Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Think Biblically: Conversations on Faith & Culture

Think Biblically: Conversations on Faith & Culture artwork

Weekly Cultural Update: Televised Execution of Fort Hood Shooter; Screens and Youth Mental Health; A New Wave of Feminism; AI Wins Literary Prize

Oct 16, 202659 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Televised Execution of the Fort Hood Shooter: Scott and Sean analyze Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth's announcement that the U.S. military plans to execute Fort Hood shooter by firing squad and live-stream the event for public deterrence. Screen Time and Youth Mental Health: Examining a New York Times opinion piece, the hosts evaluate whether compulsive device usage is the root cause of rising youth anxiety or merely an anesthesia masking underlying relational voids and mental health conditions. The Next Wave of Feminism: Scott and Sean review a report in The Dispatch covering a new feminist movement and its "Declaration of Interdependence," which rejects radical autonomy and body-denying technologies in favor of mutual community obligations. AI and Literary Integrity: Responding to The Atlantic's coverage of an AI-flagged short story winning the Caine Prize for African Writing, the hosts discuss the growing crisis of trust across literature and academia. They stress that passing off AI-generated work as original writing violates the Ninth Commandment, noting that technological safeguards can never replace personal character and virtue. Legal Accountability for Men in Abortions: A listener asks if men who impregnate women should be held legally accountable for abortions, questioning whether an unfair legal and moral burden is placed solely on the woman. The hosts address the query by examining the legal asymmetries surrounding parental rights, financial child support, and instances of male coercion. Elisha and the Bears (2 Kings 2:23-24): In response to a listener asking if Elisha overreacted to taunts about his baldness, the hosts clarify that the original Hebrew phrase refers to young men aged 12 to 30 rather than small children. They explain that mocking the newly appointed prophet with calls to "go up" derided Elijah's ascent to heaven, making the taunt a direct act of contempt against God Himself during a pivotal period in Israel's history. ========== Think Biblically: Conversations on Faith and Culture is a podcast from Talbot School of Theology at Biola University, which offers degrees both online and on campus in Southern California. Find all episodes of Think Biblically at: https://www.biola.edu/think-biblically. To submit comments, ask questions, or make suggestions on issues you'd like us to cover or guests you'd like us to have on the podcast, email us at thinkbiblically@biola.edu.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Sean McDowellThe Pentagon says it will publicly execute the Fort Hood shooter. Is blaming social media for the rising mental illness phenomena missing the deeper issue? A new wave of feminism emerges that is rooted in the truth of male-female differences, and a massive literature prize is awarded to an author who may have used AI to generate the short story. These are the stories we'll discuss, and we also address some of your questions. I'm your host, Sean McDowell. I'm your co-host, Scott Ray. This is the Think Biblically Weekly Cultural Update brought to you by Talp School Theology, Viola University.

Sean McDowellScott, now before we jump in, today and this week is special. Why?

Scott RaeWell, Sean, this week, it was nine years ago this week that we posted our first episode of Think Biblically with uh a guy named McDowell as our guest. Uh your dad was our guest on our very first program. So it's been a it's been a wonderful partnership. I've so enjoyed doing this. This is uh, I say, one of the things that is so life-giving for me. And uh so just wanted to let our listeners know we've been at this for a while and we're looking forward to another nine years.

Sean McDowellAnd by the way, one year out, Lord wound, we can continue this. What kind of celebration or live airing should we do? We did this for five years, where maybe some folks could come in in person at Biola, maybe interview special guests. If you have any ideas for something we could do for a 10-year kind of celebration, shoot us an email. We'd love to look at that and just start kind of planning ahead in plenty of time. Well, Scott, as always on our weekly cultural update, there's fascinating stories. And the moment this one dropped, I thought, I wonder what Scott is going to think about this one, because it's right in your lane.

Sean McDowellAnd by the time we literally air this, there could be an announcement uh that they're not going through with it, but it's the ethical principle that matters that I did not see coming in terms of. The Pentagon says the Fort Hood shooter execution will be live streamed. Now, by firing squad, this is Nadal Malik Hassan, a former officer who admitted to killing 13 people in a 2009 shooting at Fort Hood Army Base in Texas. Uh, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth said in an interview with a conservative news outlet uh that he said that he wanted to ensure, quote, people are able to watch it because people need to understand that there's serious consequences for these types of things.

Sean McDowellIt's scheduled to be set December 3rd at Fort Hood. He said he'd be carried out at 1 p.m., which is around the same time Hassan opened fire at the base on November 5th, 2009. He called the decision to execute by firing squad a no-brainer. This is Hegseth. Hassan's execution would be actually the first by the U.S. military in more than 65 years, and a service member hasn't been executed by firing squad since 1945.

Sean McDowellThat's crazy. That's the time of uh obviously World War II. And Hegeth said it was a radical Islamist attack in uniform inside the ranks, and so he's going to get a firing squad of soldiers as it should be. Now, obviously, Trump came out and made a statement. He's like, I'm not sure that this is going to happen or not. And Vance was like, if it does, I'm not going to watch it. But what's what's your take on this? Is this the right direction for justice or is this the wrong direction?

Scott RaeWell, Sean, I think this is the wrong direction. Uh, but I found this really interesting that Heggseth, the argument that he made sounds a lot like uh an argument from deterrence. So when he said so, the people will know that these things have consequences. And I've actually made this argument before in my classes when we talk about the death penalty, a bit tongue-in-cheek, actually, to point out that the argument from deterrence is not really the primary reason for the death penalty. And I did that, Sean, by suggesting that if we were really serious about deterrence, we would televise executions, assuming that no civilized person would ever countenance such a thing.

Scott RaeI thought it was a pretty effective counter-argument against deterrence being the main argument for the death penalty until this week. Now, this is especially since public executions are somewhat rare. Uh, Iran, Saudi Arabia, North Korea, none of which are governments that we would want to emulate. Uh, and it seems to me they they do this in part for reasons of deterrence. So here's, you know, I dug into this a bit uh in the last few days since this announcement came out.

