Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Skintrovert

The Skintrovert artwork

Season 3 Ep. 34 - Supplements in Skincare featuring Dr. Doris Day

Nov 10, 202629 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

With so many supplement options flooding your feed, is there anything that actually helps? Dr Doris Day joins Sam for a conversation around supplements in skincare - what is needed and what you may want to pass on. If you are tired of guessing when it comes to supplements, this episode is for you! Support the show Connect with Sam Bazile Stay connected and continue the conversation beyond the podcast. Follow The Skintrovert and explore more educational, honest discussions around aesthetics across these platforms: Instagram: https://instagram.com/the_skintrovert Website: https://theskintrovert.com YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@theskintrovert Join the community, trade noise for knowledge, and dive deeper into the conversations shaping modern aesthetics.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Hey y'all, welcome to the Skin Trovert. I'm your host, Sam Bazil. So, how many times are you scrolling on your phone and yet another supplement ad pops up? You need this for your next skin health journey. Ooh, if you have acne, you need this. If you are wrinkling, you need this. Oh, if you're on your weight loss journey, you need this supplement. If you're on your wellness journey, you need this supplement. If you're having hormonal fluctuations, you need this supplement. I don't know if that's just my FYP because I'm getting old, or if that's everybody's, but I am inundated with ads for supplements.

SPEAKER_01And while I do feel they have their space and their use for certain things, I also feel like everyone is different. Our chemistry is different, our body is different, our needs are different. And I don't know that just buying everything that we see on the internet is the right thing to do. So I have a solution for you guys. I asked the incredibly amazing Dr. Doris Day to join us today and share her thoughts on supplements and skincare and what we need and maybe what we don't.

SPEAKER_01So, y'all tune in and give a warm welcome to Dr. Doris Day.

SPEAKER_00That's so sweet. Thank you. I'm a board certified dermatologist and clinical professor of dermatology at NYU. I'm based in New York City. I started my practice in 1998, and my background is in both general and cosmetic dermatology, but I also do a lot of consulting and brand development. And I used to work in a research lab. So I'm really interested in looking for ways to not just do what we do, but to make everything we do work up, work better. So always trying to build and grow and improve my specialty.

SPEAKER_01Well, that's why I wanted to have you on because you definitely wear many hats in this industry. And I think you have a lot to say about a lot of things in aesthetics. But today I wanted to bring you in on the topic of supplements in skincare. So I'll just go right in with the big question. Are supplements actually needed for healthy skin?

SPEAKER_00No, they're not actually needed, but they are a nice bonus. And supplements, as you hear over and over again, I'm sure, are they just that. They are supplements. They're not replacing a healthy diet. They're not replacing other things that you do. But there are times and there are ingredients that are difficult to get from a healthy diet. So if you look at ingredients like CoQ10, they're great to add on. Vitamin D, you can get it from natural sources, including the sun, although that's not the best way to get it.

SPEAKER_00But generally, even with people doing all those things, many and most are still vitamin D deficient. So adding vitamin D in a supplement can be helpful. Most people are magnesium deficient. These have many functions, and including helping to support skin. So all of these supplements will add value to what your body is naturally trying to work with. And as you get older, you may not do as well. Acazanthine is another one. It's naturally found in foods like salmon, but you'd have to eat so much of it to get what we would call the skin benefits from that, that adding it as a supplement is good.

SPEAKER_00But you still want to eat the salmon, you still want to eat the foods, the eggs, meats, other things that are good for the skin, good for the body. But sometimes adding a supplement can add value.

SPEAKER_01So I have a question, and I hear this a lot when people talk about supplements. We hear the words deficient and then we hear optimize. So is there a difference between just being deficient but optimizing your supplements? For sure.

SPEAKER_00So when you look at the recommended daily allowance, that's the minimal amount you need to prevent disease, but it's not the amount that you need to optimize health. So the RDAs, recommended daily allowance, are basically the minimum that you should have. Now, when people add supplements, they often have a thousand percent of the RDA. That isn't always ideal. And then some people now are stacking. They're taking a multivitamin plus they're taking individual other supplements. And some pills have cocktails of ingredients.

SPEAKER_00So you could be getting too much of an ingredient if you're taking multiple products at once. And I think that's becoming more and more of a problem as people are sort of just adding things on. And some things are better taken in the day, some things are better taken at night, some things compete with each other. So it isn't every time I see another supplement, I think, oh, well, that's really interesting. You look at quercetin, which is a bioflavonoid. It's found in grapefruice, but has great benefits for the skin, but you don't necessarily want to take it every day.

SPEAKER_00So there's so much that we have to learn still about supplements. And then of course, there's the sourcing. Is this a reliable source? Is it is it contaminated with heavy metals? How much of that supplement are you getting? Because these are not regulated as tightly as drugs are. And that means that when you find that supplement, it could be you could be getting a minuscule amount. I'll take melatonin as an example of that. People take melatonin to sleep, and the problems are they take it in too high a dose.

SPEAKER_00It actually can affect puberty. So I wouldn't give it to a child on a regular basis, but most people don't know this. And then the other problem with it is that you could be taking a pill and you can get a tenth of the amount, or you can get 10 times the amount, but nobody is overseeing that quality control. You have to count on the company to do its own quality control. So where you're getting that supplement from, what the quality and the quantity of that particular ingredient is from pill to pill, from batch to batch, can vary widely.

SPEAKER_01So with all this, do you think it's important? Because I look, I'm just as a consumer, I'll tell you, I've I feel like every time I scroll through Instagram or TikTok, it's another supplement, like screaming at me. And I don't know if that's because I'm perimenopause or if what it is, but I would imagine it's also happening to everyone else. So my question for you is at what point are we to stop independently just purchasing? And when do we see a physician? And is blood work even needed?

SPEAKER_00Well, I would say see a physician because that's what I do, but you need to see a physician who cares and who actually studies it. There's doctors come in all sorts of flavors. There's the doctors that say, and I have colleagues that I have been sort of talking about this with for a long time who were like, I don't need supplements, I just do pure bar and I eat healthy and I'm this and I'm that. I'm like, that's great. But meanwhile, you're putting products on your skin and you're advocating for that, which is a supplement for the skin. So if your skin needs it and you believe in that, your body's gonna need it too.

SPEAKER_00Then, in terms of the guidance, you have to find a doctor who actually studies it and who cares about it and who understands that while it's not a prescribed drug, there are benefits to supplements. Like around perimenopause, there's one that I like called Fossium Plus that has genestine, which helps with collagen, but helps with bones. So Foscium Plus is made for people who are prone to osteoporosis, but it supports collagen in the skin as well. So there's overlaps of benefits. There's another one that has an ingredient that supports blood vessels that helps you bruise less.

SPEAKER_00And that's an issue for people as they get older, as their skin becomes more fragile. But the reality is I study this. I spend time learning about supplements, learning about what to take. And even for me, it can be overwhelming. I get excited about new ingredients. And my I put my supplement list out on social media and it's changing, but I I'm happy to share what I take always. Um, but I think you need to find a doctor who cares about supplements and who understands the value add that they have, and that it's not replacing a healthy diet and otherwise lifestyle.

SPEAKER_00But some of those doctors go so far as recommending only supplements, and like they'll say, take red rice yeast extract instead of a statin, and that's not necessarily sound science either. So you can have extremes on both sides where people go all one way or all the other. I'm kind of take the best of all worlds. Sometimes things are prescriptions, lifestyle is always an issue that we have to talk about, and then supplements can have a role as a value add along with that.

SPEAKER_00Very carefully done. And yes, you should measure. You can measure your vitamin D levels and your vitamin B levels, along with your iron stores and your liver function and your kidney function. So some things can be measured, some things can't, but a lot of it can be measured, and then you have to know that measurement is a snapshot in time, it's not necessarily where you are for always from one day to the next. You're some things like D vitamins are fat soluble, it's a bit more stable, but B vitamins are water soluble, so the levels can fluctuate more.

SPEAKER_00So there's a lot of nuance to it, and you just need one to say you don't have to think about it that hard. If you don't know what else to do, take a multivitamin and be happy that you're getting the basic basics. If you want to go next level, then you can see a doctor who understands supplements and start to build slowly. But understand, I can't say it enough times, it's not replacing a healthy diet and lifestyle.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Okay. Um, so while it can be simple, it can definitely be extremely complex. So we definitely need to invest our time, not so much in purchasing everything we see, but finding someone that actually knows what they're doing and what they're looking at that can help. So I love that because guys, we are putting this into our body. It's something we are putting into our body to either supplement or optimize our health. So we we need to know what we're taking and why we're taking it. So I like that.

SPEAKER_00And there's also a difference because what makes the difference between a supplement or let's take the skin. The difference between a cosmosceutical and a drug is a claim. Most cosmosceuticals, even water, affects structure and function of the skin. But if you put out a product and you just claim it improves the appearance of wrinkles, that's a cosmetic. But if you say it improves a wrinkle, that's a drug. So then you have to go through the FDA. So a lot of these products that people are taking work like drugs, but they don't make drug claims.

SPEAKER_00And therefore, they sort of get around this loophole of having to go through an FDA process and trial and all the rigors of an FDA test, which is hundreds of millions of dollars sometimes or tens of millions of dollars. I'm working on a skincare line, and to do the drug side needs a lot more money in the in the many millions of dollars to just bring one drug to market. So most people where they can and where they can make different claims, especially with things like acetanthine and vitamin D.

SPEAKER_00Vitamin D is a hormone, but it's over the counter as a supplement and as a vitamin. So there's a lot of nuance to how these products are taken. And that's why I think it is important to follow with a doctor because it can affect your liver and your kidneys, and it can affect your overall health. So I don't take any supplement lightly.

SPEAKER_01And I think that is probably the one thing you take away from this today is that it shouldn't be taken lightly. Now, there are some supplements right now that I feel like are getting just maybe overhyped. So help me understand the need for a collagen supplement. It's probably the biggest one in beauty right now. What's your take on that?

SPEAKER_00My take is that it's a protein and so it has value there. There's a meta-analysis that came out that showed that it didn't improve hydration in the skin. And I have, if you break down all these studies, you can see that they're all flawed, basically. So I don't, I don't think we have any good studies that would say it's good or not good for the skin. But the way that I explain it to patients is that if you take it and you don't overdo it and you don't have kidney problems, you're not going to make collagen directly from drinking collagen in a powder in a drink.

SPEAKER_00But you are giving your skin and your body the building blocks for collagen. And that I've seen data that at least hypothetically, theoretically makes me think that you can have improvement in the skin. So I don't object to it, but I don't tell people that this is a must-do. I think it could have some value. I think data over time will be helpful. But again, because it's a supplement and because whoever does the studies is going to spend all the money to do that study, but everybody else is going to use those claims.

SPEAKER_00Nobody's going to do the study. So you just, and the data that I've seen says that it seems to show that it does help the joints. So at least I think there's value for the body in general. And if it's helping the joints, it's probably helping the skin a little bit. But we don't have great studies. We have at least a theoretical framework that hydrolyzed collagen, if it's processed correctly, can have benefits for the skin and maybe the joints as well, or the joints and maybe the skin as well. And so if you're otherwise healthy and you're not overdoing it and it's part of a complete diet and exercise plan, I I have made recommendations of that for certain patients.

SPEAKER_00So yeah, I'm not against it.

SPEAKER_01Okay. I think another supplement that's being hyped up right now, and I have my theory on this, but it's biotin. And I think because everybody's on a GLP one and we're all having this like hair loss issue. And so biotin is now blowing up. But as an aesthetician, I'm aware of some maybe not so great things about biotin that can maybe be problematic. So tell me, can high-dose biotin worsen acne or cause other unwanted side effects in people?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, including hair loss. I mean, it's funny, there's like a switch that goes on in people's brain that if you're losing hair, take biotin. But biotin is one of those that if you're not deficient in it, it probably doesn't do much for hair and it can mess up your thyroid labs. If you have a thyroid issue, if you're doing thyroid studies, it can it can affect the the thyroid level reading, not your thyroid exactly, but the reading. So that is a problem. And when when we as dermatologists look at products that have biotin in them as hair growth, we're kind of suspect if that's the selling point.

SPEAKER_00So um, and then if you're vegan, biotin comes mostly from animal sources or animal sources that I know of. So that's another issue as well. But I would say biotin is probably the single most overhyped supplement for hair.

SPEAKER_01Wow. You know, I'm glad you confirmed that because I always thought that, but it's good to hear from an actual physician that I'm, you know, onto something there. Okay. Another hyped thing, and I guess maybe this is just dependent on the supplement itself. But what do you think about gummies? Like all of these gummy vitamins. Do you feel like they're helpful with all this sugar?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's an issue. I think some have less sugar than others, and I would definitely pay attention to that. But you know what? If it sometimes that's the only way somebody will take something, you have to think, though, that they have to get all those ingredients into the gummy. So that generally does not taste good. And so they're gonna have to do something to mask the flavor, and that's the issue. But some people don't want to swallow pills. Gummies taste good, people will eat them. They're good for kids because kids will like that, but it's another source and it depends on the gummy, what they put in it, how much sugar is in it.

SPEAKER_00And those are things that I would definitely read on the label and then decide what the value proposition is. But you know, for that person who puts three teaspoons of sugar in their coffee, that gummy sugar isn't going to add that much. But if you're really trying to limit sugar, then probably not so good.

SPEAKER_01Okay, fair enough. All right. So, switching from overhyped things, now let's talk about all these social media trends and people doing all of this detox stuff. And glutathione comes up a lot. And while I think glutathione has its place, what do you think about glutathione being taken now as far as detox? Where's your thoughts on that?

SPEAKER_00Your body is always naturally detoxing. That's why you have a liver, that's why you have a spleen, even your kidney to some extent. So your body does this naturally. Glutathione, I think of as a battery recharger. So when your body goes through chemical reactions, you give up a certain electrons, you gain other ones, and that depletes like vitamin C has two plus charges. When it goes through its cycle, it loses those charges. Glutathione helps give it back. So it helps the same amount of energy you have refresh better.

SPEAKER_00And you can think of that as a detox. So you can take liposomal glutathione when you need, if you're going through a difficult time or if you're working out harder, but it's not something you necessarily have to take every day. And I'm not a big fan yet of IV uh products or supplements because I think the data is not there yet. I don't like to put things into veins because you're going, you're eventually going to hurt those veins and you might need those veins later for if you're really sick or if you have an issue.

SPEAKER_00So I'm more of the idea of taking things by mouth. The idea of getting at IV, though, is you bypass the liver for metabolism because it goes right into the blood. Whereas if you take something by mouth, it goes through your digestive system, goes through your liver. But sometimes that can help process it and that can be good too. So for me, IV, I'm not such a fan of yet. Um, I know with like NAD by IV, you don't get much absorption from everything I'm reading. It doesn't, you're much better off taking the precursor by mouth, like NMN or NR, but doing NADIV isn't the best thing.

SPEAKER_00Glutathione, I think it'll be short-lived for the benefits. And taking liposomal glutathione would probably have longer benefits and probably best taken when you're under stress or when you have a heavy exertion or something that's gonna stress your body, not so much for detox, but to help restore it.

SPEAKER_01Okay, I love that. That's a great way to put it into perspective. It's about when it's needed, not necessarily forcing yourself to have it every day. Correct. Um, okay, now there are some supplements that I feel may have a place. So I was hoping we could kind of touch on some of these. So you mentioned vitamin D being like a hormone, but who do you think benefits from a vitamin D supplement?

SPEAKER_00Probably everybody, but you can measure your vitamin D levels, and it should be, in my view, around 60, should be the level. There's different labs, different measurements, but most people are way too low. And uh when you take vitamin D, your gut usually makes vitamin K, but most of us as we age, our gut biome isn't so healthy. So I like vitamin D3 with K2, and then magnesium helps. So vitamin K helps with vitamin D absorption, and vitamin D and magnesium help calcium get absorbed into bone rather than soft tissue.

SPEAKER_00So for me, vitamin D in the morning and then magnesium glycinate at bedtime are part of the trifecta that help both with skin health and bone health and also brain health. But vitamin D has many uses for the body, but it is important for the skin and the hair. Okay. What do you think about zinc? Zinc um is good, but you don't want too much zinc. So I think zinc can be 15 to 30 milligrams a few times a week, but it's in supplements.

SPEAKER_00So I would read supplements to make sure you're not getting too much zinc over time.

SPEAKER_01Okay. Now I have been obviously I'm an aesthetician, so I've been reading a lot about the connection between the gut and acne, right? So how strong is the evidence for probiotics helping acne, rosacea, eczema? What are those? What is that relation?

SPEAKER_00I think probiotics are another area where it's it's a it's a term, but it's not an ingredient. So there are many different probiotics and they probably have different benefits. And that is a whole category that I think we still don't really understand as well as we need to. But I do think that eating things like fermented foods can be helpful and just uh maybe taking probiotics to some extent, but that's an area where I think you do need guidance from somebody who understands your gut and what you need rather than just popping a probiotic.

SPEAKER_00There are topical probiotics that are actually natural to the skin that are skin probiotics, not gut probiotics that you apply to the skin, that can also help the skin directly. But taking a probiotic can be helpful. I think it can help the gut. But if you, let's say you travel to India or Brazil or another country, your gut biome is gonna change just by changing environments and changing diet. So it's something that's an ongoing issue. But I think overall, if you eat less processed food and less sugar, you're gonna have a healthier gut.

SPEAKER_00And probiotics could be a nice add on. Or if you're sick or if you take an antibiotic, you can add a specific probiotic. But in general, eating healthier foods because whatever you put in your mouth goes into your gut. If you eat sugar, sugar gets absorbed before it gets to the large intestine. So your your microorganisms in your gut, the E. coli, all those good things that are helping you eat and and make they make ingredients that are anti-inflammatory, that are anti-aging, that are good for your brain, good for everything, they don't get fed very well.

SPEAKER_00So they suffer. But if you eat high quality foods and high fiber foods, then every time you put that in your mouth, those microbes in your gut, they eat them too. So just think of them as consuming calories for you. Wow. Okay. And then they make things that actually help you age better and help you live better and they're anti-inflammatory. So you can have leaky gut from eating foods that are high sugar, highly processed, that get broken down before they get to the large intestine.

SPEAKER_00And those can create inflammation that can affect your acne, that can affect your joints, that can make eczema psoriasis, acne, even hair loss worse. So eating high quality foods means you're going to get more food to the microbes in your gut. And those are going to help you age better. So that's one more reason to just eat better food.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_01Okay. One more supplement that I want to ask you about what about vitamin C for supplement but also topical what are your thoughts on that?

SPEAKER_00They're both good. And vitamin C, I think of in general, if you're eating fruits and vegetables, you're probably getting enough of it even for your skin and your health but if you're getting sick, that's when I load up on it to high high doses like 2000 units like just going high. But otherwise vitamin C yes it's good and topically it's good for the skin helps with brightening helps with collagen production it's a good add on it in the morning it gives you better added antioxidant benefits against sun damage. So I like it topically and orally adding some as a supplement into your day is a good idea.

SPEAKER_00It's water soluble but if you're prone to kidney stones it can make kidney stones worse. So it's not necessary for everybody.

SPEAKER_01Yeah we found that out the hard way my poor husband gets kidney stones terribly and I have a feeling it was me because when the COVID craze happened I was like throwing that down his throat. I'm like you have to take these every day and he just was getting kidney stones left and right. It was terrible but yeah so and also he's probably genetically prone to it so it's not all you yeah no he did he is his dad gets them yeah um okay so last thing before we say goodbye um I wanted to ask because you brought this up how important it is to be choosing quality supplements that that makes the biggest impact.

SPEAKER_01So when someone is considering purchasing is there something that they need to look for on the label any type of claim? Help us understand what we need to look for.

SPEAKER_00Yeah there are there are claims I think it's USB on the label there's there are claims on the label. I have to look that up and tell you exactly what it is you can add it to your show notes but there definitely are things you can look at for on the label that will tell you that it's high quality it's going to make it more expensive because to get those labels they have to be money to the people who give the labels but yes there's definitely uh things on the label that can tell you that that supplement is is a higher value for sure. Okay I'll make sure I put that in whenever we um we check back but is clinically tested the same thing as clinically proven like do those mean the same thing no it and neither of them mean that much unless it's tested on that specific product.

SPEAKER_00So a lot of products whether it's oral or topical make claims based on the ingredient itself. So you could say that vitamin C is clinically tested to make or clinically proven to improve gut health or skin health or something but unless they tell you the data for their formula their particular product that means that they're making claims based on the ingredients not based on their formula. So I I want the data on that particular product not just on the ingredient.

SPEAKER_01Okay. All right well that was a lot of information which I think would be very helpful for us moving forward because like I said I'm like it can't just be me that every time I log on to social media I'm inundated with some kind of a supplement that these people are making me feel like I absolutely need and then they play on me. They're like are you having uh are you tired? Are you having I'm like yes yes check check check that's me so like I just get sucked anesthesia it'll solve all your problems and have your kids and clean your house yes I know 100% terrible um all right I think I know the answer to this because I think we've tapped on it but in summary what is the one takeaway from this that you would want listeners to do or avoid when it comes to supplements for skin health be careful.

SPEAKER_00Use them as a supplement not as a replacement and stick with the simple ones to begin with the vitamin D, magnesium those are the two basic ones that people are usually short of a multivitamin is not a bad place to start although if if you get further into it I don't think a vitamin a multivitamin is necessarily the best thing but I think it's the best thing if you want the fastest easiest way to get the the general range of what you need. And then see a doctor get your certain levels measured and if you're having symptoms tell the doctor what your symptoms are and see if adding supplements can support helping those symptoms get better.

SPEAKER_00But lifestyle is the single most important thing.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_01Okay thank you so much Dr. Day it was wonderful having you on the skintroverts and um for those that do not currently follow you although I don't know how that's not possible but where can they find you on social media?

SPEAKER_00I'm at Dr. Doris Day, DR Doris Day on all social media.

SPEAKER_01Easy enough. All right thank you so much for joining us and thanks everybody and until next time bye guys think of the skintrovert as your aesthetics roundtable not a training manual. This podcast is for professional education and discussion. It's not medical advice your scope of practice matters regulations vary and your license always leads to continue the conversation follow the skintrovert on Apple, Spotify or any platform that you listen to your podcast

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Season 3 Ep. 35 - The Psychology of Aesthetics featuring Jessica Cvetic

    Nov 17, 202630 minAudio

    Is there ever a time where we should say no to aesthetic treatments? According to Jessica Cvetic, yes! The good faith examination doesn't tell the provider or the patient everything needed for aesthetic treatments. What...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Season 3 Ep. 33 - Skin in the Spotlight featuring Shekinah Guven

    Nov 3, 202641 minAudio

    In aesthetics, we talk a lot about how we see ourselves. But what happens when everyone else gets an opinion too?! In this episode, Shekinah Guven, aesthetician and reality TV show celebrity, shares her side of "Skin in...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Season 3 Ep. 32 - Regenerative Skincare - Science or Storytelling featuring JC Dombrowski

    Oct 27, 202639 minAudio

    The term "regenerative" is everywhere in aesthetics - but what does it really mean for your skin? In this episode, Sam sits down with cosmetic chemist, JC Dombrowski to unpack regenerative skincare, explore the science...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Season 3 Ep. 31 - The Patient Perspective featuring Janna Wilson Sadler

    Oct 20, 202631 minAudio

    With so many perspectives in aesthetics, we forget to check in with the most important perspective -- The Patient's! In this episode, we hear from Janna Wilson Sadler. Janna is a patient, a mother, a corporate employee...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Season 3 Ep. 30 - Showing Your True Colors featuring Kelly Fairchild

    Oct 13, 202631 minAudio

    What if everything you're doing for your skin is a waste. What if you are doing it all wrong? Or...what if you could simply do it better. Join the conversation with Kelly Fairchild, owner & founder of The Fifth Season....

    Credit the people on this episode