Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Quicky

The Quicky artwork

Your AM Headlines + Should Australia Pay Its Surrogates?

Aug 30, 202613 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

HEADLINES: Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has declared he “owes it to history” to defeat One Nation. After a spate of sexual assaults the Federal Government is funding a review into its current consent and respectful relationships programs. Hundreds are dead and thousands are still missing in Nepal. Australians may soon have a chance to opt out of social media algorithms. Australia’s biggest marathon has taken place in Sydney, with a record breaking 40,000 racers crossing the finishing line. Today we explore the debate about surrogacy in Australia. Charlotte Mortlock is sitting down Network Ten's Ashleigh Raper on what it's really like to carry a baby for someone else, and hear why a UN advisor says paying surrogates crosses a dangerous line…. GET IN TOUCH Got a story, news tip-off, feedback or dilemma? Send us a voice note or email us at thequicky@mamamia.com.au HELPFUL LINKS: Become a Mamamia subscriber and get an all-access pass to everything we make, including exclusive podcasts and early listening, subscriber-only articles, monthly giveaways and our home workout app, MOVE. Get access to Very Peri, Mamamia's exclusive perimenopause series, for just $59. 25 world-leading experts, over 20 on-demand sessions, available now. We’ve sorted through the noise so you don't have to. Go to veryperi.com.au today. You hot? Same. CREDITS Host: Charlotte Mortlock Audio Producer: Scott Stronach Group Executive Producers: Georgie Page and Tamsin Rose Check out The Quicky Instagram here and our TikTok here Discover more Mamamia podcasts here Did you know some of our shows are now in video on the Apple Podcast app? Make sure your phone is up to date and check it out here! Mamamia acknowledges the traditional owners of the land on which we have recorded this podcast. Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1You're listening to a Mamma Mia podcast. Hello, I'm Charlotte Mortlock with the latest from the Quickie Newsroom. Every year, hundreds of Australian babies are born through surrogacy. 75% of them are born overseas and then brought here. Currently, altruistic surrogacy, where the carrying woman isn't paid, is legal, but and commercial surrogacy, where she is, is banned. But some are

Speaker 1pushing for that to change as a review into our surrogacy laws ramps up. We'll unpack the many differing views on this debate and why one United Nations spokeswoman is vehemently against the idea. But first, here are your headlines for Monday, August 31. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has declared he owes it to history to defeat One Nation... as the Pauline Hanson-led party stormed to victory in yet another historic win for the minor party. For the first time,

Speaker 1One Nation now holds a lower house seat in Western Australia after winning the by-election for the state seat of Sacred Harbour. It is unusual for state by-elections to garner as much attention as this one did, but analysts have closely watched it because they're trying to figure out If A, the pattern might replicate at the 2028 federal election, and B, whether pre-vote polling or surveying is actually translating to voting trends. In this case, it is. While One Nation has been

Speaker 1encroaching on the conservative side of politics and threatening the Liberals and Nationals, this vote saw a massive swing against Labor, resulting in them losing what was once a safe seat. After a spate of sexual assaults, the federal government is funding a review into its current consent and respect for relationships programs. In an interview with the Daily Telegraph, Education Minister Jason Clare said he wanted to ensure students, parents and teachers had the resources and support they need, adding

Speaker 1it came at a time where young people, especially boys, are being targeted with poisonous content online. Six private school boys have been charged with sexual assault-related offences in the last month. Hundreds are dead and thousands still missing in Nepal after flash flooding was triggered when a massive ice and rock avalanche broke off high in the Himalayas. Dozens of Australians are still missing, but there have been some miracles. A six-year-old girl has been pulled alive from the rubble

Speaker 160 hours after flash flooding hit. Coming up, your social media feed could soon look very different. Plus, surrogacy laws in Australia may be on the cusp of change. Australians may soon have a chance to opt out of social media algorithms. Labor has committed to legislating a digital duty of care that that would force tech companies to proactively

Speaker 1prevent online harms rather than just requiring them to act on complaints. We should see the draft legislation later this year. Australia's biggest marathon has taken place in Sydney with a record-breaking 40,000 races crossing the finishing line after a 42.2km run through North Sydney to the Opera House. Ethiopian Adissu Gabina has smashed the course record. The 21-year-old, who until 2023 was a javelin thrower before a family member, suggested

Speaker 1he switched to distance running, slashed nearly 60 seconds off the old record. Kenyan world champion Perez Jepchurcher won the women's. Network 10 political editor Ashley Raper will always remember the moment she offered to carry a baby for one of her oldest and closest friends.

