What If Your Identity Was Settled Before You Started
25 minAudio
If you’ve ever stepped onto a platform, opened your laptop, or walked into a meeting with the sick feeling that you have to prove you belong, this one names the wound clearly: performing for approval. We talk straight to pastors and kingdom leaders who are doing the work but feel like the joy leaked out somewhere along the way, and we trace that ache back to a single lie that keeps getting repeated over your calling. We open Mark 1 at the baptism of Jesus and slow down long enough to hear what the Father actually says: identity, affection, and approval before Jesus preaches a sermon, heals a person, or builds a following. That sets the order God always works in: approval before assignment. Then we follow Jesus into the wilderness to watch the enemy’s tactic in real time, keeping the title but dropping the love and adding one word to the front: if. If becomes a trapdoor that turns sonship into something you must prove, and many of us have been answering that question for years. From there, we bring it all the way into your body. Stress research on cortisol shows why being evaluated without controlling the outcome hits us so hard, and why leaders can stay braced all week long. The goal isn’t self-hype or denial; it’s spiritual formation that retrains your reflexes with truth. We give you a simple, repeatable sentence for the minute before you step up: “I don’t work for the Father’s approval. I work from it.” If this helps you breathe again, subscribe, share it with a weary leader, and leave a review so more pastors can find it when they’re running on empty. What’s the loudest “if” you’ve been carrying lately? Support the show Renew card: https://markcasto.co/renew Shepherd’s Tent and the Weekly Leader Call: https://connect.theshepherdstent.com/leaders-call The Lion Was Always the Lamb tee: https://markcasto.myshopify.com/products/the-lion-was-always-the-lamb-tee UNVEILED ebook (free): https://markcasto.co/unveiled Become a Partner: https://markcasto.co/donate/ Care line (a phone number, not a link): Focus on the Family 1-855-771-HELP (4357); in crisis, call or text 988.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00All right, welcome everybody to the Mark Casto program. I'm your host, Mark Casto, and this show is for kingdom leaders, for pastors who are running on empty, leaders who are doing the work, but you've lost the joy. This season, what we're doing on this podcast is we're naming the wound because you cannot heal what you refuse to see. Episode one, we saw the orphan in the father's house. Episode two, we saw the system that raised him. Today, we're going to watch what he does all day long.
SPEAKER_00You ready? He performs. And then by the end of this episode, you're going to know the order that God always works in. You're going to know the one word that the enemy keeps adding to your identity, and you're going to walk away with one sentence to say out loud right before the moments that you would usually perform. So I want you to go ahead and open up your Bibles to the book of Mark, chapter number one. So in the Gospel of Mark, chapter one, verse nine, it says, At that time Jesus came from Nazareth in Galilee, and he was baptized by John in the Jordan.
SPEAKER_00Now stop and look at where we are in the story. Jesus hasn't preached a sermon yet. He hasn't healed anybody. He hasn't called a single disciple. There's no water turning into wine. There's no feeding of the 5,000. Luke tells us that he was about 30 years old. And most of those 30 years were spent in a small town in a carpenter's shop where nobody was writing anything down. And as he comes up out of the water, the heavens open, and the Spirit of God comes down on him like a dove.
SPEAKER_00And then the Father speaks in verse 11. This is what the Father said. And a voice came down from heaven. With you I am well pleased. Now I want you to notice three things here, okay? You are my son, friend, that's identity. Whom I love, that is affection, with whom I am well pleased, friend, that's approval.
SPEAKER_00And guess what? The father said all three of these things before Jesus ever did one public thing. I want you to hear me, pastor. I want you to hear me, leader. Please don't rush past this. The father didn't wait to see how the ministry went. He didn't wait for the crowds or the results or the reviews. He said, I am well pleased over 30 quiet years and an empty resume. So, friend, here's the order God always works in.
SPEAKER_00Approval comes before the assignment, never the other way around. See, Babylon's order is assignment first, and then maybe if you produce enough, approval. But the father's order is approval first, and out of that approval, the assignment. See, most of us were trained in the wrong order. We heard the call, we took the assignment, and somewhere in the back of our minds, we decided the pro the approval would come later. So when the church grew, when the book came out, when the right person finally said, I'm proud of you.
SPEAKER_00Guys, I can remember being a young preacher and literally didn't didn't even know how to really walk with the Lord, but I had a gift to communicate and preach. And in that time I felt like such a failure. But everybody would walk up to me and say, Mark, you're such a man of God. You're so anointed by the Spirit. And man, God breaks out when you speak and you just move powerfully in the anointing, but on the inside, feeling like a fraud because I know I wasn't where I needed to be with God. I know I wasn't burning like I needed to be. And in that moment, I'm being affirmed by people, even on the inside, feeling like I had not earned that.
SPEAKER_00And guys, that's just a part of a culture that exalts gifts above identity. And guys, if you ever confuse the two, you'll never get off the hamster wheel. So here's the question that drives this whole episode. If the father settled the verdict before the ministry started, why are so many of us still working like the jury is out? Friend, the answer is in the very next scene.
SPEAKER_00See, right after the baptism, the Spirit leads Jesus into the wilderness. Forty days Jesus went without food. He was fasting. And the very first thing that the tempter says to him is this Matthew chapter 4. You can find this in Matthew chapter 4, verse 3. It says that the tempter came to him and said, If you are the Son of God, then tell these stones to become bread. Now I want you to pause for a second. What should we be emphasizing here?
SPEAKER_00It's one word. If see, the ink is barely dry on the Father's words, and the enemy goes straight for those words. He doesn't attack Jesus' power, he attacks his identity. And I want you to watch what he does with it. Okay? The father said, You are my son, whom I love, with you I am well pleased. And then the enemy repeats the title, son of God, but he drops whom I love. He drops the well pleased.
SPEAKER_00And then he adds one word to the front, if. See, friend, that's always the strategy. Keep the title, lose the love, add an if. And now sonship isn't something that you receive. Now it's something that you have to prove. So I want you to look at all three of the temptations that Jesus experienced in the wilderness. Turn the stones into bread. Prove it by providing for yourself. Throw yourself down from the highest point of the temple.
SPEAKER_00Prove it with something spectacular. That way everybody can see. Or bow down and take the kingdom of the world. Prove it by getting results faster without the cross. Every one of them is an invitation to perform for an identity that he already had. And Jesus refused every one. He refused every one of them. And verse 4 says this Jesus answered, It is written, Man shall not live by bread alone, but by every word that proceedeth out of the mouth of God.
SPEAKER_00Do you see what he's living on? Every word that comes from the mouth of his father. And the last word that came from the mouth of the father was, You are my son, whom I love, and with you I am well pleased. See, friend, Jesus doesn't need to prove what the Father already said, He lives on it. Now, let's bring it home to me and you. The enemy still uses that one word on every kingdom leader. See, if you're really called, why isn't this ministry growing?
SPEAKER_00If you're really anointed, why did that sermon fall flat? If God is really pleased with you, why did those people leave your church? And every time you hear that, if you go back to the stones and try to make bread one more time. See, Paul knew this pull. Galatians 1 10, Paul says, Am I now trying to win the approval of human beings or of God? Or am I trying to please people? For if I was still trying to please people, I would not be a servant of Christ.
SPEAKER_00See, here's what I've noticed in a lot of leaders, and I've noticed it even in myself. We'd never say that we're trying to earn God's approval. We know the theology, but we work for the crowd's approval. And then we quietly treat the crowd's response as if that's God's verdict. Good Sunday, God is pleased. Bad Sunday, he's disappointed. That's the if that we all deal with in the room today. See, I know what it's like for me to perform at a conference.
SPEAKER_00I know what it's like to stand on the stage before when I had a gift and didn't really know who I was. I know what it's like to stand up there and say, man, I've got to have something fresh. I've got to have something strong. I've got to preach a better sermon this time than the last conference. I know what that feels like. Friend, and it's a feeling that is a, it's it's more than an irritation. It's an ache of the soul that's crying out for identity. But in when all you have is a gift, guys, you always will depend on the approval of man.
SPEAKER_00So if that's you, I want you to hear me. What I'm saying to you is not meant for condemnation, it's meant for recognition. Friend, you're not a fraud. You've just been answering a question that the Father never asked. Paul wrote a whole letter to a church that started right and then slipped right into performing. Galatians chapter 3, verse 3, Paul says, Are you so foolish that after beginning by means of the spirit, are you now trying to finish by the means of the flesh? Friend, that's a pastor who loves his people and asking them really hard questions.
SPEAKER_00You started by grace, you were brought into the family as a gift, and now you're going to try to earn this thing by staying in a place of efforting. Friend, that's the performing leader. And most of us didn't start out performing. We started out amazed from our encounter with Jesus. We were saved by grace, we were called by grace, we were filled by grace, we were given the Holy Spirit, and then somewhere along the way, grace became the way in and performance became the way to stay in.
SPEAKER_00See, we would never preach that, but we live it every single week. So here's what changes everything. If you go over to the book of Romans, Romans chapter 8, verse 15, it says that the spirit you received does not make you slaves, so that you live in fear again. Rather, the spirit you received brought about your adoption to sonship, and by him we cry through the Holy Spirit, Abba Father. See, friend, performance is just fear with a work ethic.
SPEAKER_00Fear that if I stop, I'm gonna lose my place. Fear that if they see the real me, then the approval will be taken back. See, friend, that's the spirit of a slave. And Paul says, that is not the spirit that you received. You received the spirit of adoption. So the same voice that spoke over the Jordan now lives inside you, and he keeps saying the same word: Abba, Abba, Father, not boss, not judge, father.
SPEAKER_00Your spirit, his spirit cries out with your spirit, Abba, Father. And here's the part that should set every single person watching this free. In Christ, the Father's words over Jesus at the Jordan have been spoken over you also. Not because you earn them, but because you're in the Son. This is the finished work. You are my son, you are my daughter whom I love, whom with you I am well pleased. And friend, that's not a reward for a good Sunday or a good ministry.