Scott RaeI discovered that there are a lot of Christian people who are raising theological objections to this, but most of them are more principled objections to the death penalty more so than objections to live streaming it. Live streaming it sort of, I think they would they would say this, it being public adds insult to injury, morally speaking. Uh so what one person, one pastor in Texas put it this way, he supports the death penalty and supports it being public.

Scott RaeHe put it like this that life is so valuable, God said that whoever takes a life should pay with his own life. And the more people that can see that truth illustrated through a public execution, the better. What I didn't find as much were people who supported the death penalty in principle, like you and I, like we talked about a week ago, uh, but who are who think that televising it is a bad idea. Now, I'm not I'm not presuming to speak for you on this, and I'll let you weigh in in just a moment. But um those those folks I think are more rare, uh, who you know, who see the death penalty as okay in principle, but really don't like the idea of it being a public spectacle.

Scott RaeSo I've got a little bit more to say, but I'm curious to hear to know if you agree with me on this take or if you see it differently.

Sean McDowellI I do agree with you on this take, and I'm glad that you you differentiated between the death penalty itself being just and the live streaming of the death penalty. And barring some of the points you made about it not being carried out justly, in principle, I support it for a range of reasons. Biblically, I support it uh ethically and philosophically. I think deterrence is a piece of it. But live streaming, at first, I actually thought this must be a Babylon B kind of headline.

Sean McDowellAt first, I was like, no, you've you're kidding, right? Now, if I'm gonna charitably look back at, say, the wild, wild west when they had public executions, they didn't have the state police system and control like we do today. So they probably relied upon fear more than we need to rely upon fear for the state today. So I just don't see it. I get, I guess, my concerns, if I were gonna sum it up, is a few things.

Sean McDowellNumber one, and Albert Mueller raised this on his briefing. He said, does this fuel radical Muslims to just use this as potential fodder for how bankrupt we are, and America is against Muslims? It's only gonna give them fuel. I think back of when we we really took out bin Laden, they killed him, put him in a bag, dumped it in the ocean, and it was done. There was no trial, there was no room, and it just cleared away any of that uh kind of use.

Sean McDowellAnd I fear that that could happen. I think second, just the idea of a spectacle. If I had, I might, and I'd emphasize might be persuaded differently. If you could convince me that people would watch this with maturity and not turn it into a spectacle and realize what it is, then maybe, and I emphasize maybe, but I have not only zero confidence, I have negative confidence. I can just imagine all the social media videos and the TikTok and the responses of people airing this.

Sean McDowellI have no confidence that our culture can handle this with any degree of maturity. And it takes something, the taking of human life that is so like sacred and turns it into a spectacle. And the last one, you know, some people might not like this question, but or this angle, even somebody who takes 13 lives, who I think deserves to have his life taken from him, is still made in the image of God. And should his life be taken in a way that becomes a spectacle to others, I don't know that it should be.

Sean McDowellSo for those reasons, I fit apparently in the smaller category that you described.

Scott RaeYeah, I I agree that we we ought not take a solemn event and turn it into a spectacle. And Sean, one of the articles I read on this, ironically, was called A History of Picnics. Okay. And one of the things that's in the history of picnics was how frequently public executions became uh occasions for family picnics prior to witnessing the execution.

unknownWow.

Scott RaeNow, I I think the mo mo when public executions are staged in in free countries, I think you can make an argument that they undermine our respect for life. Uh it course it coarse it coursens us. I think it can sh it can shape the character of those who view it. Um when they occur in totalitarian countries, they are used to terrorize people as part of a program of authoritarian rule. Uh and I think the other thing that troubles me about this, Sean, is public executions, I think, can blur the distinction between justice and vengeance.

Scott RaeUh and like you mentioned, I think it can undermine the dignity of the condemned person if the execution becomes a spectacle. And I I want to sort of raise the virtue question on this. You know, I, you know, J.D. Vance had a comment about it here where he supports the idea but said he's not going to watch it. Uh and I said, you know, what the the virtue question asks, you know, what kind of person would watch a public execution? And what does that what does that do to our character to treat the a sacred event like the taking of life as a spectacle and as a form of entertainment?

Scott RaeUh that that's the the thing that troubles me about this. You know, Paul tells us in Philippians 4, he counsels us to think on things that are lovely and noble and righteous and honoring to God. And I I I the this thing I think fails that test.

Sean McDowellI think that's well said. I, you know, one Christian who defended this is Patrick Bett David. He's a businessman, has a popular podcast. He's a Christian, really thoughtful. And he was, and the point that he made that was interesting was that the military, this guy served in the military and swore an oath to the military to defend the nation and directly betrayed that in a way that a normal murderer doesn't. And that's why he wanted to make an example. That might persuade me to say, okay, maybe the execution is in front of certain military personnel so they see it.

Sean McDowellMaybe, but it doesn't even go beyond that to the public to me in this case. I I think the downsides culturally, like you said, morally, far outweigh the upsides of reverting back to this, in in my take. Anything else in this one, Scott?

Scott RaeNo, I I I hope. I I'm I'm hoping and praying that they actually cancel it.

Sean McDowellNot the execution, but the televising of it. Oh, gotcha. Good. I'll I'll end with a little quote by Walter Kim, who's the president of National Association of Evangelicals. He was on campus a couple weeks ago, and he said, while he affirms the need for justice regarding the crime, quote, at the same time, a live stream execution by firing squad risks turning one of the state's most solemn responsibilities into a public spectacle, promoting a culture of death rather than a culture that upholds the dignity of every human being. And I think he's right in the way he said that.

Sean McDowellWell put. All right. To radically shift, this story caught my attention. It's an opinion piece in the New York Times. And there's been all this discussion about social media and cell phone use affecting the mental health of all of us, including young people. And there's been some massive rulings, like we've discussed here, towards like Facebook and YouTube paying out culpability for using their algorithms to hook kids, even when they had awareness of its negative effects.

