Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Progress Report Podcast

The Progress Report Podcast artwork

What the hell did the Supreme Court just do?

Jul 3, 202657 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

It was a historic week at the Supreme Court, as the conservative justices took a wrecking ball to some segments of society and (barely) spared a few of Americans’ most basic constitutional rights. The court handed down eight decisions, some of which invented new standards to bully trans kids, gave the president carte blanche to fire regulators, and unleashed a torrent of dark money on our elections. They also Donald Trump several significant and embarrassing losses, though even those decisions come with intrigue and indications of future trouble. I’m no lawyer, so to really understand these decisions, their implications, and the broader question of how the hell we are going to get out of this situation, I spoke with Lisa Graves, a former senior counsel on the Senate Judiciary Committee and the co-founder of Court Accountability and True North Research. She’s also a cohost of Legal AF and author of Without Precedent, a book that chronicles Chief Justice John Roberts’s rise and how he has quietly defiled and rewritten the constitution again and again during his two decades at the Supreme Court. Our conversation touched on all of those decisions and much more beyond; you can watch the whole thing above or excerpts below. First up, I asked Graves about the court’s decision in NRSC v. Federal Election Commission, which repealed what thin veneer of campaign finance limitations remained. The decision removes the limits on the amount of money that political parties can spend in coordination with a candidate, opening the door for even more billionaire influence on elections. Graves explained the ins and outs of what it means and how it works: Soon after, we moved on to another decision, where the court upheld birthright citizenship. It was certainly good news, but not unequivocally so, as four justices - one short of a majority! - were willing to accept a manufactured right-wing “theory” claiming that the 14th amendment does not mean what everyone has unanimously accepted it means for the past 150 years. I wanted to understand how the hell we got to this point and whether these justices - who all attended the best law schools in the country and presumably have closely studied the constitution - were just being cynical opportunists or actually somehow believe the stupidest interpretation of tha amendment possible. I spent much of the Biden administration campaigning for Senate Democrats to seriously investigate the blatant corruption on the court, particularly the clear bribes taken by many of the right-wing justices. Graves played a large role in breaking those stories with ProPublica Judiciary Committee chair Dick Durbin did everything he could to avoid taking meaningful action, and over the past few years, I’ve theorized that the lack of consequences - or even a real investigation into the millions of dollars in gifts, trips, and financial help provided to the justices - emboldened them to author even more extreme rulings. Obviously, I asked Graves what she tought about that: OK, let’s end on a hopeful note. Here, we talk about how we can stop the bleeding and reverse the damage being done to American democracy, civil rights, and human rights all across the world. The easy answer is Supreme Court reform, but what does that mean, exactly? For Graves, it’s an expansive to-do list, and to give you a bit of hope going into this holiday weekend, she thinks it’s closer than it might seem. Wait, Before You Leave! Progress Report has raised over $7 million dollars for progressive candidates and causes, breaks national stories about corrupt politicians, and delivers incisive analysis, and goes deep into the grassroots. None of the money we’ve raised for candidates and causes goes to producing this newsletter or all of the related projects we put out. In fact, it costs me money to do this. So, I need your help. You can support Progress Report for just $5 a month. You can also make a one-time donation to Progress Report’s GoFundMe campaign! This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.progressreport.news

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01i am very excited to be joined by lisa graves who is um you know she's got a lot of titles you know i was looking i was putting together this this introduction this little document and i mean you know i could go on for a while she's a lot of distinctions she's the co-founder of courtability a court accountability and true north research she's the former chief counsel the senate judiciary uh committee she wrote a book you see in the background without precedent uh it's about john roberts's takeover uh moving the supreme court to the right um and she's uh she co-hosts legal af

SPEAKER_01on midas touch network so she is very busy uh so i'm very lucky that she's joining me here talking about the supreme court so lisa uh thanks without further ado thanks for being here um thank you so much

SPEAKER_02for inviting me i was chief counsel for nominations uh there was a chief counsel but thank you so much for that kind introduction

SPEAKER_01that's very humble of you i would uh that's like a while ago so like well uh there you go that's the kind of person you are so thank you for uh thank you for being here and i guess we can jump right to it there's actually news that came out this i've been following i follow voting rights a lot i'm not a lawyer but a journalist i cover that a lot um and one thing i've been covering a lot is the executive orders on mail-in voting uh obviously uh this this week the supreme court ruled that they can um uh which call it ballots can show up a little bit later as long as there are times that are postal stamps uh whatever uh you know postmarked by by election day

SPEAKER_01but just today a judge um uh court blocked the usps's plan to withhold mail ballots from states that wouldn't cooperate and hand over just their unredacted voter rolls to the administration and that was a big part of his executive order um and i'm curious when you make a bad because you know it's um supreme court session's done um you they're going to hear some more voting cases in the fall but what do you make of that does that mean that they're not going to be able to do it

SPEAKER_02or are they just going to what do you think well that is a great result at the lower court level uh because that that order that intention by trump and by the postmaster general dennis steiner is is unconstitutional is outrageous um but that's the lower court's determination which is spot on the law the u.s postal service has no business playing a role in in trying to implement donald trump's unconstitutional effort to take over and federalize the elections but clearly they're signaling that they're going

SPEAKER_02to continue to try to move this tack forward and you know this happens in the in the aftermath of the decision by the supreme court as you mentioned in the watson case where the supreme court the roberts court agreed that just because congress set a day of election a uniform day of election for congressional elections it didn't mean that you couldn't have early voting or you know when the votes could be counted and you know the the claims in that case were just ridiculous because you know on election day on

SPEAKER_02the national you know national election day in in november um what we see in the media is the projection from the you know the uh in many counties particularly in cities where there are millions of voters it takes a while to count the votes and then to allow people to um to uh to fix their ballots if they made a provisional ballot like they came in and didn't have an id in that id state come back in give their id so their provisional ballot will be counted um and in that watson case what was

SPEAKER_02at issue was ballots that were postmarked by election day and then arrive afterwards and we of course have no control over how long it takes to get the mail in fact under donald trump's uh postmaster generals and under his um his sort of takeover of the postal service in years past what we saw was the consolidation of mail centers so that you you know everyone's mail is taking longer because basically lewis de joy was trying to part out the postal service by creating these um regional processing centers

SPEAKER_02so your mail isn't postmarked at your post office unless you walk in the door and get it postmarked it gets sent off someplace else and then sent back and so it's a common sense rule to say that the mail the postmark is the right date and it just takes a couple days and by the way and you may remember this back in 2020 donald trump went to court to prevent the state of pennsylvania counties from counting the ballots ahead of the end of election day because they knew they were going to have so many mail-in ballots due to covid

SPEAKER_02that they were going to have to count those ballots into the night into the next day and the day after and back then trump didn't want those ballots open until nine you know eight or nine p.m on election night um and you know that meant that there were going to be even more delays in finalizing the results of the election so this is just the same old game by donald trump trying to claim any any election he wins is legitimate any election he or his loyalists lose is illegitimate and trying to use the postal service to accomplish that and disrupt our elections

SPEAKER_01yeah you know and you know with the california election recently right with the primary election i mean that's the one he criticized a lot because they were counting afterwards right because they were counting for days because california is such a mail-in vote state you know but he like you said in pennsylvania in 2020 he wanted to stop them from counting afterwards and so it's like he's setting it up so that he can just so he can like delegitimize all of it right he's creating these obstacles so he can say look it doesn't count

SPEAKER_02yeah i mean and in pennsylvania it was like they couldn't open them that day during you know or ahead of election day they could only open them after the polls closed and of course this all happens in the in the midst of donald trump himself voting by mail and say of course he did of course he can and in some states people only vote by mail and in other states people predominantly vote by mail because it's more convenient in california that was an um a particularly unusual circumstance compared to other states because california has this super restrictive matching of the signatures between

SPEAKER_02the signature on the poll the rolls for the voters and the signature on the envelope and i know my signature is often different depending on how long i'm taking to sign it but that's what was taking so long in california was first the numerosity like millions of ballots in los angeles but also then comparing you know one by one by one those ballots so this is just another tactic by trump and what i'm also concerned about is some of the reporting out this week about the notion that trump has assigned a sort of right-wing journalist might be

SPEAKER_02the wrong terminology for a guy who who's buddies with steve bannon but he's assigned this guy who was a journalist to amount this case of so-called of supposed foreign interference by pushing for the declassification of documents from the intelligence committee community which we think or i think is another way for donald trump to try to assert by executive order that he can nationalize or federalize the elections if he claims there's foreign interference when you know we all know what happened

SPEAKER_02in 2016 which was donald trump invited the foreign interference of russia saying hey go get those emails of hillary clinton um and then denied that there was any you know actual russian interference even though the intelligence community found that russia was buying but russian bots in essence and and groups were buying huge numbers of ads in facebook to divide americans but leaving all that aside that's where the foreign interference was it was donald trump inviting the foreign appearance back then but you know so we this this election continues

SPEAKER_02to be at risk it continues to be at risk from the machinations of donald trump to try to use the postal service to block the postal service from from giving ballots to americans who are entitled to them but their state doesn't cooperate with donald trump's demands for their for their voter rolls and by the way on that issue donald trump has lost over and over and over again on those demands and mark elias and other groups have spearheaded that litigation and that's because donald trump has no right to the voter rolls of americans and in fact

SPEAKER_02the fact that our voter voting processes is so decentralized is one of the things that helps guard against election theft the guard against someone internally or externally i mean and you bring that up being blocked over and over to try

SPEAKER_01to get these voter rolls i mean it was something that a court i think blocked a week or two ago right this uh this national list and it i did a story about this like you know i work for the union and we did a long story about it i was getting confused by the amount of lists and and like the things they were going to check it against it was pretty it was pretty confusing like there's my job to know um like the things they wanted to check uh people's i guess names against the what you call the same system in terms of the um uh social security then they wanted to the postal office like a list people can check it again it just seems all an effort

SPEAKER_01to purge voters and now i understand that they're still working to try and the court's going to take a case about border purges in the fall that's going to make it possible to you know purge things even closer to an auction

SPEAKER_02i mean it's really extraordinary one of the things that was astonishing when the watson decision came out was this absurd claim by trump's ally saying that they were disappointed because they they really are concerned about about voters and voters intent if they were concerned about voters intent they would be trying to make sure the voters ballots are counted not trying to find everything everywhere under the sun to disqualify them and you know we've seen part of this playbook

SPEAKER_00before this was the chris kobach playbook out of california

SPEAKER_02around and over the past couple years that there's like 30 lisa graves one of them is like into witchcraft i don't know who she is she you know writes books about it she's not me i don't know how many people share your name how many times you can probably not a lot but you know right of like lisa graves at gmail like that's taken over and over like there are common names and so you know we can't have a 1-800 big brother situation where someone in washington who's loyal to donald trump is deciding whether you can vote in whatever state you are because they think there's another person with your name in another state and supposedly that's you it's it's ridiculous and

SPEAKER_02and these methods have not been proven to be accurate at all in fact you know one of the reasons why the resistance to the save act in congress was is so strong largely by democrats but by some republicans is because this again is a solution it's not even a solution but it's claimed to be a solution in search of a problem that doesn't exist which is voter fraud there's no cognizable voter fraud no stitches would be significant voter fraud people who vote twice you know if they do it's super rare they risk jailing

SPEAKER_02if they're an immigrant that's even rarer for an immigrant to vote they risk deportation and you know a criminal sentence this is not a real actual threat every single blue ribbon commission that has looked at it has found this is not actually something that's happening in america to the extent that there ever is some amount of voter fraud or people voting twice in recent years it's been a lot of trumpsters but by a lot i mean like less than a dozen right oh yeah um you know it's not a real thing but that save act which trump now is trying to use the supreme court decisions to push forward

SPEAKER_02as well is about disqualifying millions of voters from being able to vote and in particular women women who take their spouse's name when they get married or husbands who take a joint name when they get married or same-sex couples who have a hybrid name and if you don't have that if your birth certificate and your driver's license don't match they may disqualify you particularly in you know so-called red states that are you know cooperating with trump and this you know this is outlandish

SPEAKER_02because it doesn't just affect democrats i don't know why they think it would it would affect people from both parties all parties but particularly would be a hardship for women and this comes in the midst of you know uh sort of close association or bosom buddies for example by pete hegseth with some preacher who claims women shouldn't even have the right to vote like this is that's also absurd of course the constitution says women can vote and of course women should be able to vote but you know this is not happening in a vacuum this is a wholesale effort

SPEAKER_02to make it harder for people to vote and the other part of that save act is access to these voter rolls it's what they want to to gather to glean in order to stop votes from counting to basically make sure that only the votes they want will count and that's just not how a democracy is supposed to work so you know i'm i'm happy the court did not go along with the effort coming out of mississippi by the republican party to block the votes from being counted if they are received

SPEAKER_02after election day within a few days of election day that would affect voters from both parties um i think that's also one of the distinguishing components of what we're seeing um you know we're seeing out of supreme court is that if the if the issue would would very much help republicans like the changing of the maps the voter the voter um you know the voter changes this this spring then the republican appointed judges on the Supreme Court are yeah very happy full speed ahead go ahead redraw your maps but something like counting those ballots that are mailed after the fact you know in

SPEAKER_02that instance it doesn't give the republicans a decided advantage and so they didn't do it on the other hand when you look at the FEC case from just yesterday where the republican national you know republican senatorial committee wanted to strike down the long-standing limits spending limits uh for coordinated activity um against you know democrats who were opposing that largely um of course the republican dominated supreme court said sure yeah go ahead in fact

SPEAKER_02the first moment compels you in essence the first moment blocks anyone from regulating uh blocks congress from limiting this activity even though just 25 years ago the supreme court said there's nothing unconstitutional

SPEAKER_01about these types of spending limits and that was going to be my next question so perfect segue like this this is a big deal we talked about citizens united as a huge huge kind of groundbreaking shifted the terrain in terms of elections this one uh like you mentioned that being able to coordinate money between party and campaigns i don't know if it's gonna be as big but it's huge and i think it's probably gotten less covered because of the birthright citizenship and other everything else which i also talked to you about birthright citizenship but um could you walk us through what this means practically and

SPEAKER_01because you know i think it's gonna change i'm sure a lot this fall uh day because we're probably gonna have a lot of money but be just like the way everything works what's allowed

SPEAKER_02yeah you know this i think the coverage on this has been harder just because it's a you know it's a complex part of the campaign finance law otherwise known as the anti-corruption law and most people know like most people in america don't make enough money to even meet the limits so you know you wouldn't you wouldn't even know there was a limit because you couldn't possibly like give enough money to a political party or to a candidate to get the limit based on the average per capita income in the united states it's sort of like just by the way back when i was working uh for the federal judiciary when i was

SPEAKER_02the deputy chief of the article three judges division and we were working with the judges in july i noticed that their pay went up and i asked my boss like why is this and he says oh that's because of the cap on social security so by july all the federal judges in the country stopped paying into social security because they've hit the you know the cap i think it's now like 120 or something yeah um and then they they get they get basically a pay a take-home pay increase so you you wouldn't know it unless you had that salary level so it's the same thing with this campaign finance rule ordinary americans aren't ever going to run into

SPEAKER_02that spending limit because they're not even running into the you know the overall limit um of of donations within a cycle which i think is uh somewhere around 128 000 um or the equivalent right so but the billionaires care right because they are hit by it so this is about helping the billionaires again that's why i think the citizen united decision shouldn't be called citizens united despite its actual technical name it should be called billionaires united because that's what it's really all about so this is a way in which you know um

SPEAKER_02if you look at the actual sort of numbers of billionaires numbers of democratic billionaires numbers of republican billionaires in the united states there's more republican billionaires and those billionaires are very active in electoral politics george soros is someone who has been active in the in the non-profit sector in particular in trying to protect civil society from rising authoritarianism but when you look at the numbers of billionaires on the right and the left there's they have an advantage and so you can see how they would want to have no limits on these

SPEAKER_02on this coordinated spending and that's what this that's what this is about and it is a further effort by this roberts court to limit the ability of congress to regulate corruption to limit the undue influence of these billionaires who um i think the the famous phrase it might have been bob dylan was you know money doesn't talk it screams but um you know in this instance money allows these billionaires to scream so loudly and through so many megaphones and the coordination is a big deal um

SPEAKER_02because it allows them to have you know a more coordinated campaign uh toward the victory that they're hoping for um i have to say because i just feel like i'm compelled to say this but uh so i hope you'll uh bear with me but the citizen decision was a fundamentally illegitimate decision not just on the merits not just on this arrogance of the supreme court claiming that the first amendment commands that congress cannot limit the spending of this outside money to influence our elections like that itself was

SPEAKER_02an outright outrageous in you know grafting onto the first amendment to protect big money dark money but it was also a decision that was five to four um and clarence thomas sat on that case even though we now know his wife jenny thomas received five hundred thousand dollars from harlan crowe the nazi memorabilia collector the real estate airing texas gave her half a million dollars to start a tea party group to take advantage of the decision to come she got that money or was told about

SPEAKER_02that money like around new year's eve just uh two weeks before the decision was about to come out in citizens united she rushed uh with her friends to get uh an llc so she could deposit the check an expedited llc this is on new year's eve uh there's no scenario in which jenny thomas doesn't talk to clarence thomas about the fact that their benefactor who's been taking them on trips and luxury occasions just gave her a half mil for her org and then just a couple weeks later clarence thomas is there casting

SPEAKER_02the fifth vote in what would have been a four-to-four decision which would have let the campaign laws stand and he cast the deciding vote that decision never should have gone forward and just to underscore the arrogance and outrageousness of this in that case in citizens united clarence thomas issued a concurring opinion claiming that disclosure would be unconstitutional because it would chill the giving of money oh i'm sure yeah i'm sure

SPEAKER_02that he had just that his wife had just received you know a six-figure sum from his billionaire benefactor no and so that decision is poisoned from the from the jump right that is and this decision builds on that citizen decision we're gonna have to over get that decision overturned we're gonna have to restore the ability of congress to you know put in fit in for common sense rules about this dark money because these billionaires it's not it shouldn't be a dollarocracy they shouldn't get so much more say than us in our elections based on

SPEAKER_02these massive megaphones and now due to this case that you so kindly asked me to describe now to do so on a more coordinated basis

SPEAKER_01so like the party let's say rcc republican senate uh campaign committee they can work with let's say harlan crow elon musk whoever whoever wants to donate money whichever uh super PAC whichever whomever give money they can give money to these committees and they can just go spend it alongside with the candidates right it's like they can just they communicate they coordinate it's

SPEAKER_02now everything is go for it yeah there was there was a cap on on uh on how much could be spent that could be coordinated uh in order to it was sort of the last little sliver of uh you know so just to step back a second the reason this this uh activity is called dark money is because you know back in the 1970s when congress replaced the anti-corruption act with the federal election campaign act feca what they were trying to say is you shouldn't be able to give more than x amount to any politician for his

SPEAKER_02or her campaign and to the party and and you shouldn't be able to give more than you know why amount in a cycle and so and if you give money it's disclosed and who you are is disclosed and the idea was that would limit the influence of any one person on a candidate if everyone can only max out the same amount let's say it's 2800 or something um you know then everyone is sort of equal that the the millionaires the pre-billionaires at the time they couldn't give you know 100 000 a million dollars and anything they gave to the party or

SPEAKER_02to the candidate would be disclosed and so it with citizens united and the follow-on cases after citizen united that created super packs what happened was suddenly there was the ability to give unlimited funds to a superpower is to a super pack that you couldn't give directly to a candidate or to a party and then there was the way in which these entities these different non-profit entities were relating to each other and one of the last remaining rules was this cap on the spending uh

SPEAKER_02if coordinated money so now that cap is struck and so there aren't limits on how much money can be spent in that kind of coordination so it really does supercharge the billionaires as if they needed to be supercharged even more

SPEAKER_01as if they didn't have enough influence you know yeah you wouldn't want to silence them elon musk okay you know he's always at risk of being silenced a guy right some billionaires aren't

SPEAKER_02doing dark money right it's right out in the open but it's still too much money for any one person because then you have politicians that are beholden to that individual you know and not to the american people not to the people who voted for them and that's because you know what part of what musk and others are doing is propagandizing individuals with disinformation with you know attack ads against the opponents in order to get their guy or their woman into office to do their bidding and that's why so much of the congressional uh policy is distorted toward things like

SPEAKER_02the so-called big beautiful bill which i call the big billionaire bailout bill um you know where you know our our taxes we're paying more in taxes than most billionaires that's ridiculous it's not beautiful it's big it's big but it sure as heck isn't beautiful but that we get that distortion out not just because it's who can run for office meaning you know are you have a viable campaign if billy if you don't have a billionaire on your side for some of these big races it affects what type of legislation is brought up whether we're going to regulate ai for example or these data centers or we're going

SPEAKER_02to stop these mass massive mega mergers that are driving our not our cable bills but our streaming bills up and up and up you know you know are we going to regulate against you know poisons in our air and water you know or are we going to have a congress that you know is in the pocket of the fossil fuel industry and so um you know this affects us in a lot of ways in terms of the quality of our life and so this was another case this case just this week by the roberts court that basically puts billionaires in the driver's seat and and leaves us behind on

SPEAKER_02the road on the side of the

SPEAKER_01and i feel like there's so many steps we have to take to get back to like even like uh equilibrium where we were even like 15 years ago right it's just it's like and we'll talk about solutions in a second but i wanted the one thing i wanted to ask before we get there is um the final ruling this week uh was personal citizenship and uh on the positive they affirmed that uh as has been for 150 plus years if you are born in the united states you are an american right in almost all cases but it was like six three slash five four right like it wasn't it was uncomfortable

SPEAKER_01and you know it's kind of it's crazy that it even got heard right like the president could say no more citizenship for certain people like that yeah you know that's that's nazi-esque it's insane that it got heard but the fact that it's like four of the nine justices one away from majority said that you know maybe the 14th amendment doesn't say exactly what everyone's been saying it's been saying for 150 years um how do you how did we get and then you write write this in your book how things have changed but how do you even get to that point and like does that feed feed you like are you obviously you're happy about

SPEAKER_01the decision but are you like looking at it like oh this is not over we're in trouble however many years from now

SPEAKER_02yeah i mean this is a case where it reveals the utter lie of so-called originalism or textualism they don't care about the text when it is against what they want um we saw that with the immunity decision where john roberts invented immunity out of thin air for donald trump basically pardoning him and then sweeping him back into power by signaling to some subset of the american people that he did no wrong and could do no wrong that he could not be charged with the crimes that he you know that there was ample evidence that he committed um and so

SPEAKER_02in this instance like you said this shouldn't even have been a case this should have been smacked back you know just no this is contrary to the language of the constitution it's contrary to you know 140 almost 140 years of supreme court precedent is contrary to the statute the immigration statute and that's been on the books now for i don't know we're going on 80 years or more um this court is acting like every issue is just a brand new issue and they just get to change their change their mind

SPEAKER_02or disregard precedent disregard history disregard disregard language to get to the result they want it's utter lawlessness by the dissenting group and you know for clarence thomas to basically assert that the 14th one only applied to that first generation of newly freed slaves is so it's so offensive and so grotesque um it really really is um and then you you have kavanaugh sort of ducking and being like well i'm only gonna i'm only gonna look at the statute you know not the constitution he keeps trying to have his cake

SPEAKER_02and eat it too somehow um because he doesn't have any principles in my personal opinion and then you have alito and gorsuch who are united basically in advancing a really far-right reactionary america you know i'm not surprised given alito's roots you can see what he wrote when he was a reagan administration attorney trying to get a promotion how devoted he was to this right wing agenda including as i've written about his opposition to having the apportionment cases you know cases about protecting voting rights in america

SPEAKER_02that was something that was an anathema to him and then of course neil gorsuch who i can't refer to ever without really saying neil fascism forever club uh gorsuch uh that's you know kind of who he was as a young man was you know thinking that fascism was fabulous he sort of claimed that you know those were youthful indiscretions i suppose but his decisions tell a different story the decisions tell a story that he is committed to this mega maga agenda even when it is actually contemptuous of the constitution

SPEAKER_02and and remember this executive order that trump signed he signed it just moments after he was sworn in as president of the united states where he took an oath that john roberts administered that he was going to faithfully execute the constitution which um like i keep joking although not so joking execute you know basically execute the laws united states meaning to implement them not kill them right but there he is on january 20 saying as of february 20th he himself gets to decide who's a citizen regardless of what the constitution has always said

SPEAKER_02and this theory this ridiculous fringe theory that they put forward about the meaning of the 14th amendment comes straight out of the playbook of the guy who was advising uh advising donald trump to subvert the 2020 election who got disbarred in california for his efforts to try to prevent our votes from being counted in 2020 and that theory was put in place or you know set out there in an op-ed to try to say that kamala harris couldn't run for president because she's not a real citizen

SPEAKER_02because her parents were students were here on student visas that's the poisonous origin of this super nasty theory that we now have three slash four of the republican appointees saying yes what that means is that we have we're one heartbeat away from them possibly having the votes to do this if one of the democratic appointees were to not be on the bench with a republican president or republican congress they could get the votes To destroy our constitutional rights in this instance roberts did

SPEAKER_02The right thing but he did the right thing In the aftermath of a whole 18 month period Basically you know 17 month period Of doing the wrong thing all these emergency orders siding with trump overturning these lower court temporary restraining orders on all sorts of things these massive cuts the doge the what i call the dodgy act of elon musk to cut you know cut down agencies john roberts you know sort of lifelong hostility to the voting rights act you know giving the pin to alito to destroy what was left

SPEAKER_02of the voting rights act uh you know this so-called administrative state attack through slaughter where john roberts eagerly overturns a precedence on the books for more than you know 90 years um in order to accomplish his agenda to destroy what they call the administration administration which is really the the ability of us to have federal agencies that are implementing the congressional laws to protect our public health to protect our economy um and to make sure that we have experts and people who you know a bipartisan basis

SPEAKER_02for resolving things when you look at the ftc um right now what you see since last march is that uh when trump fired the democratic appointees that left two republicans on that ftc so there's not even a democrat in the room they don't want a democrat in the room to be considering these mergers they can't be in the room where it happens because they might see evidence or information about these mergers that would you know become part of the public record in a way that they don't like they want to have just trump loyalists making decisions that type of cronyism um uh is it has not been part of american modern american law

SPEAKER_02and for good reason and john roberts has swept it back in in part because when he was some 20 something guy and no offense to any 20 something year olds out there he wrote a memo saying you know why you know why shouldn't presidents be able to fire these commissioners and so here you have a guy who had this thought bubble when he was a young man and barely a lawyer only been a lawyer for a little while but in a high position due to his you know friends in high places and then he with absolute arrogance uses the judicial power here in 2026 to impose his idea

SPEAKER_02from way back when as a lawyer when he was a lawyer for the Reagan administration right that's not what a judge should do a judge should be applying the law fairly a judge should be honoring the precedents that court after court after court and president after president have honored not just using donald trump as an opportunity to accomplish his personal wish list and that's one of the reasons why i wrote without precedent because john roberts you know wasn't put on the court to be fair he was put on the court to impose this very regressive agenda for uh for on the american people

SPEAKER_02um to drag us back to before the new deal to drag us back to

SPEAKER_01that robert baron era you know i'm curious you know you can't know what's in their hearts obviously but like you you've worked for a lot of a lot of years kind of researching these people knowing these people um you think about the birthright citizenship thing like you said four basically four justices were didn't want to say hey the 14th amendment grant you these guys are ideologues you know hugely ideologues but they also went to law school they went to good law schools they worked in the government for a very long time presumably they kind of understand the way people understood the constitution for a long time do you think it's they're being opportunists

SPEAKER_01or really just they're finally taking the mask off and saying hell we never thought they'd allow birthright citizenship i struggle because none other is good they're either super cynical or insane but it's hard to know which one is what

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think the mask has fallen. I think, you know, when you saw when Ruth Bader Ginsburg died right before the 2020 election that September, and they had that big rose garden ceremony for Amy Coney Barrett, like the done deal, they were going to push her through as Americans were voting Donald Trump out of office, even though they had blocked Barack Obama's nominee for the Supreme Court in 2016, claiming you just can't have a confirmation during an election until the people vote. when they were pushing

SPEAKER_02that wasn't just about the anti-choice agenda you know getting the vote it needed it was about having six votes which meant there was no single swing vote that could impede them from rapidly implementing their agenda so you know having thought have five to four means you know one person could be swayed on an issue and slow them down but once they got that supermajority that sixth vote then it's like you know all steam ahead this sort of approach that john roberts had taken over the years patiently

SPEAKER_02since he's a lifetime appointee under the current way the system is structured you know just patiently this year it's this year it's taking down the wall between the separation of church and state this year it's gun issues that year it's abortion what another year it's you know like they're setting a political agenda because they have hardly any actual required cases to take those are cases between two states almost every case they take is a matter of discretion meaning they have at least four votes who want to take a case and so they're setting up this slate

SPEAKER_02and they set this up with this president in this year uh to take him up on the on the invitation to overturn humphrey's executive which has been on john roberts wish list for you know 40 plus years and so i think that I think that originalism was always a made-up theory to try to drag us back to some past era to have us, you know, enchained in their view of what a slaveholder would have thought should be the scope

SPEAKER_02of our rights circa 1791 So it's been a tool, it's been an invented tool of regressivism And I will tell you, having studied this deeply for many years the origin story in essence of originalism was that they hated brown versus board of education and they wanted to have a way to attack it and there were these books that they were writing saying hey you can't have brown versus board because there were segregated schools in the district of columbia after

SPEAKER_02the civil war and so brown versus board was illegitimate in this originalist view that wasn't gaining a lot of traction because even though there was a continuing thread of white supremacy in the united states there was not an appetite to embrace that as a legal matter to say that brown wrong and so they really decided to focus in on roe versus wade and attacking that as as white as you know their their cause and that's actually what the first meeting of the federal society was all about it was about roe and it was about this originalist attack on roe

SPEAKER_02but now we can see that it doesn't mean anything because if they were originalist they would not have invented immunity for donald trump it's totally contrary to the origins of our you know the federalist the actual federals papers and you know so we're trying

SPEAKER_01to have a king then

SPEAKER_02yeah you know we're not a king we had you know he had created revolution against king -like powers um and you wouldn't see them doing things like with the voting rights act their language is very clear in the vra the case the mobile versus bolding case that congress was uh overturning uh that was the case that uh bill reinquist signed on to who was john roberts mentor then bill reinquist makes a call to the justice department when reagan comes in and says hey hire john roberts

SPEAKER_02and so he gets hired at the top of the justice department what's he put in charge of oh voting rights the attack on congress's effort to fix this this particular issue of vote dilution and um and john roberts spends hundreds of hours fighting it and loses loses so he knows damn well that when he joined this opinion uh in the clay case this year he was accomplishing through judicial fiat what he could not win in the reagan administration which was

SPEAKER_02to basically reverse the clock and allow these racially gerrymandered districts to happen by claiming they're not racial.

SPEAKER_01That's what he did when he was in the Justice Department. He wanted that they had to prove that there was racist intent without a shadow of a doubt. Now I think Samuel Lito decided that racism doesn't exist in his world because this is something they've been trying to do for like 40 plus years.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. And to your point, I don't know what's in their heart

SPEAKER_01right now one thing i wanted to you know you were very involved and the uh kind of investigations into these uh like you mentioned before harlan crowe all the corruption all the amount of money going to um you know just it was loans or houses and whatever vacations on yachts things going to alito things go to clarence thomas uh them first and foremost of this as well um you know i was very i mean i think anyone was like outraged by it right

SPEAKER_01finding out what they found out more i think outraged but the lack of doing anything about it right there was a point where democrats had control and you know I you know when you're judge or court just and the way that was just allowed to just be and exist kind of like galvanize them in a way to kind of do whatever they want this term you think if there was any sort of like real um i don't know like public shaming or some sort of consequence

SPEAKER_01that things would be different maybe that's just me projecting

SPEAKER_02but i've always thought that well i i really appreciate the point because this is corruption it's corruption for someone to befriend a justice or a judge after they get on the bench then they're friends then there's some sort of massive loophole in in clarence thomas's head where he's like well he was my friend and so i'm just getting massive gifts from my friend doesn't matter even that his friend is actually a major donor to the republican party to george w bush to you know republican causes you know helps fund these right-wing groups

SPEAKER_01that friends just pay shows mortgages off all the time

SPEAKER_02yeah right and you know and and or alito the arrogance of that absurd interview in the wall street journal where he's like hey paul singer was just going to the same place as me and he had a uh an empty seat on his plane and so it's a-okay and i didn't go to alaska it was fine they were going on a vacation together it wasn't like you know we were both going to alaska yeah who knew like you could just hang out at the private jet uh lounge and just catch a catch a ride with a billionaire going your way i mean it is really blatant

SPEAKER_02it's it's really pretty outrageous and you know the paul singer thing continues to be salient in part because singer has major investments and had you know a case that came up to the spring court and he now there are cases coming up on fossil fuels where he's a major investor in fossil fuels so there's a lot of overlap in terms of the billionaires who are either befriending these justices or who are backing campaigns to get them on the court and i do think i take your point that it's possible that they've been emboldened

SPEAKER_02in some ways by the lack of consequence and in fact you've seen alito assert that there can be no consequences right that under under their absurd uh construction of separation of powers there's no ability of congress to regulate them notwithstanding the fact that congress created the size of the court or the judiciary act funds the you know building funds the clerks uh you know created the legislation of the judicial conference which sets policy um not with the fact that these justices every year sign

SPEAKER_02a document that's required by the office the government the ethics and government act saying that here's all the money that they have to disclose under federal law but instead you have this court treating itself like it is untouchable and john roberts has asserted as much uh in that you know so-called ethics um that he announced on the eve of the vote to issue subpoenas to harlan crowe and leonard leo by senate judiciary committee suddenly roberts you know releases this ethics code well that

SPEAKER_02ethics code is less has a lower standard than the code that applies to all other federal judges in the country first of all second of all it's totally non-enforceable there's no enforcement mechanism third each of those justices including clarence thomas and samuelito a sign that they comply with it which means it means nothing you know given all the gifts that that they've taken and and in particular thomas especially and in that code it absurdly insanely says that these justices can sit on cases even

SPEAKER_02if they have a conflict of interest due to the rule of necessity if their vote is needed to resolve it that's not federal law you don't get to sit on a case because you want someone wants the case to be decided in one side or another by a biased person who has an interest in the case no the case then just isn't decided it's a tie too bad that's just the way impartial justice is supposed to work so yeah i think they've been emboldened by the lack of consequences and i but what i see is a real call for accountability both among policymakers

SPEAKER_02and increasing number of policymakers calling for you know court reforms of an array of types of court reforms and people across the country saying this is rank this is foul we don't trust this court this court is not worthy of our trust based on both the cloud of corruption that surrounds it and also these ridiculous decisions that are contrary to the constitution statutes regulations contracts precedents you know and and our you know culture in a way in terms of like you know

SPEAKER_02this what this administration is trying to do for example and how this this court has helped it so yeah i think they've been emboldened but i think there's wow there is a movement building for real accountability and i would say when you think about the voting rights cases that you've written about um and you know have worked on so much part of it is a in my view about helping the republicans keep control of the house sure which trump wants desperately to insulate himself from any accountability or any having to negotiate about anything but it also protects the court

SPEAKER_02from oversight hearings from investigations into the corruption so it's very self-serving of this roberts court to put its thumb on the scale to help mississippi and louisiana or alabama um alabama and louisiana in particular to change their maps midstream in order to try to give republicans an edge and then say okay but not virginia we're going to leave that one to stand right down below you know and so you know they can do math those just yeah math and i think those decisions are not just about advancing the party

SPEAKER_02that appointed them

SPEAKER_01but protecting themselves you know i wonder let's say it's actually something i've been thinking about let's you know there was an effort they made an attempt uh filibuster stopped it to pass a new voting rights act during the body administration the first few years if they were to do that today or you know with a democratic president and democratic congress and legislature uh and senate would it be just struck down by the supreme court like there's bigger reforms required is it so that like they need to whether expansion or just you know term limits or

SPEAKER_01do you think it's just like we're past the point of even passing laws that need to there just needs to be new laws for the supreme court before we get anywhere else well i think if you can

SPEAKER_02do it simultaneously um but i think it has to be done together because this court the roberts and john roberts in particular is deeply hostile to the voting rights act and i'm sure that they would strike down an effort to put forward or to pass you know strike down a law passed and signed by a president along the lines of the john lewis voting rights you know amendments or restoration act because of that hostility because they you know they have adopted this um sort of what they describe as

SPEAKER_02a race neutral view of the 14th amendment even though the 14th amendment you know was designed to ensure equal protection law which doesn't mean you get to have um all white an all white legislature in alabama chosen by an all white legislature to dilute the votes of black voters that's part of why the voting rights act was passed was because we knew all the different ways that these white legislatures and these white counties would go about to try to limit the ability of black staff representation after in the immediate aftermath of

SPEAKER_02the civil war there was enormous representation by black americans in congress and in state houses and so you know you you cannot just say it's okay in america for a state that is one-third black to have no representation yeah in congress it's not okay but it's okay with this court because they claim that a partisan goal where they get to systematically move the black voters around uh is is a-okay

SPEAKER_01and it's not things don't coincide who black people look for and partisan yeah

SPEAKER_02so they like this loophole we didn't even know this loophole existed you could just call it partisan and you could do all the racist yeah wanted so yeah i mean the congress has to reform this court in order to restore our rights or this court will continue to destroy our rights but i'm very much in favor

SPEAKER_01of expanding the court i mean i think it's given you know i'm sure trump will get another justice in there someone will be there for another 30 40 years um but do you think that there's i mean you're you're on the inside right you you've you know lots of people you've been discussing this in dc for people forever is there an there was no appetite for that under biden and you know it was a very small majority there's a lot to do um you know that was frustrating but do you think that this has changed anything do you think there's that that there's a groundswell for reform but even expanding like where do you think where's the appetite you think

SPEAKER_02well i was pissed i will say about the so-called blue ribbon panel that did the initial review back in the early biden administration where like on the one hand x on the other you know like that was intended to thwart reform that was absolutely necessary absolutely necessary but by the end of the biden administration joe biden and kamala harris were speaking out in favor of reforming the court because it just it became impossible to ignore what this court was doing to assume that this court was acting in good faith to assume this court is just following the law

SPEAKER_02or just quote conservative they're not conservative they're reactionary they are trying to destroy the progress of the 21st century so there's really been an awakening and you know even rahm emanuel i don't often praise him i you know has come out in favor of court reform you have a lot of democrats who now recognize that they miscalculated or underestimated the threat that this court poses to our rights and now it's basically undeniable

SPEAKER_01so what does reform look like to you like expansion uh rules on the uh term limits what kind of thing it could be all the above

SPEAKER_02so they can stick out it yeah i think i think for now it has to be all the above because there's so many ways in which this court is broken one solution is not going to fix it and i also think that it's worth us really thinking about whether it's whether it's right in a democracy to have us wait every june like at the oracle at delphi back in the old you know olden days of greece will the court you know allow us to have continue to have birthright citizenship will this unelected unaccountable court let us

SPEAKER_02continue to have voting rights you know like that's no way to run a democracy they're unaccountable we need to we need to assail this judicial supremacy we need to address the aggrandizement of the executive branch that they have put in place which is reckless and dangerous but also the fact that the court has made itself the kingmaker and has has set itself up for like a legislative agenda every term now it's going to be assault weapons ban are they going to block the state blocking these assault weapons that's on the nra wish list

SPEAKER_02the nra was active in endorsing every single one of the trump nominees to the supreme court and they got what they wanted in the brewing case to try to tie our laws to clarence thomas's vision of what a founder with a musket would have you know would have allowed to be regulated back in the 79 like this term to have the supreme court considering whether you know how drunk the founders were in that gun case you know like you know could you could you let could you could you

SPEAKER_02prosecute someone for a gun crime you know if they were if they had pot that was an over prosecution that was a ridiculous over charge but the fact that we're deciding it based on whether neil gorsuch thinks that people were drinking or how much they were drinking and having weapons in 1791 is absurd same with our rights women's rights why should our rights be assessed by the views of men who didn't didn't give women you know wouldn't give women the right to vote we didn't we had to fight for that right into the 19 you know the 20th century so like they don't get a say they don't get

SPEAKER_02to determine what our you know what our rights are are based on some ancient view although by the way um you know not not for nothing but benjamin franklin published a recipe for abortion in his newsletter so it's not like it wasn't around or known to some of our founders he was one of the most philandering founders around so perhaps he had his own it was useful

SPEAKER_01to him yep

SPEAKER_02yeah but but the fact is to go back to your original question yeah we need an all the above approach but that all the above approach needs to include ethics reforms it needs to include procedural forms but it also needs to include a reform of our mindset of of ceding our power to an unaccountable court to limit our rights and instead to envision a robust congress that is an equal player with the executive branch and the judicial branch in this system of checks and balances that can advance our rights and isn't handcuffed by

SPEAKER_02the supreme court handcuffing us with you know manacles is it manacles whatever they are from 1791 or whatever like this is no way to run a modern democracy and um as senator whitehouse pointed out we were on a panel together at netroots a couple weeks ago you know one of the most democratic components of the entire american system is the house races because every two years you you get a chance to say whoa wrong track uh pull back change course get a chance to really have lost

SPEAKER_02of course the supreme court has tried to limit that through its machinations on these maps but that's the most democratic component of our entire system is the house and so i think we should be empowering the house to protect and advance our rights and that has to be part of our like the reform is also of our mindset Yeah.

SPEAKER_02i would personally go volunteer for a number of impeachment efforts but i also understand that the senate is a wasteland for trying to get an impeachment given the rules for conviction over there but i still think people need to see the case made for justice to be impeached

SPEAKER_01yeah i mean it's i think you guys made it pretty well it just uh was not taken up by people who were who were in charge of that um uh this penis didn't happen and you know it was it was it was kind of lost opportunity but i i like to i want to agree with you i want to see your way in that people are ready for i you know i think people are ready for change uh hopefully people with power are ready for that change because i think that's the only thing

SPEAKER_02where it's going to get us out of this yeah i i agree and we're in it together you know my view is um you know our the people who came before us didn't give up because they lost one battle you know the civil rights movement was many years in the making i i think the tipping point will come sooner for us for these reforms i think that we're you know we're we're not quite rapidly approaching it but but people get it people understand that this court is out of control and is doing things that a court shouldn't do that a fair court wouldn't do um and i think it's our obligation to not give up and give in and to imagine

SPEAKER_02that we can fix this because we can we lose if we don't fight we lose if we don't try and i refuse to let all the sacrifices for liberty and freedom that came before me die because i don't have the patience or imagination to stick with this fight um you know in the years to come but i think it'll be faster i think we could achieve reform much faster than than it took them to capture the court

SPEAKER_01i hope so took them a while and uh we got to get it we got to reverse it soon but i will leave it there uh thank you so much this has been great i learned a lot and uh really excited really happy to have you and love to have you back sometime uh thanks for doing this lisa um how can people find all

SPEAKER_02of your expertise online oh jordan it's lovely talking with you we'd love to come back anytime i'm at the lisa graves basically on all the socials um and uh i'm at court accountability uh true north research.org is is the research arm that i and you can find my book and legal AF. I do the Monday night live show with Dina Dahl where we break down the news of the week and I'll come back here anytime with you, Jordan, that you'll have me so gracious to invite me on this show

SPEAKER_02and thank you to your listeners and watchers

SPEAKER_01Thank you so much for being here and we will talk soon

SPEAKER_00Thanks, Jordan. Thanks everyone

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How the South *finally* went blue

    Nov 19, 202655 minAudio

    Welcome to a Thursday edition of Progress Report. Today marks three months since my latest open-heart surgery and I’m happy to say that I will soon be headed back to work. As I ramp up, I’m starting to do at least one...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Inside the NC Democrats’ epic, history-making election sweep

    Nov 8, 202652 minAudio

    Welcome to a Saturday edition of Progress Report. Anderson Clayton wouldn’t just be forgiven for gloating after Election Night, any reasonable person would expect the North Carolina Democratic chair to be in party mode...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Inside the biggest Democratic primary upset of the year

    Aug 16, 202655 minAudio

    When the many books and expensive consultant-prompted postmortems are written about the ideological and generational uprising that is currently remaking the Democratic Party, the good ones will pay special attention to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Melat Kiros on her big win, the "woke 1.0" debate, navigating Israel, and changing DC

    Aug 14, 202655 minAudio

    When the many books and expensive consultant-prompted postmortems are written about the ideological and generational uprising that is currently remaking the Democratic Party, the good ones will pay special attention to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. What we can learn from Francesca Hong's campaign

    Aug 12, 202648 minAudio

    Well, that’s not what we expected to happen. When we began our live stream last night, it looked almost certain that Wisconsin state Rep. Francesca Hong would win the Democratic nomination for governor, and in...

    Credit the people on this episode