How do you know when you have enough information to make a good decision? Good judgment isn't about always knowing the right answer. It's about making thoughtful decisions with confidence, even when the outcome is uncertain. In this Introspective Moment, Colleen shares a personal story about a parenting decision and explores how the strength of Judgment helps us weigh information, trust our thinking, and remain open to changing our minds when circumstances change. Discover why good judgment requires confidence without certainty, and consider where you might be ready to take the next thoughtful step. Episode Show Notes Introspective strength affirmation cards: https://www.introspectivecards.com/ Skills Discovery assessment: https://www.skillsdiscovery.com Have a question or want to suggest a guest for the Strengths Catalyst Podcast? Email Colleen (Colleen@strengthcatalyst.com)
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Hello, and welcome to Introspective Moments. I'm Colleen Baseli, an executive coach and a strength strategist. Each week I'll spend just a few minutes exploring one strength to use our strengths with greater intention and to notice how they shape our work, our relationships, and our everyday lives.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Introspective Moments. Today I'd like to talk about judgment. When we think about someone who has good judgment, we might imagine someone who seems to know the right answer, someone who is decisive, confident, certain. But here's something I've learned over the years. Good judgment requires confidence without certainty. Because most of the decisions that really matter don't come with guarantees. We gather information, we consider the facts, we listen to other perspectives, and eventually we have to decide, even though we can't know exactly how things will turn out.
SPEAKER_00My niece Julie reminded me of this. Julie will tell you that she can sometimes hesitate over everyday decisions. What's for dinner, what to do over the weekend, wanting to consider all the options. I get that. But recently, she faced a parenting decision that felt much more consequential. Her daughter had reached an age when many of her friends were getting phones and smartwatches. Parents around Julie were debating the pros and cons, and some questioned why her daughter didn't have a device too.
SPEAKER_00So Julie thought carefully about what mattered most to her: her daughter's safety and health, the development of strong interpersonal and social skills, and her family's values and priorities. And once she was clear about what mattered, the decision became clear too. Her daughter wouldn't get a phone or smartwatch yet. Instead, Julie and her husband gave her an old school watch with features like a stopwatch and decided that a phone could come in eighth grade.
SPEAKER_00Even when other parents made different choices, Julie didn't second guess hers. But she couldn't know with certainty how the decision would turn out. But she had enough information and enough clarity about what mattered to trust her judgment. Her daughter accepted the decision. She even started saving toward the phone she would eventually get. In the meantime, she and her friends began using the stopwatch on her watch to time themselves at recess.
SPEAKER_00What I love about Julie's story is that she wasn't able to see into the future. None of us can. She simply made the best decision she could with the information she had and what mattered most to her. Good judgment requires confidence without certainty. Judgment is the strength of assessing a situation, considering the evidence and facts, and reaching a decision that you feel confident can stand up to challenge. And here's something coaching has taught me. Being confident in a decision isn't the same as being certain about its outcome.
SPEAKER_00Confidence says, I've considered what I know and I'm ready to decide. Certainty, however, can tempt us to say, I've decided, so I don't need to reconsider. And that's an important difference because good judgment doesn't end the moment we make a decision. We keep paying attention, we notice what happens, we listen when new information emerges. And when circumstances change, sometimes our thinking should change too. Adam Grant explores this idea in his book Think Again.
SPEAKER_00He writes about the importance of questioning what we think we know and being willing to reconsider our conclusions when new information warrants it. And I think that's an important part of good judgment. Changing your mind when the information changes isn't poor judgment. Sometimes it's evidence of good judgment. But knowing that doesn't always make decision making easy. Like every strength, judgment can be both underplayed and overplayed.
SPEAKER_00If you tend to underplay judgment, you may recognize the feeling of wanting just one more piece of information before you decide. So you ask another person, you read another article, you might revisit the pros and cons. And sometimes that additional information helps, but sometimes you're seeking something no amount of information can give you certainty. And at some point, good judgment asks us to decide. At the same time, if judgment comes naturally to you, you may reach conclusions quickly and confidently.
SPEAKER_00The overplay can happen when that confidence turns into attachment. You've made your decision, you've explained your reasoning, and then new information arrives that suggests you might want to reconsider. Can you stay curious enough to hear it? Can you change your mind without feeling that doing so means your original judgment was wrong? Trust your judgment without becoming attached to being right. So that's the balance I invite you to notice this week.
SPEAKER_00Think about a decision that's been occupying your mind. Do you truly need more information? Or do you already have enough to make a thoughtful decision and move forward? And once you decide, can you trust your judgment while remaining open to what you learn? If you have a deck of introspective cards, you might pull out the judgment card this week. Its question asks, what decision can I make with confidence today, even if I'm unsure of the outcome? Maybe there's one decision in your life right now where you don't need certainty.
SPEAKER_00You simply need enough information to take the next thoughtful step. Thanks for spending these few minutes with me, and until next time, take a few moments to be introspective and notice what changes.
How can you make the most of being in the spotlight while helping others shine? The strength of Spotlight brings energy and confidence to moments when we're visible, sharing ideas, or engaging an audience. Used well,...
What if finding greater purpose didn't require changing your life? We often think of purpose as something grand: a calling, a career, or a cause that gives our lives meaning. But the strength of Mission reminds us that...
What helps you regain your footing when life doesn't go as planned? Resilience is more than pushing through difficult experiences. It's also about recognizing the strengths and resources that help us recover, regain our...
What if you could help someone recognize a strength they don't yet see in themselves? Building someone's confidence goes beyond offering praise. It's about recognizing their potential and helping them discover what...
What makes it easier to connect with someone new? In this Introspective Moment, Colleen explores Rapport Builder and the role curiosity can play in creating connection. Through a personal story about her daughter Mary...