David Levine: Hey folks, welcome to new episode of the Whiskering Podcast. today we are not going anywhere, now that you think about it. Usually say we're going to a state or a country, but today, for the first time in quite a while, we have a non-producer guest on. And this is all about the launch of the American Whiskey Scholar program. it was launched in I think officially at the end of August, beginning of September of this year, with their level one certification. And to talk about it, we've got Colin Blake. One of the three co founders, alongside Peggy No Stevens and Susan Riegler. So Colin, welcome on.
Colin Blake: Thank you so much. it is a a delight to be on. And I know I'm not like a traditional producer with like a a brand, but I I have had my hands fairly dirty in the distillery. So I have produced. I've also made horrible mistakes in a distillery and have had to climb inside a a pot still with a pressure washer and f fix some bad choices I made. So
David Levine: Yeah.
Colin Blake: I have gotten these mono's dirty.
David Levine: Yeah, I was gonna say we'll we'll certainly touch on some of those aspects of how you well, the next question's gonna be about how you got into the industry, but talking about the context of of Moonshine U and everything that came out of that and all the people that have been impacted and helped by that over the years. but before we get all to there, let's start off with broad overview. What is the American Whiskey Scholar program?
Colin Blake: So the American Whiskey Scholar Program is something that when I came to work for Peggy Stevens a little over two years ago, it's something we started talking about as as soon as I I I came on board. But what it is, is it is online self-paced certification program that covers all aspects of American whiskey, but also fills in some of the gaps that we saw that other certifications don't have. So we really tried to not only go deeper than we saw a lot of certifications go, just because there's the the fact that the the industry and consumers are just more educated these days. They they know more, they they want more. So we really kind of launched at a a deeper level overall. but we wanted to make all of that very functional knowledge as well. So it's more than you know, just kind of like memorizing all the facts. we take all the the education on production, aging, everything about the the industry and different class and types, and try to integrate it in a very functional way. So we actually cover food pairing, cocktails, building menus. and then even our our history, you know, working with Susan to develop this. I mean, she is a wealth of knowledge. so interesting. so when we decided to tackle history, we looked at it as well, let's get into the weeds and let's cover things that maybe people haven't even heard before. So it's a very in-depth Certification, again online, at your own pace. There's over three and a half hours of video, over 70 diagrams, flow charts, downloadable content, and then about a textbook worth of text. so so it's in depth. And one interesting thing about American Whiskey Scholar as well is we built it to be modular. So if you want to take the certification. All modules get bundled together. You go through, there's quizzes, review questions, and then you're actually tested at the end. But when we were doing market research and talking to people about like, what do you wish that certifications would include or do? we were a little surprised when we were asking that question. And some people were just like, you know, I I wish I could just pick and choose what I wanted to learn. I don't really care about getting a certification, but I'd love to know more about bottling infiltration. I'd love to know more about history, but I don't want the entire certification and all all the the other stuff. So we actually built it to where you can get the whole kit and caboodle, or you can just buy individual modules that are things that tickle your fancy.
David Levine: Nice and you yourself are coming from this well, I'll ask you to talk about your background a little more, but you know, you have two arts degrees, no original background in distilling or chemistry, as you said, you have more, but with the no original background, you ended up helping to educate a veritable generation of distillers. How much of your career has been about learning how to translate technical information? rather than being the technical expert in the room.
Colin Blake: So a a good deal. And when I started at Moonshine University, again, you know, I have a photography degree, a film degree, v both very useful in a distillery. but what I ultimately found is I was approaching all the knowledge from a different way. I was in love with the process like so many other people, but the people I was learning from very much came up through as engineers or the the hard sciences. so I just made them explain things to me over and over again until there was a way that it made sense to me. And I knew that is where we we were gonna start. If I could understand it, that's that's our foundation. We're gonna build from there. And then just coming from an entertainment background, because I was in Los Angeles and worked in film and television before moving back to Louisville. So I also wanted to approach education as fun and interactive story based as much as you can. and I feel that when I was working with all of our our faculty and the team at Moonshine University, we were very successful in putting together an education that was very easy for anybody to digest. it ramped up to more advanced topics pretty quick. and the reality of it, why I think we had so many success stories coming out of that company is because we worked really hard at creating community. and I will say the spirits industry is already a really, really good community. The amount of stories I've heard of you know, Heaven Hill calling down to Jim Bean that they just re rejected a truckload of corn and just to save them some time, they're calling saying that driver's head in your way and is gonna try to offload it to you. Just save yourselves all all the time. I mean, essentially as long as you're not in marketing, everybody is very friendly
David Levine: Mm-hmm.
Colin Blake: and and and nice in this industry. But as Moonshine University not having a brand and being that kind of Brand neutral central hub where we loved sharing information. It was great to become part of a community, build a community, and to have access to all these brilliant minds to help me and the team really figure out what was going to be important for people to learn and how to set people up for success overall.
David Levine: And as I said to Colin before we came on the air that because of the timing of this interview, a timing of American Whiskey Scholar launching, it's an unavoidable necessity to contextualize a lot of these questions within Moonshine University and similar certification programs of one type or another that exist in in the region and in the industry. Now, Moonshine University itself, we're recording in the beginning of October. The Moonshine University is scheduled to conclude operations at the end of twenty twenty six after fourteen years, while American Whiskey Scholar is launching almost simultaneously. How much does that closure, the closure of Moonshine U, change the way you think about what whiskey education needs to look like going forward?
Colin Blake: That's a great question. what and you know, just personally, it it was really hard for me to hear that Moonshine University was closing, potentially Staven Thief also closing. You know, I spent a quarter of my life building those programs and they were very personal to me. So it was extremely sad because I think that there's a need and a place for those things. And I would love if they found new homes overall. but the timing was pure happenstance. It's not like we read that announcement and Susan and I got locked in a room by Peggy and she wasn't gonna let us out until we built the entire program. we had already been working on that program for over a year. and when we read that announcement, we definitely kind of changed our approach to the marketing and PR of the launch because there's greater opportunity with you know that kind of hanging question mark of what's gonna happen to stay and thief overall. But even before we heard that, we knew that we wanted to serve people who wanted the the deeper dive. That's one thing we heard time and time again is, you know, I wish there was more to to learn or a deeper dive I can do. And particularly with the certification programs that do offer very in-depth dives into spirits, it's generally spirits. You're getting the whole array. So we are, you know, really focusing in on that that fine line of American whiskey. So it it's really unique in in that sense. And We we're nerds. So we want to make things that we're proud of, that we wish were easier, information is easier to find. And again, that's why we started our level one as a pretty deep dive overall. And when we looked at that level one, very much we wanted the kind of a even split of it's going to service the enthusiast who wants that deeper dive and to know as much as they can and industry focused for people working in the various aspects of the industry and that can also be on off-premise accounts, distribution, really ancillary industries and roles that are beyond just, you know, being part of a brand.
David Levine: And as I'm just thinking about there are you know, there are a couple of other certifications and I'm th I immediately thought of the WSET, which is highly respected, don't get me wrong, but you're right, it is more kind of spirits broader. So you said in a couple of interviews that you did while still at Moonshine that Moonshine eventually realized its core competencies were hands on distilling, as you said, getting getting your hands dirty, and
Colin Blake: Mm-hmm.
David Levine: sensory training. but also that at heart you're really in the hospitality business and like it it took a few years to get to each of those realizations. Looking at American Whiskey Scholar, are you and Peggy and Susan going in pretty clear eyed about what your core competencies are?
Colin Blake: We are. we're definitely doing a little bit of a a rollout of the services that are supporting it. 'cause the main focus out of the gate was just launch the the curriculum. then as we start to have more and more signups, then we're gonna focus on opportunities and places for community to actually come and talk and chat, ask questions online. We're going to start offering office hours as part of the curriculum. So once a month, you know, Susan will have office hours where anybody who's signed up can ask deeper questions, get clarification on various things. But coming into it, it is pretty clear we want a laser focus on one type of spirit and we want to go as as possible.
David Levine: Bringing together the the competencies that you have in you know yourself with the the really hands-on aspect of it. And I know I'm gonna miss some of the competencies here, so forgive me, but you know, you were the hands-on the hospitality side, the education, Peggy with the hands-on, the marketing, the visitor experience side, and the sensory training, Susan, history, cocktail, writing, you know, the very broad range that you've got here. I'm curious to see how all of those work together but it also does I think put you a little bit ahead where you know, whereas Moonshine was in the first couple of years because you also know what your competencies are pr individually coming into this. So there's we can say like this is my resume, this is my my stamp on this, as opposed to like bringing in people as as needed, ad hoc even, to be like, we need to teach this 'cause no one knows this aspect of the business. So I wanna address just quickly and I promise like I said it's not gonna be all about moonshine and comparing it, but one's mentioned Staven Thief Society. So I guess I'm I wasn't aware. Will Staven Thief Society, as far as you know, be continuing?
Colin Blake: I don't know. so they announced the the last class for Staven Thief is in December. but part of that messaging was we're also we know it's important, we're gonna try to find it a good home or find a fit of some place that can continue it. but I haven't heard anything since that announcement. So my my yeah, again, I'm very proud of that program. it was my my baby, and I I don't want it to go away. I think it has a great community. I think it has its place. It's got a good reputation. So I mean I would l love for it to continue on and and find a home and someone who can service it well. Because again, part of the the challenge there is at Moonshine University, it was at a brand neutral location with no other real direction other than we educate. So hopefully it can find a home somewhere.
David Levine: I mean the one of the reasons I ask is because over the I mean over its existence is you've got over ten thousand bourbon stewards that have been credentialed through this. so it's pretty significant, like ten thousand people who around the country, around the world even who had enough interest to take the courses, take the education and get credentialed through this. coming from you know, this decade of experience with that credentialing program where it really was, like you said, it was your baby. what do you see American Whiskey Scholar doing differently in or what will address that Staven Thief didn't, especially in terms of the credentialing?
Colin Blake: Well, as far as the the credentialing, you know, I when when we launched Steven Thief, we thought we were gonna be having that class once a year for local bartenders. we did not realize it was gonna become what it became. it grew very quick. and that's one thing that when we launched American Whiskey Scholar, we were very open to, well, let's see What potential partnerships, how this can evolve and grow organically and just through conversation that happens. So there is going to be a natural evolution. We're open to what that looks like. So we're we're not hard goal other than we want to to have this education readily available. And one of the big things for us, particularly being at Moonshine University for so long is one of the challenges with Staven Thief was not only, you know, the the price point, but then you have to travel, which is a a big added expense as well, which is why we built ours for accessibility wherever you are, lifetime access and all of your materials are centralized in one location. so overall We know it's going to evolve and be more than just, you know, any person who can log into a computer can can sign up for it. but we're not quite sure. Like even today I had two conversations that could potentially be partnerships that would would evolve the offerings and what we can do overall in a really exciting way if they came to fruition.
David Levine: Inherent in the name, American Whiskey Scholar is not just bourbon. this is it's notable obviously because it it won't be, for example, a bourbon steward or an educator, it's about American whiskey broadly, with all of the types that that includes. And was the choice to name it that mainly because the category is is outgrowing bourbon as a center of gravity, or was it more that you know, teaching these other styles, rye, wheat whiskey, corn whiskey, single malt is more beneficial or result in a more complete scholar.
Colin Blake: Well, I mean, the the short answer is yes. A absolutely. One thing that we found when looking at other certifications like WSET, it's it's broad, right? like particularly once you get to level three, like you have to know about the solid state fermentation of soju. like it it's really myopic, even though like historically I never really thought about Sochu or Soju, but I was delighted to learn about it. It's very interesting process. And then with Steven Thief, it was a little too myopic. and that's one thing we found pretty quick is bourbon was the focus, but even out of the gate, we were talking about other world whiskeys and American whiskies. And the reality is, is there's other Categories of American whiskey that are really popular, very much worth talking about. And, you know, there's over 60 different TTB classified types of American whiskey. So we want to kind of dig into all of it and have the latitude to explore all those different whiskies and talk about them in a a very natural way, opposed to it, you know, being like, Well, I thought this was a bourbon class. Why are we talking about malt whiskeys and rye whiskey? You know, but because they're worth talking about and they're amazing whiskeys.
David Levine: There is a way to work in that solid state fermentation if you want. Just with the build in Takamine and the whiskey trust and the history portion of it. But no one's doing that
Colin Blake: That's true.
David Levine: currently, I think, but I don't think. I definitely would have heard about them 'cause
Colin Blake: Not yet, but's
David Levine: yeah. So as you said, the focus right now is on level one, launching with the we'll say level one, I'm calling it kind of the broad strokes. You have the mix of the history, production, and it covers ten modules with level two and level three releasing you know around the holidays this year and in the spring, respectively, becoming progressively deeper dives. How did you and Peggy and Susan go about deciding what someone genuinely needs to know at each level versus what whiskey enthusiasts merely enjoy knowing.
Colin Blake: It's a fantastic question. a lot of level one came from feedback we got when we were talking to people about certification programs, what they liked and disliked about other certifications. And to a great degree, that really helped form the the original outline. And then working with Susan when she and I would get together, Finding those transitional points of at what point is what we're going to be talking about in level one becomes so advanced it's it's level two. So it was really going in and trying to find those breaking points because really with level two and level three, we're revisiting those same topics. We're just doing a much, much deeper dive overall.
David Levine: this point, you have the tentative launch dates for level two, level three. Are they mapped out completely?
Colin Blake: Yeah. well, level two so level two, level three have been outlined. and well actually the reality is is level two is mostly written. it's mostly together. I just need to find a little time in the next couple weeks to actually sit down and start reviewing and doing edits and laying out materials and doing editions, things like that. So We're already pretty deep into level two as is. And as soon as we get that launched, we're gonna roll straight into level three development. So it's exciting. And even though we know the progression of people going through to level two and level three is going to be a much smaller number than level one, as is the nature with these things, particularly when it gets much harder. because in level three, there's actually going to be an in-person sensory test that we're trying to we have a good concept of how the test is gonna go. It's more of well, where are we gonna do it and how to make the kind of logistics of showing up for an in-person test? how how that's gonna go. So we know ultimately it people are gonna winnow down, but you know, you even if it's a you know, five percent or less make it on to to ultimately be level three. It's really important for us that level three is out there so that people can take it and get that knowledge. and and have it out there because that's one thing with other certifications, much like Steven Thief, fantastic program. But it kinda has a hard stopping point with no real avenue of how to go deeper. and again, us working in those lifestyle aspects overall was really important for us as well because that's one thing I felt so many certifications. or are lacking or don't focus on is just that integration into lifestyle, making all of that knowledge functional.
David Levine: brings up an interesting question too because I I have been thinking about this for a couple of years in anything from tasty notes to sensory education packs that I know a couple people tried selling those in the last few years, especially post COVID. It's really hard to teach sensory virtually and to test it's even harder to test it virtually. So I I get the idea that you would you really need to do that in person. It's the only way to to ensure that no variable or minimal variable environment, everyone has the same setup. otherwise, I mean you'd have to do it four or five times probably to have a significant sample of of anyone taking that part of the certification. based on what you all learned from COVID and the media post COVID, I I listened to Peggy talking about how she had to adapt her tasting classes. and seminars for COVID and post COVID because couldn't be in person. So coming from the knowledge of of that and how you had to adapt sensory, how you ad had to adapt education through that, at what point do you think is the line between this can be taught virtually and self taught virtually versus no, this part has to be in person?
Colin Blake: And that's a a big part of where that division for level three comes, where there has to be in-person aspects of it. Because the level one, again, that's the level where you want people to understand sensory, understand the practice of sensory, and be comfortable doing it, and be in the practice of doing it to to get better. But the level one isn't to the point where you would use that to apply for a lab position at a a producer. it would be later levels overall. But we worked really hard on the sensory for level one to make sure it was very step by step. Again, video helps with that to a degree, but I I agree at at some point there needs to be some level of in person when it comes to sensory.
David Levine: I know you said you're still kinda figuring out the logistics on this on this point, but do you envision it being more how do I put this more like in a seminar style or small group setting to to do that part of certification? Or on the other side, putting someone in front of a G CMS and having them
Colin Blake: Yeah.
David Levine: sniff out different scents that are coming their way.
Colin Blake: I yeah, getting in front of a GC, you know, with a puffer, would be pretty extreme. And that would be very logistically hard. just getting samples run on GC seems to be a a challenge to some degree these days. But Would be so cool. the
David Levine: You know, we know there are a couple of distilleries that do have machines on site.
Colin Blake: They they do, but G C you have to have the adapter to where you can smell what's coming off of
David Levine: You do, yeah.
Colin Blake: it. otherwise you're just getting your your graft chart the the back end. and then I lost your original question because I really went down a mental rabbit hole of how to integrate G C or HP L Cs or any fun you know, lab equipment in Education.
David Levine: no, it it it was asking, in in thinking about the logistics for the that final part of the sensory test tasting, how would you what kind of setting are you imagining that they would be in to have that tested?
Colin Blake: Yeah, so the that's always the the challenge because even at Moonshine University, we we taught a sensory class and got really in depth on the environment and how to do it and where to do it. And of course we're teaching that while people are looking around the classroom being like, So not here? And we're like, Yeah, this is not the best place, other than you have access to everything we're doing sensory on because not like Not often do you have someone who just has a pure sample of like geosmin or all all the other compounds overall. So ideally w it honestly a hotel conference room would be perfect, 'cause it just needs to be boring and most hotel conference rooms are. and then just do the best to control to make it negative pressure as possible. which you know doing with fans or certain rentable ventilation isn't real negative pressure, but really just trying to keep the aroma in the room. I'd love to find a place. and I don't think they have the rooms anymore, but Seabold Institute up in Chicago.
David Levine: Chicago, yeah.
Colin Blake: Yeah, so there was a rum consultant, Eric Watson, who was telling me about like he did his sensory. training there and they actually had these like white, boring, negative pressure rooms, and you had to go in to the room and acclimatize to the environment. You just sit there for a half hour doing nothing. And then they would come in with, you know, caps of glass, you know, with your wash glass on there. and you would do threshold training to figure out what you can pick out as far as compounds and then what threshold you can pick them out in. and that would be my dream. now ultimately we would love to have a location to where it would be a little bit of a home place where we can do these types of things. and what what that looks like is a question mark, if it's a partnership or something that we own ourselves that would be great to ultimately have that home place. And the reality is even though this is an online certification, we also know that people, particularly companies and and groups of people, like to do these things in person. So if you wanted to do it in person, you could reach out to us and we could figure out a a training under, you know, whatever metric and guidelines you you want to train at. But yeah, the sensory part ultimately I would love to recreate those old seabolt. And am I saying it right? SIBOL? SIBOLT
David Levine: I think so. Seabold. Yeah.
Colin Blake: Institute rooms and really just have a place where you can come do some intense sensory training over
David Levine: So really what I'm hearing, you just need an endowment. Yeah, no big deal.
Colin Blake: Yeah, no no big deal.
David Levine: Especially these days, no big deal. so
Colin Blake: Yeah. And and there's so much money out there for people looking to do a for profit sensory training.
David Levine: Yep. Right. One thing, and you alluded to this earlier, one thing that always interests me with education programs, certification programs, is the difference between knowledge and usefulness. someone can can memorize the legal definition of bourbon, God knows we hear it in every single distillery tour we've ever taken. things about mash bowl rules, barrel entry proof, and so they can have all that knowledge and still be absolutely terrible at explaining whiskey to another person. How much of American Whiskey Scholar is, let's say, testing recall versus whether someone can actually communicate that to another person?
Colin Blake: So level one is more testing recall with the focus on how to to weave it in your in into your your life. but part of that is not we have not yet built in any aspect of how good are you at communicating the these aspects. The the platform we use does have some limitations as far as how and what you can do with testing. so level one is you know question and answer multiple choice for the most part so pretty straightforward but I would love to be able to and you know particularly level three have some sort of testing rubric on how clear you can communicate these things. Because getting into level two, we're already looking at doing some short essays as part of the the testing, because that's kind of like the next step there. So there will be some degree of that. with those those short essays as far as how how well people can communicate these concepts overall.
David Levine: It's something I think obviously WSET does well because they that's part of the job. It's it's an industry focused certification. So you have once you get to those higher levels, you have to be able to communicate that information. and like you said, most people are probably not gonna want to go past that. Like they're okay, let me learn about this, let me be able to say, I know this, I've got a certification that says I know this. but I think there's there is this opening when it comes to communication. is like I said, you hear the same things on a lot of distillery tours, and you and I I guarantee have both been on distillery tours where you're listening to someone and you're like, that's not right. Maybe they said what's not right or maybe it is right and just like they there's not for lack of a better is not engaging and exciting. So I'm I'm fascinated about that aspect because when you're speaking on behalf of American whiskey Whiskey in general,
Colin Blake: Mm-hmm.
David Levine: but let's say American whiskey, the best thing you can do is be a an ambassador for it. So if you know how to communicate, be effective, be entertaining and engaging, it's it's really a skill that a lot of people don't have. that's public speaking, the communication role. so it's it might be beyond your beyond your ken, but it could be something interesting to to consider there.
Colin Blake: And and we're always open to to other aspects. And Peggy even teaches professional presence and public speaking and things like that. Not solely in the the scope of the the whiskey realm, but more of like on the just professional presence side. but it's interesting because there it's true. There's so many times I've been on tours and it was either they memorized the script and the bullet points and they're just running through it. or they're very conceptually adventurous with how they're interpreting that information where you're just like it's not exactly wrong, but it's not exactly right either. And then there's just that very small handful of truly exceptional I mean educators. They can be a tour guide, they can be working at retail, but really like they love it, their passion, they can talk about it. And it it it is a small handful of people who I think have a passion for it and are good at it. Because even and I love public speaking, which is if you would have told me that 15 plus years ago, I would have crawled into the corner and cried to myself. because I hated public speaking. But the the owner of Moonshen University told me, you know, you're gonna teach and you're gonna lead classes, because if you're gonna work at a teaching facility, you have to teach and you have to do it. so he just pushed me in front of the the class enough times that I found a natural love for it. And I think a lot of that for people is they don't have the capability to get in front of people and try to communicate time and time again. It's different when you're at at a a restaurant or with friends or at a social engagement because there's the latitude of kind of finding it as you go and getting those follow-up questions and the engagement. You know, it's like comedians where I think the the com comedian saying is you don't know who you are as a comedian until you've been on stage at least a hundred times. and I would say that's just public speaking in general. It took me a very long time to to find my voice and my presence and how I choose to do it. So it would be interesting to and I think that is even somewhat outside the the realm of what American whiskey scholar could do because I think it is kind of taking that knowledge, but then really focusing on a public speaking aspect, which I would love to teach those classes and work with people to enjoy it. Because even at Moonshine University, when you know I hired new staff, they they were not happy with me when I told them the same thing I was told when I got hired. And it's like you're you work at a school, you're gonna get in front of people and you're gonna talk about Either what we do here or actual share the information. But I think you need that access to doing it. because what what's the the whole club and community Toastmasters? Right? I those people who are drawn to Toastmasters love that public speaking, but they also need a club like that so that they have the opportunity to actually get up and do it over and over again.
David Levine: So I've this is a question where I'm kinda gonna be asking you to speak on Peggy and Susan's behalf a little bit.
Colin Blake: Okay.
David Levine: and you know, just have that as a as a forewarning. In in listening to to Peggy talk in interviews and and what she's written, Susan as well, but it's usually through Peggy's lens, she's talked a lot about people, particularly but not exclusively women. in male dominated tastings, where they're just afraid to say something dumb. And especially in front of the maker. And doesn't mean what they're saying is dumb, doesn't mean that they're wrong. In many cases they're not. But it this caught my ear because I was thinking about how you're building a curriculum that gives people vocabulary and knowledge without without accidentally convincing them that there's a correct answer hiding in the glass. So when you're when you're designing this, how do you think about how people are going to receive the information between that idea of yes, these these are right answers, but if you don't get that one note in the glass, it doesn't mean you're wrong.
Colin Blake: And that was a really big thing for me. coming up through Moonshine University and even with Staven Thief, you know, the the catchphrase is whatever you smell and taste is what you smell and taste. No one can tell you you're wrong. It's how you relate to that. And of course, you know, that's kind of the consumer facing thing that we say, but then people come to the professional. sensory classes where we clearly tell them they're wrong. when they're they're saying certain things. we're very kind about it and you know, like, you might be interpreting XYZ as Anis because it has these things in common and when you combine it with it, you know, so we were always very kind about it. but as far as Peggy, I mean she she came up in the spirits industry in the eighties. And that is a hell of a time to be a woman in the the spirits industry. so she is a a really big believer in that people have confidence and have a way to build that confidence, but she also got trained by Lincoln Henderson, you know, to become a master taster. so she actually went through a very formal training and process in order to get where she's at. So Peggy, and again, the Peggy might answer this totally different. I'm but this is what I would assume. is that you know she went through a process that helped her get to that point and she views sensory as there's a process, you work the process, and you you get better at doing sensory overall. and and I really can't speak to Susan's viewpoint on sensory other than Susan is very good at doing sensory. and, you know, we we kind of talk about sensory, what we get, things of that. But Susan and I've never, outside of just kind of putting together like how do we explain this XYZ process so that someone would understand and, you know, what whiskey are we recommending that they pull from their home bar in order to do it? But we've never really got into sensory theory or personal viewpoints on it quite yet. I know it's gonna be coming once we're finishing up level two and getting into level three, that's for sure.
David Levine: we're going through levels one, two, and three, and you said two and three will be more it'll be deeper dives, it'll be really drilling down into some of these topics. Are there topics in let's start with level two that are already advanced enough that there really is no precursor in level one. It's just you start in level two with this concept.
Colin Blake: Really, we really did kind of do it as a a continuation. there's a little bit of the opposite where we have one module in level one that once we finished it we're like this this doesn't need a level two. talking about bottling and proofing and things of that nature, you know, we we're like What are we gonna do? Like show them the different styles of bottling lines and how a volumetric filler is different than a gravity filler, and there no one cares. or very, very few people do. So we had a little bit of the opposite where we found a topic where we're like we kind of covered it. I don't think people want to go further in this. Now part of that topic was also. Finishing and the finishing process, which we're just gonna take that aspect and move it up to to maturation. but yeah, as far as bottling, we kind of felt we covered in the level one.
David Levine: Yeah. It's been about twenty, twenty five minutes since I've asked a question involving Moonshine University, so we gotta come back to that.
Colin Blake: Yeah.
David Levine: pulling pulling back a little bit, the craft distilling boom of the early two t twenty tens and let's say late two thousands or early twenty tens really gave Moonshine University this enormous wave of startup students. at one point I think I heard you say you had over three hundred distilleries. that it had touch points there dozen plus countries and so not even just in the US but around the world with this
Colin Blake: Mm-hmm.
David Levine: concept of from start to finish, how to start a distillery, how to run it, how to define it like finance a distillery and realize have a lot of people realize we can't do this. but you also always you said you always knew that That wave of startup and that wave of craft boom couldn't last forever. And that education in response would eventually shift towards sustaining existing businesses. How as you're building American Whiskey Scholar and you see the industry growing and changing, do you
Colin Blake: Mm-hmm.
David Levine: think that we're we've reached that point where the the wave is cresting and things are changing?
Colin Blake: a as far as the want and need for the consumer and industry education.
David Levine: Yeah, let's yeah, let let's start with the the education moving towards let's say sustaining existing businesses and less about everyone starting a distillery.
Colin Blake: Right. Well when it came to Moonshine University, we knew, you know, there's not gonna be new distilleries forever. But the one thing that we found and is true and it's gonna be the same thing with American Whiskey Scholar, is it's much easier to outsource education and staff training than build your own internal program and operate it internally. There There are definitely distilleries that do those types of internal trainings and and process, but we found a lot of the education dollars that distilleries got, they would come train their teams at Moonshine University. and that whether that's the professional distilling education or stake and thief society, and we've already started having those conversations with American Whiskey Scholar, where certain brands at certain levels want to talk about how this can be used for their kind of like internal foundational training when when they're onboarding overall because the all the nice thing about American Whiskey Scholar, because it is modular, we can also kind of move the modules around to to make it very specific for one brand and we can write new modules just for that brand that you know other consumers wouldn't get. So it it's a very malleable structure overall. So yes, I don't think the need for the information on how to start up a distillery is going to go on forever, but I do think that that Education and training will always be a part of the distilling industry because it's just a good thing to to outsource as far as training overall. and when it comes to certifications, you know, it's a a lot like degrees. you know, you see some people's business cards and they they have a whole list of commod certifications after their name because they got so many different degrees. And it's the same thing with certifications. We found that people want more than just one. because the the variety out there, the polyphony of all the different information, you get something a little different from from each of them. So I think there's always going to be the need and particularly on the consumer side, we just now live in a world where people want to know about everything that they're into and to a very deep level. Like I collect records and I I'm a simple record collector. Do I like the band? Can can I play it on my my turntable? But I mean You talk to people and they wanna know the the weight, what type of is it P V C or is it actually vinyl? Like d you know, and they get now like a crushing level of knowledge no matter what you're into. So I don't really see that going down. I don't think people are ever gonna wanna know less about their their hobbies or what they're consuming. So I always think there's gonna be that demand.
David Levine: Looking a little bit further afield too. It's funny, I had two thoughts in my head of w what to ask next. Now they're battling each other out up there. The one of them is the I'm always interested when when a new system it comes up, a new system comes online, this American Whiskey Scholar being one of them, about replicability and and scalability. So My first thought was with the as you said, the proliferation of knowledge that is out there, it's very different than well, it's different than five years ago, but certainly different than fifteen years ago, when you might be able to Google how to start a distillery, maybe able to Google some information, maybe even some basic mash bill stuff to look around for the major distilleries. But it w it was limited, for sure. a lot of the knowledge was still in in books or magazines that you Couldn't necessarily get very easily, or were industry focused. Now, a lot of that is everywhere. And it doesn't, I don't think it takes away from the certification idea because some something that you can find in a blog post is a lot different than something that's being designed by you, Peggy, Susan, as something that also ends in a credential. Not equating those two, but it I'm thinking about. As new opportunities in the market open up for knowledge that goes beyond what level one, two, or three of American Whiskey Scholar will do, but are still related, things like finances at a distillery or some aspect of the production maybe that is really specific to a particular type or style. Is there a do you think you could replicate the model to grow American Whiskey Scholar? laterally as opposed to in depth.
Colin Blake: Yes. yes, we're we're American whiskey scholar is, you know, level one, two and three is a column, but ultimately we want a whole bunch of columns to build a much greater thing. American whiskey is definitely where Susan Peggy and I have hung our hat for a long time. but we like other spirits too. So we have definitely looked at this as okay, let's get American whiskey up and running. And then what other spirits can we move into? And when it comes to if there's desire for the professional side, we would definitely explore it if there was a a need or a a demand for it. But I don't know if people wanna learn how to fill out their T T B tax paperwork online. be more than happy to to teach it and how to do it. but we have definitely thought about how the the overall company can grow and what that looks like. I just know that Peggy will not have any part of the gin class at all. as that is not not her favorite. but you know, I I love gin. so does Susan. So yeah, there's definitely we've looked at how to expand this overall, mainly with going into additional spirit types. and again, I I I cut my teeth on helping people open distilleries. So, I mean, that's a big soft spot for me. I would love to. service that market, but I think it will need a few more years to see how the the industry shakes out and where the real need is as far as that co content.
David Levine: As I was saying and I was thinking this is almost into the realm of of consulting as opposed to education. So it might be a little further afield than than this particular mission. but I don't know, it's it's something that comes up. Like I said, people are whoever makes it through this this crucible is gonna need help on the f on the flip side to keep it going. if I remember seeing Peggy didn't really love gin, but I thought her favorite non whiskey drink was a martini three olives up. So I guess maybe it's a vodka martini.
Colin Blake: Yeah, it it must be because I I I've heard her describe her emotions about Jen and
David Levine: Not subtle.
Colin Blake: Yeah, that martini is a gin martini.
David Levine: Awesome. So Con surprisingly, and I'm surprising myself here, you have answered the questions so in depth that we're actually ahead of schedule and you have run the gamut on the questions that I had for you. which I thought we were gonna have a couple left over, but You what can I say? You you're a thorough answer. so I guess to to give you a chance to to wrap it up, to summarize You had you know, you had the decade plus at Moonshine, you've had a year plus now plus the launch for American Whiskey Scholar. What do you hope American Whiskey Scholars legacy will be?
Colin Blake: I really hope that it has long-term staying power, the industry buy-in and backing, and really becomes the silent marketer and educator for for all the brands out there. I I think I'd love just to see the less wrong or inconsistent information. out in the marketplace. So I would love to you know see where we've grown in 20 years and how many different students have come through and are wearing their lapel pens. but really I I want it to be part of the the industry. I I love the the spirits industry. I think it's such an amazing community. It's a such a good group of people and I would just like this to be more integrated into the the industry overall.
David Levine: Well said, I like it. And I'm already thinking about I really hope places like Total Wine, ABCs will have their employees take some of this so I don't get asked if Maker's Mark is aburban or not in the store anymore. 'Cause I just start like creaking up a little bit when I start hearing that. but anyway, on that note, Colin, thank you so much for coming on representing American Whiskey Scholar talking about this new program just launched in the beginning of last month. With level two and level three coming in December-ish and the spring. hang out with me for just a minute for some closeout. Thank you everyone for listening. This has been another episode of the Whiskey Ring Podcast. Please like, rate, and subscribe wherever you find us. Let's keep those five star ratings going on Amazon, Apple and Spotify now. and there will be links in the show notes for where you can follow American Whiskey Scholar, where you can follow Colin, Peggy, and Susan. Or all the news about this new program as it launches and expands. And I'll see y'all next week.
Colin Blake: Thank you.