The Fifteenth Sunday after Pentecost Matthew 18:15-20 The Rev'd Ezgi Saribay Perkins, The Rector
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00In the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. Please be seated. In many parts of the Middle East, there's an old practice called Sulha. The word means reconciliation or settlement, and it is used when a conflict has become too serious to ignore and too dangerous to leave alone. The point of sulha is not to pretend that nothing happened. It is also not to let anger spread until two families, clans, or communities are pulled into a cycle of revenge.
SPEAKER_00The wrong has to be named and faced, but it is done carefully, often with trusted elders and mediators who help parties speak and take responsibility. That word sulha reminds me of a Turkish saying many of us grew up hearing. It is heard as a national saying of Ataturk, but it carries a very human truth.
SPEAKER_00Peace cannot be only something we want for the world in general. Peace must begin close to home in our families, neighbors, communities, and for us in the church. But that is often the hardest place for peace to begin. It is much easier to talk about world peace than the face the person we have wounded or the person who has slighted us. My husband likes to tease me by saying, There is nothing longer in this world than Ezgi's memory of a perceived slight.
SPEAKER_00And public service announcement, it's true. One Christmas he even gave me a book of Esgi's perceived slights as a gift. It was under the tree, really. And he's not entirely wrong. We Turks can chew on a good resentment as a Sunday pastime. But resentment is not the only danger. We also know what happens when private hurt becomes public too quickly on social media. People take sides, gossip grows, the original wound gets buried beneath embarrassment and pride.
SPEAKER_00But Jesus gives the church another way this morning. He doesn't pretend that conflict will never happen among us. He assumes that people who love God will still hurt, misunderstand, and sin each other against each other. But he doesn't allow the church to choose between silence and spectacle. He says go and point out the fault when two of you are alone. Begin there, begin close to home, begin with the person, not with the crowd.
SPEAKER_00And if that doesn't restore the relationship, then you bring the others not to shame, but to help discern. And if the church must become involved in this mess, which never happens in the Episcopal Church until it's too late, then the goal is hopefully the restoration. Here's what I think the point of the passage is. Jesus teaches the church how to face broken relationships with honesty, accountability, and prayer, trusting that his presence guides this hard work.
SPEAKER_00The first thing Jesus teaches us is to go toward the wound, not away from it. He begins with a direct command. If another member of the church sin against you, go and point out the fault when to you're alone. So the first thing is not to complain or withdraw or recruit allies or wait for the other person to figure it out. The first movement is a go. That matters because Jesus places this teaching right after the parable of the lost sheep.
SPEAKER_00R.T. Franz says that the flow of thought in the text is about how a disciple should act when another disciple is in spiritual danger. In other words, this is not only about managing conflict. It is a passage about pastoral concern. The person who has sinned is not first treated as an opponent. Jesus calls this person a brother or a sister. So he keeps the relationship in view.
SPEAKER_00And the goal is to regain that person that might be slipping away from the life of the community. That's why the command the goal is searching. Jesus does not let us hide behind leaders, committees, or vague concerns. You'll have been in a situation when somebody quickly sidles up to you after the mass and says, You know, people are saying. Beware of those people that do that by the way. That's exactly what it means to hide behind a committee or a vague concern.
SPEAKER_00Who are these people? R.T. Franz points out that the individual disciple here is expected to act. If a trust has been broken between two people, our first faithful act is a private, honest conversation. The ancient commentators understand this with great seriousness. Chrysostom says Jesus does not tell us to accuse, punish, or drag the person in the court, but to correct.
SPEAKER_00And Augustine says if we see our brother's wound and say nothing, our silence may not be kindness, it may be neglect. That is hard to hear, especially for those of us who would rather keep the peace by avoiding the conversation altogether. But Christian peace is not the same thing as avoidance. At the same time, Jesus is not blessing harsh Turkish confrontation either. The word point out the fault is strong here.
SPEAKER_00The truth has to be made, yes. But Jesus says do it when the two of you are alone. So privacy protects the person from shame. It protects the community from gossip. It protects us from turning our heart into a public trial before we seek restoration. On the other hand, the passage, however, can be misused. So we should say clearly that Jesus is not asking anyone to enter danger, hide abuse, or protect institutions at the expense of the wounded.
