
Q2 2026 Trade and GDP numbers plus Earnings
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/the-way-i-see-it--5905056/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/the-way-i-see-it--5905056/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Speaker 1Thank you.
Speaker 2Hey, a very, very warm welcome to you all joining me today. My name is Kalu Aja. Welcome to our weekly money space, that's what we call it. And of course, in our space, we are talking money, we are talking the economy, we are talking personal finance. That's what we do here every week. We're live on Twitter, expert. We're also live on YouTube, so you can follow the link, which was my last post, I believe, on YouTube, because
Speaker 2we always like to do visuals. And we've got great visuals for you again this week. This week, we want to talk around the economy. And then we might delve into the Dangote offer, but not like the way, we're not going to talk about the IPO in terms of the fundamentals. But I want to sort of start to give you a bit of insight guard post or guardrails, how you should look at earnings and why earnings are very important when you take a look at offers like that. So we'll go there. But I want to just review
Speaker 2this last week, Nigeria published the 2026 quarter two GDP numbers. We had it for GDP. We also had it for trade and they were quite revealing. So I said it's going to be a good idea for us to just do an overview of those numbers and see what it's actually telling us. If you listen to the news, you'll have heard a lot of talk about the GDP has grown, agriculture has expanded and all that. What does it actually mean?
Speaker 2Are those true? Are those false? You see on the space here, we go a bit deeper. I want to basically look at the facts behind the figures. So that way we can give you an unbiased view, but also a view that allows you to do an analysis to become a better investor as it were. Again, guys, I'm going to speak about 15 minutes. If you want to then have a say, do request for the mic or send me a DM and I'll be sure to read them. So,
Speaker 2I mean, we've titled our session today. It's going to be Nigeria grew, right? but the market stayed quiet. You can see we're trying to link in the GDP with the trade. And then we'll try to see if we can have any linkages with these two and this massive Dangote IPO that is coming down the pipe. We're going to talk about Dangote in particular, I think, from next week. But we'll just try to see if we can talk about it now and see if there's any relationship within
Speaker 2the GDP of Nigeria. The trade starts for Nigeria. and then see where that takes us. So if you take a look at the first slide we're sharing with you, the numbers look fantastic. Real GDP, real basically means if you strip away inflation, was up 4.43, right? Up 4.43, not bad. Nominal GDP, about 111 trillion. Again, large numbers there. We had a trade surplus. A trade surplus is always good.
Speaker 2I mean, that's what Trump is fighting for, right? It basically means that we are exporting goods And we're earning more foreign exchange than we are importing. So on the surface, this is a fantastic trade report. Trade has gone up. GDP real growth is positive. We're no longer in a depression or recession. The economy is growing. And nominal GDP looks very, very good. Are there any bots? Are there any things in this report that should give us pause? Yes,
Speaker 2there are. And that's essentially what we want to go into detail and sort of analyze and see what we can learn and pick from this. Let's now look at the GDP numbers more in detail and just to reference them with what we had in prior quarters and, of course, in prior years. Again, the numbers, again, still look good here. If you compare 4.4% GDP that I just posted, quarter 2-26, It's better than when we posted the same quarter, i.e.,
Speaker 2quarter one. And it's also better than when we posted a year ago. If you look at nominal growth, nominal growth, this is just numbers, right? It's also better, 18% better than what we had nominal growth, should we say, the last numbers I'm looking at. When you look at half-year 2026 growth, then the you start to see some, okay, what's going on here? We're just going by, last half
Speaker 2year was 4.16. We've grown by 4.43. Not a lot of growth there. Nigeria wants to achieve a $ 1 trillion GDP number. So we've got to be growing at the minimum 5, 6, even 8 to achieve that number. This is a quarterly growth, right? It's a half year growth. We're only growing about 4%. To put it in perspective for you guys, right, the highest growth that we have achieved in Nigeria in terms of GDP from, say, 2015
Speaker 2till date, the highest growth we have achieved has not matched the lowest GDP growth Nigeria has achieved from, say, what's a good number, from, say, the year 2000 till the year 2014. So that puts it in perspective for you that we need to grow a bit faster. Even though this is positive growth of about 4%, we need to grow at double this to achieve our own stated goal of having a GDP number of 8%, right? So
Speaker 2it's a strong GDP print. We can't take that away. It's a strong GDP print, right? What about trade? If you look at the merchandise trade, it's a surplus. You are talking about $ 12 trillion. In merchandise surplus. Meaning like I said. We are exporting more than we are importing. So exports are up 18%. Imports are up 12%. Total trade about 41 trillion.
Speaker 1Surplus.
Speaker 2That's a 100% surplus. From quarter to 2025. So clear growth is happening. In that figure. Cash flow is improving. But this is the but. The composition of the trade. Nothing has changed. So again. whilst we are growing the raw numbers, almost 100% if you compare the surplus from Q2 2025, the actual composition of this trade has not changed. We like to talk about diversifying the economy, right? And
Speaker 2also diversifying revenue sources. That has not yet happened in trade. So those two numbers, the headlines tell us a very, very positive number. But when we start to drill down into the figures, We start to see a bit of shakes and balances there, which is what we want to really delve into. So, what grew in terms of GDP? What grew? For the first time in a long time in Nigeria, agriculture grew. Let me explain what that means.
Speaker 2There are three sectors that prop up the Nigerian economy. You have agriculture, you have trade, you have telecoms. This three combined would give you nearly, nearly 65% of Nigeria's GDP, i.e. the base. What makes up the Nigerian economy is agriculture, it's trade, it's telecom. Telecom has not disappointed Nigeria for a very long time. Since telecoms came in, it's always been positive. We might have a bump when we had
Speaker 2the issue about them increasing tariffs, but they've always delivered. This quarter, The telecoms live about 9%. This is material because when you have a large sector that is growing, it has a powerful effect on the GDP of the country. So telecom is large and telecom is growing 9%. That's the numbers we want to see. So that's why the GDP numbers are looking good. But what we want to applaud is the agricultural side of the economy. It's 26%
Speaker 2of Nigeria's GDP. And for the first time in a very, very long time, it grew 4.39. Massive growth, 4.39, right? So that's why you have that big showing of 4.43 because the largest sector in Nigeria, for the first time in a long time, grew. It had a very, very positive, not anemic GDP growth number. So that's what we're seeing. But look at where we now start to falter. Trade. And when you talk about trade, you're talking about your
Speaker 2mom and pop, your balogun, your onecha, import, export, that trade that Nigerians do, going back and forth, that didn't grow so well. That did not grow so well. Because when you are saying that agriculture is growing at about 4.39, then where do the farmers or what do the farmers do with those produce? They have to sell that produce, right? So I'm growing yams. That sector has grown by 4%. When I go to the market to sell that yam, it's only growing. I'm not giving antelope figures. It's only
Speaker 2growing by about 2.4%, right? So the shops are open, but nobody's buying because the households have very, very weak consumptions. And that's the story of Nigeria, right? Where before agriculture was not growing, now it's growing. But the trade side of the economy, the buying and selling of the household that has collapsed. And hence you see trade collapsing. This is local trade. Now domestic trade is 17% of GDP only growing by 2%. There's nothing busy happening there, right?
Speaker 2Look at industry also collapsing. it's only growing by about 3%. It's slowing down. So the industry conjunct growth is actually slowing down. So when you look at the large sector of the economy, those sectors should give Nigeria the growth because that's where the bulk of the population is employed. If you take a look at agriculture, right, that grew, the others are slowing down, most especially trade. And when you have trade slowing down, that's what you see. This guy is doing hustle. He's trading. He's buying this, selling this,
Speaker 2doing this contract. That woman is selling Mama Put. That's trade. And that figure is slowing down. So that's a worry for Nigeria. That, listen, the consumers are not buying, but we have agricultural output and all. So a big worry. So we have the positive there. Then we have that negative that has come because the industry is not buying. And then we then have this summary exactly that just shows us on this slide. It shows us what I'm talking about. what is growing what is not selling but
Speaker 2it's there in the market and what is falling what is actually falling if you look at the national economy you can sort of group nigeria into those three buckets what is growing what is not growing and what is falling and you now see reason why there's a lot of problems in the economy in consumption as we go along right so if you look at this slide what's growing agriculture like i said very important it's largest computer economy It's the largest employer of labor. It's growing by 4%. What else is growing? Construction is growing by 6%. It's
Speaker 2growing fast, but it doesn't employ a lot of people. I mean, is there construction happening in your state? Outside maybe Lagos and Abuja, maybe Rivers. Where else is construction happening at scale across the nation? So it's growing at 6%, but the contribution to the economy is a bit muted. Telecom's fantastic, 9% growth, and it's everywhere. Even in your village, there's a guy selling GSM recharge card. So you can see that once telecom is growing, the contributory base is large,
Speaker 2so it's also growing. Oil, yes, it's growing. It's at 1.72 million barrels a day, but it's still below our total budget output. And Nigeria was doing 2 million barrels per day casually in, say, 2025. So even though we are growing, we are growing from a lower base, we should be doing more if we want to hit that $ 1 trillion market size. So Nigeria has to do more in even these growth areas, right? Let's come to what's not growing. What's not growing? And we start to see some issues there. Again,
Speaker 2just also in the growing part, you have finance, banking and finance and insurance. That's one of the fastest growing in Nigerian economy. but very, very small contribution to the economy. So lots of bankers, lots of bank branches everywhere. Everywhere you go in Lagos is a bank branch, right? But their contribution to the economy, very, very little. Same with entertainment. Entertainment is, I think, the fastest growing sector in Nigeria, but very tiny contribution. So everywhere you go, people are playing music. You see Ashake, you see Thames, you see Bonaboy,
Speaker 2but there is no contribution. We're not capturing... That activity in Nigeria. They are doing concerts outside the country. The flow of the revenues are not coming back to Nigeria. So very, very tiny contribution. What's stalling?
Speaker 3Trade.
Speaker 2We mentioned trade before. Trade is a massive part of the economy. It's only growing about 2%. That's below population. 2.4%. That's below population. Agricultural exports also not growing as fast. That's the trade part of it. We are producing locally, it's going up in local production, but we're not exporting. Exports of agricultural produce are down 36%. Hear that number again, down 36%. So whilst we have a trade surplus, our agricultural exports have fallen 36%. Same with manufactured export, that
Speaker 2has fallen 51%. So trade surplus, but exports have fallen 51%.
Speaker 1Not good.
Speaker 2And, of course, we have the retail trade that is not doing as well. So, again, you see it doesn't match. Where GDP is growing, trade is growing, but manufacturing, agricultural exports are crashing. The household is also consuming. Let's go to what's really bad, what has stalled in the Nigerian economy.
Speaker 3Power.
Speaker 2I mean, this is clear. Power sector, right, has fallen about 10%. That's massive. Because when power is falling 10%, that just tells you that there's no power supply to power industry. That's why manufacturing exports are down. You can even argue that's why trade is down. Because you have all these yams, but you're not making yam cubes or potato chips. You're not processing the agricultural inputs for sale locally or even for sale externally. So power is down 10%.
Speaker 2Industry is down 3%. It's up about 3% but has slowed. Manufacturing share is 7%. That's also down. So this is the second period that the power sector has been down. And I don't understand how in any economy you can grow the economy to a trillion if you don't have power supply. Dangote has the largest refinery now on the African continent. We'll see if his plans come to fruition soon. be the largest in the world right but largest in
Speaker 2any measure you know on african continent and you can count the refineries on earth that are bigger than dangote but when dangote wanted to build the refinery what's the first thing he built he built a power plant almost a 500 or so kva power plant to power the entire refinery right if dangote was building a power plant in say texas he would just pay more but there will be power there right even if he decides to build his own power plant he has the option of using public power because the grid is going to be there he's just going to pay more so this idea
Speaker 2that you have to build your own power before you can sell when you guys see the ipo and your complaints expensive remember he's got to build his own power who's going to pay for that power you are going to pay for that power so this is the problem if you're a manufacturer in nigeria and you have to take 30 percent of your capital or 30 percent of your profit and reinvest into producing power That the government should give you. That you should then sell at a cheaper price. So that the market can buy. You're in a bit of a bind. Because you can't really sell much.
Speaker 2Your prices are going to be high. So households won't buy. That's why trade is weak. That's why your exports are falling. Because you cannot compete. As a Nigerian exporter. With an exporter in say Ghana. Or even Cote d'Ivoire. That has got constant power. If you make the same cocoa powder. It's sold in Ghana. It's sold in Ivory Coast. The Nigerian cocoa exporter is going to add 30% power to his cocoa paste that the guy in Ghana and the guy in Cote d'Ivoire will not add. Hence, agri-exports are down. Hence,
Speaker 2power GDP is down. Hence, the economy is not growing at that 9% or 10%. It's all connected, guys. You can't fix one and run it from the other ones. It's all connected. GDP trade is all connected. So that's for that point we want to make on that slide. Then again, this slide is just a scoreboard of what, like I said, what is going up, what's coming down and all that. I just want to point out the fact that if you look at the areas in Nigeria
Speaker 2that are very, very visible that you think should be contributing more to the economy, actually the areas in Nigeria that don't really contribute a lot. So they are growing fast. but they do not add to the share of real GDP. Case in point, look at banking and finance, what we call finance and insurance. It's growing at 9.29%, but only contributes 3.37% to the economy. So all these banks you see in Lagos, all of them, Abuja, Lagos, all those
Speaker 2nice-looking bankers, just 3.37% contribution. But agriculture, look at agriculture. In every village there's a farmer in Nigeria, in every village. Agriculture is only growing by 4.39%. And remember, this growth is an improvement. So we have improved to 4.39%. But what's the share of contribution of agriculture to the economy? 26.15%. You see the problem? The large areas that employ people
Speaker 2that add to the GDP growth are not growing. The ones that are growing very, very fast, look at arts and recreation. Arts and recreation are growing at 11.93%. 11% growth for arts and recreation. Your parks, your viewing centers and all that, 11% growth. But they only contribute 0.31% to the economy. So if you're an economic person and you look at this map, What should you do? It depends on your strategy. If your strategy is to create jobs,
Speaker 2you should be going directly to agriculture, trade, telecoms, and maybe manufacturing. That's where the job growth is. If you affect anything in agriculture, Nigerians get employed. So if you simply say there are going to be local government areas, break them further into polling units or whatever, and you say, if you're a polling unit in the city, we would do an urban farm, which could be poultry or whatever, right? And if you are in a large place, like say you are in Kogi that has lots of land, we're going to have demonstration farms and all that. If you
Speaker 2simply do a strategy that works to employ people to grow agricultural inputs, you solve unemployment, you grow the GDP. You don't grow the GDP according to the numbers we're seeing from oil and gas, from banking, even from construction. I'm just giving you the figures I'm seeing, not my figures. So let's go back to the point. If you look at the foreign direct investment that is coming to Nigeria, where is the money going to? Look at this map
Speaker 2we're looking at. Where is the foreign direct investment going to? And I hope you guys can see what I shared. Yeah, you guys can see that. When we say Nigeria got $ 5 billion in investments back into Nigeria, Where is that money going to? That money is going to finance and investment. Nearly, from the money going to the banks and the money going to buy financial instruments, you have nearly, nearly, I think my numbers are quite about 90-something percent, going to banks,
Speaker 2insurance companies, going to buy bonds, going to buy equities, which are maybe bonds of the federal government, things like that. Nearly 90-something percent. Only about, let's round fingers and say about 5% is going to manufacturing. I'm not sure anything goes to agriculture. And that's the problem. So when we celebrate that we are attracting investment, we have to ask where is the investment going to? If it's not going to agriculture, trade, telecom, manufacturing, it's not going to affect
Speaker 2your job numbers. If it doesn't affect your job numbers, it's not going to affect consumption. No consumption, no GDP growth. It's tied back in again. That's why I set up by showing you guys the numbers for GDP. It's growing, but trade is falling. Agriculture is growing, trade is falling. Farmers are producing yams. Nobody can buy the yams. They're expensive.
Speaker 1Why?
Speaker 2Because the capital that's coming in to create jobs isn't going to the job creation sectors. It's going to factories. finance and insurance again it's better it goes to finance that doesn't come at all i get that we're celebrating nigeria is going to be added to the ftse index that's good that's a big boost of confidence for nigeria but we need to attract investments going to agriculture and trade when we had mr akinwumi the former minister of
Speaker 2agriculture we had a lot of monies that were going into agriculture we need to get back there in nigeria otherwise There's going to be numbers that have no impact. And I particularly, again, want to just talk about power. Because I don't want it to be a rounding error to say, we just skipped over power.
Speaker 3No.
Speaker 2If Nigeria doesn't fix power, we are speaking English. You know, you can't grow GDP without power. I gave a story all the time, right, of how I went to Lagos to cut my hair. It was a barbing salon. There were people outside. There were barbers. Nobody was doing their economic activity.
Speaker 1Why?
Speaker 2Because if you want to cut your hair in that barbers salon, you pay for your haircut, but you have to pay separately for power. Separately. So they didn't want to inflate the cost of hair. So they said pay for barber, then pay surcharge for power. So nobody wanted to pay for power. So when I came and I paid for the power, everyone was there to work. So all the barbers, everyone lined up, let's cut your hair now before this guy goes. That's exactly how Nigerian economy is. The economy is comatose. We are waiting for power. If
Speaker 2you drive to Transamadi, drive to Maturi, drive through the industries in Kano and Kaduna, you'll see lots of factories. It's either they are churches or they've closed down. And why did they close down? There's no power. Just drive, go to Maturi, drive. You'll see lots of foreign names. Those were industrial estates that were functional in Nigeria in the 70s. Right now, we have more population. We are more connected to the global economy. You might even argue
Speaker 2that Nigeria is earning more, but we're not spending because the produce that those guys bring out is too expensive. There is no power. You can't manufacture without power. So when you have power falling at 10%, and this power, this 10% is the second consecutive real contraction. In Q1, 2026, power fell by 15%. To Q2, it's falling by 10%. If power falls, what does it do? It drags down manufacturing,
Speaker 2drags down industry, drags down manufacturing exports, drags down construction, drags down cold chain. Nigeria has no cold chain. Crazy, we have no cold chain. The Lagos to The roads going from the east to the west is blocked, so it's not bad. So if you don't have any refrigerated trucks, you can't move things. So imagine if you're moving drugs on that road and those drugs are standing in the hot sun in a hot car. On that road, are those drugs still usable? Do we ask ourselves those questions?
Speaker 2You put those things here that they bake in those trucks. How can they still be usable? I doubt it's usable. But this is the point we're making. Power, if you don't fix power, why are you building a coastal road, right? We had a president in Nigeria that built 10 brand new gas power stations. Then we stopped. I know the other guys, we built about some dams in the country and all that, and then we stopped. We should be
Speaker 2building more power stations, building more distribution, fixing the discos, fixing those things so that there can be power in the economy to grow the economy. You cannot have a $ 1 trillion GDP without power supply. It's just not going to happen. So if you know this, why not go back and fix power before you then, forget even the roads, fix power before you then go back and do stuff. Again, it sounds very simplistic, but it's just, that's why it
Speaker 2boggles the mind. They know it, but why they don't do it, I do not know. So again, if we then had to do a summary of what we've talked about, the GDP and trade numbers looked good until we started to dive into the numbers. We had a high GDP number. We had a high trade number that was posting exports. But the exports have turned out that the largest part of our exports, the agricultural side, is down. So, Kalu,
Speaker 2where is the export coming from? If agriculture is down, where are we getting these export numbers that we're seeing in GDP numbers? I'll show you. Look at the slide we're talking about. Total trade, 41 trillion. Export, 27 trillion. What makes up that 27 trillion? It's crude oil. So crude oil is 12 trillion. It's 47% of all the exports. So crude oil alone, 47%. Then other oil products, maybe gas,
Speaker 2maybe crude, whatever, distillate, whatever you want to call it, yeah? Then make up 38% of the exports. So if you add up crude oil itself, and then you add up other crude products or oil products, maybe gas, natural gas, you get, give or take, 47 plus 38, let the smart students add that. That's what you're getting in total exports. So Nigeria is still a mono-exporter, a mono-community nation. From 1960,
Speaker 2we've been trying to change this. This is 2026. We haven't done it. The non-oil exports are only 13% of our total exports. And that figure itself is even wrong. Not that the numbers are wrong, but the classification that makes it go to 13% is even wrong. In that 13%, we are counting eleme petrochemical. Here are the words. Eleme petrochemical is counted as non-oil. You can argue with me
Speaker 2all day, but you can't call something petrochemical. Something that takes its byproducts from oil and says it's non-oil. I'm sorry. I'm not going to agree with that argument. Number two, dangote urea. What's urea fertilizer? Urea is from natural gas. so you turn natural gas to fit light. We are counting it as non-oil. How can it be non-oil when it's from natural gas? You're going to say we added imputes. I get that. But it still can't be that we are counting natural gas as non-oil. Non-oil is cocoa, cashew,
Speaker 2and it's on that list. But that list, if you count the top five non-oil exporters in Nigeria, Two is Elemen and Dangote. And they are substantial exporters. And that's the picture we're posting. So when you post a surplus, that surplus of 100% captures the rise in crude oil prices, not the rise in cocoa or cashew exports. And guys, that's the wrap. Because if you keep on posting oil, then we're really not doing anything. Oil in revenue is good,
Speaker 2but we've got to diversify the economy.
Speaker 3Why?
Speaker 1Why?
Speaker 2Because if we wake up tomorrow and Putin and Zelensky say, okay, no more, we're not going to bomb each other again. We're enemies, we're not going to bomb each other. And Russia can export crude oil. And then Iran says, okay, okay, okay, we're not going to bomb any ship passing through the Strait of Hormuz. Then the price of Bonnie crude and Brent crude, which we are tracking, will fall from $ 104 and will go to nearly $ 50. All these lessons I've showed you, if oil goes to $ 50 a barrel and
Speaker 2stays there for six months, Nigeria is going to have a liquidity crisis. Why? Because we've borrowed a lot in dollars. Our debt has gone up, not in Naira, in dollars. And those debts are because we are selling crude oil. We're going to take that crude oil to pay back. I give you the case in point. We've done a swap deal with a bank in Dubai. That swap deal says that Nigeria is going to take $ 5 billion. In return, we're going to give that bank in Dubai federal government bonds.
Speaker 2That deal makes sense if oil prices stay high. Because if we're at $ 5 billion, we can pay back $ 5 billion if oil prices are $ 1. 4 billion. If oil prices go to $ 60 billion, $ 70 billion, what happens? Nigeria has to give them more bonds. So it's a swap deal. And that's just one of them. The Euro bonds are priced in dollars, not naira. So we have to pay Euro bonds in dollars, irrespective of whether we sell oil. We don't sell oil. So it's a problem. And that's
Speaker 2why you want to diversify the revenue. The economy is diversified. Diversify the revenue sources away from crude oil. That's the point, guys. That's why this is kind of troubling, if you ask me.
Speaker 1And, yeah.
Speaker 2Summary. We are growing at home. but we're not selling at home. Farms, agriculture is growing. Nobody's buying, right? We're exporting crude oil, but crude oil is expensive in Nigeria. Agric exports are down 36%. Crazy. Manufacturing exports are down 51%. Not good. We are broken in the middle. Our main producing issue, which is power, down 15% Q1, Down 10% Q2.
Speaker 2That's a story that we have to emphasize because nothing can happen without power. So when you read the speeches of the government, you haven't heard what was told you in this slide. You don't hear it. This is the government's same report. Look at my source, Nigeria's Q2 2026 GDP and Trade Review. It's from the government's own sources, but they don't tell you this. So you think, oh, if you look at it, GDP is growing, exports are growing, but that's not the reality on ground, guys. So knowing
Speaker 2all this, we'll know now. Let's see if we can, let's see, just to see, let's see if we can attempt to talk about the Dangote offer and what it means for us. And I want to approach Dangote in a different way. Dangote prospectus is not out yet. So, I don't want to start to talk about Dangote till I read the prospectus. But overall, what I've seen on social media, everyone is talking about the numbers of Dangote, numbers,
Speaker 2earnings per share, blah, blah, blah. You want to be very careful that you look at it the right way, that you're understanding what you want to look for in that offer, right? So, let me give you this story. I think most of you guys would know this story. If you are younger... Philip Osundu would not mean a big deal to you, but those that know who Philip Osundu is will understand the story I'm trying to give. So let's pick Messi and Philip Osundu, right? And let's see,
Speaker 2what can we learn from Messi and Philip Osundu? Let me share this on Twitter. Yes, yes, someone's sending me a text. Kalu, are we still on? Are we still talking football? Yeah, we're talking. This is still economics. You're going to see it in the next slides. We're going to talk about Filippo Sondo. We're going to talk about Messi. Also, I have a first question for you. If you own a club, should your club buy Messi? The answer is yes. There's no point to read the scouting report on Messi.
Speaker 2If Messi is available and you own a club, you buy. Does that sound familiar? Does that sound familiar?
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2That if this company comes to market, you buy. Don't read the prospectus. Don't do anything.
Speaker 1Just buy.
Speaker 2So if Messi comes to market and says he wants to move to any club, every club owner will want to buy Messi. Second question. Should you buy at any price? The answer is no. Because Messi is good. We know fundamentally Messi is fantastic. But the problem is the price. And it's not the price because we don't have money. The Arab guys will buy Messi at whatever price. It's not the price that's the problem. And that's what I really want to show you guys today. The price that
Speaker 2we quote is not as important as knowing what the price means. So three things, again, we are confusing with Dangote. Number one, we are confusing the cost to the price to the value. We're dealing with Dangote Refinery. There's a cost of what you're going to pay. You're going to pay about 525 Naira per share of Dangote. That's historical. You're going to pay it once. You are never, ever going to use it again unless you want to do your return. That price is gone. It's sunk. It's gone.
Speaker 2What is the price of Dangote? We don't know because we haven't bought. When we buy Dangote at 525, if I want to sell, the stock market will give me a price. The stock market exists for price discovery. So the price of Dangote is not 525. That's what you're going to pay the cost. The price will be what the market will tell me tomorrow. What's the value of Dangote? That's where it gets messy because there is not one way to determine value of anything. There's not one way. There are many ways to determine value of something, right?
Speaker 2So I can determine the value of less and I give you a good example of how I'm going to determine value. What if I gave you, let's hold on a pause and I'll use example. If I bought Messi when Messi was 12 years old and Messi was offered to me at a million dollars, And I bought him. Is that a good buy?
Speaker 4Yes.
Speaker 2Why is it a good buy? Because at a million, when he's 12, there's a margin of safety for me. If Messi turns out to be a fantastic footballer, then I bought a bargain. I bought a bargain. So I'm all good. But if I buy Messi at 10 billion, even if Messi is a fantastic footballer, I have no margin of safety. I can never sell Messi for 11 billion after I've bought him. Nobody else will buy from me.
Speaker 2It's too expensive. It's not the cost. It's the earnings that Messi would give back to me after I buy him. So if I bought Messi for 10 billion, will I sell tickets and jerseys and TV rights that will get up to 10 billion over the life of Messi playing in my club? It's difficult to say. It's nearly impossible. So when you say something is expensive, you have to say it's expensive when compared to earnings. Not that it's expensive.
Speaker 2Because what's expensive to me might be cheap to you. What's cheap to me might be expensive to you. But earnings is the same. So if I buy Mercy at 10 billion, I have to compare what it's going to give me back to the earnings I'm going to get from Mercy. So margin of safety. You can be right about the investment. and still lose money because you have no margin. And that goes for the question of value. What we are debating today is not the cost of Dangote,
Speaker 2it's not the price of Dangote, it's the value of Dangote. Why are we debating the value? Because if we know the value, we can determine the earnings, we can compare that value to the earnings. We are never going to agree on the value, but earnings are going to be black and white. Dangote can never come and say he didn't make, he made and he thinks he made earnings. No, we're going to know exactly what Dangote made in earnings. We know exactly what we paid. We're going to know exactly the price. The way we're going to argue about
Speaker 2it is the value of Dangote. If we know the value, we compare the value to the earnings, then we can know exactly if we've made a good deal or if we made a bad deal right okay let's now compare mercy with osundu so mercy is quality the market is not going to give you a fair price that's fine but philip osundu in 1987 went and played in canada he was maba he played from he played for El Kanemi Warriors. He was the tournament's best player. I say
Speaker 2it again. He was the tournament's best player. He was only 16 years old. He played in U16. He played in U21. In both, he got to the finals. Best tournament. So, of course, Anderlecht bought him because his cost was good. They assumed he was going to get them earnings. He's a 16-year-old guy. They assumed they bought him with that margin of error. Like, hey, we're buying a 16-year-old guy
Speaker 2and he's going to play for us for 20 years and all that kind of stuff. I'm not going to say what all Nigerians know about 16-year-olds. I won't say that. But you can see where they missed it, right? You can see what's going on, right? Because they bought a 16-year-old, they assumed they bought with a margin of error. So when you buy with numbers that you think are good, you are going to make a fundamental error and you're
Speaker 2going to value a company at the price that you should not value that company. Does that make sense? Very important. So value ties into earnings. It's not cheap or expensive. Value tells us if those earnings are cheap or expensive, right? Or the other way around. If we know the earnings, we can tell if we've bought value. That's the whole idea. Because we know cost, we know price. We will know
Speaker 2earnings later on, but we don't know the value. Not that we don't know the value. There are many ways for us to know that value. And we're going to argue, oh, should we use this method or should we use that method? That's the whole idea. So the whole idea as an investor is to keep on adding to your portfolio value. things, seeds that can grow your portfolio, right? So if you're an investor, the best investors like Warren Buffett are buying high-earning stocks relative to the price they paid. Look at
Speaker 2the words what is in here. You are buying high earnings. Look at high earnings, very important stock, relative to the price you paid. The price is not that material if you are earning a lot. Go back to the Mercier example. A million dollars is a lot of money to pay for a 15-year-old. But if that 15-year-old earns you a billion, then the price is cheap because he earned you a billion. But reverse it. If you paid a billion dollars price
Speaker 2and you earned a million, then that price is expensive. Not because you're paying a billion, but because the earnings are low. The average investors overpay. That's the price number.
Speaker 1Overpay.
Speaker 2For a story and hope earnings catch up. That's the average investor. So that price, the 525 that you know, you are overpaying because you are hoping that earnings catch up. And of course, the poor investors, they're buying a great asset. So you are buying a good asset, nothing wrong with the asset, but a price that has already capitalized every profit you're going to get in the future. So look at Philip Osundu. Because they assumed he was 16 years old,
Speaker 2they paid that price for him. But was he 16? If they knew he's, let's assume he wasn't 16, would they have paid that price for him? They would have looked at the investment differently. So he wouldn't have failed because of the price they paid for him. If they paid for him lower, they would have said, wow, okay, it's a good deal because we're paying lower for a guy. But if they assumed he was 16 and they paid for him, then they made a bad deal. Because the earnings,
Speaker 2even though the earnings came, did not cover their price. So price, you know price, you know cost, you are going to know earnings, but you are not ever going to agree on value, right? Okay, so the true worth of a company, like I said, there are many valuation methods, but the one I would like you guys to focus on is the earnings. What is that company going to earn for you? A bank that has billions in deposits
Speaker 2can still be a poor purchase if you buy it 20 times or 50 times its earnings. The problem is not the bank. The bank is profitable. It makes money. Great brand. But the price you pay for it is the problem because you are paying at a price that's already captured in future earnings. So it's not a bargain. You see the points I'm making. The same with a refining company. It can be a fantastic company. It can be the largest in Africa, largest in the world, and
Speaker 2all that. But the price you pay for that company, the earnings cannot pay you back. Then it's going to be a messy situation where you have a high-quality asset, acknowledged globally to be a high-quality asset, but the earnings cannot pay you back so that you're going to be carrying a great asset on your books at a bad price. Make sense, guys? Okay, fantastic. So when we get to next week, right, we're going to go deep. I'm not saying, don't,
Speaker 2I use Philip Osundu, I use Messi. Don't read anything into it, right? So if the price is low, this is the final thing I'm going to tell you guys. And you guys can request to speak, right? I see your comments already here. Finally, finally, asking if it's a good asset, asking me, you guys are flooding my DMs, asking me if I should buy a DM. That's not the question you should ask. You shouldn't be asking, is Dangote a good offer? Should I buy? That's not the
Speaker 2question you should be asking. What you should be asking is, what will be the earnings? What will be the earnings? Go and find out what the earnings will be. If the price is low relative to earnings, you have a margin of safety. Go and buy Dangote. End of story. If the price already assumes that that those earnings, it's already captured those earnings in, you want to wait and say, let's give it a wait and see. So you want to pay a price for the earnings that you can justify. That's the simple answer for Dangote Refinery. You want to
Speaker 2find out if that price you are paying, what's the price? Where do you know the price? 525. How do you compare that 525 to earnings? That's really your question. If you think that that price, you are buying earnings at a cheap multiple, go ahead and get it. It's a good deal. If you think that the 525 already captures all the future earnings in that 525 price, they want to wait a bit, right? Because remember the price, when you see a broker tell you the price is 525, what they are telling you is that the total future
Speaker 2earnings that the Dangote Refunding will make in its entire life, if you discount it back to today with a discount rate, it's going to go back to 525. Let me say it again. If Dangote pays you a thousand next year, Pays you 10,000 next year. Pays you a million the other year. If you discount that 1,100,000, 10,000 back to today, the valuation means that you're going to get 525. So the point is you want to buy a stock at
Speaker 2a price lower than the intrinsic value, not higher. You want to buy a stock at a price lower than the intrinsic value. That intrinsic value is that 525. discounted back to today at an appropriate discount if that's the way you do it professionally all right guys fantastic so if you want to speak guys you've got the floor i've got some great questions here on on twitter carlo should we buy dangote that's all i want to know i just told you what you should do with dangote
Speaker 2you want to approach dangote the way you approach um an earnings report you want to if you want to buy messy what would you say and you are the owner Would you buy him because he's a good footballer? You don't care if he's a good footballer. You care that he's going to make you money. Why do you want to win a cup? You want to win a cup because you want the club to rise so you have more supporters, then you make more TV rights. You don't want to win a league because you like football. Football is a business. The same way you don't want to bank because you like banking. No, it's a business.
Speaker 2If you like, you can do fantasy football, right? So it's all about the money. It's all about the money. Yes, we're going to talk about Dangote in specifics next week. This is a good one here on GDP. Sorry, I added Tomiwa. I don't know where he went to. Yes, let me go back to the slide you're talking about. The slide on Nigerian companies and what they are contributing to GDP.
Speaker 1Yes.
Speaker 2So let's go back to finance. So you are saying, if I understand you well, Chronicles, you are saying that the numbers for Nigerian banking should be higher because in every state in Nigeria and almost every local government in Nigeria, we have a bank. So it should be higher than what we have. I don't think so. How many nine how many people work in any a standard bank branch how many nigerians work in a standard bank branch maybe maybe 25 maybe 25 maybe okay let's call it 50.
Speaker 2how many banks do we have in nigeria 25 right so 50 times 25. So even if you did that, even if you did 100 times 100, that's.
Speaker 310,000, right?
Speaker 2Per state. How many people do you know work in farming, in just your little local government, in farming? And farming, I'm talking about the women that work. In farming, women work, men work. Old men, old women. They farm, they process, they transport, they even consume. So if you compare it like that, don't look at banking and say there are banks everywhere. The farmers, how many women, young people work in banking? To work in a bank, you have to
Speaker 2have graduated, right? But they work in farming. They start to work in the farm when they are 15, 14. They work in the farms. So there's much more contribution. Look at the whole of the north of Nigeria. They are all farmers. In the south, you might have a guy doing this or doing that. But in the north, they are mostly farming. Look at the population of Nigeria. So agriculture is about 26%, finance is about 3%. That's not a wrong figure. That's why what you are seeing is the growth of finance. That's the 9%. So you are right, the growth of finance is 9%. But the
Speaker 2actual contribution of that 9%, it's only 3% of the population producing 9%. But in agriculture, 26% are producing 4%. You don't fix it by fixing the growth. You go and fix that share. You say, why is 3% generating 9%? But 26% is generating 4%. That means if you simply go to that 26% and you double it, imagine the numbers.
Speaker 2If you do 26% and you now double it to eight, the total GDP will grow because you have a larger base. That's the whole idea. So don't look at it in terms of the growth. The base itself is what is worrying. It's not growing. Because it's not growing, then you don't feel the effect. That's why you hear them say GDP is up, but you don't feel it because the sectors that are growing are not contributing to Nigeria's GDP. I hope that makes sense to you. Same with arts and recreation.
Speaker 2If you go everywhere in Africa, my friend from Rwanda is here, if you go everywhere in Africa, you hear Nigerian music, you hear Afrobeat. But those Afrobeat artists are not contributing to the economy of Nigeria. The skits you are talking about, you are talking about skits. Skits, where do they sell the skits? If I make a skit, let's say I am Brain Jotter or whoever it is. When he makes those skits, where does he sell the skits? He sells them on YouTube. Who owns YouTube? A Nigerian company?
Speaker 1No.
Speaker 2So all the skits you're talking about are not being sold on the Nigerian platform. You are the consumer, but you are paying YouTube. The YouTube ads, you are the product, right? That's the whole idea. We're on X. X is not owned by Nigerian. So you see it growing, but it has zero contribution. For instance, we said if you're a Nigerian skit maker, You had to register. I'm not giving them ideas. You had to register in Nigeria and they will do some things. Maybe we'll tag your video with
Speaker 2a digital ad coupon that YouTube had to pay us. Then you now see that whenever you do that skit and you upload on YouTube, you get paid. But for now, there's no Bonaboy, Thames, all your skit makers, all your artists, Wizkid, all of them, they have no contribution whatsoever. to Nigerian economy, I didn't say so. The numbers are saying so. They only contribute 0.31, not even up to 1%. But in Africa, if you go to Kenya, you go to Nollywood, so
Speaker 2Nollywood is nothing. You might say Nollywood is information and communication. There's also Nollywood in trade. You can make that argument. But arts and recreation, zero. Construction is shocking, just 3%. So, Again, these are numbers from Nigeria. It's not my numbers. I'm just interpreting those numbers out for you. To grow the economy, you've got to go focus on those large sectors. It's like saying, what's the key? Focus on what gives you
Speaker 2the most results. It's the same work you're going to do. If you do 10 hours of work and you get paid one naira or you get paid 50 naira, why would you then work for the same hours and get paid one naira? Focus on where you work you get paid more.
Speaker 1Right?
Speaker 2Makes sense, right? I'm not sending video requests and I really can't read DMs that fast. So, guys, if there are going to be any requests, we'll call it closed by the top of the hour, which is 12 o'clock. And I'll let you guys go enjoy your day. Welcome to the Man U fans. I mean, Man U today played like an NPC. They had a monopoly. They couldn't take advantage of it. That's life. That is life.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2So not great question here. Yes, let me just go again to the slide and see what we're talking about here. Yes, so telecom, I see the point you're making. Yeah, telecom is going to be your GSM, your base stations, the guys selling GSM cards, the adverts that go to telecoms, everything about telecom. That's why you see it's growing at 96%. If you look at Nigeria, again, look at your country.
Speaker 2Every village has someone selling telecom. So that person's employment comes from telecom, GSM. It's trade, but they are trading telecom. So telecom has a much wider base and a much larger contribution to the economy than, say, just trade. So whilst that person on his store will be selling milk, will be selling dairy, will be selling tomato, he's also selling recharge cards. So what we are seeing is that recharge cards are selling, but food is not selling. Because
Speaker 2people are saying, I want to talk more than I want to eat luxury food. I saw a skit where a guy was eating Gary and Gary's soup. It's not a skit. People can't afford food. But there is no other substitute to talking on the phone. If I'm hungry, I can eat Gary, no meat whatsoever. Just, even no soup. I can just take Gary, boil the Gary, eat the Gary alone. Nobody's going to see me, right? And I'm not hungry anymore. But if I want to make a phone call, I can tell MTN, make the phone call
Speaker 2for me for free and I'll pay you next. They're not going to listen to me. I have to go buy a recharge card. So that's why you see trade itself. Trade in what? What do Nigerians consume the most? If you look at trade, what's Nigeria's largest country? What do we buy the most? It's food. We've spent 57% of our income on food, right? So what we are saying, or what the data is saying, is that when a Nigerian goes to the store, what are they buying first? They buy food, but they're just buying food enough to survive.
Speaker 2They're not even married, they're just buying the basics to survive. But for telecom, they can't do without telecom. So they have to go buy telecom. Power. They can say, we don't want power. We are not going to do power. But their phone, they want to call someone, they want to know what's happening. The phone is too important to them. So they charge the phone when they get to work because there's no power at home. They charge the phone at work, come back home, make a few phone calls, do some trading on their phone, all that kind of stuff. So that's what's going on with the way Nigerians consume.
Speaker 2Rent is not going to be captured here the way you're seeing it. But this data is instructive of how we spend money. You know, what NBS is capturing is how you spend and how you save and all that. So that's what's showing up in this data. You really can't run away from it. Claudine, how are you doing? Yeah, thanks.
Speaker 1I got you.
Speaker 2Claudine, how are you? Okay, I can't hear you, Claudine. If you were speaking, I cannot hear you. Yeah, so I hope that makes sense to you, right? Just want to make sure. Are you good? Why are you not talking?
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 2Claudine, hi. If you are speaking, you're on mute. You have to unmute, Claudine. And on that quick question here from this gentleman talking about, yeah, Dangote. So again, with Dangote, like I'm telling you, it's not about, don't get caught up in the cost, in the pricing. It's a very, very technical offer because what does a refinery do? Look at the refinery the same way Look at a woman that grinds tomato in your store. You buy tomato, you
Speaker 2take to her, you give her your tomato, she grinds the tomato and gives you tomato paste. That's how Dangote is. That's a refinery. You give her tomato, she'll grind tomato, put pepper, give you that paste, you go back to your place. How is that woman making money? She has built that grinding machine. You bring her crude oil. She grinds. She gives back to you. How does she make money? if she has cheap petrol to run her grinding machine then she can make profit from you right and number
Speaker 2two if her machine is new it uses less petrol So how new Dangoda Refiner is is very, very important. That means the crack ratio is going to be very, very, you know, you can do more. The one in India can do over 200 products. You can give it crude oil, it does 200 products. The older ones can't. So Dangoda has a big advantage going forward that he can do more, buy products for more people. That's more revenues. That's more earnings. See the point? Those things matter to earnings. I'm not saying you should ignore technical stuff, but that's what you
Speaker 2are going out for, earnings. Claudine, how are you doing? Welcome back. Hi, Carlo. How are you doing?
Speaker 1Doing well, thank you.
Speaker 3Fantastic.
Speaker 5Great conversation, always.
Speaker 1I had one question.
Speaker 5You said that all the Nigerian artists, they only make up to 0.03% revenue in Nigeria.
Speaker 6Is there a reason why?
Speaker 5Not revenues.
Speaker 2Go ahead, finish.
Speaker 3Go ahead.
Speaker 5Yeah, is it because their companies are based in other countries? Because, like you said, the Nigerian music movie basically has taken over Africa. Besides South Africa, Nigeria is maybe number one or number.
Speaker 7Two, right?
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 5So I would think they will contribute to their country's GDP.
Speaker 6In higher numbers.
Speaker 2Yeah, that is the point as well that I make with this slide. So what I'm saying is that the share of real GDP of arts and recreation, it's only 0.31. So let's take a Burna Boy concert. If Burna Boy comes to Lagos to do a concert, how many sectors are captured in that concert? Obviously, there's trade in that concert because people are going to buy and sell tickets, right? Obviously, there's telecom because people are going to buy, talk, take videos.
Speaker 2There's telecom, right? Then there's obviously arts and recreation. Really, really, if you look at how Bonner Boy would do a concert in America, who sells the tickets? Ticketmaster in America. Who owns the building? A company in arts, in real estate or in art owns the buildings. Bonaboy would get his money, you pay, you tap your card, so he goes through your bank, either through Zelle, he goes to the company, they get their money instantly. He's going to stay in a hotel. They're going to promote brands. All
Speaker 2those brands he's associating with are all locally based. They are capturing the revenues of those people that have gathered to watch a concert. If you bring that same club to Nigeria, what's happening? Maybe he goes to Lagos, maybe he's at the arena in Lagos. The folks taking the videos on their phones, those are not Nigerian apps. Those apps are not registered in Nigeria. They're not paying tax in Nigeria. Maybe they pay VAT, yeah, but they're not returning to Nigeria. The company that owns Ashake's rights, I
Speaker 2doubt it's registered in Nigeria. I could be wrong. But I doubt, you see, Devido has a company registered. When you book a concert with them, you are paying to a company outside Nigeria. You book them out of Nigeria. They fly private jets. Those jets are not made in Nigeria. You buy them with gas in Nigeria. I get it. But they're not made in Nigeria. They're not set up in Nigeria. So there's a lot of activity occurring. But the base of that activity where the value is being captured is captured outside Nigeria. The music videos for a
Speaker 2long time in Nigeria were done outside Nigeria. There was a time when the government said you must do music videos in Nigeria. They're done outside the country. So the audio, the finishing, it's done outside. Pick a Bonoboy CD. Look at the CD. Do you see any Nigerian company there on the CD? Maybe the producer or the DS? Yeah, you don't see it. I'm not calling them out. I'm not saying they should do it here. I'm saying that's how the economy is set up. Look at Nollywood also. They've moved from CDs done in Aba to Netflix. Most
Speaker 2of the Nollywood movies, I mean, you see Nollywood movies being advertised on Netflix. And they are hitting 1 billion Naira revenue. What a local Nigerian guy that bought Nollywood titles. And he's also doing, what's the name of that Nigerian, that house of the movie titles. He's also doing that as well. But if you don't capture the value locally, it's difficult to make money locally. Hollywood, what is Hollywood? It's where they capture the movie titles in California. Nollywood
Speaker 2can shoot a movie in Lagos. But they take it back to California and do some things there. And they say it's produced in Hollywood. Even though they shot the movie in Jordan, where was Star Wars shot? Tunisia. Where did the money from Star Wars go back to? To California. So it's the same thing. It's not like a Nigerian thing. But as long as you don't capture that value locally, it's not going to show up. It will show up maybe in your hotel. So in Tunisia, if you go to Tunisia, you can go to where they shot Star
Speaker 2Wars and watch where they shot the Star Wars. If you want to go to where they shot Jews of Nazareth in Israel, in Tunisia, they will show you and you can pay in a hotel and go there. If you go to New Zealand, you can see where they shot the Three Rings. They have a whole industry around that. You go to Georgia, you can see where they shot all those slave movies. So, Africans are going to be a bit smarter. I saw Togo and Bennett have that slave ship, where they have that ship, where you can see where the slaves were going to. We have to
Speaker 2do more of that. We're not going to bring Hollywood here. But there are ways you can capture the value that Davido is making, that Bonobo is making. There's a way you can capture the value and bring them home. We are wasting those guys. When I grew up, when we grew up, we didn't have any African artists. We had Fela. We have Angela Kiju. That's it. Now, the random Nigerian or South African or Tanzanian artist is on billboards. And
Speaker 2we've taken it for granted. But we're not capturing value from those people. And we have to get smarter about how we can look at those guys as revenue machines for and bring them back home. That's just it, Claudine. But it's a great question.
Speaker 6Okay, thank you.
Speaker 5And what about the Tangote IP?
Speaker 6Is it coming up soon?
Speaker 2Yeah, I think next week. It's out. They've signed the paperwork. So I think next week the prospectus should be out and then people can buy. It's a fully digital offer. That means you can just go online, download an app, and buy as long as you pass the KYC. you should be able to buy it in Nigeria. There are lots of apps that do that. I mean, I recommend the Bamboo one. If you get Bamboo, it's okay. You can basically... You have to be in Nigeria to buy it?
Speaker 2You don't have to be in Nigeria. You just have to make sure you pass the KYC. So if they're asking you, are you Nigerian? I'm not sure how that would work if you have to say you're not Nigerian and then have documentation. If they don't let you do it, How else can you get it? So the FTSE is going to add Nigeria to the index. So they will clearly add Dangote to the index. That might be on that way to get exposure. But download Bamboo and see if you can do it as a foreigner.
Speaker 1What about Robinhood?
Speaker 2I doubt you can get it on Robinhood. Not now. Maybe later, right? Maybe. You will get the FTSE on Robinhood. The index that will be created for Nigeria, it will be there. Robinhood might do it later. The problem is float. Robinhood would want a lot of float because they put it there, pool, try to buy, there will be no float. He's not selling a lot. He's selling very, very little. I don't think he's selling up to 15% than Gote himself.
Speaker 2So that's what kills Nigeria. When we had the ETF 30 for Nigeria, they had 30 companies and it was one ETF. So you could buy that one ETF and get the 30. I don't think Robinhood will have it. I'm going to check. I doubt they will have it. But Bamboo definitely and all those Nigerian apps. SEC registered Nigerian apps will have it. And there are many of them, yeah.
Speaker 5Okay, thank you.
Speaker 2Fantastic. If you have any issues, just let me know, yeah?
Speaker 1Of course.
Speaker 2You're welcome.
Speaker 1Hey, Cleo.
Speaker 2How you doing? Cleo, you've got your hand.
Speaker 3Hello.
Speaker 2How you doing, Cleo?
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah, no problem.
Speaker 2What's happening? Yeah. Yeah, uh, there's just too many, too much. It's like the World Cup, bro. It's like the World Cup of investing.
Speaker 3This is it.
Speaker 2This is what we live for.
Speaker 1I don't think it's the World Cup of investing.
Speaker 7I think what is going on is that Nigerians have overcorrected. We've overcorrected because we already had a bad image and.
Speaker 1So there is now this thing of.
Speaker 7There's this one success story that was now broadcasted.
Speaker 6This is Africa's list.
Speaker 1This is Africa's renaissance.
Speaker 7This is Africa's breaking of shackles from colonialism. Africa's... break, even people that, even people that.
Speaker 1Are very suspicious of Western.
Speaker 7Something, you will see them talking about Africa is breaking free from imperialism. I saw a certain David breaking free from imperialism, breaking free from this, breaking.
Speaker 1Free from that, but look at the construction of Dango Terry binaries.
Speaker 6They flew in welders.
Speaker 7They flew in basically most of the labor that high-end value added labor that was used. Even the boring machines were brought in from Belgium. They essentially brought almost everything from abroad. He has double left.
Speaker 1He's a very popular person on Twitter.
Speaker 7I think it was him or there was one other guy too that was teaching one very interesting thing.
Speaker 1They were asking a, I think it should be.
Speaker 7Tango Telefono or the competitor, the other cameraman, I think it's one of those. They were asking one of the, yeah, yeah, I don't want to say the person's name, the company's.
Speaker 1So they're asking the company, he screenshot.
Speaker 7Something about the conversation, the financial press were asking one executive from the company and they were saying, they're asking him about cost.
Speaker 1Of setting machinery that the company was using.
Speaker 7And this is something that you expect that executive to know what the cost was.
Speaker 1The executive did not know.
Speaker 7Most likely because because the company that.
Speaker 1Is making it is not Nigerian. All Nigerians are just doing, we're.
Speaker 6Just there to maintain it. So we're there.
Speaker 1To do the day-to-day running.
Speaker 7But then in terms of the maintenance, in terms of the value addition, capturing more value, we're not doing all of that.
Speaker 6And it now brought up a very interesting question.
Speaker 1The person was now asking, that what we are.
Speaker 7Doing in Africa is we are doing a lot, we are trying to do industrialization without actually doing the hard work.
Speaker 6Of value addition. It's a very odd.
Speaker 1Thing that is currently going on.
Speaker 7The refinery that they want to do in Tanzania, that is it Ibrahim Duji, one of the billionaires, they said is going to.
Speaker 6Drop $ 100.
Speaker 1Million out of the money.
Speaker 7Most likely, they will fly in Chinese artisans living down to the world as the equipment, everything will be done abroad, and they will just fly in to come.
Speaker 6And fix it.
Speaker 7I'm not saying that we don't need all these things, but what is the value addition that.
Speaker 1We are doing in Africa when it comes to this?
Speaker 6If, for instance, and.
Speaker 7I know I keep on saying, I've said this in some other spaces before, if, for instance, and this is not a ridiculous thing to look at, If, for instance, there is the.
Speaker 1World actually tips into a world war situation.
Speaker 2The state of.
Speaker 1Malacca is closed.
Speaker 6Bab el-Mandab is closed.
Speaker 1The state of Hormuz is closed.
Speaker 7The daily streets are closed. Like, everywhere is just like blocked, blocked, blocked. People can't go out and everywhere is just missiles flying here and there.
Speaker 6Can Africa.
Speaker 1actually industrialized?
Speaker 6My answer is this, no.
Speaker 7And if you look at, we've not invested in our people.
Speaker 1We're just doing a lot of sexy, sounds good, looks good.
Speaker 7Then we go on the internet and talk about, oh, this is an.
Speaker 6Example of African industrializing. Look at the numbers.
Speaker 1Hmm. Nigeria has been industrializing at.
Speaker 6A very fast rate, fast pace.
Speaker 7If you look at the manufacturing sector as a share of the economy, it was already falling even.
Speaker 6Before this current government came in.
Speaker 3It was falling.
Speaker 7But this current government has turbocharged the fall of the manufacturing sector.
Speaker 6Now, manufacturing is less than 10% of our economy.
Speaker 7It's effect that the telecom.
Speaker 6Sector is bigger than the manufacturing sector.
Speaker 7The manufacturing sector is dragging with the oil sector again. For a country that is poor, Nigeria is a poor.
Speaker 1Country, Africa is a poor continent.
Speaker 7I don't want to hear this nonsense that.
Speaker 1We like to tell ourselves that we're a rich country. We're a poor continent.
Speaker 7There's this a post that somebody posted on LinkedIn.
Speaker 6In the last week or two weeks ago.
Speaker 7Very interesting post.
Speaker 6I think I'll try to send.
Speaker 1It to you on LinkedIn, Carlo.
Speaker 6I think I have you on LinkedIn.
Speaker 7I was trying to send it to you on LinkedIn.
Speaker 1It's very insightful about how.
Speaker 7You lead ourselves into thinking where.
Speaker 1You are resource-rich continent and everything.
Speaker 6See, with all of these things.
Speaker 1That is going on with....
Speaker 7Industrialization of africa and especially of nigeria in this.
Speaker 6Case we then come out and be.
Speaker 7Surprised why in our country today we are not having high income jobs our government seems to think that all you just need to do is remove this remove that remove this remove that they don't know that the hard work of development is.
Speaker 2Actually being done yeah i don't want you to i think you made a Powerful point. I don't want you to lose sight of the powerful point you're making. I mean, you've asked a fundamental question. Is it really, you made the issue about the Dangote and not just Dangote, most of the things you see in Africa and Nigeria, we have the railway from Mombasa to Nairobi. We have the Dangote refinery. We have the stuff going on in Egypt. How many are actually built by Africans? By Africans, yeah.
Speaker 2With knowledge that we've gained from Africa. So that's the problem. If you go back to 1976, 1970s, Africans were building these things. There was a bit of a time where we were educating professionals. They were going abroad. They were getting education. They were bringing the tools back to Africa, and they were building them. The Russians were doing a lot in that regard. There was a lot of empowerment, basic education, and all that. Then all that sort of died out a bit. We had the Cold War where
Speaker 2it became more interesting who was on the West or the Eastern side. So the West didn't care about economics. It was more like if you were a vassal state, we supported you. So what then happens, a fall off in leadership in Africa where instead of building the economy of Africa, we became socialist, capitalist and Marxist because we wanted to be Russian or American. That killed us a lot because in Asia, even though they were like Africans,
Speaker 2look at South Korea, look at Nigeria, look at Taiwan. If you go back, we started almost at the same level. If you argue that China, Nigeria had a larger per capita income than China, China was a dynasty millennia ago, that's fine. But look at South Korea, look at Taiwan, look at all the Philippines, look at all the nations that we started off in Nigeria with.
Speaker 1And we had crude oil.
Speaker 2You know, I've told a story here of how the military dictator in South Korea woke up one day, called all the quote-unquote big men, and said, I give you guys an offer. If you bring your money back to South Korea and you invest it, I will give you, I will not touch you, We'll give you state protection. You can grow. We don't ask any questions. But if you leave it out there, we'll come after you. And those guys sat and said, let's give it a try.
Speaker 2And they all came back. This tube, what's that name? Is it tubal or whatever they call them?
Speaker 1Tubal.
Speaker 2That's part of how they sort of came and they started to invest. And there's a story where the guy called on them and said, South Korea needs to go into ship production. They had no ship manufacturing base. They had nothing. He told the guy, go and start to make ships. Because he saw that there was been a lot on ships. The guy went to Scotland, to Europe, and got order for ships. He had no base. Then he took his people in South Korea. I forget where
Speaker 2he took them to. They went to learn ship building. Then he brought them back to South Korea. And they started to make ships that were crappy ships. But after... After 25 years, yeah. Yeah, it was Hyundai or one of them. After 25 years... Correct. They were looking for a way of how do we get an FX. correct but the point again.
Speaker 1To your point.
Speaker 7Is that they did the education they just didn't announce a slogan like ships for up by the year 2020 they did they.
Speaker 1Did the education they.
Speaker 2Your point is that they did the education they just didn't announce a slogan like ships for all by the year 2020 they did the education they got the government support they gave tariffs they stopped ship imports over the years They are now, if you want to build ships in the world, is that China, South Korea, or is it Japan? You have to go to them.
Speaker 3Japan, yes.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 2Those three companies. Those three. So look at Eleme Petrochemical. Nigeria had Eleme Petrochemical. Nigeria ran it. We crashed it. The Indians have come and have turned Eleme into a massive industry. It's now one of the top three in Nigeria. I can go on. Look at NNPC. NNPC, in my mind, is the only oil and gas company with a monopoly that made a loss. I can't think of any. And
Speaker 2I say it sadly. I'm not trying to... Not this NNPC. The NNPC, not limited. The NNPC of before. You have an oil and gas product. You have a monopoly. And you make a loss. You have to be... Even if you're not doing anything, you can't make a loss with oil and gas. But they made a loss. So, again, it's back to this human capital. You know what happened to Africa again?
Speaker 3Telecom.
Speaker 2Telecom gave us a false picture where we assumed that with telecom, we were able to leapfrog. You know, we didn't have telephones in Nigeria. We didn't have telephones. I remember if you had to make a phone call in Nigeria, you would go and line up in NITEL. I went to my school, my university... We're at the telephone room. Then if you go there on Saturday morning, because we go Saturday morning because all the workers have gone home. You will line up with students. You will wait for like an hour. Then you can call Lagos from the
Speaker 2telephone room in my university. And God bless the person you are calling. They don't pick up the phone. They will pick up the phone. Then you talk to them. Then you put the phone down. Phone! That's where we give kids to play games on. So what happened with phones? We never built phones. We never built phone lines in Africa. We simply went GSM. We built the cell towers. We gave everybody a phone. And suddenly, we had telecom penetration. Nigeria has got 99% or 91% telecom penetration. But there
Speaker 2are no phone lines. So we now said, oh, this thing is easier. We can do the same with power. We don't need to do any, we don't need to build what Europe has built. We don't need to build transmission lines. We don't need to build trunking stations. Let's just do, yeah, let's just do base stations. Then they took it to power. So now what do you hear in Nigeria today? Solar. Everybody's doing solar. And they say it's a solution. There is no solution. You can't solar your way into development.
Speaker 1You can't.
Speaker 2Europe has tried it. It works, but you have to have a grid. Even if you want to have solar, you have to have a grid. So the solar goes to a grid, then you sell that power from the grid. Europe has got feeding tariffs where you make your own solar. If you don't need it, you sell the power back to the grid. Then the grid goes to the guys that need power during the day to make manufacturing. So we've gotten lazy in Africa. We haven't trained our people The roots, when they ask Nigerians, what is the number
Speaker 2one goal? They ask Nigerian youth, what's your number one goal in life? Do you know what they said our number one goal in life was? To emigrate. No, no, no, no. To emigrate.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2The number one goal of every Nigerian youth aged 20 to 35 is to leave Nigeria. And to go where? To go abroad.
Speaker 3Why?
Speaker 2Because there are opportunities. Nigerians are very smart people. We built Nollywood. without the government we build fintech without the government if you leave if you take away the nigerian governments overreach on nigeria if you just take it away the gdp will double just double because the government pulls nigeria doesn't help nigeria it pulls nigerians back So these things you are saying, look at Ajao Kuta. I mean, we can talk. There are many examples. Ajao Kuta.
Speaker 1Let me add something about this.
Speaker 7I once did not want to take this article seriously, but there's a guy on the internet.
Speaker 1I'm forgetting his name now.
Speaker 7I'll try to get it and send it to you right here.
Speaker 6This guy, he has a PhD in.
Speaker 1Geology or something, or mining technology. He has actually made the argument.
Speaker 7That uh for the requirements or what we need to basically solarize the world like cover everything we don't have the we don't have enough of those minerals that are commercial or even viable to be mined.
Speaker 6To be able to create all the solar that.
Speaker 7Will solve the world's problems so now we sit down here and we talk about And as you said, when we sit down and talk about, oh, let's just do solar, let's just do solar, the truth is it should be developed towards China and some parts of Southeast Asia that will get most of the solar if there is a shortage of silicon and of germanium.
Speaker 2And the like. Let me give you a story. Nigeria wants to do solar. Nigeria says we should do solar. I mean, the president of Nigeria is not on the national grid. The Prime Minister has removed himself from the grid. He's on solar. Okay, now, we now say we're going to do solar, right? The Nigerian government, the same government that wants to do solar, said we're going to tax solar panels at a point. Solar is... Nigeria has got an existing solar factory before this new one that came. It's in Kaduna. Katsina has got silica.
Speaker 1Silica.
Speaker 2So, if you want to make solar between Kaduna, Katsina, you have everything to make solar panels there. So you ask yourself, why have we not have, don't have a mega, not micro, mega solar factory making solar panels that you're going to give away for free? In Ghana, Ghana, your neighbor Ghana, they give them solar panels away as subsidy. Ghana, not US, Ghana. Nigeria will tell you there's no money. There's no money to give people solar panels. If you
Speaker 2say that solar is a solution, then you should be giving people solar as they pay their tax. You say, okay, this new year, as you pay your tax and you bring your tax certificate, go and take solar panel from the backyard there. This is the only nation where you bring in tractors for agriculture and the tractors are packed for a full year. We bought tractors from Belarus and the tractors are packed. I don't want to beat up the government. The point is that, you know, Africa makes
Speaker 2too many excuses. We say CIA. CIA was in Asia. CIA was in China. There was a guy in Nigeria called Chris Woods. Chris Woods used to be the chairman of the Nigerian China Chamber of Commerce or something like that. He was given a story once in Lagos. He said the Chinese in the 70s, they couldn't go to Europe because there were communists, they were fighting in Europe. Do you know where they came to learn how to build bridges? Do you know what nation they went to to learn how to build bridges? Do you know where they went to?
Speaker 1Yes.
Speaker 2The Chinese came to Nigeria to look at the overhead bridges in Lagos Island. Back then, you could count on your hands the nation that had overhead bridges. Lagos has about six. When you just leave Yaba, from Yaba to the island, you are on overhead. It was a wonder of the modern world. That was a swamp. That was a swamp. We built the damn bridges there Did first stack. Invited everybody to come and see the bridges. Light everywhere.
Speaker 2Bridge everywhere. Over swamp. We converted the minor, everything to livable areas. So the Chinese came here to study because they're going to go to Europe. And I'm like, wow. The same China today is the one building railways and bridges in Nigeria. We can't build it again. If you count engineers in Nigeria that were graduating after ASU strike, they can't fix generators. So you are an engineer, mechanical engineering, but you can't fix generator in Nigeria. I'm not an engineer, so I don't know why it's different, but I'm a
Speaker 2finance guy. I can do present value the same way a US guy can do. But if you say you are a mechanical engineer or electrical engineer, we can't do POP plastic. We have to import it from Togo. We can't do doors. We can't do... Even the solar, the inverter, we are not making the inverters in Nigeria. The panels, maybe we make them some later. So it's... There's plenty, Kilkulu. I think your comments are well taken. I think we have to.
Speaker 3You know the thing, right?
Speaker 2Yeah, you know the thing. Kilkulu, real quick, so I can get to see you in here real quick.
Speaker 1Okay, okay, okay.
Speaker 7So finally, to wrap up everything, what I was actually wanting to end up with is the thing is in Nigeria, too, we don't believe.
Speaker 1In having a competent state. State capacity is very important.
Speaker 7For instance, you see this whole thing we're talking about how China now.
Speaker 1Is doing the hardware.
Speaker 7To memory, doing EUVs, DUVs, and all of that stuff. This is investment that was started.
Speaker 6By the Chinese government.
Speaker 7Proper investment, even the infrastructure and everything.
Speaker 1The railways, the high-speed railways that is the longest in the world. This was done by Chinese bureaucrats.
Speaker 7Nigeria cannot even be sure that if they say they want to put 5,000 Naira in the hands of 10,000 Nigerians, that those 10,000 Nigerians will get that 5,000 Naira.
Speaker 2You are talking as if you are as if it's fiction. The Nigerian accountant general just said that the monies that were given to poor people, they cannot prove it went to poor people. Let me close this argument. Let me tell you, there's a guy on Twitter, Alex. Alex is running Olympiads for kids. Alex took Nigerian children taught by Nigerian teachers to a world Olympiad and Nigerian kids came first.
Speaker 2So it's not a function of that we're not intelligent. If you take those Nigerian kids, I bet you, I bet you see all those kids that Alex is training, I can assure you the government of Canada, the government of the UK, of the US is going to be very interested in bringing those kids over on scholarship and taking them over there. What do you think visa lottery is? Why do you think the Canadian government gives you visa to go to Canada? Because they like you?
Speaker 1No.
Speaker 2Because you are the best in your nation. When the Babylonians took over Egypt, what did they do? They got the best Israeli kids, Jewish kids, right? Turned to Babylon. Same thing.
Speaker 4Same, same, same.
Speaker 2It works. You go to a place, you take the best. Then the Israeli people were saying, oh, Babylonian CIA is causing Israel not to progress. If you don't value something, it will go away. Let me make it sound better for you. The Nigerian government, that same competition or a similar competition, did not pay for Nigerian students to go for that competition because they said they didn't have any money. But a private guy took Nigerian students to Math Olympiad
Speaker 2and they won awards. And we're also celebrating them. It's the same thing we're doing. But we'll not address your point about Dangote. It's better that a Nigerian, an African like Dangote, can take $ 20 billion and invest in Lagos, Nigeria. And we call him a monopolist. Dan, he didn't do it. I see the guy you talk about on Twitter. And everyone is saying Dangote is a monopolist. I can assure you.
Speaker 2Dangote's biggest problem is that he's in Nigeria. If Dangote built this refinery in Rwanda, in Ghana, in South Africa, that nation would have imposed a mandatory monopoly that only Dangote can operate in that nation because he invested $ 20 billion. He's creating jobs. He's bringing in revenues. These export revenues you saw, The non-oil export revenues are from Dangote. The
Speaker 2revenues I posted, when you look at the export numbers, the non-export revenues are Dangote exporting aviation fuel and fertilizer to Brazil and the US and the UK. Dangote alone is doing nearly on export income from byproducts of crude. He's nearly at a quarter of NNPC's exports of crude oil. We have that sort of sector here. What are Nigerians saying? He's a monopolist. Labor wants to go and shut him down.
Speaker 2The regulator said his products are fake. That's how Nigerians rule. So whatever anyone says, whatever anyone says, if I was a private, if Nigeria was owned by me, it was a company, and one divisional head in one company invested money I was making for my company a quarter of my revenues. Every week I would invite that guy to head office. And I would ask him, do you have any problem? Anybody disturbing you, tell me. So we've got
Speaker 2to also applaud Danguti. If he didn't do it, a foreigner would have done it. I don't want to belittle what Eleme Petrolemka is doing. They are investors in the country. I support them. If Dangote had not done it, those guys would have done it. And they will not, Dangote brought Nigerians and Indians. Who do you think they would have brought? So in the end, Nigerians, we have to be a bit, give these guys some slack. There are people richer than Dangote have not invested a cobo in Nigeria.
Speaker 2I'm not saying it's in Monaco, it's in whatever. They haven't invested a cobo. These guys invested 20 billion. I dare you, I dare you. Go on Twitter or go on Grog or Claude AI and ask it. List to me five nations that have attracted a single investment worth 20 billion, not government-supported. List it for me on your hand. Dangote will be number three. He will be on your first five names there. In the entire world. But because
Speaker 2it's Nigeria, we just... People are even dissing the IPO. Is Dangote want to take your money? Of course he wants to take your money. Is he doing charity? Of course he wants your money. But look at what he has done in the country. There's a 500 megawatt power station in that refinery. 500 megawatt.
Speaker 3How many?
Speaker 2I don't want to go there. Guys, it's your money.
Speaker 7The only issue I have with Dangote is refinery tech.
Speaker 2But that's an investor yeah that's one investor and I've said it.
Speaker 1Here you.
Speaker 2Know so okay and that's the point I'm making again I think Niger should ease off on the guy ease off a bit on the gentleman and stop all this I say it again His risk is because he's in Nigeria. If this refinery has found its way to Rwanda, you say you want to... Do you know Nigerians are importing PMS with Dangote? Do you know that Dangote has to go and buy crude oil from the US when we
Speaker 2have crude oil in Nigeria? If you ask them, they'll tell you it's because there's a contract that Shell and Chevron will take crude oil before Dangote. Which nation Which nation will sign that sort of contract that when a local has built a $ 20 billion refinery, that foreigners will get crude oil first? Which nation does that? So, sometimes, you know, this man will do, do, do, do, do.
Speaker 2He's building one in Kenya. He's building one in Kenya. You know why he's building one in Kenya? Because, you know, you know. I won't say it, but, you know, let's be looking. CU, thanks for waiting in there, CU. Thank you so much, sir. I think you're going to take us home, sir. CU, go ahead.
Speaker 3Yeah, I can hear you.
Speaker 2Yes, I can hear you, sir.
Speaker 3Yeah, I just want to ask a few questions.
Speaker 6Go for it.
Speaker 3So, I'm just mainly looking at GDP.
Speaker 8I know when the numbers came out, the price came out, a lot of people tend to be excited.
Speaker 3I don't know whether they understand what's going on or they're just... sheep if you get what.
Speaker 8I'm saying um i'm obviously a contrarian you know when i studied economics in university you know obviously if you study economics in university they tell you the way to measure a country's way to measure a country's growth is your gdp but you also have a contrarian view and my contrarian view is obviously if you're an investor and you look at gdp to use a lagging indicator first and foremost but in terms of nigeria there are other factors that i think um you have.
Speaker 3To also impute as well, such as for me, most importantly, it's productivity growth.
Speaker 4This is where productivity growth is very important, but I don't want to go into depth with it, but it's.
Speaker 3Very important in an economy because I think unless you reach.
Speaker 4Growth faster than other methods, so for example, if.
Speaker 8You look at post-2008, G7 countries up until recently didn't recover.
Speaker 4They had no negative productivity growth. And Nigeria's case, I think, is below, is a negative. So, for me, I think that's very important, looking at the print. My question is, basically, if you want to look at improving the.
Speaker 8Contribution to GDP from agriculture and manufacturing, which I'm a very big.
Speaker 4Supporter of, how do you apart from the power issue, how do you then make it marketable?
Speaker 3How do you then make it interesting?
Speaker 4How do you make it in such a way that, obviously, in the business cycle, there are going to be ups and downs, but how do you make it in such.
Speaker 1A way that people would be willing to invest in it?
Speaker 4So, for example, look at Chinese real estate, for example. They pumped so much credit into the system, and obviously, it became a bubble.
Speaker 8In fact, I was even telling someone that, you know, could we create some sort of artificial manufacturing bubble in Nigeria, so that even though I know bubbles have the after effect of, you know, things crash, but the assets are valuable.
Speaker 4So how do you then make it, first of all, interesting to people?
Speaker 6Yeah.
Speaker 4Make it interesting, make it a way that look, the most important thing is let us diversify our international revenue mix.
Speaker 3It shouldn't just be petroleum products, it shouldn't just be oil.
Speaker 8How then do we have those inputs from manufacturing, agriculture?
Speaker 3Yeah. Amigos, have a good day. international revenue mix? I think that's just my question for today.
Speaker 2Yes, it's a fantastic one, a good one to close on. So, Siyu, let's go back to history. The first Nigerian mass economic empowerment program was based around agriculture. It's become a mini-name still. You used to have Operation Feed the Nation. We used to have dry season farming. So the government understands the role agriculture pays to job creation, to productivity growth, and all that. But what we have failed to do, right, is not the policies that have been fantastic, but to
Speaker 2implement and actualize the policies that we have failed. Let me give you a good example. Why will I, as an investor, not invest in agriculture? Because it's risky. If I put in a million, quail eggs can come and eat my seeds, Or guys with cows can come and eat the farm produce. So it's risky and my money is gone. So what can I do as a government? I can say I'm going to de-risk the value chain. What does that mean? That means I can say if
Speaker 2you invest in agriculture, what's a million dollars in a real farm? And I give you the pharmacies, registered pharma, blah, blah, blah, that kind of nonsense, right? If you lose money, the government will pay you back. via an insurance company, you know, backstopping and all that. If you de-risk that, then why won't I invest in agriculture? I have friends in America that bought seed, invested in feed farming in Nigeria and all that. And they said the biggest issue was that if the villagers were eating the produce, this is food
Speaker 2meant for feed, but it was Akamo. They were turning the thing to Akamo to eat. But if there was a de-risk, then they would invest more money and do CCTV and all that because they know the government is going to pay them back if they lose. And that's just an example. But you've got to go to the market and de-risk the value chain where it has to do with capital. Come in there and backstop it, right? Backstop it. That's one. Number two, and I'm using my chin up thought here. The thing again with agriculture is
Speaker 2to say, okay, this is what produces income revenues for Nigeria. and not just revenues, employment for Nigeria. If you take employment as a number one activity in Nigeria, then of course you have to also then go and support that. But let me come to where I want us to land. The government today, led by the, let's look at it, the financial governance today, led by the Central Bank of Nigeria, they've put inflation as their number one target. When you fight inflation, you raise interest rates because you want to
Speaker 2make the cost of money expensive. In finance, there's no free lunch. If you make the cost of money expensive, folks that invest in liquid, in fiscal assets, make a lot of money. But SMEs, manufacturers that use money to grow the business, they suffer. So many governments in the world like to have a hybrid because they recognize that the central banks or the Federal Reserve exists for price stability.
Speaker 2So they are doing their job. I'm not attacking CBN. CBN is doing its job when it keeps rates high because rates high stop inflation and the job of the CBN is to fight inflation. But you cannot in a growing and developing economy like Nigeria or any African economy say I'm going to copy 100% Western economic ideas. You have to go whatever name you call it, subsidy, support,
Speaker 2direct support to the manufacturers that are at the bottom of the value chain that cannot borrow because when they borrow commercially, they can't make profit. We did it in the past. MFLA did a lot of bad things, but used to do direct support, direct support to industries in Nigeria. The Dangote refinery we're talking about would not have existed without Godwin and Mephile, giving it direct allocation of capital
Speaker 2to him. When he was struggling, it was an investment case, he gave him direct supply of capital and said, I'm doing this because down the line, you are going to be a supplier of capital, foreign capital, back to Nigeria. It's happening today. Dangote 2 is now supplying foreign capital back to Nigeria because a CBN governor gave it scarce foreign resources Fact check me to Dangote. We have to do more of that. You have to go down the
Speaker 2line and say, what is the problem with textiles? Is it this chemical? Who makes that chemical? Oh, it's not made in Nigeria. Okay, we are going to support you to make that chemical in Nigeria. America is doing it today. They're investing in chips. They're investing in rare earth minerals. They're investing in Intel. They are going back and saying, we are going to invest locally because it's a national security, not just economic imperatives. If you say food is national security,
Speaker 2because it is, why are you not de-risking fertilizer, food packaging, and all that food storage, food transportation? Why is not a priority in Nigeria? And that's where I think CU are getting it wrong. that we are applying while looking at Nigeria as a developed Western economy, like Denmark. So because there's high inflation in Denmark, we increase the interest rate in Denmark, then inflation comes down, then the people
Speaker 2would not consume, but they would be okay because they have savings. The average Nigerian, we did the numbers here last week or so, 68% are poor. Not poor, extremely poor. Poor as in they can't afford food. Forget savings. We're not talking about poor that, you know, there's poor like you are broke. That's not the point I'm talking about. Poor as in they cannot eat. You can't go and tell that guy that foreign jobs are going up. So,
Speaker 2come back home. and say, yes, we want to fight price stability, but we've abandoned growth for too much. You have, take out a billion and start to do direct support to SMEs. And you can do it easily through power. Through power, there has to be a way where you can tell SMEs that if you buy diesel and you can track that diesel to your gas, to your generator, and you can show us output from your company, we
Speaker 2will subsidize your diesel costs by 90%. Do something like that. Because when you do something like that, you are affecting prices. So you are bringing inflation down. You are affecting consumption. You are bringing consumption down. You are, again, you are de-risking the whole manufacturing value chain because it's driven by power. But to just say, we're going to do band A because the economics say we must do band A to a nation where 68% cannot eat Again, forget that they
Speaker 2can't save, they can't eat. You have to do band A. You've taken away fuel subsidy. You've taken away dollar subsidy. I support those things. But if you take it away, what are you giving them in return? That's why the numbers are showing us that trade is weak. Nobody can afford anything. So to answer your question directly, sir, you've got to go back to an economy. that you have mixed government intervention. We are fighting inflation, we get it, but we are still going to support the SMEs. We
Speaker 2are still going to support our doctors, our education people, our security services. We are going to go and do direct support. If America can support farmers, why can Nigeria support farmers? It doesn't make any sense. So see, I said a lot. I just hope I've tried to at least give you a bit of insight. Does that make sense?
Speaker 1Yeah, it does.
Speaker 3It makes a lot of sense.
Speaker 4The thing about food security is if you compare it to what's happening today in the energy markets, there's a thing they're talking about in terms of China having energy security. And what that does is if you have food security, is that too much government intervention?
Speaker 3Are you putting too much of these. These players in the hands of the government. Because if you say, for example, you do food security, the.
Speaker 4Government's incentive is different from the private sector incentive.
Speaker 3It's no longer about profits anymore. It's more about, in terms of the.
Speaker 4Government side, how can we use these limited resources to protect our future.
Speaker 3In a world that is volatile?
Speaker 4Also, one thing I want to also say in terms of manufacturing, you know, there was an article in the Financial Times that they were talking about, you know, is the UK well enough with China?
Speaker 3How is the UK going to benefit.
Speaker 1From, you know, China's shock?
Speaker 3You know, China doing what they did again, but part two. You know, someone said, look, that, you know, if you, how did he put it?
Speaker 4He said that the UK shouldn't forget about manufacturing in a world of, you know, Well said, well said.
Speaker 3If a country like the UK, which.
Speaker 4Is not known for its manufactures, more of a service economy, is saying, look, I don't think you should abandon it. And in fact, most of this manufacturing would come from steel and textiles anyway. But if you're saying we don't want to abandon it, why can't our country... Even if, you know, in a large-scale photoshoot, you know.
Speaker 2See, you're right. So, look, if you notice, well, in Nigeria, you see a lot of Chinese guys come to Nigeria now to open a factory. Have you noticed in Nigeria? Lots of Chinese people come to Nigeria to open a factory. If you ask, they'll tell you, oh, it's the government's policy.
Speaker 3No.
Speaker 2It's because of Trump's trade war with China. China's now doing transshipment. They are going to Mexico. They are going to Costa Rica. They are going to Canada. They are going to any nation where they can ship the manufacturing out to then export to the U.S. to avoid the tariff. Nigeria has a 15% tariff. Canada has a 30% tariff. Makes perfect sense for them. So question for you, CU. Why can't the government designate that every Nigerian state on the coast of the Atlantic is a free trade state? Not free trade zone. Lagos, Ogun, Benin. No, Benin is
Speaker 2not on the coast. Delta, Bielsa, Cross River. Any Nigerian state on the coast of Atlantic is a free trade state, meaning any international investor can come to Nigeria, set up shop, and not pay one kubo in corporate income tax. If you want gas, you want power, get the gas from the ground and use it. Don't pay us any tax. Why can't we do that? Bold, massive idea. You know what will happen? All the aluminum companies in Europe that
Speaker 2today can't function because of the Russian gas issue, they will all rush to Nigeria. We have Alscore there, it's there. They will all rush to Nigeria because there's gas in Nigeria. They're not going to pay tax, they're not going to pay imports, they're not going to pay exports. They're all going to rush and come to Nigeria and create factories in Nigeria. Then what happens? Where will they stay? Where will they eat? Where will they drink? Where will they buy inputs from? From Nigeria! So we will then turn the coast of Nigeria to a massive manufacturing zone. The exact same thing China did. So instead of the Americans,
Speaker 2because labor is expensive in America, they will come to Nigeria and make Pampas. Why is it cheaper? There's power. The Pampas company will pay for its own gas, make its own power. It won't pay tax. Oh, Carlo, we're going to lose tax. No, you're not going to lose tax. They won't pay import tax, but they will pay P.E. They will export P.E. They will pay for trucks. They will pay for storage. That's where you get them. They will pay for telecom. They will pay for flights. They will pay for everything. It's not a tax. But you've
Speaker 2now attracted that investment to come to Nigeria. You know why? It will take you about 15 years to start to reap the benefits of that investment. But once you start, they can't move. That's why they can't leave China. They have locked in China's economy. It's hard to move. Apple took a long time to go from China to India. Nigeria speaks English. We are the good time zone. We are a young population. We should be a manufacturing base in the whole of the world. Because we just have
Speaker 2all the attributes. Our weather is perfect. But we're not doing manufacturing. Because the government wants to build roads, powers by themselves. No, you can't do that. So, if we start to think of smart ideas like this, to say we're going to work with the government, the state, local governments, and pass sort of a law like this, even if you don't do the whole coastal states, make Lagos a tax-free state now, and attract, make it, let everything go there to Lagos. There's bias there.
Speaker 3See you.
Speaker 2The largest investment that was announced, not oil, not gas, in Nigeria's history, That was not oil, not gas. Do you know where it went to? Do you know what state it went to? Do you want to guess?
Speaker 3No, you go ahead.
Speaker 6I'm listening.
Speaker 2That was Cross River when GE was going to invest a billion dollars to build railways in Cross River because Nigeria had given, I think, GE back then the colour to build out the whole Nigerian railway system. A billion dollars. And actually, they came to Calabar. There was some digging of shovels, but it all died away. That's the potential that we have for non-oil. But you've got to be smart about this. We have all these attributes. We have a diaspora. If you have a good quote-unquote government that
Speaker 2Nigerians abroad trust, you know what you can bring back to the country? Go to any hospital in Maryland. Go to any oil company in Houston. Go to any factory, any accounting firm in London. There's a Nigerian there. China has, is it a thousand brains? What do you call it? A thousand minds or a thousand lights? where they are bringing Chinese people back to China with the nudge that they have.
Speaker 4But don't you worry about, you know, if you want to do some of these larger, attractive projects, aren't you worried about policy risk?
Speaker 3Policy risk in terms.
Speaker 4Of, for example, let's say this new government comes in and says, we're going to do.
Speaker 7X, Y, Z.
Speaker 2I agree with you. That's what I, that's exactly, That's exactly what I'm saying, CU, that we've got to sit down and do it. That's exactly... Is there any government that says they don't want foreign investment in Nigeria? Is there any political party that says they don't want foreign investment? Is there any political party that says they want to increase taxes? Is there any? Is there any political party that says they don't want to reduce unemployment? It's how it's framed. If Nigeria sits down today, whether you are APC, Labour, PDP, NRC, and you say we want to increase jobs, a party
Speaker 2will say, no, I don't increase jobs. But if you make it an APC thing, then it's not going to fly. When Americans were building the highways that go across nations, was it a Democrat or Republican thing? Same with China and all this. When Europe is fighting Russia, are they saying it's labor and conservative fighting Russia? There are some things we have to agree on. And then once we agree on it, and that's what we're feeling, From 1960 to about 1975, Nigeria didn't have budget for infrastructure. We
Speaker 2had development plans, five-year, six-year development plans. And I was mostly with you guys. They said, we're going to build these hospitals, these roads, these schools, these power stations, development plan. And they did it. If you go and search my tweets for development plans, you'll see all what Nigeria built on our development plans. We then abandoned development plans and went into annual budgets. Now we have Coastal Road funded by annual budgets. In the past, that road would have
Speaker 2been on a development plan. So whether APC wins or Labour wins, it's in the plan. You have to fund it. Which means before you go into the plan, there will be serious debate. They will say, where is the money going to come from? Today, we just wake up. We are building a coastal road from Lagos to Calabar. At the same time, we are building a road from Sokoto to Badagry. At the same time, about in lagos airport at the same time we're doing a gas master plan to go from ajalkuta to kano at the same time we are innovating all the railway stations in nigeria we
Speaker 2are going to do the eastern railway standard gauge from lagos all the way to mid-degree at the same time we are going to build school it's not possible china has a trillion dollars in reserves they do 10-year plan these 10 years we're going to do this next 10 years we're going to do this that's what china is doing Nigeria is owing debt. I want to build road. Although I've not heard one project see you that the government has announced that I didn't like. I love all
Speaker 2their projects. They are all fantastic projects. If we build a railway road, from pedagree to sokoto the gdp nature would double if we build a coastal railway from lagos to calabar gdp would double but how are you going to fund it you just can't say i will build it because it's good the bible says before you do anything you consider the cause this is the bible it's not what there's not everything is good but not everything is expedient you just can't build everything because it's good
Speaker 2You can't say, I'm going to build power stations all across Nigeria because it's good. How are you going to fund it? That's the nitty-gritty of national planning. You sit in a room, you call the opposition, okay, what are the critical projects, top three in Nigeria today? Power must enter somewhere. Can we fund it?
Speaker 3No.
Speaker 2Okay, let's do a policy that says that the private sector can fund power. That's how it's done. if you keep on making it that PDP has agenda, Labour has agenda, then you will never get anything done more than four, eight years. And that's where Nigeria is feeling.
Speaker 3Yeah, and there's also, at last, you know, there's precedent to it.
Speaker 4The reason why I'm saying it is because, you know, we've done something like this before.
Speaker 3Like, for example, look at cement in 03 on that bus and job.
Speaker 6What happened?
Speaker 3What were the effects of that?
Speaker 2It was successful. It was successful. You went from from cement armadas in the 70s to importing cement as a major import to now having a local cement manufacturing base to then export cement where we have failed is to now drive those cement exports to say if you are manufacturing locally we have to get a local dividend that the price have to go down that's what we have failed it's not that the cement policy failed but we have not moved on with it aganga came to nigeria and said okay If you want to do cars, you
Speaker 2want to import cars to Nigeria, don't bring it in fully built. Bring it in secret. CKD. Even that CKD meant that you had a Ford in Lagos, you had Corsair, you had a Namco in Anambra, where people were bringing in things, assembling in, adding in some value, and then exporting or importing locally. So you have to keep on evolving policy. But those policies have got to be national. They have to be passed into law. that even when a new government comes, you don't change it. You don't just wake up and say, I'm going to change it. Let me give you a good, and I'm going to
Speaker 2close with this, guys. Environmental sanitation, I think it was started in 1980. Correct me if I'm wrong, guys. Correct me if I'm wrong. Environmental sanitation day. That was the longest running policy. Maybe NYC is longer than it. But every Saturday in Nigeria, we did environmental sanitation. And everyone said, because it was a good idea. Whether we did it well or didn't do it well wasn't the point. It was a good idea. We knew that the environment was dirty.
Speaker 2And it was a sad thing to go and clean. It stayed for a long time. Now I think we need to go back to it. Because we simply can't pick up trash. But why was it a good idea? Everyone bought in. It was a simple policy. It wasn't political. Clean your environment. Simple, simple policy, clean environment. Where we are failing to see you is that we are running the government as if it's a PDP, APC, Labour or NRC government. Whoever is going to win the elections in
Speaker 2America in November, do you know what's going to happen? The yellow bus will still pick up kids in America to go to school. That would never change. 911 will still work. If you call an ambulance, it will come and pick you. That would never change. It will never change, whoever is in power. And Nigeria runs on four to eight-year cycles. We've got to break out. We've done it before. Go back to development plans. Have a Nigerian conference, economic conference. Put it in the plan. There is no political party
Speaker 2that says, I plan not to create jobs, or I plan to cause inflation, or I plan to have expensive food. So if that's your plan, walk back to the answer. How can we get cheap food? Then walk back to the answer and then put in the plan. So whoever is the president can implement it. That's really, really what you have to do. Whoever is the president. Final example, see you. Final, I promise. When Obasanjo was the president,
Speaker 2he wanted to connect the east of Nigeria to the west of Nigeria because there is no connection I mean real connection from the east of Nigeria to the west of Nigeria. Economic, not economic. When we built the express road, we went from the port in Apapa to Ojota. Then we went slightly right and then we stopped there. The roads outside Lagos are no longer 10 lane. The 10 lane goes from Apapa port. Apapa port is a 10
Speaker 2lane expressway that goes all the way to Lagos toolkit and it stops. The plan was that taking that road to the east and to the north. We stopped. Okay, our passenger comes and says we have to do east-west road. So the road will continue from the east to the west. It will go near the coast. So it will go near the coast and all that. That road is not completed. It's not completed. The east-west express is not completed. When good luck came, good luck says, okay, you know what
Speaker 2we're going to do? We're going to build a railway. Not a road, but a railway. Because railways are cheaper. Perfect idea. From the east to the west. That was the largest single contract ever issued to a Chinese company in history. The road to go from, the railway to go from the east to the west of Nigeria. The plans were developed. If you look online, you'll see the plan that was developed by the Chinese government. Federal government stamp on it. going through all those states and all that, from Lagos to Calabar. That rail was abandoned. Tinubu has come.
Speaker 2We're now building a coastal road from Lagos to Calabar. So we have the east-west road from Lagos to Calabar. We have the east-west railway from Lagos to Calabar. We now have the coastal road from Lagos to Calabar. Same project, same economic benefits, but everybody wants to label a project for himself. I saw the governor of Edo saying that the president has said that they will now put Edo in the coastal road. Edo is already in the east-west road.
Speaker 2Edo is not on the Atlantic Ocean. But the governor is saying that the president has put Edo on the coastal road. Edo is not on the coast. But the governor is celebrating on a coastal road when he's already on the east-west road. See what I'm saying? So it's not the... There is something wrong with the way we are governing. We know these things. On this space, we've said it now. So that means if I know it,
Speaker 2they know it. But we don't sit down and... Are you telling me that if Tinopu calls Peter Ruby, Atiku, who else is running? All three. And they say, okay, we want to build roads in Nigeria. What is the most important? And they bring in all those economies. They bring in World Bank. They say, okay. We have made, according to the government, we have made 20 trillion in revenues. 20 trillion. These are the government's figures. 20 trillion. We want to build roads in Nigeria. Peter Obi, Atiku, Tinubu,
Speaker 2what's your plan? They present their plan. Economists look at the plan and say, well, the road that will give you the most economic benefit is the road from this one to this one. Or the road from this one to this one. Do we agree?
Speaker 1Yes.
Speaker 2Oh yeah, Jules Vega, take the money, go and build it. Why won't that work? It will work. That's why they won't do it. Because it's no longer an APC has fixed Nigeria in 12 years or PDP has fixed it in 24 years. That's the problem. They want to do self-aggrandizement project and not project that will actually impact. There is a railway today we are building. Oh my God, Nigeria won't kill me. We are building a railway today. from Kano and Kaduna to Niger Republic. That railway is
Speaker 2not connected to the railways in Nigeria. So the railway will go from standard rail gauge, Kaduna-Kano-Niger Republic, but it cannot cross Kaduna-Kano because Kaduna-Kano is narrow gauge. So why are you building it? So the railway, the whole loan is just to take goods from Kano-Kaduna to Niger? Is that the most important use of money? And in all fairness, Dinobu didn't do it. He was a past admin. But
Speaker 2is that the best use of money? I've seen your tweet. I'm laughing. But as if I'm... Google it. Don't say Caluset. Google it. It's a standard gauge rail. The Nigerian rails are narrow gauge. But we're still building it. We're doing a massive railway transition there. So it's not an issue of that we don't know what CU is saying or that we don't have economies in Nigeria. But the political economy in Nigeria is very, very weak in translating what
Speaker 2would help the people. On that note, guys, I have to call it a day. I want to thank you all, all sincerely for hopping in here and being with me every Sunday by 7 p.m. Like I said, everyone wants to talk Dangote. The whole chat on my DM, everything here, you guys have left GDP or Dangote. We're going to talk Dangote. We're going to bring you guys from Bumble, I hope. We're going to talk about it in detail. We'll give you the numbers. I also make sure that you understand how to review that product. Let me just say that if you want to buy that stock, it's
Speaker 2not something you buy today and tomorrow you are going to see profits. Just keep that in your mind. It's something you want to buy and say, okay, bottom box, let's see how it is as a matter of fact, equities all equities are not for short term people, it's for you, buy and you hold, so thank you guys for being here, my name is Kalu Aja hope you guys will join us again next week, this week when we talk again about other issues on the weekends, on Sundays we're always here, 7pm West African time, there's lots
Speaker 2of people that have been here with me, all the white is it, Ken, Henry appreciate you guys for being here all the time all right guys thanks so much for being here i'll see you guys later have a good sunday and bye
Nobody is credited on this episode yet.
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/the-way-i-see-it--5905056/support.
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/the-way-i-see-it--5905056/support.
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/the-way-i-see-it--5905056/support.
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/the-way-i-see-it--5905056/support.
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/the-way-i-see-it--5905056/support.