Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Three Key Insights with Sanjiv Yajnik

Three Key Insights with Sanjiv Yajnik artwork

How Dealers Can Compete with Carvana And Other Digital Retailers | Yossi Levi

Sep 14, 202622 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Sanjiv connects with Yossi Levi, founder of Car Dealership Guy, to unpack how digital platforms like Carvana are reshaping the new car franchise landscape and pushing traditional auto dealers to evolve. In this episode of Three Key Insights, Sanjiv and Yossi Levi examine how digital platforms leverage massive marketing budgets and leaner cost structures to challenge traditional OEM dealer networks. The discussion breaks down why auto dealers can't afford to sit in the middle of the market, highlighting the choice between running a hyper-efficient transactional model or doubling down on a boutique, community-first experience. Yossi shares critical benchmarks on personnel costs, showing how digital competitors operate at roughly 20% labor cost relative to gross profit compared to 40% or more at traditional dealerships. Together, Sanjiv and Yossi Levi outline actionable playbooks for franchise leaders, from optimizing team performance through modern tech tools to leveraging grassroots local trust and industry advocacy. This conversation offers auto retail executives a practical blueprint for thriving alongside digital-first competition. Hosted by the President of Capital One Financial, Sanjiv Yajnik, Three Key Insights convenes elite dealers and industry innovators to decode the shifts shaping the future. Learn more at https://www.capitalone.com/cars/about/leadership CONNECT WITH SANJIV YAJNIK LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/sanjivyajnik/ X: https://x.com/sanjiv_yajnik

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

On this episode of Three Key Insights. So it does make you wonder, like, what is going on here, and how is Carvana operating? And are they operating under a different set of rules or guidelines than that traditional dealer, which, you know, is that happening, and does that give them an advantage? The auto industry is moving fast, and it's getting more complex. Success today takes more than instinct. It takes insight. Welcome to Three Key Insights with Sanjiv Yajnik, President of Capital One Financial Services. Today, Sanjiv is joined by Yossi Levi, Founder and CEO of Car Dealership Guy. From his early days on the dealership floor to creating a powerhouse industry media network, Yossi shares his unfiltered playbook on competing with digital platforms, slashing overhead costs, and why the secret to long term profitability in auto retail is mastering the barbell strategy. I'm here with my good friend Yossi Levi.

He is the founder of the Car Dealership Guy, and we've been connecting with each other for a fairly long time. Yossi, congratulations on your fourth child, I believe. And you've just had a daughter, so congratulations to that. You got me with that one. People typically say congratulations on the business, so you got me with that one. Thank you. Thank you. But let me just start by asking you about your view on Carvana. And the dealers, you know, there's been a big kind of conversations about Carvana, how they're stepping into somewhat of the franchise space. So can you shed some light in the way that you've seen it? And I know you've spoken with many, many dealers about this particular issue.

Thank you, Sanjiv. With respect to Carvana, I think there's two pieces. There's the Carvana used car business, and now there's the Carvana new car business. I think what is arguably right now more interesting or being followed more closely by the dealership community is the new car business. Because the new car business is, Carvana has been, for those that don't know, they've been acquiring Stellantis dealerships. They've acquired over a handful at this point.

It's been, you know, a little bit over a year or a year and a half or so since they began this process. And our team at Car Dealership Guy, we basically spent the last three weeks investigating, is Carvana being offered some flexibility in their, with the respect to their partnership with Stellantis? To be specific, like, are they being allowed to operate under a different set of guidelines? And so what did we do? We interviewed over 40 dealers, brokers, just industry participants, and we asked them questions.

And I will tell you, this was a very eye opening investigation. We didn't come up with anything conclusive that they violated any franchise agreements. Right? So we're not making any accusations. What we are saying, though, is that it does warrant at least a bit more investigation and for, and dealers have the right to ask questions and get answers. I'll give you one specific example that can make this really practical. But for example, service centers. Dealers, a big part of their their operations and, you know, whether it be allocation, bonuses, comes down to their CSI score, customer service index score, which is directly correlated to service centers. So it does make you wonder, like, what is going on here, and how is Carvana operating? And are they operating under a different set of rules or guidelines than that traditional dealer, which, you know, is that happening, and does that give them an advantage?

The thing that I have picked up in speaking with with a lot of dealers across the spectrum is that they are really worried. They don't, they don't worry about competition, but there are two particular things that they're worried about. You pointed out one of them, which is Carvana is coming in, doing the digital sales, but they have to do the servicing. And so it's almost like Carvana is riding on the backs of traditional dealerships to be able to do their business. And they also feel that Carvana is using its market position, so the market cap, which is really high, and all of the power they get from that to flood the market with marketing.

And so the combination of the two, of excessive marketing that they can't compete with and riding on the backs of dealers. And one of the things that they are worried about is given what is going on and given the impact that they're seeing, how can they even support the communities in which they are? Because dealers not only do their servicing of cars, et cetera. You know, they really support their local communities. So what advice would you have for dealers? How do they orient themselves? How do they kind of position themselves to allow themselves to do good enough business and compete in this environment?

Yeah. I think it's separating the free market such as things such as marketing and the, and any potential favoritism, which, again, we're not saying we've proven, but we are saying that it makes you ask some questions, and you wanna get some answers from the OEMs. So I think that's a very valid point by dealers. Right? So let me just play one more thing by you, and then I really wanna pick your brain because this is uncharted territory. Everyone is trying to figure it out. We have a situation where a digital only dealer is getting into the the new car market with a company. They are using their powers of whether it is the high stock price or market value and all this stuff. Whatever they're doing, they've got enough ammunition to flood the market with marketing, which is having a real impact on traditional dealers.

And traditional dealers feel like they are taking advantage of the situation because they have to do the servicing, but the fear is this whole thing taken to an extreme will put them out of business. And then once they're out of business, then competition collapses, and then there's one player and and so on and so forth. And, of course, it is their livelihood, their families, and, you know, the car business is a month by month cash flow business. You can't make a couple of months, You can go under.

Given all of that, if you are a traditional dealer, what would you do? So the first thing is I would support the, all the industry advocates, whether it be NADA or, you know, or us or whoever is out there doing the work. I would look at their playbook, and I would try to emulate that. So, as much as I can. So Carvana is in their case, they are going very deep with one OEM. Think about that. Right? There's a lot of sense in doing that. I just had a dealer on my podcast, Eddie Stivers from Stivers Auto Group. He used to be the, he used to be the chairman of the Ford Dealer Council.

And what I found very interesting about Eddie's model is that he's doing something very similar. He's consolidating his entire dealer group, and he's focusing it and centralizing around one OEM, Ford. And the reason that's so important is because what he's discovered and what he believes is that in the world we're moving into, where, again, it's driven more by AI search, there's increasing consolidation among dealerships and rooftops, he believes that having, being very close to a single OEM is more advantageous and gives them a competitive advantage versus being spread out across, you know, four or five or six OEMs. I think that is a, that's a great suggestion. I guess my pushback would be when you go to, you focus on one OEM, it's like owning one stock in your stock portfolio. It's you know, you go up and down. It's a lot more risky. You're not diversified.

A 100%. You're not diversified. And look, one could say fortune favors the bold. Right? Maybe some, all the wealthiest people in the world got very wealthy by owning one business to the top and then diversifying after they got wealthy. Now, of course, we're not seeing the other millions of people that didn't make it. It's very much selection bias in that sense, but it's, there isn't, and that's exactly why it's tricky because you're taking a lot more risk when you're not diversified with your OEMs. Just look at the last five years where Ford had its challenges, then Nissan, Stellantis, those dealers, I mean, were, in many cases, in really tough shape, losing money.

And if you only have one certain store and you're losing money, what now? You better be able to ride that out for two years until you get out of that cycle. Yeah. And two years is a long time. You just, it's not possible to ride out unless you've got a big cash thing sitting somewhere. Let me play back, let me play to you some of what I think I would do, although I just want to be clear. I've not run a dealership, but I meet up with all of these folks, and I love business, and I love startup businesses. So let me riff on one thing that you said.

Get with industry groups to come to a good conclusion because I think everyone wants a healthy auto market. I don't think the manufacturers want a unhealthy one. I don't think Carvana wants an unhealthy market, and I don't think dealers want an unhealthy market. So there's gotta be some way to square the circle. And that can only be done if people, if this is a big enough deal, and I'm hearing it's a big enough deal, they've got to get together with the industry group. So I totally agree with you on that one. That was your first point.

The second one that you brought up was, like, focus on one OEM. Let me play a different way of doing it. You've gotta look at not only your opponent's strengths, but also your own strengths. So what are the own strengths? One is you are deep in your local community. The second is you've got your servicing department, and not only are you deep in your community, there are people who you support in your community. Like, you know your local community when you're a dealership.

And I am astounded when I go across the country. I've always said dealers are some of the best entrepreneurs I've seen in the whole world because they have, they don't only have the head part of it, they've also got the heart. And so maybe it is attacking from that perspective. You can't spend the marketing dollars, do things from the grassroots. I totally agree with that. And then let me do the third one, and then you push and pull this. Please, go ahead. The third one would be, you know, find out exactly what the total price and service competition looks like so that when you're competing with someone else, you gotta look at all their strengths even in the pricing and figure out your strengths in the pricing and show how you're competitive. So those are my three. I'd love for you to pull, It's great, any, all of them apart.

So first of all, on the OEM, just to put a pin in that, I'm not endorsing that strategy, but I do appreciate the creativity and boldness of an operator willing to do that. Second thing is what you just said, I think, is very, very true because I call it barbell, the barbell method. Right? If you look at our industry today, I don't, I think that in the middle is where you just simply die out. You either have to be highly tailored, highly personalized, highly local, very boutique, right? And own that. Or you have to just be like, don't talk to me. Get me what I want. Transactional, commoditized, online, right? Carvana, essentially.

I think the middle is where you simply go to die out. When I look at how I bought my car, right, I bought a Lexus. I didn't go to just a normal dealership or something. I didn't do that. I went to the very local, very boutique, personalized service, texting with me. Hey. What do you need? How can I help after the fact? Right? You really get that community feel and someone that you can lean on, and that's what I wanted. I wanted someone I can trust. I can lean on. Even me, right, with everyone that, the whole industry, right? And so the point I'm trying to make is, like, when I think about where the dealers that are gonna increasingly win, I just think it's a lot harder to compete on the commoditized side because you obviously have billions of dollars here at play that are working to consolidate that segment of the market. So if you lean on the local, you know, you do your local, very local social media. They get to know you. They build trust.

You offer that tailored experience. Right? You leverage AI tools and technology for everything else, but not for the actual experience and the communication with the customer, then I think that is a way to differentiate yourself. Because what can the big guys not do? They can't give every single customer an absolute world class tailored experience. They just cannot. Is there anything else that you have picked up? Like you said, you inform dealers, you talk to dealers on this particular topic.

Because I think the Carvana piece just brings it to a head. You know? Digital, physical experience in the store, experience online. And just pull it back into this topic. Anything else that you picked up that the dealers would be, it would be useful for them to know from the success of others who have, you know, if they use that particular playbook, they can actually compete appropriately with a with a company like Carvana.

The other thing that I'm seeing that's interesting is dealers working under cost structure. So Carvana, again, from another conversation I recently had, Carvana is at about 20%. people cost as a percentage of gross profit. 20%. And then dealers, on the other hand, are 40%, 45%. That's a very meaningful difference because, again, that gives your competitor a direct advantage over you. So I think where the smartest dealers are also doing is saying, how can I have a smaller team but a better team?

Right? How can I instead of having ten people that are, where eight are average, how can I have seven people where there's no one who's average? That's the point. I think people are with, given all the tools that exist today in the market for dealers to use, whether it be on you know, you're on the lending side or on the digital retail side or, you know, in store when it comes to actually doing the deals. Like, there's so many options out there. The tech has gotten so good. So now the question is, how can I have better, the best possibly trained people, the highest quality people doing more with these tools? They're making, you know, they're making a better living. The customer's happier because they're getting a better experience, and the dealer has a lower cost structure. And the way it's being done is with technology.

So I think that's the other area where you're gonna see the smartest dealers continue to focus on. It's how can I improve my cost structure, not doing it by by just reducing my teams just to reduce my team because then I'm gonna help or hurt my sales. Rather doing it by leveraging the right tools and technology for my market leaning into local and community so that I have that very strong trust and bond with the customer and they come back to me? And then, ultimately, and ultimately growing their earnings and being more competitive against a company like Carvana. I'd love to ask you about this whole, you know, the technology piece. Here's what I'm seeing.

There are in general, you know, you're stuck between two choices. One is a company that comes in and says, take my technology. It's the whole thing. But to be able to transfer to that technology, it takes six months, eight months, ten months. Very, very hard to do in a normal store when you've got a 100 other things running. And you can't put your business on hold, and it's a cash flow business, so you need to continue to go. And the technologies I see on that front are not versatile enough to keep up with the business. It's like focus on the technology.

And then you'll see with the technology changing so fast, being able to get to the technology that is going to keep up with the times requires a certain architecture that's also a problem. So how do you see that playing out? How do you see dealers kind of trying to deal with that issue right now in the marketplace? It's not easy. I think everyone is, a big, I would tell you the most talked about conversation in Circles, which is our intelligence tool. It's a community for dealers, essentially. Call it, like, a professional network for dealers. The most spoken about topic are vendors.

And it's funny to think about, right, because you'd think it's maybe something else and not vendors or just the day to day or hiring or whatever, but it's vendors. And the reason is because it's still very opaque. Right? The entire space, you don't know, you know, like you said, will this company be around? How are they well capitalized? Are they compliant? Is this gonna be the best integrated platform for my DMS? Because you're right. It's very tricky, and you make the wrong, you know, you make a mistake. You just wasted three months until you get it onboarding. And I'm not even talking about a DMS or a CRM, then you've wasted nine months. Yeah. And so you have to be very thoughtful about these decisions. One of my motivations to make sure that this industry remains very healthy because only with a healthy industry, we are in business and so on.

