Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Thunder Down Under Chargers Podcast

The Thunder Down Under Chargers Podcast artwork

Did Joe Hortiz Cook? | Chargers Initial 53-Man Roster Reaction

Sep 1, 20261 hrAudio

#BoltUp! The initial 53-man roster is SET! Today on Thunder Down Under Chargers, we break down Joe Hortiz's roster construction, analye the surprise cuts and trades, and grade every position group ahead of the 2026 season. What we cover today: 53-Man Roster Reactions: Initial takes, the biggest cut/hold surprise, fringe player trades for draft capital, and who is primed for a bigger role than expected. Roster Confidence Meter: We tier every single position group into Ready to Contend, Good Enough, Developing, or Needs Help. Final Offense & Defense Grades: Giving our final letter grade and one-word verdict for the entire unit. Hit subscribe so you never miss an episode of the Thunder Down Under Chargers Podcast!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Who's got it better than that? No way! Robert is being chased, throwing on the run, and it is caught! Touchdown! Keenan Allen! What a great goal! My goal is not to break you, my goal is to make you harder to break. Touchdown! Number six! Number six! Touchdown! Nineteen yard touchdown! Nineteen yard touchdown! Grab your lunchboxes

and go attack this day with an enthusiasm unknown to mankind! The pre -season is in the books. The 53 -man roster has been released. We are that much closer to football, baby. Hope you are all doing well, guys. You've got Andy, Alistair, and return of the Jack today on the Thunderdown Under Chargers podcast. Jack, welcome back, man, and a massive congratulations on everything that's going on with your growing family. How are you?

I'm back. I'm back. I'm really sad to miss the show with Sam Monson guys. You guys absolutely smashed it. I listened to it earlier today. Fantastic. And if you tuning in for the first time, you didn't listen to that. Go back and listen to it before you listen to this show. These two guys were awesome. But yeah, no, it's things are great, mate. Thank you so much. Matilda is our young daughter. She's almost two weeks old, hitting all the milestones that she should. Older sister, Molly, who's just turned three on Sunday. She's an incredibly responsible and doting big

sister. So my wife or my partner is very healthy as well. So that's all we can ask for. And I'm so excited to be back. Terrific, man. I want to just second it. We're very excited for you. We're very excited. We've got a new football season coming up soon. We're all going to be at the game together, the three of us. So, oh boy, it's just over a week at Jack. I think you're probably even more excited after a certain signing that just went down over the last 48 hours. Sam Monson predicted it. We asked him about it, didn't we? Um, we did. Anyway, we thought Jack was missing

the show because of the babies. He was just hitting refresh on his phone, waiting for Leslie to announce the signing of Aaron Donald. Well, it's happened, mate. I'm so excited. That is if Aaron Donald plays and it looks like he might to actually be able to see one of my favorite plays ever live in the flesh. I'm just over the moon, Andy. It's just I can't wait to see you guys and sit for an NFL game. It's so exciting. Yeah, the prospect of Miles Garrett and Aaron Donald on the same defensive line is very exciting. I must

say, just while we're all kind of patting each other on the back, I'm more excited to see you in a little over a week's time. Folks, like I said, the top of the preseason is done. We are that bit closer to regular season football and that much closer to the NFL coming to Melbourne. Folks we've we've really appreciated the contributions Bryce Julio on Eric. Thank you so much There's a link if you'd like to shout us a beer for that Rams 49ers game But we appreciate all the support

regardless guys, so thank you very much Thanks, let's get stuck into it Jack right away your immediate reaction to the initial 53 Yeah. Offensive line university, baby. Swimming in it. It's kind of like we had issues with the depth of the offensive line last year. So you know what? Let's go out and go 11 guys. Uh, so no, I, um, I'm, I'm fairly happy. I didn't think there were too many things

that were out of the ordinary. Uh, we'll, we'll get into it a little later with some of the minutia, but, uh, yeah. And really fascinating, I guess, out of that offensive line group to see, uh, so Jacob Spomer get named, uh, they clearly didn't want to put him on the practice squad. Uh, he played really well, I think across his, I think he played almost 140 snaps in the pre -season. So a really decent sample size. And obviously with Beardish going down, Slaughter looked okay. You know, they really wanted to show up that center position. So I honestly thought he was

going to get cut. Uh, it was one of those, you know, pre -season darlings as it, as it always happens, but L he made it and whether he plays any meaningful snaps in the first half of the year, who knows? Uh, let's, let's hope that he doesn't because if he does, it means something's going wrong. Yeah, absolutely. And. I find this this day it's becoming one of the more I think underwhelming days of the calendar that gets all sorts of hype the roster breakdown because it gets analyzed to death and at the end of the day not a lot changes from the back end of the

53 and there's a lot of gamesmanship that goes on in terms of keeping guys who you don't know what to expose to waivers and everyone gets up in arms because Tony Jefferson's been cut again oh actually no he hasn't and everyone then gets excited because JK Scott you've been shown the door for being a shank No, actually, we've got Jim Harbaugh calling him a top 10 punter in the NFL again, as soon as today. So yeah, everything changes, but not much changes and the something in the middle. I don't know. Yeah, full of surprises, full of trickery from Hortiz with the JK Scott

move. And then out of nowhere, Denzel Perryman winds up on IR. Now I got confused. I read the website before I watched Harbaugh's. presser and I don't know whether or not to take Harbaugh in full seriousness because he wanders off at a time during a press conference but he did mention that Denzel Perryman is designated to return. I initially thought that he was on the reserve injured list and that was that like with Beardish

etc but no he's scheduled to return so that's yeah a bit out of nowhere to me but yeah look Al, how much do you think the 11 listed O -line plays into what Harbaugh has been talking about with sort of platooning the left guard role, like playing the hot hand? Do you think they just - You've just set me up for - Yeah. I threw that one right up in the air. Set me up. Set me up. No, no, no. I have it now. Yeah, I don't

know. I don't know how - the cognitive status of our head coach is going, I've got to say, there's a fair bit of concern, at least internally, and I'm hoping you guys can help walk me off the ledge and the listeners as well. Just where I thought we might be at this point of the season and where we are, there's a bit of a gap in my mind. I'll go there. I was really excited at the start of this season about our offensive line, thinking if this thing works, I think we

can be a top 10 offensive line in the NFL because I was really excited about this idea of Slater and Ault returning and signing Tyler Bjardis. We didn't even make it to pre -season week two before Bjardis is out for the season. That kind of fundamentally changes everything. What to me was looking like awesome depth because Slaughter is your rookie early round pick depth. That's great depth. Suddenly he's launched into the starting position and Slater really hasn't been practicing consistently because there must be

something going on with his body we don't really know about. So even though Pipkins has looked okay and Travis Birks looked really good and Spomers looked good I don't know if right now I feel like we've got a deep offensive line even though we've got 11 guys on the 53 and more so Jack before you can opine. My kind of take for this Initial 53 is some guys made this who I don't think really earned it and then other guys kind of earned it and either didn't make the

initial one or got traded away. And I know that's the gamesmanship, but I'm thinking like did Darius Davis earn his spot? Bud Dupree. I've just got him. Bud Dupree did all 11 of those offensive linemen, including Harky and Logan Taylor. And whereas some of the guys who really earned it, we've traded away because they earned it so much, we decided another team can give us capital for them. Uh, and then even guys like junior Colson and Greg DeRosier, who really stood out and played

well, we've got them back on the practice squad. So it doesn't matter, but then not on the initial 53, Jack, all these offensive linemen are. Tell me what the bigger picture is here. Yeah. Uh, there's, there's two schools of thought, just as you were talking about that. And you look at the offensive line and go, wow, they've really championed depth here and really wanted to shore it up. Right. Or the other way of looking at it is they're absolutely spinning because they've got absolutely no idea what they're going to do week one. I think I think they're spinning.

I think Harbaugh's reaction to that yardish injury, he had no poker face whatsoever. He was like, our whole plan is fucked. And since that moment, we've been butchered by the 49ers look kind of meh against the Rams. And now I think I'm feeling a little bit weird. Hitting in 2021. I, and listen, I never really liked the strange or the, uh, I was seeker experiments at left and right guard anyway, but you kind of then you sell it to yourself

and go, well, you've got the other three pieces in Beardish being a, being a pretty good center. He'll, he'll support them in the interior, you know, pressure and understanding stunts and communicating. That'll be fine. Then you've got your two anchors. They'll be all right. Slater. Oh God. Now Slater's not okay. Alt's staying at the right. So now we're pushing out, you know, I mean, Branson, um, uh, Branson Taylor has looked really good at tackle. Let's, let's be honest there that that's been fun. Travis Burke, I should say, sorry, not Branson Taylor. Yeah, I, from what

I saw in Slaughter, I think he's going to be serviceable, but against someone like an Aaron Donald, which we have to line up against, he's going to get absolutely monstered. I just don't think he's got the play strength to, even though people are saying, this is why we picked him in the second round. He's going to come in. He's going to be good. I have real questions about his play strength at, at the NFL level personally. I think he's athletic. He can get out, but I don't know Andy, is this just Mike McDaniel being like, you know what? Let's just take these 11 offensive linemen. We're going to treat it like

a platoon. Guys are going to be cycling in, cycling out. There's going to be, it's just trust my offense guys. Trust, trust what I'm going to do. It's going to be okay. I don't know. I don't want to rehash anymore of the chat, but you know, the, the sweet, the, Preseason sweetheart guard option or left guard option Branson Taylor is on IR so perhaps there is a lot there is a fair bit of spinning going on and there's a Because they can't be hanging on to 11 guys Thinking

we can't possibly cut them. They'll get picked up. Like it's not a it's not a paranoia thing I think the depth is just the now that we've had, you know, the loss of Beardish Taylor on IR depth is now Pivotal so interesting. So you think this isn't even about they were worried Haki and Logan Taylor would get pinched by others They actually think we don't really know who our starters are So we need to keep more and more of these guys in case we need to keep on swapping it around till we find our ideal combo

Yeah, there was no there was no change to the Like you they you know, they could have put Hockey on the practice squad today Made a move like that or something. So I Don't know. I don't I don't think that's the I think that's the way it all but I could be wrong. I don't know. I'm, I'm worried. Cause okay. Joel hasn't played a meaningful snap in a while. Coyote, our seeker has never played for the charges. Travis Burke has never played for the charges. Harky's never

played for the charges. Trevor Penning came to the charges halfway through last year. Pipkins has been there for a while. Slater hasn't played a meaningful snap in a while. Slaughter's never played a meaningful snap. Spoma, Colestrange and Logan Taylor. Cool. So the vet is Trey Pipkins. Everyone's right. All right. Listen, I know there's a lot of positivity around, but you've got to be realistic, right? You have to be realistic Alistair. Like if you're looking at that, you, when you literally look at that and go, wow, Trey Pipkins is there returning like veteran

who's been listened and people will be like, yeah, but it's a different coordinator. So it's all going to be. Yeah. Okay. Sure. But when you look at it like that, it's a coordinator who's, who's run back to back years of being the least pressured offense, the least pressured quarterback. And you just hope. Herbert plus the play calling plus a Marion Hampton getting handoffs. You're you're minimizing your damage as much as much. Well, if if a Marion Hampton gets the ball that is because we're not too sure that if that if those if those handoffs actually gonna happen, right? They can just be fumbles. I didn't know

I didn't know where I was going there plummeted on this. No, I'm actually over positive, but you have to be realistic. Because I've two weeks. I think the offensive line is probably the one down, but I'm going to be very, very about some other places I think. But I think that's a valid place for us to start because you're never gonna have a perfect team. You're gonna have a couple of position groups where you're feeling a little bit dicey. The problem for me is offensive line is one of them and that's not really what we wanted after the last however many years. But

you've got the offensive coordinator to... to do it. You don't have Greg Roman. So that's the there's the positivity and I'm I love Mike McDaniel, we all do. But he does have a big task ahead of him now. But he's all that big QJ bomb him jacket. We'd be remiss not to mention it that that looked pretty good in the past protection in the pocket held up pretty nicely. It did. It did. That was pretty sexy. That's that was very sexy. We'll keep on the offensive side of the ball. Are there many, if any, kind of position

groups that surprised by number or, we've said, did Darius Davis earn his spot, Jack? Yeah, I was very surprised that we rolled with six wide receivers. I thought it was either going to be Lambert Smith or Davis that was going to get cut. It's whether we suit up six wide receivers every game I don't think we do But clearly Darius Davis still has some chops. I mean, we haven't

seen Darius Davis be used with someone like a Mike McDaniel KLS has clearly done some stuff, you know, we I think a couple of shows ago, we talked about his attitude, that maybe he wasn't doing the things that you know, blocking and those types of small things. So the wide receivers is again, it's got an interesting unit. Alistair Who would you, who would you have rathered realistically Davis or KLS? What was your, what was your feel? I can't remember who we picked when we did that

show, but I'm pretty sure it was, um, I cut Darius Davis. I can't, I just can't remember. Yeah, we, yeah, nor can I, to be honest, I, I don't feel, I don't feel strongly about it. I came to, I came around to the view that tower, one of our very good listeners, uh, has made over the years, which is that maybe we're overrating the punt return ability and how much extra yardage that really gets you across the season to be carrying a dude who's really a non -factor at all on offense. Had a couple of catches in the

Rams game, but he also misses catches, or there was one he didn't quite come down with. And KLS intrigues me. There's enough route running chops and occasional playability. Like, we're so quick to judge these days. He's entering year two. So I don't mind looking at him for a little bit longer. Darius Davis is now QJ's class, right? He's entering year four. So I thought he was pretty lucky to make it and I would have, yeah, I would have gone in a different direction if, if it was me, Andy. Uh, yeah, look, I, I think

there's more sort of, there's more potential upside to Keondre Lambert Smith for mine. Uh, but Yeah, for me it was just an interesting one. I thought they'd take five, but they both get their roses for now So I don't think any big inclusion at all on either side of the ball for me. It's not a major surprise kind of a final 53 No, I don't I don't I don't really think so Rodney Shelley is probably the the name the the

name that you'd mentioned at corner but I guess they see more sort of boundary depth in Rodney Shelley than like Nico Reid, sort of smaller corner, but we get him on the practice squad. And we've got to shout out Joe Hortiz because it's his workings within the margins or within the lines as a GM in instances like this where you get two undrafted free agent, potential 53.

roster candidates, right? Like Avery Smith, I probably thought he had a greater chance than Tarah Edwards, but he's both turned, he's turned them both into sixth round picks, which is just phenomenal. Come the trade deadline, all those sorts of things. Like it's just ammunition to have. Can we give up less than that for Elijah Maldon, when we brought him in two years ago? That's like, it was either a sixth or a seventh. To get a sixth for each of those is pretty impressive. Didn't give anything back. And we know, yeah, it's, there was no pick swap and we know what

Hortiz can do on day three. So, uh, yeah, but going back to surprises, Rodney Shelley, probably the only one for me, but it just, it sort of makes sense how they, uh, treated that depth of, um, at, uh, corner. I'm, I'm, I'm super surprised that Nico Reed didn't get picked up. to be honest, and we were able to get him on the practice squad. Cause he had, cause I mean, he showed enough last year at the top level to be like, Oh, well, this guy's actually okay. I don't know whether that says more about Minters system and maybe

guys go, Oh, actually Minters system is the one that makes these guys look good. Like individually, perhaps they're, they're not as strong, but anyway, I think that, that, that Nico Reid. to, you know, I mean, he played well for us and probably come in and do some, probably need to do some stuff this year as well. Alistair, I, my other concern would be carrying only four edges. I mean, yes, the, the big names are the Khalil Mack and Tuli Tua Pelotu. Mezador I think is going to be fine. But then, you know, you talk about Dud, Dud Bupri.

And who we've got, we've got Tucker and who's on the practice squad is Andre Carter. I mean, that, that group is one and Caleb Murphy. Yeah. Good, good point. But you know, um, I don't know that that's deceptively thin. Do you not, do you not think? I think it's deceptively thin. Like the names are there, but how many games did Mac miss last year? Six I reckon something like that six or seven. Yeah. Yeah that that

that position group looks thinner than Alan Meyer hair If max to suffer something half as bad or miss any time at all Yeah, yeah, it's a concern. That is for sure. I was hopeful that bud Dupree would be clinging onto a roster spot for dear life and Canard got injured Tucker was a bit exciting. It was kind of flavor of the week for a little bit and then petered out trying to do a bit too much I think in the last game ended up with some missed tackles That practice squat

depth is fine. There's still an opportunity to make some kind of a move early in the season, but hey, maybe schematically this signifies You're gonna see a bit more sending guys off the edge who aren't edge rushes I know doing blitzers off the edge every now and then they go day on Henley off the edge could it Could it maybe lean towards that? I don't know. Like you, I was surprised. I don't know if you've only. He tends to send these blitzes from all over. So you can see corners. Who knows? Yeah. What was that? What was that

blitz right against the Rams guy? He's just sending people from everywhere. Um, Alistair, you said something really interesting there. So do you think it's a little bit of a GM tactic that Hortiz has kind of got? You know what? Maybe for the year we find a team because edges one of those premium positions and so it's one of those positions where you draft and you spend a lot of draft capital on. Do you kind of think that maybe there are the teams that are kind of petering in that playoff form or not? And all of a sudden that they're not that you do get guys a little bit

disgruntled by week six, week seven and goes, Hey, actually I'd like you always, you know, maybe Hortiz has got a little bit of a strategy to do a mid season kind of big trade for someone like that, just to sort of thicken that group out a little bit. I don't know. Is it, is that something that has ever crossed your mind? It just, it literally just came to me now. I think that's exactly what he's doing. And he's now got two additional six round picks with which to trade around the deadline. He's shown himself to be active at that time. It is it is quite a good way to approach things I think because

the risk the risk is so let's think it through if if maybe you're not fielding your best strongest team earlier in the year. hoping you can bring guys in and around the deadline you're risking losses earlier in the year but if you manage to have enough wins and get to that deadline where you know you're going to be a contender that is the time of year where the bottom eight teams are looking to offload dudes and each of those bottom eight teams will have a few star players and if you can get them at these premium positions like edge Especially if they're dudes

on expiring contact or contracts, or kids would be like, where am I expiring contracts guys? Where I can get a nine game rental. He almost looked like a genius. Cause like OA has three sacks in that first playoff game. Imagine if we win that playoff game and actually go on a run, you're stealing a Superbowl with a key acquisition around the deadline. And it just feels like edge Andy is kind of one of those positions where It's not really scheme dependent. Like if you can get to the quarterback and set the edge, it doesn't matter what scheme that you're playing in. It could be a three, four, could be a four,

three, could be zoned, could be mad. It doesn't matter. You just do your job. Whereas I think maybe for your linebackers, your safeties, your corners, a lot of those, you go, oh, is he going to actually work, you know, given, given that he's successful in this system? Yeah, that's, that's a, that's a fair comment to an extent, definitely more so for edge and, um, But now that Perryman's on IR, we've got four backers, four inside line backers and four outside line

backers. So I think overall it's quite a thin grouping. And for me, we're definitely gonna need to see an increase in workload from the likes of Marlowe Wax if the team's looking to keep Troy Dye. and Del Sean Phillips, predominantly for special teams. But who, Al, do you think that second, second up linebacker would be? Probably

Die. I think it is probably Die. I wouldn't mind saying it be Wax, to be honest. Because I'm thinking of the the Perryman. run -first mentality, and Henley's probably a little better in coverage, although I made a fantastic tackle for loss in the backfield against the Rams. Wax is more of your downhill thumper who's showing an aptitude. I don't really feel that way about Dye or Delshon Phillips, to be honest. Kind of more hybrid or coverage -style players, so that'll be interesting

to see. Harbaugh hinted at Delshon's name today, so maybe Wax isn't really going to be considered, at least to start the year. Look, I know we're sounding a little negative even though the the edge and linebacker spots aren't deep I still feel pretty good about the starters in those rooms to start the year. I like Not a lot of teams can say they've got a first round pick and a second round pick and another first round pick rushing the passer and I thought Mezador looked fine in the preseason. It's easy not to see it because it's only a few snaps a game,

but I think he'll play with a lot of effort. And all the talk from Mac this training camp has been he's, he's picking off Justin Herbert, intercepting a screen, he's blowing up practice. So Mac seems like he's no different to the guy it's been the last few years. So let's not write us off yet. Yeah, he'll be fine, I think. And I've, I've, I've got some, I've got some takes Andy, but I don't want to sort of jump into the next segment too much about, uh, about, about some sort of, yeah, we'll get there soon enough.

No doubt. Uh, another Hortys little tidbit cutting ties with former Michigan third round pick waving, uh, junior Colson. Again, he did end up on the practice squad, but three pre -season outings with PFF grades of 87, 89 and 69, not enough to cut it. So we're now seeing Kyle Canard as well. We're seeing a bit of a swallowing pride and making the right decision, not just sort of hanging onto those mid -round draft picks as a GM can tend to do to sort of Tom Telesco,

sort of ride it out and see it out, you know, so. And were you guys shocked? I was shocked that Colson cleared waivers. I know our friend, Stephen Hagelin, put out this stat that over the last two years, only 56 out of about 2 ,200 people have actually been claimed on the release on the day after final 53s. But Colson, Colson's mainly missed time because of injuries and appendicitis and these types of issues. When he's been on the field, he hasn't looked good. Don't get me wrong. He hasn't looked like a complete liability.

And as recently as two years ago, he's an early third round pick, comes from a great championship program. He was equally good against run and pass. I'm really surprised that there's not one other team out there who thought they'd pick him up. Yeah, definitely. I think a fair comment for what he showed that he was capable of in the pre -season. Absolutely. Yeah. And a big win for us because let him continue to develop. Well, yeah, especially with what's happened with Denzel. I was surprised that the Minter didn't pick him up. Like you saw him there and went,

Oh yeah, this guy played for me for however many years. Great player here. Come, come, come to me. So obviously he'd be stepping in. He'd be stepping on the, the Messiah and all God's, you know, coat tails there. Don't didn't want to ruin that relationship. Perhaps Jesse, not yet. Anyway, until though, until we play them in the playoffs, we'll see what happens. Maybe just the safety is gone. What's your name again? Six safeties. Did that surprise either of you too? Uh, I guess, you know, Chris O'Deby. Yeah, Chris

O'Deby. Yeah. Yeah. I was surprised by that. We've gone with six guys. We didn't talk about it. Well, in the hindsight, which is 2020, I'm not surprised, but that's a lot of DBs for, I don't know if they're the most talented DBs. Oh, they're in the entire NFL. There are a few guys, you know, Shelley and most of us wouldn't recognize him if he popped up in our Weep Bix. Um, we didn't talk about Kendall Williamson really at all this off season, but he's just a solid special team. Vickens laughing. He's got all

these guys. Yeah. Uh, it's just going to be interesting to see what kind of role they all play. Will we see a permanent role for doing in the nickel? Will he still be sort of used in bits and pieces everywhere? Um, because We can have two two other safeties on the field and one operates sort of as a hybrid corner Who the hell needs this many safeties? I'm really I'm actually surprised like Again, are we showing ourselves to be a team

who really wants to place three safeties all the time a bit like bit Minter did? Yeah, we probably are Yeah, and is doing basically full -time slot, but then some of these guys aren't gonna suit up I mean, how many safeties are you going to address on game day five, right? Maybe there just needed to be some special teams depth. Like, cause we were poor. Like it was one of Thicken's worst seasons last year. I mean, the fact is we're not, you know, like who, like who

are the special teamers? So let's just, just on this, on, on this, um, who are they? So Troy Dye, Del Sean Phillips, Marlo Wax. Probably are you going, Dean Leonard, Rodney Shelley, are they are they playing or are they playing meaningful snaps? And then you've got not not Tony Jefferson. Probably not. Is it Genesis, Williamson and maybe Mickens as well? So. You're kind of building a like, they're all relative, they're smaller linebackers and safeties in DB. So maybe they

want to go a little bit quicker on special teams rather than having, you know, you're big, you know, carrying an extra edge or an extra, I don't know, like a tight end or something like that. Those, those guys sort of perhaps round out those position groups, but are not particularly good athletes for that. So maybe there's some thinking around that because special teams was such, was such an issue last year. I don't know. I'm, I'm, people will go, this guy's an armchair gym. He doesn't know what the fuck he's talking about. I don't know. I'm just trying to provide some answers, I guess. Yeah, that's all. I thought

that was fair. I've got no issue. Was it fair? Yeah. I mean, only three tight ends rusted. I know there was no one else who really was being thought of for Bodo and whoever the other guy was. Pazoo. Pazuzi. Johnny Pazuzi. Pazuzi Pazuzi. But yeah, I think there's probably something in that wanting to in a certain way on special teams And as long as we can't see Scott Matlock on special teams, I'm happy. Let's just be honest with that one. Yeah All right guys, we're going

to We're gonna play a little game called the roster confidence meter So I'm gonna go through the position groups and you're gonna give me a ready to contend good enough Developing or needs help. Yep. All right, so let's go quarterback Jack? That's that's easy. Ready to contend? I think we're all on the same page. Yeah, we're all on the same page. That one. Yeah, let's not move on though. No, no, I want to unpack that now that we've got Jack back. Trey Lance is your backup. How do you feel about that? Should the team have done something different? Keep DJ,

there's rumors about JJ McCarthy. Are you comfortable that Trey Lance can win us football games if called upon? Absolutely. Because I think Mike McDaniel can do some really interesting things with his legs and he can, and I reckon Mike McDaniel, if, if really pushed, he could probably win a couple of games with Trey Lance as your wildcat quarterback. You saw him how incredibly, when those, when the sort of the play broke down, listen, let's not talk about his passing game and his ability or lack thereof to get through his progressions. The fact that he can move and get, you know, run for 10 yards, 12 yards and

go, I think, you know, I think that in that Shanahan style system, there's room for Lance to succeed, but it would probably become a one trick pony. Would we win a championship? Absolutely not. But if Herbert hurt himself for a couple of weeks and Trey Lance had come in, I trust Mike McDaniel to do something in that zone running game to really sort of throw off the opponent. That's where I sit. Sweet. All right, Al, the wide receivers.

Of the ratings we're assigning here, ready to contend good enough, developing or needs help, I have gone with developing for the wide receivers. Maybe a bit of a surprise, but we've got a youth movement. They're all first contract players. None of them are really experienced or proven commodities in the NFL. Bit of pressure on McConkey after a slightly down year, although I think it'll be fine You've got QJ and Darius Davis your most experienced players in the group And

there's just quite a bit of unknowns for me. So developing means And it's not a pejorative because you do have Trey Harris developing into a non blocking role because he's got a real OC you do have Quentin Johnston developing on crossing routes and being used properly because he has a real OC you do have these different players developing in their roles so that is my grade and I'll just Ask you guys would either of you go higher to to good enough or ready to content

I Actually had it as developing as well for the same argument of all on first contracts It was sort of at the just below good enough because I think we We've seen the output that some of these guys have had and I'm expecting improvements from Trey Harris, but still developing. Same, but these are not static grades. I'm just saying sitting here today, developing and by middle to the end of the year, we could be singing a different tune and will be if we're winning. We hope so. Hope they're all ready to content.

Uh, all right, Jack, the, the running back group. Uh, does that include Alec Ingold? I'm just gonna, or are you putting him with the tight ends? I'm going to put him with the running back group. putting with the running back group. I think it's good enough. Yeah, I think it's good enough. You really, if you asked me this at the start of last year with the group that we had, I probably would have said ready to contend, but a firework going off into someone's eye put a dampener on that one. So I'd say this good enough. There's

still a little bit of unknowns for me about Keaton Mitchell. and Kamani Vidal and whether he's going to be okay in this. I think they're going to be. Marion Hampton, I think is going to be okay. But again, we haven't seen much pre -season. So I'm saying good enough. There's enough capital in there. And Alec Ingold is a sneaky, possibly one of the most important players that we have on the roster that not a lot of people are talking about. Why are you laughing Alistair? Because he disagrees, vehemently. No, not vehemently.

This is why I needed like some positivity in my life. I'm clearly in some kind of a slightly cynical mood because I felt so good about the running back position about three and a half weeks ago and the concept of it all. And since then, Hampton's one carry went for minus one yards because he didn't see a cutback lane properly, which was something we talked about. when he came out. Although, I've wrote on Twitter, tough to expect him to see that cutback line. It's his first carry. He's just tried to hit the stretch

outside run. That was his one carry. Keaton Mitchell has not played at all because he's been injured. They just haven't said what's going on. We've got no idea. And this is a guy who's been injured his whole career, wherever he's been. And then Kamani Vidal has 12 carries for 23 yards in the preseason. Looks completely lost out there. Andy may as well being under center. Yeah. Taking the handoffs. Well, I was excited. Yeah. Okay. Then add, then add, then add DeRozier, add DeRozier. Am a boy. Am a boy. So I'm hopeful cause they

could be like Hampton could be an absolute start in a top five NFL running back. It's a bit like I need to, he will be, he will be. That's it. That's it. Okay, I've convinced him. They're good enough. So where did you land? Are you going developing? Are you creating, are you doing a jack and creating your own answer of unknown? Well, again, we've got to see developing. We've got to see Hampton running in his own scheme and we've got to see Keaton not injured and Vidal averaging more than 1 .9 yards per carry. Yeah,

I do agree with that. Okay, Al, the tight end room. Maybe something to be a little bit more excited about. Yeah, they're good enough. I'm happy. I'm happy with that. In this on this case, I'm going to put down some of the group's concerns in the preseason because they've also looked a bit suspect Kolar and Najoku down to some rust and getting into things and and they're both veteran guys Kolar and Najoku. I think when the bright lights shine, they'll be at their best. I also really liked Gadsden's preseason. I thought he thought he was great. Yeah, I thought it was

great. He wants he does not want to be an afterthought. I love his I love his presses. I think he's a really thoughtful, introspective guy who wants to be the best pro possibly can be. I like that group. Would a fourth one be nice? Yeah, I guess but we've just got Justin Herbert's brother rocking up. Yeah, and you've got in gold and you've got in gold if you want to go a sixth offensive lineman. So good group that group is good enough to get us there. Yep. Okay. Lots to go through of 11 of them, but Jack, what do you have for the offensive

line? It's a real tough one now. Yeah. Okay. I'm going to say it. I think it needs help. I think it needs help. Yeah. I think it needs help. It's I started with it being a little bit negative and I think I might have sort of put myself into a bit of a negative spin for those reasons that we've all that that I said before is that when Trey Pipkins is your most experienced lineman, I know that it's a new coordinator and all this kind of stuff. But I'm going, oh, no. And we

just don't know with Ray Sean Slater. So if Alistair's using the injury cloud to really take my good enough running back room to developing, I'm going to say move this from developing to needs help. They're going to get help. They've got a great coach in Butch Barry. And I think they're going to be OK. But it's. They're not starting from developing to be good enough I don't think I think they're a grade lower than that and without a grade in between developing and needing help Unfortunately, I'm I've left it needs help. I

don't know I don't know whether you feel the same way about that or not guys, but that's where I am look I've gone with developing into good enough because if you get Joe Alton Rashawn Slater as Joe Alton Rashawn Slater then you've got excellent tackles. The sort of developing is obviously, you know, Jake Slaughter being flung into starting centre and I'm giving them the benefit of the

doubt for the Mike McDaniel situation. So, you know, I'm really trying to buy into this. the guard position isn't it's easier to to mask over uh in Mike McDaniel's offense so I'm being a little bit more well a lot more sort of optimistic than than you Jack. I'm on developing like almost like you Andy I I need to unsee the preseason and just cling on to this idea that the team wasn't trying and it didn't matter to them and we're just going to rock up and be awesome. against

the cards and the Raiders because what I saw was Joe Ault struggle on an outside zone run and struggle on a pass pro rep where he slightly over set it and then got beaten to the inside and was a little bit gimpy after the play. I look at the all 22, no one's noticing that shit on the broadcast. I'm going, Oh, that's interesting. Only 11 snaps to old two things that I would say are uncharacteristic from him. And then we've talked about Slater and we've talked about the audition. And I like the idea that we've got that we've got these great tackles, which we

do. Will they play great early in the season that I'm less sure of, but developing is I think again, they will play great the more time they have in the system as the year goes on. Cool. Well -rounded offense onto the defense interior of the defensive line, Jack. Yes. Okay. I think this is where I want it to be. This is, and so I'm flipping this completely on its head. I think this group of defensive linemen, because we haven't spoken about them so far on the show. I think

they are ready to contend. I think there will be a top five unit, a top five unit by the end of the year. I think they've got the right amount of size, the right amount of experience. I love the addition of Tomlinson. I think Tia Tartt is great. to, uh, is, is going to be there a leader. He's nasty. He's got a bit of balls about him and a Boigby. I'm happy to eat my humble pie has looked really good too. Then you ran it off with Caldwell, who who's going to be another

year in the system. And then you've got Barrett for me. This is the ready to contend group that is going to lead the defense and be sneaky, sneaky good. You will not want to play against the charges defensive line because they're gonna make you sweat. Alistair that's that's how I think. Yep. Great mix of age groups. Excellent depth with upside because some of them are still young, but you've got some veterans. Only one thing missing is like your obvious stud pass rush threat, but we'll see if the boy B can become that because it certainly looks like he could be based on

preseason form. Ready to contend. I agree with the label. I love this group. I love it so much. I thought they had a really good preseason too. I love it. I love it. All right. I'll take the edge. Yep. Uh, I've gone with good enough in this group. I know we said that there weren't too many of them, but we do have Mack Tully and Mezador, a prospect I really, really liked. And much as I pay out Bud Dupree, he tries hard and sets an edge and he's a leader. Like he can place teams. He is kind. He is a kind guy. He's one

of these real mental. He's meant to be one of the nicest guys in the locker room. Reportedly. All right. Take it back. Take the mic back off me, Andy. That's it. They're good. I think they're good enough. And it would be weird to call them developing because you do have like a super duper old guy ready to win right now in Kalimak. Desperate to win right now. Jack the backers. I, this was hard, but I had to land on developing. I just haven't seen, unfortunately, I mean, Henley's

got the capacity and the ability and the measurables to be a really good linebacker in the league. Unfortunately, due to all sorts of reasons last year, we just didn't see that. Troy Dye, I think has kind of hit his ceiling of where he's going to be. Perryman, we know what he's bringing. Wax and Phillips, they're kind of really unproven at the NFL level as just yet. So yeah, for me, this is a developing group. Not needs help because

I think there's enough. There are enough players in there that can do different roles and do them relatively well. We know when Denzel Perryman plays, the run fits look better. Um, that's, that's his, that is if he plays. So I'm, I'm developing out. I put it as a good enough because I do. Yeah. Cause I think that collection of six Perryman use. Well, I'm going to look at it. I make up my own rules. Now I'm looking at it in a long view system perspective. I think

about playoff teams, Super Bowl winning teams. Does this linebacker room look way worse than a potential Super Bowl winner? They might be, we're missing like a Mike who's their best player or having a Mike linebacker like a Fred Warner who's a freak. Could be Henley. Could be Henley. Yeah, and not a lot of teams who win Super Bowls even have that. They just have two steady Eddie dudes. And then I reckon having Colson on the practice squad and wax and del Sean and I reckon all of those guys can can play in a pinch and not be liabilities. So I think they're I think

they're good enough by league standards. But I hear where you're coming from, Jack, they need to they need to show a bit more, especially Henley. I found myself in the realm that you did earlier, Jack, with the they're not being a grade between developing and good enough. So I won't landed on developing. They're not developing as youthful careers, although maybe Henley could play with a little bit more maturity at times. But that's probably being a bit harsh. All right, Al, the cornerback room. Yeah, corners need help, guys.

And that help may be schematic help playing a lot of zone. But if we're going to blitz at the rate we were in the preseason, and go seven man pressures, just hold your hats in the back end. I don't know. I don't know. We're one injury away from Dean Leonard or Shelly being in there. And I know we've signed Kaeya Ilham to the practice squad. Again, we like these former first round guys. The concern with former first round guys is when you start to forget the team that originally drafted them because they've been five since.

Yeah, Elam is getting there as a Buffalo Bill and now who like Dallas, who else? Maybe chiefs, chiefs, chiefs. There might be another one though. What's interesting though is I don't know if needs help suddenly means you're gonna Be a terrible past defense because I do think in the NFL you especially the modern version You can choose to be conservative and not get torched I just

don't know if O 'Leary is gonna do that and if he doesn't I don't feel like this is the right cornerback room to be Playing a lot of man coverage with them holding up one -on -one. Yeah, I I don't know What O 'Leary is gonna do? that kind of left Horty's not kind of covering the output of Benjamin St. Just even though it wasn't much I don't know if Rodney Shelley is expected to be able to sort of supplement some of that skill set but Nico Reed not really as you sort of Only

real corner on the practice squad. I think It's pretty thin there, but look then they've gone with Six safeties Jack. How do you grade this room? Well, you have to, I mean, there's one, so we haven't sort of talked about like a lot of the, I guess the alpha on the other defense, sorry, in the other defensive group is Khalil Mack. You've got to talk about the alpha, which is, you know, Derwin James. So, and then Tony Jefferson, Mickens, Maldon, Smith, Williamson.

I found it really hard after I get after Derwin James to give them anything other than good enough. I was flirting with ready to contend. But I but I think I have to land with with good enough as well. TJ I love I think he brings a bit of nastiness that we need on the back end a little bit. Mickens has done well. I think last year, Maldon, we know can play, but has had some health issues. Genesis, we don't know. I wouldn't expect him getting many snaps early in the, in the year.

And Williamson, we kind of have hardly talked about. So for me, it's good enough. Alistair, before I do throw to you, what was interesting, I was listening to it was either the athletic or the ringer the other day. And they were talking about the charged defenses. Is it a top 10 or not? Um, and one of the pundits on there was talking about how, what he heard from Chris O 'Leary's defense when he went to Eastern Michigan. Is that right? Eastern, Western? Eastern Michigan. Western, sorry, I should say. that he tried to bring Minters playbook to, to, to the guys, he essentially sort of put the playbook on the table

and said, this is what we're going to try and do. And then as the season went on, he realized that they couldn't actually do that sort of NFL sort of style. And what he started to do is generate different types of pressure and, and, and play a little bit more man on the backend and try to get pressure on the quarterback. So it is, you brought it up before, like, you know, these groups at CB and safety and, um, Are they good enough to sort of maybe make that shift and go to man? I'm with you because I didn't get a chance, but I think that the CB group is, is needing

help too. But I think the safety group is good enough. I do too. The one wild card is Genesis Smith. Cause you asked, if you asked me, who is the young springy guy with the range to cover great expanses of distance. when you're blitzing it would be that guy he's got like a 90 second percentile wingspan and can we saw flashes of it in the preseason elijah molden's kind of a smaller guy with choppy legs he doesn't cover great distance tony jefferson's an older player so yeah i'm with you jack i do worry a little

bit if it is going to be more aggressive, unless Genesis Kansas surprise us. I did have them as good enough though. I do think Maldon's a good player. Jefferson brings some hate. Derwin's a superstar. So anything less than good enough, I think would just not, not be acknowledging those first three guys. Yep. Nice one. All right. Let's round it out with a couple of superlatives of the roster. Jackie Golden Broom, your best position group on the team. Defensive line by a long way. My boys. My boys. Al, who have you

gone with? Yep, defensive tackles. Nice. We have to fight each other in a pit full of mud naked for those then. I think I'm a little bit higher on the youth in the safety room. My golden room is the safety room for the charters. Boldest call. So the bravest confirmed roster decision. Jack. Well, what I, I actually had this as, uh, cutting junior Colson. That was, I thought, I

thought that was a, a brave call given the connection at Michigan and the draft capital that they put in. I actually quite liked it. Didn't perform. So we cut you on the practice squad. You'll probably still play, but, but I like that. That's what I said. Boulder's call. Jack, you're stealing my lines, man. Seriously? Yeah, cutting Junior Colson. Because I just, God, Hortiz must have had some good intel. Maybe they just didn't care if they lost him. But if the plan was they wanted to get him back and did, wow. But bold call,

cutting your guy who, as you said at the top of the show, Andy, was like a top five graded linebacker across the league in the preseason. Finally looks like he's coming good. Your third round dude from Michigan. Cut! In some senses, I'm really impressed by it. Goodness, it was bold that he survived and made it to the practice squad. And he did tick, tick, tick. Yep. Nice. Uh, possibly another one for me was just the, the number of edge and cornerbacks, uh, and sort of the makeup, um, predominantly in the cornerback room. I did also have a funny one. I, as I looked

through the roster, you know, I went full back. Oh, no Scott Matlock, uh, offensive line. No Scott Matlock, tight end. No Scott Matlock. No Scott Matlock. But they found a way to keep him around and he winds up on injured reserve designated to return. Son of a gun. Hidden value Jack, most underrated player or a role. I have to go back to the defensive line and Alistair, if you've got the same one, then that's incredible. It's

Justin, it's Justin Aboigbe. Don't tell me it is. It's Justin Aboigbe. I'm saying it's Aboigbe. I'm going back to the well. in terms and saying that I actually thought it was a bit of a waste of a pick. If he can provide that interior pass rush, which is what we've seen flashes of that makes that golden room. I was going to say something, but I won't. It's going to make it even a more golden room. Let's let's call it a that. So Justin and Boyd V is his is the hidden value there.

That's what you do when you celebrate is it yeesh Do you know if I spent more than 20 seconds thinking about this answer I think yours is better than mine and I would have ended up there so but I'm glad I haven't gone three from three Copping you I went with the key mesador Because I think if someone like a Mac goes down or Tully for a while It is going to be so important that he can almost replicate the value. He's got a real chance to make an impact this season in year one Yeah, nice I had Alec Engold. I don't think

that Herbert or the Chargers have had a fullback like this, so we've been kicking about with some pretty rubbish names over the last few years. Biggest opportunity, player whose role is set to grow the most, Jack? Yeah, I've actually found this one quite easy when I think of what we're going to see on offense. I think it's got to be Trey Harris. You line up with QJ, you line up with Ladd, you line up with Trey. I think

the attention's going on the first two. Trey Harris is going to really grow into the role of the third wide receiver and to have him, the calibre of a second round pick, the quality as a third wide receiver. I think that's going to, that's by mid -season we're going to be going, oh boy, he's doing well. So Trey Harris for mine in the biggest opportunity. Great chat. The biggest opportunity is there for Arunde Gadsden to take. As we said earlier, I thought he blocked well

on a lead toss play against the Rams. He wants to become a better blocker. The chance is there. He was so dominant in a couple of games last year, having over 100 yards receiving. He can grow into the role. He shouldn't be scared of Najoku, who's on the back end of his career, or even Cola, who's mainly been a blocking tight end. he's got a great opportunity to be tight end one if he wants it. Yeah. Wow. Tight end one. Huge. Uh, I have Dayon Henley and Akeem Esador, uh, for biggest opportunities, just seeing

Perryman go out and yeah, the thinness of the edge group. Okay. The move that ages well decision likely to look smarter by mid season. Alistair, you, you go for this one because I'm interested to see what you've got. I'm I'm just banking on being totally wrong. It happens all the time and I'm honestly going with Darius Davis and that we've spent all this time laughing about

him. They keep telling us he was injured all last year. They keep saying the dude was injured all last year. We want this guy. He's a difference maker. He's a difference maker on punt return. What if he's had two punt return touchdowns by mid season and we were all going, oh, okay. He's back. Ficken. Special teams is looking good again. Maybe that is the move that age as well that we've all been canning this pre -season. That's my left field pick. My one is going back to the blue chipper. His name is Jake Slaughter. Fanbase

was divided on the pick. It is now... already looked like a good decision to take a center that early because of the Beardish injury. I just have this feeling and I really hope that I'm right. I really hope that I'm right that even though I did criticize him for his play strength, I feel like just he's meant to be this smart, eloquent, erudite, hard worker, yes sir, no sir, guy and that by the middle of the season,

we're getting these games into a hopefully what will be our starting centre for the foreseeable future depending on how well Beardish comes back. I'm really, really hoping that is the case for Hortiz. I'm loving the positivity out of these two. My move that age as well is Joe Hortiz manufacturing sixth round draft picks for undrafted free agents. Welcome the trade deadline. At least one of them for this year. Guys, a one word verdict. I'd

say give grades, but let's just give a one word verdict to close it out of the roster. What have you got Jack? Alistair or one of you two can go I just need to I need to think that's okay right now in case you haven't been able to tell all show listeners it's apprehensive that is my word for how I'm feeling right now now ask me we're in war but an Andy watching with 25 beers against the Cardinals and I will be excited,

pumped, thrilled, every other word under the sun. Right now, it's apprehensive because of all the things I've seen that haven't quite gone to plan yet, but the season hasn't even begun yet. So I'm hopeful that these nerves are just me being a bit of a little coward earlier in the season and we'll pick it back up. Yeah, mine is almost. It's just not quite there to be one of these rosters that you look back over and go, yep, that's a Super Bowl team. I just think

there's a lack of polish and some of it's come up with luck as well. Beardish is a big one. This year, Slater, so there's just a lot is being banked on potential. Almost and I'm hoping that changes too. Hey, there we go. We saw it. I have one and the word is McDaniel It's the one thing it's the one thing to end and and that's where

I landed I was gonna go with introspective or apprehensive was one of them or you know calm or no Realistically Andy, can you get up what the prompt was? We were meant to give one word on what it was on the final roster, wasn't it? I make it just says final overall grades. To close it out, to close out, to close it out. It's a perfect Daniel. I find it. I find myself coming back all the questions that I have of

this team, all the questions. Cause I was thinking like, Well, where does Herbert go? If this doesn't work, what is the criticism? It's like, you've, you've got the best offensive coordinator in the game. And if it doesn't work, then where am I? And I go back to it's McDaniel. I go to the offensive line. I look at what are we going to, it's going to be McDaniel. I look at the running back. It's going to be McDaniel. I look at, Hey, but then I go, well, if the defense is going to be, you know, are they going to be put under pressure from the office? Is it going to be turning? It's McDaniel. So my one word

verdict is McDaniel. Awesome. I think that's an awesome place to end up. Guys, we want to hear what your one word verdict is on the Chargers roster. I hope you've had fun with us breaking it down. We'll see you next time on the Thunderdown Under Chargers podcast. Hooroo! Bye, Hooroo!

Looking fiery, he's got Floyd turning, go!

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. MNF WIN RUINED THE TANK?! | Chargers Shock Ravens for Win #1

    Nov 18, 202658 minAudio

    #BoltUp! The drought is officially over. In a gritty, ground-and-pound battle at M&T Bank Stadium, the Chargers secure their first win of the season, edging out the Ravens 23-20. While the majority of Charger Nation...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. THE 0-8 CHARGERS FIRE SALE! WHY TRADING HENLEY TO DENVER MIGHT BE GENIUS

    Nov 11, 202658 minAudio

    #BoltUp! An absolute nightmare at SoFi Stadium followed by one of the most shocking trade deadlines in recent franchise history. Hours before the deadline, Joe Hortiz sent young leader and linebacker Daiyan Henley to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. DOWN WITH THE TANK! 0-7 & NINE QUARTERS WITHOUT A TOUCHDOWN | Chargers vs Rams Wk 8 Recap

    Nov 4, 202655 minAudio

    #BoltUp! Another absolute fizzer for the Bolts Offense at SoFi Stadium. Despite Joe Alt’s brilliant return anchoring a clean pass-blocking performance, the Chargers collapse to 0-7 following a lifeless 24-9 loss to the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. MCDANIEL’S LAST CHANCE?! | Chargers vs Rams Week 8 Preview

    Oct 29, 202637 minAudio

    #BoltUp! At 0-6, the Chargers return home to SoFi Stadium for the "Battle of Los Angeles" against Matthew Stafford, Puka Nacua, and the 3-4 Rams. With the Offense sitting 32nd in EPA per play and scoring just 15 points...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. HARBAUGH REFUSES TO BACK MCDANIEL! | Chargers Drop to 0-6 in Arrowhead Disaster

    Oct 21, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    #BoltUp! An utter, non-competitive disaster at Arrowhead Stadium. The Chargers crash to a 22-6 loss against the Kansas City Chiefs, dropping to 0-6 for the first time since 2000 - when Jim Harbaugh was the starting...

    Credit the people on this episode