Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Reading Instruction Show

The Reading Instruction Show artwork

George Hruby presents After the Flood: Reading Instruction Post SoR

Apr 10, 20261 hr 23 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Feeling deluged by SOR media, materials, and mandates? Science of Reading’s murky waters have crested, says Dr. Hruby. Our classrooms are ours to reclaim if we strategize now. Join Dr. Hruby in a conversation about why SOR may be on the outs, the backstories behind it, and how we can take back control of our teaching and students’ learning.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

I am thrilled to welcome Dr. George Ruby. I just realized I had my microphone off when I was doing your intro. Sorry about that. I'm gonna post it. I'm gonna post it in the chat. Sorry about that. Just know that it's incredible. If you want to go ahead, go ahead, George. Oh, well,

hello, everyone. Thank you for signing in. I'm thrilled to be here with Andy Johnson's webinars and ILAC, a fantastic group. And you're just a dedicated group of scholars and teachers and educators. And I'm glad you're here. The title of my presentation today is after the flood reading instruction post science of reading Now what

in the world do I mean by that? Well before I get started, maybe I should say a word about me You may not know exactly who I am Which just goes to show that how dedicated you are to the ILEC And and I would say that well, let me begin by saying Andy that I don't seem to be able to Get my screen to move Oh, there we go. So most people know me from the work that I've done synthesizing the research in the neurosciences on reading

and reading difficulties and reading development. This is just some of the work that I've done along those lines. But I've done a lot of other stuff as well, and I've published on other things as well. But I mention this because I want you to know that while I may be somewhat critical of the science of reading, I am not critical of science. And while science, like anything, given human ingenuity, can be weaponized in oppressive

ways, it can also be very useful. So I think especially now with the attack on science from the right, and along with the attack on education generally, we should be cautious. about being overly critical about that. But I retired just a year ago, and up until then, I was a research title faculty at the University of Kentucky, and the executive director of the Collaborative

Center for Literacy Development for the Commonwealth of Kentucky. The CCLD was founded in 1998 by the state legislature, had a very, very generous budget, many millions of dollars per year. And we provided teacher professional development through the state universities and their faculty at all eight of the state universities in the Commonwealth of Kentucky. This shows the service regions for those. I can say a lot about the CCLD, but I really can't. But I just love it so much because it's such great work working

with with teachers and helping them become the sort of teachers that they wanted to be, allowing them responsible autonomy to pursue the questions that were of concern to them and to develop the skills that they felt that their students would be best served by rather than imposing pre -structured programs. And I'll just share this little bit of data. These are the National Assessment of Educational Progress reading scores for Kentucky,

the United States, and Tennessee from 1992 to 2019. The black line is the US average. The light blue line, Kentucky blue, is how well we did in the Commonwealth. And you can see from 2002 forward, every single testing year, which is about every other year. So it's about 12 testing years. We scored significantly above the national average. The red line there is Tennessee. Just by point of comparison, we share our longest

border with Tennessee, just to the south. And a much more affluent state, I might say. You know the correlation between school achievement and income. And it just so happens that we are, through most of this time period, the fourth poorest state in the union. And yet we defied the odds, not in math, not in the other subject areas, but we did it. And we did it through devoting immense amount of resources to supporting our

teachers so that they could in turn support our students. As I say, there's a lot about that that I could go on about, but I won't, except this. I had to spend a lot of time in the state legislature ensuring that we maintained our budget. We had lottery monies, we had appropriation lines, and I brought in probably about three quarters of a mil on average every year in grants. But that money could easily have disappeared. And so I had to be in there on a regular basis. And I'm not a policy person. I'm not a government

person. I'm not an administrator, usually. I mean, I became one for this position. And I learned a lot by the seat of my pants. And I'm happy to say that in the 14 years that I was there, uh we never lost any of our funding even though our state university where we're located and the others as well sadly lost funding year over year over year because of the sorts of budget cuts that have been hitting the state universities

and their colleges of education deeply unfortunate and it eventually began to have a toll on the literacy faculty available to to work in our programs ultimately our center was shut down because of political pressure from the forces that are behind the science of reading. So that does bias my interpretation. But in fact, what I'll be presenting tonight is rather similar to what I've been presenting since 2020, 21, 22, 23, about what is really behind the science

of reading. And with that in mind, I would propose, what should we be doing to prepare for what's coming next? uh... some of you may know that uh... back in twenty twenty i did a six minute video on you to call what this politics is the science of reading you can look that up it's still there and it i did the point there that uh... the initial caps give it away science of reading is a branding And why would you brand something called the science of reading? The answer is to sell it. I didn't know exactly how

or what was going to be sold at that point. It was 2020, but I soon enough found out, and I imagine many of you have as well. I've also done pro bono work for the states bordering Kentucky, Ohio, Tennessee. North Carolina, even New York, Wisconsin, Iowa, and yes, Minnesota. I got this off a Minnesota government page. It's a research piece. It's two pagers for legislators. But this came out in 22, I believe. And so it's, you know, I would offer, they tried to get me to come up and present actually to the state legislature

up there. And I declined because of my schedule. But, you know, it's been a tough fight everywhere in the U .S. If you're not from the US, and I know many of you are not, I want to point out that what we call the science of reading is what many of you refer to as evidence -based reading. If you're in the UK or Ireland, Australia, perhaps the EU, you refer to it as evidence -based. If you're in Central Africa or in New Zealand, the

Maori schools, for instance, you might refer to it as structured literacy. These are fairly analogous terms, and they change. And what we call science of reading now, we used to call scientifically based reading back in the 90s, in the early aughts. So these terms are flexible, but the pedagogy, unfortunately, is not. My point tonight is this. The science of reading is kaput. It's done with. And the time to strategize for

what follows is now. Now, you might not believe that, particularly if you're in the United States, because it seems to be going strong. Legislation in your state mandates that schools must use a program or a teacher PD or an assessment that is from an approved list from the State Department. And interestingly, all the states with their approved lists have the same pretty much approved list and there's a reason for that and I'm going

to discuss that tonight because I think to have a voice in what's coming next and we need to have a voice we need to have influence on what's coming next we need to take back our schools take back literacy education for our students and for our communities and to do that we have to understand what the motivations are behind the science of reading and many people have done some really great work contributing to this. I shouldn't say too many because it's sad to

say that, at least in the U .S., many teacher education faculty are bewildered. We were hit with this flood, it's like a tsunami, and it came so fast. But some of us of a certain age, a certain vintage, and Andy, I have to include you here, and a number of other folks as well, we were able to say that we knew what was coming in the 20 teens. because we said we'd been here before in the 1990s when we were starting our career. When it came, we pretty much respected

what was behind it and we said so because we'd been here before, you know, and we said, you know, this isn't going to work. We've tried this. We've been here before. And because we've been here before, we also know that this too shall pass. And the question is what's coming next? And how do I know that it's about to? has or that it already has. Well, I'll share some examples of that. And then I'll talk about what I think is behind it. And then I'll talk about the strategies we have to consider for moving forward and what

maybe we might want to avoid. But there's lots of room for disagreement. I would love to hear your comments. I would love to hear your thoughts. So I want to leave time at the end for discussion about that. And this is a discussion which should go on for a very long time. Just to make sure we're on the same page. I'm not gonna talk about the flood the zone kind of science of reading You know the wild -eyed claims by Emily Hanford and stuff like that. Our kids can't read You know, really all of them at all at any level, you know, come on. Have you ever met a kid in

school? Yeah, of course they can read Some kids have more difficulty than others, but we're human beings. And anything you want to measure a human being, they differ. That's not a disability. That's just the nature of organic growth and development. People differ. They differ between themselves, and they differ in response to their own past. So what I'm talking about here isn't the stuff like we're in a crisis. when in fact we had the highest reading scores that we had ever had in history, when Emily Hanford came

out with her, you know, hard words article with American public media reports. I'm talking about a legitimate stance, which I don't necessarily agree with, but at least I respect the people who do believe this. They believe you should emphasize letter sounding over comprehension and synthetic phonics over other phonics approaches for word recognition. And if you're not sure what synthetic phonics is, I would invite you to go look at some of Andy's previous webinars.

There's a good one there about the different types of phonics. And emphasizing decoding skills over language comprehension development. in the early elementary grades to a certain extent makes sense. You can't do everything all at once. But the idea that you should emphasize decoding to the exclusion of everything else and not just until second grade or third grade or fourth grade but till, you know, fifth grade or even in one state here, eighth grade. That's kind of crazy,

I think. The other thing that worries me about the science of reading, even the legitimate science of reading, is that it posits language developers occurring naturally and you hear this said repeatedly it's interesting they are vehemently against whole language and whole language used to say that you didn't have to be overly structured with decoding skills instruction because kids would develop an understanding of that naturally provided you focused on meaning now not all whole language people said that but some people did So it's strange that they are now, you know,

taking the exact same tact. But the problem is we all know that language develops in response to the linguistic environments that a child inhabits. And those who inhabit linguistic environments that are privileged by the school system, the text they use, the language conventions they privilege, the language conventions they test. are at an advantage compared to those who don't have that, or not as far along in their language development. And so language comprehension, which

starts in the earliest months and years of life and continues throughout your life, should not come to a screeching halt just because you're going to do decoding skills in the early elementary grades. It should continue on, I would say. The other thing about science of reading is it's prepaced, packaged, scripted, systematic, structured, technologized. Now Andy says that structured or systematic just means that it's organized. And if that's all it means, that's fine. I mean, who's ever recommended disorganized literacy instruction, right? But what they're really talking

about here is a preset structure that is supposed to be marched out. presented by the teacher or increasingly now by the technology itself directly to the children. And this is not going very well. Let's remind ourselves what science is. I saw this quote in the New York Times. It's by Celine Gonder, an epidemiologist. She's talking about, this is in relation to the assault on the CDC

and the health. department here in the US and funding for medical research and scientific research and so on. And she points out that science is a method for formulating and testing hypotheses. It is not a fixed set of facts. It should work alongside other ways of knowing, but it must also be protected from political or commercial capture. Protecting the science is, I should

say, of literacy education from political or commercial capture is what my presentation today is all about. She goes on to say that perhaps I'm naive to think that such preservation is possible, but when it fails, people manipulate facts, trust collapses, and public decisions lose their anchor in a shared understanding of reality. This undermines the very goals of public health policy, and I would say public education policy, which is meant to be a collective endeavor, a collective endeavor And we need to get back

in the game, making sure our voice is heard, not as a course of demands, but as an informed set of professionals who are there to guide those less well -informed, but who have their own vested interest in our education systems being successful. And these are many. Now, I would say, I think this is true for the Anglophone world generally. uh... but certainly true in the u s that there is this uh... pension by the general public for

uh... lord is called scientism Okay, and it's basically science for people who don't understand very much about it kind of conflates science with technology and accountancy You know and if you ever been to Tomorrowland at Disneyworld, you know, it's kind of like that or the Jetsons or Star Wars You know, they love new technology. We all love to run out to buy the latest iPhone You know or the or the latest laptop and we just take it for granted that this is progress and it's turned out that we're kind of being led

into places that we've never really asked for, and maybe we don't really want to go. And with AI now emerging, this question has been asked much more loudly and evidently. But I point out that scientism is not the same thing as science. Okay, with that under our belt, let's look at the what I would call health metrics for science of reading as of the early 2026. We have declining

reading scores since 2019. In 2015, U .S. NAEP reading scores for fourth grade readers was the highest it had ever been in the U .S. in history. It was a full half grade level above where it had been in 2000. Today, we're back down to where we were in 1998. There are reports of childhood mental health issues related to technology use. And while the focus on this has been first on

too much phone use, actually first on COVID, then too much phone use, then the nature of social media and the rather toxic content that's available there. But increasingly parents are expressing their concern about the use of technology in the schools and the technologization of scientifically based reading or science of reading. is an issue that I want to touch on, because it is related to what's behind it all. We've had a loss of emergency federal learning lag funding that was

there for COVID. It began a little bit in the late 2020, two large amounts in 2021, but in 2024 it ended. And now that is creating financial problems for the schools who are forced to face financial contingency. Pulling back, they can no longer afford the two -year leases on their operating systems. They are two -year leases on the programs that run on the operating systems. The two -year leases and licenses for all the testing that they do, the diagnostics, the screeners,

the progress monitors, the summatives. They can't do that anymore, you know? And it's creating problems. Purveyors are trying to kick the can down the road. They're offering special deals. There's a blockage here, but that can't go on for very much longer. Associated with this, we see a retreat of aggressive pro -science of reading public relations and gentle admissions of failures at websites that used to be dedicated entirely

to the science of reading orthodoxy, vehement about it. And there were even some mainstream outlets that allowed these sorts of stories to be run as well, even the New York Times, the Washington Post, and so forth. We've seen an increase in mainstream and social media on the importance of comprehension, deep reading, writing, language development. That's wonderful. But why weren't people acknowledging this five years ago, three years ago? The reason is they're no

longer getting the funding that they were used to getting to support science of reading. No spoilers here. The AI threat to the software industry, including EduTech, EduTech software, those proprietary programs the schools have to buy. There's a threat to that industry. And as a result, it's undermining the private equity investments in those companies, as well as in private equity finance that are loaning large and rather risky bets to those software startup

companies. More on that later, if you're not familiar with what this is about. Parent groups are pushing back against technology in the schools and finally the mainstream media is beginning to run stories acknowledging this and the science of reading professional development is Now being extended into high schools now that might seem like a further advance of the science of reading but that is a coffin nail I remember reading first and you knew it was over when in the late

Aughts The question emerged though, okay, so the funding is ending on reading first. It hasn't done what it was supposed to have done. We've hired all these reading coaches, which were essentially fidelity monitors. They didn't really, they weren't qualified or certified to teach kids themselves, but they would show up at the schools with their clipboards and their checklist and they walked down the halls, looking in the windows, making sure the teachers were actually doing what they were supposed to be doing. So when the whole program ended, what do you do with those folks? Do you just gonna let them go? Well, what they

did is, they sent him into the secondary schools, into high schools, to teach and provide PD to the high school teachers, the English language arts teachers, to teach them how to teach early elementary reading. What? Needless to say, the teachers wouldn't stand for that and eventually the principals reported to the teachers. departments of the State Departments of Education and isn't a very good idea and it lasted I think about two years and didn't didn't go well at all. But we're seeing this again. It's called the science of secondary reading. The only thing I love about

this is the SOSR. In other words, it's SOR giving us an SOS. Okay, I'll just leave it at that. Now, I'm not going to walk you through all these stories. Here's one from the Los Angeles time on how Mississippi gained its national reading test scores to produce miracle gains. But of course, the story is going to tell you that it's because third graders who don't read very well are held back and therefore are not included in the fourth graders who are tested on the NAEP. And so that increases your NAEP average and increases

your state score. I didn't know that. And holding kids back in third grade raises other problems. long -run costs, both financial as well as to the child's reading development and their schooling, they're more likely to drop out because they'll be older by the time they get to high school. Just like phonics, comprehension requires explicit teaching. Yeah, 2020 -2019, I had a piece in Kappen about the disappearance of oral language in early elementary reading standards. What was

going on with that? slowly but surely this stuff pieces together, you know, and on and on it goes. Here's one reading's thin line between difficult and boring. Did you know that it's the teacher's responsibility to keep the kids motivated? Even though in many classrooms in America today, thanks to the technology, they no longer have any control over the instruction. They don't plan the lessons, they don't design the curriculum, but somehow they're responsible to keeping the kids interested. in low level skill drilling. Okay, well on and

on it goes disappointing, you know, Ohio science of reading switch, not yet bringing results in some urban districts, science of reading limits, robust comprehension. So my point is that there's this admission that maybe things that we were cheering about aren't working as well as we had promised they would. The cost of over teaching phonics, again, both financial as well as developmental. The real culprit of our literacy gap? The kids don't have any time to read. Well, when you're,

you know, this is what Murzoff in Boston Review in his essay last year was pointed out. There's an instrumentalist bias to this edu -tech software. It's all based on computer game design theory. And so the idea is to keep you continually, you know, interactive with the program. For that reason, anything that involves time away from the program, away from the machines, away from the operating system, is disappeared from our

curriculum. Kids need time to practice their reading and their writing and their discussions. We do have this. We have open AI and Microsoft bankrolling, new AI training for teachers. This came out in the Times just last summer. And more recently, a week ago, Malene Trump wants robots to teach your kids. So yeah, technology, it's very much in the classroom and more is on the way. another disconcerting sign at the House of Representatives in Congress, a bill has been

put forward that is essentially identical to the science of reading bill you probably have in your state if you live in the US that prohibits the three queuing system that mandates that you use science of reading approved reading programs. And you know, this is remarkable because it's a Republican controlled Congress. Why would the House propose to essentially take back for the federal government control of school curriculum, when back in 2015, the Republicans worked so

hard to get the Elementary and Secondary Education Act revised to take control away from the feds and give it back to the states. And the reason is, I'm here to tell you, something that is near and dear to every red -blooded American. and probably many of you who aren't Americans. It's called money and lots of it. How much money am I talking about? I'm talking about $190 billion.

That's how much money the federal government threw at post pandemic learning lag relief from 2021 to 2024. It was well intended. The largest portion of that probably went to infrastructure development, and that includes building new schools and refurbishing old schools that needed it severely. But a big chunk of that is also technology infrastructure, because the same thing that, at the same time

that COVID was going on, 5G networks were being brought in. And it's the 5G network streaming that allows the kind of instructional technology that we have in the schools today. Now I want you to visualize this with me. How much is $190 billion? Well, let's start small. Imagine $100 ,000. Imagine earning $100 ,000. You probably don't earn that much, but if you're part of a two -income earning family, you might. And you certainly probably know people who do, people

further up the food chain, your principal or the district superintendent, the dean of the College of Education or whomever. Okay, so fine. And you know, celebrities and business tycoons who make a heck of a lot more. But you can imagine $100 ,000, okay? How long would it take you hundred thousand dollars a year to earn one million dollars just one million and the answer is ten years okay well you can imagine ten years you can imagine a hundred thousand so you can get your head around a million bucks how long would it take you at

the rate of a hundred thousand dollars a year to earn one just one billion dollars and the answer is ten thousand years Now, you're not going to live that long, obviously. Most of us can't trace our own ancestry back 200 years. And 10 ,000 years ago, think about 10 ,000 years ago, there was no agriculture. There was no pottery. There was no metallurgy. There certainly was no literacy. The earliest quasi -permanent settlements

were appearing. They seemed to be mostly for periodic religious observation where the hunter -gatherers would come together, and it's mostly in the Fertile Crescent area of the Middle East and southern Turkey. So, you know, I mean, that's just an immense amount of time, and that's just 1 billion. 190 billion? That'd be 1 .9 million years ago. There weren't even any Homo sapiens around back then. So, okay, so maybe that does or does not explain what's going on here. The problem is the states have lost what the legislators

call free money. And they can't afford to maintain all these mandates that they've legislated. So they want to throw the baby back over to the federal government, which has the ability, which states do not, and which school districts certainly do not, to just print money. And so I think that's what's behind this. But I sincerely doubt the Senate's going to pass this. But always remember this, and remember this in relation to the legislation in your own state. Anything that gets passed

into law can be modified. It's not a one and done sort of situation. I learned that when having my own victories, the very next year, you have to be back at it defending it again. So keep that in mind. Let's look at a little history. Here again, the NAEP scores, the black line there in the middle, this is from 1992, and the lines here at this point go to 2017. Black line in the middle is the national average for fourth

grade. The light blue line, that's the thick one, that's Kentucky. The others are other states, you don't need to get into that. But I just have that out there to show you that during the... from 1994 through 2017, it was an upward, slow but steady, upward improvement in how well our fourth grade readers were doing. And you see the same thing at the eighth grade level as well. Then in 2018 comes hard words. Emily Hanford's

APM report story claiming that our kids cannot read. They're teaching kids to guess the words. Right? They're not teaching phonics. No empirical evidence for any of this. Sweeping assertions that couldn't possibly be true, let alone probable. And we are doing better than we had ever been done before, historically. Well, here's what happens after that story. And you can't blame it on Emily. There were other things going on. From around 2013 to 2019, there was a push for

urban district phonics for the major urban districts. The push for phonics remediation starts in the early 20 teens. It morphs into mainstream classroom instruction for children who are at risk, which, when you know it, are kids who are more likely to be in poverty, who are more likely to be English language learners, who are more likely to be minority. And that's all the students you find in urban districts. So that's what was funded and it was a colossal disaster. Here are the NAEP district scores from 2015 to 2019. The bottom

seven cities there all were doing science of phonics. skill drilling in the classroom and PD for the K through three teachers. I saw it happening in Jefferson County, Kentucky, which is Louisville, but our center was banned from Louisville because they had a private agreement with a local. private university one million dollars a year to provide this training and I had conversations with the folks there and I said, you know, I think you need to include some

comprehension and language development support. They didn't want to hear it. They'd done this before. They sure had. They'd done it in the University of Memphis in Tennessee where it had been a colossal failure and before that in Houston where it was a failure and as you can plainly see it was a failure here too. Meanwhile, however, San Diego and Fresno too, high poverty districts, high ELL districts, high minority districts, they are doing very well. What's going on there? Well, California started a little early on this urban phonics push, and when it didn't work out

very well, they allowed districts to propose modifications. Here's my rendition of the Fresno Unified literacy wheel. Yeah, they did phonics and phonemic awareness. They did fluency practice and so forth But they did a lot of other things as well speaking and listening reasoning strategy use engagement and motivation vocabulary and writing and and They bracketed the whole thing with language and and ELL support and they got results So, you know, there's just another one

of those little Correlations that aren't causation that kind of suggests maybe something's going on here And it shouldn't be surprising, because that darn national reading panel report that you're going to hear a lot about next month when Denny Taylor presents, this is a quote from the subsection on phonics. It is important to emphasize that systematic phonics instruction should be integrated with other reading instruction to create a balanced reading program. That's right, create a balanced reading program. The NRP report

recommends that. Phonics instruction is never a total reading program. Phonics should not become the dominant component in a reading program, neither in the amount of time devoted to it nor in the significance attached. By emphasizing all the processes that contribute to growth in reading, teachers will have the best chance of making every child a reader. That's a national reading panel report that many people misrepresent as supporting the science of reading and an overemphasis on synthetic phonics skill drilling in systematic

fashion. So that's what happened there. And then it morphs into science of reading, because why just allow the urban districts to suffer? Let all the districts in your state suffer. And that's what happened. Then, of course, comes COVID. OK, that's that yellow bar. And then comes the $190 billion to make everything better. OK? This coincides with the classroom digital technology push, which gets started in the 20 aughts with

the one child, one laptop movement, right? And people like the Gates Foundation and the Hewlett Foundation and other philanthropies funded by big tech companies. No surprise why they want that. Here's some of the secret sauce behind what's going on. This is a chart. And on the left -hand side, you see the top five, as best I can determine, the five most commonly used science of reading approved reading programs

for early reading. And I've actually done this list down to the top seven, but I couldn't fit that in here. So these are the top five. The middle column are the publishers, and you may already know that if you have to deal with any of these programs. But on the right -hand side are the owners. And what you'll notice is that every single one is an equity, a private equity group or hedge fund. And in bold, I have the years that they bought the publishers that you

see in the middle column. And you can see most of them are 21, 22, 23, right? Which is the year when the big $190 billion hit the table. That free money was there for the states to use, and anything that stood to profit from the science of reading was bought up by private equity. They're no fools. They know where the money is and they know how to handle an amount as large as $190 billion. There were three that were early in,

I must say. The first is the Emerson Collective. That's the core of the Applify and core knowledge language arts. Emerson Collective is owned by Lauren Jobs, the wife of Steve Jobs, right? The co -founder of Apple and I should say the widow. But she's certainly savvy about technology and the people she has on her team certainly are savvy. And they saw what was coming, 5G networks that would allow things like the Khan Academy, which was very important. It got lots of good publicity in the 20 teens to really get serious

within the schools. And you know, I'm an Apple fan on that. But but so she was early in on that. So was Silver Lake Technology Management. I mean, the name speaks for itself. It's a private equity group that bought Weld North Education, and that publishes Imagine Learning. And Veritas Capital, which in 2018 bought Cambium Learning, which produces Kurzweil learning, or learning from A to Z. You know, they specialize in online educational

programs at that time. But it wasn't until 21 that Veritas got super serious. They bought Rosetta Stone, an online foreign language program, and they took off its learning division, Lexia. and combined it with Voyager Sopris, an imprint that Cambium owned, each of which had their own unfortunate reading program, and turned it into what, in a press release, they called their super brand, Lexia Learning, which then proceeded for 125 million to buy the rights to the letters program

from Motz and Tolman. They also began to become the major corporate sponsor for the International Dyslexia Association, which, by the way, has the registered trademark at the U .S. Patent Office for the term Structured Literacy. In 22, they're a task bought Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, major conglomerate itself the result of the merger of Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Brace and Holt Reinhardt. And they owned InterReading, the number one foremost used reading program for science of reading.

In fact, if you're in New York City, it's the only one you're allowed to use. And a year later, They bought Northwest Education Association, the owners of the MAP test, the measures of academic progress in reading and math, foremost progress monitoring. test in the U .S. So that's just a taste of, you know, what's going on. Now, I want to say, Veritas, I hope, through Old Mifflin Hardcourt, also owns Heinemann. So they produce good stuff. The problem with Heinemann's stuff is, especially with people like Lucy Calkins and Fonteson Pannell, the problem with that stuff

is that it wasn't amenable to quick application with online, engaged, low -level skill drilling. in a Q and response behaviorist fashion, which is what the computer game design requires. And so that is the big money behind the science of reading. And what about those laws that got passed? Well, this is a timeline. It reads from the top down the top. A block there is Mississippi, 2013.

The bottom set of blocks is 2024. So if you read it down, you see Mississippi passes its law, South Carolina the next year, Nevada the year after that. But by 2018, only seven states have passed such laws. And most of the states are toothless. There's no mandates, there's recommendations, but there's no money behind it. So there's not a big deal. Then comes COVID, that's the red line. Then comes the 190 billion, that's the green line. And you can see the explosion of states that suddenly passed science of reading

laws. And these laws now are highly aggressive. They mandate curricula. They mandate teacher trainings, certain products that must be used, certain things that cannot be used. 14 states prohibit the three -queuing model, basically the teaching of reading from using meaning. Really? So, and I'm sad to say the closure of literacy teacher professional development centers like the CCLD, which was because of pressure through the new very right wing board of directors on

the upper administration of the University of Kentucky. So we were finished and replaced with a reading research center, which doesn't seem to get any funding and isn't doing anything in Kentucky, as far as I can tell, but I could be wrong. Now, is it a matter of corruption? Do these big money folks hire lobbyists? Well, yes. And do they go in and they corrupt the morals of our noble legislators? No. Our legislators actively go out looking for this funding, especially

if they're in the assembly or the House of Representatives. Every two years, they got to run for reelection. The minute they get elected, they're on the phone to their funders trying to get more. Money, you know, billionaires are swaying elections in all corners of America. I'm just reading. I'm like Ted Danson and the man on the inside. I'm just reading you the headlines here, you know, from my clip file. Four things billionaires are doing with their money to influence elections, which include board of election. uh board of education elections right wealthy to over the past two

election cycles two billionaires that's two people have provided more than nine million dollars to fund the california charter schools association which in turn has contributed to a range of legislative and school board races including one in 2024 for the sacramento county board of education okay you gotta read this stuff folks you gotta watch what they're doing over there at the wall street journal too they're telling you about this stuff they're not they're not hiding any of this stuff and it's not illegal and I think this is where we need to maybe get a little more savvy and realize that those resources could

be used for good and I'm not I'm pretty sure that these folks aren't really out to harm kids they just Don't care that they don't stay awake at night worrying about how kids learn their phonics, you know So if you want to know what drove a science of reading predisposition towards scientism A lot of ed tech tools that are always wowing us the science of reading story promising We have a crisis 190 billion dollars to address the crisis Suddenly social and mainstream media advocacy out the wazoo and voila science of reading laws mandating science of reading And there you

have it uh now The timeline now takes you to 2022. What happened in 2024? Well, everybody knew there was going to be a rebound. And everybody knew that the science of reading folks were going to take credit for it. And for those of us who knew that was bunk, we were really upset. But you know what happened? The scores continued to drop. Most states continued to drop. So we're now in 2026. We won't know the scores for 26 until probably January of 27. So that's coming

up next. So here's where we are. The Fed dollars ended in 24. The NAEP reading scores are down eight points. And you software losing value due to AI threat. What's that about? Well, I got to tell you this real quick, real fast. AI can not only can generate a realistic human language, it can also generate functional. So you don't need to buy preparatory software from, you know, these publishing companies that have turned into tech companies. You can just get AI to produce

your program for you, a bespoke or custom program to address your and your students' needs, you know, aligned with what is going to be functional and responsive to them and their community. Now, do we know how to do that? I know I certainly don't. You probably don't either. But imagine where you had a critical mass of talent, an urban district, where you had good teachers, teacher educators, educational researchers working together with IT people who knew how to do the prompts

to get AI to produce this kind of thing and beta test it and get the bugs out. You'd have programs that were custom made for you. Don't make you do stuff you don't want to do, that forced stuff upon you you never asked for. I think there's a lot of potential here for power and liberation, but you know what? Technology is always promising power and liberation, and it always turns into surveillance and control. So I'm not so sure, but we'll have to see. More headlines. Oakland can't afford to dismantle its literacy infrastructure,

but it has no choice. It's over 100 grand in the red. The future of e -books in school libraries, says Publishers Weekly. School libraries face shrinking budgets and a shifting vendor landscape for digital materials. Even the one laptop per child movement back in 2009, this is from 2009, in the subhead it says, the vision is being overwhelmed by the reality of business, politics, logistics, and competing interests worldwide. And that's the story with the science of reading. It's an alliance of convenience. Advocates for phonics

and curriculum, people with pet theories about teaching and learning, policy advocates, political PACs, publicists and media, lobbyists and lawyers, all with their shingles out, and behind it all, the big money. Dintech, edutech, hedge funds and private equity, okay? It's an alliance of convenience, but these things fall apart pretty easily. And when the funding stops, as it has, and when the scores plummet, which is not a good look, as it has, something has got to give. And people are already starting to snipe at one another.

Here's The Economist, the foremost publication for the business world, right? And tech is profitable. It is also mostly useless. Independent research identifies few learning gains. Wow. When the economist gives you a thumbs down on your financial model, your business model, you're in trouble. Here's from the times which was always heavy breathing for science of reading. It's starting to confess up. From book remorse, tech backlash at schools extends beyond the phones. Well, Wall Street Journal was onto that two years ago. Screens

have taken over classrooms. Even students have had enough. Educators question whether the rapid shift toward more technology has benefited learning. When kids adopt new technologies, hype can turn to backlash. And indeed, parents are now rising. Schools beyond screens. Join the movement. Safe and intentional tech in school. Call to action from Los Angeles Unified School District. Here's another one. Excuse me. distraction -free schools, a policy project with Jared Horvath, who's a

cognitive neuroscientist, but he's got a book, The Digital Delusion, and it really hits hard. But this is interesting, because his webinar is focused on legislators, school administrators, and district leaders, right, and he's identifying them as the decision -makers. I think it's time we got involved in becoming decision -makers too, you know, and we will. And here are the tech titans, you know these folks, they're all, this is a photo of them at Trump's second inauguration. In 2024, there was strong bipartisan support

in both the House and the U .S. Senate for the online Kids Safety Act. And the Senate said, OK, this looks good, sends it back to the House. There's a few tweaks you need. And one of them is about a phrase is that the tech titans don't like so much and it was duty of care the idea that tech titans who were producing products that are being used by children have some duty to do no harm to the children was an outrage it impinged upon their their their liberty and

their free market ethos okay and what happened it shot down the kids safety act and it did not even come back up again in 25 but it is back up again this year i think it's got a better chance of past Meanwhile, juries are paying out, you know, making decisions that are forcing Meta, there's two, just this past week. Meta and YouTube got whacked for being responsible for their customers' well -being. In Europe... they take a much more

measured approach and they plan in advance. So they're doing things as well. Australia has prohibitions against certain media for young kids, and that's just reasonable. So when I look in the schools, When I see the science of reading, I see excessive use of screens and keyboards despite their limits, a loss of oral language, writing instruction, book reading in the curriculum, limiting activities for engagement, creativity, and personal relevance in classroom instruction, shuddering the socio -emotional support of classroom community. I

see, of course, you know there's laws mandating lower level skill drilling, outlawing higher order reading for meaning, prohibiting three queuing methods, displacing higher order language use and knowledge development, because the computers... Maybe it'll change with AI, but the computers can't do that. They can't engage in a helpful way. So therefore, what happens? Do we put the computers aside? No! We keep doing what the computers can do. This is what Morozov meant by instrumentalist bias. The technology systems there deliver instruction with fidelity, displacing teachers' autonomy

to effectively mediate the instruction and muting teachers' cognitive and social mentoring for the students. This is terrible. Okay? Displacing a higher -order language, it isn't just reading skills and writing skills. All right? Once you get past the decoding stage, you must be reading for meaning in order to advance your language development, because the advancement of language development is responsible for the advance of your symbolic reasoning. You're not born with

symbolic reasoning. You're born with the capacity for it. But the symbolic reasoning you master is what you encounter in your culture, just like the language that you develop is the language you encounter in your culture. And what is the first and most paramount symbol system that a young child must master? Language. And that's why the measures of these two things correlate so powerfully. But it's that symbolic reasoning that g -weights all of our standardized tests and makes them reliable. Otherwise, they wouldn't be valid as instrumental. for measurement, and

they may not be valid for what we really need, but they are reliable. And of course, we don't just use language and reason symbolically. We use language and reason symbolically about stuff, and the stuff about which we use language and reason symbolically becomes our prior knowledge, which is crucially important for language comprehension, which is crucially important for reading comprehension. So we're not just talking about simple reading and writing skills, the mechanics. We're talking about improved language reasoning and knowledge for communication learning and thought what is

required to be a member of a democratic polity rather than a serf okay I could go on you know me but I won't instead I'll just jump ahead here there's so many great things that you need to check in on including people from uh people whose political views you may not agree with but it's worth remembering now here's here's uh this is just for fun and then i gotta wrap it up i think right because i'm getting at the end of my time um every 30 years we switch in america between

didactic reading instruction and experiential reading instruction. For the past 30 years, we've been focused on didactic, as I'll show you. Experiential is sometimes called holistic, didactic is usually called scientific, but really they're both scientific and they're both. holistic. And there will always be didactic teachers. And that's fine. And there will always be experiential teachers. And that's fine. Or at least there should be. The problem is, when policy goes didactic, it tries to stamp out everything else. Experiential is more tolerant of the diversity. So in that way, it's got some

benefit. I take a comprehensive view myself. So I believe in both of those things. But there are multiple brands that come and go seven year, nine year cycles. But the didactic experiential goes through 30 years here and then 30 years there. The first didactic phase was, of course, you know, Puritan, Cal... Alvinist Sunday School being used as a model for inculcation in the schools for reading and writing. And then you had the Prussian model in the mid -19th century. But it becomes scientific with the scientific

industrial management wave from the 1890s to the 19Ts, factory model schools, standardization, workflow studies, and scripts. For teachers and so on and that doesn't go very well So what displaces it is progressive education thoughtful reading dick and Jane look and say, you know that that range from the 1920s to the 1950s then comes the second wave of scientific reading a Programmatic reading instruction. I went through this in the New York City public schools as a kid, right? It's basically based on BF Skinner's operant

conditioning theories right scale learning schedules and so forth phonics physiolingual notions of It's about sound making and hearing. New criticism, meanwhile, in the upper grades and the establishment of the Elementary Secondary Education Act as part of the cold wave battle with the Soviets so that we had to fund education and fund education research. So that was good for education colleges and researchers. But eventually we realized that

wasn't working either. Iowa tested basic skills in reading. down year over year over year from 1958 to 1972 and then it starts to climb again back to 1998 because by then we were doing something different collaborative project -based portfolios whole language balanced literacy. Then comes the third wave, and this is the one that we're in right now. It's in four acts. The first one is scientifically based reading, systematic phonics. Bush's reading first, for instance. Then comes close analytic reading. That's the Common Core

State Standards. Go look at the early English language arts standards. It's the five pillars of reading, right? Then comes structured literacy in the science of phonics, the dyslexia push, the urban district push. And then finally, as which I pointed out, was a disaster. And then finally, you get the science of reading. 43 out of 50 US states now have passed such legislation. Although the most recent stuff, like in California, isn't as bad as it first looks. And some people will say, that's science of reading in name only. Maybe so. So the question is, what comes next?

I think that if 30 years are up, It's time for us to switch back to the experiential view. So four scenarios. a rebranding or relabeling of the same old thing. And I think evidence -based is going to be what will come up. The reading league is using the term evidence -aligned. Evidence -powered is another one. Evidence -driven, that's interesting. There's a possibility of rebranding with serious modifications. But if the modifications are always going to require that the instruction

be reduced to low -level skills for comprehension, that isn't going to be as helpful. as it might be. Then there's the possibility, however, of getting more experiential and allowing 1 ,000 flowers to bloom AI. Again, I say might offer some opportunities there. I don't know. But I do worry about everybody doing their own thing because we need unity now. We don't all need to be doing the same thing. But we need to be unified in insisting that our voice is heard and that teachers' responsible autonomy be key.

I would love a paradigm shift. I would love a return to, and you'll see in the superscript, the decades when these particular terms were prevalent. The return of progressive, collaborative, activity -based, student -centered, teacher -directed, project -motivated, culturally relevant, sustaining, authentically engaging, portfolio -assessed, joyful, experiential language and literacy learning. You come up with a shorter term for it, okay? But the takeaways here are broaden the choice of phonics approaches that can be employed in

decoding instruction. Do not overteach phonics. Redesign early literacy curricula to include fluency practice with developmentally engaging text, language development activities, including discussion, writing. performance, for learning content, strategic reasoning for text comprehension and vocabulary, rely on individual student interests, needs, and emerging identities to guide instruction for motivation and engagement. Support and trust our teachers. No one knows better than the teachers do what the students in their classrooms need.

Beware of overusing assessments, averages, benchmarks, or silo labels, okay? You all know this, but here are the two hard truths. Big money is not going away. Equity funds now own the problem, but their resources could be used for good, and it is in their longer -term self -interest to do so. I think it's time we had a conversation. EduTech is not going away, but its use requires serious adjustments, and the amount needs dialing down at the present. Moving forward, get Big Tech finance to the table, and avoid the blame

game, okay? I know you're probably not comfortable with this. There's good reason. I think not to be. But we have to have a conversation. And I would be, you know, avoid commercial capture, but avoid political capture, too. And that includes of your own team jersey. OK. We need to get away from antagonistic binaries and look to pull together enough of a majority that we can actually enact a policy change. We have to get the right people involved. Us. OK, we have to acknowledge EdTech

limitations, miracles, or mirage, and EdTech has not been helpful for language development or comprehension. That's what the meta -analyses and syntheses demonstrate. Learn to love the problem, not the solutionary. Levine came up with this. He brought two apps to IPO, two billion. evaluation each he knows his money he knows his tech and he wrote this book with this title it's an old adage from uh engineering the problem is coming up with nifty solutions that don't do anything that anybody necessarily wants and boy oh boy are you guys tired of ai yet being

imposed and who asked for a summation of my my email thread with andy johnson i you know i i can read my own emails and i do have some memory left as old as i am you know all right and let us address the financial drain on schools, reduce the price use and continuous assessment, rededicate funding to student -centered teacher PD, not tech implementation. Because we need to start getting away from so much emphasis on teaching the program and get back to teaching the students.

We need to get away from relying on the technology and get back to relying on the teacher. because the teacher is the single most important variable in school for student reading achievement. Okay? And the quality of the professional development, the support that they receive. It's the teachers and teacher educators that make the difference. And do we do it for ourselves and our career advancement? No, we do it for our children. Hey, I don't have any kids. No, I mean all of our

children. Okay, societies, children, we all have a duty of care to do no harm for the kids or for the fellow adults while we're at it. So that's my two cents and a half. Thank you for letting me sound it out. It's much more than two cents, George. Let's take some questions. This was incredible. Incredible. If you have a question, you can unmute your mic and ask it directly, or raise your hand,

or you can put it in the chat. Andy, can I allow you to be the master of ceremonies here? Yes. OK. So you can throw me the questions. All right. So you can type it in the chat, and I'll be happy to send it to George. So everyone is thanking you. All right. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. I'm so glad you're here. Thank you. Thank you for the great work you do. I can't thank, you know, you need, you change

so many lives. You make things so much better for the world. And it's easy to get depressed, but don't. Change in the world one kid at a time. Yeah. 25 kids a year for 30 years. That's a lot of kids. It's a lot of kids. All right. Tell it to the secondary grade teachers. That's right. That's right. You're getting a lot of love there, George. Oh, I love getting love. All right. My

kids are all adults now, so I don't get that much love. If we move toward being frustrated with oligarchs, won't we start understanding these private companies will be dangerous too? I didn't read that well. Yeah, yeah. No, I get your discomfort and I share it. However, I don't see them going away. I mean, you know, a couple years ago when I was pointing this out, people thought I was nuts. You know that there were

you conspiracy theorists, you know, there's no see there's no secret cat Why would they you know, and I said I would tell them I said listen It's not just the you know, the the the programs they deliver to the classroom It's all the data that they vacuum back out again, you know without any informed consent without any permission slips from the parents You know these kids it's not just that their answers to the multiple choice questions It's the keystroke by keystroke pause by pause. I glance by I glance that you know, this is psychometric it's psychiatric data, it's

behavioral data. And people said, well, George, what would they want with that? And then out came chat GPT. Oh, so, and now they're talking about the tutors, private tutors for individuals. I think this would be wonderful if they could do it, but I think it's going to be a heavy lift in terms of the training data that would be required on an individual basis. A child isn't going to produce enough data for these systems, but in the future, they may be more efficient. Anyhow, the oligarchs are an issue, and I'm not happy

with that. And I think there needs to be a way to bring that in. But that's a political issue that I keep in a different bucket because, you know, I mean, I don't know if I should share this with you or not, because I don't want to turn anybody off. I'm a democratic socialist, OK? But when I went to the state legislature, as I did numerous weeks every darn year for 13 years, in Kentucky, a deep red state, it actually used to be a bipartisan state, and then it became

a deep red state while I was here. It wasn't my fault. But you've got to come across as being neutral. or you put people off their feed. And we aren't going to win any policy battles with a small minority. We aren't going to win any elections that way either. We have to start finding a consensus. on things that we can't agree on. And I think most Americans now are agreeing that the inequity of our economic system has gotten

way, way overly extreme. They feel it at the cash register, of course. They feel it when they look at their paychecks. And that's already reported in the news. I don't have to overemphasize that. The rich aren't happy about the idea of taxing billionaires and so on, of course. But that's a whole different set of arguments, and we can't be trying to hook that cart to our children's literacy instruction. It's not fair to them. You know, I mean, of course, education is political, but some things are more political than others.

And I think the most political thing is politics. So if you want to be a political activist, get, when I was younger, I was, you know, back in the 70s and 80s in Atlanta. You know now I'm Quite so much energy. So I leave it to the young but when it comes to advocating policy I wouldn't get let allow it to be captured by your own political preferences or anybody's political preferences. I try to keep it as Seemingly neutral as possible

the philosopher Richard Rorty had some interesting things to say about American education But I don't have time to share that but maybe some other day Next question. How many years to go until the 30 year shift begins? I think it's time right now right because if science for reading started in the mid 90s and it's now the mid 2020s That's 30 years times up So we're gonna and and you know these things change pretty pretty quickly you look at the shift, but you know in in 20

in 20 Sixteen, the philosopher Bertrand Russell wrote a piece for the Atlantic Monthly about education and the politics of education and the fact that education was political in nature. And he talked about how forlorn these didactic, authoritarian, rote, skill -drilling forms of instruction were in American public education classrooms. He had just sort of come over to

do some work here in the States, Harvard. And by golly, but by 2020, I mean by, excuse me, 1920, the professional uh the progressive education association was founded and its conference in the 20s 1920s would bring in over 25 000 teachers to attend every year so you know or more So, we can do that. We did it. And it turns on a

dime. It turns so fast. Unfortunately, it goes the other way, too. In the 1880s, 1870s, 1880s, there were neo -romantic approaches to teaching reading, which were very experiential. Colonel Francis Parker's Quincy method. And when the first state tests in Massachusetts were imposed, which were the first state to do statewide testing in the 1890s, they discovered that districts that use the Quincy method did better than other districts. So the very next year, the state legislature got together and passed a bill that prohibited

the Quincy method. Sound familiar? Three queuing method. So here's the next question. How do we get someone to publish something that explains all the errors in thinking? By the way, I have a book coming out this summer making sense of the science of reading. Context matters. So that's one. There you go. I think that, yeah, Andy, that's great. You need to do a webinar just on that book when it comes out so that we can all

celebrate it. You know, all of the errors are too many. I think priority of relevance is handy here to economize our efforts and to hit on the things that are most useful. I mean, bless academia. I'm so glad I'm not an academic anymore, you know, really. I mean, I'm coming in my 70s. I'm entitled to retire. You know that you come out with this crazy talk about kids can't read they're teaching kids to guess the words Do you mean using inference to understand what the word might

mean? You know that? It's just crazy talk and bless the hearts of the academics who took the time to explain why those statements were nonsense And it had no impact they kept making the same statements and eventually we got tired of trying to correct them Other people, you know, focused on what does the research actually say, what does it not say? They did technical meta -analyses and synthesis and wonderful reports. You know, the... Great, great critique on science of reading

has been done by a lot of people. You know, Helen Idarova in Wisconsin talking about the political groups that are behind it. Rachel Gabriel with the sort of religious fundamentalism that's behind it, you know, in the Moms for Liberty team and so on. Like that more in Ackerman in Alberta, you know her work on wrecked and on explaining the irrationality of the science of reading narrative Excellent work excellent work, but you know who reads that stuff We do you know that that's not

going to reach the general public and right now is the time to reach the public I mean the public is acting on their own. They are say we've had enough We suspect that the problem is this technology because we see what happens when the kids bring it home You know, I had two kids are going through the public school system here in little Lexington, Kentucky. And I saw the all the bringing home the Darren Chromebooks, bringing home the laptops, you know, and I remember when the when the booklet of worksheets disappear and I said, oh, no more worksheets, huh? No, dad, they're in the computer now. You know, oh, so anyway. Next question.

Yeah. Correcting all the problems is too much. Find a few that are going to sell to the general public. and not put people off their feet. Very good. Next question. By the way, ILAC has webinars recorded of the people that George just mentioned, Rachel and all those people. So do you have any advice for teacher -to -be students at a state university in Massachusetts? They're all in practicums with phonics packages. Yeah. Yeah. The battle

in, you know, next month Denny Taylor is going to present, and I know she was very active in communicating with the Massachusetts legislature. I know also Rob Tierney, dean at the University of British Columbia, wrote a letter to them as well. And you know but it's tough when when the science of reading people come in with their waving their checkbooks. You know that's the

carrot and the stick is if you don't get on it we're going to get our pack after you and destroy you politically. You know the big money they're ruthless they're aggressive right and. But it's not a good look for them and i think we have to have more people. know what's behind this. If you are a student who is looking to become a teacher, don't lose faith. Things are going to turn around. They're going to turn around in part because you're going to be there to help

make them turn around. So do the phonics packages. And let me say, when that tsunami floodwaters, when they recede as they are now, I promise you receding, a lot of crap is going to be left up on the beach. But some of it is worth saving. We don't want to become a cargo cult, but we should never think that phonics doesn't matter. We should never think that the coding skills don't matter. There's a lot that we can learn. It's a painful and expensive and wasteful way

to do it, but there's a lot that we have learned from the science of reading error. Or should I say error? So don't lose faith. Stick with it. And you're better off in Massachusetts than a lot of places. So here's a question. Can you find a new term for student -centered responsive ways of literacy teaching and intervention? I use meaning -based. That's one that I've been using. Yeah. Yeah. The only problem with Meaningbase

is, and I like Meaningbase too, Andy, but the problem I recognize with it is that it does challenge the fundamentalists who are afoot. They're fearful of reading for meaning because it might give kids ideas. I know it sounds like I'm trying to set out a caricature, but it's true. There are folks, because I've actually met folks like this and had discussions and tried to understand them. They're fearful of the word development,

because development suggests substantive change. Well, of course it does. You get an education, hopefully you're not going to continue to be a six -year -old, but they're afraid of that. It's like a pod people scenario for them. They're conservative by nature, so they don't believe in change. They believe in cycles that keep repeating themselves. Sadly to say, when it comes to education policy, they might be right. But if that's the case, then we're on our way to more experiential

work. I think we do need a good term for it, and it's one that won't be already freighted with concerns. I don't understand why you would be afraid to teach kids to read for meaning. And I think most sensible people, I think most moderate liberals, moderate centrists, and moderate conservatives would all agree that that's what reading is for. But we have this flood the zone kind of extremism that distracts and misinforms

and strikes toxic emotional states in its audience. And we just need to be sensible. We're talking about kids, and it's harmful. That stuff that's harmful for kids on their phones, it's harmful for all of us. And again, you're seeing that pushback from an adult perspective as well in the media. So I think we're going to have a reset on technology and make it a tool for us to use rather than a tool that uses us. All right, go

through a couple more here. The next on the list, could you talk through how early career researchers can protect their emerging careers as they investigate and research in this arena? Excellent question. Excellent question. I don't know where you are, but you may come to discover that most academics are fairly timid, and they know it. And they

compensate for that by speaking very bravely, but to a closed audience. And that's why they're so good at circular firing squads. And I think this is unfortunate. We need to get away from that. We have a lot of folks, let's just say a percentage of folks, who get into academia. Because they wish desperately to become members of the professional class That's that that that chunk between the super rich and the middle class,

you know like the top Second to top 9 % if you will, you know, there's the 1 % that owns 90 % of the wealth and then there's the 9 % of the professional class who like the house servants and When you become an academic, you find yourself in that strata, even though your earnings are really only putting you at the middle class level, but you pretend you have cultural capital and you're superior in your opinions. Well, about what you have a degree in and expertise, yes.

But that doesn't mean everything under the sun. So your opinions about other things are no more important, particularly to democracy, than the guy who collects the trash. And nothing wrong with collecting trash, either. That's a job that needs to be done. And I think that there's a lot of toxic attitude about that. You don't want to upset the money when it is funding things in your. university, obviously. So be very knowledgeable about what your other colleagues are doing research

and getting grants, especially. If you really want to fly in your career, it's not enough to publish. You've got to also get grants and then publish out of the grants. And grants are harder and harder to come by, particularly in the United States now. If you defy the The the power it's the beat And you are a pain in the side of normative social convention. You're in trouble So give up the being the pain on the side of the normative

social convention allow that just as a matter of politics And you do so anyway in your committee meetings. So stop stop kidding yourself And but stay firm in your opposition to people whose self -interest is intentionally or not and probably not arming children and harming our schools and harming our democracy as a result. All right. Let's go with one last question. And George has written an excellent article on this. How do we debunk their brain research? Well, you don't

do it by debunking science. And I want to say that the neuroscience, the neuroscience is, because they're plural, are Are very legitimate, but they aren't going to tell you about how to teach kids to read effectively Okay, nothing works for everyone. Nothing works for any one person in a good teacher hoist a heavy toolkit No one knows better about that than the teachers themselves. Okay So if you want to know about how to teach kids well in classrooms You have to look at the

research on teaching kids in classrooms research on the biology of the brain, the genetics of the brain, the proteomics, the systemics, is very fascinating stuff. I am particularly fascinated with life sciences. And most of the neurosciences are situated squarely in the neurosciences. Cognitive neuroscience is an outlier. And between cognitive neuroscience the way it's done at Harvard's mind, brain, and education program, and brain -based education on the other hand, there's been a lot of effort on behalf of grabbing the public's

imagination. which is a good way to get attention and media and grant funding. But it misrepresents, I mean, I've been a member of the Society for Neuroscience and it's not like, you know, AERA or LRA where you just send in a check and presto, you're a member. You got to be vetted. They look at, you got to get letters of recommendation from neuroscientists and so on. But I got in there and I was invited to panels and to present on this stuff. So my work has been, I think Vouch is pretty legitimate, OK? But it's the it's the

misrepresentation and and within the neurosciences neuroscientists themselves have noted that there is often over interpretation of the significance of findings and Particularly when you realize in cognitive neuroscience that over half of the studies are reporting false positives according to the neuroscientists themselves and that that's a problem. That's a problem in cognitive psychology and social psychology too. This is why the term psychology has been dropped by people who want

to claim that they're cognitive scientists. You know, psychology's got too much baggage. There are good there there are sources I wouldn't waste your time trying to debunk it and I know how frustrating it is You've got somebody from IT or from administration who say we got to worry about learning styles and all the research evidence shows That teaching kids learning styles has no impact on their learning it makes you feel good maybe and that's all right but it really

isn't helpful and you know you could devote time better spent to understanding that kids need a diverse range of instructional methods and that they're not mutually exclusive and you don't need to take on a team jersey and say you know that our side versus that side of what's the best way to teach reading that's just the wrong way to think. The life is far, far too complex. And even the most complex models of reading development and reading differences are so crudely simplistic

and reductive. They're not worthless. Even the simple view of reading is not worthless if you're communicating to legislators and journalists. It's just complex enough for them to understand and seem intriguing, but you have to make sure you don't misrepresent it. Okay, but it's far too simplistic for those of us who do legitimate research. Am I off topic there? I hope that addresses everything is on on topic George when you're around everything's on top All right. Well, let's

leave it there with the idea that Denny Taylor's coming on May 7th And her stuff is just as good as George. So better Oh, she's incredible. So I would invite you, I'll be sending you all the information and I'll be sending you a recording of this. So thank you, George, Dr. Ruby for an incredible evening again. Thank you. And I look forward to seeing you all next month. Excellent. Thank you, George.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Importance of Context and the Science of Reading

    Nov 4, 202625 minAudio

    The Science of Reading seems to refer to a general consensus related to the strategies and practices that lead to improved reading outcomes. These strategies and practices have been determined to be effective using...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Structured Literacy: Forward to the Past

    Nov 2, 202629 minAudio

    Using Blanche DuBois’s tragic reliance on the "kindness of strangers" as a central metaphor, this article critiques the recurring cycle of corporate-driven reading mandates and the reduction of literacy instruction to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Conversation with Kathy Brown, Master Educator

    Oct 6, 202633 minAudio

    If you’re looking for accessible, research-based information that slices through the endless loads of overly worded baloney, I would encourage you to subscribe to my free Substack, The Reading Instruction Show....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Reading Instruction, Word Confirmation, and Confirmation Bias

    Sep 19, 202615 minAudio

    Purpose statement: The reader will become more effective in evaluating online sources related to reading instruction. Behavioral objective: Readers will be able to identify instances in which confirmation bias results...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Quiet, Piggy: A Trumpian Response to Science of Reading Critics

    Aug 14, 202612 minAudio

    If you’re looking for accessible, research-based information that slices through the endless loads of overly worded baloney, I would encourage you to subscribe to my free Substack, The Reading Instruction Show....

    Credit the people on this episode