Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Top Guys

The Top Guys artwork

Marvel's Mount Rushmore (Part 2)

Sep 16, 202627 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail Three comic book fans. One impossible question. Stan Lee, Jack Kirby, and Steve Ditko are locks for Marvel's Mount Rushmore - but who deserves the fourth spot? The Top Guys dive deep into Marvel history, debating legendary creators, game-changing artists, industry saviors, and the people responsible for shaping the Marvel Universe as we know it. Along the way, expect comic book nostalgia, unexpected hot takes, and the kind of passionate nerd arguments that only lifelong fans can have. Who belongs on Marvel's Mount Rushmore?

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Alright, I should have gone first.

unknownOh.

SPEAKER_02Because I gotta follow. I gotta follow y'all.

SPEAKER_01He's gonna That's right.

SPEAKER_02And I know it's gonna be hot take territory. You know, so children, listeners, I apologize in advance. This is not bad, it's not hot take, but I ain't gonna be able to live up to what these fine gentlemen have done. I'm gonna start with an honorable mention that is very personal for me. I I I can't put this person on my Mount Rushmore, but I really want to because but it's it's it's it's in my feels.

SPEAKER_02And Devon, you're good, you'll appreciate this. My honorable mention is Paul Smith. Okay, okay. And the reason is the very first X-Men comic that I ever purchased, you know, and this was when I first started collecting comics and I go to Jeppy's, all in fact, what made me get on comic collecting to begin with, I had a kid that I went to elementary school with, and we had known each other from first grade all the way through, you know, sixth grade.

SPEAKER_02Name was Robert Cassidy. Shout out to Robert Cassidy. Robert was like my rival in elementary school. So anything he did, I wanted to do, and I wanted to do it better than him, and vice versa. And so we were like each other's like motivation and villain. We were each other's ops, young ops. And so he comes into class one day and he's got G.I. Joe number six. And everybody's around his you know desk, and you know, they're like, What's this?

SPEAKER_02He's like, Oh, it's this G.I. Joe. And I'm looking, and well, now I want G.I. Joe because he has GI Joe. You cannot have that and I not have it. So I go home, you know, to Mama Mills, and I say, Listen, I need G.I. Joe. Now, mind you, my mother, you know, baby boom mother, goes, You want a 12-inch action figure?

SPEAKER_02Which is what G.I. Joe was to her. And I'm like, no, it's a comic book. And she was like, You don't do comic books? You all of a sudden, I gotta read. Yeah, you don't even, you know, you ain't got time to be reading. Like it started young, you know, the not be reading. So she was stunned, she was more stunned than y'all are, now, saying that I want a book, right? I want something to read. So we go, you know, we living in I was, you know, my grandmother lived in northeast DC at the time.

SPEAKER_02And so this was Von, this is how long ago this was. Heckinger Mall was new.

SPEAKER_01Heckinger Mall.

SPEAKER_02Heckinger Mall was, mind you, it was new. Like they had just built it. And so we go, because my uncle was working in Variety Records at Heckinger Mall. So this is 80, I want to say 84. Come on, local lore. Yeah, exactly. So we go in and there was a mind you, it wasn't called CVS back then for you, you youngsters. It was called People's Drugstore. You could go into People's Drugstore and they had the little spinner that had all the outdated comics.

SPEAKER_02And I'm looking and I find G.I. Joe number six. And I said, Ma, I gotta have it. She says, Okay. You know, and I think back then they were what, 50 cents, if even even that. I'd have to check and see what it was, but it was less than a dollar to get it. So I get it, and I come into school and I'm ready to, you know, face my ops. But my ops has G.I. Joe number seven now. And I'm like, this is some boy. What? How now I have to have that.

SPEAKER_02I go back to Hack and Jamal and I'm at the spinner, and they ain't got G.I. Joe number seven. In fact, none of the comics have been updated. And I'm I go up to the counter and I said, Where's number seven? And they were like, Oh, it'll probably be here in a couple weeks. Because that was when they you know they got around to convenience stores or the market. Because it wasn't the market. And I now I gotta go, you know, hat in hand to my ops and say, Where you get that?

SPEAKER_02So I'm I'm salty that I gotta ask him for this. And so he, you know, Mr. Burns steeple fingers, right? He said, Well, I go to Jeppy's, and I'm thinking he's making this up. What the hell is Jeppy? He said, No, I know, but I'm legit. So this is a long ago, I had to look it up in the phone book. I said, mind you, I'm looking in J E P P I and can't find it. And I'm like, I knew he made it up.

SPEAKER_02You know, and then dawned on me, wait a minute, go back, I find it, find it. It's you know, Silver Spring, 8317 Fenton Street, Silver Spring, Maryland. Wow. Why I remember that is, you know.

SPEAKER_00Damn.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. I can't tell you what I did yesterday, but I remember the address to Jeppy's Comic World. Come on, Memento. Exactly. So I beg my mother, you gotta take me to Jeppy's. She's like, okay, we'll go this weekend. So, you know, I had to live with the fact that I didn't have G.I. Joe number seven from the ops for a week and it bothered me. But eventually we go, and now I know where I know it's real. I go into Jeppy's, and all I'm collecting is G.I. Joe. You know, because G.I. Joe, the earth, like, you know, it's awesome.

SPEAKER_02And over a few times I'm going and I'm noticing, like, by the time G.I. Joe number eight's coming out, I happen to look, and I'm going to just get it, and I'm used to just getting one. Getting one rolling out, taking my little allowance and getting that. And I look and I see X-Men 173. And this is the iconic cover of Wolverine, Brown Suit, and Rogue behind him. And this is a that's the first time. And what I remembered was, I said, man, that looked like the dude on Spider-Man and his amazing friends that got stuck in the brick wall with the claws.

SPEAKER_02That look like that dude's in comics. And the cover just kind of just draws you. So I pick it up and I flip through, and I'm like, well, he ain't getting stuck in no brick wall in this. I grab that and I grab 172. Let me get both, let me get both, both of them. Now 172, I might have my numbers off. I think it's 172 has is the cover that has Wolverine in his Japanese samurai with this with the knife through it.

SPEAKER_02It's the wedding invitation for him and Mariko. And then 173. It's in fact, these are continuations from his four-issue series, you know, where you know he is basically in Japan, and this, you know, it's the continuity. If you get the Wolverine book, it has all of them. It goes from his four-issue series through the end of 173. And I didn't realize that until I got it. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Claremont and Frank.

SPEAKER_02Claremont and yes. So I get this thing. I remember I get in the car and I go straight to X-Men 173. And why I remember this, I don't know. But Atomic Dog by George Clinton is on the radio. Nice. So the soundtrack that plays in my mind every time I look at X-Men 173 is Atomic Dog. So I Paul Smith's run, I don't think it was about 10 issues.

SPEAKER_02No, it was only eight.

SPEAKER_01Only ever eight issues.

SPEAKER_02But when you think about what that man, what the the the the work he did, you know, if I'm not mistaken, it he gave us Mohawk Storm. Yep, that was him. He gave us the fight between Storm and Callisto and the Morlocks. Just amazing. It's a and it's his body of work, though limited, was epic to me. Because and I think part of it is that just that it it resonated with a very young me.

SPEAKER_02And it could be because of that that I have some struggle with my actual Mount Rushmore, which is John Byrne. Byrne is tough for me because there was a window with Byrne Man that in his to me, Byrne is like the human equivalent of Prince from 84 through the end of the run with the revolution.

SPEAKER_02It's a that run, it is tell me a thing, man, that John Byrne did that you can't look at and go, yeah, this time that was heat. She-hawk. I wasn't thinking about no She-Hawk, but let John Byrne draw it. I had to have it. Drew Byrne wrote it. Oh yeah, Drew and then wrote it. When John Byrne went to the Hawk, you had like it was mostly splash pages and giant panels, but you go back and look at that, and it's like, man, all right.

SPEAKER_02I ain't mad at it. When Byrne did, well shoot, just Alpha Flight. Yeah. You know, when I think about just his run on Alpha Flight, which I believe he he created the entire did he create Alpha Flight? Okay, so that was him. That was him. Just incredible. The only thing I'm mad about on Alpha Flight is Alpha Flight. It sucks. Apart from that, apart from it just being trash.

SPEAKER_02The thing I'm mad about is when he brought back Vindicator in issue 25, I loved the way he did it. And then it was a bait and switch. And I feel like you you lost out on some opportunity for some additional stories that would have been really cool with him in that setup. But when I again when I think about Fantastic Four, his run on Fantastic Four, amazing. Now mind you, we're talking about Marvel, so I won't get into his Superman or any of those other things.

SPEAKER_02But Burns one of those dudes whenever he touched, it was like Prince in his, you know, young 20-something Prince, prime Prince. Now mind you, Prince's Prime is, you know, you can't really it end. Yes, his whole entire life was his prime. But the the prince that I fell in love with that was like, oh yes. It is that was Byrne. Byrne to me is that is that for Marvel.

SPEAKER_02But again, it's a when I think about when I line him up against the people that you're talking about, to me, it's kind of the Prince or Michael. I go with Michael. Wow.

SPEAKER_01Much as I love Prince. Paul Smith means like he made that much of an impact on you.

SPEAKER_02He did.

SPEAKER_01It's outstanding.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's you know, when I think about it, it's a I can't because I somebody else can have that that drew the same characters. Paul's, I don't know about the X-Men without Paul Smith. It was because of Paul Smith that I was like, oh, who's this dude? His art looks cool, you know, and then I was trying to find all the back issues that Byrne did, and that's when I fell in love with Byrne's you know art and was looking for anything that he was doing.

SPEAKER_02But without Paul Smith, I never pick up a copy of the X-Men. It's X-Men 173 that did it, and it was Paul Smith. His run was not long enough for me to really make a strong enough case to put him on my on the Mount Rushmore. But because of his impact, I have a more of a difficult time really just being like burned. In fact, I'm giving you all my thought process. I was like, oh, it's burned. And then I was like, wait a minute, you wouldn't even know about him if not for this dude. And so how is that dude not into consideration? Had he done it longer, would you be there, you know, with him?

SPEAKER_02Like he he everything he did for X-Men, just the eight books, you remember I remember all eight of them. Like, it's a I have mind you I have them in the omnibuses or omnibi, but I had to have them. Like, those are issues, those are must-have in my collection. So the other thing that I will hold slightly against John Byrne, and this may not be fair, you all tell me this. You take away Terry Austin, do you even have John Byrne?

SPEAKER_01Now that might be hot take. To hang with that particular aspect of the conversation. Him and Terry Austin are they're hauling oats, man. Yeah, they're hauling oats.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's like so how much of that is burn and how much of that is Austin?

SPEAKER_01Right? That's kind of the comes my question. Yeah, I mean, that's a dream team right there. That the ultimate dream team was Claremont, Burn, Austin. Yes, yeah.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, everything that we're seeing on 97, X-Men 97, shoot, the before that, just X-Men the 90s, X-Men 92, or whenever it was it that it dropped, is all based on their run.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I can't uh like as many in people could ink burn. Like, they could, but nobody was better than Terry Austin.

SPEAKER_02No, no, it's not even I'm surprised that none of you said Chris Claremont. Devon, that's honestly who I was expecting you to come with, which is why I didn't say him. Yeah. I went there and I was like, uh, one of them will have him.

SPEAKER_01I would only say Chris Claremont, he would absolutely be on an X-Men Mount Rushmore. He would not be on a Marvel Mount Rushmore because all he ever did was X-Men. And I mean that would be enough. But the fact of the matter is, is like outside of that, and let's be we're gonna be super real about this.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01It lost its way a lot of times.

SPEAKER_02Dude, man, he was out there on the shy are stuff. I'm gonna be honest with you, man. I to this day, I still don't entirely understand it. It's kind of like my own personal East of West. Yeah. It's kind of one of those things where it's so dope that I I feel like I owe the book an apology. Like it's my fault that I it's not that it's not dope. I'm just not smart. You know.

SPEAKER_01No, it's just that the man was just doing too damn much. Like the problem was was like he wore his influences on his sleeve. Man sees the Shogun miniseries or reads the book, and he's like, I'm gonna I can do Shogun, but with Wolverine. He goes and sees Star Wars. He's like, I'm gonna do Star Wars, but with the X-Men. Right. Oh, I just saw Alien. I'm gonna do alien in the X-Men books and call them.

SPEAKER_02Sure enough did.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And it ruled.

SPEAKER_02I mean, it all ruled, but this is wow. I I never made I never connected the threads there, man. It's like, dang, that's exactly what it is.

SPEAKER_01Oh, they're brown. Watch out. And it was just like, I mean, as you get older, you start to realize it's it's almost like music. It's like when you get older, you start to realize where everybody's taking things from, and that's like what Chris Claremont is to me. Chris Claremont is Bruno Mars of comics. Damn.

SPEAKER_02It's so mean. That but that's but that but that's yeah, I can't I can't argue with that at all.

SPEAKER_01It's true. He's just pulling from everything and he's making great stuff with it. But the fact of the matter was that, yeah, you know what? I'll give him this. In the dynamics of the X-Men, nobody did a better job than Chris Claremont. Like he was the one who said, okay, Nightcrawler's here, Wolverine's there, I'm gonna have them be buddies. Like, here's the super calm guy who looks like he should be evil, but he's good.

SPEAKER_01Here's the evil little guy. Okay, I'm gonna put them together, and they're gonna like bounce off of each other, and it's gonna work. Storm, okay. I'm gonna put her with uh Gene Gray. Yeah, and now they're buddies, they're sisters, shit, they're sisters, and you know, he just had a great uh knack for putting characters in the places they needed to be. So yeah, but he only did that with the X-Men.

SPEAKER_01Like we we talked about at the very beginning who the three locks were, and of course, it was Stan Lee, it was Ditko and Jack Kirby. And Ditko, here's another thing, does not get his due for being like everybody just goes, he's Spider-Man. No, Ditko is strange. I implore you, if you can, anybody listening to this, watching this, go find the Steve Ditko, uh Doctor Strange stuff.

SPEAKER_01It is some of the most beautiful comics you would ever put your eyes on. And another thing that people don't talk about enough, Iron Man. He did a fill, he was the fill-in artist on Iron Man. And you know what he did when he was on Iron Man? He was the one who redesigned the Iron Man outfit and gave us the red and gold. Really? Did not know that. That was him. He was the fill-in artist on Iron Man, came and redesigned the suit.

SPEAKER_01I'm not drawing this whack shit. I'm not drawing this crazy nonsense. And basically, that is the costume that we've been riffing on for 60 years now. Is his his iteration of Iron Man.

SPEAKER_02So he has the definitive Iron Man and Spider-Man.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And also, what a lot of people don't know is that he also inked early issues of The Incredible Hulk. So he had his hands across Marvel. Well, superhero-wise. And we're not even going to talk about his Atlas horror stuff, like, which is so good. But yeah, that man's footprint in Marvel just excellent.

SPEAKER_01If I may, I've just thought of another maybe not necessarily on the Mount Rushmore, but certainly Jason. The the steps leading up to it, you know. Devon was talking about how Marvel Knights basically pulled Marvel out of bankruptcy, but I think what is worth being discussed is the time period in the bankruptcy.

SPEAKER_01Like they were it was bad times at Marvel for everybody, not called the X-Men. And the the the sun has rarely set on the empire of the X-Men. And this was one of the times where I was drawn back into X-Men comics. Not necessarily for the writing. Shout out to Scott Lobdell. Not not my guy.

SPEAKER_01But I didn't care because who was drawing it? Joe Madrari. Boy, that man, that man is an unsung hero within comics, probably because he takes too long to draw stuff, but hey, I get it. I get it. You tell you people complain about waiting on books and shit. You draw one. You draw it. You do it one time. You do it one time. From conception all the way to getting it printed and going over your roughs, you do it one time, and you will gain an appreciation for how long and how arduous a process this whole thing is.

SPEAKER_01But I digress. Mans and I think it should be said along lowercase Adam Warren around the same time period. These two guys were pretty. pretty influential in bringing manga sensibilities into American comics and getting new eyes on that kind of stuff. For me, the way he the way he iterated on Jim Lee's X-Men designs in the the late 90s they still stink they like they still stick with me.

SPEAKER_01Like I see Jim Lee's X-Men all the time. That's because it's the Fox Kids team. But they kind they look like Joe Mad Drum. And as man, he stayed awesome all the way to the end and actually he is responsible for probably my favorite J Jonah J. Jonah Jameson sequence in anything. It's in the middle of the zero tolerance story which involves Bastion for you folks watching X-Men 97.

SPEAKER_01Bastion comes to Jonah with all this dirt about the mutants about the X-Men about everybody and I can't remember exactly like the the full setup of the thing but it leads to J Jonah telling Bastion go fuck himself and burning the evidence because Jonah is a man of integrity about everything except Spider-Man Spider-Man? Oh he'll make shit up he's a mantan he eats babies but the mutants why why are you oppressing this marginalized community you son of a bitch get out of my office before I throw you out the window which is crazy because you know Bastion is is Nimrod I think right like it's like don't fight him Jonah don't do that you're gonna get a New York ass whooping stop but yeah Joe Madd I think he goes up there too all right gentlemen that is uh we are at a tight 47 minutes I like that I like that I think we should I think we should bring it home for the people bring home Chris please pray us out close your damn eyes Dubon turn your lights out turn them out your reference teddy penetrat I thought I was thinking the same thing we've enjoyed a time of good Christian camaraderie talking about people shooting laser beams and other doodads from their hoo ha um we've had a we've had a great time we've had a time we've we've enjoyed your company and we hope that you've enjoyed ours um do yourself a favor if you're not an older fan like some of us on this call not me I'm only 40 um seek out some of the back pictures you will you will you might gain a new appreciation for comic art and it's its creative process um yeah take care of yourselves drink water we'll see you next time

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Worlds You Don’t Want to Live In

    Nov 18, 202621 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail In this episode, the Top Guys flip the usual fandom debate on its head and ask a much darker question: Which popular fictional worlds would be absolute nightmares to call home? From dystopian futures...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Things That Made You A Fan (Part 4)

    Nov 11, 202619 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail In this episode of the Top Guys podcast, Devon, Chris, and Omar talk about the things that made you a fan of a genre: comics, movies, and cartoons. They reflect on the stories and moments that first...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Things That Made You A Fan (Part 3)

    Nov 4, 202623 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail In this episode of the Top Guys podcast, Devon, Chris, and Omar talk about the things that made you a fan of a genre: comics, movies, and cartoons. They reflect on the stories and moments that first...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Things That Made You A Fan (Part 2)

    Oct 28, 202624 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail In this episode of the Top Guys podcast, Devon, Chris, and Omar talk about the things that made you a fan of a genre: comics, movies, and cartoons. They reflect on the stories and moments that first...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Things That Made You A Fan (Part 1)

    Oct 21, 202629 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail In this episode of the Top Guys podcast, Devon, Chris, and Omar talk about the things that made you a fan of a genre: comics, movies, and cartoons. They reflect on the stories and moments that first...

    Credit the people on this episode