Sean McDowellWell, this New York Times piece, which interestingly came out after those cases, says it talks about how children and teens today spend far more time in front of screens at home and at school than previous generations. And anxiety and depression have been climbing for years. Okay, we know that. But as a doctor who treats children with mental health problems, I see screen time as a tantalizing distraction from bigger problems. America doesn't offer enough mental health care for children or sufficient health insurance to pay for it. So this doctor, psychiatrist, says, I see children who use phones, iPads, other devices compulsively, but the compulsive use is usually a sign of something deeper: depression, anxiety, attention deficit, hyperactive disorder, which can both feed the screen use and in turn be fed by it.

Sean McDowellSo the case for screen time, this doctor argues, uh screen time limits rest in part on an unproven assumption that fewer hours will mean fewer anxious and depressed kids. The best evidence doesn't support it. Limiting screen time can promote children's overall health, but doesn't get to the heart of the issue. This doctor argues that genetics and certain experiences in childhood, as well as the lack of proper diagnosis and treatment, appear to be far more influential.

Sean McDowellDoes this ring true to you? Do you agree with this or do you disagree with this take?

Scott RaeWell, Sean, I can see a lot of merit in the argument that screens in social media, like other addictive behaviors, are a bit like anesthesia, to deaden the pain of loneliness or other mental health conditions. And I'd say normally with these types of addictions, like to drugs and alcohol and to pornography, to sex, other things like that, they're not the root cause, but a way to deal with deeper mental health issues. And I think the the one point I think the author makes that is surely right is that the resources that we have devoted to deal with mental health issues in adolescence are not adequate.

Scott RaeBut I find it hard, Sean, to dismiss the findings of Jonathan Haid in his book, The Anxious Generation, that put the explosion of youth mental health issues beginning around 2007, the year that the smartphone was introduced. And he makes the point that that's not just correlation, it's causation. And I, in my view, there's there's no doubt that screens and social media exacerbate mental health issues, to say the least.

Scott RaeAnd I think, in my view, that's reason enough to urge schools and families to limit screen time, whether the whether they're the cause or not, or just make it worse, maybe another matter. I'm willing, I think I'm willing to be a bit agnostic about that, but that doesn't change how I feel about the overuse of screens, nor does it change what I think should be done about it. So I think this is you know, this this is a distinction that's being made that that I, in my view, uh it's not clear to me how much difference that distinction ought to make in how we treat screens and social media with adolescents.

Sean McDowellSo I I agree and concur with your take, as well as this article, which is basically asking the question: what's the root and the heart of the problem? Why are we seeing mental illness and anxiety increase so much? And the solution here seems to be we don't have enough resources towards mental health care for this generation. Now, I agree that that plays a role, and maybe it's under-resourced for a lot of kids, especially in vulnerable communities.

Sean McDowellBut in some ways, this is still downstream from the question of what's causing the anxiety and what's causing the depression and causing the loneliness. And a lack of mental health care doesn't explain why that has increased. That's still the problem. And so you're right that height points towards uh the increased use of, again, social media and screen time as being correlated, if not causing that. Now, I think the article's right to ask the question why is it that some people become addicted and others don't?

Sean McDowellWhy is it that screen time affects some people differently than others, especially young people? And I think when we begin to answer that question, then we're getting to the heart and the root of it. And the article says, uh, it says genetics and certain experiences in childhood, as well as the lack of proper diagnosis and treatment, appear to be far more influential than screen time. What I would posit, and I don't have the data to back this up. So if I'm wrong, I'll I'll circle back and correct it.

Sean McDowellI would say probably the root of the issue would be the health of relationships in a young person's life. Period. That would be the most definitive factor in terms of how social media affects them or doesn't affect them. Now, there might be some experiences that play a role. There might be some genetic differences, but I think the root of it are relationships. Biblically, we're made for relationships with God and for other people.

Sean McDowellWe are relational beings. And when we lack them, there's something broken in our lives, and we will look for a substitute to replace those relationships. Probably 20 or 25 years ago, Scott, at the Medical Institute for Sexual Health, they had a conference in Vegas I went to. I don't even think they have conferences anymore. And there was a psychiatrist, a Christian psychiatrist, I believe from Texas at the time, Paul Warren said something that's always stuck with me. He said, an addiction is something used to fill the void.

Sean McDowellA relationship is meant to fill. An addiction is something used to fill a void that a relationship is meant to fill. In other words, why do some people are more prone to certain addictions? At its root, in many cases, we're going to find, if not most, a broken relationship that is there. So this is where I agree with the author saying, let's get to the heart of it. And screen time alone doesn't explain this. When the author says the heart of it is a lack of funds and mental health care, I think, no, this is a government kind of solution that doesn't get to the heart of what makes us healthy as human beings.

Sean McDowellNow, what the government can do to foster that is a separate issue. I don't have a simple answer for that, but we can only find a solution when I think we properly identify the problem. Agree, disagree, give, give me your take on that.

Scott RaeAgree. It's a good take on this. And I think that, you know, theologically, we are we are created for in real life community. And the community created by social media is, uh, in my view, a cheap substitute for the real thing. But here, I want to let me tag on to your point and maybe frame it a little bit differently. I think the question that the author's point here begs is where does the primary responsibility lie for ensuring the mental health of kids?

Scott RaeIs it the state, the mental health profession, schools, or is it the family and the parents? And I wonder, does this speak to the breakdown of the family in this area? I, you know, Sean, I don't want to be overly simplistic about this, but it seems to me that a lot of mental health issues could be alleviated or prevented by parents who are unconditionally loving their kids. They're present to them in the home. They show up when their kids are doing important things.

Scott RaeUh, you know, and I and I know that there are a lot of parents who do all those things and their kids still have mental health issues. I realize that life is complicated. But the article makes makes reference to the, and you you referred to this just briefly, the family environment that makes a big difference. Here, they put it like this: children who have had adverse childhood experiences such as neglect, abuse, poverty, homelessness, parental violence, or substance abuse. Uh what they discovered is that children who have who are exposed to four or more of these experiences have three times the odds of problematic screen use.

Scott RaeNow, some of these are some of these kids who have attention issues, and you know, some of these, you know, we have I and I I know lots of, I know lots of families. They're great parents, they're attentive, they do all the right things, and their kids have ADHD. Issues that I think are no fault of anything that's going on in the family. But kids with attention issues are also prone to more addictive screen use. But children who come from families with other types of addictive behaviors find themselves much more vulnerable to this.

Scott RaeSo in my view, the family environment makes a huge difference. And I wonder if, you know, the fact that ra raising a family has gotten more expensive with both parents having to work full-time and lots of kids in, you know, in other childcare care arrangements other than with the parents. I wonder if all of that is having an impact on this as well.

Sean McDowellTotally a fair question. I don't know the answer to that, but I think as the family has broken down, the government has gotten bigger and bigger and stepped into a role that the family should, in principle, be providing. But I think at its core, I do appreciate the article points out four or five of those relational breakdown experiences make somebody far more susceptible to addictions, whatever they may be, and mental health issues. But it reminds me of the conversations we've had multiple times about kind of the gender, rapid gender onset dysphoria we've talked about.

Sean McDowellAnd underneath that is a key issue that people often are not being aware of. And if we don't address the deeper core issue, then just changing some of the surface stuff doesn't fit. And I think that's true when it comes to social media. So we need to limit use at school, helpful. We need to maybe have harder access to certain platforms, but that's not going to fix the root problem itself. I think this article points out. All right, this next article you sent to me, Scott, I think it's fascinating.

Sean McDowellAnd I'd heard about this a little bit, uh, but I think it's a positive sign. And this is an article called Feminism's Next Wave. Now, there's been like four waves of feminism. Some would say five, depending on how you count them. If this is the next wave of feminism, this would be a remarkable turnabout. And so what apparently happened just recently is the article starts by talking about how women own more property, exercise their civil civic rights more frequently, like voting, hold more levers in our socioeconomic system than ever before.

Sean McDowellBut in the midst of this and their political gains, women appear to have suffered a corresponding loss in contentment and purpose. And then the article says something interesting. It says, while women aren't getting happier, they are getting more liberal. And in many ways, so many of these women have a blame the system, carrying a grievance kind of mentality that we actually see in a lot of men on the right as well, interestingly enough. But then the article, this is where I stopped and was like, this is good stuff.

Sean McDowellThe article says ultimately this problem is not political, but anthropological. Amid the frenzing push to make women equal to men, we have forgotten what women are. I paused in the article right there, Scott, and was like, Amen, thank you. I think somebody gets it here. And then what happened in this meeting is a historic uh in Rochester, in the historic Lion Mansion, uh, a home full of old books and hand-carved woodwork, over a hundred women of all ages assembled to chart a new path forward for the fair sex in the 21st century.

Sean McDowellAnd just a couple of quick things about it is that one of the roots is that they're they're kind of following the tradition of the wildly influential philosopher Alistair McIntyre, who said that true human freedom mass manifests itself in mutual dependence of persons. So, in other words, freedom being independent and autonomous, do whatever I want or feel. Real freedom is actually found with interdependence and community. Love that. They also talk about how this other waves of feminism denied human biology, again, what women are, and it leads not to real freedom.

Sean McDowellSo this article says women today are incentivized to take birth control, abort inconvenient pregnancies, freeze their eggs, or outsource the childbearing process altogether, all artificial interventions used to make women more like men, unburdened by the nature of their own female bodies. Sarrogacy itself instrumentalizes a woman's body. Her womb becomes a space to lease her body. Now, the one that might give some of our audience that is presumably more Protestant is she ties in abortion and surrogacy with birth control, which is a conversation and a debate we don't necessarily have to have right now.

Sean McDowellBut the idea being freedom is found in community, and freedom is found in recognizing what we are as beings and avoiding technology that denies who and what we are, and specifically applying this to women. So, Mike, I have a couple questions. Uh, do you agree with this movement? I presume you do. Do you think that it's going to take off and get any legs, or do you think it's a fad that's just going to pass?

Scott RaeWell, Sean, it's been a long time since I've been so encouraged by a story that we've been covering for the cultural update. Good. This was, I found profoundly affirming and encouraging of so many of the things that we've been talking about. And some of the people who signed the document that came out of this conference was the Declaration of Interdependence. And some of the folks who signed that are actually some of the people that we've interviewed, you know, Abigail Favale, for example. And we've cited very favorably the works of Louise Perry and Mary Harrington in their critiques of the previous waves of feminism.

Scott RaeI am very curious to see what kind of reception this will get among more, what I would call more mainstream feminists. I suspect that this is a shot across the bow to them that they're probably not going to like. And my guess is that the reaction to this will uh they will take this as a step backward for women. When in our view, this is precisely the opposite. In my view, there is so much to like about what's in this piece and about what's in this movement.

Scott RaeYou mentioned several of these things. Uh you know, here are a couple other things that the article mentions that I found very encouraging. When they say women are living under the shadow of a false feminism that denies their biology and their dignity. Technology promises a world where women are no longer the only path through which new life can be brought into the world, which they say is a terrible thing for women. Such technology may promise to liberate women from the suffering of childbearing, but such relief can only be acquired through the denial of a woman's biology and her unique right to motherhood.

Scott RaeYou know, radical autonomy has come to be regarded by many as life's highest good, as though our obligations to one another ought not order our lives. You know, that's a profound statement. Um it refers to what they call the unbodying of women, which I thought is a great term, the body, a body-denying ideology. It's a the article points out today in grasping for equality with men, we've abandoned belief in the natural distinction, biological and otherwise, between the sexes.

Scott RaeWe hold to the sacred particularity of man and woman. Uh they say, I mean, the theological makes its entrance here. They say we are transcendent beings, ultimately made for a union with God. Uh now they they probably will get dissed a bit by the mainstream feminists for that religious stuff. Um, but it sean, the the really encouraging thing here to me is it puts autonomy in its place. That's right. And gives a proper our obligations to one another, not our individual autonomy, is what orders our lives.

Scott RaeAnd, you know, to see evidence of this, Sean, you know, we've talked about this repeatedly. All of the all of the quote, one another obligations in the New Testament, those are everywhere in the epistles that talk about our obligations to one another in our communities, in the body of in the body of Christ, in our families. Uh, you know, in Ecclesiastes, Solomon tried radical autonomy, and he concludes that that search for self-fulfillment that centers on the self is ultimately self-defeating.

Scott RaeYou know, and Jesus had had something to say about this too: that uh, you know, he who seeks to save his own life will lose it. You know, what does it profit someone to gain the world and lose their soul? Um, and it says it says what we've been saying for I'm just so encouraged by this. You know, we're sect beings. Men and women are not interchangeable. Uh, there are things unique to both sexes that are God ordained. Uh, you know, Abigail Favali points this out in her book, which we loved, The Genesis of Gender.

Scott RaeYou know, that that what's unique about women is their ability to generate life in their own bodies, as opposed to, you know, that not being the case for men. Uh, I mean, there's there's just so much good stuff here. And the the article points, the article will link our listeners to this declaration of interdependence. And the article encourages people to read the whole thing, which I've not done yet, but I'm planning on it.

Scott RaeUh, and so I would encourage our listeners to, you know, click on that link that will get you to the entire document uh and re- and read the whole thing for yourself.

Sean McDowellI agree with you. And I read this article, I was like, yes, great find, Scott. This is so encouraging. Uh, some of the writers here, specifically Luis Perry and Abigail Favalli, have written brilliant books making a case for what would be a biblical sexual ethic through natural law without using chapter and verse, which involve like The Genesis of Gender by Abigail Favalli is my go-to book of what it means to be male and female in terms of just looking at our bodies and what they mean.

Sean McDowellNow, she's Catholic, so she brings in a theology of the body. But I think as a whole, I think Protestants and any Christians could celebrate and agree with the case that she makes. Louise Perry, again, wrote a book. I, again, I think before she was a Christian, called The Case Against the Sexual Revolution. And it's one of the best critiques against it. And she argues in that book, she says not only just from an ethical perspective, but the monogamy molecule works in society. It creates better mental health, it helps economically, it just causes a society to flourish, which you and I would say that's because the monogamy molecule lines up with the way God has designed us to be.

Sean McDowellAnd really, what we're seeing come to fruition is this debate over what it means to be free. And I think this line here in the article says indeed, the only way to escape the battle of the sexes is to be reground, is to reground male and female in a shared humanity. An anthropology rooted in mankind's unique dignity within the visible world, or recognizing holding sacred the particularity of man and woman as made by God, she writes in the article.

Sean McDowellThe question is: if there is a God, what is freedom? If there's a God, freedom is living according to this God's design and being who God designed us to be. If there's not a God and we came through some naturalistic evolutionary process, then we get to define and explain what freedom is for ourselves. That's at the root of this, what really truly is freedom. So I love that that comes uh to the surface. I'd also say the last comment on this, I appreciate how holistic this is.

Sean McDowellSo she makes a case towards the end that these body, a body-denying ideology, which is basically saying that a woman's body is not essential to who and what she is, has threatened the sanctity and safety of female-only spaces. So, in other words, there's questions of birth control, there's questions of IVF, there's questions of female spaces, there's all these questions tied together. And I'm not sure we've developed a consistent sexual ethic rooted in the body itself.

Sean McDowellAnd this is important because one of the most important books in five years, I'd encourage our audience to read if they haven't, is by Carl Truman in his book, The Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self. At the very end, he says one of the things the church needs to recover for the sake of the culture is a robust theology of embodiment. And that's exactly what I think this uh this article captures.

Scott RaeJohn, one one final thing on this before we leave it. I think uh, you know, the article starts out with a with a diagnosis that uh that Mary Harrington points out as well in her book, Feminism Against Progress, uh, where she where she points out that w women have never been more prosperous. Uh they're earning higher than ever wages and salaries, they're filling leadership roles, they outpace men in educational attainment, accomplishments, they own property, exercise civic rights more frequently, hold levers in our system more so than ever before.

Scott RaeBut in the midst of all these gains, women seem appear to have suffered a corresponding loss of contentment and purpose. Say women take antidepressants at an unprecedented rate. Uh fewer women find meaningful in fulfillment in their relationships, which include marriage and motherhood. Um, they're less likely to be satisfied with life, uh, things like that. So that the diagnosis here is what is sort of what is driving this. And as opposed to sort of doubling down on the things that are producing these kinds of what I would call anti-flourishing things, uh the the art the article and the conference and the declaration of interdependence are suggesting maybe we need a different direction.

Scott RaeMaybe we need to go back to some of what I think the found our founding fathers had in mind when they talked about uh autonomy and freedom being not the freedom to do whatever you want, but the freedom to do what you ought, the freedom to follow your moral obligations and the freedom to live into the kind of person that you've created, you've been created to be. So I I find, I mean, I find the whole thing just incredibly encouraging.

Scott RaeWe will keep our listeners posted as to how this is received. Uh some of the I read some of the comments, there have been you know several hundred comments on the article already. Uh and the artic, the the comments were were somewhat mixed. Uh not uh I would say not outright rejecting the point, but sort of offering some counterpunches along the way.

Sean McDowellMy hope for a movement like this is not that there's a genuine fifth wave, complete return back to biblical ideas. Now, of course, that's my ultimate hope. That would be amazing if we had that kind of revival. But more realistically, and still would be a stretch, is that they partner together, is that they think of creative ways to just offer a solid biblical, life-giving alternative that women and all people in our culture are aware of. So they have a voice opposed to the common mantra and ethic that we see all the time, like a prophetic, consistent voice in our culture that offers people the real freedom and ultimately leads them to the gospel.

Sean McDowellSo, this is the kind of movement I think we should pray for and we should talk about and encourage and support as we can. Uh, the women behind this are pretty amazing, and I'm I'm rooting for them in a lot of ways. All right. So, this last story again, you sent this one to me, and I I it's like every week there's an AI story. I'm like, okay, here we go. Didn't see this one coming, should have, but this is in the Atlantic, and there's yet another literary prize winner, seems to be AI. So the article doesn't land and say it is AI, but apparently there's a recent story called The Blue Fighter that will find its way to a lot of people who have read it because it was named the winner of the prestigious Kane Award for African writing, which is awarded the equivalent of$13,000 for a short story by an African writer.

Sean McDowellNow, this article, art art or this uh author in The Atlantic, says, taste is subjective, but trust me, this story is bad. It's really, really bad. Now, I haven't read it, so I'm relying upon this author's take. Says the narrator has all the personality of a chat bot. That's not coincidental. And there's an AI detector Pangram that flags almost the entire story as AI generated. And this comes after similar scandals over this year's Commonwealth Prize and Prick's Gone Court to other renowned literature contests in which Pangram flagged AI use among finalists.

Sean McDowellNow, the author says any of these incidents might have been written off as a fluke, but they point to something of a crisis of trust in writers and technology that, quote, threatens to undermine a global system of literary recognition. Now, that feels a little overstated to me since I'm not in that world, but nonetheless, it's concerning. And the author says AI detection is fallible. Uh, it's not perfect, but it's also highly accurate when it's used for classification of text.

Sean McDowellSo this author ran all 25 of the previous Kane prize-winning stories through Pangram and labeled them as 100% human written. 100%. Now there's certain things this person can identify. I'm not sure we need to go into too much detail, but things like just uh certain kinds of language that's used, uh, certain what they said are stereotypes about African life that that anybody who's on the inside would pick up. So it seems now we have yet another industry rocked by AI, up-ending trust, and people don't know where to turn.

Sean McDowellWhat's your take?

Scott RaeAnd in my view, it was only a matter of time before we saw this happen. Uh the temptation is irresistible. Uh and I found what's really striking about this is how the the what was what took place in the attempt to contest the accusation of AI use. Notice the people did not attempt to justify use of AI. They all contested that they actually used it.

Scott RaeAnd here I think what strikes me about this is that it seems to me that all of those involved know intuitively that using it for writing stories in their entirety and passing it off as your own is not right. And constitutes deception and plagiarism. But but you know, no nobody was attempting to say this is a valid, justifiable use of AI. Um they're simply deni simply contesting the accusation in itself.

Scott RaeUh now I I you know I I I would I would agree with the article. Uh you know, the article it concludes like this it is a matter of literary integrity. Uh I think, you know, and I think in other fields I'd say a matter of academic integrity. Uh several of the most prestigious literary prizes have been infected by language that represents not people's actual values and cultures, but a damaging mimicry of them by products of the most powerful companies in the world.

Scott RaeAnd this is the line that it concluded, this is the time to do something about it. I kept waiting for the author to say, and here's what I'm suggesting that we do about it. But there's the it was completely devoid of any practical suggestions to how to combat, you know, this is this is not this is not using AI to prime the pump to get ideas. It's not using AI to check your grammar. Uh it's not it's not using AI to you know to help edit your work and make it sound a little bit better.

Scott RaeThis is using AI from start to finish. Um I would love, I would love to I would love for the article to have suggested something that they would recommend to do about this. Uh you know, strip the person of the prize uh if it's if it's proven that AI was used to to author the piece in its entirety. Uh you know, just disqualify I mean disqualify submissions where Where there's this overwhelming suspicion of AI saying, you know, something like give me something that we can that we can suggest to these uh uh prize awarding committees that they can actually do about this.

Scott RaeYou know, now we've done this in education. We have a lot of, I mean, we have things that we do with our students when we suspect AI use. We, you know, same thing that we do when we suspect plagiarism. We call them in, we ask them to tell us about their paper and see, you know, see how much they remember of what they actually wrote. And if they can't, if they don't uh recall very much, the chances are really high that they have either plagiarized or used AI to replace them as the author, and not just, you know, and not just to help edit their work.

Sean McDowellI've got an idea. Why don't we bring back public executions for people that use it? I'm glad you laughed and saw my humor on this one. Maybe in five years it'll be so bad, somebody will bring it back, and I won't be able to make that argument. Uh kidding aside, it isn't, you know, it is a question about like public shaming. You know, how much do you just make an example about somebody without totally ruining their lives and bringing back a culture of shame? I mean, does that help minimize?

Sean McDowellUh, I I don't, I'm not even saying I'm for that, but it seems like something like this, there ought to be some sense of shame. Like, wow, this is not how humans should act and we shouldn't do this kind of corporate accountability. I think, you know, biblically speaking, the obvious principle is just the ninth commandment, thou shalt not lie, thou shalt not bear false witness. And to submit a short story as if it's your own and it's not is clearly an instance of deception because the audience's expectation is that this was written by the individual, not an AI system that they could generate themselves.

Sean McDowellI only have two responses to your question. Number one, I do think we need to have real clarity in the classroom. I have clarity for my students. Maybe I should even get more how they can use AI, how they can't. And things like the Evangelical Theological Society with papers, how can you use AI? How can you not use AI? Pastors is their clarity. The first thing we need is just reasonable, clear guidelines that we know and largely agree on. And then, second, that there's no tool that's going to catch everything.

Sean McDowellSo, this tool right now, this pangram tool, whatever it is, can detect certain things, but it's only a matter of time where AI learns, and I put that in bracket, to avoid the test that this AI detection system has and is no longer detectable. Now, I do wonder how at what point will human beings not be able to tell the authentic from the fake? Because there's a certain implicit kind of knowledge that we have.

Sean McDowellAnd maybe this is a bad example. I remember I was watching a Christian movie years ago, and this basketball player played for D1 school, and the director of the film was like, isn't that awesome? He has a great jump shot. And I, as nicely as I could, I said, Yeah, he looks like a good player, but he's not a high-level D1 player. I can just see the way he shoots and plays implicitly because I played basketball in a way that a machine couldn't tell. Well, when does our implicit knowledge run out of these experts because AI is so high?

Sean McDowellIt feels like at some point that's probably going to happen, which our safeguards can only go so far. When it's all said and done, the only way we have of resisting this is virtue and character, something internal that's going to resist these temptations. And I wish I could say, Scott, every time in my life I've resisted it because I've always had character. Reading this article, I thought back to a time, even in sixth grade, I was like, you know what? Man, on this, I think it was a vocab or spelling test, I cheated because I wanted an A and I gave in.

Sean McDowellI still remember in sixth grade with this teacher that I loved. And it's still like, as I haven't thought about it for years, but thinking about it now, it almost bothers me. Like, gosh, I wish I hadn't done that. Like all of us have fallen short. Now the temptations are even greater than they ever were. So we need more character than we've ever had. I don't think there's any way around it besides that. What do you think?

Scott RaeUh yeah, I completely agree. I've and I've told my students, you know, if you know, if you if you if you're in this course just to check a box and to fulfill a requirement and don't really care about learning anything, don't really care about the kind of person you're becoming, I I think, you know, I I'm I'm not gonna lose a lot of sleep if you use AI. But if you really care about learning something, if you want something that you're gonna take with you for for a grad student into into the pastorate or into their, you know, their pastoral ministry, uh you know, then use it, use it within responsible limits.

Scott RaeAnd we've clear clarified exactly what's appropriate to use and what's not. Uh but I do think that you know it's it it we do have the virtue person asked the question, you know, what kind of person would use AI from start to finish and turn it in as their own work? You know, it's not that different, Sean. I had a student years ago who uh for a for a paper on in my ethics course, this was in an in an ethics course of all things, took took a chapter from Moral Choices, reproduced it almost in its entirety, word for word, and put his own name at the top of it.

Scott RaeAnd I I caught, I, you know, thankfully, I you know, and understandably, I caught it within the first paragraph. Oh my goodness. As as I as I would hope I would. Um and I think the the there is there is, I think, a you know, a point you're making about shaming and sort of public shaming for this. Uh that can, I think, can go too far as the the case, this this uh Cambridge professor, Jason Arde, uh, who was you know widespread accusations of plagiarism, uh, and and he was so shamed by it that he ended up taking his own life.

Scott RaeUm and so I think uh I I I I've got questions about you know the propriety of some of that. Uh but I think to let, you know, we we have to be clear that you know do using AI in the same way that you would copy somebody's work and put your name on it as your own is just as much egregious plagiarism as the old-fashioned definition of it.

Sean McDowellWell said. Yeah, I I agree with that. And it's ultimately character and virtue. Uh, I think we're gonna keep circling back that here as a theme on think biblically, because of course it's a biblical idea. All right, we've got some questions. And before we go to our two questions, just want to remind our audience that we would love to have you come study. That's at Tauba School of Theology. Scott, I wish I knew over the past nine years how many students have decided to come study at Talbot because of hearing the podcast. I really have no idea. I've gotten emails, have people tell me anecdotally.

Sean McDowellIt actually means a ton to us if you. In fact, since it's nine years and you're listening, if there's a way that this podcast has helped you, would you just shoot us a quick email and let us know whether you came to Talbot, whether you shared with somebody? We would love to just hear some stories that would help us kind of gather its impact and think about the next 10 years and beyond. We definitely would love to have you come study with us at Talbot, either our campus at Phoenix or our campus here in Southern California or by distance. All right, we had three questions, but one was about the public execution.

Sean McDowellWe gave our two cents on that one. So here's one that says it seems that much weight is placed on the woman's responsibility in pregnancy and little mention of the male's role. In brief, it'd be refreshing to hear why the men responsible for impregnated women are not also held legally accountable for abortions. Do you believe these men should be held legally accountable?

Scott RaeNo, because it's not their decision to end the pregnancy. Uh they they and I would say they are accountable if the woman keeps the baby for child support for the next 18 years, whether the man wants to keep, whether the man wants the child or not. And this is where, Sean, I think there's an inequity between the sexes that we don't often acknowledge. That is, the decision to avoid responsibility for the pregnancy is entirely the woman's, even if the man, and even if the man does not want the child, if the woman keeps the child, he's still on the hook for child support.

Scott RaeBut the woman, simply by her choice, can end her responsibility to and for that child. And I think the right answer is that neither of them should be able to do this simply by their choice at the expense of the child. And only on the assumption that the child is not a person, does this rationale even begin to make sense?

Sean McDowellThat's exactly the heart of it. What is the unborn is the heart of the question. The difficulty of just giving an across-the-board response about how men should be held legally accountable is I know many cases of men who desperately try to talk their girlfriends or wives out of having an abortion. And then some men who manipulate and physically take and threaten to have an abortion. Those are very different cases. I don't know legally how to settle it, but if it gets beyond just encouraging and gets to the point of threatening and physically taking somebody to a clinic, then it seems to me there should be some legal accountability for it in those kinds of cases.

Sean McDowellAll right. Last one is like a theological question. In some ways, it came out of nowhere, but it's a fair question. If somebody's reading the Old Testament, they're going to have questions that pop up. And I might emphasize, I haven't covered this passage yet, but one of the things on YouTube that I've been doing, Scott, is interviewing Talbot faculty on the toughest passages in the Bible. And they're like eight to 12 minute interviews. So I just had uh Charlie Trimon recently talking about who are the sons of God in Genesis chapter six. What about slavery with Carmenines in Exodus chapter 21?

Sean McDowellSo there's a lot of short takes there with Talbot professors that might be helpful. But this question says, I have a question about 2 Kings chapter 2, verses 23 through 24, where Elisha apparently overreacted to taught by a bunch of boys who call them Baldy. Elisha calls down a curse on the boys. Two bears come out and attack the boys. Was Elisha really that sensitive about his hair? Or is there something else going on here? Could there be a connection with cutting hair as a sign of taking or ending a vow? Really, the question is, you know, could the boys in 2 Kings have been mocking Elisha about the audacity of cutting his hair as a sign of joining the prophets?

Sean McDowellLike, is this complete overkill for calling somebody Baldy? And I'd say a few things. First off, it's a short passage. We don't have a lot of context for it. So we have to do our best in the Bible as a whole, in 2 Kings and the role of a prophet, to make sense of this. A couple other things to keep in mind is number one, Elisha had just taken the prophetic mantle from Elijah. So Elisha, one of the key prophets of the Old Testament. We see Elisha take over, and then very shortly afterwards, somebody is mocking his status.

Sean McDowellSo a lot is at stake. To ridicule Elisha would have been understood in that culture since he spoke for God as a prophet, to ridicule God himself. This is a ridicule of God's character. The other piece was we're at the point in the story where the people had been given warning after warning after warning, given the Mosaic covenant, about how important it was in obedience, given the nation of Israel. So you see these warnings increase in how severe they are to finally wake the people up.

Sean McDowellIn some ways, this didn't wake the people up because shortly thereafter they get exiled for further disobedience. Last thing I'll say is I don't know why, but the ESV translate this as small boys, but the Hebrew phrase refers to those at least 12 to 30 years old. So a translation of small boys or boys is likely incorrect. Anything you want to add to this?

Scott RaeYeah, just one thing. I think you're right that the big idea is that contempt for the prophet here was tantamount to contempt for God Himself. Because the prophet is seen as God's special, specific messenger. And the the the taunt that they're making is the the NIV translates this get out of here, Baldi, get out of here. Literally, the term in Hebrew is the taunt is to go up, Baldi, go up, and it's for and it's a taunt referring to Elijah, which had taken place earlier in the chapter, Elijah's ascent into heaven uh you know, directly uh you know at the end of his at the end of his life.

Scott RaeUh and so I think it's it's for it's it's definitely an expression of contempt and derision for the the messenger of God, which is also I think uh equivalent to contempt and derision for God Himself.

Sean McDowellLook at you, man, pulling out some context and Hebrew language to explain this passage. You're on fire today, my friend.

Scott RaeI think I think you are I'd be I'd be interested to see hear you uh you know interview one of our Old Testament prophets on that passage, too.

Sean McDowellYou know what? We've been working through Genesis and Exodus, have not got to 2nd Kings yet, but I will put that on my list to hear what Charlie Trim or Carmen Imes or Daniel Kim and so on, the rest of our amazing crew would take on that passage.

Scott RaeYeah, we may have to rescind everything we just said.

Sean McDowellWe might have to, but fair enough. Hopefully that helps uh for now. Uh all right, Scott, as always, this is fun. This has been an episode of the podcast Think Biblically, Conversations on Faith and Culture, brought to you by Talbot School Theology, Biole University, where both Scott and I teach full-time. We have master's programs in theology, apologetics, marriage and family, Bible, Old Testament in person at our our our Phoenix, uh Talbot Phoenix Seminary, as well as our Talbot Seminary in Southern California, and online.

Sean McDowellPlease keep your comments and questions coming. You can email us at thinkbiblically at biola.edu. And again, if you have any thoughts or ways that this podcast has helped you over the past nine years, we would love to hear. That would be encouraging and helpful for us on a lot of levels. Please give us a rating on your podcast app. If you've been listening nine years and have not given us a rating yet, now is the time. It's due. We appreciate you listening, and we'll see you Tuesday. We've had a really cool conversation with archaeologists named Paul Weaver about his top archaeological discoveries that support the Bible.

Sean McDowellIn the meantime, remember to think biblically about everything.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 140 Near-Death Experiences and the Afterlife (with Randy Kay)

    Nov 17, 20261 hr 17 minAudio

    Randy Kay was a biotech CEO and a self-described skeptic who didn't believe in near-death experiences until he flatlined for 30 minutes in 2005 and, in his telling, found himself face to face with Jesus. Now he's...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Weekly Cultural Update: Legal Protections for Polyamory; Parents Suing Over Bad Grades; Is AI Able to Read Minds?; Parents May Face Jail for Saying No to Gender Transition

    Nov 13, 20261 hrAudio

    Polyamorous Domestic Partnerships in West Hollywood: West Hollywood’s city council unanimously approved a domestic partnership registry for multi-partner relationships, granting rights such as hospital visitation and...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Fine Tuning Argument is Stronger Than Ever (With Jay Richards)

    Nov 10, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    Is the universe fine-tuned for life? Or has the fine-tuning argument been defeated? In this conversation, Sean sits down with Dr. Jay Richards, a philosopher, co-author of The Privileged Planet, and one of the world's...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Weekly Cultural Update: Identity Politics 2.0; The Supreme Court and Colorado Religious Schools; Family Time Replacing Time With Friends; Doctors and Carbon Footprints

    Nov 6, 20261 hrAudio

    Political Identity 2.0: Scott and Sean examine how identity politics is shifting from race and gender toward economic class. They encourage believers to reject zero-sum financial mindsets while engaging civically....

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Sharia Law and the US Constitution (With A.S. Ibrahim)

    Nov 3, 202631 minAudio

    Should Christians be concerned about Sharia law being implemented in the US What is Sharia Law, and is it compatible with the U.S. Constitution? Sean and Scott are shared by Dr. A.S. Ibrahim to discuss his latest book...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode