Send us Fan Mail Have you noticed that division in the United States feels higher than ever? What if conflict isn't the cause of our division, but rather the normalization of contempt within conflict? In this dual release, Matt Todd of The Ranch podcast invites Alexis on to talk all things Dignity Index. As a member of the Dignity Politics team at Dignity.US, Alexis takes listeners behind the scenes of the index: how it was developed, how research studies have verified and validated it, and how it's spreading across the United States. Together, Alexis and Matt break down: What it means to use the language of dignity How to see ourselves honestly in the moment through self-confrontation How you can be part of the dignity movement to help ease division in your family, neighborhood, school, community, and workplace Learn more about the Dignity Index at www.Dignity.US. Find Alexis on Instagram and JOIN in the conversation: https://www.instagram.com/the_idaho_lady/ JOIN the convo on Substack & STAY up-to-date with emails and posts https://substack.com/@theidaholady?r=5katbx&utm_campaign=profile&utm_medium=profile-page Send Alexis an email with guest requests, ideas, or potential collaboration. email@thealexismorgan.com Find great resources, info on school communities, and other current projects regarding public policy: https://www.thealexismorgan.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Hey friends, welcome to the Purple Zone where public policy, practice, and people meet. Because policy isn't abstract, it's personal. So let's talk about it.
SPEAKER_02Alexis Morgan. Are we gonna do a musical interlude in the middle of this episode? I feel like we need to dance it out today.
SPEAKER_00It is a Friday.
SPEAKER_02Have you heard the song? My wife has been playing the song non-stop, the bad times song. Have you heard of this? No?
SPEAKER_03I don't know.
SPEAKER_02Okay, hang on. I'm gonna play it for you just briefly. Here this has been playing in my house non-stop for the last 48 hours. And I'm like, and my 12-year-old on the way to school today leans over, he's like, Honestly, Doug, I hate the song. I hate this song. And it just goes on. And it's somebody, and it's like, it gets your shoulders going.
SPEAKER_00But it's you need oh my gosh.
SPEAKER_02It lids in my nightmares.
SPEAKER_00Oh my gosh. Hashtag first time you started an episode with playing some random song.
SPEAKER_02God bless it. It's the best. How are you?
SPEAKER_01I'm good. You know, living through the it's finally fall. It's finally fall, Matt, and I'm really excited about it because fall is my favorite time of year.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I love fall. I love fall so much.
SPEAKER_02Dude, I love Halloween. I love the the we now have um, we now have like maples and other trees that are deciduous and lose their leaves. Yes, they're is that the word? That's correct. Yeah. And all we planted like 30 of these trees, and they're all, all their leaves are changing. And they're like, they're not, they're only like 10 feet tall. They're not like these gigantic, beautiful, magnificent, but you are seeing it. It's like the leaves are changing color.
SPEAKER_01Oh, it's incredible. We used to live in New Hampshire and you would round a corner, and then all of a sudden, like this entire valley would be full of trees and color, like all the colors of the fall time. And um, because I think New Hampshire, like the New England area, is like the number one place to see fall. They actually call it this ready for this leaf peeping season.
SPEAKER_02Leaf peep that leaf. Peep that.
SPEAKER_01You are called a leaf peeper. I like have a sweater. I'm pretty sure this is leaf peeping or something like that. Um, it's actually a beautiful sweater, and no, but it's it's a real thing. Like it's not this is it's not a fake thing. Um, and I learned about it when I lived over there, but it truly is like it's just so beautiful. And I grew up on a farm in Oregon, and this time of year we called the holly season because this was when our farm uh we were getting ready for like the Christmas greenery, right? Christmas time, rays, garland, centerpieces, all those things.
SPEAKER_01So we called it the holly season. Um everyone else called it fall. Uh, but it was just But in New Hampshire, leaf peeping. Leaf peeping season. Yeah. You know, so anyways, everyone's got like the name of what they call it, but I think there is a j uh general feeling of like love for the fall time. I actually don't know if ever I I mean have you ever met someone that didn't like the fall?
SPEAKER_02I know people that really like summer. Sure. But I mean, you know, I knew this gal from uh she was on my wife's water polo team. She listened to Christmas music year round. Oh my gosh. Like she couldn't help it. She just loves and like we watched the Grinch year-round, the the the new one. We're like, ah, like the dog, the CGI one. It's great, not like the Jim Carrey one.
SPEAKER_01When you look at the seasons, people have strong feelings between s uh summer and winter.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But and and people are sometimes iffy about spring. But I don't know that I've ever met someone that didn't enjoy fall.
SPEAKER_02That's a good point. That's a good point. Yeah. Well, listen, that's exciting. And it's happening. Um the other thing that's exciting is you are now one of the official members of the Dignity Index team. Yes. Which I love because you have been talking to me about the Dignity Index. And in fact, you and I met because we were both trying to talk about these complex systems that exist in Idaho and elsewhere with clarity, with dignity, with just, hey, I just again, we met. I was interviewing people for the school board and not screaming and yelling at people and not doing anything crazy.
SPEAKER_02And the first show of yours that I heard, you were just talking about the education system and not saying, like, can you believe and blah, blah, blah. It was just, no, no, no, hang on. Like, we have this board, and the only member of the board that's elected is this and the rest of it and going through it very clearly. And, you know, pretty soon thereafter, you started talking to me about the dignity index out of Utah and what people were doing, and now you're part of that team.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I uh was introduced to the Dignity Index two and a half years ago when I was in DC as the state PTA president for Idaho. I was there for the legislative conference. And uh Tammy Piper, who's one of the co-creators of the Dignity Index, the Dignity Index is a scale, like it's the tool essentially. So we just it's interesting how now everyone, because of the language that's used, we just refer to the whole thing as the dignity index, but that's the tool. Anyway, she was teaching that um at the legislative conference, and I went in and I remember looking at the description, like how to navigate, you know, conversations and a way to be able to do that in a productive way or something.
SPEAKER_01That's kind of what I remember. And I remember thinking, oh, that sounds really interesting, right? As I was looking at all the different topics, because I thought, I'm somewhat familiar with this topic over here, right? Or, you know, I've been in education for quite a while. So when it comes to kids in education, I I thought, okay, this is something new that I haven't seen before. And uh I did my master's project that was centered around civility. And so I thought, oh, I'm I'm interested. Room was packed, only seating area on the ground. So I was one of the people on the floor. And um maybe, maybe not, no, I can't remember.
SPEAKER_01I'd like no, I don't know. It doesn't matter. But there were people sitting on the floor, like that's how packed this room was. And as she presented, you know, you have like those moments where you hear something and it just resonates with your entire being. Like your body knew that that was true before you actually heard it in your head, like you know, audibly, and you you feel like, oh, they're putting language to something that I have seen and experienced. That's what it felt like.
SPEAKER_01And for someone that spends a lot of time talking with people and talking about challenging topics and trying to um, you know, I had been a school board member trying to engage in a way that uh was, you know, like as a school board, we were talking about tough things and people weren't always happy with what we were doing. Our parents were coming to us with some of their tough, you know, experiences and how do I navigate the system in here? The dignity index tool really put the concept into uh like something that was like actionable.
SPEAKER_01Like, oh, you could do this and participate in conversation where I, as an individual, was using language that facilitated the conversation and helped the conversation continue, versus making the conversation hard, challenging, and contemptuous and making the other person not want to continue in it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And again, as as when you were the PTA president, right, going through it, the time you were the PTA president, especially in Idaho's uh in Idaho's history, was like a really weird time for public ed. And it still is to a degree, but you're the PTA president in the middle of this kind of national conversation around what are our public schools doing? Are they relevant? Are they serving us? Are there ulterior motives that people were alleging? And you had, you know, like I had lawmakers on my show during this time frame that you were in there that were like, oh yeah, they're 100% failures, they're like terrible, all these things.
SPEAKER_02Like, well, wait, where did you go to school? And they're like, oh, well, I went to public school. It's like, was it a hundred percent failure? Like, well, they're different now, all these things. Like, okay, but and it's very hard. And people would just go to a 10, right? They would go, and I'm not saying that's on the dignity index scale, but they would go to a 10 with like aggression, you know, intensity. The flip side of it was our teachers are saints, they've never done anything wrong. And there was this cult of communication around if you said anything bad, you were the devil. You can't say anything good, you only have to say things bad or only have to say things good, and both sides have to come out like swinging.
SPEAKER_02And it was a like this. I remember going through this and talking to you about a lot of things that were being said and acted upon of like this is what like there's no practical or functional dialogue to be had here. Like everybody's just teeing up the next person for the next most intense thing.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. And that points to something that the um dignity.us has seen in in their research and what they've done is that the the, you know, our our um our communities, our country are divided, right? There is a large, there's a you know, a large division. We talked to a lot of people about it, um, and they'll acknowledge, like, yeah, I really feel a division. And what's interesting is that it's not disagreement has not caused the division.
SPEAKER_01It is the normalization of contempt within the disagreement that has caused the division. We've normalized as human beings, throwing in contempt into our disagreements. And because we've normalized contempt, it's made it so that we continue to become more divided and more divided. So to your point, when I became the state PTA president and you know, there were some thoughts around this is what the PTA is, or you know, and and education and all of those different things, one of the things that I did in the in the parent world of nonprofits, PTA has been around for a long time.
SPEAKER_01And it started nationally in 1897, in Idaho in 1905, and this was because this is around the time where there was just a large movement of women gathering for different purposes. So when the net it was actually called the National Congress of Mothers started in 1897, it was around the premise of kids, right? That's why they were wanting to speak up and it was a way for women to also gather and share their voices about something that they cared about. So as time progressed in um in the PTA, they became uh the National Congress of Parents and Teachers instead of the National Congress of Mothers.
SPEAKER_01And they um they as they were going through, right, PTAs really start popping up like between the early 1900s and 1950, PTAs, the organizations are popping up everywhere. But then uh another form of parent organization popped in that wasn't affiliated with a national organization, and that was called the parent teacher organization, PTO. Okay. So then as time goes on, because PTO is this different thing, now those two organizations are clashing up against each other.
SPEAKER_01We're better than you, this is better than that, all you know, that that uh that conversation around those two are occurring. So when I became the PTA president for the state, I I was aware of that. I was hearing that language spoken uh in that way from PTA parents and from PTO parents.
SPEAKER_02And may may I ask a question? So from 1900 to 19 roughly 50, you start seeing a lot of PTAs pop up. And the at the at least structurally, the PTA in Idaho is a statewide organization, association, right? And it's an uh it's an upside-down funnel, right? It looks like a uh like a street cone, right? So it's like you have the people at top and they represent the interests that are aggregated from across the state. So it's all these upward arrows going to like somebody in East Idaho's, hey, I care about this, and somebody in North Idaho, hey, I care about this, you know, west, south, all these things, and everybody funnels it to the top, and then that person who is an unpaid volunteer because the PTA is not a lobbying uh, you know, uh professional lobbying entity, those people then go to lawmakers and say, hey, listen, I represent, you know, all of the people that are PTA members and not, like I'm we're here for kids, right?
SPEAKER_02And the kids and the parents are saying this, right? This is the an issue that's going on, or you know, teachers, obviously, whatever it might be. And that's distinct from PTOs because PTOs represent individual school sites. So if you uh you have like Matt's Elementary, and at Matt's Elementary, like the PTA does go to bat for them for various things, but they might have a school site entity that's like we are the parent-teacher organization at this school site. We are not tied to a state level organization. I am a school site entity, and we care about the playground here, we care about the library that you know has a leaky roof, we care about these individual things, but we're not going necessarily to lawmakers to advocate for this school site.
SPEAKER_02So we're hyper-localized as opposed to the PTA, which is statewide and aggregating and then re having representation at the state level.
SPEAKER_01Right. And the PTA, the PTA is also all those little local unit PTAs, they're also localized for their local area, right? But they're also connected to that state level.
SPEAKER_02Right. Right. So they all are these like little batteries of interest, but the PTA ones get connected to a larger system.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_02And also and going back to the 50 years where all these things pop up, that's also the transition where you had like 50% of the US workforce working in agriculture shifting to the 1950s where it's like 10%. And now we're down to like one or two percent. So you had this mass, you know, essentially unemployment movement as we develop uh, you know, petroleum systems and we develop general motors and we develop, you know, like tractors and tanks and all these different things, and we can automate far more things. You had a portion of the US population where it's like, well, four decades ago, five decades ago, I would have had a job.
SPEAKER_02I'm not saying it's an easy job, like working in ad is not easy, but I would have had a job. I don't have a job now. And the United States looked at this and they're like, we really need to train a lot of people and educate them to have offerings to our economy that aren't based around ag. So as children started moving into this new system of, okay, how are we gonna provide an education that then provides opportunity for people because it's not readily available everywhere like it used to be? As more kids are going into it, more parents are saying, hey, we want to say about how this is going.
SPEAKER_02Hence the development of this parent-teacher association that says, hey, we represent the people that are coming into this school. Education's mandatory, we want a seat at the table.
SPEAKER_01Right. And so all of those things are happening. And so you got the PTA and the PTOs pop up. And as PTOs pop up, PTAs are starting to switch to PTOs now, right? You've got that that that's really starts what mostly happening in the 1960s and onward to 2026 today. And so in that switch, you get that's where you get the conflict. We're better than you, us versus them, kind of a deal.
SPEAKER_02What was the value proposition that made people switch? Like, what was it that people are like, oh, we should be a PTO?
SPEAKER_01They don't uh, you know, whether that's like they don't want to be affiliated or connected to some national organization, they don't right? This is um the decline of associations in general when people don't want to pay dues to be a part of something. Um, you know, there's definitely benefits for dues, and and basically like I just want to focus on my local area. I don't even want to think about what's going on up here.
SPEAKER_02So uh Or I don't want to be affiliated with a national sentiment. I care about this school, these kids right here. Right. Ah, interesting.
SPEAKER_01Yep. So when I became the state president, I said I saw what was happening visually and I went, we're gonna disengage from this conversation because I don't believe that it's an us versus them. As the state PTA president, I say that I value we speak up for all Idaho kids. Therefore, I value what all parents have to say. So I want to hear that. So then that's when I started traveling around the state that summer. Um, that following summer, I traveled around the state and just I reached out to my friends in the different towns in Idaho and I said, Hey, will you get parents together?
SPEAKER_01I don't care. They don't have the homeschool, private, whatever. I don't care. It doesn't matter to me. I want to hear what they have to say about their kids and how they feel about education. I need to know because I'm gonna be at that capital. And I, so, anyways, I went around, it was the coolest thing ever, took all these notes from from the uh entire experience, learned from people, and I took that, and that's how we as a state organization started to engage in conversation. But the reason I share that story is because um, you know, here I met the dignity index.
SPEAKER_01I saw, you know, I'm seeing all these different things. And it's like this uh this conflict between us versus them with the PTO and PTA, that's not productive. What what are we really trying to do here? What do we have in common and how can we take those things and work together when it's appropriate? And you don't have to, you know, you don't have to participate in other things when you don't want to. And so to me, the dignity index is a scale, it's a measurement of speech that says um, you know, the closer you get to one, the more contempt you're you're using in your language.
SPEAKER_02And I assume by the uh as well, the less effective speech is to actually engage in anything productive.
SPEAKER_01Right. Because the because the sentiment is the more dignity you offer someone, so the closer you write five on the scale, I'll show you in a second, on the scale from five to eight, that's more dignity you're using in your language to facilitate dialogue. And when you facilitate dialogue, we open the door, if we're talking about it through a political lens, for democracy. Because democracy demands dialogue. And you've been having conversations with, I mean, you know, the other yesterday we were you were meeting with a federalist expert, right?
