Key Issues Ignored by Christian Voters: Host Scott Rae and guest host Rick Langer examine an article highlighting critical societal issues - such as systemic poverty, housing affordability, and long-term care - that Christian voters frequently overlook in favor of high-profile political debates. Measuring Faith with the Religious Behavior Index: The discussion dives into recent survey data analyzing shifting trends in religious practice, exploring how active engagement is measured and what declining scores signal for the future of the local church. When AI Anticipates Crime: The hosts unpack the bioethical dilemma surrounding Anthropic's Claude AI flagging a murder plot in Pakistan before it occurred, weighing predictive safety interventions against severe risks to user privacy and free expression. Thank God for Brave Men: Unpacking Louise Perry’s WSJ piece, the episode highlights the vital role of traditional male heroism and courage in maintaining civil safety and civic flourishing. Audience Question: Use of AI for Children's Cognitive Development: Scott and Rick respond to a listener's question wondering if AI could have positive uses in helping in childhood cognitive development. Audience Question: Engaging in Existential Apologetics: Following up on last week's conversation, an audience member wonders what are some good ways of engaging in an Existential Apologetics Dialogue. Audience Question: Defeated Satan and Spiritual Warfare: An audience member questions how we still engage in Spiritual Warfare even when Satan is defeated. Scott and Rick expand on the idea explaining that Satan's fate is known but that does not mean that the battle is over. ========== Think Biblically: Conversations on Faith and Culture is a podcast from Talbot School of Theology at Biola University, which offers degrees both online and on campus in Southern California. Find all episodes of Think Biblically at: https://www.biola.edu/think-biblically. To submit comments, ask questions, or make suggestions on issues you'd like us to cover or guests you'd like us to have on the podcast, email us at thinkbiblically@biola.edu.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Scott RaeAs the election approaches, are there issues that Christian voters are neglecting? A new study questions how actually engaged our believers in their faith. What happens when AI anticipates a crime that is yet to be committed? And a response to a school shooting suggests that society still needs male heroes. These are the stories we'll discuss and will answer some of your questions. I'm your host, Scott Ray, and sitting in for Sean this week is my longtime Talbot and colleague in philosophy, Dr. Rick Langer. This is the Think Biblically Weekly Cultural Update coming to you from Talbot School of Theology at Biola University.
Scott RaeRick, thanks so much for joining us. Really glad to have you filling in. Look forward to your insights. Glad to be with you guys. Like I said, it's from the Atlantic. It does have a bit of a progressive slant, yet it asks a good question about the issues that the Christian community tends to be most passionate about. The article begins with the admonition coming from the president of the Southern Baptist Convention at their recent meeting, urging his fellow pastors to be more politically engaged around four specific issues that he highlights abortion, the redefinition of marriage, transgender identity, and illegal immigration, issues that he considers central to human flourishing and the flourishing of communities.
Scott RaeThe article asks the question of why there tends to be a Christian silence about other issues that also seem to impact human flourishing. The author cites the funding aids, funding cuts to USAID, the U.S. Agency for International Development, which, according to some estimates, has resulted in half a million deaths around the world, many of them children. In addition, he cites the suspension of the refugee admissions program, resulting in reducing the number of refugees, mainly refugees, mainly Christians, fleeing for their lives to just a trickle.
Scott RaeFurther, he cites what he calls the assault on medical research from the drastic cuts to the National Institutes of Health, disrupting research on life-threatening diseases. We could also cite cuts to Medicaid, which is the insurance program for the neediest among us. Now, Ricky raises the question: why don't these three issues, saving the lives of the world's poorest children, offering refuge to those fleeing war and persecution, and advancing research that brings healing to the sick, occupy more attention of politically active Christians.
Scott RaeNow he insists, and I'm quoting here, after all, these are not peripheral concerns. They go to the essence of what mattered to Jesus. He told his followers that whatever they did for the least of these, they did for him. He counted welcoming the stranger among such acts, and he spent much of his ministry healing the sick and relieving suffering. So, Rick, I know you've given a lot of thought to things like this. I'm really curious to hear your take on this particular author from The Atlantic asking good questions, I think, about are there are there issues that we as a Christian community are neglecting?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so uh I the the first thing I'd want to say about the article is I think that he is asking the exact right question. So I I'm a huge fan of the of the question itself. And I I want to kind of highlight something. He's asking this question are we are we really neglecting the important issues? Um and I think he did a pretty good job of not making that a rhetorical question, but answering that as if it was a serious question.
SPEAKER_00Are we? And if I say that we are neglecting these things, in what way are we doing that? What why or how are we neglecting things that are legitimately important? And I think that's always the thing we should be asking ourselves. I don't think we're skeptical enough about our own selves sometimes. And with it are the uh, you know, the preferences of our political tribe or our, I don't even want to call it political tribe, kind of our subculture in the evangelical world.
SPEAKER_00You know, you look back through church history and to say that that the predominant Christian voice at every time has always been right, I'm just saying you're reading different church history books than I am, if if that's what you're claiming. So this is one of these questions that I think we ought to always be asking ourselves. And so I appreciate uh Wayner's comments here in terms of provoking uh some really good thought about that. Um, so that would be the first thing I'd want to kind of want to underscore. And he's right. So the the uh cuts to USAID um and the consequence, those cuts, I would want to point out those are always debatable consequences.
SPEAKER_00In other words, this is a thing that's hard to assess. You're predicting, um, it's different than abortion statistics in the sense that you're often actually counting it. It's like predicting how many people would die in abortions after some social policy change. But the point is, he's making, I think, legitimate forecasts. And I was in a Bible study group where one of the people was working with a foundation that was largely supported by USAID.
SPEAKER_00And when these cuts came through, they basically were closing. She lost her job as well as a whole pile of people with within that organization. And I'm like, why was that a good thing for us as Christians to be excited about? Is the, you know, the doge cutting of things like USAID and things like that. So I agree with a good number of the things that he pointed out. As long as we aren't saying, therefore, we don't care that much about abortion, we don't care that much about transgender identity, we don't care that much about the redefinition of marriage, which I don't think he was saying, but it would be easier to read the article that way.
SPEAKER_00So those are some things that came to my mind as I was um thinking about it. And yeah, I have a couple other comments, but let me go ahead and kick it your way. Trevor Burrus, Jr.
Scott RaeWell, I guess my my first my first reaction to this, Rick, is wondering sort of why people who have a more progressive political slant tend to be silent about protecting the most vulnerable among us, who I would consider to be the unborn. Uh though to be fair, this particular author has written about abortion, but I think that's you know, pr protecting the unborn tends to be that that I think that's the area where people have a more progressive bent are also silent.
Scott RaeUh and I think if we're gonna if we're gonna take seriously Jesus' admonition to uh put a priority on those that are the the weak and the powerless and the most vulnerable among us, uh then I think we we we have to include the unborn in that category, given the the number of unborn children that have been have desired died via abortion since Roe v. Wade was legalized in 1973 is in is in several million.
Scott RaeUh now one of the things I think that helps explain to this, maybe help explain the selectivity, is maybe a a difference in views about the role of government in solving these issues. And I wonder if this sort of maybe speaks to this maybe a slight libertarian strain among our evangelical brothers and sisters, uh who hold the who some who hold the view that Jesus never expected government to take over these areas away from the responsibility of the community to address them.
Scott RaeNow, of course, uh, you know, we we did you know there was no democracy in ancient Rome. It was a brutal, ruthless, totalitarian regime that had had no interest in taking care of the poor among them. Uh so I wonder, but I wonder if that is a is a factor in this, that it's not skepticism about the issues, but maybe skepticism about to what degree is this government's place to do this, and has government usurped uh the role of churches and other uh more boots on the ground or nonprofit organizations.
Scott RaeNow, of course, the the counter to that is that you know, the churches and nonprofits don't have the resources that state and federal governments have to solve these problems. But I think there is merit to the idea that the the closer you are to the issues at hand that you're trying to solve, the more the more capable and competent and efficient you tend to be with the resources you have at your disposal. And the the issue, I think, is the the amount of resources at the disposal of these various groups tend to be a drop in the bucket, uh given what the what the huge factor that the needs are.
Scott RaeUh I I wonder a second factor I that I just wonder about is that uh in our social media fueled polarized culture, it's these culture wars issues that get the most attention, and they the most immediate attention. But global poverty, uh refugees halfway around the world, I think is a bit of uh out of sight, out of mind. And so the farther the closer the proximity to the to your locale, the issues, the more urgent they tend to be.
Scott RaeAnd I wonder, uh this may be overstated, but uh the article points out that partisanship may also play a part in this. Uh that for many evangelicals, party identity may drive the issues that feel religiously important. I don't think it's quite right to say, as the article points out, that politics has become the master identity and that everything else lines up behind partisanship. I think that's way too strong a statement. Because I think most people see their political positions as entailments of their faith, which is the reason they're so passionate about them.
Scott RaeUm but so that that's my my initial take on this. Uh I I you know I've got a few other things to say, but uh I'm curious to know, Rick, if you if you've thought, if you if you responded to this, uh what you make of his the author sort of ventured into hermeneutics, biblical interpretation, and his understanding of the Bible. Uh so I wonder if you've thought about that. I have a few thoughts on that, but if you want to take it another direction, you feel free to do that.
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_00I I think I I I would say that Vayner's comment, the author's comments about why it is that people, in order, as I said at the outset, he took seriously the question of why is it this way? It wasn't just a diatrap against that. And his suggestion, as you were pointing out, he kind of identifies three sort of things. One is that we live in this culture war environment, so everything becomes them against us. And so it's like expecting an American GI you know coming across on the D-Day invasion to say, well, you've got to remember there's good things about the Nazis too.
SPEAKER_00You know, that's not the context. Once you're in a war, you're not making those distinctions. Uh, certainly not on the ground. Maybe if you were forced to philosophically or in abstract, you could do it. But I think he's right. When you're in the culture war mentality, you really do have that kind of in psychology, you call it splitting, where you see the this other person is all bad. These guys are all good, and there's just no room between it. And so I think he's right about that. He already mentioned the issue about um the uh polarization and kind of tribalizing these things because it becomes identity markers for our tribe versus their tribe.
SPEAKER_00And these four that are identified here, uh, you know, from the Southern Baptist uh, you know, leaders are indeed tribal markers for evangelicals. So I think that's definitely uh part of it. And then the other part is actually just the clicking behavior of consciousness, like you pointed out. Are we aware of these things? And the answer is no. And I think he pointed out all three of those. And I go, yeah, I think he's kind of right, right, and right about why that does make things the way they are. The question is, should we be thinking, be correcting that?
SPEAKER_00And I'm a lot more open to his correction. I uh as long as we're viewing this as an addition and not a subtraction. Uh again, I'm like, why don't we care about unborn kids in Africa? Uh, why why do we care if they only die by abortion, but they don't die because we refuse to give them malaria vaccines that have been developed? This is stuff that's well within our power, and the cost of this is just crazy small. But when we suddenly withdraw the aid, then suddenly this is no longer available, and then you just plain have kids who are dying.
SPEAKER_00And it's not that uncertain how many people will die because we've got a lot of statistics about that on the average here in Africa. And these are the last, the least, and the lost that become victims of those kinds of aid, which is a significant portion of what USAID was involved in. You know, vaccinations, malaria treatments, things like that were a huge part of this. And those were were discarded. So I'm like, yeah, good question. And I I think that is one of those things that says, you know, we've got stuff what if you've heard me talk about this probably before with some things you do with the Winsome Conviction Project, where we talk about how we form our convictions.
SPEAKER_00And there's kind of biblical principles and truths that I think are transcendently true that by and large I want to say Christians would all hold in common. But we have really different particular policies. How does that happen? And I say, what happens is all of these great scriptural truths pass through the black box of your particular subculture and particularly your own personal life. You have life experiences that change not necessarily what your values are, but how you rank order them.
SPEAKER_00And so we get a lot of differences out the backside. So one of the things when I read this is to say, huh, we should become more self-reflective about what's in our own black box that colors the specific policies that we draw out of scripture and blinds us to other policies that we could equally well draw out of scripture, but we don't. Why? A lot of times it's things inside us that are or our subculture, our tribe, our small group Bible study. You know, you have you have these things that kind of make you see things a particular way that could be different.
Scott RaeYeah, and I think we get, you know, we get better at this. I think we all have our lenses through which we see the Bible. Uh and I think we we can get better at what you're referring to by reading the Bible with those from other parts of the world. Yeah. Uh and but uh uh better yet, traveling to some of those parts and interacting with believers from other cultures who read the Bible and maybe read the Bible the same way, but apply it differently than we might. Um I think there's you know, there there I think there's there's there's much to appreciate about this.
Scott RaeAnd I think you're right to say as long as it's addition and not subtraction, is because it's not a zero-sum game here. Trevor Burrus, Jr. That's right. And I think I think we have to admit there there are issues, the issues of uh you know, the definition of marriage. That's important. Uh you know, the transgender identity, uh, you know, that's an important issue, you know, in in immigration. I'm you know, I'm convinced our immigration policy is still quite broken. Uh and how we how we address how we address that, I think is important.
Scott RaeAnd I think people who have strong convictions about those things do so largely on the basis of seeing those as outworkings of their faith. Uh but so is caring for the weak, the powerless, and the vulnerable. I think the Bible is very clear about that. Uh you know, government's role in that, I think maybe a little less clear, uh, but I think there's there's good reason, I think, to be supportive of policies that care for the weak, the powerless, and the vulnerable among us.
Scott RaeAll right.
SPEAKER_00Anything else you want to add to that? Uh just one quick note on uh intellectual humility. Uh and the idea that, you know, just what we talked about of us tending to live in our our little subculture and we have these uh things that are clearly value to us, and that we become blind, and therefore to just have a posture when you're talking to another person of stopping, counting to 10 or at least give them five, and then say, huh, I never thought of it that way.
SPEAKER_00I'm curious, why do you view it that way? And exhibiting that kind of intellectual humility, because sometimes you may find out you're wrong, but I think a lot of times, and I think this article is a great example, a lot of times you just realize, I never really thought of that. I just never thought of that. Um, and I think it's great to listen up and have that kind of intellectual humility uh when talking about issues like this.
Scott RaeVery good. All right. Here's a second story, very interesting story from our friend. And for Sean and me, we consider him our chief data guy on religion in America, Dr. Ryan Burge. This is based on survey data from the Pew Research Group. Roughly 35,000 survey participants of all stripes, religious, non-religious, including the nuns and O N E S. And the question is asked, how engaged in their faith are Americans really? Now, to put it simply, statistics show roughly about a quarter of Americans report that they attend a house of worship at least a couple times per month.
Scott RaeBut how engaged are they in their faith? Often it's normally measured through three different measures, what are called the three B's, belief, belonging, and behavior. But the main one social scientists look at is church attendance, important, certainly, but not the whole story. Byrds cites eight religious behaviors that further refine what religious engagement looks like. Okay, they are in-person church attendance, online church attendance, prayer outside of church service, sharing religious views with others, reading devotional or religious literature, reading scripture, attending a prayer or Bible study group, and saying grace before meals.
Scott RaeInvolvement is measured on a scale ranging from never to seldom, to once or twice a year, to once or twice a month, to at least once a week. Now, the result of this I found really arresting. Because Rick, guess which groups of Americans are at the top of the religious engagement scale? First place, and it's not even that close, may surprise you, Jehovah's Witnesses. Second, second are Mormons, third, historically black Protestants, fourth, evangelical Protestants, and then a whole host of others that include Roman Catholics, mainline denominational folks, Hindu, Buddhist, uh, Muslim, and and and then none at all.
Scott RaeUh so I'm really curious to think to hear what you think about this data. Uh I've got some observations about it, but uh, you know, give me your take on this.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so uh I number one, I appreciate uh Ryan Burge trying to do a difficult task of get a beat on what does it really mean when a person says they are a Christian or says they're religious or whatever these sorts of things might be, and trying to come up with measurable behavior markers that give you at least a little more nuance on that. Um, so that I think was great. Uh, I get I get I can't really complain about this, except what what he found, I found worthy of complaining about, but I can hardly blame him for that, right?
SPEAKER_00Um, because I was amazed at um how little impact people's religion tend to have on their behavior. And back to your scale. If you wanna, if you wanna, you know, on the on a zero to 10 scale, um, where are you? And the scale uh is so skewed to the zero side as opposed to the 10 side, I found it very, very disturbing. And so basically, you have 33% of the scale uh squeezes you into the the top, the top quintile, the top 20% of religious behavior.
SPEAKER_00You just it's hard to get up by the his scale on that. And I looked at his scale for those markers and go, that isn't really that rigorous a scale. I would hope that the vast majority of the attenders of my church would be able to, if not peg the needle, at least be in the 90th percentile on the scale. And the bottom line is that if you're over 60, uh mid-60 percentile, you end up in this kind of more extreme last, you know, the last group standing of most religiously active. Um and I guess that hit me, Scott.
SPEAKER_00You you would relate to this because you and I both have a uh Campus Crusade for Christ crew background. And we were both rattling around in that movement at a time where a lot of oftentimes the conversation would be would revolve around have you made a lordship commitment to Christ? So it isn't just that you're saying, oh, Jesus is my savior, but are you saying that he's your Lord? And I'm not trying to enter into a conversation here about what genuinely saves you.
SPEAKER_00I'm talking about what makes you a real disciple, what makes you a spirit-filled Christian, to use the language that we tended to use with Campus Crusade. And the Lordship decision thing, I just have realized I don't hear people talking about that the way we did back in the 1970s, I guess for me, when I was kind of coming in age of as a believer. And I feel like a lot of what he just gave us here. Was information about the fact that we really are not doing uh Lordship of Christ kind of uh behaviors.
SPEAKER_00We're not organizing our life around these kinds of things. And I just bumped in this morning reading uh a good example of this. This is a person who's a pretty influential Christian influencer, whatever in the world that's supposed to be. But the point is, this is a person who has a significant following. They're involved in a lot of stuff and is very much identified as a Christian. She recently was involved in divorce proceedings with her husband. And this is part of what was her her reason, her self-described reason for uh divorcing her husband was that she realized she had been living in her husband's shadow, not realizing that God, quote, doesn't want us to shrink ourselves or give up our voices in order to fit in our marriages.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, going, how in the world do we reconcile that kind of language with notions of dying to self? I have been crucified with Christ. It's no longer I who live who Christ, but Christ who lives in me in the life I now live in the flesh. I live by faith in the Son of God who loved me and gave himself for me. I mean, what are we really saying things like, I don't want to shrink myself? So therefore I will go ahead and divorce my husband. Um, and this is what I feel is lurking in the background.
SPEAKER_00This these are all the things that came to mind when I was reading Burge's article. And I guess I do want to say, how engaged are we really and how transformed are we really by our faith in Christ?
Scott RaeYeah, Rick, I think, although I think the the categories he's describing here are an improvement over what we've had. Uh because you know, if you showed up at church twice a month, you were considered religiously engaged. Um but I I think your point's well taken here about me, you know, it's it's tough to measure transformation because transformation is character. And it's you know, how do you measure the fruit of the spirit? You know, how do you measure love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, gentleness, goodness, self-control?
Scott RaeI don't know how we do that uh except by being up close and personal in s in somebody's life. Uh so I think that you know that's an an inherent limitation of any kind of social science measurement for religious engagement. The other thing that struck me on this is that you know these these are mostly, not all of them, but mostly private behaviors that are are in you are engaged in a privatized faith. Now, granted, that's I'll I'll take that over nothing, but I think we sometimes forget that Christi you know, Christian faith has an intrinsic public dimension to it as well, which manifests itself in how, like we s like the previous story, how we care for the least among us, how we contribute to the flourishing of our communities, uh how we see our work as contributing to God's kingdom purposes.
Scott RaeYou know, things like that. I think we we miss the public dimension of Christian faith. And by public, I don't mean political or partisan, uh, because there's a there's a public sphere that is well, you know, well beyond what uh we define as the political arena. Now it includes that, but it is certainly not limited to that. So though those were, I think, a couple of observations. Now, again, I think the the criteria are an improvement over what we've had. But there are a couple of the things that caught my attention on this.
Scott RaeOne is that the statistics on age groups and generations and religious engagement according to these eight uh categories, it's very clear that older Americans are more religiously engaged than younger ones, and that the percentage of engagement has gone down with each successive generation. Now, this is to quote the article here. The unfortunate part of that is that religious behavior is more than likely the most beneficial type of religiosity that exists.
Scott RaeThe data indicates that those who engage in religious activities frequently have a longer life expectancy, less likely to suffer from mental illness, or more politically engaged, for better or for worse, are more likely to acquire civic skills, and are more tolerant of views they disagree with. Now, I'm not so sure about that part. Yet here's the point, though, Rick. Yet it's the type of religiosity that is fading the fastest. And that ought to that ought to get our attention about and encouraged the kind of real discipleship that you're talking about, you know, in response to that, the person you cite who's divorcing her husband.
Scott RaeI wonder what what how does she make sense out of Jesus' admonition to deny yourself, take up your cross, and follow him? You know, denying yourself, I think, means that you deny that you have ultimate ownership of yourself, not that you transfer that to a spouse, but that that that ultimately that is under the lordship of Christ. So any other observations on this?
SPEAKER_00Well, I I would want to underscore the point you just made about how oftentimes the the behaviors that are being neglected that Burgess is measuring here are behaviors that are enormously beneficial for human flourishing. Um and I I think it's tragic that we do that, but I think it's partly a side effect of we don't often cultivate enough of an imagination for how the Christian faith really is something that is a tendency to make human life better.
SPEAKER_00It isn't just a thing that you do to get life insurance, eternal life insurance, so to speak. It isn't just a thing that we do because um, you know, it gives us a devotional um kind of healing relative to the daily sufferings we have, which are great things, right? That's not a problem. But uh to just say it is a life, a way of living that is actually in keeping with what Jesus would have us do. And he does that because his intent is exactly that we flourish as human beings.
SPEAKER_00Um, so I think I think you're right that it's an interesting mark. I hadn't thought about that when I read the article, but it absolutely does identify a bunch of those kind of behaviors that don't exhaust the gospel, but are very much included within the gospel.
Scott RaeYeah. I think this this is data I think that's really helpful. I would love to see us be a little bit more specific about identifying criteria that that give an indication of what you're you were calling more true discipleship and transformation. Uh that would be a next step in this that I think would be very helpful. Now, I think how you measure that is really challenging, and we may not be we may not be able to do that with the kind of accuracy that we actually want.
unknownYeah.
Scott RaeAll right. Here's a third one. This one really got my attention. Uh and you know, Sean and I comment there's we could we could talk about an AI-related story almost every week, and and lots lots of weeks we do. Uh but this one comes from the Hastings Center, which is still the preeminent bioethics think tank in the world today. And it begins with an account from a Pakistani gentleman who describes the situation like this: two 17-year-olds in Pakistan in two different regions were recently arrested for brainstorming plans for murder using the AI assistant, Claude.
Scott RaeNow, Claude flagged the accounts of these two 17-year-olds to the FBI, which passed along the details to Pakistan's Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the National Cybercrime Investigation Agency in Pakistan, then made the arrests. The other allegedly asked about abducting and killing a police officer's son, and when questioned, told investigators he was only developing a fictional story.
Scott RaeNow, whether that's true or not is there are not enough facts to determine those things, which is sort of, which is part of the point I think the article is making. Now, it's not just in the Middle East, it's not just in places that are more totalitarian in their governments. Governments around the world are embracing what is being called predictive AI with significant investments and policy shifts. You know, one example is that the U.K. has announced a 4 million-pound initiative to develop an interactive, real-time predictive AI to help prevent serious crimes by giving police, forces, and local councils early warning signals.
Scott RaeHere in the U.S., documents show that the FBI is working on AI tools that would help predict who might be a terrorist. You know, and Rick, I can't help but think that this brings back films like Minority Report from years ago that starred Tom Cruise. But now with AI as the predictor, giving probabilities instead of in minority report, more you know, more pre more certainty in the prediction. Now, I'm curious to see hear what you think of this. Uh I know you've thought a lot about AI and some of the potential issues with the application of AI to various uh various things.
Scott RaeI I don't think we should be particularly surprised by this, but I admit I didn't see I didn't see this coming right around the corner.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So this was an interesting article to me when I read it. When I first saw the headline, you know, you send me these articles, I see the headlines, I look, I'm quickly, oh, that that's interesting. And I I thought I was going to like this article and think, hey, this made a great point. I found myself not liking it so much as I read it. Um and let me give you a couple of reasons why. Um I and begin by pointing out why I thought I'd like it. And it very well much was kind of your anxiety about the minority report sort of scenario suddenly becoming reality.
SPEAKER_00And the punchline here is, of course, people are actually getting arrested because of what they they typed into Claude, which is kind of kind of dramatic. But as I read the article, I was like, wow, there's a lot of statements here that are kind of, I don't know what to call them, sort of totalizing things. So if AI flags you as being suspicious, the article has a way of writing it up. You'll be arrested, incarcerated, and you're you know, your punishment will be executed. And I'm like, well, I'm I'm sorry, but the bottom line is police do this kind of a thing all the time with saying if there's any suspicious behavior, please call the police.
SPEAKER_00And it's possible the police in Pakistan just go out and arrest people and throw them in prison. I mean, that may be exactly what happened. I literally, like you said, we have no idea the backstory. Maybe this kid had already bought the methanol and mixed it with all of his dad's wine collection. I mean, I have no clue what was going on there. But the fact that you're identifying suspicious behavior, I'm like, well, gee, that doesn't sound like an AI news flash. When I when I moved to our house here in Littleton, uh, they had had a few crimes around here.
SPEAKER_00They had a very active uh neighborhood watch group even before they had a couple of these things happen. So I ended up going to a couple of these meetings. The first thing the police says, if you see anything suspicious, just give us a call. And the thing that precipitated this was a guy who was standing around at a park that people baptized him as looking like he was suspicious. Well, lo and behold, he was. And he went and he tried to assault a 10-year-old girl riding her bicycle home. And uh and the policeman said, look, if it looks suspicious, give us a go, we go check it out.
SPEAKER_00We don't go shoot the guy, we go check it out. And we have things like this in the airport all the time. If you see a suspicious behavior, speak up. So I'm kind of like reading this and saying, can we make a big divide between reporting suspicious behavior and incarcerating and punishing people only on the basis of the suspicion report? And so a lot of the examples he gave seem to be AI triggering this might be suspicious.
SPEAKER_00And I'm like, well, that's not a news flash. Now, the thing that does concern me that I wanted to underscore here was that all this can happen automatically in the background, universally, with no good checks and balances. And that is very concerning because the kinds of reporting I just described require a human being to actually be there, actually make the phone call, and actually talk to a human policeman to do the checking out. A lot of this, I can see it beginning with AI at level one and spreading to level two, three, and four, that does end up looking like the minority reports.
SPEAKER_00So there's my mixed bag response, right?
Scott RaeI appreciate that. I think that's a good, a good, balanced, nuanced view of it. I think to be clear, too, when an AI system flags a potential crime, it's not observing the future, it's identifying patterns in the data that statistically correlate with historical incidents of crime. And the system calculates a probability. And I would say I think the problem arises when law enforcement treats this algorithmic probability as more of a certainty that requires that they take action.
Scott RaeNow, again, I think you're right to say what action they take based on this information is where I think the battle is really is. Uh and police, I think that they detain people, they question people based on all sorts of hunches and reports of suspicion. Uh but it's but but I think it's it's it's too much, I think, to say that AI here is encouraging governments to arrest people and and prosecute people uh on the possibility of a crime being committed as opposed to an actual crime being committed.
Scott RaeUh now I'd want to be clear, you know, to flag someone is different than arresting them or detaining them, to, you know, to put someone under observation or under surveillance. You know, of course, police do that all the time when they have probable cause. I wouldn't want someone to feel like that just by what they are writing to a chat box or expressing to a chat box, a chat box can be actionable for something more severe than maybe just putting under observation or questioning.
Scott RaeUh I would not want to assume that someone's future choices are determined by these data points that AI has analyzed. Now, the the part that the part that I get troubled about is what does it say about the right rights to privacy? Uh I would not want even a right of free expression. I would not want uh AI to flag someone for political views that are opposed to what a totalitarian tyrant uh may hold.
Scott RaeSo this, I think the the the opportunities for this to go off the rail, I think, are still significant. Um but I think your your caution, I think, is right. Uh I would I would I would I would want to be careful that uh you know free expression, even even freedom of assembly, I think government could get uh get word that an AI that an AI-generated algorithm could uh could highlight uh you know a protest or a demonstration that government would have it have an interest in shutting down.
Scott RaeUh sort of diff different, I think, than what's going on in France at the moment. I think government has a has the obligation to protect their citizens and to be aware of things that could go off the rails. But I'd uh I worry that maybe at some point, if this is abused, that even freedom of assembly could be curtailed based on algorithmic probabilities. That part, I think, is still troubling to me.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I would absolutely agree. Uh and and I do, like I say, I came in with a bent towards anxiety about the way AI is being used and will be used. And the thing that that bothered me wasn't so much that there was anything this article said that wouldn't have been concerned, just that it was, I think he was trying to create, elevate our anxiety because a lot of people are kind of not properly anxious about it. And the particular arguments he gave were kind of like, uh, there's better arguments to be given for generating my anxiety than just inflating the concerns of everything.
SPEAKER_00Because again, if you're starting to say, well, they're flagging suspicious behavior, I'm like, okay, every time I ride a train, every time I go to the airport, every time I go to a neighborhood watch thing with the police, they're they're telling me to flag suspicious behavior, and that doesn't lead to bad law enforcement inherently. Of course it can be abused, but the telephone call can be abused, all those things can be abused. And I think this article kind of clouded that distinction for me.
SPEAKER_00But I appreciate what you're underscoring is that AI is very much susceptible to being abused in this kind of a direction. And we should be very, very concerned about that. Uh we can add that to our long list of reasons we ought to be worried about that.
Scott RaeYeah. And it may be it may be that the you know AI-generated algorithms might be more accurate in giving us warning signals than the average person who we to we rely on to call in to report suspicious behavior. Yeah. I'm open to that possibility. But the the prospects of this being misused, I think, are pretty pretty significant, although the way the UK is describing it, uh just using predictive eye to by giving you know early warning signals, which I th I think is is totally appropriate.
Scott RaeUh now most I think m as as I think the police will tell you, most of the suspicious behavior that gets reported doesn't amount to anything. Uh and so this this actually this could make it even a bit more reliable. All right. One final story here, Rick. Uh I love I this is a this is a this is sort of a good news story in my view. This is from the Wall Street Journal from a British commentator that Sean and I both have great admiration for, and I suspect you do too, Louise Perry.
Scott RaeAnd it's entitled, Thank God for Brave Men. Now, recently, just last week, in Bend, Oregon, a carpenter by the name of Caleb Giamanco happened to be driving past his children's school, elementary school, when he saw a gunman enter. He retrieved his own gun from his trucks, pursued the attacker into the school, and shot him dead. He entered the rampage just minutes before police arrived, although not before the gunman had killed three kids, ages five, eight, and eleven, and a twenty five-year-old teacher.
Scott RaeAs as Mr. Giamanco recalls, he told himself, this is probably the last thing I'm ever going to do. But he felt a profound impulse to intervene. As he told he told he had called 911 at the moment he left the safety of his truck to enter the school with these words, I have to go in. Now, four days later, on the other side of the world, Australian politician Helen Haynes was deliberately struck by a car outside her office in her rural town in an attack that later led her to lose both of her legs.
Scott RaeNow, a gentleman working in a nearby barber shop, the father of three, said later he felt he had no choice but to intervene. He dragged the attacker out of the car, removed the knife from his possession, and held him down until police arrived. Now, the author here, uh, Ms. Perry, makes the point that in both cases the attackers and the heroes were male. She suggests that this kind of instinctive physical courage is more common among men than women.
Scott RaeShe cites the Carnegie Medal for Heroism is awarded to those who voluntarily relist death or serious injury to save or attempt to save the lives of others, and roughly 90% of Carnegie Medal winners are men. And men are most likely to more likely than women to be honored for rescues of strangers. That's not to say that women don't exercise heroic courage, especially what I would call mother's going mama bear on anyone or anything that threatens her children. There's recently a story of a woman who suffers serious burns going into a burning house to save her four children.
Scott RaeBut the kind of altruism shown in these cases for strangers is rare and is gendered. Now it's true, men are far more likely to commit violence, but men are also far more likely to step in to defend strangers and to work in professions that demand extreme altruism and physical courage on a regular basis, such as things like the military, police. Firefighters. Now, she makes other comments about this, but I'm curious to hear your your take on this.
Scott RaeDo we need more heroic men?
SPEAKER_00So I I would vote in favor of that. And it I I do think as a matter of brute statistical fact that it I think she's probably right about you know the that men test three tend to be disproportionately involved in this. And and I don't know that it's some that it's particularly surprising that men are disproportionately involved on the negative side of this, too, right? Men men are more prone to aggressive risk-taking behavior. And I think that's uh, you know, that that's part of what we're seeing here.
SPEAKER_00And sometimes aggressive risk-taking behavior can mean saving people's life as a hero and risking your own life to do it. And sometimes it can mean just running around beating people up or killing people. So yeah, men, men do both of those. And, you know, for good or for ill, I think that's part of, you know, I, you know, our biochemistry testosterone levels, whatever it is, I don't pretend to know. But the brute fact is that I think we do occupy those two extremes. And in light of that, we should be concerned with actually promoting and celebrating this.
SPEAKER_00And I don't know that it's so bad to shy away from the fact that we do tend to identify this quality more with men than we do with women, um, as long as we don't do that to the exclusion of women. I think I think her observation is probably accurate. The one thing I want to say about this as I was reading it is um I remember writing an article, and I talked about the fact that we we don't talk about uh bravery very often as a Christian virtue. And I think that's kind of unfortunate.
SPEAKER_00And it isn't the wording isn't super common of bravery in Scripture. Although I happen to be, this is one of those things my devotional time this morning, I happened to be reading Revelation chapter 21, and it's talking about, you know, the future of people who end up on the opposite end of the great white throne judgment here. And uh, for one set of people they get to drink of the water of life forever without payment. That sounds like a good gig. But the others do not, and they end up in the lake of fire. But notice the phrase that introduces that.
SPEAKER_00But as for the, and then it lists a whole bunch of vices here. We're gonna get a classic vice list. You know what the first vice is as for the cowardly. And I was struck by that. And I thought, you know what? This is a thing where God has an expectation of us to be brave. And I would say in this case, this isn't a thing that only applies to men, right? This is a this is a Christian disposition. And I think particularly in scripture, um, if if instead of every time the Bible said, do not be afraid, that the Bible said, be brave, that we might have more of a sense of ownership of bravery as a Christian virtue.
SPEAKER_00And I would point out that that's pretty much what it does. The word for cowardice here is also the word that's used in the New Testament when we're describing Jesus walking, you know, goes out in the storm, or, you know, the disciples are out on the lake in the storm, and uh Jesus confronts them and says, Do not be afraid, do not be cowardly. Why are you so worried? What are you afraid of? And so I think that we need to kind of recapture a vision of genuine bravery as being a positive Christian virtue and an expectation that comes out of our faith.
SPEAKER_00And it manifests both in the kind of risks that are identified here. But the other thing that I think the same thing is applied to, I think the common synonym for uh uh bravery uh or courage that is used in the New Testament is actually faithfulness. So it's a perseverance, a willingness to be faithful, even in the context of suffering, of persecution, and things like this. So when we say the seed of the blood of the martyrs is the seed of the church, uh we're pointing our finger at the fact that these are people who are risking their life, and this is a quintessential act of Christian bravery, is to be able to say, I lay it all on the line for the sake of Jesus.
SPEAKER_00And yeah, so kudos to brave men and kudos to bravery as a Christian virtue. How about that, Scott?
Scott RaeRight. And I'd say, you know, kudos to brave women as well. Yeah, absolutely. You know, Rick, several several years ago, my my middle son uh exhibited this kind of bravery, and it uh I've been one of the proudest moments I've had of him of him in his life. Uh his band was playing in a in a venue uh that uh, you know, he was he was outside, he was going, he was there was a break in the in the music, and he was going, he was outside, you know, just taking a break in the alleyway, and came across a uh a gentleman who was considerably taller and stronger than his girlfriend beating up on her.
Scott RaeAnd he instinctiv he's instinctively made that same move to intervene. And although he, you know, he admitted that the the guy he was intervening with got the first punch in and caused him to lose a tooth, it cost me a couple thousand dollars to get repaired. Uh, but he ended up disarming the person. He said he actually ended up throwing him into the trash bin uh and sort and sort of rescued the rescued the young woman from being beaten further by her boyfriend who was already punching and pulling her hair and uh was probably going to escalate it further.
Scott RaeUh and I think that's you know, that's I think a good example of the the kind of instinctive thing that uh Perry points out that men tend to do in a way that's different in than the way women do. Uh now, obviously, I think one of the points of application here is we n we need to consider continue to think about productive ways for young men to channel the aggression that you mentioned uh, you know, in ways that are fruitful and not destructive.
Scott RaeUh but I think there are there are lots of ways that that we can do this. And it doesn't necessarily involve the military or combat or sports. Um, I think you can have you can have people aggressively play the piano and get the get those aggressions out. There are lots of other ways to do that. All right. Uh ready to take some questions? You bet. All right. Before we do that, uh let me just suggest here that uh if you've enjoyed the Think Biblically podcast and uh and are considering continuing or starting some sort of formal theological education, we would love to have come have you come study with us at Talbot.
Scott RaeWe have two campuses now in Southern, one in Southern California, another in Phoenix, with master's, doctoral, and bachelor's programs in all sorts of fields from old and New Testament, Bible theology, apologetics, philosophy, marriage and family therapy, pastoral ministry, spiritual formation. Uh, and we're beginning cohorts in cities across the country. We have them now functioning in Seattle and San Diego, I think soon to be in Las Vegas, and others to be launching very soon. Visit us at biola.edu slash talbot in order to learn more.
Scott RaeAll right, here's first one. Uh this is an AI question. What a surprise. Uh I feel that there are some unexplored uses of AI for enhancing a child's cognitive abilities. For instance, what if a Socratic AI model was developed to function like a human tutor? This could be used to work with children at their own pace and guide them with individualized training and developing problem-solving skills rather than providing fully solved answers. What do you think of this? Is this possible? And do you think this is a healthy use of AI?
Scott RaeRick, what do you think?
SPEAKER_00Well, the easy question, is it possible? Uh for things like this, I I I don't know there's any question that it's possible. Um So let's just take that part for granted, at least for the sake of the conversation. What do I feel about using this um to help children who need some uh help with their cognitive abilities? I'm not opposed to replacing the human being in this transaction. I am opposed to, to put it bluntly and simply, uh, as an as a way for generating a curriculum.
SPEAKER_00I can imagine sitting there with an AI model generating some good Socratic questions and me being a tutor for a young kid who's having problems and say, hey, that's a good question. What do you think about that, John? And then you're having the human interaction. I tell you, I freak out when it's like, let's eliminate the human from this, because it's, I think we're denying our embodied existence, we're denying our social existence, and we're denying the power that comes from seeing an adult modeling a behavior lived out that you want a child to pick up on.
SPEAKER_00So there's a whole side to human formation relative to culture, uh, to to uh education that never shows up on an intellectual assessment. Oh, the kid has moved up from the 20th percentile to the 50th percentile. We had victory. And I'm like, yeah, if the if the victory came at the price of making social connections, making relational connections, uh, and engaging in all of the behaviors that come from face-to-face interaction, I'm not a fan.
Scott RaeUh so very that'll be my great take on that. Uh I think it's it may be possible to use this in a healthy way, but I would say only under the supervision of a skilled Socratic teacher uh who can, you know, who can offer correction uh if the model provides questions or answers that are are not appropriate or are just flat out wrong. Um I think it could maybe give maybe could give a start you know at generating questions for a Socratic model.
Scott RaeBut most of the time, I think a Socratic model is best done in conversational mode in the first place. And that's that is best done with a human being. All right, here's a second one. Uh said in last week's cultural update, Thad Williams, who sat in for Sean, mentioned an existential apologetic related to the Michel Foucault discussion. Is there an approach to engage with people using this apologetic without first appealing to Scripture? What are some of the best strategies to engage in existential apologetics? So I sent this to Dr.
Scott RaeWilliams, and here's how he responded. Great question. An existential apologetic seeks to show the non-believer how the triune God of the Bible is the only one who can reach and scratch the deepest longings of the human soul. So, in a deep sense, it leads with scripture about who God is and how our souls are restless until they rest in Him. So it's less about a case for the reliability of the Bible, uh, which is also important, but more about what we call the resonance of the Bible, uh how we should want it to be true because it fits humanity's most profound aspirations.
Scott RaeHere's a couple of suggestions on how to do that. In his book, Our Deepest Desires, Taubaprop Greg Gansel, who we talked about last week on this, zeroes in on our shared human longings for truth, freedom, beauty, and love. Talbot Grad also, Paul Gould's book, Cultural Apologetics, builds the case from imagination, reason, and our moral sense that Christianity is true. Much of the work of the great apologists also appealed to the fact that only an infinite God can satisfy our deepest appetites and desires.
Scott RaeEven Thad's new book, Reflecting the Sun, How to Mirror Jesus, was written to offer a Christ-centered existential apologetic. Uh and just last week, uh Sean also uh interviewed Gavin Ordlin, uh, and they do a great job of talking about beauty as an apologetic that uh can be can be used in this way. All right, hope that's helpful. Here's a third one. We are always hearing that Satan is a defeated foe. If this is the case, why are we in spiritual warfare against him?
Scott RaeAlso, why did Jesus say that he is the ruler of this world? Okay, got an answer for that?
SPEAKER_00Well, uh, so this is in some ways a classic example of the danger of just reading one Bible verse, right? So you can get, it's really easy to talk about Satan as a defeated foe or or that, and then think, oh, therefore, there's kind of no such thing as Satan left. And I think the analogy that's often given in spiritual warfare discussions, it's a little bit like once the allies had successfully landed on uh D-Day and were going across uh, you know, France and then, you know, Netherlands and Belgium and whatever, and on in through Germany.
SPEAKER_00Germany was a defeated foe. Um, and you know, the the fate was sealed, and especially with the Russians coming in on the eastern side. And so just like there wasn't a question of what was going to happen. But that didn't mean the Nazis all threw away their weapons. They were gonna make make a havoc of all of this till the last moment. And I think this is clearly portrayed in the New Testament with, you know, Satan prowling like in the lion, looking for he who can be devoured, right? Uh so we're devourable, or at least he he thinks he can devour us, even if Jesus steps in to save us.
SPEAKER_00We're being warned to pay attention, and that's exactly the spiritual battle. You see the same kind of formulation in Ephesians chapter six, where Paul is writing about our put on the armor of God so that we can stand against uh Satan and his devices. And this is exactly a preventative intervention from the harassings of Satan. And if Jesus will ultimately save all those who are his own, wonderful. But the point that Paul and Peter are making in this context is in your daily Christian life, you should be actively seeking to re to resist the unrelenting temptation that Satan puts upon us, either directly or through the context of the world or through our own sin nature.
SPEAKER_00All of those things are being prodded and enhanced by by uh by Satan's activities, and we should by all means be aware of that and be fighting that sort of a spiritual battle.
Scott RaeAmen. I'd say Satan's defeated, but guerrilla warfare is still ongoing.
SPEAKER_00You got it. Yeah. When you say that, Scott, I just remembered I I was on Guam in the late 1970s doing a uh mission project, and the last Japanese soldier came out of the jungle in Guam four years before I got there in 1979. I think it's unbelievable. So yeah. Still going on. There you go.
Scott RaeThat's it. Hey, Rick, thanks so much for joining us today. Lots of good insight. Really appreciate your contribution and your take on these stories.
SPEAKER_00Well, thanks for having me. It was great to be here.
Scott RaeYeah. This has been an episode of the Think Biblically Weekly Cultural Update, coming to you from Talbot School of Theology at Biola University with lots of programs to offer, uh, both in our Phoenix and LaMerata campus and fully online. Visit biola.edu slash Talbot in order to learn more. If you want to submit comments, ask questions, make suggestions, please email us at thinkbiblically at biola.edu. If you enjoyed today's conversation, give us a rating on your podcast app and share it with a friend.
Scott RaeAnd join us on Tuesday for our regularly scheduled episode. In the meantime, thanks for listening and remember, think biblically about everything.
Randy Kay was a biotech CEO and a self-described skeptic who didn't believe in near-death experiences until he flatlined for 30 minutes in 2005 and, in his telling, found himself face to face with Jesus. Now he's...
Polyamorous Domestic Partnerships in West Hollywood: West Hollywood’s city council unanimously approved a domestic partnership registry for multi-partner relationships, granting rights such as hospital visitation and...
Is the universe fine-tuned for life? Or has the fine-tuning argument been defeated? In this conversation, Sean sits down with Dr. Jay Richards, a philosopher, co-author of The Privileged Planet, and one of the world's...
Political Identity 2.0: Scott and Sean examine how identity politics is shifting from race and gender toward economic class. They encourage believers to reject zero-sum financial mindsets while engaging civically....
Should Christians be concerned about Sharia law being implemented in the US What is Sharia Law, and is it compatible with the U.S. Constitution? Sean and Scott are shared by Dr. A.S. Ibrahim to discuss his latest book...