Send us Fan Mail Alexis Morgan welcomes Will Goodman, Director of People and Organizational Services for Boise School District, to unpack the Idaho journey of AI in Education legislation and why Idaho is leading the nation on guardrails and implementation. They talk candidly about the question many people are asking: Is this a good move, or a potential risk? They dive into the process behind Senate Bill 1227, including the work group work and how the bill ultimately moved through the 2026 legislative session. From there, the conversation gets practical: what implementation actually looks like on the ground, and how Idaho is working to answer the “now what?” for schools. The episode covers educator impact, student impact, the parent perspective, and industry perspective, including the most common concerns like misinformation, data privacy, and the difference between screen time and AI. Will and Alexis explore what we’re actually worried about when AI enters classrooms, and they end by reinforcing the episode’s guiding theme: AI is already here, so the goal is human-centered guardrails: first, middle, and last...including clear boundaries for what should never be automated in schools. Find Alexis on Instagram and JOIN in the conversation: https://www.instagram.com/the_idaho_lady/ JOIN the convo on Substack & STAY up-to-date with emails and posts https://substack.com/@theidaholady?r=5katbx&utm_campaign=profile&utm_medium=profile-page Send Alexis an email with guest requests, ideas, or potential collaboration. email@thealexismorgan.com Find great resources, info on school communities, and other current projects regarding public policy: https://www.thealexismorgan.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Hey friends, welcome to the Purple Zone, where public policy, practice, and people meet. Because policy isn't abstract, it's personal. So let's talk about it. Hey friends, welcome to the show. It's Alexis. And today I have Will Goodman, who is the director of, I'm looking at my paper already, director of people and organizational services at the Boise School District. Welcome, Will, back to the show.
SPEAKER_02Thank you so much. Happy to be here.
SPEAKER_01Um, the last conversation that we had, I will tell you that people just really appreciated. You did such a good job breaking down. I think we we talked about, I mean, tech in general, maybe some AI stuff, um, some things that you and I were working on in a work group together. And I know that I have had other parents since listen to some of your presentations and they just thoroughly enjoy how you break technology and you know, these different components that are impacting our kids, how you break it down to stuff that just makes it's like common sense for everyone.
SPEAKER_01Like, oh, I get it now because sometimes it's so confusing. So that's why I'm so I'm really grateful you came back on the show so we can talk about kind of an update about what's happening around AI in public education.
SPEAKER_02Awesome. Great to be here. And thanks for saying that. I really appreciate it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you're welcome. Okay, so basically, what I kind of wanted to start with was how we got here in the first place. And um, you fill in any of the gaps that are here. But essentially, on the on the most basic level, uh, you and I got asked to be a part of a work group that Senator Kevin Cook put together because he wanted to create a piece of legislation around AI and education. He felt that Idaho had the potential to be a leader in AI when it came to uh education and making sure that our kids were ready for the workforce.
SPEAKER_01So uh a large group of stakeholders came together for that work group. And I think that that's significant to note because when we have like the key stakeholders at the table creating legislation and then getting feedback from the various uh, you know, other groups, we can create some really good public policy, I think. Uh and so we did that, and then that legislation passed, and that legislation directed uh the Department of Ed and the Board of Education to essentially uh create a framework in which school districts could create their own uh policy around AI and at their local school district, and also to create standards around AI in classrooms in our K-12 system.
SPEAKER_01And so where we are right now on that is that the AI framework has been um has it's been adopted, hasn't it? Isn't that what they say?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, a couple of weeks ago or maybe a week ago, the state board approved it. So it is now official um and available for districts to start using.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and then they're um they put together, the Department of Ed put together um AI standards. So they brought in different adults. I know that um I had a friend that was a parent on one of the work groups, and so they created K-8 AI standards that they integrated into technology standards, which we'll talk about. And then they also made 9 through 12 uh AI standards in education. And those right now just had their first reading with the Board of Education, and they will have a second reading, and I believe it's after the second reading that it's then open to the public for 21 days.
SPEAKER_01That's gonna happen in October, and then they will have their third reading make the you know various adjustments and then likely adopt the standards.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's correct. And I actually sat on the junior high portion of that, so I helped write the six, eight component of those standards. And um, those also then do go to the legislature. So the legislature will have to approve um the rule that was adopted with those. But I think it's a great set of standards.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Um so it it in anyways, like talking about it though, it's a lot. Like it's not just, hey, we want to do this and then we're gonna do it. There's a big long process that goes into this. And one of the things that I kind of wanted to pull out as we uh get started is the and and anyone can access this. This is the framework. It's called the Generative Artificial Intelligence and Education Framework that's available. You can go find it. You literally just type that into just type in the AI framework Idaho, and it will, you'll be able to find the PDF.
SPEAKER_01But one of the things that was interesting to me was the historical timeline for AI. That um I kind of was one of these people, admittedly, sometimes I feel like I don't know anything. And AI to me was, you know, as it was as if it popped up in 2022. Um, and what I like about this framework, uh, what's inside here is that they give this historical timeline. And it talks about how as early as the 1940s, researchers were exploring the foundations of machine intelligence and computer-based problem solving.
SPEAKER_01And in the 1960s, there were some of the first uh adaptive tutoring systems that emerged. And by the 2000s, it says that AI was quietly powering tools such as GPS navigation, recommendation engines, uh, fitness trackers, search engines, and digital assistance. But the public's awareness of AI came dramatically with the release of Chat GPT in the late 2022. Um and then in the rapid adoption that everyone used uh in 2023.
SPEAKER_01And so generative AI marks a significant shift. It says in here from systems that primarily analyzed information to systems capable of creating new content, including text, images, audio, video, and code. And so this is why they then say it is increasingly important for educators and students to understand the foundations of artificial intelligence, how these systems work, and how they can be used responsibly, effectively, and ethically.
SPEAKER_01And to me, I mean, I started as a history teacher, and I am like, yes, when we understand the context, often the historical context of how we got here, I think it helps uh in the conversation.
SPEAKER_02I also started as a history teacher. Oh, you did? Yeah, I was taught history for about 10 years.
SPEAKER_01Oh my gosh, and then you shifted over into technology. Oh, that's fascinating. Did you feel like you just really connected with his historical timeline then?
SPEAKER_02I did. I think one, I think it's super important to kind of show that it's been around for a long time, that it's not something new. Um, it's something researchers and data scientists and computer programmers have been using for a long time. And for all the rest of us, we've been using it whether we knew it or not. And I think the most obvious example is predictive text, right? When you're texting somebody you know and it's filling in the next words, um, that's a form of AI that we've all been using and we didn't really know we were using it. But um, yeah, I think the historical perspective is huge. And it was, you know, it, if nothing else, it shows that it didn't really come out of nowhere.
SPEAKER_02It's had a lot of research behind it. I remember growing up the first time I really remember hearing about it was I think it was deep blue, was playing chess against masters, and for the first time a computer beat a chess master. Um, and that I think was in the late 90s, or might be early 2000s. Yeah. Um, and that was uh I think that was when I first really kind of knew about AI, that it was out there and that it was computers thinking um kind of for themselves and making decisions about what they do next. And that was a huge breakthrough when IBM was able to get a computer able to do that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I think I remember that and thinking having no vision of the future, like not even having any type of thought as to what that would look like next. That was I mean, that was me in the late 90s, high high school, high school, high school version of Alexis in the late 90s. So um I want to ask if you had to explain if you had to explain Idaho's like overall philosophy about AI in education, how do you how would you explain that?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, uh I think there's the biggest one that I pull out of the framework and about the work that we did is it's human first. Everything we're doing is about human first. And then the second part of it is we're trying to do what's best for students. So we want to make sure that whatever we're doing is empowering students to be as successful as possible when they leave the education system. And of course, that's always a little bit up in the air because things do change very quickly. But the way it's looking right now, our students to be the most successful are gonna be using AI every day. Um, they're gonna be using it in their personal lives, they're gonna be using it in their work lives, and it's gonna be incorporated into what they do.
