Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Reading Instruction Show

The Reading Instruction Show artwork

A Journalist is NOT a Literacy Scholar

Feb 6, 20269 minAudio

Journalists should not get a free pass on ignorance. This podcast describes the difference between journalists and literacy scholars.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

This is The Reading Instruction Show. I'm your host, as always, Dr. Andy Johnson. Today we're talking about the difference between literacy scholars and journalists, an important thing to know. Journalists write stories. People tell them things, they write it down, they put it together to create a story. They are writing for impact versus accuracy. Often. For example,

Sarah Schwartz writes a lot of stuff. She is a journalist. Accuracy doesn't really matter for her. A new low, she says. Well, she's just writing that. She's choosing what to look for. There's no peer review in what she writes. She's just writing stuff. Is this really a new low? Well, natural fluctuations over time. What she's writing about is conveniently inaccurate. These are eighth grade scores. It's not a new low.

Yes, we had the COVID dip and we're still coping with that. And besides, her article was written at the end of 2025, Sarah Schwartz. We've been making a big deal about all this new legislation and science of reading. Look at the years when all this legislation has passed. 2019, 21, 22, 23, 24. So you're saying a new low? Correlation?

Hmm. Sounds like all this new science of reading legislation is causing this new low. If The science of reading was to create miracles. We should be expecting to see miracle upon miracle by now. Journalists are welcome into our academic discussion, but they should not get a free pass. Publish in an academic journal, speak at a conference that allows for discussion, get alternative points

of view, cite specific research. Scholars are subjected to blind peer review. And again, Sarah Schwartz is one. She and Emily Hanford, they're just saying stuff. There's no checks and balances. She's talking about queuing and she doesn't even know what queuing is. Journalists are not literacy scholars. Research has shown. All right, scholars

can't get away with just saying, Research has shown. What research? Show me, show them for who, for what? You can't just say stuff. And in bizarro world, American public media is cited as a source of academic information and too often we are living in that bizarro world. Scholars must rely on research, not data. Not surveys,

anecdotal evidence, not interviews, but research. And research is not research unless and until it has been subjected to blind peer review and published in an academic journal. Here's the process. Someone conducts a research. They write it up. They send it to a journal. The editor sends it to people who are experts in their field, usually two to five. Blind peer review because

these reviewers do not know who wrote the manuscript and the manuscript writer does not know who the reviewers are. The reviewers assess and evaluate. They give their comments and criticisms and they make a recommendation either to accept, accept with revisions, or reject. The editor takes all that and the editor makes the final decision and often there's back and forth between the

writer and the editor before it's published. That's a lot of filters there. Let's see what happens with the journalists. Oh, people tell you things, you write it down, you send it to your editor, and they publish things. Not a lot of filters there, no blind peer review by experts in the field. And if you write stuff on the internet, you just think of stuff and you write it. Karen Viatas and Kelsey Piper wrote this hilarious

thing on a substack called The Argument. And if you want a good laugh, go ahead and go there. Lots of laughs there. A scholar is different from a journalist. Anecdotal evidence, which journalists rely on, is different from evidence. And being popular. is different from being right. Now, see if you can tell me which one of these refer to a journalist and which one to a scholar. The work is submitted to Blind Peer Review. They

write stuff. Hmm, scholar journalists have extensive background knowledge about what they write. They write what people tell them. Important. Cites specific research when making a research -based claim. Just says research has shown, scientists are telling, it has been proven that. Understands the basic elements of science in determining causality. Randomly assigns causality. Oh, scores

are going down, it's that. Correlation does not infer or imply causation. If two things occur together, one must have caused the other to occur. Generalized to larger population only if the sample is similar and ample. Generalized to large populations based on a sample size of one or two. It happened to this kid, therefore it happens

to all kids. This is what my daughter did in New York, therefore all of New York. Reading curriculum is bad. Read Jessica Winter's article. Uses anecdotal evidence and experiences to illustrate research versus using it as research. Considers journalists to be journalists. Considers journalists to be valid sources. Writes research, scholarly

articles and books. Writes stories and columns. Writes for an audience with some knowledge and expertise. Writes for an audience with little knowledge or expertise. Strives for objectivity, reliability and validity reports limitations. Strives for accuracy creates the illusion of objectivity does not report limitations or conflicts. considers themselves to be experts because they

are, considers themselves experts on a subject because they write about it, understands the basics of science and research, understands the basics of journalism. Who might be able to provide the best information about reading instruction? Expertise is important in conducting research and scholarly work in any field. You know what

questions to ask. You understand the constics. You know what data to collect. You understand how to collect the data. You understand how to make inferences based on the data. You understand the limitations of data. You understand the difference between data and research. Why is scholarship knowledge and expertise being shunned in favor of common sense, business sense, and political sense? I welcome journalists into our academic

conversations, but you do not get a free pass on ignorance. You need some background knowledge to have the conversation. It's really hard and I've tried to have conversations with journalists who have shallow and disjointed knowledge base and I'm often having to correct the questions they ask. This has been the Reading Instruction Show. I'm your host, as always, Dr. Andy Johnson.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Importance of Context and the Science of Reading

    Nov 4, 202625 minAudio

    The Science of Reading seems to refer to a general consensus related to the strategies and practices that lead to improved reading outcomes. These strategies and practices have been determined to be effective using...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Structured Literacy: Forward to the Past

    Nov 2, 202629 minAudio

    Using Blanche DuBois’s tragic reliance on the "kindness of strangers" as a central metaphor, this article critiques the recurring cycle of corporate-driven reading mandates and the reduction of literacy instruction to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Conversation with Kathy Brown, Master Educator

    Oct 6, 202633 minAudio

    If you’re looking for accessible, research-based information that slices through the endless loads of overly worded baloney, I would encourage you to subscribe to my free Substack, The Reading Instruction Show....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Reading Instruction, Word Confirmation, and Confirmation Bias

    Sep 19, 202615 minAudio

    Purpose statement: The reader will become more effective in evaluating online sources related to reading instruction. Behavioral objective: Readers will be able to identify instances in which confirmation bias results...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Quiet, Piggy: A Trumpian Response to Science of Reading Critics

    Aug 14, 202612 minAudio

    If you’re looking for accessible, research-based information that slices through the endless loads of overly worded baloney, I would encourage you to subscribe to my free Substack, The Reading Instruction Show....

    Credit the people on this episode