There is something uniquely tragic and terrifying about carbon monoxide poisoning. The way it comes on quietly, without warning. How it alters your reality and changes your behavior. The fact that without a carbon monoxide detector, we can’t smell or taste or see or otherwise sense this poisonous gas. Humans have been dealing with the threat of carbon monoxide poisoning since long before we were a species, and only recently have we developed the skills and knowledge to contend with it. In this episode, we get into the details of carbon monoxide poisoning - why it’s deadly, what symptoms look like, and how we manage cases - before delving into the history of our relationship with the gas. How many ghostly apparitions were actually instances of CO poisoning? What maritime mysteries can be explained by the presence of the gas? And where does carbon monoxide poisoning still remain very much an issue today? Tune in for all the details. Support this podcast by shopping our latest sponsor deals and promotions at this link: https://bit.ly/3WwtIAu
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1From a post titled, Post-it Notes Left in Apartment, posted on the subreddit LegalAdvice by rbradbury1920 in 2015. On the 15th of April, I found a yellow post-it note in a handwriting that wasn't mine on my desk reminding me of some errands I had to do, but told literally nobody about. While odd, I chalked it up to something I did in my sleep, thinking maybe in my half-awake state I scrawled it so it didn't appear to be my handwriting. I threw it out and thought little of it.
Speaker 1On the 19th, I found another post-it note on the back of my desk chair in the same handwriting as the previous note, telling me to make sure I, quote, saved my documents. I was freaked out, but there were no other signs of a break-in, so I set up a webcam in my house aimed at my desk and used a security cam app for it to record after detecting movement. On the 28th, I woke up to find another post-it note, this one saying, quote, our landlord isn't letting me talk to you, but it's important we do.
Speaker 1I immediately checked the webcam's folder on my computer and found nothing from the night before, but my computer's recycling bin had been emptied, which I am certain I did not do recently, indicating someone had noticed the webcam and deleted the files. They were just saved straight to a folder on my desktop called Webcam. Today, on the 1st of May, I found another post-it note, this time on the outside of my door with nothing written on it. And there also appeared to be post-its on many other doors in my apartment complex, all blank in varying colors.
Speaker 1Do I have any legal recourse here? I have no proof except for the post-its, but those are written by my pen and on my post-it notes, so conceivably I could have faked them. Would contacting the police get me into any trouble if they can't determine an outside source for this? I just want to make sure I'm not wasting anyone's time. Should I consult my landlord, those also living in the complex? Edit to the original post. I pulled up a letter I received from my landlord back when I moved in, and the handwriting is identical. Could this count as evidence? And then the top voted comment
Speaker 1from this Reddit thread is by a user called Cackerlack. You seem sincere, and this doesn't appear to be the plot of a Ray Bradbury short story. It's possible that your landlord is leaving notes inside your apartment, but they don't make any sense in the context you're describing them. It's likely that you are writing the notes yourself, but you are forgetting. Do you use post-it notes as reminders in any other parts of your life or job? Yes, this might be a mental health issue. You might be experiencing some sort of dissociative disorder. Or it might be
Speaker 1a physical problem. You mentioned that you have a very unusual narrow bedroom with no windows. Is there a chance that you are not getting enough ventilation when you sleep? Or that there's a carbon monoxide leak in the building? A cheap carbon monoxide detector, which you should have anyway, is a fast way to find out. You'll also have really bad headaches. In reply, Ray Bradbury 1920, the original poster, wrote, I have had really bad headaches, and I actually already do have a carbon monoxide detector. Guess I should probably
Speaker 1take that out of its box and plug it in. And then in an update post to Post-it Notes Left an Apartment. Thanks to everyone who sent suggestions and gave advice on how to proceed. especially to those who recommended a carbon monoxide detector, because when I plugged one in in the bedroom, it read at 100 parts per million.
Speaker 1So this is like from the Reddit Hall of Fame. I mean, I'm chronically online. So I think that like this... When we decided to do carbon monoxide, this immediately popped into my head.
Speaker 2You already knew about this.
Speaker 12015, I mean, okay.
Speaker 22015, yeah. I still have so many questions. Like, why was the handwriting so different? Well, so I actually have an answer to that a little bit. So there's another comment that said, hi, so on further inspection, the handwriting really doesn't match up. However, both documents were on the same desk as several printed typed documents. And next to the typed documents, the handwriting seemed so similar. Also, it wasn't even a letter from my landlord. It was a letter from my mom.
Speaker 1And so I think there was just like a lot of confusion, delusion happening. Yeah. And so carbon monoxide poisoning.
Speaker 2Carbon monoxide.
Speaker 1The symptoms that it can cause are so strange and bizarre that you're like, this doesn't make sense what's going on. I don't know how to put this into any sort of logical order. And oftentimes, I think that's one of the scariest things about carbon monoxide is that your brain might not immediately go to carbon monoxide. It finds other explanations.
Speaker 2Right. 100% not. Especially when you don't have a reason to. Initially.
Speaker 1Right, right. So yeah, that's from Reddit. I'll post a link to both the original post and the update.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1Hi, I'm Erin Welsh.
Speaker 2And I'm Erin Allman Updike.
Speaker 1And this is This Podcast Will Kill You.
Speaker 2Welcome to Carbon Monoxide.
Speaker 1To Carbon Monoxide.
Speaker 2Well, clearly this is going to be a good episode, Erin.
Speaker 1I'm already... I mean, I just like... There was... I also found several more first-hand... I mean, several more first-hand accounts, several more that were really tragic because somebody was not recommended a carbon monoxide detector or did not have one or did not make the escape that the person in our first-hand account did. And it's just... Yeah, there's a lot here. It's a It's going to be a strange history for my part anyway. I don't really know. But I'm excited to learn more about like why it causes
Speaker 1these strange symptoms that it does. Yeah.
Speaker 2I don't know that I'm going to have that satisfying of an answer for you, but we'll talk about it.
Speaker 1We'll talk about it at least. But first, it's quarantine time.
Speaker 2It's quarantine time.
Speaker 1Well, what are we drinking this week?
Speaker 2We're drinking Silent But Deadly, which we're pretty sure we've never named a quarantine that before.
Speaker 1We might have named like an episode title this.
Speaker 2Maybe. That's possible.
Speaker 1That's possible. In any case, Silent But Deadly is a cherry milkshake.
Speaker 2Cherry milkshake. You'll know why. It will make sense.
Speaker 1It will make sense later. We'll post the full recipe for Silent But Deadly on our website and all of our socials. So if you're not already following us there, you should be.
Speaker 2You should be. And on our website, it's there. Thispodcastwillkillyou.com. We have a whole bunch of stuff there.
Speaker 1Check it out.
Speaker 2You've heard this spiel before, everyone.
Speaker 1A million times.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1All right. No more business. No more business. Let's get started. Okay.
Speaker 2So carbon monoxide is a gas. Mm-hmm. It is made of one carbon and one oxygen. That's pretty obvious, I think. And it is the product of incomplete combustion of organic compounds. And I don't know a lot about combustion or anything like that. But basically, when we use anything that requires a fire, anything that burns, whether it's our cars, unless you have an electric vehicle, gas stoves, fireplaces, Some portion
Speaker 2of the combustible material is not going to completely burn into CO2 or carbon dioxide gas. And instead, it will form carbon monoxide. Okay. That's the limit of my combustion knowledge, okay?
Speaker 1Great.
Speaker 2This gas, carbon monoxide, is colorless. It is odorless. It is tasteless. And it's not irritating to our mucous membranes in any way, which means it is entirely undetectable by our human senses. And it is incredibly quickly and easily absorbed into our bloodstream when we inhale it, which is how we get exposed.
Speaker 1Is it detectable by other substances? Animal senses?
Speaker 2What a great question. I have literally no idea.
Speaker 1Okay. I know that like other... I mean, any animal will experience symptoms of carbon monoxide poisoning, but I don't know if it has a smell for them. Fascinating.
Speaker 2Yeah. Oh, that's a really interesting... I would have had to Google totally different things than I did. But we cannot detect it. Right.
Speaker 1But.
Speaker 2I'm going to pause right there and take a couple of steps back because I feel like to understand the consequences of carbon monoxide poisoning, which is what we're talking about today, we actually first have to understand a little bit about how our body carries other gases, particularly oxygen and carbon dioxide. Because once we understand that, then we can understand why carbon monoxide causes so many of the consequences that it does when we get exposed to high levels of it. So I think everybody knows that we
Speaker 2all need oxygen to survive. We, our cells, our tissues, we rely on oxidative metabolism. So we have to have oxygen. And as our body uses up that oxygen through metabolism, we create carbon dioxide. And then we have to release that carbon dioxide. So the way this works is that we breathe in oxygen gas to our lungs from the air. Deep in our lungs, past our trachea and our bronchi and our bronchioles, we get to these alveoli, which are
Speaker 2these tiny little grape clusters of air pockets that are surrounded by capillaries, super thin, teeny little blood vessels. In those little grape clusters, alveoli, the concentration of oxygen is going to be really high in that airspace. And the concentration of carbon dioxide in our blood is going to be high because this is all the blood that we used up and has traveled back to our lungs. So we have a switch where oxygen gets forced into our
Speaker 2bloodstream and carbon dioxide is released into the airspace so we can breathe it out. And the oxygen can continue on in our bloodstream to oxygenate all of our tissues. But like many things that we've talked about in our body, Things in our bloodstream generally aren't just floating around in our bloodstream, and oxygen is no exception. It's not just dissolved in our bloodstream. Most of it actually gets attached to a protein called hemoglobin, which is part of our red blood cells. That's why our red blood cells are
Speaker 2the thing that carries oxygen. This protein not only has to grab onto oxygen in our lungs, in the blood in our lungs, but It then has to carry it to all of our tissues and release it at the right time and the right place so that that oxygen can get to where it needs to go. And then it like exchanges it for carbon dioxide and then comes back to our lungs. Right. So you can think of hemoglobin on our red blood cells like a truck that's
Speaker 2carrying packages for delivery. And it has to do both things at the same time. It has to grab and hold on to oxygen really tightly. to be able to carry it from our lungs to our tissues. And then it also has to release it. It has to let it go and deliver it at the right time and place so that our cells can use it. And our body does a really good job of this. We can actually map out these really interesting curves that we call oxygen dissociation curves.
Speaker 1We talked about this in our high altitude, altitude sickness episode. That feels right.
Speaker 2Because basically what that tells us is The pressure of oxygen dissolved in our bloodstream versus the saturation of hemoglobin, how many oxygen molecules are packed on that truck. Right. And when our hemoglobin is going to hang on versus when it's going to release that oxygen. It depends on a whole bunch of things. pH, blah, blah, blah, CO2, temperature. Carbon monoxide screws this whole system up.
Speaker 1It does.
Speaker 2It does.
Speaker 1It does.
Speaker 2Because what carbon monoxide does is it competes with oxygen for space on our hemoglobin molecules. So it literally, the trucks of our hemoglobin get packed with carbon monoxide preferentially. Because the affinity of our hemoglobin for carbon monoxide is over 200 times as great as it is for oxygen. Ooh, that's so bad. It's really bad. So if there's any carbon monoxide there, our hemoglobin is picking that up first
Speaker 2before it loads any oxygen. All right? That's what that means. Okay. So first, that's the first problem, right? If you have carbon monoxide in your lungs, your hemoglobin is going to pick that up, which means that we are loading less oxygen onto our hemoglobin trucks. So less oxygen is going to be able to go through our bloodstream and make it to our tissues.
Speaker 1But wait, there's more. Of course.
Speaker 2In doing this, what also happens is that that oxygen dissociation curve that I talked about gets shifted so that even though our hemoglobin is carrying oxygen, it will not give it up as easily if it's also carrying carbon monoxide.
Speaker 1Okay. It wants to cling tightly to carbon monoxide, but it's clinging to everything. Everything.
Speaker 2So even though it's like twofold, our trucks are not carrying as much oxygen. And once they get to the point of delivery, they're not offloading that oxygen as readily. So what that means is that when we are exposed, especially to high levels of carbon monoxide, our tissues end up literally starved of oxygen. And that is the main consequence that we see from carbon monoxide. You get the formation of these carbon monoxide and hemoglobin bonds, and that leads to hypoxia. Our tissues lack oxygen. It's not just hemoglobin.
Speaker 2Carbon monoxide also binds to other proteins in our body that also contain that heme protein. So it's like the same protein, it's just on other things.
Speaker 1One of them is.
Speaker 2Myoglobin, which is a protein in our heart and our skeletal muscle. It does the same thing. It's binding to it, and it's disrupting the way that it is supposed to work and leading to hypoxia. Carbon monoxide also binds to this enzyme called cytochrome C oxidase, which is involved in our mitochondrial function. Our mitochondria, the powerhouse of.
Speaker 1The cell, are.
Speaker 2Sorry. I'm fining you for that. But these are what literally produce energy. And so by carbon monoxide binding to this enzyme, we are literally reducing the amount of energy that we can produce, which further ends up causing hypoxia. Like all of this ends up with our cells and our tissues are not able to function the way they're supposed to. We also see things like platelet activation. We see free radical formation. We see inflammation. So there's a
Speaker 2lot of damage that happens to our tissues from hypoxia itself. And then from all these other downstream effects that are happening from carbon monoxide binding to stuff that it doesn't belong. Okay.
Speaker 1How is it getting to these proteins? It's a great question.
Speaker 2So because we are inhaling it the same way that we inhale oxygen and nitrogen gas through the air, it is being forced into our bloodstream the same way that any other of these gases are. Okay.
Speaker 1So it's just like there's loose molecules of carbon monoxide. And then when they find these different heme proteins or cytochrome C, then that's what happens.
Speaker 2Then they're going to bind to it.
Speaker 1Yeah. So the other question I have is about is twofold. Well, it's timeline of this. So like when these symptoms start to develop and then the concentration at which symptoms appear and resolution.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1Is it cumulative? Is it chronic?
Speaker 2You know, yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2These are all really, really good questions. And I don't have perfect answers for them. So carbon monoxide concentrations in our atmosphere, let's say just like outside or walking around or something like that, Typical atmospheric concentrations range anywhere from 0.03 to 0.2 parts per million. So it's there, we're always breathing it in, but at very low levels. One paper that I read suggested that in most households, so indoor air with adequate ventilation, If you do not have a gas stove, which is obviously going to be a
Speaker 2potential source of carbon monoxide, then you're usually looking at like 0.5 to 5 parts per million in your house.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 2If you do have a gas stove, but it's well ventilated, then we're talking maybe 5 to 15 parts per million in your house. One of the big ways that we look at like how can we decide how much is too much or how much should we be exposed to is we look at like OSHA guidelines, which is Occupational Health and Safety guidelines. The World Health Organization recommends in 24 hours no more than 7 parts per million should we be exposed to on average in 24 hours.
Speaker 1So our first-hand account who had 100 parts per million?
Speaker 2That's very high. The World Health Organization recommends that you should be exposed to 100 parts per million for no more than 15 minutes. Uh-huh.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 2Now, the EPA through the United States of America has higher limits for workers. So they say that workers should be exposed to no more than 50 parts per million averaged over an eight-hour workday with an upper limit of 200 parts per million over a 15-minute period. Now that's higher than the World Health Organization. Why?
Speaker 1I don't know. Have those changed?
Speaker 2That was the most recent. That's the World Health Organization paper that I read was actually a bit old. The OSHA was updated like this year. So the EPA recommendations. You've got links to all of that if you want to read more. But so anyway, so that's like how much we're exposed to. I have a really hard time. understanding parts per million concentrations because like it's not very meaningful to me. It's also not like that easy to say this many parts per million equals these symptoms in people,
Speaker 2if that makes sense. Because the way that we're going to measure someone's exposure is actually by measuring the amount of carboxyhemoglobin. That is those hemoglobin molecules with carbon monoxide attached to them. And that level, first of all, varies drastically with time from exposure. So you could be exposed to a really high concentration, but within a few hours, your amount of that carboxyhemoglobin is going to drop. And other people, for example, people who smoke cigarettes are constantly
Speaker 2being exposed to pretty high levels of carbon monoxide. So their blood levels of carboxyhemoglobin are.
Speaker 1Actually quite high.
Speaker 2Right. So typical blood concentrations in people who do not smoke range from 0.5 to 1.5% of your blood. that's how much carboxyhemoglobin you have in your bloodstream.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 2People who smoke really heavily might have up to 15% carboxyhemoglobin, whereas people who smoke maybe one or two packs a day might be somewhere from like 3% to 8% carboxyhemoglobin. But most people are going to start to experience symptoms if their carboxyhemoglobin levels rise to about 10% to 15% or greater. Okay. That's for most people if they're not chronically exposed.
Speaker 1If they're not chronically exposed.
Speaker 2And the issue of chronic versus like acute exposure, we don't really have good data on that, which is really interesting, especially when you think about like a carbon monoxide detector is generally detecting levels above that 100 or so parts per million because that's the level at which we know for sure you can have acute carbon monoxide poisoning.
Speaker 1I see.
Speaker 2But it's not necessarily detecting 20, 30, 40, 50 parts per million, which over time could have effects, which is why the World Health Organization recommends that we not be exposed to that much. But we're not necessarily monitoring for that, if that makes sense, except maybe in an industrial context.
Speaker 1Interesting. I don't know. I just assumed that carbon monoxide detectors would detect carbon monoxide. I mean, and they do, but like it's at a threshold.
Speaker 2Right. Exactly.
Speaker 1I guess I would have just assumed the threshold would be slightly lower.
Speaker 2Yeah. Most of that. I mean, it's going to vary by, you know. detector, of course, as well, too. But in general, the point of a carbon monoxide detector, at least residentially, is to detect a level at which you need to get out of the house.
Speaker 1You need to get out of the house.
Speaker 2You need to do something, right? Okay.
Speaker 1So then that leads me to another question, and that is diagnosis. So if somebody shows up to the ER and they have these symptoms and they don't know, for example, that they have been exposed to high levels of carbon monoxide, what do physicians look out for? Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 2This is a really good and really important question. The way that we diagnose it is generally by measuring those carboxyhemoglobin levels, which means that you have to think of it and then you have to measure it. Let's talk about the symptoms because we actually haven't yet. And you'll see why this can be such a really hard question, actually, because the symptoms are very nonspecific, especially in that acute exposure phase. So often we're going to see headache. We're going to see nausea, maybe vomiting. We might see an
Speaker 2increase in heart rate or sometimes an increase in breathing rate, which is kind of our body trying to compensate for that lack of oxygen. Yeah. Kind of pumping blood a little bit faster, forcing oxygen to our tissues. As the symptoms get more severe, meaning if you've been exposed either for longer durations or to higher concentrations of carbon monoxide, we can start to see pretty severe neurologic effects. So that might mean syncope, passing out. it might mean seizures, and it can end up meaning coma. And often the reason that we see this is because the blood vessels
Speaker 2in our brain become very dilated, in part directly due to the effects of carbon monoxide, which is a vasodilator, but also in part as our body trying to compensate shunting as much blood as possible to this vital organ, our brain. But what happens when the blood vessels in our brain start to dilate is that, like all blood vessels, they become leaky. And so that can lead to edema or swelling in the brain. So that is why we see such severe neurologic complications from carbon monoxide, both from
Speaker 2lack of oxygen and from this swelling that happens in the brain. We also see a lot of effects on the heart because, again, lack of oxygen— your heart needs a lot of oxygen— And because carbon monoxide is going to be attaching to the myoglobin itself. So it's going to be causing direct damage to the heart cells, to the heart muscle. And so we can see arrhythmias. We can see things that look like heart attack. So ischemia to different parts of the heart, even though you don't have any blockage in your arteries. It's just from the carbon monoxide.
Speaker 2And so then people can die from things like cardiac arrest as well, too. Often, we can see that some things like motor function, can start to be impaired slowly and before you have like loss of consciousness. So someone might notice like things feel off. I don't feel right, but I'm not able to like move fast enough. I'm not able to do the things that I need to do to improve ventilation, to get myself out of this situation. And it's because of just overall the effects that this
Speaker 2carbon monoxide is having. The things that you learn in medical school about how to pick out carbon monoxide poisoning from anything else actually don't happen all that often. Because what we learn in medical school are cherry red lips.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 2Hence the cherry milkshake for our quarantini. We also see cyanosis or like purple or blue extremities, fingers, lips, toes, things like that. And then sometimes hemorrhages in the eye or in the retina. But even those are not that specific and they're certainly not happening in all cases of carbon monoxide poisoning. So it can be really difficult in the emergency room or in, you know, an office setting to know and to think of, could this be carbon monoxide? So it really comes down to exposure.
Speaker 1Most often.
Speaker 2Commonly people are exposed in something like a fire. So that you're going to have paramedics on scene who hopefully are going to be able to detect carbon monoxide with devices at the scene and know what the levels were there.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 2But it can be really hard in other circumstances. Like in the firsthand account where it was this chronic exposure, that would be a lot trickier to actually detect in an emergency room setting.
Speaker 1Which is very scary.
Speaker 2Yeah, it's really scary.
Speaker 1Because there's not like these... Especially if somebody came to the emergency room, if that person went to the emergency room and said, without knowing they were exposed to carbon monoxide, and said, my landlord's leaving Post-it notes, they would be like, let's get your psych eval.
Speaker 2They would say, you're having a psychotic episode. Well, and here, this is yet another interesting thing that can happen from carbon monoxide exposure, whether acute or chronic. And again, we don't have great data on chronic exposures or what level constitutes, et cetera, et cetera. But- After an exposure to high levels where you have carbon monoxide poisoning, right, you're sick enough, you go to the emergency room, something bad happens. Even if you recover, something like 10 to 40 percent of people actually end up having delayed onset neuropsychiatric symptoms. Really?
Speaker 2This could mean depression. This could mean Parkinsonism. This could mean dementia. This could mean psychosis, right? And we don't really understand who this is going to happen to, why exactly this is going to happen, or is it a specific level of exposure? Is it a time of exposure? We really don't understand these delayed cognitive and neuropsychiatric effects that we see, but they are definitely a thing that is real and that happens.
Speaker 1Yeah. And how is this treated?
Speaker 2Great question. The only treatment that we have is oxygen. And what oxygen is going to do is by forcing 100% oxygen into your lungs, you increase the concentration of oxygen and literally just try to out-compete carbon monoxide on your hemoglobin. So if you are just breathing regular room air, which is like 20% oxygen, then the half-life of carbon monoxide on your hemoglobin is usually about four to six hours. So you will eventually get rid of all that carbon monoxide.
Speaker 2If you're breathing 100% oxygen, then that decreases the half-life to about 40 to 80 minutes. So you can offload that carbon monoxide a lot faster. When people have really severe symptoms, either really high levels of carboxyhemoglobin above like 30, 40, 50%, or if they are comatose from exposure to carbon monoxide, Or if they're pregnant, because pregnant people are at particularly high risk of carbon monoxide poisoning, the fetus specifically is
Speaker 2at really high risk of hypoxia from this. It's because of their fetal hemoglobin. It's interesting, but too much. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. Because it already doesn't give up oxygen as easily. That's right. That's right. So at a lower level of carboxyhemoglobin if you're pregnant, then you might be recommended to get hyperbaric oxygen, which we talked about in one of our episodes. Wounds? Maggots? Wounds. Maggots.
Speaker 1Maggots.
Speaker 2Something like that.
Speaker 1It wouldn't have been the bends, right? Yeah, probably was. Of course it was, Erin.
Speaker 2So yeah, so hyperbaric oxygen essentially is even further increasing the amount of oxygen that we're forcing into your lungs. And so in those cases, we can actually decrease the half-life to like 15 to 30 minutes and push off that carbon monoxide a lot faster.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 2But that's if you have access to a hyperbaric oxygen chamber, which not everyone does.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 2But that's the only treatment. We don't have anything else.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 2We don't have any other way to like metabolize the carboxyhemoglobin or any other drugs or medications. It's just oxygen.
Speaker 1Whoa.
Speaker 2I know. I know. And that's carbon monoxide, Erin.
Speaker 1I mean, honestly, I just want to keep hearing about the numbers and stuff like that, but I should tell you about the history. Please. Would you? Please. Yeah, I will.
Speaker 2I will. I will.
Speaker 1Haunted houses, coal mine canaries, mysterious maritime disasters, the history of carbon monoxide. is steeped in tragedy, where fables teach cautionary tales about lighting a fire without ventilation or communing with demons, and science shines a light on the previously unexplainable. From the dawn of fire, which we learned in our first burns episode was about 400 million years ago, creatures have been contending with the threats posed by carbon monoxide intoxication.
Speaker 1And in the case of humans and our hominin ancestors, that means as long as we've been controlling fire, perhaps as long as one and a half million years, we've not only had to deal with burns, but also this potentially toxic compound as well, especially if burning a fire in an area with poor ventilation is such as caves, which were great, you know, residences for our ancestors. 100%.
Speaker 2Yeah, you're protected from the weather, and then you are exposed to carbon monoxide.
Speaker 1Yeah, I read a short little note to the editor in a science journal that pondered whether artists of cave paintings, like those in the Pyrenees in France and Spain, may have suffered the negative effects of carbon monoxide as they worked on their masterpieces because lighting was provided by the only available source, which was fire.
Speaker 2Fire, yeah.
Speaker 1Isn't that really interesting?
Speaker 2That is really interesting.
Speaker 1Yeah. I mean, surely humans or our ancestors quickly grew aware of the hazards of fires in close quarters. But since carbon monoxide is colorless, odorless, tasteless, what did they think that it was?
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 1Ghosts? Gods? Evil spirits? I mean, many cultures hold beliefs that on very cold nights where you might be burning a larger or more intense fire than usual— demons. That's when demons come to carry away the very young and the very old. There are ancient Greek and Roman scholars that had their own theories and made their own recommendations. So Aristotle wrote that, quote, coal fumes lead to heavy head and death, end quote. And Hippocrates recommended sleeping in a large room so that you could breathe pure air
Speaker 1rather than a smaller room, which was more likely to fill with toxic smoke and fumes from heating sources. So like this was kind of I mean, common knowledge in a way. Interesting. Lung damage, neurotoxicity, disturbance of motion, and death were also all noted as potential side effects of cold fumes by ancient Roman scholars. And in the 11th century, the famous Persian physician Avicenna described the paralysis that can result. And by the late 1500s, other hallmark symptoms like Fever, vomiting,
Speaker 1and cherry red skin had been noted by various scholars. I mean, I didn't include any of this in my notes, but I read an article that was really, really tragic. It was about a family that had experienced carbon monoxide poisoning. They had called 911. It turns out other people in the hotel where they were staying had also called 911. And so the wrong family was taken away or a different family was taken away anyway. But they all called because they thought we have the flu. Like we're all vomiting. We have fevers. We feel nauseous. We have the flu. Anyway,
Speaker 1but like. It just shows how easily it can be mistaken for other things.
Speaker 2Right. Especially if you don't like I think we think of it if there is a gas fireplace or something that is like actively burning. But if there's not that, then why would you think of it?
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1When there's no smoking gun.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1But unfortunately, all of this knowledge, the knowledge we have today, as well as the knowledge that these ancient scholars had, it came at a cost. So in order to describe the symptoms of carbon monoxide poisoning, people had to, of course, experience the poisoning. So for example, the bright red skin sign or the bright red lip sign was noted as indicative of carbon monoxide in 1570 after a group of inmates had tried to escape by melting the prison bars, but instead a wooden frame caught on fire and they died of the resulting smoke. And I should also note
Speaker 1here that people weren't calling this carbon monoxide poisoning. It was more like These symptoms appear due to the negative effects of being exposed to coal fumes or fumes from fire.
Speaker 2Smoke fumes.
Speaker 1Right, right, right.
Speaker 2And it's probably, I didn't even mention this, but like when it's fire, there's a lot of other things going on.
Speaker 1There's a lot.
Speaker 2It's only carbon monoxide.
Speaker 1Yes, yeah.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 1There were many isolated incidents, as there are today, you know, individual cases or household cases. But there were also larger scale tragedies over history, like leaks in heating systems in Roman bathhouses that caused deaths by suffocation of those who were in there. And these cases were not all solely accidental. So Hannibal's armies around 200 BCE reportedly executed Roman prisoners with carbon monoxide bombs. And in fact, carbon monoxide poisoning
Speaker 1was not an uncommon form of capital punishment. Whoa. So, quote, the greenest possible wood capable of producing the most smoke. That was like the methodology for execution.
Speaker 2That's dark.
Speaker 1And it was also commonly used as a method of suicide, including possibly by Cleopatra and by Roman philosopher Seneca. So people were using carbon monoxide, or more specifically, the toxic fumes from coal and other fires, intentionally to cause harm and death. But there still persisted a belief that supernatural forces were behind the poisonings.
Speaker 2Interesting.
Speaker 1Which, honestly, it's totally understandable. Given our firsthand account, that sounds like a haunting, right?
Speaker 2A hundred percent, yes.
Speaker 1There's this handwriting, or it sounds like something nefarious is going on. Yeah. heating sources were ubiquitous, right? You got to have heat. And people weren't getting poisoned all of the time. And so cause effect was more difficult to tease apart.
Speaker 2Yeah, you can't just say one to one.
Speaker 1Right. When was lighting a fire or a lamp okay? And when wasn't it? And so stories of death that in retrospect could be ascribed to carbon monoxide poisonings were often told to teach like a moral lesson or to prove the existence of ghosts or just give people the heebie-jeebies. So take, for example, this story from Germany in 1715. A student, it's like, it's one of these like legends, right? A student promised a couple of farmers that he'd share a treasure with them on the condition that they come
Speaker 1with him on Christmas night to a little hut in a vineyard. And at midnight, the student would call to the spirits to tell him where the treasure was buried, and then they would all dig it up together. But Christmas, Germany, wintertime. Pre-climate change, things were pretty cold. And so it was getting very, very, very chilly. So the three of them lit a fire in this hut to warm themselves as they waited for the spirits to arrive. Whether they communed with the spirits remains a mystery because none of the
Speaker 1three survived to tell their tale, their version of events. They were all found dead the next morning. Wow. And we know today that carbon monoxide poisoning from the fire was a likely culprit. But at the time, and for years after, the story was told as a cautionary tale that evil and death awaits those who call upon the devil.
Speaker 2Interesting.
Speaker 1So it's a fable, kind of. There's a moral meaning to it.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1The belief that malevolent spirits cause these deaths was so widespread, even apparently among the medical establishment, that German physician Friedrich Hoffman felt it necessary to publish a paper on this case. And he was anonymous. He like wrote it anonymously where he outlined the effects of carbon monoxide or smoke, you know, the hazardous smoke. And denied that there was any involvement by the devil.
Speaker 2Quote, End quote.
Speaker 1Mining deaths, which mining is one of the oldest professions. were also attributed to malicious supernatural spirits over the ages, and miners would pray or fast to try to protect themselves from demonic harm. So when Joseph Priestley discovered carbon
Speaker 1monoxide in either 1772 or 1796, there seems to be some disagreement on what counts. It doesn't matter. Okay. It came at a time when interest in chemistry and physics and the natural sciences was mounting. And Priestley's works on carbon monoxide were in– it was in no way an isolated event. Several scientists either picked up on his research where he left off or were simultaneously working on teasing apart the different characteristics of the compound, including those that
Speaker 1made it toxic to humans and other animals. In 1800, William Cruikshank resolved the formula of carbon monoxide and gave it its name, gaseous oxide of carbon. It was only later, starting around 1879, that carbon monoxide began to be used, by which time the pathophysiology of carbon monoxide poisoning had largely begun to be figured out. Pinning down what exactly carbon monoxide was, how it worked, and the settings leading to exposure, it helped to shed light on past mysteries.
Speaker 1such as what exactly had happened to the English sailor Sir Hugh Willoughby and the 62 men who traveled with him on the Bona Esperanza and the Bona Confidentia in 1553 to find the Northeast Passage. You know that I love a maritime disaster.
Speaker 2You love a maritime disaster, especially like the North.
Speaker 1The North. I mean, the terror is like peak. Yeah, just I'm fascinated by it. But yeah, so this he... this this captain and his 62 men all perished. They found the ship in the bodies and they were like people who first found it were like, I think it was exposure. I think it was scurvy, you know, things that did happen. But Exposure deaths actually seem to be fairly rare. Scurvy deaths were certainly not, but like... But it.
Speaker 2Wouldn't have happened all at once.
Speaker 1Exactly.
Speaker 2Scurvy isn't like a mass killer in that way.
Speaker 1It's not like a massive onset, right?
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1And then everyone just dies at once. Right.
Speaker 2It would be like people... Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah. See our scurvy episode.
Speaker 1See our scurvy episode. It's one of our faves.
Speaker 2It is.
Speaker 1But yeah, so there was a more recent hypothesis, I think actually just like a few decades ago, that placed the blame for their sudden and near simultaneous death on carbon monoxide. They're trying to stay warm in the frozen winter months. I don't know if I think they were like locked in the ice. Light a fire inside this cabin. It's well sealed because it's a ship. Right.
Speaker 2And then everyone.
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah. And carbon monoxide and understanding its pathophysiology, it provided a scientific explanation for paranormal encounters. A famous example of this is the 1913 science article, like article published in Science, titled An Investigation of a, quote unquote, haunted house. The author, Franz Schneider Jr. from MIT, he was called to a house in Boston, which was, quote, acquiring an unfortunate and annoying reputation as being haunted, end quote. The
Speaker 1occupants of the house who lived on the third and fourth floors described strange sensations and sounds that kept them from sleeping throughout the night, especially on cold evenings. Quote, it was said to be a common occurrence for servants to awake in the night with a sensation of oppression, as if someone were tapping upon me or with a creeping feeling going all over me with a feeling of being paralyzed, end quote. Sounds like a haunted house.
Speaker 2It sounds like a haunted house to me.
Speaker 1They experienced delusions. Like one of the children rushed into the nurse's room saying that a man woke him up and scared him. And the children were slow moving and pale in the morning and were more and more difficult to rouse with cold water. This had been going on for a couple of months that the family had been living there. They were just recent tenants. And apparently the previous tenants also experienced similar occurrences, lending support to the haunted house notion. Everyone who comes to stay here experiences someone creeping into their room at night. So it has
Speaker 1to be the house. It has to be the house. Yeah. When the author arrived at the house to trace the origin of what he suspected was a gas leak, he found a, quote, viciously defective hot air furnace, end quote, leaking loads of gas and carbon monoxide. At the end of the article, he says that this case should be interesting to those investigating psychic phenomena since the haunting at this house was readily explained by the inhalation of carbon monoxide.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1And another great example, just because like I I've heard this before that like so many haunted houses can be explained by carbon monoxide.
Speaker 2That's so interesting, Erin. I don't think I knew that.
Speaker 1And I don't know how many of them actually were. There's an interesting paper I read too that was like, let's look at the environmental epidemiology or something of haunted houses and what it could be. How does humidity play a role? How does carbon monoxide play a role? Temperature, things like that.
Speaker 2All the different things.
Speaker 1Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. But so then I tried to find more examples. So there was another one in 1921, a paper in the American Journal of Ophthalmology titled Effects of Carbon Monoxide Upon the Eye by W.H. Wilmer. And he details a very similar case of a haunted house. Hearing things go bump in the night, listless children, seeing apparitions, feeling like someone was sitting on their chests as they slept. The previous tenants experiencing the exact same symptoms. And it was
Speaker 1all traced to carbon monoxide poisoning.
Speaker 2Fascinating.
Speaker 1Yeah. So how many haunted houses or paranormal experiences then and now can be explained by carbon monoxide? Yeah. More than a few. If you think you are living in a haunted house, buy a carbon monoxide detector.
Speaker 2This is not a medical advice podcast, but everyone should have carbon monoxide detectors.
Speaker 1Everyone should have a carbon monoxide.
Speaker 2Yes. Yes.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1Understanding carbon monoxide and the risks that it posed, it helped not only to explain these mysterious occurrences, but also to intervene and prevent further harm or poisoning from happening in the first place. So by the early 20th century, carbon monoxide had earned a deadly reputation among the general public, referred to by a couple of scientists as the, quote, Frankenstein of civilization, the automaton that turns on its maker, pursues him to the ends of the earth and finally destroys him, end quote. It's a little dramatic.
Speaker 2That feels extreme.
Speaker 1Well, I think it was like, so if you think about this time, cars were becoming to be more of a thing. And so the exhaust that was produced, inefficient.
Speaker 2And this is before the carburetors or whatever it's called. Sure.
Speaker 1There's something in cars now. I don't know enough about the history of cars.
Speaker 2Catalytic converter.
Speaker 1Catalytic converter, yes.
Speaker 2That was before catalytic converters. And now they burn much cleaner, even though they're still terrible.
Speaker 1Yeah, they're still carbon monoxide. But then it was like, we are poisoning our planet. And so it was like a huge, yeah, a huge deal. That makes more sense now. Yeah. The Frankenstein.
Speaker 2The Frankenstein.
Speaker 1But public awareness could only go so far, right? And precise diagnostic tools and at-home affordable carbon monoxide detectors were still decades away. I think specifically the 1970s is when diagnostic tools emerged and the 1990s is when at-home carbon monoxide detectors became more readily available. Okay. That's recent. And so carbon monoxide poisoning were still quite common and quite deadly, especially in industrial settings like mining. Where high concentrations of deadly gases could be found and finding fresh air to
Speaker 1escape the carbon monoxide was much more difficult than if you were just on the surface and you could leave the room, leave the house.
Speaker 2You're trying to go up, up, up.
Speaker 1Hundreds of miners died every year in cave-ins and explosions and from exposures to deadly gases like carbon monoxide. And in the later decades of the 1800s, Increasing rates of industrialization brought things to a fever pitch. There had to be some way to mitigate at least some of these dangers. Enter the pit canary. Canaries had been a popular pet since at least the 1500s throughout Europe, brightening any home with its lovely little singing voice. But in the mines,
Speaker 1these birds offered more than companionship. They saved lives. Bird respiration is really fascinating and is quite different than mammal respiration. The long and short of it, I was like, should I explain bird respiration? I don't think I'm equipped to. Yeah, I don't think I'm equipped to. The long and short of it is that the way that it works is that these birds are very, very efficient. At taking in oxygen. Okay. More efficient than we are with our mammal lungs. Okay. And that also makes them super efficient at taking in
Speaker 1airborne toxins such as carbon monoxide. And so if carbon monoxide is present, a canary, a bird, will show signs of poisoning before a human will.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 1Acting as kind of like an early carbon monoxide detector in a grim, grim way.
Speaker 2Very grim.
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah. To give you a sense of timing, apparently it was reported that a canary would faint or fall off its perch about 20 minutes before a human would faint.
Speaker 2That's enough time to run away. That's enough time to run away. Exactly.
Speaker 1And also, these birds were not just seen as these detectors. They were loved. They were beloved by the miners.
Speaker 2You have talked about canaries before. on this podcast before because I remember you talking about how much the minors loved them.
Speaker 1What? I don't remember this, Erin. Oh, no.
Speaker 2I wonder, was it the Benz or was it, it couldn't have been the Benz. I don't remember what, someone who knows our podcast better than we do, what episode was it? Because I swear the thought of you talking about minors and specifically that they loved these canaries and they weren't just like these throwaway things. I remember you talking about this.
Speaker 1I'm going to go to our transcripts right now and see if I can search this because this is going to, I genuinely have, I mean, like my memory is so bad when it comes to this podcast. I'm like, did we cover things?
Speaker 2Am I, what do you call it? Manufacturing a memory?
Speaker 1I don't see anything in our transcripts, but oh, maybe they're not all there. I don't know, Erin.
Speaker 2I don't know either.
Speaker 1Let us know if somebody finds it.
Speaker 2I love this.
Speaker 1Keep going.
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 1So yeah, these canaries were beloved by these miners. And so if a bird did faint, it wasn't just, oh my gosh, I got to save myself. Of course it was that, but it was let's go revive the canary. And so they like had these little revival devices that they had also with them.
Speaker 2I did not know that.
Speaker 1It's really, yeah, it's really cute. And so officially the first recommendation for the use of canaries in coal mines came in 1894 by J.S. Haldane after a Welsh mining disaster in which both miners and volunteer rescuers died from carbon monoxide poisoning. But based on other writings and references to these birds in coal mines, it's likely that they were used possibly since the early 1800s. Hmm. But yeah, miners grew quite attached to these creatures. Like I saw a picture of one tiny coffin. It was inscribed with,
Speaker 1in memory of little Joe, died November 3rd, 1875, aged three years. Oh my gosh. I know. It made me want to cry. And yeah, these little resuscitation chambers, there's also a picture of these that are really, really just incredible. Some mining companies constructed aviaries on site to breed canaries for the mines. And these birds were used as late as the 1980s. Really? Until they were phased out as more precise electronic monitoring devices were introduced. Also, it was like,
Speaker 1we're not going to put these creatures. Human rights.
Speaker 2Or, I mean, animal rights.
Speaker 1Animal rights, yeah. Into these situations. Right, right, right. And so nowadays, the canary in the coal mine only exists as a useful phrase. Reports of fever of unknown origin, coral reef bleaching. You get the idea. Like these are all the canaries in the coal mine signifying what's to come. This summer is a canary in the coal mine for 100%.
Speaker 2All of the fires burning around the entire world right now.
Speaker 1Yes. Yep. But once upon a time, these birds were really the only thing standing between a miner and disaster from carbon monoxide. Over the course of the 20th century, deaths due to carbon monoxide fell, actually, quite a bit, in part due to a broader switch from coal to natural gas, as well as improvements in treating poisonings, better diagnostics, and greater public awareness. Awareness is such a critical component to this.
Speaker 2It's huge.
Speaker 1Huge. And of course, these poisonings have not disappeared entirely, as you're about to tell us, Erin. And many lives could be saved by installing monitoring devices in homes and workplaces. But as overall poisonings fell, there simultaneously was a growth in the possible benefits of carbon monoxide. Like how can we use it to treat cancer or inflammation? I don't know if you're going to talk about any of these things.
Speaker 2That's my ending because it astounded me, Erin.
Speaker 1Yes. Me too. Okay. So I was like, I hope that Aaron's going to talk about this because I have no other way to end this like hodgepodge of history for carbon monoxide. So turn it over to you, Aaron.
Speaker 2Let me tell you about the terrible things first, Erin.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 2And that is that carbon monoxide remains one of the most common causes of morbidity due to poisoning, not just in the U.S., but around the globe. One paper that I saw out of Japan said that carbon monoxide poisoning counts for over half of the total number of poisoning deaths every year in Japan.
Speaker 1Whoa.
Speaker 2In the U.S., many years ago, it was reported that there was around 600 accidental deaths due to carbon monoxide every year. However, intentional deaths due to carbon monoxide are 5 to 10 times higher. Mm-hmm. There are up to 15,000 cases of carbon monoxide poisoning that are intentional every year, which is so devastating. Mm-hmm. And a paper from 2017 estimated that there's about 50,000 cases total of carbon monoxide
Speaker 2poisonings in the U.S. every year, with mortality rates that still remain between 1 and 3 percent. So overall, mortality rates have been on the decline globally for carbon monoxide mortality, but the rates of poisonings have actually been fairly stable for the last several decades. And they tend to be highest overall in low and middle income countries. And mortality rates are also much higher in low and middle income countries where people are often cooking over, say, open fires
Speaker 2or just have less food. fuels that burn less cleanly so that they produce a lot more carbon monoxide. So things like natural gas and propane produce a lot less carbon monoxide than things like coal or firewood or gasoline and things like that. So this is definitely still a huge issue worldwide. And like you said, Erin, prevention and public awareness are some of the most important things because we don't have any treatments for carbon monoxide poisoning other
Speaker 2than access to oxygen, which requires access to a hospital. So that means things like inspection and maintenance of appliances. That means things like ventilation for any kind of device that is going to have fire. And it means the knowledge that when things get cold, when their, you know, power goes out and things like that, that gas powered devices are not safe to be used indoors because we see, especially in northern latitudes, when Things get cold. People bring
Speaker 2space heaters, gas power generators, and things like that indoors. And then we see accidents because of that. Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2So that is where carbon monoxide poisoning stands today. But I learned something new, Erin, which you mentioned. And that is that people are really interested in using carbon monoxide for good. As a therapeutic.
Speaker 1Astonishing.
Speaker 2It is astonishing. So the reason that people started to think about this and figure this out is not just because of carbon monoxide poisoning, but is actually because our body at baseline produces small amounts of carbon monoxide. We produce carbon monoxide actually through the breakdown of heme, the protein on hemoglobin that carries carbon monoxide. And it's not because it's carrying carbon monoxide. It's just because when you break it down, you get iron and biliverdin and carbon monoxide.
Speaker 1Okay. Okay.
Speaker 2And it turns out that we probably use carbon monoxide or the function of carbon monoxide in our body at low levels, like the amount that we're producing, which is very low compared to what you're getting if you, you know, inhale a lot of carbon monoxide from an unventilated source of fire, right? is very similar to nitric oxide, which we also produce, and is used already in therapeutics for things like pulmonary hypertension for preemie babies and things like that.
Speaker 2But basically, carbon monoxide can act as a vasodilator. Okay. It can also affect our inflammatory cascade and our inflammation system. It's potentially also used in our bodies endogenously as a neurotransmitter. So there is a lot of interest in using this for the treatment of a lot of vascular diseases, for the treatment of inflammatory conditions, and just like Just the
Speaker 2idea that we could use something that I have only ever thought of as a poison as a therapeutic is super fascinating. As far as I could tell, it's still, like, very early stages. I saw, like, a phase one trial, and that's about it. So I don't know that it's actually being used anywhere at this point, but there is certainly a lot of really interesting research going on on this molecule.
Speaker 1It is so cool. It's so cool. And, like, I can't wrap my head around how— it would work the administration. How do you localize it?
Speaker 2That's one of the big things. Like what I saw the phase one trial was like a slow inhaled product, which is really interesting. But I think that that's one of the big things. It's like, how exactly do we use this? Where are we targeting it? What are we targeting it for? And so I think there's still a lot of work to be done on like, how? How do we actually do that?
Speaker 1Yeah. I mean, it is really interesting to think about like, there's more to the story than just poisonings.
Speaker 2Isn't there always, Erin?
Speaker 1There is.
Speaker 2The dose makes the poison, etc.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Speaker 2So if you'd like to learn more, there is a lot more there.
Speaker 1There is. There is.
Speaker 2We can tell you all of our sources.
Speaker 1I have a bunch of sources. I'm going to shout out just a few. So if you want to learn more about just like general carbon monoxide history, there's a paper by Kashfi and Patel from 2022 called Carbon Monoxide and Its Role in Human Physiology, A Brief Historical Perspective. Then if you want to learn about canaries and coal mines, there's a paper by Pollock from 2016 called The Canary in the Coal Mine. the Journal of Avian Medicine and Surgery. And then if you really should, it's a fascinating paper on the haunted house from 1913 by Schneider, An Investigation
Speaker 1of a Haunted House Published in Science. I'll post all of them on our website. Yeah.
Speaker 2I had just a few papers actually for this, fewer than typical, but There was one from 1998 by Ernst and Zebrak from the New England Journal of Medicine just called Carbon Monoxide Poisoning. It's super straightforward. It tells you what you need to know. There was a more updated one that goes into a lot more detail on some of the effects other than just on hemoglobin, which was by Rose et al. from 2017 called Carbon Monoxide Poisoning Pathogenesis Management and Future Directions. And then I've got links to the World Health Organization guidelines for indoor air quality,
Speaker 2the EPA and OSHA recommendations, and then two papers on the therapeutics use of carbon monoxide, one from Nature Reviews Drug Discovery from 2010, and then an updated one from just last year or the year before. You can find the list of sources from this episode and every single one of our episodes on our website, thispodcastwillkillyou.com.
Speaker 1You certainly can. Big thank you to Bloodmobile for providing the music for this episode and all of our episodes.
Speaker 2Thank you to Liana and Tom and Mark and Pete and Jessica and Christina and everyone else. I know exactly right.
Speaker 1Everyone, everyone.
Speaker 2For all the work that you do to make this possible.
Speaker 1Yes. And thank you to you listeners for also making this possible. Just the fact that you tune in is still incredible. It is. to us so thank you thank.
Speaker 2You tell your friends and that you're watching on youtube thank you so much we love it um thank you as always especially to our patrons for your support over on patreon it means more than we can say
Speaker 1Truly truly well until next time wash your hands you filthy animals
Having just experienced humanity’s latest pandemic, you might wonder when (not if) the next one is coming. Many public health experts believe we have entered into a new age of pandemics, where globalization, land use...
It’s got all the ingredients for a classic TPWKY episode: Deadly zoonotic bacterium (Burkholderia mallei). Tier 1 Select Agent role in war (greatest risk from a bioterrorism perspective). Historically caused devastating...
Since his first appearance in A Study in Scarlet in 1887, Sherlock Holmes has captured hearts and imaginations around the world. Featured in countless tv shows, movies, books, plays, comic books, songs, and other media,...
Looking to get swole (do people still say that)? Want to rewind the clock and smooth those bothersome wrinkles? Trying to lose weight rapidly and without a prescription? If you’ve spent any time on social media lately,...
Come one, come all to learn of the miraculous news we’re buzzing to share with you at this limited time, low price offer. If you’ve been troubled by aches and pains, sores and sneezes, look no further than this very...