Thinks Out Loud: E-commerce and Digital Strategy

Traffic Is Down. Revenue Is Up. Clicks Are Overrated. (Digital Reset Foundations Episode 512)
Quick show of hands. How many of you have sat in a meeting where somebody said traffic is down and then treated it like the building was on fire? Tim’s not convinced that’s the right approach. Traffic is a means to an end. The end goal always is revenue. And increasingly, traffic and revenue are decoupling in ways that should change how you measure success. AI Overviews and AI Mode have made that decoupling even more dramatic since this episode was first recorded. Organic clicks are down for many businesses. At the same time, branded search and direct navigation are up for many of the clients Tim works with. Revenue is holding or growing even as raw traffic numbers fall. That shouldn’t surprise you. It shows the difference between traffic that probably was never going to convert and customers who actually want to find you, your brand, your products, and your services. As a buddy of Tim’s likes to say, “You don’t deposit clicks. You deposit money.” In Digital Reset Foundations Episode 512, Tim Peter looks at what your marketing and content should accomplish, how to measure their real contribution, and where AI can help you produce work that drives revenue while preserving the human voice that makes your brand distinct. What You’ll Learn in This Episode Why marketing exists to drive revenue and profits How clicks and traffic contribute to the larger goal of revenue and profits How content works as your 24x7x365 salesperson and customer service representative Why content can acquire and retain customers even when they never click How branded search, direct navigation, app activity, and revenue reveal marketing’s impact Why content that makes customers curious about your business is good content How AI can help with ideas, personas, rough drafts, production, and analysis Why your people must own the final voice and face of your content How human-crafted content helps your brand break free from a sea of sameness Key Data Points Marketing has one ultimate business goal: drive revenue, or even better, profits. Content has two core jobs: convert potential customers and keep existing customers. Three signals can help you see value beyond clicks: branded search activity, direct navigation or app activity, and revenue. Content serves your business around the clock as a 24x7x365 salesperson and customer service representative. AI can improve efficiency and scale, but the work still needs to start and end with human-crafted content. Digital Reset Framework: Revenue Before Clicks Clicks and traffic can help your marketing drive results. Revenue and profits tell you whether the work ultimately succeeded. Your content should help customers understand who you are, see how you solve their problems, and choose to do business with you. It should also help existing customers stay satisfied and come back again. Measure whether your content helps you gain customers, keep customers, and grow revenue. Use AI to make the work more efficient and to uncover patterns in your data. Keep your people, personality, and judgment at the center of what customers see. What You Should Do Now 1. Measure the Outcome That Matters Watch branded search, direct navigation, app activity, customer acquisition, retention, revenue, and profits. Use those signals to determine whether your content reaches the right people and does the work you need it to do. 2. Create Content That Makes Customers Curious Give people a reason to care about your brand, what you do, and how you make their lives better. Build stories and useful content that they want to share with friends, families, fans, and followers. Curiosity and investment in your brand can lead to customers and revenue whether the path includes a click or not. 3. Use AI to Support Human-Crafted Content Use AI to brainstorm, test personas and ideas, build outlines, create rough drafts, streamline production, and analyze data. Then put your people, your personality, and your experience into the final work. That is how you build trust and stand apart. Resources Mentioned Traffic Is Down; Revenue Is Up? from SparkToro Audacious: How Humans Win in an AI Marketing World from Mark Schaefer Audacious: How Humans Win in an AI Marketing World on Amazon Related Episodes AI Changed Your Website’s Job. It Didn’t Kill It. (Digital Reset Foundations Episode 511) AI Got Better. It Still Won’t Save a Bad Strategy. (Digital Reset Foundations Episode 510) Google’s Most Valuable Search Is Your Brand Name (Episode 509) Will AI Kill Content Marketing for Customer Acquisition? (Episode 449) How Should You Think About Website SEO for AI? (Episode 448) What’s the Point of Your Website in an Age of AI? (Episode 447) When Will AI Get Good at Marketing? (Episode 446) Buy the Book: Digital Reset Ready to build marketing that creates demand beyond Big Tech’s clicks? Get Tim Peter’s book, Digital Reset: Driving Marketing and Customer Acquisition Beyond Big Tech, on Amazon. See Tim Peter in Action Want Tim to help your team connect marketing activity with revenue and profits? Learn more about Tim Peter’s speaking, workshops, and consulting. Free Downloads Content Distribution Checklist Visit the Digital Reset resource center for more tools and frameworks. Subscribe to Digital Reset Apple Podcasts Spotify Amazon Music Full show notes and episode archive If this episode helped you look past clicks and focus on the business results that matter, send it to a colleague who needs to hear it. They’ll be glad you did. Contact information for the podcast: podcast@timpeter.com Technical Details for Digital Reset Recorded using a Shure SM7B Vocal Dynamic Microphone and a Focusrite Scarlett 4i4 (3rd Gen) USB Audio Interface. Running time: 15:47 Transcript: Traffic Is Down. Revenue Is Up. Clicks Are Overrated. Quick show of hands. How many of you have sat in a meeting where somebody said traffic is down and then treated it like the building was on fire? I’m not convinced that’s the right approach. Traffic is a means to an end. The end goal always is revenue, and increasingly, traffic and revenue are decoupling in ways that should change how you measure success. In this Foundations episode, we’re looking at exactly how you can do that. That matters because AI Overviews and AI Mode have made that decoupling even more dramatic since this episode was first recorded. Organic clicks are down for many businesses. At the same time, for most clients I work with, branded search is up. Direct navigation is up. And for a lot of clients, revenue is holding or growing even as raw traffic numbers fall. That shouldn’t surprise you. It’s showing you the difference between traffic that probably was never going to convert anyway and customers who actually want to find you, your brand, your products, and your services. I’m Tim Peter. This is Digital Reset Foundations, episode 512. Let’s dive in. Before I get too far into this discussion, I want to address the big question, which is, what is the point of marketing? The answer, which you probably know but might surprise a few folks, is marketing exists to drive revenue. Your job isn’t to drive clicks or traffic. It’s not even to build your brand. The point of marketing is to drive revenue. Period. End of story. Building a brand is a great way to do that, to drive revenue. Almost always, it’s a critical step towards driving revenue. And clicks and traffic certainly help. But they’re also steps towards the overall goal, and that goal is revenue, or even better, profits. As a buddy of mine likes to say, "You don’t deposit clicks, you deposit money." I don’t mean this to be mercenary. Your company and your team and you yourself may have larger, more altruistic, more beneficial motives for the work that you do. There are so many companies who do great work in this area. Think of companies like TOMS or Patagonia or Out of the Closet, a thrift store in my backyard that donates its proceeds to the AIDS Healthcare Foundation. They’re all remarkable. They do tremendous work in their communities, and they deserve credit for their commitment to making the world better for all of us. But without revenue, without profits, without cash money, those companies can’t deliver on their amazing, admirable promises to their communities. Marketing that doesn’t deliver revenue, at least in the longer term, is a waste of time, it’s a waste of budget, and it’s a waste of effort. That’s why I always say that content is your 24x7x365 salesperson and your 24x7x365 customer service rep. It is marketing in action. It is marketing intended to drive results. The salesperson part of it is obvious. It drives sales. And the customer service rep part helps drive satisfaction and retention among your customers. Those lower your long-term cost of customer acquisition by helping you keep the people already using your products and services and getting them to come back again and again and again. That’s why what you’ve heard me say before, that content is king and customer experience is queen. They work together to sell and retain your customers. So shouldn’t your content at least drive clicks? I mean, it’d be great if it did. But it’s not necessarily what you need it to do. Your content exists to connect with your customers, both real customers and potential customers. It helps them understand who you are and help people solve their problems, how you make their lives better, and again, help convert them to customers and keep those customers coming back again and again and again. Convert and keep. That’s what your content needs to do. Clicks are one way to do that, sure. But your content can do so much more than that, so much more than simply drive a single click. When your content is shared on social channels, it can keep your name in front of potential customers. And that can drive people to type in your URL or, far more common, search for your brand name. Think about how much search has changed over the last couple of years. We don’t have 10 blue links any longer. We don’t have the way search has always worked. When people search for your category or a topic area or something more generic, you might show up. Do you know what comes up when people search for you by name? You, your brand. That is a genuinely good thing, capital G, capital T, good thing. You love to see it. And getting people to be invested in your brand is part of what your content is supposed to do because that’s how you drive revenue. You get people to care about your brand. You get people to care who you are. You get people to care about what you do to help them live a better life. That’s the whole point. My friend Mark Schaefer has a book, "Audacious: How Humans Win in an AI Marketing World," which is well worth your time. It is filled with tons of case studies of brands doing amazing work, creating great stories shared with their customers, friends, and families, and fans and followers that drive actual, real, honest-to-goodness engagement in the best possible sense of the word with brands just like yours. It causes those folks to want to learn more, to browse, and yes, to buy, to create revenue for your brand, to create profits for your business. Content that gets people curious about your business is good content, is really good content. That’s what it’s supposed to do, because getting people curious about your brand, getting them invested in your brand, is how you convert them to customers and how you convert to revenue. You also can measure it. I know this might sound contradictory relative to what I said a little bit ago, but you can see the value here even without clicks. Pay attention to changes in traffic from branded keywords. Keep track of how much direct navigation and activity on your app you receive if you have one. Most importantly, keep a close eye on your revenue. While the specifics of how you drill down into the details around this kind of tracking are beyond the scope of today’s episode, every one of these are signs that your marketing is reaching the people you want to reach, that it’s doing the work you need it to do. In fact, I’m going to say something a little controversial here, but if you can’t see it show up in your revenue, then your marketing isn’t working. That’s a sign right there that you have work to do. You need to be able to see something to know that it’s working, and if you’re not seeing it, then it’s not working. And if you are seeing things happen, then it’s a sign that things are working. It’s just drilling into the details to know how to do that. So content marketing is good even without clicks on the content itself, right? It makes sense why you want to use it. How does AI fit into this picture? Well, I’m glad you asked. First, I want to go back to our prior episode where I said AI won’t kill content marketing. Bad content will. Boring, obviously machine-generated content that lacks humanity will. Content that fails to connect with human beings as individuals and as members of the communities they care about will kill content marketing. In short, AI will only kill content marketing if you let it. I am dead serious about that. AI will not produce the content that your customers love. Almost no way, no how. What AI can do, though, is help you brainstorm ideas for content. You can use AI to generate personas for your target customers, then ask your favorite AI to provide feedback about your ideas before you invest too much time and treasure into producing them. You can use AI to help you craft outlines or even, and I can’t emphasize this word enough, create rough drafts for your content, for your imagery, for your video scripts, and for your social media posts. Again, rough drafts, not the final draft. You can also use AI to help you parse your data to uncover whether any spikes in your analytics represent a fluke or a longer-term trend. When you use AI to help you craft content, do not, and I am begging you, do not take the output these tools provide and post them as is. Do not use them as the final version of your content. Anyone can do that. Increasingly, it feels like everyone is, and that’s why we see so much crap content. I mean, if I’m being perfectly honest, I use AI-generated images more than I should. We’re going to be moving away from that over time. They’re just not always great images. They don’t do what we need them to do. They don’t tell the story of the brand we need them to tell. It was great to test them out. It was great to learn about them. It was great to see what can be done with them. But fundamentally, do they actually represent us at our most human, at our most sincere, and at our most truthful and honest? No. They’re not great content. They’re fine, but they’re not great. Instead, your content should reflect your brand, your personality, and as much as possible, a specific individual, a specific human within your company who can build longer-term relationships and trust with your target audience. You don’t want customers to connect with a robot. For one thing, they probably won’t. For another, it doesn’t stand apart from anybody else’s robot. Instead, you want your audience, you want the people you want to talk to, to connect with human beings, with the human beings that make your company, your brand distinct and human. To give one real-world example, this podcast that you’re listening to right now is not scripted by a machine. It isn’t hosted by a machine. We do use AI to transcribe the recording. We use AI to test titles. We use AI to generate the image that accompanies each episode and do some careful curation of multiple possible images. We occasionally use AI to review the script and provide feedback. And that’s it. That’s all we do. Other companies we work with use AI to help personalize messages or test alternatives for different customer segments. Some use AI editing tools to streamline video production. They and we use AI to improve efficiency and scale. But all of those start and end with human-crafted content. That’s the only way you’re going to stand apart. Otherwise, you’re going to sink into a sea of sameness. So what are some key takeaways as you think about using AI to help your content marketing drive revenues without clicks? The first is that the point of your marketing is to drive revenue, period. Next, your content marketing is your 24x7x365 salesperson and 24x7x365 customer service rep. If your content helps you gain customers or keep existing ones, your content is doing its job whether those people click… or not. Next, your content that makes customers curious about your brand and your business is good content. Do more of that. Next, you can track your content’s effectiveness by watching branded activity in search, social, and your website. And AI can help you identify traffic and trends there. Next, AI can also help you streamline or scale production of great content. But AI shouldn’t be the face or voice of your company. Customers want to work with people they like and that they trust. Your people must own and produce your final content deliverables. Plus, remember that everyone who uses AI to create their final content deliverables increasingly all look and sound the same. Break free from that herd. Be human. Ultimately, great content produced by and for humans will help you drive revenues and profits for your business with or without clicks. Embrace that reality. Your business, your brand, and your bottom line will all thank you for it. Now, looking at the clock on the wall, we are out of time for this week. I’m willing to bet that you might know someone who would benefit from what we’ve talked about today. Are you thinking of someone? Why not send them a link to the episode? Let them know what you think too. You can also find the show notes for this episode and an archive of all of our past episodes by going to timpeter.com/podcasts. Thanks so much for listening today. This show wouldn’t happen without you. I very much appreciate you doing it. Please be well, be safe, and as always, take care everybody. Take Your Next Step Toward a Digital Reset “Digital Reset with Tim Peter” helps you look beyond the “shiny objects” to build a business that lasts. How can we help you today? The Brief: Get the weekly email that turns these strategic ideas into actionable demand. Subscribe to The Digital Reset Brief The Book: Master the framework with Digital Reset: Driving Marketing and Customer Acquisition Beyond Big Tech. Buy the Book The Experience: Need a bespoke digital strategy for your hotel, resort, SaaS firm, or financial services firm? Tim Peter & Associates can help you. Work with Tim The post Traffic Is Down. Revenue Is Up. Clicks Are Overrated. (Digital Reset Foundations Episode 512) appeared first on Tim Peter & Associates.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
