Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

This Week in Privacy

This Week in Privacy artwork

Is This The End of Anonymous Reddit?

Oct 3, 20261 hr 49 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Reddit is forcing users to login to view old.reddit.com, discontinuing it's RSS feeds and ending public API access killing privacy preserving third party clients. We'll be covering the latest in privacy & security news, so join us for This Week In Privacy #73! ★ Support this podcast ★

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Reddit further erodes anonymous usage, cops can now bypass the iPhone's automatic reboot, and a new attack that can track you across all operating systems. All of this and more coming up on This Week in Privacy number seventy-three, so stay tuned.

Welcome back to This Week in Privacy, our weekly series where we discuss the latest updates with what we're working on within the Privacy Guides community and this week's top stories in data privacy and cybersecurity while answering viewer questions. I'm Nate, and joining me this week is Jonah. Howdy, Jonah. It's been a minute. Yeah, it's good to be back. And I've been having a good week with the video stuff that's been going on. That's been going well for you. So I hope we could talk about that later. But how have you been doing? Pretty good.

Yeah. Just, uh, busy with the videos. Um, like you said, we'll talk about that later, but we put out a couple of videos in the last couple of weeks and we got more on the way and, um, yeah, so I mean, good week for sure, but definitely keeping super busy. Sweet. All right. Yeah, I think with that, we'll go ahead and jump into the latest, biggest news from privacy and security in the past week. As a reminder to any viewers, if you have any thoughts or questions while we're going over the story, feel free to leave it in the chat and we will address them at the end

of the story. So first up, we're going to talk about Reddit. And this headline, this comes from Ars Technica, says Reddit is putting more limits on old.reddit.com. So back in July, some of you may remember that Reddit started requiring that users be logged in to access old Reddit, which real quick for anyone who doesn't know for now, we'll see how long this lasts. You can literally go to old.reddit.com and it's the old version of Reddit. It definitely looks kind of dated these days, but it's also a lot lighter.

I think there's like less JavaScript. I think there might even be less trackers, but don't quote me on that. But most notably, It's usually also a lot less strict about requiring you to sign in. Some of you may know that if you try to go to Reddit right now and you're not signed in, and especially if you're using a VPN, it's probably going to block you and force you to sign in. Old Reddit didn't do that. So a lot of privacy people preferred old Reddit because, again, it was lighter, it was a little bit less of a nightmare, and no sign-in required. But now... uh the article says today but this is you know a few days old it says

that the social media platform announced additional upcoming restrictions on old reddit a reddit post from an employee said that in the next few months will further limit access for logged in users to only those who have used old reddit in the last six months which covers the majority of all old reddit users so if you want to be grandfathered in now is your time to uh go log in they said there will be an exception for moderators who are still able to view old reddit regardless of when they last log uh last used it as long as they are logged in And they claim that this is basically to help reduce scraping and automated abuse. Yeah.

The article says that there's concerns that they may completely shut down old Reddit one day, which... Yeah, well, let me see here. Yeah, I mean, I guess we're at that part of the article. It does say down here that in twenty twenty five, Huffman said the old Reddit would remain online as long as people are using it. But in August, he changed his tune, saying in a post that the reality is we're getting to a time where we need to make some changes. And those changes would probably include limiting access, migrating important uses and rebuilding old Reddit on a modern tech stack. So I guess technically it doesn't sound like it's going anywhere, but it may not survive in a noticeable

form. And then. This is the one that really pissed me off. They kind of threw this in here at the end. But Reddit is also going to stop supporting RSS feeds on November, because RSS is now a common surface for large-scale scraping and automated abuse. It will still be available for moderators who use it for workflows through supported alternatives, which I think they said there's an app called Discord Relay and some other stuff. Yeah, that's super, super nifty. I think that's kind of it as far as stories go or as far as details.

Jonah, I think I'll turn it over to you. I know like you, for example, you say, if I remember correctly, you're not a super big Reddit user. And I personally, I kind of go through phases. Like right now, I've actually been on Reddit quite a bit, but I'm probably going to stop using it a little bit for a while. So why does this matter for people like you and soon to be me who may not be heavy Reddit users? Well, you know what? I think I'm kind of in the same boat where I use it kind of off and on. The reality is I've experienced this a lot lately where a lot of just niche information is still only available on Reddit. It's just been such a prolific form for

such a long time that A lot of discussions are still taking place there, and especially if you can find older discussions about things like from two years ago or something, instead of all of the AI slop that is now kind of permeated the search results. I think that those Reddit results tend to still be a bit better, which is it's a shame that it's all locked down into that one ecosystem. But that is, of course, the main business strategy of Reddit and

why they can make changes like this because people are kind of stuck using it, you know? Yeah, for sure. The RSS thing really pissed me off because to me that is just such a it feels like, um, what's the word I'm looking for? Uh, like, like a canary in a coal mine of like the direction that the web is headed in where the web used to be this open. And it's funny cause like, I remember, um, I'll be honest, I don't know how old you are. So you may or may not remember this, but when I was about in high school, so about like the mid two thousands, um, RSS really popped off in the mainstream.

And it seemed like every single website you went to had RSS. And I didn't even know what it was. It's almost like apps. When apps popped off in every single website, it was like, download our app. And so every website I went to was like, we have an RSS feed. And now what's funny is a lot of them still support RSS, but they just don't broadcast it that same way anymore. So I don't know where I'm going with this. With them saying we're not going to do RSS anymore, to me, it's just such a... like it feels like they're just really um like the whole web is turning into this walled garden you know like twitter requires logins now uh facebook and

instagram have required it for a long time now reddit's doing it it's really sad to see the internet getting increasingly siloed and closed off like this and super turning against what the web was supposed to be especially considering who was involved in the founding of reddit but yeah Yeah, social media definitely, I think, played a big part in people moving away from like personal websites and blogs and that sort of thing. It's funny, I was just watching a video about it was from I don't know when it was, two thousand one or something.

It was a video of Steve Jobs kind of announcing the first Apple store that they opened and they were selling software like create your own personal website. Like at the time, that was just the thing you would do online. And now that's kind of been uh you know centralized onto all of these platforms because people don't want to people don't want to do that but that's at the risk of um you know these platforms being able to do whatever they want with your content at at any time um and obviously i think reddit is really no different than a lot of other social

media platforms in the sense that they have just awful data practices. They're doing all of this crazy stuff with like tracking you across the site. It's obviously an advertising supported platform, and then they're also using that content on the back end to sell it to AI companies for for training and stuff like that. So Yeah, that's kind of just not a fantastic situation that they've created. And this is just kind of another anti-user approach to things. It's unfortunate that everything just kind

of needs an account these days just to access. But we've talked about that with Twitter or X switching to that as well. Reddit is kind of no different. And yeah, I'm sure this is going to upset some contingent of Reddit users. But I think Reddit in general has just been going downhill for some time. And I don't know if old Reddit really saves people from a lot of the stuff that they're doing. Fair. Yeah, I'm glad you mentioned the AI thing. That was something I wanted to make sure we mentioned.

Reddit struck a deal with, I think it's OpenAI, and now they sell user data to OpenAI to help train the models. And Yeah, real quick, I do remember those days. Like you were saying back then, there were things like GeoCities that were real plug and play. And like you said, everybody had a website. I think MySpace was probably the first time that really took off because they had that ability to inject CSS code and customize your page. But even before that, it was pretty common to run into people who had a random, you know, for whatever reason. So... Yeah. I also just want to point out, I know you kind of touched on this at the beginning, but unfortunately,

there are still some privacy projects who only or primarily use Reddit or sometimes Discord. Proton. That's exactly who I'm thinking of. They're not the only ones, but they're probably the most prominent one. Yeah. So even when we step back from the privacy stuff, we think like, oh, well, you know, we don't need Reddit. Like, you're right. We need them to get the memo, though. It's really frustrating. So I think that'll bring me to, you know, is there anything that we can do about it? Are there any alternative platforms? Or do you think it would help to... Is there any kind of protest or anything? In some cases, like the one you just mentioned with

Proton and these other companies who are using Reddit as, like, their main... news announcement form for whatever reason. I think it's kind of unfortunate. Getting them to switch would be great. But there are alternative ways to access Reddit. FoundDoug in the chat mentioned RedLib as a good self-hosted frontend for Reddit. We do recommend these frontends for accessing a lot of social media sites on a read-only basis. I don't know if there's... I haven't looked into... red lips specifically too much.

I don't know if there's public instances, but stuff like that that can kind of abstract the content of the site away from like Reddit running a bunch of JavaScript in your browser and tracking you, I think is generally a good thing to do if you're just trying to access Reddit. But I would certainly just I mean, because this is what we do and I've been a big proponent of, you know, websites and organizations kind of starting their own forms, running their own blogs and comment

sections and kind of having their own communities separate from these major platforms, because if you do everything on your own domain name and you kind of do it yourself, that as a as an organization or a business that provides you with a lot of safety because you're not just at the whims of however the business that you're trying to use operates. And I think that a lot of people don't realize that because from a short term perspective, you know, having all of this, all of these tech resources available for

free and very easy to set up, it's obviously appealing. But at the same time, Um, it's just, it's just a way for you to basically send all of your users or all of your customers to these other platforms who will eventually lock you away from, from those users, from your own users and customers. We've seen it on like Facebook, for example, where everyone was like encouraged to make Facebook pages. And then all of a sudden, now that everyone's on Facebook.

Now, if you want to communicate with people on Facebook effectively as a, As a business, for example, now you have to pay Facebook a bunch of money for advertising, right? That's the main goal of really locking people in to these platforms, I suppose. So certainly there's some Fediverse alternatives. I'm not super familiar with a lot of them. I haven't used them recently, but Lemmy's around and I know some communities use that. I'm a big proponent of Discourse, the form software. Thankfully, I've seen a lot of open source

communities, especially like Linux distros, kind of adopt Discourse as the de facto form software of choice for a lot of these and for good reason. I think it's a good. setup for organizations and businesses. And of course, we use that for our form, discuss that privacy guides.net. So stuff like that, setting that up, having going back to like a more decentralized web, I think benefits a lot of people, I think it certainly benefits users. But it also has a lot of benefits for businesses to kind of get away from

these from the social media sites that are shifting to more predatory practices, I think. Yeah, for sure. I think, um, with like, uh, like discourse, that's probably not ideal for like a Reddit replacement per se, like from a user perspective. But yeah, especially when we think of like bigger projects, like, uh, like Linux distros, proton Tudor and like places to get help and tech support. Like, yeah. Discourse is, I think really good for that. And I think, um, I think we'll talk about this probably more in the site updates, but I left a comment last night on,

uh, our latest video on the forum where the comments, uh, it felt, uh, cause for those who don't know, our last couple of videos have gone fairly viral. They've, they've gotten a pretty good reach and they've also been very polarizing. And so I commented on the forum. I'm like, man, it's really nice to see like sane takes and like people that even though they might disagree with us, they're not like calling me names or anything. And it's just, it's so refreshing. And people kind of pointed out, it's like, yeah, this is kind of like the way the web should be like the future of the web, these smaller communities where people can get along a little easier. So it's,

I almost wonder if it would be good for the internet to be a little bit more, uh, I don't want to say fragmented, like decentralized like that. So yeah, I don't know. I think I'll turn that one over to a viewer. Yeah. Oh, one more thing. Yeah. I found dog said Libra or red lib was previously called Libra. I definitely, I don't know if you mentioned this cause I'm trying to troubleshoot something over here, but I do wonder if they're almost like a, what was it called? The knitter, like knitter. I do wonder how long these things are going to be able to function when Reddit is increasingly cracking down on this

stuff and if they're going to get a cease and desist. But in the meantime, I am all for that kind of stuff. So yeah, I think we'll turn it over to viewers. If you guys use Reddit, what are you going to do? What are your recommendations? Do you have something to add? Those frontends are definitely a short-term solution. I mean, in the long term, we just got to switch away from platforms like this. I know we have an announcement post on our forum for this live stream, like we do every week. We've gotten some comments on the forum from people who have talked about this Reddit story.

There's mixed opinions, for sure, on it. Somebody said... that that sites that archive like deleted comments on Reddit and stuff might lose access because of this. And that might be a privacy win. I think that that's a little the I mean, there is certainly an argument to be made a lot of the time. So I think when you put out content publicly, I think people in general need to be more mindful of content that's put out publicly because a lot of the time it does just exist kind of forever.

And so if you're really worried about that, There might not be much you can do, but yeah, I thought that was an interesting argument. Yeah. I had a thought on that one, but I don't remember what it was now. This one, I think we touched on this one a little bit, but somebody, a new user asked, do you think the anonymous internet access is becoming impossible and what can users realistically do to preserve it? Do you want to weigh in on that one or want me to start?

Because I do have some thoughts on that. I don't think it's becoming impossible in a lot of areas. I think age verification is certainly causing problems in that regard, and we may start to see it becoming more difficult. But at the same time, I don't think it's an unreasonable burden to switch to these more decentralized platforms. I think that's ultimately the solution is to find or start communities outside of Reddit that aren't going to be subject to these onerous restrictions or requirements

to create an account that can be used for tracking you and what you're browsing. I would imagine for a lot of the kind of stuff that people are doing on Reddit, having all of that tied to a specific profile is definitely going to... tell Reddit, tell advertisers, tell the people that they're selling data to a lot of stuff about you and then tied with your IP address and that kind of thing. It's probably trivial to tie a lot of that information to your real to your real information. And so, yeah,

just decentralizing all of that, I think, is the long term goal to definitely to definitely work on for for people in organizations. Yeah, and one thing I want to point out, somebody else responded and basically said that. They said the end game of all this is self-hosting and federation. And I totally agree with you, but I want to add to that. I'm not disagreeing. I'm always the person who's like, well, think about the normies and the people who aren't super tech savvy. And I think this is one of those situations where actually those of us who

are more tech savvy can be like the – was, I'm not good with words today. Um, but the anchor point, I guess, for our friends, you know, like if you know how to host, like my, my sister, for example, has access to my, my, um, jellyfin server and she can just text me and be like, Hey, it's not working, you know, or whatever. And it's, it's super easy and she doesn't have to handle any of it. And so I think, you know, there's certain things that like, um, like switching to graphene or switching to Linux, like, or switching to proton mail, you know, we need, yeah, the user has to do that. But when it comes to things like hosting

Mastodon or peer tube or, um, next cloud, like those are things that you can do and then manage for your friends and family. And, you know, you kind of need to like, you need to be upfront with them. Like, um, Like we actually, I actually just installed a pie hole on my network yesterday. And I told my wife, I'm like, just FYI, technically I can see all the websites you go to. I don't really care. I'm just looking for trackers and stuff like that, but I just want you to know. And she did not care. So, um, you know, but like letting people know, like, Hey, I have this cloud. You're welcome to use it. And I mean, some people will probably take advantage

of that and be super entitled and crappy about it, but you know, other people will just like, Oh, this is really cool. Thank you. And you know? So, um, yeah, I guess what I'm getting at is like, this is one of those rare situations where like, it's not so much every single person needs to host their own Mastodon or, uh, I think there's, what is it? Plymora Plymora is like the lightweight version, but like you could host a small instance and just give a few family and friends access and that helps them out. And they don't necessarily have to be super tech savvy. So yeah, for sure. As found dogs that we can all be big tech. Exactly. Yeah. And that's super true.

I think people forget, um, that like hosting forums in communities, you could do that on like really low end content back in like two thousand five or so low end hardware back in two thousand five. Right. I mean, it's not like computers are super powerful. You could certainly host it on pretty much anything today. It's really not very intensive to host a lot of these to host a lot of this software. Not that everyone can do it, but just like you said, I think it

can be on some of the more technical people in certain communities to create these platforms for other people to join. It would be great if instead of the movies subreddit, if a bunch of people got together to discuss movies on some site like that. But it does require a lot of collaboration and I know that people find that difficult. Well, and also just to add onto that, I was going to say, if you're hosting a small community, like again, for like a family, next cloud instance, the beauty of that is you probably don't

need to pay a ton in storage because you're not providing like five gigs for everybody. It's just, you know, a handful of people, I guess, unless you come from a big family, but, um, Yeah. I was just going to say real quick, Ben said I use RSS feed regularly to get the best post without doom scrolling. It's yeah. Like RSS is so useful. I used to, um, I used to use it to get like, Oh, click the wrong button to get like news feeds. And then, um, I could filter out like, uh, right now I use next clouds RSS, which admittedly is not great for this.

Um, but Thunderbird used to be amazing. I could filter out like sponsored posts and ads and like all kinds of cool stuff. So yeah, RSS going away really sucks. Um, people are chatty tonight uh do you think they could still get around this like like knitter yeah we were just talking about that earlier um right now we do have a few reddit front ends but it's really a question of like with this access closing off are they still going to be technically feasible and then if they find workarounds like knitter did are they still going to be you know are they going to get hit with a cease and desist so we don't really know at this

time um we'll just have to wait and see but um let's see here sorry i'm trying to read a whole bunch of things um Yeah, somebody in the forum thread pointed out that apparently the social media propaganda is much stronger than we thought it was. And they actually provided a source for that. So that was pretty interesting to read. I kind of skimmed that because it was pretty long. But I was like, oh, lovely. So yeah, maybe we should all just get off mainstream social media. It's probably not great.

Let me ask or read a couple of these questions here. Yeah. Well, this kind of goes back to what we were talking about. The problem is that the quote unquote normies are unaware or simply don't care, outnumber the rest of us. So the experience on a wide range of topics ends up being very limited. Yeah. I think that's the problem we're all struggling with is like even something like Mastodon, in my opinion, is very feature rich. It's very mature. It's, in my opinion, a very nice experience. And it's like, well, how am I supposed to get people? It's like the network effect, right? It's like, yeah, but you can't follow Taylor Swift and Mark

Ruffalo. Actually, Mark Ruffalo is on Mastodon, but he hasn't posted in like a year um you know like all these big names that you want to follow it's you can't really find them on a lot of these other social media it's it's a problem i think everybody's trying to figure out yeah uh torsten on the forum who's a member thanks for your support uh just left a comment agreeing that like the small web type self-hosting is nice but they find it really intimidating uh because you need to do so much stuff to protect them protect those servers um like if you use tail scale, for example,

to kind of limit that, that's a good way to keep your things secure. But then that kind of limits who can access it by design, which is hard for communities like larger communities. I mean, it is a tough issue for for sure. And I think I think a solution for that is not just like for a lot of techie people to spin up things on their own, but I think people You know, coming together and creating a small community of people who have technical

skills who can kind of work together on that kind of stuff is going to be a lot more sustainable. But that's kind of where the collaboration stuff comes in again, at least if we're talking about public things like a Mastodon instance or a forum or something like that. Yeah, for sure. Anonymous said they just joined. Have we been talking about Reddit the whole time? We have, but actually I was going to say, unless you have anything to add or any last thoughts, there's one more question here in the forum. I wonder if you guys could discuss the secure paste feature added to Graphene OS.

I think it's a great feature that everyone should enable. Do you have any thoughts about this one? I thought it was still in beta. I didn't know it was like out out. I only know that it exists, but I haven't looked into it myself, so I don't know how it works. Okay. Yeah. I, um, again, I thought it was still in beta, but apparently it is out out. The only thing I can really say is side of burritos, the YouTuber, he does pretty much nothing but graphene videos on YouTube. And he did a video about this. That was really interesting actually. Um, which remember for those of you watching

now, remember when we talk about this later on, cause I'm going to mention that video again, but he built his own little app that, um, reads your clipboard to illustrate what the secure clipboard feature does and why it's useful. So, um, Yeah, I'd say if you're curious about it, go check it out because I thought that was a really interesting video. Yeah, I think that's all I got on that. Yeah, I'm sure other people on the team have used it and have more experience than me. There's probably discussion about it on the forum too. I think that's a good place to find

out information about new stuff like that. Probably, yeah. There's always discussions on the forum, especially about stuff like graphene. Yeah, I think for now it's probably a good time to go ahead and move on to the next story. Yeah, let's take a look at this one here. This is by ForoForMedia. The headline is, Cops can bypass iPhone's automatic reboot to get into locked phone's leaked videos. Claim, Magnet Forensics, the owner of the gray key phone unlocking tool, says it can bypass an iPhone reboot... It can bypass an iPhone rebooting feature

that was locking cops out. In November, twenty twenty four, four or four media revealed that Apple quietly introduced a new feature in iOS that automatically reboots an iPhone that has not been unlocked for seventy two hours. And the idea behind this so-called inactivity reboot is to revert the phone to a state that makes it harder for police to break into the device and thus extract sensitive data from it with forensics technology. If you're in the Graphene OS community, you've certainly heard about this like

before first unlock or after first unlock state for encryption. And in a a phone that's in a before first unlocked state, whether it's Android or iOS, is going to be more secure than after you unlock it for the first time. So that's where rebooting your phone may come in, especially if it hasn't been used in quite some time. However, this new technology to get around the inactivity reboot on iOS was developed by Magnet Forensics, the company behind Gray Key, a popular tool sold to law enforcement

agencies that allows them to unlock and access data stored in iPhones and Android smartphones. Magnet has developed a new device called GrayKey Preserve and a feature for its regular GrayKey devices called Evidence Preservation Mode, according to the leaked video. This is an educational and tutorial video, which was made exclusively for law enforcement agents and appears to be dated early twenty twenty five. The video does not explain the technical details behind the new product and

feature, but it gives some strong hints as to how it works. Taking a look here, it says, yeah, in a quote, now, one of the many things that the gray key preserve is going to do is it's going to enable airplane mode or more specifically, it's going to disable our radio transmissions like Bluetooth, Wi-Fi and cellular. In doing this, that's not only going to allow you to preserve the data in the field, but also isolate the data in the field, as an employee explains. even if that device doesn't have the

ability to turn on airplane mode or to turn off the transmitters through the control center of iOS. Once initial access is gained and the device is in a preserved state, we also disable all of those radios to make sure the data cannot reach that device. Um, so it says that the after first unlock state is captured by gray key preserve and evidence preservation mode. So that even if that device does reboot for any number of reasons, memory maintenance or the power is lost or whatever the after first unlock state is not lost.

Um, So, yeah, it says when using the new solution, law enforcement agents only see the iPhone software version and device model rather than any data within, according to the employee in a screenshot of great keys customer interface that's included in the video that allows the cops to preserve the data they care about without actually seeing it before they're authorized to do so. So a researcher who has looked into this thinks that Magnet has found a way to manipulate the iPhone clock,

effectively slowing down time or even stopping the clock from ticking even after a reboot. Most likely, according to this researcher, the Great Key may disable the iPhone tasks that set data to expire. So lots of stuff to unpack here. What does this mean for iPhone users? What do you think, Nate? Yeah, I mean, I don't know. The best I could come up with is, I mean, the automatic reboot is designed to be there as a safety net, right?

And in my opinion, seventy two hours is a crazy long safety net anyways. But I would say my first thought is don't rely on the automatic reboot if possible. Like something I think I mentioned this on previous episodes. I don't think my threat model is particularly high, but just to be safe when I go through airports now and, you know, you have to put everything to go through the X-ray machine, I go ahead and reboot my phone. And by the time it gets through the x-ray machine, it's fully rebooted and ready for me to log back in. And that way, in the off chance that I do get pulled aside and they're like, oh,

we're gonna take your phone into this other room and do whatever weird stuff with it. Well, it's in BFU. That is literally the best case I can do. And I won't have time to like, oh wait, let me see it real quick. And obviously they're not gonna let me do that. And then I know this is actually a video that you and I have talked about making for some time, but digital minimalism is a bit of a luxury. It's not always like, just don't have anything on your phone, obviously. That's one thing people talk about a lot is if they're traveling internationally, they're like, oh, bring a burner phone. And it's like, yeah, that's cool if you can afford a burner

phone. But still, just being mindful. Are there things that you can take off of your phone, especially if you do know you're going to be going to a protest or somewhere where you might get pulled over or something? And so, yeah, just kind of, keeping that kind of stuff in mind, I think is at least the best I could come up with. I don't know if you have any additional thoughts. Yeah, for sure. It's it's tricky to rely on a lot of these software defenses. I would think that I mean, this video is from early twenty twenty five, so I don't know if this is like

already been patched. I would imagine that if it hasn't yet, Apple will probably look into it now that this capability is is known. But yeah, all of this privacy and security stuff, it's really just a game of cat and mouse. We see all these vulnerabilities come out all the time and then they get patched by these companies. And then the people who are developing these vulnerabilities for a variety of reasons will just find new ones because none of this software is, you know, it's not going to be perfectly secure by any means,

especially like if it's Internet connected, you're going to have you're going to potentially run into problems. I guess there's a lot of effort being made in terms of securing new software by default, or there's things like on iOS, memory integrity enforcement, or on Android MTE, which are going to keep software more safe and prevent a lot of these vulnerabilities from happening in the first place. But even even with those vulnerabilities

are found in them and the amount of just old legacy code in all of these operating systems and apps that we use is like that's not going to be replaced with with safer code for quite a while. So yeah, I think this kind of stuff will continue cropping up as an issue. But of course, to minimize your risk as much as possible, uh, keeping your devices up to date and making sure you have the very latest security patches is super important because new vulnerabilities like this are found, uh,

just constantly. Yeah, for sure. Definitely. Um, Penguin had a comment here that as far as we know, graphene is not hackable, um, especially because graphene comes with, I think it's enabled by default. Um, or no, it's so they have a feature where the USB port, uh, you can basically turn it off if you want to, where it doesn't do anything, or you can set it to only charge and not transfer any data. I think the default is that while the phone is locked, it does not transfer any data,

but then when you unlock it, it can do Android Auto or whatever, which actually, it's funny you mentioned that. We didn't put it in here, but literally an hour before we went live, I think it was Jordan posted an article about how somebody in Canada, yeah, there's... I'm not going to share it yet, but yeah, somebody in Canada was arrested for a shooting, I guess. And the police are currently unable to get in there, get into their phone because they're using graphene. So please don't use graphene for illegal

things. But, you know, these are the kind of articles we look at and we're like, oh, OK, like graphene is doing what it says it's supposed to do. And. Yeah. Username is nice. It reminds me of when people used to set their set the date to January first, nineteen seventy to break their phones. I didn't know about that. That's funny. Nick Spice here said that they thought if people had the accessory blocking enabled, that would help combat this. I know that's not enabled by default, so it's possible that that would have combated it,

but it's just not a common thing for people to have. I know that in the past, ways around that have been discovered as well. It's why even graphing OS, for example, when you can disable the USB-C port, there's varying levels of how much you can disable it. I have it disabled to where the USB-C port only works if the phone is off, and then it's only used for charging when the device is off. But if it's on, you can't use it at all, even for charging. I know they have a charging-only feature, and then they have the feature like Nate was talking about where it's just

restricted when it's locked. iOS obviously doesn't have quite that granular of an approach, but it... Yeah, I don't know if this would have prevented this specific case, but enabling features like that is probably good. I know that a lot of these vulnerabilities, especially when the phone is locked on iOS, can also come from having a lot of features enabled on the lock screen. If you go to your Face ID and password settings, there's a lot of switches for like,

do you want to allow Siri when the device is locked? Do you want to allow Control Center? And in this case, I think they mentioned even if Control Center is disabled, they can get around some of that stuff. like as a general rule disabling all of that stuff and locking down your phone when it's locked is going to any little bit helps when it comes to security like this Yeah, for sure. And I was going to say like one thing that stood out to me that I, the moments I always feel kind of mixed is it talks about how like,

I wonder if this is a technical limitation or like a pinky promise like flock, but it says that like when they use this thing, they can only see the phone software version and device model. So in theory, it's designed to just like prevent the phone from BFU. Cause I don't know if I copied it in the notes here, but they mentioned that a lot of the time when they, they get these phones. Yeah. You know, Oh, I don't think I put it in the notes here. A lot of the time... when they get these phones, they don't break into them right away because they have to get a warrant or

they have to get approval from a judge. And so I, I kind of like that, like, um, like you still can't see the data. You still have to wait and get legal approval, but I don't know. It's, I mean, it's the same with anything, right? Like, sure. In theory, it's great. The celebrate can be used to hack phones that are being used by, you know, violent cartel members and pedophiles and stuff like that. But also it can just as easily, easily be used by authoritarian governments to spy on journalists and stuff. So, Yeah, it's definitely an interesting case. I mean, this is that's more of a case of like gray key policy kind of coming into

play and preventing police officers from like going rogue and using this for personal purposes, which, of course, is a big issue. You know, we've talked about it in numerous videos in the past of like law enforcement agents kind of abusing these powers for their own personal gain. And maybe this prevents that. But it doesn't. I mean, at the end of the day, they still have the data, even if it's not accessible to an individual officer before it goes through like this approval process. And it kind of calls into question we

talked about this with flock cameras, for example, which are kind of collecting all of this data all the time and storing it in a database. And even though you're only supposed to access that database with a warrant, in some cases, you know, the fact that the data exists in the database in the first place, I think is is an issue and in a Fourth Amendment violation, like just on its own without regardless of whether that data was queried by a government agent. I don't think that I think the data collection in the first place is kind of

the bar where a warrant should be required. It's not just when a government agent later tries to access and view that data should a warrant be required. So I think that stronger laws need to be in place for a variety for something like this, because my dog is being loud. I don't know where I was going with that. The point is, I think stronger warrant requirements

should be in place just for this data collection to be happening in the first place. And we're not really seeing that right now. Yeah, no, totally agree. I just, like I said, I don't know if, you know, that, that thing, like they can only see the software version and device model. That's why I'm like, I don't know if that's a literal technical limitation. Like, no, no matter what, they can only see that with this tool. Or if it's like you said, is it a, a policy thing like flock where it's like, well, they're only supposed to look at that tool, but in theory they can access other stuff too. So I don't know. It's either way. I have mixed feelings about it.

Not a fan. I'll be looking forward to Apple to patch it. Yeah, I'm looking for a comment here. I think it was, yeah, FoundDog said, I'm surprised Apple hasn't ditched the USB-C port entirely. I don't think that that... is going to well, the way that it's implemented is probably not going to help because I know Apple is going to want some sort of diagnostic way to access these devices, and that'll be just as useful as a USB-C port, especially to these well-funded companies like like Magnet and Craykey and Celebrate, for example.

I know like on the Apple Watch, for example, There isn't a USB-C port, obviously, but they can still do some diagnostics in an Apple Store or if you send it in. On the original Apple Watches, it used to be like there was a hidden port you would need a special connector for. Nowadays, there isn't a hidden port. It's all wireless, but it's like a... They have like a sixty gigahertz wireless connection that they can do in the store to basically establish the same thing as a as a wired connection.

And I would imagine that Apple would leave something like that in the iPhones that can be, in theory, accessed by only, you know, tools that Apple has. But if that is available, it wouldn't be that hard for a specialized company to develop a way to connect to that, even if, you know, that that connection point isn't available to Apple. mere mortals like us who just want to connect to our phone anymore. So I don't think that just going to a portless design is really going to help when it comes to when it comes to this problem, unfortunately.

Yeah, what's funny, Apple seems to like I shouldn't be surprised by this, but they seem to be one of those companies that like when it when it benefits them, they're OK with it. I used to know somebody who worked for Apple for the the Genius Bar, and they said that they've actually used celebrate tools before. like in their job officially, like Apple has had celebrate tools in the past. I don't know how long ago this was. It was a while ago from what they told me, but like they used to use celebrate tools as part of their job to like, you know, help people recover data if they brought it into the genius bar or something.

So it's, you know, I mean, fortunately they were doing it with consent, you know, like this is my iPhone, I'm broke, it's broken, whatever. But yeah, it's like, it's weird how like, okay, you're willing to use this when it benefits you and your employees. But I don't know, it's Apple's weird. They're a weird company. I did have a couple of questions I flagged while we were talking. One of them, I think this went back to our first story. Nick said, for those of us who are more tech savvy and wanna be more private online, where do we draw the line between self-hosting and self-creation?

I think they're talking about making your own tools, but I'm not too sure. Do you have any thoughts on that one? I mean, certainly that's going to be more and more of a thing with AI. I think anyone can make their own tools these days. Yeah, I don't know exactly what you're asking. To be honest, I would need more clarification on what that means. But I think doing anything yourself is going to be an improvement over... again, using those centralized platforms.

I think that that is kind of what has caused a lot of the issues with the Internet that we've now run into more than anything else. For sure. And username is Nye here said we should write an article about privacy fatigue. I feel like have we done that? I feel like we have in the past. um we certainly have we have some videos about that um i don't remember the exact title of it right now i could look but sometimes we change titles on things and yeah that's fun lose track of it okay because um i know i've written about

it a little bit at my old blog on the new oil i've talked about burnout um not specifically privacy related but i've i've definitely talked about burnout for sure um i'm looking through some of our past articles here privacy washing Mastodon tutorial, dating apps. In the meantime, mixed by said self-dev work. I think in the self-hosting space, if there is something you can self-host that already does what you want it to do, I think standardizing on certain...

Maybe not standardizing, but supporting existing implementations of things tends to be the better way to go. It's just easier for other people. You benefit from a community of software just as much as you benefit from a community using these self-hosted platforms to host discussions and stuff. And so if you're all on a similar platform, like Discourse, for example, there's a wide variety of plugins that you can install on the forum that make community management easier. And so using self-hosted tools like that,

if you're trying to start a community that other people would use, is very helpful. And it's the same with like Mastodon, for example, I think a reason like a lot of the big public instances of these Fediverse platforms use Mastodon because it is really geared more towards larger public communities. And it has the largest ecosystem on the Fediverse, for example. And so you can get more support from it from other people if things are going wrong. And I think that that's important when you're when you're self hosting things.

I used the search button and I did not find anything on our website. So yeah, we may have to add an article about that because that is definitely an important topic. I think we all get burned out from time to time. We definitely do have a video about privacy being like what if privacy feels overwhelming to you, strategies that you can do. For example, it's one of our first videos. So if you go back to the older ones, I think it's... Oh yeah, here it is on the list. It's just how privacy can stop being overwhelming. If you're looking for strategies on how to

secure your digital life, if you're facing kind of burnout and stuff, it's a good place to start for sure. Yeah. And I think, um, I do actually really want to write this as an article now, so I'm not, I'm not going to dig too deep into it, but, um, I mean, just basic burnout strategies. Like, you know, we talked to Cindy Cohen, um, about how does she, cause she's been fighting for privacy in some form or another for like years. And I remember asking her, I'm like, how do you stay motivated? And she's like, I celebrate the little wins I have. Um, this is a big one personally is like,

I have spaces that are not privacy spaces, like, especially, um, I don't wanna sound full of myself and I promise I'm not, but being Nate, I know I'm a bit of a well-known figure in the space, but outside of privacy, I'm nobody. Privacy is a very small space. And honestly, I love that. I love the fact that there are other spaces that I can step outside and I'm not this expert anymore that people are like, well, what's your opinion on this? It's like, I can have an opinion and nobody cares. because i'm just another normal person like everybody else and i think just having those spaces where you can go you

know whether it's video games whether it's music whether it's um you know whatever it is camping i don't know like having things you can do where you can unplug and disconnect is really fantastic uh at least it is for me so anyways odd bite one of our biggest supporters welcome to the stream hello Yeah, as username is nice, I think calibrating one's threat model step by step is one way to stop being bored. I think that's definitely a good strategy because

You do have to have a plan going into it of what's most important to you, where you have to start out. I think if you don't have a plan and it's just kind of an unstructured, try to secure everything, try to make everything as private as possible approach, you're just going to have way too much to deal with from the start. like on our website, the knowledge base, for example, we do have a list of like common threats that people face, and maybe those aren't the things that you're concerned about. Maybe they are, but it could give you a starting off

point or an idea of like, oh, I never thought about this issue before, but maybe I'm concerned about it. Or it could help you narrow down like which of these things on the list you're most concerned about, and then you can focus on it from from there. I think that definitely makes things a lot easier, which is why we talk about threat modeling all the time instead of just doing everything you can because you can um it's just a more sustainable way to to do things and i think you can also it helps you be a lot more thorough uh because you can kind of

set goals for yourself and evaluate how you're doing and stuff like that which i think helps a lot of people as well Yeah, I was going to say, I think a lot of the burnout I see, like there's definitely the burnout of just like, you know, I've been in the privacy space for years and it feels like we're always losing, which is not true, but it can feel that way sometimes. I think there's a difference between that. The one I see most often is what you were just saying is like somebody is trying to do everything and they're just overwhelmed by like, oh, cool. Now there's this new my neighbor's Wi-Fi can sense my position because of this new attack or whatever.

And it's like. Like you said, like stepping back and being like, OK, what's my actual threat model? What am I really trying to defend against? What don't I care about? And what's like realistic, you know, like it's yeah, I think personally, I do think people should go as far as they can to protect their privacy. But there does hit a point where, you know, it starts to become a lot of work and you have to ask yourself, like, what am I getting? What am I gaining? What am I losing? Like, is this really worth it once I'm going beyond the minimum? And but you don't know that if you don't know where the minimum is, which is the threat model. So Yeah, it's important.

I'm going to have to briefly remind Oddbite that if you opt into sharing your membership status on the forum, that's going to be publicly available on our website. I think we have a list of members. And if you opt into sharing that publicly, we include the list of members at the end of videos now to thank people. Definitely want to highlight all the people supporting us. Of course, this could be an impersonator. Who knows if you're the real Oddbite, but... Um, again, we won't spend too long on this,

but yeah, one person said, uh, doing things in phases and set a cap for how much is on my plate. Um, yeah, doing things in steps for sure. Um, not trying to do everything at once. Uh, what's this one compartmentalization with identities for sure. So, yeah, I mean, there's a lot of stuff out there. Maybe, uh, Yeah, I think there's some interest in this. We should talk about this some more in the future. But for now, I think I'm going to turn it over to you to go over our first forum post here that we wanted to highlight, which I think is just kind of a

signal boost about Chat Control Yeah, just an update. Somebody posted here. There's always chat control stuff going on, I feel like. Patrick Breyer, who's a former MEP with the Pirate Party and current, of course, digital freedom activist, posted about the upcoming sixth... Trilog on ChatControl. The Trilog negotiates extent of the later proposal, which, according to a leaked document, is said to now include a workaround to

deploy a mass scanning by allowing scanning of parts of a service in search plans, which Breyer calls mass surveillance by another name. The council's own legal service says such framing would not hold up in judicial review. This is likely due to targeted targeted being reframed as parts of a service instead of a person. So what information do we have here? Of course, you can always go to fightchatcontrol.eu.

You can go to fightchatcontrol.eu hound sign, delegates, or find the delegates section on that site. You can set the filter to EP Trilog Shadows and you can see all eight responsible MEPs. If you're in the EU and you are represented by these people at all, definitely worth voicing your support. I mean, this is the kind of thing where for some reason, all of these track control measures are just a constant fight in the EU.

Seemingly, it'll never end and hopefully all of you in the EU can get your act together and pass some law that prevents this from happening. So it doesn't just have to come up all the time. But that's really going to come down to getting your representatives to do what you want, which is always challenging. So yeah, were there any replies to this post that you wanted to highlight, Nate? Yeah, Chat Control is definitely like a terrible

movie franchise that just will not die. Yeah, there was one here somewhere from another user said, don't forget that Canada has its own chat control in the form of Bill C-Twenty-Two. So if you're Canadian, definitely keep that on your radar. This other person actually commented about, I know there's been some talk about Canada becoming an EU associate member, which is not a thing that currently exists. So nobody even really knows what that means. But they did point out that if that does go through, that it might like pressure Canada to,

Play by similar, what'd they say? More like an obligation to play by rules by similar demand or by popular demand. So yeah, definitely stuff to keep an eye on. And there was actually a video down here. I think Freya shared it in the chat where it's not chat controlled directly, but apparently there's this similar proposal called the EU Kids Act. And the Stop Killing Games movement posted a video where they basically talked about how, like, there's a whole bunch of things to it. But one of the things I remembered is

it would basically make it illegal to self-host games. Like, if you self-host your own Minecraft server, that would effectively become illegal. And it's just, it's wild. So, yeah, things are... in a tough spot right now. I will end by saying this person updated their post and said that for now, the plan to work around the targeting limitation has been blocked. But again, there may be a seventh trial log in November, possibly. So, yeah, if you're in Canada, if you're in the EU, I would say go ahead and follow this this forum post so that you get updates

and just, yeah, try to keep updated with this stuff. I know it's a lot. We were just talking about burnout. It's a lot, but unfortunately, it's important stuff. Username is Nye. I want to know more details about this Jonah act. That's what I was going to say. I saw that. What is the Jonah act? Two chat, two control. Love it. Yeah, so I think that's all we got on that one. I think now we can move on to the site updates. I guess I'll kick this one off.

In a little bit, we're going to be talking about a new attack that can track you regardless of what operating system you use and does not require administrative privileges, by the way. But first, like I said, we're going to do some site updates. Yeah, like I mentioned, we did, well, we put out a video last week about My brain is blanking. The twenty sixteen San Bernardino shooting and the fight that followed between Apple and the FBI, with the FBI trying to pressure Apple to

unlock it and Apple saying no. And that one got I think it's now got over a million views on YouTube, which i don't want to downplay it but i will say um youtube changed the way they count views now so it's more like a million clicks than a million views but even so it's got i think half a million what they call engaged views which is what we used to know as views so um like half a million real views which is pretty amazing um definitely the most viral i've ever any video i've ever worked on so super proud of that but yeah this week um

Lewis Rossman, a lot of you guys probably saw, posted a video where he revoked his endorsement of Privacy.com. And for any of you who haven't seen this video, I've met Lewis. I consider him a friend. He's a really cool guy. And I didn't disagree with him, but I remember sitting here and thinking, like, while I'm watching his video, I'm like, okay, so what's... What's the alternative? Every service is going to KYC you. And I just thought it was part of a bigger discussion. And so I kind of pitched it to Jonah. I kind of expected Jonah to say no, to be honest. But I was like, hey, what if we make this video?

And he was like, yeah, let's do it. So we whipped that up pretty quick and posted that. And that is now available. And it has not gone as viral, but it's definitely gotten a ton of discussion in the comments. I feel like that's an issue that comes up a lot with maybe idealists in the privacy space. We see it especially in cybersecurity where I think people can let perfect be the enemy of the good. As long as you know the downsides of things, a lot of tools do have

aspects of them that can help your privacy in meaningful ways. And I think Privacy.com is one of them. Of course, there are alternatives to that. And so if you disagree with the specific provider that Privacy.com is using, you can switch to my pseudo or another provider that's similar, or you can switch to prepaid debit cards. There's a lot of those which you can obtain completely anonymously. Right now, all the virtual card services, they do KYC in a similar manner. They just use different companies, but But those prepaid cards can or gift cards

could be obtained with cryptocurrency or cash. And so that's always an option. But I think Yeah, as long as you understand you're giving up some privacy in some respect when you're using privacy.com, which is unfortunate. I've never liked the name of this privacy.com service because I think that is a little misleading. But at the same time, being able to use a different card number on every site that you use, it has security benefits for sure because you can disable those cards. And it also has privacy benefits because...

uh merchants can't track you based on your billing information or like two websites can't collaborate and share their databases and link your accounts because you can use not only different card numbers but you can use different billing addresses or whatever you want with privacy.com it doesn't get checked on those cards so they're like it sucks that they're doing this uh it's very annoying but at the same time if you want those privacy benefits in a different respect, you also don't have a lot of options.

But I do think privacy.com should stop doing that. And I think that if you do use privacy.com right now, you should write to them and complain. I don't use privacy.com. Personally, I use virtual cards from my bank, which I think is the more convenient option if you have that option. But yeah, Yeah, for sure. And for the record, again, if anybody hasn't seen the video, we said all this in the video. Like I even said at one point, I'm like, look, I think at bare minimum, Privacy.com could have gone with a different provider that's not funded by

Peter Thiel. Did you see the comment that said I was defending Peter Thiel somehow? I stared at that one for a minute. I'm like, what? Where? But yeah, anyways. Yeah. So, I mean, we, we said that like, look, they, they should do better. There's probably providers who are slightly better, but they're not all like, there is no provider that's like, oh, this one's great. And they should have gone with them. It's like, yeah, there's a lesser evil, but not by much. And yeah, we did go over some of the alternatives, like you mentioned. And yeah, I don't know. Anyways, that's,

that's a video that's out there. If y'all want to check that out. I think on that note, I will turn it over to Jonah to discuss any site changes that are coming up. Yeah, there's some minor updates. As usual, people keep plugging away at pull requests on the site. And if you have any suggestions or want to add new content, we always accept that stuff on on GitHub. We have some changes revising the guidance we have for Android app installation. We have some changes to

We have some improvements to our Tor interview and how we changed that, and we changed our custom domain requirement for email services again. This is all based on forum discussions that we have, so if you want to get involved, you can either create a pull request based on discussions that you've seen on the forum that people generally agree on, or if you want to make a change, you can open a discussion on the forum at discuss.privacyguides.net. That's the best way to contribute to our shared knowledge base, and we can hopefully get the best privacy information we can out

there. Of course, Freya and others constantly work on news briefs that we post to privacyguides.org slash news. These come up very regularly and they cover a lot of news topics, especially ones that we can't cover on the show because we do a lot of discussion on the show. Of course, we can't We can't cover every news story. Some of the headlines from this week. Critical Tor vulnerabilities were patched across all Tor components from the LLM

report firehose. New technique was discovered for breaking RSA faster than ever before. Meta promises to upgrade Ray-Ban smart glasses with private processing. Whatever that means, you'll have to read the article to find out. um highly sensitive data of three million people in the pentagon system were accessed by unauthorized users and german police are using linked devices to read messages from messaging apps without cracking the encryption which i believe we've talked about a similar story on the show before um of course every week nate

also publishes the data breach roundup to this same page privacyguides.org news you can also subscribe to it as a newsletter but there's just constantly data breaches happening all the time. And it's kind of just a way to show how often it happens, because I think people wouldn't believe how often these companies get hacked. So yeah, if you want to either be aware of that, or if you just want to see how often it happens, that's a good resource to check out. Yeah, all of the stuff that we publish,

all the stuff that I talked about and the videos that Nate talked about, all of it's made possible by our supporters. You can sign up for a membership or you can donate at privacyguides.org slash donate. You can also pick up some swag at shop.privacyguides.org if you like. At Privacy Guides, we are a nonprofit. We research and share privacy-related information, and we facilitate a community on our forum and matrix and these other platforms like here on YouTube where people can ask questions and get advice about staying private online and preserving your digital rights.

So yeah, with my spiel out of the way, Nate, let's talk about some new research on car privacy or the lack thereof. And everyone, remember... The chat's been pretty active, which is fantastic. But if you do have questions, either about what we're talking about or just questions in general, we will get to all those questions in between stories. So definitely feel free to leave them. Now you don't have to wait. Yeah, real quick, I'll jump into a couple of those questions. First of all, apparently the Jonah Act is the just open nothing and hide act.

So if you were curious about that. Username is Naya said, where's Tudor encryption wise? They receive government funding to post-quantum cryptography. I think either they're still rolling it out or it might be done. I know Tudor Drive uses post-quantum encryption. Yeah, I, I know it's, it's in progress at very least if it's not already fully rolled out. I believe they fully rolled it out and it should protect all that data. Um, yeah, yeah. Proton still is not rolled it out annoyingly,

even though they have it supposedly. Um, but yeah, I've complained about that on the Reddit and hopefully we, hopefully we see that soon. You know, I really want to add a soundboard on my little stream deck here for the clip from Letter Kenny, where he just says allegedly, because I feel like I use that a lot. But anyways, I digress. We'll move on to the next story, which is a study about cars. And I do apologize. I'm going to read pretty much all of this article. It's not very long for the record.

And I read fast, but it's one of those articles where there's really not a lot of fluff and it's very dense. So it's one of those times I found myself taking notes and I'm like, I literally just copied the whole article. So the headline says, this study looks at how and with whom connected cars share your data. So I can actually summarize the first couple of paragraphs. Back in twenty twenty three, Mozilla published a report that actually broke all the way into the mainstream. And what they did was they looked at the privacy policies of more than two dozen automakers. And they said, quote, cars are the worst product category we

have ever reviewed for privacy. But this article notes like, yeah, that was conducted by reading the privacy policies. But now we have actual research. Northeastern University and Consumer Reports tested twenty one cars from nineteen different brands. And let's see two attempts to actually see what was in the data packets using modified certificates failed in every case. But the network traces still yielded valuable information, including the domains contacted via DNS traffic. uh server name indication in tls handshakes the volume and timing of transmissions and differences in behavior

across experimental scenarios so all of the cars contacted a first party domain uh you know honda.com mercedes.com whatever um uh where did they say A few left it there, such as the Buick Invista and the Mercedes-Benz EQS didn't appear to reach out anywhere else, for example. Others were far more promiscuous, with Tesla topping the chart. The Model Three contacted thirty-four advertising, tracking, and analytics domains, as well as thirty-seven domains from apps integrated into the infotainment system. Alphabet's domains were most frequently

contacted, which is not enormously surprising given the penetration of Android Automotive OS into the sector. They said, but there were many second level domains that were not necessary for core services like DoubleClick.net and GoogleSyndication.com, which are used for advertising. Media streaming like Spotify, SiriusXM, and so on are also there, as well as mapping companies like Here, TomTom, and Mapbox. They said using a car's infotainment system resulted in contacting the most domains versus just sitting idle or driving for all the cars tested, which would make sense,

apart from the Cybertruck, which instead contacts twenty six more third party domains while driving than stationary, which is. What? I digress. So with the EVs, they were able to put them in a Faraday tent and actually test. They couldn't do that with the internal combustion engine cars because of fumes, but they were able to put them in a tent and see would they try a different way to phone home. And they said some of the EVs, including the Cadillac Lyric, Chevy Blazer, Honda Prologue,

and Rivian R-I simply stopped using those connected subsystems. But some of the cars redirected their traffic to Wi-Fi, allowing the researchers to see traffic flows that were previously unobservable. And then they tested thirty different connected car apps. So I'm not gonna lie. I tried one of these one time just because I was hoping that we would be able to remote start our car in the winter and let it like warm up. It did not do that. So I deleted the app because in our case, you know, you download an app for like Honda, Toyota, whoever, and in my opinion they're pretty useless it

like tells you it tells you things the car already tells you like you know oh you've driven this far oh it's time to get an oil change and it's like what do i need an app for that but anyways um they said in some cases uh this exposed users to more than twenty new advertising tracking and analytics companies from general motors toyota and nissan were the worst offenders um the authors reached out to seventeen of the automakers and heard back from fourteen the replies are not entirely encouraging all of the oems told researchers that data sharing with with third parties was covered by contracts prohibiting the use of pii outside the

scope of their privacy agreements the same privacy agreements that horrified bozilla in uh some of the automakers deflected blame onto the embedded browser running inside the infotainment system and said it was up to the users to select the right prompt or reject a cookie uh seven said it's the consumer's responsibility to read and accept all the terms and conditions even though in many cases the software is already installed and the author's note that declining a data sharing agreement can result in loss of services and functionality not a great solution if it means losing useful features you expect to work when you bought the car they said there was at least one positive outcome after being contacted Honda changed its

data practices and no longer shares precise location data with at least one tracking company so yeah that was a lot but i don't know the the fun thing about cars is i feel like right now there's not a lot of defenses i mean are you aware of any any uh defenses against car privacy invasions jonah it's definitely a field that could use a lot more research unfortunately um i don't know maybe that's an opportunity for us to look into that but it's it's tricky as

these Yeah, cars just become even more connected and they're all kind of doing their own thing, of course, because like all of these companies, they just want to monetize that data. I'm sure very soon we'll see information like the LG TV information that just came out, except without with cars. Certainly we know of a lot of privacy invasions that cars have even today, and it's only kind of getting worse. what exactly we can do about it i

don't know though i don't have specific car advice unfortunately um but it would be great if there was was an option yeah for sure i know one thing that gets thrown around a lot is like just drive an older car um you know australis actually said we're cooked when all the old cars break down that's not always a feasible um solution because i know i used to have a that was my last car was a and I got rid of that just a couple years ago, so I had it about thirteen years or so, ten years, something like that, and it was a very common car,

I'm not gonna say what it was for obvious reasons, but it was a very common car, and yet, I remember the last time I went into an AutoZone, and I was like, yeah, I need a headlight, and they're like, oh, we don't have any headlights for that car, and I'm like, What do you mean you don't have any headlights for that car? I passed six other ones on the way here. This is not an unusual car. And you know, especially like my new car, one of our AC fan broke, which was just wonderful when we lived in Texas. Our AC fan broke and I jumped online and I spent days scouring,

not just YouTube, but like forums, like multiple search engines. I was like, there has to be tutorials on how to swap out this fan. And I could not find any tutorials. I could find, I found that repair for a different make and model, the right make and model, but different repairs. But we are no longer living in the glory days of YouTube where it's like anything you can think of, there's a tutorial on YouTube for it. So my point being is we're hitting a point where just drive an older car it's only going

to work if you have the money to like get parts custom ordered and fabricated and go to a mechanic every time it breaks down because it's just becoming impossible to like maintain these cars anymore so i don't know personal rant on that one but um anonymous one shared uh a link about rivians um this has come out come up a few times when we talked about car privacy and EVs. I haven't looked into it. Rivian claims that you can disable a lot of the stuff, which is cool. You do lose some features.

It is sort of like very similar to trusting Apple with like, is it truly disabled? Are they collecting all of this stuff? If you want to. Yeah, if you want to trust that that's happening, it could be it could be an option. And it's cool that, you know, they at least recognize that this is a privacy problem. But I think I don't know if people have evaluated that yet. um another comment i saw was from username isn't high grok helps me drive this comment is how i just found out that

tesla's integrate grok now i was just looking this up um and that is very sad knowledge for me to have so thank you for sharing that with me um that is that is terrible Um, I'd buy said it here. Thank you so much. I was trying to remember the name of the company. Carrie Parker mentioned them a couple months ago on firewalls. Don't stop dragons. Apparently slate alleges that you can turn off all the tracking. Same thing with Rivian. It's like, how much do you trust it? I will say, um, in my opinion,

what's up? Sorry, I was just going to say Slate might be a better option than Rivian because my understanding is there's not even a computer unless you buy one. Everything is kind of modular with the Slate truck. That's what it is. Yeah, the Slate's all modular. I remember looking at Slade and kind of configuring one on their website. I don't have the thirty grand to buy a slate truck, but I think even like the speaker system they recommend is basically a Bluetooth speaker that you mount there and then a phone holder. So

I mean, that is kind of the ideal way to do it in some in some sense, because I think it makes a lot of sense to kind of have everything on your phone and kind of only trust this one computer instead of this whole system that you're using. But I also don't know anything about the slate truck or how nice it is the drive or how many people will buy it. But it's an interesting concept for sure. a little bit off topic, but you said, I don't have the thirty grand to buy it. I remember one time just purely for laughs, I went to system seventy six's website.

This was years ago before the ramp apocalypse. And just for laughs, I was like, what is the most powerful computer they sell? So I got like the best, like the most RAM, the biggest hard drives, like multiple GPUs. And it came out to like seventy thousand dollars. I mean, to be fair, it had like nine I-Nines in it or something crazy. So it's, yeah, but I just, just for fun, I like to do that every now and then just how bad does it get? But yeah, we actually have quite a few here.

Oh, I remember I was going to say like with the whole like Rivian, you know, you can go to this link thing. Yeah, we're kind of trusting them. Like you said, it's like Apple. We're kind of trusting them to turn it off. But it's one of those things, in my opinion, where it can't hurt to do it because worst case scenario, you're in the same boat you started in. Best case scenario, they do actually shut off at least some of the telemetry. Worst case scenario, literally nothing has changed. So it's not like you're going to be worse off for doing it, in my opinion. But... Yeah, what about a start a farm life when the digital world is too much?

Seems like a lot of people are retiring to the farm life. Oh, what do we have here? Jonah, it's different from Apple. They say you can disable all cellular connectivity. It's a simple on off. So but, you know, it's like a proprietary system, right? Just like Apple. You just have to trust other switches work. I mean, there's got to be a way to like check and see if there's anything coming off of it. I would feel like I don't know. I'm really curious. I remember when we looked at the review and stuff last time,

it does disable things like active lane centering, which isn't great. It disables navigation, which might make sense. But I mean, even even in like two thousand eight to twenty ten, we had cars that just had maps in them. Could we just could we just have offline maps for a fan? Maybe I'm curious whether I don't know anything about Rivian, honestly. I don't know if it supports CarPlay. I wonder if you could disable this but still use CarPlay for music streaming. Or Android Auto. Either one,

depending on the phone you have. Yeah, it's interesting. This article does say that they can disable the eSIM entirely through a service appointment, which maybe would be even better. But yeah, it all depends on how well they've implemented this. But I would certainly hope it works as advertised. Yeah. Yeah. Um, the last thing I'll add before we move on is, uh, I know there's services out there. The two I know of is privacy for cars and vehicle privacy report.

Um, they basically submit opt-outs on your behalf, or you can do it yourself if you're a masochist. Um, it's, it's one of those things where you're trusting another party. Uh, this is not an official privacy guides recommendation, but, um, you are trusting a third party because you have to, and I think you even have to like check a box that basically says like, I am giving you legal authorization to act on my behalf in this instance. And even then, it's not really, it's very limited. It's like a lot of websites where it's like, oh, opt out of targeted advertising. And it's like, okay, but opting out of targeted advertising is not the same as opting out of collecting

the data for targeted advertising. So it's definitely not, I'm not trying to say it's foolproof and like, oh, you sign up for one of these and they'll delete everything or whatever. But again, it's one of those things where I think I would argue you're probably not worse off. Like I've done it. I haven't had any downsides other than I got a bunch of letters that are like, we received your request and we'll process and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And then, you know, at very least it sends a message. You know, if they get tens of thousands of these requests, then maybe they might just be like, hmm,

people feel strongly about this. So I don't know if it would be enough to change, but yeah. So I just wanted to throw that out there. I think you have a forum post to pull up, but right before that, I want to do one more comment here. Foundog said, I think I'd want the ability to remove the five G modem. I think that that would be like that's that's the main thing. If I was going to look into this vehicle stuff more, which maybe we should do, to be honest, because nobody else seems to be doing it these days since Mozilla stopped updating that. But I think that that would be probably

the best solution is just there's probably going to be some vehicles where you can just pull out this module or make make a change to like force it to no longer be connected and then see like what functionality remains. I think looking into that would be would be cool. I know that Henry from Teklor suggested something similar because at one point, I think he got like a Nissan Leaf or something, but it was like an older EV that only had two G connectivity. So then when all of the towers stopped

supporting two G, he said that that would that would make it private. know that's certainly an approach i think removing it entirely would be uh certainly a lot better um but i don't know of any cars that make that super easy to do but i feel like there might be some out there where you could just like remove a fuse or like disconnect a module and and lose that functionality and they they might be options to explore and i think doing more research into that would be pretty useful.

So we should think about that. Username is not what's bad about five G exactly. I think just any connectivity, like if you could remove the connectivity features of your, of your vehicle pretty easily, no cellular, no, no wifi. That would, that would stop a lot of these privacy problems. You'd lose functionality. So I think looking into like what functionality you, you would lose if you disconnected, that would be something to, to look into, but it would be good for privacy. If that's a possibility.

Yeah, I don't know if it's true. I've heard some claims that that could potentially be like a warranty voiding thing, but also if you're buying a car secondhand, usually there is no warranty, so. yeah another thing we'd have to look into like can you easily reconnect it when you bring it in for servicing maybe and that's what i was about to say i feel like a good mechanic could probably like you said like there's probably just one cable they just pull out and you know but also a lot of the time i no offense to mechanics a lot of you guys seem to like talk down to non-mechanics well you know you're gonna lose this this and this yeah i i

know just please unplug it i i did my research so I don't know, but yeah, anyways, actually we did have a couple of questions before I dive into the forum post. We had one basically, okay, sorry, I closed it out. Now I can't see it. It's basically, they found on our forum, there were some recommendations for Venadium and one of them was to turn off, do not track, but since it's on by default, wouldn't that make Venadium users stand

out more? What do you think of that? That's definitely true that it could. In theory, the reality is Vanadium doesn't have billions or millions or even probably no more than like a handful of thousand users. Right. So fingerprinting is kind of already going to be an issue for a lot of people. It's not really geared to prevent fingerprinting.

I think that Graphene OS has said they want to focus more on that in the future. I believe that they've said in regards to fingerprinting, it'd be cool to release Vanadium on the Play Store so other people kind of blend in with it. But the reality is with a lot of these mobile devices, it's almost impossible to prevent a lot of browser fingerprinting. And even Tor Browser on Android is not as good at preventing fingerprinting as... as it is on like desktop with mobile browser or Tor browser, for example.

It's just there's too many variables. We talk about this all the time with cellular devices. They're machines that are basically built for tracking. So There's only so much that can be done with the current operating systems, unfortunately. Yeah, Jordan just said in the chat that Graphene OS has said they have around a half a million users. So yeah, in the grand scheme of things, as far as browser fingerprinting goes, that's a pretty insignificant number of users who are browsing the web. So you're going to stand out if you

use Vanadium either way. I think the idea... You said this was advice from a... community wiki posts, those are obviously maybe not obviously, but those are submitted by people in our community and they're kind of collaborated on by other forum users, but they haven't been like added to our website. So this isn't a post that I've read, but I would imagine changing some of these settings may help Vanadium users blend in more with like Google Chrome users, which may be a bit more beneficial. But again, even Google Chrome users,

despite there being a ton of them, because the browser is sharing so much unique information, you're still going to be fingerprintable. So it's just not a thing that really any browser on Android, to my knowledge, tackles. Tor browser might be doing the best, but there's so few Tor browser users on Android that you run into exactly the same issue. So that's not really a protection either. You're just not going to be protected from this on Android at the end of the day. That's what I would say. Another thing Jordan said that I know you kind of touched on is not everyone that

uses Graphene OS uses Vanadium either, which is true. I use Brave, so yeah. Yeah, I use Brave on mobile just because I think they're the best at what they do. Yeah, Oddbyte said Brave. I use it because it syncs, you know. I don't use the sync. Oh, no? I just, I like that it has, I feel like it has the best anti-fingerprinting for an Android browser, but, you know. It's good ad blocking, too, yeah. Oh, yeah, ad blocking. I don't remember what the ad blocking situation is on Finadium, but...

I heard they were going to make a change list built in, but it's not really robust. That sounds like it might be right. Um, yeah, username is nice that some websites can ignore and bypass do not track requests. And I also know that, um, there is a. Uh, I don't know if this necessarily, like, I don't know how this compares versus, um, like the idea of trying to make everybody blend in on vanadium, but do not track can also be used ironically to track people because of the way it works and the headers. And so that's typically why it is disabled. Yeah. Yeah. I was going to say that's, that's probably why we re uh,

or that forum post recommended. You wouldn't want to disable it. I think it's a good point. Like in general, if the other people who use your browsers have it enabled by default, you probably wouldn't want to disable it. But I think in this case, it probably doesn't matter too much in the grand scheme of things. So as Yeah, who said that? Where did that chat go? Well, it doesn't matter. The do not track setting is ignored by sites because, yeah, that one.

Because it's not a legal requirement. I mean, it's just kind of a request that you make. There is a new standard, I think it's called GPC, Global Privacy Control, but I could be wrong about that. But the nice thing about that one, in theory, is that in states like California, for example, in other regions where there are stronger privacy laws, they've decided that this setting is... considered a legally binding request, whereas Do Not Track isn't because there's

some like requirements on how GPC is used. It can't be like enabled by default on standard browsers. People have to opt into it. So that's more like an affirmative choice. I think a big problem with Do Not Track is that like it just got enabled on Firefox, for example, by default, and then everyone was using it and then Nobody really respected that request or checked it because they wanted to track a bunch of Firefox users. Probably back in the day when a lot of people use Firefox.

Now Firefox would probably get away with enabling it by default, arguing that most Firefox users care about privacy. But there was a time where people used Firefox for non-privacy reasons back in the day. But I think those people are few and far between now, unfortunately. Well, what's funny is I think Brave enables GPC by default, but yeah, that's another video idea I've submitted but we haven't gotten around to. Because if you market your browser as specifically for privacy, everywhere on Brave it's the privacy browser.

So people are opting into it because they downloaded a privacy browser. But even Firefox probably couldn't justify enabling it by default and Chrome certainly couldn't. you can't say this person specifically requested privacy. Would it be nice if we just had data privacy laws that you don't have to opt into? Yes, that would be awesome. But yeah, we don't. Fair. Yeah. Somebody said Vanadium uses easy list and-

Yeah, I think that's about it. There was another question from that person real quick. We'll just run through these. Basically, if I enable some hardening exploit protection on Graphene OS, when should I enable it for specific apps? In my experience, you should enable it by default. I've only ever had to, I kind of bounce around between a lot of different operating systems to keep testing them. In my experience, I've only ever had to disable exploit protection once and it was with Apple Music because it was,

for some reason it started giving me a lot of trouble about like, it wouldn't let me sign in and then when I did sign in, it like wouldn't find my library and then like, It wouldn't download music. It was giving me all kinds of errors. And finally, when I disabled exploit protection, suddenly it worked perfectly. So, I don't know. I would use a whitelist approach, personally. Every other app I've ever tried has worked just fine. Yeah. I enabled all of them by default, and I have not run into any issues on my Pixel. I would say...

If you can deal with that pop-up, there are definitely a few apps where I open them and I get that pop-up, but nothing really seems to change. I think that gallery app, Avis Gallery or whatever it's called, has this issue where sometimes I open it, that pops up, but it's perfectly fine. And if you can kind of just deal with that pop-up, then it's... whatever. But also, if you get that pop-up and functionality is clearly impacted, you can consider disabling it. It just depends on how much you trust that app, right? It's just a sign.

I wouldn't disable these features every time an app breaks or crashes because I think it's a good... point in time to evaluate whether you need this app in the first place or whether you can find an alternative that's not going to break because of security features. But if you really do need this app, then the whitelist approach, like you said, Nate, is the way to go, where you just have everything enabled by default and just disable it very selectively. Oddbite also read my mind. Oddbite said you can disable the pop up,

which honestly is what I do, because, yeah, it shows up all the time. And then but there's like never a functionality issue. It's so yeah, you just had at least one if you have. I was going to say, I think I have at least one functionality issue. I don't remember what it was, though. But yeah, like I also just said that that's usually used by tracking SDKs. I think that that's most of the reason that it pops up. Can you disable that pop up? for a specific app or can you just disable the pop-up from the system in general? Because that's what I would wonder. I would still want the pop-up for some

apps, but if it was an issue with a specific app, I'd want to turn it off. But I've never looked into disabling it. I can't remember. They're saying per app. They're saying per app in the chat. So great. That's a great option. All right, and then last one, this one's really quick. Is there a difference between wired and wireless headphones security-wise? Generally speaking, wired is going to be more secure. We did, I think last week, actually, we did cover an attack that also works on wired headphones because it targets the actual analog components. But yeah, usually when there's security issues,

it has to do with the Bluetooth of wireless headphones. Yeah, I mean, Bluetooth is just not a... very private standard. And anytime you're like, I mean, it's radio waves, this can be picked up by somebody if they have the equipment. Yeah. for sure. All right. On that note, uh, we'll get into the forum post here, which, uh, this is a forum discussion. It was actually, I think our most popular forum discussion this week is how often are people sending encrypted emails? Um, so I'm not going to read any specific

messages here because basically the whole thread of it was somebody was like, I feel like a lot of the people I email are using like Gmail or outlook or Yahoo and everybody else kind of just, uh, um, agreeing like, yeah, everyone I, I email is, is, uh, using one of these mainstream providers there was some discussion about like you know should you like teaching people how to use mail envelope or how it comes built in with like firefox or uh not firefox um thunderbird and uh i saw some people said that they've actually stopped using encrypted email providers for that

reason specifically but i don't know i uh i also wanted to talk about this because i have opinions about this and uh i actually don't know I'm assuming you are probably on the same page as me with this one, but in your opinion, is there a point to using an encrypted email provider even if nobody else is? Yeah. I think we hammered this down pretty hard on our website actually, but the main reason we recommend these providers is their protection at rest, and especially if you can prevent the provider from having the keys to open

that, that would be great. A lot of people will say, well, your data is encrypted by email. Google and their servers because they use disk encryption. But Google has the keys to unlock it. So how secure is that really? Whereas with Proton, you have the key to unlock it and they can't do it. And I think that in terms of long term storage of emails, you might be emailed a lot of sensitive information. You're certainly emailed like a lot of account related stuff. But like I almost never use email for communication because there's no point to it.

And we really, I think, discourage people from using email for communication in general. And so I think we're not really pushing for a lot of end-to-end encryption for email just because there are much better platforms to use if you want to communicate securely. Whereas I just use it as an inbox for all the accounts that I have. And having that data encrypted at rest is very important to me.

And that has nothing to do with the end-to-end encrypted stuff. Anyways, what I would say is it's probably a good thing that we're not focusing so much on end-to-end encryption in email because I think everyone should spend their time switching to better instant messengers like Signal instead of working on that. Yeah, for sure. I feel kind of the same way. It's to me, I think of it in terms of like a data breach. Like, okay, if I'm using Proton or Tudor and I'm communicating with people who are using

Gmail and Outlook and whatnot, if that person has a data breach, yes, my correspondence with them is going to be leaked, But it's not gonna be my whole inbox. Like you said, it's not gonna be my doctor's office, my bank, all these different things. That's not gonna be in there. It's going to be my communication with them, which may still be bad, but it's not as bad. And to me, it's also cutting the risk in half because, like you said, my inbox is still encrypted at rest. And that can't be as easily breached as something like Gmail or Outlook,

especially Outlook. So it's again, yeah, it's not a perfect solution, but it's a it's a risk reduction solution. So I still think it's worth it. Also, again, you know, these providers are not like farming your your email for marketing information, which I think Google said they stopped doing that, but whatever. And yeah, I had that in the notes, too, that email is a legacy tech to begin with. And all these things like PGP, even like Tudor, I know Tudor like has their own version of PGP where they encrypt even more metadata. But even that is still just like adding

band aids on top of email. And there are better things like Signal or SimpleX or whatever. So but unfortunately, we are at a point where, you know, my bank is not going to signal me a login code. So we do still need email from time to time for sure. Yeah. Jordan just said that, but it would be nice if we could use something else, but I don't see that happening anytime soon. Yeah, Intel just said it's the standard, and it is. And it's just so entrenched in everything

that it's very unlikely that we'll switch away from using it. But protecting as much as you can, I think... I think the risk of, just from a security perspective, the risk of a data breach impacting your email provider is much higher than the risk of your emails being intercepted live. That all depends on your threat model, of course, but end-to-end encryption is a huge benefit just for that data at rest against data breaches, even if it doesn't stop active attackers.

Switching to something like Proton, even if you can't convince anyone else to switch, and I think somebody even said, yeah, anonymous once, I'm not going to spend time on convincing people to change email for writers. Yeah, I think that's not the best use of anyone's time, but... It would be great if people switch because it would secure their own emails. And just from a personal perspective, it's one of those things where if you switch, you benefit a lot, even if nobody else uses it. I think that's a problem that we have with instant messengers when we think about Signal or SimpleX.

like you don't get a lot of benefit from Signal if nobody else is using Signal. So there's more of that problem, but there's a clear benefit to switching to a more private, secure email provider. So yeah, highly recommend. Yeah, that's something I think about that I'm probably gonna write a blog post at some point about is like there's certain privacy actions that do require you to get other people to change, like you said, like using Signal or something. But then there's a lot of things that you can do yourself that don't depend on anybody else. Like you can switch to Brave or Firefox.

You can switch to Linux if you can afford to do that. Yeah, you can switch to a private email provider. Like there's a lot of privacy stuff you can do on your own for sure, so. Anyways, on that note, I'm going to turn things over to you now and you can tell us all about this new attack. This is actually our last story of the day. So if anybody has been holding on to any questions that you haven't asked yet, please do drop those in the chat and Jonah will tell us all about this new attack. Yeah, Fria wrote this article,

new attack can track you across operating systems without elevated privileges. Fria, sorry, researchers at the Graz University of Technology Austria demonstrated a new attack that can track you via file change events on all systems allowing for various data leaks. They say that modern operating systems like Linux, Windows and Mac OS provide built in subsystems to monitor file system events. I notify redirectory changes to view NFS events. User processes, programs on your computer can subscribe to

receive file operation notifications when actions like accessing, writing, opening and closing are performed on a monitored file or directory. And so the research paper that was published essentially points out that these tools can be used by programs to read information about large number of operating system files and other files on your computer. A lot of these files that can be read or that you can monitor events for

can be read by any program without any special privileges. I saw people talking about this story on Reddit on the r slash privacy subreddit. And I think people were like, well, this attack can only be, it only matters if you're like locally running software. It's not like an attack you can get over the internet. But I didn't really understand that argument because malware exists. People are downloading software on their computers all the times and this, I think it gives any malware a large

amount of insight into your system and what's running on it without that malware needing any special permissions other than just running on your device. So it's not something that would need to escalate to admin privileges. And according to the researchers in this paper, it leaks a lot of information that like more information than you would think. So it says on Linux, they were able to achieve a keystroke timing attack,

which is a type of side channel attack that measures the timing between key presses in order to infer information about the text being typed, including the actual text. That attack could potentially leak passwords or sensitive text being typed, such as private messages. They were also able to perform a fingerprinting attack on the top one hundred websites, since visiting certain websites would trigger specific access patterns for fonts in the fonts directory. So from just this alone, an attacker can figure out what websites you're visiting, basically

malware running on your computer without any access to your browser at all, because it's sandbox, can see whether you're accessing a certain site, like a major one, or at least guess and potentially track you based on just files in the operating system that can be read by pretty much any software running on your device. So I think it is a concerning problem. And the paper also goes into similar attacks to that on on Android, on Windows, on Mac OS. So, yeah, if you read this article,

you can read some specific attacks in the paper is is linked. But I think that that is kind of the the situation there. So, yeah. Do you have any thoughts about like the malware running on your computer side of things or anything like that? Well, I do want to answer, username is Nye, said, is this article peer-reviewed? I don't think so, but it is kind of confirmed. The last sentence of the article says, in particular, Microsoft stated that the private data leakage was actually there by design,

which is a pretty insane thing to say, but whatever. Yeah, I think, to me, the thing that stuck out to me, so, okay, I know this was an hour and a half ago, but at the beginning of the live stream, I talked about that video from Side of Burritos where he demonstrated how the secure clipboard works on graphene. And one thing he pointed out is that there are certain apps that as soon as you copy something to the clipboard, as soon as you open the app, before you even hit paste, they already read what's on the clipboard.

So if you've got, let's say you've got three apps open, and you're trying to copy from app A to app C, but you accidentally open app B along the way for whatever reason, and it's one of those apps that does that, even though you never hit paste, it can read what's on your clipboard. So to me, and for the record, I don't think all apps do that, I'm just saying some have that capability, which is why the secure clipboard exists. So to me, that kind of reminds me of this thing, where when we talk about malware, we talk about malware, right? Like whether it's bundled in a cracked game or a phishing link or something, but I'm also thinking of just really

shady, unethically acting apps, like a game you download or anything from Meta that is not technically malware, like it is not actually malware in the literal sense, But it basically behaves like malware. And now it's probing your system and doing all this stuff. And now it could potentially be picking up, even if it's hopefully not picking up your actual passwords and the messages you're texting, it could still be tracking what websites you visit. Like you said, even though the browser is sandbox, it can still use these other side channels to track what you're doing and pick up

information that it's not supposed to have. And it's not a virus. It's not actual malware. It's just behaving like it. And yeah, it just... To me, that's the big thing that stuck out to me. It's like, this is a problem, and this is actually why I wanted to include it on this stream, is because it's like, this isn't strictly malware. This could be... Sorry, I know I'm rambling a little bit, but that whole thing with Signal a year ago where Signal was storing the encryption keys unencrypted on Windows devices on the desktop, and everybody was like, dude, what the heck?

And they're like, well, if you have malware on your computer, you're already screwed anyways. Okay, what if I don't have malware? What if I have this? So, yeah, I don't know. To me, this is just a really important thing, and Microsoft is completely insane for saying, yeah, we know. I digress. Let's see. This sounds like a thing that does not sound bad until more research is done and then a real world targeted attack gets done to show us an actual example. Yeah, that too. Now that it's out there, how many tech bros, this will be a quick rant, I promise.

How many tech bros watched Black Mirror and then went, hey, that's a good idea for a business? How many other tech bros do you think are gonna read this article and be like, ooh, build this functionality in? So yeah, pretty bad. It's a situation like this malware can't in a lot of cases, read the files involved. But if you can read all this metadata, we talk about metadata, revealing all sorts of sensitive information all the time, just in so in this case, like just the idea that software can see

when you open the file, even if it knows nothing about the file itself, that can reveal a lot of information. So yeah, all of this metadata protection, I think needs to be, like always taken taken more seriously than it than it often is. I just want to say, I think I might go back and read the actual paper itself because I want to see if Microsoft justifies why this is there by design. Like, what do you, why? What purpose? I don't know. But yeah, I don't really know if there's any, because again, this doesn't necessarily, this isn't taking advantage of any

vulnerabilities. This doesn't, um this isn't uh like actual malware so i don't know if there's any defenses against this other than don't use windows um but yeah just being careful what you download and run uh hopefully apple and linux will roll out some some fixes for this but yeah you got any additional thoughts uh yeah i don't think so just just goes to show that you know any any local software you run just like you said can

running anything locally will give will give programs a lot of information about you, regardless of like privileges in a lot of cases, just because the operating system is so vast, right? There's so many potential things that software can access that it just isn't locked down. So being aware of that is important. Yeah, yeah, if you need further examples, y'all should look up what's going on with Meadows Muse AI on Mac. That is the gift that keeps on giving.

Username is Nye said, did you watch the Hotel Reverie episode? No, I haven't watched anything since the season with Miley Cyrus doing Nine Inch Nails songs. I want to, I just, I'm not gonna lie, This is going to sound completely deranged. I miss the old Black Mirror where I would watch an episode and be like, wow, that was really good. That was also really intense and soul crushing. And I can't watch another episode for at least a week. And I miss that version of Black Mirror. Now it's more just like sci-fi, like occasionally a little bit bleak.

And I'm like, like that season I mentioned, I binged that entire season in two days, which at the time I was still working like my super long hour job. So two days is really fast for me, was really fast for me. So it's like, What happened to that Black Mirror where it's like every episode crushed me internally? Yeah, I'm sure the creator of Black Mirror has definitely said this in numerous interviews. But with this type of show, you can't outpace reality at this point.

It's hard to think of things that wouldn't already be done. And I think some of the most recent seasons of Black Mirror were absolutely all about that. Like that one where they made a parody of Netflix. But Netflix basically does... They're working on all the stuff in that episode. They're working on AI content. They're working on content specifically tailored to you. Yeah, I just think that we've seen a lot of the Black Mirror stuff come true. It's real products. I will say I did watch Hotel Reverie.

That was a great episode. Yeah. I mean, I'm definitely planning to catch up. I've actually been the last six months or so, I've really been putting a dent in my to watch list and I've been catching up on stuff. So it's on my list. It's just not very high on my list because there's so many other things that like, you know, It's like, I've been meaning to watch this forever. I was really excited about this and I just never had time. And so, yeah, and I'll get to it eventually for sure. But yeah, I get what you mean. Like the onion is like that too.

Like they have to go so ridiculously over the top now because politics has gotten so ridiculous. It's the only way they can, which that's a different thing. But Jordan said, is it really a stream if Nate doesn't talk about sci-fi? Yeah. I was actually going to throw it out there. Since it's October, I know a lot of people are doing that thirty one for thirty one thing. If you all have any horror movies you think I should check out, definitely. I don't think you can message me on the forum. I think I shut that off, but I don't know. We need to start a forum thread for this. I'm down.

Yeah, leave it in this forum thread. I don't know, ping me. I don't even know what Thirty One for Thirty One is, should I? Am I missing out? I mean, I'm not going to do actual Thirty One for Thirty One because I'm just not that committed. It's basically every day of October you watch a different horror movie. And I mean, I guess the good news is you can circle back. It can be movies you've seen before. Good excuse to watch The Invisible Man again. I love that movie. That is a, oh my God,

that is such a good movie. Yeah, I love that one. I don't know. I've been on kind of a horror movie kick. I finally watched Weapons. I finally watched Fall of House of Usher. I've got like, twenty minutes left on the black phone, too, because I'm just, like I said, I'm not that invested. I mean, I'm invested enough that I'm gonna finish it, but it's like, you know, I started watching it last night, and it was like, it got to be about bedtime and it was still like an hour left in the movie. And I'm like, yeah, no, I'm not that invested. I'm going to bed. And then today, Fridays are always my busy day because of

the show. So username is not, the onion has no more material left. How can anybody really, I think, I mean, we definitely see that in black mirror. I think the last season of black mirror, uh, unless there's been a more recent one that i am unaware of i don't i don't know how often they make these but the last one that i saw it kind of ended on like a werewolf note like we're just getting out of sci-fi now you're kind of you're trying to spin off into a new franchise it seems like because you just can't come up with any more any more bleak tech stuff anymore i think the

the tech space is just bleak as is so it's not not it's no longer groundbreaking I wonder if he's just afraid to inspire more people. Like I have a ton of ideas, but I know that they keep watching this and every time, because I'm telling you, I've seen so many news articles and it's like, oh, there's this new startup that does this. And I'm like, that is literally a Black Mirror episode. Why? So I digress. Yeah, I'm looking in the forum. I'm looking in Signal. I'm not seeing any more questions. So unless you or anybody else has

anything, I think we can wrap this up. Yeah, probably can wrap it up. I mean, we've asked for questions this whole time. So if you haven't sent it in yet, I think that's on you, but you can save it for the next stream. For sure. Yeah. Do you want to wrap this up, Nate? Sure. I got this. All right. So all the updates from this week in privacy will be shared on the blog every week. So sign up for the newsletter or subscribe with your favorite RSS reader. If you want to stay tuned as a reminder, that newsletter actually goes out right at the same time that we start streaming.

So that works as a good notification as well. And there's a link to the stream in the newsletter. So super convenient, super easy. We also offer a podcast available on all podcast platforms and RSS, which now includes video on supported platforms, if you prefer that. And this video will also be synced to PeerTube. PrivacyGuides is an impartial nonprofit organization that is focused on building a strong privacy advocacy community and delivering the best digital privacy and consumer technology rights advice on the internet. If you want to support our mission, you can make a donation on our website at privacyguides.org slash donate.

You can also make a donation on any page of the website by clicking the red heart icon located in the top right corner of the page. You can contribute using standard fiat currency via debit or credit card, or you can donate anonymously using Monero or your favorite cryptocurrency. Becoming a paid member unlocks exclusive perks like early access to video content, exclusive video content, and priority during the Q&A. You'll also get a cool badge on your profile in the Privacy Guides forum and the warm, fuzzy feeling of supporting independent media. Thank you everyone who watched. It was awesome to have you guys in the chat and we will be back next week.

Thanks everyone.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Hosts

  • Jonah Aragon Host Feed-stated
  • Nate Bartram Host Feed-stated

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Invisible Company That Got 200 Websites Hacked

    Nov 21, 20262 hr 2 minAudio

    Hackers have inserted malicious code into hundreds of popular websites to steal credit cards, cryptocurrency, and personal info - the culprit? Hijacked javascript used in a commonly used website optimisation tool. Join...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Nvidia Scandal Is a Massive Security Nightmare

    Nov 14, 20261 hr 42 minAudio

    Nvidia's board and the FBI are investigating their CEO Jensen Huang after he admitted to an affair with a suspected Chinese intelligence operative, we'll be breaking down why this was such a massive OPSEC failure and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Would You Pay $1600 to DeGoogle?

    Nov 7, 20261 hr 46 minAudio

    Motorola has announced the pricing for their Signature 27 device which supports GrapheneOS, and it's $1600 USD. Is this overpriced or actually justified, we'll discuss all the details! Join us for This Week In Privacy...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Google is Using Your Emails for Targeting Ads AGAIN

    Oct 30, 20261 hr 34 minAudio

    Google has updated it's privacy policy to allow for data from Gmail and Google Photos to be used for personalized advertising, Bitwarden has made a controversial license change to it's published applications, Proton is...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Digital Apocalypse Just Happened

    Oct 23, 20261 hr 25 minAudio

    The internet goes on high alert as 8 TLS certificates are compromised to due weak private keys, allowing anyone to mint browser and app credentials for any site on the internet, a leaked Cellebrite document describes a...

    Credit the people on this episode