Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Reading Instruction Show

The Reading Instruction Show artwork

Orton-Gillingham: Behind the Pretty Words

May 6, 202518 minAudio

The problem with Orton-Gillingham and similar for-profit products (Lindamood, Wilson Language Training, Barton System, etc.) is that they try to reduce teaching to an algorithm. An algorithm is a formula for solving problems in which you follow a step-by-step set of procedures (with fidelity) to achieve a specific outcome. In other words, by correctly following a prescribed set of steps in the specified order, you will be led to a predefined solution. Algorithms are useful in mathematics and computer science for calculation, data processing, and automatic reasoning. For teaching of any kind? Not so much. However, Orton-Gillingham would have you believe that if the teaching algorithm is followed explicitly, the teacher can be assured that students will learn to read. And if the algorithm does not work, you run them through the algorithm again … and again … and again. What these algorithmic programs offer is a false sense of certainty. Despite all the certainty thrown about, research to support the long-term effectiveness of these “direct, explicit, multi-sensory, structured, sequential, diagnostic, and prescriptive” instruction, it is simply not evident (Compton, et. al., 2014).

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Greetings, this is The Reading Instruction Show. As always, I am your host, Dr. Andy Johnson. The title of today's podcast is called Orton Gillingham, full colon, Behind the Pretty Words. So let's see if we can learn something today. Unpacking Orton Gillingham. Orton Gillingham is an approach to teaching reading that is, quote, multisensory, sequential, incremental, cumulative,

individualized, phonics -based, and explicit, so said Ripple 2020. A recent article in the Reading League Journal said that, quote, many of the defining features of OG approach are supported by extensive scientific research, including direct and explicit instruction with scaffolding, structured and sequential instruction, and diagnostic and prescriptive instruction, Austrian et al 2024.

Also, the Orton -Gillingham website described the approach as, quote, direct, explicit, multi -century, structured, sequential, diagnostic, and prescriptive. Now if the number of superlative adjectives used to describe a thing determine its effectiveness, then by all means Orton Gillingham would be very effective. But what exactly do

all these pretty, pretty words mean? Let's do a little unpacker right in here. Direct instruction. Yes, direct and explicit instruction is supported by extensive scientific research. Absolutely. Everybody in the world knows that. They would agree that direct instruction is an important part of reading instruction. Old language teachers

use direct instruction. Balanced literacy teachers use direct instruction. And I'm sure if penguins could be trained to teach reading, they too would use direct instruction. Direct instruction is a pedagogical strategy consisting of a, explicit input, b, modeling or demonstration, c, guided practice with a gradual release of responsibility called scaffolding, and d, independent practice.

Direct instruction. is an effective teaching strategy for the initial learning of any kind, absolutely. But it's a strategy that every teacher should have in their teaching toolbox. It's basic teaching 101. It has never been a question of if direct instruction should be used in early reading instruction. It's always been a question

of how or how much direct instruction should be used. For the science of reading people, it's always been much. For balanced literacy practitioners, it's always been as much as needed. Scaffolding. Educational scaffolding is any kind of support used with initial learning. This initial support is followed by a gradual release of teacher responsibility

as students become more adept with what's being learned. Scaffolding is a part of guided practice used in direct instruction. However, it's also used to provide support with any type of learning. Everybody believes that scaffolding is an important thing. This is not something new or unique. This is not something that needs extensive scientific

research to determine its effectiveness. Again, basic teaching 101. What about structured and sequential instruction? Well, according to the International Dyslexia Association, structured instruction for reading includes these six elements, phonology, sound symbol association, syllable instruction, morphology, syntax, and semantics.

Again, you'd get little argument from anyone in the field of literacy that these elements should not be part of initial reading instruction. But what's interesting here is that each of the three queuing systems are used here. Hmm. Hmm. Does the International Dyslexia Association support the three queuing systems? Hmm. Perhaps there's hope for this organization. And why am I dragging

the International Dyslexia Association into the mix here? It's because of their strong link to Orton Gillingham. This organization was originally called the Orton Society. In 1982, it changed its name to the Orton Dyslexia Society. And in 1997, it changed its name to the International Dyslexia Association. IDA. But more importantly,

in 2014, they were the ones who came up with the term structured literacy, from which structured instruction is derived. And the quiet part was said out loud when they stated the purpose of the term was to, quote, unify and sell what we do, unquote. It's all about marketing, you see. Now, according to the IDA, structured instruction

is, quote, systematic and cumulative. Now let's pause a minute to look at the accumulation of all the important sounding words used so far. Structured, systematic, scientific, diagnostic, prescriptive, direct. explicit, extensive, sequential, cumulative, logical order. How could anybody

be against these things? But what exactly do they mean? Now if you want to have a good time, ask your Science of Reading friends or your IDA and Orton Gillingham friends. to define these 11 terms and then record their responses. You'll notice quite a bit of variation in the responses as well as a lot of squirming. The IDA says,

quote, systematic means that the organization of material follows the logical order of the language. More words thrown about. What is the logical order of language. Is there an illogical order? According to the IDA, the logical order, quote, must begin with the easiest and most basic concepts and progress methodically to more difficult

concepts and elements, unquote. To which I say, brilliant! But again, this is Basic Teaching 101. Good teachers, always start with easy or simple things and progress to more difficult or complex things as students are ready. However, what's easiest and most basic in reading is based on one's experience with language. Reading things

that make sense and using words and concepts from children's experience is much easier. than decoding lists of words and nonsense words in isolation, and reading decodable books with artificial sentences like nan and pap sat on a pan. Cumulative means that each new thing builds on the last thing, and again, basic teaching 101. Good teachers

always make connections to or build upon previous learning. This is basic constructivist learning theory. This also reflects Bruner's learning theory that calls for skills and concepts to be taught in their simplest form first to become a platform for more complex skills and concepts later on. But what about sequential instruction?

What's the sequence? And who decided that the sequence was to be a sequence? Hence, you get things like a scope and sequence chart. Now these can be useful in providing a general sense of the kinds of things you might teach early on, as well as the types of letter patterns you might ask students to notice, However, scope and sequence

charts are not reliable enough to be used in a prescriptive fashion. They should never become the roadmap to instruction. However, the giant I -thinkism behind structured instruction is that if children just put all the teeny tiny parts of a scope and sequence chart together in a logical order, they'll be able to read.

And that's just playing cookie talk. Alright, diagnostic and prescriptive instruction. An effective diagnosis of any kind first determines if there is a problem and then identifies the cause of the problem. According to the IDA, International Dyslexia Association, diagnostic and prescriptive instruction uses, quote, careful and continuous

assessment that is both formal and informal, unquote. Everybody agrees that careful and continuous assessment is important. Nobody wants careless and discontinuous assessment. However, a proper diagnosis of reading occurs apart from instruction and focuses on three deficit areas, word recognition, fluency, and comprehension. And I have yet to

find a more effective diagnostic instrument than a diagnostic reading assessment sometimes called an informal reading inventory. But diagnostic instruction uses assessments within the context of instruction. The proper term for this is progress monitoring. Effective reading instruction of any kind has always included pragmatic measures

to use for progress monitoring. Prescriptive instruction is an instructional plan based on the diagnosis. Now struggling readers are not all the same. Each has different strength and deficit areas. Since each deficit area is addressed differently, the instruction prescribed for each student should be different. This points to the

importance of a valid diagnostic measure specifically addressing the three deficit areas, word recognition, fluency, and or comprehension. Now this is much different from the one -size -fits -all instruction used in Orton -Gillingham and other reading products. Here the same reading subskills are prescribed in the same order in the same way. High -ability readers go a little faster and are a little ahead.

Struggling readers go a little slower and are a little behind. But the same prescription is used with everybody. This instruction could hardly be said to be prescriptive. And multi -sensory. Ah! Multisensory instruction is said to be the magic ingredient in Orton -Gillingham. Multisensory!

This simply means visual, auditory, and kinesthetic modalities are used when teaching. In other words, as children are learning, they see things, they hear things, and they do things. This is nothing new or magical. It's not unique to Orton -Gillingham. It's called multimodal instruction, and elementary teachers have been using various forms of it

for decades. So the research, what about the research that, quote, proves, unquote, the effectiveness of Orton -Gillingham? Well, despite the claims of being heavily research -based, it's simply not. The research used to support the use of Orton Gillingham often measures students' progress using pseudo -reading or non -reading tasks.

It uses measures of questionable validity. It does not use comparison groups. It's derived from unpublished master's or doctoral theses. Is a study put out by organizations that have a vested interest in certain outcomes or makes claims of superiority without controlling for covariates such as gender, socioeconomic status, ethnicity, verbal IQ, or initial reading skills?

The problem with Orton Gillingham and similar for -profit products, Lindemude, Whilson, Language Training, Barton Systems, etc., is that they try to reduce teaching to an algorithm. An algorithm is a formula for solving problems in which you follow a step -by -step set of procedures with fidelity, to achieve a specific outcome. In other

words, by correctly following a prescribed set of steps in a specific order, you will be led to a predetermined solution. Algorithms are useful in mathematics and computer science for calculation, data processing, and automatic reasoning. But for teaching, not so much. However, Orton Gillingham would have you believe that if the teaching algorithm

is followed explicitly, the teacher can be assured that students will learn to read. And if the algorithm doesn't work, you run them through the algorithm again and again and again. What these algorithmic programs offer is a false sense of certainty. Despite Despite all the important sounding words thrown about about the long -term

effectiveness of these direct, explicit, multi -sensory, structured, sequential, diagnostic, and prescriptive instructional products, their effectiveness is simply not evident. This has been The Reading Instruction Show. I'm your host, Dr. Andy Johnson.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Importance of Context and the Science of Reading

    Nov 4, 202625 minAudio

    The Science of Reading seems to refer to a general consensus related to the strategies and practices that lead to improved reading outcomes. These strategies and practices have been determined to be effective using...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Structured Literacy: Forward to the Past

    Nov 2, 202629 minAudio

    Using Blanche DuBois’s tragic reliance on the "kindness of strangers" as a central metaphor, this article critiques the recurring cycle of corporate-driven reading mandates and the reduction of literacy instruction to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Conversation with Kathy Brown, Master Educator

    Oct 6, 202633 minAudio

    If you’re looking for accessible, research-based information that slices through the endless loads of overly worded baloney, I would encourage you to subscribe to my free Substack, The Reading Instruction Show....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Reading Instruction, Word Confirmation, and Confirmation Bias

    Sep 19, 202615 minAudio

    Purpose statement: The reader will become more effective in evaluating online sources related to reading instruction. Behavioral objective: Readers will be able to identify instances in which confirmation bias results...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Quiet, Piggy: A Trumpian Response to Science of Reading Critics

    Aug 14, 202612 minAudio

    If you’re looking for accessible, research-based information that slices through the endless loads of overly worded baloney, I would encourage you to subscribe to my free Substack, The Reading Instruction Show....

    Credit the people on this episode