Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Present Illness

The Present Illness artwork

How Racism (Not Plagiarism) Killed Dr. Jason Arday

Aug 21, 20261 hr 12 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The flagrant racism in the recent death of Cambridge scholar, Dr. Jason Arday; Also, how new technology hasn’t stopped attempts at medical knowledge gatekeeping Note: Alex Vindman raised $16 million compared to the $1 million raised by Angie Nixon. Nixon won. Chocolate with viagra recalled Sourdough bread recalled Blueberries recalled (brand is GreenWise) Granola recalled Clear Eyes eye drops recalled List of recalled foods Jason Arday Peter Thiel-backed network targeted Jason Arday Fact check on Arday’s story Nathan Cofnas under investigation Nathan Cofnas says vigil for Jason Arday is about him Kate Manne: Gossipy Academics Helped Kill Jason Arday. Or, the anatomy of a pile-on History of lynching in the US 22 Black people found “dead under unusual or suspicious hanging circumstances across the country” since March 2025 GoFundMe for Jason Arday Sign a letter demanding an investigation of the handling of Jason Arday Open Evidence Doctors are quietly using this AI tool Open Evidence is the preferred LLM of countless physicians Other News Lindsay Clancy trial USS Lincoln deployment ends Who is Natalie Harp? 💊Take Two and Call Me in the Morning💊 Video of a young woman doing kung fu Sterling Point Text us! Thanks for listening to The Present Illness! Follow us on TikTok, Instagram, and YouTube @ThePresentIllness Credits Production by Arghavan Salles & Alyssa Burgart Editing by Alyssa Burgart Music by Joseph Uphoff Social Media by Arghavan Salles Don’t take medical advice from random people on a podcast. This show is for informational purposes, is meant to be fun, and is certainly not medical advice. Please, take your medical questions to a qualified professional. Nothing we say represents our employers or anyone else.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hey there, fellow nerds. Welcome to another episode of The Present Illness. This is the podcast where two physicians try to make sense of a world that is increasingly febrile and continues to be underdiagnosed. I'm Arghavan Salles, a surgeon scientist in your friendly neighborhood Doom in residence. I'm Alyssa Burgart, an anesthesiologist and bioethicist who tracks news and health law like their EKGs full of spikes and surprises. The present illness is where we dig into public health, politics, culture, and ethics with a scalpel in one hand and a meme in the other. As a note to our listeners, we often talk about tough topics that can be intense, activating. And if you need to take a break, we totally get it.

Absolutely. we want to give a big thank you to everyone who's listening, wherever you have found us, ~ and send some extra love out to our subscribers and followers on the various platforms. And we also want to extend a special warm warm welcome today to anyone who has stumbled in from the many food recalls as it's becoming increasingly what we actually can safely eat in this country. ~ and I want I feel like every every time I open the damn news, I'm like, what the hell? Exactly. Like every day that every y every day at least I open, you know, Twitter or whatever and I'm like,~ like so today there's two two that popped up for me today.

One was sourdough bread and another one was ~ chocolate that has Viagra in it,'cause that's like a normal Shut up Shut up I'm Yeah. sorry, you said you just said Viagra? How I don't even what how those Uh-huh, yeah, yeah, exactly. So there are two should never be at the same place at the same time. Right, you would think. And so at first I thought it was like a contamination issue, because that's what's happening with like the salmonella in the granola, for example, which is also weird.

but looking at the FDA announcement, it sounds like actually it was this ~ these two supplements that supplements are being sold that did not declare that this is what was in them. So one is ~ Called Gold Lion Aphrodisiac Chocolate Male Enhancement Sachet. Yeah. What the shit? And then the other one is Elam Sex Chocolate Male Sexual Enhancement Booster. And so these, ~ yeah. No. my gosh, so this is like penis chocolate? It's supposed to be for your Exactly.

penis? I guess so. So they have sildenophyll tidalophil in them. ~ but they didn't declare it. Yeah, What? I know. I know. What? That's dangerous. Exactly. And that's what the issue is, right? Because patients who are have, you know, nitrates that they take for other reasons would not know~ the risk that they would have in taking these chocolates. What? I know. I know. it is wild.

So that was, yeah, that I was like, what's happening? What's in the chocolate? ~ and then we have like this very long and ever growing list of like now there's E. coli on the blueberries. ~ and yeah, I mean it, yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. That's a new one. Also, I don't know if you saw this, but in dryer's fruit bars there ~ are shards of glass apparently because that's a normal thing that you would have in fruit bars. ~ there's my god, I mean did somebody find glass in their fruit bar?

Is that how they found this out? I actually I don't know how they discovered that or the shards of glass and the sourdough. I mean and the thing is that a lot I'm s a lot of these people are finding out like after they already consumed the product, right? ~ and so that's such a great feeling to be like, I just had, for example, there was like a the blueberries, one of the recalls was at Publix, and they're like, I just had frozen blueberries from Publix. That feels good to be because they elevated the level of ~ risk. You know, they have these like different levels to be the one that includes like risk of death. So that that feels good.

I feel like, I might die from these frozen blueberries that I just consumed. ~ so glad I'm finding out about it now after I consume them. ~ yeah, same with the like somebody on Blue Sky actually had seen the recall notice for the fruit bars and was like, I I did there's nothing to return because I've already consumed them. ~ so yeah, we have this very long list. I'm not gonna read it all, but ~ there is also dog food. I mean people have nothing there's nothing to eat.

Well, this is the challenge. I mean, genuinely it's a real challenge. Like, how do you know what's even safe anymore? Because we had, I think we talked before about the bacon recall, the beef recall, the salmonella and the eggs, right? Twice like almost 20 million eggs that were recalled. And now we have got the salmonella in the~ granola and also in dog food. Granola and dog food? Yeah, yeah. Granola and dog food in addition to the jalapenos, which I think we talked about before. ~ I'm I mean, I'm holding my emotional support dog right now and like Sierra, I don't want you to get sick.

I know. Well then somebody online was like, Now they've done it. Now they've got now that they've gotten the pets, the white people are gonna go crazy. This is all gonna stop right away. I wish I had that sort of power. But they're not wrong that like, you know, some people seem to care more about when something harms a pet. Animals than humans? Correct. Yeah. ~ there's like pistachio nut butter. Of course we've got the ongoing my gosh. Taylor Farms whatever situation with the cyclospora, which has yet to be really resolved.

~ as we've had thousands and thousands of cases of that. Mm-mm. Also, BTW, like ~ I also haven't heard of any other group being implicated in that besides Taylor Farms. Yeah, so the weird thing about that is not only a fraction of the cases were traced back to Taylor Farms. So it does seem likely that there's other products and we just don't know what they are. And that to me is even more concerning because, like, okay, I'm not eating lettuce, which I by the way, I would love to be eating some lettuce.

Thank you very much, FDA. and I don't know what else I should be avoiding, you know, and I think we really don't know. So we're all just kind of doing the best we can. But ~ there's also eye drops that I just saw. Like I think it was 40,000 bottles of eye drops were recalled due to not being sterile things people are What? putting in their eyes. Uh-huh. anyway, the the list, as I said, is very, very long, and I I don't think we need to read the whole thing, What yeah.

but you get the sense that like The deregulation and the fact that they laid off like twenty percent of the staff at the FDA is having very real consequences for all of us. And Well, yeah. I was just gonna say, you know,~ the new nominee for Yes. head of the FDA, not somebody who's gonna be a friend of the pod. Not somebody who's a friend. No. Ha ha ha~ it her name is ~ Dr.

Heidi Overton. We were gonna talk about it later in the episode, but like Since you're bringing up the FDA, like she's the one who's the nominee for FDA commissioner and she hates trans and she doesn't think that people ha should have access to abortion. And I don't know why I'm hearing so much about that when we also need to actually have like food that we can eat. Yes. And like there's a lot of people being like, we can grow our own foods. Listen, we cannot grow all of our own foods, certainly not in a short period of time. ~ but I believe this person I mean also it's it's August. It's the end of the growing season, folks, for like a lot of crops.

It's true. I also don't grow granola, you know. ~ but this person just Do you know how much work it is to like grow wheat to like make your own flour? It's a lot. ~ it's wild. ~ I s labor that I don't think I have capacity for at this point in time. That sounds like a real that's a real trad wife endeavor. Maybe we should do like maybe for a year I'll just like pretend to be a trad wife. Do you think we can monetize it? I could like do all the things and we could see how it goes. Document like a year in the life of a of a trad wife in I worried that her mid forties.

I worry that you'll starve. I'm gonna have Yeah. to door dash things to you to keep you alive. Yeah, that's real. ~ but okay, I was gonna say about Heidi Overton. ~ my understanding is that she doesn't really have any experience with food and drugs. No. Mm-mm. No, she has Yeah. a she has a history of being one of ~ you know, the conservative movement's like chosen darlings. She's been part of the America First Foundation. She was like one of Mm-hmm. their, I think, fellows or whatever.

I I mean, shocker. The clown car of public health has room for more. And they're like, bring in some other political lackey to make, you know, who isn't gonna be a good public health officer. Sounds great. Yeah, she's apparently ~ so doubt about vaccines and anyway. Yep. Great, hooray. So she's definitely gonna turn things around. Even Bill Cassidy doesn't think she's a good fit. And as we've talked about before, Bill Cassidy has like, you know, no moral fiber to actually prevent anybody, all these people from being in charge of this country's public health.

But you know, he also doesn't like her in case you're wondering. great. We'll just add it onto the list. It's like saying Susan Collins is very concerned. Okay, next. ~ Okay. Can we switch gears for a moment? Yes, please. You know, folks, we are oftentimes bringing you some of the toughest stories, but like, you know, we try to give it with like a little levity. we had a, as promised, I've been, you know, watching our Spotify to like see if people had comments. And so we had a lovely comment from a listener.

So I thought I would read it to you. You ready? Okay. Yes. It's from Dr. Zombie, ~ spelled with a a one for the eye. I don't think they're a a doctor doctor. I think they're just maybe playing one as a zombie. based on what they had to say. But it's a lovely review. Y'all are amazing. I love every podcast that has been added to Spotify. As for a blue collar worker that lives in the blood red state of Florida, I support everything y'all do. love ya. Aw, that's very nice. And Florida just had an interesting win this week.

Did you see in their~ primaries? So Angie Nixon won the primary for whatever, I don't know which number district it is in Florida, but she was outspent by her colleague by tens of folds. Like I think he spent like something like twenty million or something, and she spent like one. ~ something along those lines. Don't quote me on those numbers. We can put a an article that has the actual numbers in the in the show notes, but you know, Love it. really come from behind unexpected wins. She did not spend anything on media, like TV, broadcasting. Mm-hmm.

And she's a she's a democratic socialist, isn't she? Love it. Correct. Exactly. And she's a she's a she's a mama five. Congrats, Miss Nixon. She is ~ you know, really sticking to her morals and her principles, which I think is a lesson for the Democratic Party. People don't want you to be like, well, I like abortion. If you like abortion, do you like abortion? You know, we're like, I think we should, what is it you want to do? Okay, yeah, let's do that thing. No, like people want someone with conviction, which she clearly has. So congratulations to Angie Nixon and her team in Florida.

And ~ Dr. Zombie, if you live there, we are delighted for you to be able to have the opportunity to vote for her. She seems amazing. ~ Yay. Yes. Okay, shall we get into our two main topics for today? Yes. and you know, the first one, my understanding is we're gonna talk about which is a really tough story. It is it is a very difficult story that I just cannot like get out of honestly like every level of my body. Like I think about it a lot and have thought about it a lot over especially the last week. ~ so yeah, we're gonna talk about that and I'll summarize it in a second. And then our other story is gonna be a little bit about AI in medicine. So okay, Mm.

starting with Jason Arday. So Professor Jason Arday ~ was the youngest black professor ever at Cambridge. highly esteemed university. And ~ unfortunately, he died last week at age 41 after being hounded by the press for weeks on end due to accusations of plagiarism and you know exaggeration of his life story. And it's important to know that the campaign against him was started by a man named Nathan Cofnas.

Nathan Cofnas himself is ~ currently a postdoc at Ghent University, but he was or University of Ghent, he was ~ previously at Cambridge as a research associate and he lost his post there because of the racist things that he said. This is a few years back. So ~ he had said I mean I saw an I saw an interview with him and like I mean super, super racist and like very much~ yes, definitely. So this is from ~ his own newsletter, his Substack. He's he wrote, In a meritocracy, Harvard faculty would be recruited from the best of the best students, which means the number of black professors which would approach 0%.

Blacks would disappear from almost all high profile positions outside of sports and entertainment. Yeah, so he he calls himself a race realist, but really he's a you know, a race essentialist, race biologist. Like he believes that race is a biological category and that black people are not as smart as other people. None of that is true. So he's a dumb he's a dumb person. Yeah, Correct. Correct. okay. And so he I should back up and say there had been these allegations against Professor Arde, to my understanding, mainly because he's the youngest black professor at Cambridge, and so people, racist people, were upset about that.

And so they started digging into his past. And so there had been these allegations that he had plagiarized~ in his dissertation. And his the university where he had obtained that for his PhD. Did an investigation, and that was concluded in February of this year. And they said, No, like we don't see plagiarism here. We see some honest mistakes. So just to give you a sense, there are a few passages that are very similar to another person's in the background. Okay, not in like the research that he did, but like in the background that that are similar to the dissertation of another person who he cites extensively in the dissertation.

But just not write in those passages, basically. That's the, you know, question of plagiarism. And so his university, his degree granting university, said, We think these are more likely honest mistakes and that this person didn't have, in our estimation, adequate supervision. ~ but this isn't plagiarism. Like he if he were going to try to pass off that person's work as his own, he wouldn't have cited that person many times in the dissertation. Yeah. Right. Anyway, we I don't want to get too bogged down in whether he did or didn't do that, but that That was the accusation. The university investigated it.

They said, no, we don't think that's what happened here. That was in February that their investigation concluded. In July, Cofnas writes this ~ essay again on his Substack, where he rehashes all these allegations that ~ Professor Arde has plagiarized all these things. And for reasons that may seem initially like unclear, the press ran with it. Like there were literally hundreds of articles, hundreds of articles written about this man in the span of like three weeks.

And that that essay was July 21st. On August 5th, Professor Arda Arde resigned. And he my gosh. Yes. So he basically he put us out a statement that I will read you just a a short bit of that I think is really telling. He said, the year since my appointment, Have been marked by an unrelenting level of public scrutiny and personal attack. While criticism is an inevitable part of academic life, what I have experienced has gone far beyond scholarly disagreement.

The relentless accusations, speculation, and public commentary have taken a profound toll on me and those I love, and on those I love. And then he you know talks about why he had tried to stick it out despite all of that, caring about the work, hearing about his students and his colleagues. And he says, but there comes a point when the personal cost becomes too great. So he resigned. ~ and I I did forget to mention that he's also autistic, it's relevant to his story. So he resigned on August 5th. The media, multiple people had on his behalf basically requested that the media stop him because they knew that he was unwell.

He says it right there in his own statement that it's too much. Yet the media did not stop. Well, in the and the British media has a long history. So that was August 5th, nine days later, he is dead. His family obviously devastated. He had he was 41. He had two children and a wife. And There has been an outpouring of support for him and outrage for what happened after his death.

~ the family, his family put out a statement earlier this week on Monday, there was a big vigil that was held for him in London, and tens of thousands of people came. and his family put out a statement ~ Where they basically said, you know. We appreciate this, and kindness is needed in life, not just in death. so that's the kind of overall story of like what happened here, but I think the there's obviously a lot more to it.

There's many layers to this story. What happened, what the press did, was unjust, obviously. and many of the people and ~ outlets that publish these. articles have not apologized, have doubled down on saying that this was a public interest story. And I I just wanna yeah, shut. I just want to encourage people to think about anyone else who has had that number of articles written about them in hundreds of weeks.

I mean sorry in in a couple of weeks, hundreds of articles in a couple of weeks, even outside of academics, you you'd have a hard time unless it's like Trump, you know, like a head of state, maybe. But Yeah, this is not somebody Think of like who was a public figure. Exactly. Think of even a murderer. Can you think of a murderer who had hundreds of articles? ~ well and if the and if the murderer was white, I mean it would be a picture of him having a great time. Exactly all these men who killed their entire families. It's always them like on a ski trip or something, you know. those are the pictures that are shown.

And so even if we narrow down into academia, you know, there are Mm. numerous examples of white academics who have been accused of plagiarism. You know, an example a lot of people have talked about is a man named William O'Reilly at Cambridge, same institution, took 12 pages of a student's essay, a student's essay, put it into his own work that he published. 12 pages. And there was an investigation, and they said that it was, you know, a mistake, whatever. He remained, remains at Cambridge. There were a handful of articles written about that.

And that was just a couple of years ago. It's not like it was 20 years ago. It's just like just a few years ago. Or Neri Oxman, who is the wife of Bill Ackman. Bill Ackman is the guy who one of the guys who was going after Claudine Gay, the former president of Harvard University, who is also plaque. That's the only other person I personally can think of who has had this much coverage of allegations of plagiarism, and she's plaque, Jason Arday, plaque. And these other folks, Matt Goodwin is a Brit former academic, now politician, who had written a book where multiple passages are fabricated.

And there are footnotes that include URLs to ChatGPT. You can find a handful of articles about it, but that's it. Rachel Reeves, who is a high-up politician. again in the UK, because it's all happening in the UK,~ had been accused of plagiarizing in a book that she published. And she basically said, Yeah, I should have paid more attention. And that was kind of the end of the story. So you we could go on all day. There's so many examples. And if we want to talk about research misconduct, which he was not ~ accused of, but if we want to talk about research misconduct, we have, you know, the president of Stan former president of Stanford University, right? Lost his position, was forced to resign.

Because of allegations of research misconduct. And did that get some coverage? Sure, it got some coverage. Did it get hundreds of articles in three weeks? No, absolutely not. And that was a president of one of the top universities in the world. So, all that to say, not only did this campaign start with a racist and self-described eugenicist, but even if you just look at other academics, who were accused of plagiarism, you see that this was not a normal response.

And this idea of like this was in the public interest doesn't hold any water because who cares about academics? I mean, like think about all the academics who are ~ in the How much sleep? well in the Epstein files. How many articles have been written about any of those folks? Nowhere near. Nowhere near this number. What about the guy at Mount Sinai who ~ put stitches in a young woman's forehead after she had been in a supposed accident on Epstein Island and he did it on a kitchen yeah.

table? Hundreds of articles about that? Nope, absolutely not. And all these people are like pretending like this is about academic standards when clearly that's not the case. ~ so that's one part of the story. I just want make clear that it's definitely about race. And before I go on to the next thing, I th I thought actually I should play you this ~ short clip from Nathan Cofnas so you can hear directly from him what his motivation was in doing all of this. Is this what's happened if you don't give Kafness a job, right? Yeah, you got your own ways to retaliate.

What are you gonna do, do you think? You were you gonna finish a PhD? Or no, you've already finished it. You're just gonna No, I finished a long time ago, yeah. Yeah, so what are you gonna do? well I'm I have the job currently and I'm still waiting for the revolution to happen and then I'll it's gonna take a while. Get another job. After the revolution, I'll be the ~ You know, the head of ~ the department of eugenics and race science at Harvard. So you heard him say it. One, that he's looking for an anti-black revolution to happen.

Two, you heard him say that this is vengeance for him having lost his position at Cambridge. And three, you heard him say his dream is to be heading a department of race and eugenics at Harvard. And yet people out there are pretending like this has nothing to do with race. Like the real problem, I mean, I've had many people in my comments saying the real problem was, you know, Professor Arday that he of course they don't call him Professor, but that he he lied, he plagiarized, it's all his fault. and even when you look at these examples I've given you of of this disparate coverage, they still say, well, it's cause he's he told these audacious lies.

And so just I feel like I c ~ I want to share that piece of it so that the story is complete. There are allegations that things that he said about his life were not true. ~ he, as I said, was autistic and he was nonverbal until ~ 11 or 12, and then wasn't able to read and write consistently until about age 18, which makes it really fascinating and impressive that he was then able to become the youngest black professor at Cambridge, right? Given that backstory. So people are saying none of that is true.

~ he Had raised money for charity in in large sums, like over $5 million. People are saying that was not true. He had talked about running, I think it was 30 marathons in 35 days as part of an effort to raise money for charity. People are saying that's what so just different aspects of his life story, people are calling into question, which I think is part of the kind of overboard response, right? Because Let's even say all of that was a lie.

What does that matter to the public? I don't know. You know, whether I ran 30 marathons or not, like I don't know. I genuinely don't know what the consequence is, what the harm is. and there have been a couple of outlets now that have dug into these questions about his past and found, you know, evidence supporting the claims that he had made, you know, whether it's talking to classmates from his elementary school who were like, yeah, he definitely didn't really talk. He could sing, but he couldn't really talk. I get probably selective mutism.

there was, you know, he had said he played for a semi-professional football club, and there's people who played on that club were like, yes, he was our teammate. Like, why are you questioning this? ~ there was an article that was written at the time that he was running these marathons. Anyway, so people are doing a lot of fact-checking and finding support for the claims that he had made. And again, even if there wasn't, I, you know, this is not a public. Well, the real the reality is like I should never have to know the name Jason Arday. Like and I and I obviously I I know it now because he's because he's died.

And otherwise, why do I care? I mean, I'm in academics. Like you and I are both in academic positions. Like, we kind of pay attention to what's happening in academia, but like this is not this is not relevant to our day to day lives. This is not we Yeah. don't work at that university, like There's just no reason for there to be this sort of scrutiny from from media. And certainly not when like No. None whatsoever. I mean, it's like the type of thing where, okay, if there is an issue, the university should investigate it.

When the university investigation is done, it's done. Like move on with life. Instead of dragging it on and having this person's name really dragged through the mud in the press. ~ which really also I I should be clear, you know, some of these articles really fixated on this idea that he was black and that he was some kind of diversity higher at Cambridge, that he couldn't possibly have been. qualified for this position, really taking off from Nathan Kaufness's posts, which is again, they're just running with the ideas of this racist eugenicist without, it seems, much critical thought as to why they're doing this to a man who's not a public figure figure.

He's not rich, he's not famous, he doesn't have some influential post. He's a professor at Cambridge. No, he's su he's a he's a bitter person who lost their job because their behavior was not conducive to the work environment. Koughness, yes, absolutely. And I mean, he's he was also in another he had a conversation with another person whose I'll forget right now, but who also is an older person who had been at Cambridge and also lost a post at Cambridge. ~ and they're both talking about how peacefully satisfied they are that they able to bring down this person and that this is the kind of revenge that they wanted. ~ because, you know, they deserve that job and he didn't.

And that's playing right into. What the right wing is doing here, right? In this country, look at our government, look at the purge that's happened in the military, with the idea being that the only people who are qualified to be there are white men. And in fact, it it's just so it's such a glaring misapplication of the word meritocracy when you see the least qualified Secretary of Defense that we've ever had talking about the need for. I just saw a clip from him from yesterday talking about how we must have a gender blind.

Whatever, race blind, blah blah blah. Meanwhile he's gotten rid of all the women leaders. He stopped the promotions of multiple women leaders. He's talking about gender blind, meritocracy. It's all just lies. Well, if you're a man that's just the default. A white man is the default human for him. Right, exactly. And anyone else is not qualified. ~ anyway, I yeah, go ahead. Well, so be and before we before we move on to to how this clearly relates to the things that we're in the United States, Kate Mann,~ who is a brilliant academic who wrote ~ wrote ~ in her substack, Gossipy Academics Helped Kill Jason Arday or the Anatomy of a Pylon.

And I'll I'll put a link to it in the show notes. And and part of it as well is not not just this one guy who sort of like started all of this. But all of the drama that like other academics really fed into in in this thing like really continued to give this more attention than it ever should have gotten and and Jason's the person who paid the price. Yes. And I do want to say that like the work that he did is probably part of what motivated these attacks as well, because he worked on and studied the impact of race in higher education and the challenges that are imposed on black and brown people because of racism.

And you know, for someone like Kopfness or other people like him, like that's even more infuriating, right? Like, how dare he take this job that should have gone to a white guy in their eyes, and then write about this thing that makes me really angry because he doesn't belong there in the first place. ~ so no, I agree. I'm sure there are academics who contributed to this and continue to contribute. I mean, there's been an argument on Twitter over the last week about like. what even is plagiarism and does this count?

Doesn't I mean there's some really disingenuous people saying that plagiarism is like the worst thing an academic could do. And, you know, I might suggest that something like sexual assault is is is yeah. We can think of~ and there are plenty of yeah, there are plenty of other There are plenty of bad things beyond plagiarism. things. And there are even specific, I mean people have talked about these folks as well, specific professors in higher education in the UK who were accused of and or convicted of sexually assaulting their students. That's Clearly a much larger offense and it's so disingenuous to pretend like,~ we are we have righteous anger over, you know, some miscitations, essentially.

and it's just been so what's been what has what one of the things that struck me about this is the conversation that's happened around it. If this all had happened, say five years ago, I think we would be having a slightly different conversation. And I think there would be a lot more empathy. For Professor Arday and his family. And I think there would be a lot more genuine effort to understand like what did or didn't happen here and what what really are the implications, as opposed to what it feels like happened was just again, people upset that a black man had gone kind of like above his perceived station.

And in the US specifically. I think we're seeing the exact same type of movement where the types of comments that Cofnas has made. Kopfness is is American, ~ to Mm-hmm. be clear. So the types of comments that he made, you know, if you said things like this five years ago, 10 years ago, I think there would have been a significant backlash. But instead, he's kind of amassing a following in the same way that a light lot of the right-wing extremists in this country are Mm-hmm.

gaining ~ support. And I see this in in a number of ways, both in the comments that are made, like on these articles, the actual articles themselves, like what articles have been written about this. And then what I'm seeing folks say online. There's a lot of people, even after Professor RD's death, who are still calling him a liar,~ blaming him for what happened. You know, the real problem was him. If he hadn't said these lies, if he hadn't plagiarized, he would still be alive. These are choices he made. Even worse, I think, are the people who are saying that.

Actually, the problem is Cambridge because Cambridge falsely elevated someone who didn't deserve to be there and they put him in this spot spotlight. It's so racist, ~ the discourse that I'm seeing. And what we also have happening in this country is not just, you know, all the layoffs that are disproportionately, by the way, affecting black people, but we have young black people disappearing for lots of reasons, but a really unprecedented number. being found hung in trees with the police determining that they died by suicide.

And black people do not hang themselves from trees. And there have been at least a dozen, I believe, in the last 12 months or so of these young folks. Tasia Fortune is one, Kyle Basinga is another, Trey Reed. ~ You know, I can put a list in the show notes. And We have to think about the degree to which racists are emboldened, that they think this is something they can do and get away with.

And in fact, they are getting away with it. It's not even getting major media coverage. ~ even Nolan Wells, who we talked about before, his his story didn't Mm. get media coverage until there were more and more and more and more people, majority black people, talking about him on social media. was the push from the people that made media cover it. Otherwise they weren't covering that story. By the way, we d we still don't know what happened to to Nolan Wells, and the case continues. ~ But I just want to connect the dots that like the same attitudes and behaviors that normalized and allowed what happened to Professor Arday to happen are also allowing for the Voting Rights Act to be gutted in this country.

And for black people to go missing and almost no one to look into it, seriously look into it. I mean, we have these flock cameras everywhere, right? They can trace a woman who's trying to get an abortion, but they can't tell us who killed Taysha Fortune. Like there's th that that's not ~ credible that we don't have more information~ about these deaths. And so one thing I want folks who are not black to think about is what we're all doing to raise awareness of these stories, to call out that I mean this is blatant racism.

These are lynchings, to be clear. These are lynchings, and people have called what happened to Professor Arday a digital lynching. We can't just kind of, I mean, I know there's so many other things, and we talk about lots of things that are happening, but this is a major threat to black people. And it seems not exclusively, but almost exclusively, they're the only ones talking about it. and we know historically that's not going to lead to a change. and so the rest of us need to be thinking about how to keep drawing attention to these stories, how to question the narratives that are put in front of us, and how to hold accountable.

The police, the justice system, and the media. I appreciate you pulling all of that together for us because this story has been so heartbreaking. And you know, I do not understand how people can look at whether it's the death of of Jason Arday or or all these other folks in the US. I mean, the dozens and dozens of of lynchings that have gone ruled as suicides, as you've mentioned.

I don't understand how folks look at that and think like,~ No big deal. Blame them. And Mm-hmm. that's also the racism, right? And it's it's not just, I mean, Jason Arday's story obviously starts with these accusations from somebody who is a flagrant eugenicist who, you know, you listen to him talk and it's so obvious. And I think that there's still, even in 2026, people who are like,~ well, that person's racist. I can hear it.

I can tell. Mm. Racists are bad people. As opposed to racism is in the air we breathe and the water we drink, and we are surrounded by it at all times because we live in a racialized society. And so it really takes so much more critical attention to be able to see like, whoa, there's so much more to this than like one bad guy. Absolutely. And I think that's one of the~ things that people struggle with with racism is people who are not black, I should say, is get thinking about or getting stuck thinking about it's like bad actors, individual people, Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.

when in fact we have racist systems, right, and structures. And that's what's causing the most harm. And that's like things like taking away the critical portions of the Voting Rights Act. That's a an act, a structural ~ racist structurally racist act. It's d it there are racist individuals who contributed to that decision being made. But now that that decision has been made, actually there don't need to be any racist people. We know there are racist people, but there doesn't need to be racist people for that harm to keep being enacted in election after election after election.

~ Mm-hmm. and so yeah, I think you're you're absolutely right. And I appreciate you making that point because it's not just individual bad actors like Nathan Cofnas. Nathan Kafness is taking advantage of other people's racism and the fact that the systems are built to support his views and not to defend someone who was vulnerable and marginalized like Professor Arday was. And I think like so many other folks in Conservative spaces, whether it's in the US or it's in the UK, there's a lot of money to be made in being Mm-hmm.

in this ~ outrageous, outlandish, bombastic, just totally open faced way of behaving. And that it's like, it's like this ~ insult to injury doesn't even begin to categorize how horrible, how horrible that is. Mm-hmm. and I should note, ~ just for everyone's knowledge, that ~ Nathan Cofnas has now been suspended by his university.

It turns out you can't say just anything you want no matter where you work. He didn't learn it the first time. no, he didn't learn it the first time because he doesn't see that he did anything wrong the first time, right? Like so he sees that he was treated unjustly by Cambridge when they let him go. I mean, he he sued them. he did not win. He's now appealing. And he lost. Anyway. Yeah. ~ but he he was suspended and they are now doing an investigation with~ the university putting out a statement this morning. I mean, I think it was yesterday for them,~ now.

Depending on what time zone you're in, but they they put out a statement that they said the statement on respect for human dignity in opposition to discrimination. ~ and they said, We wish to be clear about the Seems a little late. values. I know, we wish to be clear about the values we uphold as a university. Get University stands for respect for human dignity and opposes discrimination, hatred, and racism. ~ anyway, so That's all happening, which I think Nathan Cofnas is going to use to try to gain even more fame and notoriety for himself because now he's been wronged.

He has been wrong. I should just Okay. I I say there's so many things about this, liter just but just but the last thing I want to say. but just like listen like for people at home I literally had to pick up a stress ball in order to have this conversation with you. Like I'm so mad. I'm so mad I mean, it any any reasonable person would be infuriated by this. I had posted a video about this. ~ I posted multiple videos about this tragedy, and I posted something today, and somebody wrote, Who cares? And I wrote back, any decent person, but apparently that's not you.

okay, last thing I really did want to say though about Nathan Cofnas is that on Monday, when there was that vigil for ~ Professor Arday in London, Nathan Cofnas posted that it was an anti-Cafnas hate route. Like how disgusting a person do you have to be to take away a memorial for someone you harmed so deeply and to make it about you, not even allow space for people to mourn and grieve that loss and to make it about you. It's a despicable person who does that.

~ but yes, no doubt he will ride this to fame and glory in a similar way that Riley Gaines has used coming in fifth to catapult an entire career. Being a not being not as good of an athlete as she wanted to be. Yes, yes. ~ One thing that we just didn't have time to talk about, but I want to just highlight in case folks are curious is that Nathan Cofnas himself, there are a lot of ~ concerns about like his academic work. and in fact, the when he was appointed,~ My level of surprise is zero. yeah, exactly. Yeah, I know.

So when he was appointed, there was a lot of opposition to his appointment because of the poor quality of his work. And in fact, there are Academics who have said they do not believe he was the most qualified for the position to which he was appointed, which is a postdoc position, mind you. So this is a postdoc tearing down a professor. ~ I know there's so there's so many issues here. And as you said, like, are we surprised that a man who was deemed by his peers to be mediocre at his job was pissed off that a black man was successful?

No, we are not surprised. But what is Deeply upsetting is that the media went along with it and played right into his hands and chose to support that narrative without questioning who it was that they had who had even planted this story for them in the first place. And that is enough on Nathan Cofnas. In fact, that's probably too much on a racist eugenicist who ~ really does not belong. If you want to talk about who doesn't belong in academia, it's that person. I want to end this portion of our conversation by saying rest in power to Jason Arday. And then also, of course, our thoughts are with his family.

I did want to just share two things that folks can do if they want to help out So one is there's a GoFundMe that was put together by a friend of the family, and that money, you know, can support funeral costs and the children and you all sorts of things. So if folks want to donate to that, I'll put the link in the show notes. And then the other is that. ~ there are folks in the UK who are calling for an investigation into how the media handled this story. And so they have a letter that we can sign I've already signed it, but that folks can sign. And it all it is is saying, please, something has gone very wrong here and there should be an investigation into the media's handling of this.

So I'll put a link to that as well. Awesome. Thanks for sharing. Pineapple. Well, as a palate cleanser, let's let's talk about AI. Your f Yeah, great. your favorite topic. You know, I have to do some, I have to I have to be aware of a lot of AI tools and the ways that they get used or not used in healthcare contexts. you know, for part of my job and for some of the oversight work that I do. And ~ so I'm familiar with many of the AI tools that are available. So for folks who have not heard of it before, there is a tool called Open Evidence.

I don't really think that they branded themselves that well because it sounds a lot like it's just part of open AI, which it's not. If they're competitors in a way. ~ But Open Evidence is specifically a large language model, so an LLM, that is geared specifically towards clinicians. And one of the things that they require in order to make an account for you to have free, unlimited access is to have a national provider identification number. So if you're a you're a physician, you're a nurse, you're a social worker, you get assigned a national provider identifier number, and that's this like unique number that you get.

you can use we use it across a bunch of different things with our licensing and So in order to get access to Open Evidence, you need to have an NPI. So that initially when I first saw it, I was like, ~ ew, gross. ~ you know, I believe in the democratization of knowledge. I I think that the role of you know physicians and nurses is integral in terms of healthcare delivery and access to information. But the reality is that like patients have been Googling Mm-hmm. Their symptoms since Google came out. And like there was a lot of hand-wringing about patients.

no, they're Googling their symptoms and they have questions. Like, Mm. yeah, like pa searching for things is something that humans do. Doctors use Google too. I used Google, you know, when I was in medical school and residency to like find things. I still use it. Like if I need to find the most up-to-date, you know. national guidelines on something. Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Like we all are using search engines. This is part of what do. You and I have lots and lots of feelings about AI in general and the way that it's like accelerating, you know, climate catastrophe, etc. That's it. AI is clearly here.

Patients are using it. Doctors are using it. Open evidence sent me an email last night at 7:30 at night when I was like, I like wanted to like soothe myself and get ready for bed, but I made the mistake Of checking my email. I shouldn't have done that. That's on me. ~ Yeah. that's on me. But I'm gonna Like the gatekeeping in medicine makes me bananas. And so when I see it cropping up in like a new flavor, it Yeah. is like nails on a chalkboard to me. So this is the email I get from Open Evidence last night.

And it says introducing patient take homes. And like they got me with the subject line because I was like, what are these folks up to? Mm. And they are basically touting that as a physician or a nurse, you're using if you're using Open Evidence to look up. I think of it as like, it's sort of like if you want to aggregate, like, what are the papers that are available on this topic? Like, you still have to read all of the papers because just like any LLM, I don't trust it to be correct. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. but so they're like, well, you could actually take that information and you could summarize it and then send a link to your patient.

And so your patient could read it. And I was like, okay, well, sure. If you are a physician and you're gonna vet that that information is correct. And you think that that will help your patient and you're gonna send them a link to it like super duper. I'm like, okay, I'll keep reading. I'll keep reading. And it says Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Patient take homes are a new, fully optional way to share specific curated evidence with your patients. They underlined this part fully at your Ha ha by converting Open Evidence answers into patient handouts. Okay. So, like patient education, it's hard.

We want to be able to send people home with things that make sense. There's a real paucity of like effective handouts for a lot Mm-hmm. of very basic things. Like we shouldn't all have be having to make them. That's a whole other thing. But going when I as I look into it, they they have like certain things that are, you know, bolded or highlighted or whatever that like they really want you to And the thing that really, really stuck out to me was a little bit later where it said, Your your patient receives a secure link by email. To Open Evidence take home where they can read their take home and share it with eat with family members or caregivers.

On take home, underlined in bold, patients are not able to ask their own questions. They only they are only able to see the content that you curate for them. And I just thought, like, it is the year of our Lord 2026. And we still think that we should be the gatekeepers of medical knowledge for our patients. And like, If you don't give patients access like I don't know, and if and if Open Evidence thinks like they're the cat's meow or whatever, like what are they afraid of? What are they afraid of of letting people look it Because you know Or or what do they think physicians are afraid of?

Like why is that a why why Yeah, well, exactly. are they touting that as a good thing? your patients won't be able to ask questions. To me that that's concerning. Like It's embarrassing. why yeah, why would you not want your patients to be able to ask questions? Yeah, it's it's it's it's so offensive to me. And it's also something where like obviously if you if if Open Evidence truly believes that they are better, they believe that they're like better than Chat GPT or they're better than Doximity GPT or like all these other things that are available, Gemini, like these free ones. ~ Mm-hmm.

patients are just gonna go to what's free. So all this tells me is that. If you think that what you have to offer is better than what's available on those platforms, you are just denying it to patients and you think that it's Mm-hmm. serving physicians. ~ but also like, what why is it that at this point in time we're still saying, like, as a medical culture, feeding into this idea that like we need to be the gatekeepers of all of this knowledge that patients want? you know, it's so expensive to get health care.

Many people cannot afford to get health care if they can even get access to a clinician. And so it should not be any surprise that people have been like, wow, well, I relied on Dr. Google to find me some information about how worried I should be. And Now I'm going to use an AI tool in order to find that information. I just I found the marketing of this tool to physicians to be embarrassing for doctors because, like you said, what is it that doctors are are afraid of?

They're are we afraid? I mean, like, yeah, are there some patients who are gonna come in kind of freaked out because they go down some rabbit hole? Yeah, but like that is not new. I'm much more worried about patients being like,~ my doctor will let me have some information, but they're trying to stop me from having some like, where do you think these people are just gonna go to some other tool that's free? Yeah, no, I think that's exactly right. And it's yeah, it's the same idea of like, I'm I'm looking for something ~ because somebody ~ replied to a post I had yesterday about why phys why people don't like, dislike, don't trust physicians. And this person's response was really kind of in line with what you're talking about because they said something like, They were making fun of the fact that patients will look up their own symptoms.

~ and I was like, why would you not want that? You know, yeah, they wrote, yes, if if we own so the whole point of my video was that like a lot of patients feel like we're not they're not listened to, their symptoms are dismissed, they are misdiagnosed. So they they experience a lot of harm at the hands of the healthcare system. And this person's reply was. Yes, if we only paid more attention to the GP chat GPT readout that told them it was their lysinopil that was causing their bradycardia and not the metoprolol. So for folks who aren't in medicine, like lysinoprol doesn't cause bradycardia.

So what this person is saying, like, is that patients are wrong because they're using a source that's wrong, blah, blah, blah. But the real problem there, it seemed to me, is that this person has a frustration with patients trying to understand what is going on with their own health. Because even if someone comes to you with that, then you have an opportunity to teach them, right? What's the harm? Like, why are you so upset that people dare to try to understand what's happening with their bodies, especially when they know their time with us is limited because of how terrible our healthcare system is.

Mm. And so visits are short. People often have multiple things they're trying to get accomplished. So like it seems to me, it's very concerning that people ~ have a negative view. on patients trying to understand what happens, why they might be having certain symptoms, what might be causing the problem, who might come in even with like potential ideas for treatments or medications or labs. They're doing that because they're not sure if you're gonna have the time and the capacity to do what they actually need.

And they're just trying to get the care they actually need. Why are we upset about that? And we're we're in a crisis of trust in healthcare generally. And like, you know, for example, like so many of the criticisms, for example, and you and you and I have talked a lot about ~ you know,~ vaccine beliefs and like how is it that people I do my own research and you should do your own research and all that stuff. But but the the peer reviewed research it exists behind these paywalls. Mm-hmm. They're it's it's very expensive to get access to this information.

It is difficult to understand, you know? And like if if LLMs are going to be a way to simplify some of that information to at least steer somebody in the right direction, like I don't think that that's something that we should think is inherently bad or that we should be making fun of patients for. And because there's also a lot of patients who might actually come and see us if they could find information that would be like, hey, go to a doctor. You might need help. Yeah. Yeah. And I th I think there's kind of like that person's comment confounds two different issues. ~ could at least.

So I to me, like patients trying to understand what's happening with their and what might help them is always a legitimate thing for patients. I mean, it's crazy I have to say that it's always a legitimate thing for patients to do and to then want to discuss with their physicians. A separate question of like, should they be using Chat GPT or any LLM versus like Sure. Googling whatever you know, my feelings are, I think, pretty clear. But regardless, I think the central question and the reason I brought that up is this idea that like,~ only we should have access to information.

And that doesn't make any sense because patients have way more time. There's not enough of us. Yeah. And patients have way more time to think about what's going on with them than we do. So it's actually like an alliance, Well and like right? If they come in with like, here's what I've learned, and then you're pulling from your medical knowledge and together maybe you can figure it out. That's way better than a patient with complex issues showing up to a 15 minute visit, and all you can barely understand is what even the symptoms are before the visit is over. Well, and like honestly, I I wouldn't like if my car is broken, like I'm gonna do a little research before I just show up at the mechanic.

Like Mm. I don't have enough knowledge to understand if I'm getting good care at the mechanics. I don't. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. And so, like, obviously I'm gonna look that up. And the idea that patients wouldn't do the same, I just think it's totally unrealistic. And I think it's dismissive of of our patients. And like there are some patients where Yeah, they're gonna come in with like a really wacky interpretation of whatever they've found. And like, but that's also not new. Mm.

So I don't know. It just it frustrates me. Like I don't l ever anything that says disempower patients to learn about their bodies, I think is a bad move. Yeah. No, I think that's absolutely right. And I don't know, there's there's lots of stuff ~ to discuss about AI specifically in healthcare,~ which maybe we can do at another time, but certainly I think this attitude of like the knowledge should stay with us and not go to our patients doesn't make sense. Well, and like clearly, no matter what the technology is that's being assessed, like this advertisement sent to me is trying to play on the idea that doctors they must maintain control about what access to information patients have, and I just think they're dead wrong.

Well, I think that there that that attitude is wrong, but I do think there are some doctors who feel that way. And that's the problem, right? Like that Yep. that patients are finding themselves with physicians who either don't want to or can't or don't have time to explain things. And so they're like, Here, we're gonna get these labs, but I'm not gonna tell you why, because we don't really have time to get into it. You know what I mean? So there's ~ har you know, problems at multiple levels. Yeah. Well, and this is what I mean it too, about like, you know, people compla you know, there's those mugs that say, like, don't confuse your Google search with my medical degree, and like, yeah, it's a little funny, it's a little true, it's a little bit rude.

Like it the technology is gonna keep changing, but like if the attitude never changes, we will never Mm-hmm. move past this. Yeah, you're exactly right. Well, Well, I think that we should just go through our list of all the things that we like wish we could do a full episode on, but like we chose not to this week. Yeah. And as always, the list is long. ~ so the Well, we already we already did Heidi Overton, thankfully, so one down. Yeah. Excellent. ~ at the top of the list that I had is Lindsay Clancy.

So folks will know, of course, that this is a trial that's ongoing. ~ Lindsay Clancy is ~ a woman who is accused of having killed her three~ a lot of the story is revolving around her mental health and issues after she had her third child,~ with an extensive record of seeking care with psychiatrists, psychologists, even an inpatient stay. ~ and so the defense is ~ in essence arguing that she was not well at the time that this happened.

~ the prosecution is arguing that she is a premeditated murderer who ~ carried and birthed and raised three children and then decided to kill them all and and tried to kill herself. ~ she ~ Anyway, so It's been a really hard news cycle to watch. Yes. It's obviously a tragedy that this happened,~ regardless of what all did or didn't happen before. The fact is that these three young children are gone.

Lindsay Clancy herself is paralyzed ~ from fall. you know, there's some theories or lots of internet theories about whether she was pushed or fell or whatever, but she ~ is paralyzed and so she's in the courtroom now having to listen to all of this. ~ more more to come for sure on that story. do you want to talk about kindergartners? Kindergartners, my gosh. So annually the C D C reports the rate of kindergartners who are up to date on their vaccines. And unfortunately, yet again, US kindergartners ~ vaccine coverage has downtrended another year.

It's fallen another point one percent ~ in the last school year. And unfortunately this has been declining~ every year except one since the onset of COVID. And ~ Unfortunately, this is really fueled by vaccine exemptions, which were at a high of 3.6% and have now increased to 4.2%. And the exemptions rose in 41 states and ~ Washington, DC. vaccine coverage decreased in more than half of the states.

this is bad, bad, bad. I continue to be nervous about the kinds of diseases that are going to clinicians like myself who take care of children are going to start seeing things that we have just never seen before. Mm-hmm. because in the past we always had a really well highly vaccinated population. so super scary. This comes out every year. And of course, this is no surprise after everything that we've talked about on this show, about our clown car of public health in the United States and how they are just continuing to decrease confidence in vaccination, continuing to do all sorts of things that really ~ dismantle public health in America.

And as we mentioned at the beginning of the show, Heidi Overton, yet one more person ~ going into the FDA potentially who is has also ~ fueled anti-vaccine or vaccine skepticism. So very concerning. Don't like it, zero scars, zero zero stars, do not recommend. Yeah, no, absolutely. It's very worrisome for school children. ~ and a direct consequence of what has been said by the leaders,~ so-called leaders, in this country.

we wanted to follow up on our story from last week about the USS Lincoln, the ship Mm. that has been deployed for many, many months, ~ with inadequate food supplies, hygienic supplies, et cetera. so they're finally going to be brought back. out of deployment, which is I think only because of public pressure and the families of those ~ deployed to raise awareness of what was happening. ~ and so despite the president saying things like like he was asked, you know, has that deployment gone on too long?

And he said it's not gone on long enough. I mean, while he's like golfing and whatever anyway. ~ so that ship is coming back. That is good news. And ~ we hope that everyone on board will be able to get some rest and food and get some semblance of healthy behaviors ~ going or accessible to them~ after that long ~ deployment. And the last thing on this list is ~ Republicans have been kind of losing their minds over a statement that John Osuff made ~ at a rally.

And ~ I think we should just listen to it. It's short clip. Give me one second to play it. And while the sailors on the Lincoln fight his war. While he fruitlessly drains our munitions and oil reserves, the president sleeps through his meetings. He golfs and trades stocks. See he doesn't want to do the job.

He wants to build his ballroom and travel with Natalie on their apparently defenseless flying palace gifted by the Emir of Qatar. So a lot of conservatives are disingenuously acting like they care that he mentioned a woman. How dare he talk about a woman in a negative way? So disrespectful. That's that's how they're responding? Yes, yes, yes. So Natalie, for folks who don't know, Natalie is like the president's personal assistant, essentially. Some people call her the human printer.

So when things need to be Shown to him. She's the one who prints them out. She writes a lot of the truth social posts that are on his account. ~ though she's a 36-year-old woman, I believe. It's very weird. ~ she spent a summer living in a locker room,~ to be b to because there wasn't like room for her to be where he was. So she stayed in a locker room at the country club nearby. ~ There are reports that at one point when they were traveling together from one place to another, there wasn't room for her in the car.

So she wrote in the trunk. ~ she's written letters that are weird. Okay, the whole thing is weird. Her brother has gone on TV to be like, we hope she wakes up and snaps out of it soon, essentially. ~ so that's who Natalie is. And ~ a lot of conservatives have have decided that Osoff was like implying there was a An affair or something, which I mean, he doesn't say that. He just says that the president would like to be traveling with Natalie in the in the ~ plane that he was gifted from Qatar, right? ~ but it's been just fascinating to see that this is the thing that people picked up on. Like they were so outraged that he dared to mention Natalie and all these stories that I'm telling you, like the ~ the locker room and the trunk and stuff that didn't come out before.

Reporters were like sitting on these stories about Natalie. For who knows why, and then all of a sudden Wait, yeah, why have we never heard of her before? Exactly. Because they weren't talking about her, even though she seems to have a quite influential role in like what is the president's aware of, what what he's posting, Who has paid etc. who has paid the media for her to be off limits until now? Well, this is the question, like what why why were they holding on to these stories until their hand was basically forced by Osoth to start talking about it because it was such a major story that like they had to cover it? just it's weird.

And just based on that comment, It's really weird. so weird. Yes, just based on that one comment because conservatives got like so upset it and you know, they're talk again talking about how he was so disrespectful to women. Excuse me? Who is High Every day disrespectful to women, the president. And they're like in defense of the president and Natalie. Like it's it's wild to watch how much of a reaction this has gotten. And even some interesting, even some Democrats have been like, I think he went too far. He went too far.

He just said that the president likes to travel with Natalie. He hardly said anything. Yeah, what are you talking about? This is why we'll never win. Like this is going too far, just like stating the fact that he. travels with this I mean she's with him pretty much everywhere. I thought I thought grabbin' by the pussy was too far, but that was a long time ago. Yeah, apparently that was super respectful. But talking about Natalie on a plane, you know, definitely disrespectful. I yeah, I I don't I don't understand,~ Okay. but that's ~ yeah, anyway. So if people want ~ to learn about some weird stuff happening between the president and this young woman, Natalie Harp is her name, and there's no shortage of stories about her.

let's talk about happy things. Okay. Take two, call me in the morning. Prescribe me something. Yeah. So I came across these videos. I I well I saw one and I I didn't know that it was like a whole genre of video actually. But these women who I think I might have mentioned to you not on the show, who go to like some kung fu training place. Yes. It's like these monks and ~ and they do really challenging physical things. and it turns out like I guess there's like a lot of young women going there.

Cause I just like since then I keep seeing different women. So either either they're AI generated. I had that thought. Or it's like a real thing that like all these different women are going to these like training programs and because they're all posted by this account master somebody. I'll put a link in the ~ in the show notes. And you know, they'll they'll show a woman like standing with her arm out and somebody's breaking ~ Okay, sweaty. Somebody's breaking like a ~ sorry, I just noticed that gross. ~ it's warm in my house.

~ anyway, so somebody's breaking a ~ a piece of wood like on her arm and or like on her back or on her stomach or whatever. And the early part of the video you'll see the person, the trainee, like reacting right with pain and then like and then and the wood doesn't break, but then later on they're like, strong. And now the wood breaks and they still hurt, but they're like, yes. ~ and they're, you know, just doing crazy things and it just feels so nice to see women being strong and ~ I don't know, doing cool things. ~ so I'll put a I've link to one of the videos in the show.

I've seen you sent me at least one of these videos before, and so I started watching some of them. And like it's very like Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon. Like there's all these like Yes. wild stunts that they're doing. They're like, they're like leaping off the wall and chopping things, and I'm it's it's very cool. It's very cool. Yeah. Yeah. So go go I agree. ~ women. the bottom line. What's your what's your take too? ~ it definitely those videos definitely made me dream about like quitting it all and heading to be trained.

~ Yes. I would love to do it. Anyway. so ~ I have been watching Sterling Point with my family. ~ it is like a teen drama. It all takes place like up in Canada, like on an island outside of Toronto. You have to like take a seaplane to get there. It's very remote. ~ and there's like a whole bunch of like familial drama happening. There's like multi-generational family drama, there's a lot of teen drama, it's very like ~ queer forward.

~ there's a lot of fun characters. ~ there's a couple of things I don't love about it, which is that ~ they are showing people smoking. And showing quite young kids ~ drinking quite extensively. So I I have a lot of feelings, and in particular about smoking, because there's been so much work. like on network shows, you can't show people smoking during certain hours, for example, ~ as part of settlements that came out of ~ smoking stuff. But anyway, the but the other thing that I have noticed in this show, and like for folks that I don't want to do any spoilers, but like my thesis about this show is that it only exists because every adult in this show is a terrible immature parent.

Like there are no adults in this show who have made good choices. And you're basically Mm. getting like the story evolves when like this generation of kids who are like the result of a lot of parental drama ~ and Mm. like fam family drama. So it's every time there's like a new plot twist, I'm like one more dumb adult decision come to haunt them. ~ so if you want to learn what not to do as a parent, also Sterling Point, wonderful. ~ I'm also watching it with my teenager, Yeah.

which is fun. ~ Okay. I'll I'll I'll add it I'll add it to my list. ~ It's good, it's catchy, it's a fun show. That's it. Well, that was seems like a lot. That's it for this week's episode. if you didn't like what you heard, this has been Storytime with the Second Lady. ~ if you liked it, don't forget to subscribe to the Present Illness, leave us a review, and tell other folks about us as well. We know that you do not need Usha Vance to read to you, so please follow us on TikTok, Instagram, and YouTube at the Present Illness, and you can stay on top of all of our TPI related news.

We will be back next week with more headlines, hot takes, and doom scrolling, hopefully wrapped in some laughs. Until then, agitate, hydrate, take a nap, and we'll see you next time on the present illness. Production by Argon Salas and Alyssa Berghart, editing by Alyssa Berghart, social media by Argon Salas, original music by Joseph Uphoff. Don't take medical advice from random people on a podcast. This shows for informational purposes. It's meant to be fun, and it's certainly not medical advice. Please take your medical questions to a qualified professional. This podcast is our hobby, and it does not represent the opinions of our employers employers, just ourselves.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Bye Bye Measles Elimination Status

    Nov 20, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    The RFK Jr. Clown Car of Public Health achieves a new low: America has lost its Measles Elimination Status. We now get to fight a disease used to have well under control. Who could have seen this coming? We stumble in...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Veterans are struggling to get healthcare. Here's why.

    Nov 14, 202658 minAudio

    Community Care Isn’t a Simple Fix for Veteran Care - One Veteran’s Emergency Reveals the Cost of VA Cuts. Scott Colom wins Senate seat in Mississippi - first Black senator in state since Reconstruction Lynching in...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Midterms Healthcare Wins!

    Nov 6, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    So many firsts in the Midterms! Big Healthcare wins! The HELP Committee has a lot of changes ahead! Note: Russell Brand verdict Big Firsts in the Midterms Women governors make history Black governors make history 10...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The One with Matthew Perry

    Nov 1, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    Matthew Perry spent $7 million on rehab. The doctors who sold him ketamine charged $55,000. Plus, Tennessee execution physician thinks he’s like Jesus. Note: This episode is a couple of days later than usual due to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. You Can See... Everything?!?!

    Oct 23, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    What do we really see in You Can See Everything? Never forget that Elizabeth Holmes is a lying liar. You Can See Everything Wired’s interview with Nathan Fielder Q&A with Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim at the New...

    Credit the people on this episode