Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Weekly Scrap, Firefighter Podcast

The Weekly Scrap, Firefighter Podcast artwork

Weekly Scrap #375 – Sean Duffy: Training, Search and Mindset!

Sep 30, 20261 hr 45 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Sean Duffy is BACK on The Weekly Scrap! Sean has been part of some great Scrap conversations over the years, and every time he comes on, he knocks it out of the park. Serving in the fire service since 2004, Sean has built a reputation around search, training, fireground performance, and building a culture that puts the mission first. He’s the founder of the Great Lakes HOT Fire Conference, co-founder of Build Your Culture, and has spent years teaching firefighters across the country and internationally. In his previous Scrap appearances, we’ve dug into Searchable vs. Survivable, Search and Culture, and the Mega Scrap Echo discussion surrounding OSHA and two-in/two-out. If you haven’t heard those episodes, go back and check them out. This time around, we’re digging into “training for reality,” SEARCH, and why “policies are our playbook.” There’s a lot of knowledge and experience to pull from with Sean, and it was awesome to dive into. Fire Innovations IdentiFire - Use code VIGILANCE for 10% off your order. Snap-tite Hose UL Research Institutes' Fire Safety Research Institute (FSRI) - Visit the dedicated page created specifically for Weekly Scrap listeners, giving you access to some of the best firefighter research and training resources available at fsri.org/weeklyscrap.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_03Lube them up, you do put them in the scenarios that you wish to see. This like hiding them under drywall or stuffing them in weird spots just to get a gotcha moment. Like that stuff's just not practical. It just creates training scars.

SPEAKER_00Firehouse Vigilance presents the weekly scrap, a podcast dedicated to the never-ending fight against complacency.

SPEAKER_01Corley Moore, Firehouse Vigilance. It is weekly scrap, number 375. My guest tonight is Sean Duffy. He has been serving in the fire service since 2004, is a nationally and internationally recognized instructor, author, founder of the Great Lake Hot Fire Conference, and co-founder of Build Your Culture. Throughout his career, Sean has traveled to deliver training focused on the fire ground realities, emphasizing victim-centered decision making, search operations, firefighter performance, and developing a culture of professionalism.

SPEAKER_01He has contributed articles to many fire service publications, including Fire Engineering, Firehouse Magazine, The Book of Search, and Setting the Standard Training for Success. I'm excited to have him back once more. Sean Duffy, welcome back for scrap episode number 375.

SPEAKER_03It's great to be here. Thanks for the invite.

SPEAKER_01You've been here a few times.

SPEAKER_03Just a few.

SPEAKER_01Count some mega scraps in there, uh, and boom. It's been good. Anything I missed in the intro that you want to throw in there?

SPEAKER_03No, I mean, let's just keep it simple. There's there's like those intros are they're just bluff.

SPEAKER_01I didn't I did not mention Britney Spears or the punk rock band. Both of those things could be mentioned.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, well, you know, uh, I got a little too small for my Britney Spears shirt, so uh uh I tried to find it just for you tonight. Can't find it. Probably somewhere in some search building, some somewhere.

SPEAKER_01Somewhere lost out there. I will get another another Britney Spears shirt for you, and we will someday teach in our matching or not matching uh pop star shirts at some point.

SPEAKER_03Heck yeah, let's do it. Punk rock band, the name is social ruin. Just remember that one.

SPEAKER_01Social ruin. Yeah, okay. Anyway, go ahead. You got a package today. You got a package, it had instructions not to open it, but now you are live on the scrap, so now you get to open said package from the weekly scrap podcast. Here it is, live on the air.

SPEAKER_03All right, it's gonna crunch.

SPEAKER_01Luckily, I don't I don't think there's anything fragile. No, there we go. This is an extremely exclusive club. Bam! But number three is I gotta put this on now. Look, yeah, this is number five, isn't it? This is it, baby. You have joined an elite, the so the the the penta sodalitas is the is the name of the club.

SPEAKER_03I feel so official. Look at that that fancy that is a cigar to smoke.

SPEAKER_01It's the real deal, buddy. It is the real deal. We don't mess around on the scrap, that's all there is to it. You're gonna be hot. So when you get hot and start sweating, you can ditch it. But for now, that looks primo, my friend. That looks awesome.

SPEAKER_03Awesome. I'm gonna keep rocking this thing as long as I can tolerate it.

SPEAKER_01Social ruin, the front man for social ruin is gonna have to wear that out there as he's screaming.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah, that's that's not me, thankfully. I just use the bass, I just played bass guitar here. I uh I sing on occasion, but I'm not I'm not a singer, I'm more of a screamer.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, okay. So well, there you go. That was one of the big things was the your fifth appearance on on the scrap. So absolutely honored that you've come on so many times, shared your knowledge so many times, and uh welcome to the club. And so with that being said, you are a very popular person. I don't know if you know this, and I'm not here just to fluff, uh, but they were people fighting to sponsor this episode. So I've got a lot of sponsors to read here. So here we go. We'll get through them so we can get to scrapping.

SPEAKER_04Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Fire Innovations builds the most innovative UL certified NFPA escape belts, ladder belts, and class two harnesses right here in the USA, as well as the best bailout kits in the fire service featuring the Talon Escape Anchor and Core Descenders. Check out fireinnovations.com slash weekly scrap featuring the new Osprey, an NFPA certified carabiner and ladder hook that fits in the palm of your hand and opens with a simple twist. Fire innovations built by firefighters for firefighters, proven to save lives.

SPEAKER_01Fireinnovations.com slash weekly scrap. Not all fire hose is created equal. Some hose is built to meet the standard, snaptight hose is built to exceed it. From exceptional durability and kink resistance to industry leading heat resistance in the warrior attack hose, every snaptight hose is engineered to perform and tested before it leaves the factory floor. Snaptight, it's American made, firefighter trusted. Learn more at Snaptighthose.com or find a distributor near you. Everything about firefighting is a science.

SPEAKER_01Knowing the why of a tactic is just as important as the how. Go to fsri.org slash weekly scrap to access free training resources from UL Research Institute's Fire Safety Research Institute to learn how to adapt with evidence and overcome with confidence. That's fsri.org slash weekly scrap for freely accessible, evidence-based training and instructor reforces covering topics like firefighter health and safety, lithium ion batteries, and so much more.

SPEAKER_01And the best part, like I can't say this enough, free resource, go take advantage of it. Firefighter safety and accountability starts with being able to quickly find and identify individual firefighters operating on the fire ground. Identifier safety combines the best in photoluminescent materials for durable firefighter identification solutions that can glow for up to 20 hours, no switches, no batteries, which means being able to rapidly identify firefighters by name, unit, or assignment, even under hot fire conditions. All specifically designed and tested for the rigors of the job.

SPEAKER_01Use code VIGILINGS to save 10% on your order. Be seen on scene, identifiersafety.com. There we go. Woo! Like I said, there was a lot of it for you. I did, I got it done. I did not pass out this time.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. Good.

SPEAKER_01So now we get to the scrap. And dude, there are there are people showing up to hear John Duffy spread his message. I'm trying to think of the best way to say it. But uh you sent me your topics as always. There's hype already here. A lot of talk about Mr. Secretary from from Kevin Kate, of course. But yeah, of course. Not just that, we've also got training for reality. That's where I want to kick things off with because uh you've been passionate about this for a while. But as you've traveled, as you've taught, as you've done hands-on, I mean, so much, let's talk about training for reality and the challenges you see in the modern fire service.

SPEAKER_01And I'll just let you take it whatever direction you want.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's uh, I mean, we could go a whole show on just that topic, but I'll try and keep it brief. Um, as I travel, I see a common theme with with training, right? People, they're getting better, but they're still reluctant to put like furniture in the buildings, you know, um, or to to even do like live fire properly in a way that resembles as close to possible what we're gonna face uh for fear of damage in the building or or whatever it is. So I uh I always try to put the emphasis on like, you know, when we're training, um whatever training that topic is, for me that happens to be a lot of surge training, right?

SPEAKER_03So we should be using each other as much as possible, right? Hose mannequins, dummies, they don't manipulate the same. I see a lot of videos of people doing like the leg lock or you know, you know, whatever drags, and it's like, well, that that's great, but those hose mannequins and dummies are are pretty rigid, and um, you know, they're let's let's just face it, they don't really replicate the weight of a of a real victim either. Um, it's better than nothing, but um, I'm gonna advocate that hey, if you really want to know how to move a person, you need to move a person, right?

SPEAKER_03Um yeah, I love it. You know, you lube them up, you do put them in the scenarios that you wish to see. This like hiding them under drywall or stuffing them in weird spots just to get a gotcha moment, like that stuff's just not practical. It just creates training scars. Um, so that would be one. Two with the furniture, like again, whether you're doing search training or just moving line, there I've I've never been in a house fire where there was nothing. Like, even in a quote unquote vacant structure, there's always been stuff right in my way, right?

SPEAKER_03So, you know, you gotta mimic what you're seeing on the fire ground, what's what's true to you. You know, what's in my first two area might not be in your first two area. So make sure that you're just setting yourself up for success and throwing the variables in. And um, you know, I I with the live fire stuff, three pallet fire isn't doing much, you know. Uh you really need to set that up and let fire come down the hallway so that your crews can experience like what a true push looks like and feels like, sure.

SPEAKER_03Uh, as well as gear. Man, like we have firefighters that are just going into to average fires, right? Your normal bread and butter structure fire that's like, man, this is really hot because they don't know what hot feels like.

SPEAKER_01Hot is, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. So it's like, you know, on all ends of this thing, like we we really need to do, and I don't think we're doing terrible. I think we're we're catching up, but we we need to do a better job as a fire service as whole, um, creating those situations for people, those that putting that stress in there and everything else. So people don't freeze up, they don't they don't bail when when they're perfectly okay to keep pushing on, you know, they're they're doing searches adequately, right? They're they're not slowed down because for the first time they've had like a bunch of things in their way all of a sudden, you know.

SPEAKER_03Right. Um, so that that's just my take on it, just to keep it brief.

SPEAKER_01No, and and it's phenomenal. Just the point you brought up, uh, and you hit on a lot there fuel loads, uh, contents uh and challenges of the props we use all the way down to the buildings and the mannequins dummies. And I'm gonna use the clip, I'm gonna clip it up, go to where it says lube them up, stuff it into weird places, and that's what I'm gonna use as your as your thing for the podcast. Uh, but no, that's my brain. I'm sorry. Uh it's it's great, it's great. But no, um, and now I squirrel and forgot my my point that I was gonna make to you on that, on that, which was yeah, I'll come back to it when I I'll think of it out of the blue here in a minute and then interrupt my thoughts.

SPEAKER_01But I've got questions coming at you already from the audience. Are you ready to start kicking it with questions? Yeah, man, bring them on. Fireman Piv, Kyle Piverall checking in with you says, why do departments still do propane burns?

SPEAKER_03Uh I have no idea. I I would think maybe it's cost. I I I don't know. Um, you know, it's it's probably less labor intensive, meaning, like, you know, you do class A burns, you need a whole team, right? You need people to rotate through, like safety, all that kind of stuff. Um, I I don't know. Uh I wish I had a better answer, but I will say this. Um propane burns, they're just clean, right? So that goes back to the training for reality. Like, yeah, you get a cool fire overhead and stuff like that, but like I've never been in a fire where I had no smoke.

