Political arguments often feel like debates, but many of them are really two people talking past each other. We tend to focus on proving our point before we’ve taken the time to understand what the other person is actually saying, why they believe it, or what concern is driving their position.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Good morning, and welcome back to the same page podcast. Lately, I have been debating a lot of people on social media, mostly about just random topics here or there. And I've noticed this interesting and very real trend that's happening, which is people largely prefer this comfort that comes with certainty over a reality of it's complicated. So I think that that's really interesting and kind of Nice to dive into a nice to be aware of because I think that a lot of debates end
up turning into this like fact -checked Is it you know the statistic actually say 36 or 37 when in reality? I think that there's a lot more psychology going on here And then if you can realize that in this certainty angle And I think that it will lead to a much more productive discussion So basically what I'm trying to put my finger on here is that people often think they're searching for truth, but a lot of the time they're searching for clarity or certainty, not clarity, it's a brother. Truth is messy. Truth changes when new
information appears. Truth sometimes requires us to admit we were wrong. Certainty asks us to do none of those things. Certainty feels good because it removes doubt. It tells us who the good guys are, who the bad guys are, what team we're on, and what we're supposed to think. It creates a world that feels understandable, even when the reality is not. The problem is that reality rarely fits into any categories. Most political issues are complicated. Most economic issues are complicated. Most historical events are complicated. Most people are complicated. But complicated isn't sexy, so the people who
speak with the most confidence often attract the largest audiences. Not because their answers are necessarily correct, but because confidence is emotionally comforting. Everything is connected and complicated is intellectually honest, but here's the reason everything is broken is emotionally satisfying. One requires thought, the other requires loyalty, which I think is what we're seeing in, you know, big picture happening politically and why it's so difficult for some of us to understand where the rest of us are coming from. And I think this kind of explains that a lot of inherited
beliefs survive for this exact reason. Challenging them creates uncertainty. If a belief becomes connected to our family, community, religion, culture, political identity, then questioning it can feel like questioning ourselves, even when the evidence points elsewhere. That's a natural temptation to protect our identity before examining the claim. And that's why facts alone often fail to change minds, which is what I was pointing out earlier. When a belief becomes part of someone's identity, evidence is no longer competing against an idea. it's competing against
belonging. And changing your mindset sounds easy in theory, but in practice, it can mean, you know, disagreeing with your parents, your friends, your coworkers, political allies, entire communities that help shape who you are, you know, people you looked up to as you were growing up. And that's a much bigger cost than people acknowledge. And so the result is sometimes, you know, something we see constantly, which is people demand simple answers to complex questions. It reminds me of It was some Zac Efron movie and he quoted Dr. Seuss and he said, sometimes the answers are
simple and it's the questions that are complicated. And I think that that is something that is very real and something that comes to my mind often when these things happen because people want simple answers and they have very complicated questions. People reward certainty over accuracy. People defend conclusions they never independently arrived at. And people mistake confidence for expertise. People treat changing your mind as a weakness instead of evidence that learning occurred. goal is actually understanding the world then uncertainty is not the enemy. Uncertainty is often the starting point which is why I personally
usually try to play devil's advocate and usually try really hard to see the angle that another person is coming from because I think that is how you actually make progress. So the person who is saying I don't know. might be much closer to the truth than the person who is claiming to have every answer. And I think the Dunning -Kruger effect really dives into that. If you don't know what that is, you should look it up. It's basically a chart about confidence versus expertise and how confidence spikes at the beginning. But as you become more and more of an expert, it actually goes down because you realize there
is much more to a certain topic. So I think that in and of itself the self -awareness of the fact that there is just so much to know and so much out there that things are complicated. In and of itself should make you lean more towards that person when ironically it's the exact opposite. So given the massive backdrop of this issue that came along with a political argument that I was having or have been having relatively recently on TikTok where I've been talking about my podcast. What's even the point? You know, I mean, so if
we realize that facts don't matter, quote unquote, then what difference does any of this make? And why should we even have a debate to begin with? Which actually might be the most important you could question that you could ask. And it's the reason that I want to go into it, because once we recognize that people are not purely rational fact processing machines, the obvious follow up next is if facts don't change minds, then what are we even doing here? And at first glance, I think that it feels really hopeless. You know, if people reject evidence, protect identities,
seek certainty, and often decide what they believe before examining the facts, then debate starts looking less like search for the truth and more like two people taking turns defending conclusions they've already reached. But that isn't the whole story. The first thing to understand is that most debates fail because the participants are trying to answer different questions. One person is arguing facts. The other is arguing values. One person is discussing what is true. The other person is discussing what feels right. One person is debating policy and the other is defending identity. Those conversations can go for hours
without either side making progress because they are not actually talking about the same thing. For example, a debate about immigration might sound like a debate about border statistics, but underneath it may actually be a debate about cultural change, security, fairness, national identity or economic anxiety. A debate about guns might sound like we're talking about crime rates, but underneath it may be a debate about safety, autonomy, trust in the government, or even fear itself. A debate about taxes might sound like a debate about economics, but underneath it may be a debate about fairness or what people
quote -unquote owe each other. Until we understand what question is actually being asked, facts often bounce off harmlessly. The second thing I've realized that changing minds is rarely the purpose of a productive debate. That sounds strange, but most people never enter or most people only enter debates trying to win. But if two people are honestly exchanging ideas, the goal should not be immediate or the goal should not be immediate conversation. The goal is understanding, which is why I say on this podcast, you know, coming to the same page is not a courtesy. It's a prerequisite.
So if we leave understanding each other. Better than where we started, then that is progress. Most meaningful belief changes happen privately. People rarely hear one statistic and immediately abandon their held belief. What usually happens is much slower. A conversation creates a crack. A question creates doubt. An inconsistency becomes difficult to ignore. Weeks later, months later, sometimes even years later, a person reexamines what they thought. The debate was not the moment that changed. The debate was the moment they started changing. The third thing that debates
often are not for the people participating. They're for everyone listening. Imagine two people arguing in front of a hundred observers. Maybe neither debate or change their minds, but 20 people listening may hear an argument they've never considered before. 10 people may realize they agree with neither side completely. Five people may decide to learn more and do their own research. The participants are often the least persuadable person in the room. The audience is where most persuasion actually happens, which is why if you think of like a presidential debate, it's
not actually Trump versus Kamala. It's Trump and Kamala explaining themselves to everybody watching. And I think that's an easy way to think about it. So the goal of a good debate is not to force agreement. It's to create curiosity. Curiosity is dangerous to certainty. A person who becomes curious starts asking questions. A person who has questions starts investigating. And a person who investigates eventually becomes willing to update their beliefs. That is why the most powerful phrase in any debate might not be you're wrong. It might be. Why do you believe that? Which is why I recently have updated
the podcast logo from what's a you? to why over what, because I think the why is very often more important than the what statistic to prove a point. And so maybe that is the point not to win, not to embarrass and not even to change people's minds on the spot. But maybe the point. is to plant certain seeds of curiosity that can grow and lead to that change and lead to that search for something else in a person. So it may seem useless, but statistic A, B, and C are
not really the most helpful thing, even though it's what we reach for first. And becoming an expert on intellectual ins and outs of every political issue is less effective than becoming more advanced in your emotional intelligence and focus on why instead of what. Facts still matter. to be clear. And I'm not saying that the problem is that facts are often the last step in persuasion. While most people when you debate or you're on Facebook or whatever, it's the first thing you latch to. So imagine someone says immigration is destroying the country. Most
people immediately respond with statistics. But before any statistic can matter, there are several more fundamental questions. Why is this issue important to them? What are you afraid is going to happen? What experience led them here? What values are they trying to protect? What need is this belief serving? Those are emotional intelligence questions. And until they're answered, statistics often sound like someone is arguing with their feelings rather than addressing them. A useful way to think about this for future debates or just a good mindset to have is that facts tell
us what people believe in. Emotional intelligence tells us why they believe in it. The what is usually visible. The why is usually hidden and the why is often the real where the real conversation exists. For example, someone may oppose immigration because they genuinely fear crime. Someone may oppose it because they're worried about wages. Someone else may oppose it because they feel their culture is changing. Those are three completely different concerns that happen to arrive at the same policy position. Yet we often argue all three persons as if they're the same person.
That's why so many political debates feel pointless because. People are responding to positions while ignoring motivations. And in that sense, becoming an expert on human psychology, identity, belonging, fear, status, tribalism, and incentives may actually make someone a better political commentator than memorizing 100 statistics. Not because facts don't matter, but because facts only work when someone is emotionally capable of hearing them. The irony is that many people think politics is mostly about policy. A lot of politics is actually about human behavior. Why do people
vote against their interests? Why do people reject evidence? Why do people join movements? Why do people trust certain leaders? Why do people become radicalized? Why do people cling to inherited beliefs? Those are questions that are all psychological long before they're political. And in fact, this might be one of the biggest mistakes modern political discussion makes. We assume that disagreement is caused by a lack of information. Often, it is caused by identity. And you cannot solve an identity problem with an information solution. A person can Google facts. A person cannot Google self -awareness. That maybe, why do you believe
that, is often more powerful question than can you prove that. One invites reflection. The other invites defense. A person learn much more when they're reflecting than when they're defending. What's interesting is that this idea also circles back to the core theme that I've been trying to explore lately, which is people often choose certainty over complexity. which is true and the most important political skill might not be knowing more facts than anyone else. It might be understanding why human beings become attached to a certainty in the first place. So to summarize,
I think that the real key to quote unquote getting on the same page, which is the whole, you know, idea behind this podcast is that it's it's not about cherry picking a study between comments and a Facebook arguments. It's to step back from the argument itself. Take a breath. understand why someone feels the way they do to know where they're coming from, because even if it's more comfy to have, you know, this black and white certainty of the world doesn't work this way, the world does work this way. You can be the
fastest Google user in the entire world, but if you don't know the person's real why for a topic, you could easily end up arguing positions they didn't make and might not even actually have, which I have seen happening a lot projected at me personally in these debates. And so I think that. The easiest way to really get to an equal starting place and allow for real discussion isn't to immediately fact -check people. It's the first check for mutual understanding between you and that other person. And so the goal is
not to replace facts with feelings. And I don't want that to be the take -home message of this. The goal is to understand that feelings come before introducing facts. Otherwise, you're answering a question that nobody has. What you're really describing is that most political arguments skip the most important step, which is we hear position and immediately start arguing against what we think that means. Someone says they support gun rights. Someone assumes they don't care about gun violence. Someone says they support immigration
restrictions. Someone assumes they're motivated by hatred. Someone says they support universal health care. And someone assumes that government control over everything. The conversation falls apart before either person has even established what they actually believe in. The strange thing is that we would never accept this in any other aspect of life. If a friend says they are upset, we don't immediately start correcting them. We ask why. We ask what happened. We try to understand where they're coming from. Yet in politics, we skip straight towards rebuttals and then wonder
why nobody's changing their minds. Maybe the first responsibility in any discussion isn't fact checking. Maybe it's understanding. Because if we don't understand someone's actual position, we're not debating them. We're debating our assumption of them. And assumptions are much easier to defeat than real arguments. That's why the most productive question in a political discussion might be, can I explain your position in a way that you would agree is fair? If the answer is no, we're probably not ready for a debate yet. We're still trying to understand each other. And maybe that's what getting to the same page really needs. not that we agree, not that we have reached the same
conclusion, not even that we share the same values. It means we've reached a point where both people can accurately explain what the other believes in and why they believe in it. And only then are we discussing the same topic. And only when we are discussing the same topic can we argue real positions instead of imaginary ones. And only then do facts have somewhere useful to go, because a fact can correct an error, but a fact cannot correct a misunderstanding if we never understood each other in the first place. And
that might be why so many political conversations feel impossible. Most people are trying to determine who's right before they've determined whether they even understand what the other person is saying. And if that's true, then mutual understanding isn't a reward at the end of a good discussion. It's a requirement for the beginning of one. So those are my thoughts on this, you know, kind of quick episode about this immediate knee -jerk reaction we have to throw facts at somebody when I think, like I said before, the most important thing that you could possibly do is step back,
take a deep breath, see where the person is coming from, and then have an actual discussion about where each of you stands instead of an imaginary position where you think the other person stands. Now that we're on the same page. What say you?
For decades, abortion has been one of the most powerful and persistent issues in American politics. But what happens when we temporarily set aside the question of when life begins and instead ask what should logically...
Christians often vote remarkably consistently, even on issues with little or even no connection to Christianity itself. This episode looks at how faith, politics, identity, and decades of coalition-building became so...
What happens when the sacrifice is clear, but the reason isn’t? How much does having a reason change what we’re capable of enduring? What happens when there’s no clear end date, no finish line, and the explanation keeps...
Why do political ads spend so much time showing punishment and so little time talking about prevention? Is that because punishment is more effective... or because we've accidentally turned politics into entertainment...
We say we vote on policy, competence, and results. So why do politicians spend so much time showing us workouts, carefully staged photos, perfect hair, makeup, posture, and strength? What do those images communicate...