It is very hard to have a serious and substantive discussion about a topic like reading instruction with somebody whose knowledge base is shallow and disjointed. You end up in a teaching role.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
This is The Reading Instruction Show. I am your host, Dr. Andy Johnson. Topic of today's show is called John Stossel, My Adventure in Television. Now on August 8th, 2025, I was sitting in my basement writing my next New York Times best -selling book about reading instruction when I got an email. Bing! and it said, Hi, Dr. Johnson,
my name is Dan Stefano. Dan Stefano, Stefano, I'm a producer with John Stossel for Stossel TV. We're doing a story on the literacy crisis in America and it came across your advocacy for whole word reading instruction and would like to get your take on the subject. If you're interested, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. Okay? Now, I'm often very naive about things, but I'm not naive
enough to think John Stasso really wanted my take, quote unquote, on anything. He didn't really want to understand the literacy crisis or anything related to literacy. He had no real interest in my thoughts on any issue. He was looking for good TV. And because I drink 15 plus cups of coffee a day, and I tend to be a bit over -excitable,
I am good TV. And when I really get worked up, I wave my arms in the air and twitch a lot, and my voice goes up a couple octaves. Picture an over -caffeinated Barney Fife. Nip it, nip it. Nip it in the bud. Good TV. It was obvious from the message that the sender that Dan sent that Dan didn't know much about reading instruction.
And this is not an uncommon occurrence for those entering into the science of reading discussion from the outside. Here is my very polite response to Dan. Hi, Dan. I'd be happy to do an interview, but it is not whole word reading instruction. This doesn't exist. I can talk about whole language, meaning -based instruction, or balanced literacy. I don't know of anybody who currently advocates
whole word instruction. Okay, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. So, whole word instruction. Let's look at this. I... I'm not quite sure what whole word reading instruction is, and I'm an alleged reading expert. John Stossel also brought this up during the interview, so let me try to clarify. First, the look -say approach. In the early 60s,
there was something called the look -say approach, and this That may have been the reference that Dan Stefano was making. Now here, children were taught to read by having them recognize entire words as single units, instead of sounding out the individual letters. Common words were introduced, then repeated many times in simple sentences
using what's called a controlled vocabulary. The Dick and Jane series, published by Scott Forsman and Company from 1930 to 1965, was used for this. And you can see see some of the scintillating dialogue from these posts you can listen to it here it is look dick look jane see baby see see
oh oh oh dick look see see baby there was a lot of looking and seeing back then and this was my reading instruction back in 1963 that's the look -say approach now Sight words. There are these things called sight words. And I tried to explain this during the interview. Sight words
are the words that students recognize instantly on sight without having to use letter cues, word parts, or context clues. These words can be found on lists of most common words or most frequent words that include the 100 to 200 words that students encounter most often in print. And these are comprised mostly of function words. That
is, they have little or no lexical meaning. They're things such as pronouns and prepositions. and instead they express a grammatical or a structural relation with other words. There are several most common word lists. Dolsch, Frey, and Zeno are the most common, and they're all relatively similar. It doesn't really matter which one you use. I tend to use the Zeno word list, and these
are 107. words that students will encounter most often in text. Now, attention to sight words should be part of a reading or reading instruction for beginning readers. And three reasons for this, for attending to sight words. First, recognizing words instantly frees up cognitive space that can be allocated to creating meaning. Second,
words stored in long -term memory can be used to help students recognize and identify words in print with similar letter patterns. And third, having a large store of sight words enhances reading fluency. Whole language! Whole language is a language learning theory! Both whole language and whole word have the word whole in them, but
that's the only similarity. It has nothing to do with whole word reading. So, whole word reading instruction. Whole word reading instruction is not something that I or anybody that I know advocates. There is no significant whole -word reading instruction occurring today. It doesn't exist. Oh, maybe there are seven or eight around the country someplace.
But nonetheless, John Stossel still wanted my take on something because I was contacted two months later and flown out to New York City. So... I want to say up front, I was treated very respectfully by John Stossel, Dan DeStefano, and all the staff. And even though the interview was designed to be one of those gotcha interviews, I found John and his staff to be respectful during
the questioning in that he allowed me to answer the questions. And it shows that you can be against something, you can disagree vehemently, and you can even have an interview designed to highlight the flaws or inconsistencies of another. But you don't have to be disrespectful. So John or Dan, if you hear this, thank you for that. Thus said, I have no doubt that the interview will
go through some creative edits, and that I'll be portrayed in a less than stellar light. And I know there will be some convenient, inaccurate things said before or after the interview, and these things will make me look misguided or even foolish. I knew this going in. That's how the
game is played. And I'm okay with this for two reasons. First, it gives me something to write about. And oddly, I seem to have no shortage of things to write about lately. And second, this is illustrative of what's occurring on a larger level with Emily Hanford and all the Hanford wannabes. The purpose of these kinds of interviews
is not to transmit information or to understand the issues. Rather, it's to elicit an emotional reaction. This, in turn, leads to substantial speaking fees and other opportunities. And by the way, I don't think Emily Hanford will be greatly impacted by cuts in the SNAP program. A libertarian, John Stossel is described online
as an American libertarian television presenter, author, consumer, journalist, political activist, and pundit. I always wondered what a pundit is. How do you get to be a pundit? Is there a pundit school someplace? He has a podcast called The John Stossel Interviews, and I'm guessing this is where an edited version of our discussion will appear. Now, to get a sense of John Stossel's speaking fees, I contacted LAI Speakers, this
is Leading Authorities, Inc. This is a speaking bureau, and I told the person that I was with a group called Liberty Minnesota, which is true, I am with the group, there are like two of us, and was interested in having John Stossel do a keynote address. They sent me a quote which was 75k! And this included expenses and first -class air travel. Now, I realized two things.
First, making good TV is certainly more lucrative than being a literacy professor. How silly of me! to spend five years earning my PhD and 30 years teaching and doing scholarly work, when I could have been making good TV and doing keynotes for 75k a pop, and secondly I need to ask for better airline seats next time. When they flew me out I was literally in the very last row of
the airplane. So I bring up his 75k speaking feed, not because I think it's a bad thing. For 75k, I give you a keynote speech and dance like a chicken. I bring it up because everything in this science of reading conversation must be understood in the context of money. Money, whether received directly or indirectly, is used to influence
reading policy. Those with more money dictate what information is presented, how it's interpreted, and how things are perceived. Those with less money are silenced. So the way to get heard is really quite simple. more money. Now let's take a look at the interview. In the next couple podcasts,
I'll be highlighting different parts of this interview. Right now I'm doing this from memory. When I see the final interview product, I'll be able to respond more specifically. But confirmation, bias, and data resistance. It was clear that his staff did some background research to prepare for the interview. It was clear as well that the staff had a hardy case of confirmation bias.
This occurs when someone begins with strong beliefs and sees only information that confirms with their beliefs. In other words, they see what they're looking for and they don't see what they're not looking for. In this case, they were looking for data to show how wrong I was about reading instruction. And this made them data resistant to any data that might have showed how right
I was about reading instruction. So, a false literacy crisis. John Stossel kept insisting, that there was a literacy crisis, and he would not be convinced otherwise. After all, he had a chart in front of him showing such a thing. And I tried explaining the difference between norm reference and criterion reference tests. Norm reference tests compare students' test scores
to a normal population. Test scores of a large representative sample of students are collected so that comparisons can be made with students at similar grade levels. If it's a normal population, you get the familiar bell -shaped curve. For example, if Mary was in 3rd grade and her reading scores were at the 80th percentile, it would
mean that she scored higher than 80 % of all 3rd grade students. And you would know, with absolute mathematical precision, just how far she was away from average. In this case, Mary was 30%. away from average, which is the 50th percentile. And she was on the good side of that. Now, if you used a norm reference test with a
bell -shaped curve, by definition, 50 % are above the median average and 50 % are below the median average. But that's far different from saying that 50 % of students are reading below average or reading below grade level. Instead, 50 % read below the median average, and this is called normal and is to be expected in a normal population.
Now the National Assessment of Educational Progress, NAEP, is part of the U .S. Department of Education. They've been putting out test data since 1971, and you can visit their website to get the particulars. Their norm reference tests are given to students in 4th, 8th, and 12th grade. Test scores are broken down by states and subjects as well as by various subgroups such as race, ethnicity,
SES, gender, and school type. And since the test is the same, the same test is used, comparisons can be made over time, as well as between states and among subgroups. And these are useful in tracking national trends, but not for assigning causality. Correlation does not infer causation. If a test score goes down, you cannot say, ah,
it's because of that. You can't do that. But if there were a literacy crisis, which there is not, NAEP data would show a graph with the scores that looked like a ski hill going down, or even a slight hill constantly going down. It would not look like how they are, which is from 1971 until 2020, scores were consistent
or maybe even rising a little bit. Yes, there was the natural fluxation of scores, absolutely, but there simply is no reading crisis. And the question asked, and then John Stossel asked this, well, how come they're not getting better? That's not the way it works, John. That's not the way they work. So if there's an imaginary test and the scores were 500, and that's the score range,
you would expect these scores to continually be climbing all the time? That's just not the way it works. Now, criterion reference tests. With criterion reference tests, students are not compared to a normal population or even an abnormal population. They're compared to a set of criteria that somebody has arbitrarily defined. And these criteria are aspirational, not mathematical.
Meaning they represent what a group of people has decided that students at each grade level should be able to know or do. In other words, they're based on I -THINK -isms. I think third graders should know this and fourth graders should know that. And this means that students' achievement can easily go up or down simply by changing aspirations,
categories, or test content. Thus, you cannot compare the results from a criterion reference exam in one state with the results from a criterion reference test in another state. Two different tests, two different states, two different criteria, two different measures, two different populations. And you cannot compare the results of criterion reference tests over time if the tests differ, and they usually do. They change. Okay, this
has been the end of part one. I will give you some more parts of the John Stossel interview later. This has been Andy Johnson and this has been The Reading Instruction Show.
The Science of Reading seems to refer to a general consensus related to the strategies and practices that lead to improved reading outcomes. These strategies and practices have been determined to be effective using...
Using Blanche DuBois’s tragic reliance on the "kindness of strangers" as a central metaphor, this article critiques the recurring cycle of corporate-driven reading mandates and the reduction of literacy instruction to...
If you’re looking for accessible, research-based information that slices through the endless loads of overly worded baloney, I would encourage you to subscribe to my free Substack, The Reading Instruction Show....
Purpose statement: The reader will become more effective in evaluating online sources related to reading instruction. Behavioral objective: Readers will be able to identify instances in which confirmation bias results...
If you’re looking for accessible, research-based information that slices through the endless loads of overly worded baloney, I would encourage you to subscribe to my free Substack, The Reading Instruction Show....