Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

This Whole Life

This Whole Life artwork

Screening Prospective Priests & Religious: Storytellers #7

Jan 26, 202611 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

What's it like to have the responsibility of discerning whether a man or woman would be a healthy and suitable priests or religious? Dr. Anthony Isacco shares his humble insights into the quietly holy work of psychological assessments in the process of discernment. Support the show Thank you for listening, and a very special thank you to our community of supporters! Join our email list and never miss an episode or an event Visit us online at thiswholelifepodcast.com, and send us an email with your thoughts, questions, or ideas. Follow us on Instagram & Facebook Interested in more faith-filled mental health resources? Check out the Martin Center for Integration Music: "You're Not Alone" by Marie Miller. Used with permission.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome back, friends. It is this whole life yet again, and you are back for another story of glory or something else. It is yet to be seen. We're back again with Dr. Anthony Asako from St. Mary's University in Minnesota. Welcome back, Anthony. How are you? I'm doing great. Good to be back. Thank you. Good to be with you again. Yep. Yeah. We just, if you haven't listened to uh Anthony's episode previously to this one, last week, on depression and its its clinical expressions, relationship to faith, I I won't say stop what you're doing, because listen to this story and you'll hear exactly why you need to go back and listen to that other episode because of this story and everything that Anthony has to offer.

SPEAKER_00Anthony, I know that um part of your uh clinical work, part of your professional experience has been working with uh seminarians, with clergy, with religious sisters uh in their own psychological health and healing. Um so I'm wondering if if there's a story that you have, especially related to clergy or seminarians, you know, uh we have many, many great priests and seminarians who listen to this whole life, but I would say the majority of our listeners are lay people who don't have the experience of living the seminary or ordained life.

SPEAKER_00Is there a story that you have that you could offer that would help us lay people understand some aspect of priestly vocation that we wouldn't have access to otherwise?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I'm very blessed to work with that population, you know, priests, women religious, seminarians, uh young men and women who are discerning a vocation to the church and are applying to different dioceses and communities. It's kind of like a call within a call to be able to work with that population. And I think one of the reasons why it's so important is because um we often hear the negative stories of a bad priest or a bad nun and how that has a ripple effect out into the community.

SPEAKER_01Um, you know, one bad priest can impact thousands of people negatively. Yeah. And so I come at it as well, one good priest could have a positive impact on thousands of people as well. And so if I could do one small part to contribute to a happy, holy, healthy priest or woman religious, then it has like a communal and kind of collective impact, you know, and so that really drives me and gives me meaning and purpose. And it basically makes up about you know 95% of my clinical work is to work with that population.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Any any stories that you can think of that um would highlight any of the the challenges of the priestly vocation and uh any kind of anything that might help us lay people have a greater sense of understanding and empathy for the priest in our parishes.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. So a lot a lot of lay people I talk to, whenever I tell them I do evaluations and I and I work with uh applicants to the seminary and women women religious, they usually kind of have two um two images in their mind of applicants. It's either like the uh the Boy Scout kind of um older altar server, like this like this little young saint who who's gonna be like ordained and be like, you know, um you know, the next uh, you know, um Saint John Paul II, you know, overnight, like, you know, they're they're ready to like ordain them and and canonize them immediately.

SPEAKER_01Yep. Um, or they're like, are you screening out all the bad guys? You know, are you getting all um and so I think one of the things that I try to educate lay people on is um the church has really grown in discerning with these applicants over time and has really grown at that admission stage, and including the work of the psychologist. And the work of the psychologist during that early discernment and admission stage is to give a comprehensive evaluation that is not just to screen out the red flags and the bad guys or bad women applying, but to use the evaluation as a tool for growth.

SPEAKER_01Because these people that are applying to seminaries and women religious communities are just that. They're people. They have their strengths, they have their flaws, they have their growth edges, just like anybody else. And so a good psychologist and a good psychological evaluation will kind of paint a beautiful mosaic of that human person and really respect their anthropology as a created uh person of God that is made in the image and likeness of God and is inherently good and worthy and has value and dignity.

SPEAKER_01And if they're gonna enter into a formation program, they have some work to do. Yeah. They have some work to do. And so the psychological evaluation, the psychologist can play a very valuable role. And so I feel most alive as a psychologist whenever I can bring my integrative skills to that role, and I can work with the seminary rector, the vocation director, the bishop, the applicant, and kind of communicate the psychological knowledge and science and practice in a way that all those stakeholders can say, Oh, here's the person in front of us, yeah, here's their goodness, here's their strengths, and now we have kind of some targets or a path forward that will help this young person, man or woman, uh move forward in their discernment and their formation.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. And something you said at the beginning, you know, I I think back to uh in in the Archdiocese of St. Paul, Minneapolis, where we live and work back in 2013 when the abuse scandal exploded here in the Twin Cities area. I think of seeing on the news the Diocese of Pittsburgh and when the news broke there, my home diocese in Iowa, of Davenport, and you could go on and on and on through dozens of dioceses in this country around the world. Um, how how has that experience?

SPEAKER_00You mentioned it a little bit, of like people asking, well, did you get the bad ones out? You know what I mean? How has that, how is how having that history so close in the rearview mirror, how does that impact the work that you do, the work that dioceses and dioceses and seminaries do? Um, what what does that do for you in your work now?

SPEAKER_01Well, I think that's kind of like the dark cloud that hangs over a lot of the work, but there's so much light in that darkness. Yeah. You know, I am incredibly encouraged, and I'm personally inspired actually by the young people that show up at my door for an evaluation. They're laying it all on the line. They really are. They're saying, This is who I am. I'm here because I think God is calling me to this vocation, and I want to follow God's will. I think it's a very authentic and genuine disclosure that they're making that takes a ton of courage.

SPEAKER_01It's very countercultural in a lot of ways right now. I mean, they're really working hard to follow this calling and to see if they are the one that's supposed to answer this call. So I feel incredibly encouraged, and there's so much hope and light that kind of breaks through the bad news stories that are out there, the things that have uh caused a lot of darkness in the church and different dioceses. Um, but part of our job is to um is to take a look at that and use the best tools that we have available to us uh in the screening process to see if there is a problem in that area of their life that should prevent them from entering into the seminary or women religious community and moving forward.

SPEAKER_01So those aren't always the easiest conversations, but those are the necessary conversations that are part of the job.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. For the good of the church and for even the good of this man or woman, that that they need to be in a place where there's a genuine calling, where there's a place for the safety and health of everybody. And I mean, to your point earlier about how much good one great priest can do, I I think back to an earlier stor earlier earlier storyteller's episode of ours where we talked to Father Nathan La Liberte, a good friend of ours, and I know you've gotten to know him as well.

SPEAKER_01He's a friend of our program. He's our he's our university chaplain. Exactly, right.

SPEAKER_00So he's yeah, he's the chaplain at St. Mary's University here. Um he's going through a graduate program at Saint at St. Mary's as we speak. Um, and he told his vocation story on an earlier episode, and he would be the first to say, I'm not exactly sure why they accepted me, but I'm really glad they did, because he was coming from an odd place, man. He was not, he was not the Boy Scout, let me put it that way, right? He was not like canonizable material coming into minor seminary. But clearly, you mentioned the light and the darkness, someone, or more people than one, saw a light in him where they're able to identify some psychological health, first of all, in the midst of maybe some chaotic environment, and they were able to help identify and help him to identify a genuine calling, which is really what what the question is.

SPEAKER_00Is there a genuine vocation here? How can we lift that up? How can we support it? And if not, how can we help that person understand in good discernment that there's another path for his good that is just not this one? Yeah. That's beautiful.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, this doesn't happen often, but it has happened a few times where I've been out at a gathering, been wherever, you know, at a retreat or what have you. Um, and someone has come up to me and said, you know, Dr. Isako, and I said, Yes, and I haven't recognized them at all. And they said, you know, you evaluated me some time ago for the seminary or the diaconate or women religious community, and you it was a tough conversation. Like you you really kind of read me the riot act, um, and I didn't get in.

SPEAKER_01Um turned out to be the best thing for me. Wow. Turned out to be the best thing for me. I'm now doing what God is calling what was calling me to do. You know, and so those kinds of stories are are not prevalent, but they do happen and are a little bit affirming in terms of, yes, sometimes you have to hold the line and be the person that delivers the bad news for greater good.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. That that that no to seminary or religious life is really hopefully a yes to something that they really are called to, that is going to be a path of joy and freedom and holiness. And it's just not this one, you know? Correct. I bet your I bet your shoulders scrunch up a little bit when they say you evaluated me and you said no. You're like checking for the exits, you know what I mean? Like who me?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, right. Um, but we're all on the same team with the same goal. You know, I want the I at the end of the day, I do want the best for the candidate that's in front of me, and I want them to do God's will too.

SPEAKER_00I love that. Well, you clearly are doing God's will in helping men and women discern of helping the church be safe and healthy and led by great people. So thanks so much for your work with them. Thanks for being here again with us, and uh thanks for all you're doing here at St. Mary's as well.

SPEAKER_01Great, thank you, Pat.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Hosts

  • Kenna Millea Host Feed-stated
  • Pat Millea Host Feed-stated

Guests

  • Dr. Anthony Isacco Guest Feed-stated

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The L that was really a W: Storytellers #27

    Nov 16, 202614 minAudio

    Fr. Matt Guckin is back to share a heart-warming story about a heart-breaking game. Support the show Thank you for listening, and a very special thank you to our community of supporters! Join our email list and never...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Ep113 Finding Peace in a Violent World with Fr. Matt Guckin

    Nov 9, 20261 hr 3 minAudio

    "Peace in the heart can lead to peace in the home, which can lead to peace in the world." ~ Fr. Matt Guckin What if peace is not the absence of war, but the presence of order? Why do the desires to control, to give our...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Surviving the Honeymoon: Storytellers #26

    Nov 2, 202614 minAudio

    The honeymoon period never lasts forever. But it's nice when it lasts at least to the end of the honeymoon... Pat & Kenna share stories from their honeymoon that didn't go exactly to plan. Support the show Thank you for...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Ep112 What Does Mental Health Actually Mean?

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    "The point of mental health, the whole thrust of it, is not just to be at peace alone in a vacuum. It's to be in connection with the people and the God that I'm related to." ~ Pat Millea Why can't mental health...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. In good times...and in bad: Storytellers #25

    Oct 19, 202617 minAudio

    Marriage is a gift, and not just for the birthdays, Christmases, and highlights. God has given us our spouse for the depths of suffering, too. Pat reflects on his role in the deaths of three of Kenna's family members...

    Credit the people on this episode