Time for the off-season (for the Giants at least). Kerry Crowley and I get into the question of whether the Giants should look to compete in 2027 or take a step back for runs in 2028 and 2029 - and whether or not it really changes their winter strategy very much. There R Giants is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit rogermunter.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
[music]
SPEAKER_00Kerry Crowley back here with Roger Munter for another K-Rodge podcast. Roger, we fire these up every offseason and I feel like there's going to be an interesting amount of episodes this offseason given the expected lockout and all that the Giants have to do. So let's let's go real broad with this conversation and, you know, figure out what the Giants need to do and spend some of Greg Johnson's money.
SPEAKER_01You know, Kerry, this is KROJ number 51 is what I have on my site. So we'll see if we can finish the off season before we hit 100. That'll be a challenge. That'll be a challenge. Where do you want to start today? Okay, here's what I really want to talk about with you today, Kerry. Your colleague, the The estimable, is that actually a word? John Shea at the end of year presser specifically asked Buster Posey about looking
SPEAKER_01at 2027 as a bridge year to 2028. Posey said they want to compete, but it was clear. And then John wrote an article after that kind of laying out his thinking. What I really want to talk about is what it would mean For the Giants thinking this offseason, if it were a bridge year, if it actually makes any difference, what it would look like if they were aiming at 2028 rather than 2027. And just see if we can, boots on the ground, figure out if there are different strategies in those two ideas.
SPEAKER_00I love it. I love it. And the very first thing in talking with John, because I've got the ability to have these behind the scenes conversations with him before he writes these stories. I think the very first thing that we both agreed on, and the Giants would never agree on this. We know they'll never agree. And so.
SPEAKER_00While every season, Buster Posey, Larry Bear, everyone who's in a high ranking role in the organization says our goal is to compete. Our goal is to play, you know, down to the wire in September being in this race as long as possible. Very first thing the Giants would do on the first day of spring training and say, That has been the organizational goal ever since we opened the ballpark in 2000. And we have to reframe the conversation this year to align with our expectations, what fans should expect from this team. And we all kind of know that that will never happen.
SPEAKER_01It is true. The ownership has always been... Hesitant for that. They want that park filled. They believe their business model needs the park to be filled. At this point, we're a decade into not competing. So it's kind of meaningless what they say. And, you know, baseball is a weird game. The White Sox are a win away from the American League Championship Series after losing 100 games three years in a row. Weird stuff happens in this game.
SPEAKER_01I really like what you said about thinking creatively about developing at the major league level because it's going to take creativity. I don't think they are moving whether they want to or not. I don't think they're moving Willie Adamas. I don't think they're moving Rafael Devers. I don't think they're moving Jung-Hoo Lee. I don't think anyone is taking those contracts off their hands. I don't think they're moving Matt Chapman. The available options for developing Are not plentiful, really.
SPEAKER_01I will say, so one thing that caught my eye about John's piece that I would push back a little bit on from my perspective, it specifically said 2028, you start to have the pairing of Bryce Eldridge and Joshua Gonzalez. I think that is Pushing that window too aggressively. Joshua is going to be 20 years old in 2028. He's got what? 30 games above the complex of experience. If you Bryce Eldridge, his development has been as good as you could ever hope.
SPEAKER_01We've seen these lists of the other guys who've done what he's done and it's Juan Soto and Bryce Harper essentially. So if, if Gonzalez matched Eldridge pace, He would be providing an impact for the team in the second half of 2029. So I would at least think in terms of that when you're talking about that kind of talent. But the one thing that sticks out to me is this question of pitching. What are they going to do about pitching?
SPEAKER_01And to me, in a sense, it doesn't matter what year they're looking at. They need to make smart choices about adding pitching to this roster. And that's going to be true next year, this year, two years from now. They are not going to, as much as they want to, because it's way cheaper, they are not going to develop a 13-man playoff pitching staff from within their system in the next two or three years.
SPEAKER_00I think that is abundantly clear for the San Francisco Giants right now. And I also think when you think creatively about developing pitching, what does that look like? Maybe it means taking guys on waiver claims this offseason and bringing them into camp and having three different guys on waiver claims. Pitching for a fourth or fifth starter job at that point, you know, signing guys to minor league free agent deals who are six-year free agents who, you know, came out of the international signing pool and maybe haven't developed at
SPEAKER_00the same rate as some of the American prospects who go to college have. And, you know, giving those players opportunities as opposed to the one-year deals for Tyler Malley's that you've seen the Giants consistently make for the last few years. Or... Signing Kevin Gossman to a three-year, four-year deal because you can this offseason because you say, okay, We've got this hole in our rotation behind Logan Webb and Landon Rupp. How do you fill that? Well, you just find the third or fourth best pitcher on the market and you sign into a market value deal and you call it a day.
SPEAKER_00I don't think the Giants can do that. I think that is where they have to think creatively. And maybe it means thinking like the Rays do when it comes to pitching. Maybe it thinks that, you know, thinking like the Brewers do and the Tigers with some bullpen chaos that they've deployed over the years. But Buster came into this job saying he didn't want an opener. He wanted five traditional starters making the majority of the outings for the Giants, just like they had in 2010 when they used six starters all season.
SPEAKER_00I just don't think that's realistic. I think you've got to create opportunities. And if it means finding out that, you know, Anthony Molina isn't going to be in your rotation in 2028, if it means finding out that Cesar Perdomo isn't going to be in your rotation in 2028, I think you have to commit to cycling through these guys and giving them opportunities that you might not otherwise do. If you were fully committed to being a playoff team in 2028. Well, so.
SPEAKER_01Let's revisit that Tyler Molle conversation because here's, I think something that's more important than maybe who they bring in and who they don't bring in is what are they doing to help the people they bring in produce and be at their best? Uh, you know, every, everybody knows Tyler Molle went to Atlanta and suddenly transformed into the second best pitcher on that team. Primarily because Atlanta had him stop throwing the cutter that the Giants wanted him to throw.
SPEAKER_01The Giants front office has to be auditing what they are doing to their pitchers to help them be successful. And this story does not look well at them. They need to figure out how they are going to make, to help their acquisitions be the best decisions they can be. And that's gotta be part of their process. No matter what they're doing on the personnel side, because they're not going to succeed in the modern game of baseball if they cannot help players be the best versions of themselves.
SPEAKER_00I completely agree with that. And I think when you see someone like Tyler Malley go to Atlanta and produce essentially the same way that he did for the Texas Rangers in his 18 healthy starts in 2025, it has to not just be a wake-up call, but the alarm has to be going off. And you have to Look inside at your pitching infrastructure, the three coaches that you hired last offseason, and the pitching infrastructure in the minor leagues as well, and say, what are we doing wrong? What data are we not using that other teams have at their disposal
SPEAKER_00and other teams are effectively coaching up their players with? And you have to take a good, long, hard look at the processes over the last few years and probably have to look deeper than just the two years of the Posey era, but also look back to, you know, Farhan Zaidi era as well. I know that they want to do this big audit on why all of their pitchers are suddenly stricken with Tommy John surgery and UCL injuries. And that's good. That's important. But it also has to be looking more closely at pitch mix, biomechanics, all this stuff that I am not smart enough to understand. But I know that there are people in the game of baseball
SPEAKER_00who understand this extremely well and who have implemented it very well across the major leagues.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And from that perspective, it's not really a matter of should they do this or should they do that? All of these things work, whether you're looking at minor league free agents or you're getting one year deals for Tyler Malley or you're, you know, trading for Corbin Burns. Four or five years. All of these things can work and can be part of a really successful overall strategy. But how are you making those decisions? What are you targeting in your acquisitions?
SPEAKER_01And what do you think you can help guys get better at? That's the underlying question. It's not necessarily are they picking from poo-poo platter A or B. It's what's the process behind those that I think is important.
SPEAKER_00So I want to use a specific example of someone who I think we've both followed his career long enough to know there has been an evolution and a real plan. And that is Logan Webb, because when he was coming through the Giants farm system, Roger, you saw a lot of him at double A Richmond. You didn't see a two seam fastball coming up through the farm system. You can correct me if I'm wrong, but you didn't see the two seamer and you didn't really see the sweeper. Did you?
SPEAKER_01No, not at all. He was mostly, when I first saw him, a four-seam curveball guy is what he was at the beginning. Logan had a very... Weird minor league career. He never threw very much for a variety of reasons. He had TJ almost immediately after he moved to full season ball. He spent two years in short season ball. And then when he came back, they were they were careful with with building him back up. But he was always a forcing guy.
SPEAKER_01And he was always a curveball guy with a little slider in there. It was really the work Brian Bannister You know, worked with him. They got him in the seam shifted wake, got him into the two seam. But Webb's also been a great indication or a great example of what pitchers do today, which is he's constantly innovating. Every year he adds a pitch or he He tinkers. He's a real tinkerer. And I think the modern era of pitching development rewards people who are tinkerers because that's what the game is today.
SPEAKER_01I will say that my answer back to John or people who think that the Giants should take a year off is how do you look Logan Webb in the eye and tell him that when they've already quite possibly wasted the best years of his career and this guy just wants to pitch in a playoff game and you're going to make him wait until he's 32 and the best years are behind him. That's a tough ask to me.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and that's why I don't think they would publicly make it, because if you said that to your fans and to your players, you're probably getting a couple trade requests, and one of those is probably coming from Logan Webb. Realistically, if he knows that they're not in it, he wants to go use the prime of his career, and who knows how much longer is left in the prime of his career. He understood this season. He got sick and tired of being asked about the WBC and ramping up so early, but I think he, you know, Quietly acknowledge that that may have had some sort of an effect on his durability throughout this season.
SPEAKER_00It wasn't the same level that we saw for the last four or five years. And so that is where you run into these issues, because you've got Rafi Devers, Matt Chapman, Willie Adamas, and, you know, Jung-Hoo Lee, and it's not realistic to think that you can trade any of them. So... You know, what do you do? Tell him we hope we've made the right fixes on the margins and you guys are going to lead the charge. We're going to go 84 and 77 and make the playoffs.
SPEAKER_01Well, and this is kind of where I come back to what does it really mean if you're trying to quote unquote, trying to compete in 2027 or not? The Giants are not going to do this, but if they wanted to go sign Tarek Skubal. That's going to help him in 2028 and 2029 and 2030 because he's almost certainly going to be one of the five best pitchers they have in all of those years. It's just, you know, they need more. Pitching is an area where you never are blocked, as we saw this year.
SPEAKER_01There are always, always, always going to be opportunities.
SPEAKER_00That is abundantly clear for the San Francisco Giants. And next year, it's just it's a wide open race. I mean, I think the 40 man conversation is fascinating. The Rule 5 decisions that they're going to have to make are somewhat interesting because You know, you could very much find yourself in a Spencer Miles situation again with a couple of the arms that the Giants have in their farm system right now. I just like I look at the next month, really two months before the potential lockout, as it is historically been a very boring time to be a baseball fan
SPEAKER_00because things don't really heat up until the winter meetings. I actually think that the people who followed the San Francisco Giants most closely know that the next two months are going to be really telling. And they're going to say a lot about what this front office is prioritizing, what they're thinking about. And news could start to leak here in the next couple of days about potential coaching changes, potential changes in the farm system with the leadership there. And you kind of want to dig in and figure out who's going to lead this path forward in terms of pitching development.
SPEAKER_00Because if it's the group that you saw this year, I don't know that that inspires a ton of confidence. They'll be able to maximize the pitchers that Are in this organization and are going to be counted on to cover all these innings next year.
SPEAKER_01Okay, so I'll take off from a conversation I was having yesterday on a podcast that posted on Tuesday. You mentioned earlier kind of the way the Rays think about pitching. So I'll just say this for the Giants. One thing the Rays have done this year, and this comes from Matthew Knauer, who everyone should follow on Twitter. Great, great
SPEAKER_00follow on Twitter.
SPEAKER_01They are throwing far more change-ups, particularly in the playoffs, than any other team. Do you know what Jacob Bresahan's best pitch is? I don't.
SPEAKER_00It is a change-up. I'm embarrassed to say that I didn't know that.
SPEAKER_01Jackson Flora picked up a kick change last year that was his most effective pitch. Yep. Ramon Marquez, who they got in trade, his best pitch is a changeup. Henry Lalani, Henry Lalani's best pitch is a changeup. Miguel Mendez throws 99, follows it with a changeup. They picked up an awful lot of fastball changeup guys this year. And I wonder if there's some, if there's an actual changeup Analytical strategy being formed in the front office
SPEAKER_01that isn't that far off of what the Rays are doing, what they're pitching right now. The Christian Wonders effect
SPEAKER_00in San Francisco.
SPEAKER_01I've heard nothing but good things about Christian Wonders.
SPEAKER_00That is really interesting to think about, though, when you consider all of, I mean, if we wanted to project forward in 2028, pretty much everyone you mentioned, the Giants are hoping will Be part of that roster. I mean, they want Jackson Fora by the end of 27. And I think when you talk about Miguel Mendez, he's on the 40 man. You know, we talked about that a little bit. I think in our last K, Raj, maybe more of a reliever at this point. But 98, 99 with the changeup, that'll play. Like the Giants didn't have 98, 99 with the changeup, except for, you know, Keaton Wynn in April this year.
SPEAKER_00And that was a splitter. And that was before they started using Keaton Wynn every day. And we saw how that worked.
SPEAKER_01I mean, so... Totally agree with everything you say. And it's really fascinating to look at that Richmond rotation that's going to start 2027, which could very well be Flora, Marquez, Bresnahan, Lalani, Josh Bostic coming back from injury and say, oh, wow, all these guys are going to be in the majors this year. I would just caution anybody from thinking that's going to be true. So I did research on this in 2026.
SPEAKER_01Across baseball, there were 19 pitchers, 24 years or younger, who threw 80 innings. There were nine who had ERAs under four. Wow. And they tended to be clustered, actually. Pittsburgh had three of them, which is not surprising. Paul Skeens, Jared Jones, Bubba Chandler.
SPEAKER_00Jared Jones is still under 24? That's incredible. Feels like he's been a part of... I saw him in the Eastern League.
SPEAKER_01When was that? Three years ago? He was the best pitcher I saw in the Eastern League. I saw Chandler the next year in the Eastern League. He was the best pitcher I saw in the Eastern League. And I think that's instructive, right? Because they have these three guys who are about the same age. They got into the majors. One's been a generational talent. One's been mostly injured and one is still trying to figure it out. And that's kind of what you're going to get with young players. Young pitchers, even elite young pitchers, it's going to be a mixed bag. You're not going to get, I mean, we've watched Kyle Harrison, who's as talented a pitching prospect as the Giants have had in years.
SPEAKER_01It takes a while for these guys to figure it out. And I don't think you're going to have a competitive pitching rotation in 2028 or 2029 that is a bunch of rookies suddenly showing up and blowing the doors off. That doesn't seem to happen in baseball anymore.
SPEAKER_00No, and so if that's the case, how do you build that rotation? So my rule of thumb is, and this is true of free agents and of prospects, if you think a free agent signing is an absolute slam dunk, the Giants should do it. Three cases. Take three cases. One of those is actually going to work out. Two of those are not. One is. Three prospects. You're really excited about three guys.
SPEAKER_00And I think for Giants fans, people were really excited about Marco Luciano, Joey Barton, Bryce Eldridge. In the last decade, those three generated a lot of excitement. One of those three guys worked out. And so if you're building your plan for 2028 on your rotation and you've got six guys who you really believe are going to work, maybe two of them make it. Maybe two of them stick. And, you know, so I think the Giants have to think like that. So if that's the case, how do they stock their system?
SPEAKER_00How do they stock this roster? How do they get themselves to a point where they can feel confident about their pitching moving forward? Because they're so far away from it. And in 2028, They're going to be adding Wizenhunt, Tidwell, McDonald, and who knows who else back to the mix.
SPEAKER_01You know, I totally agree with what you're saying there. It's funny because I think Giants fans, all of our brains are a little bit broken by what happened in the 2000s when essentially the Giants never had a great farm system, but their top prospect Hit absolute gold repeatedly. You know, they had five consecutive top prospects who became like the best version of themselves possible. And they added in a few like sleeper dudes who are also way better than anybody thought.
SPEAKER_01So that idea that like, yeah, everyone who we think we're excited about, they're all going to be good. That is sort of built into Giants fan braindom right now, I think at this point.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. And it goes with the theme of having five or six shortstop prospects that they're really excited about right now. I mean, they've got, you know, Gavin Keelan, Johnny Level, Joshua, Luis, Johnny L down in the Dominican League this summer. You know, if one of those guys becomes an average shortstop at the major league level and an everyday starter, that's still a win for the organization. They certainly want a lot more than that. But realistically, maybe one of those guys moves to second base and a couple
SPEAKER_00of them probably will be fringy backup infielder types when it's all said and done. That's just like the raw numbers of how these things work. And so while it's easy to project forward and like create your ideal 2028 lineup, You have to insulate yourself with a bunch of different backup options and get creative with, with waiver wires or minor league free agents or real, just real strong coaching, which you mentioned, uh, the Giants were, were maybe lacking in their player development.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And it's funny because actuarial actuarially it's right. Most, most of these products will crap out. And if you get one out of three, one out of four, that always works. However, the team that does get like two guys. Or three guys who really hit at the same team. Those are the teams that really strike gold. This era of Cleveland Guardians baseball that has been very, very successful started when Francisco Lindor and Jose Ramirez came to the majors at
SPEAKER_01about the same time, right? When that happened, usually franchises turn around. Now, the Cincinnati Reds maybe say hello with L.A. De La Cruz having a six-four season and Chase Burns being a four-war pitcher at the same time. But usually you hit on two guys at the same time and things do start to turn for you.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah, it's true. So what's next?
SPEAKER_01What's next? So going back to your creativity comment. One of the things that I think a lot of commentators said about the Giants this year is they weren't resistant to things like giving Adrian Hauser an opener, even though left-handers just beat him to death and he usually got killed by the left-handers in the first inning. So maybe I will lob this off all up to you.
SPEAKER_01I really hate bullpenning, even though I know that it's successful. Please help me.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, I hate it too. I really do. And I covered a lot of bullpenning with Gabe Kapler and Farhan Zaidi, and I understand why fans hate it. But just with the way that the game has trended, it's impossible to think that you're going to get five starters giving you 150 plus innings on an annual basis. And it's, you know, if you want to have a higher hit rate at the major league level than And two and six of those arms coming up and being valuable pieces in your major league rotation or
SPEAKER_00on your major league pitching staff. And that's really how you have to think about it. Major league pitching staff, as opposed to rotation versus bullpen. And I don't think the Giants think of things that way. You have to think, okay, is this guy a three inning guy or a five to six inning guy? And maybe there's a world in which they look at Miguel Mendez and they say, He's got this fastball changeup combination. We think he can help out of the bullpen next year. Let's make him a one inning guy. But what if there's an in between for Miguel Mendez where you're using him as
SPEAKER_00a bulk innings nine to 11 outs guy and that strategy works far more effectively than just deploying him one inning at a time every other day? What if you look at Lalani and you say the same thing for him? Oh, right. He's kind of kill him. Well, can you use him effectively three to four innings at a time in 2027? And maybe that's the year that the Giants try to find this out, because if they know that about certain pitchers who are going to be on the 40 man, you give yourself data point to enter 2028 with concepts of a plan.
SPEAKER_00And I think that that's maybe and this also requires like. A lot of experimentation from Tony Vitello, and I don't know how comfortable they are with that, because who watched the bullpen management this year and thought that Tony knew what he was doing? But he might be thrown into the fire more next year if the pitching staff shapes up the way that I think it might shape up.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so what I was starting to say before you threw the Tony Vitello wrinkling into Because that is a little scaring. Maybe this is the answer to the question I posed at the beginning. If you were thinking about 27 as a bridge year, what would it look like? What would the logistics look like? It probably is something like pitching staff chaos for two or three spots in your rotation. Go find, if there's a pitcher out there that you like,
SPEAKER_01or you think you can help, or you think is going to be a valuable You know, soak her up of innings next year. Fine. Sign them for two, three years. It's going to help. But after that, because I, you know, Cesar Perdomo was one of my favorite stories of the year. I don't think he's a full-time major league starter. I would be surprised by that outcome. I'd be surprised by Anthony Molina or Matt Wilkinson. I kind of be surprised by any of these guys succeeding as a good major league starting pitcher, but.
SPEAKER_01A lot of one time through the order guys, I can see that. I can see mix and matching that successfully. And maybe that would be the approach you would have to have if you were thinking of it that way.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And when I saw Perdomo this season, my expectations were on the floor. I mean, I hadn't heard about this guy much, hadn't read about him much coming up through the minor league level. And I just thought, here's someone who might be able to give you seven and nine outs with some regularity. I agree he's not a full-time major leaguer, but he has options available. And during the Farhan Zaidi era, Giants fans hated the idea of a guy getting nine outs one day, going back to Sacramento, and then coming back 10 days later to come get nine outs.
SPEAKER_00That might be... The best way to make the Giants more competitive next year. And I think you're absolutely right on Wilkinson being a part of that group. For whatever reason, I find myself as being in like the one percenters of believers in Anthony Molina. That this guy can be good. I think that they found something there. And the fact that his career started in Colorado, I think he was just... Pitchers who start their career in Colorado are left for dead. It's just the worst thing to happen to you in baseball.
SPEAKER_00I think Molina has a future. And... If you get six or seven guys who you think can be nine to 12 out pitchers, I would rather see that than signing a free agent veteran to a one-year deal in 2027.
SPEAKER_01No, I'm with you on Molina. It's more than 1%. I actually texted somebody in the Giants organization immediately after that trade, and they were like, we think he can start. And I'll say this, he throws hard and he throws strikes, which, you know, that's two things that are hard to find in this organization. So I am to see more of him. I just want to say about Cesar Perdomo, he threw the best game. Game. He wasn't the best pitcher I saw this year. He threw the best game I saw this year. It was a one hitter, a seven inning, one hitter with 13 strikeouts.
SPEAKER_01Unfortunately, the team didn't score and they lost that game. But there were a ton of scouts at that game for whatever reason, plus several pretty high brass. I know Randy Wynn was at that game. I think there were a lot of people watching that game. And the next day, everyone was like, wow. So good for Cesar because his improvement in the last couple of years has been incredible. And by the way, changeup.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, there you go. Really good changeup. I mean, this is the path forward. The changeup is going to save the San Francisco Giants. It could be. There were a lot of changeups this year. Forget a non-competitive 2027 season. If they just bring in guys who throw changeups, it'll be interesting. I do like the idea of having a cohesive plan for a pitching staff. And what you've mentioned indicates that behind the scenes, long term, the planning is there for the Giants to have a direction.
SPEAKER_00And the thing about a change up is if Buster Posey wants the Giants to control the strike zone, which they were abysmal at this year. It is easier to control the strike zone with a changeup in the ABS era, in my opinion, than it is for someone like Trent Harris, who was outstanding this year. I mean, but to control the strike zone with a curveball is a lot more difficult.
SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah. The reason the curve has kind of died off in baseball is... Analytics show that it's the hardest pitch to throw for a strike. Yeah. And I hate saying that because I know people go like, ah, analytics destroying the game. But that is the reason that you don't see curveballs as much. It's hard to throw for a strike. And Harris has battled that a little bit on his way up, but he's figured it out.
SPEAKER_00It is also, I think, the easiest pitch to tell out of the hand as opposed to like the sinker slider guys who get such great tunneling. If you're, you know, four seam and change up, there's, you know, some real tunneling. That's involved there. And you can get some bad swings off of that. You can get guys thrown off in an era where if you've got 98, 99 mile per hour velocity, which again, we didn't see enough of at the big league level this year, you're going to get the whips and you're going to control the strike zone in ways that the Giants just haven't in recent years.
SPEAKER_01Hey, let me just ask you quickly, because you mentioned Wizenhunt, McDonald.
SPEAKER_00Tidwell.
SPEAKER_01Somebody recently I was listening to. Suggested that maybe as they go through this huge roster crunch at the end of the World Series, maybe Wisenhunt is a non-tender re-signed candidate, which is kind of a sad thing to say because a lot of expectations were put on him. Do you think they have a chance at sneaking any of those guys through if they try removing that group from the 40 men and keeping them at house?
SPEAKER_00No, I don't.
SPEAKER_01Somebody's going to want those guys, right? I mean, the Giants just spent Rowan Wick on their roster for the entire year. Exactly.
SPEAKER_00And someone like Wisenhunt is the obvious candidate because he doesn't throw hard enough. Whereas I think Tidwell, there's no way you're sneaking him through. McDonald, I think someone could turn him into a plus reliever at some point. Like that feels like if no one claims him. The Rays of the Brewers are claiming Trevor McDonald and they're going to unleash him two years from now in the sixth inning. Wisenhunt's the obvious candidate there, but lefties are at a premium. And someone has watched the videos from February 17th in each of
SPEAKER_00the last three years when he shows up in Scottsdale and is throwing 97. And they're going to say we're going to get him to do this on August 17th and not February 17th, which is what's happened for Carson. I do wonder if amid this 40-man crunch, and I don't know if there's historical precedent here, but if the Giants could say to those guys, look, we will pay you a major league salary next year on a minor league deal. If we can take you off of the roster and use those 40 man spots, it's risky on both sides.
SPEAKER_00And, you know, it would allow for someone like a Tidwell to say, hey, maybe I want to go pitch somewhere else if they took him off of the roster. But I wonder if you work out a deal with the Wisenhunter or McDonald in that way, just so that you don't have to use that spot throughout the offseason.
SPEAKER_01I mean, they have done that with people in the last few years, but it's usually not been major leaguers. It's usually been guys hanging on the 40 men who are, you know, kind of minor league types. I think the bigger question or not the bigger question, but another question in the same venue is if you look at, say, a Perdomo or Wilkinson or Turner Hill, Turner Hill is like a perfect guy like this because a I love me some Turner Hill. But skill set wise,
SPEAKER_01he and Scott Bandura have a lot of overlap and Scott Bandura is three years younger, right? So does Turner Hill open enough eyes where you could possibly move him to another team and get a younger player that isn't part of the 40-man roster that you can develop for later? What kind of deals are key to this situation?
SPEAKER_00I think it has to be done in November. I think they've got to make two to three trades like that. And Hill's an obvious candidate. And there are some pitchers who are obvious candidates as well, where you say, we are going to trade you, you know, Pitcher A, who had a little bit of Major League time this year, for pitcher B, who is in the Dominican Summer League or pitched in the Arizona Complex League, is years away, but we think within two to three years can help the Major League roster.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, the Giants have done really good at scouting the Dominican Summer League. Each of the last two years, they've gotten a pretty talented player in trades from that.
SPEAKER_00They've been really good, I think it's worth saying, in Latin America the last few years in a way that I think, you know, Their investment there is going to pay off long term. I know that they got Joshua, they got Luis, that's big. But you went two decades in between Pablo Sandoval coming up and really meaningful talent coming out of Latin America for the San Francisco Giants. And it is just one of those ways to really beat other teams is to thrive where,
SPEAKER_00you know, Other teams are not as well positioned. And I think the Giants have positioned themselves really well in the last couple of seasons.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I, you know, obviously Joe Salamo and his group need to take a bow. All the scouting departments, I think. Uh, in this organization should feel really good about themselves. Hadi Rod's group has done terrific on, uh, scouting for these trades. Uh, you know, Michael Holmes work in the draft has been good. Uh, the scouting for this, this organization is in a good place. Um, and, and I hope they add more as you see teams like the Miami Marlins eliminate their, their, their pro scouting group. I hope they're, they're picking some of those guys up.
SPEAKER_01Cause I know, uh, they did that a couple of years ago. Donnie Veal was let go bad. Maybe the Cubs. Who has a great reputation for scouting pitching. And I know some places that Donnyville was at this summer that ended up having good results for the organization. So I hope they continue to build out those staffs because they have done great work for them.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I would agree with that. So that's the plan. Scout, develop, and then win. Whether it's 27, 28, or 29.
SPEAKER_01And pitching chaos. Is that where we're going?
SPEAKER_00Pitching chaos and change up city. Okay. Okay. I think we've got the offseason off to a good start, Kerry. There we go. That's K-Rodge for today. And I am sure whenever the Giants make a minor move that catches our attention, we'll devote a full 30 minutes to it.
SPEAKER_01Emergency K-Rodge.
SPEAKER_00Indeed. All right, Gary. Thanks so much, man. Thank you. [music]
Kerry Crowley and I sneak in a pre-lockdown KROG where we discuss left-handers, Rule 5 protections, Casey Schmitt’s trade value, and the idea of a gap year. There R Giants is a reader-supported publication. To receive...
Giants broadcaster, Dave Flemming, joins me once again to talk about the blueprint for success that the World Series might provide the Giants, an interesting rules experiment going on in the Arizona Fall League, and the...
This week’s guest is Brendan Gawlowski, who writes about prospects for Fangraphs, following several years as a pro scout with the Pittsburgh Pirates. Gawlowski included several Giants pitchers in a recent round up of...
In light of the Richmond Flying Squirrels being named the 2026 MiLB Organization of the Year, this seemed like a perfect time to get together with Squirrels’ Director of Communications (other duties as assigned) and...
My guest this week is NBC Sports Bay Area beat writer, Alex Pavlovic. We talk about the perception that the Giants are moving against the grain of analytically-driven decision making, the upcoming roster crunch, and the...