Speaker 2Look, I think If I'm really honest, when I offered to be a surrogate for my friend, I thought I probably wouldn't have to do it. I was literally opposite Stanmore Mackens. Can I say it now? And I often drive home there and it's like one of those moments in your life that it always just flashes in my head when I drive past.

Speaker 1In Australia, commercial surrogacy is illegal. Altruistic surrogacy, where the motivation is purely compassionate, is legal. That's what Raper did. The intended parents are allowed to cover costs associated with the pregnancy, but there can't be any financial profit or compensation. And it's heavily regulated.

Speaker 2My husband and I had to do counselling together and be signed off. Then we'd go to another counsellor and we all had sort of an individual session. And then it was Lucy and her husband and my husband and me. Like, so then we had the four of us. So we had to have that. Then we each had to have separate lawyers, but we couldn't have the same lawyer. So we had this legal contract, which that's a whole other thing because almost like the legal contract, it's there almost as a guide, because in the end, even though the

Speaker 2embryo was not mine in any way. But because I was the birth mother, I owned the baby.

Speaker 1Despite laughing about it now, Ash's offer was genuine and she was committed. The timing just wasn't quite ideal for a political reporter.

Speaker 2The election was held at the start of May. We did the transfer of the embryo three weeks later at the end of that month. It worked because then I wanted to get on a plane and the prime minister was traveling to the G7 and he was going to meet US president Donald Trump. And I wanted to be there and I wanted to cover that. So we were incredibly lucky that it took the first time. So I was basically six weeks pregnant and got on a plane.

Speaker 1So is that three international work trips while you're pregnant?

Speaker 3Yes.

Speaker 2Yes. While I was pregnant. And the obstetrician said, I think the last one I was maybe like 24, 25 weeks pregnant. He's like, It's done. You can't keep going around.

Speaker 1In Australia, there are roughly 100 to 150 births a year from domestic altruistic surrogacy. A further 350 children are born internationally, often by commercial surrogacy for Australian parents. Right now, the Australian Law Reform Commission is doing a review into our surrogacy laws. The findings are due to be handed down this coming month. I spoke with Reem Alsalam, the United Nations Special Rapporteur on Violence Against Women and Girls,

Speaker 1about it. Her concern is that disadvantaged women, often women of colour and from low socioeconomic backgrounds, can be exploited or worse trafficked for commercial surrogacy.

Speaker 4It will be the woman from a minority that is already suffering huge discrimination.

Speaker 1Alsalam's biggest concern is for the children born through surrogacy.

Speaker 4It may disappoint some of your listeners and it might be hard to hear, but my work has to be guided by international human rights obligations and standards. And I'm sorry to say as difficult as this may sound, but international law does not give you a right to have a child. We also have to understand that it is about selling and buying. I know this sounds harsh, but what we are essentially doing is we're allowing persons for an amount of money to order a child. And so

Speaker 4that is the sale of children and it's prohibited in international law.

Speaker 1But there are some stories of women who have had a really positive experience, both in being a surrogate and the family desperate for a child.

Speaker 4Like any phenomena, you will have a small minority of cases where there was, let's say, no abuse or no problem. But when we design policies, we're addressing systemic manifestations and patterns. And here, really, the overwhelming majority of situations is a situation that is extremely problematic.

Speaker 1Surrogacy lawyer Sarah Jefford, who has been a surrogate herself, disagrees and believes that commercialising surrogacy in Australia could make it safer.

Speaker 3So we have this real patchwork where it's less accessible in Australia to do surrogacy than it is to go overseas where there are risks of exploitation and human trafficking. We need to consider ways to stop exploitation happening, including overseas, in the United States, for example, where compensation is not the reason why it might be exploitative or unethical. In fact, if we have a good regulated framework for compensation, it can actually make it more ethical than if we call

Speaker 3it altruistic and exploit the unpaid labour of the women involved.

Speaker 1Al-Salam notes that while there are rigorous checks and vetting processes for anyone wanting to adopt a child, they're not in place for surrogacy.

Speaker 4We have this perception in our head and also as society that those who commission children through surrogacy are, by definition, people who want to become parents, people who will provide love, people who can't have, let's say, children of their own. And this is a little bit of a myth, actually. We don't know that. We cannot say that. Nobody knows. There are no red flags that emerge if somebody is a paedophile or somebody has a history of violence. And

Speaker 4we've seen in the press around the world cases, and we've just scratched the tip of the iceberg, where individuals have commissioned children actually to harvest their organs, to abuse them, to sell them further.

Speaker 1Surrogacy can be big business. It in a case of commercial surrogacy, a huge portion of the payment actually goes towards legal fees, IVF clinics and other industries which support the whole package. Jefford says it isn't fair that the woman carrying the baby is the only one not making money. and that a financial risk is deterring those who might be otherwise willing.

Speaker 3Compensate women for the time and the effort and the risk of pregnancy and birth without commercialising having a child, which might actually make it more accessible and easier for women to put their hand up in Australia because they know that they're not going to be financially at risk.

Speaker 1But Al-Salam believes that if women need to be incentivised to be surrogates, that's part of the problem. Having been a surrogate herself, Raper has concerns with the commercial model.

Speaker 2I really struggle with commercial surrogacy from a female perspective in how it can't be exploitative. And I think possibly that's very easy for me to say because I'm not the one desperately trying to find a pathway to have a baby.

Speaker 1There have been a number of high-profile surrogacy cases gone wrong. Recently in Ontario, Canada, a same-sex couple sued their gestational surrogate for refusing their request to abort the baby after it was diagnosed with a cleft lip and a potential cleft palate. In Florida, a single Chinese man failed to pick up babies from a surrogate who birthed triplets in November 2024. In the altruistic model, like for RAPER, Most of the time, the surrogate and intended family have a close relationship, reducing some of the risks.

Speaker 2It goes back to trust and that's why, you know, Lucy and I did it. I've known Lucy since I was five years old. You know, I had Christmas with her. She lived with my parents for a while. Like, she's my sister's best friend. She's in my life. But it goes back to trust.

Speaker 1From her own experience as a surrogate, Ashley believes the legal process needs to be streamlined to provide more certainty. and that changes need to better support the aftercare.

Speaker 2It was a really, really good, nice time in the delivery suite, and we were there for a couple of hours. Then we went up to the ward, and we had quite a different experience when we went up to the ward. It was pretty clear that there wasn't any protocols that they just could whip out. To how to deal with a surrogacy when there was a mother... a new mother there with her baby and also a woman who'd given birth. And I think both Lucy and I reflect, it was pretty disappointing what happened when we got up to the ward.

Speaker 1The findings of the Australian Law Reform Commission's review of surrogacy laws are due on September 11. Thanks for listening today. For more news like this, please click follow on the quickie wherever you get your podcast and please leave a rating and review. Mamma Mia acknowledges the traditional owners of the land on which we have recorded this podcast.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Weekly Debrief | Sandpapergate Scandal Explained & The AI Company Now Worth $2 Trillion

    Nov 20, 202611 minAudio

    HEADLINES Albanese tells Putin to “end your war” Unemployment jump raises recession fears Anthropic valued at $2 trillion after sharemarket debut Fiona the hippo dies Ella Langley dominates the CMA Awards Plus, in the...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Elon Feels ‘Foolish’ & Are Men To Blame For The Falling Birth Rate?

    Nov 19, 202614 minAudio

    HEADLINES Closing arguments in Beau Lamarre-Condon trial Unemployment hits five-year high Cameron Bancroft claims whole team knew about sandpapergate Elon Musk feels “foolish” over midterm spending Gordon Ramsay gets a...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Thursday News Update | PM Poses With Putin & Why GTA 6 Is A Big Deal

    Nov 19, 20264 minAudio

    HEADLINES Marles defends Albanese over Putin photo General Pants collapses into administration GTA 6 launches Police seek charges against Thomas Markle Sr Stars pay tribute to Gloria Steinem Tame Impala dominates the...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Compensating Surrogates & The Election Everyone's Watching

    Nov 18, 202613 minAudio

    HEADLINES Surrogates to be compensated under proposed reform Paper medical records leading to gaps in healthcare Nvidia rejects Jensen Huang’s bid to return Jeff Bezos was “heavily involved” in picking Bond Fiji records...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Wednesday News Update | Sandpapergate Saga Continues & The Crabs Go Walking

    Nov 18, 20264 minAudio

    HEADLINES Cricket Australia won’t reopen sandpapergate investigation Early voting opens in Victoria Melbourne Cup horse owner demands investigation Millions of red crabs march on Christmas Island Cambridge announces...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode