo, have done tiny adhesive dots that are between palette layers.

SPEAKER_03It was really a very nice product that kept the pallets from moving around and kept them very stable. And there were great use cases for it. But now I think with Walmart's very tight specifications for pallets and the specs actually getting narrower and narrower, brands who are shipping product are I have to, out of necessity, have to be much more careful with the dimensions and the size and the palette patterns and all these things, such that Walmart's automation can handle it. So even though these adhesive, I don't even know the name for the technology, but the adhesive dots that were used instead of for closing cartons, which is what we think of it for adhesive, but for tying together different layers of a palette that's existed for a while, but now they're being used again to create straighter, more perfectly dimensional palettes that are much more palatable, forgive the fun, for Walmart with their tighter spec.

SPEAKER_03So, like what's old is new again. There's a new brand awakening to the fact that to serve Walmart better, they need to have better transport packaging. So you're seeing all those companies I mentioned. Signode is another one with some of their straps and some of their strapping and pallet handling. So, from a wider perspective, pallet handling, pallet building, and being very precise with that because of Walmart's new automation needs is come back into the floor again. So something that doesn't sound sexy when you talk about all the new innovations at Pac Expo, but this is one that really will have far-reaching implications and impact.

SPEAKER_01Interesting. Yeah, that's pretty cool. I I thought of glue dots when you mentioned the little adhesive dots, which maybe it is a similar product, but it is.

SPEAKER_03Just think of a nozzle that prints either a bead or however they're closing the carton on your. I mentioned crust already, your crust toothpaste carton, whether that's a bead or whatever the pattern is, instead of applying it to carton closing, they're applying it to palette locking. So we'll be seeing more of that, I'm sure, going forward.

SPEAKER_01Now, was there a stability? Oh, I'm sorry. I was gonna say the same thing.

SPEAKER_02I was you already got it though. You go.

SPEAKER_01You can ask it, Sean.

SPEAKER_02No, I just thought the same thing. I thought, are there sustainable implications, not using slip sheets and things like that and just using the dots?

SPEAKER_03I'm sure there are. I don't know the details, but uh a lot of these adhesives are water-based and they're in such small quantities, especially when you're talking about pallets. The the ratio of adhesive to I don't think it's impacting corrugated recyclability, if that's the question. But the reduction of slips slip sheets or using slip sheets in different ways, I don't know how that really moves the needle because that's such a small portion of once you're getting down to the unit level, then that the ratio of packaging to product goes gets higher. But at that full palette level, I don't think it's a big load containment is really the the name of the game at that size, at that tertiary packaging step.

SPEAKER_03Once you get down into the individual SKUs and the individual units, then the product to package ratio changes. So, anyways, and I would say that this is a largely a back of house kind of situation. So whether it's the slip sheets themselves or the corrugated, the retailers really do, or the distribution centers do a really good job of recycling that material. And they have whole formed methods of doing that for shrink wrap too. So they they do a better job than the consumer. So I would entrust a Walmart DC to do the right thing with whatever corrugated they have from case packing and case breaking down for for repaletizing and also for slip sheets and adhesives, water-based adhesives, that sort of thing.

SPEAKER_01Interesting. Very cool. I've been working on some of my PACE reports, reporting, I should say, and came across one that I think's pretty neat. It's from Global Vision, it's called the Verify Comply, and they're really selling it like another set of eyes for your artwork, compliance artwork. So think of maybe a food item that calls out an allergen. So it checks your nutrition facts, checks that, oh no, you did call out the allergen, or wait, you forgot to mention soy or whatever. And it really keeps you in line with what you need to comply for.

SPEAKER_01So that it's AI powered. So I was gonna bring that up because I know we like to touch on AI in every single one of these, but it's an AI label compliance assistant. So pretty neat, but again, just that another set of eyes for your labeling. So a cool way to use AI, and I guess you don't even have to feed it necessarily your specific parameters, but it's just checking everything over and checking that that it complies. So it can be used in a lot of different industries. Fun to see some AI stuff on the docket here. Sean or Derek, anything AI in your world these days?

SPEAKER_04Go ahead, Sean.