SPEAKER_01A professor from University of Utah, and he's talking to you about the Constitution. And another guy that talks about the Constitution in a book about the American Covenant talks about how the Constitution has integrated, if you look at it through a framework, lots of different ways to use that, right? But one is unity and not unity in thought, but unity in action. And the only way to achieve unity in action is if you can have that dialogue to move forward.
SPEAKER_02Okay, so contempt is like the the end of the road. And as you move away from contempt and more to dignity, you open the door for more dialogue. More dialogue means more meeting of minds and better collaboration, more meeting of minds and better collaboration leads to a better outcome and process, which is like democracy.
SPEAKER_01Right, right.
SPEAKER_02Okay, great. So like contempt kills democracy and dignity actually facilitates it.
SPEAKER_01Right. Great. Yep, yep.
SPEAKER_02And um two books it should be the democracy index. That's what it should be.
SPEAKER_01Well, what they have found though, like what they found with the dignity index is that it fits everywhere because it fits in politics, it fits in education, it fits in higher education, it fits in faith, it fits in community. It's a it's a way to talk with each other, it fits in family. It's not just in one space, but you know, as in the work that I do, I see which is centered around, you know, uh government and public policy. It definitely has been a tool for me. Um, and I'll tell you why. I'll I'll go there first, and then I wanted to tell you a few, a couple of things about the index that I think are really um like just need to be highlighted.
SPEAKER_01Okay. So um this is this is the thing that I love about the dignity index. Um, so imagine.
SPEAKER_02Imagine if you will.
SPEAKER_01Imagine if you will, Matt. Um Do I have to wear that shirt?
SPEAKER_02I mean it's a good one. It's a very nice shirt. The vest. It's the it's the vest.
SPEAKER_01It's the best. Okay, so imagine you're a parent, which I know you are.
SPEAKER_02Hey, a quick question for you. If I wear jeans and a jean jacket, that's a Canadian tuxedo.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_02Okay.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_02You're wearing jeans and a jean vest. What is that? Is that the Canadian romper?
SPEAKER_00Oh my gosh. Oh my gosh. I wouldn't know. I wouldn't know, Matt. I wouldn't know. Oh my god, we should invent that. The Canadian romper. The record? I'm like wearing like black denim.
SPEAKER_02Okay. I d I had this whole bit when rompers were like, they're the most unfortunate. I had this three minute.
SPEAKER_01What do you mean by romper? So a romper. I wear jumpsuits. I wear like jumpers and stuff. Okay. You've seen me in them.
SPEAKER_02I have seen you in them. Rompers to me are a uh female garb. Oh my gosh.
SPEAKER_01Rompers are like a thing that toddlers wear.
SPEAKER_02That's no, no. I've seen grown women wearing rompers and their shorts. It's like, it's like an overall, but again, like full shirt, and it could be like all the way down to your wrist, but usually it's short sleeved. So full shirt that is tied to shorts, right? So it is one unit. And I remember seeing this. It was like 2020, 2021. Yeah. And they're like, hot, they're hot on the scene. They were building through the teens and then COVID and everybody bought rompers. And it's like, what in the hell?
SPEAKER_02And I had this whole bit about the war on women through fashion. I was like, we make them walk around on chopsticks, they're twisting their ankles, and then they have one continuous piece of fabric that they have to deal with all day. I'm like, what do you do when you go to the bathroom? You gotta take the whole thing off. I was like, this is terrible. I was like, had this whole three minute bit about like the war on women through clothing. So unfortunate. Your jumpsuit's like, that's just a jumpsuit. It's not a romper. Like, and I've seen your jumpsuit before. It's not like I don't think of it as a romper, but this is not the Canadian romper.
SPEAKER_02It's fantastic.
SPEAKER_01Thank you. Thank you. You're welcome. What were you saying? So now I want you to imagine that you're a parent. Okay.
SPEAKER_02Okay. I'm but I'm you. Okay. I'm a parent. I am a parent. I can be myself.
SPEAKER_01The reason I say this, because this is my experience, but I just want you to imagine, like you're a parent, you're paying attention to politics, um, and you notice that your lawmaker is making decisions that really frustrate you. He's saying things that are, you know, pol polarizing, and you're frustrated by it. And you see him on different clips, and the more you see, the more you get irritated. You're just like, ugh, every time. Every time there's every time every time the image of him then drives you nuts. You're like, ugh, okay. So then you become you become the state PTA president.
SPEAKER_01Hi. You're the state PTA president. And that means that you have to go have conversations with people sometimes, people that you might not like.
SPEAKER_02Because I've been watching Brian's Facebook and Brian. And now I gotta go because I'm the PTA president.
SPEAKER_01You gotta go because you're the PTA president. And you um and and the reason you have to go and talk to this particular lawmaker is because he's got this bill at the Capitol now that could deeply impact the local school districts. The local school districts. And you know, because you've had experience as a school board member and in public policy, you know that the schools already have the power to do this thing that he wants to kind of enforce across the state. And this is a hot topic and um it's polarizing.
SPEAKER_01Okay, so you're kind of coming in with that and you're just like, uh, and I gotta get on. And by by the grace of God, you're able to make an appointment with him because you reach out to him and he says, Okay, I'll meet with you.
SPEAKER_02Can I tell you what Brian's bill is?
SPEAKER_01Sure.
SPEAKER_02Okay. Brian, the lawmaker, okay, he is deeply concerned with the funding obligations or funding reliance that Idaho has on the federal government. And he's looking for ways to sever ties with these things. So Brian looks at the education system and he's like, Well, I can't go after special ed, I can't do this thing. But we get a bunch of money from the federal government for free or reduced lunches. I'm just saying this is Brian's idea. Okay. And I'm pretty sure we do. It doesn't matter. Brian's like, here's the thing though, we need to start severing these ties. So what he does is he's like, I'm gonna pass this bill that one prevents Idaho schools, public schools from taking money, and then also creates a separate taxing district within the area to allow communities to self-tax themselves to pay for the free or reduced lunch program.
SPEAKER_02And this is gonna be great because we can support ourselves. And I'm going into Brian saying, Brian, I understand your concern with the federal government.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_02But Idahoans, but that's not how you start. No, no, no, no, that's I'm just thinking you're thinking. What are the odds that communities it that don't like taxing themselves are going to pony up funding for free or reduced lunch programs for kids that they may or may not know. They already don't want to fund school districts. We're already having this discussion. Don't do this, Brian. This is a bad idea. And I understand you're very concerned about Idaho's reliance on the federal government, but this is going to hurt young children that do not even have money for lunch right now.
SPEAKER_02This is what's going on in my head.
SPEAKER_01That's what's going on in your head.
SPEAKER_02And that's a pretty great made-up bill, by the way. It's a great thing. Like it weaves in federal reliance and like let's do our own thing, and then it's like, but it wouldn't work.
SPEAKER_01It's amazing.
SPEAKER_00It's the best.
SPEAKER_01It's the best. And with that, so and with that, you're going in with, I know more than Brian. Brian hasn't figured this stuff out yet. How am I gonna approach this conversation? Because this is an important moment here because I don't want to burn this bridge, but I really I know that my organization does not like this bill. Right. I know that my organization does.
SPEAKER_02The freedom and food bill. The freedom and food. Freedom and food. He's marketing it perfectly. Freedom and food.
SPEAKER_01Freedom and food. It's a super hot topic. Super hot. Super hot. So you go in and you look at Brian, and you're like, I'm not quite sure what to do here. And so what you do in order to facilitate conversation is you lean hard into curiosity. You lean the hardest you've ever leaned into curiosity, and you look at him and you thank him for the opportunity to meet, and then you say, Help me understand why this bill is important to you.
SPEAKER_01And like, how did you get here? And so Brian talks to you for 30 minutes. I'm not kidding. Brian talks to you for 30 minutes. He's an intense individual. He talks to you for 30 minutes.
SPEAKER_02Do I get to ask him questions? No, he just talks straight through.
SPEAKER_01He's an intense individual. He's intense. And as you're sitting there, something happens. Something happens while you're sitting there. And what happens is in that moment, there's a moment in that conversation that he's telling you this thing, where instead of seeing yourself above Brian, you see yourself in Brian. And what you realize is that you and Brian are both parents. You have that in common. Brian cares about his kids just like you do. Brian's kids are actually younger than yours. They're gonna be in the school system longer.
SPEAKER_01Yours are nearly half out the door. And in that moment, you switch from this guy drives me nuts to okay. Like I can see that we have an issue here. We do not agree on how to solve this issue, but I can understand why Brian is feeling this way. And in large measure, it's because I see myself and him. We have this thing in common. And so you engage in a conversation, you ask questions. Brian gives you an opportunity to share your perspective too, because not not that he asks you for it, but you say, Hey, I'd like to share my perspective too.
SPEAKER_01He says, Okay, he's ready to listen to it. But when it's all over, you know exactly what needs to be said. You stand up, you shake his hand, you thank him for the opportunity to meet, and then you say, you know, uh you know that we don't like your bill. And after this conversation, we want you to know that we're gonna come out and oppose your bill. So it's not that the conversation ended with you hopping on board anything with that piece of legislation, but you're gonna oppose that legislation. And Brian shakes your hand and he says, Okay, thanks for the meeting.
SPEAKER_01But because you had that conversation with Brian, like so now me, so this is a real thing. I had that conversation with Brian. I have now changed the the way that I thought and interacted with him in the conversation because I saw myself in him. I went from contempt from contemptuous thoughts, because I never use contemptuous language while we were in engaging, but I had contemptuous thoughts and I tried really hard to offer him, to honor his dignity, because he's a human being just like me.
SPEAKER_01Right? He has value just like I have value. He's got flaws, and so do I. But my flaws and his flaws don't take away from his value nor mine. So I honored his humanity in that moment. And then, as and and I think from that experience that I had, I earned his respect that day because I offered him dignity and I was honest with what we were gonna do next. Now, we did not engage in an outright war against that bill.
SPEAKER_01We just shared with our members why we disagreed with it and then encouraged them to contact their their lawmakers phone, email, text, however you want to do that. And because of that, you know, I later had my lawmaker, I saw him at the grocery store, saw him at the airport, had him on my podcast. And now when I see him at the Capitol, he smiles big time, comes up to me and is like, hey Alexis, how's it going? But I don't think that I would have had that moment.
SPEAKER_01I wouldn't be having these experiences with my lawmaker if I hadn't had that moment where I saw myself, where we had this thing in common, and I honored his humanity through my language. And by the way, he did the same for me. That is the power of language in using the dignity index.
SPEAKER_02I love that. You know, when you're I take the things you say seriously, so you're like, imagine. And I'm running this whole time through this scenario, and you're like, imagine partway through, you know, Brian's rant that you see yourself in him and you see yourself as a parent. And just, you know, here's a great example. The Freedom and Food Act. Yes, right, like this made-up build that I literally just made up five minutes ago. I could be sitting in front of somebody, a hundred percent Brian, and Brian's like, look, man, I've got little kids.
SPEAKER_02Okay. And to be clear, I'm not rich, which changes the curriculum or the analysis. Because when you realize that somebody who's advocating for something to like reducing social services or something, when you realize they're loaded, you're instantly like, oh, but when you find out that like, no, no, no, I'm not loaded. Like, I have five kids. We live in a three-bedroom house. Like, I probably qualify for this program, but I don't like it or I want to change it because so like I find out first Brian's not loaded. And then I'm like, oh, that takes a little bit of the edge off.
SPEAKER_02Then I also find out that he's got a bunch of kids, and his concern is that he has seen the way the federal government has been manipulating Idaho through, as our lieutenant governor Scott Betke once told me, perverse incentives. And he's like, they can get us. This is literally what our lieutenant governor told me. He's like, the federal government waves a carrot in front of our face with funding for something, and they're like, do this thing to get this thing. And he's like, Look, we if left to our own devices, we wouldn't want to take action X, but we want the purse of money over here.
SPEAKER_02So we engage in this action at times, not all the time, to get the funding, which is, again, talking about the federalism, something that that Professor Troy Smith was pointing out. He's like, the federal government can now get states to do all kinds of things they wouldn't do normally for the money. And Brian is really worried about this. And he's like, listen, if this keeps happening, by the time our kids are older, we won't have 50 states. We'll have one jello mold that's kind of that everyone wiggles just right when the federal government tells us to do something.
SPEAKER_02We have to start figuring out ways to cut that cord. And this is one that I see in front of us. And I can tell them, like, okay, I hear what you're saying. And I actually don't want that for my kids either. Like, okay, I hear what you're saying. Is there a way to do it without asking for this levy that, you know, obviously I think a lot of people will reject? He's like, I don't have one right now. I think this is important, and I have to tell them, I really appreciate you explaining this to me. I represent an organization that has members that do not like this.
SPEAKER_02And I am an upside-down funnel. I have to represent and act in a way that reflects them. I don't get to tell them what to think. I represent them. And so my organization will absolutely have to oppose this, but I really appreciate you explaining to me. And I hope for a better future for both of our sets of kids. God bless it, man. Right. Like I could have that conversation today and see exactly what you're talking about. And I would hope that Brian would say hi to me too.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02I could also see somebody being like, you're a monster. You're killing the kids. And then it's like, oh great, here we go. It's all over.
SPEAKER_01Well, and that I think that just kind of points back to we have a culture that has normalized contempt and disagreement. And we have to do something about it. And the way that we do something about it is create a new create a movement, a culture that inserts dignity into disagreement. Because I I really do love that dignity opens the door for conversation and dialogue, which then opens the door for continued democracy in the United States. And and I really like that idea. But um, it requires us to be able to say, um, I want, I can see this thing that's out there.
SPEAKER_01I see that I can I can start to see how language is being used in a way, you know, that's um that is contemptuous here. I'll give you the, I'll so you can see that in front of you. That is the dignity index match.
SPEAKER_02Why don't you guys do a scale to eight? Not that you did it.
SPEAKER_01I know. Why are you looking at me like why not, why not go to 12?
SPEAKER_02You know what?
SPEAKER_01They I think I asked that or someone asked that question once, and they were basically like, it's it gets hyper like hyper complicated. What's the purpose, right? We want people to be able to understand it. And I think from my perspective, the the I really like that at the end of the day, it's not about for me, it's not about the numbers, right? Like, oh, that was a three or that was a six. Like that's that's that's irrelevant to me as Alexis Morgan. What's relevant to me is what language am I using to engage with people?
SPEAKER_01And by the way, I can go up and down on the scale in one day. Like I'm not suggesting no one can live in an eight. Like if you look at that scale, no one could live in an eight. Like it's not possible to be up there all the time. Um, but am I making an intentional effort to try to be more thoughtful, more intentional, kinder in my language? How am I doing that? So when you look at that scale, the numbers four through one. So when you the closer you get to one, the more contempt you have, someone has in their language.
SPEAKER_01And by the way, for the record, this is looking at language and it is assessing language to understand. It is not a tool for judgment of people. Like full, like let's just get that out there. Okay. We are not judging people. We are assessing and understanding language so that we can see how that may or may not impact so that we as people can see how that impacts the situation. Arming, so what's really interesting actually is I I was having a conversation with someone and they were like, you know, there are these other, there are these organizations that they, you know, they talk like disagree better or braver angels.
SPEAKER_01There's organizations that offer a way for people to practice, you know, disagreeing and whatnot. And I have heard from people that they've said, oh, I really like the index because it gives me this thing to visualize. It's like a tool, like a measurement. That's what it is. It's a measurement scale. And it's a scale, by the way, that has been um research and tested. This is what I love about it. So a couple years ago, um, dignity.us partnered with um University of Utah and they did a uh, they, you know, did a research project in which they were, you know, there was a quant, it's quantifiable.
SPEAKER_01There, you know, they inserted credibility and reliability. All the things were built into this research project. And what they were able to see was that in fact, it is um uh I can't think of the language at the moment, and I feel silly for not being able to think of it. Um, you know, based on their like methodologies, they're able to generalize the findings from this, from this research. And what that shows then, I like this, I have my cheat sheet here, so I don't have to remember all this stuff.
SPEAKER_01Um, what it shows is that the dignity index was tested under academic oversight. So it's not theoretical, it's actually something that's been tested and proven. Independent scores could apply it consistently. So they had people scoring and practicing this, and it was applied consistently. The structure of the scale was refined. Here's the answer to your question based on data and feedback. So, based on data and feedback, that's why they came up with eight, right? And the tool functions in real-world contexts involving for them, they were looking at political context and active campaigns as well as personal reflection.
SPEAKER_01So the story I told you about, you know, my lawmaker and me as a as the state PTA president, that's personal reflection, right? So that's what's really cool about the index is that it's not just a way to observe the language, it's also a way to hold up a mirror and say, oh, like what am I doing here? So the other thing that I think is interesting when you look at that scale, and I'm trying to see if I have one in front of me because it's not like I have it. I mean, I know it, know it, but um, is that when you're at four, that's the language when you look at that.
SPEAKER_01Would you mind like so? What's the language of four?
SPEAKER_02And again, these are different quotes. Uh could I start with one and go to four just real fast? No, no, no.
SPEAKER_01Start at four, start at four and go down to one.
SPEAKER_02And four is orange. We're better than those people. They don't really belong. They're not one of us. Did you get this off Facebook recently?
SPEAKER_00Oh my gosh.
SPEAKER_02Somebody this morning's like, go back to California. You're not an Idaho. And I'm like, bless you, sir. Yeah. Okay, so that's at four. That's at four. Go to the four.
SPEAKER_01Which, like, which, by the way, I think that we can both like I've been there plenty.
SPEAKER_02Totally normalized. Totally normalized. Okay, number three. We're the good people and they're the bad people. It's us versus them. So four to three, four really starts establishing a cohesive group and othering people. And then you go down to valuing other people. So it's like we're an in-group, they're an out group, and then it's like, no, no, no, we're good people and they're bad people.
SPEAKER_03Yep.
SPEAKER_02Then two is those people are evil and they're going to ruin everything if we let them. It's us or them.
SPEAKER_01Us or them.
SPEAKER_02So now there's an existential risk, like real fundamental. Not just like we establish different groups and then we establish value sets. It's not just they're bad people, we existentially are in a crisis if they continue to exist here. And then finally, one is they're not even human. It's our moral duty to destroy them before they destroy us. Which yeah, I see that that's a real clear progression.
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm. Yeah. And it's not hard. I think it's it's when you start at four, you're like, yeah, I've totally been there. Can see myself doing that. I've used language like that. I mean, I've used I used language like that yesterday, you know.
SPEAKER_02I mean You did? Number four? We're better than those people. Alex is Morgan.
SPEAKER_01It's othering. It's othering people.
SPEAKER_00Who did you say that to?
SPEAKER_02Was it in your head? It's in my head.
SPEAKER_00It's in my head. Like the language in my head, I'm like, ugh.
SPEAKER_01You know, that's what I'm saying. That's the mirror effect, Matt. It's like, uh, and it's so but it's othering people. And that's really easy to do in politics. Our two-party system is really good at at facilitating that. And so the the thing that I like then about the dignity language is to say, listen, you're a human being, and I can honor that. I d and I love the statement, respect is earned and dignity is honored.
SPEAKER_01I don't have to like you. I don't have to like what you say. I don't have to, I don't have to like anything about you. And there's plenty of people that I don't for the record. There's plenty of people that I don't, but I can honor that they're a human being. And you know, I mentioned this to a day to the other day to a friend, a friend of mine who is a senior citizen, and she and I engaged in a lot of things. And as I was talking with her, I, you know, we were having a conversation about topics, and I all of a sudden I realized I was like, oh, we really disagree politically about this particular individual. It was an individual. And um, and I was trying really hard to use language that could like continued the conversation.
SPEAKER_01Didn't want to kill it. I like her, she's my friend, you know. I don't want to I don't want to tick her off or make it uncomfortable. Yeah. And so I I said, I was like, you know, this person, I don't like the way that they engage with people. I don't like the language that they use. I do like some of their policies. I can agree that some of their policies are good, but I cannot, I'm not gonna be able to support someone who engages in that way. I I personally am not gonna be able to do that. And she looked at me and she said, Okay.
SPEAKER_01And she, I mean, she was serious. She like got serious really fast. She goes, Alexis, what I hear from you right now is that you're someone who can disagree with me and uh and have it be like a normal conversation. We can actually, we can actually be friends. And I was like, whoop, glad I passed that test.
SPEAKER_02Don't you hate it when you realize you're being tested?
SPEAKER_01Well, I don't think that she was, but she was definitely listening to the words that I was saying. You know, and that was impacting how she was feeling in that moment. And what she was expressing was, I feel safe being with you because you're not gonna treat me like crap because I disagree with you.
SPEAKER_02That and that's such that used to be a thing that you could do like that. The big uh in the final in the build-up to the episode 1000, I had Monica Church on, right?
SPEAKER_03Yes.
SPEAKER_02And the the only time I had Monica on, like before that or something, was you know, the episode where we started going back and forth about bathroom stuff.
SPEAKER_01And by the way, people need to understand why that matters.
SPEAKER_02Right. So Monica, uh Monica is a Democratic representative, and uh not that that matters, but she she and I are friends, and she you know, has a very deeply entrenched family in in Idaho, both political and historical. And she's the best. She's great, and we are friends, and she doesn't take crap from anyone. And we go back and forth, and she is razor sharp and super quick and has great positions and We argue like friends.
SPEAKER_02We just happened to argue like friends on a podcast, and people freaked out. There were the I was literally getting text messages where people were like, Oh my God, are you guys frenemies? I'm like, no, we're just friends. Like, there's no frenemy here. We just don't see this eye to eye. And we go back and forth. And I had her on as is like, this is how you make friends. You don't have to agree with everything they say. And Monica and I go back and forth. There's this one episode, this is really terrible.
SPEAKER_02This is really embarrassing. Oh my gosh. She was advocating for more robust public transit systems.
SPEAKER_00I do remember.
SPEAKER_02In Idaho, yep. And she's like, we need to get transit so the people in Parma can get connected to the economic engine that's in Boise. And I was like, it's not my job to provide a job to somebody in Parma. And she was like, okay, Matt, like, you don't and like I was really snippy that day. I remember. I had like too much coffee or something. And I was like kind of making jokes and I was kind of being dismissive. And the more I thought about it and the more, because there was something that sat funny with me about that episode. And I started digging into public transit stuff. And then I started learning things like, hey, here's the thing.
SPEAKER_02People in Parma don't have a lot of economic opportunity. I'm like, okay, yeah, I understand that. Parma's not, you know, like an economic up. Like, right. But that means that the probability that somebody in Parma is going to be on some manner of social system is higher. And I was like, okay, they're like, so you can pay for social services and have somebody in Parma have fewer opportunities and you're going to pay for that. Or you could have tax dollars could go to increasing public transit.
SPEAKER_02Now, what the ROI is for the community, I don't know. Like, I don't know all these numbers. But that at least to me started bringing a shred of doubt to the confidence I erroneously had, where it was like, oh no, there's a financial calculus here. They're like, yeah, there's a financial calculus here. Right? Like, think about it. You connect people, like you have all these. And I apologized to Monica many times for that episode. And I started digging into other things. I started inviting public transit people on and transportation people in general, like civil engineers and like trying to understand what the transportation system is within the Treasure Valley.
SPEAKER_02And it's just uh I brought Monica up because she and I have a history of going back and forth, but we don't end the episodes and say, I'm never talking to you again. We like give each other a hug and she goes away and I go my way and like we just move on. It used to be that we could be friends and disagree. And I'm so happy that your friend, who seems to be coming from a different generation, is like, there we go. We can disagree. You're not gonna get mad at me, I'm not gonna get mad at you. It can be normal that we disagree and then we go and have lunch.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Yes. So I want you to start. Now you've got the scale in front of you. I want to I want you to share what the dignity side says in numbers five through eight.
SPEAKER_02Okay, and just to be clear, four is establishing an othering, three is establishing a value judgment based on the groups, two is establishing an existential crisis, and one is establishing all out war, we're all dead if we don't do this. Okay, so boom, boom, boom, boom. Five up. Five is the other side has a right to be here and a right to be heard. They belong here too. So we still have an othering system, but we establish that they have a right and we have an obligation to uh to uphold that right.
SPEAKER_02They can be here. It's okay, even though they're not us.
SPEAKER_01Yes. And and as an American, I would say, like simply because they're an American, they have a right to be right in a in a conversation, simply because they're a human being, they have a right to be here and and to have their perspective.
SPEAKER_02They have they we're gonna have a perspective.
SPEAKER_01They do. They have a right to their perspective. Yep.
SPEAKER_02Okay. Six, we always talk to the other side, searching for the values and interests we share. So we have the other side. We're not abolishing, we're not saying we're all one party, but we are starting to say, hey man, this is a Venn diagram. We're overlapping. And where's the overlap? Because I bet there's overlap here somewhere. So it's not just that the other side has a right to exist. It's we are the other side on certain issues. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So what are our shared values here?
SPEAKER_02Okay.
SPEAKER_01So you're leaning into curiosity for six.
SPEAKER_02Right. Where's that overlap? So seven, we fully engage with the other side, discussing even values and interests we don't share, open to admitting mistakes and changing our minds. So welcoming a dissolving of the values we hold, right, and barriers that we have placed. It's like, I think X and you think Y. It's like, yeah, but why do you think X? Yeah. And like, you know, X really was based on like some BS, like brrr.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Like let's let's talk about the disagreement because I'm okay that we still might not walk away with the same thing. And I'm actually okay changing my mind. You might say something that gets me to think about something different in a different way. And I'm okay to change my mind. I'm comfortable with that.
SPEAKER_02Okay. Eight, each one of us is born with an inherent worth, so we treat everyone with dignity no matter what.
SPEAKER_01So eight is eight is this incredible space where it's almost you're putting something on the line to acknowledge the humanity of someone else. So as a person, on an everyday basis, not every situation you could have an eight. That's not really necessarily possible.
SPEAKER_02Right. Somebody cuts you off in traffic and then flips you off. You're like, that's not an eight. In my head, I'm not an eight.
SPEAKER_01But um, one of my stories, uh, one of my favorite observations actually of this, like of dignity, and I would argue that it's an eight, um, starts with a teacher who's a leader in the Idaho Teachers Union and a guy who's a senator up in north central Idaho. And these two people um think very differently. They have very different perspectives on education. And the teachers union rep is a part of the negotiating team for her school uh for the school district, for the teachers union, okay, when they go and negotiate for the with the school board.
SPEAKER_01And she is aware that this particular senator has not been favorable to education policy in Idaho. She knows that. She's seen it, she's watched it. And so she reaches out to this senator and says, Hey senator, do you want to come watch our negotiations? Because technically they're open to the public. Do you want to come watch? Now, by the way, that's a risk because it might not go well. And so he says, Okay. Because he represents this area, you know, she falls within the area that he represents. So he comes down, she tells her superintendent, hey, by the way, this guy's got a couple, this guy's coming, and he's like, Ryan's coming.
SPEAKER_01Ryan's coming. And he's like, Are you serious? And she's like, Yes, I am serious. And he's like, Okay, okay, we're gonna make this work, it'll work. And so, anyways, this starts, it it ends up going well. It ends up going well. And so it starts this relationship between the senator and this teacher union rep. Now they still think very differently and they don't, they they do disagree on a lot of things, but they're starting to understand each other a little bit, they're starting to interact.
SPEAKER_01Well, now fast forward, I don't know, X number of years to, I don't know, uh one to two years, and there is a bill at the Idaho Capitol. And this bill is what's referred to. This is a real thing. Basically, people are calling it the anti-teacher union bill. This happened just this last legislative session, okay? And you can go see this. I mean, this is a matter of like public record, you can go see this. So it um this bill flies through, it goes through the House, passes the House side, comes to the Senate side.
SPEAKER_01It comes to the Senate committee that this senator chairs. He he's not sitting on this committee, he chairs, he chairs this committee. And in Idaho, a chair can hold a bill and not give it a hearing. So now he's in a hard spot because he's developed a relationship with this teacher and the teachers union. He values their perspective, though he may not agree with it. And he also has a relationship with the people in his party and at the Senate on the committee, and he's getting pressured hard.
SPEAKER_01He's getting pressured hard to let that bill have a hearing. And what he decides is that he's not gonna let it have a hearing because he believes that it will negatively impact his relationship with the teachers' union that he's trying to understand and build and create a better relationship with, but also build trust with. Because and so then the bill isn't, it doesn't get a hearing. But then the house side does their little magic on their house side, and they somehow get this bill and they insert this language into a bill that's already passed.
SPEAKER_02Oh, the radiator cap.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Okay. It's just called they do some little magic. It's called some magic. It's called some magic over there. And so now this bill is on the Senate side and it's being heard on the floor. Right.
SPEAKER_02And the the standard practice would be it goes through, let's say, a house bill goes through a house committee and then it goes to the house floor, the broader populace. They vote on it. If it passes there, then it goes to the Senate committee. If it passes out of committee, it goes to the Senate floor. But what the radiator cap did is because the House had passed it and it was being held in committee, they were able to take a different bill that was theoretically already passed, change up the language, insert this language, and circumvent the committee where this guy was holding it, and then it went to the Senate floor.
SPEAKER_01Yes. I'm so glad that you described the radiator cap, the magic that they the little stuff that they're doing.
SPEAKER_02Well, it's important because it's like, listen, we have this mechanism where you don't get to pass go. You have to go through the committee first, the germane committees that are supposed to have specialized knowledge and you have hearings and you have public commentary, that's where the public gets to come in and say, hey man, I really don't like this. When it's on the floor, you don't have public comment. You went, you don't get to address the assembly, right? You only get comment in the committee. And if it doesn't pass out of the committee, then it doesn't go. So there's a reason we go through that. It's part of the process. But this bill, in effect, dodged the committee where we would have public hearings and you have the uh the specialized, you know, knowledge base and it went straight to the overall body.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And so I'm kind of hearing about it from the side. You know, I uh did a little bit of social media stuff on it, uh, just kind of reporting about what is actually in this bill, right? So people kind of understand. So the bill is now on the Senate floor, and this Senate member who held that bill in his committee wouldn't let it be heard, has to vote on this. And so he stands, and you can find it. It was on um, it was on X. Someone pulled the segment and put it on X, and he basically stands and says, I'm voting no on this because if I vote yes, it will damage my relationship with the teachers union.
SPEAKER_01And I have built a rapport with them, and this bill in general is going to hurt our relationship with the entire teacher union. When he did that, he, from my perspective, used an aid in his language because he put himself on the line to raise the teachers union, the the teachers in our state, to make them at the same level that he did. And he did that at risk to himself politically. And what was so cool is I talked to the teacher afterwards.
SPEAKER_01She was t she was the one telling me, like, you can go look on Twitter, you can see this, or X, you can see this. And she said, Alexis, I had no idea he was gonna do that. He never reached out, he never asked, like, he just did that. And she goes, I was so overwhelmed with like immense gratitude sitting. She wasn't even in Idaho at the time, she was traveling somewhere else. She was like, I was, I couldn't believe what I saw. She felt so seen and heard and valued in that moment because of what he did, because of the rapport that they had established with each other.
SPEAKER_02That bill passed though, didn't it?
SPEAKER_01It did.
SPEAKER_02But he voted no and he said exactly why.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Yeah. And that to me is just like super awesome. And he has, you know what, he won his primary election. And so he um, you know, that election, then the um general's coming up in November, he'll likely win. And um, I've been working with that senator on a committee and to listen to him talk about his local constituents and um how he engages with people. Listen, I don't agree with some of the legislation that he supports or doesn't support.
SPEAKER_01Um, he and I diff disagree on a lot of things, but I I mean, I have come to respect him and how he converses because from my perspective, he works to use the language of dignity when he's interacting with people. And as a bystander, I appreciate seeing that. And that is what um that is what uh Americans want, by the way. 94% of Americans, they did the dignity.us did a survey um this year.
SPEAKER_01They released it, it's called the dignity barometer. Anyone can go check it out. And they asked, you know, that we needed to get a baseline. How you know, like a baseline on dignity, because in in changing the culture, you have to know what the baseline is to try to, you know, are we improving? Are we moving the needle? 94% of Americans believe that we that everyone should be treated with dignity. 94% of Americans believe we deserve that. That's a huge number. 94%. Only 31% actually believe that is happening.
SPEAKER_02Oh, yeah. And the 94%, what percent of them are on Facebook talking trash to people?
SPEAKER_01Well, so that's the other thing. They actually asked, um, there was a question about self-perception versus personal experience. And when they asked that question, they said, you know, how often do you do you treat others? 23% said always.
SPEAKER_02Okay, so people know, like, hey man, this is the target. Like, I'm on a diet, I know I shouldn't have the ice cream, but dang it, like four days out of the week I eat the ice cream.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Do you may I ask like I've been thinking about this as you as you're talking through these and as we went through this grading scale, that uh Daryl, um, it's like Daryl Hayes or something, uh, the African-American gentleman is very famous because he's converted like 200 plus Ku Klux Klan people. Um and I I saw this um converted them away or two.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_02Not two, not two, but he's I've heard I've heard of this guy.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_02And I I heard about him when I was in high school. I watched this documentary on TV back when you watched the telly.
SPEAKER_03TV.
SPEAKER_02And he's a jazz, I was also in jazz band, he's a jazz musician, like incredible pianist. And he goes through this whole story about this guy comes up to him and he's like, I can't, like, this music was incredible. Like, I've never he asked me if you can buy him at Drake. He's like, Yeah, you buy me a cranberry juice, and he's sitting there talking to him. And the guy lets on that he's in the clan. And he's like, that's so interesting. Why? Like, Daryl leans in and like, why? And goes into, you know, oh, you know, a bunch of crazy racist thoughts, right? Like, oh, the the the you know, you want to come after, you know, white women or something. The guy's like, no, like I've I've got no interest.
SPEAKER_02Like, what what do you mean? So he develops this rapport, doesn't fight people. But one of the I listened to a recent interview where it was a two-person interview, so it was him and this guy, it was on a Rogan, and I highly recommend you check it out. But it was this guy who was part of, you know, this clan group way up top, right? And like was very nationally recognized and can, you know, had recruited all these people into this, you know, hyper racist movement.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And Daryl offers to meet with him. And so they go out to this restaurant and it's like this cafe, and they sit down, and it's like, because you're sitting down at a cafe, like you can't start it at 10, right? So it's like, hi, how are you? And it's like the the conversation's going, and the guy, the clan member, lets on that he realizes he's losing control of this thing because he was planning to come in and like get crazy and like really toe the line. And here this guy's like, oh no, the blueberry pancakes are awesome. Like, you should definitely like a normal person, right?
SPEAKER_02Totally disarming. So the guy says that in this is he recounting, he like slams his hand on the table and he's like, I will not let your people continue battering, blah, blah, blah, this stuff. And Gerald just looks at him. He's like, Okay, well, do you want more coffee? And just totally lets the moment hang and then continues on with a human interaction. And the guy was like, What do I have to do to get like a rise out of this guy?
SPEAKER_02I have thought about that a lot because, you know, obviously, the more interactions we have online, the crazier we think people are. Now, mind you, I don't go out in the world very much, and I certainly don't talk like very intense things with people, but I find myself in conversations with people in person, and it's like there's no world where somebody could say the crazy things that they do uh online in your face. It's like I've had people say wild things, and I just go, What do you mean?
SPEAKER_03Yep.
SPEAKER_02And they're ready for some fighting. They're like, Well, I mean this. I'm like, well, I I understand, but like, how do you mean?
SPEAKER_03Yep.
SPEAKER_02And they're like, oh. And they're like, well, what I mean is blank better. It's like, okay, is that related to this? Or like, yeah, actually, it's kind of related to that. I'm like, well, isn't they like, well, yeah, you know, and all of a sudden you're in this back and forth because there's timing, there's uh, you know, body positioning, there's facial movement, there's all of these things that dra that oblige you to meet somebody as a person when you're in person. And you can't let a moment hang online. Like I got some crap comment last night. I can't like let the moment hang and let them reflect on me just staring at them.
SPEAKER_02Like they don't get that input back. They're just like, aha, I called him a liar. He's terrible, he's destroying Idaho. And it's like that comment just sits there as if it's being uttered for the first time in that second, whenever you're viewing it. And you know, I know a lot of people talk about online discourse. I get that, but it's it's like if we want dignity and we want to stay online, there's gotta be a way that people find their way to offering this style of communication, even in the face of a one online.
SPEAKER_02And I've been like the last 48 hours, again, there's a lot of stuff going on in in Idaho right now, especially around abortion, which is a supercharged topic. And so many people are like, You're lying, Saka. And I continue writing. I was like, How do you mean? Like, what is it? Like, just tell me what if I've made an error, just let me know what is it? And they're like, it's in your comment. I'm like, can you just tell me exactly what the comment was that I made? And then they quote them like, no, no, no, I said this right there. And they're like, Oh, I suppose you did say that. I'm like, yeah.
SPEAKER_02And like, by the way, like this is, you know, whatever. And it's very exhausting. And it's like on my end, it's not very like what I'm typing is not what I'm feeling.
SPEAKER_01But that's yes, that's kind of the art the that is one of the harder things, I think, is that it can, when you're online, it is emotionally exhausting, right? Like, we I'm looking at this data in terms of like where uh the perceptions of dignity in subcultures and you refer to online social media platforms, it is the lowest of where we can see dignity in a subculture. So um 10% believe that there are high levels of dignity online. It's our lowest, versus like 54% would say like in their immediate family, high levels um of dignity.
SPEAKER_01But your example points to um what we also know is true about dignity is that when you have dignity and you have it right next to contempt and you shine a light on both of them. Bright light, dignity must retreat because it's so disgusting and revolting. Excuse me, contempt must retreat because it is so disgusting and revolting. Dignity is what stays. People like it, it feels good, it feels um uh what's the word? Like natural.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_01Right. So when you've got dignity and contempt right next to each other, which you are just that's what you're describing online, and someone is throwing out contempt with their language, because that's all we have right on social media, and you're you're leaning into curiosity, you're offering them dignity, contempt has to retreat because it's so gross and disdained.
SPEAKER_02They're like, oh in public, in the public eye, in the shining the bright light.
SPEAKER_01In the shining the bright light on it, but also in our social settings too. So that's the other thing about contempt and dignity that is super interesting. I experienced this the other night. Someone, um, uh Clinton, that's my husband. We um we'd gotten together and uh we were conversing with a friend and we were talking about this topic, and uh, you know, we kind of meandered into uh I wouldn't say it's a hot topic, but it's a you know, muddy one. It's tough. And so we're talking about it.
SPEAKER_01And Clinton and I are kind of sitting there, and you know, the our friend, we're all kind of engaging in this way. And then my friends. Says, I really wanted to say this thing, but gosh, I'm just noticing like how much kindness you two are offering people who think differently than you. And she goes, I don't feel like I can say the thing that I was originally gonna say. And so super vulnerable, right? Like she's being really honest. But I was like, Oh, well, you can like what what do you mean? Like, you know, I lean into curiosity.
SPEAKER_01You're like, how do you mean? Like, what do you mean? And like she then did, she figured out a way to say it. And by the way, I thought she was too hard on herself. I'm like, nah, I don't really think that was that bad, right? But in that moment, it was like, oh my gosh, my friend's telling me what she's thinking in her head, which is when dignity is out there, contempt doesn't want to come play if you're right in this little subgroup as friends, because it doesn't feel good, because it's not being uh it's not being valued.
SPEAKER_02You know, and I've what you're describing, I've seen um if you're hanging out with a bunch of people that are being polite and nice to offer something nasty, I completely agree with you. You're like, you can't. You can't like it, you just nobody wants to do that. Like you'd be looked at like, what are you doing? Right? Like you'd be socially maladaptive, right? 100%. And I've also experienced where I'm being negative with a group of people, and somebody's like, you know what? I thought it was very good food.
SPEAKER_02And then you feel shame. I was we're I this was uh I we were talking about a wedding menu, like, and somebody's like, I thought the salmon was very good. And I was like, uh. So it's I mean, again, you can go up, yeah, and then it pulls everyone else up. You're like, oh gosh, shut up about the salmon. And you also can't go down because people were like, oh, the salmon's so great. Yeah, dude, and the steak was good too, and we got a little piece of steak and salmon, and somebody's like, it was trash.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_02Everybody would look at that person and be like, I'll eat yours. Yeah, like whatever. But here's the But you can go up, but you can't go down if you have a light on both.
SPEAKER_01Right, right. And so here's the thing. Let's say, like, you know, you and I come together, because we are, and we're having a conversation. And when we're together and we're having a conversation, it's like, wow, like two people that let's say we deeply disagree on a topic, but it's like, wow, and we're there's a few other people in the room, and it's like, wow, wow, I I didn't think that we could have this experience together. But then you and I go back to our different subcultures where contempt is honored and that's all we use. And so then this moment that we've had is over because we're not taking it into the spaces in which we live on a regular basis, which is why we need people to have the courage to honor the dignity of other people.
SPEAKER_01And by the way, people want it. So there's two books that I highly recommend. I have them here so you can see. Um, this one is called Dignity by Um Donna Hicks. Um, I've listened to her speak. She's incredible. She is a um conflict resolutionist, an international conflict resolution.
SPEAKER_03International.
SPEAKER_01International. Um, you know, and one of the things that she talks about is that when in her uh as she's going through, you know, conflict resolution with people, this was the thing that she saw. She said she could see, you know, like she's interacting with Middle East, you know, areas of high conflict. And she noticed that people could be agreeing, like, okay, we're gonna come to this agreement, right? So they're this far, and then they're coming here and here and here. And then all of a sudden, one side does something, like, and the other side goes, forget it.
SPEAKER_01I'm not participating in this anymore. Peace out. And she's like, what just happened here? Like, what was the thing? And she noticed it different times. And the thing that she saw that was the deciding factor that could ruin it all was when someone did not honor the humanity of the person sitting across from them, when they were dehumanized in some way. They just that was it.
SPEAKER_02It's it just stops and tracks. It stops and it tracks.
SPEAKER_01So then the other book that I highly recommend is called Love Your Enemies by Arthur Brooks. Love this guy. Um, he came to Boise State a couple of years ago, and I listened to his to him speak, and he he talked about um how he grew up in Seattle in a very liberal family, um, how he is now a conservative.
SPEAKER_02Um, and you know, just Thanksgivings must be rough. Woof woof woof.
SPEAKER_01And he was saying that the thing that's interesting about um the thing. Oh, sorry.
SPEAKER_02I'm sorry. I I want I was showing you the clock. I want to honor your time. Yeah, yeah, yeah. No, I appreciate that. I'm sorry, I totally just screwed you up. Arthur Brooks, okay, Seattle Lib. And now it's conservative.
SPEAKER_01Now he's a conservative. So we was here at Boise State um and because Boise State had brought him in to speak. And as he's talking and talking about how can he's the one that basically says contempt is our problem. Contempt is our issue. Uh, we live in what he refers to the outrage industrial complex, meaning that the system that is built around us is designed to outrage, outrage, foster the contempt, right? Build it, grow it, all the things. Um, and so he talks about, you know, ways to confront and deal with that.
SPEAKER_01Um, and so the language then of Donna Hicks of dignity, right? That that's what that's the word that we honor the humanity of other people. What was interesting for me is I'm sitting there, and this is something that I think this was like four years ago I heard him speak um three or four years ago. He he said, you know, one of the things that I've started to do when I'm with a group of people, he's like, okay, I'm a Republican and I'm with Republicans, and then they start talking negatively about Democrats. He's like, I've started to think about that's my brother Joe that you're talking about.
SPEAKER_01That's my uncle Sam that like I sit across on the dinner dinner the Thanksgiving table. The person that that you're demonizing, that's my relative. And he said one of the things that he said that initially I was like, that's kind of an odd way to think about it. He was like, start personalizing the things that people are saying that might help you as the individual see that there's a problem with the language. So what's interesting is that I have my oldest son, he and I, we have a lot of things that we agree on politically.
SPEAKER_01And he's done, I think he and I both have done a good job like navigating, like, oh, where do we agree? Where do we disagree? All those things. But um he the other day sent me, um, he sent our family a scr uh a picture of a letter that he got that he is now a part of uh, you know, a particular political group. And I will tell you that it is different from mine. And it is a political group that I think um in some measure has been demonized. Um and uh so it was so interesting because the other day I heard someone say something real terrible um take a moment, something really terrible about this political group.
SPEAKER_01And I did what Arthur Brooks said, and I thought, that's my kid you're talking about. And that's not how I see and experience my kid. And so what I did was um to shoe, thank you. Um what I did was, and this is what these are like simple things that people can do, are when you're on social media and you're scrolling and you know you follow an account that it's just really kind of contemptuous, they're always othering or verse oring people, unfollow.
SPEAKER_01Don't give those people the platform to be able to continue the contempt. I know people I I heard someone the other day say, um, you know what I did? I uh unsubscribe from a newsletter. You know, some of the stuff in there is good, but the language that's really used doesn't resonate with the values that I have. So I'm not going to engage with it. And the more that we do that, the more that we build a um a movement of dignity, the more that we and and that for me, like when I think about the thing that pulls us all together, right?
SPEAKER_01Whether we're in the education space or politics or community or faith or wherever, wherever you live and love to spend your time, the thing that pulls us all together is the fact that we are Americans and that we have this constitution, and in a little bit over a decade, we will celebrate the 250th anniversary of our US Constitution. And our constitution demands that we figure out how to work together so that we can continue in this you know democratic republic that we have.
SPEAKER_01We need people to figure out how to disagree better. And we need, and that means for us at at dignity.us that we honor the dignity of others.
SPEAKER_02I say we end on that, Alexis Morgan. God bless you. Thank you for coming in and explaining this.
SPEAKER_01Thanks for giving me the opportunity. I appreciate it.
SPEAKER_02First of many.
SPEAKER_01And that's a wrap for today's episode of the Purple Zone. Thanks for being here. If you liked what you heard, leave a review on your fave podcast app or on YouTube. And from me to you, the heart of the purple zone says community is where policy comes to life.
Send us Fan Mail Should phones be allowed in school at all? And what about the laptops? In this episode, Alicia Purdy, an Idaho educator, talks about cell phone and technology policy in her local school district. Across...
Send us Fan Mail Roughly 85% to 93% of Idaho's incorporated towns and cities are considered rural, depending on the population threshold used. About 70% of our school districts are rural too. Yet people in rural...
Send us Fan Mail What if helping the young people in your life had nothing to do with being an expert? Dr. Megan Smith, a professor at Boise State University and executive director of Communities for Youth, joins the...
Send us Fan Mail Alexis Morgan tells the story of The Civility Project. In 2019, after an opinion piece hurt the Nez Perce Tribe, three leaders of the Lewiston Tribune set out to confront incivility in their own...
Send us Fan Mail What does it take to turn an issue into legislation? Time? Relationships? Listening? The AI in Education workgroup is highlighted in turning an issue into public policy. In this episode, Alexis Morgan...