Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Quicky

The Quicky artwork

Tax Fallout Deepens & Can You Freeze Your Eggs Behind Bars?

Oct 18, 202613 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

HEADLINES Federal Government under more pressure over the ATO decision Coalition against an EU free trade deal Pope Leo cleared for South America following surgery Judith Lucy's advice to all Australian women Drone used to identify Aboriginal rock shelters in the Blue Mountains Listen now: Judith Lucy Wrote the Book on Wellness. Then She Got Cancer Plus, if you were in prison over your 30s, would you want the right to freeze your eggs? A woman serving time for serious drug offences in Queensland has just won a High Court challenge to be allowed the fertility treatment. GET IN TOUCH Got a story, news tip-off, feedback or dilemma? Send us a voice note or email us at thequicky@mamamia.com.au HELPFUL LINKS Become a Mamamia subscriber and get an all-access pass to everything we make, including exclusive podcasts and early listening, subscriber-only articles, monthly giveaways and our home workout app, MOVE. Get access to Very Peri, Mamamia's exclusive perimenopause series, for just $59. 25 world-leading experts, over 20 on-demand sessions, available now. We’ve sorted through the noise so you don't have to. Go to veryperi.com.au today. You hot? Same. CREDITS Hosts: Charlotte Mortlock and Tamsin Rose Audio Producer: Scott Stronach Producer: Ella Maitland Head of Show: Tamsin Rose Check out The Quicky Instagram here and our TikTok here Discover more Mamamia podcasts here Did you know some of our shows are now in video on the Apple Podcast app? Make sure your phone is up to date and check it out here! Mamamia acknowledges the traditional owners of the land on which we have recorded this podcast. Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1You're listening to a Mamma Mia podcast.

Speaker 2Hi, I'm Tamsin Rose for the latest from the Quickie Newsroom. Last week, the High Court handed down a major decision that could open the path for a woman convicted of drug trafficking to to freeze her eggs while in jail.

Speaker 1Other than Victoria, no other states have we seen cases where incarcerated women have been able to access assisted reproductive technology.

Speaker 2Today, what happens when you want to preserve your fertility from behind bars? But first, here's Charlotte Mortlock with your news headlines for Monday, October 19. Thanks, Tamsin.

Speaker 3The federal Labor government is under more pressure as the fallout from the Australian Taxation Office's decision to ban businesses using credit cards continues. Business groups are calling for an explanation about why they were left in the dark for months about a looming change, after Assistant Treasurer Daniel Molino said his government became aware in July, but the final decision wasn't made until September. Molino said the government wanted the ATO to continue negotiations with credit card providers to

Speaker 3set up a transition period rather than just implement a straight ban, but said those discussions were unsuccessful. After outcry from small business, Labor announced the government would cover the fees incurred on the card payments until the end of the financial year. Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry Chief Executive Andrew McKellar said it was concerning businesses were not told about the changes until the day before the ban started. The Federal Coalition of Liberals and Nationals will vote against

Speaker 3an EU trade deal that's been in the works for eight years. Under the $ 10 billion a year deal, which Australia signed with the EU in March, Australia would remove a 5% tariff on imports of European products, which hits carmakers such as BMW and Mercedes, along with goods such as fashion products, foods and drinks. Nationals leader Matt Canavan said it's not a good deal for Aussie farmers and could leave Australia open to sanctions if we don't meet our climate targets under the 2016 Paris Agreement. Senior Liberals

Speaker 3are denying that their junior partner, the Nationals, are dictating the Coalition's stance. On Sunday, Liberal frontbencher Sarah Henderson said concerns held by the Nationals were valid and the Coalition was united on the topic. Pope Leo has returned to the Vatican four days after lung cancer surgery. Leo is scheduled to make an ambitious trip to Uruguay, Peru and Argentina in about three weeks, including a dozen flights and two helicopter rides to high altitudes. His surgeon says there

Speaker 3are no clinical reasons to cancel his trip after Leo had the lower lobe of his right lung removed on Tuesday, confirming he had lung cancer. Coming up, an incredible discovery in the mountains and one woman's fight to retain her fertility from jail. Australian comedy great Judith Lucey has undergone a double mastectomy surgery, announcing she'd been diagnosed with breast

Speaker 3cancer almost a fortnight ago. Ahead of her surgery, she had a message for all women.