SPEAKER_02Just the usual, yeah, from a sense that, and I think we've started talking about it, and I was going to mention that now that you brought that up, is that it's interesting to see it now find its way onto the machinery versus just the front-end checking data type of stuff, where now it's actually being used to verify things like you were saying. So I guess I'm still amazed by the amount of trust that's being put in it in such a short amount of time. Like I guess maybe it hasn't been a short amount of time now. I guess it's been a couple of years or more than a year, but just the trust of putting that on there to verify things like food allergens and stuff like that.

SPEAKER_02But I guess if it's another set of eyes, there's other sensors along the way. But yeah, that's it. I guess I'm just still surprised by the how quick we are to how quickly we've grown to trust our overlord.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. So a lot of that out if I don't, if you don't mind me interjecting, at Interpak, Esco is the kind of the some of their programs are the golden goose for basically having if you're in California, you can't use this type of logo because of SB343, but you can elsewhere, having that, like you said, an extra set of eyes, AI eyes that's checking every single package design in an entire package design portfolio, which for Unilever or Procter and Gamble has to be massive. Yeah, but it but they always did encourage that there should be a human being somewhere homunculus, just pulling all the levers and making sure that things are operating the way they should be.

SPEAKER_03So it's not fully divest, even the latest and greatest at Interpack was not fully divested from human oversight.

SPEAKER_04Exactly. That's what I saw a lot of at Pac Expo was the excuse me, was that AI is being incorporated, as Matt likes to say, baked in into different products, where it's there. They're not touting it as AI like they maybe have may have done in the past, but it's there. And a lot of what they're using it for is to create actionable data. Instead of just being a user being flooded with all kinds of data, it now collects it, organizes it, looks through it for humans, but in the end, it doesn't just take an action on its own.

SPEAKER_04It offers suggestions for the human to take with is this bearing gonna go? Is this machine operating slowly? Maybe there's a problem at this set. There might be a bottleneck creating at this point in the line because this machine's slowing down, or just something that people can look into as opposed to just blindly here's this, go fix it, go do it, and tell it it's maybe this is the problem, go take a look at it. So just like Matt said, that AI is is there, but there's definitely that human element that I think that's been a bigger push, not just AI, humans taking vested control of what of their own destiny, as opposed to just having AI control it.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. And with this system that I mentioned, which Global Vision is actually part of Esco, Matt. So you teed that one up nicely, but yeah, it'll flag it, right? And say you might want to reconsider or you didn't call this out. But there's always a human looking, which I always find comical because it's humans that can make mistakes too, right? And that's just why we're using AI, and then we're doubting AI. And it's so I think if we work in tandem, hopefully, right? That's kind of the secret ingredient, secret sauce here of really being a hundred percent maybe accurate on some of these systems, is really working with both humanity.

SPEAKER_03I think that's the I think that's the best we can hope for right now because AI cat's yeah, the AI cat is out of the bag. Yeah, you can't beat them, join them at this point.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, which it looks like a lot of companies have been doing. I would say I heard a lot of AI at PECExpo, usually on the equipment side going a little bit faster in inspection detection, in this case, verifying artwork. So maybe like use of cameras and that kind of type of things. I think AI is gonna be here. Yeah, absolutely. Did you see a lot of inspection detection on the food side, Derek?

SPEAKER_04Yeah, not maybe not so much as we would have seen in the past. Again, there was a lot of data, a lot of data companies this time around. But I think I mentioned, I can't remember if it was on end of the line or another one of our podcasts. Maybe it was one that at Pac Expo, Eagle Inspection Systems, has totally introduced a new product, blanket on the name of it, something six. And it's exactly what they were touting it as was using AI to as an assistant to help find contaminants for contaminants in food product, and being able to tell using that to extrapolate where along the chain something might be problematic.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_04Um, so that was unique about it. And there were other others that we saw at Pac Expo that were also at Interpac, along the lines of using different frequencies to detect contaminants. So it was inspection detection, but it wasn't necessarily using AI per se, but different wavelengths to detect different types of contaminants.

SPEAKER_03You said something interesting there that I've been seeing. No way, I can't believe I did that. As long ago as two years ago, three years ago, even Rockwell uh has been positioning some of the vision and inspection detection as not only being preventative, like removing something that might have a contaminant in it, not only being predictive, where it says this this contaminant is happening every 100th tube tube of toothpaste or something like that. So not just predictive, not just preventative, but prescriptive, such that it knows that if this happens at this frequency, then that must mean that there's a bearing on machine four in the filler that is near the end of its life.