SPEAKER_00When ordinary sin and broken trust wound the body of Christ, Jesus gives us a harder and holier path. Do not pretend that the wound is not there. Do not expose it carelessly. Go toward it with truth, humility, and the hope that what is broken may still be healed. No shortcuts. Secondly, he outlines a careful plot process for honesty, accountability, and restoration.
SPEAKER_00So first go along, and if that doesn't work, take one or two others. If the person still refuses to listen, then make it public. But Jesus does not rush immediately to the largest audience. He widens the circle only as much as love and truth require. That matters because this passage, as we've said, stands between two important teachings. Just before it, Jesus told the parable of the lost sheep. Just after it, Peter asks how often he must forgive, and Jesus answers with a mercy larger than Peter expected.
SPEAKER_00So Matthew 18 sits between seeking the lost and forgiving the sinner. And that tells us how to read the process. The first step is private because the wound should not be exposed before it has to be. One of the commentators says that the focus of reconciliation is not punishment. Another says the regain of brother or sister is the message here. So Jesus does not think we have an opponent against us when conflict happens.
SPEAKER_00He says our whole goal is to restore the relationship of a family, not to compete with one another. The second thing he asks us to do by taking the elders or somebody else with us is to protect the process from distortion. As you know, in the Old Testament, there is a requirement that a manner be confirmed by witnesses. The witnesses are not simply there, though, to help us win. The others may help the person hear the truth, the sinner, if you will, in this case, but they may also help us to see whether we have misunderstood.
SPEAKER_00And that requires humility on our part. So we don't choose witnesses as a cheering squad. We bring them because serious wounds need careful discernment. And last step is to bring the matter to the church, as I said, a very non-Episcopalian thing to do. Franz says the goal is not to pronounce judgment, but the strength in the pastoral appeal. The church is the body of Christ. When sin damages communion, the community has a responsibility to seek healing.
SPEAKER_00And that's where Matthew is so wise. Jesus refuses avoidance, where we sweep everything under the rug and call that peace. He refuses exposure, where we turn every wound into a public spectacle and call that truth. Instead, he gives the church a tall holy order. Speak directly, widen carefully, discern and keep restoration the goal. And finally, he promises to be present when this happens through prayer, discernment, and action.
SPEAKER_00Jesus' words, truly I tell you, whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven. I used to think that this this scripture passage referred only to priests. What a self-conceited thought. But it is a waity sentence for all of us. Because it means that whatever the church does together matters before God. The way we handle conflict, forgiveness, restoration, sin is not just a human matter so we get along.
SPEAKER_00It is a spiritual matter. But we have to be careful. Jesus is not giving the church permission to do whatever it wants and then claim God's stamp. The church is not free to baptize its anger, protect its pride, and call its politics the will of God. Binding and loosing belong to the community only when the community is seeking God's will under the authority of Christ. So our intention changes everything.
SPEAKER_00And that's why prayer is important. When Jesus says, if two of you agree together on earth about anything you ask, it will be done for you by my Father in heaven. In context, it's not a random promise that God will give us anything we want if two Christians get together and pray. The promise belongs to the hard work Jesus has described. The church is praying for wisdom, repentance, and healing to know what must be restored and no longer ignored.
SPEAKER_00Then Jesus gives the final promise we know so well, where two or three are gathered in my name, I am there among them. When community has to face a wound, Christ is not absent, he is here in the room. And that should comfort us greatly, but it should also sober us. If Christ is present here, then we can't treat each other carelessly. We can't gossip in his name, we can't shame in his name, we can't confuse peace with silence in his name.
SPEAKER_00Jesus does not give the church an easy way around conflict, he gives us a faithful way. Go toward the wound, not away from it. Speak the truth carefully. Pray and discern together, trusting that He is with us at all times. Friends, this is how I think true peace begins. Not as an idea we admire from a distance, but as a practice we learn to close we learn close to home, with honesty, accountability, prayer, and the promised presence of Christ.
SPEAKER_00I hate to tell you this. Reconciliation is never pain free, but it is worth it. Peace at home, peace in the world. And as they say in the South, it ain't for sissies.