Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Reading Instruction Show

The Reading Instruction Show artwork

The National Reading Panel: Phonics and Word Work

Feb 11, 202638 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Research-based strategies to addres phonics and word work.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Greetings, this is Andy Johnson, The Reading Instruction Show. This is part two of my five -part series looking at the five core elements of the National Reading Panel Report. It says five there instead of two because this is part of a larger conference presentation. So phonics instruction, phonemic awareness, phonics, vocabulary, comprehension, fluency, the big five, the core five. So we're looking at phonics instruction

and word work. Phonics, well, you'll see why. Reading is creating meeting with print. It's not simply sounding out words. As we read, there is 10 times more information flowing from the cortex down to the thalamus, that little relay system in the middle of your brain, than from the page and the thalamus up. That means we're using what's in our head to create meaning with

print. It's not just sounding out words and listening to the sounds in your head as the simple view of reading would have you believe. And there are three interacting systems, phonological, syntactical, and semantic systems. They are interacting and interdependent. They all work together. Three -queuing is not something you teach, it's just an understanding that we use multiple sources

of information when we're recognizing words. Word recognition is the ability to automatically recognize a word during reading. Word identification, which we will cover, it's in your lexicon, the mental dictionary in your head. You don't recognize it, so you must consciously apply some strategy. And in a really, real comprehensive reading program, we have activities to develop all three cueing

systems. That does not mean we ignore direct and explicit and systematic phonics instruction. Here are some activities. Phonics, letter sounds, letter patterns, direct instruction, word sorts, that sort of thing. Semantics, we use close and maze activities, and you can still reinforce phonics using that. And the same with sentence. A lot of writing, a lot of sentence anagram. Not something mysterious. And again, three -queuing is not a strategy. We teach. It's not an approach.

It's not a method. We don't teach three -queuing systems. We develop. And I have plenty of research to support this. You can go to my sub stack. My book, Making Sense of the Science of Reading, will be coming out this summer sometime. What 3Qing is not? It's not a strategy to teach. It doesn't exclude phonics. It doesn't encourage children to use picture clues to figure out words. And I laugh because some of these are so silly, but it's so sad because this is some of the garbage

that people are talking about. It's not an approach. It's not a method of decoding print. It doesn't exclude direct, explicit, and systematic files. What it is is simply understanding that the brain uses multiple sources of information when creating meaning with print. So it's using and developing what the brain naturally does. It's not that mysterious. And our brain does three things. It looks for patterns and fills in the blank.

That's gestalt, tries to make sense of stuff, and it makes predictions and inferences based on partial data. Gestalt, looks for patterns, fills in the blanks. You see that and you go, what? You're making sense of it and you may see a saber -toothed tiger or some sort of cat and maybe a hippopotamus and, all right, your brain is looking for familiar things to create meaning. Tries to make sense. You see a chalice or you see two faces looking at each other. You see

a young woman looking away, chin at nose eyes, or an old woman looking down, mouth, chin, nose. your brain creates meaning it fills in the blanks this is three pac -man heads but really you see a triangle blobs and you see kind of a groucho march character blobs but you see a dog a guy playing sax or a guy wearing a tambourine i think it is three systems to cue the brain is as to

what the word is during the act of creating meaning. And if you're looking at this PowerPoint, looking at the words, you're doing it right there. When you see the word systems, you do not sound out s -s -t -m -s. You don't do that. You're using multiple sources of information. And these act together, not singular. So if you're just teaching phonics and you're ignoring these two, you're giving your students one -third of a word recognition

education. And again, they don't work independently. They work together. Think about it. We don't encounter single words floating in space. Words are always found in the context of a sentence, a sign, or a product of some sort. The only time you see words in isolation is on a dibbles test, and they don't make sense. If reading was simply identifying random words we encountered, well

then just focusing on phonics would make lots of sense, but it doesn't, and it doesn't. So, phonics instruction. Everybody believes in phonics instruction. It's not the how, it's the how much of phonics in which there are differing views. But everybody believes that you have to teach letter -sound associations. Now here's the thing, phonics instruction has been shown to be more effective in raising scores on measures of phonics

than no phonics instruction. And the clown says, oh, this proves it. This proves that all students need lots of phonics instruction. And that's the type of research that's used to support these science of reading mandates. However, that is wrong. It doesn't mean that all students need heavy doses of phonics, that students will be better readers if they get more phonics. There's no research to support that. That phonics is