SPEAKER_03And you better go check that bearing because we're seeing this, I don't know, a smudge on this side of the tube of toothpaste or something like that. So I think that's really interesting where the AI can recognize a fault or an error or uh something that's creating a scrap, but not only recognizing that the scrap is happening, but where the fault is going to be happening upstream that you can go fix it. So prescriptive is pretty interesting use of AI there.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, it's just so much quicker at detecting patterns than humans are. And I think that's where it's the benefit of AI comes if it's something that can be that does create a pattern where it can go back and say, you know what, X A plus B equals C and go check this out. And that's much faster than humans can do it. Not so that's yeah, that's I think seeing a lot more of that.

SPEAKER_02It hasn't been a great year for food recalls in the food world. Can that help? Or no, because that's a product-based thing.

SPEAKER_04Potentially, but it potentially, but a lot of it also has to do with cleaning practices, sanitation practices. Yes, it can definitely help with recalls, but a lot of what we've been seeing has been on the bacterial side of things, where that is an indictment on a company's cleaning practices. Again, not saying that it can't help with that, but a lot of this is mostly down to human error.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Interesting. Well, thank you so much, Derek. Unless you have anything else to add.

SPEAKER_04I did talking about human error.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_04Something we we've seen back in August, soldiers losing their ice cream because the failures froze or freezers did not freeze, they were hacked. And then later on, just a few weeks ago, supermarket freezers being hacked and heat being cranked up, fires actually getting started. A lot of people don't realize that freezers in supermarkets can go both ways. They can cool down and they can heat up because it has to be temperature controlled, and so they have to maintain that temperature no matter what, if it's too cold or it's too warm.

SPEAKER_04And then most recently, as Liz Blood Bank system was hacked, their freezer system was hacked. Now, it's very early days with any of this. We don't know exactly the motivations, who was behind it, anything like that. But what's interesting is that a lot of blame has been thrown around. I'm not going to name the company, but at one company's controllers in particular, that they were left exposed to the internet, not the intranet, internet, and which gave bad actors access to that. Now, why they had they were left exposed to the internet, that's a good question.

SPEAKER_04But that is what they think happened. Now, whether or not how they got access to that, where again it's all very earlier days, don't really know how or why, but we do know that it's down to the fault of the controllers on these systems, and hackers are able to gain access and crank up the heat to these freezers. So, what can be done about that? I had a great call with Kristen King today. She's the author of Securing What Feeds Us, um, Cybersecurity and Food and Agriculture. And I've talked with her before about cybersecurity, of course, but wanted to talk to her about this specifically just because a lot of this seems on the consumer end of things, but I was really curious as to know how what can a food and beverage manufacturer take away from this?

SPEAKER_04What and are there problems that they need to address? And the answer is yes. Number one, and this is one of the things that I said that struck me was uh when you get a new router as an individual or you know, any a printer, one of the first things you should do is change the password from admin, which can be found uh usually in the documentation on a company's website for oh, in the instruction manual. A lot of people don't change those personally, but it's possible again, don't know this is speculation.

SPEAKER_04It's possible that was the case with some of these freezers that maybe somebody didn't change the password, and so bad actors we don't know again, we don't know if any of these are related. Maybe something happened like, oh, somebody hacked this the US Army's freezers. Maybe I'm gonna do that with supermarkets and try this. And so we don't know what there's any relationship at all. But did somebody change the password or not? We don't know how come this wasn't noticed earlier. A the bad actors did change the alarms, they turned those off.

SPEAKER_04So the people that these systems were intended to identify to notify if there was a problem that they reached went beyond the set point temperature excursion, yeah. Exactly. Yep, they turned those off. So, okay, that's how they were able to get away with that. But you've got some freezers that were hitting 122 degrees Fahrenheit, 50 degrees Celsius. Now you can't tell me that somebody's walking by, and that's a hot that somebody's not walking by one of these and saying there's something wrong with this freezer or seeing melted product.

SPEAKER_04So, what again, it was that human element. That how did humans miss this? Did they have systems and checks and balances in place to ensure something like this didn't happen? And that's what when I was talking to Kristen, what she wanted to get across to manufacturers is have a plan in place. Don't just assume because you've got this latest and greatest in technology that everything's hunky-dory, that you still have to have a plan in place, that you still have to have emergency procedures. And more importantly, probably beyond any of it, is have a culture in your plant where people feel empowered if they notice something to say something.

SPEAKER_04And that is probably because who knows, maybe somebody did walk by, notice uh this freezer's pretty warm. And it's not my job, and walk past it or not my department. I'm just a stock person in this other aisle. That's this isn't my department. So you don't want that happening in your plant and not just in a food and beverage plant, at a cold storage, any a warehousing environment, any of those you want to make sure probably in general, not just your freezers, but in general, that you want to make sure you're you've got a plan in place with your cybersecurity systems.

SPEAKER_03And we're gonna be seeing more and more of that because that I know a lot of the retailers that we talk to and the brand owners, but the re the the retailers who own those shelves are leaning more and more into smart shelves, connected shelves that know the expiration date of the milk on that shelf, such that they can change the price when the expiration date is getting closer. So that it's an incentive to move that milk faster than the I always like to look for the milk that has the longest runway in front of it. But all of that is possible. So there's a lot of advantage for having connected shelves, connected freezers.

SPEAKER_03But now we're looking at what the potential dark side of that could be and exposure to bad actors. Really interesting.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, that access is two-way street.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's and that's what I talked about too, which we'll I'll just give a teaser or two. We can talk about another episode, but how remote access can be a problem when not secured. But it's really the remote access that actually allowed, in the case of the blood bank, for them to see that things were actually going sideways. So it's a two-way street, what you said, Derek. Good and bad. We'll see what happens there.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. That's how they called it with the remote access.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, noticing that because it really wasn't in the blood bank, it was like off, it was like an off-site place.

SPEAKER_02Like an off-site place. Okay.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And they were like, temperatures are not in the right, so they could remotely see that. So it does good and bad there.

SPEAKER_03Get that message to all the IT people out there that the remote access was the hero in this situation.

SPEAKER_02Because I was immediately immediately thinking that they were at fault, but that that's a great way to say that, yeah, they stepped in and saved what could be saved. Absolutely.

SPEAKER_01Very good, gentlemen. Thank you for your time today. Hope everyone enjoys this episode of End of the Line. And I know we'll talk again next week.

SPEAKER_00Thank you for listening to Through the Line Packaging and Processing. You can listen to more episodes on all streaming platforms. Be sure to visit us at packworld.com, profoodworld.com, and healthcarepackaging.com for more packaging and processing news. This podcast was edited by Bri Guntz.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Why the NDC-12 Deadline is a Hard Stop for Pharma Packaging Lines: Healthcare Packaging

    Nov 20, 202625 minAudio

    What happens to a pharma packaging line when the industry runs out of 10-digit drug codes? Listen in to hear why the FDA’s move to a 12-digit National Drug Code by 2033 can’t be extended, and how the denser 2D barcodes...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Traceability in an Uncertain Regulatory Environment: ProFood World

    Nov 18, 202625 minAudio

    Why are food manufacturers still investing in lot-level traceability when the FDA has pushed back its deadline by 30 months? This episode looks at how retail mandates from companies like Walmart are setting the real...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Recycling can’t Keep Pace with Packaging Innovation: Packaging World

    Nov 17, 202619 minAudio

    Why does the U.S. recycling system always seem to be playing catch-up with packaging design? Senior editor Anne Marie Mohan sits down with Cody Marshall, chief programs officer at The Recycling Partnership, about the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Interlocking Bottles, Retro Castile Soap, and the Push to Go Paperless in Packaging: End of the Line

    Nov 16, 202626 minAudio

    Could a QR code one day replace the paper leaflet in the box? In this week’s End of the Line, PMMI Media Group editors Matt Reynolds, Derrick Teal, Anne Marie Mohan, and Casey Flanagan sit down for a weekly roundup....

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. BayCare Trials Drone Delivery for Pharmaceutical Packaging: Healthcare Packaging

    Nov 13, 202612 minAudio

    How do you ensure a medication arrives at the proper temperature and uncompromised when its trip takes place by air rather than by delivery vehicle? BayCare Health System, a not-for-profit academic healthcare system in...

    Credit the people on this episode