In the second of a two-part conversation, Bishop Donald Hying continues his conversation with Karen Paschke, a consecrated virgin living in the world in the Diocese of Madison, as she shares her conversion and discernment story. Raised Lutheran, Karen spent 15 years away from God before waking one morning in 2009 knowing she had to come home. She entered the Catholic Church in 2010, and not long after, an unexpected question set her on the path to a vocation she didn't know existed. Karen recounts the surprise, resistance, and eventual joy of that discernment, the deeply personal formation process that followed, and the beauty of the consecration itself - a rite that, as she describes it, radiates a joy even her agnostic and atheist friends could see.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Bishop Donald J. HyingWelcome to Things Visible and Invisible, a podcast that discusses life, faith, current events, culture, history, and more, all in relation to Jesus Christ and his church. I'm Bishop Donald Hying, and today we're continuing our conversation with Karen Paschke, a consecrated virgin living in the world right here in our own Diocese of Madison. And today she shares with us her conversion and discernment story. So maybe you could just speak a little bit about how those two fit together, how all that happened.
Bishop Donald J. HyingThose are two big leaps. And you've you've made both of those.
Karen PaschkeThose are two very big leaps, yes. I came into the church in 2010. I was raised Lutheran and was very active in my faith all the way through university, all the way through college. And then God and I had a falling out, shall we say. And I actually ended up spending about 15 years. I refer to it as my dumb lost sheep period. I spent about 15 years away from God, 15 years not going to church, not praying.
Karen PaschkeI people sometimes say, oh, well, you became an atheist. No, I never became an atheist. The prodigal son did not doubt the existence of his father. He just didn't want to be there. I always knew this was temporary. I always knew that I would come home. And to make a very long story short, I basically woke up one morning in uh 2009 and said, Oh my goodness, I have to come home and I have to come home to God now.
Bishop Donald J. HyingWow. Um did something trigger that, or is it just kind of a growing feeling?
Karen PaschkeIt was it was not a growing feeling. I woke up one day. God got tired of waiting. Holy Spirit went into overdrive, is really all I can explain. There wasn't a particular life event that surrounded. I simply woke up one morning and said, This isn't okay. I have to come back, I have to figure this out. And through a whole series of events, ended up in the Catholic Church, for which I am so grateful. And then it was a few years later, so I came in through OCIA, and it was a few years later I was on the OCIA team, and I was talking with our director of that about something going on with one of the people on who's part of our group.
Karen PaschkeAnd when we were done talking about that, he looked at me, he said, So what about you and marriage, Karen? Which is a really weird question to be asked, especially by a married man. And I just looked at him and said, What? He said, Marriage, what do you think? And I said, I think marriage is a beautiful and wonderful thing for other people. What are you talking about? And he said, So is it totally off the table? And I said, Oh, you need to be so careful before you tell God something is totally off the table. But from my point of view, yes, it is.
Karen PaschkeAnd he said, Okay, I went to a talk on vocations a few months ago, and they were talking about priesthood, religious life, marriage. When they started talking about consecrated virginity, all of a sudden I thought about you and I keep thinking about it. Well. That was a Tuesday. So I went home. Wednesday, I dutifully Googled it. And I read about it and I said, This is way more serious than I am. What are you thinking about? And wrote him back and said, You're out of your mind. On Thursday, my life went into a little bit of a tailspin, one of those where you cry a countable number of tears.
Karen PaschkeAnd Friday, I was just angry at God. I was just mad. Because if we go back about a year and a half before that, I had started praying. And I started praying very regularly. God, I want to give my life to you completely. I don't even understand what that means, but I really think this is what I'm supposed to be doing. So I'm gonna pray it even though I don't understand it. So Friday I was saying, wait, God, I've been like offering my life to you, and this is how you treat me? No wonder you have so few friends.
Karen PaschkeAnd I went to bed so sad. And I snapped awake Saturday morning and said, wait a minute, what was that thing that I was supposed to look up? And I reread the same pages and suddenly said, Oh my goodness, this is what God has been calling me to, and I didn't even know it existed.
Bishop Donald J. HyingWell, so from there you just discerned and then Yeah, maybe just talk a little bit. And that's a wondrous narrative because those are such unexpected things. I mean, as a young girl, I mean, if somebody had said you're gonna be Catholic and you're gonna be a cancer virgin in the Catholic Church, I mean that probably would have seemed unimaginable. What what is that even very much so, yes. So, I mean, God has been abundantly active in your life. But could you tell us a little bit about just the discernment of that and then what what the formation process is?
Bishop Donald J. HyingLike what what are the steps uh a woman would walk through to move from this sounds like maybe what God's calling me to to the day you show up at church with your candle and your white dress and you you make the vows.
Karen PaschkeYeah. Um both the discernment and the formation are very individualized. There's a such a small number of us. It's growing. It's a very fast-growing group, but it's very fast growing from such a small number. So just to give a sense of this, there are six in the Diocese of Madison, there are three to four hundred in the United States, and 5,000 plus in the world. So it's very, very individualized, very personalized, very one-on-one.
Karen PaschkeIt meets a woman where she is. So where I am and where the women who I have mentored are have been in very different places with our spiritual growth, with our understanding of the Catholic Church. I only sort of knew what Liturgy of the Hours even was at that point, whereas other women who I've worked with have been praying that for years. So it has to meet you where you are. So the first thing I did, I had a spiritual director who I was already meeting with.
Karen PaschkeAnd the first thing I did is I went and talked with him. And his face just lit up and he said, I've been waiting for you to come to me with this. I I knew this is where you were going.
Bishop Donald J. HyingUh, which other people saw it in you before you did. Multiple as is so often the case.
Karen PaschkeMultiple other people saw it in me before I did, yes. Um, so he was one of them. So working with him was certainly a part of it. I had my own mentor who is a consecrated virgin and met with her regularly. And each month I had a new task, shall we say. So one month it was you need to start praying the liturgy of the hours. The next month it was, here's an article, let's read this and discuss it next month. The following month it might have been, you need to figure out how to get to mass every day.
Karen PaschkeThis is going to be an important part of your life. You need to start living this now. So the day of your consecration is not this sudden, dramatic change of, oh my goodness, suddenly I have to do all these things. You've already been living this life by the time you get there. I met with now you meet with the vocation director at the time you met with the vicar general. So I met with Monsignor Bartilla uh several times. And at some point along the way, he said, now you're ready to start working on the more formal application, which was a little daunting.
Karen PaschkeIt had, I think, 27 parts to it, a couple of them with subparts, but it was really an excellent experience going through that. I part of it was easy. I mean, get copies of transcripts, give approval for a background check, things like that. But other parts of it, writing my spiritual biography, for example, gave me a chance to sit and process and realize how far back this calling had gone, that this calling went back much further than my being Catholic.
Karen PaschkeThis calling went back even before I had fallen away from God. I could still see this calling just like a ribbon through my life. And the process of doing that helped me understand myself as well as this calling much better.
Bishop Donald J. HyingYeah, that's beautifully put. So there's a point where a diocese coming up to the bishop needs to like accept you as a candidate, kind of approve of you moving through the formation process and the application process is that. It's it's similar to a young man applying to the seminary, I think. Like you have to have a psych test, write a spiritual autobiography, all those things. And then there's a formal sense of being accepted as a candidate. And as you said, you know, the church has some beautiful documents that you study.
Bishop Donald J. HyingYou're studying the spirituality, the theology of the consecration. And then how do you come to the point of mutual decision with the person of the diocese that you're working with or the bishop where okay, we we all mutually agree you're ready, you set a date for your mass, and it happens. Like how how does that go?
Karen PaschkeWell, some of it happened behind closed doors. So it took me about nine months to fill out this whole application and complete all of the different parts of it. A bunch of them I completed the first weekend, but some of them took me a long time. And it really was beautiful because the last part that I did, as I finished writing it, I realized that I could not have written this nine months earlier. I could see how much I had grown in those nine months in my own spirituality, in my own understanding of myself and my relationship with God.
Karen PaschkeSo that was really beautiful to see. And then I took all of that, I put it into a big envelope, I took it to the post office and put some postage on it and sent it off. And a couple of days later got a confirmation. Hey, I received it. I'm a little busy right now. We'll get back to you soon. And soon was about seven or eight months later, which the church moved slowly. We've got a 2,000-year history. Seven or eight months is soon. But that also gave me time in some ways to rest.
Karen PaschkeIt also gave me time to anticipate. And one day I got a phone call letting me know hey, the bishop and I have talked from this came from Monsignor Bartella. The bishop and I have talked and we have approved. Let's talk about a date.
Bishop Donald J. HyingAnd you can see that the wisdom of the church and wanting to help this person discern, is this truly my vocation? Do I have the natural and spiritual capacity to live this life and then to move through formation to that decision point where both the individual and the church come to this mutual decision that yes, this is the will of God. This is what the Lord is inviting this particular person to step into. So, Karen, you've shared with us that your family is not Catholic. You came into the Catholic Church. How did your Protestant parents respond to this mysterious, wonderful call in your life?
Karen PaschkeOh, that was funny. So I sat down with them. It was Christmas time, and I sat down with my parents and my sister and my brother-in-law, and I said, We need to talk. And I told them what had been going on for the past several months in my life and what I was pretty sure I was being called to and what this would mean. And I remember my dad looked at me and he said, Okay, Karen, but what happens if you meet a really great guy? Now I was 45 years old at the time, for probably 43 years old at the time. I was 45 when I was consecrated.
Karen PaschkeBut my I looked back at him and I said, Dad, what happens if you meet a really great gal? And the room just went quiet. And I said to Dad, if you have any hope of sleeping in bed tonight, you should repeat after me right now. I already did, thank you. And he repeated that. And as I explained to him, anytime you make a decision, you are always unmaking other decisions, whether that's important or not.
Karen PaschkeI'm wearing a gray sweater today, which means I'm not wearing a green sweater. I'm marrying God, which means I'm not marrying somebody else. But that would be true even if I had said, Oh, I want to marry this other person. It always means I am not marrying everybody else. And my sister looked at me and she said, Well, is this kind of like Mary and Martha? We have no evidence that they ever married. I mean, maybe they did, but we have no knowledge of a marriage, but they gave their lives to serving Christ.
Karen PaschkeAnd I said, Yeah, it is kind of like that. And she shrugged and she said, Well, I'm okay with that.
Bishop Donald J. HyingOh, that's beautifully put. That's like saying yes to one vocation means saying no to every other vocation. So at some point, the Christian is called to not keep all the options open. At some point, you have to go down one particular path. And if you don't, you end up not making a decision at all and not living the vocation that God has for you. So there's always a specificity to it. But yeah, the answer is I'm already taken. I've already met a great guy. His name is Jesus Christ, right? In terms of your life and your conversation with your father.
Bishop Donald J. HyingHaving been privileged to be the bishop at the Mass in which a woman takes her vows as a consecrated virgin in the world, I'm always struck by number one, the beauty of it, the emotion of it, but also the similarities to um priestly ordination. Obviously, there's some big dissimilarities, but but the idea of the candidate being presented, the candidate being called, the litany of saints, the prayer of consecration, the the vows.
Bishop Donald J. HyingIt's a very public event where the church really witnesses with this person the this consecration to Christ, this living out of the spousal relationship with the Lord in the communion of the church. And I think everyone that goes to such a mass or to an ordination comes away just inspired by the the beauty of the ceremony, but also that this person is laying down her life for God and making that self-gift that is at the heart of the gospel, that just as in Christ God has given himself to us, so too, love invites us to make that total self-donation back.
Bishop Donald J. HyingAnd this this life of consecrated virginity in the world is your way of living that, Karen, and doing so beautifully.
Karen PaschkeYou kneel before the bishop and put your hands inside his hands. There are many different parts that are very similar. There are also many parts that are very similar to a wedding. It's really kind of the overlap where where the two cross, the Venn diagram of the two. So you wear a white dress. Uh, you have to be careful with that white dress when you choose it because you have to remember you're gonna have to prostrate so it can't be too fluffy of a skirt. You wear a ring. Uh so I wear a ring for the rest of my life.
Karen PaschkeYou wear a veil, although with a wedding, oftentimes a woman has the veil covering her face when she starts and then reveals her face. In uh consecration, she comes in without a veil at all, and then the veil is put on her head midway through. So there's some similarities, but some things that are very distinctly different. One thing that is so true about it is it is such a beautiful expression of joy. Uh the right is joyful.
Karen PaschkeIt is the church here on earth and in heaven coming together to just rejoice over what has God has done in this woman's life. I had many people, because I'm teaching out in the world, and I had many people who were there who are agnostics, atheists, other religions, and they noticed. I had a couple of atheist friends come to me and say, this was so joyful. They could see that.
Bishop Donald J. HyingYeah, all of it points to the wedding feast of heaven and the the joy of the marriage of the lamb. It it is a beautiful ceremony, and look forward to doing many more, God willing, if uh the Lord continues to call women in our diocese to this beautiful way of life. I don't know if you have any final thoughts. What would you say to a woman who perhaps is listening to this and has maybe already been thinking about the potentiality of this vocation for her, or maybe this is brand new for somebody and they just want more information. What should they do?
Karen PaschkeAbsolutely. Uh if somebody is thinking about this, the first thing that you should do is spend some time in prayer. Go to adoration, spend some time in prayer. Talk to someone who you know and trust, whether you have a spiritual director already, whether that is your parish priest, someone else who you have a spiritual relationship with already, probably outside of family is your best choice, although not always. That can vary from person to person.
Karen PaschkeAnd then after that, if if you're still saying, yes, I want some more information, I think that this is what I'm called to do. Talk to Father Jared, who is the vocation director. Get in touch with him here at the diocese. Or if you're in another diocese, wherever you happen to be, talk to your vocation director. And most likely they are going to put you in touch with a consecrated virgin or more than one to help you through this process.
Karen PaschkeBecause, as I said, it is so personal and individualized, which is how it should be, because God is wooing you, and any kind of courtship is going to be very personal and individualized. But meeting with meeting with other consecrated virgins is certainly something that can be helpful for you and help you learn, is this really who I am? It should fit. It should just fit and you should realize this is truly who I am, not, yeah, I think I can do this.
Karen PaschkeI think I can shove myself into this mold. You should say, I am freed by this. This makes me more me than I ever realized I was.
Bishop Donald J. HyingYeah, I love that. It's like I become more myself by living the vocation that God has given me. And I think that applies to everybody within the church. So I think those that have heard our conversation will come away with a far better understanding of this beautiful vocation that goes all the way back to the beginnings of the church, is often misunderstood or unknown. But I'm grateful to you, Karen, for living it so beautifully and passionately and for giving witness in the middle of the world to the primacy of Christ and his love for us through his spouse, the church.
Bishop Donald J. HyingSo thank you for being on. And uh please know my prayers and gratitude always.
Since 2021, the Diocese of Madison has shared a sister relationship with the Diocese of Jacmel in Haiti, a country facing deep poverty, political collapse and gang violence. Bishop Hying reflects on his visits there and...
Advent is Bishop Hying’s favorite liturgical season, a time of hope, joy, and expectation that teaches us to wait in a culture that wants everything now. In this episode, he invites listeners to slow down and "let...
Bishop Hying welcomes Fr. James Kubicki, SJ, author and longtime leader of the Apostleship of Prayer, for a conversation about what Fr. Kubicki calls “the devotion of all devotions.” Fr. Kubicki traces devotion to the...
As November approaches, the Church turns our hearts toward those who have died and toward the hope of the resurrection. Bishop Hying sits down with Damian Lenshek, director of cemeteries for the Diocese of Madison, to...
Ahead of his Oct. 22 feast day, Bishop Donald J. Hying reflects on St. John Paul II, the Polish pope he calls his spiritual father. He traces the saint’s life from his boyhood in Wadowice through the Nazi occupation,...