SPEAKER_02Right.

SPEAKER_03Right. And and that's really the thing is like this is a class B building, it's got fire, we don't really have smoke. And they're like, oh, well, we could plumb in the fake smoke. They're like, that doesn't do anything for me. Like, I need I need smoke to do what it naturally does, right? I need to see the pattern of that mixed with fire behavior and all those things. Um, plus, in my opinion, and I could be completely wrong on this class B fires. You got that nice fire rolling overhead.

SPEAKER_03I'm just teaching you to keep crawling underneath fire and not do anything about it.

SPEAKER_01Not do it now, not not fighting the conditions on the way in.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, and then you go, well, we skip the same thing that we run into with class A fires, right? Hey, watch where you put in the water. It's like, well, I shouldn't have to worry about that in a real fire. Like, I'm gonna put the fire out, so let me put the damn fire out, right? So I'm not a fan of them, to be honest. I'm not trying to like shit on them by any means. Um, but I don't I don't have a better answer for you, other than that, unfortunately.

SPEAKER_01No, no, no. And maybe I should look reach out and find someone who is an expert on class B burn buildings and and and the and the benefits of them because I don't outside look, you know, uh I know that Chiefs, I don't want to just pick on Chiefs, but the people who make decisions are like real happy about the sensors in there and they can hit a button and it shuts the whole thing down just instantly, you know, that kind of stuff.

SPEAKER_03And it's like, well, that's a maybe they'd be a lot better if I could like put a burn barrel in there or something and actually get some good smoke rolling through there. I don't know, but that I guess that kind of defeats the purpose, doesn't it? Right.

SPEAKER_01Just a bunch of smudge pots, just cook just with and some leaf lowers to get it, get it chunky. Yeah. Uh Matthew, KFD wants to know, Sean, in a large department where search isn't a number one priority, how do you get the buy-in for VES?

SPEAKER_03Man, oh, I get this question all the time. And I can always speak.

SPEAKER_01I figure this is like right, like there's certain ones you're like, I know he's fielded this one about a thousand times, but go ahead.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, well, and you know, I can only speak to my experiences, right? So I hate to say like this is the plan, this is what you do, because that's not everybody's reality. Um, I I happen to work for a quote unquote larger department. You know, it's just because I work for an urban city doesn't mean I have the great staffing levels, right? So we have some challenges as well. I think to get buy-in for VES, one, we have to break it down to its very simple form and like get everybody to understand that this is not a new concept. We've been doing VES in the fire service for a very, very long time.

SPEAKER_03It just maybe looked different or was it called VES or whatever the case is, and for whatever reason we put an acronym acronym to it, and then people lose their minds. Like, oh my God. In its truest, purest form, uh, VES is just a mode of entry. You're just going through a window through instead of a front door. Like that is legitimately the only thing that changes. And what I I tend to try and get people to understand is when I go unprotected, right? Like I don't, I'm I'm searching ahead of a handline and I open this front door.

SPEAKER_03Let's just call that like 27 square foot of opening. Like I typically don't close the front door behind me. And then how far is it till I find a room where I can isolate myself?

SPEAKER_02Right.

SPEAKER_03Maybe 20, 30 feet. Nobody says anything about that.

SPEAKER_02Right.

SPEAKER_03Right. But I say, go into a room that's like 50-50. There's either a door or there's not. Sure. I'm dumping you in the place where one victims are most likely to be found. You're getting put in there right now. Two, it's a smaller, manageable space. Obviously, there's uh there's variables there, right? Like sure. I don't know, you can you can have like a master bedroom which is larger, but that's why we advocate to dump two in instead of one. That's also why we advocate for the first person in the window to pick up that camera and identify that door opening and go straight to it, assess conditions in the hall, and isolate so that the search could be happening behind them, right?

SPEAKER_03When we look at the success rate of VES, I don't know, I think it's like 17% of the time we're doing this. So small percentage compared to all the other searches, but the survival rate, your returning investment is incredibly high.

SPEAKER_00Right on, right?

SPEAKER_03So it's like 68%. I think. I don't know. I don't have the numbers in front of me, so don't quote me directly.

SPEAKER_01Um but the sense the sense of it, yeah. You may now don't hold into the numbers, but the sense of it's not a good thing.

SPEAKER_03But this, yeah, the sense is like the return investment on that is incredibly high. In fact, it's it's probably one of the most safest things we can be doing on the fire ground, to be honest. So back to the question, how do you get the buy-in? You you've got to like maybe not be so aggressive with it and just have a conversation with people and say, like, what is the point here? What do we hope to accomplish? We hope to get to victims the quickest way possible. We hope to get them out the quickest way possible. We hope to create a space, right, that is ventilating so that for our victims it's better, but also for us, yeah.

SPEAKER_03Should I leave that room, right, by entering the window and like closing the door? One, that room continues to exhaust behind me. But two, should things get bad, I've got a place to fall back to that we've created. That's a huge benefit.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Right. And then we'd bring in the numbers, right? Like, there's no better way to prove why we should be doing something than to put it up against true fire ground data. And we have that data. Right. Granted, it's it's voluntary, right? But it's we're getting more and more. I I would argue that we're probably close to six thousand rescues by now. If we're not close, we're we're getting pretty close, you know. Um every time we get a thousand rescues, you know, this stuff gets analyzed.

SPEAKER_03But one thing that continues to be surfacing, and again, this could be changing because that's how data works, is that window-initiated searches are definitely uh yielding high results. And removing victims from windows is an exceptionally high way that we're taking people out of buildings. So those two kind of go hand in hand. Right on. So break it down like that, have the conversation, and then put it into training, right?

SPEAKER_03Do a time to task. How long does it take me to get to this room from entering the front door and navigating through the structure via me just taking the window and going right in? Right. And and we could talk VES again all day. It's one of my favorite things to talk about. But um, how I've had to get buy-in uh throughout my career is is to prove those things, to show them. Like, hey, you know, I'm not saying we should just be jumping into spaces that it doesn't make sense, right? But we should be paying attention to what the smoke shows us when we take a window, right?

SPEAKER_03That'll tell you right then and there if you should enter or not. It'll tell you how close your fire is, it'll tell you if you got some time, it'll tell you if the fire's in that room, if the fire's not in the room, it'll also tell you if the door is closed.

unknownRight?

SPEAKER_03So if I take a window and I got like lazy smoke, the door's closed. What am I worried about? Search the room. Right? Oh, I get this. I love it. You know what I mean? Like we got to match some things there. We got to match like the smoke reading and conditions to like what the action is that we're about to perform and make sure that they go hand in hand before we just start randomly doing stuff.

SPEAKER_01No, phenomenal, phenomenal breakdown of a question. I know you've filled it a lot of times. And one thing I want to know from Matthew, Matthew asked the question. He says a large department where search isn't a number one priority. He didn't even say VES wasn't a number one priority, he said search isn't a priority.

SPEAKER_03So I Oh yeah, just went on a tangent, didn't I?

SPEAKER_01No, no, no, but he asked about VES, he he went on to ask about VES specifically. I'm I'm circling back to the question because I'm intrigued in the fact that search is not a number one priority, then what is, you know, and that's what I've so Matthew, if you want to give us some info, let us know. But Kevin Kate coming at you, Mr. Secretary, Sean, you among others helped me build my first training program. For those that are struggling with the decision to do it or not, what advice would you offer them?

SPEAKER_03Man, okay. Um this this I'm gonna try and keep this like direct. Um don't just start a program to start a program, man. There's plenty of those out there, right? The information is the information, most of it is is the same, right? Any of us could get on the internet, we could read the the book of search, we can read, you know, the uh you know, book Andy, we could read whatever it is, all the UL studies that are that have come out, or the FSRI studies that have come out, those are available.

SPEAKER_03There, there's a tremendous amount of information available. And if you think you're the only one that has it, think again.

SPEAKER_02Right.

SPEAKER_03Most people have it. What makes the program isn't necessarily information, it's your ability to break it down and relate it to people. It's your your comfortability with being able to answer questions by people who may not have read it or understand it and get them to understand it, even if you disagree. Okay. So the the the point here isn't to go out and like just talk and be like, you have to listen to me. Like, this is the way you do it. The point is to have a conversation. The point is to to get people to think, even if they're if they wind up in that conversation being stronger in their convictions and they don't agree with you, then they know why they feel the way they do, right?

SPEAKER_03Also being humble that like some people are gonna bring things to you that maybe you haven't thought of, or or they're gonna ask you away, you know. And I'll own this one. I was just in Canada and I said something in the program on like, you know, we're terrible about getting information out in the fire service. And this gentleman got me after class. He goes, I don't think that's true. I think we are great about getting information out. We just have too many conduits. And somewhere throughout all those conduits, things get lost. And I'm like, you know what?

SPEAKER_03You're absolutely correct. That makes more sense. So being able to humble yourself and have that conversation and then go back in front of a group of people and be like, hey, I'm gonna take what I learned and I'm gonna pass that on, right? And always fine tune that message so that you are able to have those conversations with whoever chiefs, firefighters. people who aren't firefighters, you know, we've gotta we've got to do that. If we look at hands-on, when you're doing a hands-on program, again, don't teach a skill just to teach a skill.

SPEAKER_03Like if you can't break down the skill to its bare minimum roots of like why we're doing it and how to do it and do it in every phase and make it that everybody in that class can have confidence in that skill, then don't show it.

SPEAKER_01Right on.

SPEAKER_03There's a there's a lot of gimmicky stuff out there that people get confused with. And it's your job as an educator to be like, that's not going to work and here's why. And then show them something that does work so that you can send them out and they can practice and train and maybe make up, I don't know, their own way of doing something. But the end result is that we're all walking away from this better than when we came in, even the instructors.

SPEAKER_01Right. No, and that's the phenomenal part about a good program is you learn as much from the students as you do uh from instructing. I mean it it's a two-way street when it's done well. And so uh I love thank you for the question Kevin and thank you for the answer.

SPEAKER_03Sean Rob Reed coming at you says what are the best ways to train our rookies during the academy for search short of being able to burn so when you can't burn what's the best techniques you found well first you got to get everybody on the same page right you don't know everybody's like everybody coming into an organization they can come from a different organization they could be coming straight from the fire academy like there's all these variables and even if they came from a different organization you got to understand like you can't look at them be like oh well you have experience you're good no because you have no idea how they were trained in that organization or how they were performing search on fires before they got to you so clean slate through the front door you want everybody to like start operating the same even without live fire I actually would say like live fire is the least of my worries okay when I'm starting train because you lose a lot of the one-on-one you lose a lot of the ability to add other stressors right like if you're if you're doing a training in live fire I can't use real people right which means that I can't put stress on you by like having conscious victims presenting from a window or doing like a baby drop or having any of the other things that make up a scenario not including live fire.

SPEAKER_03Meaning like if I'm if I'm taking somebody down from a ladder and you're not communicating with that victim, right? And you're not controlling them, that victim's gonna take right up the ladder and go back in. I could do that because I'm not using live fire. Anyway back to the point I I think we got to break it down and start of like just just the mindset of search. Like what is it that we're looking for like this starts from before the fire even gets to us right like what is the dispatch information we have what kind of house are we going to what is our size up because we're not just sizing up for fire we're sizing for searchable space those two have to go hand in hand right get people start thinking like visual cues are going to help them.

SPEAKER_03If I got a building that's 30 feet long you know and 20 feet wide like that kind of tells you a little bit about the area you're about to search because that's going to get a little bit more reduced right so when we talk about like things like split search or whatever like that matters getting comfortability. So we get the mindset down I think is important then we break into like some of the data like where we're finding victims um and and show them how that correlates to the fire ground and then bring it into skill based I want you to search in a tripod position.

SPEAKER_03I I gotta understand that not everybody bends the same way right some people that's very uncomfortable for me it's very easy. I do it all the time right but I got to get you to move the way I want you to move before I could do anything else. And then we start you know working that stuff in okay like get a little bit further from your partner do you have to be on the wall right these are core principles of of performing a primary search that we need to dial in before we start doing live fire.

SPEAKER_03What does a split search look like for you? What should the communication be? How do you know how far is too far? How many thresholds are we crossing before we stop and check in with each other how many people do we have right like there's so many questions based on like the organization that you're in and how you operate that you really need to progress these things in phases so phase one would be like understanding what this search should look like phase two showing some skills making sure everyone's comfortable with that maybe now we're adding more gear right coats packs on air right then we put that into like cool so you guys have moved around let me now bring you to the training grounds and even if we have to make a pallet house I want you guys to search it the way that you normally would communication use your thermal imager if if that's what you do like all of those things and then the final scenario is the last part putting that all together all together you know yeah oh game day it's close to get like the scrimmage it's as close to game day as you can get without it being the game day.

SPEAKER_03Yeah but I I think too like and and we're gonna talk about this later I'm sure but like you know my biggest thing is what do we do when we get in trouble at the fire department everybody always goes back to policy they want to pull it out and be like oh you didn't follow the policy and this is what you violated right here. Yeah I don't know right like I think when it comes to search ops in part of that equation when you're trying to build maybe for a first time you're trying to build something um or you're trying to improve what you have or like however you know whatever situation you're in I I I truly believe that having a policy written down of what you want this to look like is instrumental.

SPEAKER_03And people disagree with me and that's fine.

SPEAKER_01Yeah I want to dig into that a little bit but go ahead.

SPEAKER_03Our our policies are the playbook of of what we do. So if I make a search policy of how I want you to operate and what's totally acceptable as long as we operate in that inside of that thing like we're starting from the very beginning that indoctrination here's your policy read it you'll know what we want you to do on the fire ground you know that also becomes a training manual. You go back and you pull it out and you're like okay today we're talking about communication it's here right here it's in the policy this section we're gonna build some drills based around just this paragraph or just these three parts of this policy before you know it people are doing like really good searches and they're they're doing all the things instinctively and you're following the policy so what what is there to really be left with at the end right to question.

SPEAKER_01I guess my question to and again I I love the topic I love the topic I think we could talk about this policy topic and people would be uh until people were tired of it. But what do you do when the I it sounds great if the policy seems to be based off of good data and good tactics and good and and it gives you the freedom to make decisions within it.

SPEAKER_03What do you do when it's a micromanaging policy and it's more used to uh PP spank and and get people in trouble than it is for actually helping people train does that make sense does that make sense what I'm trying to ask yeah no it it makes sense and here's the thing a couple things on that one you should always have a revision date on your policies right so when you make them because not everything we put in at first is is going to stay right like we might find more things data might change uh we might realize like hey we're just not prepared for that yet whatever the situation is right like you should always have that revision date but to your question and I'm gonna be perfectly frank here I I don't think the chief should have anything to do with writing those policies that should be for firemen by firemen.

SPEAKER_03The companies performing those functions should write those policies and bring it to the chief and have a conversation. Oh wow I love that hey this is what we'd like to do this is what we're countering on the fire ground this this is how we want to operate and and have that back and forth. Are you going to get everything you want? Maybe not but I think in that process you could come to an understanding of of how you need to operate or how you want to operate you know just by having the conversation and and once it's out there send it out for like 30 days.

SPEAKER_03Get it to the whole department see what people think right if if people are like ooh you know what that should really be in there or I'm not so sure that needs to be in there whatever the case is get the feedback go and when it's finalized everybody in the whole fire department has had a say in what this policy looks like. So if you're getting your PP smacked it's your own damn phone.

SPEAKER_01That's fair. That's fair. And and the problem you know and this is uh my experience is I've experienced it traveling and talking to people and stuff and it's but far from the entire fire service and I'm sure there's many exceptions to this but my own anecdotal experiences is usually the policies are coming top down from like you said the one person probably that doesn't need to be writing them. That's my that may not be the right way to say it, but it is the it's top down.

SPEAKER_03It's coming out without any input it's just here it is follow these rules and if you don't boom here's your reprimand yeah and you know here's the thing all right again this isn't to batch on on anybody in in administration right there's nobody more dialed in or let me rephrase that there should be nobody more dialed in in your fire department than the people on the street doing this day in and day out some of the policies have to come from administration sure because they're doing things that you're not and you have to respect and understand that position on things.

SPEAKER_03But when it comes to tactical decisions leave that stuff to the people who are doing it right and hopefully you got a chief that's got its thumb on the pulse of the fire service and actually know what's going on. Hopefully you got a a person who's writing policy that continues to read, that continues to educate themselves and goes to fire conferences or listens to podcasts or does whatever they need to do to make sure that they can still relate to those underneath them.

SPEAKER_03Because once you're no longer on the rig, man, that thing's gonna surpass you if you don't keep touch with it. No right no without a doubt. I think that's the problem right is it's like oh I did 15 years on a rig and now I'm gonna make all these rules. It's like yeah that that was like five years ago and in those five years all of these things changed right yeah no it's a great point.

SPEAKER_01It's a solid point. So I don't know I'm not a chief I I'm not gonna certainly pretend to talk like one or that I understand no but I love I love the conversation because I like the fact that you said that that policy is the is the backbone of training. It really is. And I I do I do agree with that but I understand also the sentiment of and I I'll read you some comments here because I saw a couple scrolling by and uh firefighter nobody said hmm are we certain we could get four firemen to weigh in on a policy and I know that's a lot of people's mindset is you know but I think they would and I think you can agree or disagree and let me know your thoughts I think they would if they felt like it actually mattered when they when they presented it.

SPEAKER_03If it didn't matter then of course eventually they check out yeah I mean if you don't create a way for people out by in they're just gonna be like yeah whatever then nobody listens anyway. I mean I've experienced that through my career where like you get an email and it's like hey let me know what you think and it's like why you're just gonna do whatever the fuck you want.

SPEAKER_02Right, right.

SPEAKER_03Well and that's your right to do but don't ask me my opinion if you don't want it. Yeah right um however with that said we got to keep in mind with this that like oh rally the troops yeah that sounds like really romantic and stuff like that but like you're gonna get a small percentage of people that actually give a shit those are going to be the people that weigh in with their with their voice and and that's fine because when the rest of the fire department says well why are we doing this anymore be like well you had a say right you you had a chance to to make your say and like maybe there's only two of us that came to the table with any ideas and we took this on oh well that's why you send it out to the department for 30 days.

SPEAKER_03So people can be like maybe they're on vacation maybe whatever maybe maybe they hadn't heard about it or checked their email like I don't know. But at the end of the day when you give all of the avenues to get input if nobody gives them the input then don't be don't be pissed off with the policy that you wind up with.

SPEAKER_02Right.

SPEAKER_03That's your own fault. If you're giving an opportunity to have an say in how that is shaped and you don't that's on you.

SPEAKER_01If you are given the opportunity yes yes if you're given the opportunity if it's crammed down your throat then then that's a whole nother that's not what we're talking about. That is not what we're talking about here.

SPEAKER_03Like I said this sounds great but like some people I'm also a realist some people may never be given that opportunity. Right so like maybe create it or try at least right like hey chief like I I noticed we don't have a policy on this or like hey this policy hasn't been updated and stuff like I'm really passionate about this. Do you mind if I take a crack at it and like add some things and you you might get shot down.

SPEAKER_01So what at least you tried yes right you know what I mean no no and and somebody in the comment said it's already scrolled past because I can't see it but I saw it a minute ago said basically policy change and culture change are both long games they're not they're not instantaneous they take a while to to have that impact and so whoever said that you could repost it and I'll give you credit. But moving on to questions and you can you can revisit any of this you want um I love that on the not being able to burn question I wanted to say on that look at the strengths of not being able to burn and and maximize those things that's one thing you said in there and I really appreciate that.

SPEAKER_01And then it's all about mindset from there. Fireman Piv this is a broad question aimed at the fire service.

SPEAKER_03So Kyle Piverall says how did non-search non-search focused first mindset become so pervasive in the fire service oh man I I like these how did this happen go ahead and tell us Sean I don't know how it happened but what I can say is I I'd like to think it happened just like everything else nobody challenged it right nobody was loud enough maybe they didn't have enough people we're we're in a time in the fire service now where it's really hard to ignore the facts prior to that again I don't know maybe I'm wrong prior to that I would like to think that you know we were come from that like post-war era where it's like don't question me just do what I fucking say.

SPEAKER_03Yeah here's what you need to do and then when you said well why do we do it that way I don't know that's how I was taught and that's why you're being taught it and there wasn't really like a a question right like digging deep and then we started getting the science and then we started getting more things coming out and and I think some of that kind of broke down I also do think that um you know for lack of better words uh we we love to put stuff out there for safety of firefighters which is not a bad thing but when we put like everyone goes home or like you know we say shit like the fire went out you know and and nothing happened we high five like there's all these things that we put in there and I remember being brought into the fire service and I asked a question on on one of the first fires I ever went to did we search quick enough that's all I wanted to know.

SPEAKER_03Right like hey did did we get in there fast enough and was our operating time efficient right yeah it's a great question. And and what I was told was pretty much like I've been doing this a long time when people are in fires very rarely do they survive they're probably dead before we got here. Yeah and that was something I heard a long time so I I think that's kind of like the mentality that has been for you know decade maybe more is you know put water on the fire that's the best thing you do if anyone's in there they're probably dead and we had some misunderstandings like large fire automatically meant no one could survive.

SPEAKER_03You know we're calling things fully involved that that have searchable space right I I think we just thought it you know that I don't want to say this was on purpose. Right. I think we just thought that like the best thing we could do at that point is put the fire out and then get to searching and if anybody was alive we'd find them and what we now know is searching ahead the handline is is a thing and and that is very beneficial. You know like 98% of the time we're searching simultaneously or before the fire's knocked down when you start breaking that down you're like oh that's like a 68 something percent survival rate like you're able to dispute some of that before we didn't have that ability.

SPEAKER_03So it's just kind of like my thoughts against your thoughts.

SPEAKER_01Yeah my opinion versus yours and shut up kid you don't have the time on to challenge my opinion.

SPEAKER_03Yeah and when you come to the table with facts I think it's a little easier to have conversations right and at the end of the day like you're gonna agree or you're gonna disagree but like I make my decisions based off of facts. And I think that's where we're heading opposed to where we were because I even see like in the class that I do the surgical reverse survivable program I've got people that have they're chiefs or they've been in the department 30 something years and like they're like man this information's fantastic this definitely changed the way I think and I didn't give them anything mind blowing right I just took what was available to me and I said hey if you haven't heard it here it is.

SPEAKER_03Here it is and they're like oh my God I haven't heard it and I and I think that's that's part of it is that you know like you have a generation of firefighters that never believed in the science or wanted to hear it. It was just their way and that's what worked for them and that's what they were going to do.

SPEAKER_01I love it man. I absolutely love it. Okay I'm pivoting I'm going to T Berry 1989 he's going back to training here and I wants to I like this question. How do you set up a training evolution to allow members to experience loss? Training evolutions are usually set up so that if you follow instructions you will succeed how do you safely experience loss or is it just failure? I'm not sure Tyler you can uh correct me if you're saying just failing in the in the in the thing or coming up even negative like we always find a victim in training but but go ahead and field the question.

SPEAKER_03I think I think what he's getting at is is how do you set up evolution so that people don't think they're gonna succeed right because that's often what we do is like we set it up for them to succeed because we want to build that confidence. Right. And you kind of touched on it there is like man not every fire has a victim in it. You know and if if we're watching in groups like we always do people are talking oh yeah I found the I found the victim in this bedroom or the there's two victims in there and there's like you've got to be able to change it up.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_03Make sure there's no victims make sure you have a baby victim or an adult victim or like just honestly have the conversation you you have to have the conversation when you're doing search training like hey here's where we're at okay the goal is that we search every bit of space that we possibly can and we find all the people the reality is that we're all imperfect and we make mistakes and we might blow past an area that gets caught later we might miss a victim entirely in a space that we're operating in all those things may happen.

SPEAKER_03Our goal is to reduce greatly reduce the chances of that happening by continuing to practice over and over and over again so I think letting them experience some sort of failure um is is important. A lot of times like what I like to do is before I do a window lift drill or I do like uh the any type of drags show me here's your your victims in there somewhere go get them and bring them out because I just want to see what they do.

SPEAKER_03Right.

SPEAKER_01What what skill set hey you're checking their skill set but also you're seeing what they're bringing to the table and yeah go ahead.

SPEAKER_03Yeah and and in that moment there's there's some failure there right sure because they're gonna resort back to what's comfortable or what they know and often like a window lift they try to do that bear hug thing and they squat and they try and lift and like okay so we've got a couple things you drug them to this location with their airway high which is a no no right we don't want to do that and here's why and we break that down and then when you got here you did this and this is why you're not going to be able to complete this lift and and you don't you know you tried it three different times and and whatever.

SPEAKER_03So um I think there's variables that we can add in there as long as there's a lesson learned right don't set someone up for failure just for the sake of setting them up for failure because that that doesn't do anything for them. Like you got to let them not do the the thing you want them to do so that you can revisit it and then kind of talk about and be okay so now that you know we're gonna run this again and I want to see what you do. Right on you know and failure can look different man like it's not just victims it could be search time right I can say I want you to search this building and I want you to be out in five minutes.

SPEAKER_03Okay. Yeah put obstacles in there for them that you know they're not Going to get out in five minutes. See what they can get.

SPEAKER_01And it is so important. Because a primary search, man, uh especially because that's usually what we're practicing. We're practicing primary search. Very rarely are we doing secondary search drills. But uh that's that's not to say we don't, but usually we're talking about a primary search, it's a quick and dirty search, it's covering as much ground as possible so we can locate those victims as quickly as possible. But I I I do know that whenever, at least on evolutions that I have led, if they don't find a victim, they will sit there forever because they're like, there's supposed to be one here, there's supposed to be one here, there's supposed to be one here. And that is that training wound, you know?

SPEAKER_01And and so, yeah, and just just making it to where you're going for to find a victim if they're there, and to find no victims if there are no victims, and then be able to have the confidence to call primary search negative.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I mean, when you say primary search negative or primary all clear, you own those words. You cannot take that back, right? So make sure that you throw some failures into training. And like I said, failure can look any different, like all different ways, right? Doesn't that be one specific thing? Uh I I think that's what the question was about. I don't know if there was clarification, but he may come back.

SPEAKER_01Uh yeah, he may come back. I don't know if he'll if he does, Sam will throw it at us. So if he gives us more clarification, because I love the questions. So far, you guys have been killing it. Uh at I mean, as always, the scrap audience is amazing. Uh I like uh well, Rob F. Fisher, this is not a question. Rob F and Fisher said, Congrats on the jacket, brother. Welcome to the club.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, we're gonna have to smoke a cigar to celebrate.

SPEAKER_01Heck yeah. Uh all right, here we go. Fireman Piv. How oh I we just we just cleared that one. Sorry, Kyle, I was trying to read you twice. How we lost focus on search. Uh following up, Kevin Kate wants to follow up on Piv's. How much of bringing the change to your organization is being loud and heard? And how much is Rob's Rob F and Fisher, by the way, 10% of pressure 100% of the time.

SPEAKER_03All right, so I'm gonna caution everybody from being loud and heard, okay? And I was that for a long time. That doesn't go over very well. Nobody likes that. It's too aggressive, right? We think we're doing good by being loud and be like, oh, you don't understand, and then we disguise it as being passionate, and it just turns people off, right? You have to be emotionally intelligent if you want to win any kind of this stuff. And and being emotionally intelligent includes not allowing yourself to get pissed off and yell and scream at people, right?

SPEAKER_03It is a long game. Some battles are gonna take forever, some some you might get a little bit right up front. It is what it is, but when you get a little bit of that up front, like just take that for for for what it is and work with that a little bit, all right. Um, again, I can always speak on my experience. It did not get me anywhere when I was like, Yeah, we gotta be doing this, you know, like we're our searches suck, blah, blah, blah. Because now you're just attacking people and they're like, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. Like listen, man, like calm down.

SPEAKER_03And it doesn't matter what you say from there, it doesn't matter how correct you are, like, no one's listening. Right. Because you're just annoying, right?

SPEAKER_01If you if you're hearing you, you're just having no impact. They're actually annoying.

SPEAKER_03I mean, eventually they just stop engaging altogether, like, oh, Duffy's talking again. You know, white noise. Yeah, because that's all it is. You just keep saying the shit. There's a time and a place, is my point, right? Um, if you get time to train with people, like, like, hey, can I try this thing? And and you know, sometimes you might have to like let somebody else show you something, even though it's not necessarily like what you like or what you want, and be like, okay, what if we did this? Can I show you this?

SPEAKER_03Like, ask, right? Can I? And then they say no and be like, all right, cool. It it this doesn't have to be a back and forth all the time. And we often, like, as firefighters, because we want to see that change, right? We're so like, why isn't anybody listening? You know, it might just take a few people retiring, it might just take getting another fire chief, it might just take getting another officer, whatever the situation is. Like, stay true to your mission, bring it up when you can, have the conversations respectfully, right?

SPEAKER_03And and just be the same person. Like, you cannot come in and start barking at each other about mascot times when you don't ever do a mascot drill. You can't. No, yeah, that's a great point. You can't be like, oh my god, I can't believe this firefighter messed up forcing that door, blah, blah, blah, blah, and like become part of the problem when like you're like flipping that thing like a paton yourself, right? Like, if you're gonna make the noise, you better be dialed in. Right on, right on.

SPEAKER_03And I think that that loses some of it too, right? Is like a lot of times, like all well-intentioned, we make the noise, and it's like, all right, hot shot, show me. And then you have your moment and you totally shit the bed, right? Right. So um, time and place, I guess, is my point. And and just little nuggets, like that's it. 10% of pressure, 100% of the time, man. Like that 10% of pressure might come once a month. Yeah, it might come in, you know, in a conversation that's totally random throughout the day.

SPEAKER_03It doesn't matter, right? Keep it on the table. Keep it on the table, just keep it on the table and like do stuff that fires. Right? Like it, like, I don't know. Let's insert any topic. We'll keep search out of it because that one's a little weird sometimes. Um you want to be the forceable entry guy? You want to talk about forceable entry and all the things you should be doing? Any chance that you have on an incident to show off your forceful entry skills, you should do it.

SPEAKER_03Because that's gonna conversation. Hey man, that thing you did was really cool. How'd you fucking learn that? Oh, I learned it like this. I've been trying to, you know, get us into doing this and whatever. I think having a a through the lockbag would be fantastic. Somebody might take that conversation and do the work for you.

SPEAKER_01And especially when you prove it through your actions, prove it through your competence, and then they come to you and ask the question. It lends so much more to them listening, man. I absolutely love it. Coming at you with Rob Fisher, because he had a when he actually said, Congrats on the jacket, there was a question that went with it that I did not see. So that's on you. He said, Brother, you're a social D guy. So I have to bring Mike Ness into this. And I was wrong. Ness talks about people trying to warn him, but he wasn't ready to hear what they were saying. Looking back on your career, was there something a mentor tried to teach you that you didn't really understand or appreciate until years later?

SPEAKER_01And how has that changed the way you mentor firefighters today?

SPEAKER_03Man, first off, social distortion, best band ever. Absolutely great question. Um, yeah. Anybody who knows me knows two things. One, I'm very animated, and two, I can get really passionate. That's just how it is. Maybe three, I love caffeine. So um I think when I was probably, I want to say I was like 20, maybe 21, uh, I had an officer say, like, hey man, I I love your drive and your vision for things, but you gotta slow it down, man.

SPEAKER_03You're gonna burn yourself out. You know, like you're just go, go, go all the time, and you're just like taking all these classes that you can take, and you're just doing these things, and it's a long career, you know, be it's it'll be done before you know it, but it's a long career. And you know, if if you want to stay true to your beliefs and and everything else like that, you gotta pace yourself. And I was like, ah, bullshit, all or nothing, right? All gas, no breaks.

SPEAKER_01Gonna live forever, baby.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, and and you know, like I I got pretty burnt out and like always doing the things and and you know, going to classes, and then which put me in like a a spot where I was actually starting to not enjoy the job because of it all, and I was getting very angry at people that I worked with, you know, and and you know, they probably wanted to punch me because sometimes I could be quite the asshole, right? And what I learned in that and what I would pass on to other people is two things like the fire service is great, don't lose yourself, right?

SPEAKER_03You were a person before you got in it. There's nothing wrong with going to classes and training, there's nothing wrong with getting knowledge and being invested in your career and like wanting to do things for your department. But for Christ's sakes, man, if you if if you don't pace yourself, you're gonna start hating this job. I promise you. And that was the lesson that I had to learn. And I tell that to everybody coming in my organization when I get my small few minutes with them of like, hey, whatever that thing is that you really like about this job, make sure that you always like it.

SPEAKER_03And you do the things that feed it, but you also do the things that feed you outside of here. Right.

SPEAKER_01Because you can't be a firefighter all the time, and you can't lose sight of the most important things with you know, family. Yeah, family.

SPEAKER_03Oh, honors, especially if you got kids, man. No, no doubt. Your kids don't care that you're a firefighter, they think it's cool, right? Because they got this vision of what you do, but they don't care about all the other stuff. They just want their parent, they want their dad, they want their mom, they just want you to be you, right? Because at the end of the day, when the job's over, you're still there, you're you're still their dad or their mom. That's it.

SPEAKER_01Dude, that's uh words of wisdom from the punk rocker, the skate punk rocker. I love it. Uh I love this one. Oh, I want to mention because we were on 10 pounds of pressure 100% of the time. We were also on, you know, but uh and Rob Pisher's question. So combine those two. And if you want to dig into 10 pounds of pressure 100% of the time, shameless plug for scrap solo number five, episode number five, where Rob talks about that for an entire hour and 10 minutes of nothing but that topic. So I wanted to throw that out there on that last question. David Stepp coming at you from California.

SPEAKER_01He says, Sean, can you walk us through your preferred drags and the situations you train to use them? When is a leg drag preferred over an arm drag? Does distance clutter conditions does that impact drag triage? And I like that term, drag triage, but I know you can talk for two or three hours on drags alone. So I'll let you go wherever you want with it.

SPEAKER_03Uh yeah, I'm gonna rely on you to kind of keep me on track so I don't miss anything because there's a couple of things on there that that I think we need to discuss. Number one, conditions are always going to drive what you do, right? There's that whole thing if they can't see, or if you can't see, they can't breathe. True, right? So, what kind of smoke condition are we dealing with in the situation that we're in? If I don't need to get down low, like we teach everybody to do things low because that is the worst possible place that you're gonna be, right?

SPEAKER_03And if you can do it low, you could change your body position to match whatever conditions you have. So, number one, distance does make a difference after I've assessed the conditions I'm in, right? Um if I if I got a smoke layer, I'm gonna take a position to where I keep their airway low, but I might like squat and pull them backwards, right? Do something like that instead of getting down low and getting in this full leg leg drag.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and also if the smoke's up here at five feet and you got plenty of room, yeah.

SPEAKER_03Plenty of plenty of room. I'm certainly not gonna like pick up their airway like we do with a hose dummy or or mannequin when we're doing like CPAT testing or something. Like that doesn't make any sense, right? But we're gonna keep their airway low as long as possible, right? Distance. Okay, where are we going? The leg lock or like an arm lock or any of those quick, dirty drags, they're really good for short distance. So either like I'm taking them from a hallway into a bedroom, I've you know, opened a door, I did my life fire layout, call out, and I see somebody, I'm just gonna go get them and bring them right back.

SPEAKER_03Or like I'm going from the hallway back to the front door, whatever the situation is. Right. Short distances. I am certainly not dragging someone 50 damn feet that way. I'm not gonna do that, right? If I'm dragging someone 50 feet, I've missed something somewhere. You know what I mean?

SPEAKER_01No, no, yeah, unless you're unless it's some sort of big box store in some really weird outlandish, outlandish scenario of some sort. Right.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, like maybe residential search.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Basic, we're keeping this thing bread and butter searches, right? We're not gonna throw all these crazy variables in there because those those all mean something different. Sure. So that's that's what I would look at there um when we're when we're doing that. Um how I how I do it, because I think this is part of the question, right? Walk you through how you do it. Um, I come through, I assess. First thing I do is make sure that I do a 360 around the victim, making sure that there's nobody else in that immediate area that I'm operating in.

SPEAKER_03You know, where there's one, there's likely two. We also have the data to support that. Right. So we we just want to take a moment to clear that. Followed by that, I I kind of reach out just to see how long this individual is to give me an idea of what I'm working with. I also kind of come in a little wide just to see how wide they are. If they're taller, if they're longer than me and they're wider than me, like you know, this is gonna be a little challenging. But I'm gonna set it up the same way. Basically, I I cross the ankles, I push the feet completely up.

SPEAKER_03I create space for me to slide into, and I throw those legs over my uh thigh. And I reach in above the knees and I come in and I lock it just like this. The reason I want to do that is as I lean back, I'm gonna lose some of that. And when I turn my body in the direction that I'm gonna start moving, I'm also gonna lose some of that, especially if they're slippery. So basically, you're buying yourself some real estate right from the beginning so that as you continue to go, you're not starting from the ankles and losing it.

SPEAKER_03No movement. Right, you know, nothing to lose, nothing to lose, right? So, and that twist also when you do that twist, it kind of pops up their pelvis a little bit and uh throws them on their shoulder, so you have less surface tension.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I was gonna say it gives actually a the possibility of moving easier.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, so that would be it. Conditions, right? That that drives it, leg drag or any other dirty drag, and then how I do the leg drag, what else am I missing? Something else, right?

SPEAKER_01Oh, you got conditions. You said distance determines you know if you're gonna do a quick dirty drag or not. Yeah. I don't know if you want to talk about your route of exit, like depending on we could we could do that.

SPEAKER_03So basically, what I consider is is where I'm about to take them worse than where I'm currently at. Meaning, if I find them in this room and I I opt to drag them out of it and down the hallway, do I pass a fire compartment? Right? Do I pass the host team, dragging them over all the embers and all that other stuff versus like in the room that I'm currently in? That has to make a difference for you. Right? Often we want to go back the way we came because it's natural and it feels easy.

SPEAKER_01And we also know the route. Yes.

SPEAKER_03And we know the route, but that's not always the best route. Right. And if we do these things correctly, right? We're in this room. Even if we find someone in the hallway and we drag them into a room, we isolate, we open the window, we start getting the lift. Sheltering in place is a good option. If we're not getting the conditions that we need, right? But where I was about to take them is far worse than where I'm currently at. We'll just wait for a minute and let that thing lift.

SPEAKER_01Especially with the isolation. Like you said, when you can isolate it, man.

SPEAKER_03They're already in the best spot they could be right there, which is closest to the ground, which is where the most fresh air is going to be, regardless, right? So when we look at that window, right?

SPEAKER_01So But it is counterintuitive to everything I was trained in my career. Hopefully, people are getting trained better than not my early career and coming out of the 90s. But it's always you went in and you came out the way you went in, usually dragging a hose and following a hose, you know.

SPEAKER_03And and so you know, like total, total like caveat to this. Sometimes that is a good solution. Let's flip that for a second. I'm in a bedroom, I didn't get to window to isolate or to uh ventilate yet. Smoke conditions aren't that good, but fire attack's making an awesome hit on the fire and condition that hallway. I've now had gas contraction and I get some lift out the front door. If I peek down there and the conditions down the hallway are far better than the room I'm in, I'm gonna go down that hallway, even if it takes me three times as long because I'm keeping the airway low where the freshest air is, generally in that like one foot space.

SPEAKER_01No, and I love it because it really does melt down to conditions. Like you let off with it, and that is the the most important conditions determine the tactics, and it's conditions for the victim, because we can tolerate a lot more with our SCBA and our space gloves and our and uh the Romagas papers touches on this immensely. And you said it best if we can't see, they can't breathe, and that's uh I credit Brian Crush with that one.

SPEAKER_03I don't know if that is brain crush, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Brain crush, ooh, even more.

SPEAKER_03Hey, I wanna I'm gonna put this up here. Hopefully, everyone can see it right there. Okay, that's what we're after. Can you see it?

SPEAKER_01And it says for those listening later, search fast and rescue low.

SPEAKER_03Okay, so that's that's the ultimate goal right there, and whatever we're trying to do here. And who made that sticker? I saw I saw something at the bottom there. Training dot fsri.org. Right on.

SPEAKER_01Fsri.org slash weekly scrap. Okay.

SPEAKER_03Fire rescue academy. Get to it.

SPEAKER_01It's got free free resources. Okay. Uh sorry. Firefighter nobody wants to know. Question, sir. Thoughts on rescue/slash drag straps, webbing loop, fancy high-end GI Joe strap thing, etc. I like your I like your answer already.

SPEAKER_03Sorry, I'm hiding my laughter. Um I'm I'm not laughing because I'm not laughing because I think webbing is dumb. Okay. I I'm laughing because I I often hear, well, why not just use webbing? Why all this other stuff? I think as one, as educators, and two as people in the fire service, we we need to understand our techniques and and when to use them, when not to use them, and what that means for us and victims. Okay. There is absolutely a time where you're going to need some type of rescue strap.

SPEAKER_03Having said that, what we don't need is a fancy like nine-point harness. Okay. Nobody's going to be able to do that in those conditions like they do under no stress in an apparatus bay when things look all cool, fancy, because you're making a video for YouTube. Okay.

SPEAKER_01And you do you get you get eight takes because the first seven you'd you screwed it up when you had full vision and you weren't wearing your gloves, right?

SPEAKER_03Correct. Like we've got to understand like a few things. One, victims have been in there longer than we've been dispatched, so their exposure time is is likely high. So when we do fancy things like that, we're just adding to that exposure time when we should be moving to an exit. We can do a lot of that with dirty drags. However, large victims may not always move the way you need to with a dirty drag. You may need some help with some leverage. I get that. People in bathtubs may not always move out of those the way that we we traditionally train.

SPEAKER_03So plan B would be like some type of webbing strap so that we can girth hitch around the torso, throw that loop out to our partner that's that's in there. One pull person pull, the other one push, so that we're actually like making some leverage. Windows, let's talk about that. Not every window you encounter is one going to be the size that you need to get someone out, but two, which I feel is is really important, 36 inches, which is typical of our of our structure.

SPEAKER_03Residential structure around here, anyways. Sure. Happens when you have a a 42 or a 48-inch sill.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_03And all we've ever told you was drag them to the window, prep them up in this nice little tight ball, and do this cool lift. It works great because the uh the window sill at 36 inches creates a pivot point for that torso to fall over. Now you don't have that, so you're basically trying to stand them straight up. What are you going to do at this point to get them out?

SPEAKER_04Oh, that's right.

SPEAKER_03That goes back to the hole, hey, this is likely more manpower, right? I probably want somebody on the outside of that window to help me. And then I am going to have to most likely turn the victim so that their head is facing the window, not their feet. Wrap them with a girth hitch, right? Hand that loop out to the window. I grab underneath here. My other firefighter grabs the same thing. We we we pull tight as that person's pulling on that piece of weapon we just gave them, and we're lifting and we're delivering the torso out that way.

SPEAKER_03Again, you're creating like a fulcrum, right?

SPEAKER_01Right on their hips. That's what you need. So, long story short, it's hard to prescribe tactics using using hand motions and I know. That's why hot is so much better than a podcast, but it but you do a great job of it, brother. You do a fantastic.

SPEAKER_03I feel like I need like puppets on my hands or something. Anyway, um, the reality is there there is a time and place for that, including patient movers, i.e., like rescue tarps, things like that, where that has handles that we might need to roll them on and slide them. Okay. Don't discount all of those. I would say get really good at your hands and learning what weight is too much for you when you're gonna need more help, you know, and work through that progression. Because needing more help also means that it's not just you and me doing this.

SPEAKER_03We need to call for help early, right? If we feel like we have a large victim or for whatever reason this removal's just kicking our ass, call for another team.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_03We have to do that.

SPEAKER_01Um, and we need to train on that. That goes back to the the the whole thing of training for failure and all that stuff, too. Yeah, absolutely.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, but I mean, in that same context, right? Webbing, maybe it's plan B, maybe it's plan Z. Who knows? But I would highly encourage someone to have a a piece of it on them that's like, I don't know, I use like 10 foot looped or 20 foot looped, right? That's what I tend to use. Because it just needs to be quick, down and dirty. Wrap them and go. Also understand though, we've created something constricting across the torso.

SPEAKER_03So the longer you yank on this or pull around corners, we tend to crush that torso area. It's a lot of weight that we're not feeling that we're just pulling on. Right. So it can get problematic if we're doing this for long distance.

SPEAKER_01Kyle Piv following up on this question, this specifically on the tactic you're talking about, especially on the height of the window. He goes, at what point do you think uh window conversion when you start thinking that might be a better option?

SPEAKER_03And again, I I love window conversions if building construction allows for it. Here's the thing we teach them, oh, quick, zip zip down, but we often forget like how old are the buildings in your area? Okay, some buildings still have like galvanized pipe going through it, you know, for radiators or or whatever. You go do a window cut down on a building that still has galvanized pipe running through it, you're gonna run your chain off and you're not gonna get a cut, right?

SPEAKER_03So you get a lot of sparks. You get a lot of sparks. So I'm a huge fan. And honestly, going back to like the whole like shelter in place, like if you have a large victim or whatever, and you're just getting your ass kicked, and you have the ability because building construction allows for you to do it, absolutely do that as soon as possible. And your truck cruise train on it or your your engine cruise for that matter, but your truck cruise typically man, make it happen, make it happen, but also I would I would encourage people to to understand when you do that, do a full cut, don't just stop at the floor, like cut so that you can flap this thing out.

SPEAKER_03A lot we we tend to cut and stop too early, right? Which kind of becomes a little problem.

SPEAKER_01Like Sean said, know your area because not just the old. I mean, we have tons, like Oklahoma, we're a clay bed, so acne brick is like located here somewhere. Everything, even low-income housing, has brick veneer at least, you know. And veneer, you can rip it down, but it's a lot lengthier process than zip zip pulled it out. And so you got to know your construction, even like yeah, I said, if it's sighting and stud construction, then go for it. Uh, Montreal Fred says, Do you think it would be beneficial to teach split search before VES or simultaneously?

SPEAKER_01By the way, your class of searchable versus survival at FDIC was great.

SPEAKER_03Oh, well, thank you for that.

SPEAKER_01Um that's how you get that's how you get moved to the top of the line and compliment the guests, by the way, everybody.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah, just go right to the top. Um my opinion, I I don't know that one is more important than the other, but I would say that if if your fire department is more likely to do search through a front door, I would definitely stick with teaching a split style search and what that looks like for you, because it's gonna correlate to a VES, especially if we dump two two people in, right? Because if the first person in is identifying the door and they're going in and they're assessing conditions in the hall and they're isolating through all that, like a search is still happening in that room.

SPEAKER_03And then if we assume that conditions warrant us to be able to push further, we're just gonna transition right into that, right? Which is where another split search technique is gonna come in. Hey, I'll take this room, you take that room, like we're good. Um, so I would say if you had to pick one to start on and start pushing maybe a search culture or mindset, uh, I I would say split search is good. It's it's our highest percentage of searches that that you know we do. I think it's like 38% of our searches per the survey was a split search.

SPEAKER_03So I mean it's it and it's got a significant uh survival rate. I want to, I don't again, I don't have the numbers, but I want to say it's like 67, something like that. Um so you know, you pair those together. That's what I would do if I had to make it right on, dude.

SPEAKER_01I love that. I love the question, like again, such phenomenal questions. And I'm uh and of course, Sean uh excels at absolutely crushing the answers. Uh some good ones coming, some good ones coming. Uh, can you talk about what we should be telling? This is Jennifer Williams. You may know her, you may know her, my friend and yours. Can you talk about what we should be telling the public to get them to be behind closed doors when we get there versus in the hallway or unconscious somewhere else in the house?

SPEAKER_03Oh man, I love you for asking this question because this is a pet peeve of mine. All right, so I'm gonna I'm gonna start off by saying this. To this day, we have those educational bounce houses, you know, those blow-up houses we put out there. To this day, it still says that the number one thing you should do if your house is on fire is go to the door and open the door, crawl below the smoke, and get to the front door. Number two, out the window. Why are we going to fire education and telling people close your door?

SPEAKER_03It's gonna save your life. You have reduction in temperature, increase in oxygen, you know, decrease in toxic gases, all that stuff. We're telling this to children every October. That's what we do. Right. And in that same sentence, we're like, yeah, man, just open your door and crawl out in the yard with somebody. It's crazy to me. So now I lost my my train of thought. Um, what was her question? Repeat that so I can answer it directly. Can you talk about what we should be telling the public? Yes.

SPEAKER_03Well, we should be telling the public about closed doors. Okay. What we should be telling the public is about again. If you had the choice to choose between, I don't know, a thousand degrees and and you know, like a hundred, what would you choose? Right.

SPEAKER_01No brainer.

SPEAKER_03Okay, no brainer, right? We're gonna choose a 900 degree decrease in temperature. Okay, you're breathing 21% oxygen right now. If you had your choice to to breathe 8% or 18, which would you choose? Right on.

SPEAKER_01Well, again, no brainer.

SPEAKER_03So those are the things we need to tell them of why this matters. We need to tell that to the adults and the children because if your children are like mine, when I first told them this, like, hey, we're doing this because you know, if our house caught on fire, they freaked out. They were like, Oh my god, our house is gonna catch on fire. It's like, no, no, no, no. Like, I want you to be safe. But we also need to do a good job to say, if you do this, we are coming for you. I know exactly where we're gonna find you, right?

SPEAKER_03If you're behind a closed door, I can come through your window and I can get you, and you have a longer chance, right? Because behind this closed door gives like 20-ish minutes of protection before we start getting burnt through. So I'm buying you time. You are buying yourself time just by listening to the message, right? And I think we're seeing an increase in that, but I I think too, we have to have a realist conversation, and this might not be necessarily geared towards children, but definitely the public.

SPEAKER_03If I could say that 28% of our rescues have been made by closed doors, right? People have listened, they close the doors. 28% of the time, we're finding victims behind closed doors with an 86% survival rate. Should there be a fire inside of your home, you are very likely to survive if you just close your damn door. You know? Yeah. And then I get that things like, oh, well, what about my cats? They'll just claw out my door all the time and do this.

SPEAKER_03And I was like, oh my goodness, okay. Let's just keep the message to what the message is. This is what we know about closed doors. You make the decision you want to make. I'm telling you, if I had to choose right now, my house is on fire behind beyond that door is floor to ceiling fire. If you're telling me that I could still survive that, I'm gonna do what you do.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, it's again, no-brainer when you actually look at the data and and what's going on. Uh, Jason coming at you, I believe from Florida. I could be wrong. Sean, your thoughts on a search size up prior to making entry and its importance for orientation.

SPEAKER_03I so I kind of touched on that a little bit in the in the beginning. I think it's very important, right? Our eyes as humans track towards movement and light. That's why we get so focused on the fire every time. Every time. And we we lose sight of actually what's happening. So search eyes, search size up. Man, if your fireman's in the back seat and I know the address, guess what I'm doing? I'm looking on Zillow or something else like that, and I'm getting a basic layout because most of those have pictures of what the interior look like.

SPEAKER_03So I'm looking at those. Okay, to the left is the stairs, boom, boom, boom, whatever. I'm taking those quick snapshots, and then I'm marrying that up with what I see on scene. Okay, 20, 20 feet long, you know, 20 feet wide, you know, 10, 15 feet long. Okay, I've got two, three bedrooms, they're 10 by 10, 10 by 12, whatever. Okay, where's my fire? I know where it's been, I know where it's at. I'm looking at where it's projected to go and where are my searchable spaces that I need to prioritize right now.

SPEAKER_03Then I get in, and because I've married that with, you know, what I looked at in the truck, or maybe familiarize myself with the floor plans in my area. Sure. Maybe I've been to that house before, whatever the situation is, I'm starting to navigate those spaces. Right? Bedrooms to the left, I'm starting to feel okay, that's a bed. Now I know kind of where I'm at. I also know that when I come out of this room, if I hang to the left, like it goes to this room. And you know, paying attention to like not all the time, but sometimes like the floor coverings, right?

SPEAKER_03So does it go from carpet to wood, wood to tile, things like that? Like now I'm in a different space. Right. So just basically, if I had to just throw it out there without going on a tangent, I would say that every bit of information that we get, we need to be analyzing, including during our search with our hands.

SPEAKER_01Right on.

SPEAKER_03Feeling what's this that I feel like, right? Where's my orientation at and things like that? So hopefully that answers his question.

SPEAKER_01No, it's a good question and a good answer, especially with the resources available uh in route uh that that are that are available, not to mention pre-incident planning to familiarize yourself with the size up. You could have pre-incidented your size up and be so far ahead of the game if you take advantage of those medical calls in your district. And uh yeah, absolutely. So I'll try not to be on a tangent. Uh Kaylee Rose coming at you from Michigan, I believe. Any insight on how to how to work with those creating approving curriculums to get this data and training into fire academies.

SPEAKER_01So firefighters are learning this from the start. And she went on to say that uh one of the things she said, we're still being told to teach search in a fire academy is hands and knees, hold partner's foot hand, and don't leave the wall. You know, the old human centipede.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. So I get this all the time when we do hands-on classes, right? Um, and and I try and be like break it down. So I'm like, okay, YouTube, do the search the way you told me to do it, or that you were taught to do it. And I time it and I film it. One of the other things I like to do if I if I have the time is get like baby powder or like uh flower or something thrown on the ground so they can actually see how ineffective their search pattern was. And then we put that all together and we're saying, hey, okay.

SPEAKER_03So now we're gonna do it again and we're gonna branch it off and we're gonna see just how much space we can cover, keeping the same communication.

SPEAKER_02Right.

SPEAKER_03Right. Basically, what what our goal is is is not to have an argument of this is right, that's wrong. It's to to answer the question, why? Why were you taught that?

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_03Okay, so when we take somebody, and and this is basically what we have to do for the people writing curriculum and hope they listen.

SPEAKER_02Right.

SPEAKER_03Because sometimes it just takes like common sense, I hate to say it, to show them like we're we're past this. Maybe at the time that we did this, our gear wasn't good as good, our communication, our ability to talk wasn't as good. So this is what we had to do. But now, 2026, our gear is fantastic, our search communication is incredible. We have devices that can help us navigate spaces, like we have a lot more than what we used to, right? So getting the buy-in from them to show them like, okay, 27-pound air pack on average, and you want to crawl around on your hands and knees.

SPEAKER_03When are you looking up? You're not. Never because it physically hurts you to do so. So you're not really situationally aware to your surroundings because you're looking down at the floor. Then we'd say, Hey, have your partner hold your boot. What are they searching?

SPEAKER_01No, the sole of your boot, yeah.

SPEAKER_03Because they're out here like this, like half-assed sweeping with their tool, and then their arm gets tired, and they eventually just start dragging it, and their other hand, which could be used for searching, is attached to you.

SPEAKER_01Right. No, it's it, yeah.

SPEAKER_03No, it's it's just, you know, and then what happens when you find a hole? You're going straight through it because all that weight is forward instead of centered to where I can rock back, right? So when we can show those things and then break it down and say, watch me do the same exact thing by changing my stance, by spreading out, still maintaining orientation with my wall, and I'm getting you know my situational awareness better. So as we start opening spots or fire attack makes uh hit on this fire, and I I can actually see what's happening and you just break it down, right?

SPEAKER_03Unfortunately, the conversation itself isn't enough. You've got to let them like physically feel it, put the gear on, do the drill. You have to. No, without a guess. If you can't really you know what I'm saying, if you can't relate to it, it doesn't make a difference, right? So having said all that, I think we're we're all having challenges trying to get the people who write the manuals to to change things. We're also having challenges because we say stupid stuff like, Hey, I'm gonna teach you what the book says, because I that's what you need to do to pass the test.

SPEAKER_03Right. And then I'm gonna show you the real way. The real way there should be there should be no way to pass a test. The way you do it to pass a test is the real way. Right.

SPEAKER_01No, right. There's a lot of there's a lot of and because compounding the problem is there's 50 states. Usually each one of them has a state fire academy or or or or there's probably a hundred regional fire academies across the country. Each one has their own way of doing it that answers to a different entity that has a different stakeholders that are involved in what curriculum is passing. Uh, you got a few inner, you know, between Ista, Jones, and Bartlett, and I don't know what else is out there now, but writing the curriculum, and that's such a slow moving, but anyway, anyway.

SPEAKER_03It is, but I I honestly think we're doing good.

SPEAKER_01I agree. I think we're I think the pendulum, I mean, it's it's a giant aircraft carrier we're turning, but it's turning.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. Tiny rudder, big ship, right?

SPEAKER_01I would say that the human centipede, like what Kaylee experiences, is the outlier now instead of the norm. I think that I I feel that way. I don't know if that's actually true.

SPEAKER_03I think most people get the idea. I think there's enough search stuff out there now, and people hopefully have taking enough programs to to kind of get the idea. Unfortunately, if the state or whoever doesn't change the way they want to do things because they're they want to be ignorant, they don't want to listen, whatever, there's there's not much we're gonna be able to do, which is why I say it gets confusing. Because now you have to show two ways instead of one.

SPEAKER_02Right.

SPEAKER_03However, we've made tremendous progress with NFPA 1700, right?

SPEAKER_01We we've got a lot of the new build, the new, the new the new uh standards are yeah. I mean, I just can train off of them. You can train off of them now instead of yeah, yeah, you can.

SPEAKER_03And I've had people reach out to me, like, hey, I'm sitting on this uh this committee for IFsta and we're doing the search chapter. I'd like your opinion on this. And I give them the information that's out there. Here's a firefighter rescue survey, here's what FSRI has done, you know, here's all of these things, all of these need to be evaluated. And and hopefully those people are are able to get that information into the right hands and have the conversations that need to be had and and change that.

SPEAKER_03And uh, you know, maybe in 10 years or so we'll see the books look different, you know, but part of that is on us too for not trying to get on these committees.

SPEAKER_01So no, 100%. And and we are our own worst enemies at times, and we like to bitch more than we like to take action and fix. So yeah, and so absolutely. Okay, I've uh I'll sit here and talk to you all night. You know this. But I'm gonna I'm gonna do a couple more questions and then we'll get to the we'll we'll wrap we'll we'll get to booker books and then we'll wrap up. But the and and I'll be honest with you, Sean. We got to one of your topics. You fitted in another one talking about policy, and there's still probably two dozen questions on the on the list. But uh I'm going with Kevin Kate coming at you.

SPEAKER_01Actually, I'm gonna go with Ben Jones first. I'm gonna go with Ben Jones first, and I'll close out with Kevin Cates because there's a lot of hype around this question. And uh I'm I'm very interested in it too. But Ben Jones had a great one and I liked it. It's a there's a story from World War II about analyzing airplanes that came back with the bullet holes. Uh, I believe the it's called survivorship bias, I think is the is the fallacy. But basically they were armor armoring up the wrong spots, and they looked at it and said, we need to armor the spots where the holes aren't because those are the ones that are coming back. And so, all that being said, if you understand for survivorship bias, he has a great question.

SPEAKER_01He goes, Is there a similar possibility that may exist with the fire rescue survey? Are we missing valuable info by only studying successful removals? Do we need to somehow study fire deaths and missed rescues? So I want to address that because I don't, I'm not sure. Yeah, but go ahead.

SPEAKER_03I'll do the best I can. Full disclosure, I am not on the survey team.

SPEAKER_02Right on.

SPEAKER_03So I am just a uh a person who believes strongly in in what they do, and I want to share that message. Part of that is to understand that like we can only go off of the information we're given, which is obviously all voluntary. So yes, we are missing a large portion of data. Um, I do think that some of the questions are are kind of geared towards that when we ask, like, how long did it take you to find them? Did you do left hand, right hand? Did you go out a window? Did you go out a door? Did you do this? And we match survival versus non-survival.

SPEAKER_03I do think it would be worth maybe possibly diving into having some questions on um, you know, was the victim originally missed? But I do also think that that is kind of covered in how was the victim found? Primary search, secondary search, right? If I didn't find the victim on the primary and we found him on the secondary, it's implied that that victim was probably missed. I I gotta be careful how I answer that question because I said I'm not on the survey team.

SPEAKER_03I I think that um, you know, if if you there's something you want to see that maybe we're not addressing or they're not addressing, I should say, shoot them a message.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, they're 100% wide open. They're all open to it. And I love that question. And one thing I will add to it, because as I understand it, and they do a lot of follow-up research on on the firefighter rescue survey, they usually follow up, and and I believe, I know they've tried to always follow up a to vet, because I know uh there was a time when people were actually trying to submit fake reports to see if you could just fill one out and and prove that it was BS. And they were like, why are you doing this? You know, and and getting called out on it. So that's that's that's one. Second one is I'm uh not every victim survives.

SPEAKER_01Like they the the grabs it are voluntary, first of all. So if you make the grab, man, write it down. If they pass, if they you know the the final outcome of the victim is not the thing, is all not the only thing being measured. I think there are quite a few that are I don't know, I don't I don't want to speak for the survey, but that did not make it. And they find that stuff out and they follow it up. But yeah, the survey is filled out simply if they made the grab.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, and and to be fair, survival, just so we're clear, a rescue is defined as like I physically removed somebody from a place that they could not remove themselves. They could not remove themselves. That's the rescue, right? Because we had to intervene. The second part of that is the the survival is actually when we count that out, those are people that left the hospital and are still living, right? So when we start matching that out, I think we are doing fun or they're doing phenomenal catching some of that data.

SPEAKER_03Um, could there always be more? Yeah, there could always be more. Right. Could those numbers look different, you know, in a few years? Yes, they can. That's why we said more analysis is always needed.

SPEAKER_01And they have changed, they have changed since the first 1000. They have, yeah. And they've also shown trends, they've also shown very strong trends.

SPEAKER_03But yeah, and that's that's a great question.

SPEAKER_01No, it was a phenomenal question. So, and it's the kind of question we need to always keep asking to keep our data relevant. Um, all right, final question. And it's Kevin Kate's final question. He actually led off by saying my final question, and then I'll shut up. I'd Doubt it. Where are you? Where are you and others in your fight against Tito? Is that still ongoing from your end? On the two in, two out. Where are you at?

SPEAKER_03You know, I get this question asked quite a bit. And um, I wish Nick was on here with me uh because he he was he actually went in and and did the you know the question that they asked, you know, who wants to come in and talk. And he actually got in on the meeting and and addressed some concerns. Having said that, um I've heard nothing. Uh I'm not sure if anybody else has heard anything either. I think there was enough uproar about it to maybe like everyone say, hey, pump the brakes on this for a second.

SPEAKER_03Let's kind of see what's going on. Um, you know, if if anybody's got more information on it, I'd love to hear it. I've I've tried to look, I haven't really found much. It seems to kind of still be in limbo. But that doesn't mean that we stop fighting for what's right.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_03You know, I think I think we still need to be loud and you know, not aggressive, but we need to to kind of voice our concerns with this stuff and and let everybody know that this is not an attack, right? It's not an attack on anybody, any certain organization. It's just we have to do what's right by by the people that that basically trust us to make decisions when they can, right? Otherwise, the fire department wouldn't exist. Right on.

SPEAKER_03And when we know that things are not necessarily what they seem or what we've been told to be, and we've got a lot of information to support that, it's our job as as firefighters and and a fire service to to kind of stand up against, I don't want to say agendas, because that sounds pretty, pretty wrong. Um, but it's our job to stand up for for what we know is is not necessarily true. And what we know is not necessarily true is that firefighters aren't dying like we're being told.

SPEAKER_02Right.

SPEAKER_03Okay. What we know is true is that the longer we wait to put people in the building to solve the problems to to everybody, that's that's where we find ourselves in trouble as firefighters. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I love it. I love it. Bill Carey, data, not drama, boom. I'll just put the plug out.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. So that's it. I'm not gonna go any further on that because we could go on with that forever. But to answer Kevin's question, uh it seems to be kind of at a standstill.

SPEAKER_01And I will say this, because this has come up kind of twice. I almost mentioned it earlier when you were talking about uh you were answering the question, how do we get here on search losing its priority, you know? And you said because someone didn't stand up and say something, that's why, you know, all across you know, as as a service. And and it's a great thing because I think Edmund Burke, Edward Burke, his quote is the all it takes for the triumph, I don't butcher the quote, but all it takes for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing, right? And then and I think that absolutely applies, and it's not necessarily evil, but all it takes for complacency to win is for good men to do nothing.

SPEAKER_01Those who know better to just not speak up, and so yeah.

SPEAKER_03No, go ahead.

SPEAKER_01You're no, no, no, that was it. That was the point that I I was gonna make earlier on the search point, but then it came back up again, and I'm like, no, this needs to be said.

SPEAKER_03I'll just say this real quick because I know we got to move on, but um, you know, the ideology of just put the fire out and everything gets better, you know, the best thing we can do for the victims to put the fire out, that that's a little flawed. Um, I don't disagree. We have to get that line in play as quickly as possible, and we have to start taking care of the threat to everybody. But if we don't ever put people in buildings to get them out, they're gonna die 100% of the time. If I don't ever put an ounce of water on a fire, it'll burn itself out.

SPEAKER_03Okay. So we we have to kind of like look at that and realize that people take that that that verbiage and they're like, oh well, I put water on the fire, so I'm doing good for civilians. No, you're not because they're still in the building, and although you're hitting the fire, they're still in a toxic environment. So the longer they're in there, the more likely they are to succumb to that, right? No, I love it. We we can't just spray water and say, Well, I took care of the fire, so I'm saving people.

SPEAKER_03Saving people, like that's only one part of it. The the full like cycle of this is I'm taking care of the fire, and the moment that I possibly can, not 10 minutes later, not 15 minutes later, the the moment I can, as close to simultaneously as possible, I'm putting more firefighters in that building and get those people up.

SPEAKER_01Right on. Right on. Hey, like I said, just preach. Preach, Mr. Secretary. Yeah, I love it. Okay. We uh book or books. You think firefighters should be reading? Oh man, phenomenal questions, everyone. I wish we could talk. I I would keep he's East Coast, I would keep him up all night long and make him keep on talking. But we we got I got nowhere to be tomorrow.

SPEAKER_03I'll I'll talk as long as you want. I'm respecting your time. Book or books. So I recently went through a promotional process. This book is probably not one that uh you know you haven't heard before, but extreme ownership right there. Um, not not a book for for everybody. I know a lot of people, it's not their type of read. However, a lot of valuable lessons in this book.

SPEAKER_01I like the principles in that book a lot.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, for life in general. Yes. Take the fire service out of it, take it all out of it. Just your life in general. This book, I've read it like three times by now. I absolutely love this book.

SPEAKER_01No, I love Jocko. I'm a Jocko fan. I'm a huge fan of prioritize and execute, no bad teams, only bad leaders, all of it, all of it. The all the principles of no great, great, great book. All right, buddy. You've done this before. It's the five questions for firefighters. You only have one song on the list, so I'm anxious to see if you if you add to it or if you if you double down, but that's up to you. Here we go. You know the rules. There are no right answers, only your opinions. Are you ready for the five questions for firefighters? Yeah, man, I'll do my best. The bassist for social ruin.

SPEAKER_01Here you go. Number one, you have a time machine, but it can only be used for one thing. Go back in time, give young Sean Duffy one piece of advice. What would that advice be?

SPEAKER_03I think I'm gonna have to go back to kind of what I said in Rob Fisher's question. It's just don't lose yourself. You know, you were somebody before you got in the fire service, have hobbies, do things, be normal. Okay. Uh when we're when we're facing this mental health crisis in our job, um, there's a lot of reasons for that. But I also think it's if we have outlets, right, which we all had before we became firefighters, those would be important.

SPEAKER_03Play music, skateboard, surf. I don't care what it is. Do something, right? Um, just don't lose yourself because becoming a firefighter is the greatest, one of the greatest things you'll ever do. But we often get stuck in that, right? We're not on duty, we're still wearing fire department t-shirts. Everywhere we go, we're just a fireman, right? We've got tattoos on ourselves that are that are all about being firemen, which all that is fine. But be true to yourself and and don't lose that person that that you really are for the sake of just always being turned on.

SPEAKER_01Beautiful. Max points out the gate. Number two, it's job town. It's time. You are in route and responding. Think of the scene from backdraft. Last time it was the cruise kickstart my heart. But what's wrong? What song are you playing while in route?

SPEAKER_03Man, this is one of my favorite songs right now. Uh, I I play it like every day just because it amps me up. It's AFI, the checkered demon.

SPEAKER_01It is demon.

SPEAKER_03You know, just something about old school AFI punk music, just like it gets me going. So um I did like on repeat in my vehicle all the time.

SPEAKER_01Righteous, righteous. Well, it's now officially added to the playlist, and so now you've got two entries. You've got two entries. Two entries. I'm gonna have to check out the checkered demon. I probably know what I just have to go back and hear it because we'll have to check it out. Because what's their what's their they had their one hit that was like mainstream?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, the Miss May or whatever.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_03Miss Murder, I think it was or something.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, Miss Murder. That's it.

SPEAKER_03I didn't like it, so I didn't listen to it.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it was the mainstream one. Yeah, right. Your counterculture, buddy. Number three, number three, cold weekend at the station. Rig checks are done, training is done, PT is done, food is cooking, the town is being silent, like it's a lazy day at the station, but you're not being lazy, you've taken care of business. You're in the day room, clicking through those channels, and you see that movie. No matter where it's at in the movie, what's that movie? You always finish.

SPEAKER_03All right, I gotta I gotta put these on for this one. All right, hold on. Sandlot. I know where it's going. Sandlot. Yeah, look, just squints 2.0.

SPEAKER_01Squints. Uh yeah, max points for Sandlot, one of my favorites, one of the ones you can quote all the time. A great, great movie for Over. Uh, number four. Max points, by the way, three for three. What is what is the one habit that you believe separates average firefighters from exceptional firefighters?

SPEAKER_03Man, this is a weird one, but hear me out.

SPEAKER_01Okay, I'm intrigued.

SPEAKER_03Uh, I think setting boundaries is is super important. Like, not everybody should have access to you all the time. I think it's important for you to kind of like be in your own thoughts and process some things. And like, you know, whether you're in the gym and working out or you like you take a break throughout the day to go to your bunk and like read or just process or whatever, like you've got to protect yourself, you know. Um, limit the interruptions because those interruptions throughout your day could really like derail.

SPEAKER_03And if you're trying to stay disciplined or be on a regimen or or whatever that looks like for you, more interruptions, the easier it is to be like, yeah, I'm not just I'm not feeling this today. I'm not gonna do that today, right? So, you know, manage your stress and your cognitive load, make some make sure that you set some boundaries there and you uh you take care of yourself.

SPEAKER_01I'm processing. I'm processing. So I'm trying to think to myself, do the exceptional firefighters I know, you know, the ones that I've known throughout my career and through training and traveling, is that and I'm I'm I'm like, oh, that's actually something that they they do know how to set boundaries. That's uh that's actually I would not have like you said, this is a different one. This is intriguing. So yeah, I will give it max points, and I think I think it holds true. And I I would not have put that as a it's not a go-to, like oh, passion or or work ethic or something like that.

SPEAKER_03But I think it's very yeah, no, it's I think it holds. I like to go against the grain if you haven't noticed.

SPEAKER_01I might, yeah. Max points four for four. Here we go. Heavy fire, searchable space. You've had this question a few times. Would you rather be assigned to the nozzle or first in on VES?

SPEAKER_03Man, it's gonna be the same every time. Every time, first in on VES. And my my reasoning is is not gonna ever change. That puts me in a position to make the the greatest chance at rescue, which is the whole reason I got into the fire service was to rescue, right? I mean, that's that was like the whole like sexy draw to the fire department was like, oh, I get to go into burning buildings and pull people out, and like that's cool. I want to do that, and like being on the nozzle is cool, and and you know, I I love doing that too.

SPEAKER_03But if I had to choose, it's always gonna be take that window, dump into that space, and if they're in there, get them the hell out.

SPEAKER_01Right on, man. Right on, and it's never changed. I don't expect it. You teach searchable versus survivable, and I don't expect it to ever change. So there you go. Sean Duffy, I don't know if you've ever not gotten max points. I would have to go back and check the tape, but I can't I can't imagine that occurring. But that officially, with those answers, puts 375 scraps in the books, which blows my mind, I'll be honest with you. That's crazy, isn't it? Yeah, yeah, you were number 58, the original-eight.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, that's oh go back in time. And here's the best part there was a lot of questions still to ask you, but the best part is I can have you back anytime now because I don't have to buy a jacket, right? The jacket's done. Yeah, so jacket's done. I have to be careful who I have on right here, right? I have to be careful who I have on because if they hit five, I gotta get them a jacket. Yeah, yeah. I want it to be exclusive. Uh, all right, housekeeping. Oh, wait, somebody wants to get a hold of you. Let's start there. Somebody wants to get a hold of you. Uh, and also plug Great Lakes Hot.

SPEAKER_01Uh, do those two things. Go ahead.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah. So Great Lakes Hot this year. I'll start with that. This is uh June 16th through the 19th of 27. Um, we moved to a new location. We're we moved to Grand Rapids. Um, just logistical stuff, I think it's gonna be a great thing. We have a uh live nation venue that we're using now, so um plenty of space for people, which was a challenge for us, right? I hate saying no, and we were just at a spot where like I just couldn't tell everyone yes. So hopefully it works out. If if you've been before, make the trip to Grand Rapids.

SPEAKER_03I I think it's gonna be uh an incredible year and a very, very different vibe. Um, those that were there last year, we did a concert at the end. This year we're doing it in the front uh on the first day, so that everybody who's coming in can can enjoy that and doesn't have to you know rush to get home. So obviously punk rock music. So if that's not your thing, I'm sorry. But uh it'll be a lot of fun. Just come and hang out.

SPEAKER_01Social ruins we'll be playing. Social ruins.

SPEAKER_03So yeah, yeah, we're gonna be opening up the show. So if you want to see me make a fool of myself, come uh come watch my band. All right. It's gonna be a good time. Uh, so that's it. More details to come on Great Lakes Hot. We're finalizing some things this week and we'll be pushing out registration probably second, third week of October, and we're gonna be announcing all the classes, you know, throughout the week. So lots of work to do there, but I'm getting excited for it. Um, if you want to get a hold of me, full disclosure, uh, I'm trying to be better about not always being by my phone or attached to a computer just for my sanity.

SPEAKER_03So um you can email me info at buildyourculture.org. You can find me on Facebook, Instagram, things like that. Or if you go to buildyourculture.org, you can get the phone number and uh you can call me or shoot me a text. Um, I will answer you when I can, right?

SPEAKER_01If it's something that you how dare you try to set boundaries, set boundaries, right?

SPEAKER_03I told you you have to set boundaries. So uh I'm terrible about emailing. I often like mean to get back to it and I don't. So if you need just give me a little bump. You're like, hey, dude, I emailed you two weeks ago, and you know, that'll kind of remind me. So it'll buy you another week.

SPEAKER_02That's how you get a hold of me.

SPEAKER_01Buy you another two weeks.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Two weeks. Perfect. All right, housekeeping for me. Go to patreon.com slash the vigilantes. Best part is the after party where we go and we roast the guest. Sean Duffy is invited to come be roasted, so we'll see how that goes. Next week, you coming up on the scrap, it's the White Whale. Seriously, like the legend that I've been trying to get on the show basically for 375 episodes, and finally agreed to come. Chasing for years, Kevin Shea is coming on the scrap, so you don't want to miss it.

SPEAKER_01And uh two weeks from tonight, Jenny Grema. So you want to show up, bring your questions. So man, 2026 has been out of this world and it continues to be so. Enough jabbering for me. Let us get to the after party. Sean Duffy, thank you for sharing your evening with us, your your passion. Uh, every time I have a conversation with you, it's awesome. I love it. So thank you.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, thanks for having me on. This is probably one of my favorite things to do. So uh I appreciate you giving me that opportunity.

SPEAKER_01Dude, it means the world to me. And the guests, of course, I cannot say this enough. You guys bring the questions each and every week. I say it each and every week, but you guys bring it and you set the guests up for success. You set the show up for success by being here. The show wouldn't exist without you. I love you all. Remember, mutts don't scrap. I hope the tone stays silent unless it is burning. This job is not safe. So stay smart out there.

SPEAKER_00Thanks for listening to the weekly scrap. Please subscribe and please share. We'll see you at the next episode.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Weekly Scrap #383 – The Elm Street Fire: 20 Years Later!

    Nov 18, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    Episode 383 of The Weekly Scrap takes us back 20 years to a tragic Thanksgiving night in Atlanta, Georgia, and a line-of-duty death that continues to offer critical lessons for the fire service. Joining me this week are...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Weekly Scrap #382 – LIVE from Pensacola Beach: An All-Star Instructor Lineup!

    Nov 11, 20262 hrAudio

    Episode 382 came to you LIVE from Pensacola Beach, Florida! The SCRAP went to the beach during IHROC, with a rotating lineup of instructors joining me throughout the show! 📅 Tuesday, November 10th 📍 Hilton Hotel |...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Weekly Scrap #381 – Blake Stinnett: Next Rung - Five Years Later

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    Blake Stinnett is coming BACK on the SCRAP! It's been FIVE YEARS since Blake joined me for Episode 95, and a LOT has happened since our last conversation and I can't wait to get into it. Blake is the founder of Next...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Weekly Scrap #380 – Mike Dugan: A Lifetime of Lessons

    Oct 28, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    I'm fired up to have THE Mike Dugan on the SCRAP! Retired FDNY Captain on Ladder 123, longtime fire service instructor, one of the greatest storytellers in the fire service, and someone who has spent decades pushing...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Weekly Scrap #379 – Brent Brooks: High Rise Time-to-Task

    Oct 21, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    I'm excited to have Brent Brooks back on the SCRAP! Brent joined me for Episode 220, and here we are almost three years later, getting ready to do it again! Brent brings more than 30 years of fire service experience,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode