Nothing Just Is: On Becoming, Belonging & Beginning Again
38 minAudio
What if the future isn't already written? What if the path we're walking is actually being created, in part, by the steps we take? In this episode of The Remembrance Codes, I'm sharing a little of what I've been exploring through my studies of Alfred North Whitehead and process philosophy. Don't worry, we're keeping the philosophy approachable! Through puzzles, acorns, and everyday experiences, we'll explore a world that is always changing, always becoming, and deeply shaped by relationship. We'll talk about patterns, probabilities, and participation, how the past influences the possibilities available to us, and why recognizing where we've been doesn't mean we're destined to keep going in the same direction. I'm also sharing a more personal chapter: an unexpected encounter with grief while attending my son's college orientation, the discovery of an entire year I'd somehow misplaced in my own memories, and my decision to return to college at 48. From ecological responsibility to the stories we tell about ourselves, this conversation is an invitation to remember that nothing is entirely fixed. Not our world, not our circumstances, and certainly not who we're becoming. The story isn't finished. And we get to participate in what comes next. ✨If this conversation resonates, you can also explore more reflections on embodiment, conscious living, sovereignty, relationships, parenting, and personal transformation on website www.susansutherland.com And be sure to check out other episodes of The Remembrance Codes podcast.🎙️
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Hello, my friends. I have had so much to talk to you all about, and I keep getting stuck because every time I think about recording something, I think, but wait, you should probably talk about this first. And so instead of sharing what's on my heart, what's coming up from me right then, I keep waiting until I've caught you up on everything that came before it. Egg. My sister and I were actually talking about that the other day. She talks to my niece, who's away at college for the first time several times a day.
SPEAKER_00And my niece calls her while walking to class or walking back to her apartment, and their catch-ups are small. They can get right into what's happening right now. Meanwhile, my sister and I might go weeks between substantial phone calls. We text all the time, but when we actually want to talk, talk, we need to find enough time to catch up on an entire month's worth of life. And I think that's what I've been doing here, which makes sharing little things feel overwhelming.
SPEAKER_00So today might be a little longer than usual, but I want to share a few of the bigger things so that hopefully the little things will feel easier to share as they come. So we are going to start with a little philosophy, and I promise it won't hurt. I told y'all that in the spring I started a philosophy course, and I have continued studying through that course, Alfred North Whitehead and process philosophy and ecological civilization.
SPEAKER_00Now, it is a luxury, but I didn't go into any of these courses because I was looking for someone else to tell me how the world works. I approach most learning these days with curiosity. I want to see what happens when I encounter an idea, what resonates for me, and what challenges me, and what shifts in my own understanding having met something new. And interestingly, while Whitehead and I use very different language, there is quite a bit of resonance in how I have come to experience the world.
SPEAKER_00There are things I disagree with him on too, and I hope to talk about those things along the way as well. My intention, though, isn't to convince you to agree with me. It's really just to hopefully open a few doors. Maybe you'll find something interesting behind one of them. Maybe you'll disagree. Maybe you'll start asking questions you hadn't thought to ask before. And that's, I think, what I love about learning.
SPEAKER_00So I'm going to give you just a little bit of foundation because I'm sure Whitehead is going to come up in our future conversations. So probably no other conversation you'll ever have in your life. But I don't want you wondering who this man is that I keep talking about. One of the big ideas in his philosophy is that reality isn't made up of fixed things that simply exist, fixed and separate from one another. Reality is always happening, it's always changing, it's always becoming.
SPEAKER_00And nothing becomes entirely on its own. Every new moment carries something of what came before it.
SPEAKER_00But we don't make choices from the same starting place. And we certainly don't make them in isolation. We inherit family patterns and religious traditions and economic systems and cultural expectations and habits and beliefs. It's not just us becoming in isolation. Trees inherit the conditions in which they grow. Birds hatch into environments they didn't choose.
SPEAKER_00Even mountains are shaped by everything that has happened around and within them. We are all becoming, but we're becoming within relationships that influence what's possible. Think about your own life.
SPEAKER_00And some of those influences I'm very aware of. Others are working quietly in the background. And whatever happens in this moment becomes part of what the next moment will inherit. Now imagine that on a much larger scale.
SPEAKER_00There is still possibility, still uncertainty, still opportunity for something genuinely new. And I happen to love that. Because nothing just is. That's one of the things I've been noticing, especially in my ecological civilization course, is how often we talk about the world as if the story is already finished. And I don't want to minimize the very real environmental challenges we're facing.
SPEAKER_00The data gives us plenty of reasons to pay attention, and there are things happening in the natural world that deserve our concern. So in my biology class, we were learning about climate change and had to do a research paper, which I was able to weave in some ecological civilization stuff into. But anyway, it is amazing how so many of the threads that I'm walking seem to be breeding together these days. Anyway, we learned a story about the caribou. Now, these caribou, I think they live in Canada, but I might be remembering some things wrong.
SPEAKER_00That's not the gist of the story, so bear with me. The climate change in the areas where these caribou babies are born in the spring changed by 1.6 degrees Celsius. But that impacted the budding time of the plant that they eat. And so, over the course, even though the caribou are okay with the condition of the climate, the food that they require was not. And the food was not available when these babies were being born.
SPEAKER_00And now they can see statistical data of reduced offspring, of reduced population of this caribou because of the impact of this one plant that they require for their infants. I was talking to Mark the other day, and he's going on a motorcycle trip and going up north and through Boone. And I was like, wow, the leaves should be really beautiful right now. And I told him, you know, like a decade ago, we were having Halloween parties, and this time of year the trees were like bare, bear, and I'm hanging bats in the trees, and you could see them.
SPEAKER_00And now our trees haven't started turning colors. And he was like, Well, it doesn't matter. It just means winter starts later. And then, you know, spring might start later too. No big deal. Well, no big deal if you are only considering the impact of you. But that one degree Celsius impacted the food required for this caribou and had reduced their population. So a lot of times we are just not, we're not seeing the big picture.
SPEAKER_00What seems like small changes are impacting all of the species that we are cohabitating this earth with. So there is very real ecological concerns with how we're living and how human actions are contributing to global warming. But I also notice how easily we turn our understanding of current conditions into declarations about what something permanently is. My class is full of people who are very dialed into the reality of the concerns.
SPEAKER_00But there is a lot of permanence in the language used. Capitalism is this, religion is this, America is this, or China is this, or humanity is this, the future is doomed. And I keep coming back to that little word. Because when we describe something as though it is fixed, do we begin to forget that it is still changing?
SPEAKER_00That it is also still becoming. And if it is still becoming, then surely our participation matters. Since I started with the environment, I'll keep going on that that thread. But our small choices matter. Collectively, they all add up. And our big choices matter too. Where we spend our money, what products we buy, which businesses we support, who we vote for, what we encourage in our communities.
SPEAKER_00And that's not just environmentally. This applies to almost every aspect of our lives. I think sometimes we get so focused on asking, how does this affect me? That we forget to ask, how does my participation affect everything that I'm in relationship? That makes me think about how I have been talking for years in my energy sessions. I see patterns and probabilities.
SPEAKER_00When I'm reading energy, I'm often looking at those patterns. Patterns in someone's behavior, in their family, in their lineage, in their relationship, sometimes in larger collective experiences. And from those patterns, certain outcomes seem more probable than others. But here's the thing: a probability isn't a sentence, it's not a declaration that something must happen. Recognizing a pattern gives us an opportunity to participate differently.
SPEAKER_00We can keep feeding that pattern, or we can interrupt it. And so lately I've been thinking about that third P that belongs alongside patterns and probabilities, maybe with a capital letter, participation. Because knowing where we are and recognizing where things might be headed is useful. But what we do next matters. Now, if you have wondered how my mind works when I'm studying philosophy, I can tell you that I spend a lot of time waiting for pictures.
SPEAKER_00Not charts or diagrams, actual images and metaphors. I read something academic and then I sit with it until some everyday image shows up that helps me understand what I am processing. And one image that I have returned to for years is a puzzle. And originally I used a puzzle to think about coherence, about things fitting together in a way that felt aligned.
SPEAKER_00And I imagine that if I had all of these pieces available to me and my sovereignty, I could choose what to do with them. I could put them together the way they fit. I could force them into some other arrangement. I could knock the whole table over, or I could burn all of the pieces if I wanted to. But there was a way that they fit together that created something coherent.
SPEAKER_00Well, that image has expanded for me. So think about a single puzzle piece. It has its own shape, its own colors, its own little portion of an image. You can pick it up, you can study it, you can learn perfectly true things about that piece. But you can't necessarily understand what you're looking at. Imagine you pick up a piece with an eye on it.
SPEAKER_00You know that there's an eye on it. You can describe its color. You might guess that it belongs on a face. Now you connect the pieces immediately around it and you discover it's the eye of a child. Then you add a few more pieces and you realize she's looking upward, and a few more, and you see that someone is holding her. Then you discover they're standing beside a house. And as you keep building the puzzle, you realize the house is surrounded by floodwater.
SPEAKER_00Now, when you go back to that first piece, the eye, everything that you originally observed about it was true. But you didn't understand what you were looking at. Maybe you thought that the child was looking upward with wonder. Now you might wonder if she is frightened. And what's so interesting to me is that the floodwater might be several pieces away from that eye.
SPEAKER_00Those pieces might never directly touch it. But once you understand how they're connected, they completely change your understanding of that original piece. And isn't that how life works? We meet someone, we observe something about them, and based on the little bit we know, we begin to form an understanding of who they are. But what about everything we don't know? What about the relationships, the experiences, the histories, the circumstances that are influencing the person standing in front of us?
SPEAKER_00And what about the things influencing those things? You can know everything printed on a single puzzle piece and still not know what you're looking at. You have to see what it touches and then what those pieces touch, and gradually a much bigger picture emerges. That's one of the things that I find compelling about relational thinking. It doesn't mean that the individual piece isn't real or isn't important. Quite the opposite.
SPEAKER_00Every piece contributes something unique that the picture wouldn't have without it. But the picture becomes understandable through the relationship between the pieces. And that brings me back to White Hood. Rather than focusing on what something is, he invites us to think about how it is becoming. And when you start looking at the world that way, you begin to notice how much of life we understand through relationship.
SPEAKER_00For example, I can tell you that my name is Susan. Okay. Great. But what does that really tell you about me? I'm a wife. Okay. Now you know something about my relationship with Mark. I'm a mother. Now you know something about my relationship with children. I'm a student that tells you something about how I'm spending my time, what I'm learning, and the people I'm learning alongside.
SPEAKER_00I'm a North Carolinian. I'm a woman. I'm an American. Those descriptions give you more, but they still don't tell you everything because you still don't know how I've experienced any of those things. But with each relationship, you get a little bit more of the picture. And sometimes the way other people understand us depends entirely on how many of those puzzle pieces they've been able to see. There's uh another reflection I sat with and want to share is about a line that has been attributed to Rumi for years.
SPEAKER_00As you start to walk on the way, the way appears. And for a long time I thought about that like it's a GPS. When I'm driving somewhere, I don't necessarily see every turn I'm going to make. I get the next instruction, follow it, and then another direction appears. And that made sense to me spiritually. I don't need to know the entire path, I just need to take the next step. But after studying Whitehead for a few months, I've started hearing that idea a little differently.
SPEAKER_00Because with the GPS, the road already exists. I just can't see all of it from where I am. Even when the GPS recalculates, it's still working with roads that are already there and a destination I've already chosen. But what if life isn't quite like that? What if the next part of the path doesn't fully exist yet? What if my next step actually participates in creating it? I stand here with a range of possibilities in front of me.
SPEAKER_00I make a choice. And because I made that choice, some possibilities disappear. Others open up, and the world from which I'll make my next choice is a little different. And so am I. And I love that image. My foot, my path, my movement, the soil, the everything is contributing to what is now available. Now, obviously, we are not operating with a completely blank slate.
SPEAKER_00I was born a human being, and try as I might, I'm not going to become a dolphin. And an acorn isn't going to grow into an apple tree. There are things we inherit that shape what is possible. But that doesn't mean there is a perfect version of an oak tree waiting inside of an acorn. And I've wondered about that. I wondered if we all have some predetermined highest expression of ourselves that we're meant to grow into.
SPEAKER_00And thinking like that felt like a lot of pressure. The more I sit with it, the more I wonder whether that idea overlooks everything involved in becoming. Think about the acorn. Yes, it has the potential to become an oak. That also depends on so much. The soil matters, the rain matters, the sunlight matters, the other trees around it matter, lightning matters, disease matters, human activity matters. In my area, they're choosing not to leave any oaks and just demolishing everything to whip up some very fast houses.
SPEAKER_00The trees' own responses to the environment matter. There isn't just one possible oak waiting to emerge. There are countless ways that oak might grow, depending on the life it encounters along the way. And I wonder if we're like that too. We inherit certain possibilities and limitations, but we don't inherit an entirely finished future. And maybe that's true of civilizations.
SPEAKER_00America inherited certain ideas and structures when it was founded. China has a long history, and its extraordinary industrial growth has brought enormous challenges, including environmental consequences. And now different choices are being made. Our economic systems inherited assumptions about growth and consumption and ownership and success, but none of those stories are finished.
SPEAKER_00They're still being written. And this brings me to something else I've been studying. Alongside biology, I just finished a course in American government, which has sent me back into the world of our founders and framers. And it it wove itself in the timing of me going back to see Hamilton again and simultaneously listening to the 35-hour audiobook that inspired that musical.
SPEAKER_00So apparently that's what I do for fun right now is learn about our nation's beginnings. Anyway, in class, we were asked to consider whether government should be concerned with equality of opportunity or equality of outcome. And around the same time, I saw this reel that was so powerful on Instagram. The women sharing it asked us to imagine a game of monopoly. And for the first two hours, only the white men are allowed to play.
SPEAKER_00They're buying the properties, they're collecting rent, they're building houses and hotels. Then, after two hours, everyone else is invited to join. Now the rules are exactly the same for everybody. Everyone can roll the dice, everyone can move around the board, everyone has the right to buy property. Equal opportunity, right? Well, technically, everyone now has access to the same rules.
SPEAKER_00But is the game fair? Of course not. Some players have already accumulated properties and wealth. The new players are starting from nothing. And every time they land on one of those established properties, they're paying rent to someone who had a head start in the game. I thought that was such a powerful way to illustrate something we often overlook. The past matters. The structures we inherit matter.
SPEAKER_00The consequences of earlier choices don't just disappear because we changed the rules today. And it isn't about saying that the game is over. It's about recognizing the conditions people are actually entering into. Because if we do want to create something different, we have to be willing to understand what has brought us here. And then we get to decide how to participate in what comes next. So there you go.
SPEAKER_00My very quick, perhaps not so quick, introduction to Whitehead and process philosophy. If I start talking about relational reality or becoming in future episodes, hopefully you'll now have some idea of what I'm talking about. The simplest way I can say it is this nothing exists entirely apart from everything that has helped shape it. And what happens next is influenced by how we participate now.
SPEAKER_00All right, so now let me tell you how some of this has been showing up in my own life. One of the unexpected things about taking the philosophy course was how much I simply enjoyed being a student and a peer with other students. There was this whole group of people reading and discussing and writing papers and asking questions and expanding their understanding of the world. Not necessarily because they needed a degree or a promotion or a new career, just because they wanted to learn.
SPEAKER_00And I found that really inspiring. And then on July 21st, I went with Dashel to UNC Charlotte for his new student orientation. Now, he had no idea when he chose this date, but July 21st was the 30th anniversary of my mother's passing. That is a head scratcher for me. How 30 years.
unknownWow.
SPEAKER_00Anyway, my friend Katriona had sent me a book called Grief and Praise earlier that week, and I felt like I walked those pages before I ever read them. I don't think I could have been happier that day for Dashel. The campus is beautiful. The programs and the facilities and the support available to students, it's amazing. And he gets to arrive there with not only the support of the university, but a whole team at home cheering him on.
SPEAKER_00And I loved seeing that for him, for feeling that for him. But the day was also really hard. And I wasn't expecting that. She showed up to walk around campus alongside us that day. And I could feel that heaviness that I had carried then when I was there. My mother had died.
SPEAKER_00My plans to go to art school had fallen apart. I didn't really know what I was doing. My dad was fine, but we didn't have the kind of relationship where I could call him when I was struggling or talk through what was happening in my life. And I think being there with Dashel, seeing how supported he was brought me face to face with how alone I felt at that age. And we had a wonderful day. And when we got in the car to leave, as soon as we pulled out of the parking lot, I just balled.
SPEAKER_00I mean, the dam broke open. And I had no idea that that cry was coming. It just like boom, here it is. But apparently I'd been holding it all day. And once we were in the privacy of the car, it just poured out. So for the next few days, I spent some time with little Sue. Little teenage Sue. And I let myself grieve the plans that had changed and the college experience that I didn't really get to have, the messiness of that time in my life.
SPEAKER_00And then I realized something. I'm supportive now. I'm not that young girl trying to figure out everything on her own. And I don't have to go back to school, but I could. I could finish my degree. Now, a few years ago, I looked into going to the Maharishi Institute. And when I was sitting with that decision and thinking of why I wanted to do it, I realized that part of me was looking for validation.
SPEAKER_00I wanted to prove something, maybe to myself. I think more to other people. And I decided at the time that I didn't want to pursue a degree to heal a wound. I would rather work on the wound itself. Well, I am happy to report that apparently I've done a pretty good job of that because this summer it didn't feel like I needed to prove anything. It felt fun. I like learning.
SPEAKER_00My philosophy classmates have me hungry for more. And I thought, why not? So at the end of July, I requested my old transcripts from UNC Charlotte. And that's when things got interesting. For years, I've told my children that my mother died in July, and my my plans for art school obviously were gone at that point because I would have been live in Atlanta with my sister and she had moved home. Anyway, I think I've told you all that before.
SPEAKER_00Anyway, my plans for what I wanted to do after high school were gone, and I had no idea what I was gonna do. So I registered at UNC Charlotte in August and I started college. And that's the story that I have told for years, and I'm I didn't just tell it, I believed it completely. But when I got my transcripts, I discovered something. I didn't start college that August. I didn't start until the following fall, an entire year later.
SPEAKER_00Y'all, it shook me. It shook me. At first I I felt gutted, like I was robbed of a year. I did not know where that year of my life went. How could I have forgotten an entire year? And then gradually I started piecing things together. I had waited tables for nearly a year before going to UNC Charlotte. And the more I remembered, the more fascinated I became with the whole experience.
SPEAKER_00Because the story I'd been telling myself wasn't historically accurate, but it was absolutely real in the sense that it had shaped how I understood my own life. I spent years believing that after my mother died, I picked myself up and moved forward. That was part of my understanding of who I was. And now I was discovering that the actual experience had been different. And wouldn't you know?
SPEAKER_00Found myself thinking about Whitehead again. Because here's what I started wondering. The events of that year happened the way they happened. I can't go back and change them. But every time I remembered that period of my life, I was having a new experience of it. And that remembered story was influencing how I saw myself in the present. So even though my memory was inaccurate, it still mattered, it still shaped me.
SPEAKER_00And now, with this new information, my relationship to that part of my life is changing again. The past hasn't changed, but my understanding of it I've had, and that changes what I carry forward. I find that so interesting. We often think of the past as something that is behind us, finished, done, and in one sense it is, but we don't carry around our past like a perfectly preserved historical record.
SPEAKER_00We carry memories, feelings, interpretations, stories we've told ourselves about what happened and what it meant. And sometimes we discover that those stories aren't quite what we thought they were. But that doesn't mean they haven't been part of our becoming. It means that there's something new available to us now. Maybe a deeper understanding, maybe a different kind of compassion for the person we were, maybe a chance to see something we've overlooked.
SPEAKER_00I had believed that I moved straight from my mother's death into college. Now I know there was a year in between, and I find myself wanting to know that younger version of me a little better. What was she doing? What was she feeling? What was she trying to figure out? How did I bury it so deep? It escaped my remembrance. And maybe that's part of what makes the discovery so meaningful. I haven't lost a year. I found a year that deserves to be remembered.
SPEAKER_00Anyway, after all of that, that emotional rigamaroo that I walked through, I met with advisors at UNC Charlotte and at Central Piedmont Community College, and I made a plan. And I am knocking out some of the prerequisites that I so skillfully avoided the first time around. And then I'll head back to UNC Charlotte to finish my degree. Or I won't, because apparently I just changed my mind and do whatever. I signed up for eight-week-long biology and American government classes.
SPEAKER_00And if you think that condensing an entire semester of biology into eight weeks would somehow make it easier for a person who likes to sit around waiting for metaphors to appear, you'd be wrong. Very wrong. But eight weeks does go quickly, and I made it through. And I got a really good grade because one thing you do know by the time you're 48 is that when extra credit is offered, you take it every single time.
SPEAKER_00I also really enjoyed being in class with students in their late teens and early 20s. It's funny because most of my philosophy classmates are three decades older than I am, and most of my college classmates are three decades younger. And somehow I feel perfectly comfortable in both groups. Now, next week I start a full load of eight-week classes. I am going to be taking introduction to public speaking, which should be interesting because I am excited to see if my comfort speaking to the public translates into being comfortable speaking in public.
SPEAKER_00I'm also taking introduction to personal communication, which feels funny to me at this time, but you can always learn something from that. And I will likely use so much of it more than knowing the phases of mitosis. We'll see. I'm taking writing and research with uh please just let me say what I want to say. And also Spanish one. And so we're gonna see how my Duolingo has been paying off. But it's gonna be a lot.
SPEAKER_00It is going to be a lot, but it is only for eight weeks. And I keep reminding myself of that. I am loading up now because I'm hoping that in spring I'll be spending more time working with small circles around the living gospel of Magdalene. And I'd like to have a little more room for that. Work now, play later, or at least that's the plan. And I suppose that's another example of becoming, isn't it? Because I didn't start this year planning to return to college.
SPEAKER_00I didn't even start this year planning to take a philosophy class. But when I did, it opened a door, and then I walked around a university campus with my son and had an unexpected encounter with my own grief, and another door opened. And here I am, 48 years old, trying to remember how to write an academic paper. Not exactly where I thought I'd be, but I'm enjoying finding out where the path goes. And I guess that's a pretty good place to leave us today.
SPEAKER_00I feel like we're finally caught up enough that I can start recording the little things again without feeling like I need to build an entire foundation first. So thank you for listening, especially if you've stayed with me through all of this. I've really missed sharing all my business with you. I look forward to having more of these conversations. I love you. Have a good day.
What happens when the stories that once defined us no longer hold authority over who we are? During an ordinary classroom exercise about the parts of ourselves we keep hidden, I discovered something unexpected....
What happens when the person we believe ourselves to be doesn't quite match the character we're expressing through our actions? This week's contemplation began with an unexpected phone call from my 13-year-old son's...
What can the natural world teach us when we stop trying to make it a metaphor - and simply pay attention? This episode begins beneath my oak tree, Wallace, and travels with me back to the South African bush, where a...
After a few months away from the microphone, I’m back - but not quite where I left off. This episode is less of a summer recap and more of a reintroduction. Life has shifted, new ideas have found me, old ideas are being...
A missed deadline. A difficult conversation. A mistake you wish hadn't happened. Most of us spend our energy focused on the immediate problem. But what if the real question isn't how to solve the problem - it's how to...