How Visual Aids Make or Break Learning: Design, Simplicity, and Accessibility (Revisited)
52 minAudio
Drop us a message! We'd love to hear from you. Need to create an e-learning presentation but don’t have an eye for good visuals? This episode is for you! We revisit a great past episode with Diane Elkins, instructional design pro and owner of Artisan Learning. There’s so much solid advice in this episode on what works, what to avoid, and how visuals impact the learning experience (probably more than you think). Diane explains how bad visuals inhibit learning, why simpler is often better, and why “slides” are due a name change. Plus, she gets on her soapbox to explain the real goal of e-learning. We also look at some examples of pretty, plain, and hideous slides to compare, based on a real experiment Diane used to test out visual design. One thing to note: We do share some visuals in this episode of good and bad design choices, so for the full experience, we recommend checking out the episode on YouTube. Learning points from the episode include: 00:00 - 02:44 Introduction to Diane and her work 02:44 - 04:57 The role in visuals in e-learning 04:57 - 07:33 Best practices for visuals and what to avoid 07:33 - 11:11 Mindset shifts to avoid over-the-top visuals 11:11 - 13:20 Why visuals are even more important in e-learning scenarios 13:20 - 16:25 How to decide what information to put on a slide 16:25 - 21:53 Diane’s pretty, plain, and hideous visual design experiment 21:53 - 25:00 Why simple is often better for learning 25:00 - 29:34 Why “is it helpful?” is the most important question to ask 29:34 - 31:31 Why visual aids should always be in service of the audience 31:31 - 38:42 An example of whether we should decorate or illustrate with visuals 38:42 - 46:18 Can we fix it? Diane’s advice to bad design examples 46:18 - 49:49 Speed round questions 49:49 - 51:40 Outro Important links and mentions: Visit e-Learning Uncovered: www.elearninguncovered.com Visit Artisan Learning: www.artisanelearning.com Connect with Diane on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/dpelkins/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_03I think one of the things that's important is to not try to give your visual aids too many purposes. Classroom training, you're making your PowerPoint. And they want the PowerPoint to also be the instructor notes. I don't mean the notes pane, I mean the slide. And so they're making their visual aids be their instructor notes. And hello, where's the worst place to put instructor notes? Behind me? I mean, really? Is that that's where I should put my notes?
SPEAKER_03So that the students can see my notes? No. I mean, there's presenter view. Get out an index card. Nobody will mind if you put your notes on an index card or you have a piece of paper in your hand. So your slides are not for you.
SPEAKER_00Good morning, good evening, good afternoon, wherever you are and wherever you're watching from. My name is Matt Pierce, host of Visual Lounge. I'm getting ready to go on vacation. I've got this episode. I wanted to go through it again because it's such a great episode with Diane Elkins. So I think you're gonna really like what you hear. If you're interested at all in visual design, not only from a like a how do I make my instructional design look better, but why should I do that? And you're also interested in accessibility, Diane is someone that you need to listen to. She is just fantastic. So I'd encourage you to it's a longer episode, but go through it because there's so much great information here about using visuals.
SPEAKER_00Now, if you are listening to podcasts, there are a couple sections, just as a heads up, that are better as visuals. And we got some great examples, and one of them, oh my gosh, it is it's actually looking at a hideous example and getting Diane's advice on how you would make it better. And so I recommend if you get a chance, go check out those. You can scrub to them so you can find them, they'll be easy to see. You will not miss it, trust me. But if you we also try our best to describe them so you won't miss too much. So with that said, let's dive into our episode with Diane Elkins. Our guest today is Diane Elkins, who is a co-owner of Artisan eLearning, a custom e-learning development company and eLearning Uncovered, where she helps people build courses they're proud of.
SPEAKER_00She has built a reputation as a national e-learning expert by being a frequent speaker at um uh if I could stalk, I would be I would be an expert too, but I can't. By being a frequent speaker at major industry events for ATD, the Learning Guild, and training magazine. Her favorite topics include accessibility, instructional design, and articulate storyline. She is co-author of the popular e-learning uncover book series, as well as eLearning Fundamentals, a practical guide from ATD Press. She's a past board member of the Northeast Florida and Metro DC chapters of ATD.
SPEAKER_00And with that said, please welcome Diane Elkins to the Visual Lounge. Hi there. Well, hey, thank you so much for being with me today. You bet. We're gonna start kind of broad here. I'm curious, there's a lot of opinions about good e-learning, bad e-learning. What role do you think visuals have in kind of tipping the balance? Because I don't think it's gonna be like it's not the only thing that makes e-learning good, right? But what role do you think it has in tipping the balance towards good e-learning versus stuff that's maybe less successful or less helpful?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, well, one thing that I think is really important to know is that good visuals can't fix bad training. You know, if if we don't have information that's helpful, it doesn't matter what the images are. I don't care how pretty it is. So pretty can't be the driving force, is going back to that word helpful. It's one of my favorite words. At artisan, one of our core values is to be knowledgeable and helpful. Our job is to go out there into the world and put information in people's hands so that they know how to do their jobs better.
SPEAKER_03And everything we do has to drive that. Now, at the same time, if it looks terrible, that can first of all inhibit learning. If I can't read your font, I mean we have the ability through font and color choices to induce a migraine, right? You know, electric blue and lemon yellow. Don't know. I mean, we have it, we have the opportunity to actually inhibit learning. Um, some of the research, um I like Ruth Colvin-Clark's um research on this, on such that in many cases you can learn just as well with a simple diagram as a complex diagram.
SPEAKER_03In fact, in some cases, people can learn better from a simpler diagram. But learning is only one aspect of it. You want people to take it, you want people to believe you, you want people to assign you enough credibility that they want to go adopt the things you're trying to get them to adopt. You want them to maybe say nice things about it to their coworkers. And visual design does have a lot to do with that. Because if your message is in an unprofessional looking package, people will doubt your message.
SPEAKER_00Well, there goes, I'm just starting to check off all the questions it's gonna ask you about, right? Like, okay, there we go. Uh let's talk about that though for a second, because I think there is a there is a sense of like what's the role of aesthetics? And like you said, like bad aesthetics can create migraines, it can create problems, it can make it so uh people don't learn. I know there's a study, and it this is completely different space, but it's about audio quality. That people who listen, like if you have an expert and their audio quality is bad, they'll actually be perceived as less intelligent. Uh I imagine that's the same with visuals.
SPEAKER_00Like if it's bad visual design, it will be seen as less relevant, important. So, how do we how do we know that we're getting to the right level? Right, and I know we've got some stuff we'll talk about, different kinds of levels and approach, but like just generally, what are there best practices here that we should just be aware of?
SPEAKER_03Absolutely. The way I like to look at it is three levels. There's a certain level of professionalism you don't want to go below. You know, uh comic sands in purple. You know, just just don't. Just don't. Um images that are grainy and fuzzy and poor quality. Uh one that's a piece of clip art next to a photo, and they're just it's just a haphazard look. You can't tell where you're supposed to be looking at. That's a level of professionalism you don't want to go below. Then we've got what I'll just call simple, average, maybe even kind of plain.
SPEAKER_03Then there's oh my gosh, that's beautiful. Well, oh my gosh, that's beautiful is great, but it's okay if your mes if your design is simple. Um, I talk about um the three-font rule and the three-color rule. Unless you are a trained professional, you don't need to go with more than three colors: a dark, a light, an accent. And you don't ever need more than three fonts a heading, a body text, and an accent. If you have more than that, you're trying too hard. Now, some people can pull it off. Like I have a friend, he can pull off a plaid blazer and a paisley tie like no one can.
SPEAKER_03Most people will get that wrong. So, for most people, it is a good rule to not mix your patterns unless you happen to know you can pull it off. Same thing with things like fonts and um colors. Is one of the best ways to be professional is to have fewer design elements, which might seem counterintuitive. People might say, Oh, I went to PowerPoint class, I've learned how to do this and this and this, and I'm gonna put it all in one course. Well, that's actually gonna hurt your message. So, simplicity is actually better.
SPEAKER_03Pick a few key colors that you use over and over, a few key fonts over and over. So, in terms of just your your immediate global design choices, keep it simple.
SPEAKER_00So, let me ask you, because I I see that a lot with especially uh beginner p designers, instructional designers, but outside of that too, right? We it's easy to make that mistake of too much. How do we how do you help pull someone back from that? Uh, what what would you say to someone if I'm making that vital mistake? Um, because it feels good to use lots of stuff I know, right? So so how do you help talk somebody off the ledge before they they make that, you know, leap into the oh my gosh, it's too much?
SPEAKER_03I think if your driving force is how cool it is, you're off the mark right there. If it's oh my gosh, I want to learn this, use this new thing, that is the cart before the horse. I can use lots of analogies here.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_03Is ultimately I think what we can do is change the prompts in our own head. So if I'm sitting there looking at something and saying, hmm, what should my slides say? I am seeding my brain to come up with text as my answer. What should my slide say? I am predisposing my answer to be text. What should my bullets be? Again, I'm predisposing it. Uh, what piece of clip art or what image should I put off to the side?
SPEAKER_03You're predisposing yourself for a certain thing. Instead, maybe even stop using the word slide and go back to a word back from like the 90s when you know, before we even had PowerPoint in the classroom back in the dark ages, we talked about visual aids, not slides. I want to see that term come back. If I ask myself, what's the best visual aid for this? So I look at my content and say, based on what I'm trying to accomplish, what visual will best help me get there?
SPEAKER_03Not how can I make this look cooler? Um, how can I make this hip? Hey, can I use that new thing I learned in class? Those are prompts that will send you down the wrong path. But if you ask yourself, what am I trying to accomplish? Is it to explain a point, evoke an emotion, build credibility? What are you trying to accomplish and what visual will best help you get there? That'll help make sure you're staying on track, you're focusing on what's most important, and oh, by the way, it's likely to be helpful.
SPEAKER_00I love it. I love it. And we are, okay, we're doing this. We're bringing back visual aid as a term. So let's hashtag visual aid. We're gonna we're gonna spread it across social media. I love it because I I think it's so easy to get caught up in those things because there's, you know, there's so much you can do, and there's so much like you want the aesthetic. Like I think there's the the trap I I fall, I know I fall into this, is I want the aesthetics because I want it to be believable. I want it to be trusted, I want it to feel good, and sometimes it's hard to like it's a conceptual concept, and so I'm like, I don't have anything visually like that's super valuable here, so I'm gonna make it, I'm gonna make something that's pretty.
SPEAKER_00Uh I think I do an okay job with the pretty. Uh, you know, and I'm I'm pretty good overall balancing, but it it feels like I fall into the trap because short of the other things that I could be doing, it's really sometimes hard to be simple. And so I so I love the advice that the I know there was a comment in the the chat about th the the three colors, three font rule. Um I'm I'm guessing that most of us still probably pair, even in three. Three fonts is hard. That's a lot of fonts to me. I'm gonna get it wrong. I just know I'm gonna get it wrong. Um I I want to take that what you've said though, and I want to talk about something you we talked about prior to the show.
SPEAKER_00You you talked about the difference between like a classroom trainer and like an e-learning module, where even with a subpar or poor kind of visual aids, a classroom trainer can make it work versus like an online standalone module. And I'm guessing that goes for lots of things. It could be an e-learning course, it could be a video, it could be, you know, however you present it, but those won't work, whereas the you know, I I'm a pretty good, pretty good in front of the camera, pretty good in front of the classroom, I could probably make it work regardless.
SPEAKER_00Tell us, tell us why that is.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so a good instructor can carry a bad PowerPoint. If you are, imagine you're sitting in a classroom. Remember those days when we all like gathered in rooms together? Yeah, remember that? So you're sitting in a classroom, most of the time you're looking at the instructor. The instructor is your primary visual. Yeah, you're gonna glance over those slides, and yeah, if they're awful, you're gonna cringe. But it's such a small percentage of the overall visual information you're taking in. Most of the time you're looking at the instructor. Once you're online, that changes.
SPEAKER_03Now, if it's you know, uh a live, if it's instructor-led, yeah, you still perhaps got that person on camera, but the slides are gonna be much bigger. Self-paced e-learning, freestanding video, the visuals, your slides, your visual aids are 100% of your message. So a mediocre slide that barely cut it in the classroom is going to be 10 times worse online. So you've got to up your visual game if you don't have the instructor. And then we also need to think about how often that visual changes.
SPEAKER_03An instructor can spend 10 minutes on one slide in the classroom and it's perfectly normal. 10 minutes in self-paced e-learning is an eternity.
SPEAKER_00That is probably the that's a module, right? Like 10 minutes.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. So we've if we're especially if you're converting from a person being the primary visual, converting it to something that's more self-paced, you've gotta up your visual game.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so we we've we know we've got to up our game. Is is there a rule generally? Because like I think about the visual, we we talked about visual aids, right? It's aiding the content. Um I it's easy for us to talk about slides because uh, you know, a lot of people do PowerPoint, whether it's an e-learning page or module or whatever, it doesn't really matter here. How much information should be on that in that box with that visual? Like, is there balance that happens there? Because I find, I and I'm probably maybe more skewed one way, I I have very little information.
SPEAKER_00Uh like it's one thing, like one idea, and might even be part of an idea, right? Because I'm trying to just reduce how much is there. Other people do the the kind of cardinal thing where they're like, I'm gonna put five bullet points, lots of data. What's what's right here when we're we're kind of incorporating that the visual aid with this?
SPEAKER_03Right. Um, I'm not a fan of rules in that regard, which I know for some people rules are very helpful. So you probably heard of the six by six rule or the ten by ten or the eight by eight, whatever, you know, whatever number people pick, that you shouldn't have more than six bullets with six words each. Well, that's if bullets are even the right choice for that slide. Maybe that slide, the best thing is a video with zero words. You're trying to evoke an emotion. Well, your words aren't going to do that. It is critically important that you know, that will cause nobody to care.
SPEAKER_03So um, a lot of it is again about your your goal, your message. But um I think one of the things that's important is to not try to give your visual aids too many purposes. I think one of the struggles that people have, especially I see this more with classroom training than with self-paced e-learning, but with classroom training, you're making your PowerPoint. And they want the PowerPoint to also be the instructor notes. I don't mean the notes pane, I mean the slide. And so there's they're making their visual aids be their instructor notes.
SPEAKER_03And hello, where's the worst place to put instructor notes? Behind me. I mean, really? Is that that's where I should put my notes so that the students can see my notes? No, I mean, there's presenter view, get out an index card. Nobody will mind if you put your notes on an index card or you have a piece of paper in your hand. So your slides are not for you. Period. Your slides are not for you. And so if you're trying to put enough on there to uh idiot proof yourself so you remember what to say, that's not the goal of your visual aid.
SPEAKER_03Or they say, Oh, well, we want this to stand alone for people who can't make it. If I've done my job, my slides make no sense without me. I love my message, they are not my message. If I want to make a document, then I'll make a document.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I I love that advice because I I'm pretty sure my slides I've turned into many of these conferences. They're not very good without the presentation part of it.
SPEAKER_03Yes. Because they're your visual aid, not a book.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Well, I know you you've done some work around this kind of this concept of uh looking at the kind of variety of what works, what doesn't work, the the levels you talked about earlier. Should we should we dive in to look at those? Would that be good?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, let's take a look. So a couple of years ago, you want me to set it up?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, please set us up.
SPEAKER_03Okay. So a couple of years ago, I made a short course. It was about a 15-minute little course on staying focused on your priorities. And I designed it three ways uh pretty, plain, and hideous. And for each one, the content was exactly the same. The narration was the same, the words were the same, and the content of all the images was the same. So if there's a picture of a clock on one, it's a clock on the other. But what was different is just the graphic design.
SPEAKER_03And I put it out in the world, randomized, and so that people would randomly get one or the other. And I wanted to see, you know, people like um Ruth Colvin Clark's work has already indicated that it shouldn't matter for their ability to learn, unless, again, you can't read it. But I wanted to know does it impact people's ability, willingness to receive and adopt the message? So you want to um show the slides there, Matt? And I will share with what my results were.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Here we go.
SPEAKER_03So we've got a couple slides here of the pretty. I think I have like three or four slides I can show you.
SPEAKER_00So there's slide two, there's it looks good, you know?
unknownYep.
SPEAKER_03Okay. So that's basically how they all worked is for each of the seven points, there was a teaching slide and then one of these activity slides. So same thing over and over again. Now let's look at the plain version, kind of the average, yeah. So it's very similar in concept, but I would bet most people out there in the business world could say, yeah, I could make that. I could, I could pull, I could pull that off. It's not fancy, nobody's gonna win an award from it, nobody's gonna put it up on their refrigerator because they're so proud of it.
SPEAKER_03But it's fine. It's perfectly fine. Okay, let's let's show them the ugly.
SPEAKER_00Are you ready?
SPEAKER_03Because I'm ready. Oh yeah. Oh, that's painful. Yeah, there's our menu. Somebody wanted to use every tool in their toolbox.
SPEAKER_00Got some lots of color options.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Oh, isn't it gorgeous? Yes.
SPEAKER_00Stock photos, those are fine.
SPEAKER_03Brush font. Oh, yeah, that's easy to read, isn't it? So when I was making this course and making the ugly version, I was thinking, Diane, you've gone too far. Like people don't really make it this bad. This is not gonna be really worthwhile. And then I got a PowerPoint from somebody. Someone we were talking to about doing work, and they said, Yeah, we've got some existing training. We'd like to refresh it, we'd like to, you know, bump it up a notch. And when I opened it, I physically jumped back in my chair because of the physical assault that was their course.
SPEAKER_03I'm like, nope, I have not gone too far. This does exist in the world. So I um had about 500 people go through the course, and unfortunately, I didn't get enough survey results for it to really be statistically valid. I was hoping hoping to make this like, you know, actual big R research. Um, but what was really interesting to me is that the plain and the pretty got very similar results. Pretty got a little bit higher. Yeah, so there's again the plain.
SPEAKER_03And it got very similar results to the prettier one. Um and they said that the um what I liked best was the comments, you know, and so people with both courses said, hey, this was helpful. This gave me some useful things to think about. On the plain one, there were also a few comments that says, you know, it would have been nice if it was a little more visually interesting, but and then they went on to say a nice thing about the course, and they were talking about how this would help them. Not one person who took the ugly course said anything about how it was helpful.
SPEAKER_03It was the same exact course, but not one person said, Hey, I learned something that will help me. So either they didn't finish it, I like I don't even know if I would have gone past that first slide, quite frankly.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think you that this is a showstopper.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah, right there. So, you know, you could have the best content in the world, but if it's in this type of package, people won't listen to you. And so we've got to make sure that our attempt to be cool doesn't backfire. And it is better to be plain than to try cool and get it wrong.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and and real quick, Diane, what I want to do is just I want to try to describe this visually for anyone who's listening to the audio portion of the Slater. So you imagine a slide with striped, a striped background, multiple different types of visuals that are images, fonts, or vis images, like graphics that are different types and styles and colors, blurry pictures, a very cursive font, which is wow. And so you really have to go check it out on uh on our YouTube channel, The Visual Lounge, on on YouTube if you want to get the full picture of it if you're listening to this, but it's you don't need to see it to imagine it's pretty bad.
SPEAKER_00Now, one thing I did notice, and and it was interesting because when you sent these to me, I looked through them and I was like, okay, yep, that looks really good, that's really good. I I want to point out on this slide, and this was just my kind of gut reaction, is on this ways to stay focused and prioritize. You've got kind of this arc of the icons and the numbers. I actually really responded to the average one. I thought, oh, this this feels a much clearer, much like like I easier to read. I know I wasn't taking the course. I wasn't trying to go through it as a learner, but just kind of my gut was like, I actually like this one better because it was just like I could follow along easier where it wasn't trying to kind of throw me around with too many things.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Too many things. Yeah, it was almost overdid it on the pretty.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah. And that can that can happen. Um, and you can also uh clutter up your message so that it's hard to tell what's what. And the other thing that is really important is to um, you know, think about individuals who um may not have the same physical abilities as you, the same ability to perceive color, for example. Um, the same ability to just process information. And so sometimes the clearer, more straightforward approach is easier for people to process.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, we had a question come in from uh from Garth, one of our viewers today, said, Are we saying that visuals can really do more harm than good? Would you would you say that's the case?
SPEAKER_03They can, they can, you know, from a couple of um perspectives. One is it can be uh hard to read, it can be distracting, it can be irrelevant, there's a lot of things that can go wrong with it. Patty Shank just did a really great article on uh when it is and isn't appropriate to use graphics, and I I won't remember the official three words, so we're just gonna have to, but basically using my words, I apologize, Patty. You have your helpful graphics, meaning they aid in learning.
SPEAKER_03Then you have your basically kind of neutral graphic. It might be decorative, but it's not causing any harm. But then you can have um, I think the word is like seductive graphics, where it gets you sucked in to something that is irrelevant and it actually knocks you out of learning. So, yes, the wrong graphic can actually inhibit learning.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, I love that. I love that concept because I think there is a danger. And you know, I we are TechSmith, we are all about images and visuals, but it's it's still using the right ones for the right place and the right time. But I I I love that breakdown that, you know, because sometimes there's not a visual that fits, and as long as it's not it's kind of that principle, do no harm, right? Like it's not doing harm, but it is very easy to get caught up and be like, oh, we're gonna do a really nice graphic here, and then to get caught on the graphic versus what is the message, what is the thing that we're gonna say, or what are we trying to convey, whether it's uh learning or even I would just imagine just kind of regular communication, right?
SPEAKER_00Like you get caught up on it and it's taking people on the wrong thing.
SPEAKER_03And that's why I love the question: is it helpful? Because yes, it can be cool, but is it helpful? And if it's not helpful, then we have to ask ourselves why we're doing it. And you talked about, you know, staring at something and struggling about what to what to do that's helpful. And what I tell folks, especially newer writers who come to work with us at Artisan, is I'll say if you're looking at your slide, your script or narration or whatever, and you're struggling what visual to use, question your content first.
SPEAKER_03Because theoretical, abstract, conceptual information is a lot harder to illustrate. And so what we end up doing is decorating instead of illustrating. I would rather illustrate my point with something that makes that point clearer, more memorable, more impactful than decorating a slide. And conceptual information is harder to illustrate because it's so abstract, and so that's where we end up with cheesy thumbs up or person pointing to the bullet points.
SPEAKER_03I hate that. Or uh, oh, a light bulb to indicate it's an idea. Well, you're gonna get really superficial graphic, handshake, ah, you know, people gathered around a computer pointing at it, you know, you've seen all of it. Is you're gonna come up with generic graphics if your content is generic. So I'd say, look at your content and say, Am I being helpful with my content? Am I being clear about how somebody would use this? In what situation am I giving clear examples, analogies, scenarios?
SPEAKER_03That's why I love an analogy. It is so easy to uh do great visuals if you have a great analogy. So if you're really struggling, question your content.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I I do love that. And I love that you turned it towards thinking about what are the analogies, what are the ways that are illustrative outside of pictures, right? Like, how do you illustrate to take this from a high-level thinking to more concrete thinking? Uh, but that's a real challenge for a lot of us, right? Because we do have conceptual things that we have to convey. Um and and so I guess uh the analogy stuff helps. Any other tips to get from kind of that concept down to you know, maybe more concrete things so that you could illustrate and not just decorate?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, one thing is that if you have an analogy, tell it first. So if I have a conceptual concept that I explain and then I have a great analogy for it to make sense, well, what's my visual? You know, let's say my analogy is about an elephant. Well, I can't start that slide with the elephant if I'm starting with the conceptual, because people are gonna be going, why am I looking at an elephant? Tell your story first. Have a start with a great visual, then you can explain conceptually what you're trying to tie to. So just flipping it sometimes can really be useful.
SPEAKER_03And then the other is just good instructional design is to try and focus on what people are doing on some random Tuesday in November. So um, this is my soapbox, so at a certain point you may need to cut me off.
SPEAKER_00Um I love it.
SPEAKER_03Okay, so here we go. We are in the job of helping people make decisions. So you've got some guy named Joe on some random Tuesday in November sitting at his desk or at the assembly line or on a on a um sales call or whatever, and he has to make a decision. Do I pick up this tool or that tool? Do I click this button? Do I click that button? Do I say this? Do I say nothing? Our job is to help Joe make a decision in that moment. The more we can focus our training on that decision, the better our training is going to be.
SPEAKER_03And by the way, that moment is easier to illustrate than, oh, I want you to list, define, explain, and understand these concepts. So the more we can have our training live in the moment of decision, the easier it's going to be to illustrate.
SPEAKER_00That's a great soapbox. I love it.
SPEAKER_03Well, I feel like I just had this conversation with somebody yesterday. So if you see me out there in the world, you'll probably hear me say that because it's like my thing.
SPEAKER_00Well, I I I I I love thinking about Joe in November on a random Tuesday doing his job, just doing his job, right? He's and he's got a we're providing for something for him. And you know, at TechSmith, we've been talking a lot kind of broader about communication, not just training, but it's like in in any communication with visuals, right? Like, what's gonna really make it relevant to Joe? And uh so I want to go to a question that uh was asked in the in the chat that I think is uh he James is asking in choosing visual aids, is it is the content or the audience more important?
SPEAKER_00I think I know my answer, but I think it's kind of similar thing, right? You just sort of answered it.
SPEAKER_03It's about the audience. Everything we do is in service of the learner, it is not about us, and it is not about the expert. Everything we do is in service of that person because here's the thing we might have business goals, but only the learner can achieve the business goal. Only the learner can change their performance on that Tuesday, and so everything needs to be in service of what is going to help that person understand, retain, remember, and care about your content.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I and I would say that goes to so many other areas too, right? If you're a marketer watching this or listening, you're in service of that that audience because you want them to be successful, whatever they're doing. It's not about us or you, or it's not even about your tool, it's about getting that person to be able to do the job that they've got to get done. So thank you.
SPEAKER_03And there's so many overlaps between training and advertising. Advertising is also about getting you to make a decision. Now it usually involves your checkbook. Um, but yeah, they're trying to get you to make a decision at a certain point in time. And we're doing the same thing. We're trying to get people to make a decision a certain way at a certain point in time.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I want to go back real quick because Jane was asking, Jane Davids was asking the three words. It was instructive, decorative, and seductive.
SPEAKER_03Seductive, yes. And again, these are not the official researchy words. And Matt, if I get you the link to Patty's article, I assume you can put it in the comments or whatever, and it can it can look like it was a great article.
SPEAKER_00We can put that in the the show notes as well and make sure everyone gets that. Because yeah, I'd love to see that for myself. But I, you know, Patty, Patty Shank, if you don't know Patty Shank, she does some amazing research and great stuff. So okay.
SPEAKER_03And then Matt, um, I have an example of this if you want. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00You want to do the Red Cross example? Let's do that. Let me pull that right back up and I'm gonna scroll down there.
SPEAKER_03Okay. Yeah, that's the one. Okay. So this gets back to the concept of do we decorate or do we illustrate? And if we can't illustrate, let's question our content. So um, we've done a lot of work over the years with the American Red Cross in their disaster services area, and we worked with them on a course about how to fill out a form to help them manage uh their disaster relief efforts. So imagine a hurricane comes in, there's shelters everywhere, they're trying to manage that operation.
SPEAKER_03And so the fo the audience is volunteers who do not have a financial or statistical background who need to fill out this complex financial and statistical stuff. And oh, by the way, there's a direct disaster raging around you, you know, so no pressure. And this was one of their slides. So, what's a commitment? Well, it's about how much money we believe we've spent and blah, blah, blah. It's uh, but it's a management tool, not an accounting tool. So it's critical that reflect it as soon as possible because the dollar figures drive financial decisions.
SPEAKER_03Okay, well, first of all, you know, not a very interesting slide. This was for a webinar that didn't did not have the person on camera, so this is all you were looking at. And the the guy who put it together was a just such a great person who was so passionate about how data can the power of data can really help change people's lives. But he he didn't know the right way to get that message out. Fortunately, he knew it. My job's harder when my client doesn't know their baby is ugly.
SPEAKER_03He knew his baby was ugly and he didn't know what to do about it. So he knew this wasn't right. So it's not like I'm picking on somebody behind their back. Um, we were in on this together, and so I could just decorate this slide. So you want to show the next one? Yeah, I could just um decorate it. I mean, that's a prettier version, right? Yeah, but have I added any value? Is this content easier to remember, easier to understand, remember, apply, do in the moment, get you to care about?
SPEAKER_03It's not. And so question your content. And so if you read over this, what you realize is I don't even know what it means. Like, I know what all those words mean, but I don't know what it means. And if I'm a shelter manager, I don't actually know, like, what are you asking me to do? So that's when I have to use my interviewing skills, which I think is one of the best skills you can have, whether you whether you're whether you're crafting any message, I don't care what kind of message it is.
SPEAKER_03And so I I talked to the subject matter expert. I'm like, tell me what's going on in the real world. So there's a hurricane, there's a disaster shelter. What's going wrong? What are people not getting about this? And they said, and he said, okay, so here's here's the deal is we want people to report how much money they're spending, but I want to know the minute they commit to spending it. So if they need new COTS, the minute they place that order, they've committed to spending our money. Like they haven't paid for it yet, the bill hasn't arrived, the COS haven't arrived.
SPEAKER_03You know, by the time the COS have arrived and the bill has come and we paid it, like our shelters are closed, we're done. Like, I can't respond if I know three weeks after you've made a decision or a purchase. I need to know the minute you've committed our funds. That's why they're called commitments. And what I realized is that this is not a slide about money, this is a slide about time. They were putting the expenses on the wrong day.
SPEAKER_03So coins are not even the right decoration. So if we go to the next slide, we could do something as simple. This is a very, very simple slide. I'm sure everybody watching this can make this slide. For those of you who can't see it, it's a calendar with a couple of dates and a couple of red circles. And so if this was self-paced e-learning, I'd say, okay, so let's say you order some cuts on the 7th, receive them on the 10th, and receive the bill on the 23rd. We can't wait till the 23rd to know that that money is being spent. The minute you spent it on that you made the order on the seventh, that's the day it goes on your form.
SPEAKER_03It's clearer to understand, you're gonna remember it better. And by the way, this is gonna be a much shorter slide. The right graphic makes your courses shorter in many cases. Now, if I want to go farther to an analogy, because you know, this is something that you may not do for six months. Let's hope you don't do this for six months because there's no disasters. You may not remember it. Can I do something that's maybe a little bit more memorable? And that's where an analogy comes in. So I could say, you know, imagine you're going to have dinner with your friends, you have a$20 bill in your pocket, you place your order, you get burger fries and a shake, it comes to$14.
SPEAKER_03Okay. You're waiting for your food. You still have$20 in your pocket, don't you? You do. And everybody says, Hey, you want to go to the movies? And you go, Yeah, I got$20. We can go to the movies. Well, you've already committed to spend$14 of it. So if you want to show the next slide, when you order, you commit. And it's the commitment that we put on the form. So that's another case where an analogy makes your graphics so much easier to do, but it's not just about prettier.
SPEAKER_03It's you're more likely to remember this now. It's more helpful.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, wow. I I I love these examples and I love the the walkthrough because you're, you know, I was looking at these earlier. I'm just gonna go back and like you said, this made no sense. Money on the page. No sense. It made no sense. It's because it's not about money. But it really, I was like, what is this even saying? Right. But these are very clear. Like, I love both of these because this one is like, oh, I can I could like quick recall. If I looked at it, I knew what it is. But this one, it's gonna have a different kind of reaction because of the story with it, right? Like 20 bucks, I I spend that amount, I can't go and spend it on something else.
SPEAKER_00So yeah, I love I love both of those.
SPEAKER_03And if you go back to the one with the coins, if we go back to how we craft our message first, that's the problem with this slide. It wasn't that the first one was ugly, is that our message wasn't clear. Like even now that you know what you know, and you read over this text, now it hits you in the face, obviously, like, oh, I'm not actually telling them what to do. Nowhere on this slide doesn't tell them overtly enter in your financial commitments the day you make the order and make the commitment. Like, does it say that everywhere anywhere?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, no.
SPEAKER_03If you can't figure out how to illustrate and can only think of how to decorate, and it's something cheesy and superficial, question your content.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Just so you know, uh, a couple things here. We got the link to Patty Shanks' article. It's been uh put into the chat. So we'll also put that throughout the show notes and things like that. Uh, Diane, pretty soon here, in just a couple minutes, we're gonna go to our speed round. But before we do that, I want to we're gonna try something to do. I've never done this before, so you're my guinea pig. Thank you for agreeing to this. We're gonna do something called, let's see, or can we fix it now? I have mocked up uh an e-learning page, and you know how you said uh I might maybe I should warn people about seizures and uh it's this is intentionally hideous based on my a Google search, uh, but I want to just your gut reaction.
SPEAKER_00I mean, which is gonna be terrify first of all, it's gonna be like, uh, I gotta throw up. Uh, but just immediately, what advice would you give to someone to fix it? And I I've intentionally again, I'm just I want to clear the area. I've intentionally made it bad. I would never make this myself. Are you ready? I'm ready. Everyone at home, better hold your seats and get your trash bags ready because it's it's hideous. Here we go.
SPEAKER_03Oh, pointing to content. How did you know that was my favorite?
SPEAKER_00You have said so many of the things, I'm just like, in my back of my head, I was thinking, oh boy, I'm glad I did that one. So that is uh someone comes to you and says, Diane, we've got e-learning, we need you to help make us make it better. Uh, what would you what advice would you give? And obviously, this is more like a interact, it could be an interactive module, but this could be a slide. I could do this in PowerPoint, it could be in whatever, right?
SPEAKER_03So a couple of things. I'll go big picture, little picture, etc. One is um we always want to check for color contrast. Color contrast is one of the best ways to make our communications more accessible to individuals with disabilities. So I can tell you right now that that white on orange does not meet the minimum required um color contrast. Um, I did a short video for ATD, their toolbox tip series on how to check for color contrast and what the preferred thresholds are.
SPEAKER_03So I can make sure I can get that to you as well, Matt. But that is such an easy, easy, quick thing to do to be more inclusive with your content. Um, and then we have the word resources up there at the top. Um, I took a whole semester of typography in college and liked it, and a semester of calligraphy, and I would have gotten an F for that because um you don't ever want to use all caps in what's called an ornamental. So any that's a that's considered a swash italic.
SPEAKER_03So the little swish on the R and the E and the S is you generally all caps are harder for people to read who have information processing. So the whole thing is in all caps. I would rever reserve all caps for a few words here and there, you know, for just for emphasis. So one of the other things we learn in design school is when you emphasize everything, you've emphasized nothing. So you want to use your emphasis um sparingly. So I'd be careful about using all caps, and especially if it's an ornamental. Most ornamental fonts, um, old English is another one, which you probably shouldn't be using in e-learning, but they're you know, certificate of completion or whatever, never ever, ever in all caps.
SPEAKER_03Um, I think this is a great opportunity to use the three-color rule. Um, now we have four. Um, if you're going to use three, again, I would recommend a dark, a light, and an accent, not three in your face colors. Um so you know, could you use that green and that pink? Well, you might. Um there's a national sorority that has that uh very similar to that pink and green colors. And you know, if this is for them, then you would absolutely use it. But if you're to um if you've got several bright colors like this, because maybe that's your color palette, integrate more white and black.
SPEAKER_03White and black are always free. So remember I said the three color rule, white and black are always free. So maybe that pink is more of a stripe directly below the the um uh the green. Or maybe if we kept pointy lady, uh maybe there's like a like a fun cutout behind her that's in the pink. So the the one of the um one of the things I also learned in design school is uh the more you the more you have of something, the less fun it can be.
SPEAKER_03So something that's that big shouldn't be that pink. The same thing is true with text. The more text you have, the less fun you can have with the font. So if you have two words like hot tip, yeah, pick something a little fun and interesting for that hot tip. But if you've got a paragraph, first and foremost, unless you are unless your goal is to create fine art, the goal of your text is to be read. And so if you do things that keep it from being read and using a complicated font on a larger passage, it's it's going to to eliminate um the effectiveness of your message.
SPEAKER_03So uh let's see, we've got one, two, three, four, five fonts.
SPEAKER_00So I I I did my worst.
SPEAKER_03Yes, yes. And you got Comic Sans in there, so you know, way to go. Um, and then uh the other thing that I would, this is you know, more of a subtle thing, is through design, you have the ability to um influence where the learner's eye goes. And uh some of the things that cause your eye ghost somewhere um other than other one place other versus another. See now I can't form full full sentences. Um, some of it is um if it's distinct, if everything is big and one thing is small, you're gonna look at the small thing first.
SPEAKER_03If anything's small, one thing's big, if one thing's brighter, if one thing's more dull, basically whatever makes it different. Also, a lot of room about some around something makes it more visible. So my eye goes directly to her, which is the least important thing on the message. Now, the one good thing about her little pointy finger, which I hate, is it does actually draw your eye over to where you're supposed to look. But why should I look at her first?
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_03So I won't say you can control where people's eyes go, but you can influence it. Um, there's another graphic I think I'll see if I can find it for you. It's it's awesome. It's a graphic with a bunch of tech, I think it's a web layout. And so everything's in the right font and color and position, but the words say you'll read this first, you'll read this next, you'll read this next, you'll read this last. And by golly, it's true. Just based on where it is and how it looks. So what you need to decide is where do you want them to look?
SPEAKER_03I took an abstract painting course once, and uh the teacher was off looking at at somebody's work and says, What's your focal point on this painting? And she says, Right here. And he says, Okay, what's gonna make me look there? Okay. And then where did they go next? So on this slide, I don't I don't know where where to go next. Like it's it's so disjointed. I'm just gonna be bouncing around and probably won't end up reading it as a result.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, we could look at that all day because there's probably a million other problems, but I want to I want to uh kind of keep things moving here. But thank you for that. Because I think what that did, I that I love that it brought back some of the things we talked about earlier, some of the kind of those rules, kind of see them in action. And and uh yeah, that it hurt my soul a little bit to make that. Just I want everybody to know it's it's pretty bad. There's some funny comments in the in the in the chat about peptimal peptobismol, and um, you know, pink and green are probably not the right color combination.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, lots of reasons it was bad. However, then we're gonna move on and go quickly through our speedrun questions. So here we go.
SPEAKER_03Okay, I'm right.
SPEAKER_00All right, so first speedrun question, we're gonna move fast and furious on these. Is you're you're truly an expert at e-learning. That's there's no doubt about that. You've proven your your your your kind of abilities today. And you get to talk about that at work and bio your in your bio, but what's something that you're an expert in that we might not know?
SPEAKER_03Flowers.
SPEAKER_00Really? Like arrangements?
SPEAKER_03I grow them. I I grow them, I arrange them. I have a whole cabinet in my kitchen of vases. Uh, I grow about 50 varieties of flowers. I could talk your ear off.
SPEAKER_00Oh, that is awesome. That's that's great. And next time I'm I'm with you, I'll have to ask you about flowers because I can't only if you want me to talk for an hour.
SPEAKER_03So be careful.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, that's the next podcast TechSmith is making. We're gonna only talk about florals and vegetation. So uh next speedrun question. What's a piece of advice you'd give everyone looking to design learning content that you want them to know that maybe we haven't talked about today? It doesn't have to be about visuals, so best advice you can give us.
SPEAKER_03Best advice. Um go get go check out Kathy Moore's action mapping process. It is one of the best ways, in my opinion, to stay really focused on that Joe on some random Tuesday in November. Those are my words, not hers. But it's just a very elegant process for making sure you're focused on what people need to do instead of just filling their heads with information that they may or may not know what to do with.
SPEAKER_00Perfect. I love it. So Kathy Moore's action mapping.
SPEAKER_03Action mapping.
SPEAKER_00Action mapping. Okay, yeah, go check it out. Okay, question three. There's only two questions left. So, question three, where do you go for inspiration? Obviously, you're in a creative kind of industry job, you've got to have lots of ideas. How do you keep keep the kind of the creative well filled, if you will?
SPEAKER_03Good question. One is uh I go to a lot of conferences, um, so that's great. Learning guild, um, ATD, training magazine has a lot of good stuff, so many webinars. Um, I find a lot of um uh my inspiration from LinkedIn. So connecting with people like Patty Schenk, that's how I found out about her article. Um, so LinkedIn is where I see people who post things that influence them, and so that helps. When I was newer to e-learning, um, one of the things that really helped was getting my hands on as many examples as I could.
SPEAKER_03And so doing a search for people's online portfolios, uh, companies, you know, like Artisan has an online portfolio. Go check it out, we'll go look at some of the examples. Um the articulate community has their e-learning examples page, their e-learning challenges page. Um, the Learning Guild has an event called Demo Fest. If you can go in person, that's great. If not, the winners of that event have a free webinar so you can see it. So get out there and just see as much as you can.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I love that idea because it's it really is uh it's it's amazing what people are creating, what they're able to do, and it's it is uh definitely a place because I I I I'm a firm believer of uh you know, great art. It's what Steve Jobs stole from Picasso. Great artists or bad artists copy, great artists steal. And and there is no shame in taking people's good ideas in the industry, as long as you're not blatantly ripping it off and calling it your own.
SPEAKER_03But taking their ideas, making it your own is I am a good fan of borrowing inspiration.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Well, well, Diane, thank you so you've been so fantastic. Thank you for sharing your wisdom and knowledge about so many uh things about visuals and images. I know uh I've got notes that I need to go and take and say, like, okay, gotta remember the rules of threes, and uh we don't like rules, of course, too much, but uh uh we definitely thank you for sharing with us and and being a guest today.
SPEAKER_03Well, thanks for having me, and um, I hope I won't have too many nightmares from that uh thinking green and blue slide.
SPEAKER_00I hope not. So if anyone wants to connect with you or follow you or get you know get inspiration from you, where should they look?
SPEAKER_03Uh three places I would say. One is uh follow me on LinkedIn. Uh the other is um I contribute to um two blogs. One is at artisanelearning.com and the other is e-learninguncovered.com. So artisan e-learning is more at the decision maker level, and eLearning Uncovered is more at the in the trenches, making those slides happen level.
SPEAKER_00Awesome. Well, well, thank you again for being with us today. You bet. So thanks everybody. We want to thank Diane. She's so fantastic, isn't that great? I hopefully you got wonderful information out of this. You're listening to it and thinking about how you can make your images more impactful, more meaningful, more helpful to your end audience. With that said, don't forget we are only going to be live on the YouTube channel. That's the Visual Lounge channel. We will not uh be on the Texman channel. We'll still point to it there occasionally, but but you know, go over to the Visual Lounge, make sure you subscribe, hit the bell, or if you're listening to podcasts, make sure you put it into your podcast tool of choice.
SPEAKER_00We're on all of them that you can find. You can even ask your smart speaker to play it for you if you're you really need to go to sleep or something at night. But we're we're just so grateful for all of our great wonderful guests that join us. We're grateful for our audience that joins us live and asks fantastic questions, and for you for just tuning in and listening. So don't forget, wherever you are, whatever you're doing, make sure you take a little bit of time, level up every single day. Thanks everybody. We will see you guys next week.
Drop us a message! We'd love to hear from you. What feels boring to you could be someone’s favorite moment. In this week’s episode, host Matt Pierce is joined by David Hagerstrom, Marketing Generalist at TechSmith....
Drop us a message! We'd love to hear from you. 299 episodes. 10 lessons learned. Episode 300 shares them all! In this special milestone episode, our host Matt Pierce is going back to the 90s and doing it David Letterman...
Drop us a message! We'd love to hear from you. Rance says most training happens in fairyland, where nothing ever goes wrong. This week is a revisit of one of our favorite conversations with Rance Greene, founder of...
Drop us a message! We'd love to hear from you. Bad design gets noticed instantly. Good design fades into the background. In this episode, host Matt Pierce is joined by Melissa Milloway (Mel). With over 15 years’...
Drop us a message! We'd love to hear from you. When it’s too utopian, people get bored. The best training doesn't hand you the right answer. It makes you sit with the consequences of getting it wrong. In this episode,...