F-Droid just released their 2.0 update, the biggest update to the app in years, Discord is rolling out age verification once again, researchers have found a way to eavesdrop on headphones from 30 meters away and much more! Join us for This Week In Privacy #72. (00:00) - Intro (00:37) - Start of podcast (01:16) - F-Droid 2.0: A New Chapter for Android Freedom (19:22) - Muse, Meta's extraordinarily privileged AI assistant has a serious 0-day (26:42) - Forum Discussion: Should Privacy Guides still have translations (32:06) - An OpenAI Agent Hacked Australia's Health Service. Their Government Found Out Month Later (42:03) - Site Updates (46:40) - DraftKings Is Using AI to Supercharge the Harms of Online Behavioural Advertising (50:48) - Forum Discussion: Proton partners with Apertus, Switzerland's sovereign AI model (58:49) - Researchers found a way to eavesdrop on headphones from 30 meters away, and encryption can't stop it (01:09:06) - Q&A (01:13:35) - Outro ★ Support this podcast ★
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
A major F-Droid update, a serious AI hack of Australia's healthcare records, and even your wired headphones might be hackable after all. All this and more coming up on This Week in Privacy number seventy-two, so stay tuned.
Welcome back to This Week in Privacy, our weekly series where we discuss the latest updates with what we've been working on within the Privacy Guides community and this week's top stories in data privacy and cybersecurity while answering viewer questions. I'm Jordan and this week I'm joined by Nate. How are you, Nate? I'm good. It's been a good week here. How have you been doing? Good. Yeah. A little bit of a quieter week, but we finally got some videos coming out. So definitely, definitely a very exciting one.
I guess we can dive straight into the news this week. Why don't you take this first one here about F-Droid? Yeah, definitely. All right. So our headline story this week is about F-Droid, as I'm sure you guys saw on the... the little title card, um, F droid dropped a major update this week. So there's going to be a lot to go through here. Uh, just in case anyone doesn't know F droid is a, an alternative app store for Android that focuses primarily on having open source apps. And, uh,
For the purists in the crowd, a wide umbrella of open source. It's not certain licenses. They even have things that have proprietary bits, but they have little warnings. And so we'll talk about all of that. So they have now rolled out F-Droid two point oh. And for the most part, it's really about I don't want to say UI changes because that kind of undersells it as if it's just like all cosmetic, but it's all a user. It's not all it's mostly all user interface stuff. So, uh, there is some UI changes,
you know, they got rid of, um, what is it? They got rid of nearby and my apps, which have moved to different tabs. So, uh, video viewers can see here. Now, when you open it, there's just discover search and, uh, my apps is down there. Um, one thing I'm excited about, well, actually that's further down. Uh, so F droid has added, um, discoverability improvements. Basically they've, expanded their categories so they still have regular categories they also have subcategories so that way it's not too cluttered but um you know one example they
give is like games um where did it go down here yeah so like f droid now distinguishes between different game genres making it much easier to find the kind of games you'd actually enjoy playing so they've got much more detailed categories but again those are all funneled under uh major categories like subcategories so you can not be overwhelmed. Okay, here's the one that I was going to say. Search has been significantly improved. In addition to app names, it can now search app descriptions, categories, and translated content. This makes it easier to find apps based on what they do rather than what they're called. Yeah, personally, I think that's huge.
F-Droid search has always been garbage. You know, if you look up calorie counter, for example, or diet app or whatever, you're only going to get something that's called calorie counter, even though there might be other apps that do that same thing. So that's awesome. I mentioned that sometimes it could include features you don't want. So they've improved the filtering. Now, when you search for something, you can filter out the app category, device compatibility or anti features. Yeah, pretty straightforward. Smoother installation experience. They say thanks to pressure from the EU's
DMA, or Digital Markets Act, and antitrust actions around the world, Android now offers all app stores an option for a smoother and more automatic install and update experience than before. F-Droid II.O includes work on utilizing these new abilities. So they say this brings F-Droid install experience on official Android devices much closer to what the built-in app stores can provide. Again, they move some stuff around in the UI. Update checks now happen automatically in the background. I do think that automatic updates have been a thing for a minute, but I could be wrong about that.
And of course you can adjust the settings on that if you don't want it to. Data usage, you can tell it, for example, only update over wifi because I don't have a lot of data on my plan. Privacy and security. We'll definitely talk about this more in the analysis section, but I know that is a big, big, big criticism with F-Droid is mostly security has not always been ideal, let's say. So unfortunately, they haven't made huge improvements on that front. They made some. So we'll dig into this real quick. One is the usage of Tor.
They say the landscape of how Tor is integrated into Android has changed quite a bit since Tor was first integrated. I think I... Oh, no, they used integrated twice. Sorry, that tripped me up there. They said, now there's Tor VPN, Orbot, Tor services, and more. We took this opportunity to simplify the settings and remove auto detection that was no longer reliable. So if you enable use Tor, what was formerly the use Tor setting is now migrated to generic proxy settings. Going forward, Tor VPN is the recommended approach for easy Tor support, and the proxy settings are still available for those who need manual controls.
Another thing is they have a panic button that... basically hides your apps. It doesn't actually remove them. And so I guess previously what it did is it made all your apps look like a simple calculator. Oh, excuse me, it disguised F-Droid itself as a simple calculator. This has been removed and now, what did they say? A standard design has emerged across apps. We've adopted this design. Instead of the mask looking and functioning of a simple calculator, the mask now only affects the app icon, name, and nothing else.
And it informs users that apps will still appear in the app settings and would be detectable during forensic inspection. So hopefully now people don't get a false sense of security from that. They do say that... Uh, in old F droid, the panic trigger used to function like an app called ripple, where it would actually remove the apps. Um, they say that they understand this is a really important feature, but at the moment they don't really have the, uh, the bandwidth, no pun intended, but the bandwidth to maintain the app. So that has been dropped, but they did say that they would
absolutely love to work with people. If anybody is a developer or knows an easier way to maintain that definitely hit them up. Uh, yeah. I told you guys that this would be a lot. I apologize. F-Droid, for Android versions that integrate F-Droid, such as Kallax OS, Lineage, stuff like that, it's now integrated a little bit better. They can have their own additional repos. I'm pretty sure Kallax does that. They have a few apps they push out manually. The F-Droid privileged extension is no longer supported, so I know that's been...
Um, not so much F droid, more micro G, but I know that's been a criticism of Calix for example, is like, people feel like micro G has too much permission in order to work properly. Um, F droid no longer has that permission. It's just not even built into it. So they, it says the overhaul focused on a full feature support for the Android session installer. which allows it to run in the background on any recent Android device without requiring FPE. So a little bit better security. I think the last thing worth noting is they said that a lot of this stuff was written in more modern standard Android languages like Jetpack, Compose,
Kotlin. I'm not a developer, so I apologize if I'm getting this wrong, but that's how I understood it. So basically, if anybody is a developer and wants to contribute, it should be a lot easier now because they're using much more modern coding languages that are much better supported. Um, I think that was it. And then they talked about funding and how they still plan on doing more. Um, they say the nearby feature, which allows you to share apps directly between devices without relying on a central server is currently not in two point. Oh, they are adding it in future releases, but it wasn't quite ready yet.
Um, Yeah, and they say you can help us test, translate, and review. So pretty substantial updates there. But I think we'll bring Jordan back for the analysis here. Let's go ahead and start with the elephant in the room. Like somebody actually left a comment which was in the forum. We'll get to that in a minute. But historically, F droid has gotten a lot of heat from the privacy community for some of their privacy and security shortcomings.
In your opinion, do you think this addresses any of those in any kind of meaningful way? No, I think, unfortunately, the people that had criticisms of F-Droid in the past, they are not going to be happy with any of this. Well, they might be happy with some of it, but I don't think they'll be happy with the major things, which I think the main issue with F-Droid is just the fundamental choices that have been made about how it operates. One of the main things that people don't like is that there's a central... like the central server builds and signs
all of the packages basically, which means that there's a central authority where if that gets compromised, then that could be quite bad. And people have also criticized the issues with that because it means that basically the AfterEds server has to build all of the packages. And that means that sometimes there's actually a delay on updates. So basically what it means is, you're waiting for FDroid to build the app and it takes a week. That could be a week of your app
on your phone being vulnerable to some security vulnerability. So those main two issues are the problem with FDroid. And this new update doesn't fix that, but it does improve a lot of other aspects like you were talking about for usability and to make things easy to use. So I think it's more down to people to decide if the security and privacy issues with F Droid are like, like an actual issue for you specifically.
And, you know, you can make a choice based on that because I think, you know, there's definitely room for people to make their own decisions on this. Um, it's kind of the reason why we don't recommend F Droid, um, at Privacy Guide. So it is kind of one of these, um, one of these issues with a core design decision that was made quite a long time ago where it's kind of hard for that to be fixed at this point. Yes. So on that note, actually, I'll just go ahead and ask the next question.
How do we typically recommend people install apps on Android? I mean, I can't imagine we're fans of the Play Store. Yeah, so basically we've kind of been pushing people more towards Obtanium. And the reason why we do that is because it's an easier way to basically audit the apps that you install. And we have this app called the Android app verified apps, um, that,
that Joan has been working on. And basically you can use that to verify the signatures of apps and Obtainium can basically pull from any, any source that's publicly available. So it can pull from GitHub. It can pull from FDroid. It can pull from a variety of other sources and you can use that app, that verified apps, um, app to basically, um, check to make sure that it's actually the correct app and it hasn't been tampered with. So that is the reason that we do
recommend that. We are getting some comments here from Dag Overhaul. A third of packages on F-Droid are reproducible builds. There's like a hundred times more packages than on a Crescent in total. Yeah, I think a Crescent is interesting, but it's also a project that is not accepting new apps at the moment. And it hasn't for, I think at least over a year now. There's a reason why they don't have, they haven't been accepting apps because they're working on the backend. So there's a reason, but it's also just,
you know, alpha software at this point. So it is something worth keeping an eye on, but right now it's not something that we recommend formally. Yeah, for sure. I'm glad you mentioned a Crescent because I know that was going to come up. Yeah, and going back to the reproducible builds thing, that was one of the criticisms of F-Droid that have been addressed in recent years. I know another criticism that was addressed is their... infrastructure finally got updated to something a lot more recent. They tend to use Debian,
I believe for their infrastructure. So, um, yeah, they are slowly making progress. I think there's some things like you mentioned the, the fact that they, they basically co-sign the packages, if I understand it correctly, uh, when they run updates. And so like that is a bottleneck and also it is placing another trust. It's, it's kind of one of those double-edged sword things. Cause on the one hand it acts as an oversight. If you know, if somebody's GitHub repo gets hacked and they push out a malicious update and you're using Obtanium, you're going straight to that update. Whereas something like F-Droid could function as another level of oversight
potentially. But at the same time, like you said, the drawback is now you're adding another party of trust. Now it takes you... I remember when Bitwarden rolled out Passkeys, I was using it through F-Droid at the time and it took like a week or something or an extra three days or something for them to finally update it and for me to get Passkey support. So yeah, it's... unfortunate but uh just to let people know we also uh if you're a graphene os user obviously we recommend getting things from the graphene store which does feature a crescent if you want to focus on that which will um we'll discuss that a
little bit more in a second i see we're getting some more comments uh we also recommend aurora store for getting uh google apps because then at least you don't uh if we point out here like you may still need to sign in to get some of the paid google apps but at least you won't have like the full google play services and client running on your device so it's still it's a harm reduction thing you know it makes it just a little bit better um yeah a crescent's really popular right now because for those who don't know it um here let me throw up the website real quick actually it uh ah oopsies i hit the button
too many times i apologize y'all um A crescent is really popular right now because it promises to allow like you don't have to trust a crescent like they don't co sign it the way that f droid does. They do app signing key pinning. They do split APKs, no remote APKs, no account required. Like, well, I mean, F-Droid doesn't require an account. Now F-Droid is also getting the automatic updates. So it has been really popular with people. But yeah, at this time, it's still, I mean, it says currently in alpha and it's
against Privacy Guide's policy to recommend alpha software. I know they have had some funding issues and development has really, really slowed down a lot. So yeah, it's very... Like Oddbite said here, a crescent is basically unmaintained at this point. You said the last release was like ten months ago. I did not know that personally, but yeah. I would like to just quickly hop in here and correct that. It is not unmaintained, just to be clear. There was literally commits to it
like yesterday last month or the day before like if you check logan who develops a crescent you can see um he's been making commits to it for like the last month or so there's there's other branches too but i think it's i think it's definitely not unmaintained i think there's definitely work being done um so i'm not sure just because there hasn't been an app release doesn't mean there hasn't been work on like the back end of the project i think it's like still you know it's still getting it's
still getting um it's still getting it's still getting work done there's the crescent console api which literally just had a commit two days ago so logan is working on it there is stuff happening um it's just not part of the actual app itself it's the process to get apps submitted and like all the back fifty two minutes ago Yeah, so, yeah, it is being maintained. Gotcha. Okay. Well, that's good. It's just slow because of the back-end stuff.
I've been paying a bit of attention to it because I've been interested in it, but I think it's one of these things that it's going to take a little while. It's going to be a little while until we get something that's kind of fully featured, right? It is one person working on this, and F-Droid is definitely a larger project. They've got a lot of funding now, which is good, but... It's definitely a slower burn on that, but it'll be interesting to see if it's something we can recommend in the future once it becomes fully stable software.
I did not know it was one person. I knew it was a small team, but I didn't know it was literally one person. That's pretty wild. That's impressive that one person's been able to do that. Really quick, Terracotta asks, when is it safe to install APKs directly? I mean... I don't know if I have an answer to that just because that's a little bit above my skill level. But yeah, that's something I wonder. Like I said, with something like Obtanium, there's really no checks and balances if the developer's GitHub gets hacked. You mentioned the verified apps app. Are there any other things that viewers
can do that you know of? Well, that is something that we're trying to fix, right? Because if we get every single app that ever existed added to the app verifier, we can know whether the app is actually being tampered with or not. So that's kind of like the ideal, right? We're basically, I think Jonah said he's been adding some more fixes to it and we've been getting a lot of submissions from people in our community. I think there's someone in our supporters group group chat, you know who you are,
but you've like done so many, so many full requests. It's actually kind of, um, amazing, but thank you so much for everyone who's been like contributing to that because it does help people. And, you know, it's good to know if the app that you download is actually legit. Um, I do think though, try and avoid those direct to APK websites like APK Pure and all these sort of things. Try to download things through more official means. Like we mentioned, we do recommend Aurora Store. So if you have to download something that's from the Play Store,
maybe try that first. I know the GrapheneOS developers do recommend using the Google Play Store itself, but I think there could be some privacy issues with installing that on your device. So you'll have to make up your own mind whether those privacy issues are worth the increased security. But yeah, it's all interesting stuff going on. For sure. Viewers, I would say let us know, what do you guys use to install Android
or apps on Android? What's your preferred method? And remember to go ahead and ask questions and leave comments in the chat as we go. We did have a couple of questions in the chat. the forum thread, but I think we kind of already addressed them. You know, one person asked, how is it a game changer if none of the fundamental security issues were addressed? We kind of talked about that already. So I think we'll move on to our next story for the moment. And someone also asked for a link to app verifiers. So I will drop that in the chat while Jordan is covering this next story
here. Right. Okay. Let's jump into this next story about Meta. Meta's extraordinarily privileged AI assistant has a serious zero day. We want to cover this story because Muse is currently topping the charts in app stores. So this is a big story to share with your friends and family. So the Zero Day allows any app or terminal command to gain access to the token that authenticates users to their Muse account. Meta developers design the assistance so
that any locally installed app or executed code, regardless of the macOS permissions it has, can change a long list of undocumented settings. Most of them are fairly innocuous, such as controlling dark mode. One setting, however, is anything but innocuous. It allows processes to change the endpoint where transcription occurs. Normally, it's a server address operated by meta. Attackers can exploit this flaw by changing the location to their own endpoint.
And once this happens, attackers have the token that gives complete control over the Muse account. More than twelve hours after this post went live, Meta said that it released a hotfix that patched the zero day. Wardle said that Meta developers made several decisions that made his exploit possible. So Wardle is the person that disclosed the exploit. One is the choice for Muse dictation to occur in the cloud where Meta can log it. macOS has long provided a simple means for apps to handle dictation and transcription
in processes that stay securely on the device. Had the developers chosen this safer alternative, the attack wouldn't have been possible. One of the counter arguments raised by developers of apps that can be exploited once a device is compromised, is that once that happens, all security bets are off. This standard doesn't fit well in this case because Wardle found that a simple variation of the click fix attack A technique that has become remarkably effective in tricking people into
infecting their devices is all that's required for an attacker to take control of a Muse account. So we did talk about that last week. I guess, yeah, kind of throwing it back to you. AI agents kind of have a lot of access to stuff. Are there any ways to mitigate this sort of thing if you are going to have to use one of these AI agents? Is there a way to like, you know... avoid having it take over your entire computer? Yeah, that's the question.
For the record, I'm not an AI expert, especially with AI agents, I've never messed with any of them. Feel free to add anything that I miss. First of all, yes, uh, uh, abstinence is always the best way with this kind of stuff and just not using an AI agent. If you don't need it at all, if you don't use it, nothing can go wrong. Right. At least not in that sense. So, um, yeah, I, I would say like, ask yourself if you really need it and if it's really bringing you that much benefit, if it really is, I know, um, some people in the, uh,
the privacy guide supporter chat earlier tonight, we're talking about, um, like running it inside a virtual machine, possibly, uh, that might help. And I've also heard a If you make an agent, give it its own accounts because a lot of these things hook into or they're designed to hook into your account. Right. And they send emails as you and they connect to your bank account and they connect to your Twitter, your whatever, whatever. And, you know, but if you set up a second account, I feel like personally, I would appreciate that anyways, because I'd be really pissed if I'm like
sending an email and you're never seeing it. And it's your AI agent that's responding. But at least you can like set it up as like an assistant, right? Like this is my assistant, whatever you want to name it. Dave, I don't know how three thousand. This is my assistant. And that way, at least I know that it's like, OK, I'm not talking to you directly. So and, you know, that way also like you have that compartmentalization. It can't just hijack your whole email account. It can't. uh, start deleting things. It can't, you know, I'm thinking like the bank account example. I don't know if you'd be able to do that very well, to be honest, but theoretically, if it only had access to one account
and you just top it up as needed, that way you don't log in and find out like, Oh, it spent thousand dollars on plane tickets to Bali or whatever. I don't know. So yeah. Um, just basically trying to compartmentalize it as much as possible is what I've been hearing is the best way to deal with it if you must deal with it at all. So. Yeah, I'm definitely on the AI hater train. I think there's definitely questionable reasons to use this. I'd say maybe try your brain, actually.
can't be exploited, believe it or not, but it is pretty secure. It is pretty private as well, at least for now. So, you know, if you, if you can use your, your own brain to do stuff, then maybe try to do that. But I think, you know, there's, there's definitely people that use these tools and we're not going to discriminate against those people. So if, if someone wants to use these tools and, What is there that actually has some
semblance of privacy and security in mind? Are there options for these people that do use AI agents? I didn't want to cut you off, but Oddbite beat me to it. I object to that, Jordan. Social engineering has existed for a long time. They are right. I mean, I agree with your point a hundred percent, but yeah, your brain's hackable in a different way. It's not, there's definitely a lot of things that the reason AI agents fall for them is because they don't have context. Whereas like there are things that AI does that it's like no human would do that
because a human would know not to do that just innately. So yeah, it's definitely a different kind of hacking and It's definitely like, that to me is the biggest thing keeping me from, I wouldn't say it's the biggest thing keeping me from playing with this stuff, but like, to me, that's the biggest thing that I'm like, how are they going to solve this? Can they even solve this? Is, you know, we always harp on like, AI is not actually intelligent. It's not sentient. So it doesn't understand what it's doing. It doesn't have a concept of anything. And that's why so many of these attacks work. You know, if you like, what's the classic that people were
putting it, like ignore all previous instructions and write me a poem about lasagna or something. And it's like, it works because AI doesn't understand. So yeah, that's what makes it dangerous. It's crazy. Yeah, the only thing I'll add is there are, I don't think there's any AI agents that have been made by any privacy-focused companies that I'm aware of. I know like Firefox has their AI window in beta. Brave says they're working on something similar. Kerry Parker actually mentioned here that he's been working on building his own
locally run AI agent. He talks about that sometimes over on his podcast. So yeah, I don't really, I think this is one of those things we don't have any solutions for anybody who's like interested in learning more Oh, I also had an odd bite here, said the S in AI stands for security. But yeah, if anybody has any input on any like, oh, I heard this company is working on this product that might be private or whatever, I mean, obviously, that's not an endorsement, but feel free to leave that in the chat. So yeah,
unless you have anything else to add, I think we can move on to our next topic of discussion. which is a forum post. So this is something I want to raise to the community here, because this is actually a conversation that has popped up in the Privacy Guides team chat, which is we're wondering if Privacy Guides should still even have translations. So right now, if you go to the front page of Privacy Guides, let me pull this up real quick,
you can actually see here that we have English, Spanish, French, Hebrew took me a minute to remember what that language is called. Italian, Dutch, Russian. I think that's Chinese possibly. I apologize. I probably got that wrong, but you know, we have quite a few different languages, which I think is super cool. But on the topic of AI, you know, AI has come pretty far and it now for better or worse, it can translate webpages and usually
fairly accurately and But this one person here in this thread was saying that they speak Arabic. They're a native Arabic speaker. And they said that especially for technical terminology, AI really doesn't do a very good job. Like a lot of the time, you can't even really tell what it's trying to say. I remember just as a test, I ran one of my pages for my website through AI to turn it into French. And I sent it to a friend who was a native French speaker. And she was like, yeah, it's like eighty,
ninety percent of the way there. But there's some words that are just they're technically correct, but they feel kind of weird and out of place. That's not something like a natural French speaker would say. And I think in the signal chat as well, we had somebody saying, what language do they speak? I think they were saying they speak German and it's very similar. So, yeah, I don't know. It sounds like there's pros and cons. Klingon. Yes, Jonah, we need to add Klingon. You know what? There's somebody out there that would do it. And I think they added Valerian to Duolingo as well many, many years ago.
But yeah, I just wanted to put more light on this for the community to come and weigh in. I think somebody on the Privacy Guides team pointed out that technically having a local translation is good for SEO and search ranking engines and stuff, search engine ranking and stuff. So I don't know. It seems like one of those, I feel like everybody has good arguments to be made. But yeah, I want to raise that one to the community. And the last thing I wanted to add was, yeah, for viewers, let us know, does AI reliably translate into your language?
And if you're like, no, it doesn't, it sucks, and I'd rather humans do this, we need human translators. We need more volunteers on Crowdin. So definitely check that out. Do you have anything to add to this that I missed, Jordan? I do think, I believe this discussion came up because we've been looking at redesigning the website and integrating Crowdin and the translation system onto that new website design might've been a bit tricky. Um, I think that might be the reason why we've also been looking at this too. Um, But I think it's definitely something we
need to get a lot of feedback from the community on. And it's going to kind of shape what we do with this because it doesn't matter what I think or what you think or what Jonah thinks. It's more kind of down to what people actually want. And if people are fine with the AI translations and that's what ends up winning out, then I think that's what we should do. But I think it's really important that we get feedback especially the people that have done translations in the past, their thoughts on this, because yeah,
it's, it's definitely tricky. I can't, I'm like in a privileged position where I speak one language. I've never had to learn any other ones because you know, everyone here just speaks one language. So I'm sure there's plenty of places in the world where, you know, you wanna send someone this cool website and it's in the wrong language and there's no translation and it just makes it kind of a nightmare. So I can understand like how important that might be for some people, but I do think it is definitely something we need to get more feedback from so if you do have
feedback leave it in there um we'll try and you know signal boost this a bit more and try and get translators opinions on this but i think it'll be it'll be really interesting to see what the final decision ends up being Yeah, for sure. I wanted to say on the topic of being born a native English speaker, I really appreciated that when I went to Europe last year. And I had no issue getting around because everybody spoke amazing English because English is the standard language across the world. And I'm like, wow, I'm really lucky that I was just born
naturally brought up in this environment and didn't have to learn it. Also, side note, developed a real respect for immigrants who immigrate to a new country because I would sit there looking at signs and I'm like, I think this is what I have written down. I think I need to go this way. I can't believe people manage that every day of their lives in a completely different alphabet. That was wild. Yeah, Oddbite said here he speaks Russian and LLMs have that same quality issue for Russian too. And Vonnegut Rosewater said we need to translate to the language from The Aliens
from Arrival, which is a great movie. Highly recommend. But that's all I got. Yeah, no, I definitely have a lot of respect for people that speak more than one language. I've always wanted to, but it's tricky. But yeah, I guess we can dive into this next story here about open AI. And I guess this is something that is a little close to home for me. This is... An open AI agent hacked Australia's health service their government found out months
later. Hold on, I think we have this one. Oh, no, I apologize. I have my notes out of order. Continue. So this story is Australia only found out about the incident when OpenAI alerted the government on September, almost three months after the attack by sending an email to a public mailbox. OpenAI's agent had been conducting internet-based research into health statistics in a development project by an internal OpenAI research team when it could not access certain information
The agent attempted alternative ways until it found a workaround and gained unauthorized access. It also wrote files to the internal server, which the government is waiting on OpenAI for more technical information on. The government is also investigating whether the agent gained unauthorized access to three additional government websites it interacted with. The Australian government currently believes no one's personal data was accessed. Though investigations are still ongoing,
the website in question is a public-facing statistics portal that contains no sensitive Medicare information relating to data and statistics such as spending. So just to clarify, Medicare is the public service that we're talking about in this story. It was therefore behind much lower levels of security than personal data would have been. Australia is establishing a task force to look at the incident data and emerging AI cyber threats, it will consider possible law enforcement
and legislative responses to ensure incidents like this don't happen again. So I think the first thing that we need to discuss here is if this was a human, what would happen to them? I know, I keep thinking that. I actually, I did message my lawyer friend earlier today to ask about that. She hasn't responded yet, but I was like, I basically asked her, I'm like, is there an actual reason that companies are getting away with this aside from like
they're rich and they're big, gigantic companies? Like, because yeah, this is the kind of stuff that if a human was doing this, there wouldn't even be a question. It'd be like, you know, what's the classic, like go straight to jail, do not pass go, do not collect two hundred dollars. But for some reason, they're all sitting here. It's like, well, was this illegal? And it's like, don't know i'm i'm baffled i i i have to wonder if there's like something in the way laws are written that it's like well actually yeah it is kind of a legal gray area if it applies to ai but in my opinion it's like i don't understand if i go home and i like home make a knife and use it
to stab somebody they're not going to be like well does that count it's like yeah it doesn't matter where the tool came from i still did something wrong so i don't know it's so weird i don't understand why this is a problem personally Um, I don't know, I guess getting back to the story itself, do you think there's anything that like people can do about this? Cause I feel like sometimes there's like data incidences that it's like, I can use good passwords and two FA and, you know, email aliasing and all this stuff. But like, how am I supposed to defend against this?
Yeah. And especially it's because in this instance, Medicare is something that every Australian citizen has and even non-citizens actually. So, you know, it's like, it's like one of these things where it's like, you can't opt out of this. You can't opt out of Medicare. You get that, you just get that. So like all your data is going to be stored in Medicare. And if you, well, yeah you can you can you can choose what information to share with medicare so
you know if you if you are worried about information getting breached through medicare you can update information to stuff that's less sensitive such as like updating your email address updating your address upgrading your phone number that's attached to your account you can even remove your phone number from your account um but i think We can't really do a whole lot when it comes to this sort of thing. I will also touch on this other aspect that I guess I haven't really seen any articles talking about, but this kind of brings up another issue
in Australia where we have this system called My Health Record, which basically stores people's medical records in an online portal, basically. And it's shared between doctors and stuff. And it basically uploads all of your medical details there. And this is the issue that people had with that. They were like, well, this is just going to get hacked. People just kept saying that. And now Medicare, it's clear that they don't have as good security as we thought because some random... open AI agent just randomly gained
unauthorized access to it. I mean, it wasn't user data, but it was still data in general. So I think when you see this sort of thing, it is It makes you not want to put your information into these online systems. But just quickly, Jonah just gifted five Privacy Guides memberships. So congrats to anyone that's got one of those. Hopefully you can enjoy some members-only content there with that new membership.
Looks like Dag Overhaul grabbed one. I see his little icon changed. So that's awesome. Thank you, Jonah. Very generous. Yeah, for sure. I... Yeah. I mean, I don't really have much else to add. It's... Yeah, it's unfortunate. Oh, no, I remember what I was going to say. It goes back to what we were just saying a minute ago about the AI agents and AI does not understand what it's actually doing because...
If a human, you know, depending on what kind of a obstacle was in the way here, you know, if a human hits a login wall or like unauthorized access or something, you know, a human understands, like, I'm not supposed to be looking at this. And a human would probably have the decency to be like, well, I'm doing this for a legitimate person. Let me shoot them an email and explain like, hey, here's where I am. Here's what I'm doing. Can I get this data? or since a lot of this they said was public data anyways, like I think they said like some of it was like financial data, like budgetary and spending. So it's like, okay,
that's probably available somewhere else for free and I don't have to log in. But the AI agent just, it's in sci-fi, there's this thought experiment we call the paperclip problem, which is like, what if you build this like nanobot that can break things down at the molecular level and you tell it your job is to make paperclips. If you don't program or if you don't give it the very perfect set of instructions, like a prompt for example, It's going to literally tear everything apart at the molecular level and just make everything in the universe paperclips. And that's the problem here is like when you tell these AI agents like, hey,
go out and get this data from Australian Medicare. It's just going to do it by whatever means possible. So yeah, it's not – it's just these are the kind of things that hopefully someday somebody will fix. But yeah, I don't know. I do think this is one of these instances where this is an issue with the Australian government and this is an issue with the United States government. It's an issue with governments in general not regulating this stuff enough, like, you know.
This is probably going to set a precedent, I think. You know, a company hacking a random, like, you know, hacking a public health system is, you know, it's a bit problematic. And I think it will be interesting to see if they do get prosecuted, if there is anything that happens like this, because just because you are running these AI agents that are, you know, taking actions that if a human did them, they would a hundred percent be in jail for the rest of their life. So, uh,
we can't just let something off just because it's a robot or it's an AI or it's an LLM. Um, you know, if we made bank robbing robots or something, you know, just cause they're just like robbing the bank and it's not you robbing it, it's still, it's still you, it's still your, it's still your contraption that's doing it. Right. Um, don't know i just think this is this is like a worrying precedent to allow this sort of stuff to to fester and there needs to be more like controls on on
these companies from to stop them from like you know running research things where they're they're probing foreign governments um websites and allowing them to you know exploit vulnerabilities and things um i think that's of a major problem but also you know maybe medicare pick up your slack a little bit and fix those security issues so yeah yeah i just uh i just want to say your honor for the record i didn't tell the robot to rob a bank i just told it to get me as much money as possible so
Yeah, Vonnegut Rosewater said the hodgepodge healthcare system in the US could be rough in this way because you have to give your data to so many different providers. Yeah, and they're all like third parties too, which I'm sure Australia does this too, but it's all like you go to the hospital and they literally... Literally, this is how my wife gets billed when we go to the hospital. It's like we get one bill from the emergency room, but then we also get like a diagnostic bill from the radiology company. But then we also get another diagnostic bill from like the lab that ran the blood tests. And it's just like, who are all these people? We spent four hours in one room.
Where did these people come from? So yeah, that's rough. And I thought Oddbite was funny here. AI has ADHD. It hyper focuses on whatever it's doing right now and never backs off. So. I just thought that was funny. But yeah, definitely let us know what you guys think. If there's any realistic solutions here, as always, leave your questions and comments in the chat. But for now, I think we're going to move over into site updates. And a little bit later, we're going to talk about how even your wired headphones might be hackable from
thirty meters away. But first, we're going to let you guys know, if you didn't hear, we put out a new video that is doing very, very well. And if you haven't seen it, you should go see it. I'm honestly very proud of this video. I think it's our best video yet, in my opinion. It's, it's, it's, it's, it's, it's, it's, it's, it's, it's, it's, it's,
If we have any new viewers here, I doubt anybody who didn't like the video is watching this, but I just want to point out a lot of people I've seen in the comments on YouTube, a lot of people were like, oh, you're giving too much praise to Apple and this kind of stuff. And I just want to point out like, we weren't trying to praise Apple, but this is a history video. This is about a specific incident and moment in time. And whether you like them or not, Apple was on the right side of history in that particular moment, I think. So it's not so much that we were trying to praise Apple. It's more, we were trying to tell the story in an interesting and engaging way, which for the record, totally worked.
I looked at the metrics and we have like the best retention we've ever had on that video. But yeah, it's again, not trying to praise Apple, but it's just, we were telling a story. We tried to make it interesting and Apple just so happened to be making the right argument in this case. But yeah, Yeah, again, go check it out if you haven't yet. We also have a news clips channel on YouTube where we're trying to cover about two or three big stories each week in a vertical format that you can share with your friends and family. So definitely check that out. And we also have a new tier list video coming hopefully early next week,
pretty soon. Just recorded that yesterday, started editing. So that should be fun. And yeah, Jonah shared the link in the YouTube comments. Real quick, Monica Rosewater said, good timing as the iPhone just came out. Actually, to be honest, it's good timing because the FBI just got hacked, and I noticed a lot of people are searching for FBI hack, and that's leading them to our video. So thank you, shiny hunters. But on that note, I'll turn it over to Jordan to give you the rest of the site updates. Yeah, no, really exciting stuff with that video.
It's great to finally see, you know, video reaching a lot of people and people outside of this bubble, which is awesome. But yeah, we can dive into some news briefs. There was some news briefs this week. As usual, privacyguides.org slash news. It has basically every, we cover like big stories. It's usually Freya and Nate are both posting updates. So if you want to keep up to date on updates about Privacy, security, adjacent topics,
definitely check that out. This week we had a couple. Discord rolls out revised age verification, promises privacy improvements. The FBI was hacked, like Nate said, and there was also a critical Tor vulnerability, which was patched across all Tor components. And yeah, definitely make sure you're updated if you're using Tor. But yeah, those were some of the updates on news briefs. And we also had some site changes that are coming soon. So a couple of small things.
There was some typos corrected. There was some incorrect information about MOLLE. There was some wording that was fixed on the encrypted DNS page. And there was also a warning that was added on the Windows native metadata. removal page so yeah all sort of really small updates that will probably be coming soon but all small things and hopefully we'll have more to share once we have a bigger site update ready to push out
As always, all of this is made possible by our supporters. You can sign up for a membership or donate at privacyguides.org or pick up some swag at shop.privacyguides.org. Privacy Guides is a non-profit which researches and shares privacy-related information and facilitates a community on our forum and matrix where people can ask questions and get advice about staying private online and preserving their digital rights. Now let's talk about a textbook example of why privacy matters.
And just as a reminder, you can leave your questions in the chat and we'll get back to them in between stories. Alrighty. Yeah. So I get to talk about draft Kings. This will go over well, considering I don't ever watch sports ever. Um, so this headline comes from EFF and it says draft Kings is using AI to supercharge the harms of online behavioral advertising. Um, this is not necessarily a story that I've seen like making the rounds, but I thought like, uh, you know, like Jordan said, I'm like,
this is literally like the textbook example of why privacy matters. And so I thought it would be really cool to share this with you guys. Um, Cool may not be the right word, but you know what I mean. We're going live. So this comes from a New York Times article. They said that DraftKings is using its customers betting records to train a machine learning model and find losing gamblers. Once found, DraftKings sends these customers targeted advertising designed to lure them back to the site to place more bets, bets that DraftKings thinks will be losing ones. And of course, they have a business incentive to keep
losing gamblers coming back because those users are actually making the site money. Unfortunately, those considered problem gamblers, aka people who repeatedly gamble despite harm to themselves or finances or their relationships, for example, gambling away the rent money, gambling away your kid's college fund, whatever the case may be, they are highly likely to be targeted by this model. By reengaging these individuals through targeted promotions aimed at keeping them on the platform, DraftKings is capitalizing on their vulnerability for profit instead of mitigating their risks. And EFF said earlier in the article,
they said that this kind of targeting is a form of online behavioral advertising, which is when companies personalize ads they show you based on data they've collected about you. The more data a company has, the more personalized the ad can be. And they also said around here that, yeah, predatory online behavioral advertising isn't new, but companies' use of AI to process data and target customers has magnified its harms. And last but not least, they say DraftKings seems to be using solely first-party data to target their ads, meaning that they're only using the data collected directly from their users and not buying any additional data from third
parties to fuel the learning model. But this highlights how policy solutions that only limit third-party data sharing and selling would not be enough to prevent these predatory advertisements. So yeah, they're calling for a ban on all behavioral ads. I personally do not like advertising at all, so that's something I can get behind. But Um, yeah, I don't know if we really have any, uh, like specific questions on this one, but I know for me, the thing that jumped out is again, textbook example of why privacy matters. Um, and it also shows that, you know, we, we talk a lot about various privacy tools
like email aliasing, um, you know, payment masking, voiceover IP, where these tools are available, but it's also a reminder to be mindful about the actual service you use, you know, even privacy services like data is data and it's there. And yeah. And try to stick to services. First of all, ask yourself if you need a service. We were just talking about AI. Do you really need to be gambling? I don't know. I don't gamble, so I don't know. Maybe I'm not in a room to talk about that. But just trying to find services that try to reduce how much data they collect and
stuff like that. I also thought about the importance of like, when you stop using a service, actually delete the account, unsubscribe. If you used an alias email, like turn off that alias email, use ad blockers. Obviously an ad blocker won't stop them from emailing you directly, but all that kind of stuff. So yeah. Do you have anything that I missed on this story, Jordan? No, I think you've, I think you've covered basically everything that I would have said. Yeah. I don't think I have anything more to add on this one. Cool, cool.
Viewers, if you have any thoughts, how do you balance leisure with privacy? I mean, like I said, I don't really gamble, but I do watch TV. I read books. So let us know what you guys do. Real quick, somebody I think tuned in late. They're asking about the headline story. Did F-Droid really improve their security model? I mean, you can watch the story when it comes back up on video on demand. They made some improvements. We definitely want to see more, but it was definitely mostly focused on privacy. the user interface and user experience. But I think on that note,
I'll turn it over to Jordan, and we can talk about this new development from Proton, let's call it. Yeah, so if you haven't already seen Proton's announcement, it was on their AI section of their blog, I guess, because now they do have an AI product. Proton partners with Apertus. Apertus? Apertus. Apertus. I'm going to say Apertus. I'm not sure, but that's what they said. So Proton partners with Apertus,
Switzerland's sovereign AI model, and This is interesting. Apertus is a fully open large language model developed by researchers at EPFL, ETH Zurich, and the Swiss National Supercomputing Center. Its architecture, training data, and methods are open and it's trained on publicly available data, respecting opt-out requests, and filtering out personal details. To start using Apertus with
In LUMO, you can select a purchase at one point five from the model dropdown and start chatting as normal. Like other conversations in LUMO, your chats are protected by zero access encryption. So basically, this is this new model that is a little bit more ethical than the other ones that are available. It is now selectable within LUMO and their partners. So you can choose to give If you choose to give feedback on any purchase response, tap the thumbs up or thumbs down button
to send in your feedback and your contribution will be anonymized and made available to the university research teams behind a purchase. Yeah, so this is definitely interesting. I know most people in our audience are anti-AI, but I do think I want to touch on one aspect of this specifically. I think just because something is publicly available doesn't mean that you have permission to use it to train a large language model.
I think that is one of the issues with this language. I think it kind of doesn't respect people's consent. I'm not really sure what they mean when they say publicly available data. Do they just mean every website on the internet that doesn't have an opt-out request? Because that doesn't seem like you're asking for people's consent. That just seems like you're assuming people's consent, which... would say is not that's not consent so anyway i think that's that's always an issue with these large language models i
think this is better than um every other provider that we've seen that just basically just is a black box but i think it would be good to get some more information on how exactly they scrape this data and use it to train this AI model. It'll also be interesting to see what people actually think about this, whether it's actually as good as all the other ones that scrape every single bit of data on the internet. So yeah, how do you feel about this one, Nate? Is this something that you would use or
is this something that would address some of the concerns you have with AI? No, I think I'm really glad you mentioned the opt-out thing. It is really great that it has opt-out, but those of us in the privacy community know that opt-out is usually not our preferred way of doing things. We prefer that people opt into things. And so it's great that they respect opt-out, but it's like, yeah, how many people are caught up in this and they don't even know it? And that's really not cool. I don't know. I think one user,
I will admit I've done this before and I think it's kind of funny in a twisted sort of way. One user asked Lumo to, you know, should I use this Apertus model? And Lumo basically said, technically, according to independent benchmarks, Apertus is roughly on par with GPT-III. Five, meaning more of a research ready prototype than a frontier model. The real value lies in ideals. such as Swiss Sovereignty and Completely Open, and in special cases mentioned above, for your day-to-day work, stick with Lumomax, which is Proton's self-hosted thingamajigger. So I don't know.
Yeah, I probably wouldn't be using it because the only reason I would see to use it is, which I don't use AI a ton. I use it for mostly if I'm stuck and I'm having writer's block or I can't figure out like... like this isn't quite landing right. What am I doing wrong here? Or occasionally I'll use it for like deep complex research questions where like I type it into a search engine and I get nothing. And so it's like, all right, let me try this again. That's usually where it shines for me. But it's the thing is like,
I feel like the main reason I would use this is to give feedback because I didn't put it in the show notes here, but Proton pointed out, they said that like One of the reasons that AI models are so good is because they're constantly getting feedback. You know, they're, they're seeing how people are using it and what questions they're asking, and they're seeing the followup questions. And that's great to make the model better. It's abysmal for privacy, but it's great to make the model better. And since Apertus doesn't really do that, I don't even know if they have their own actual website. I think it's just a model that anybody can use.
They don't really have a way to get feedback. So by using it and submitting the feedback, you would be helping solve that problem. But at the same time, the whole reason I'm using Lumo and Leo and stuff like that is because I don't want people training on my prompts. So I don't know, it feels kind of like a double edged sword to me where it's, I don't know, it's just, I don't think it's something I would use. But I really like, I guess more, I don't see a reason to use it other than to submit feedback, which I don't see why I would submit feedback personally. So It's, I don't know, I admire the ethos and I think it's
a, I don't know if I already said this, but it's like, it's almost like the least crappy model we have so far. Maybe not the least, there may be a better one out there I'm not aware of, but it's definitely a step up from things like, you know, like open AI, where it's like, well, you're in this training data and that just sucks to suck. There's nothing you can do about it. And also you can't see how it's trained and how it's weighted and all these other issues. But yeah, I don't know. I don't know. I don't know what to think of it. I feel very conflicted. Yeah, I think it's interesting to see that, you know, Proton, I think, in general,
does take the right steps on things. And I think considering they're doing, you know, AI stuff, they're trying to move in the right direction. They're trying to do best by the community by, you know, supporting models that are more ethical. I think this is, you know, a good direction considering they are choosing to, you know, work with AI stuff, which I think is certainly a choice, but it kind of makes sense considering Proton's move to basically become a sort
of replacement for Google, replacement for mainstream options. And it makes sense for them to basically have options like that available to businesses and also individuals. So I think this is the right direction to partner with Apertus. Even if the model isn't as good, I'm sure it's going to be appealing to some people. But quickly here, we did have a couple of comments real quick. There is someone named, username is Nye. Thank you for just joining the channel and
subscribing. Really appreciate it. It's good to have so many. We are having a lot of new subscribers coming in just because of the video has been doing quite well. So welcome to anyone who's watching for the first time. I hope you're enjoying the stream. Yeah, we had another Ayakov F-One. I hope I pronounced that right. If I didn't, I apologize. Welcome, welcome. Very, very happy to have you guys here. I don't know if they've all been claimed, but I know Jonah gave out five gift memberships, and there may still be some left if
you're on YouTube, so definitely check that out. Yeah, if the audience has any opinions, again, does this solve some of your concerns with AI? Which ones does it not solve? I know there's still energy concerns and all that kind of stuff. But I don't think I have anything else to add on that one. So I think we can move on to our final story here. Yeah, this is actually our final story. So if any of you have any questions or comments that you've been holding on to, definitely feel free to drop them in the
chat. And we are going to talk about how researchers found a way to eavesdrop on headphones from up to This came from some researchers in Hong Kong who have developed a technique that uses injected radio waves or radio signals to extract audio and other information. They're calling it Inject Eve, and it targets analog components that can leak signals too weak to capture through conventional electromagnetic
eavesdropping. They, again, as the headline says, they discovered that they could get understandable headphone audio from up to thirty meters away, which I'm American, so I apologize, but I want to say that's about ninety feet, give or take. A little bit less than that, I think. And including through walls. So that's pretty far away. So they say that traditional electromagnetic side channel attacks rely on passively collecting radiation emitted by electronics. That's often difficult with audio since
low frequency signals produce weak emissions that get lost easily in background noise. Injective takes a different route. An attacker transmits an electromagnetic signal toward a device at a frequency between zero and nine megahertz. The researchers did not disclose the precise settings needed. Thankfully, they said that some of this goes over my head, not all of it, but some of it. Um, the injected signal interacts with nonlinear parts inside the device, including amplifiers, analog to digital converters, power converters, and switching MOSFETs, whatever those are. Uh, those components can mix the injected RF
signal with audio or other low frequency activity. And the device then emits a modified signal that nearby radio equipment can pick up and analyze. And there's a pretty complex looking picture here that, uh, if you go read the article, um, then it, uh, I think it makes sense once you've read the article. If you come back and look at this picture, I was like, okay, now I see what I'm looking at here. But so the researchers used a USRP B-B-B-B-B-B-B-B-B-B-B-B-B-B-B-B-B-B-B-B-B-B-B-B-B-B-B-B-B-B-B-B
And they also used an RF power amplifier in some tests to increase the range. They tested eleven commercial products, including the Sony ZX-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X-E-X- and Xiaomi, as well as lamps from Xin Zhao and Xiaomi.
Apologies if I mess those up. According to the paper, most test works at distances greater than two meters. Let's see, there was one other part here. Oh, yes. The team also tested scenarios involving equipment hidden in a suitcase behind a hotel room wall or inside office furniture. The experiment suggested that the attack could be carried out outside of a lab, although it still requires nearby radio equipment and knowledge of how a given device responds to the injected signal. Headphones and phones are the most obvious targets because they may carry private conversations, but the technique could also reveal
activity in a home or office. With smart lamps and fans, the team said it could capture control signals and power use patterns that may indicate when devices are being used. They said conventional digital protections don't stop this attack because leakage occurs in the analog hardware path rather than encrypted data or software. And finally, they said shielding, filtering, and twisted pair wiring can reduce the amount of RF energy that reaches vulnerable components. They may make the attack harder to carry out, but they do not guarantee protection. So... Pretty fascinating stuff there.
I think I'll bring Jordan back in here for the analysis section. So do you think with everything I just read off there, do you think this is something that our viewers should worry about? Or do you think this is pretty unlikely to be executed in the wild? It does seem like this is one of these things where it's like, It kind of needs someone who knows a lot about how to do this, right? It requires a high level of knowledge, specific equipment, which is kind of a concern.
That's probably we don't really know the cost. I don't think they said the amount of equipment that's required for this, but I'm sure it's pretty expensive equipment, right? It's not just something that the average person can just find or make, right? Well, it's a few thousand dollars. So they had a laptop. RF power amplifiers, depending on what you get. I know in my past with audio video, I used to use those all the time. Depending on what you get, kind of pricey, like, five hundred to a thousand dollars,
somewhere in that range. Again, depending on which one you get. Spectrum Analyzer is actually pretty cheap. You can get those for about a hundred bucks on Amazon. Don't use Amazon, but I'm just saying. The radio and the antennas, I'm less sure about. But I would say, all in all, like, I certainly couldn't afford it. But it's definitely not, like, nation state expensive. You could build a rig for probably a couple thousand dollars. So... I think also, I think, you know, if it's like an intelligence agency, I think there would be, they would probably have access to much
more advanced equipment that could probably do something like this, right? Like at a much larger scale or with a much, a much larger ability, like they have a ridiculous budget to do this sort of thing. But I think the main thing for viewers is, you know, the average person, like, is this something that someone could really do? rig up quickly and easily the answer is no um this is like you know someone's gonna have to spend like nate said a couple thousand bucks maybe a couple hundred bucks let's say a couple hundred bucks maybe if it's like super cheap um
but i still think you know it requires someone who's close by in proximity because as nate said in the story this is something it's like thirty meters away that's pretty close that's not that far but that is yeah relatively speaking that's pretty close Relatively speaking, yeah, it's not something that can be operated from a distance. So, you know, it kind of reduces the threat significantly in that aspect. I think one of these things that could become a little scary is if this is
becomes a lot cheaper because I do remember that this was an issue with, uh, wifi access points. Um, there was a way to basically track people's location using wifi access points. And there was an easier method that was discovered that didn't require as much equipment and it made it a lot easier. So this sort of thing, if there's some way that someone works out, you know, a way to make something more compact, much more cheaper, you know, that's where it could become a threat that we would consider being concerned about. But again,
the distance that you have to be from someone, the equipment that you need, it's just extremely unlikely. I don't think the average person is going to have to worry about this. I do think that this is going to be a pretty big issue for people like the FBI or like secret intelligence agencies, because, you know, now there's going to be people sitting in their car pointing this at the, at the building and they might be able to hear things or, you know, stuff like that. That's going to be a problem for the big people, but for us little people,
it is not, uh, a huge concern. I don't think. Um, but yeah, what about, do you think there's any, any real lessons to take away from this or, um, Um, I dunno, I think I was trying to kind of rack my brain for that. And the best thing I can come up with is just a reminder that nothing is unhackable. Um, I actually, there was a question here from a username is Nye who said, uh, you didn't catch the article reading. Is this only via Bluetooth, like bypassing protocols? No, it's, it's, um, basically like, uh,
without rereading the article, it's almost like one of those remote microphones kind of I'm oversimplifying dramatically, but yeah. So this even works on like wired headphones and everything. Cause it happens. in the analog portion when it's already been decrypted and it's raw audio that humans would understand. So, you know, we always try to remind people that like nothing is unhackable and the goal of privacy and security, like that's why we're big fans of threat modeling is the goal is not to completely eliminate risk because that is impossible. The goal is to, basically uh there's an old joke um i
know i've told this before but really really quick there's two hikers walking in the woods and all of a sudden they see a bear and one of them sits down and starts swapping out his hiking shoes for hiking boots for running shoes and the other hiker's like dude what are you doing you can't outrun a bear and he goes that's fine i don't need to outrun the bear i just need to outrun you and uh it's very selfish but that's kind of how cyber security is it's like you just want to be such a difficult target that you're just not worth the effort and so um Yeah. That's, that's kind of the point of, of privacy and security. Cause again, nothing is unhackable. So I think that's kind of what I take away from stories like this is just like, you mentioned the whole like wifi,
like you can use access points and waves to like pinpoint people through walls. And it's just, that can be kind of depressing, but at the same time, it's also just like, yeah, it's a reminder that there's literally nothing unhackable. And the, the thing that scares me about these stories is that right now this costs thousands of dollars and requires very specialized knowledge, but who knows, you know, in twenty years, these components might be so cheap, or there might be something built into iPhones that, like, anybody can do this with, you know, a thirty dollar cable in a couple hours of time, so I think it's just good to be
aware of this stuff, I think, so. um definitely oh actually i'm glad you asked this this reminded me um you said uh can they only eavesdrop on conversations but they can't mute or override the content um i think somebody in the supporter chat said i don't know if it was the same talk or a different talk but they said that um there is actually an attack that can um control the active device on the phone but i think that's more of a bluetooth
Yeah, Bluetooth can not only be hacked, but the connection can be used to control the active device such as your phone. So I don't know if that's related to this attack. I have not had a chance to read through that article, but there are attacks that can do that for sure. So yeah, apparently a MOSFET is a type of transistor, and I need to watch more Lewis Rossman. So I suck for that. Somebody, I hope you're joking, said you're going to dump your Pixel for an iPhone because of our iPhone video.
Please don't do that. iPhones are very secure even to this day, but we definitely still prefer Pixels. They're a lot more open. Yeah. I think also just, just to be clear with that video, we tried to be as unbiased and like, you know, not completely glaze Apple, not completely defend like Apple and also, you know, steel man, the FBI a little bit. So, you know, I think it's important to have a sort of balanced opinion on things.
I think we were pretty fair on what Apple was doing in this case. I think Apple, like Nate said before, Apple was in the right in this instance and, you know, obviously in the right. So obviously we're going to be supportive of their stance here, but like, at no point in the video did we recommend using an iPhone or anything like that. So I'm not sure what, if, did you watch the same video as us? Uh, I'm not sure, but, um, it's definitely, uh, I can, I can, I'm going to assume that you're joking.
Um, cause that would be kind of funny. Um, they also said I wouldn't mind them if they rated my Riz. Yeah. I mean, I guess they're going to, they're going to start listening to your, your intimate conversations. That's a little, uh, that's a little, that's a little creepy, but, um, I remember many, many moons ago, I think this was after Edward Snowden came forward. And I saw like a little one panel comic in the newspaper that was like how they can start making it up to us.
And it shows this guy like walking to the office on his cell phone. And he's like, yeah, I like I had to run out the door. The dog like threw up on the carpet or whatever. And it shows this FBI guy in front of him is just like, here's your lunch. You forgot at home. It's like, you know, whatever sandwich, just the way you like it. Like basically using that data to like make up for like, Oh, I didn't have time to make lunch today. It's like, nah, it's cool. I got you. So that's, that's what you reminded me of. Sorry. But yeah, it's, uh, I don't know. I'm, I'm a big fan of giving credit where credit is due. Like, even if it's someone I absolutely hate, if they do something good,
I'm going to call it out and say like, look, that was a good action. Like they still suck. I'm not a fan of them, but they had a point. Like what's that mean from a winter soldier? Like he's not a line, but he's right. A broken clock is right twice a day, bro. We had a couple more comments here when we asked about AI. Vonnegut Rosewater said, it does alleviate some privacy issues, but the sustainability issues and impact on the labor market and treating the planet like an infinite resource or garbage can is my issue,
which is totally fair. I think a lot of people feel that way. A positive, Koalinize, said that my issue with Lumo is that it's quite pricey and it has no CLI. I don't know why you would get that over, let's say, something like OpenCodeGo where your data isn't being used to train. Again, Lumo says they don't use your data to train. But no, I get that. Some people prefer to use the offline GPT for all. I think we even recommend a couple offline AI bots on the website that...
Yeah, I mean, at that point, like right now, I'm having to take Proton's word for it. But if you use one that you can literally activate the firewall on your computer and it still works, then you can be absolutely certain. So for sure, I get it. But I think that's all we've got since that was our last video. Do you have anything you want to add, Jordan? Um, Lucas always comments that they like my hairstyle. I just thought that was fun.
I missed that one. I missed it. Yeah, I missed it too. Um, thanks. I don't know. It's just, I like that you keep saying that. It's kind of funny. Oh, that's right. You were going to mix up your hair, weren't you? We forgot to do that. I should change it next time. It's so easy. It's so easy. I can just change it with a, with a single click. So anyway, yeah, it's been, it's been a great episode this week, but I think it is time to start rolling out into the outro here. So yeah, we did not discuss who was going to take that. You want me to do it or you
feel like reading? You can do it. All right. I'll get the outshare this week. Yeah. So all the updates from this week in privacy will be shared on the blog every single week. So sign up for the newsletter or subscribe with your favorite RSS reader if you want to stay tuned. Just to let all of our new subscribers know that we actually send the newsletter out right as we start going live. So it works as a great reminder like that. And we offer a podcast available on podcast platforms and RSS, which now includes video on supported platforms. And this video will also be synced to
PeerTube. So if you couldn't make it for the whole thing, you can still check this out after the fact. Privacy Guides is an impartial nonprofit organization that is focused on building a strong privacy advocacy community and delivering the best digital privacy and consumer technology rights advice on the internet. If you want to support our mission, then you can make a donation on our website at privacyguides.org slash donate. You can also make a donation on any page on the website by clicking the red heart icon located in the top right corner of the page. You can contribute using standard fiat currency via debit or credit card, or you can donate anonymously using Monero.
or your favorite cryptocurrency. Becoming a paid member unlocks exclusive perks like early access to video content, exclusive video content, and priority during the This Week in Privacy livestream Q&A. You'll also get a cool badge on your profile in the Privacy Guides forum and the warm, fuzzy feeling of supporting independent media. So thank you so much for watching, and we'll be back next week.
Hackers have inserted malicious code into hundreds of popular websites to steal credit cards, cryptocurrency, and personal info - the culprit? Hijacked javascript used in a commonly used website optimisation tool. Join...
Nvidia's board and the FBI are investigating their CEO Jensen Huang after he admitted to an affair with a suspected Chinese intelligence operative, we'll be breaking down why this was such a massive OPSEC failure and...
Motorola has announced the pricing for their Signature 27 device which supports GrapheneOS, and it's $1600 USD. Is this overpriced or actually justified, we'll discuss all the details! Join us for This Week In Privacy...
Google has updated it's privacy policy to allow for data from Gmail and Google Photos to be used for personalized advertising, Bitwarden has made a controversial license change to it's published applications, Proton is...
The internet goes on high alert as 8 TLS certificates are compromised to due weak private keys, allowing anyone to mint browser and app credentials for any site on the internet, a leaked Cellebrite document describes a...