What’s the absolute minimum amount of exercise you need to protect your heart and metabolism? In this episode of The Movement Prescription, host Suzy sits down with the delightfully no-nonsense Professor Jason Gill from the University of Glasgow to throw out the "heroic" 100-day fitness trends and focus on what actually works for the next 1,000 days. Whether you are a frontline healthcare worker looking for practical patient strategies or simply trying to navigate your own health journey, Jason delivers a refreshing, evidence-based reminder that "good enough is good enough" when it comes to diet and movement. Key Takeaways From This Episode: The Two-Stage Weight Strategy: Why intensive dietary changes (or tools like GLP-1s) excel at initial weight loss, while physical activity acts as the ultimate anchor for long-term weight maintenance. Frequency Over Intensity: Why moving at least every other day matters more for blood sugar and metabolic health than a single grueling weekend workout. The 15-Minute Strength Secret: How doing just one or two brief resistance sessions a week - focusing on large muscle groups and pushing close to failure - unlocks up to 80% of the total health benefits. Stop Shielding Older Adults: Why lifting light soup tins doesn't cut it for seniors, and why progressive, safe heavy lifting is required to protect independent living. "Beautiful or Useful" Habits: How to make exercise stick for decades by ensuring it is either socially rewarding (beautiful) or seamlessly built into your daily routine (useful). Episode Highlight: "The difference between doing something and doing something ideally might be 10%, whereas you get from 0 to 80% just from doing something. I'm interested in getting people from 0 to 80%." - Prof. Jason Gill
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Intro and Outro: Hello, and welcome to this episode of the Movement Prescription podcast, Intro and Outro: where I interview Professor Jason Gill. Intro and Outro: He's a professor of cardiometabolic health at the University of Glasgow, Intro and Outro: and he leads a multidisciplinary research group investigating the prevention Intro and Outro: and management of vascular and metabolic diseases, including obesity and type 2 diabetes. Intro and Outro: Today, we cover all sorts of topics. He's absolutely no-nonsense. Intro and Outro: I think my favourite line from Jason is how little can we get away with? Intro and Outro: Listen in to hear more.
Suzy: So Jason, thank you so much for coming along today to chat to me about physical Suzy: activity and metabolic health. Suzy: I'm here today with Professor Jason Gill, who is a professor of cardiometabolic Suzy: health from the University of Glasgow. Jason, thank you so much. Jason: Thank you, Susie. I'm delighted to be here. Suzy: So, I'm actually just going to start with a very simple question, Suzy: Jason, because some people may not be that familiar with cardiometabolic health Suzy: as a concept. It's a pretty emerging specialty.
Suzy: Could you tell us a little bit about that and about yourself? Jason: So thank you, Susie. So cardiometabolic health, I like to think of it as the Jason: things which influence your risk of developing cardiometabolic disease. Jason: So heart disease and diabetes principally, but also chronic kidney disease and Jason: all sorts of diseases like that. Jason: And metabolic health is essentially how good your body is at maintaining homeostasis. Jason: So we look at things like your glucose concentrations, your insulin concentrations,
Jason: your lipid levels, your blood pressure. Jason: And the idea is these are all in sort of normal ranges and this reduces your Jason: risk of developing these diseases. Jason: But also the effect of perturbations on these is a little bit less. Jason: So if you have good metabolic health, what happens when you eat a meal which Jason: contains fat and carbohydrate is you get a smaller spike in your blood sugar, Jason: you get a smaller spike in insulin, you get a smaller spike in your triglycerides. Jason: And so your body is just better able to cope with all the stresses that it's Jason: facing in everyday life.
Suzy: Brilliant. Excellent. And tell me, Jason, how did you end up being a professor Suzy: in cardiometabolic health? Suzy: Because it's probably not a normal pathway for doctors to end up there. Suzy: So tell us a little bit about that. Jason: So I'm a scientist. I'm a PhD doctor, not a medical doctor. Jason: I did my first degree at Loughborough University, and it was a joint honours degree in physics. Jason: And and sports science um i Jason: was a reasonably good triathlete when i was
Jason: younger um and i was interested in sort of things to Jason: make people run faster and things like that and then during my my degree i became Jason: more interested in the um effects of physical activity on health for everybody Jason: that's not that's not trying to be an elite athlete so i i did an msc in sports Jason: science So my PhD was looking at exercise and lipoprotein metabolism. Jason: So principally how exercise influenced the way that your body handled fat in food. Jason: I then came to Glasgow about 26 years ago to start a postdoc looking at the
Jason: effects of monounsaturated fats, Jason: so olive oil type fats on lipoprotein metabolism. Jason: We did some studies looking at lipoprotein kinetics. And then basically I stayed Jason: for the next quarter century and I got various promotions through the system Jason: and I've ended up where I am today. So my work now is pretty broad. Jason: I do work on epidemiology, trying to understand how factors such as diet and Jason: physical activity and obesity and ethnicity influence health.
Jason: I do work to try and understand the biological mechanisms, so what is it that Jason: exercise or diet does to the body which influences health? and also work on intervention. Jason: So how can we support people to make changes which they might be able to sustainably Jason: do to change their health? Jason: And I'm very interested in what works in the real world. So I'm interested in Jason: what's good enough and what works and which is a slightly different question Jason: from say somebody tried to optimise their performance to run a marathon or win a medal.
Jason: So I'm interested in what works for most people in the population. Suzy: This is absolute music to my ears and i guess for many people who hopefully Suzy: will be tuning into to the podcast you know healthcare workers who are trying Suzy: to do this in their day-to-day, Suzy: but you're giving us the evidence base behind that but a very practical real Suzy: world evidence base you are a prolific researcher i see that from your bio that Suzy: you sent me that you've published over 200 peer-reviewed papers and you've given Suzy: us given this idea of the breadth of those papers.
Suzy: And you've contributed to loads of the guidelines, UK ones, signed guidelines, NICE guidelines. Suzy: So, you know, really good to know that all of that sort of practical background is going into those. Suzy: Because there is often that sort of implementation gap. Jason: Hmm. Yeah. So what's, what's really interesting is we probably broadly know what we should be doing. Jason: Um, the challenge is it's hard to do it in real life. Jason: Um, so what's the word? It's, um, it's simple, but not easy.
Jason: Or is it easy, but not simple. Jason: I can't remember. It's one of those two way rounds, but basically what to do Jason: is fairly straightforward, Jason: but doing it in the real, in the real world is really Jason: really hard so i'm interested in finding um Jason: out what people need Jason: to do and i'm kind of interested in the question that a lot of Jason: people ask me about is what's how little can you get away with because for Jason: most people um what you Jason: eat and how active you are isn't the number one priority in Jason: your life and it's often for
Jason: people who isn't the number one priority that is probably Jason: the most important for um so the question is Jason: what is it that we can do to try and get Jason: most of the way there in a way that's sustainable Jason: and fits in with people's real lives and Jason: and a key challenge is things that people are able to do for years Jason: to decades um so so one of the things is Jason: you sometimes see this idea that people need to do a hundred Jason: day plan right so so i'm more interested in thousand Jason: day plans so so what are we able to do for for a long period of time that's
Jason: sustainable because to get most of the benefits it's something you have to keep Jason: doing over and over and over again and it's not just a um a short-term thing Jason: to lose some weight for summer or something like that it's something that we Jason: need to keep doing for a long long time so. Suzy: There's no space for heroics here. Jason: I think we have to do things that people are able to keep doing. Jason: I mean, there's maybe something interesting here. Jason: If we take weight loss as an example. Jason: So I'd argue it's relatively straightforward to get people to lose weight.
Jason: I know it's hard, but over three months, most people can lose some weight. Jason: The challenge is most people don't sustain the weight loss for two or five years. Jason: Some people do, but most people don't. um so Jason: it's a long-term thing that that's that's a challenge but Jason: one of the things we can think about is the process that you need Jason: to get the weight off is not Jason: necessarily the same thing you need to do to keep it off so Jason: when you say there's no no need for heroics sometimes it can Jason: it can be really helpful to go in hard initially
Jason: and then transition to something that's more sustainable over Jason: time so an example is um there was Jason: a study called the direct study which was done at the Jason: university of glasgow and university newcastle so it's led by professor mike Jason: lean and professor roy taylor and what that did is it took people type 2 diabetes Jason: and essentially gave them what they call a total diet replacement diets they're Jason: four 200 calorie shakes a day which is nutritionally complete for between three Jason: and five months and the idea is they lose between. Jason: 10 and 15 kilograms of body weight and then
Jason: they have a food reintroduction phase to kind of keep that weight Jason: off and what it found is about 46 percent Jason: of people at one year um achieved diabetes Jason: remission so they had their blood glucose levels not in the Jason: diabetes range and uh it was Jason: about 35 percent at two years but the key thing here Jason: was there was this initial hitting people hard doing something that was quite Jason: uh intensive and then transitioning into the longer term thing so i think this Jason: two-stage model of you might want to do something quite hard initially and then
Jason: transition to something keep Jason: it up it is is it is an approach i think works for at least some people. Suzy: That's really interesting, actually, because, you know, the British Society Suzy: of Lifestyle Medicine really championed this one change. Suzy: And I guess that's what often is doable within the consulting room. Suzy: You need that support and you need these big pathways and programs. Suzy: In Scotland, we still have Counterweight Plus, which is based on that direct trial. Suzy: And they're just about to do this. Obviously, you know this because you work Suzy: in Glasgow, but this is for all of our listeners across the UK.
Suzy: They're just about to do the digital version of that. Suzy: Actually, whilst we're on this subject, I wonder, have you been involved in Suzy: research in providing these sorts of pathways digitally? Suzy: Just thinking about that accessibility and X scale and all of that. Jason: So, CountsWay is being delivered digitally as well. Jason: It's not something that I'm directly involved with. Jason: I am working with CountsWay on another project that is going to come forward Jason: looking at delivering GLP-1 treatment in primary care to see whether we can
Jason: actually help prevent conditions happening in the future. Jason: So that program is going to be a combination of a GLP-1 plus a digital support Jason: behavioral package that we're working with Councilweight to deliver. Jason: That's maybe something we can touch further in the future. Jason: But I think one of the key things here is We've now, in terms of body weight change, Jason: a range of options um which are greater than we had before and i think that
Jason: might make things um open up the range of possibilities going forward what. Suzy: What are you thinking there specifically. Jason: So i think glp1s have changed Jason: the game and i think it'll be one of these things Jason: that can be before glp1s and after glp1s um Jason: what what we've got what we've got at them um in Jason: in the past was we were able to achieve maybe 10 to Jason: 15 kilograms of weight loss when people worked really really hard at Jason: it um and some people were able to do Jason: that but many people weren't able to do that and
Jason: keeping weight off was was really hard and a lot of it is because Jason: you've got all these biological drives to try and eat more food when you when Jason: you when you're at negative energy balance and and and what the glp ones do Jason: is provide you support to take away those those food cravings um one one analogy Jason: i like to use is it's is maybe a little bit like nicotine replacement therapy. Jason: So when someone's trying to stop smoking it's it's Jason: really it's really hard but what nicotine replacement therapy Jason: does is it um it helps
Jason: damp down the cravings and stuff so you can put in place Jason: the behavior change is more easily that you might Jason: be able to sustain and then eventually you might be able to come off it so so Jason: one way of thinking about glp1s is they Jason: might they might they might do that that's not necessarily the way they're always being used Jason: now but they can actually provide this this scaffolding to help do a lot of Jason: the other things and make them easier to do and then in time some people might Jason: be able to wean themselves off the glp one some people won't be able to um but Jason: but um that might be a model that we can use going forward so so i think,
Jason: we need to use all the tools we have available to us and i think something with Jason: physical activity which I've been working on for three decades now, Jason: I think the focus on what we're trying to do with physical activity might change a little bit. Jason: Because in the past we considered it Jason: for a number of things including can it help with weight Jason: loss right um now i think we focus on a lot of the other benefits so um improving Jason: um uh fitness and and muscular strength provide additional benefits over and
Jason: above effects on weight so i think if we take all the tools we have have available um that. Jason: Increases the options i think i think we're in a much better position Jason: now than we were in 10 years ago 10 years ago Jason: when we didn't have uh so many so Jason: many options on the table when we wanted to try and help people live healthier Jason: lives but also to enable them to do things that they want to do so if you are Jason: um a bit fitter and a little bit lighter um everyday activities become a little easier.
Jason: And so the quality of life changes might be substantial. Jason: And now we've got an opportunity to help people to improve their quality of life. Suzy: Because often there's that conversation about, well, actually, Suzy: physical activity doesn't lead to weight loss per se. Suzy: I've heard you say that a couple of times before. For people who maybe aren't Suzy: clear on that, could you just sort of tell us a bit more about why that is? Jason: So physical activity on its own Jason: probably leads to modest weight loss so in the order of Jason: a couple of kilograms and and and one
Jason: of the reasons there's a couple of reasons for that one is unless you Jason: are very very fit your ability Jason: to burn calories doing physical activity is somewhat limited so if you are if Jason: you walk for 30 minutes you probably are expending two to three hundred calories Jason: right um and if you think about the number of calories you need to burn to lose Jason: a kilogram it's in the order of i think it's seven thousand seven hundred calories Jason: and a kilogram of adipose tissue. Jason: So it's a lot of 30-minute walks to do that. Jason: There's also some feedback mechanisms in that you might feel hungrier,
Jason: so you might eat a little bit more food. Jason: So physical activity on its own, if you're using it to try and lose weight, Jason: is not that effective for most people. Jason: Some people are able to do lots of physical activity and lose lots of weight, Jason: but for most people it probably isn't. Jason: And the evidence is diet plus physical activity is better than either on their own. Jason: Where physical activity does come into its own is in the weight loss maintenance Jason: phase of keeping weight off. Jason: And there is now reasonable evidence that if you have increased physical activity
Jason: in the weight loss maintenance phase, you're better at keeping the weight off. Jason: So again, we talked about this two-stage process. Jason: For the initial weight loss, eating less food, either through a diet or using Jason: a GLP-1 drug to try and make you feel less hungry so you eat less food, Jason: is probably the dominant mechanism. Jason: When you want to keep weight off, physical activity becomes really important. Jason: And one thing that we should maybe reflect on is that if somebody is very, Jason: very heavy, say they weigh 130 kilograms, doing physical activity will feel hard.
Jason: And it might feel easier if they've lost some weight. Jason: So I think there's an argument for trying to get weight off. Jason: Predominantly using diet initially and then Jason: bringing the physical activity in a little bit later when Jason: people are able to do it they might enjoy it more because the key thing is you Jason: kind of you you do things that you that you enjoy and if you if your first experience Jason: of physical activity this is really really hard you might you might be turned Jason: off about it but if you're a little bit lighter your body moves a little bit Jason: easier you might be more receptive to it later on so i I think we should be
Jason: open. I think we should be open to that. Jason: The one other thing I'd like to add, maybe before we move on, Jason: is I think it's important to consider there's two different forms of activity we're interested in. Jason: One is the aerobic activity. So walking, running, cycling, all these things Jason: that burn lots of calories. Jason: And the other is resistance exercise or muscle strengthening activity. Jason: And often when we think about activity, we tend to think about the aerobic type activities.
Jason: And resistance activities are forgotten. And there's quite a lot of evidence Jason: now that low strength is strongly related to a range of adverse health outcomes. Jason: People that do muscle strength activities have Jason: improved outcomes in terms of cardiovascular disease Jason: diabetes and all-cause mortality and Jason: doing a combination of aerobic and resistance exercise seems to be better for Jason: things like HbA1c levels in people with diabetes so I think doing resistance
Jason: exercise early on can be important not least because it can help you hold on Jason: to lean mass Because when you lose weight, by whatever means, Jason: you'll lose a combination of lean mass and fat mass. Jason: Some of this is appropriate. If you're smaller, you don't need to have as much lean mass to support it. Jason: But there is a possibility that if you do some resistance exercise while you're losing weight... Jason: You can change the mix of weight that you lose. So it's more fat mass and less Jason: lean mass. And I think that's important.
Jason: The dose of resistance exercise you need is probably smaller than you think. Jason: Probably 15 minutes a couple of times a week gets you most of the way there. Jason: So you don't need to do huge sessions at the gym. You need to do more than zero. Jason: But the amount more than zero might be less than people think. Suzy: That's really interesting and probably very accessible. so you know should should Suzy: all glp1 medications or people going on to a weight loss diet of any description Suzy: come with the instructions that you should be pairing this with resistance training
Suzy: to begin with do you think. Jason: So i think there's a benefit of doing that and i think we're maybe not Jason: doing it as much as we could do i think Jason: a challenge is with resistance Jason: exercise most people think about going to Jason: the gym which can be quite a scary Jason: place for a lot of people um and it's Jason: very very easy not to go to the gym so i Jason: think we we are developing things and other people are as Jason: well about home based resistance programs using body Jason: weight and resistance bands so i think so i think doing resistance
Jason: activity a couple of times a week is very very helpful i think we need to provide Jason: people with evidence-based programs which they can do in their home and I think Jason: if we do that then that would be a valuable thing to add to most people's weight Jason: loss programs but also for general health I think everybody should be doing resistance exercise. Suzy: That's brilliant what what what is that to look like do you know Jason? Jason: It's quite interesting if you look if you look on various online things you Jason: see people talking about their particular resistance exercise program that's
Jason: special and gives you bigger benefits and other things, but I think it's actually quite simple. Jason: We need to do activities, resistance exercises to strengthen our lower body and our upper body. Jason: And broadly, you can think about you've got the front of your upper body and Jason: the back of your upper body. Jason: So the way that you get the front of your upper body is to do what you call a push exercise. Jason: So something like a chest press Jason: or a shoulder press where you push vertically. So a couple of pushes. Jason: You can probably do a minimal thing and just do one push. Jason: Some sort of pull which gets your back so you can do a
Jason: vertical pull so a pull up if you're able to do it most people can't but Jason: you can do a horizontal pull quite easily so it's like it's it's Jason: called a rowing exercise one way you can do it is by looping a resistance band Jason: around your feet have your feet in front of you and pulling back so a Jason: pull and then two lower body exercises one Jason: to get the front of your legs and one to get the back of your legs so the Jason: one to get your front of your legs is a squat or a Jason: variation on a squat so one way a squat essentially Jason: getting out of a chair without using your arms that's a Jason: squat you can do it with a weight if you're a bit Jason: stronger and and then a hinge motion
Jason: which is where you sort of have your your body leaning forward Jason: you pull it back up so the classic hinge is a deadlift it doesn't need to be Jason: that but that gets your your the backs of your legs so if you can kind of do Jason: those four exercises and sometimes i would say do do two pushes a horizontal Jason: push and a vertical push horizontal pull vertical pull and so six exercises is probably enough. Jason: The key thing here is you get about 70% of the benefit of doing four sessions Jason: a week from one session a week. Jason: So going from 0 to 0, no sorry, from 0 to 1 gets you most of the way there.
Jason: So one session a week is great. Jason: Two sessions a week gets you almost all the way there. And the added benefit Jason: of doing three or four is quite minimal. Jason: The other thing is that when we think about the sets of exercise, Jason: people say we'll use three sets of 10 or whatever, Jason: you get most of the benefit from set one so you Jason: only actually really need to get most Jason: of the benefit one set of the exercise the key thing is to Jason: do the exercise until close to Jason: the point of failure it doesn't actually need to be failure but Jason: that's quite an easy sort of coaching point to tell someone it's easy to prescribe
Jason: it say basically if you're doing say a chest press or a bench no sorry a press-up Jason: type exercise which you can do on your knees or against the wall if you're not Jason: strong enough to do it on your feet you do it until you can't do another one right that's it, Jason: once you get a resistance band around your legs and Jason: then you pull that way until you can't do it anymore you do Jason: some variation of a squat you can do it um Jason: with uh with just body weight you can do it standing up from a chair you can Jason: do it with a jump in between to make it harder if you're quite strong you can
Jason: you can put a weight on but do that once until your legs feel they can't do Jason: anything else um a hinge you can do by sort of holding some weights in your Jason: hand and sort of standing up or you can do it with a band around your legs. Jason: Couple times a week one set to the point where you basically Jason: feel that you'd struggle to do another rep that gets Jason: you most of the way there so i think i think doing something that's very simple that Jason: you're able to do over and over and over and over again um is Jason: what most people should be doing and in in some ways i'm not fussed about the
Jason: nuance because the difference between doing something and doing something ideally Jason: might be 10 whereas you get from 0 to 80 just from doing something so i'm interested Jason: in getting people from 0 to 80 brilliant. Suzy: And that's so practical as well i don't think i Suzy: would have necessarily um even having heard you speak a Suzy: couple of times before realized actually the importance of introducing resistance Suzy: training early before cardiovascular because i guess as someone who enjoys cardiovascular Suzy: exercise i love walking i love running that comes through when you're enthusiastic
Suzy: about something but actually you need the science to back it up and you've just Suzy: given us that the the understanding of that science as well so that's really helpful. Jason: Yeah so in the aerobic activity is Jason: absolutely important and we should be doing it and Jason: there's lots and lots of evidence to show that it improves some health outcomes Jason: um my subtle point is if you're very heavy and you're trying to lose weight Jason: it's just the sequencing of the of the two um and and and not doing it initially Jason: when you find it hard uh might be an option that works for some people.
Suzy: So that's you've given us actually quite a lot You've covered a lot of the questions Suzy: that I have planned out for later. Suzy: So whilst we're thinking about what you need to do, when you were talking last Suzy: time, you were talking about the beneficial effects and how long they last for Suzy: and why it's important to do little and often. Suzy: Could you tell us a little bit more about that and the evidence behind it? Jason: Yes. So one of the things that we see with a lot of the benefits of activity. Jason: So benefits like reductions in blood pressure or improving insulin sensitivity,
Jason: which is the ability of insulin, your body to sense insulin to control your Jason: blood sugar levels or the changes in the triglyceride levels in your bloodstream, Jason: is you get this acute benefit after you've done an exercise session, Jason: which lasts maybe between two or three days. Jason: So the idea is if you do an exercise session you're in this beneficial metabolic period for Jason: a couple of days and then it kind of dissipates and Jason: the idea is if you can do activity relatively frequently probably Jason: at least every other day you're constantly in this
Jason: favorable metabolic state and a Jason: large proportion of the benefit of being a regular somebody's regularly Jason: active is from this repeated acute effect Jason: rather than necessarily a long-term training Jason: adaptation there are bits of long-term training adaptation but most Jason: of the benefit you get is from the last session you do and if Jason: you look at evidence for say people with type Jason: 2 diabetes looking at the benefits of of of Jason: activity on hba1c you find the Jason: biggest determinant of the effectiveness of
Jason: a program is how frequently you do the activity so frequency is probably the Jason: most important variable we need to we need to think about when particularly Jason: with uh people who already have um maybe impaired metabolic health is is frequency Jason: of activities important i'd say at least every other day. Suzy: Every other day okay that's um trying to keep our patients going how how can Suzy: we do that how can we motivate people jason is there evidence behind the best way to motivate people.
Jason: Yes so we we've done, Jason: We've done some work to try and see how to get people to show up and keep showing up. Jason: And one of the studies we did a number of years ago was a study called Eurofit. Jason: So this was a study where we looked at men because men are a hard to reach group. Jason: If a healthcare professional tells a man that they need to lose weight or be Jason: more active, they're generally less receptive to hearing that message than a woman. Jason: So what we did is we leveraged the fact that many men like their professional
Jason: football club they support. Jason: And so we went to the football clubs and we got them Jason: to advertise to their middle-aged male fans and we got them to to do a program Jason: which was increasing physical activity and changing diet but what we did is Jason: we trained the club coaches like the youth team coaches to deliver the intervention Jason: to the men and this was clubs you've heard of so manchester city arsenal, Jason: everton benfica porto psv eindhoven clubs Jason: clubs like that and and it was it was really effective we did a study in Jason: about 1100 men they lost a bit of weight they increased their
Jason: physical activity and it worked really well so the key thing here is Jason: to do something people are prepared to do and what men liked was Jason: showing up with other men and having the banter that you get you get you get Jason: in these sessions and people and people showing up and we're we're having conversations Jason: now with um a group called walking football and there's an organization that Jason: does walking football walking football i think is it's really good because it's Jason: something that um you can do as you get older and. Jason: Your knees give up and you can't maybe do normal football. It's something that keeps people active. Jason: So I think that's two things broadly you need to do. So,
Jason: William Morris said in your house, you should only have things that are useful Jason: or you think are beautiful. Jason: And I think we can think of the same thing with physical activity. Jason: So we want it to be beautiful in that you want to do it. You're doing it for Jason: a reason other than your health. Jason: So a man that shows up to play five-a-side football, primary reason they're Jason: doing it is not because it's for their health. It's because they enjoy it. Jason: They meet with their mates. Jason: They get the banter and all those things. So if you want people to keep doing Jason: things, you need to do things that people enjoy.
Jason: So it's kind of finding something that you want to do for other reasons than your health. Jason: The other thing that we can do is make it useful. So it's doing physical activity Jason: in a way that's embedded into your life. Jason: So one of the key things you see is if you ever go to Amsterdam, Jason: is everyone rides their bike. Jason: They don't ride their bike to get exercise. They ride their bike because that's Jason: just the easiest way to get from A to B. Jason: It's just that that's what everyone does. So it's a very useful thing. Jason: And there's some evidence that suggests that life expectancy in the Netherlands Jason: is 0.6 years higher because everyone cycles everywhere.
Jason: And so it actually has a huge effect on on population Jason: health and we're doing some work now doing a Jason: developing an interval we're doing a randomized control trial of Jason: an intervention to try and encourage people to cycle more uh for Jason: for commuting and the idea is that if people do Jason: that they're getting it in so they whether it's Jason: raining or whatever they they need to get to work Jason: so they're more likely to do it so so i think broadly thinking Jason: about one of those two things and I think going to the gym just because you Jason: think it's good for you is probably not a way to keep people active I enjoy
Jason: going to the gym I go I get something else out of it so I so I enjoy doing it Jason: but that but I'm not most people um and so just telling people just go to the gym, Jason: probably only works if there's somebody that maybe wants to go to the gym but Jason: there's other ways that they can be active and. Suzy: I know you've done research in in other you use the the word hard to reach communities Suzy: I think there's um another term that we're supposed to use um but other communities Suzy: that are more difficult to engage um can you can you give us some examples of Suzy: other types of of groups that you've researched into.
Jason: So we've we've done some work looking at ethnicity and health is that is that Jason: what you're getting so so so we we've done a quite a lot of working at um trying Jason: to understand risk of diabetes in south asians so if you are of south asian ethnic origin, Jason: you've got about three to four times the risk of diabetes compared to somebody Jason: who's of white European origin. Jason: And we've done some work to try and work out why that's the case. Jason: And we show that on average, South Asians have lower cardiorespiratory fitness.
Jason: So cardiorespiratory fitness is your ability to use oxygen to do work. Jason: So somebody that's able to run fast over 10K has a high level of fitness. Jason: And what our data suggests is people who are South Asian might need to do more Jason: physical activity to get to the same level of fitness. Jason: We also show that South Asians are a little bit less strong, Jason: so they might need to do more resistance exercise. and that when they gain weight, Jason: there's a bigger adverse consequence. Jason: So there are some biological differences in what might be optimal in different groups.
Jason: And evidence shows that. Jason: The interventions that we have to try and reduce diabetes, which typically involve Jason: taking people who have higher glucose levels than normal, but not high enough to diagnose diabetes. Jason: We call it pre-diabetes or impaired glucose regulation. If you give these people Jason: an intervention where you get them to increase their physical activity and lose Jason: a bit of weight, you reduce the number of people that end up developing diabetes. Jason: And what we find in South Asian populations is those interventions work but
Jason: they work a little bit less well than they do in in other ethnic groups and Jason: one of the things we're trying to do is explore why and that's important because. Jason: The reason why something doesn't work is important for understanding what to Jason: do next so so one reason it might not work is biologically the same intervention Jason: has a different effect physiologically and if and if that's the problem what Jason: you need to do is work out what the intervention might be and there might be Jason: a different type of intervention. Jason: The other reason something might not work is the intervention would work,
Jason: but people are less likely to engage because it's not appropriately tailored to them. Jason: So, for example, you've got a diet intervention, and it's not using foods that Jason: people typically eat if they come from South Asian countries, Jason: right? So they kind of don't engage with it so much. Jason: And if that's the case, then what you need to do is do the same intervention, Jason: but work out a way of culturally making it culturally more appropriate. Jason: So understanding which of those two is the case is really, really important. Jason: There is some evidence that it's probably a bit of both. And we probably need Jason: to do some work to both make things more culturally appropriate,
Jason: but also understand what those interventions might be. Jason: Scomist study which is the glp so it's a scotland cardiometabolic Jason: intervention study which we're designing now uh looking at using glp1 drugs Jason: in primary care we are deliberately targeting people in lower ses communities Jason: because these are the people that have less access and so what we're hoping Jason: to do is by targeting people in lower ses communities we might reduce health inequalities and,
Jason: as well as hopefully having bigger downstream effects on health service utilisation and events. Jason: Because what you find is there's quite a big social gradient in terms of adverse health outcomes. Jason: So we're targeting the people who have the most risk. Jason: And also, these are the people who might have less access to the GLP-1 drugs privately. Jason: So we're trying to address health inequalities in a range of different ways. Suzy: And that study that you just mentioned there, how big is that going to be?
Jason: So we're in the research design phase at the moment, and we need to submit a Jason: protocol sort of in September, and then hopefully if that gets approved, we go to the study. Jason: So we will have, in the intervention arm, 2,500 people will be given GLP-1 drugs Jason: over three years, and then we're going to follow up until six years, Jason: and we'll have a control arm as well that won't have GLP-1. So it'll be relatively Jason: big and relatively long. Suzy: Yeah, it sounds like a fascinating trial going forward. So we shall watch this space with interest. Suzy: That is a subject which is very close to my heart. I was just pulling together
Suzy: some information for a discussion with the Deep End group about lifestyle medicine in the Deep End. Suzy: So I may quote you on that as things that are going on, if that's okay, Jason. Jason: What are you going to say to your Deep End colleagues? Suzy: What am I going to say? Well, my goodness, we've got 20 minutes. Suzy: So my approach is that actually I Suzy: am a GP working in a deep end practice and I think it's needed there more than Suzy: anywhere else that unfortunately lifestyle medicine is whilst not a protected Suzy: term can and it can sometimes be misrepresented it is this evidence-based clinical
Suzy: care that supports behavior change Suzy: meeting the patient where they are focusing on the pillars of health, Suzy: and then I think the most important thing is that we're meeting patients where they are, Suzy: And we're making meaningful, shared decisions with them. We're not giving them Suzy: lifestyle advice. We're not telling people what to do. Suzy: We're working on their self-efficacy, all of these things that anyone who's Suzy: heard me speak before will have heard me say all of those things. Suzy: But that's what I'm really passionate about. So it's great to hear that there's Suzy: sort of research that is focusing on the groups that we are working with day to day.
Jason: Can I ask you another question? Suzy: Yeah. Jason: So you have a relatively short time with each patient. Suzy: Yeah. Jason: Right and you're normally having to deal with something else as well as this, Jason: So what advice can you give and support can you give in the three minutes that Jason: you've got? What's the first thing that you do? Suzy: Jason, you've just turned the tables on me. I thought I was interviewing you. Suzy: The first thing, Jason, is it depends. It depends what the patient is. Suzy: It depends on the context. It depends how well I know them. Suzy: But usually the discussions I have with patients, number one, they always overrun.
Suzy: Anyone who knows me will know that I continue to have on my personal development Suzy: plan that I will run to time next year. Suzy: That is an ongoing piece of work. Suzy: I think, Jason, it just depends on what the patient's after. Suzy: But some of the most impactful conversations, the ones that you expect the least. Suzy: So I will always seek permission to have a lifestyle discussion with people. Suzy: And it's amazing, actually, it's often surprising the people who are the most Suzy: invested in wanting to talk about what they can do for themselves,
Suzy: seeking advice, wanting to know where they can find out more information. Suzy: And then it's about attaching people to the Suzy: community assets that you have um i'm trying to think of an example for you Suzy: i did actually do you know what i hope you won't mind uh and i'll keep it as Suzy: anonymous as possible but i had a relatively young man in recently who's had Suzy: a heart attack already um and he came in with a list of he's been saving them up for me typical, Suzy: and he had a list of five things and i said just tell me what they all are and Suzy: then we'll just see which one matters the most to you today and see what we can do.
Suzy: And actually what mattered most to him was that he wasn't sleeping. Suzy: But by letting him talk about not being able to sleep, all these other issues, Suzy: which crossed all the pillars of health, came out. Suzy: And actually, by the end of the consultation, we'd spoken about priorities. Suzy: We'd spoken about all the other factors, the overwhelming stress. Suzy: He'd taken on too much. He had too many responsibilities. Suzy: And I stopped him at one point. I was like, let me just ask you a question. Suzy: Do you use your phone in bed at night? Suzy: And he was like, yeah, I'm answering questions all the time.
Suzy: And I was like, right, okay, well, do you mind me saying that's probably where Suzy: you need to start? And he was like, oh, yeah, that's where I need to start. Suzy: And actually, if you can find one thing that you can work on with a patient, he actually stood up. Suzy: He said, I think you were the right doctor for me to come and talk to you today. Suzy: You're right. I didn't need another pill. I've got plenty of those already. Suzy: I'm going to go away and have a think about what I need to do. so actually Suzy: i didn't tell him anything apart from Suzy: identified okay the major problem to the one of the your problem lists here
Suzy: you've got your phone on in bed at night that needs to stop and then let's start Suzy: with everything else so it wasn't a physical activity focus to that consultation Suzy: it was what matters to this patient and it's not always immediately clear sometimes Suzy: you just need to let these things evolve. Jason: Okay can i ask you two more questions um so um i'm turning the tables the first Jason: is how common do you think what you did is do you think all your colleagues are doing the same thing. Suzy: I think we all practice in very different ways it would have been very easy
Suzy: just to to comment on the dermatological things that he he started with in his Suzy: list but i think a lot of gps do the lifestyle medicine approach without realizing it, Suzy: It's good holistic care. Jason: Okay. So my next question is, we do a bunch of research on lots of different things. Jason: You as somebody on the front line, who's dealing with real people in the real world, Jason: what are the key bits of evidence or things about effectiveness would be really
Jason: helpful for you so that you can, in your three minutes you have with somebody Jason: to talk about this, do that more effectively? Suzy: Oh, that's a good question. I suppose the things that I find the most useful Suzy: are the things that I can use often. Suzy: So one of my favorite, and again, I've mentioned this in many talks and many Suzy: podcasts before, but one of my favorite infographics, because I love an infographic, Suzy: I think a picture tells a thousand words, particularly for physical activity, Suzy: is that World Health Organization dose response curve on physical activity.
Suzy: Because I'm often dealing with the red man in the corner who's sitting in his Suzy: chair. and if I can get him to move a little bit more, that's where the biggest gains are going to be. Suzy: And having something simple that I can use in just about any situation where Suzy: that seems relevant, which is often, by the way, I can point to that and say, Suzy: listen, this is what I'm interested in. This is where we could start. Suzy: So I guess it's about having... Suzy: Easy to use resources and i know moving medicine has just come out with some Suzy: patient facing resources based on both condition um and and also um symptoms
Suzy: i don't know if you've had anything to do with that jason or aware of it but i've. Jason: Seen some of the stuff i'm not involved with them. Suzy: So that's the sort of thing that i can i can point a patient at but you know Suzy: working in a pocket of deprivation not everyone has access to the internet um Suzy: so sometimes it's about having posters for the waiting room. Suzy: It's very basic where I work, but that's not necessarily relevant to anyone. Suzy: I would love to hear from anyone who is listening from this who could answer Suzy: that question. You've just put me on the spot there, Jason. I thought I was Suzy: asking you all the questions. Jason: Well, you can ask me some questions now.
Suzy: Was that what you were thinking I might say? Jason: I don't know what you were going to say. I guess one of the things that we're Jason: doing, so we can sometimes we do things that are really getting to niche detailed type things and, Jason: they help and help with scientific understanding they help with biological mechanisms Jason: but the broad messages about what we need to do are probably not going to change Jason: based on that you might change some of the nuance but we know what the broad Jason: messages are and i think that the challenge we have is to say,
Jason: I think you mentioned on the top, the implementation gap. Jason: And I think the big challenge we have is long-term behaviour change, Jason: not initiated behaviour change. Jason: Initiating behaviour change is one set of problems and. Jason: We've got solutions that work for at least some people there's kind of things Jason: we need to do for people that they work i think where we've got the big challenge Jason: is how to how to help people, Jason: sustain behavior change in in the real lives which are busy and you have setbacks you might have,
Jason: because what you sometimes find is people are doing really really well until Jason: something happens in their life and then they fall off the wagon and Jason: then it's really really hard to get back on again and so Jason: it's trying to work out how we actually help support people Jason: over the long term and i think that's Jason: the part of my Jason: job that i'm most interested in just now um is Jason: how we get how we can keep people in the real world sort of having a lifestyle Jason: that's not perfect but good enough for for for a long period of time so i've
Jason: kind of uh good enough is good enough is kind of I don't think anyone needs to be optimal. Jason: I think optimal is something that is not really worth achieving. Jason: Most people are going to fail at that. Jason: I think if we can get most people good enough, I'll be happy with that. Suzy: And I suppose this is where doing face-to-face one-to-one medicine in small Suzy: rooms can be frustrating because you're going against the grain often. Suzy: You know, behavior change within a society that is encouraging us to sit still,
Suzy: it is not encouraging us to be active. It's not encouraging us to eat well or sleep well. Suzy: That's the difficulty. And I guess, you know, lifestyle medicine as the BSLM Suzy: tries to sort of bridge that gap between... Suzy: Sort of front door medicine and public health and somewhere in the middle. Suzy: It would be lovely if we could, you know, cause this wholesale cultural shift Suzy: so that it, you know, we're not working against the grain all the time. Suzy: I don't, I don't know how on earth we're going to achieve that. Suzy: But, you know, the fact that there is a growing swell of people willing to practice
Suzy: this on the coalface, I think is so important. Jason: Yeah, I think it's really important. And I think one of my favorite phrases Jason: is both and so so we kind of need to do Jason: that we we also need to try and see whether we can alter societal things and Jason: pull pull pull those bigger levers as well and i think we need to lobby to make Jason: those changes but i think we we can't just rely on the food system to change Jason: and just wait for that to happen there's other things that we need to be doing Jason: um in the interim as well so. Suzy: We have done a whistle stop tour um and you've turned the tables on me,
Suzy: which I wasn't expecting. Suzy: And I wonder whether you can, you Suzy: know, you've sort of slightly moved us towards a bit of a call to action. Suzy: So, you know, the people that this is generically aimed at is people in primary Suzy: care who are trying to promote physical activity. Suzy: You know, we're thinking about in the context of cardiometabolic health. Suzy: So what would be your take home messages? Suzy: I've written a few things down here that I've taken from you. Suzy: And by the way, i frequently now quote you on that both and not either or i Suzy: hope you don't mind but it's on just about it i.
Jason: Think i i i i i i will have stolen it from someone else as well so i don't have copyrights on the term. Suzy: What do you think from your research point of view we should be focusing on Suzy: from a cardiometabolic health point of view what are the little gains that we Suzy: can do over and over again um do you think yeah. Jason: So so so so i think the key thing is is is doing things over and over again Jason: so so there's a couple of bits if you are heavier than you want to be,
Jason: I think considering weight loss and weight loss maintenance is two different Jason: things, I think is important. Jason: There's often discussion about, well, just do something sustainable and easy. Jason: And this is one of the things where the evidence is probably the opposite of common sense. Jason: So the biggest determinants of weight loss at one year is weight loss at one month. Jason: So people that go in hard are better off at one year. Jason: So I think going in hard initially and then moving into a cruise phase where
Jason: you do something else is probably important. Jason: Things like the total diet replacement, the direct used and is at counterweight Jason: plus, seems to work quite well. Jason: And one of the reasons it works quite well is it takes all the choice and thought Jason: out because you think about what am I going to eat next and I've got all these Jason: things there. If you go, I've got the shape and that's it. Jason: Right you don't need to think you mean it takes all that thought out so you Jason: can basically get the weight off not think about food because you don't have any choice. Jason: And then when you've got some weight off um keep keep going
Jason: and and i think one of the things that the counterweight dieticians do very Jason: well is help that food reintroduction phase Jason: actually how you how you do things going on so i think so Jason: that works quite well so the the how you get Jason: somewhere and what you do long term might might be different things Jason: physical activity is important and i think it's important to recognize there's Jason: two types of activity that we need to do broadly there's the aerobic type activity Jason: and one way to do that is just to get a step counter everyone has a step counter Jason: because your phone is a step counter now and everyone has one of those and and and try and
Jason: look at your baseline level of steps and gradually build it up so rule of thumb Jason: is a thousand steps is about 10 minutes of walking right so if you can kind Jason: of see wherever you are if you're sitting at 3,000 steps, Jason: try and increase to 3,400 or 4,000 for a couple of weeks and see whether you can go further. Jason: With the dose-response relationship, you mentioned this earlier, Jason: is the steepest part is the first bit. Jason: So wherever you're at, the first bit you do is going to give you the biggest Jason: benefit and then you get diminishing returns. Jason: With steps, a key point is we hear the number 10,000.
Jason: The number you need is probably much less than 10,000. It's probably 7,000 to Jason: 8,000 and traught plateaus. Jason: So you don't need to get to 10,000. So if you can hit 8,000. Jason: Probably good enough on top of that do Jason: some resistance type activities we Jason: talked about it earlier on it doesn't need to be anything Jason: fancy just major muscle groups um a Jason: couple of times a week one set to close to failure get you Jason: most of the way there the the other Jason: thing that i want to say briefly and i was chatting to my dad about this yesterday it's
Jason: often with older people we are scared to give them the activity that would benefit Jason: them so if you look at classes with older people they have sort of very very Jason: light weights they do things that you don't but what what you need to do to Jason: actually if you want to keep your capacity you need to keep pushing up to that barrier. Jason: So I was saying to my dad, so you need to lift heavy weights, Jason: not to get stronger, but to keep what you've got going forward. Jason: And so the idea of people saying, oh, you're lifting bean tins, Jason: that probably doesn't cut it for most people.
Jason: I remember doing something with my dad and we were trying to, Jason: I was getting some weights to lift that. No, it's far too heavy. It's far too heavy. Jason: And then it's like he was able to do eight reps. They go, no, Jason: that's the weight you need. Jason: And so i think one of the one of the challenges here really really important Jason: challenge is the the the appropriate load for people is generally higher than Jason: people think the appropriate load is, Jason: and it's giving people confidence um to Jason: say look this is the load you should and it's safe Jason: it's fine right um you need to be going Jason: using a weight that's relatively heavy for you so relatively
Jason: heavy for an 80 year old is very different from relatively heavy for Jason: a 20 year old but doing something that that Jason: isn't pushing you is probably Jason: not going to be optimal so i think that's a that's a Jason: key take-home message i think is maybe different from Jason: almost uh the the popular conception of what we should be doing with all the Jason: other so so things like chair based activities and things like that we we need Jason: we need to be pushing people a little bit and and not being scared to push people Jason: um We don't want 80-year-olds doing sort of maximal sprints,
Jason: but probably a little bit more than we are generally comfortable doing, Jason: I think, would be a take-home message. Suzy: Brilliant, Jason. Well, listen, I'm going to be thinking about what you said Suzy: earlier on. Simple, but not easy. I think that might be the way around that it is. Suzy: And the thousand-day plan, I love that. I may continue to quote you on that as well. Suzy: Listen, thank you so much for giving us a whistle-stop tour and some really Suzy: good practical advice. You know, how little can you get away with is the tagline, Suzy: I think. I might even call the whole episode that, Jason.
Suzy: Brilliant. Thank you so much for spending time with us. Take care. Jason: Okay, thanks, Lucia. Let's catch up again soon. Intro and Outro: Hi, it's Callum. I really hope you enjoyed the episode. Intro and Outro: We are so grateful to the British Society of Lifestyle Medicine for their support Intro and Outro: in producing these podcasts. Intro and Outro: And we wholeheartedly share their vision of transforming healthcare and levelling Intro and Outro: health inequalities through lifestyle medicine. Intro and Outro: If you want to find out more, please head to bslm.org.uk.
Intro and Outro: Although catering for healthcare professionals, this podcast is for everyone. Intro and Outro: If you enjoyed it, please share it. And we love hearing from you. Intro and Outro: So do reach out. Thanks for listening.
In this episode of The Movement Prescription Podcast, Callum speaks with Dr Jodie Blackadder-Weinstein, a GP in the Royal Air Force, about physical activity, lifestyle medicine, and behaviour change in military and...
We all know that getting outside feels good, but the actual science behind what happens to our biology when we connect with nature is extraordinary. In this episode, Dr. Suzy Scarlett speaks with two guests on a mission...
In this special episode of The Movement Prescription Podcast, co-host and GP Callum shares the key lessons from his recent Churchill Fellowship, a global journey across New Zealand, Australia, the Netherlands, and...
What if we stopped viewing surgery as something that passively happens to patients, and instead treated it as an event they can actively train for? In this episode, Dr. Hussain Al-Zubaidi sits down with Professor...
In this episode, we sit down with GP Dr James Carvell to explore what it really means to live and move with multiple sclerosis. Drawing on both clinical insight and personal experience, James shares how physical...