Below are seven big ideas that you should take from this chapter. 1. Having a body of knowledge is important in any field. 2. Disagreement followed by academic discourse enables a field to evolve. 3. Silencing opposing views results in cognitive inbreeding. 4. Academic journals are essential for disseminating new knowledge and for academic discourse within a field. 5. The process used to get scholarly articles published in an academic journal is much higher than that used to get an article published in a newspaper or magazine. 6. Having a body of knowledge that is shallow and disjointed is not optimal for academic discussions or TV interviews. 7. John Stossel does not know what an academic journal is.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
This is The Reading Instruction Show. I am your host, Dr. Andy Johnson. Topic of today's podcast, the importance of academic journals, full colon. John Stossel does not know what they are. Now, there's seven big ideas I want you to take from this two -part series. One, having a body of knowledge is important in any field. Two, disagreement. followed by academic discourse enables a field
to evolve. Three, silencing opposing views results in cognitive inbreeding. Four, academic journals are an essential item for disseminating new knowledge and for academic discourse within a field. Five, the process used to get scholarly articles published in an academic journal is much higher than that used to get an article published in a newspaper or magazine. Six, having a body of knowledge
that is shallow and disjointed is not optimal for academic discourse or TV interviews. And seven, John Stossel does not know what an academic journal is. So to review, I was invited out to New York City so that John Stossel could, quote, get my take, unquote, on whole word reading instruction. But John Stossel did not really want my take on whole word reading instruction. He didn't
really want my take on anything. John Stossel wanted good TV. And I understood this before I flew out for the interview. I was hoping it would give me something to write about, and I thought it might be a good example of what happens when journalists insert themselves into academic conversations. And I wasn't disappointed. So let's look at the importance of knowledge. Most
would agree that knowledge is a good thing. Knowledge. enables you to evaluate data, put information in relevant contexts, and understand phenomena. In any field or endeavor, having more of it is a good thing, and having less of it is not a good thing. And having less of it while thinking you have more of it is a dangerous thing. Interactive
theories of reading. According to interactive theories of reading, the knowledge in our heads interacts with the information on the page to create meaning. Now I'm not trying to brag here, but I've got some knowledge in my head. I earned a PhD from a prestigious university in literacy instruction. This, combined with 30 years of
reading academic books and journal articles, doing scholarly work, writing books and articles, tutoring struggling readers, reviewing articles for academic journals, and teaching graduate and undergraduate courses, has enabled me to accumulate quite a bit of knowledge in my head related to literacy instruction. And again, I'm not trying to brag. Those are just the facts.
Putting knowledge in my head and disseminating it is what I do for a living. The state of Minnesota pays me to do this. I'm a professor of literacy instruction at Minnesota State University. The knowledge in my head enables me to easily read and understand an academic journal like Reading Research Quarterly. This knowledge in my head enables me to critically analyze and evaluate
the articles. I know what information is pertinent, I recognize the research cited, and I can put things in a greater context. But most important is that the knowledge in my head helps me understand what I'm reading. But when this same head tries to read an article in an academic journal like the Journal of Accounting, Auditing, and Finance,
there's very little knowledge to help me create meaning with print. Same brain. But it takes me far longer to read an article. And I understand very little of what I've read. And I'm not able to evaluate the information. And other than the quality of writing, I wouldn't know a good article from a bad one. Same head, different kinds of
knowledge. Having a body of knowledge is important. Now, I'm sure John Stossel has a lot of knowledge in his head. However, not much of it is related to reading instruction. And this was obvious from the first email. And it became abundantly clear at several points during the interview that he knew little about educational research,
educational testing, or academic journals. And why is this relevant? Well, it's difficult to have a substantive interview, much less give your take on things, when the other party doesn't understand the questions that they're asking or the answers that you're providing. Also, the interview doesn't go too far when one is constantly
having to correct mistaken assumptions upon which questions are asked. But the interview becomes a clown show when the unstated purpose of the interview is for the person with a little knowledge to disbelieve things put forth by the person with much knowledge. Now I know I'm not the brightest turnip in the carrot patch, but even a dull turnip like me knows what an academic journal is. I
know their contributions to academic discourse, their necessity in research and the scientific processes, and their importance in addressing the salient and evolving issues in any field. I know these things. People in the scientific and scholarly communities know these things, and most people in the field of literacy instruction know these things. John Stossel does not know
these things. So let's talk about dissemination, disagreement, and devolution. Academic journals are an important source of knowledge dissemination within any academic field. They're also a place where experts within a field disagree. Here, disagreeing ideas are put forth and supported by reason and research, and this is called academic
discourse. Disagreement. followed by academic discourse is essential for the evolution of any field. It avoids the inbreeding of ideas that occur when opposing ideas are silenced. Cognitive inbreeding has led to the knowledge -based mutations and the conceptual deformities we see in groups like the Reading League. And when academic discourse
is replaced by journalism, these mutations and deformities become magnified. Now it's important that people disagree. For me, being questioned or challenged invites me to review research, to reflect, and either reify or refize my thinking. And if you read my books, You will notice slight changes in my thinking as I encounter new information
and as I was exposed to new ideas. To stay the same is to devolve. To change is to evolve. And it is only devolutionists, devolutionists such as Louisa Motes, Emily Hanford, and all the Hanford wannabes who think reading instruction is a settled science. It's not. John Stossel doesn't know
this. And also he doesn't know what an academic journal is. So let's take a look at academic journals and journalists. Academic journals and journalists both have the word journal in them. But that's largely where the similarities end. Journalists are trained to ask questions and
write down what people tell them. That's what they do. That's how they get their story. But their story is their interpretation of reality based on the interpretations of reality of the people who told them things. Now, my understanding of journalism comes from an intro to journalism class taken 40 years ago, and the movie All the President's Men starring Dustin Hoffman and Robert
Redford. Here, the bar for getting a story published was two sources. According to the movie, it was only after Woodward and Bernstein had secured two sources that the Washington Post could run the Watergate story. Now, scholars have a slightly higher bar when publishing in an academic journal besides citing multiple sources throughout an
article. Articles published in academic journals must first make it through a blind peer review. It's important to understand this process. So this is how blind peer review works. Once a study has been conducted or a theoretical article written, the authors send it off to an academic journal to be considered for publication. When the article
is first received, the editor of the journal considers the alignment of the article with the academic standards within the field and the mission of the journal. The editor then selects reviewers with expertise related to the topic of the article to review it. These reviewers evaluate the article without knowing who wrote it, hence the term blind peer review. And the authors don't know
who the reviewers are. For research articles, reviewers consider such thing as the clarity of the research question, the theoretical context in which the research question was asked, the adequacy of the methodology, the analysis of the data, the interpretation of the data, the validity of the conclusions, and the quality of the writing. For theoretical articles, reviewers consider such things as the alignment to research
-based theory, the appropriate use of reason and research to support the thesis or claim, the reflection of a body of established knowledge within the field, and the quality of the writing. Reviewers then have four options. One, recommended for publication. Two, recommended for publication with revisions. 3. Suggest specific reservations be made and that it be resubmitted for consideration,
or 4. Recommend the article be rejected. Blind peer review simply denotes a process. And the quality of this process varies. Reviewers and editors of highly prestigious academic journals use a process that's rigorous and very selective. These journals have low acceptance rates and
tend to have considerable influence on the field. Other journals have a less rigorous review process and higher acceptance rates. However, all are still considered to be peer -reviewed journals. Once published, the article is examined by researchers, scholars, and practitioners within the field. Here it is further analyzed, evaluated, critiqued,
debated, and embraced or rejected. This often leads to new studies conducted and new academic articles written to either support or denounce the initial study or article. These are followed by others, which are followed by others, and the cycle of academic life continues. And, by the way, if reading instruction really were a settled science, as Louisa Mote says it is, there
would be no need for further research. It's all settled. A filter. Blind peer review is a form of a filter. to ensure that the knowledge we get is somewhat valid, somewhat accurate, and somewhat untainted by human subjectivity. Somewhat. It's not a perfect process, but it is a process, and it's used with academic journals. Journalists
like Emily Hanford, Sarah Schwartz, and John Stossel don't have a process. There's no filter. They just say things or write things. And because they have a larger platform than most scholars, their voices are heard by the public and given more credence. Now I want to be very clear on my position here. Journalists and a free press
are essential. in the functioning of a free and open democracy. I'm not one of those who cry fake news every time there's a story I don't like. But journalists have inserted themselves into our academic conversations about reading instruction. And I welcome them, but they don't get a free pass on ignorance. Now, I'm one of
the founders and one of the managing editors of an academic journal called Equity and Social Justice in Education, and I'm very proud of our work. At the same time, I realize that words like equity and social justice are shark chump to libertarians and conservatives like John Stossel. These words are perceived as a threat somehow.
Their bodies go into fight or flight mode when threatened, mostly fight, and blood is shunted away from their frontal lobes to their survival organs. They're less able to think clearly as they work themselves into a feeding frenzy. Thus, I was not surprised when during my interview with John Stossel, John Stossel referenced an
article that was published in this journal titled Profit, Power, and Pedagogy, The Minnesota Read Act by Drake Burke. Burke's article is a solid piece of scholarly writing. Yes, it's complex and lexically dense but well worth the read. It was received very positively by the reviewers and it reflected the mission goal and goals of
the journal. The editors selected it for publication and I strongly recommend that you read it. In the article, Burke used research and reason to support a strong case for the general theses and supporting arguments in that article. And this was done using 13 pages, 64 citations, and 7 ,774 words. In our interview, John Stossel
picked one sentence from this article. And he asked me if I supported that sentence. But it wasn't asked as a question. It was asked to be a challenge. The real question behind the question was this. How can you support this horrible thing you bad person knew? And why do you hate America? And when did you last kick a puppy? This, I guess, was to be the gotcha moment. And you can't blame
John Stossel. This is what journalists do. You can't ask a skunk not to stink. Of course, the sentence was not representative of the article. It was pulled out of context and used to create a misperception. It would be like the editor of the book that this is taken from to ask that editor, do you support the idea that skunks don't stink? This is a common practice used to craft
a narrative to create stories and sadly today this practice is not limited to journalists. Well -known scholars such as Louisa Moats and Claude Goldenberg have done similar things. The only reason I know this is because I've checked the sources they've cited. When this occurs, their scholarship becomes journal -ship with big words and long sentences. And as stated previously, the blind peer review process isn't perfect.
But back to the interview. During the interview, it was clear that John Stossel had not read the article. It was also clear that John Stossel didn't know what an academic journal was. Why else would he ask an editor of an academic journal if they supported something that somebody else wrote? An academic journal is not a magazine,
a newspaper, a cable TV show, a podcast, or publication like Education Week. Managing editors of academic journals don't silence the voices of people whose views don't align with their own. Managing editors of academic journals don't craft narratives to express their ideas or promote articles to advocate their views. A managing editor of an academic
journal is like a referee making sure certain standards are adhered to and guidelines are followed. And a managing editor of an academic journal welcomes opposing ideas if a. the articles are well written b. they represent standards of scholarship and academic discourse and c. they go through a blind peer review. process. Since journalists
have inserted themselves into the conversation, I want to make sure that you understand the difference between scholars and journalists. And of course, I make generalizations here, and I'm going to name a few, but if it walks like a clown and quacks like a clown, It is a clown. Scholars, their work is submitted to blind peer review
for publishing. Journalists, they just write stuff. Scholars have extensive background knowledge about what they write. Journalists, they write what people tell them. Scholars understand the basic elements of science in determining causality. Journalists, randomly assign causality. Scholars know that correlation does not imply causation.
Journalists assume that if two things occur together, one must have caused the other to occur. Scholars will generalize to larger populations only if the sample size is similar and ample. Journalists will generalize to larger populations based on a sample size of one or two. Scholars use anecdotal evidence and experience to illustrate research.
And journalists will use anecdotal evidence and experience as research. These are just some of the difference. Final word. Seven ideas. Having a body of knowledge is important in any field. Two, disagreements followed by academic discourse enables a field to evolve. Three, silencing opposing views results in cognitive inbreeding. Four,
academic journals are an essential element for disseminating new knowledge and for academic discourse within a field. Five, The process used to get scholarly articles published in an academic journal is much higher than that used to get an article published in a newspaper or magazine. Six, having a body of knowledge that is shallow and disjointed is not optimal for academic discussions or TV interviews. And seven, John Stossel does
not know what an academic journal is. This has been The Reading Instruction Show. I am your host, Dr. Andy Johnson.
The Science of Reading seems to refer to a general consensus related to the strategies and practices that lead to improved reading outcomes. These strategies and practices have been determined to be effective using...
Using Blanche DuBois’s tragic reliance on the "kindness of strangers" as a central metaphor, this article critiques the recurring cycle of corporate-driven reading mandates and the reduction of literacy instruction to...
If you’re looking for accessible, research-based information that slices through the endless loads of overly worded baloney, I would encourage you to subscribe to my free Substack, The Reading Instruction Show....
Purpose statement: The reader will become more effective in evaluating online sources related to reading instruction. Behavioral objective: Readers will be able to identify instances in which confirmation bias results...
If you’re looking for accessible, research-based information that slices through the endless loads of overly worded baloney, I would encourage you to subscribe to my free Substack, The Reading Instruction Show....