Speaker 1It seems completely surreal because, and I am taking every opportunity to say this, but keep up with your mammograms, ladies. And if you're not old enough to be getting mammograms, check them out.

Speaker 3Lucy sat down with Kate Langbrook for a wonderfully funny and raw No Filter episode that is out today. And researchers have used a drone to identify three previously unregistered Aboriginal rock shelters in the Blue Mountains near Sydney. A team from the University of Sydney and the Australian Museum, working alongside the Darug Custodian Aboriginal Corporation, used drones to scan the area from the air, identifying potential rock shelters that were hard to reach by foot. The three previously

Speaker 3unknown shelters contain visually striking rock art, including red hand stencils, as well as stone artefacts. The team hopes the method could help elsewhere in Australia to locate and protect cultural sites more efficiently.

Speaker 2Thanks, Charlotte. Many women in their mid-30s, and I'm one of them, are grappling with decisions about becoming a mother. Is it for me? Should I try now? Should I wait? What's the best path forward? For a growing number of women, egg freezing is part of that conversation. A recent study published in the journal Human Reproduction found that in 2009, just 55 women across Australia and New Zealand froze their eggs for what's sometimes called elective reasons, or when they

Speaker 2weren't undergoing another acute medical reason that necessitated the procedure. But by 2023, it was up at nearly 5,000. For most women weighing it up, common barriers are cost. It can be upwards of $ 7, 000 per cycle and what it asks of your body. But for some women, the barriers are structural. Associate Professor at Deakin Law School, Neera Bhatia explains.

Speaker 1Rachel Smith is currently serving a 10-year prison sentence for a drug trafficking offence. The crux of this case, however, is related to her seeking egg freezing.

Speaker 2Smith is in her mid-30s and she won't be eligible for parole until she's 39.

Speaker 1And what that means for her is it's going to impact her fertility and her fertility will have a considerable decline, a significant decline in that time while she's in prison. So what she has sought to do is to apply through Queensland's Corrective Services Department to have her eggs frozen in preparation for when she is released from prison to be able to consider having a child. So really, this case is around her preserving her fertility for the future.

Speaker 2A few years ago, she asked Queensland Corrective Services if she could have her eggs frozen. She would pay for it herself. They said no. She then applied through the Brisbane Supreme Court and the Court of Appeal. each application failed. And then she went to the High Court, and on Wednesday, it sided with her.

Speaker 1This really is quite a landmark decision for Queensland.

Speaker 2Queensland law says prisoners can't take part in assisted reproductive technology, so think IVF. Corrective services argued egg freezing fell under that ban. But the High Court's now drawn a line between creating a pregnancy and preserving the ability to have one later. Freezing your eggs, it found, is about prevention.

Speaker 1The type of treatment she was seeking isn't for the procreation of a baby. It's simply to preserve that fertility for later on. And in fact, in the judgment, Justice Jago in particular reasons and says that it really is about a material reduction in her fertility prior to her release on parole. And that's what the judges fundamentally determined as to why she should be able to freeze her eggs.

Speaker 2The judgment doesn't mean Smith can book into a clinic today. Her application now goes back to the head of the Queensland Corrective Services to be decided again, this time under the High Court's reading of the law. And this is a big deal in Queensland, maybe even for other prisoners in the state if this serves as a precedent. But one state's gone a lot further.

Speaker 1So in Victoria... We have had cases where incarcerated women have actually gone one step further than egg freezing and have actually gone on to consider IVF treatment and assisted reproductive technology. In Victoria, they've been allowed to do so on the basis that it's been considered to be a necessary type of treatment for the preservation of health.

Speaker 2This first came up in Victoria in 2010 when the Supreme Court allowed a woman in prison to undergo IVF that she was paying for herself.

Speaker 1Will it have repercussions for other incarcerated women in Queensland? I think it is very likely, but I think it is likely in the sense of probably confining it to egg freezing. I don't think that Queensland will be as permissive as Victoria to extend it to allowing IVF. I think it will have some ramifications or repercussions for other incarcerated women in Queensland, but I think it will be confined to egg freezing as opposed to allowing the whole

Speaker 1gambit of IVF treatment.

Speaker 2Part of why this case has drawn so much attention is the laws in Queensland that put a blanket ban against reproductive assistance while behind bars affect men and women differently. A man who spends his 30s in prison will very likely still be able to father a child when he gets out. For a woman, those same years can be the difference between having a biological child and never being able to.

Speaker 1Incarcerated women in Rachel's case is a perfect example of where women have a very finite window of fertility compared to men and that obviously plays out in the prison system.

Speaker 2And it's not the only fight over women's bodies behind bars right now. Last week, Independent Senator Lydia Thorpe brought a bill to federal parliament to ban the shackling of women in prison while they give birth. Labor and the Coalition announced they wouldn't back it, saying prisons are the matter for the states and territories. But Paul Scar, a Queensland Liberal Senator, broke ranks and said he was deeply concerned by the Australia-wide practice. He vowed to raise it with the Queensland Attorney-General, Deb Frecklington. Not everyone thinks Smith

Speaker 2should have won this case. She's in prison for drug trafficking, and for some people, missing out on the things you'd have on the outside world is the whole point of being sent to prison.

Speaker 1Some would argue you do the crime, you pay the time, right? She committed a crime. Some would argue it's quite a serious offence, drug trafficking. Therefore, she should just serve her time. And that is part of our criminal system. And that is, what is the purpose of punishment, of prison? It's to punish, it's to deter people from committing an offence again. is to rehabilitate them and to protect the community. And therefore

Speaker 1she should do those years. And then after that, when she's released, that's entirely up to her.

Speaker 2Supporters of the decision point out that in Australia, prison exists to punish, to deter, to rehabilitate and to protect the community. Taking away someone's ability to ever have a child isn't on that list.

Speaker 1Now, others would argue, as I have elsewhere, to say she's not looking to have a baby. She's simply looking to preserve her fertility for later on in life. So therefore, it's quite different. So I think it becomes more of a question, as I said, that's grounded in both ethical concerns as well as legal.

Speaker 2From here, well, it's up to Smith and Corrective Services. But if this does go ahead, the treatment costs will fall squarely on Smith.

Speaker 1So it's not. the taxpayer that's paying for this treatment. It's not the state that's paying for the treatment. It's entirely funded by the incarcerated person, by Rachel here. And that's for every single facet of the treatment, the egg freezing, the doctors, the medical treatment, but also the transportation to and from the prison to the fertility clinic, any security that was required to take her to and from. Everything is covered entirely. by the prisoner.

Speaker 2And if it does go ahead, Smith will still have to wait until she's out of prison before she can use the eggs. That's all for now. If you have a topic you'd like us to discuss, our inbox is always open. We're at the quickie at mamamia.com.au. And make sure to rate and review us in your favourite podcast app. It helps other people find us.

Speaker 3Mamma Mia acknowledges the traditional owners of the land on which we have recorded this podcast.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Weekly Debrief | Sandpapergate Scandal Explained & The AI Company Now Worth $2 Trillion

    Nov 20, 202611 minAudio

    HEADLINES Albanese tells Putin to “end your war” Unemployment jump raises recession fears Anthropic valued at $2 trillion after sharemarket debut Fiona the hippo dies Ella Langley dominates the CMA Awards Plus, in the...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Elon Feels ‘Foolish’ & Are Men To Blame For The Falling Birth Rate?

    Nov 19, 202614 minAudio

    HEADLINES Closing arguments in Beau Lamarre-Condon trial Unemployment hits five-year high Cameron Bancroft claims whole team knew about sandpapergate Elon Musk feels “foolish” over midterm spending Gordon Ramsay gets a...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Thursday News Update | PM Poses With Putin & Why GTA 6 Is A Big Deal

    Nov 19, 20264 minAudio

    HEADLINES Marles defends Albanese over Putin photo General Pants collapses into administration GTA 6 launches Police seek charges against Thomas Markle Sr Stars pay tribute to Gloria Steinem Tame Impala dominates the...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Compensating Surrogates & The Election Everyone's Watching

    Nov 18, 202613 minAudio

    HEADLINES Surrogates to be compensated under proposed reform Paper medical records leading to gaps in healthcare Nvidia rejects Jensen Huang’s bid to return Jeff Bezos was “heavily involved” in picking Bond Fiji records...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Wednesday News Update | Sandpapergate Saga Continues & The Crabs Go Walking

    Nov 18, 20264 minAudio

    HEADLINES Cricket Australia won’t reopen sandpapergate investigation Early voting opens in Victoria Melbourne Cup horse owner demands investigation Millions of red crabs march on Christmas Island Cambridge announces...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode