#378 - Jason Fung: The Hunger Code, Rethinking the Body Fat Equation, The Three Types of Hunger, Calories vs. Hormones, Skipping Breakfast, Food Amnesia, Food Addiction, Why You Can't Lose Weight, And More!
TRANSCRIPT AND FULL SHOW NOTES: melanieavalon.com/hungercode Book: https://a.co/d/07WezKPQ SPONSORS AND DISCOUNTS: AVALONX: Melanie made AvalonX to be her ideal supplements! They come in glass bottles, are free of toxic fillers and common allergens, screened for heavy metals and mold, and triple-tested for purity and potency. Get on the email list to stay up to date with all the special offers and news about Melanie's new supplements at avalonx.us/emaillist! Get 10% off at avalonx.us and mdlogichealth.com with the code MELANIEAVALON. Plus, text AVALONX to 877-861-8318 for a one-time 20% off code for avalonx.us. AVALONX EMF: Use code MelanieAvalon to get 10% off Melanie's EMF blocking products at AvalonXEMF.us. FOOD SENSE GUIDE: Get Melanie's app to tackle your food sensitivities. Food Sense includes a searchable catalog of 300+ foods, revealing their gluten, FODMAP, lectin, histamine, amine, glutamate, oxalate, salicylate, sulfite, and thiol status. It also includes compound overviews, reactions to look for, lists of foods high and low in these compounds, the ability to create your own personal lists, and more. Get it at MelanieAvalon.com/FoodSenseGuide CONNECT WITH MELANIE FACEBOOK: Join Melanie's Facebook group for a weekly episode giveaway and to discuss and learn about all things biohacking. All conversations are welcome! IF Biohackers: Intermittent Fasting + Real Foods + Life INSTAGRAM: Follow Melanie on Instagram to see the latest moments, products, and #allthethings! @melanieavalon Our Sponsors: * Check out TruDiagnostic and use my code MELANIEAVALON for 20% off your entire order. https://www.trudiagnostic.com Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
[SPEAKER_00]: You could say that, okay, calories is sort of how the whole thing is played out. [SPEAKER_00]: But what is controlling the calories behind it? [SPEAKER_00]: The whole thing about practices is it's been a sledgehammer that people have used. [SPEAKER_00]: Oh, you're gonna die, you're gonna die. [SPEAKER_00]: It's like, what? [SPEAKER_00]: You think the pure body is just so stupid that you're gonna die if you don't eat breakfast. [SPEAKER_00]: When you stick to natural foods, you're not when we're gonna take care of that. [SPEAKER_00]: And homie is starting kind of with physical poverty. [SPEAKER_00]: We're going to take care of a lot of the emotional problems.
[SPEAKER_01]: Welcome to the Melanie Avalon Biohacking podcast. [SPEAKER_01]: Where we meet the world's top experts to explore the secrets of health, mindset, longevity, and so much more. [SPEAKER_01]: Are you ready to take charge of your existence and biohack your life? [SPEAKER_01]: This show is for you. [SPEAKER_01]: Please keep in mind, we're not dispensing medical advice and are not responsible for any outcomes you may experience from implementing the tactics flying here in. [SPEAKER_01]: So friends, are you ready to join me? [SPEAKER_01]: Let's do this.
[SPEAKER_01]: Welcome back to the Melanie Avalon by our hiking podcast. [SPEAKER_01]: Oh my goodness friends, how exciting to have the legend Jason Fung on the show today. [SPEAKER_01]: He is honestly one of the people that I have followed for the longest time in the world of health and wellness. [SPEAKER_01]: He is such an inspiration to me and this is such an honor. [SPEAKER_01]: Jason's new book The Hunger Code is absolutely incredible and we dive into so many topics in today's episode. [SPEAKER_01]: Things like, should you rethink the body fat equation? [SPEAKER_01]: like literally with math.
[SPEAKER_01]: The three types of hunger that explain why you might be gaining weight, struggling with losing weight, all the things. [SPEAKER_01]: The role of calories versus hormones when it comes to body fat. [SPEAKER_01]: Why you should skip breakfast? [SPEAKER_01]: The shocking effect of memory on food intake. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm talking about food amygia. [SPEAKER_01]: Whether or not food addiction is real, why our modern environment stacks the cards against you when it comes to everything weight loss and so much more. [SPEAKER_01]: The show notes for today's episode will be at melonyavlon.com slash hunger code.
[SPEAKER_01]: Those show notes will have a full transcript as well as links to everything that we talked about so definitely check that out. [SPEAKER_01]: I can't wait to hear what you guys think. [SPEAKER_01]: Definitely let me know in my Facebook group, IF Biohackers, Intermittent Fast Sting Plus Real Foods Plus Life. [SPEAKER_01]: Comment something you learned or something that resonated with you on the pinned post to enter to win something that I love. [SPEAKER_01]: And then check out my Instagram, find me Friday and Outstanding Post. [SPEAKER_01]: And again, comment there to enter to win something that I love. [SPEAKER_01]: Alright, I think that's all the things. [SPEAKER_01]: Now without further ado, please enjoy this fabulous conversation with Dr. Jason Fung.
[SPEAKER_01]: Hi friends, welcome back to the show. [SPEAKER_01]: I am so incredibly excited about the conversation I am about to have. [SPEAKER_01]: It is with honestly, probably the most well-known popular guest to my audience. [SPEAKER_01]: That's highly possible. [SPEAKER_01]: It's definitely somebody that I've been following for years and years and years. [SPEAKER_01]: So you know him for the obesity code, the complete guy defasting, life in the fasting lane. [SPEAKER_01]: We actually had him on the show. [SPEAKER_01]: I don't know if you remember this Jason, but you came on for the cancer code back in like, was that 2020 that that broke him out?
[SPEAKER_01]: 2020 as a while ago, yeah. [SPEAKER_01]: And you have your newest book, The Hunger Code, resetting your body's fat thermostat and the age of ultra-processed food. [SPEAKER_01]: So when the opportunity came on to have you on the show for this, I was obviously a 100% complete yes. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm just smiling because especially on the intermittent fasting podcast, which we launched that show in, I think, [SPEAKER_01]: I don't even know, 2016 or 2017, like you were always mentioned in the listener questions, like 24, 7.
[SPEAKER_01]: So we were always talking about your work and really, really grateful for all that you're doing. [SPEAKER_01]: And I loved reading the hunger code. [SPEAKER_01]: So friends, this book, [SPEAKER_01]: dives deep deep deep into the which we can talk about the potential myth of calories and versus calories out and the role of hormones and comparison to that and then it's really a deep dive into all of the things that affect our hunger. [SPEAKER_01]: So Jason talks about how we have three different types of hunger and there are all these
[SPEAKER_01]: tips and tricks that you can follow and implement into your life to deal with your hormones and your hunger and something I really liked about it is I love when I find really cool random studies with little things that I haven't heard before about our eating habits and how we can optimize our lives in that way and there were so many incredible studies in here that I've actually been talking about on the intermittent fasting podcast. [SPEAKER_01]: So, love this book. [SPEAKER_01]: I have so many questions and oh, I don't think it means that his name. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm here with Dr. Jason Fountain.
[SPEAKER_01]: Jason, thank you so much for being here. [SPEAKER_00]: Oh, thank you so much. [SPEAKER_00]: Great to be here. [SPEAKER_01]: So, to start things off, this book. [SPEAKER_01]: So, okay, I just mentioned all of your different books, but what was the book immediately prior to this one? [SPEAKER_01]: It was, [SPEAKER_00]: Probably it was a while ago as the cancer code that was in 2020, and then COVID was happening and all this pretty stuff was happening, so I sort of took a little bit of a break, and then you know, but then there's been some new research and stuff, so then I thought this is really interesting.
[SPEAKER_00]: Zempick was becoming very popular, which was sort of pointing the way to sort of how you really have to focus on weight loss, which is on the hunger piece, not the calories piece. [SPEAKER_00]: So then that's why I thought, well, this is actually really really interesting and I haven't seen a lot of stuff written about this, so I thought this actually is really important, so that's why I started working on this new compiler code. [SPEAKER_00]: That's, you know, to me it's very exciting. [SPEAKER_00]: It's sort of new stuff. [SPEAKER_00]: It's not 100, you know, it's not not all diet related because really there's a lot more to it than just the diet.
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, it's overwhelmingly comprehensive and everything that it covers. [SPEAKER_01]: And okay, I didn't really set that the cancer code was the last one. [SPEAKER_01]: Okay, so this is interesting just hearing with what you've said. [SPEAKER_01]: So you said something in the book about GLP1 agonists and like it was on Beck. [SPEAKER_01]: And it was actually the exact opposite of something another guest said, but very similar, and I'll tell you what it is, and I'm curious your thoughts on it, and how much it even matters in the grand scheme of things, which is you were saying that taking these GLP1 inhibitors that it shows us that it's about hunger, not calories.
[SPEAKER_01]: I had a prior guest on the show who literally said the exact opposite he was like these clearly show that at the end of the day it really is just calories because people, it just makes people eat less calories. [SPEAKER_01]: So I mean I know where you lay on it because I read the book but the calories versus the hunger, does it even matter at the end of the day where do you lay on it? [SPEAKER_00]: I've heard that argument too that's all about the calories and you know oh that's what it shows is like I think it's truthfully I think it's really [SPEAKER_00]: shows really a very shallow sort of level of understanding because if you think about, you know, if you say, okay, people are over getting overweight because they're overeating, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: So it's like, okay, that's fine. [SPEAKER_00]: That's a very shallow level of understanding because you have to understand. [SPEAKER_00]: Why they're overheating? [SPEAKER_00]: It's it's not that they're overeating. [SPEAKER_00]: You have to understand why they're overeating So if you're overeating, why is it that you're overeating, right? [SPEAKER_00]: And the answer is of course, you eat because you're hungry and you stop eating when you're full So the problem of the overeating is really a problem of overhunger That's the real problem, right? [SPEAKER_00]: That's what the GLP1 shows you because GLP1s Do not restrict calories in any way
[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, so if you think about what the sort of root cause analysis, if you look at that sort of what's causing problems, right, you could say that, okay, calories is sort of how the whole thing is played out, but what is controlling the calories behind it. [SPEAKER_00]: If you're not hungry and not going to eat, it's not about willpower, right? [SPEAKER_00]: You didn't eat because you didn't want to eat, right? [SPEAKER_00]: The hunger, when you turn it off, stops you from eating, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So it's the hunger that is sort of the more deeper root cause of the whole issue, if you will, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: So you can restrict calories and people have done it. [SPEAKER_00]: There's lots of ways to restrict calories. [SPEAKER_00]: You could wire somebody's jaw shut or you could cut somebody's stomach, right? [SPEAKER_00]: And the thing is that when you physically restrict calories, what happens is that you just get hungry. [SPEAKER_00]: So if you wire somebody's Joshua, which is very popular in the 60s, it's a weight loss control method. [SPEAKER_00]: What happens is that people just get hungry and hungry until they find a way around your physical restriction of calories.
[SPEAKER_00]: So they drink smoothies and eat ice cream and stuff, and they regain all that weight. [SPEAKER_00]: It's incredibly unsuccessful. [SPEAKER_00]: It fails virtually every time because if you think about it, suppose you just go on a calorie restricts a diet. [SPEAKER_00]: Well, hunger keeps going up and up and up. [SPEAKER_00]: So your calorie goes down, but your hunger goes up. [SPEAKER_00]: Well, you're eventually going to lose and it's really miserable while you're doing it. [SPEAKER_00]: So what happens instead if you're to reduce hunger, such as what the gel P1, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So if you reduce hunger, you also will reduce calories, but notice that you're not fighting with yourself anymore.
[SPEAKER_00]: Before you're always fighting with your hunger because calories went down, hunger went up. [SPEAKER_00]: They're complete opposites. [SPEAKER_00]: If you control the hunger, hunger goes down, calories goes down. [SPEAKER_00]: So therefore, you're actually going to succeed, which is precisely what it was then because show, like virtually all the studies have showed that, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So it's not about controlling the calories, because when you control the calories, you're going to fail, right? [SPEAKER_00]: It's about controlling the source. [SPEAKER_00]: Sort of like if you have a fever, you can put some cold cloths on your forehead and stuff and the temperature will go down.
[SPEAKER_00]: But you're still going to have an infection, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Because the infection is what caused the fever. [SPEAKER_00]: So if you treat it with antibiotics, then you treat the infection which naturally lowers your fever, right? [SPEAKER_00]: As opposed to lowering your fever, which does nothing for your infection. [SPEAKER_00]: Because it's, you know, the infection is the sort of [SPEAKER_00]: And in the hunger code, I talk about this concept and logic called the three wise. [SPEAKER_00]: And to understand a problem, you have to sort of ask the question, why three times?
[SPEAKER_00]: Otherwise, you're going to be stuck at a very shallow level understanding. [SPEAKER_00]: So if you're to say, for example, why did the Titanic sink? [SPEAKER_00]: The wrong answer is, because it hit an iceberg. [SPEAKER_00]: And you say, well, why would that be the wrong answer? [SPEAKER_00]: Did he hit an iceberg? [SPEAKER_00]: because if you stop at that shallow level of understanding, then your advice to prevent future marine disasters is, don't hit icebergs, which is really stupid, right? [SPEAKER_00]: It's like, that's not good advice.
[SPEAKER_00]: So, therefore, you really have to go to a deeper level. [SPEAKER_00]: So, you have to ask the second Y. [SPEAKER_00]: So, Y did the Titanic say, one, the first Y is because it hit the iceberg. [SPEAKER_00]: Y did it hit the iceberg. [SPEAKER_00]: It's like because the captain couldn't avoid it in time. [SPEAKER_00]: The third Y is to say, why couldn't the captain avoid the iceberg? [SPEAKER_00]: The answer is because it was going too fast. [SPEAKER_00]: Now, that's the real answer. [SPEAKER_00]: So, the solution, therefore, is in bad weather. [SPEAKER_00]: slow down. [SPEAKER_00]: And that's actually good advice, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: As opposed to the don't hit icebergs advice, right? [SPEAKER_00]: You know, the don't hit icebergs people is exactly the same level of understanding as the calories people. [SPEAKER_00]: Because if you say, okay, well, you know, why are you gaining fat? [SPEAKER_00]: Well, because calories in is greater than calories out. [SPEAKER_00]: Yes, that is true. [SPEAKER_00]: But that's the don't hit icebergs level of [SPEAKER_00]: The more important question is, why is calories in greater than calories though, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Not that it is, but why is it greater than calories in greater than calories though?
[SPEAKER_00]: And the answer is because you're hungry, right? [SPEAKER_00]: And then the third question, the third why, which is, I think, even more interesting, is why are you hungry? [SPEAKER_00]: And that's where you have to say, well, that's a really critical question because if you can understand why you're hungry, then you can actually control your hunger, which will therefore allow you to successfully lose weight in the long term. [SPEAKER_00]: The answer is there's three different types of hunger. [SPEAKER_00]: There's a physical type of hunger called homeostatic hunger, which is controlled by hormones.
[SPEAKER_00]: There's a emotional type of hunger, which is called hedonic hunger, and there's a social type of hunger, which is called condition hunger. [SPEAKER_00]: So there's three very different reasons why you might be overeating. [SPEAKER_00]: But the point is that you can't get to that level of understanding until you get to that sort of third-wide, right? [SPEAKER_00]: And so what I also don't think does, of course, is that it plays on the homie's static hunger, uses the GLP1 system to overwhelm your hunger, basically shuts it right down, but it shuts down all your hungers, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: So it shuts down all of that, and therefore you eat less, and therefore the calories goes down, right? [SPEAKER_00]: But again, this whole calories and calories out there is people are just stuck at this really shallow level of understanding. [SPEAKER_00]: And insisting that they're right, the calorie bullies are like, oh, I'm right, I'm right, you didn't have that, you didn't have that, you didn't have that, you didn't have that, you don't have that, you don't have that, you don't have that, you don't have that, you don't have that, you don't have that, you don't have that, you don't have that, you don't have that, you don't have that, you don't have that, you don't have that, you don't have that, you don't have that, you don't have that, you don't have that, you don't have that, you don't have that, you don't have that, you don't have that, you don't have that, you don't have that, you don't have that, you don't have that, you don't have that [SPEAKER_00]: It's like, okay, well, that's just not helpful. [SPEAKER_00]: It's just like if you're to say, okay, you're a kid, it took your car, went on an icy road, flew off the edge, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: What's your advice, right? [SPEAKER_00]: It's slow down, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Your advice is not well. [SPEAKER_00]: The reason you flew off the road is the force of gravity and the force of friction, you know, the force of friction was less than the force of force. [SPEAKER_00]: the centrifugal force pushing it off the ground like that's stupid right slow down your root cause was you went too fast slow down right but you have to get to the why did you slide off the edge of the road it's like because you're going too fast right so this is the whole argument it's not that the calories and calories out is necessarily wrong because it is technically right just like don't hit icebergs it's technically right but it's not useful
[SPEAKER_00]: And that's the real problem, and there's so many examples. [SPEAKER_00]: It's like, why did the plane crash? [SPEAKER_00]: It's like, well, because the force of gravity was higher than the lifting force. [SPEAKER_00]: Well, that's always true, right? [SPEAKER_00]: It's like, but that's not useful, right? [SPEAKER_00]: You know, you're playing crash because you didn't do proper maintenance on it. [SPEAKER_00]: So you do proper maintenance, right? [SPEAKER_00]: But you have to get to that understanding of, well, why is the force of gravity higher than the force of lift? [SPEAKER_00]: Well, because your engine didn't work, why didn't your engine work? [SPEAKER_00]: Well, because you didn't maintain it.
[SPEAKER_00]: So, therefore, when you say, okay, how do I prevent crashes? [SPEAKER_00]: It's like, get proper maintenance. [SPEAKER_00]: Not, make sure the force lifting force is greater than the gravity force, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Because that's a superficial understanding. [SPEAKER_00]: And that's the whole problem with these calories people is there's so smug and so sure how right there because they're like, it's physics, right? [SPEAKER_00]: It's all like, you know, gravity versus lift. [SPEAKER_00]: How can you deny that?
[SPEAKER_00]: the sort of deeper problem. [SPEAKER_00]: So here's the thing, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So if you think about the types of hunger, you have homeostatic hunger, you do tonic hunger, you have conditioned hunger. [SPEAKER_00]: So suppose you have somebody who is not getting enough sleep, right? [SPEAKER_00]: And that's their problem. [SPEAKER_00]: And we know that if you get the sleep deprivation, you will get, you will gain weight. [SPEAKER_00]: It's a very common reason why people gain [SPEAKER_00]: So, therefore, what's the solution? [SPEAKER_00]: Well, the calories will people say, well, if you're a calories, it's like winter second.
[SPEAKER_00]: Your problem was you didn't get enough sleep. [SPEAKER_00]: Why would you be talking about calories? [SPEAKER_00]: Your solution should be get better sleep. [SPEAKER_00]: Obviously, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So what does it have to do with calories? [SPEAKER_00]: Or say you have a situation, somebody is depressed and they're eating a lot of junk food because it makes them feel better. [SPEAKER_00]: Well, that's why they're gaining weight because they're eating junk food like crazy. [SPEAKER_00]: They're eating potato chips and ice cream all day long because they're depressed. [SPEAKER_00]: And it makes them feel better. [SPEAKER_00]: It's a comfort food. [SPEAKER_00]: So therefore, the solution is to deal with the emotions,
[SPEAKER_00]: and trying to figure out another way to feel better rather than eating, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Had nothing to do with the calories and calories out, had everything to do with their emotional state. [SPEAKER_00]: right, but you only get to that point by understanding the sort of deeper reasoning. [SPEAKER_00]: So every time people talk about, it's all calories, like they're pretending that it's a math problem, you know, it's just add this minus this and it equals this, it's like it's not a math problem. [SPEAKER_00]: Nothing in the human body works, but like that.
[SPEAKER_00]: And that's why when you simply focus on the calories, it almost always fails. [SPEAKER_00]: And that's just the reality, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Every single study has shown that if you just restrict calories, you're going to fail in the long term. [SPEAKER_00]: And it's not like nobody's ever done this. [SPEAKER_00]: Millions of people have done these calories for the diet, and it comes to be the fails. [SPEAKER_01]: Well, okay, so many things here. [SPEAKER_01]: Speaking of it being a math problem, I had a mind-blown moment when you rewrite the equation. [SPEAKER_01]: So, you know, you make the proposal that instead of thinking of it as, you know, our body fat equals calories and minus calories out.
[SPEAKER_01]: We can change it to I think calories and equals body fat plus calories out and I literally went and I did like the math with it where you like add one to both sides I was like oh yeah that actually does work out and like when you think about it that way you know that's such a reframe okay so question about the three hungers. [SPEAKER_01]: because I think when we think of, well first of all, I think when we think of hunger, most people think of the first type, the homeostatic, so the physical hunger, but we've also got, like you said, this hedonic hunger that involves emotions and then we've got the condition hunger based on our environment.
[SPEAKER_01]: So in a way, I feel like the hunger maybe people would understand it more if it's like the desire to eat. [SPEAKER_01]: Either way, why do you think, with those in pick, for example, [SPEAKER_01]: Presumably, and you touched on this, but presumably it's affecting the homeostatic hunger. [SPEAKER_01]: So just the literal physical hunger, but it seems to work for the others as well. [SPEAKER_01]: So are those hungers on a hierarchy where if you really address like that, you know, actual hunger that it filters into the emotional and the environment and everything else?
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, it's sort of like that. [SPEAKER_00]: I mean, when you're talking about GLP1 drugs, what's happening is that you're using one system, which is the GLP1 system. [SPEAKER_00]: To basically overwhelm all the other systems, because it's not a normal level of GLP1. [SPEAKER_00]: It's a sort of super high level, super physiologic, if you will. [SPEAKER_00]: So you can't achieve those levels of GLP-1 by yourself. [SPEAKER_00]: So it's artificial. [SPEAKER_00]: So you can use super high levels of that to overwhelm everything else.
[SPEAKER_00]: Just like, you know, for example, if you take certain drugs or like chemotherapy and you're nauseated, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Well, all your hunger will go away. [SPEAKER_00]: It doesn't matter if you have social hunger or if you have emotional hunger. [SPEAKER_00]: You're so nauseated that you just can't eat, right? [SPEAKER_00]: And there's different ways that the GLP1 system does this, like through the directly through the brain, but also slowing the emptying and the stomach and so on. [SPEAKER_00]: So there's multiple ways that it works, but each one of them can, like they're all part of eating behavior.
[SPEAKER_00]: So they all sort of exist on a continuum, but at any time one of them can sort of take over one of the others. [SPEAKER_00]: And this is, for example, hedonic hunger, which is the emotional type, is one of the big things that affects it is actually the ultra-processed food. [SPEAKER_00]: So ultra-processed foods are designed to create sort of maximum pleasure, and therefore they can lead to things like food addiction because of the way they're processed. [SPEAKER_00]: And that can overwhelm your homeostatic system, because of the way it's, again, this sort of artificially constructed food that is able to create so much sort of eating behavior that it overwhelms the other, the natural brakes on the system, because your body normally tries to slow down what you're eating, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: But people have had the, [SPEAKER_00]: sensation where you start and you just can't stop, right? [SPEAKER_00]: It's like an addiction, you know, if you're addicted to alcohol, you can't stop even though you know, it's really going to kill you. [SPEAKER_00]: It's the same with ultra-processed foods and that the key is not the food necessarily or the calories or whatever. [SPEAKER_00]: The key is the processing has made it such that you really can't stop. [SPEAKER_00]: And it's not really, you know, it's funny about food addiction, for example, is that [SPEAKER_00]: The research behind it is sort of exploding, especially in the last five or six years.
[SPEAKER_00]: And you really have to treat it as an addiction, right? [SPEAKER_00]: And the reason that's important is because in addiction you have to treat with abstinence, right? [SPEAKER_00]: And that's where it falls apart. [SPEAKER_00]: Like if you have somebody who's addicted to alcohol, [SPEAKER_00]: You would never say to that person, hey, just have a drink, everything in moderation, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Because when they start, they have stopped, you'd be like the worst friend ever, right? [SPEAKER_00]: But when people are addicted to ultra-process foods, people are like, well, everything in moderation, you can have it.
[SPEAKER_00]: It's like, why would you say that, okay? [SPEAKER_00]: It's like, would you say to a cocaine addict? [SPEAKER_00]: Oh, yeah, just take a little bit of cocaine. [SPEAKER_00]: Just take a little less cocaine. [SPEAKER_00]: It's fine. [SPEAKER_00]: It's like, you're not a very good friend, are you? [SPEAKER_00]: You're not a very good doctor if you say that. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: at the same time, food addictions. [SPEAKER_00]: We don't treat as real, but there, you know, what the research is showing, especially in the last few years, is that it is real. [SPEAKER_00]: And people describe it all the time, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: People say, I'm addicted to bread, I start against Tom, addicted to chips, addicted to, you know, pizza, addicted to sweets, addicted to chocolate. [SPEAKER_00]: We just didn't believe them. [SPEAKER_00]: They're saying it all the time. [SPEAKER_00]: We just didn't believe those people, but it turns out that they were much more right than raw. [SPEAKER_00]: And now we have ways to measure it, something called the food addiction score, and as predicted, a lot of the foods that are a lot of the people who struggle with weight are actually food addicts, not simply loss of little power.
[SPEAKER_00]: Just like somebody who's an alcoholic, addicted to alcohol, [SPEAKER_00]: You can't just will yourself away from that addiction, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Or if you're addicted to narcotics like Michael Jackson or something, you can't just will yourself all the money in the world won't do that for you. [SPEAKER_00]: but what you have to do is acknowledge it as a real addiction and treat it as a real addiction. [SPEAKER_00]: So that's the thing. [SPEAKER_00]: So if you have that, that may completely overwhelm your other types of hunger. [SPEAKER_00]: So all of them are sort of important in their own way, but they're going to be different.
[SPEAKER_00]: Like it's not like a hierarchy. [SPEAKER_00]: It's like some people, for some people is going to be the home aesthetic hunger. [SPEAKER_00]: For some people, it's going to be the hedonic hunger. [SPEAKER_00]: the emotion. [SPEAKER_00]: So people are going to be the social hunger, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Which is called conditioned tongue. [SPEAKER_00]: If you have a problem with conditioned tongue, but then you have to bring a totally different toolbox to bear because it wasn't about the diet, it is about your habits. [SPEAKER_00]: And therefore how you're going to get better is by treating that conditioned hunger. [SPEAKER_00]: Whereas the person who had an addiction to refined carbohydrates, their problem is you need to kind of refine carbohydrates.
[SPEAKER_00]: And the person who was sleep deprived, who had too much cortisol, the problem is to get more sleep right. [SPEAKER_00]: So you see that there's actually different solutions for everybody, right? [SPEAKER_00]: But the problem with these calories people is they want to apply the same solution to all these different problems, right? [SPEAKER_00]: To the man with the hammer, every problem is a nail, right? [SPEAKER_00]: deprivation solution calorie restriction what your problem is food addiction solution calorie restriction right it's like huh your problem is how bad habits were solution calorie restriction there's like what are why do you bring the same solution to every single problem why don't you try and understand the problem so you can treat it carry menopause you're gaining weight solution calorie
[SPEAKER_00]: It's like, we all know it's a high risk period of weight gain. [SPEAKER_00]: So why do you treat it as a willpower problem? [SPEAKER_00]: It's obviously a hormonal problem, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So the problem is on and on. [SPEAKER_00]: It's really trying to, and what I write about is always trying to understand the deeper, [SPEAKER_00]: levels of what the problem is, so that you can come up with a good solution, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Not just, oh, hey, it's all about calories, that's going to solve everything. [SPEAKER_00]: So if your problem is that you're under stress, and that's why you're eating, the solution is deal with the stress, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: Deal with it in a way that is not eating. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, that completely makes sense about the different hungers and kind of like with the the GLPs turning off the like you turning off one system and overwhelming everything else I can see how that would happen like with hedonic hunger for example say you could be depressed and you know not wanting to eat it all and then that would overwhelm you know the other the other two systems or like with the conditioned one I guess if you're environment. [SPEAKER_01]: literally change so that you couldn't eat than that would overwhelm the other ones as well.
[SPEAKER_01]: The addiction piece. [SPEAKER_01]: So I feel so strongly about this and I loved reading your take on it in the book because like you were saying about the moderation that people advocate for with food. [SPEAKER_01]: And maybe this is just coming from my own personal history, but for me it is like the foods that [SPEAKER_01]: Honestly, like turn me on the foods that would just be a gateway food. [SPEAKER_01]: I just can't have any of them because if I if I have just a little bit and they're all like ultra-process foods It's like funfity cake and stuff like if I have a bite of that.
[SPEAKER_01]: I am so miserable like the idea of like moderating that is not anything I want to engage with and yet [SPEAKER_01]: I feel like society says, oh, that means you don't have self-control around food. [SPEAKER_01]: And it's like maybe, maybe I just need abstinence here. [SPEAKER_01]: So I'm really empowering that in people. [SPEAKER_00]: But it's such a silly thing, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Because it's like, well, if you know that somebody has an addiction to food and I hear all these,
[SPEAKER_00]: The reason people didn't treat it is real is because people say, well, there's really silly stuff right it's like you have to eat right so therefore you can't abstain from food like I'm not saying abstain from food I'm saying abstain from altered the the altrust process foods that you're addicted to right so if you are [SPEAKER_01]: That's run fatty. [SPEAKER_00]: Exactly. [SPEAKER_00]: If you're addicted to alcohol, I don't say don't drink anything. [SPEAKER_00]: Why? [SPEAKER_00]: That's stupid. [SPEAKER_00]: Of course you can drink water. [SPEAKER_00]: Of course you can drink tea. [SPEAKER_00]: So if you're addicted to fun fatty cake, I don't say don't eat beef.
[SPEAKER_00]: Why would I say that? [SPEAKER_00]: So it's a stupid argument. [SPEAKER_00]: And then, other people say that, well, food is all natural, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So therefore, you can't be addicted to it. [SPEAKER_00]: It's like, well, you know, that cigarettes come from tobacco plants and morphine comes from the poppy plant and marijuana comes from the marijuana plant, right? [SPEAKER_00]: I suppose those things can't be addictive either, right? [SPEAKER_00]: It's like, of course, they're addictive. [SPEAKER_00]: Alcohol comes from, you know, whatever you're fermenting, right, grains, or whatever, hops.
[SPEAKER_00]: It's like, of course, you can be addicted to those. [SPEAKER_00]: The key is that [SPEAKER_00]: You process them, it's the way you process them and sort of isolate and concentrate the addictive substances in it. [SPEAKER_00]: And that's what happened with the ultra-processed food. [SPEAKER_00]: So you can be addicted to bread or cake or chocolate. [SPEAKER_00]: But very few people, I will ever tell you, I am addicted to eggplant, right? [SPEAKER_00]: I can't stop eating it, right? [SPEAKER_00]: It's like, of course, I can stop eating it. [SPEAKER_00]: I love eggplant, actually. [SPEAKER_00]: But I can stop eating it, it's not that difficult, or I'm addicted to beef.
[SPEAKER_00]: Like, I will eat until I explode, it's like nobody ever says that, right? [SPEAKER_00]: I'm addicted to liver. [SPEAKER_00]: Like who says that? [SPEAKER_00]: I'm addicted to eggs. [SPEAKER_00]: He's like, people eat eggs, but it's not like you're addicted that you can never stop, right? [SPEAKER_00]: But it's the process and that really makes that thing addictive, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So these arguments that, oh, it cannot exist. [SPEAKER_00]: Or you cannot eat food, you have to eat something. [SPEAKER_00]: That all these arguments have such huge holes in the argument yet. [SPEAKER_00]: You know, people just repeat them over and over as if that explains it, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: It doesn't explain anything. [SPEAKER_00]: And people, if you listen to people. [SPEAKER_00]: They'll tell you exactly the same thing. [SPEAKER_00]: They'll tell you exactly what they're addicted to. [SPEAKER_00]: Because they know they're living that life, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So if you understand that, then you have to say, no. [SPEAKER_00]: Just like the alcoholic has to say, no, we have to not drink alcohol. [SPEAKER_00]: And how do you treat an addiction, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So you go to like, alcoholics and anonymous or something. [SPEAKER_00]: And you can say, okay, well, what do they focus on? [SPEAKER_00]: in a real addiction problem such as alcohol, it's anonymous, while they talk about forgiveness, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: They talk about making a man, they talking about, you know, being a piece with yourself, spirituality, having friends, right? [SPEAKER_00]: That's the sponsor, whatever. [SPEAKER_00]: But that's the way you treat addiction. [SPEAKER_00]: Not just hey, just say no, or you know, hey, just don't do it, right? [SPEAKER_00]: It's like the way we treat food addiction is so primitive compared to our understanding of addiction medicine. [SPEAKER_00]: It's like we're in the stone ages, right? [SPEAKER_00]: You don't even acknowledge as exists, even as everybody says it, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm a chocolate hauling, right? [SPEAKER_00]: I'm addicted to sugar, I'm addicted, right? [SPEAKER_00]: It's just crazy to when you actually think about it. [SPEAKER_01]: We don't acknowledge it exists or we shame people for trying to break that addiction by abstaining. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, isn't that sad? [SPEAKER_00]: That's the hardest part. [SPEAKER_00]: It's like, oh, of course you just like, oh, you know, people say, oh, I'm addicted to the cake. [SPEAKER_00]: It's like, oh, you can have a little bit of this birthday cake. [SPEAKER_00]: It's like, why would you say something like that? [SPEAKER_01]: I literally have like childhood memories where my mom would be like Melanie when you go like when we go to our grandparents you have to have some of your grandmothers cake because she like made it for you and I was like maybe I don't want the cake maybe like so it's yeah it's so so interesting thing I just have like an in real time epiphany I think the the eating window and the eating approach that I landed on personally
[SPEAKER_01]: I came to because I realized it was a way for me to almost like hack the three hungers. [SPEAKER_01]: Like it let me have all three hungers and not experience the like the weight gain and the metabolic effects if I were to indulge in them all the time, which is that. [SPEAKER_01]: So I do daily fasting and I do a one meal a day eating window and in the eating window I only eat whole foods. [SPEAKER_01]: And so [SPEAKER_01]: So the home you start a hunger because I am hungry when I'm eating when I start eating so I get to experience that hunger and then be full it addresses the emotional side of things because I'm not like constantly using food to deal with emotions because it's just not an option because I'm fasting and then for the third one the condition it is a habit I do have my like nightly one meal a day thing.
[SPEAKER_01]: And so, in a way, I get to experience all the hungers without them creating damage. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and that's exactly what the book they're talking about, this is three golden rules. [SPEAKER_00]: And, you know, the first two is one is cut out the ultra-processed foods. [SPEAKER_00]: And two is make sure you haven't daily fasting period or some kind of regular fasting period. [SPEAKER_00]: And that's exactly right because by building that rule in, so I'm not going to eat between, you know, 7 p.m. and, you know, 12 a.m. or whatever, 12 new initiatives.
[SPEAKER_00]: That, that what it does is it creates those sort of guard rails. [SPEAKER_00]: so that you can sort of follow along, right? [SPEAKER_00]: It creates structure into that eating window, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So if you think about eating plan, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So say you have, say you want to do a marathon, right? [SPEAKER_00]: What do you do? [SPEAKER_00]: Why don't you get a coach, right? [SPEAKER_00]: And then the coach will say, okay, week one, we're going to do this week two, week three, week four. [SPEAKER_00]: You have a plan, you have a guardrail, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So if you think about it, this sort of eat fewer calories,
[SPEAKER_00]: stupid plan, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Does it tell you anything about what you're supposed to eat? [SPEAKER_00]: No, as long as you eat fewer calories, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Does it tell you anything about how you should eat, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Eat slowly, eat mindfully, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Does it tell you about, you know, [SPEAKER_00]: what you're supposed to eat in terms of processing? [SPEAKER_00]: No, nothing does it tell you about where you're supposed to eat, like, eat at a table. [SPEAKER_00]: Don't eat in, you know, while you're in the car, you know, because these things can trigger you, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: Because you can develop habits, like eating in front of the TV, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So, you know, if you think about the sort of who, what, when, where, how, sort of thing? [SPEAKER_00]: All the questions you want answered about this eating plan that you have, this calorie restricted diet gives you nothing. [SPEAKER_00]: There is no plan. [SPEAKER_00]: It's as if your running coach were to say, well, do whatever you want as long as you run. [SPEAKER_00]: And then we'll get to the marathon and you'll run. [SPEAKER_00]: It's like, what are you talking about? [SPEAKER_00]: That's the worst plan ever, like you're fired, right? [SPEAKER_00]: As opposed to the person who says, okay,
[SPEAKER_00]: week one week two week three eat this don't eat this this day we're going to go for a long round this day we're going to go for spirits you know that's a plan that's real plan right and that's what you don't have with most people and unfortunately this is like 99% of doctors give you this plan of just eat fewer calories right but no [SPEAKER_00]: No idea how to do a what to do. [SPEAKER_00]: You're not taking into account friends like who you're eating with You know, because that's actually really important. [SPEAKER_00]: So if you know talking about the social side of things If you think about how important it is you think about you know, for example, if you're in a Board meeting or something like that or a meeting at work or something like that, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: You're really bored. [SPEAKER_00]: It's a millionth or new somebody [SPEAKER_00]: orders of plate of cookies. [SPEAKER_00]: What's going to happen? [SPEAKER_00]: You're going to need the cookies, why? [SPEAKER_00]: Because you're really bored and you want a little thing to pick you up and that's going to give you pleasure. [SPEAKER_00]: So you need the cookie, right? [SPEAKER_00]: It takes a lot of well-pard to not eat that cookie. [SPEAKER_00]: Now, replay that and say it's the 1970s. [SPEAKER_00]: So there's this [SPEAKER_00]: equally boring meeting at work. [SPEAKER_00]: But there's no cookies. [SPEAKER_00]: Are you really going to get up, leave the meeting, go downstairs, find a coffee shop, buy yourself a coffee, come back in while everybody stares at you and says, where did you go?
[SPEAKER_00]: Let me, what are you doing, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So there wasn't the will power problem at all. [SPEAKER_00]: It was a social situation problem, right? [SPEAKER_00]: But it's like, okay, well, why don't we actually acknowledge that, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So it's like maybe you have to figure out ways to get around that, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Maybe you have to change your physical environment. [SPEAKER_00]: Maybe you have to change the people you hang out with, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Because again, if your friends are eating french fries all day long, you're eating french fries. [SPEAKER_00]: If your friends are eating salad all day long,
[SPEAKER_00]: reading salad, that's just the way life is, right? [SPEAKER_00]: There's lots of studies if you're best friend. [SPEAKER_00]: becomes obese, your own risk of obesity goes up by like a hundred percent, right? [SPEAKER_00]: It's like when my brother started playing basketball, I started playing basketball. [SPEAKER_00]: That's just the way life happens, right? [SPEAKER_00]: When I go out with my family, I eat pretty well. [SPEAKER_00]: When I go out with my high school friends, it's not so good. [SPEAKER_00]: It's actually pretty bad, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Lots of fried foods, french fries, and all this kind of stuff.
[SPEAKER_00]: The difference wasn't me. [SPEAKER_00]: I'm the same person. [SPEAKER_00]: The difference was the social situation, right? [SPEAKER_00]: And it's so important, yet nobody acknowledges just how important it is. [SPEAKER_00]: When we talk about the different levels of hunger, I remember talking on the fasting method, you know, some of the coaches there, because we have the fasting method we have coaching. [SPEAKER_00]: She was saying the head of coaching there, she's a PhD in psychology, she's saying, it's an interesting way to put the hunger, and I think that the homey aesthetic, the physical hunger that we all think about as hunger, is probably like 10% of the actual problem.
[SPEAKER_00]: The other 90% is between emotional and social. [SPEAKER_00]: And if that's the case, then really having some kind of person, whether it's a, you know, in like an A, how college's anonymous, you have a sponsor that you can talk to, but go to a coach, right? [SPEAKER_00]: And it's like, I don't understand why people don't don't do the, you know, don't have like a weight loss coach or some kind of coaching, which is what we do at the fasting method. [SPEAKER_00]: Because it's like, look, you have a personal trainer, like there's lots of personal trainers, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, you can find an exercise program literally in 30 seconds online. [SPEAKER_00]: That is very, very good. [SPEAKER_00]: So why do people have personal trainers? [SPEAKER_00]: Because they know that they won't exercise unless there's that trainer standing right there. [SPEAKER_00]: They've made the commitment to the trainer. [SPEAKER_00]: And that's why that's what keeps them accountable. [SPEAKER_00]: So it's a social problem. [SPEAKER_00]: Not a knowledge problem, right? [SPEAKER_00]: We treat it like a knowledge problem. [SPEAKER_00]: You must eat this and not this, right? [SPEAKER_00]: It's like it's not a knowledge problem. [SPEAKER_00]: It never has been a knowledge problem.
[SPEAKER_00]: The problem was the accountability. [SPEAKER_00]: The problem was the social situation. [SPEAKER_00]: The problem is the people, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So then you hire somebody like trainer or coach that makes you accountable. [SPEAKER_00]: And then you're successful at, [SPEAKER_00]: working out or running or doing your marathon or whatever it is that you do. [SPEAKER_00]: But we should really apply and people have life coaches, people have CEO coaches, they have executive coaches, they have all kinds of coaches. [SPEAKER_00]: Why? [SPEAKER_00]: It's not because they're stupid. [SPEAKER_00]: It's because they know that that is going to make them more successful. [SPEAKER_00]: This is the same for weight loss coaching, but that's by only by understanding that there's a huge social component that the condition component.
[SPEAKER_00]: to your eating behavior, do you get to that point where you can say, oh, though this makes sense then, let's think about that sort of framework. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and to that point, it is possible, you know, to engage in eating situations and not eat because I do that a lot and that said I've been doing that for I don't know since 2011 and it does not get I mean it is easier I can do it now pretty easily, but I still feel weird if I like go to something where I'm not eating and everybody else is like I still feel weird.
[SPEAKER_01]: because of my fasting window. [SPEAKER_01]: I had a, oh, but I will say, I felt related to that with the social eating situations. [SPEAKER_01]: I felt very seen, and I think a lot of our listeners will as well, because you do talk about the hormonal benefits of eating earlier rather than later and the effects on insulin and things like that. [SPEAKER_01]: And you also say, though, if you're skipping one meal, [SPEAKER_01]: breakfast socially for a lot of people works best to skip breakfast. [SPEAKER_01]: It's nice to hear that because I feel like everybody's like you have to eat breakfast all the time if you eat one meal eat breakfast so it's nice to know that people can find what works for them socially because I definitely skip breakfast.
[SPEAKER_00]: It's certainly true because the whole thing about breakfast is it's been a sledgehammer that people have used. [SPEAKER_00]: Oh, you're going to die. [SPEAKER_00]: You're going to die. [SPEAKER_00]: It's like, well, you think the pure and body is just so stupid that you're going to die if you don't need breakfast. [SPEAKER_00]: Forget the fact that your body has stored on you. [SPEAKER_00]: Thousands and thousands and thousands of calories. [SPEAKER_00]: So if that's what body fat is, right? [SPEAKER_00]: It's a [SPEAKER_00]: You're going to draw down those stores of calories, just like if you put food in the refrigerator and you don't go shopping, you can take food out of the refrigerator.
[SPEAKER_00]: Your body puts calories into body fat, it's a stored there. [SPEAKER_00]: When you don't eat, your body will take those calories out of body fat, why? [SPEAKER_00]: So this is 100% natural, why would it kill you? [SPEAKER_00]: It makes no sense, but you know, people [SPEAKER_00]: distort things for their own, you know, a lot of the research, of course, was done by practice through companies, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So, trying to point out how important it is to practice. [SPEAKER_00]: And I'm not saying that you have to skip practice, like some people who works very well to eat practice, right? [SPEAKER_00]: It keeps them more fall down the line and so on.
[SPEAKER_00]: If you wind up eating a whole bunch of ultra-process foods, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Then, you know, because you want the convenience, right? [SPEAKER_00]: And convenience is one of the keys. [SPEAKER_00]: So the real problem with breakfast is that everybody's in a rush. [SPEAKER_00]: So instead of eating eggs and meat to eggs and ham or something like that, you wind up eating like cereal, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Some ultra-processed refined carbohydrates, right? [SPEAKER_00]: And the problem with that is that you're going to spike your insulin way up, and then that's going to store a bunch of body fat. [SPEAKER_00]: and just leave you hungry or down the line, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: So you're not actually reducing your hungry, actually reducing the hunger by eating all those ultra-processed carbohydrates in the morning, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So you're in a rush to grab a muffin, you grab a donut, you grab cereal, right? [SPEAKER_00]: All ultra-processed carbohydrates. [SPEAKER_00]: It's like eating breakfast can work, but you have to have the time to boil an egg and eat it and clean up and all that stuff, right? [SPEAKER_00]: And people just don't have the time and don't want to get it early for that. [SPEAKER_00]: That's fine. [SPEAKER_00]: Don't eat breakfast. [SPEAKER_00]: It's fine. [SPEAKER_00]: But again, there are other nuances.
[SPEAKER_00]: So I talked about a lot of this in the obesity code. [SPEAKER_00]: In the other code, I talked a lot more about the nuances of, you know, it's not necessarily the carbohydrates, but it's really the insulin. [SPEAKER_00]: That's the issue, because insulin is the hormone. [SPEAKER_00]: And so I dive a lot deeper into the whole process. [SPEAKER_00]: Like it's not just about the carbohydrates, the proteins, fats, carbs. [SPEAKER_00]: It's not just about the calories, but also about the process of digestion. [SPEAKER_00]: then absorption, which affects the hormones, which affects your weight, right? [SPEAKER_00]: And all along that path, there are ways to adjust it.
[SPEAKER_00]: Just like, you know, for carbohydrates, you can try to increase your resistance. [SPEAKER_00]: Start, you can try to eat things that are higher in amylose versus amylopectin. [SPEAKER_00]: You can use vinegar and other organic acids to reduce the insulin effect. [SPEAKER_00]: You can change your meal timing, like eating the proteins first, or you can try eating earlier in the day. [SPEAKER_00]: You can do things like walking after meal. [SPEAKER_00]: are going to affect your insulin levels, which is going to affect your weight gain in the end.
[SPEAKER_01]: I had no idea about the Amalose versus Amalopectin and the different types of it. [SPEAKER_01]: I was really blown away by that. [SPEAKER_01]: Actually, one of my favorite tips, because again, so listeners, there are all these different sections in the book. [SPEAKER_01]: It really covers, like you did an excellent job [SPEAKER_01]: covering all the things that, you know, could play factors and people's different types of hunger, but one of my favorites, and I actually went on a rabbit hole tangent looking at more research around this topic because I just found it so interesting, but it was the thing that you mentioned about how the prefrontal cortex is probably involved in our hunger because they did studies with people with amnesia, and if they didn't know that they had eaten, they would just eat it all again.
[SPEAKER_00]: It's like, wow, I think they wound up eating and I'm sure you couldn't do those studies now because it's a little bit unethical, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, so in the study they took people at the age, gave a formula, they ate and then like, [SPEAKER_00]: ten minutes later gave them another full of, you know, they ate all that. [SPEAKER_00]: And then when they gave them a third meal, they ate like 80% of that or something like that. [SPEAKER_00]: It was like, wow, that's ridiculous. [SPEAKER_01]: It's so interesting. [SPEAKER_01]: And it led to one of my favorite tips, which was make meals memorable.
[SPEAKER_01]: And when I went down the rabbit hole, because I was like, that's so interesting. [SPEAKER_01]: So I went down the whole rabbit hole like reading reviews of the studies on memory and episodic eating and distracted eating. [SPEAKER_01]: And one of the things I was reading was saying that [SPEAKER_01]: Like if you eat distracted, not only do eat more than, but you actually eat more later. [SPEAKER_01]: And it's because you weren't remembering. [SPEAKER_01]: Like the brain basically remembers what you last ate. [SPEAKER_01]: And so you have a tip where you say, make meals really memorable. [SPEAKER_01]: Like add spaces, make them flavorful and memorable in a moment, and that will actually have an effect, which I found fascinating.
[SPEAKER_00]: mindfully as well so make sure you're not like distracted and all that make sure savoring and you know being grateful and all this sort of stuff like it's actually really important stuff like even though it's not always measurable I think there is a lot of scientific truth to these things which often gets poopy like oh you can't measure it right they're still really really important so to dumb it down to a single factor like it's all [SPEAKER_00]: It doesn't such a disservice because it's like it had nothing to do with the calories It had to do with the fact that you're you know watching the movie and stuffing your face with the popcorn Just out of pure Mechanical habit right and they've done all these studies, right where they fill people's popcorn trade like I don't know if you've read those studies
[SPEAKER_00]: you know, when people are eating popcorn, they gave them like really stale, awful popcorn. [SPEAKER_00]: People just ate it anyway because they're so distracted by the movie, they just didn't care, right, and it's like, and then when they from the popcorn, when they weren't watching them, they're like, oh, this is awful. [SPEAKER_00]: It's like, it's very funny, this whole thing. [SPEAKER_00]: But yeah, I think there's a lot of truth to what you're saying, and again, why would we deny the truth of all that, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Because they does play a role in eating, [SPEAKER_01]: Yes, completely. [SPEAKER_01]: And speaking of the ultra-processed food, you mentioned that our total energy expenditure today is down.
[SPEAKER_01]: However, our physical activity is actually up. [SPEAKER_01]: So the difference there is that the metabolism is actually down or do you think it's the speaking of the ultra-processed food could it be that the thermic effect, like just processing these foods is so easy now that we have lost that aspect of it. [SPEAKER_00]: It certainly could be thermodaspective food because a lot of the ultra-processed foods are basically pre-digested. [SPEAKER_00]: They're trying to make it easier to digest, so therefore it bypasses all of those sort of satiety mechanisms much more quickly. [SPEAKER_00]: So if you think about satiety mechanisms, there are ways that are satiety as the way that our body signals us, that hey, you're for you need to stop eating.
[SPEAKER_00]: So if you eat a very bulky meal, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Like, [SPEAKER_00]: You know, something like leafy green vegetables or broccoli or whatever, it's a big, big volume. [SPEAKER_00]: It fills up your stomach, right? [SPEAKER_00]: And therefore you get the message that you need to stop eating. [SPEAKER_00]: Or when you eat foods that are hard to digest, your body stays in the stomach. [SPEAKER_00]: So when food goes down at your stomach, your stomach actually holds it and then sort of turns it around, mixes it, [SPEAKER_00]: But natural foods are actually held there much longer.
[SPEAKER_00]: Ultra-process foods tend to get through the stomach very fast. [SPEAKER_00]: It's called gastric transit time. [SPEAKER_00]: And so if the food is being held in stomach, then your body's going to get the message that, hey, you should stop eating because your stomach is full. [SPEAKER_00]: So anything that's very bulky, right? [SPEAKER_00]: And it used to be this thing called volumetric staya, which had [SPEAKER_00]: you know, a decent amount of research behind it or, you know, there's old methods like, you know, chew your foods like 40 times a, right? [SPEAKER_00]: And then again, that's to make it mindful, to make it memorable, so that you're slowing everything down, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: So if you're eating slowly, you're going to have to time for these entirely mechanisms to catch up. [SPEAKER_00]: So yeah, it could be certainly the thermic effect. [SPEAKER_00]: It could be the ultra-processing of foods. [SPEAKER_00]: It could be, I think that's actually probably a lot of different things that contribute to this. [SPEAKER_00]: But it was interesting because a lot of the research was basically saying that if you look at the activity of [SPEAKER_00]: modern humans because there's this argument that people are less active now, you know, we walk it in the past when we used to drive and now we drive certain.
[SPEAKER_00]: But that he doesn't hold up because how much energy we expend through sort of movement and exercise throughout the ages has actually remained relatively constant. [SPEAKER_00]: So this obesity epidemic isn't simply that, oh, now we have cars, [SPEAKER_00]: the obesity epidemic didn't get going until the 1980s. [SPEAKER_00]: So it's not the cause. [SPEAKER_00]: I, car a problem if you will. [SPEAKER_00]: It's still a hill to me to die from. [SPEAKER_00]: I think there's multiple aspects, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Because certainly, if you're more active, and you're less likely to do other things, but they play different roles.
[SPEAKER_00]: So exercise is one of these things that has, you know, it's not the calorie effect necessarily. [SPEAKER_00]: It could be the effect on stress relief, it could be the effect on the synthetic nervous system. [SPEAKER_00]: There's so many different aspects to it, other than the calories rate. [SPEAKER_00]: But it's a complex subject, right? [SPEAKER_00]: And I think it deserves some, [SPEAKER_00]: You really have to think about it because there's, you know, in the book, there's like 50 tips, which means there's like 50 different ways you can go off the rails, right, and the problem is when somebody says, oh, it's all this one thing calories, right, then you're missing the other 49 other things, right, it's like that could be the problem.
[SPEAKER_01]: So actually to that point, so thought experiment, because we're saying, you know, that it's not all one thing, if we didn't have processed foods or ultra processed foods, if we only had access to Whole Foods, do you think that would? [SPEAKER_01]: would that solve it for the majority of people? [SPEAKER_00]: I would think that that's a very big step in the right direction because it takes care of a lot of the issues around homies static hunger. [SPEAKER_00]: So natural foods trigger sort of satiety mechanisms like you can eat
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, a hamburger patty could you eat 50? [SPEAKER_00]: Unlikely, it's just very, very hard to do. [SPEAKER_00]: Whereas, if you eat like one potato chip could you eat 50, yeah, quite easily, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Or if you had one sip of cola or soda, could you drink a whole liter of soda, probably, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Because natural foods have natural satiety mechanisms. [SPEAKER_00]: So therefore, that takes care of the whole homostatic thing and it also takes care of a lot of the hedonic things because the ultra-processing is what we're saying about the processing is what leads to the sort of extra reward that you get with foods, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: And that's been engineered in by different ways, like, you know, they've been books about, you know, the bliss point and stuff. [SPEAKER_00]: What's the exact proportion of salt and sugar and fat? [SPEAKER_00]: what chemicals can we use, what texturizers, what emulsifiers, what artificial flavors, what artificial colors, right? [SPEAKER_00]: It's a very scientific process of how to get you to eat more and more and more. [SPEAKER_00]: So, but when you stick to natural foods, you're not only going to take care of that homiest diet economy, physical hunger, because you're going to have natural satiety hormones.
[SPEAKER_00]: You're going to take care of a lot of the emotional problems, because again, it's very hard to become addicted to natural foods, because people don't say, I'm addicted to shrimp, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So that takes care of two big things, and then it's just a social part of the hunger, but again, [SPEAKER_00]: You know, it's not like they're independent of each other. [SPEAKER_00]: If you solve two of the three big problems, while you're most of the way there, right? [SPEAKER_00]: And that's simply by cutting out a lot of cultural process foods. [SPEAKER_00]: And the other thing about cultural process foods, again, food addiction and cultural process foods, research on this is really just exploding in the last five years.
[SPEAKER_00]: There's so much evidence. [SPEAKER_00]: And now, of course, with dietary guidelines and stuff, there's this huge focus on cultural process foods, which I think is very, very welcome. [SPEAKER_00]: Because what it tells you is it goes way beyond just the sort of calories, just the macro nutrients, right? [SPEAKER_00]: The protein versus factors is carbs to understand about processing as part of the problem. [SPEAKER_00]: And I think that's something that is, I think very, very interesting and we're only going to hear more and more about that in the future because the data is just coming.
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, to that point, do you think, I think about this a lot, like, especially, you know, something like smoking and tobacco was so prevalent for so long and such a normal part of society, and now it's very much, you know, people don't, they know it's not a good thing, then it's not cool to do anymore. [SPEAKER_01]: And with the, with the ultra-processed foods, like slowly things have been actually taken out, like trans fats, and then, you know, like red dye, whatever, recently, and then, you know, the food pyramid changing, [SPEAKER_01]: do you think they're actually as a future where the culture changes as a whole and we actually stop eating these or do you think it's too ingrained in the system?
[SPEAKER_00]: No, I think you have to acknowledge where the problem lies first, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So if you think about smoking, the real change was when, you know, people when the sort of general said smoking is bad for you and you should stop smoking, right? [SPEAKER_00]: It still took like 20 years. [SPEAKER_00]: One of the big things I think was stopping the advertising of cigarettes to minors, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So if you think back, right? [SPEAKER_00]: They used to advertise cigarettes to children all the time.
[SPEAKER_00]: They had this very famous character called Joe Camel, which was one of the most recognizable figures, you know, anywhere. [SPEAKER_00]: And it represented, you know, one of the, [SPEAKER_00]: You know, camel brand cigarette, and they had like cigarettes in the vending machines, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Which which sounds completely insane now, right? [SPEAKER_00]: That you could go into any hospital or anywhere and just go to a vending machine and buy a package of cigarettes.
[SPEAKER_00]: And they sold cigarettes in the pharmacy, right? [SPEAKER_00]: This is... [SPEAKER_00]: Like it's just the most bizarre thing to think about these days actually worked as a student when I was in high school I worked in the pharmacy and like half my day was selling cigarettes in the pharmacy right so it's it's it's totally bizarre but to think about that now You had the you know the old cars remember had the little ash tray on the other thing the the air old air planes had a little ash tray on the side like totally bizarre
[SPEAKER_00]: behind it. [SPEAKER_00]: So ultra-process foods isn't that process. [SPEAKER_00]: And what's funny is that tobacco companies in this process of, you know, they were slowly getting edged out because everybody was basically taxing them and putting restrictions on advertising and, you know, no more cigarette-vending machines and stuff. [SPEAKER_00]: So they actually went out and bought all the ultra-process food companies. [SPEAKER_00]: And basically apply the exact same playbook, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So they started advertising to kids and should re-serials, you know, applying the research off, right?
[SPEAKER_01]: And seeing how you had deep breakfast and all the sort of stuff they had to apply the exact same playbook. [SPEAKER_00]: And it really wasn't until you started to ban all the advertising that you really started to make this smoking sort of uncool, right? [SPEAKER_00]: because before people would smoke because it was cool and they didn't care that they would get lung cancer, everybody would do that anyway. [SPEAKER_00]: They still smoke, but it was cool, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So that's the thing that really sort of I think turned the tide in the United States was that sort of banning and advertising, getting rid of due to camel and stuff, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: Joe camel. [SPEAKER_00]: You know, it was just a, it was sort of this great, you know, example of how to do things right. [SPEAKER_00]: So I think we're in that [SPEAKER_00]: process now with older process foods where we're saying that, hey, these chemicals and these things are bad for us, right? [SPEAKER_00]: I mean, a lot of this stuff is just not stuff you should be eating. [SPEAKER_00]: So you look at the market for like whole foods and organic foods and, you know, non-processed foods and people want to be healthier, but yeah, they need to help to say, look,
[SPEAKER_00]: It's really important we need to focus in on this and maybe we need to stop advertising to kids and maybe we need to take away some of this, you know, this advertising for ultra-process foods that we need to get people just back to eating natural foods, right? [SPEAKER_00]: But it's a long process. [SPEAKER_00]: It's like a two-decky process, even for something as clear-cut as smoking. [SPEAKER_00]: But we've started, and that's encouraging because up until this most recent dietary guidelines, everybody has stuck on calories, calories, calories, calories, and the reason that calories is such an effective book in it, is that nobody sells calories, so you can go, you buy food, you buy drinks, you buy snack, you don't buy calories, so therefore by putting it as
[SPEAKER_00]: the sort of villain is that nobody suffers, right? [SPEAKER_00]: You can still go selling your potato chips and your, you know, ultra-process foods because hey, broccoli has calories. [SPEAKER_00]: They stay has calories, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So that's no different, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So they're trying to lump themselves in. [SPEAKER_00]: It's very sneaky what they're doing, but this research on ultra-process foods is slowly sort of healing back the dangers of it, right? [SPEAKER_00]: And there's been a couple of very, very interesting studies, one, four months ago, looking at the effect of ultra-process foods on kids' behaviors, which I thought was very, very interesting, and there's a clear link to this entire association.
[SPEAKER_00]: between how much ultra-process foods they eat and their behavior in schools, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So it goes beyond just weight. [SPEAKER_00]: It also we talk about attention, spans, and you know, until health. [SPEAKER_00]: that could be playing like a very important role. [SPEAKER_00]: And a lot of the ultra-processed foods really stimulate insulin and just yesterday us all this study. [SPEAKER_00]: Unpostmenopausal women, they look that nurses health study, so 34,000 people or something like that. [SPEAKER_00]: And I looked at all different diets and said, which one is the best?
[SPEAKER_00]: Which one do you do? [SPEAKER_00]: Do perimenopausal women do the best in terms of cardiac health and weight and it was the low insulin diet? [SPEAKER_00]: So eating things that don't stipulate a lot of insulin was far away the best diet to do. [SPEAKER_00]: Which is exactly what we're talking about. [SPEAKER_00]: We're talking about cutting down refined foods, refined carbohydrates in particular intermittent fasting, which is another way to lower insulin. [SPEAKER_00]: All those ways to lower insulin is the way to prevent weight gain in perimenopause, which is sort of one of the highest risks, periods.
[SPEAKER_00]: Just talking about perimenopause is in a slide. [SPEAKER_00]: You have all these people that tell you it's all about calories, calories, calories, but it's like, okay, if it's all about calories, and therefore about willpower, then why is it that women in perimenopause always complain about weight gain? [SPEAKER_00]: So you can look up any study. [SPEAKER_00]: Women gain weight in perimenopause. [SPEAKER_00]: That's just the fact, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Everybody knows it. [SPEAKER_00]: If you actually listen to people, they'll tell you, I'm eating the same thing, I'm doing the same thing as I did for the last 15 years.
[SPEAKER_00]: but now I'm gaining weight. [SPEAKER_00]: Like, it's not a calorie problem. [SPEAKER_00]: Because the calories are the same. [SPEAKER_00]: It's not an activity problem. [SPEAKER_00]: Their activities are the same. [SPEAKER_00]: The problem, obviously, is their hormones. [SPEAKER_00]: They're hormones were changing. [SPEAKER_00]: They're perimenopausal. [SPEAKER_00]: So if it's the hormonal part that's changing that's causing the weight gain, why are we focused on calories? [SPEAKER_00]: It was the hormonal change. [SPEAKER_00]: I don't know if it can be any more clear than that. [SPEAKER_00]: Like honestly, that's why you have to focus on the hormones. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, to that point, I actually had like a dozen listener questions.
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't think we're going to get to really any of them. [SPEAKER_01]: But Marissa, for example, she said, why are all my numbers? [SPEAKER_01]: A1C, fasting, insulin, rising and parent-menopause? [SPEAKER_01]: When I do daily 22 to 24 hour fast, work out with weights, stop eating by six or seven p.m. and take burbering. [SPEAKER_01]: So frustrating with three exclamation points. [SPEAKER_00]: It is frustrating. [SPEAKER_00]: The problem is, like estrogen and progesterone, which are two of the painful hormones, that change, determine, and wait. [SPEAKER_00]: Like you think about it this way.
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, if you change your diet, your diet, you can change insulin predominant. [SPEAKER_00]: If you were talking about stress and all this stuff, we're gonna affect mostly cortisol. [SPEAKER_00]: But the problem is actually estrogen progesterone, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So that's why you're doing all this sort of right things, but those things are focused on different hormonal systems. [SPEAKER_00]: The estrogen progesterone part, you may not necessarily be able to fix, because hormone replacement therapy is still a pretty controversial topic, right? [SPEAKER_00]: But if you think about it, it's actually really important, because during when estrogen goes up, for example, then your appetite starts to go down, and you can actually track this in the menstrual cycle.
[SPEAKER_00]: So if you look at during the 2018 cycle, [SPEAKER_00]: They've done these studies where they've looked at women and they actually have to go from [SPEAKER_00]: day zero to 14 ovulation, estrogen is rising and people are eating less and less so if you look at the calorie intake normal cycle it actually goes down from sort of day zero to day 14 and then after ovulation estrogen goes down progesterone goes up and it's a progesterone goes up it's a stimulant to appetite and they start to eat more so there's a very particular pattern
[SPEAKER_00]: going up, at the beginning of the cycle, you're eating less and then the gesture will go down. [SPEAKER_00]: So, you know, during menopause, of course, those levels are sort of all going out of whack, estrogen is going down. [SPEAKER_00]: So, therefore, you're losing that protection, people may be more hungry, right? [SPEAKER_00]: And then the change in progesterone as well in terms of, you know, eating behavior, but also fat storage, because remember, [SPEAKER_00]: It's not just about the calories you're eating, right? [SPEAKER_00]: It's about where your body is directing those calories too, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: So if you think about estrogen and testosterone, for example, during puberty. [SPEAKER_00]: So prior to puberty, men, boys and girls have roughly the same amount of body fat. [SPEAKER_00]: After puberty, after, you know, when they're 18, girls have about 50% more body fat. [SPEAKER_00]: Is it a little power? [SPEAKER_00]: No, not long. [SPEAKER_00]: It's because the boys have testosterone, which directs all of their energy, all of their calories into building muscle. [SPEAKER_00]: And in girls, you have a lot of estrogen and progesterone, which is directing a lot of the calories towards subcutaneous fat, to the rest of the hips, and preparation for child therapy.
[SPEAKER_00]: So it makes sense that the gain and fat had nothing to do with will power diet, all this kind of stuff, right? [SPEAKER_00]: And everything to do with the estrogen your gestern and testosterone. [SPEAKER_00]: So that's the thing. [SPEAKER_00]: That's the answer to the question. [SPEAKER_00]: Unfortunately, it doesn't help you answer to what you can actually do about it necessarily, because if you work on the diet more, it wasn't a insulin problem. [SPEAKER_00]: If you work on like the stress mark, it wasn't a stress problem. [SPEAKER_00]: It wasn't a cortisol problem. [SPEAKER_00]: It was the estrogen progesterone problem. [SPEAKER_00]: So should you take our movement placement?
[SPEAKER_00]: Like those are questions that are, it would be a controversial, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So the whole hormone placement question is, there's been sort of a couple of hundred, hundred, hundred, eighty-degree flip-flops in the last few decades. [SPEAKER_00]: So, you know, that's a different question. [SPEAKER_00]: But that's the answer is like it's a hormonal issue, but it's an estrogen pedestrian issue, rather than the other one, which is why it's often very frustrating
[SPEAKER_01]: To that point, I love the example of puberty and how the fat deposition changes because I love when there's an example where it just makes things so obvious. [SPEAKER_01]: Like clearly hormones are playing a role if a boy and a girl can eat the same amount of food and it becomes fat or muscle or whatever it goes on their body is different. [SPEAKER_01]: because of their biological sex. [SPEAKER_01]: Like how much more clear can you get? [SPEAKER_01]: Or like, or with the ultra-process foods, the concept that a lot of poverty will have obesity problems.
[SPEAKER_01]: So if it's a lack of money to buy food and they're buying ultra-process foods and they're actually gaining weight, I gotta feel like that's a really good example of clearly there's a problem here with ultra-process foods. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, yeah, because really if you think it's a, you know, we'll par problem, the rich people should actually have more obesity issues, right? [SPEAKER_00]: But they don't. [SPEAKER_00]: Why? [SPEAKER_00]: Because they don't tend to eat those cheaper sort of older processed foods, right? [SPEAKER_00]: They'll go for the more expensive natural foods, which are better for you and that they activate the normal proper sort of satiety, signaling and hunger, signaling and all this kind of stuff, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: So, it is, you know, once you start to think about the sort of epiphany phenomenon for obesity and you know, linked to socioeconomic status and stuff, it makes way more sense when you when you have that framework, other than calories and calories out, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Which is such a, such a simplistic flawed notion. [SPEAKER_00]: It's like anybody who says that to me, [SPEAKER_00]: You know, I sort of instantly know that it's like, okay, these people haven't really thought about it too much, right? [SPEAKER_00]: You know, and it's very, it's very hard to sort of get through to those people because they're so sort of sad in their ways of thinking.
[SPEAKER_00]: They think that it's all a math problem when it's actually a much more complicated issue of not just hormones, but it goes further than the hormones, it comes into, you know, [SPEAKER_00]: emotions and social situations. [SPEAKER_00]: It's just like if you look at countries, for example, it's like Japan has one of the lowest obesity rates in the world. [SPEAKER_00]: And the United States has more, is it just a little power problem? [SPEAKER_00]: I don't think so. [SPEAKER_00]: And what happens when you take that Japanese person and plunk them down into San Francisco?
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, if they gain weight, they get a lot of weight, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Then within a couple of generations, the Japanese Americans are actually just as a [SPEAKER_00]: And it's like, why, what's the difference? [SPEAKER_00]: It wasn't genetics, because they're still the Japanese. [SPEAKER_00]: They're still Japanese. [SPEAKER_00]: The difference was the environment that they're in, right? [SPEAKER_00]: The people around you. [SPEAKER_00]: influence what you do to a huge degree. [SPEAKER_00]: So this is called social modeling. [SPEAKER_00]: And that's why they have these social influencers, right, influencers on social media.
[SPEAKER_00]: But that's why they're so important. [SPEAKER_00]: That's why everybody's paying these influencers to tell whatever, because they know that those people have an outsized influence. [SPEAKER_00]: That is, and we all know this, right, like peer pressures need to turn me used in schools and stuff where your friends do is what you do, right? [SPEAKER_00]: That's really important, but it extends further than that. [SPEAKER_00]: All through your life. [SPEAKER_00]: Everybody around you is eating natural foods, you'll eat natural foods, right? [SPEAKER_00]: If everybody around you is eating ultra-processed foods, you're eating ultra-processed foods.
[SPEAKER_00]: And that's the difference. [SPEAKER_00]: Not the well-power or not anything else. [SPEAKER_00]: It's where you live. [SPEAKER_00]: Where you live actually determines to a huge extent your rate of obesity. [SPEAKER_00]: If you live in, [SPEAKER_00]: your rate of obesity is very low if you live in America it's very high if you live in Italy it's very low if you live in New York City as an Italian it's very high right so it's like it's where you live that's really important and again why don't we acknowledge this because we're stuck in this you know a simplistic notion of
[SPEAKER_00]: calories and calories of that's all it is. [SPEAKER_00]: It's all but with a power and your friends don't make difference in your life. [SPEAKER_00]: It doesn't make a difference in your emotional status makes doesn't make a difference in your hormonal status makes a difference. [SPEAKER_00]: It's like, no, one period we've gotten, no way in the battle against obesity because we didn't even begin to understand the complexity of the problem. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and I'm just thinking about all the messaging that just further supported this whole issue like with the like Coca Cola I think like the companies that would put all the focus on exercise so like, oh, let's raise all this money so put the focus on exercise so that people can keep drinking drinking Coca Cola.
[SPEAKER_00]: They put a lot of money that the millions and millions into promoting exercise and exercises good in many ways but for them for Coca-Cola it was a way to sort of take themselves out of the blame and then put it on something else like you know don't blame the sugary soda for your obesity blame your lack of exercise right that's the messaging that's there right [SPEAKER_00]: And unfortunately, they have huge clothes because they have lobbyists and all this sort of stuff.
[SPEAKER_00]: So even if you look at people who are very well-meaning like Michelle Obama, it's like, oh, we're going to do this, let's move or whatever it's like, okay, well, how about let's have better food and get rid of the ultra-processed foods and get rid of advertising to children, right? [SPEAKER_00]: because that's what works for smoking, like we gotta get it, so it's not like, you know, it's not in their face all the time that they should be eating, you know, you watch television or whatever and there's advertising for snack foods constantly on streaming, on billboards and you know, everywhere you go, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: It's like, okay, well, even though she was very well meeting [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, another one, and I know this is a little bit controversial to say, but the like the health that every size movement. [SPEAKER_01]: So I'm all for like love yourself at every size and body positivity and body acceptance. [SPEAKER_01]: And yet there was this whole movement where they were literally trying to say that it was healthy to be metabolically unhealthy. [SPEAKER_01]: And I feel like it was, I feel like it was because it is so hard to make these changes because of where like the the condition hunger and this is shot the societal hunger.
[SPEAKER_01]: And so it's just easier to like write it off is healthy. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and I really didn't like that either because it wasn't actually true, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So it was it was. [SPEAKER_00]: You know, there's not a health consequences of being overweight and obese. [SPEAKER_00]: And then a lot of the studies coming out of the GLP-10s and big studies are basically showing exactly that. [SPEAKER_00]: When people lose weight, there's actually all sorts of improvements in health grammars that you can measure, right, diabetes, heart attack, strokes, all this sort of stuff.
[SPEAKER_00]: And back pain and pain and all this sort of stuff. [SPEAKER_00]: So the problem I had with the whole body positivity is not that they shouldn't be positive, but it's like, don't lie to people that this is actually healthy. [SPEAKER_00]: It's not actually healthy, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So it's fine, though, you shouldn't be fat shaming, you know, we should be creating people with compassion, just like, [SPEAKER_00]: You know, the problem with, and I think that where he rose, came out of this whole calories in calories. [SPEAKER_00]: So the story we get sold is that it's all calories in calories out. [SPEAKER_00]: So you just need to eat less or move more.
[SPEAKER_00]: It's all about calories. [SPEAKER_00]: Just like your other guess we're saying. [SPEAKER_00]: It's all calories. [SPEAKER_00]: It all comes down to calories. [SPEAKER_00]: So if you can't lose weight then you didn't have enough of the power to eat fewer calories before move more. [SPEAKER_00]: It's a willpower problem, right? [SPEAKER_00]: It's a discipline problem, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So therefore, if you're overweight, [SPEAKER_00]: It means you're lazy and stupid, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So that's where the whole fat shaming came out. [SPEAKER_00]: It comes out of this calories and calories of messaging. [SPEAKER_00]: That's why I call them the calorie bullies, because you're not treating people with compassion anymore, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: Just like if you have somebody who's in alcoholic addict, right? [SPEAKER_00]: You could say, uh, it's all alcohol and alcohol out, right? [SPEAKER_00]: If you can't break their addiction, you're just lazy or stupid, right? [SPEAKER_00]: It's like, no, they're addicted. [SPEAKER_00]: Like, let's treat them with compassion. [SPEAKER_00]: And that's where alcohol is not as just like okay spirituality for given us. [SPEAKER_00]: you know, making a mental, all this sort of stuff, right? [SPEAKER_00]: And I think we have to do the same for obesity. [SPEAKER_00]: It's not necessarily their problem. [SPEAKER_00]: It's not a well-power problem. [SPEAKER_00]: It's not discipline problem. [SPEAKER_00]: It's not any of that.
[SPEAKER_00]: But let's figure out what the problem actually is. [SPEAKER_00]: Is it a sleep problem? [SPEAKER_00]: Is it a stress problem? [SPEAKER_00]: Is it a hormonal issue? [SPEAKER_00]: Is it an ultra-process food issue? [SPEAKER_00]: Is it a social issue? [SPEAKER_00]: Is it a habit issue? [SPEAKER_00]: What is it? [SPEAKER_00]: So that we can fix it? [SPEAKER_00]: and treat people with compassion rather than labeling them as if this is all calories, therefore this is all well power, therefore your weight is really a reflection of your, you know, moral status, right? [SPEAKER_00]: You don't have, you know, real power and all that sort of stuff.
[SPEAKER_00]: So that's that's where I think I really don't like the, uh, [SPEAKER_00]: the whole calories in calorie out, all those calorie beliefs because it really leads to sort of detrimental sort of attitude towards treating obesity as a bill power problem. [SPEAKER_00]: What I never was, it was at least much more complicated, much more nuanced, but rather than trying to understand the nuance, they're basically trying to hammer us with this calorie's calorie's calorie. [SPEAKER_00]: And so that that's where that fat positivity movement came out of, like, we shouldn't be shaming people, we shouldn't be doing this.
[SPEAKER_00]: And I absolutely agree with that. [SPEAKER_00]: On the other hand, you shouldn't be telling them that this is healthy, right? [SPEAKER_00]: It's like telling people lies is never good. [SPEAKER_00]: It's never good, it's strategy, right? [SPEAKER_01]: Not the solution. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, it's like, I agree you shouldn't be shaming these people. [SPEAKER_00]: I agree you should treat them, but don't just tell them it's healthy because it's not healthy. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, cannot agree more. [SPEAKER_01]: A nice, maybe ending question. [SPEAKER_01]: Zoe, she said she read the obesity code, and she wants to know if any of your theories or ideas on diet and fasting have changed since publishing that book.
[SPEAKER_00]: If anything, I'm more convinced of the correctness of that book, honestly, because as I mentioned, if you look at the [SPEAKER_00]: what people are talking about now, they're talking about insulin, and they're talking about fasting with much more acceptance. [SPEAKER_00]: So all the studies coming out now are showing that, hey, it's really a hormonal issue, it's not a calories issue. [SPEAKER_00]: You know, that study that I was telling about yesterday, that just came out yesterday on the Journal of the American Medical Association. [SPEAKER_00]: Again, the low insulin diet was the best diet by far, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: so getting to the complexity of that. [SPEAKER_00]: So all of the stuff about insulin, about cortisol, and the obesity code, it's all still there. [SPEAKER_00]: It just took a lot lot when I thought for people to accept it, but you know, and that's where the hunger code sort of takes off from the obesity code. [SPEAKER_00]: It's really a follow. [SPEAKER_00]: And if you read the hunger code, you'll notice some people, it's funny because I read this one comment said, it's a real hash of the obesity code. [SPEAKER_00]: I'm like, [SPEAKER_00]: There's nothing in the hunger code in the obesity code, right? [SPEAKER_00]: I talk about hisonic hunger, condition hunger, only the static hunger, gastric transit times, you know, there's nothing in there, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, other than maybe the first little bit, which is basically, you know, expanding on the hormonal piece, but that's where I think this is trying to take off from, but no, I haven't changed my mind to go any of that. [SPEAKER_00]: I think the research is really just coming in stronger and stronger that we have to focus in on all of these issues, right? [SPEAKER_00]: The incident in the court is always the focus of the obesity code, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So again, if you're refined carbohydrates and they made a clear distinction in that book that it was the processing, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: The unrefined carbohydrates are not necessarily about it, right? [SPEAKER_00]: You can't eat. [SPEAKER_00]: lot of natural grains and stuff is still fine, right? [SPEAKER_00]: You don't have to cut them all out. [SPEAKER_00]: You could, if you want to, but you don't have to. [SPEAKER_00]: There are other ways to sort of get to that. [SPEAKER_00]: So that's, you know, that's my feeling. [SPEAKER_00]: It's, it's, if anything sort of held up to the test of time, if you will. [SPEAKER_01]: one just really quick note about the insulin thing, something I like that you said in this book.
[SPEAKER_01]: And it's because I feel like people are always like pair of car, well you talk about no naked carbs, but I feel like people are always like pair of carbs with fat, pair of carbs with fat. [SPEAKER_01]: And I'm like, I don't know why the messaging isn't pair of carbs with protein, because for me fat, like if you look at the studies, it seems that it just elongates, it doesn't change the area under the curve much. [SPEAKER_01]: You know, the release of the carbs compared to protein where I feel like it mitigates that a little bit. [SPEAKER_00]: I think that both of them can work, but the problem is, you know, sometimes when you compare carbs with fat, it can result in a very... Like hyper palatable?
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, hyper palatable, rewarding situation like if you take pure starch. [SPEAKER_00]: not that good, like if you just take boiled potato, pure starch. [SPEAKER_00]: It's not that tasty that people are just going to keep eating it, right? [SPEAKER_00]: But if you pair it with fat, like french fries, potato chips, right, then all of a sudden it's really, you know, a lot better, right? [SPEAKER_00]: The same thing with fats, right? [SPEAKER_00]: If you take pure fat,
[SPEAKER_00]: Again, you can drink olive oil, but not that many people do, because it's not that tasty, right? [SPEAKER_00]: It's not that great to drink olive oil. [SPEAKER_00]: You can't, but it's not great. [SPEAKER_00]: But then again, you pair it with a little bit of carbohydrate, and it's a bit of an unnatural situation. [SPEAKER_00]: or energy. [SPEAKER_00]: So if you think about carbs, it's like potatoes and rice. [SPEAKER_00]: That's the way a plant is towards energy. [SPEAKER_00]: Animals store energy in the form of fat, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: So when animals eat like a pig or cow or whatever, and they want to store energy, they store fat. [SPEAKER_00]: They don't store starch, right? [SPEAKER_00]: That's just the way it is. [SPEAKER_00]: So therefore, they're two different sort of storage forms so in nature they don't mix that much. [SPEAKER_00]: That's why when you pair them together, you get these novel combinations that can be very palatable. [SPEAKER_00]: So pairing the carbs with the fats is a little on the tricky side, because it is a little bit unnatural because they're [SPEAKER_00]: just the way that people have all great plans have started and animals have found a great.
[SPEAKER_00]: So they don't mix and that's why when you go to a very, very, you know, some plants do of course coconut oil and avocado oil and stuff. [SPEAKER_00]: But in general it's, it's, it's, it's, they're, they're a little bit exclusive to it. [SPEAKER_00]: So yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, you have to be careful. [SPEAKER_00]: Sometimes the carbs plus the fact can work and sometimes it doesn't work. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, for me, I just feel like it's like carbs, stemling the insulin, and then the fat, easily stored, so together, maybe not the best combination all the time. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, it would, it may not be the best combination.
[SPEAKER_00]: That's where something like protein may be a better sort of intermediary for separating them in the meal or something else. [SPEAKER_00]: as I said, this is all great discussion because this sort of points out the complexity of the whole situation, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Everybody wants to be like, carbs good, or carbs bad, or fats good, or fats bad. [SPEAKER_00]: It's like there's a lot more to it than. [SPEAKER_00]: and more you know the better you'll do because then you'll be able to appreciate the nuance of hey this is this, this is this, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: So this is the whole thing about the calories, it's like you're trying to make it into, you're trying to shoehorn all of this complex physiology into a single statement of calories, right? [SPEAKER_00]: It's like you can't do that. [SPEAKER_00]: Just like heart disease, it's not just about smoking. [SPEAKER_00]: What causes heart disease? [SPEAKER_00]: Well, it's age. [SPEAKER_00]: It's sex. [SPEAKER_00]: It's diabetes. [SPEAKER_00]: It's high blood pressure. [SPEAKER_00]: It's cholesterol. [SPEAKER_00]: It's exercise. [SPEAKER_00]: It's smoking. [SPEAKER_00]: There's like 10 different factors that affect heart disease.
[SPEAKER_00]: It's like, there's lots of different things. [SPEAKER_00]: Whereas obesity is like, oh, it's only one thing. [SPEAKER_00]: Calories, like, what disease does that, right? [SPEAKER_00]: No disease in humans is like a single factor, like that, maybe a few genetic diseases, but other than that, everything's this multifactorial complex mix of things. [SPEAKER_00]: So you have to attack all of them, right? [SPEAKER_00]: Whereas with obesity is like, oh, it's a simple one thing, math. [SPEAKER_00]: And it's like, okay, well, if that's what you think you've already lost, right?
[SPEAKER_00]: You have the wrong idea about what the disease is, so therefore you're not confused. [SPEAKER_01]: exactly. [SPEAKER_01]: So take away is nuance and all the things and friends, again, cannot recommend enough the hunger code. [SPEAKER_01]: Get it now. [SPEAKER_01]: We only barely scratch the surface. [SPEAKER_01]: It's all in there. [SPEAKER_01]: And thank you so much for everything that you do, Jason. [SPEAKER_01]: Like I said, I've been following your work from day, well, not from day. [SPEAKER_01]: I mean, I don't know what your day one was. [SPEAKER_01]: Not from day one. [SPEAKER_01]: But from my day one in this world, the last question I just asked every guest on the show, and it's just because I realized the importance of mindset which is something that you talk about in the book as well.
[SPEAKER_01]: So what is something that you're grateful for? [SPEAKER_00]: I'm really grateful for, I think, you know, to the open-mindedness of people. [SPEAKER_00]: I think I think grateful that a lot of people have read what I've written and been helped. [SPEAKER_00]: And I think it's because people are looking for something sort of different than what they're being shoved down their throats, which is calories, willpower, calories, discipline, right? [SPEAKER_00]: This no pain, no gains or anything, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So I've been grateful that people have sort of read it and accepted it.
[SPEAKER_00]: It always makes me very happy when I hear somebody like sometimes somebody will come to me and say, oh, I saw you on. [SPEAKER_00]: YouTube, where I read your book, and I lost like 50 pounds, and like, wow, that to me is so thankful that people have accepted that, and that I was able to help them without even knowing them, right? [SPEAKER_00]: But just by pointing out the right thing, it makes me, you know, I'm grateful for, you know, through your support and for all the people who've supported me through this to get the message out there, because again, it's, it's gratifying to help people.
[SPEAKER_00]: And I think that's, it's this whole thing about altruism and it's like, you know, when people look back at the great things they did in their life, it's always about helping other people. [SPEAKER_00]: mostly like families and friends, and I was able to help my son do this, and I was able to help my friend do this, right? [SPEAKER_00]: So, you know, I'm grateful for all the support and the acceptance that I was able to help people because it makes me feel good, right? [SPEAKER_00]: It makes me feel like I've done something important. [SPEAKER_00]: So, you know, that that means is sort of the best.
[SPEAKER_00]: gift that I have gotten is that, you know, this feeling that I've been able to help people. [SPEAKER_00]: So, you know, and it's through, you know, people like yourself who've been able to spread the message and so on. [SPEAKER_01]: Well, you're certainly doing that again. [SPEAKER_01]: Thank you so much for all that you've done. [SPEAKER_01]: I know listeners all over, you have changed so many lives and they are so grateful. [SPEAKER_01]: So, thank you. [SPEAKER_01]: I love your new book, Friends, get it now, get the hunger code, and would love to have you back in the future. [SPEAKER_00]: Oh, absolutely, thanks so much. [SPEAKER_01]: Thanks Jason.
[SPEAKER_01]: Hi. [SPEAKER_00]: Bye. [SPEAKER_01]: Thank you so much for listening to the Melanie Avalon by O'Hacking Godcast. [SPEAKER_01]: For more information and resources, you can check out my book, What When Why, as well as my supplement line, Avalon X. [SPEAKER_01]: Please visit MelanieAvalon.com to learn more about today's guests. [SPEAKER_01]: And always feel free to contact me at contact at MelanieAvalon.com and always remember you bought this.
Get $30 off with code melanieavalon at theonedevice.com/melanieavalon TRANSCRIPT AND FULL SHOW NOTES: melanieavalon.com/theone SPONSORS AND DISCOUNTS: AVALONX: Melanie made AvalonX to be her ideal supplements! They come...
TRANSCRIPT AND FULL SHOW NOTES: melanieavalon.com/girlsguide Book: https://link.amazon/B04ClQgqe SPONSORS AND DISCOUNTS: LMNT: Get your free Sample Pack with any LMNT purchase at...
TRANSCRIPT AND FULL SHOW NOTES: melanieavalon.com/jeffzwiefel SPONSORS AND DISCOUNTS: AVALONX: Melanie made AvalonX to be her ideal supplements! They come in glass bottles, are free of toxic fillers and common...
TRANSCRIPT AND FULL SHOW NOTES: melanieavalon.com/austinperlmutter Book: https://amzn.to/4oF0nQA SPONSORS AND DISCOUNTS: AVALONX: Melanie made AvalonX to be her ideal supplements! They come in glass bottles, are free of...
TRANSCRIPT AND FULL SHOW NOTES: melanieavalon.com/bestshot Book: https://amzn.to/3QrB5bZ SPONSORS AND DISCOUNTS: AVALONX: Melanie made AvalonX to be her ideal supplements! They come in glass bottles, are free of toxic...