Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
What we're looking for is where can AI help you be more human rather than less human.
SPEAKER_00So the first round of AI slop was all about being less human. It was fake ideas, fake concepts written for other AI algorithms. And it didn't reflect well on the creator and it didn't reflect well, it didn't help the reader.
SPEAKER_01Hello, and welcome to The Media Co-Pilot. It's a podcast that explores how AI is changing media, journalism, and content creation. I'm Pete Paschel, long-time tech journalist and founder of The Media Co-Pilot, and I'm excited to bring you fascinating conversations with fellow journalists, media executives, and the people building how the business of news will work in the future. This week, I'm thrilled to talk to Tony Stubblebine, CEO of Medium. Tony took the helm of Medium in 2022, and since then he's been guiding the platform through a pivotal
transition, moving away from a publication model and refocusing instead on independent writers
SPEAKER_01with the goal of creating a healthy, sustainable space for them and online publishing in general. Now Medium's taking that mission into the AI era. The company just joined a coalition of major publishers and tech companies, and that includes Reddit, Yahoo, Quora, the Daily Beast. And they're all supporting a new web standard called RSL, and that's short for Really Simple Licensing. The standard's designed to give creators and publishers a way to clearly define how AI systems can use their content and,
SPEAKER_01importantly, how they should be compensated when they do. Tony and I talk about RSL, of course, but we quickly go way beyond that. Tony's a very deep thinker about writing and what its role is on how we get information online, and most importantly, the incentives that shape how people build businesses around that. Be warned, we get a little philosophical here and there on what AI means for our media ecosystem, but it's all in service of figuring out what the rise of AI means for the open web and for writers everywhere.
SPEAKER_01So I hope you enjoy the conversation. And if you do, I'd be grateful if you'd leave a review for this podcast. Reviews, especially in Apple Podcasts and Spotify. They really do help the show, so please leave one if you can. Also, a couple quick notes. I'm offering a monthly class on AI for beginners. It's only 60 minutes. And like everything I do, it's focused on practical takeaways for media professionals. That's people in journalism, PR, or communications. And it's only $49.00. Each one's a live class, so it's always up to date, and I guarantee you'll walk away with something you can apply
to your day-to-day.
SPEAKER_01You can sign up at mediacopilot.ai. Also, this is your last chance to enroll in one of my two advanced AI courses that are starting in November. One's for journalists and the other's for PR and comms. These are loaded with lessons on things like deep research, how to automate workflows, and even building your own agent. You can sign up for those at, where else, mediacopilot.ai. Alrighty, now it is time for my conversation with Tony Stubblebine, CEO of Medium. Tony, welcome to the Media Co-Pilot.
SPEAKER_01Okay, Pete. Yeah, thanks for having me. I'm thrilled you're here. We need rescue. We need someone who's in the thick of all this AI business, particularly how it's intersecting with big platforms and in particular creator-driven platforms like your own. Um, I know you've already, uh, recently talked about RSL and all of that. I want to get into all of that. Uh, but right now I want to like just sort of zero in on Medium itself a bit because obviously it's gone through a bit of an evolution over the years.
SPEAKER_01Uh, it had publications for a while and, uh, you know, it's always... kind of seems to have evolved to memberships. And now obviously you've taken some stances on AI and licensing. Basically, when you look at what medium is today, like how would you describe it? And what is it trying to be as we're advancing to this next chapter where AI is a big factor?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, Medium is a writing platform for everyone. And I think that kind of got lost in a certain era of the internet where we all got obsessed with influencers and content creators and kind of quitting your day job to be an independent media creator. But what got me excited about the internet was the idea I could hear from anyone. And especially if that anyone happened to be an expert in some like big or tiny topic that I was caring about.
SPEAKER_00And so Medium, in the many iterations of Medium, it went through a period where we did have a lot of professional media people on Medium, sort of like yourself. And we've gone back to being a place for amateurs, because I think a lot of times A professional who writes is a very exciting person to hear from. Our business, essentially, the part of the business that makes media and profitable is
people writing about their job so that people who want that job can learn how to do their job better.
SPEAKER_00We have a huge traction in, I think what we're going to talk about right now actually is like a lot of people are coming to Medium to learn how to use AI to do their job better. And that'd be an example of professional development, which is like a kind of a core pillar inside the Medium community.
SPEAKER_01I'm curious, do you guys use the term UGC anymore at all? Is that kind of like how you describe it? Because that sounds like... Totally.
SPEAKER_00I use it because I grew up in that era. I was working for a book publisher in 2003, but when we realized everything we were writing about... was a year too late and had already been covered by some UGC blogger on the Internet, and those bloggers were getting into the crevices that we would never bother to write a book for. I think that that term is so technical and so boring, but I haven't found a better one. I might test one on you if you want.
SPEAKER_00I think of it actually, honestly, as if you're the fourth estate, medium represents the third estate. Typically, religion and politics and government, they're the powers and the media, press holds them to account. And the third estate was the commoners, and they never had a voice. And this is what the internet changed, was the idea that all of us could have a voice And that, you know, it turns out, you know, sometimes that means you're hearing from the same person you
would hear from at
SPEAKER_00your local bar. But a lot of times it means you're hearing from some expert that just otherwise was unfindable before. And so we try to like kind of narrow in on that as the place that, you know, where we're the most, you know, we do the most good and we're the most helpful.
SPEAKER_01So to someone in the industry, maybe looking on the sort of broad categories here, I might put medium kind of, at least in the same near ad in the same bucket as like Reddit, where they're both kind of like UGC platforms that have like, I almost, you can almost say mediums like the cleaned up version of Reddit. That's a little more much easier to navigate. But Reddit is an interesting story, obviously in the AI era in that it's somehow became,
SPEAKER_01well, newly valuable for its corpus of all this human generated content that the AI platforms became valuable and they've leveraged that I think probably more effectively than a lot of people. Do you sort of see a similar path with Medium? And has that sort of led you to maybe some of the things that you've been doing lately, in particular RSL? Or is it sort of a different thought process there?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. what, what is the, well, first of all, basically I'm saying, how do you see yourself vis-a-vis that platform specifically? And also, um, how is the, that sort of affected your, um, your strategy with regard to AI mediation?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Um, we're going to talk about the RSL standard. I love it. Like you led with media needs saving and we're going to talk about an internet standard, like famously popular and viral, um, uh, a way to grab eyeballs and attention. I guess maybe we should talk about the RSL standard too and what the hell that is. We could talk about the problem. Essentially, the AI companies launched in a way that I think was antisocial.
Our society is based on an exchange of value and they launched without any exchange of value. They didn't ask if they could train and then they didn't offer any money and they
SPEAKER_00didn't offer any credit a lot of times. And so kind of the internet runs on a particular type of credit. It's that I link to you and send traffic to you. Like, you know, we all let Google train on our content because Google sends us all this traffic, right? So that's the social contract the internet was based on. And the AI companies ignored that. And in a way, I feel sorry for them because if they don't come back with a working social contract,
SPEAKER_00the Internet is just going to retreat from public publishing altogether. Actually, if you think about it, public publishing is weird. Because you're putting yourself at so much risk right now from getting attacked by strangers and misinterpreted. It can be very toxic. But the thing that makes it worthwhile is that essentially Google had been offering so much free traffic to put yourself out there. But if you don't have that incentive,
we're all just going to retreat to private spaces again.
SPEAKER_00And you see this in so many trends right now. I think Substack is an example, probably. You've got your paid newsletter, and that's kind of your semi-private space. I think a lot of the Twitter exodus actually went to Discord, definitely went to private group messages. And... Over the summer, we had spun up a whole separate blogging platform just to experiment with ourselves based on the idea of private blogging.
And immediately you realize how many things people want to say that they would
SPEAKER_00never say to the entire world. And so I think that there's something that the AI companies have missed, which is if they don't provide the incentive for people to publish in public, their ability to train and learn will just flat out disappear. And so the content world, like people like Medium, Reddit, Quora, O'Reilly Media, which is actually a company I used to work for, like have gotten together to support a new internet standard.
SPEAKER_00This is like always sounds so boring to me, even though I guess I was early and excited about it, you know, in some wonky way. Not to me. You're among monks here. You're good. Yes. Okay, good. And it's called the Real Simple Licensing Standard. It came from some of the people that were behind the RSS standard way back in the day that made a lot of blogging possible. Podcasting.
SPEAKER_00And the idea is to have a standardized way to talk about this tension, which is around the social contract. If you as an AI company want access to the content we have, here is the arrangement that we will allow. Otherwise, we'll block it. I usually make the point, too, like medium is capable of poisoning the results, too. And like you've actually seen Cloudflare has like will poison the content that AI crawlers see just as a way to dissuade them from from being a bad actor.
SPEAKER_00Block blocking by default or. They have something beyond that that will just rewrite some of the content. Interesting. Essentially, you're in a... If they're bad actors, we have tools to deal with them in the same way we have tools to deal with spammers and whatnot. So I think there's going to be a way to force the AI companies to some sort of agreement. And that agreement is either going to be you've got to send
traffic or you've got to send money.
SPEAKER_00And if you don't, why would we support you in any way? And we're going to hide ourselves from your view. I think because there wasn't a standard, every media company went and did a custom deal. And that's what you're talking about with Reddit. Reddit was very early and successful about doing a custom deal. Medium, I think we were just waiting for the standard and thought...
SPEAKER_00But it was better for the internet if we all operate together.
SPEAKER_01As opposed to all these licensing deals, which sort of has become not quite the standard, but sort of was the way things have been done for the past couple of years anyway.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Exactly, right. And one of the problems is that if you do ad hoc deals, you don't have the negotiating leverage. This is actually I think what you mentioned about Cloudflare and their blocking service is the smart thing about that service is they realized... In order to start the negotiation, you had to be able to threaten to turn off the access to almost all content. Because if one media company blocks their content,
SPEAKER_00there's still plenty for the AI companies to train on. So you needed leverage first. It just... it doesn't make sense to me to have vendor lock-in. I don't want to negotiate. I don't want to have to be a customer of one company in particular in order to negotiate with all AI companies everywhere. So I really appreciate what Cloudflare did. We're very, very happy customers of Cloudflare,
but this is the thing that just deserves an internet standard rather than...
SPEAKER_00Yeah. To be offered by one.
SPEAKER_01So if I'm a either like a medium writer of basically one of your users, like how does this manifest to me? Is it just a setting that I go in or I mean... What is sort of the mechanism here and then sort of can get into what I can expect next? Our intention is to start the negotiations and then pass all of the money back
SPEAKER_00directly to the authors. I think we're the only social media platform that thinks that way, that we're just negotiating as a service. But the thing is that... the first step of the negotiation is to threaten to take all the content away and so we've been more aggressive about blocking and we're um and i think starting those negotiations but there's nothing really for the writers to do until ai companies start um uh start standardizing on what they what
they're going to pay
SPEAKER_00and i expect i would say i'm 90% certain within the next year, there'll be some AI payments flowing through Medium to the writers on Medium. And so how does this sort of fit into what I guess you might call sort of the
SPEAKER_01payments ecosystem for AI, which is to say like there's startups like Tolbit who are doing sort of these monetized endpoints. Maybe this is more for people on the open web as opposed to people on... medium. But there's people who do essentially paper crawl or paper inference. And we've been talking about Cloudflare, who's doing it at the CDN level. And we're already throwing all these acronyms around and these different things,
to be honest with you, like I'm in this and I can't keep it straight.
SPEAKER_01Like what if I were a little guy who has very little resource, whether I'm on medium or not to even think about this, like, you know, I just want to turn something on and get paid whatever the fair rate is, you know, like you're scraped at some rate, which we can talk about the actual rates at some point and who's actually making money if anybody on this. But before that, let's just start with like, Where does this fit in and are all these systems compatible or
will something win out?
SPEAKER_00I think there's going to be two eras is how I would answer you here. You're talking about wanting kind of the standardized era where everything is simple. There is like a known rate for what people get paid. We're not in that era. We're in what I would call the get your popcorn era. Because it's a bunch of big companies fighting and and something is going to come out of that. Right. So like there there is no standard rate. There is no standard. Like what we have right now is the first part of the fight
where we have a standard
SPEAKER_00way to say no. And once we have a standard way to say no, we can open the conversation about here's how we're going to say yes. And so like this get your popcorn era includes lawsuits. It includes poisoned AI. Yeah, poisoned AI. Do you know why? I haven't explored that much.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Um, the M dash is popular in AI generated writing in a large part because the M dash is very popular on medium and like we were one of the training sets. And so it was like, it was the first time we realized we're big enough to change the output of an LLM. Um, let me just double click on that really quickly.
SPEAKER_01Just a quick question. So given that and assuming you're correct, um, To my knowledge, Medium has not entered into litigation on any of these LLMs. Is that correct? So why not, given that everything you've just been saying about compensation and how that should just broadly be handled? You're going into essentially the explanation I give people at work whenever we're
SPEAKER_00talking about legalities, right? Essentially, anytime you're in a legal situation, you also have other levers. One is social and one is power. And I look at this situation and I say, I don't think the legal standing is actually that good, right? It's not... turning out necessarily to be a copyright violation. You might have some standing around terms of service and crawling. But that prior era where the original training,
I'm not sure that it was illegal.
SPEAKER_00And that's a long battle for us. And also, importantly, where is our standing? Because we don't own the copyright for anything on Medium. All of our users own that copyright. So you're talking about we're a software company. Do we get in the business of facilitating lawsuits for our customers? It's very far away from what our actual business is. It's an important distinction. I get it. But what we do have is power and influence.
SPEAKER_00And so that's what we try to wield. And the power is essentially... You know, what do we block? What do we display? And the influences, you know, how can we help stand up Internet standards? Because I think the small AI companies will ignore the standards, but the big ones will find a way, will find that they really have to have to participate. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Cool. Let's talk a little bit about standards and I guess, well, just sort of keeping with like what has to happen. So you mentioned sort of in about a year you would expect something to coalesce either around a standard or – you know, just a new way of doing things from a business perspective. Do you think the courts are going to be a part of that in terms of steering things that way?
SPEAKER_01Or do you think that can happen absent some, some indicator either from, uh, the courts or the regulatory bodies or whatever to, to, I guess, straighten things out. And I guess I would wonder about vis-a-vis that, like as more sites, uh, like yours and others do blocking as players like cloudflare enter into this does like and you mentioned the poisoning which is a great little thing to go does then the quality of all this stuff in terms of what you get out of
ai start to go down if they don't and is that is that going to be the thing that sort of forces them to
SPEAKER_00the table uh yeah i think the quality i think The quality will go down and also they'll start to have competitive fears, right? Like imagine that if every content and media company got mad at open AI at the same time and only did exclusive deals with Google, then what, you know, right, what's going to happen there, right? You'd almost find like the AI news internet sort of shifts
overnight in that kind of situation.
SPEAKER_01You know, then just like, gotta go to OpenAI or gotta go to Google.
SPEAKER_00And in the technology, there's really two pieces. There's the LLM, which is the language model. And those, I think, are sufficiently trained. They're very, very good. But in order to give you results, they want current information. And that current information is the rag, you know. So, like, Gemini summaries are this great LLM that's doing a Google search on your behalf and then summarizing the content for you. So if the rag part goes away, that's essentially what we're talking about, then those AI search results,
SPEAKER_00those AI tools, are going to be much, much less effective. And, I mean, I'm just like, this is... What I'm telling you is what I tell Google when I talk to our reps there. I'm like, look, we are available to Google because there's an exchange of value. If that goes away, we're going to redesign everything about Medium to be private. And in fact, we already have things in the works for that. And that's just the way the whole, like, how we're responding is how the whole Internet will respond.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I don't I mean, it will be painful, I guess. And in a way, I'm sad not to have the information superhighway that I was promised when I was a kid. But also there's something more human about, you know, publishing for five people, you know, and getting a response directly from them versus publishing to a number, you know, like. How like how many page views is enough to satisfy your ego? Right. And it's just it's very generic and kind of dehumanizing
sometimes to be on the
SPEAKER_00Internet and to like be performing for these. artificial systems. And there is also, I think there's something about the retreat from the public internet that I'm actually really excited about.
SPEAKER_01Sweet. So I'm really curious, right off the bat, what are the things you have planned for that potential post-Google era, if that value exchange no longer makes any sense? But it also speaks to sort of the overall point of So enforceability, you know, like if you have these things, whether it's standard, a payment system or whatever, and the players you're dealing with aren't going to play ball, how do you deal with that?
So like on the big level, it sounds like sort of there's a nuclear option.
SPEAKER_01Love to learn more about that. But also like absolutely below that level, you know, there's the sort of level one robots.txt kind of stuff you can do and then sort of what's in between.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and the RSL standard basically operates at the robots.txt level, and there's some extensions that operate at the page level. And when we get into it, we'll probably implement it at the page level so that individual writers can opt out or opt in as necessary. I think the thing that I'm wondering about, kind of an open question to me is, How does the writing on the internet, how does the content change if the value proposition shifts
from heavy on free
SPEAKER_00distribution but light on payment to... light on free distribution and not heavy on payment. I mean, I don't think these AI companies are going to pay a lot, but they'll pay something, right? That's going to be a shift. And who does that shift work for and who does the shift kind of leave out? And I think that maybe this is good for independent content creators like you, but um maybe not like i think you you rely on the free internet at
some level to get your paying customers right and um so i just like that shake out people are like the content we see online is so sensitive to the incentives but you can't really predict what will happen just by interviewing people you just know if you change the incentives we're going to see something different and that like we're kind of
SPEAKER_00we're waiting for that to shake out
SPEAKER_01Yeah, my general sense, and you tell me if you disagree, I haven't seen a study on this, but my general sense is that paywalls are going up more. And that's like a continuing trend. It's not like AI is the entire source of this. But I do feel like as a default defensive move, it's your one go-to option whether or not that actually blocks the bots or not um you know you at least are getting something because to your point the value exchange isn't there so why not i gotta sort of make your money
elsewhere yeah that's the professional side i i'm interested in the amateur side and i had this conversation on monday that kind of blew my mind and i think it's not surprising
SPEAKER_00like given the person he was like, this person was like employee number one at Napster has been in tech for a long time, is an engineer originally turned CEO. So it's like, I'm not surprised he has like kind of like weird to me forward looking views, but he was saying that, uh, AI has for him kicked off a writing Renaissance. It's just like now that, um, And he's not writing for other people. He's writing for the AI itself.
SPEAKER_00And essentially, he realized that he has so many AI tools that need really thorough and deep prompting. And so he's trying to capture all of his life wisdom about entrepreneurship and running a business and running his business in particular so that he can then feed it to an AI. Yeah. And I thought that was really interesting. And then I had been talking to another co-founder of another startup who was starting to put AI bots into roles around the company.
SPEAKER_00So he wasn't replacing people's jobs. He was just creating new AI-specific jobs that you'd like, you know, you might talk to Steve in accounting, but you also might talk to the head of product bot that had, like, all of their, like, kind of, like, It represented some knowledge inside of the company. And so when I was talking to my friend about the CEO, he was saying, it's not just that he's writing for the AI. What he wants to publish to the humans is no longer writing.
SPEAKER_00It's a chatbot.
SPEAKER_01And...
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you're actually touching on something that I'm thinking about right now with
SPEAKER_01vis-a-vis journalism. So like the sort of broader concept of like collaboration with AI and that conversation being content or at least using the version of content, I think is very interesting. I think vis-a-vis sort of the journalistic stuff. that I gravitate towards, um, there's a, I think a desire now, or maybe not necessarily a desire, but a trend toward more transparency overall. And this speaks to sort of the trust issue in news media today.
SPEAKER_01Um, in that if you think about it, you as a person, as a reporter or writer are sort of taking a corpus of information and putting it through your lens, um, And then, well, what if you just sort of put the curated corpus of information and then that goes to the AI and then whoever is interested in that can put their own lens on it? Is that what journalism is going to become? Is that what writing is going to become on some level? I know we're getting kind of like high-minded philosophical here, but this stuff does – I'm actually really fascinated by and would be curious to see
if you see that as kind of where the puck is going and then how would you –
SPEAKER_01adapt a platform like Medium to sort of get ahead of that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. You know, I think that the chat is a really good format for this concept of why would you ever read anything that isn't personalized in real time for you, the reader? Like, that's essentially what I think you're getting at. So, I mean, let's take a simple use case. I'm reading something about the news. There's background information in that article as if I've never heard this topic before. But if I've heard the topic, just cross all that out. Like, I already know this information.
SPEAKER_00Or if I'm coming to it for the first time, OK, make it longer, right? That kind of like you could just expand or contract it based on what the reader already knows. I think that there's a potential to do annotations, right? That as you're reading, here's extra information that's specific to you. You could do actual rewriting on the fly. All of these things end up being kind of contextually...
like okay sometimes and kind of awful and in others because a lot of times what you're like what you're really looking for is not the facts but the human content
SPEAKER_00right like tell me a story about a person and if you start morphing that too much then you lose the humanity of it um and like i hate to break it to all the technologists out there like we're not robots like there's a reason that we communicate through story it's because that's how our brain works we need that human context we need the emotion in order to make sense of whatever facts happen to be hiding in in the story so yeah we don't want a bloomberg terminal as
SPEAKER_00uh you know our our version of news And this is a good sort of spot to sort of ask you a little more directly about AI-generated content itself and its role today and what medium's stance is on that.
SPEAKER_01Obviously, there's on the low end the AI slop, but then there's other ways that various companies and those individuals are leveraging it. using AI in their writing process, but with as sort of a co pilot or in a human assistant way. What what is your thoughts on that? What's medium stance like was in terms of AI and AI content generation?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm curious to how you're using it in your own because it's like it's such a tension for what we had kind of perceived as the virtue of writing, right? Or the virtues of journalism, right? Like there's like these opportunities to do things that would like maybe make your like your journalism professor like like blow their you know like blow up at you right and and so what we're looking for is where can AI
SPEAKER_00help you be more human rather than less human. So the first round of AI slop was all about being less human. It was fake ideas, fake concepts written for other AI algorithms, and it didn't reflect well on the creator, and it didn't reflect well on, you know, it didn't help the reader. So I think we kind of always come back to first principles that I don't think there's ever going to be a world where people aren't trying to
be smarter and
SPEAKER_00aren't going to feel like their life will get better if they're smarter. And so you have to judge every AI tool through that lens. Is this helping elevate the human customer or not. And so the first wave, no one was a bigger AI hater than me. I was early at calling bullshit on all of this stuff. And it was not that AI could not be good. It's just what we were seeing was really, really kind of upsetting in terms of unfairness,
SPEAKER_00in terms of Like, it's not just that the AI companies stole the content, it's that then they sent a wave of spammers back at us, right? So it was, like, less than zero value. The current era, like, Medium, at our Medium Day event a couple weeks ago, announced that we had broken ground on a new writing app. And this app very much has AI in the middle of it. And it's because we're seeing... I guess I would say like I'm mostly focused on the flow,
SPEAKER_00like the cognitive flow state of writing. And if you have like any propensity to ADD or procrastination, you realize anytime you leave your editor. is a chance for you to lose an hour to complete nonsense, right? And so these AI tools, the way we've been building it is with the idea that help a writer stay in their train of thought. And when they get stuck, there's kind of an assistant to bounce off of.
So the AI is not replacing the writer, but it's there to be an agent to do your bidding.
SPEAKER_00And so... My default, the first good use case that blew my mind, because I knew that I would have wasted an hour doing this trivial task just because I would have procrastinated. I was writing a blog post for the Medium blog, and I needed to reference something. from my predecessor, his name is Ev, the founder of Medium, Ev Williams. And so I highlighted a paragraph that I'd written,
SPEAKER_00and I said to the AI, Ev wrote about this topic, I didn't even say exactly what the concept was, on the Medium blog in 2017, find the link and add it. And it just did that so seamlessly. So I don't feel like my humanity has been reduced because an AI robot went and looked up a link for me. I really appreciated that. I also know that you would have seen the worst of me if I had to go Google that link myself.
SPEAKER_00Because I would have created another tab and I was like, well, am I ready to go to Google or should I check like Hacker News or should I check Medium or like should I like go like I would just get distracted on my way to do this very simple task, which is look up a link. And that kind of that kind of helped me. like really kind of amazingly smart help built directly into the editor. What we found, you know, we're like, we're in friends and family kind of beta right now.
SPEAKER_00Like, let's say there's like 20 people using what we've written so far. what we've built so far. But what we're finding is that just like, we love writing. And if you make it easier, if you lower the bar, if you get rid of the hurdles, we write a lot more. And some of what we write is meant to be published to the entire internet. Some of it is just for our own notes. And a lot of it is kind of in this in between the sort of like private internet. And There's a phrase I was just talking to someone about this morning,
SPEAKER_00a sort of like performative note-taking. And Scott, the person I was talking to, he lives in New York City with me, and I think of him as the ultimate New Yorker. And so I was asking about his notes about what to do in New York. Like, does he have good notes? And he does. He has amazing notes. And I was just like, I want to be your audience for that, right? Like, I want to be able to talk to Scott's New York City chatbot and say,
SPEAKER_00hey, my parents are coming into town. These are the things they like. What recommendations do you have? And I think that's maybe a concrete version of this middle ground of publishing retreating from fully public back into something more private, but also maybe something more AI native, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I love a lot of what you've described, particularly the editor. I think you'd see a lot of demand for something that is a keep-you-focused style editor and has features all around. There's obviously a very fine line between... clippy style interruptions, which I think are very unpopular, but things to sort of just keep you on track. I think that's going to resonate a lot. Certainly resonates with me. If you need user 21 on your alpha, I'm here for you.
As AI's role in the writing process continues, do you think you'll ever... add something like an AI assisted badge or something, or that writers can do.
SPEAKER_01Cause a lot of other platforms, like, you know, just to name one YouTube and there's different pressures there a hundred percent with like deep fakes and stuff. But you know, some platforms are, are basically putting the, letting folks put the label on, but also forcing them to sort of say yes or no on whether there is AI content. Do you think that's a thing for a writing platform at some point?
SPEAKER_00I mean, yes, but we just flipped it. You know, it's like, what is the, What is our confidence in the human provenance of something? So we don't always know if it was AI generated and we don't trust people to label it correctly. But we do often know if it was definitely human created, right? Like we know, was it typed out? Was it edited, right? And so... um this writing tool will have the full history of the creation and that's a signal that we can put into our recommendation algorithms and we
absolutely are already
SPEAKER_00doing that nice
SPEAKER_01So I wanted to just dive a little into the weeds a bit, maybe. Maybe it's not the weeds, I don't know. But basically, I was really interested in a stat that you gave out because it's really hard to pin down certain numbers on a lot of this stuff. So you had mentioned, I know in the post you wrote about RSL, that chat GPT's referrals were really minuscule compared to Google. It was something like 1.3%. Yeah, right around that neighborhood. But the conversions of that traffic were 4x better.
Now do the math, you're still not making up for whatever, whatever traffic you were getting.
SPEAKER_01But that said, you sort of alluded to things you might be able to do in terms of product in terms of what you can do on whatever power that you have, like you said, as a as a platform to amplify maybe those high intent users. And I'm just curious if you could give a little more texture there in terms of helping your users get like member growth. And how do you do that without maybe over optimizing for AI? Is there a danger of that even? I don't know.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think we tend to like content that does well in search anyways. I think there's a lot of overlap between Google search success and medium success because it's a person who knows what they're talking about kind of dumping their knowledge out for the Internet. And that's always been rewarded by Google and I think often ends up being really valuable to the medium community. So can we help incentivize people to write that way?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Medium's content is maybe 80% free, and 20% is this paid partner program, which is an open subscription bundle that any writer can write for and participate in the earnings for. And so... I think November, like we've been making tiny changes to it recently to make the incentives for external traffic a bit sharper. And we're going to do a change November 1st to pay more for
stuff that does well in
SPEAKER_00Google search. And directionally, we're really more intending for Gemini, success in Gemini than success across all of all of google so that's just a way that we can help kind of make the incentives work um yeah okay cool um assuming it all goes well let's start projecting out a little bit to what things are going to look like maybe i'm uh
you mentioned time
SPEAKER_01frames of like a year in terms of what The AI companies do, what is sort of the best case scenario, worst case scenario in terms of how this ends up playing out, at least for your customers,
SPEAKER_00the people on your network? Here are the things that I'm optimistic for. Obviously, we're champions of writing. Regardless of media formats, we think writing is the best one because it's the thing that promotes the deepest thinking. And so we actually think we're in the middle of a writing renaissance right now because so much of the AI interfaces are written. and they encourage you to be more articulate, more verbose a lot of times,
to really write a lot more because suddenly you're getting a lot more value out of
SPEAKER_00what you have written. I think we're also very pro-human, and I'm excited. That's the other thing I'm really optimistic about is it's a little bit tough on the business to lose all this free traffic, but it's really good for human connection to stop being so focused on writing for anonymous algorithms and instead to be writing... for really specific audiences. So Medium really upgraded our email subscriber list.
SPEAKER_00It's a great place to build an audience. That's a consistent audience to write for. Medium's always been built around these community publications. So it's like, if you're a paleontologist, there's a paleontology publication that you can go write for. And it's much more concrete. Here's this group of people that I'm writing for. And that retreat away from the global town square has actually... it increases the humanity of who you're writing for. You can actually picture the audience. And so the writing app,
SPEAKER_00the note-taking app that we're working on, it kind of fills in even smaller groups. It's like I'm writing for myself, I'm writing for four people, I'm writing for private groups. I think all of those things get me excited because they feel more like human connection to me. And that's, I think, where these trends end up. So I guess defining success then is that that sort of narrowing
ends up being more
SPEAKER_01successful in some way. It doesn't necessarily even have to be monetarily, but hopefully monetarily. So that's in the interest of these people to keep doing that. And if the dystopian sort of view of that is like that isn't as... successful as what came before this different incentive system produces something that makes you less successful uh and that's i think maybe the core tension of why you know everyone is sort of like great we're all going to get smaller we want to go smaller we love the human connection can you can you be a
six quote unquote success what is what does that look like in a a good future versus a bad future
SPEAKER_00Right. It's like it's both. Right. And this is why I called it like get your popcorn. Like the public Internet that we know is going to die in a really interesting and entertaining way. Right. And OK, like let's enjoy it if we can. But it doesn't mean that nothing good will replace. Right.
SPEAKER_01Nice. Okay. We'll leave it there without necessarily getting too specific on what replaces it. But I think we've given a pretty good sort of a lot of Tinker Toys that people can put together here to figure that out. If anyone remembers Tinker Toys. Tony, this has been a great conversation. Thanks so much for dropping by the Media Co-Pilot and sharing your thoughts. Love to regroup with you at some point and see how it all turned out. All right. Thank you, Pete. Thanks for listening to my conversation with Tony Stubblebine of Medium. If you enjoyed this episode,
I'd appreciate it if you'd take just a minute to leave a rating or review of the
SPEAKER_01Media Co-Pilot in your podcast app. Also, don't forget to subscribe to the Media Co-Pilot newsletter and check out mediacopilot.ai for our classes on AI for journalists, PR professionals, and communicators. Be seeing you in the future.
For years, Yahoo News has occupied a peculiar position in the media ecosystem. It is not a social network, not a traditional publisher, and not a search engine in the modern sense. Yet millions of people still use it as...
This special episode of The Media Copilot is a look back at the conversations that defined the past year… the questions, tensions, and turning points shaping how media, journalism, and technology intersect right now....
AI has made verification a newsroom survival skill. In this episode of The Media Copilot, Pete Pachal talks with James Law, Editor-in-Chief of Storyful, the newsroom partner known for verifying the videos and social...
AI in journalism can feel abstract until you talk to the people actually shipping products inside newsrooms. In this episode of The Media Copilot podcast, host Pete Pachal talks with Darla Cameron, Chief Product Officer...
AI is rewriting the rules of digital media and few people have had a closer view of the shift than Adam Singolda. In this episode of The Media Copilot, host Pete Pachal has a candid conversation with the Taboola founder...