Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Quicky

The Quicky artwork

The Mona Lisa Of Diamonds & Can Pauline Hanson Become Prime Minister?

Nov 11, 202615 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts

HEADLINES David Jones to close 19 stores after Christmas PM joins COP31 climate summit in Türkiye US soldier arrested in UK over alleged Russia ties Retirees refuse to let cost of living ruin travel plans “Mona Lisa of pink diamonds” sells for $21 million Plus, while the US had a blue wave, Australia has been riding an orange one. Pollster Tony Barry explains who’s voting for One Nation and why, and whether Pauline Hanson could actually become prime minister. GET IN TOUCH Got a story, news tip-off, feedback or dilemma? Send us a voice note or email us at thequicky@mamamia.com.au LINKS We want to hear from you! Take our quick 3-minute survey for your chance to win a $1,000 gift card. Subscribe here for 30% off your annual Mamamia subscription for Black Friday with code BLACK30. Code applied at the checkout. Offer ends November 30. CREDITS Host: Charlotte Mortlock Audio Producer: Scott Stronach Producer: Ella Maitland Head of Show: Tamsin Rose Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1You're listening to a Mamma Mia podcast.

Speaker 2Hello, I'm Charlotte Mortlock with the latest from the Quickie Newsroom. Last week, we saw a blue wave as the Democrats swept across the United States.

Speaker 1But in Australia, we've been experiencing.

Speaker 2More of an orange wave, the rapid rise of One Nation over the last 18 months. Pauline Hanson first got into Parliament in 1996. She launched One Nation as a political party the following year. Despite this, she and the party have positioned themselves as anti-establishment.

Speaker 3Then you've got the political grievance, the triple haters, people who don't like the Greens, they don't like Labor, they don't like Liberal. They're the burn it all down squad.

Speaker 2Today, We scratch below the surface of exactly why people are turning to One Nation in droves.

Speaker 1And if Pauline could actually be Prime Minister.

Speaker 2But first, here are your headlines for Thursday, November 12. 19 David Jones stores in five states will be closed by the end of the year in the latest move to save the struggling retailer. The stores will continue trading through the busy Christmas period and and then close at the end of December.

Speaker 1Most of the affected stores are in.

Speaker 2Suburban areas, but the Hay Street Mall store in central Perth will close. The Prime Minister is in Turkey, joining Climate Change Minister Chris Bowen at the United Nations COP31.

Speaker 1The hosts want a.

Speaker 2Collective goal to electrify more than a third of the global economy by 2035, up from around a fifth today. but India, the world's third largest greenhouse polluter, has already opposed the proposition. A US soldier has been arrested by British counter-terrorism police over alleged ties to Russia. The 41-year-old man was arrested near Gloucester on Tuesday on suspicion of offences under Section 1 and Section 3 of the National Security Act, assisting a foreign intelligence service and obtaining or

Speaker 2disclosing protected information. He remains in custody at a London police station. Coming up, a very fancy diamond just sold and can Pauline Hanson actually become the PM? Despite cost of living pressures, retirees aren't letting it ruin their travel plans. Flight Centre Travel Group Chief Executive Graham Turner told the company's annual general meeting on Wednesday that retirees and those

Speaker 2that were mortgage-free were prioritising travel, particularly to the UK and USA. Value destinations such as Vietnam and Bali were also seeing solid growth. And if you're in the mood to treat yourself or sending engagement ring photos to your partner, this one is for you. A very fancy 24-carat pink diamond, dubbed the Mona Lisa of pink diamonds, has sold at auction for 12.1 million Swiss francs.

Speaker 1That's more than 21 million Australian dollars.

Speaker 2The extremely rare jewel has been with the same family since it was purchased in India in the 1950s The emerald-cut Bulgari pink went under the hammer as the headline item at auction house Christie's seasonal jewellery sale in Geneva. In roughly 18 months, Australia will head to the polls.

Speaker 1There's been a lot.

Speaker 2Of hoopla about the role that One Nation and Pauline Hanson will play at that election. I've called in Tony Barry, director at Redbridge Group and one of.

Speaker 1The country's best pollsters. Thanks for joining The Quickie today.

Speaker 2Tony, what is the current lay of the land in terms of federal polling?

Speaker 3What we're seeing is a multi-party race, which is highly unusual in Australia, quite unprecedented, where we've got three parties all polling in the 20%. What we're seeing is One Nation are still leading on a primary vote basis at 28%.

Speaker 4Labor at 26%.

Speaker 3They've suffered a 9% fall since the election. and a 12% fall in the last 12 months. So November last year, just before Bondi, they were at 38%. The coalition had a not insignificant increase in their primary vote on this month's track. They're now at 25%. And the Greens were up two points to 13%. But what we're seeing is, you know, this real fragmentation in the electorate, which we've never really seen before. I mean, I go back to when I first started in politics in the 90s, the

Speaker 3combined major party vote, was around 90%. So just 10% went to the minor parties. The Democrats, which preceded the Greens, would pick up seven, eight points and a couple of independents would pick up a couple more. At the last election, 32% were not voting for their majors.

Speaker 2You mentioned multi-party there. For a long time, every Australian pollster said, we're a two-party country, we'll never have multi-parties here. Are we heading closer to a Scandinavian model where you do have more fractured, smaller parties making coalitions? And is that going to be beneficial for our democracy? Will we see better results? Is there some positives to this?

Speaker 3Yeah, I think we're going to see this fragmentation continue. I'm not sure the one nation vote will be sustained at these levels that we're seeing. We're starting to see some fractures and contours around their vote. But I think their floor is still around 15%. So even with a lot of missteps and problems along the way, it's not going to collapse down to single digits anytime soon.

Speaker 1Yeah, that's interesting.

Speaker 2So you think that they're almost like rusted on One Nation voters now and that's increased?

Speaker 3I count about four different cohorts of One Nation voters. And there's obviously more, but When they're polling at around the high 20s, close to 30%, and there's 18 million voters in the electorate, you're talking around 5 million Australians are voting One Nation at the moment. And that is the red meat One Nation supporters. Those were there for the entire journey. The 67% who voted for them in previous elections, they're sort of more the cultural grievance voters.

Speaker 3They're the ones who are most likely to raise in focus groups voters. issues around welcome to country, those sort of cultural issues. The next segment, which is the softest vote of all, and that is probably the most recent people to join the One Nation support base, are what I call the precariates.

Speaker 4So economic grievance. These are the ones who are.

Speaker 3Feeling anxious about their economic security, worried about providing for their family. They're largely Gen X, overrepresented with Gen X males. They will be in the outer suburbs and regions. Then you've got the political grievance, the triple haters, people who don't like the Greens.

Speaker 4They don't like Labor. They don't like Liberal.

Speaker 3They're the burn-it-all-down squad. Drain the swamp, anti-establishment. You've all failed me. The current political models are no longer working for me, so I'm looking for a disruptor, and there's no better disruptor in their view than Pauline Hanson. And the fourth group is what I call the Hanson enthusiasts. These are the group that they like her... as a leader and the curious thing when you talk to them is they think she's authentic and this is the group that sort of got turbocharged after Bondi and so they

Speaker 3credit her for that and when you sort of push back on them and focus groups and say well she said these outrageous things like there's no good Muslims in Australia they're like oh I don't agree with that but you know she at least speaks her mind so she gets a reward for consistency and perceived authenticity.

Speaker 2With One Nation, they've had kind of this meteoric rise across the board, but we have seen something interesting happening in Victoria.

Speaker 5One Nation has dumped its candidate for Preston Meantime for once glorifying Hitler in social media posts. Warren Pickering says anyone who holds such views does not have a place in the party.

Speaker 2The closer we get to that state's election with just mere weeks away, we have started to see a drop in One Nation's vote. Can you explain kind of the watermark for where they got to, where they are now and what's caused that?

Speaker 3Yeah, we are seeing fractures around their vote in Victoria, but they're still polling in the 20s, low 20s. So they're still very competitive, but they don't have the brand of Pauline Hanson. She's not on the Hatter vote card per se. But the really unique situation at Victoria right now is that it's an ageing government. It's a 12-year-old government asking for 16. There's a strong mood for change. And the Liberal campaign is really hammering away, making voters a binary, giving them a binary choice. You either get

Speaker 3rid of this government and replace it with Jess Wilson. If you vote for One Nation, that is at risk. And, of course, people are so keen to get rid of this current government that that binary choice, they don't want to take the risk of Pauline Hanson sort of having the balance of power or winning.

Speaker 2The big one for Pauline, obviously, that she can be a candidate for is the federal election, which, you know, is set for 2028, could be earlier. How many seats would One Nation need to win to get into government?

Speaker 1And is it a reality? Could Pauline Hanson be Prime Minister of Australia?

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 3I think what the last 12 months have shown us with their vote, and it peaked at 31% around May this year, but then at the National Press Club, instead of just identifying grievance, which she's been incredibly effective at doing, she started putting some policy prescriptions out. out there and that gave her opponents a target to hit. And we saw some of her votes sort of start to sort of fall away, but it's still very high. But I think probably what we could say with some confidence is

Speaker 3that their ceiling is around 31%. There will be seats where they'll poll that strongly, but they're going to be limited in number. And of course, in federal politics, you need 76 seats to govern. So they could be a minority, a balance of power force.

Speaker 4But again, I think it's going to be a fairly modest sort of offering.

Speaker 3And it is a bit hard to model at the moment because with three parties all polling pretty strongly in the 20s, where they come in each seat, the order in which they come is going to be critically important. If the coalition can come in the top two, they'll perform pretty well. But the problem when the last time we looked was the coalition were coming in third in a lot of seats, which means they get excluded and their preferences flow to first or second spot. So that said, I can't see them getting anywhere close to 76 seats.

Speaker 3The Labor Party... despite having 94 seats out of 150 at the moment, are in a lot of trouble. And of course, Albanese's problem is interest rates like kryptonite to governments.

Speaker 1You mentioned interest rates there.

Speaker 2And it's interesting because I think most people assume that when interest rates go up, it is bad for Albanese.

Speaker 1And that is a very simple concept.

Speaker 2But what's interesting is it's very rare that economic or fiscal policy people understand it enough for it to really have cut through because it can be complicated. But government spending does seem to be having cut through. And how is that link between government spending to interest rates changing the sentiment around those hikes?

Speaker 3Interest rates has a big impact on people's lives, whether you're a renter or you have a mortgage. So that is sort of one of the reasons why Albanese and Labor are losing altitude lately, is because voters are reassessing. And when we ask voters who's best to manage cost of living and the economy, Labor's also losing positioning on all those issues. And in fact, One Nation were leading on cost of living last month, which goes to show the despondency and the frustration voters have with the current

Speaker 3political model, And that's sort of what's driving some of the problems for Labor right now. And I think unless they can get on top of the economy, we're going to see further erosion in their vote.

Speaker 2Tony, we spoke about the watermark of One Nation. Do you think people will drift back to major parties? And do you think that's a good thing for our democracy? Or do you just interpret that as resignation and apathy?

Speaker 3I think with the non-major party vote increasing at every election except 2013 and 32%, I think it's just going to keep on increasing. It's hard to see how that trend will break. I think some vote will go back to the major parties and the coalition and Labor. But I think the real issue is going to be, and it's something that worries me a little bit, is that when that hard right One Nation, not the economic precariates but the sort of red meat Hanson enthusiast cohorts of

Speaker 3the One Nation vote. When she departs the stage or if their vote sort of fractures completely, where does that vote go? I'm not convinced it's going to go back to the major parties. So do we then have this sort of further fragmentation again of the right and then we get some really truly wacky parties or sort of, you know, smaller parties? But In some sort of crazy way, she's an organising principle that keeps that group together. And

Speaker 3I think if that breaks, this idea that I'll just go back to business as usual to the major parties and coalition polls at around 40% and Labor polls of 35% and the Greens poll of 12%, I'm not sure that's going to happen.

Speaker 4I think it could be scary.

Speaker 2Well, buckle up.

Speaker 1Thanks for coming in today, Tony. That's all for now.

Speaker 2If you have a topic you would like us to discuss, our inbox is always open, thequickie at mamamia.com.au. And make sure to rate and review us in your favourite podcast app. It helps other people find us. Mamamia acknowledges the traditional owners of the land on which we have recorded this podcast.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Weekly Debrief | Sandpapergate Scandal Explained & The AI Company Now Worth $2 Trillion

    Nov 20, 202611 minAudio

    HEADLINES Albanese tells Putin to “end your war” Unemployment jump raises recession fears Anthropic valued at $2 trillion after sharemarket debut Fiona the hippo dies Ella Langley dominates the CMA Awards Plus, in the...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Elon Feels ‘Foolish’ & Are Men To Blame For The Falling Birth Rate?

    Nov 19, 202614 minAudio

    HEADLINES Closing arguments in Beau Lamarre-Condon trial Unemployment hits five-year high Cameron Bancroft claims whole team knew about sandpapergate Elon Musk feels “foolish” over midterm spending Gordon Ramsay gets a...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Thursday News Update | PM Poses With Putin & Why GTA 6 Is A Big Deal

    Nov 19, 20264 minAudio

    HEADLINES Marles defends Albanese over Putin photo General Pants collapses into administration GTA 6 launches Police seek charges against Thomas Markle Sr Stars pay tribute to Gloria Steinem Tame Impala dominates the...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Compensating Surrogates & The Election Everyone's Watching

    Nov 18, 202613 minAudio

    HEADLINES Surrogates to be compensated under proposed reform Paper medical records leading to gaps in healthcare Nvidia rejects Jensen Huang’s bid to return Jeff Bezos was “heavily involved” in picking Bond Fiji records...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Wednesday News Update | Sandpapergate Saga Continues & The Crabs Go Walking

    Nov 18, 20264 minAudio

    HEADLINES Cricket Australia won’t reopen sandpapergate investigation Early voting opens in Victoria Melbourne Cup horse owner demands investigation Millions of red crabs march on Christmas Island Cambridge announces...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode