Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Pulse

The Pulse artwork

From Council Table to Caucus Room: Peter Milobar’s Governance Playbook

Feb 24, 202646 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

"Send us a text about this episode!" In this episode of Nonpartisan Hacks, Joel Grenz and Sean Wood sit down with Peter Milobar, MLA for Kamloops Centre and BC Conservative leadership candidate. Milobar’s political résumé spans city councillor, three-term mayor, regional district chair, and provincial legislator - what Sean calls “a full political bingo card.” The conversation covers what he learned managing a city through the 2008 financial crisis, why infrastructure funding has dried up, and how he got all 10 regional district projects funded when no one else could get one. Milobar also shares candid advice for anyone thinking of running for local office, explains why councillors shouldn’t try to make it a full-time job, and makes the case that fixing a road has nothing to do with how you vote federally. Episode Highlights: How Milobar delivered infrastructure under the rate of inflation during the 2008 economic crisis The story of getting all 10 regional district projects funded by refusing to re-prioritize the list Why BC’s $13.5 billion deficit concerns him as the province’s finance critic His advice on what voters actually look for - and why single-issue candidates should reconsider Why councillors showing up with hedge trimmers creates more problems than it solves The case for staying in your lane at every level of government Voice message: Voice message The PULSE and be part of the podcast! You'll find all episodes of The PULSE Podcast on Apple, Spotify, Amazon, iHeart, TikTok and YouTube podcasts, as well as PULSECommunity.ca Special Thanks to Our Sponsor - Ian Lindsay & Associates. Check out Skookum Kid's Stories on Apple, Spotify, Amazon, iHeart, and YouTube Podcasts, as well at SkookumKids.com. Sign up for our weekly newsletter of new podcast releases and contests! Click here to learn how to Support the show "Like, Share & Listen!" #PulseCommunityPodcast #publicengagement #ThePulseCommunity #SeanWood, #JoelGrenz #ParksvilleQualicumBeach #NonPartisanHacks #PeterMilobar Support the show

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02Ian Lindsey of Lindsay and Associates has played an active role in the local community since nineteen seventy-nine. He has been with Remax, Vancouver Island's most advanced real estate business network, since nineteen ninety-six. Marketing and selling residential rural strata, recreational investment, and project development real estate. You'll find true real estate professionals at ianlinsey.ca.

SPEAKER_04You're listening to Nonpartisan Hacks, the politics and policy podcast where we talk about good government from the local level on up. I'm Joel Granz, a city of Parksville counselor.

SPEAKER_03And I'm Sean Wood, also a Parksville counselor and mayoral candidate. Today we've got a guest who's done something not many people can say. He's been a city councilor, a three-term mayor, a regional district chair, an MLA, and now running to lead a provincial party. That's a full political bingo card.

SPEAKER_04Our guest is Peter Milibar, MLA for Kamloops Center. Peter's career spans over two decades in public life from the council table to the legislature, and we're going to dig into what he's learned along the way.

SPEAKER_03Before we get started, our usual disclaimer the views on this podcast are our own and don't represent the city of Parksville. Peter, welcome to Nonpartisan Hacks. Good morning. Thanks for having me, guys. Thanks so much for making some time, Peter. We know that the campaign trail, especially on the leadership uh race is crazy. And uh we appreciate you making some time for us early this morning.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, it's uh it's always I like doing podcasts, longer form interview. I I tend to uh like a bit better, so uh this this works well. Right.

SPEAKER_04And the bonus is that if you come on this podcast as a guest, you get bread. Sean makes his uh what do you call it again?

SPEAKER_03Uh it's it's an organic uh organic white uh loaf and no-need recipe, but there's a little bit of flake salt on it. We'll see if we can get you some uh some Peter. I think your maybe your campaign manager is eating it right now, but yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, he's he's uh he's my tester to make sure it's uh it's suitable for me to it's already the king's tester, yeah.

SPEAKER_04Uh unfortunately the coffee did not work out this morning. Sean's fancy coffee maker uh didn't no I screwed it up. Oh you yeah the some big handle thing you have to pull down.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, it's a manual press. We don't have to talk about the flare 58, it's very fancy, and then they're not a they're not a sponsor of the show or anything, but I screwed it up.

SPEAKER_04Not not when there's no coffee, they're definitely not a sponsor.

SPEAKER_03I had to serve Peter tea. I'm already embarrassed.

SPEAKER_04So apologies for the tea. Uh we're doing British style today. Uh so let's maybe get into your political career here. I think you first got elected in uh when you're 32, is that correct?

SPEAKER_00That's right, 2002. So there I just gave away my age, I guess. But uh yeah.

SPEAKER_04Cats out of the bag.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_04Uh so Kamloops City Councillor, and you became the city's longest serving mayor.

SPEAKER_00If that's not That's true, and and uh for a time they ever was telling me I was the youngest mayor ever uh when I got elected, but Al Thompson, who is uh still alive, was the first mayor of Kamloops when amalgamated, and and he uh he promptly corrected me that he was a little bit younger than me when he uh and fair enough, I'll give Al that. Uh it's it's uh yeah, so um Cliff Branch Flyer was close. He was uh a couple months shorter than me, but um yeah, it's it's Camloops has been one of those cities that's always kind of turned their mayors over fairly fairly frequently.

SPEAKER_00So even uh three three terms is is not that common in Camloops either.

SPEAKER_04Well, I will admit that we have watched so well so Sean and I like to watch other council meetings from other communities, and we have watched some uh some Kamloops council meetings lately, and uh the some interesting stuff there for sure.

SPEAKER_03And we're gonna leave that one right there. Yeah, we'll just um yeah. Peter, so since you're talking to a couple of counselors, uh we're big local government fans. Um I sit on committees for FCM, I've been on the board of UBCM, uh local government runs balanced budgets, um, and uh you know, kind of always trying to not get things downloaded onto them and uh really appreciate the three-term mayor thing um because it's a relatively non-partisan role. You're you're just managing uh a city with your city manager and your council.

SPEAKER_03Um can you tell us a little bit about your what you look back on on those three terms as mayor?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean in Camloops, it's not a it's not a party system either. It's not like a Vancouver or a Surrey. So um we had pretty diverse councils, uh, all three of them. Um they it was almost like the the public said, well, that was a pretty diverse group of people. Why don't we add one more diverse person into the mix to see how he handles that? Um so I I had other people that ran for either federal or provincial uh NDP or Green Party uh on that council. In fact, uh a counselor and myself both ran in the 2017 election when he ran for the Greens in a different riding, and I ran um and and uh for the uh for BC Liberals at the time.

SPEAKER_00And uh then we had another council that ran for the NDP. So um we were always able to put all that aside though, especially on on the bigger, bigger structural things needed for the city. Uh we we definitely had long uh dragged out debates longer than I would have liked around backyard chickens. He used to always say, look, a deep ideological issue for sure. Yeah, and I would say, look, I I I just I don't want them in everybody's yard, but uh if you if you can convince four of your colleagues to get them, uh I'm not gonna lose any sleep over it either, right? Like I've got other things to worry about.

SPEAKER_00And so um I think that was really the key to it all. Uh I came in in 2008 when there was that economic meltdown happening around North America. So um it really did require a council that was willing to look at doing things uh slightly differently. Um uh we were blessed that we had uh very strong senior management that uh were on board with it as well. So uh the two together we were able to find efficiencies, we were able to uh work with the with the QP staff to find out what they thought would make their workplaces more efficient and and uh still deliver the services needed.

SPEAKER_00And as a result, uh, you know, we added at a time when people were were getting rid of firefighters and and getting rid of uh downsizing police forces, uh letting critical infrastructure just kind of wait until things got better. Uh we I I get criticized sometimes because I campaigned talking about delivering our sewage treatment plant on and and in my first campaign, but we did that. And I think if you're in North Vancouver right now, you kind of wish someone had actually taken some control over that project. Uh we did it on time and on budget. Uh we we deliver we actually hired firefighters, we we expanded and built a whole new fire hall, added 20 more firefighters to our our complement.

SPEAKER_00We um we added to our police force, we added parks, we stuck to making sure the core infrastructure was taken care of, and we did all that over that nine-year period uh at under the rate of inflation on average. So um, you know, it can be done. Uh it takes a lot of hard work, but it takes it takes that ability to to park the partisan stuff when you're at the council table, yeah, and actually do truly focus in on what your what your job actually is, and that was elected to worry about the city, not worry about the province, not worry about uh the country, and not worry about what's going on, you know, down in Tennessee or or somewhere else in the world.

SPEAKER_03Are you throwing us a softball here, Peter, that uh you became mayor during the 2008, you know, credit default swap crisis. Um is there any similarities to the financial budget that we just heard the other day and uh and and uh the province needing needing someone with that experience?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean uh yeah, I'm our finance critic. I have been for the last three years, and and this is by far the the worst budget uh I think anyone has seen um in terms of uh record deficits, uh record debt going up, but also that inability to find um or or really spell out clearly exactly what those efficiencies you're looking for are or where they're going to come from. And I think ultimately that's what's concerning people is that we we know you're not going to solve a$13.5 billion deficit overnight.

SPEAKER_00Uh, it should have never been allowed to grow that high, but it and it is what it is now. But but uh spend the last year talking about how you're going to create a path and then not actually be able to show that path when you deliver the budget. I think that's the bigger concerning part. You can't just keep putting a number in a budget for next year that says things are gonna get better without showing us the work. And and I mean last year they did the same thing. It showed that it was gonna be a ten billion dollar deficit this year, still bad, but better than it had been.

SPEAKER_00And now we're back at 13 and a half. So seeing 10 billion next year's budget uh doesn't really mean anything to me because the track record would say it's it's an irrelevant number. And and you touched on it in the opening. Local governments have to operate without any deficit. And yes, they have debt, but they also have caps to that debt. Uh they have to to make sure that their debt doesn't uh exceed certain ratios for what they're able to borrow and and reasonably pay back. And conveniently, the people that make the laws for municipalities, i.e.

SPEAKER_00the provincial government, they make sure that they can just spend at will. And I don't I don't think it's realistic to say a government would never run a deficit at a provincial level. Um but to not even attempt to stay away from it when local governments everywhere are forced to make very hard decisions uh on a yearly basis, uh just seems uh a little strange to me given the the strength and the size of the public service and the expertise the province actually does have to tap on. Um it just seems it seems almost in reverse of how it should be.

SPEAKER_04Well, you're throwing another softball here at us with being in local government. Uh speaking of the the relationship between the provincial government and the local government, uh definitely in the four years we've been in, just about in office, we've seen lots of uh requirements put on local governments that make, especially for smaller communities like ours, uh, put pressure on our community to be able to deliver things that are provincial priorities. Maybe you can speak a little bit about your experience of that sort of thing from both sides, uh being at the provincial level and at the local level.

SPEAKER_04Have you seen that or how do you contend with that and what would your approach be on that?

SPEAKER_00Um I think back to my time, and this would be more related to when I was chair of the regional district, but but still um, you know, it was the same what we had to do with the sewage treatment plant. We had to wait. Um we we waited a little while uh to make sure we were meeting the waiting for the new federal discharge regulations. I know I'm getting a little uh granular, but this is for an elected official, so they'll get it.

SPEAKER_01Yep.

SPEAKER_00Um and that gave us the time to find uh an infrastructure program to apply to to be able to pull in um you know$14 million of grants. And and even then the government wanted to have this artificial well, we're back to one-third, one-third, one-third funding, which is a pipe dream now. Um and so we had to actually pull off a uh a component of the project and resubmit because they they let it be known that they could probably find$14 million for us, but it was a$42 million plant, so we found half of the cost, and and suddenly they could do one-third, one third, one-third on 21 million of it.

SPEAKER_00I didn't care, I just wanted the 14 million out of the 42. It didn't matter to me what what percentages. But the the point being, there was always an infrastructure program to tap into. It was always oversubscribed, but there was always a federal provincial uh shared infrastructure pot to get into. And right now we don't have that. So when the government says, well, when EB became premier, he said, Well, I just gave the cities a billion dollars. Yeah, that was the only infrastructure money in the five years leading up to that, and there's been nothing since. And so, of course, people are having a harder time um getting infrastructure projects done.

SPEAKER_00So when I was the chair of the regional district, we had gone in and and same thing, the water program was oversubscribed to what eight to one. Uh we put down our list of ten projects, and the minister sat at UBCM, pushed the sheet back, said thank you very much. Um go back and prioritize this list and and uh talk to us. And I said, push the paper back. I said, Thank you. It's it's this is our list. And she said, No, but you need to prioritize this. I said, We have, and I said, and we'll get you the minutes of the meeting, but it was a unanimous vote.

SPEAKER_00And this is a board of 26, 10 electoral area directors, and then a mix of municipal municipal directors. And I said, uh, this has been prioritized by the board unanimously. And one of our smaller water systems at the front top, there was a medium-sized one in the middle, like there were they were all over the map. There was no rhyme or reason to the size that the minister could figure out why we had prioritize them this way. So we kept bugging them year over year, and it took about two years, two and a half years. Uh, and at a time when every other regional district was fighting over their priority list on a on a fund that was eight to one oversubscribed, uh, we got all ten funded because no one else could actually say with certainty which projects they wanted to happen or not.

SPEAKER_00Um, so that's that's when you you're able to pull people together and work together and and see the bigger picture. Um, yeah, it sometimes takes a little bit longer, but on the aggregate, it's it's still way faster and and you can still get projects done. But the key to all of that is you actually needed the infrastructure program in place to actually apply to. And those have not existed um for the whole time at uh NDP, but but even federally, um they've not created those, and they need to get back to doing that to leverage those three levels of government's dollars to make projects actually happen.

SPEAKER_04Aaron Powell There are two sides of that then in terms of making that work. One is having that pot that people can subscribe to or apply to. Uh and then the other side is actually at the local government level and regional district district you're talking in this case, uh, having consensus and an agreement about how to move forward pretty quickly. So how do you even get to that? And I can see that being an issue looking at maybe how caucuses operate as well, is how do you get a caucus all around the same idea and priority list?

SPEAKER_00Um you actually just make a uh you make a bloody decision. Um that's how you do it, right? You have a conversation, you make sure people have access to the information, you you basically make sure the group understands when a decision is needed by, and then you stick to it. And and uh, you know, me mulling over uh technical reports uh for an extra ten days is not going to change the technical report. It just gives me time to dither, uh second guess.

SPEAKER_00Uh frankly, uh if I'm not trying to besmirch anyone in local government, but let's be honest, most people are going to read that package the day before, if you're lucky. Um a lot won't even have read it until they're sitting at the table talking about it. Um that's the reality of local government. People are busy and and and uh if it's not a priority issue or topic area for them or a passion for them, they're not necessarily gonna scrutinize it heavily. So dragging a decision out um doesn't actually change the timeline of the decision making.

SPEAKER_00It just drags out when you're actually going to get to that decision making, if that makes sense. So um I've always found that's the best way, and uh, and that's what I find in caucus. We we have conversations around issues and topics, uh we share ideas, we figure out how we want to vote on something, and and um and then that then we set that direction. And and because of the pace of Victoria when you're actually in session, the the timeline piece kind of takes care of itself because you just literally don't have the time and you don't control the time when you're in opposition.

SPEAKER_00The government controls when a bill comes forward for debate, um, when the votes happen. So you're really at the mercy of of what the government tells you is going to happen in the schedule versus um what you might like to do.

SPEAKER_04Um maybe before we switch to a different topic, you can give a little bit of your perspective on uh what you maybe wish you had known before you ran and advice you may have for folks thinking of running for local government. We want to get the best possible local government people here in the province. So how do we get that?

SPEAKER_00Well, so I didn't give it a whole lot of thought before I ran. I was watching my my son's uh uh preschool soccer in the morning and and they they came out with the list of candidates on the radio in the morning broadcast at around nine o'clock or ten o'clock. And it's like, well, geez, I I think I might have to do my civic duty. And phoned my wife and and she says, Well, you should do it. And I said, Well, we'll see. So we stopped by City Hall just before noon, and I made her go in to get the paperwork because I didn't want to uh go in.