SPEAKER_02And and we saw from some company polls that you know the people currently losing their jobs right now are not losing it to AI. They're losing it to people who know how to use AI. And if that trend continues, we're gonna need to make sure our students know how to use AI as productively as possible, but also as safely and ethically as possible so that they're best prepared to be competitive when they enter the job market.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I felt, I mean, I was um at the table, I uh kind of from the parent perspective, not because I know anything about AI in that way. And um the thing, one of my biggest takeaways was that it's important not to move based on fear. And that was kind of one of the things that I took away from the overall experience was that we're not coming at this from from a position of fear, and we're not trying to scare people when it comes to AI in the future. So I really like how you said it's not, you know, because a lot of people I feel like I've seen on social media, they talk about how AI is coming for your job.
SPEAKER_01Like AI is coming for your job. And I think that that's such a terrible way to put it. And I'm not here promoting AI, but I think that um to your point, there's value in understanding it because that's how, you know, the it is being used and it will continue to be used.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I wish I had the source here, but it could probably be looked up. There's a chart which has a list of jobs on it, and on one axis of the chart, it's um susceptibility to being replaced by AI. And then on the other axis, it is um the ability to adapt to AI. And so it has on there some jobs which are very susceptible to AI and very difficult to adapt. Things like call center workers, which you know, they don't have a lot of adaptability in the job skills for a call center worker, and AI can do that job relatively easy.
SPEAKER_02But then on the other end, which might be surprising, are things like graphics designers and computer programmers who are very susceptible to AI, but also very adaptable, meaning that their careers likely will survive any kind of influx to AI. And again, with all this, we don't want to make people scared or worried about their future, but we also want them to be prepared. And so how do we make sure they're steering towards professions, you know, as we help them with their career counseling and selecting where they're going in college, that they're moving towards careers that are, I'm not gonna say safe from AI, but are adaptable to AI.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, and I think about, I mean, like just even in terms of history, I think about like the industrial revolution, right? Like we know that different pieces of technology have been integrated over time. And as humans, we have had to adapt how to use them, make adjustments in the choices that we make in terms of the skills that we learn so that we can, you know, make a living and provide for our families.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_02And I might have said this on the last podcast. I can't remember, but that's okay. It's okay.
SPEAKER_00If you're repeated.
SPEAKER_02Uh there was an education futurist that was talking about AI when it first really was coming out, and he talked about how, just to your point, that when the assembly line came out and the automobile was coming out, there was a lot of fear that it was going to replace all blacksmiths and the blacksmiths would go out of work. And it wasn't necessarily wrong. Um, there's very few blacksmiths left. There are still blacksmiths, but not like there were prior to the assembly line and the car, Henry Ford, and all of that process. But when Henry Ford kind of revolutionized that process, he also created a lot of industries that didn't exist or greatly expanded them.
SPEAKER_02Glass making, uh, upholstering for the seats of the cars, metalwork, um, assembly line work. He created a lot of other professions. Um, and what we saw out of it was actually more people working, not less. And then the same thing happened in the 80s with computers and accountants. When the personal computer was suddenly available, there were a lot of people talking about how this will put accountants out of business. We will no longer need accountants, the computer will do it all. And what actually happened is we have more accountants per capita today than we had before the computer came out. And the job is just very different than it was before the computer, but we still have a lot of accountants.
SPEAKER_02And I think we'll see the same thing with AI. We'll see jobs that do actually go away or mostly go away, but I think we'll see new industries, new jobs created, and we'll see other jobs just completely changed. And there'll still be a job, but it just won't be done in the same way it was done in the past.
SPEAKER_01Gosh, you just say it so well. You say it so well, Will. I'm so glad you're here talking about this with me today. So, first I wanted to um I want to talk about like what Boise is doing because you know, you're this, um you have this really long title here, and that includes um it includes the technology piece. So I'm curious when we're when you're looking at Boise and we're looking at policies, does Boise school district already have an AI policy or is that still being developed? Do you know?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so we uh intentionally chose not to develop an AI-specific policy for a couple of reasons. Uh, and this will change with the framework. So this will have an upcoming change to that. But in the initial phases, we decided not to go with a policy because AI was changing so quickly. And anything a student did that they shouldn't be doing with AI, we already had other policies that covered it. So if they were using it to cheat, we have an academic honesty policy about cheating and plagiarism. Um, we have policies around computer use and what's appropriate or not. We have bullying uh policies around bullying and harassment that AI could be used to do.
SPEAKER_02So everything a student could do that was negative with AI, we already had policies that covered. So we thought it was safer to stick with our policies that are already in place than it was to try to constantly adapt a policy specific to AI. Um, the other thing we started waiting for was the framework. We knew the framework was coming, we knew that it was going to dictate some of the policies that would be appropriate. And well, now that that's passed, we're gonna look at that and we will develop an AI policy that fits within the framework, but then is also adaptable for the future.
SPEAKER_01So um I do know that within the policy there was a template that was offered to school districts. Do you think that policy um do you think that Boise will eventually like just kind of create their own though, based on something and not just a straight up template that's there?
SPEAKER_02What I think will probably happen, but I don't know this for sure, is um so the Idaho School Boards Association, they often will take model legislation or model policies. They will adapt them for Idaho. This one's already Idaho specific, but when other ones come around, um, they will adapt those and then they'll publish those out to schools so that schools can take it and kind of make it their own, whatever fits. So with the there's kind of a year to implement a policy per the framework. And so we'll be looking to see what ISBA does, we'll be looking at what other school district does, and then we'll kind of decide whether that fits our model.
SPEAKER_02So some districts don't want to use AI or want to kind of limit it, so they might have a more strict policy than what we develop. We're looking to not ban it, we just want to make sure students are using it safely and ethically, and then within the framework, which has some really important pieces about what grade levels different students can access different components.
SPEAKER_01And how does the ball uh the Boise School District navigate creating their policy when it comes to stakeholders within the district?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so we have a policy committee. So our policy committee is made up of stakeholders, and they meet and they draft policy, they look at policy changes that we might need to make, they then promote that up to um what's called a governance committee, which has three board members on it, and we have seven, so um has three of our board members on it, they then review it and then they will recommend it to the full board for the board to approve it. So there's a and then at the full board meeting, anybody who wasn't involved in the process before then, so if you weren't one of the stakeholders on the policy committee, we have open public comment. So anybody can come and comment on the policy and what it will look like.
SPEAKER_01And are parents a part of that stakeholder process?
SPEAKER_02Yes.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Okay, that's good to know. I just wanted to make sure I added that in there since I do a lot of parent stuff. So um another question. So when Boise, so like as you're gonna be evaluating, so let's talk about AI tools for a minute. So as Boise evaluates AI tools, um, what happens before a student or teacher is allowed to use it? I know we're kind of going from policy to tools, but this is just Boise specific.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so in Boise, we kind of break our students up into three groups. We have elementary, junior high, and high school, and we do different policies basing on based on their grade level. So Gemini, for example, um, we don't allow Gemini's use for um elementary or junior high. So high school and for Boise, high school starts in 10th grade. So in 10th grade is the first time our students can use Gemini. Um what is Gemini? Sorry, Gemini is Google's version of, say, ChatGPT. It's a generative AI. Um and then they've also incorporated Gemini into several of their tools like Google Docs.
SPEAKER_02So if a student goes into Google Docs, um if they're a tenth grader, Gemini is there to help or assist or to answer questions. But at the younger grades, we've turned that feature off uh so that they weren't be able to use that. And then sorry, excuse me.
SPEAKER_00Um the air has been terrible for weeks. Sorry.
SPEAKER_02Um for for investigating a new tool. So one of the great things the framework points out and that the AI standards point out is you don't actually need technology to teach about AI. And so at our youngest grades, our students can learn about AI, the logistics, the history, um, what it is or isn't, um, identifying when they're talking to it versus a real person, all of that can be taught without the students using AI. And so we have very, very limited use at the elementary level. And as far as generative AI goes, because we talked about the other types like predictive and things that are built in, spell check and stuff.
SPEAKER_02But as far as generative AI or chatbots, our elementary students don't have access to it. Um and but we're still going to be teaching them about AI, and we'll still be teaching them to the standards. They just won't be using the chatbots. And then when they move into junior high, we've have a product which allows students to use a chatbot, but it's uh what I call a walled garden, or some people call a walled garden, where it's a protected, safe environment that's student safe. Um, it's got a lot of uh policies around it about what students can or can't ask. It alerts the teachers if students ask it to do inappropriate things.
SPEAKER_02Um, an example of an alert we saw last year was where a student kept trying to get it to write a paper for them and it kept saying no. And then after about the fourth time it had to tell them no, it just told the teacher that the student's trying to make me cheat. Um the teacher could go address it with the student.
SPEAKER_00Oh, fascinating.
SPEAKER_02And so we have that available upon when the teachers want the students to use it. So that product's available. And then at high school is when they can start using Gemini, which is kind of our chosen product for the high school level. And the reason we picked Gemini to begin with was it also has an education-safe environment. So we know none of the student data is getting out of it. Um, it's not being used to train any of the models, so it's safe is from a privacy standpoint. Um, and then we can monitor it. So we have access to every question that gets asked by a student, we can review those, and then there's safeguards for those.
SPEAKER_01Oh, wow. That's there's a lot of things that you just said, which I really appreciate. Um, one of the things that you said made uh was when I was sitting in one of the work groups and uh one of the Department of Ed employees was talking about uh she was going over the framework and then she went over the standards. And one of our uh lawmakers was on the call, and he um is uh he's a he is essentially not a fan of technology, I could see, and then also um is kind of he's he's weary of some things I could tell.
SPEAKER_01And so it was really interesting when he said, Okay, well, but some of our schools and specifically some of our charter schools in the state that are in elementary don't use computers. So how are we supposed to have these AI standards with computers? And to what you just said, her comment was you can actually teach these things without in in the elementary ages without the use of a computer. And he went, Oh, okay. Like, I mean, it just totally satisfied that, you know, curiosity.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah, I think it's fascinating that there's so much about how AI works or what it does and what it is or isn't that it can all be taught without a computer. So our classical academies that are out there um can, just to your point, um, can still hit all the standards without ever having to have kids on a computer.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think it's a really cool. I think it's really cool. Um, okay. So um I want to move into um teachers. Oftentimes I wait until the teacher component at the end and I feel like I have to hurry and go kind of go through the teachers. But I do have a lot of teachers that listen to the show. Um, and you know, they're really curious about what this looks like for them. And then also parents, I think, are curious about what this is gonna look like, you know, in the classroom from the teacher's lens uh lens.
SPEAKER_01So right now, just based on kind of like what you're seeing, what what has been your observation, not just necessarily in Boise, but things that you hear around the state. What's the emotional landscape for teachers right now? Do you think they're excited, overwhelmed, skeptical? What's been your observation on that?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think it varies wildly. Um I think the level that the teachers at also uh kind of varies their use of AI or whether they use AI. Um in our own statistics, secondary teachers tend to use it more often than elementary teachers for you know, kind of the administrative work that they do. The that, and just as a kind of a tangent, that's my favorite thing for teachers. So for me personally as a teacher, what I've always really, really wanted us to get to is a point where we can individualize for every student. We have a mastery-based system for every student, so we can meet every student exactly where they are, teach them exactly what they need to know to reach that mastery level for every subject.
SPEAKER_02And the ability to do that has always been a lot of additional work for teachers, usually beyond what they can do. If you have 160 students a day, knowing where every single student is on every single standard at every given moment, and then customizing each lesson for those students is not something most people can do. What AI's doing for teachers right now, back to your question, is it's allowing teachers to take some of the administrative work they do. I'm talking about lesson planning, crafting questions, creating exit tickets, even things as simple as creating clip art that they want to hang on the wall or include in a uh slide deck presentation or something like that.
SPEAKER_02They can have AI doing all of that for them, not putting student data in it, not having it grade student papers for them, but helping them know, helping them take that piece off their plate so that they can focus just on the students. And the more time they can focus on the students, the better it will be for our students. And hello to all the teachers that are watching and parents.
SPEAKER_01That's awesome. Well, I love it so much. Um, so you kind of just talked about some of the things uh when it comes to AI. And what's interesting, I I say what's interesting, and people are like, that's not interesting at all, Lexis. Um, but one of the things that I have heard that has really got me thinking though, when it comes to we, you know, we hear this phrase, you just said it, we can meet students right where they are. And I heard this thing once, um, I think it was I thought it was funny. Some person said, Okay, okay, actually, I think meeting students where they are is somewhat of a fallacy and or a disservice for them.
SPEAKER_01Because they said, What other part of our daily lives does something meet us right where we are? So for example, they said, when you go to a movie theater, I might be able to process information a lot faster than you will. And that, but that movie's not gonna move faster for me because I am processing the information quicker than you are, which by the way is untrue. This is not that's not a true um, you don't process it slower than I do. I'm just saying. Um, but it was I that kind of got me thinking though, about the premise of where, like even in college, college doesn't necessarily meet students right where they are.
SPEAKER_01And so is it and then you know, like if they're using AI, if teachers are using AI and they're using it for the value of, you know, improving um, you know, the classroom experience or something in their, you know, in their background work, is it is it a good thing or is it even really possible? I mean, I get those are two different things. Is it really a good thing that AI can really meet a kid right where they are? And is that really like is that really what's gonna happen, you know, in the use of it?
SPEAKER_01Am I making is this tracking for you? Yeah, it is.
SPEAKER_02And uh the person who said that we shouldn't meet people there, I would disagree with them all day long. But um I think with the student case, what I was Or if it's even possible, like we have.
SPEAKER_01Anyways, okay, sorry. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So um I think what I would kind of in that regard is what I'm thinking about is the teacher right now that's spending a lot of time typing, crafting, um, looking for a clip art, looking for articles, all of that work is what I would have the AI do. I would not have the AI evaluating where the students are. That to me is the teacher's job. Because we always want the teacher involved, the human element. Um, we're people first, uh, and even the AI framework is human first. And so by taking off the work that they're doing that is not focusing on students and where they are, that's what I would use the AI for.
SPEAKER_02So um I don't see the AI being the one that meets the students where they are because that requires it to know the students and have their data, right? Which we wouldn't be feeding into it.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_02Um but um it would be it would be nice if colleges met you where you were too. I guess we all have the same end goal. Yeah. Um let's get everybody there as quickly as possible. So if you can be accelerated, let's accelerate.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So I went to about I don't know if it's like a summer ago, last summer, I went into it, it was like the biggest tech um education space in the nation. Or at least I had never seen anything so big in my life. I have a friend in a different state that um, she's like in her school district, she's like a coach for technology. So she's um, you know, finding different resources that teachers can then use in their classroom. And she loves it. So she invited me to this uh tech conference. Um, and so I went and I walked into this big, huge, you know, room, like the expo center.
SPEAKER_01And I'd never seen anything like so massive in my life, truly, like in terms of like expo centers and stuff like this. And uh, you know, one of the things that I thought about was I feel like this is such a money grab for uh companies and education. Like people look at public education like, oh, this is a place where companies can come in and charge lots of, you know, large amounts of money for things. And um just meaning that like there's a lot of funds and public edites tracking for you as it's making okay. Um, and so I as I was like walking around, there were some tools in there that were promoting kind of what you're suggesting is not what you're going to be doing at Boise in the Boise School District.
SPEAKER_01For example, they were talking about hey, you can you can have this, it's like magic something. Magic school, it's not the magic school bus, but there's this magic school is uh an AI that's out there. Okay, so magic school, and they were talking about like how they could use teachers can use this to grade a student's work. Like, oh, you can, you know, teachers, it's gonna help you, you know, grade things faster, whatever. And then I saw that and I was like, that really feels like you're taking the personal experience out of education. But then fast forward, and I was talking to a friend and they were talking about how they're they heard a school district leader, not in the boisey, I'm gonna be really clear, it's not boisey, but they were talking about a school district leader saying, Hey, we're using this tool, and it's so great that teachers can speed up their grading.
SPEAKER_01How do you like what do you make of that?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I I'm gonna differentiate quickly about the two different types. Okay. If if and this is not the best way to teach a student, but it can be a quick exit ticket. If you were looking at things that were multiple choice, true, false, yeah, there have been machine grading of that for probably it seems like ever, at least my whole lifetime. Yeah. I think I I took the Iowa Basic and we filled out our bubble sheets and then a computer graded it and kicked it out. So um, those have been around. Um, I don't think you need AI for those. I don't think you've ever needed AI for those because obviously pre-AI they were being graded.
SPEAKER_02There's apps out there that'll take a picture of uh, you know, uh an assignment and grade it that's not using AI to do that. Um so when I'm thinking about grading, I'm thinking more of the students' personal their writing, um, short answer, long answer, things that take kind of some human decision making. Yes, you could have AI do it, but that doesn't inform the teacher. And the point of an assignment is not to penalize a student or force a student to do work. Um, not the only it's to help the student learn, of course.
SPEAKER_02But the other part of it is to help to inform the teacher of where the student is. So the teacher knows if they're learning and they can help, you know, kind of draft the next lesson. If the whole class is struggling with a concept, the teacher needs to know that. And again, you AI can do it all, it could do it all, but the teacher is going to be that personal touch. They're the ones that are going to be delivering the lessons, they're the ones that truly need to understand it. And there's a lot of talk right now about cognitive offload with AI.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_02And I do personally worry that if we offload too much cognitively to AI, we'll lose it. And I think that's a real risk for teachers is if you have this AI writing every lesson, grading every paper, how much is that teacher losing of their ability to really know their students, know where they are to keep track of that? Um, there's other things that AI does that are not education related at all that might be fine for us to cognitively offload. Yeah. Um, the big example that's not AI specific, but like phone numbers. Um we used to all be able to remember, you know, long, you know, seven-digit or even the like 11-digit or 10-digit phone numbers with no problem.
SPEAKER_02People could rattle it off and you just remembered it. And now, I for me personally, I think a lot of other people, if you read off 10 random digits to me, I don't know that I would remember it like I used to.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_02So I but before AI, I offloaded the ability to remember phone numbers at some point. And so I see that with AI use is there's some things that people are offloading that I don't think we should. Yeah. Um, that we're just gonna lose those abilities and they're important abilities for human connection, human relationship, understanding, and then for teachers specifically, not grading and seeing your students work, not reading their journal, not reading their, you know, papers they've drafted. I think you lose something.
SPEAKER_01Oh my gosh, I just think those are like such valuable insights. Well, especially the Iowa testing. I hadn't even like remembered that. And then you said it and took me right back to sixth grade. Oh my gosh. And people asking, what'd you get on your Iowa score? That's so funny. Uh, but to your point, like we weren't, you know, like scoring things long before AI, you know, in that way. Um, but I do agree with you that there is the, you know, the the connection that we have to each other, but for teachers specifically to the student's work and understanding the student, but then like finding that right uh like that right space of not cognitively offloading what we need to be doing, you know, as human beings, as teachers, you know, in whatever space that we're in.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah. There's a huge amount of learning that even teachers, you know, do every every time they present a lesson, every time you create a lesson, you're learning more. Uh and so that you lose, I think, all of that if you have something else doing it for you. Um because just the art of creating is learning.
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm. Yeah. Oh my gosh, yes, it's so, so true. Um, last question. What does meaningful uh AI professional development look like for teachers, do you think?
SPEAKER_02That's a great question. And I think it's gonna be tool specific. Um while we've I mostly when I think of generative AI, I think ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude. Um, but there are, to your point, products like Magic School and several others out there that are not just chatbots, but they're actually tools doing something. Um and the next big change that we're probably gonna see in AI is Agenic AI, which is basically where the AI agent will control your computer or will be able to control other things and perform more complex tasks than what a just a chatbot could do.
SPEAKER_02And so not necessarily punting on your question, but um it that's what's coming next will be very interesting to see. And I think that'll shape what AIPD looks like for teachers. Uh, because I right now we're mostly talking about chatbots and how can a teacher use a chatbot to um again reduce that kind of administrative workload or the backside workload or whatever you want to call it there. Um and then how do they um how do students need to learn about it so they can use it in the workplace? And so you've got both of those pieces.
SPEAKER_02But when Agenic really takes off, I think it's gonna shift how everybody uses it. Because now it won't be asking a chatbot to write a paper or to create a graphic or to help you know, understand something or research something. It'll be asking uh an agent to perform a full complex task.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Ross Powell Like what?
SPEAKER_02Um you could have it do quite a bit of things. Um trying to think of just a simple example could be a spreadsheet. Okay. You could ask it to go to multiple spreadsheet, uh multiple websites, pull certain information down, place it into a spreadsheet, take the spreadsheet, format it a certain way, um, produce charts, and then kick that out. And that that would you could kind of do that with a uh chatbot at this point. Um but the agent can just do that even more so, and it does it using your computer. Another example that's more recent uh is using Photoshop.
SPEAKER_02So you can actually have the agent use Photoshop and all the tools built into Photoshop to edit it live in front of you as you ask it to make certain changes, and it's just gonna move your mouse around, it's gonna select the tool in Photoshop, it's gonna draw the lines or delete the background. So right now you would have to do that with a chatbot. You'd upload a photo, ask it to do it, and hope it did it right.
SPEAKER_00Right. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Um but now it would actually just be using Photoshop and right in front of you using the proper tools and doing it just as you ask. So that that again changes a lot of things.
SPEAKER_00Oh, wow.
SPEAKER_02And then if that expands beyond your actual computer to vehicles or other things, that again is is a whole nother level, which will adjust it. But right now we're training on chatbots and we're training on what students need to know for the current upcoming environment. That goes way back to why it's so hard to have a policy.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_02Why the framework, when when your viewers um read the framework, the framework is written very loosely intentionally because we don't know what's next.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. No, I totally agree. I appreciate that point. Um, okay, so let's talk about parents. Let's shift over to them. What are Boise parents asking about AI? Or are they?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so um we have a really great group that we work with. Um we meet with them pretty regularly and kind of work through um, you know, we talked about screen time, about cell phone usage, about artificial intelligence. It's the group UMI We All, which is Youth Mental Health Wellness Alliance, I believe.
SPEAKER_01Youth Mental Wellness Alliance, UMI, We All. Youth Mental Wellness Alliance. Yes, UMI We All. There we go. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yep. So they're they're friends of mine.
SPEAKER_01I like them. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02So they're a great group. So we work with them quite a bit. Um and the they're probably the reason I bring them up is they've probably asked the most questions and very good questions. And so how are students using AI? What grade levels are students using AI? Um, what's appropriate or what's not? Um talked to them about the framework very early on. Um we went through it and talked about it so we could get some feedback from parents on it. And you were also, of course, providing feedback from parents. But as a district, we wanted that same feedback, so met with them and talked about it. Um and I have not, there's very few parents asking us to ban it.
SPEAKER_02In fact, I can't think of any that asked us to ban it at the high school level. Um, we have had a lot of concern at the elementary and the junior high level, and we've shifted um as those concerns have come up, um, adjusted what students can or can't do. And um, we have great groups like theirs that are actually helping us test uh on their own students' Chromebooks. Like what, what, what are the students doing? What should we be doing? And how can we make sure that they're using it safely and ethically, or not at all, depending on the grade level.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, what I'm hearing from this is that you are intentionally working with parents and it sounds like it's a good experience, and you're using their feedback to improve the student experience, which are their kids. Yeah. That's what I'm hearing you say, which I thoroughly appreciate.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Thank you. Yeah, and that's that's the big thing. And so again, I I don't think anybody said to Van at high school that I remember. Um I could be forgetting it's been a couple of years since it's been out, but um I think everybody kind of knows it's the students need to learn it for the future.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, so okay, so if I'm this I liked this question. Um, and I should say I did not generate this question, so that's why I'm not giving myself a pat on the back. That's what I'm saying. Um so I really like the question. If I'm a parent listening to this and I don't know anything about AI in education, what are three things that you, as the director of people and organizational services, what would you want me to know?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, for I think not just for Boise. So maybe three things that parents should maybe ask their school or their teacher. Um a big one is what age levels can students access AI? Because that can vary quite a bit district to district. And once you know what age levels, you know, I would ask them in a in a polite manner, um, just for understanding of um how were the decisions kind of made at what level and why for the students to access it. So what was the academic rationale for allowing AI use at certain age levels or not allowing it at certain age levels? And then the last one, and I would actually ask four, but yeah, oh no, I like it.
SPEAKER_02I like it. But the next one asks is what AI tools there are available? So not just when can they use AI, but what tools, and so within Boise, we have a tool called BRISC, which I talked about. Um we have Gemini, which I've talked about. For our teachers, we have starting very soon um uh OpenAI's EDU product, which they have a product for teachers now that only a few districts nationwide have been able to access. And we've been selected into that cohort. So our teachers will have access to that, but not students. Um we don't give students access to that. Uh so what tools are available?
SPEAKER_02And then the last one I would probably ask is what are the expectations for student use in the classroom and how does a student know that? You know, what is that ethical, safe, appropriate use?
SPEAKER_01Those are really good. Now you say all of those things, and the thing that I'm thinking about is uh before we started the show, you were telling me about your um your professional journey, which I mean I can appreciate again, I love like historical things and people's timelines and stuff. Uh, and you spoke about how you used to work at a small school district and now you work in one of the largest districts in the state. How do um what do you think is do you think that there is a difference of experience for a parent in a very large school district going through um, you know, these like this AI conversation and um in that versus a parent in a small school district?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, there probably is. Um and it it's gonna vary district by district. But the district I started in had 360 students, um, so a very small community, very tight community. And so it was pretty easy if you had a question to call the superintendent or stop by their house because they lived right there by the school and talk to them or to talk to the principal. And I think as you scale up, you start losing that, not to say that the superintendents aren't reachable. Our superintendent's very approachable, um, but we have 44,000 parents. And so for 44,000 parents to be able to reach out and speak directly to anybody can be difficult.
SPEAKER_02And so where in a small district you might be speaking directly to the superintendent or the principal of the school in a large district, probably starting with the teacher is more appropriate just because it it's not that nobody, it's not that we don't want to talk to people, it's not that we wouldn't love to talk to you, and we talk to them all the time. It's just scope and scale. 44,000 parents. Um, it's much easier to go talk to your teacher if you're one of the 20 to 50 parents that that teacher has and really get the answer there. And then if you don't like the answer, definitely talk to the principal, talk to the district, um, kind of move up from there.
SPEAKER_02So I think that's probably the biggest difference is um in the smaller districts, everybody's just kind of together. There were, I trying to remember, I think there were 25 staff members in the whole district. And we have schools with in Boise with hundreds of staff members.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I really thought it was so fascinating when you said in order to get everyone together, like the entire staff of the Boise School District, you have to rent out the Century Link Arena. Is that what you said?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So again, that's kind of the when I was in Bruno Grandview, which was the small district I was in, if we were doing a staff training, we could fit the entire staff in the cafeteria, all 25-ish staff members. We could be there, we could learn the same thing at the same time. Uh and I then went to a larger district from Mountain Home with that had about 4,000 students and around 300 staff members. And so it was harder to get everybody in one room, but if you really needed to, you could get everybody in one room for a back-to-school and things, uh, you know, the back to school meetings and stuff like that. Um, with Boise with uh about 4,000 staff members, they're the facilities to bring all staff together for a beginning of year meeting, uh, you would have to rent Century Link Arena.
SPEAKER_02And the district's done that a couple of times in the past, usually through donations to have that back-to-school staff meeting. But yeah, there's there's very few facilities in in the state that can hold 4,000 people.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's really true, actually. Holy cow. Um, wow. Yeah, I um I think just as a parent, as I have had different experiences in different school districts, I know that for me personally, I love that smaller feel. I mean, I grew up in a small town, so did my husband. Um, and uh three of my kids have now graduated from the largest school district in the state. And that, like there were some things that were hard about it for me um in that way. But one thing that um I have noticed is the same in every district, and you kind of pointed to it.
SPEAKER_01Um, and it came up during uh the framework conversation was, you know, like, well, what what happens if something happens? Like what if, you know, a parent has an issue or a reporting problem or any of those types of things. Um and in the state of Idaho, what I think is so great is that we don't need to be calling the Department of Education. Um, we just need to be communicating within our local school district, that that takes place within our local, you know, within our s within our districts. And to your point, it's like the teacher, right, is your main point of contact. And um, that's why I have seen, and just so everyone is kind of aware, the Department of Ed is putting together a large professional development and they're really focusing on making sure that teachers in all parts of the state um are equipped with good information, they know what's going on, and they can be ready to use.
SPEAKER_01I mean, they can um they're prepared to use the tools as they, you know, have been integrated and will continue to be integrated. I like that point. Anyways, you're like, yeah, yeah, okay, okay. Um so um I wanted to um I don't. I'm like sitting here like, uh uh uh one of the things that you kind of talked about all you kind of mentioned, but I I do want to go back to it because um I think there's some value in talking about things that um, and I and I want to be really careful not to say never, something never should be this, because this was actually a conversation that we had in the work group, which was how do you create something that is um that's breathable, that allows for that flexibility, um, but that also still allows good decisions to be made.
SPEAKER_01And, you know, uh kids are learning in a good environment, teachers have the tools that they need. And and the reason I say this actually is I was listening to um I was listening to the ranch podcast not long ago, and my friend Um, who just uh she Representative Britt Raybold, but she um just recently received her PhD in the same program that I'm in, actually. So I went to her uh dissertation defense and it was on water policy. And she had focused on uh the Great Basin.
SPEAKER_01And as she was presenting the information to the group, there were actually quite a few lawmakers at the uh defense because they had just actually finished the legislative session. And so um a lot of the policymakers, as they were sitting there listening to her presentation and then it was over and they were asking questions, you know, like what can Idaho learn from what's happening down, you know, in the Great Basin, water area, and stuff like that. She then went on the ranch podcast and was talking about her dissertation, which again I found really fascinating. I don't know a lot about water, and so I was learning a lot about water from her.
SPEAKER_01And uh one of the things that they were talking about was that um, you know, water needs change over time. And Matt basically was like, well, why aren't the policymakers better? Like, why aren't they staying up on all of and then he wasn't trying to dig on the policymakers, but he was like, why are they in this situation? Why haven't they been updating, you know, more frequently? And she, her response was so good because she she shared, she kind of pushed back a bit and said, it's not good practice to be changing water policy every six months, that that doesn't allow for, you know, planning for farmers.
SPEAKER_01And um, you know, she kind of went into a lot of the details for that. And so that's kind of where um that's kind of what I was thinking about, just in terms of, you know, here there's this policy that has been created and the need to make sure that there is enough um space in it so that we're not so specific that we say, no, you know, like this can never be automated, this can never be, this can never be, this can never be. And then because it's in there, we can't actually do those things.
SPEAKER_01And then the process to change it makes it so hard. You know, but how do we draw those lines when we're talking about AI and we have this policy?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, great question. Congratulations, Dr. Rabald. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01That's huge. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02So um so that that was something that we we looked at in the work group. And part of it, I want to um really wreck uh lost my word there, but um really uh want to compliment basically the process that Senator Cook went through with this because Senator Cook brought together a huge stakeholder group, as you mentioned. Um we all came together. There was industry, there were parents, there were educators, there were other stakeholders, um, all came together to try to draft this legislation, which then led to the framework.
SPEAKER_02Um, so that that to me is one huge step in this, right? The right process is bring as many experts and as many stakeholders together and then try to craft the best legislation you can to start with. Um, once you've got that legislation, you then in this case, um what the legislation didn't do was put a bunch of restrictions in place that would have to be changed over time. Um, it created a framework that allows flexibility and more movement much more quickly. And so it the legislation basically empowers the State Department, State Board of Ed to create a framework and to create standards, and they can move much quicker than the legislature can.
SPEAKER_02And to your point, when laws change every year, it becomes really, really difficult in a lot of different ways. Um, one, making sure everybody's compliant with the law, because it takes time to develop policies, train staff, make sure everybody's aware how the law has changed or what the law is, uh, to roll all that out takes a lot of time. And then people have memories, of course. So once you get trained one way, if it changes next year and then changes next year, you sometimes forget which law is current, which what is the current policy I'm supposed to follow. Uh so that can become difficult. And so this allows the state board and the state department, which can move much quicker if they do need to make changes and not be locked in because we're dealing with a technology that's changing very quickly.
SPEAKER_02And it's the second fastest adopted technology in history. Um, the only one that was adopted faster is Pokemon Go.
SPEAKER_01That's so crazy. And I never did Pokemon Go. Did you play Pokemon Go?
SPEAKER_02I did not, but I was in Washington, D.C. when it came out and it felt like it was overnight. Like I had walked around downtown or it I'd walked around in DC one day and through some parks and stuff, and it was just normal. And then the next day there were just people everywhere. Everywhere I went, there were people with their phones out staring at them, and I had no idea what happened. Um and then I found out later that day they were all playing Pokemon Go, but it it just felt like overnight.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Um, everybody was on it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So that was like overnight, Chat GPT, wasn't that like within like two months or something?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yes, yeah. It was very quick. Um, and so second fastest ever. And then it's changed a lot in the three, four years that it's been out. Um, things like hallucinations we rarely talk about anymore. And that used to be a huge deal. Um what's that? So hallucinations when AI doesn't know an answer, so it makes one up.
SPEAKER_00Oh, okay.
SPEAKER_02That's it used, it still does it a little bit, um, but it used to be really prevalent that it would, if it didn't know any answers, it just always made up an answer. It was always trying to solve your problem, even if what it did was wrong.
SPEAKER_01Um Yeah, and that wasn't that long ago because actually so funny. Um, Matt was telling me about how he um he very specifically doesn't talk about his family, like hasn't doesn't give names and of his uh of his kids and his wife. And he went on another podcast about a year or so ago. And the person who was asking him questions was like, Okay, well, yeah, and your and your wife, Tammy. And Matt was like, My wife's name isn't like that's whatever the name was, you know, and he's like, that's not what it was. And the and the funny thing was that that AI had generated that name for the person who was, you know, asking the questions.
SPEAKER_01It didn't, they had made it up. And um because that information is not out there. Anyways, I just thought that like that's the what you're talking about, right?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, exactly that. Um there probably the most famous case I've heard about, there was a lawyer who I believe was disbarred because they had asked AI to write uh, you know, some kind of response to a case, had submitted it, and when the judge looked at it and the opposing counsel, um, almost all of the case references were made up. AI had just it couldn't find actual case references, so it just made them up. Yeah. And um last I heard they were being disbarred. I don't know if it actually happened. Um so that that used to be really prevalent, and that's changed. And then I already mentioned Agenics coming out, and that'll be a big change. And so we wanted to make sure this was very flexible and could adjust to that.
SPEAKER_02But to your point, we need stability at the same time. Um, because when you write standards, you then take a year, as you said, the state's going to be training all the teachers on it. Um, then the teachers need to actually be out there training and and using the training, either for themselves or if they're you having students do it both, because both trainings will be involved. Um and then once that's all that training's happened and they're actually using it with students, or students are using it, um if you suddenly change it, you have to repeat the process. And that's very expensive.
SPEAKER_02It takes a lot of time and it again it's it's just that all ever evolving. So the more loosely you can ride it and the more adaptable it can be, the longer you can stick with the program. Um and it in the long term it saves money, but it also saves people time and it saves a lot of confusion.
SPEAKER_01So what um what are things that you feel like AI does really well for a student experience and what perhaps um like it shouldn't be doing for our students?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, the this shouldn't be doings easy, shouldn't be helping them cheat. Yeah. Um we don't want it cheating for them, writing their papers, um, doing math problems for them, uh things like that, generating artwork that they turn in as their own. We don't want any of that happening with it. Um I think the best tool for students right now is an AI tutor. And there's some controversy over whether AI tutors are good or not. But if you're at home struggling and you're, say, a student in stats and your parents haven't taken stats for 20 years and don't really remember how to help, you can get stuck. Um, and you know, there's a few places you can turn to YouTube, you can turn to several other sources to try to find somebody to help you understand the problem.
SPEAKER_02But using an AI chatbot, a proper good AI chatbot, you can put the problem into it and it won't solve it for you, but it'll teach you how to solve it. And that gives that student that extra help at home versus coming back to school tomorrow with the problem unanswered. Um, and of course, when they came back to school unanswered, they should have gone to their teacher first thing in the morning and gotten help, gotten support and all that. But this this helps reinforce the learning they're doing during the day with the work they're doing at home. And to me, that's the best tool right now.
SPEAKER_01Right. So one of the things that I have seen also kind of in this conversation really with AI is I don't want my kid on the computer more. I've, you know, you and I have kind of been a part of some conversations actually where it's the screen time is actually the bigger thing than AI. Though I will say that I do feel like AI, it kind of so often I think is can is really sometimes dependent on what's happening on social media, what people are being fed, you know, what the news is kind of talking about. But it sounds like to me, and what I've experienced is that parents are really far more concerned about screen time.
SPEAKER_01And sometimes when they hear AI, the automatic thought is that means more screen time. And I know we talked about that earlier with listen, you don't have to use a screen to talk about, you know, to learn about AI. Um, but what are like what are the things that I think people should be aware of when it comes to screen time, particularly when we're talking about education, but then even in their own homes.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, great question. And uh gonna take a tangent but come back to it. Love it. Um IETA is an organization, Idaho, Idaho Education Technology Association. So they are a nonprofit that promotes the use of educational technology in the classroom. And I'm a board member on that, and I have been for about 18 years.
SPEAKER_01Um That's a long time to be a board member, Will.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Uh so I've been on there a long time. Um so I bring that up because this might sound strange, but the IETA this year is promoting legislation to decrease or eliminate screen time uh for students third grade and younger. And so we've written a bill. Um, we've been sharing that around with legislators, with other stakeholders, getting feedback on it. Um I think I shared a copy with you. Yep.
SPEAKER_00I wasn't gonna bring it up because I didn't know if it was uh if that was permissible.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Um and it's it's gone through some changes um since we can't the original one just banned all screen use, K3, and then had limited use on older grades, eliminated some state testing that was computerized and some other things to try to really decrease the amount of screen time students are using. Um there's been some pushback, so we've had to take back a lot of that, the state testing, for example. We've had to add that back in and some other stuff as we're trying to work with stakeholders to get a bill that might be something that can be passed. But as an organization that supports the use of educational technology, we don't believe students should be on the screen all day long.
SPEAKER_02Um we think play is super important. Um, we think, especially the younger students, they need to have some physicality to what they do. They need to be using manipulatives and developing fine motor skills and all of that. And so we don't want them on devices, you know, before fourth grade. And then from there, it should be very limited. And what we push, and um, Boise School District has also sent this to all teachers, is all usage should be intentional and should be educationally intentional. It shouldn't be free time, it shouldn't be game time, it shouldn't be entertainment for at school.
SPEAKER_02What parents want to do at home, that's up to the parents. But um at school, the use should be educational only. And that's what we promote, and that's what the bill was there to promote. And to go way back to answering your question, the biggest takeaway for me is always not all screen time is equal. And I talked about that last time. But you know, a student playing a minion rush type game on their phone when they've done studies have very little to no brain activity while they're doing that. They're not learning anything, it's not developing anything, and um, it's just not good use of screens. But a student doing complex work on a screen is learning and learning a lot.
SPEAKER_02And some of the research we were looking at when we drafted the bill, and the research is a little fuzzy between third and fifth grade, or really second and fifth grade. But for older students, I'll start with secondary high school students, if you give them a physical textbook and you give them a PDF version of the textbook on their device, they learn better with the physical textbook. Um but it's very, very negligible difference. If they have a physical textbook and they have an interactive textbook on a device, they learn much better from the device.
SPEAKER_02But it has to be an interactive textbook. If it's just a static screenshot, they might as well read it out of the book. Um they'll get a little bit better, not much to make a difference that really matters, but it's a little bit better. The younger you get, the more that sways. And when you hit somewhere between second and fifth grade, um the students actually aren't learning well off the device. If you give them a static PDF to read on the device, they learn better with a physical piece of paper in their hand. And they learn better with a manipulative in their hand. And um, we picked third grade because it kind of aligned with some other state things, but anywhere from second to fifth, and it's based on the maturity of the student and brain development.
SPEAKER_02There's a point where it's better for them to learn from an interactive than it is from a physical. But in those younger grades, it's better to learn from something physical. And most of us can equate it to maybe like a science experiment. Like, would you learn more reading about a science experiment, or do you learn more doing the science experiment? And most people learn better doing it than they do just reading about it. And that's the same with the interactive versus the static.
SPEAKER_01Wow. I mean, I will tell you when you shared that um, you know, draft legislation, I was surprised. I think of all of the groups in the state of Idaho, I would not pick your group to um to have uh, you know, policy that says let's limit the amount of screen time, um, which is actually so funny to me. Not funny. It is funny to me, but most people aren't gonna think that's funny. So I was thinking, I was um, you know, reflecting earlier today on you coming on the show.
SPEAKER_01And um, I was thinking about how I have this, I have this bias uh towards I think people who work in tech, because I have this, I have this assumption in my brain that a, they just want us in front of screens more. That's what, because they love technology and they're all nerding about it, you know, and all that. And so I when I met you and like then I it was in the work group. It was the work group that I first met you.
SPEAKER_01And you were up in front of everyone, and I was like, oh, geez, we have a tech guy leading this conversation. That's so terrible. I probably shouldn't be saying it out loud, but that's what I thought. I thought. And um, as I was like, no, no, I like this is someone who actually knows what he's talking about. Um, you know, really true, really, I was like, I gotta lean into curiosity here. Like, what can I learn, you know, from this experiment or experience? What can I learn from this experience? And what I learned was my assumptions were wrong. I was like, I'm wrong about Will.
SPEAKER_01That's not who this guy is. Actually, he really does want to make sure that kids are having the right um experiences in school. He doesn't just want us, you know, on a piece of technology all the time. Um, and when you came on the show, I learned so many things about you, um, just about you as a person, but then uh so much, uh such a clear perspective on technology and screen time use and all of those different things. Anyways, I'm rattling on about how I'm a terrible person.
SPEAKER_01And uh and so that's why when you sent that legislation, I thought, whoa, this is not the group that I would expect this from. And how great is that? How great is that this idea is being generated from a group that they focus on technology, but also how great is this because they're they're the group, because they're focusing on technology, they're also focusing on things that are they're acknowledging that some of this stuff isn't good for kids.
SPEAKER_01And that's a group in Idaho that's doing that, and how awesome that is. Anyways, a long way to say I'm a terrible person and you guys are doing really cool things.
SPEAKER_02Oh, thank you. I don't think you're a terrible person, but thank you.
SPEAKER_01Um so what can people expect from this? Like what, you know, what do you think? Um, what do you think about this legislation? Do you, you know, where are you in this process?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so we've met with a lot of stakeholders um and we're encouraging more people to come and join the conversation. Um we're hopeful that we can run something um coming up. We I don't know, it's too early to tell. So we're in those early stages where we started with a draft, we shared it with stakeholders, they suggested edits and changes, and we take the edits and changes that we agree with um and trying to get something, trying to build a coalition um that really believes in what we're doing and that's something that everybody can live with. And you know, state testing, like I said, we had blocked that in there, the the IRI, um, because it's K3, and that's where we were looking at the ban.
SPEAKER_02And um, we just weren't convinced that that was the right way. And we had a previous way that we tested students that didn't require a device for the IRI. Uh, but there's there's good reasons to stick with it. Um, there's legal reasons, there's federal reasons, there's there's reasons, but I could see why the State Department needs to or wants to stick with that. So we'll make those kind of adjustments and hopefully have a group that's willing to stand up and support it. And maybe at something passed, that'll that'll help districts kind of similar to the AI framework, help districts kind of establish where are some appropriate uses of technologies and where are they not.
SPEAKER_01So if people are listening and they're curious about connecting with you or your organization, how can they connect? Well, I guess with the organization.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, um, so you can look up the Idaho Education Technology Association. We have a website, and um, you can jump onto that. It's idahoedtech.org. Uh, and you can find our contact info, you can find out information about the organization.
SPEAKER_01Thank you for that. Um, so I want to connect with policy here, just specifically the AI standards. So, what's the difference between the K-8 technology standards and the standalone 9 through 12 AI standards?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, great question. And the committee talked quite a bit, the standards committee, not the framework committee, um, talked quite a bit about whether we should have standalone K-12 AI standards, or should we take the existing K-8 technology standards and just add AI into them? So Idaho has had K-8 technology standards for, I'm gonna guess 20 years, but I don't don't quote me on that. They've been around for a long, long time. And they're basically the basic technology skills that every student needs to learn between kindergarten and eighth grade. And they start out as simple as in the younger grades learning to use a keyboard, learning to use a mouse.
SPEAKER_02Um, and then towards the upper grades, more about how to use word processors and things like that. And probably the same stuff we all learned. I mean, they've been around a long time. Um and when we looked at that, do we want to have teachers have that plus a whole nother document that has to be taught K-8? Or do we just have one document and just list all the standards in it? And that's where the committee landed, that we would have one K-8 document. We would take the existing technology standards, we would add the AI standards to the end of each grade level so that there are just one of their own components in there.
SPEAKER_02And then we're very conscious of making sure that those grade bands that each standard addressed were things that could be done again with or without technology, depending on the age level, and that were age appropriate and proper for a student of that age to use. Then when we there are no 9-12 generic technology standards. Once you hit high school, the standards become course specific. And so in order for us to have all students learn AI in 9 through 12, we had to write a separate standalone document that addressed those grade levels because there was nothing to add them on to.
SPEAKER_02So they became their own.
SPEAKER_01Um so those AI 12 uh 9 through 12 AI standards. Um was there something about like when they're like when people can expect that to be integrated into the process? I can't remember.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so the the committee um they wrote the standards. Um, it's gone to the state board. It'll have a couple of readings at the state board, it'll be open for public comment. It'll go through what's called the negotiated rulemaking process. So anybody can comment on them. Um it'll be advertised in the administrative bulletin, which you can subscribe to through the, I think it's the Department of Admin. You can subscribe and get those so you can see when the hearings are coming up. And you can, if you want to testify on them, you can read them once they're public and make any comments or suggestions. And then uh they have to go to the legislature.
SPEAKER_02So the legislature would then approve them, hopefully in this upcoming session, which would mean they would go into effect for the 27-28 school year.
SPEAKER_01Okay, okay. So uh, you know, we've covered a lot of things today, which I so thoroughly appreciate. Um, you know a lot about AI and technology, and I feel really fortunate that we um yeah, you know, that you're in the state of Idaho. Um what if we if we were to have this conversation one year from now, what do you hope is different for students?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think a there's kind of a lot in there that I hope for students, and when we talk about technology and AI standards and everything, um, I do hope we have some screen time limitations in place that are um not just full bands K-12 or anything that's too drastic, but that really focus on educationally appropriate use. And when is it better for a student to learn physically off of something tangible in front of them? And when is it better to use some kind of an interactive on a device? And that we have some real clear um understanding of that and are doing what's best for students.
SPEAKER_02And then incorporating AI into that, it's kind of the same thing is I hope that we have a plan for making sure our students are prepared for the future. Um that's that's our whole goal. Our whole goal is to make sure that when our students Leave us, they can be great productive citizens. And we want to make sure that they are. And using AI is going to be a part of that, it looks like.
SPEAKER_01So as uh when I'm going to circle back to this work group, I'm going to end on this idea that when we all got together and you were up there leading uh the conversation in many spaces, and I learned a lot from you when when you were doing that, um, you uh had been tasked with looking at what other states are doing. And so you presented that information to the group and kind of you know aggregated things and then created uh, you know, kind of like a suggested like, here's where I suggest that we start.
SPEAKER_01So um from my vantage point, you have been deeply immersed in this work over the last year, and I'm and I know before that too. Um, from your perspective in what Idaho has done versus what you're seeing done in other states, what do you do you think that Idaho is, you know, we people talk about leading the way? Um, I've heard the argument that it's not necessarily good to be the first person there, that um, you know, like when people were settling the West, sometimes the people who came second survived better than the ones who were first.
SPEAKER_01Um what do you think about where Idaho is in this process and how Idaho has um taken steps within the process? And I'm not asking for a pat on the back of Idaho here, right? And it like we've all been anyways, that's Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Um when I think when the uh legislation is Senate Bill 1227, I believe, um, when that passed, uh it was reported that we were the first state in the nation to have a actual legal or an actual statute um specific to AI and education. Some other states had frameworks. Um there were a handful of states that already had frameworks, and those I looked at all those, as you mentioned, when we were developing ours, but they were not set by statute, and there was not, they were not empowered the same way Idaho's did. And again, I want to compliment Senator Cook and want to compliment Katie from Bosch Wilson from the State Department of Education, because the process that was used to create this I think helps insulate us from kind of the worry about being first, because we didn't come out reactionary.
SPEAKER_02And often those who come out first are reactionary. Um, and so you know, ban it or get rid of it or have it wide open for everybody or whatever that reactionary stance might be. Um we came out really methodical and we developed policies that fit the time and that are moldable to the future. And so my hope is that protects us from that, from you know, being the leader and the dangers that come from that. But I do think Idaho was a leader because we did, we had the first policy that was on the books, and we did it in a way that I think other states can model to help protect themselves too.
SPEAKER_02And it, you know, and all that comes back to the students and making sure the students are as is are well educated and taken care of. And and I my hope when we come back a year from now um is that that's what it's done.
SPEAKER_01Um so I realize that I get to kind of be in this. I feel very fortunate to kind of be sitting where I am right now, like in 2026 and some of the stuff that I've been involved in. Like I've been the state PTA president, and so I've been able to interact with parents across the state, but then also be a stakeholder at the table, you know, with conversations. Um I got to be a part of the work group for this. Um I have a podcast that talks a lot about, you know, public policy and how it's impacting us, you know, all the way down into our homes and in our neighborhoods.
SPEAKER_01And then I'm a PhD student studying public policy and administration. Um, and so I appreciate like that I I I just feel really fortunate to be able to um kind of understand what I do in terms of understand what public policy is and how it's made and and through that lens of um over the last couple of years of learning about it at Boise State. Um, but then also being a part of this process of I know because I have studied what it means to make good policy and the the amount of effort that goes into making policy.
SPEAKER_01And I've been at the Capitol and seen how some stuff flies through there and I'm going, this is terrible. Like, what's this gonna look like, you know, when it's implemented? And so I just feel I'm I'm just saying out loud that I feel so fortunate to have been a part of this process. And I really hope that, you know, moving forward that um I hope that other people see how cool this was in this moment, just in terms of the intentionality, the work of Senator Cook, what Katie has done, and and the, you know, the industry that's been brought in, and then the intentionality now uh moving forward of making sure that the public is aware of what's going on.
SPEAKER_01I do think it's really special. I think I think sometimes when we get past moments, then we look back and we think, oh my gosh, that was really special. And I had, I had no idea. And but I think right now and what we have experienced with this, it's not that I think that I've drunk the Kool-Aid with AI. Um, I think that I have been so uh impressed by the process and the intentionality that has gone in. And I think that we're all really fortunate to be able to be here right now and see it and experience it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I agree. That's a great, that's a great um sentiment.
unknownYou're so funny. You crack me up.
SPEAKER_01Oh, you're so, so funny. Um okay, so I really um I appreciate you coming on. Thank you so much. I appreciate what you are doing at the Boise School District and the intentionality of connecting with parents and making sure that they are aware of what's happening, and then also for our teachers too around um within your district, but and then also what you're doing with your association and the legislation um, you know, that you're working on. And then I really appreciate the expertise that you brought to the work group and um moving forward, I have really learned a lot from you.
SPEAKER_01So thanks so much for being on the show today.
SPEAKER_02Thank you, and thank you, Back, because I mean just hosting this and you know getting this information out to parents is always a struggle. So you having this is huge. And then all of your work, you've been on all these committees and supported all of it. So thank you.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, here's to the future, and you know, I'm really I'm um I'm interested to see what comes next and what will be what what this will look like in a year. It'll be good. And that's a wrap for today's episode of the Purple Zone. Thanks for being here. If you liked what you heard, leave a review on your fave podcast app or on YouTube. And for me to you, the heart of the purple zone says community is where policy comes to life.
Send us Fan Mail Should phones be allowed in school at all? And what about the laptops? In this episode, Alicia Purdy, an Idaho educator, talks about cell phone and technology policy in her local school district. Across...
Send us Fan Mail Roughly 85% to 93% of Idaho's incorporated towns and cities are considered rural, depending on the population threshold used. About 70% of our school districts are rural too. Yet people in rural...
Send us Fan Mail What if helping the young people in your life had nothing to do with being an expert? Dr. Megan Smith, a professor at Boise State University and executive director of Communities for Youth, joins the...
Send us Fan Mail Alexis Morgan tells the story of The Civility Project. In 2019, after an opinion piece hurt the Nez Perce Tribe, three leaders of the Lewiston Tribune set out to confront incivility in their own...
Send us Fan Mail What does it take to turn an issue into legislation? Time? Relationships? Listening? The AI in Education workgroup is highlighted in turning an issue into public policy. In this episode, Alexis Morgan...