Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Think Biblically: Conversations on Faith & Culture

Think Biblically: Conversations on Faith & Culture artwork

Weekly Cultural Update: Is Scripture Outdated? The Rise of Polyamory; Worldview and AI Safety: UK's Assisted Dying

Sep 25, 20261 hr 1 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Are Biblical Truths Becoming Outdated? Sean and Scott analyze recent Lifeway research revealing that a growing number of younger churchgoers view certain biblical teachings as outdated, highlighting the need to help the next generation understand how Scripture promotes human flourishing. The Rise of Polyamory: An article in The Christian Century addresses the rise of consensual non-monogamy, spurring analysis of how alternative relationship structures affect personal fulfillment, emotional stability, and the social frameworks supporting mutual care. AI Safety and China's Worldview: While Western nations debate whether AI poses systemic risks to society, China approaches AI safety around protecting Communist Party control and embedding state ideology into algorithms. Defeating the UK's Assisted Dying Bill: The discussion turns to how Christian advocacy helped defeat proposed assisted dying legislation in the UK, standing up for the vulnerable and affirming the value of human life. Audience Question: Flock License Plate Cameras: Sean and Scott evaluate the ethics of widespread Flock surveillance cameras, balancing the benefits of crime prevention against concerns regarding personal privacy and government overreach. Audience Question: Can we choose evil in heaven? Responding to an audience question, the hosts clarify how free will is maintained in heaven, yet sin would still not be present. ========== Think Biblically: Conversations on Faith and Culture is a podcast from Talbot School of Theology at Biola University, which offers degrees both online and on campus in Southern California. Find all episodes of Think Biblically at: https://www.biola.edu/think-biblically. To submit comments, ask questions, or make suggestions on issues you'd like us to cover or guests you'd like us to have on the podcast, email us at thinkbiblically@biola.edu.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Sean McDowellAccording to a news study, half of younger churchgoers are more likely to say that cultural change makes certain biblical truths obsolete. Polyamory is exploding in the cultural conversation. Is the church ready philosophically, biblically, and practically to address it? Because of its commonist worldview, AI safety means something very different in China than the West. And Christians help defeat UK's assisted dying bill. These are the stories we'll discuss and we'll also address some of your questions. I'm your host, Sean McDowell.

Sean McDowellI'm your co-host, Scott Ray. This is the Think Biblically Weekly Cultural Update brought to you by Talbot School Theology, Viola University. Scott, we regularly want to take stories in the news and help people think biblically about it. But occasionally, studies come out the week we're preparing this about how Christians view the Bible. And so I thought we'd pause and look at this study that does raise some flat red flags and concerns for me. And I saw it basically the title was it was from the Christian Post.

Sean McDowellHalf of younger churchgoers say culture change makes some biblical truths obsolete. So these are Protestant churchgoers in the US. They seem increasingly willing to reject some biblical truths, with young adults under 30 more likely to say some of these truths are becoming obsolete. Now, this is rooted in a lifeway research uh study. Now, a few things that they pointed out. More than a quarter of respondents, 28%, agreed to a statement that as culture changes, some biblical truths become obsolete.

Sean McDowellNow, that's up about 4% from 2019. About a third of churchgoers said they accept some truths from the Bible, but others do not fit what they believe, which is up another 4% from 2019. But it's younger churchgoers that marked the most significant increase, you would say. So younger adult churchgoers, again, according to the article, were the most likely to agree that the truth of God's word can mean different things to different people. 87% is pretty significant.

Sean McDowellNow, there's some other things in the study. Uh, for example, 56% of pro Protestant churchgoers find it challenging to make sense of the Bible when they read it on their own, which is roughly the same from in the past. So that hasn't really changed. But increasingly, this uh US adults uh are increasingly reading the Bible more, especially men, but fewer Americans believe the Bible is 100% accurate. I love your reaction to this, Scott.

Scott RaeWell, Sean, there are a couple things that stood out to me on this. The first thing I'm I must admit is I think some of the reason for this is because us in the older generations have failed to help younger generations make sense of the parts of the Bible that they think is outdated. Now, the article doesn't say which biblical teachings they think are outdated, but I think you and I can make a pretty good guess at which ones they might be. That's right. Uh monogamous marriage, sex outside marriage, gender binary, male headship in the home and the church.

Scott RaeUh I and I think the question is, have we adequately explained why these are there for our flourishing? You know, God's commands are they're not arbitrary, as you have pointed out many times before. You know, God's commands are there for our good. And I think we have we have failed in persuading young younger generations how this is the case and why this is true. Now, the other the other thing that stood out to me, Sean, is to go back to the first century of the early church.

Scott RaeThey were immersed in a Greco-Roman culture, and virtually everything that the early church stood for was incredibly countercultural. And their role was they brought good into a harsh world. How they viewed sexuality, infanticide, wealth and possessions, the dignity of work, taking care of the poor, opposing the gladiators, and many other Roman traditions that they refused to participate in or took care of because of the neglect of the of the Roman culture.

Scott RaeAnd for many of these things, refusing to participate in these Roman traditions, many of which involved idolatrous oaths to Caesar, those were viewed as treasonous. But they they turned that they turned the ancient world upside down in how they viewed sexuality, for example. Uh how how they've how they viewed, they basically stopped the practice of insanticide by essentially adopting and taking into their care, I mean, this was this was sort of the the foster system before the foster system was a thing.

Scott RaeAnd I'd say it was it was the the initial foster system on steroids, where the common practice in the Roman Empire was if if families couldn't support additional children, they would leave them by the roadside and to die of exposure. And the church came and rescued these kids and brought them up in the community of God's people. Uh and it changed, it just turned upside down the way the ancient view world viewed infanticide. Not because they were out protesting this, but they were out there solving the problem that was created by this cultural tradition.

Scott RaeUh the poor, for example, in the Greco-Roman world were basically left to fend for themselves. There was no safety net, uh, and they were left essentially to, you know, park themselves by the side of the road and appeal to people who to give them alms. Uh and the church was the first institution in the Greco-Roman world to actually have something systematized and a value on taking care of the poor. Uh, you know, they they held their wealth and possessions loosely.

Scott RaeUh they have, you know, they just did, they did so many other things that introduced notions of freedom and equality and dignity that have just become part of the culture, cultural air that we breathe today in most of the Western world. And I and sometimes I think we just we we've we have failed to remind younger generations how out of step with the first century culture the early church was. And that there is there is nothing there's nothing morally problematic necessarily with being out of step with cultural trends and traditions.

Scott RaeUh so the uh I think there's there's there's a lot of room, I think, for uh just encouraging younger generations and help helping them make sense out of these parts of the Bible that they wrestle with. And I understand why they wrestle with them. That's that's that's fair. Uh you know, Sean, it reminds me of a conversation I had with my young my youngest son several years ago, where I asked him, sort of, just tell me a little bit about sort of where are you at with your faith?

Scott RaeAnd I said, I said, this is a no judgment question. I just want to know kind of where you are. And he and he he affirmed that it was still a real thing, uh, that he still took it somewhat seriously. But he said, Dad, I got some parts of the Bible that I really have trouble with. And he said, so I said, well, tell me what they are. And he said, Well, the one about wives being in submission to their husbands. Uh, he said, that that sounds like a prescription for abuse.

Scott RaeAnd so I said, Well, let me let me just explain to you what I think is meant by that. First, look at the verse right before that, which which counsels mutual submission in the body of Christ. Uh and and I said, as a result of this, uh, you got to look at the the whole passage that affirms the main thing for men, which was not to claim any right uh to have spouses submit to them, but it was instead to love them as Christ loved the church.

Scott RaeAnd I said, that that's a really tall order when you think about it. Uh and the the burden is really on the guy to love his wife like Christ loved the church. And if that happens, uh I think that the issue of submission will never probably never be, will never emerge as a topic of conversation. And he says, so, oh, he said, well, that makes a lot more sense. Well, good. And so, you know, but I think we just took some time to explain the sort of the full context in which that biblical text occurs.

Scott RaeAnd I think it I think it was helpful to him to get a sense of what was intended.

Sean McDowellScott, you're not only explaining this to us, you're modeling what it looks like with the next generation to non-judgmentally have a conversation, bring back to what the scriptures mean, and remove some of these barriers that this article is talking about. My quick take is submission comes from two words. Sub means under, like submarine, and mission is a mission. Well, what's the mission of the husband? To love Christ as Christ loves the church. Will you join me in my mission in loving you as Christ loves the church?

Sean McDowellWhen it's framed that way in practice, I find the vast majority, if not all women I've ever talked with, say, oh my goodness, that reframes things for me. And I understand. Now, I think in one of the things that you're doing here, one of the differences between today and in the past is many of the people, especially younger generations that I speak with, will think that certain things make the Bible obsolete because they find the biblical teaching restrictive. It was actually in the first culture and first generation that people found the Bible liberating and freeing from the licentious sexual ethic of the culture.

Sean McDowellThey said, oh my goodness, these boundaries actually protect us. So ironically, we've lost that. So I love that you brought that up. I just have a couple observations from this article that might help. One of the studies said more than a quarter of respondents agree to the statement that as culture changes, some biblical truths become obsolete. Now, in some ways, when I see one study like this with a thousand people, I've got to qualify it. My dad always taught me you need multiple studies really to establish something definitively.

Sean McDowellI could see somebody reading this go, look, the truth that you can't have a tattoo because it's listed in Leviticus, does that still apply? I could see somebody arguing that that commandment, because it's under the Mosaic law, is now obsolete. If that's what they meant by it, I wouldn't in principle have an issue with that. But it's the next one that gives me concern. It says a third of churchgoers said that they accept some truths from the Bible, but others do not fit what they believe.

Sean McDowellSo there's a difference between certain laws were given under a theocratic system of the Old Testament and they don't apply in the same way. That's obvious. Read the book of Hebrews. We don't need the sacrificial system anymore because Jesus laid down his life once for all as the perfect sacrifice. That's different than saying, oh, stuff the Bible actually teaches doesn't align with my beliefs. That's where I say, wait a minute, that gives us concern. And I wonder, just to add to your point, if it's not us not just explaining why these teachings are good, but really getting to the heart of what kind of book is the Bible?

Sean McDowellWhat is it? Why do we embrace sola scriptura? The reason we embrace sola scriptura is because the words of the Bible are actually God-breathed. This is 2 Timothy chapter 3. And of course, Peter tells us that the writers were carried along by the Holy Spirit, meaning the Bible has a human component to it, but the writers were inspired by God. And so I have to think that if anybody looks at the Bible and thinks their beliefs superintend what it actually says, on some level, they don't understand and deeply believe that these are really the words of God.

Sean McDowellSo A, we got to explain, like you just modeled for us, what the Bible actually says and why it's good. But B, what kind of book is the Bible? And make sure people understand and have reasons for that. I wonder if that could challenge some of this as well. Anything before we move on to the story on polyamory? No, because we got a lot to say about that one. Yes, we do. And in fact, these relate directly together because I would say one thing that we've seen over the past few years is increased deviant marital and sexual behaviors being accepted and justified in our culture, amongst other ways, by people pointing towards the scriptures.

Sean McDowellNow, this was sent to be my mutual friend of ours. And on one level, it surprised me. On the other level, it didn't. But basically, in here's a few backstories part. In March, the Portland City Council passed an ordinance prohibiting discrimination against individuals due to, quote, family or relationship structure. They this Oregon City ranks second in the U.S. for its percentage of LGBTQ residents, many who live in unconventional polyamorous arrangements. These individuals, according to the article, face structures, family structures, such as housing, healthcare, education.

Sean McDowellAnd so they need to be given certain rights to live out their polyamorous unions. We've seen this in Somerville, Massachusetts. Similarly, in Hollywood, California, this trend is coming up. Now, we saw almost 12 years ago now, 11 and a half years ago, the Supreme Court's Oberfell versus Hodges, and Chief Justice Roberts wrote a stinging dissent. And he said, What's next? Basically, people find fulfillment in polyamorous relationships. But it appears that the COVID-19 pandemic really brought polyamory into the public consciousness.

Sean McDowellApparently, a lot of people use the opportunity to explore different kinds of relationships from before. And the article gives all these books and these articles we don't need to go into. They even make the argument that in the past, polyamory was considered those who are kind of elite, white, privileged people. And the article argues that that may not be as much the case as assumed. And of course, there's a difference between polyamory and polygamy. Polygamy is typically multiple wives. Polyamory means multiple loves.

Sean McDowellSo you could have a thruple or four people who are married and according to the definition, love one another. What's interesting to me here is now there's theological and biblical arguments being put forth. And they're the same kind of arguments that we've heard for same-sex unions. Now I might circle back to these, but one of the arguments, this is a new one for me, Scott, although the others are not, that in Acts chapter two, the model of holding all things together not only includes private property, but monogamous marriage.

Sean McDowellNow I'm going to circle back to this. I'm not going to mock a lot of arguments, but that argument literally deserves to be mocked. It's so bad. But there's other arguments that are being put forward that I find super interesting. There's evolutionary arguments being put forward. There's one if Christ's relationship to the church is a model for marriage, then it might as well be a plural marriage because it's not just one bride, it's many of us. You see the kind of arguments that are emerging here. And of course, it concerns me biblically, especially because we just saw there's not the level of biblical authority and understanding with this generation.

Sean McDowellDoes this concern you, or do you think it's still kind of on the fringes of society?

Scott RaeWell, Sean, first of all, I think this was a hundred percent predictable. That's right. Once the Obergafeld decision was ruled on by the Supreme Court in 2015 that legalized same-sex marriage, uh that established essentially established the autonomy basis for same-sex marriage, that you should be able to marry and love whoever you wish, regardless of sex. Then restricting marriage to one person was the next domino to fall.

Scott RaeNow, to be to be clear, we're not talking about multiple marriage, we're not talking about polygamy here. I think you you rightly pointed out that polygamy means multiple spouses, where polyamory means multiple loves. And as far as I'm as far as I know, uh polygamy is still illegal in every state. Now, the question is, I think you rightly pointed out that the city of Portland's decision to protect the rights of these polyamorous structures sort of parallels the LGBTQ framework for the eventual approval of same-sex marriage.

Scott RaeBecause it started out, I think, correctly, protecting the rights of sort of rights basically not to be discriminated against for same-sex couples when it came to housing and employment and things like that, which I think was right to protect those. But that was the first step toward the eventual approval and sanction for same-sex marriage. And it would not surprise me to see maybe the state of Oregon or some other state where this is this is you know it is widely practiced to recognize these as legal marriages next.

Scott RaeSo I think that for our listeners, keep your eyes open for that because it's following a well-worn uh track record. Uh now, they also, you know, you I think correctly distinguished between polygamy and polyamory. They also use the term, which I find really a puzzling term, as ethical non-monogamy. Right. Uh, which is they still say is still different from that, where you're committed to one person, but allows for other sexual partners.

Scott RaeSo usually I think committed to one person, usually in marriage, but not always, but allows for other sexual partners, which Sean, I think, raises questions about the level of commitment. It also raises questions about whether the term ethical non-monogamy is an oxymoron. I'm sort of inclined to think that it is. I agree. Now, the the article also points out that there are both hierarchical and non-hierarchical forms of polygamy, the hierarchical one meaning that one partner is privileged over the others, uh, which I think is part of what makes these, I think, in inherently unstable arrangements.

Scott RaeNow, in my view, Sean, when a married couple engages in polyamory, we should call it what it actually is, which is adultery. I would say it's still adultery, whether it's consensual or not. Amen. What makes adultery a problem is twofold. You know, one is that violation of one's marriage covenant, and usually in adulterous situations, there's some sort of deception or concealment that's involved.

Scott RaeUh but what the other thing that makes adultery a problem is that you are establishing a one-flesh union with someone who is not your spouse. So, I mean, we can call it what we want, but I think when a married couple engages in this, we ought to call it maybe what it actually is. Now, the the part of the article that struck me was the when they said pro-Poli arguments are grounded in the practice of plural marriage in the Bible, in the Old Testament in particular.

Scott RaeUh now, I think we ought to, for one, hermeneutically, we just we ought to be skeptical about taking as authoritative something that was practiced in biblical times. We would say not necessarily so, because there are lots of things that were practiced, as you mentioned, in the Mosaic Law, that are not intended for us today, because we're not under the law today. There are lots of things that Israel did in the Mosaic Law, which we probably should not be doing today. Now, in particular, I think polygamy was allowed.

Scott RaeTo say it was a practice that was condoned by the law, I think is a way too big a stretch. I say it was allowed because I think largely as a safety net for women, since there there were no other safety nets. I think we we ought to be we ought to be clear, too, that uh it was very rare that that this was done, since there the number of men who had the financial resources to afford multiple wives, with the vast majority of the population being subsistence level poor, that that that was very small.

Scott RaeAnd the only record we have of this really in the Old Testament, Sean, is some of the early patriarchs who had, you know, who I think were were were well off. They've been blessed by God uh agriculturally, they were well off. And the kings, later kings. So David, Solomon, for example.

Sean McDowellYeah.

Scott RaeBut that these these were rare exceptions to the general rule. Rule. And to say it was a widespread practice, I think is way overstating the case. The other one that I think is a little trickier is in the case of Leverett marriage. That's a tradition in the Old Testament, which is again a safety net for women whose husbands died before they had children. And the law commanded that the closest next of kin actually marry the woman, raise up a child to carry on the lineage of her deceased husband.

Scott RaeNow here's the tricky part. And we get an example of this in the case of Boaz and Ruth in the book of Ruth. The tricky part, Sean, and I'm not quite sure how to deal with this, is that the law nowhere restricts the eligibility to perform the function of the kinsman redeemer in Leverett marriage to single guys. Now, Boaz, of course, I think it's pretty clear from the book of Ruth, was a single guy. So I think it's in the realm of possibility that we did have multiple marriages in these kind of exceptional cases to provide a safety net for childless widows when there was really no other option except for prostitution.

Scott RaeBut things that happen in rare cases, as ex, you know, in these kind of exceptional instances should not be taken as norms for practice today. Certainly does not give biblical support for something like polyamory. And then I think Ephesians 5, you mentioned with the what we just talked about, uh with the you know, with marriage being being seen as a image of the relationship of Christ and the church.

Scott RaeThat is hardly an argument for polyamory since there is no sexual union involved in the marriage of Christ and the church. Among other issues with that. The article also points out that there, you know, some people make an argument that monogamy is a is natural, making a natural law argument for that. I find that somewhat less persuasive. Um and even if even if it is natural, I think we can ask the question, is it natural due to being a function of the created order, or is it natural due to the pervasiveness of sin in the world?

Scott RaeYou know, death and dying is natural too, but that was not part of the created order. It was part of the general entrance of sin into the world. So I think we have to, those there's just additional questions we have to ask before, I think, naively assuming that just because a practice occurred in the biblical text, it's allowed or a moral norm for us today.

Sean McDowellExactly. That last point is key. Now, there's a whole book coming out on this, apparently in spring, on polyamory theology. We will come back and do a deep dive on this since it's coming. I just a couple observations that jump out for me on this is the opening paragraph describes that these alternative family structures face obstacles, housing, healthcare, education. And so they need to adapt a lot of these family structures. I'm going to ask what should be an obvious question.

Sean McDowellAre these laws being framed to benefit adults? Or are these laws being framed for the best of children? And I think the answer to that is obvious. This is where sexual desires really have become one of the key driving forces in law and all of society that we need to make sure we have in place laws that don't quote discriminate against really whatever chosen lifestyle we want within thinner and thinner boundaries and restraints.

Sean McDowellIf we started with the question, what's best for kids? How would they flourish the most? How would they become citizens in the future generations that will help society thrive and flourish and grow? I'm sorry, but we would never start with, we would never even conclude with coming up with these laws to protect adults. This is where our friend Katie Faust has talked about them before us. So, in some ways, part of me wants to say, you know, shame on these people who put these laws in Hollywood, who put them in Massachusetts, who put them in Oregon.

Sean McDowellI'd invite them to think about what is best for kids first. And on one small level, we know all the data shows that kids with a mom and a dad in the home survive and thrive the best, period. It's alternative adults in the household, not biologically tied to the kids, that are more likely to give one example, to not treat the kids well physically and sexually. It's a dangerous institution for kids, period.

Sean McDowellSo as I look at it through that lens, this kind of enrages me. I'm not going to respond to all of the theological arguments here, but it's interesting that I'll just give a couple. One of them talks about evolutionary psychologists kind of show that animals are not wired towards monogamy because they need one spouse to maybe go get food and another one to help. Spouse is the wrong term, but you get the point. One to get food, the other to stay back with the mother to protect. So here's the question: Can we look towards animals in nature and how they behave to conclude what we think is moral and good for how we ought to behave?

Sean McDowellAnd why is it that we tend to pick the examples that support our views, but don't pick those examples that don't? Obviously, in nature, we have all sorts of things like cannibalism that obviously wouldn't say, oh, it's natural in nature. Therefore, cannibalism is okay. Not pointing to nature as an example is what we should do because we are qualitatively different as human beings. Animals are not moral beings. We uniquely are moral beings.

Sean McDowellThey're not hosting podcasts, they're not writing articles, they're not even thinking about this stuff. They act on instinct. So I think the evolutionary arguments are just at most, they can say, here's what we observe in nature, but they can't tell us as human beings how we ought to behave. I think they're somewhat desperate. Now, one other philosopher says she proposes viewing relationships like a choose your own adventure novel or a buffet dinner. We've picked the form of love that best reflects our values and interests, she argues, without insisting everyone else conform to the same model.

Sean McDowellIf that's not a recipe for subjectivism and individualism and relativism, I don't know what is. We choose our own moral values and we don't judge others. I mean, on that, you cannot now condemn things like ancestral relationships. If somebody decides sex with kids is better, I mean, if that's their value based on the ethics she's given here, how do we condemn that? So I think these arguments are really bad. Part of me says, bring them on, let's have this conversation. But sadly, I don't think it's the clarity of thought that's driving this.

Sean McDowellI think these arguments are downstream. Somebody's saying, I want to be in a polyamorous relationship, so I'm going to find Ephesians 5 and Acts 2 to justify it. This is clearly the train that's driving the caboose, which is the opposite of how Bible-believing Christians or really any wise culture should approach the text. I could keep preaching. I won't. Anything else you want to add on this one, Scott?

Scott RaeNo, I think I think we've I think we've done okay with this one.

Sean McDowellAll right. So one of the stories I felt like we need to talk about this week was AI, because of course, President Xi from China came over uh to visit, and we're talking about the race of AI with China and the US. And I heard this morning that maybe China is roughly six months behind where we are. That's kind of a consistent estimate I hear. But this article was totally intriguing to me from kind of a biblical perspective. It's a guest post in the York Times, and it talks about how AI safety means something different in China.

Sean McDowellSo AI safety to us, we talk about concern that AI would steal all our passwords. AI might steal all of our funds because they can create these hugging face type of swarms that can get through protective firewalls. Well, according to President Xi Jinping of China, AI safety is bound to one overriding concern, the security of the Chinese Communist Party regime. This article says correctly, while the debate in Western capitals has centered on the danger AI poses to society, the animating concern is China is the threat it poses to the state.

Sean McDowellChinese models are well known for avoiding politically filtering or avoiding politically sensitive information and shaping it in a way that reflects state censorship. Key developers are working to embed Communist Party orthodoxy deeply within the models. Now, why is that concerning? Because these models are now available worldwide and people are starting to use them. And they quietly, according to the article, carry the Communist Party worldview far beyond Chinese shores.

Sean McDowellAccording to Xi, he was quoted as saying that, quote, China lays great emphasis on safety and security in AI and is committed to keep it safe, secure, and here's the key word, controllable. Controllable. Now, what they mean by controllable is different than what you and I would mean by controllable. Now, the article goes through, we don't need to go into this, how at least apparently we could have this debate, that things like anthropic and Google Deep Mind, we're told are built on liberal democratic values.

Sean McDowellWhether that's true or not, for the sake of this conversation, let's just assume that it is. But Mr. Z minister for state security, uh, they mentioned literally no existential threat of AI turning against its masters, the fear that dominates conversations here. But rather it'd be used as a direct assault on our political security, institutional security, and ideological security. There is a very different worldview driving the second largest, most powerful developer of AI in the world.

Sean McDowellWhat's your take on this, Scott?

Scott RaeWell, I think this piece, I think, exposes how the biases that we've been talking, we've been talking about bias in AI systems, large language models since their inception. That's right. And I think it's you know, it's naive to think that the AI that you're using is is neutral because it's value-laden, it's got built-in biases. Uh and it's just these, the ones built into the Chinese systems, are intentionally built into them, but with an entirely different goal.

Scott RaeAnd it's very clear the goal is the preservation of the power of the Chinese Communist Party. As opposed to what you mentioned, the liberal democratic values of some of the Western models. And I think the article summarizes this, I think, really nicely. It says that the race over AI is no longer only about technological superiority. It's a contest over whose concepts of freedom, security, and the role of state become embedded in the powerful systems that are increasingly shaping how societies think, make decisions, and wield power.

Scott RaeAnd Sean, this is, I think, another example. And here it's just more overt here in China than it is in other AI systems. But it's a classic example here of how the technology shapes us and has the potential to shape us morally in our moral views and decisions. And we've become, I think we've become a bit desensitized to these biases due to what uh what another article calls AI's tendency to encourage cognitive offloading.

Scott RaeI love that term. This is another piece that you sent that you sent me from the New York Times that talks about it's sort of asking the question: who says about the moral code that's embedded in a lot of AI systems? I this cognitive offloading, I think, is a great term for this. And what they mean by that is that as AI solves more of our problems and manages our lives, conducts our research, our own intellectual abilities atrophy.

Scott RaeAnd this, I think, is magnified by what this other article calls AI's growing authority over research, that we tend to read summaries increasingly instead of actually digging deep into the sources themselves. And I think that, you know, Sean, this is an example, this whole thing is a classic example of what I would call the says who question as applied to morality. Now, the the folks in the West who are developing these, they claim that they're working off values that have a moral consensus to them.

Scott RaeAnd I think as a result of the law written on our hearts and the moral sense that's built into all of us, though it's been skewed by sin and self-interest, no doubt. But I think that reservoir of shared moral values is probably deeper than most scholars would like to admit. And that approach, I think, is reasonable in a pluralistic culture. But I think at the end of the day, the answer to the question, says who, from a Christian worldview, is that God is the one who says for morality based on his character and revealed in his commands and general biblical principles.

Scott RaeAnd I don't, you know, as much as I want to make morality accessible to people who don't share a Christian worldview, at the end of the day, I think we have we have to come back to that says who question, Sean. And I don't know any other way to answer that that's not arbitrary except to say that it's it's God who says, both in his character and in his word. And I think as far as natural law is concerned, how he reveals some of those things in his world as well as in his world, which I think accounts for some of the moral consensus that some of these AI developers sense about some of the values of freedom and equality and consent, things things like that, that is we've, as we mentioned, I think, a couple, a couple stories ago, was part of what the early church instituted that's become part of the air that we breathe today.

Sean McDowellWell, well said. I think one of the points you made that really jumps out to me is that AI and these systems are not neutral. It's impossible for them to be neutral. So the title of this other article I sent you that you cited, here's the title Who gets to decide AI's moral code? The question is not, does AI have a moral code? The question is who gets to decide it? So you can't build an AI code without certain morals and values built into it.

Sean McDowellAre they going to be communist China's values about the collective and protecting the state over the rights of the individual? Or are they going to be a more libertarian Western view that says actually the government is supposed to exist to protect the rights of the individual? Decisions about this have to be made. It's not possible for these systems to be neutral. So this article says, I think real interesting, how can humans get automated machines to behave as intended?

Sean McDowellAll these decades later, much of the AI debate focuses on misalignment. How can we ensure that technology creates a utopia, not a dystopia? So the question they're wrestling with is how do we get people to believe rightly? How do we get people to behave rightly? But that assumes that there's such a thing as behaving rightly, what humans are, and how we're supposed to operate. So either this is what you said, a who says, like a biblical worldview built into it, or maybe a Muslim worldview built into it, or maybe a communist, materialist worldview built into it.

Sean McDowellIt's inescapable. Now, the one thing I think we're going to see more as these models develop is early on there were some very clear hallucinations. You and I did a show, I don't remember, a year, year and a half ago, on the new uh notebook kind of AI technology where you could you could actually drop a PDF in there and it would create a podcast with the content in the PDF. It's really remarkable. So I threw a PDF of Galatians in there. And one of the results, when, because it's a book about freedom, the the solution is all like freedom from a total critical theory perspective.

Sean McDowellSomehow these other ideas filtered into Galatians, and it was not analyzing Galatians. It was so obviously imported from another worldview. My concern is these things are going to be more subtle, is that they won't be as obvious and we won't be on the alert for them, and they'll be affecting us in ways that we don't realize. That's my concern. So the article goes more and says, for example, certain models uh tend to show a preference for values like fairness and consent over authority, loyalty, and sanctity.

Sean McDowellSo a Chinese model might have more focus on, say, authority and loyalty, or an American model might emphasize more on fairness. But a decision has to be made. And they point out how many early models were built, models were built on utilitarian ideas are woven into it. So whatever's considered the best for the most is going to shape it. Now, how does this get practical? Is this article I thought was fascinating, Scott? It says these kinds of values are already affecting your life.

Sean McDowellThey said, many hospitals. AI writes the messages that doctors are sending patients. My wife has gotten AI messages specifically related to medical issues. They said on religious apps, tens of millions of people are confessing their deepest secret to chatbots. More than a quarter of Americans say they have personal and emotional discussions with chatbots. And nearly one in five young people use them for mental health advice. It says the AI value shapes the guidance that it gives.

Sean McDowellAnd I think that's exactly right. So I just want to put on the radar of people that it's not a question of do these AI systems have a moral code? Because they're imitating human beings and they're giving advice rooted in the way the world works, what we should value, how we should think. There are undoubtedly ideas woven into every single AI system. And that's why we need to know scripture and we need to use them with real discernment and care.

unknownYeah.

Scott RaeA couple things just to add to this. I did a similar experiment that you did. I put a sample prompt in and had them base it on my own work. And I came out to be a raving utilitarian.

Sean McDowellAre you you did?

Scott RaeI suspected it all along, Scott, just for the Which which was quite a surprise, actually. My word. And I wonder, Sean, I wonder if if for some of our listeners, this might this might be news to them that AI actually has a moral code. They, I mean, you know, that that that's not that's not obvious to me that a large language model would have that built into it. But I think it's, you know, be aware that there are moral biases, uh, some of which I think are consistent with the Christian worldview, but others clearly are not.

Scott RaeUh so I yeah, I I did not want to I did not want to be known as a raving utilitarian uh in the in the spirit of John Stuart Mill. Uh, but that's that's that's how I turned out.

Sean McDowellUh at least at least with this one example. I couldn't think of an ethic. Well, I guess I could think of one that's more off than that, but I've read your books, talk with you for a decade doing this, had you as a prof. If that's what the AI system you use concluded, it just could not be more off base, which is a caution. I I wonder if this is a way to think about it. If you imagine like a system with all these different levers, and you push up on, say, the fairness metric, uh, lean into fairness. Well, let's let's lower the loyalty.

Sean McDowellI wonder if that this is kind of the way that you have to build a system and its responses. I I don't know if it's that strategic, but I think it has to be. And a lot of it is because this is built by human beings, and this is not like we're building a car that is morally neutral, not in terms of how we use it, but in terms of its system. AI reflects and imitates humans' behavior. So by definition, it can't be neutral.

Sean McDowellSo I think there's probably people building AI systems intentionally with a worldview behind it, and some that don't even realize it, but it reflects their worldview because they're shaping it in a certain way. Either way, like you said, there's a moral ethic built into it. It. All right. Let's shift to a story. You sent me this piece. Those last two are from the New York Times. This is from Christianity Today. I would not have seen this one, although this story cropped up. And so I think it's important we talk about it. And the title says Christians came together to defend or to help defeat UK's assisted dying bill.

Sean McDowellNow there's a few things that there was a vote that was just within recent times, and it was a close vote: 286 to 270. So no's as opposed to A's. And the article says the vote followed nearly two years of passionate debate over assisted dying in England. Kim Ledbetter, a labor party MP from north of England, first introduced the bill in October 2024, so two years ago. The bill would have allowed adults to request assistance from doctors to end their own lives, provided they had mental capacity, were terminally ill, and were in their final six months of life.

Sean McDowellNow, the article points out a few things. It said for more than a decade ago, supporters of assisted suicide presented a similar bill to MPs, and it was easily defeated. So it makes me wonder if this is good news with an asterisk about where the trend might be going within another five or 10 years, but we can circle back to that. There's an evangelical alliance which represents 30,000 individuals and 3,000 churches, lets the organization's leadership know early in the bill's journey that they were concerned. And actually, one of the key individuals here said it's it was not difficult to mobilize them, this is evangelicals, to campaign against the bill's passage.

Sean McDowellSo it sounds like they were very had convictions about assisted dying and willing to get engaged in the political process to stop it. So they formed a letter, published it in the Daily Telegraph in November 2024, and they described the assisted billing as a dangerous threat to our society and talk about how it reduces the value of human life to physical and mental capacity and uh some of the other problems with it. A thousand members of the clergy uh signed it, which is pretty significant.

Sean McDowellSo I thought this was a great example of the church stepping up on a life and death issue, working together across differences, and making a collective case together for the common good, rooted in biblical ideas, but even more broadly in human rights ideas. I'd love your take on this since you've studied this in depth. Even if you're utilitarian, Scott, I still want to know what you think about this one.

Scott RaeWell, even on utilitarian grounds, I think this should be opposed. Uh that's that's another story for another day. Uh I think this is overwhelmingly good news for the elderly and the chronically ill, that they do not have to fear uh having assisted suicide or euthanasia performed on them having having been coerced either by physicians or family members into making a decision not because they're tired of living, but because their loved ones are tired of them living.

Scott RaeAnd I think that to recognize that this is a what I what we call a logical slippery slope that moves from the voluntary, which the law requires that it be fully voluntary. But in my view, Sean, that's impossible to enforce because there's no way that government has access to private conversations between patients and physicians, or patients and family members who may be trying to subtly or not so subtly twist their arm to sign an assisted suicide declaration.

Scott RaeAgain, not because the patient's tired of living, but because they become a burden to their loved ones. And remember, too, I think the important thing is that the context is really different in the UK than here. Because they have a national health service, essentially what we're calling Medicare for all, and they have huge concerns about resource allocation with their aging population. And remember, this is you know, I get this probably more so than you do because I'm one of the baby boomers who are becoming what have but would have been called the geezer boomers, who are, you know, who are rapidly aging.

Scott RaeWe have the highest percentage of people in the population over the age of 65 in almost every Western country in the world. And uh the other thing to remember is that on average, people will spend roughly half of their lifetime healthcare expenditures in the last year of their lives, when it will I when it will arguably do them the least amount of good. And in the U.K., different I think than the U.S., legalizing assisted suicide is, I think, seen as one of the ways.

Scott RaeIt's tough public relations to do it like this, but nevertheless, it's been emphasized as an important way to control health care expenses for this still growing part of the population. For example, Dame Mary Warnock, who is who is very influential in bioethics in the U.K., has said in the past, and I quote, if you are seriously demented, you are wasting the resources of the National Health Service. And I think the solution, since as a as a colleague of mine said many years ago, there's nothing cheaper than dead.

Scott RaeAnd it is much more expensive to care for someone at the end of life than it is to have them exercise assisted suicide. Now, so I think this this has the this has the potential, I think, to protect the elderly from a slide down that slope from voluntary to nonvoluntary assistance or some sort of coercion that the this the law being completely voluntary, I would argue is impossible to enforce on a widespread scale without intolerable invasions of privacy.

Scott RaeBut the other thing that's encouraging, and this is the point that you had mentioned, is the impact of the Christian community on this. They unified around the cause. They also made a big difference, and the reason, I think, is twofold. One is they were clear and unapologetic about the importance of their theological convictions. Now, they also appealed to other arguments in addition to their theological ones, but they did not try to hide the religious basis for their position, even though some members of parliament wanted to rule those perspectives off the table.

Scott RaeAnd Sean, I remember a conversation I had with uh the, he's retired now, but the theologian Gilbert Maylander, who had served for eight years. He's a Lutheran theologian, taught at Valparaiso for many years, one of the most insightful theologians I know. And he has served as a sort of evangelical representative on President George W. Bush's National Bioethics Advisory Commission. And a number of us sat around the lunch table with him at a conference after he had, after he was, he was getting ready to go off the commission because the Bush administration was winding down.

Scott RaeAnd I remember him saying, he said, you know, I think in the future I'm going to be unabashedly Christian and let the chips fall where they will about how persuasive that is. Wow. And I thought that was really a remarkable admission for someone who had spent a good bit of his career trying to make arguments from a Christian worldview, make them publicly accessible for a pluralistic group on the bioethics commission and for the general public who reflects that. But he but he said, I think I'm I think I'm done with that.

Scott RaeI think I think the time is right to be unapologetically and unreservedly Christian about this. Show my theological cards. And if people don't find them persuasive, then sort of I he never didn't say it like this, but sort of shake the dust off my feet and move on. Now I think that I think that's that's an important, I think, balance to the need to have reasons that are publicly accessible if we really want to be persuasive in terms of public policy.

Scott RaeHe was, I think, at the end of his career in terms of that kind of influence.

Sean McDowellYeah.

Scott RaeUm, but it was, I think, a remarkable statement, I think, that this organization that you describe has adopted and actually found it to be pretty effective.

Sean McDowellThat is powerful. When somebody's towards the end of their career and they have reflections like that, it's really worth listening to and weighing. And of course, there's a difference between convincing my neighbor, making a case, maybe from natural law or from history or psychology or the harms of something, and just publicly saying with a thousand clergy members who are citizens of the UK and have a voice, here's our concern. And stating it out very clearly with a biblical justification, I think there is some power in that.

Sean McDowellI like this example. You and I have talked endlessly about how Christians engage politics, how they don't. Obviously, things are different in the UK. I'm not even going to pretend that I understand the dynamics there and how it maps on and is similar or different than here. But on an issue as serious as this, and by serious, I mean it's dealing with life and death. Because as you've pointed out, this is this is not a slippery soap fallacy. We've seen these laws go from voluntary to involuntary, from adults to children, from physical health and dying to mental health.

Sean McDowellWe see these things happening. And so for the church to come together and say we stand against people uh being treated this way, even in the name of compassion, because every life has value. I think there's something powerful and core issues like this that are clearly gospel related, broadly speaking, in terms of humans made in God's image and how we treat people and our witness to the society. I love this example, seeing the church come together in this way.

Sean McDowellUh, anything else on this one that jump out to you? I know this is an issue you've really studied in some depth.

Scott RaeWell, no, because I think we've we've talked about it quite a bit, but uh, you know, I would I guess to our listeners, uh what keep watch in case uh this is resubmitted in the House of Commons. I suspect it's going to be in the next two or three years. Uh, we'll try to keep you apprised of that.

Sean McDowellLove it. Here's a a question for you, Scott. I'm gonna ask you to weigh in on this one because this is not an issue I've studied. I want people to know that you and I spend a good amount of time reading the news and trying to think about it biblically, but sometimes stories crop up and I'm like, I don't have time to read that story. There's too many today. But this one, I've seen a lot of conversation about the ethics of flock cameras. And most of the conversations, according to this question, apparently focus on the legality of it, uh, kind of from a consequentialist view of ethics, giving up rights to keep us safe.

Sean McDowellBut is there a way to think about this biblically? Like, is this good for society? How ethically should we think about flock cameras?

Scott RaeWell, John, here's the thing. Uh I'm not I'm not convinced that we have rights of privacy when we're in public. That that strikes me as a bit of an oxymoron. Uh if you want if you want rights of privacy, stay private. Uh now the surveillance can't invade our homes, it can't invade our cars. Um but I guess just because you know the public is not a private sphere.

Scott RaeNow, to be fair, I do worry a bit about these use to prosecute people for things other than criminal activity. And you know, if I I I might have a different view of this if I lived in in totalitarian countries. So you can you can be prosecuted for opposing the state, for free exercise of religion, things like that. But I think in general, if you in a in a liberal democratic society, if you have nothing to hide, then I'm not I'm not totally sure what what the buzz is about on this. Now I know these can be misused, but uh I think the Bible calls us to be people of integrity, whether in public or in private.

Scott RaeUh and I think part of the reason for that is because you sleep well at night with with a person w being a person of integrity. Uh you you don't have to worry about people catching you in gotcha moments if you're always telling the truth. Amen. Uh so I I guess I'm not I'm not I'm not losing a lot of sleep over public surveillance, uh, because I don't uh I don't I don't think I have a lot to hide. Uh and I'm trying my best to be a person of integrity.

Scott RaeSo I think that I think that's the Bible's emphasis on this. Uh and I suspect you have something to add to this too.

Sean McDowellYou know what? I don't have a ton to add to that. I just think the concern is more you've made an in-principle argument. The concern a lot of people raise would be the abuse of that, again, like we're seeing in China, where that data is being used against people. So does their existence lead to that? Not necessarily, but we'd want to make sure certain safeguards are in place. But in principle, I think you make you make a great, great point. I don't have a problem with that. Well said. All right, here's a question. One of the most actually common questions I get.

Sean McDowellIn fact, I recently, Scott, was in a prison and I took a hundred, about 200 prisoners were asking me apologetic questions, and it was really fun. Posted it on YouTube, interacted with them. And this was one of the questions that they asked me that I've been emailed about here as well. And it's basically a question will we still be able to choose evil in heaven? If so, like are, you know, will we still be ourselves if we can't choose evil? If we do, can we get kicked out of heaven?

Sean McDowellAnd my quick take is some people argue that we actually lose free will when we get to heaven. We're kind of sired in the choice that we made. I think we have free will, but we understand the depths of our sin. And there's no longer any sin in our hearts, there's no longer any sin in the environment, and there's no longer any tempter who's tempting us. So I would know more sin in heaven because I see through a glass clearly, than I would just, you know, take my son and go drop him off a freeway to see if he would bounce on the five.

Sean McDowellLike that is not even remotely tempting to me because I love my son. I think we have that level of clarity and we're transformed by Christ that it's logically possible, but guaranteed we wouldn't. And the difference with the garden is we've chosen to be there. We've repented of our sins, invited Christ in to transform us in a way that Adam and Eve didn't. Anything you want to throw in on that one?

Scott RaeWell, it's just the, you know, the the two different sides of eternity are completely different worlds. And it's part of our humanity on this side of eternity. Freedom means the prospect of sin. But on the other side of eternity, we have transformed bodies and characters, unlike on this side. So I think the the prospect of the prospect of sin, I think, is sort of off the table because of that.

Sean McDowellI love it. Our colleague Clint Arnold talks about how there's the sin of the world and of the flesh and of the devil. That's where temptation comes from. Well, we're now in a train, we'd be in a transformed world. Our flesh is transformed and the devil is gone. So the means or motivation, we're in God's presence and we've been completely redeemed. It's guaranteed we won't. All right, good stuff. Again, there's other questions that have come through, but we just simply cannot get to all of them. But Scott, good stuff, man.

Sean McDowellLooking forward to next week. I agree. Enjoyed it as usual. This has been an episode of the podcast Think Biblically Conversations on Faith and Culture brought to you by Taub School Theology, Biola University, where both Scott and I teach. We'd love to have you join us in person. We have campuses in Phoenix and Southern California or online in our programs on apologetics, philosophy, marriage and family, Old Testament, New Testament, Spiritual Formation. Please keep sending your comments and questions. You can email us at thinkbivocally at biola.edu.

Sean McDowellPlease take a moment to just pause right now, dude. If you're still listening, give us a rating on your podcast app. I'm not kidding. Every single rating helps. Thank you so much for listening. And we'll see you Tuesday when I sit down with one of my all-time heroes and now colleagues, JP Morland, to talk about his life, what he's learned through suffering, and what he considers the best argument for the existence of God. Don't miss that Tuesday. In the meantime, remember to think biblically about everything.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 140 Near-Death Experiences and the Afterlife (with Randy Kay)

    Nov 17, 20261 hr 17 minAudio

    Randy Kay was a biotech CEO and a self-described skeptic who didn't believe in near-death experiences until he flatlined for 30 minutes in 2005 and, in his telling, found himself face to face with Jesus. Now he's...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Weekly Cultural Update: Legal Protections for Polyamory; Parents Suing Over Bad Grades; Is AI Able to Read Minds?; Parents May Face Jail for Saying No to Gender Transition

    Nov 13, 20261 hrAudio

    Polyamorous Domestic Partnerships in West Hollywood: West Hollywood’s city council unanimously approved a domestic partnership registry for multi-partner relationships, granting rights such as hospital visitation and...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Fine Tuning Argument is Stronger Than Ever (With Jay Richards)

    Nov 10, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    Is the universe fine-tuned for life? Or has the fine-tuning argument been defeated? In this conversation, Sean sits down with Dr. Jay Richards, a philosopher, co-author of The Privileged Planet, and one of the world's...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Weekly Cultural Update: Identity Politics 2.0; The Supreme Court and Colorado Religious Schools; Family Time Replacing Time With Friends; Doctors and Carbon Footprints

    Nov 6, 20261 hrAudio

    Political Identity 2.0: Scott and Sean examine how identity politics is shifting from race and gender toward economic class. They encourage believers to reject zero-sum financial mindsets while engaging civically....

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Sharia Law and the US Constitution (With A.S. Ibrahim)

    Nov 3, 202631 minAudio

    Should Christians be concerned about Sharia law being implemented in the US What is Sharia Law, and is it compatible with the U.S. Constitution? Sean and Scott are shared by Dr. A.S. Ibrahim to discuss his latest book...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode