Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Thunder Down Under Chargers Podcast

The Thunder Down Under Chargers Podcast artwork

Herbert NFL MVP Voter Sam Monson Talks Chargers with TDU!

Aug 30, 20261 hr 14 minAudio

#BoltUp! We are joined today by special guest Sam Monson from Check The Mic! Sam breaks down why he was the lone NFL MVP voter for Justin Herbert in 2025, his outlook on the Chargers’ 2026 season, and overarching NFL trends to watch. Plus, we put Sam to the test with our famous TDU Aussie Quiz. Hit subscribe so you never miss an episode of Thunder Down Under Chargers!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Who's got it better than that? No way! Robert is being chased, thrown on the lawn, and it is caught! Touchdown! Keenan Allen! What a great... My goal is not to break. My goal is to make you harder to break. Number six! Number six! Touchdown! Nineteen -yard touchdown! Nineteen -yard touchdown! Off to the eight -yard run by Derwin Jean! Susses me, takes a shot downfield, has Knighton! Pond! Touchdown! What is going on everybody? Welcome

to the Thunderdown Under Charges football podcast, Andy and Alistair today. Sadly, no Jack, however. We do have a more than apt fill in today with a bachelor of history in politics of his own. He's the cohost on Check the Mic, formerly of the PFF NFL podcast and the sole Justin Herbert MVP voter from season 2025. Great pleasure. We welcome friend of the show, Sam Monson. How are you going? I'm doing good. How about you guys? Doing great. It's that exciting time right at the precipice of the pre -season into real football.

As Al said on the show last week, death taxes and the Chargers losing an offensive lineman in a freak pre -season injury. So, you know, just going through the standard emotions of being a Chargers fans. Yeah, the standard sort of cycle of being, everyone being excited for the Chargers, the off season of hope, and then when does it get dashed and taken away? And, you know, maybe it happened earlier this year with the Adish going down. Yeah, well, no doubt we'll get into that. What's your workload like at the minute?

I know you guys have smashed out all your team previews for, for the upcoming season. So what are you, what are you and Steve up to at the moment? Yeah, it's a weird, um, it's a weird time, uh, at the moment because of this extra long kind of gap. Like it's a, it's a weird NFL calendar this year because of just the way everything's fallen. So there's this giant gap now between the last preseason games this weekend. We'll cover those on Monday, just kind of bits and pieces. What stood out, you know, what we noticed. And week three of preseason, there's not necessarily

a ton of that. But then we've actually got a fair amount of time to kill before the actual season starts. We're not straight into it. There's another week of that. So we've got a full season preview to fit in at some point, like our official kind of picks for division winners, awards, all those kinds of things. But other than that, we've still got some work to do. Yeah, nice. Nice. Yeah, it's sort of getting that way with us as well. love doing the last trope of all your predictions and, uh, how wrong you end up feeling at the

end when it's all completely out of nowhere. So no one ever reposits them. Anyway, you throw out your playoff teams, NVPs, people aren't keeping your receipts. Yeah, that's right. Or you just amazed that you even said it in the first place. Um, just before we sort of jump into talking football, it's If you don't mind, it's been a pretty fascinating story for you, kind of being in Ireland and if I'm not wrong, sort of getting on UK NFL blogs and then getting sort of picked

up that way and then you're analyzing games. What has it sort of been like over the last 20 years or thereabouts? Yeah, it's definitely been weird. You know, I get people kind of... message me or hit me up on LinkedIn or, you know, stuff like that. And they're like, you know, looking for kind of advice for people to kind of get into the industry or whatever. I'm like, I feel bad because my my my pathway is useless. Like I was lucky. And, you know, really, that's it's kind of the case for any of the first sort of people that were in a PFF. We all just got lucky,

struck gold at the right time, the right place. Neil Hornsby kind of created the site concept, the whole thing. And then he needed people to come on and help him actually do data or do games, actually get some information into the system. And the place that he knew to go for people that knew football, knew enough to do this kind of thing was it started off as the official NFL UK message board. And then that kind of became a bit of a mess. And there was like a splinter

group that formed and. What was Dean the kind of the smarter and less? argumentative section kind of went off over there and it was basically most of those people that Neil was employing sort of single -handedly out of his own pocket to do these games to player participation who's on the field where are they and the actual grading and that group ended up kind of becoming like the core team of PFF through the the sort of the startup phase Um, and then eventually, you

know, once it grew, we, we expanded, hired some, some more people on board, but it's not a repeatable pathway. You know what I mean? Like we got, we got blind ass lucky just because Neil knew us and was setting this thing up. Um, it, I mean, beyond like, Hey, if you can hit yourself up to a startup, go for it. You might get lucky. I got no, no more useful information to impart to people. Yeah, that's, that's very fair. How certified. into it, did you kind of have the realization that you, it was kind of legit and

totally life altering and like, you know, you could see that you would have to probably move over to the States. Yeah. It's kind of like, it was a little bit, um, incremental, like there was never any sort of one moment where it's like, wow, look what's happened. Uh, it was kind of bit by bit, although from pretty early on, I think we thought it could be something like we, I remember. We were in Neil's front room way back in like 2009, maybe, and we had this whole

plan sketched out. We're like, here are all the places that would use this data. Teams could use it. Agents could use it, like media. We had this whole thing. We kind of nailed it. I mean, we had no idea how to do any of it yet, but the actual plan is remarkably close to where we ended up being, even though it was just theoretical and just kind of sketched out. And then various people along the way were able to kind of help out and little bits and pieces. You know, the first team comes calling the first team signs the client. There's a media section, you know,

all these sort of little road markings along the way. And then I guess in terms of like big seismic, you know, changes for things, Chris buying the company, Chris Collins worth buying the company is obviously a huge step along the way. From that point on, PFF. was going to stop being a completely remote entity. You know, he was going to sort of establish a home base in Cincinnati and the core people were going to try and move over at least a lot of them. And then because most of my stuff was kind of media

consumer side of things, like mine was going to be one of the positions that sort of needed to be over in Cincinnati. So then it was like trying to move over here, which took a little bit of time. So yours is kind of the reverse charges. You draw out the plan and it actually follows through. It goes exactly how you drew it up. Yeah, I guess. I mean, like I said, there were some some things that would have been different, I guess. But like broadly, you know, big picture, take a step back and kind of look at it. I mean, PFF became the kind of the preeminent analytics

entity in in the NFL in the sort of football landscape. That would have been like the North Star on that board, you know, way back in 2009 or whatever. And so, you know, didn't go exactly the way we would have planned it out. And, you know, mistakes were made and other things, but like in terms of like the broad picture was pretty much right on. Yeah. Awesome. Um, and obviously then it's sort of translated and now, you know, into the podcasting realm. And now you're off

doing check the mic and, um, still, still working with Steve. You can, you can tolerate him, uh, enough to, to sit across the table and talk football. Yeah one of the few people that i seem to be able to tolerate for that period of time without souring on them enough yet since it's been remarkably successful movie. Between like all of the early people started all of the things that pff just because there were not many people around to do it so i like set up pff social media channels initially me and steve i think were the first

two people set up a podcast or at least worse were. Certainly part of the initial. pretty limited rotating cast. And we were certainly part of it from the beginning. And that's the thing that kind of that kept on going. We basically kind of became our show more or less. And then we ended up leaving to sort of do our show by ourselves. We didn't own any of it when it was at PFF. It was all owned by PFF. So we basically left, started

over and tried to spool it up ourselves. Yeah, awesome. How did you find that, uh, sort of building that up and then sort of starting again? Uh, yeah, it was like, it's, it's quite a broad space where even really big popular podcasts, they can have thousands of listeners and then overnight you hear, oh, NFL media has cut that show or this platform's cut that show. There's some, you know, danger inherent, no matter how popular you are. And it's a very sort of shifting landscape

at the moment, right? Like everything is changing, the whole sort of system is shifting, platforms are changing, like where people consume podcasts is changing. So our show was always kind of two pronged. It was a YouTube video show, but it was also an audio only, you know, RSS, wherever you get your podcast type of thing. And that That was the side that had been more successful for the history of the show. But we also knew that was the side that was probably going to

be hardest to rebuild if we had to start over. And then the YouTube channel was the other way around. Like it was probably the smaller side of it for us. And we felt better about being able to build that back up if we had to start over again. So first of all, we had a whole thing of. Not being able to jump until we found a kind of guaranteed safety net somewhere So we needed a company which ended up being the 33rd team who was willing to kind of provide the guarantees and saying yeah We'll take the gamble on it And let us jump in the first place and then we had

this thing of well We're not gonna tell them we're leaving until sort of the last minute because we wanted to do it When our numbers are gonna peak right up against the season. So this kind of time But then we also wanted to take a swing at buying the feeds on the way out the door and say, look, we're leaving. This is basically our show. Your numbers are going to tank. The second we leave, you can, you know, spend a lot of money and live that experience and figure out what it looks like, or we'll give you quite a large amount of money for the feeds and let, you know,

we get everyone can win. Right. And I think we got kind of close to them saying yes to that. Um, before they, they talked to somebody else who sold them a pipe dream and they went off and took a gamble at that and it, you know, nobody, nobody won. Okay. There you go. All right. Well, let's, let's get into talking to symbol and it wouldn't be a charges podcast talking to Sam Monson, um, without a little bit of discussion around the MVP vote for Justin Herbert. Um, sort of how you don't, I'm sure you've thrashed it

to death, but, uh, how was the sort of Coping with the backlash that came of, you know, the criticism around Drake may being robbed of an MVP career. Obviously this is for people who haven't kind of listened and heard you speak on this, um, which I've always find very entertaining, but sort of how did you, how did you sort of wear that? And why did you have yourself Sam on Twitter? That's the worst with all the assholes out there. You've gone, you know what? I'm going to, I'm going to be accountable for my vote. Yeah. That was the, on, on reflection, that was

the stupid thing. I, I. And, you know, there's a bunch of people that are like, oh, look, he's just doing it for the engagement and stuff. Like, look, if anyone had listened to our show throughout the season, like this would not have been surprising. We had been kind of soft launching this like all the way through the year. I'm like, I honestly think Justin Herbert might be the most valuable player in the NFL. I think I might vote for him. Like we had been saying this kind of thing for the back half of the season. Right. So. And then the other thing we had said is, look. the AP doesn't want you putting your vote out there until, you know, all the thing gets released

and then you can put your stuff out there. So again, we'd said, look, I can't officially say who I'm voting for, but as soon as the thing goes live, I'll put out my vote, you know, and let everyone know what we did. So in my head, it's like, oh, look, it's out. You know, everyone's going nuts here. I'll put out the thing saying that I'm the Justin Herbert voter because I said all along I would do that. Ton of people took that as like proof that I was just engagement farming like oh, he's only in it for the the clicks Look at this Otherwise, why else would he put you know this tweet out there? So I didn't

really see that coming probably should have and then the other thing I didn't really see coming was Like whatever about just an avalanche of abuse coming your way. That's kind of standard internet these days I didn't expect to get doxed off the back of it and have people like posting my address and phone number and stuff. Oh shit and it's like And the problem, the big thing about that is like we're in San Francisco. The only people at my house are my, you know, wife and daughter and stuff. And I'm like, I don't know if this is a problem or not. Like I, you know, so I had Steve, a friend of his has like

family in every Cincinnati law enforcement agency. And this guy was like saying, Hey, if you know, do you want somebody going around the house? I'm like, I don't know. And then a guy, Tyler, who was our producer at PFF, Tyler was offering to drive around in my house with a gun and sit in the driveway. And I'm like, again, I don't know if that's a good idea or not. I don't think so. Thanks for the offer, I guess. But like, can you imagine you've got you've got like Dave Portnoy or Nick Wright rocking up throwing eggs at your house? Yeah. So that would be their juvenile approach. The assumption was it was just some

idiot kid, you know, posting it to be an asshole. But it's like that's the that was the bad part where it's like, I don't know. If this is a problem or not, because all it takes is one idiot or a lunatic, you know, with a gun to show up at your house when you're not there. Um, so that part wasn't fun, but the rest is just, it is kind of crazy how like way over the top people are going to take stuff like that. It's like, it's not that serious guys, you know, chill. Yeah. Yeah. In Australia, we say play the ball, not the man. So like disagree with the opinion,

which is fine. And people will. But then they, you know, they start with the person should have his voting credentials removed, like in a true democracy. Right. And then, you know, they're doxing you. It's just a dark underbelly. Yeah. And even then, like that, that's fine. Right. Like, oh, this guy should have his vote taken away. Like, all right, cool. That's your call. That's your opinion. Fair enough. Right. But it's like the immediate jump from that to like, we're going to, you know, post this guy's Address and phone number online. Like we're, we're going to actually wish serious harm on this person.

Like that's taken it too far. Yeah. Just a bit. Yep. Yeah. But you also say like guys in their sixties with full face paint and like paraphernalia on it, the game. So it's hard to know like what the expectation would be of, um, of. people being passionate about, uh, you know, potential MVP being taken from their quarterback or something. I just don't think the Bostonians would probably travel over to San Fran to cause too much trouble.

It was, that was the other thing. At least it wasn't like Jalen Hurts or something like that. Yeah. That was the other part that made me think it probably wasn't that bad. It's like, look, it's, I'm in Cincinnati, you know, the people really pissed off about this. We're in Boston. It's probably not that big of a deal. Um, but that's like, uh, that's the other aspect of it that was kind of crazy. It's like, it needed to be the perfect storm that it was where it basically came down to one vote for it to be as big of a deal as it was. Like, and again, when you're making the vote, you don't know what anybody else is voting. I knew I would be out on an island. I knew I would, you know, it'd

be in a minority. I didn't expect the difference between Stafford and May to be like one vote effectively. And suddenly, you know, my vote is like, oh, look, you're the swing vote here. And also the people, the two people that voted for Josh Allen, like they really dodged a bullet because they just sat there and stayed quiet. I'm like, and they should have. Like, don't stand down and put yourself on that. All right, let's get into some NFL chat. Al, where do you want to start? Well, since Sam's led us down the Herbert

MVP pathway, it would probably seem reasonable that you would be pretty high on the charges this year, since last year you thought Herbert was an MVP. caliber player under Greg Roman. So maybe talk to our listeners a bit on your thoughts on the Chargers off season. Is this the year where they finally achieved their potential under Mike McDaniel? Yeah, it's interesting because before last year, I would have been of the opinion that Herbert hadn't really put it all together yet. And that he's, you know, a quarterback that's obviously got the talent to, but was inconsistent,

was sort of streaky, you know, hadn't really had that year. We were like, Oh, he's arrived and he's as good as anybody now. Um, and then I think last year he did. And then it didn't look like it during the second half of the season because the offensive line just became like a complete mess and you can kind of tell who's even watching when they're arguing because like people will bring up that philadelphia game they're like look at these numbers is terrible like did you watch that game like the fact that they were even in the game at any point was only because of justin harvard right even though the numbers

weren't good it's like that game is a positive for his MVP case, not a negative. And if you'd watch it, you would, I think, see that. So going into this year, you're like, well, if that was real and we just fix the offensive line, we're in business. Right. And that's before you get to the idea that, you know, maybe Lad McConkey was playing hurt last year and maybe Quinton Johnson could take another step forward and Mike McDaniel's arriving now. So there's, you know, more good stuff to add. If we just fix the offensive line, we might have an MVP type of player on

our hands. you're getting two fifths of it back just by getting, you know, the two tackles coming back from injury. Joel, I feel very good about Rashaan Slater. It's a little bit more kind of TBD because the injury is more severe because he's already had it flare up and stuff. So we'll see how that goes. But theoretically, we're getting bookend tackles back in business. And then it's like, well, what does the interior look like now? The adage there, you're like, OK, we've now got three fifths of a good offensive line. And McDaniel tends to be able to sort of make magic happen with the other guys. So Don't love

it on paper, but I'm okay with it the adage goes down It's like I don't really like any of the three guys in the middle and we're asking a lot of Mike McDaniel now to make this magic happen And that so you don't feel great about that, but the other things are all still there right Herbert should still be amazing I you know, there is this world where Mike McDaniel he's kind of said bits and pieces of this before Like it's basically the first time he's had like a real like a real quarterback, right? The guy that's drawn up the thing that's everybody's looking for, like the huge cannon, athletic, like all

the physical traits. This is the first one of those he's really had. And if he was able to turn Tua into a guy that could operate like an offense that hung 70 on the Broncos, you know, was the league leading all time type of pace offense for like six weeks of the season, like what does Herbert put on the table that he's never been able to do before? So I think there is a world where that combination can create something pretty spectacular. But now we just need to see, A, is that realistic? Or is this

sort of, are we expecting it to scale more than it's actually possible to scale? And then B, how much of an impact does that offensive line have? And will that hold the whole thing back? There's a lot to unpack there. I mean, so something that's come to mind is the throw that Herbert made to Quentin Johnston just yesterday in the third preseason game. It traveled 45 air yards per next -gen stats. That was the greatest number of air yards a Mike McDaniel quarterback has had on a throw since he's been in the NFL. So

it took all of two, three games for McDaniel to think, hey, I've got a different kind of weapon. Let's attack different parts of the field. Bjardis is one that hurts. And I know Andy, you've got some questions coming up, but it seems like the approach Hortiz took Sam was to think... In an outside zone heavy scheme, your bookend tackles are really important getting out on, you know, lead toss plays or whatever. You need an athletic center who can reach block. We're going to invest there. Beardish, you know, he was PFF's 11th ranked center last season. This is a really good,

solid center who should provide a significant upgrade over the play the team was getting from Bradley Bozeman last year. And then it seems that the approach they took to guard I mean, man, you can you can tell me I'm pretty obsessed with the NFL. I'd never heard of Coyote Awashika, this kind of seven year veteran depth interior offensive lineman. He's penciled in to start at left guard. You bring in Cole Strange, really a former first round bust on his third team, has the scheme familiarity. They're your answers

at guard. You're already a little bit suspect that the team looks like they may have three out of five solid or better pieces and the other two they'll work it out. You then lose Beardish, in comes a rookie center who people had graded differently depending on who you asked and in for what scheme. The question now, I mean, I feel that the dread, I feel like all season are we going to be patching over this interior offensive line? Do you think, Sam, we've seen, we've seen Mike McDaniel do this in the past. Do you think just having Herbert and moving the pocket and throwing screen passes and all the different

ways you can try and mitigate a poor interior offensive line, are you expecting McDaniel can do that again? Or are you a bit worried about the names on paper who are, who are on the interior this year? I mean, I think both like, the the Shanahan scheme and McDaniel in particular have shown like a fairly consistent ability to elevate offensive lines that do not look good on paper right and basically every year we went into the season looking at Miami's offensive line going man that looks that looks pretty rough right

and it was rarely that big of a problem like they were able to pretty consistently hide that and paper over it and make it not look like a big problem and you know so much of what this offense does as a base scheme is all the stuff you talked about get these guys in the move, shift the pocket, not ask them to just drop straight backwards and hold up as a kind of clean classic pocket shape. So you are kind of minimizing the number of plays, where the problem is a problem. But they still exist, right? And the problem

is, I think they tend to exist in the most critical highest, highest leverage situations you're going to find, right? So when it's third and 15, that's the play, right? And Those are the ones you can't really run if you don't have an interior trio that you can trust to hold up for two and a half, three seconds in a straight drop back, you know, pure pass type of set. So I think that's probably where it manifests the most. So I think you could probably say, look, it looks pretty bad on paper right now. It probably won't be as bad as it

looks because of Mike McDaniel and all the stuff we're talking about. But the question becomes, is it enough of a problem that it sort of stops Herbert looking like the MVP that I think we think he can be, right? Like if he had a top five offensive line in front of him going into the season, I think most people, like he might be the betting favorite for MVP at that point. If you go from that to what they're about to have, like how much does that take away from that MVP case? Outside of the MVP sort of conversation,

Does Justin Herbert need to play at an MVP level for this team to be more successful? So will the scheme overall like lift the sort of level of all the other players to, especially with Alton Slater back, that we're not as reliant on Herbert doing superhuman things like he did throughout last season? Honestly, I don't think we know yet because There's a lot of variables about this team. A lot of unknowns for this team going into this year. You've got the defensive

side, what it still looks like now that Jesse Minter is moving on. They've got to replace him. Are they able to pick up where they left off and is that going to be a strong? Omari and Hampton, I thought looked really good, even though his numbers aren't necessarily great. Again, that's an offensive line problem as much as anything else. Does Omari and Hampton take a big step forward this year? How productive will he be? um talked about the wide receivers already you know lad mcconkey coming back uh from injury that's that was sort of quiet last year does he go back to looking like his best mike mcdaniel's

talking up quentin johnson a lot is he able to get the best version of quentin johnson out there you know what does that receiving core look like generally and then you and then the offensive line that we already mentioned and then it's sort of you roll all that together and you're like well how good is this team independent of the quarterback Now, how good do we need the quarterback to be in order for them to be Denver, Kansas city, you know, Baltimore, Buffalo, Cincinnati, all the other contenders in the AFC. I just, I don't think we know that yet until we see sort of the impact or the effect of all these other elements of the team. Yeah. Well, it's been a

pretty similar story for in the two years that Harbaugh has been in charge with, you know, double digit wins and then an early exit in the playoffs. So I think it's almost like we won't quite see until that the result of that first playoff game as to whether this team has mentally, uh, improved and being able to sort of get over that hurdle. But, um, Sam, where do you stand on, on that? So the last two seasons team bows out in the wild card. Herbert plays underwhelming fashion

as well. Like a couple of his worst games, right? Like I think just objectively Herbert, like some uncharacteristic poor decisions, just looking like he's shrinking in those big moments. Where do you stand on that Sam? Because on the one side, you've got the people out there who didn't like Herbert from the get go, right? As an Oregon quarterback, he's a quieter guy, introverted dude, he's not a leader. And then you've got the other side who say, well, look at the situation around him. Look at the play calling, look at the offensive line, look at the Brandon's daily

defense, look at and come up with the excuses. Where do you sit on that spectrum? Yeah, I mean, I think I think it's true to say that Justin Herbert has not played his best football in the playoffs so far That was also true for Lamar Jackson until it stopped being true It was true for Josh Allen until it became the exact opposite and actually now Allen's played a lot of his best football in the playoffs I'm generally of the opinion that Your weaknesses get exposed in the playoffs, right and often that just sort of gets It just get it reflects on the quarterback

and we just go well the quarterback didn't get it done, right? But actually how much of that was the quarterback not getting it done how much of it was some other element of the team? You know got looked way worse in the playoffs and the quarterbacks just kind of dealing with that like Drake May last year played his worst football in the playoffs Because his offensive line suddenly became a complete and total liability and his receiving core couldn't get open right and they were against literally I think the four best defenses in the NFL one after another like he played the top four defenses that he could play

and Suddenly his offensive line can't protect and his receivers can't get open So, of course, he's gonna play worse like that just makes sense, right? And he still made some big plays in that and you know, it wasn't like a complete and total disaster but like My opinion coming out of that would be more that look, Will Campbell couldn't block anybody in the postseason. Nobody could get open and therefore Drake may like two out of the three pillars that support quarterbacks fell apart, right? So I would expect him to play worse. I think that's the Occam's razor, which

thing is most likely to be the case. I think that's way more likely an explanation than we reached the playoffs. And so Drake may just imploded through the pressure, right? I think that's Significantly more likely and I think generally that's probably the case. I it takes a lot for me to I think shift in the other direction The only one I can think of at the moment is I think Dallas and Dank Prescott some combination of those I think they they are having problems in the postseason that are independent of things just get harder like I think they are working against You know

25 30 years of history and when they get into the playoffs they they tighten up they choke generally Um, I don't think that's the point, Sam, right? Cause it's, it's a sample, sample size issue. Like with, with Herbert, he's played three playoff games, one in 2022. And then those kinds of confounding factors can, can have an impact. It's hard to draw strong conclusions. You're talking about the Cowboys over, over a period of 30 years. Yeah. I mean, it's sample size and it's, you know, the quarterback is always the focus. So if it goes badly, the quarterback's

going to get blamed. If it goes well, the court, like, you know, quarterbacks can win playoff games playing terribly and nobody will know that they played terribly right like it just gets swept under the rug but if they don't win the game because another element of the team isn't good well then the not great quarterback performance is a disaster and it's them that choked yeah it's sort of like up the top my head Trent Dilfer in the 2000 Ravens where you know it's purely like a defensive effort and he uh kind of rides in and did enough But if, if they lose, it would

have been all on him, right? So it's just, that's the nature of the beast of carrying literally the entire football team on your shoulders. Yeah. Or, um, you know, Peyton Manning, when he won his second Superbowl ring, I mean, he could barely play. He was terrible. Peyton Manning was not obviously any better than Brock Osweiler that season, right? But the Denver defense was like one of the best defense of all time. They carry him to that second ring and nobody remembers.

Nobody cares, right? He got it done. He got the second wing. It's ring. It's validating. But like, you know, the average like six yards per attempt in that playoff run, he didn't play particularly well. I don't think in any game he was carried and that's fine. But that's, you know, this is the way this works, right? We only remember it in the light of whether they won or lost. Yeah, exactly. If we can just jump back to, as Al touched on, the approach to the off season and sort of rebuilding the interior offensive line, how do

you feel like the heat under Joe Hortiz's sort of seat? Because it was an astounding amount of cap space. That was the clear issue last year that Herbert was hit and sacked at a record rate. And they spend 10 million a year on Beardish and then get Cole for street change and, and no -name at all. Well, you know, a very under noted left guard. So how do you sort of feel like the heat is on Hortiz and his approach to

building that line? Well, I think if it does look like the biggest problem on the roster, like if we go into the season and it's like, oh man, this offensive line's getting its ass kicked again, you know, Herbert's running for his life, like this is going to be the thing that stops this being a Super Bowl team, well then I think there's some real questions to answer because I didn't love their off -season approach generally to the offensive line, like I expected them to treat the line the way the Chiefs did when they lost that first Super Bowl and their line got torn to shreds and That wasn't even

their starting line. They just lost so many people that at that point it was a second string unit, basically, and it got wrecked. But they came out of that game and they went, oh, we are rebuilding this thing. That is never happening again. We're going to invest in the offensive line. We're going to pay more money than anybody else. And we're going to make sure Mahomes is never running for his life again. I kind of expected the Chargers to do that coming out of last season. It was so bad that I assumed they would go all the way the other way and say, We are making sure that

Herbert never has to deal with that again. And instead, you know, OK, you could say two fifths of that offensive line are coming back. That's fine. You don't have to do anything about the tackles. And the Beatish move was good. And I like jumping on that before free agency. Right. He got cut. He's available before the frenzy. Grab him, get him signed, get that done. And now you're down to two spots. From that moment on, I thought they kind of went, you know, they got way too relaxed about the offensive line. Like I thought they still should have gone. looking for a free agent guard, prioritized in the draft.

And you could come out of this off season with, you know, five starters that you felt really good about on paper, albeit one of them would be, you know, an unproven rookie first rounder or whatever. But like, you know, the kind of guy that's supposed to step in day one and be good. And OK, there's some there's no continuity there would have been new faces. But like you would have felt good about that offensive line instead, even before Biatish went down. You're like, the Adish is an upgrade, but he's sort of solid rather than great. And then the two guys either side of it, like the entire interior

might still not be great. Right. And that was before he went down hurt. And now you're like, the entire interior is probably not good. And given where they started, that just feels like such a like such an easy miss. Like you could have done way better than that. Even even if you say, look, the Adish thing is not their fault. Injuries happen. That's unlucky. it still feels like you didn't treat it as seriously as you could and should have. What's hard there? I agree. I mean, that's the common refrain from all fans, us included as a pod. I suppose Portiz, you know,

the Baltimore model of team building, he gets a bit of sticker shock. You know, he wants to pay fair value for what he perceives to be the player's worth. And maybe he just thought this free agent class wasn't as good as last year. He might say, Who did we really miss out on Sam, like Isaac Sayamalo, some guy in his mid to late 30s, Elton Jenkins, Elijah Vera Tucker, some of these guys we might have been interested in, they didn't want to come to us. So we prioritized finding the guys we thought were a scheme fit, and we attacked defensive line three times in the draft, slaughtered round two, a couple of

flyers in round six. and reprioritize center and we're going to spend our money out elsewhere. It's a bold approach based on your key principles and tenets. The problem is you have one injury like this to be artish. And if it all now falls apart, you're just going to look like an idiot. Yeah. I mean, I do think I do have some time for that argument. Like I think if he was going to make that argument publicly, I think he'd be right to a large degree. It wasn't a great off season for interior offensive line help generally. Right. And it's certainly there would have been

better off seasons, you know, to have had a war chest to have had a need and gone out and overhauled three guys on the interior offensive line. But the first thing is if, you know, if Bjaric goes down and then the interior offensive line is getting wrecked all season, nobody cares. Right. Like you can't make that argument then. It's like, hey, it was the right thing on paper that the value just wasn't there. Like nobody cares. Your quarterback is getting killed. Right. You had to do something. And then the other thing is. there's a difference I think a lot of NFL GM's and this is kind of this is where this gets

awkward because analytics and Sort of camp management people and all the kind of the people in that type of world They're all there to try and steal, you know little edges here there and percentage points and Do optimal kind of roster construction strategy and the problem is that all that kind of takes place in a vacuum I don't want to say you know spreadsheet because that's It's so where the criticism always starts but like they tend to treat it as this happens in a vacuum and theoretically

you never want to do this and that but nobody starts from a blank sheet of paper right you are always in a situation it's like football manager right you're given scenarios it's like well here's the scenario you're six points back there's eight games to play. Go win the championship this season right like this is the scenario we're giving you so the charger scenario is you getting two tackles back. You got nobody in your interior trio that we trust and your quarterback just is an mvp caliber player who right now is running for his life right free agency is about to start

the draft and the pipeline you got some here's your resources go make it happen right. And what they did is they looked at that scenario and they said well we don't really like the options we just kind of punk on it will bring in behind us cuz that was value and we'll just sort of basically trade water until maybe next year where we prefer the options. Okay that's. that's definitely an option but like sometimes you just have to say the need is now we need to deviate from you know the the optimal best practice thing like know when to bend the rules and a good example

of that if you go back a year ago um john schneider and the seahawks schneider said publicly they do not draft offensive lineman interior offensive lineman in the first round they don't think it makes sense you can get these guys later on you can get starters later on And they, for one year, they did that. And then the second year, they still had the same problem. And Graze Abel was sitting there and he went, you know what? It doesn't make any sense to not pick Graze Abel because we think it's not value. It's not optimal. We can get them later. Like take the guy that fits your biggest need and just move on. Right.

Graze Abel. He was a huge player for them as a rookie. It fixed the problem. And it's like, look, is that optimal? Probably not. But it's better than the alternative. Right. And that. Like that, I think is the balancing act that NFL general managers have to make. And it's not easy, but I think we've almost pushed them too far in the other direction now. I think the old school way of doing it would be reactionary knee jerk. You know, this is the thing that needs to be fixed. Let's just do that immediately. And then I think all the data pushed them too far in the other direction where they're now

like, no, it has to be optimal at all times. We can never deviate from the book. And now it's like, look, sometimes the need is there, the players there, like let's not overthink this and that's where I think it's difficult to be an NFL GM and why there's no right answer to this, right? Every situation is unique, every situation is a different set of pressures and options and alternatives and sometimes you need to deviate from what the book would say and just lock in an upgrade at a position of need. And

if you don't like the free agent market, I mean, we've just seen an off season where guys like Trent McDuffie and Miles Garrett and AJ Brown, we're seeing active trades, right? Go out and identify a dude who maybe no one's talking about and all of a sudden, you know, Quentin Nelson's being traded to the charges for a futures that just to pick a name out of out of a hat that that would be another way if you don't want to pay Zion Johnson, let him walk to the Browns don't like the free agent class. go get creative in the trade market would be another option. Alright, I might expand a bit out to some broader

NFL themes before we play a couple quick games, Sam. It would be remiss not to ask you a PFF based question since you're here. So we're at the time of year now where everyone online is pissing and moaning about PFF grades. Talking to someone who's been involved or around how they're built and calculated is I don't know, just interested if there's one element of PFF grading you think's done really, really well that people are overlooking. And then conversely, is there something that you think's problematic or could be improved and you kind of regret being

out there? I think the underlying grade is pretty sound and pretty predictive and pretty powerful. And actually it's something that gets missed by almost everything else. Like there's a lot of other data out there now more than there's ever been. Whether it's NGS stuff, whether it's other people's charting, but like the PFF grading system is still picking up a lot of things that don't get captured anywhere else. So I think the underlying raw grade is still very good almost across every single position. Some are more better

and more powerful than others, but I think overall it's a pretty powerful and good thing. What I think the biggest mistake they made down the years was is in putting it on that zero to 100 scale and shoehorning it onto that. And I think that's the root of a lot of problems because the logic was you need something that's easily digestible that somebody can just intuitively know, well, this is 75. It's like the problem is you feel like a zero to 100 scale should be like that, but it isn't because every instance

of a zero to 100 scale is a different Use case right Madden's grades are different to like school grades over here You know like 75 % in the test is different to your Madden grade of 75, which is different to your PFF grade of 75 So you still have to educate people what your scale means? Only now they like there were definitely gonna be people think they know what the scale means And it just it ends up as a mess and it gets mathematically very awkward to put it onto that scale Whereas I think the old way doing it was actually more sound Didn't create as many problems

and I think if you'd run the same educational sort of process you would have ended up converting a lot of people to that anyway, so Those would be my things. I think underline that great is so powerful. The presentation is a mess Can you explain that old grade for listeners who might not be familiar that the one that you think is better than zero to a hundred potentially So the way the grading works is on every single play every single player gets a grade in 0 to 0 .5 increments, either side of zero, right? So if you imagine a play starts, everybody starts

off on a zero, which is an expected grade. If you do nothing either good or bad on a given play, you're going to get a zero. If you do something above expectation, you'll get a positive grade. If you do something below expectation, you'll get a negative grade. And then how positive or negative is like, well, how much above or below expectation was it, right? And it goes up in zero point five, one, one point five, blah, blah, blah. And then all those grades get rolled up by the number of snaps and they just basically get added up at the end of the game. So the old system was basically a plus or a minus number

based off the number of snaps or the period of time we're talking about. So a game grade would be like, you know, zero sort of plus four was a good game. Plus eight is like an obscene game. And then over a season that expanded out to like, you know, plus. 20 is a good grade over a season plus 30, 40 is really good. And then when you get JJ Watt shows up, blows the whole grade up to like a plus 90 or something, right? So that's kind of the world that you, we inhabited before we tried to shoehorn everything onto a zero to 100 number. Yep. Thank you for explaining. So

that's, I can understand why some decision maker may have thought Well, that's going to be difficult for people to understand, whereas if they see green 75 out of 100, they're going to have some kind of basis to compare that to. But you're saying it creates some issues that were being pointed out to by the time by people creating the formula. And I know for my part, I've always I've always been an advocate for at least PFF grading, giving us a language to talk about some positions where None really existed right we

used to talk about the number of starts for offensive like literally he's had eight stars this season so i've always been an advocate i've. You know not venting my spleen i've always thought is there a case to be made that like i know. I know the the premises that each snap is created equal and we're gonna grade you plus two to minus two per snap i've always wondered. To get closer to some of the traditional stats, might it be that certain outcomes are weighted a bit more heavily, like a sack, like an INT, like a third

down stop? Because I think where people get really upset is they say, oh, you know, James Pierce Jr. had three sacks in this game and his PFF grade is 38 .5. And they just don't understand. And that might've helped, you know, if you weighted those players a bit higher, maybe it would've made a difference. I don't know. I'm speaking off the cuff. Maybe it wouldn't have, Sam. Yeah i mean i think there are some instances where you do i think wanna wait the individual play their situations i think you wanna wait right so garbage time you don't wanna wait as much as you do other parts of the game cuz it's it's

the monster less important period right so the guy goes and gets three sacks and garbage time. I mean those weren't important those weren't as good plays the three snacks for the three three sacks you made. to get it to garbage time, right? So I think situation. Meanwhile, if you make a big catch on third and 15 in the fourth quarter, that's a way bigger play than if you may get on first and 10, you know, with the first play of the game. Right. So I think situations should definitely end up resulting in different grades and they do within the system. So that part is taken care of where I think where it

gets difficult is PFF grading as a concept was always designed to separate the player guy is making from the results, right? And that's not necessarily intuitive. Like a lot of people are like, well, the results are all that matters, right? But we know if you think about it long enough that, like, you don't always get the results that you deserve based off the play, right? A quarterback throws the ball right to a defender, but bounces off his head, goes up in the air, and his receiver, like, goes up and mosses everybody and comes down with it. Like, woohoo, 20 -yard

catch, first down. Maybe we get a touchdown on the play. Like, great play by the quarterback statistically, right? But it was it was a terrible play through the ball right to a linebacker. Right. He just got lucky. And he dropped it. Right. So the PFF grade is an attempt to sort of separate that out and actually tell you what play did the guy make, not what result did he get. And like, that's the easy example of where it can really lie to you. But you brought up the sacks thing. And that's where it gets complicated because you're right. From like an EPA point of view or like win probability point of view.

A pass rusher getting a sack is like a way more valuable play than getting a hit or getting pressure or whatever, right? But it's not necessarily a skill that he made to turn the win into a sack, right? And this is why you hear a lot now that sacks are a quarterback stat, and that's becoming a kind of more common saying than it used to be. And it's because quarterbacks, more than almost anything else, Like determine whether that win from a pass rusher becomes a sack ahead

or hurry right he's basically at in control over when he gets rid of the ball. So if you're you know pick your favorite pass rusher miles garret wins in one second flat. What happens after that is usually not miles garret's control right it's usually does the quarterback get the ball does the coverage hold up does you know something else determines. what result that individual play gets to the pf grade says what he what is going on second flat that's elite right. What

happens after that is not really within his control unless he like miss is that you know falls off the quarterback fails to actually finish the sack which case like will take a like pf would take a bit of great often but generally they're like your job was beating your block within a second and bearing down on the quarterback and the results are not really within your control. And so that I think is the problem with with trying to sort of separate that way and go well if we all because similarly right there are some sacks where they're not good plays by the defensive

end he just happened to be there when a guy got like flushed past him and literally all he did is reach out grab the guy and fall over right botch snap quarterback falls over the ball yeah exactly right the Brett Favre you know the Michael Strahan play right he literally falls down in front of him Michael Strahan just sort of runs up taps him down gets a record like That's demonstrably not a good play by Michael Strahan. It would make no sense to me to give him like a boost just because it was a sack, right? Because the, the statistic at the end of it is more valuable than the play he made earlier where he, he just

like whooped the guy and only got a pressure. Yeah. It's like the guy who recovered Sanchez's butt fumble. Just did nothing but be in the right place at the right time and execute a pickup. Yeah. Yeah. How did you have a question on personnel charges? Yeah. Yeah. I've got one more man. And then we'll, yep. And then we'll do some lightning round questions. So this is more of a take Sam. Let me know what you think. Let me know what you think listeners in the comments. So most teams, my take is most teams who went down this 13 personnel pathway this off season will live

to regret it. And for those who don't know what I'm talking about, 13 personnel, one running back, three tight ends. And we've just seen a draft where a whole bunch of tight ends. We're drafted higher than they were ranked on the consensus board where most analysts had them. So the Jags draft Nate Borkertscher, the Texans draft Marlon Klein out of Michigan. You've got the Dolphins drafting Will Casmeric. Why are teams doing this? It's because of the Rams, right? Last year, the Rams ran 13 personnel at 30 .51 % of their plays,

more than twice the amount of any other team out there. And they also managed to create explosive plays from that personnel grouping. Their EPA per play was pretty good. Looking through though, I've taken a look at the top 10 teams who used 13 personnel last year by utilization. The Rams, Steelers, Cardinals, Colts, Spares are the top five. It turns out only three teams inside that top 10 had positive EPA per play on 13 personnel down. So it's not an especially efficient grouping

generally having three tight ends off the ball. It's just the Rams kind of found this magical elixir, which for the record, they also were doing with 10 personnel and 11 personnel. They were very efficient in those personnel groupings as well. And I look at a stat like explosive play rate, right? So an explosive pass is 20 yards and explosive rush is 12. The teams who ranked in the top eight in that metric last year on offense were the Patriots, the Bills, the Ravens, the Rams, the Bears, the Packers, Seahawks.

These are the best offenses. So my take is explosive plays still win in the NFL. And what we're going to see is a whole bunch of teams wanting to control time of possession, maybe not being very efficient at it. And I, you know, to quote Oscar Wilde, Sam, I think imitation, it's the most sincere form of flattery. That's great for Sean McVeigh, but doesn't guarantee similar results. What say you, Sam? Um, I think I agree if, if the reason everybody is going hard after tight ends is because

they just want to do the Sean McVeigh offense or, you know, copy what Sean McVeigh is doing. I think you're right. It's not going to work. Um, if the shift towards all these tight ends is something more broadly indicative of a push back towards kind of power football more conceptually generally and just a pivot in that direction um and also okay the the tight ends got wildly overdrafted generally but it was an unusual year

for like Just those bodies right six foot five guys that could run effectively, right? We had an unusual number of those tight ends Coming out this year and there aren't that many of those guys kicking around like when you when you go and sort of meet nfl players face to face two got two positions Are the guys that make you kind of go? Whoa, those are different human beings. It's tight ends and it's defensive ends, right? tight ends are just freaky sized human beings and You might think you have a tight end, but

if you actually see a real one, it's like, dude, we don't have anybody that looks like that. Like those guys are different. So there was a bunch of those guys coming out this draft, actual tight ends that were that shape and could run. And so I think teams kind of pounced on those guys generally. But I also think we are seeing now this shift that we're going to start pivoting back towards more powerful ball. You're seeing a ton more under center stuff. in preseason and training camp like teams are going back to old school under center seven step drop hard play

action and these are things you use tight ends for right and so as much as you stockpile the roster for so you can run 13 personnel like the rams you also stockpile the roster because you're going to use tight ends a lot generally and if one of them goes down you need the next guy right so it's an attritional position you're going to need to start resetting what the roster looks like, as well as just being able to run three of them on the field at the same time. Yeah, I think that's a good response. And the question is always whether whether offensive coordinators

have the patience to continue to run the ball when they're seeing favorable looks where they're getting a quarter shell. Do can they continue to do it? Maybe some teams have struggled to really stick with the run. I know charges fans feel that way in certain games, maybe the best offensive coordinators, hopefully Mike McDaniel know when it's time to pass and when it is time to run to win. Like what would have been a really interesting kind of case study for this theory is if this had been like a really weird draft where there were like seven Lorenzo Neil shaped people in it, right? Like seven guys out of old

school sort of eye formation, smash mouth offenses, like seven dominant fullbacks. I kind of suspect those guys would have been drafted way higher than they've been in the last decade. because of this pivot towards those types of offenses as well. And instead, it was just it was tight ends. Right. So now we're all like, oh, everyone's going to copy the Rams. Everyone's going to try and run 13. I think it's more that people are just looking for those players again in a way they haven't for a while. Scotty McLaugh. Yeah.

Well, so now you see it because because nobody has a Lorenzo Neil, everyone's just get finding a 300 pound guy that they think. and throwing him in a fullback. There's like five 300 pound fullbacks in the NFL right now. Yep. It's wild. Bring it back, Mark. I'll stop. All right. Should we head into the lightning round just to sort of throw some hot takes around? Let's do it. Let's do it. Sam, first one for you, Guinness

or American beer? Guinness because it's not American beer. Are you a Guinness drinker or just that's what you'd pick over the two of those? I'm not really a beer drinker period, but if I was going to have something that would be Guinness and only in Ireland, I'm not drinking it over here. Yeah. Yeah. I'm yet to experience the traditional in Ireland. It is different. I mean, it's a cliche, but it is. Like it tastes different. Can confirm. Andy, you're forced to sing one song at a Dublin

pub for karaoke. Zombie by the cranberries with or without you, you two or whiskey in the jar. Thin Lizzy. Oh, whiskey in the jar for sure. Yeah. Absolutely. Absolutely. Uh, Sam, I've been, I'm making a habit of asking this question because it's, you know, it's hot on the topic of at least Australian NFL fans. So increase my sample space

for me, if you'd please. Is Australia too far for teams to travel to play a regular season game? I'm going to kind of reserve judgment to see how this week one goes. If it's going to happen, it should happen week one, right? For sure. I think that makes it possible. But like if you said teams are going to have to start doing this in week six, I would say that's insane. Yeah. Yeah, that's a, that's a lot to ask. Even if it was like favorable with the buyer situation, like at least having the sort of come here a bit earlier, having not played a game. You do

know where Australia is on a map just out of interest. Oh yeah. Okay. I'm like, that's one for two. I would love to have to have tried. I feel like Australia and New Zealand to me are like running a marathon, right? There are things I would like to have done, but I don't want to actually do because I don't want to do what's required in order to get to Australia or New Zealand. I want to get on that plane for 20 something hours to make it there. Yeah, that's fair. That's nice. I'm happy with that answer. Yeah. Over

to you, Al. All right. Sam, which NFL quarterback? Has the single most aesthetically pleasing throwing motion in football history That's a good question, you know what I think it's Michael Vick I think Michael Vick there's something about the way Michael Vick would just like Flick of football. He had this kind of like elastic band like whip to him that just looked awesome Yeah, it's something about the left -handers isn't it they can sort

of like slingshot it that does That does change things. You ever see those videos where they flip it left to right, like they reverse the video so the left -hander becomes right -hander. I've never seen anybody do it actually to Michael Vick. I'm kind of curious what it looks like now that you said it. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I still remember that throw Monday night football, whatever, 80 yards off the play action against the Redskins at the time. Just yeah, gorgeous throw of the ball. You go Andy. Al, Kansas City will miss the playoffs. Oh, that's a good one. I Yeah,

I think they'll miss the playoffs. I'm going to lean in to my homes being a bit slow coming back from the injury. I just don't see three teams coming. I'm confident the Chargers and Broncos are going to get through. So I don't know if we're going to have three teams from the West, but maybe I'm wish casting a little bit on that one. Uh, I'll go straight back to you, Andy. Tully to Apollo two and the Chargers will agree to terms on a long -term deal before week one of the regular season. Yes or no. No,

and I don't think it matters. Okay, why is that? I just think Thule, he returned from his hold in without anything on. It's clear that he is a little bit more sort of professional and football and team minded than perhaps. you know, just holding out for the contract. So I think he's maybe just wired a little bit different to the sort of standard approach that, uh, guys looking for with their hand out, uh, kind of take it.

That's why I think he'll be wanting to get in and, and, uh, I don't think it matters. Sam, can I invite you to comment on that one? So I'm I'm assuming the deal isn't done because Tully's agents are wanting 34 million or something like that a year to hit that top of the market. And maybe the charges want to see a little more production before they do that. Do you, do you kind of get why they're at an impasse? Do you think it matters? Yeah, I think I would be in the same bucket. I think they probably don't get it done just because we're getting pretty close up against it now. And I agree. I think it probably doesn't

matter. I think they will get them signed long -term at some point, but yeah, like he's. he's an interesting player where he's not like clearly in that will anderson jr buck you know like the top top tier pass rusher but anytime you're trying to sort of establish what the second layer looks like in terms of contracts i think it's always a little tricky so yeah i get why it's a bit of a struggle for them to get it done but i think they probably will uh sam Even though it's kind of getting, I feel the closer to the season it gets, the less likely it is. But an Aaron Donald

return to the LA Rams would put one hand on the Lombardi if it's not already there. Yeah. I mean, look, I was saying, I can't remember a more prohibitive favorite going into a season than the Rams are this season. And that honestly is whether or not they have Aaron Donald. But if they get him back, and I think they will, it only makes it more likely. I think just from a statistics standpoint or a betting standpoint, you're always going to take the field over one team. But I can't remember a team being more favored going into

a season than the Rams will be this year. Yeah, Miles Garrett, certainly a big contributor. And the sort of taking of the Kansas City secondary also sort of helps. McDuffie's a massive gain as well. You know, from a neutral standpoint or for science, right? The idea of having Miles Garrett and Aaron Donald lining up next to each other is sick. Like every single fan who's not dealing with it directly at that specific moment should love that as a concept. Like we deserve to see that. Yeah. In a crazy world that it does

happen and Aaron Donald winds up on a plane out to Australia with Miles Garrett, that would just be the greatest treat for us going to that game and being able to witness those two specimens, uh, on the field together. That would be. And now is the kind of time where it should happen. Like pre -season is done, training camps done, roster cuts are happening. So they actually kind of need to know somewhere around now. Now's the time it makes sense for it to happen. Yeah. All right, Andy, this one's for you, mate. The death

of the Pro Bowl game announced by the NFL this week. Sad moment or long overdue? Long overdue for me. I kind of liked how they went into the skill set side of things, but the way that it sort of deteriorated to like a flag football, the fact that, yeah, give it, just give it an accolade. It's a fan voted thing as well. Like I keep seeing things of, um, instead of having the pro bowl, they should have the two worst teams in the league playoff and One of them that

determines the number one pick. So, uh, I'd get like something like that. Glad it's kind of gone. You're not shedding any tears, Sam. Well, it needed to die. I mean, the way it's going the last few years, like it's been put out of its misery, but I do think it's kind of sad that football just doesn't get an all -star game because it became that much of a mess. Like, you know, you go back. The Pro Bowl used to be kind of cool, right? Seeing all these all -stars playing together. It was a good thing. I've seen some pretty compelling arguments that say like the

worst thing they did was take it out of Hawaii and move it off like move it before the Super Bowl when it was sort of treated as this. It's after this. It's like it's a big celebration victory for everybody after the season in Hawaii, right? There was a reason to go when you moved it before the Super Bowl to like Orlando. Nobody wants to go to that. So the thing is sand is playing in it. And that's the thing like he like he's gonna get held up is like the reason this game died and he was but not for the reason I think people are saying the reason that was the

problem is He was literally the first guy that said yes, right? So they picked up the phone like everyone pulled out and they started calling up AFC quarterbacks and every single one of them said nah I'm good. Don't worry. Nope until they got to Shador Sanders. So they went through the entire conference before Shador was like, yeah, all right, I'll do that. I'm not busy. So like that was the problem. It's not that they, you know, they got this terrible player who ended up being a pro bowler. It's that literally the entire conference told him, well, like hell no.

When they were trying to phone around to find somebody like that's the reason the game is no longer viable because you can't get people to say yes to it. Yeah. Yeah, that's a good shout. All right, Sam, you get, uh, you get tickets, VIP tickets, court side tickets, whatever you want to a hockey, baseball or basketball game of your choice, any matchup, any venue, what are you taking? Uh, I'm going to basketball, I think just cause I can't stand baseball and I have no interest in hockey, even though it's

a game that it feels like I should like, it's got all the hallmarks of a sport that I would like. I just, I just doesn't do it. Um, so I would go to a, uh, go to a basketball game. I mean, you'd probably want to see the Lakers against the Celtics in some capacity with the question would be which venue. I think I'd go Boston before I went to LA. Yeah. Cool. Atmosphere is a big one. If you're kind of not that enamored by any option. Yeah. Just the old drive -by of, uh,

Steve with the baseball slander. If he's listening, uh, last one. Um, before I ask my last question, who holds their liquor better, by the way, out of your, you and Steve and you guys go for a few jars after the. I mean, it would be Steve just from a volume standpoint. He's just so large. He's got an advantage, right? Like there's no way of avoiding that. I will say though, that I am underrated in that capacity. Um, I don't generally drink, but I did that the last time I drank was my sister's wedding a year or so

ago, like properly. And her, like all the guests were. They basically assume that don't drink equals can't drink. And so we're like on at me to like, no, come on, we'll drink. We'll drink. And I eventually I was like, all right, fine. Let's just get some drinks. So we did. I put down some, you know, finance, bro, just myself and a couple of cousins basically ended this guy. And then we went, all right, now, now I'm going to get back on water and be be done with this. But yeah, I can. But Steve's working with like 100 pounds of extra capacity than I am.

It's cheating. Yeah, the third one of our show Jack Jack is a you know, big six foot three hundred and forty five kilo guy So he puts us under the table every single time we're gonna be seeing him week one Rams 49ers at the MCG Jack So you get another chance to shine Sam. All right. This is my last question for you. It's another Irish one. Okay You can invite two of these famous Irish people to a long lunch with you in Dublin. The list is Patrick Pierce Bono, Sinead O 'Connor,

Conor McGregor, Roy Keane, and James Joyce. Pick two of the six. I think definitely Roy Keane and probably Patrick Pierce. It was much through elimination as anything else. Roy Keane I love. Roy Keane, I have a tremendous amount of respect for the man's ability to hold a grudge. Um, and he's funny. Like that's the other thing that he doesn't get enough credit for. Roy Keane's legitimately hilarious. Um, and not, not just unintentionally. So like he's genuinely funny.

So I think he'd be good. Too many of the people on that list, you wouldn't want to, you couldn't sit at a dinner with it. So you are kind of like just finding the last person standing that wouldn't be painful. Yeah, we do have a couple of English listeners out there. So just plug up your ears for that answer with the Easter rising reference. Uh, okay. That's I'm out of questions, Andy. Any more from you, mate? I am too. We've timed that incredibly nicely. Um, awesome to have a chat. We're going to do something that we love to do when we get guests on the show and that's

the thunder down under Aussie quiz. So Alan, I've got three questions loaded up for you. We'll try and give some. Uh, some helpful multiple choice to not make you feel like too much of a goose if your level of obscure Aussie trivia isn't up to, uh, kind of curious what my baseline is on this now. Yeah. Well, like everyone, I guess usually get zero out of three. Yeah. Okay. That's a pretty standard and that's kind of what we're aiming for, but, um, it's not anything

really, I never would give anything that you could kind of think to research. So any kind of. preparation would have been just a waste of time really. I'll kick things off and test your knowledge of AFL and all -island Gaelic football. Of all the Irishmen to have played in both the Australian Football League and obviously all -island as well, what sets Tige Kennelly and Conor McKenna apart from the rest? Are they

the only people that have won championships in both all islands and whatever the AFL equivalent is? Bang on. So, Ty Canelli won in 2005 with the Sydney Swans and with County Kerry in 09 and McKenna with Tyrone in 21 and Brisbane in 2024. One from one. That's a good start. Sam is off to a flyer. All right. Here's your question from me, Sam. If you flew directly from Sydney on our east coast to Perth on our west coast,

the flight time is roughly the equivalent of flying between which two US cities, and there are four options. Is it A, New York to Boston? B, Los Angeles to Las Vegas? C, New York City to Los Angeles? Or D, Chicago to Miami? I think New York to LA is the only one long enough. Ding, ding, ding, ding, ding, ding, ding. It's about

a five hour flight covering roughly 2000 miles of mostly empty outback. Andy Sam is on the precipice here becoming our second guest ever to get three out of three pressure is on Sammy boy. Here we go. I've set the bar very low and you've launched over it thus far. Okay. So Third and final question, this one pertains to Australia's coat of arms, in particular, the use of native animals, the emu and the kangaroo. So Sam, if you could tell

me which of the following is false regarding these two, sorry, which of the following is false? Yes, I apologize regarding these two native of the animals. A, neither can walk backwards. B, Military intervention was once used against a large flock of wild emus. Emus cannot fly despite their large wings. It is illegal to eat either animal or both can be considered pests in certain

areas with their population swells. I'm looking for the one that isn't true. Yep. I know that there was such a thing as the emu wars, so that is true. Yes. That's impressive, just to know. He knows these stuffs. I know that they can't fly, so that's true. Was it? OK. I can imagine

that neither one of them walks backwards, so that makes that true. What am I? What are the two left? The other two? Both are considered pests in certain areas with population swells and that it is illegal to eat either of them. I'm going to say it's not illegal to eat either of them because they can be pests in certain areas. Excellent. He's gone 353. So that is an absolutely outstanding way to take on the TDU quiz, but also to end what has been a real delight to have you on the show, Sam. Also, Andy, it

just shows... American guests' knowledge of the world outside of America. Maybe not quite the same as our European continental guests who maybe a bit more in the outlook. Yeah, that's true. Really sort of blending the two, the crossover. Yeah, Sam, thanks so much for joining us on your Saturday night. Yeah. Have a, have an awesome year. Don't forget to chuck that ballot paper in for Herbert at the back end when, uh, you know, it's, it's your turn to cast your vote. Hopefully you're not alone and hopefully it brings

good things for the charge. Yeah, no problem. Thanks for having me guys. Alrighty. Uh, we'll be back. We'll see you next time. Thanks again to Sam. Take it easy. We'll see you next time on the Thunderdown Under Chargers podcast. River's

back, Piddle's looking, Fiery's got Floyd turning, got it! Six and a ten, five, high step, touchdown!

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. MNF WIN RUINED THE TANK?! | Chargers Shock Ravens for Win #1

    Nov 18, 202658 minAudio

    #BoltUp! The drought is officially over. In a gritty, ground-and-pound battle at M&T Bank Stadium, the Chargers secure their first win of the season, edging out the Ravens 23-20. While the majority of Charger Nation...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. THE 0-8 CHARGERS FIRE SALE! WHY TRADING HENLEY TO DENVER MIGHT BE GENIUS

    Nov 11, 202658 minAudio

    #BoltUp! An absolute nightmare at SoFi Stadium followed by one of the most shocking trade deadlines in recent franchise history. Hours before the deadline, Joe Hortiz sent young leader and linebacker Daiyan Henley to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. DOWN WITH THE TANK! 0-7 & NINE QUARTERS WITHOUT A TOUCHDOWN | Chargers vs Rams Wk 8 Recap

    Nov 4, 202655 minAudio

    #BoltUp! Another absolute fizzer for the Bolts Offense at SoFi Stadium. Despite Joe Alt’s brilliant return anchoring a clean pass-blocking performance, the Chargers collapse to 0-7 following a lifeless 24-9 loss to the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. MCDANIEL’S LAST CHANCE?! | Chargers vs Rams Week 8 Preview

    Oct 29, 202637 minAudio

    #BoltUp! At 0-6, the Chargers return home to SoFi Stadium for the "Battle of Los Angeles" against Matthew Stafford, Puka Nacua, and the 3-4 Rams. With the Offense sitting 32nd in EPA per play and scoring just 15 points...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. HARBAUGH REFUSES TO BACK MCDANIEL! | Chargers Drop to 0-6 in Arrowhead Disaster

    Oct 21, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    #BoltUp! An utter, non-competitive disaster at Arrowhead Stadium. The Chargers crash to a 22-6 loss against the Kansas City Chiefs, dropping to 0-6 for the first time since 2000 - when Jim Harbaugh was the starting...

    Credit the people on this episode