the key variable in learning to read. that anything other than phonics should be excluded, that phonics should be taught at all ages and levels, and that phonics skills transfer to authentic reading situation. And a skills -based program emphasizing phonics is more effective than a meaning -based program. And it does not mean that all students need phonics instruction. and that phonics instruction

is sufficient. Here's the thing. What works for a student in Blackwater, Arizona struggling with word recognition doesn't necessarily work for a fifth grade student struggling with reading, but struggling with comprehension in Edina, Minnesota. Just because something works for one population for a certain purpose, does not mean that all struggling readers need something, and that's

the mistake of these standardized programs like Orton Gillian Ham and Wilson Reading and some of these other boondoggles. Now, some claim that the National Reading Panel provides irrefutable evidence that phonics should be the center of all reading instruction. It's irrefutable! Well, people that say those things haven't actually read the National Reading Panel report. This is what it says. Systematic phonics is more effective

in helping students read single words out of context and nonsense words, pseudo words, than unsystematic phonics or non -phonics. Something is always better than nothing, but this is just reading single words and pseudo words. That's not reading. We always encounter words in the context of a sentence, a sign, or a product. But this is what the National Reading Panel Report actually said. Wait for it. Wait for it. Boom

goes the dynamite. Impact on comprehension is limited. Contributes only weekly, if at all, in helping poor readers. apply these skills to read actual texts. And what good is a skill if we can't apply it and use it to read? Insufficient data to draw any conclusions about the effects of phonics instruction with normally developing readers above first grade. Sound that out very

carefully for you phonics fanatics. Normally developing and Phonics instruction fails to exert a statistically significant impact on poor readers in second through sixth grade. This isn't me saying it, it's the National Reading Panel. If this is to be your holy book, you must read the holy book, because that's what it says. And what do we do with struggling readers? We give them a whole bunch more phonics. And if phonics doesn't work, we give them more phonics, so it cannot

work to an even greater degree. It doesn't make sense, does it? Now the National Reading Panel, not me, said there are, they identified six ways of teaching phonics and they also said each is equally effective. Equal means the same. Synthetic phonics, that's what we normally think, putting letters and sounds together to create words. Analytic phonics, analyzing the words children

already know, they see. Here's the word run. What's the last sound in run? Find the word that has v in the middle. Analytic phonics. Embedded phonics in the structure of what, context of what they're reading. If you're doing guided reading or shared reading or language experience approach. Or if you're using treasure hunts, they've read a book and then you create a data retrieval chart and you say, find the short a

words you and a friend. Large unit phonics, teaching the most common phonograms or word families or prefix, suffix, and roots and using those to identify words. Onset rhyme, word building, yes, onset beginning sound. Rhyme is the word family. Cap is cap, that's onset rhyme. Some teachers use Scrabble letters for this so children can

manipulate in the early grades. Phonics through spelling, dictated sentences, and we'll look at that later. Spelling practice and. temporary spelling, invented spelling. People get worked up about the word invented, so temporary spelling. Use a couple letters to hold the idea. We'll come back and edit later, you say. We teach the child, not the program. So we need a little of

each. Use what works. And here is a good teacher being what Yetta Goodman calls a kid watcher. At all levels, reading instruction should include authentic writing. Authentic is not your cute story starter or prompt. It's children describing their ideas or their writing about their experiences. Writing is multimodal. Get some working. It reinforces

letter sound patterns, and writing is the best way to develop syntactic knowledge. That's grammar and word order. How can you develop literacy by ignoring half of literacy? And writing is an essential part of literacy. And again, daily, need not be long, two to five minutes, and then share with a friend. Get responses. And again, authentic writing. write their ideas and experiences.

And I love this picture. You see the little guy there laughing as he's thinking about what he's going to write. Love that picture. All right. Here's a strategy. Simple strategy. Dictated sentences for spelling and word identification. You design one to six short sentences. Use the sentences to reinforce a target letter sound or a spelling pattern or a sight word and then create sentences with meaningful connections.

I always like to have sentences about students' lives or maybe a book that you're reading as a class. Instead, you dictate sentences to students one at a time. Eventually, you can do this in pairs and small groups as well as large group. The students write that sentence without worrying about spelling. Just say, give it your best shot, and you skip a line between sentences because after each sentence, you say, all right, look

for words that don't look right. Are there any words that don't look right? And if they're working with a partner, they can do this with their partner. They identify words that don't look right. Then you show the complete sentence on a screen or a poster and students don't erase. They simply draw a line through the incorrect word and write the correct spelling on top. So the students see both the incorrect and the correct. And when

all is finished, they reread the sentences. until fluency is achieved. For example, this is one, the dog is a stray. I'm reinforcing the ay. Do that. See the sentence. Line, right. Second, third. And then afterwards, we would reread until fluency is achieved. So here I am reinforcing grammar and word order. reinforcing the ay phonogram

and fluency by rereading until fluency is achieved. Word sorts, a powerful learning strategy, a form of inductive analysis to reinforce letter patterns and word parts. and it's part of large unit phonics. You give them a series of words with young children. I like to have them written on cards so they can manipulate. And they look at the group, and

ideally this is done with two or three students, and they organize them in groups related to vowel sounds or letters. Sometimes I have the same sound with different letter patterns. These are all long A spellings. or semantic groups. And that's where this strays into vocabulary. This is a powerful form of learning, inductive analysis. James Bruner described this as part of discovery

learning. Here it is with older students. Shared reading for phonics. You start step one, shared reading. You read the book aloud to students. or with students. This is for primary age. Students then read independently with a buddy, buddy reading every other. Then students identify interesting or important words that they found. So they're choosing words from the context of a book. Teacher

collects their words, writes on three by five cards, and the next day students use these cards to create groups. This could be based on letter sounds, patterns, or meanings. And it's nice to have word walls. If these words are taken from a book, the classroom becomes the book with these word walls. And you can do writing prompts and bingo and scrabble. For older students, We'd do it. We'd adopt and adapt. Read a book using

shared reading or close reading. With a partner, they would choose five to eight words, collect them all, and then students used to create groups. Adopt and adapt. This is powerful. Replay analysis. Adopted from Yetta Goodman's retrospective MISCU analysis. Students given three to six sentences on a sheet of paper, they read the sentences into an audio recorder, then they listen. With a buddy, the student underlines the trouble words

or the stumble words, then they go back and they reread until fluency is achieved. Usually, two no more than three times is taken for this. Here's an example, and I'm reinforcing again the AY phonogram. Which word looks right? English's language is not consistent. Too many aberrations.

Give them a set of words, letter patterns, and One of the words doesn't look right. You know, neat, neat, neat, neat, neat. These are all letter patterns used to create the long E sound. And these are short three to eight minutes a day. Three to eight minutes a day. I will ride my bike. Which word looks right? It gets them looking at and noticing letter patterns. It's all about

the patterns. It's all about the patterns. No single activity, but all of them. Usually when I'm tutoring a kid, it's usually 30 minutes, four to six minutes an activity, pause and process, four to six to the next, four to six to the next, a series of short activities. No single strategy works best, learning. occurs over time. No single

strategy should be your only strategy. Here are some ideas for semantics. That means using context to recognize words, not identify, but recognize. Close is a sentence with one word missing. Maze is a sentence with either two or three words choices. and story close our maze is using close our maze to create a story again six to ten minutes

you can create a pre -reading maze pre -reading activities are designed to get students ready to read the story and this develops semantic queuing this is the first grade book related to bees it's called bees to honey bees to honey reading level one bees make blank and you help them. Sometimes you have to sound out the words for the younger readers. Bees make honey help. Which one fits? And then they see the correct

one. Bees live blank a beehive. What word makes sense here? Bees blank fly. Then they see the complete paragraph or sentences, and they reread until fluency is achieved, this then should get them ready to read the book independently. That's what a pre -reading scaffold does. Analytic phonics. Show them the sentences. Teacher might ask, find

the word with the v sound in the middle. That's analytic phonics. Sentence mix -up for comprehension and syntax. Cut the sentences into individual words. Mix up each sentence and students have to put them back in order again. Close. I had a b - dream. The answer should be abundantly

obvious with these. We're not trying to trick students, we're trying to develop what their brain does naturally. And when we read, our eyes don't go like this. Our eyes go like this. So I say, I ask them, say blank and finish the sentence. I had a blank dream. And see if you can figure it out. Sometimes I say, look on both sides for clues. I had a blank dream. I had a bad dream. Yes. Had a bad dream. What did you say? Yes.

Now some of you phonics, penguins are freaking out here. Here's the thing, I had a student third grade struggling reader working with her online and she would come to a word she didn't understand and she would stop and sound out every single letter and it would take her about 10 seconds and then she would guess dinosaur and I say yes dinosaur and she'd keep going on. So I tried a strategy. I said, well, just say blank and

continue reading on. I said, try that once or twice. So she would do that. And in two seconds, she'd go back and she knew what the word was. Ten seconds versus two seconds. This does not mean that I do not teach phonics. I'm simply giving another strategy. I'm developing what the brain does best. And she said, Dr. A, that's what she called me. Your magic, the words just pop into my head, she said. May's same thing.

He had a blank day at school. This invites them to look carefully at the letter patterns. It's all about the patterns. I liked using May's mini stories. This is about a six to eight sentence story. The first sentence is complete, followed by May's sentences. Come back here, blank yell, and you can do this together or in large group. This is one short activity. And then at the end,

you see the complete story, short story, little paragraph, and you reread, tell, fluency is achieved. And if you want to do, you can use this for analytic phonics, analytic phonics. There's a long a word in this sentence. See if you can find it. Syntax, which has to do with grammar and word order, and these all involve writing. These can be used as pre or post reading activities used to reinforce

phonograms, sounds, sight words, done orally or in writing. Group edits. You put a sentence on the board with edits, with errors, grammar, word order, punctuation, and in large groups students are asked to come up one at a time and make a correction. And here's where you have the little mini lesson. And these sentences should be about student's lives, what they're experiencing, or maybe what they're reading about. You want

to make reading connections to the greatest extent possible. Did you see them big dog outside? You get the idea. Sentence combining. This has a strong research base for grammar. Jill is strong. Jill is a soccer player. Jill is a strong soccer player. They must combine the two sentences while retaining the initial meaning of both. And here I'm reinforcing the short I sound or the I -L

-L phonogram. Sentence combining, sentence mix -up, sometimes called sentence anagrams. And this develops an important thing called metacognition. Does it make sense? Online, I can't have them rearrange letter cards or word cards, so I show them a mixed up sentence and say, tell me when you think you know what this sentence is. Ran away the cat, and it's usually right about here,

they know. These are short, three to six minutes, and I can reinforce a letter sound if I get all worked up. I like students doing this in groups. You can cut a sentence into three by five words, keep them in an envelope for use later on, and they rearrange the sentences. If I'm reading Winnie the Pooh, I have a whole bunch of Winnie the Pooh sentence mix -up things in an envelope, and I can get them out and use them from year to year. write the sentences in first grade and

kindergarten in front of students, cut them up, and then mix them up and create order. Sentence mix -up or sentence anagram. And the level of support you give, of course, is related to the students. Sometimes with some very low -functioning students, I show them the complete sentence. Sometimes I keep the complete sentence up there. Cookie sentences. Here are three sentences. Only one of them makes sense. See if you can find

the one that makes sense. And again, develops metacognition. Does this make sense? That's an important cognitive skill to have for beginning readers. Does this make sense? Sentence alteration. This is for older students. Give them a sentence and see if they can say the same thing using different words. This is a fun activity. This can be used to reinforce vocabulary or letter

sounds. What you want to do is stop correcting oral reading mistakes. I know there's a tendency when a kid is reading out loud to jump in there or to say, sound it out, and if the kid could sound it out he wouldn't have stopped or she wouldn't have stopped. So if you jump in there the student becomes reliant on you and the student doesn't develop the ability to ask what makes sense here. So be patient, stop jumping in, stop

telling them to sound it out. Now here's the thing. A buzzword is a word used to elicit an emotional response instead of transmitting information. And academic buzzwords are buzzwords used in education, and they create the illusion of something important. But they are buzzwords. And take a look at these. These are common academic buzzwords. And if you want to have some fun, go to a reading

league meeting, have this list of words, and ask, give, give, put them on a sheet of paper and ask every participant to write a definition of the words and then see if their definitions match. Evidence -based. Well, there's evidence and it's based on it. Oftentimes these are buzzwords just used to create the illusion of something important. Oh, we are evidence -based. We use direct and explicit instruction. Okay. Okay.

Systematic simply means a general plan, not a rigid adherence or pre -described order. It is not a specific set of skills taught in a predetermined order and in a specific way. That would be absolutely silly because students are not standardized products. Instead, you document when you teach a skill and when students have mastered a skill. Something simple like this. Document, put the date when

you teach it, and you could have one of these for every student, the date when they mastered it. Here are sight words. This would be, again, kindergarten, first grade, and phonograms. Keep it simple. And I ask unto you, is there research evidence to demonstrate that teaching a whole bunch of reading subskills in a specific order is more effective than teaching some skills in

a general order? There is not. And the onus is not on me to disprove a negative. The onus is on those who are making the claim that this is research -based to demonstrate some research to support that teaching all these subskills in this order is more effective than a general set of skills as needed. Direct and explicit instruction is another one of those buzzwords.

Everybody believes in direct and explicit instruction. Everybody agrees with this. I'm the holiest of whole language practitioners. I believe in direct, explicit, and systematic instruction. It is a strategy, a pedagogical strategy that should be in every teacher's toolbox. It's not a method. It's not an approach. It simply consists of the

elements of effective skills instruction. This is what direct instruction is. It has a purpose to teach a letter and a sound the input. This is the letter A. It makes this sound, ah. That's the short sound. Here are some examples. C -at -a -ple -ant -m -at. Guided practice with scaffolding. You do a few together, a few with a partner, gradual release of teacher responsibility, and

then a few by yourself, and I can see who's got it. And then independent practice of what has just been learned. And you learn nothing with a single encounter, so you review and revisit several times. Direct instruction is very effective in teaching low -level skills. Everyone agrees with that. So let's define our terms. Direct

instruction is a pedagogical strategy that includes purpose, input, guided practice, independent practice. These are the elements of effective skills instruction. Explicit, clearly defining what you're teaching and teaching it. Who doesn't believe in this? You want implicit instruction, implied instruction, vague instruction. Everybody agrees that explicit instruction is important.

And systematic, simply a system in place to document what skills are taught, when they're taught, and when students have mastered the skill. This does not mean you need to use a commercial program. This is all related to phonics. A balanced approach to literacy includes direct, systematic, and explicit phonics instruction. Balanced literacy is not an approach. It's not a singular approach.

It simply says there's a balance between teaching skills and practicing them in authentic context. And with every class and every student, there's a continual. Some need more of this and less of that. Some need more of that and less of that. It varies on the students. It looks a little different in every teacher's classroom. Teachers aren't standardized products and neither are their students. So what does the National Reading

Panel say? about direct instruction. Students need to apply their skills in daily reading and writing activities. If you focus too much on phonics, with little time spent practicing, that instruction is likely to be ineffective. Ooh, they actually use the term balanced reading program. Hmm. Systematic phonics integrated with other reading. That's on page 2 -97. You can look it

up. They said balanced. Phonics should not become the dominant component in a reading program, neither in the amount of time devoted to it nor the significance attached. And again, 2 -97. Balanced. Balance. And word identification. different from recognition. You see the word in print, it's in your lexicon, but you don't recognize it, so you must consciously apply a strategy.

Hmm, I don't recognize you. I think I will apply this strategy. And there are four of these, and we teach the strategies explicitly, directly, and systematically. to develop the skill, meaning that so we don't think about them as we're doing that. We do it automatically. We use direct and explicit instruction. Here's how you teach analogy. Step one, read the sentence and say blank for

the target. Look for word parts you recognize. Use word parts to experiment, make a guess, reread to see if your guess makes sense. One group said, you should change the word to experiment instead of make a guess, because some science of reading people freak out with the term make a guess, not realizing that even with explicit phonics, students experiment or make a guess. Dinosaur,

they say. They see if it makes sense. Experiment. Morphemic analysis. Here are the steps. Say blank for the target. Look for prefixes, suffixes, and words you recognize. Use them to experiment. Reread to see if your experiment makes sense. Context clues, say blank. Look for clues on both sides. Experiment. Reread to see if your experiment

makes sense. And phonics. Oh, look at, I'm experimenting again. Say blank for the target. Use letter clues to sound it out. Experiment. Reread to see if your experiment makes sense. All right, that has been phonics and word identification.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Importance of Context and the Science of Reading

    Nov 4, 202625 minAudio

    The Science of Reading seems to refer to a general consensus related to the strategies and practices that lead to improved reading outcomes. These strategies and practices have been determined to be effective using...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Structured Literacy: Forward to the Past

    Nov 2, 202629 minAudio

    Using Blanche DuBois’s tragic reliance on the "kindness of strangers" as a central metaphor, this article critiques the recurring cycle of corporate-driven reading mandates and the reduction of literacy instruction to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Conversation with Kathy Brown, Master Educator

    Oct 6, 202633 minAudio

    If you’re looking for accessible, research-based information that slices through the endless loads of overly worded baloney, I would encourage you to subscribe to my free Substack, The Reading Instruction Show....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Reading Instruction, Word Confirmation, and Confirmation Bias

    Sep 19, 202615 minAudio

    Purpose statement: The reader will become more effective in evaluating online sources related to reading instruction. Behavioral objective: Readers will be able to identify instances in which confirmation bias results...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Quiet, Piggy: A Trumpian Response to Science of Reading Critics

    Aug 14, 202612 minAudio

    If you’re looking for accessible, research-based information that slices through the endless loads of overly worded baloney, I would encourage you to subscribe to my free Substack, The Reading Instruction Show....

    Credit the people on this episode