SPEAKER_00My family was reasonably well known, and and a lot of people in City Hall would have known, and I didn't want to trigger anything that way, uh, in case I decided not to run. And uh maybe that was a little bit self-uh arrogant on my part given at the time, but uh, you know, in your mind, you're thinking everybody knows who you are. And I'm famous in my own mind. Exactly, right? So, so anyways, I I took out the paperwork, and then uh it was about quarter to four, and we were sitting in the parking lot at City Hall until that same day, because it was the last day of nominations, and I'm like, I don't think I'm gonna take it in.

SPEAKER_00She goes, You get in there and do that, you know you want to do it. So uh my wife kind of gave me the last nudge. Uh so literally I was a day of um maybe I should do this. Um actually had to leave town for a week or two for work right after that. So I was missing for the first part of the campaign, and uh was fortunate enough to get myself elected on the first try, and uh realized I I had a skill set that was well positioned for the job. I was able to get a lot of big stuff done.

SPEAKER_00I was fortunate in the mayor at the time. Uh Mel Rothenberger had put me on a lot of fairly major committees, so I chaired our tournament capital committee, and in the first nine months we went to a successful referendum to build out all our sports facilities in Kamloops. Uh he put me on the arts commission and and uh we had to redo our arts and culture uh heritage plan that we're still working off of today. We I was on the Social Planning Council, had to redo the social plan uh for the city at the same time. So that was my first nine months. So frankly, when I hear local elected say it's it takes a couple years on the learning curve, I'm like, well, mine trap first nine months was pretty busy.

SPEAKER_04Um in your case, you had the history already, so maybe that helped get you elected to the job.

SPEAKER_00I you know, it frankly, I had I had family name recognition, right? And and I've said this to other candidates that run uh if you if you have that, um you you will get votes because people know who your parents are or your siblings or whoever. Um but uh whether you get re-elected or not is 100% on you at that point. Because people will be willing to give you a chance because they say, oh, you know, his dad was a pretty rational thinker and and uh you know pretty pragmatic. I bet you he's the same way. Let's let's see. Because there's nine of us, right?

SPEAKER_00So it's not a massive gamble. But whether or not you get re-elected, at that point they're judging you on on you. And and so it's it's sometimes how do you get a seat at the table? It's no different in provincial politics. Sometimes if you win a nomination in a riding, that's it doesn't matter what political stripe, if it's that's the the political flavor of that riding, you know, the old saying you could run a fence post. Um right? Uh that's the same thing. So so you know, I don't apologize for that. That's that's a simple reality. I have been re-elected seven times in in so I've been in eight general elections and been elected eight times.

SPEAKER_00I I think at a certain point I can say it's it's on my own merit. Yeah. So so I mean there's all of that.

SPEAKER_04But what I think about the skills though, like that you brought. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So I I think what happens, what I see happen in most municipal elections is candidates get too hung up on promising or talking about a specific project as the sole reason that they're running. And if you're only running because of a project, you probably shouldn't run. Um because projects come and go, uh issues come and go. I firmly believe that the electorate really looks for your thought process. Um like we're all lay people at that table, right?

SPEAKER_00I wasn't I'm not a city planner. I I'm I don't have degrees in in uh sewage engineering, and you're there for I mean I dabble a bit on the side, but yeah. You're there to ask the right questions of the experts that you've brought in the room that did go to school for planning and and all those types of things. And you're there to to demonstrate and convey back to to the staff and and drill through the report and question the reports and the recommendations, key being recommendation.

SPEAKER_00Everyone says, Oh, you just rubber stamp things. So it's a recommendation. It doesn't mean you have to do it. And so I think the public wants to know and looks for people that they feel will actually represent and ask the questions that they're asking when they're watching well back when back when you watched it on Shaw Live, uh sitting at home watching it, right? And going, oh, well, why aren't they asking this question? And then some some counselor asks that question, and that person you've instantly almost connected with the that constituent because unwittingly you literally asked the question they were thinking.

SPEAKER_00Um so I think it's more important that you you get out there, uh you know, a bit of your personality, obviously, but more how will you handle situations and topics and issues that come up? Not, you know, there's always going to be the flashpoint uh topic that you need to have a stand on in an election. I get that for a project, but but if you think that's the sole thing, I always say, and it's like this in the in the provincial leadership race right now. Okay. Um we all say that we're going to repeal DRIPA as an example.

SPEAKER_00Great. Uh we've done that on day one. Uh now what are you gonna do to run the rest of the province? Like like it is a critically important topic, uh, but I would argue so is healthcare, so is education, so is uh the overall economy. Or things we don't even know yet are gonna come up. So so it's great to have a firm position on on a issue, but that issue will come and go, and then what do you have in a as a thought process on all those other things that are Going to come up and basically how would you handle it or how would you approach those things?

SPEAKER_00And the counselors that I saw that had the most success for years, Pat Wallace, a good friend of mine, she was elected forever in Camus, right? And she was president of SCM and president of UBCM. She did it all. But she was always consistent. People knew what she was standing for when they voted for her, right? And she she didn't overly waver a whole lot. She wasn't all over the map. And she had, you know, she was she was a BC Liberal Silk Red, uh, you know, free enterpriser. Um, and uh she would have a lot of people that voted NDP provincially would still vote for her as a city councilor because they knew what they were going to get from her.

SPEAKER_00And at the local level, I think people just want to know what is it, what's the value proposition I'm getting out of this person, basically, right?

SPEAKER_03So that makes me think of uh provincially, Peter, that you know, we we didn't see our closest trading partner go in a certain direction. But since you don't have that financial pillow to be able to kind of roll with tariffs and whatever else came our way, well then you're gonna point to that being the problem, but you weren't ready for they weren't ready for that problem. Um which speaks to your point where, hey, you know, you don't know what's coming down the road, so be prepared, you know, financially or however it might be.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and and if if anyone thinks, I mean, it it definitely was a shock to the system what what's happened over the last year with the United States, but if anyone thinks that's just gonna be dialed back if you change who's in office down in the states, you're kidding yourself. If you think some uh what does anyone honestly think that a Democrat's gonna run and say, you know what, I think we should shut back down that auto plant and move it back up to Canada? Um, Democrats are typically more protectionists than Republicans. So um now that that door's been opened uh for the Americans to kind of rally around that protectionism, um, I'm hard pressed to see where where any government is uh if Democrat or Republican is going to meaningfully um, you know, at least very publicly dial it back.

SPEAKER_00You may be able to do through the negotiation of trade deals, but it's it's forever changed. Um and and you know, even things like the duties on on the softwood, and let's let's remember that it was Joe Biden and Kamala Harris that actually had laid out that schedule of of ever increasing duties. Um the current president just decided to continue on with that trajectory. We as a country, I think, take for granted or or think sometimes that other countries are are going to play nice in the sandbox like we try to, and they they just don't, right?

SPEAKER_00Not just the states, but but China and and other trading partners too, right? They they uh take the gloves off and and they protect their own very very well, very quickly and as a priority.

SPEAKER_04So as a province then that behooves us to have plan A, plan B, plan C, uh in in order to be able to absorb any blows that come our way, I think is kind of what you're getting at there, Sean. Yeah. Um and uh with the budget being the way it is, we're in a tricky position now because we're kind of behind the eight ball uh fiscally. Wh what are your plans for that? Should you get into the position to be able to do something about it, how would you tackle that?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I've been asked since the budget came out by the media a few times. Well, what what would have you done differently? Or and I'm like, well, first off, I wouldn't have created a$13.5 billion deficit. Um and and you can't ask me how am I gonna uh fix everything on day one when uh it's taken them nine years to create the mess we're in. So how do you eat an elephant? Well, yeah, and and so I think it's about it's about taking those those steps and and it's it's a culmination of things that needs to happen, right? You you need to actually as a province strive to grow our GDP growth higher than than what the economists are even projecting it to be, and take them by surprise and actually exceed expectations, not not accept mediocrity, not say, well, we almost hit what people projected a year ago we were going to do, so I guess that's okay.

SPEAKER_00Um I come from a competitive sporting background. Um, you know, I I um I believe you you strive, you keep striving and striving, and um if you're a little bit ahead, get further ahead. If you're a little bit behind, figure out a way to tie things up and and and get ahead. Um and I I've always just believed that. So I don't see that happening with this budget. I don't see that it happening with this government year over year over year, and that's where that you think if they had just had a little bit of of ambition as a government to actually exceed GDP targets over the nine years they've been government, how different our books would look right now.

SPEAKER_00Um it would be a massive change, and household incomes would be that much higher, and people would not be as freaked out. And so um the fact they're not even attempting that, and nothing clearer than in the forest industry. They they have managed decline year over year over year. Um they're not doing anything the industry's asking or unions are asking. Uh they can't, you know, they they project they're gonna collect$500 million in in fees and and revenue from forestry, and then they collect$500 million, even though only three years ago they were collecting$1.8 billion.

SPEAKER_00Not even attempting to get it up to$700 million, or attempting to get it. Like that's the problem. How do you grow an economy? And I I said this uh yesterday in my budget response. If if you if you have just lost 15,000 forest sector jobs, it's great to say we're gonna grow the economy by going after our natural resource strength. But that means you need to create 15,000 mining jobs to replace the 15,000 forestry jobs just to get to even. And so it it's great to run around and talk about an announcement of this mine or that mine, and those are all wonderful and needed.

SPEAKER_00Uh, but that only actually increases our economy if it's net new to the economy, not just uh a transferring of which worksite somebody happens to be working at.

SPEAKER_04Aaron Powell Being able to do that, whether at the local government or the provincial government, requires a collaboration between the elected side and the staff side. Um I have zero experience on the provincial side, but have s have seen now how that can kind of work between the the staff and the elected board, so to speak, of the local government uh that's working with the staff. How do you how do you get those results? And what have you seen in terms of the approach of this provincial government versus maybe what you've taken from working in local government with that staff to elected respon uh relationship?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I've always found that uh you know the public service is is very professional. Uh they take a lot of pride in their jobs and and uh they want to do a good job. Uh I don't think they they go to work hoping that they have a an inbox of angry emails from the public and and um you know how can I make someone's life miserable today? I I don't think that's the driving force behind people that got into public service in the first place, right? Um and it doesn't matter what job you do, I I don't think people that you know take your admission fee at the at the local swimming pool are going, how can I make this line longer today?

SPEAKER_00So people are really angry when they get up here with their their kid to get into the pool, right? If you start from that starting point, you realize it's like any other workforce. So there are those that are just marking time and and not but but you go to a grocery store and there's an employee that's doing that too, right? So um I think sometimes that you gotta cut through that. And once you establish that uh we're all here for the same thing and and want uh uh a shared goal, uh that starts to help cut into that whole public sector versus um uh uh elected official kind of dynamic.

SPEAKER_00But then you need you need to have strength uh both in the mayor's chair but around the council table, and you need to have strength in in the premier's office and around uh the cabinet table. So that uh those deputy ministers or CAOs uh are are they have a level of respect that that you have find that working relationship that you can you can push each other a little bit in the right appropriate setting. Uh I had many a very loud conversation with the two CAOs that I had uh at the city at the time um throughout the years, uh but they were always in a closed office door and and not in front of all of counsel or nothing.

SPEAKER_00And we would hash things out in a in uh in an adult kind of way where where we were just going back and forth and you know, voices rise or whatever. It's not like we were over angry with each other.

SPEAKER_04It was just passionate for what you want.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, or or trying to press your point, right? I mean uh and so it's that time and place piece. It's also having councils that know their place, and I'm not trying to again be disrespectful of councils, but I've ran for both positions, they are completely different. Um they just are, and um, even down to the the pit in my stomach, I was a popular so first time I ran for city council, I came in eighth of eight. Second time I was fourth. Then I ran for mayor. And very popular, uh well known. Um it was assumed I would I would do good in the mayor's race.

SPEAKER_00Um, and uh even that putting in my paperwork where you're filing paperwork where there's no safety net, it's not well if I come in third, I'm still fine. Uh it's a pit in your stomach. Like, what did I just do to my political life, right? Yeah, I had a nice comfortable gig at the end. Sean's getting nervous. Now you're telling me Peter. Yeah, sorry. Yeah, that's right. No, it's good. It's good. No, but it's true, right? And then the same happens if you run provincially, right? That's happening a little less extent for me in the leadership race because I'm still an MLA. Whether I win, become leader or not, I'm still an MLA and I can still do the job for my constituents and and everything else.

SPEAKER_00But but it's it is a different role, it is a different job. What I've noticed over the the time that I've left is that, and this is across the province, is there seems to be a lot of cities and towns that have city councils that are trying to make city council work a full-time job. And it's not. And and I think that's where the problems start, is um people, counselors getting too ingrained in trying to direct staff to operations, um constantly following up on things, uh, getting too into the weeds with a constituent issue instead of the person who phoned about the the tree branch hanging low over their sidewalk, uh, instead of just passing that on to public works and getting someone to take care of it.

SPEAKER_00They're they're wanting to know from public works when it's going to be taken care of. And then the counselor's showing up on the sidewalk. And jumping in with their heads trimmers and uh put on their white hat and be the site supervisor of the job. And like I mean over dramatic, I guess, but but that's what I'm finding is that um uh people are are feeling, I think it's because of of access on phones and and and accessibility of the public. So I I understand where it's coming from in a way, that feeling of pressure, like I always have to be on, I always have to demonstrate, but it actually is, it does create problems in a system that's not really designed for that, and it creates confusion in the public service in a municipality because then they're like, well, who who am I actually answering to?

SPEAKER_00And if it's not firmly the mayor um who should be speaking on behalf of all of council, and I did that, there was there was things I didn't agree with the council was doing, but I would still defend it um after the fact because they won the vote. I would make sure staff were still following through on those instructions and those directions, and so that that built me credibility within the council that they could they could stay part-time because they trusted that I was following through on what their wishes were as well.

SPEAKER_04So I I think there's always that balance of of just trying to make sure that things are well you have to be kind of removed almost as a counselor, like you don't want to be right in the day-to-day because you're supposed to be providing some of that uh reflective perspective at the table, I would as opposed to yeah, I'm out there doing the thing all the time and uh yeah, trimming the hedges or whatever it is, uh customer service style calls.

SPEAKER_00And and again, I do think our phones have uh and technology has played a large part in that. So when I when I started in 2002, uh the controversy within council horseshoe was um half a council was not wanting and and and refused to use an electronic calendar. Um and so they still wanted uh stuff written down in daytime and and everything else. We had big controversy over our technology allowance of whether or not the city would help pay for our cell phone bill or should we have a laptop or not.

SPEAKER_00I mean, that was literally a year's couple years worth of discussion. By the time I left um in 2017, I mean I was probably getting upwards of a hundred emails a day as a right. And so, and and as an MLA, it's kind of similar. So so it's uh uh like I say, I do understand it. I'm not I'm not saying it to try to to be um you know a jerk about it, but but the system is not designed, and so it's like if if you're running for counsel or want to be a really effective counsel and and have staff kind of liking to work with you, frankly, and and help um stay out of their way, like direct them and and and guide them at the council table and make sure that that's being followed up on through the CAO, but but then kind of get out of the way and do what city counselors are and should be good at.

SPEAKER_00Show up to ribbon cuttings, show up to every community event known to man, and um and get your name and your face out that way and and talk to people on the ground in the community and then let the the you're supposed to be that's what you're supposed to be doing. Uh it's not meant to be the the parks worker um out at that community event, it's meant to be you. Let the parks worker deal with the issue in the park that you brought forward two days earlier, and and you go deal with with the community group in general, right?

SPEAKER_04So yeah. Well, you've been very generous with your time. Appreciate you squeezing us in. I know you've got a media hit to do here soon, so maybe we can wrap up the conversation with an opportunity for you to I'd love to hear your thoughts on the role of nonpartisan spaces given the polarized political landscape we're in right now. Council is supposed to be one of those areas. Uh, how do we get better decision making by putting aside some of these partisan fights that we see all the time?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I I did not own a party membership in any party, federally or provincially, until I decided to run uh provincially. And so I I bought my membership in 2016 as a VC Liberal uh to run in the nomination because I wanted to be able to legitimately say to people, um, yes, I obviously have my leanings. Um, you know, the NDP didn't invite me to very many, uh well, they never invited me to their fundraisers, I was invited to other fundraisers, and you say, well, I'll go to where I'm invited if my calendar works, right?

SPEAKER_00Um, and so I think there is that that space, and I I uh especially in communities the size of Parksville and Nanaimo and communities like Kamloops, um the the partisanship I think does a disservice at the local level. It's not, they aren't big enough cities. It's kind of like they're also not big enough cities to have full-time city councillors, right? You're not Surrey, um, you're not Vancouver. And so your populations don't don't necessitate that. Uh the needs don't necessitate that.

SPEAKER_00And it doesn't necessitate having the partisanship uh seep in. It doesn't mean you don't have, like I say, everyone knew uh the counselors that were green, quite literally green, and ran for the greens. Like you you can do that. We had counselors that ran federally for various parties and then come back to the council table. Uh I guess I'm I'm tipping off who around the council table ever actually made the leap to the next level was was one person um and sitting here today. Um so you know, and that was just you know, some of that is just timing of which party they ran for in the wrong cycle or whatever, right?

SPEAKER_00It wasn't that they weren't wouldn't have been good representatives at that other level. But so we were always able to to kind of let people go off and do their thing and then come back to the council table, and and I think it's incumbent on those that are even um a little more partisan uh in in their off hours to to kind of take a beat and take a step back when they get to the council table and say, that's not what I'm here for today, right? I'm not here um to to praise the government unnecessarily, and I'm not here to to um you know just take shots for the sake of taking shots.

SPEAKER_00Uh Leonard Krog would be a good example of that. Right. Um he is he has been pretty pointed, one of the more pointed uh critics of of things that the government is doing, especially around um addictions and and and cr public safety, crime and safety and all of that. Um, you know, but he's also, you know, at times worked with the government. So you gotta kind of again know your lane and stay in your lane. I'm a big fan of that, right? I I'm not a fan of provincial politicians that go running off out of their lane. We have we have very strong and capable MPs in BC, um, both parties, they can go to Ottawa and fight the fight in Ottawa, right?

SPEAKER_00You don't need MLAs fighting the Ottawa fight. Um, you don't need MLAs uh that wake up and and see that something happened in Arkansas this morning and so it's coming to BC for sure tomorrow, and then suddenly it's the topic of the day because they saw something on a social media feed, right? From some publication somewhere, a left or a right-wing publication, doesn't really matter, right? It's like, well, what does that what relevance does that have to do with what you're doing? What relevance would that have at the council table? And I actually had a media guy that would phone me up uh uh every morning around 6 30 and for his morning show and say, so this town and and it was always somewhere in the States, uh just passed this.

SPEAKER_00Do you think Camels would ever do that? And finally I just said, I'm not doing this anymore. And he said, What? I said, Because you you you're phoning me, you're asking me about something that council has never even remotely talked about, and then it gets torqued as if we are suddenly contemplating it, because the mayor just made comment about so I just stopped doing it. Yes. And that was kind of the aha moment for me of like, why are we getting caught up in stuff that has never even been in in quiet conversation with counselors talked about uh uh on the media, right?

SPEAKER_00So I think there are ways. Uh bottom line is um sorry, I ramble a lot. It's as I say to people, it's genetic, I get it from my mother. So um uh you know, there is ways to to keep that non-partisanship out of it while still being true to what your your political beliefs are, right? But whether or not you need to rebuild a road uh really isn't a partisan issue. Um I really don't care how you vote, uh federally or provincially. Um is the road in disrepair?

SPEAKER_00Does it need to be replaced? Maybe maybe you you get a little more aggressive on the lobbying for dollars or whatever, but at a certain point you either agree that it stays in the capital plan or you don't. Like what what does provincial or federal politics have to do with that, right? Um, or whether park benches should be made out of composite material or wood. Um okay, maybe there's an argument if you're in the Green Party that that there's a little bit more heft to your argument one way or the other, but ultimately that's still not a partisan.

SPEAKER_00And that's that's at its core what you're running for at local government. So I guess the final word I'd say to people is if you're running for local government to try to change how the province operates or try to change how even your neighboring community operates or the federal government operates, you're running for the wrong level of government. Right? And if you're running provincially to deal with Bill C, whatever federally, run to be an MP because you're you're running for the wrong level of government.

SPEAKER_00Like I think that's partly what what we get caught up in is your inboxes are probably the same people screaming and yelling at you about something the province has done. And then mayors and councils start trying to solve the provincial problem.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, all the time.

SPEAKER_00Instead of just saying, Well, go talk to your MLA. Yeah. Right? I I used to say that to people all the time in the mayor's office. Well, you better go talk to the MLA. I'm not trying to pass the buck, but that's who you need to talk to. Ironically enough, uh, my first five meetings as an MLA were people I'd sent to that MLE's office, but as the mayor, but you just switched your hat and like, oh, uh, you can talk to me now. Yes, but it was an appropriate conversation then. Then I actually had the ability to try to do something for them, right? And so that's that's what I'm driving at is that people just really do. I'm a I'm a huge fan of understanding what it is you're actually running for, um, and and then sticking to the lane of what that is.

SPEAKER_00And again, that doesn't mean I didn't hold the government to account. I had I had BC liberal governments the whole time I was there. Um, but it didn't mean that I didn't push back when we needed things like the hospital expansion or or other other issues. Um and so you you can do both, right? Uh it's not like they said I couldn't run for them because I was, you know, doing my job.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Um, I was doing my job, right? I remember getting uh Todd Stolen asked me, how come you sent me a letter about the ferries to Bella Cula? And I'm like, well, because council wanted that done.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And he's like, Well, how did that like how did that even come up? And I'm like, I don't know. The communities were sending letters to everybody asking for support. Council said we should send a letter of support. And he says, But why would you still send it? I said, Because the majority on council said we are sending a letter. And the mayor at that point sends the letter.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Right? And once even some people in the provincial government started to understand how the process worked, they went, Oh, okay, that's fair enough, right? Like you're doing your job. It's not a personal thing, it's just that's how the system is set up.

SPEAKER_03Peter, uh, as we wrap up, I really appreciate uh you making some time for us. I was down for the budget, and uh, you're a heck of a finance critic uh when you stood up after after uh finance minister stood up. And you know, from local government where uh the municipal finance authority uh ranks municipalities with an amazing credit rating because we're given rules that kind of provide excellent governance where you can kind of be hands-off and we just run balanced budgets. Uh, really appreciate your feedback to the government about their own budget and uh all the very best in your in your leadership race.

SPEAKER_03Really appreciate it.

SPEAKER_00Great, thank you, and and good luck on the the mayor oral aspirations. Thank you. It is a it is a it is a great job. Uh the mayor is the only head of elected government in Canada people directly vote for. When you think about it, you know, you don't vote directly for premier, you don't vote directly for prime minister. And it's also, and I I learned this as I traveled the world as the mayor, it's also the only title that every every nationality understands. Sure. Because premier in in different countries means different things, or president does, or whatever, right?

SPEAKER_00Whatever title of the head of that government is, um, governor, all that. Uh, but mayor is a mayor, is a mayor. Everyone understands what that is that you do. So it is a very unique uh position and and it's a lot of fun. Um and and good luck on city council as well. Well, thank you. But the mayor, the mayor, the mayor gig is a very unique and and special uh role that uh is for a lot of those types of reasons. Sure.

SPEAKER_04Absolutely. Well, thanks again. Really appreciate you coming on. Uh for our listeners, you can follow Peter's work as MLA for Kamloop Center and keep up on the BC Conservative Leadership Race, which wraps up on May 30th, I believe. Yep. And uh with that, we'll call to wrap on this uh episode of Nonpartisan Hacks.

SPEAKER_03Peter, thanks so much. We'd love to chat more, but uh you're a busy guy in this uh leadership race, so thank you again for making the time to time for us. You bet, thank you.

SPEAKER_04Until next time, take care of yourself and your community.

SPEAKER_02Ian Lindsay of Lindsay and Associates has played an active role in the local community since 1979. He has been with Remax, Vancouver Island's most advanced real estate business network, since nineteen ninety-six. Marketing and selling residential rural strata, recreational investment, and project development real estate. You'll find true real estate professionals at IanLindsey.ca.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Jackson Davies on The Beachcombers Boats Restoration & Travel Vaccines with Pharmacist Aki Shah

    Nov 18, 202644 minAudio

    "Send us a text about this episode!" Why You Should Listen to This Episode: Jackson Davies shares how two lines as a nameless Mountie turned into 16 years as Constable John Constable on The Beachcombers, what Bruno...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Jumanji (1995) - Special Guest Dan Sissons Jumanji Prop Master

    Nov 18, 20261 hr 17 minAudio

    "Send us a text about this episode!" What happens when the person who built one of the most famous props in movie history sits down to rewatch the film it starred in? On this episode of Too Old or Movie Gold, Vancouver...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Week 10 NFL Surprises, Grey Cup Sunday, Fantasy Frustrations and BBQ Beef Sliders

    Nov 18, 202630 minAudio

    "Send us a text about this episode!" BONUS RECIPE: Download Chef Jonathan Frazier's Recipe for Slow-Cooked BBQ Beef Sliders: https://pulselinks.ca/S2EP10FootballRecipe Erin Haluschak and Chef Jonathan Frazier kick off...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Jason Priestley & Cindy Sampson of Private Eyes West Coast and the 18th Annual Tigh-Na-Mara Toy Drive for SOS

    Nov 11, 202638 minAudio

    "Send us a text about this episode!" Why You Should Listen to This Episode: Jason Priestley and Cindy Sampson are back as Matt Shade and Angie Everett, now married, raising a baby and solving crimes in Victoria on...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. NFL Week 9 - Quarterback Injuries, Fantasy Football Decisions & Jalapeño Poppers

    Nov 11, 202627 minAudio

    "Send us a text about this episode!" BONUS RECIPE: Download Chef Jonathan Frazier's Recipe for Homemade Jalapeño Poppers: https://bit.ly/S2EP09FootballRecipe The NFL season has reached its halfway point, and Jonathan...

    Credit the people on this episode