I just love the conversation we had, Yossi, and it's so good picking your brain and jumping right into it. So I really appreciate that. Let me give you my three insights that I've come up with from our discussion. And it is very focused on what does one do when a company like Carvana starts competing, and maybe they have more competition like that. So this is for the traditional dealers, and what does one do? The three things that you want to keep in mind. One is this is a time to get together.

Get together with the industry participants, the industry leaders, NADA, others, other dealerships, and potentially with OEMs and with companies like Carvana to figure out what is the best path forward. Because the way I would orient this conversation is it's not us versus them, but everyone wants a healthy industry. No one is served with an unhealthy one. I think it is really important to do this early versus when there's a massive issue at the back end and then we are faced with that. The second is, what do you do kind of moving forward?

So, you know, there's a couple of ways you can go. One, as you pointed out, is kind of having a stock portfolio. Either you have one stock, you write that. So you consolidate everything into one brand, and then you lean into that, have more say, make that happen in a really big way. Or you'd have a portfolio that is, you know, of many, many stocks of many brands, but then you've gotta play a very different game on that front because you'll have to use your other strengths to kinda get there. But in each one of these, what you've got to do is don't focus only on the strengths of the competition. In this case, if Carvana's coming to market with new cars, you study them to understand their strengths, but then look at your own strengths.

Remember your strength is in the local community. That is where your strength is. That's where the big companies do not have the strength. Lean into that one million times to figure out how you can combat lots of dollars spent on marketing. The third insight is really how are you running your dealership? Don't get stuck in the middle, either the boutique or an incredibly efficient low cost way of doing things. If you're low cost, then look at Carvana's cost and your cost.

And you've got to use all sorts of technology and all this stuff, but you've gotta bring your cost down and become the most efficient player. And if you're running at 40% and Carvana's running at 20%, you're out of luck. So you've gotta do that. Or you go the boutique method. I don't think either Yossi and I are saying, the boutique means no technology. It is the omnichannel method, but what you're doing is you're keeping a little more cost. You have to. But it is all about the human connection, and you overdose on that, and you hone that to a fine degree, and make sure that as you put your technology together to support that, it is supporting that one thing. That is the most important thing that you're doing and put that together.

And, hopefully, this is kind of helpful because I know a lot of folks are looking at this and trying to figure it out. But I would tell you, it is very important for the US to have a vibrant dealer community. And I think together, we can look at this particular issue, put our arms around it, and hopefully, we can move forward. Well said. But thank you so much, Yossi. This was awesome, and, look forward to seeing you soon. Thank you so much. This is great.

The dealers who win turn insights into action. Now's the time to take the lead. This has been Three Key Insights with Sanjiv Yajnik. We'll see you next time. Views and opinions expressed by guests on this podcast are solely their own and not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of Capital One Auto, Capital One NA, or its affiliates. This content is provided for informational and educational purposes only and is not intended to serve as financial, legal, tax, or business advice. Viewers should consult their own independent professionals regarding their specific individual or business needs.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Hosts

  • Sanjiv Yajnik Host Feed-stated

Guests

  • Yossi Levi Guest Feed-stated

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Preventing Auto Fraud & Other F&I Strategies with Justin Buzzell

    Nov 13, 202619 minAudio

    Growing up in the car business from the sales floor to leading F&I across 75 stores, Justin Buzzell brings an unmatched perspective to the frontlines of dealership operations and rising automotive fraud. In this episode...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. How non-commissioned sales thrives in the hub and spoke model | Easterns Auto Group

    Oct 23, 202634 minAudio

    In this episode of Three Key Insights Sanjiv Yajnik sits down with the father-son leadership team, Robert and Joel Bassam of Easterns Automotive Group, to unpack their revolutionary hub and spoke operational model....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. From cashier to dealership CEO: Growing your auto career | Armina Mgerian

    Oct 9, 202618 minAudio

    Sanjiv reconnects with Armina Mgerian, CEO and Partner at the Nouri/Shaver Automotive Group, to share her inspiring leadership journey and learn about automotive retail strategies for today’s demands. Armina shares her...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Building trust with your customers and why Gen Z prefers the physical dealership with Drew Tutton

    Sep 25, 202622 minAudio

    In a high-velocity, low-margin automotive market where competition is fiercer than ever, traditional dealerships must adapt to protect margins and retain buyers. In this episode of Three Key Insights, Sanjiv Yajnik...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Navigating the AI world of dealer, vendor and tech | Marguerite Watanabe

    Aug 28, 202621 minAudio

    To stay ahead in the game, dealerships should have the AI and tech talk with vendors and DMS providers. In this episode of Three Key Insights, host Sanjiv Yajnik, President of Capital One Auto, sits down with Marguerite...

    Credit the people on this episode