SPEAKER_00That's the verdict on everyone the Father has adopted. See, friend, this is the whole promise of this season. Jesus said in John 14, verse 18, he said, I will not leave you as orphans, I will come to you. See, orphans perform because nobody's told them who they are. Sons rest because the Father already did. And I want to be careful here because some of you are thinking, so should I just stop working hard? Well, the answer to that is simply no. Jesus, I believe, worked harder than everybody.
SPEAKER_00He went from the wilderness straight into three years of preaching, healing, and pouring himself out for his generation. The difference is where he worked from. He didn't work for the Father's approval, he worked from the Father's approval. See, friend, that's the difference between a performer and a son. Both of them might preach on a Sunday. Both might lead the meeting and may build a quote unquote successful ministry.
SPEAKER_00But the performer walks off the platform asking, How did I do? And the son walks off already knowing what his father thinks about him and feels about him. I remember when this teaching of beloved identity first came into my life. And I remember just feeling such an affection from the father and just knowing that he no longer loved me just uh because of what I did. He loved me for me. Guys, that changed the way that ministry was for me forever.
SPEAKER_00Because I would many times leave the platform going, man, I wonder if they'll have me back. Boy, I hope I did good enough so that I can get their approval and maybe they'll invite me back next year. I can remember just being so torn by the opinions of man. But when beloved identity crashed into my life, guys, I'm telling you, I was able to stand up in front of people, say and do whatever God told me to say and do, and do it however that authentically felt to come out. And I was able to walk away from that platform going, it doesn't matter what people think.
SPEAKER_00I was obedient to the Father. It doesn't matter what people's opinions are, I was obedient to him. And as long as I please the one who has already been shown his pleasure for me, then we win. But see, friend, knowing this and living this are two different things. See, you've been answering that quote unquote if for years, and your body's learned to answer it before your theology can. So in a few minutes, what I'm gonna do is I'm gonna show you what happens inside you every time you step up to perform and how to answer it.
SPEAKER_00So, first, I want to tell you about a few things around the family table. All right, before we talk about what's happening inside you, let me tell you what's happening around the family table. See, guys, this episode was never meant to be something that you just watch alone. Guys, I want to invite you to join our community. If this one is landing, this session right here, don't carry it by yourself. We have a community, the Shepherd's Tent. It's a free online community for kingdom leaders and pastors. And every single Tuesday at 10 a.m. Eastern Standard Time, Craig C.
SPEAKER_00Wright and I, he's my friend from Ireland, we lead a weekly leader call that lives right inside the community. It's not a stage, nobody's performing. You just show up and we spend some time together. So if you want to be a part of that, the link is in the description below. Also, I want to invite you to Covington, Georgia on Friday, December the 11th. We're having a night of worship right here in Covington at Living Way World Church. So if you're anywhere near us, jump on a plane, jump on a train, get in your car, make plans to join us. Every gathering that we're doing is listed at markcasto.co backslash events.
SPEAKER_00Now, I want you to remember Romans 8.15 that the spirit doesn't make you a slave so that you live in fear again. Well, guys, we made a shirt about that. And it's literally called I Am Tired of the Fear. It's from 1 John 4.18. Perfect love casts out all fear, and every order that comes in helps keep this podcast going forward for free. And guys, if you haven't grabbed it yet, my brand new book, The Unveiled ebook, is still free at markcasto.co unveiled. Both links are in the description.
SPEAKER_00And guys, the last thing I'll say this show, the leader call, the books, the renewed cards, all of it's free because of a small group of people we call the Shepherd's Tent Partners. They give monthly to the Shepherd's Tent. That's our nonprofit, so that this that literally the tent stays open for every weary leader. And in an episode about performing, I want to say this plainly: nobody earns their place here, and partners aren't proven anything. They're family who decided to help us set the table. So once a month, Desi and I sit down with our partners for Partners Night.
SPEAKER_00We pray for them, talk with them, take questions. So, friend, if that's you, you feel called to support us, go to markcasto.co backslash donate. There's no pressure at all, but it does help our ministry go forward. All right, let's talk about what's happening inside of you right before you perform. In the in episode one, we talked about naming what you feel. And then in episode two, we talked about how repetition wires your brain.
SPEAKER_00So today I want to talk to you about what your body does when it feels evaluated. Okay, so back in 2004, two researchers gathered up 208 laboratory studies on stress, all measuring cortisol, that the which is the body's main stress hormone. Okay. And they wanted to know which kinds of pressure hit the body hardest. Was it noise? Was it hard math? Was it time pressure? And what they found was this the situations that pushed cortisol highest and took the longest to come down from were the ones where two things were true at the same time.
SPEAKER_00People were being judged by others and they couldn't control the outcome. I want you to think about that. Now read that list again and tell me it doesn't describe a Sunday morning or anytime you preach or stand behind the pulpit, or maybe a board meeting, or the minute after you hit post. See, being evaluated and not being able to control how it lands, it's devastating to us. Leaders, we live in that most days.
SPEAKER_00And the researcher's explanation is that we're built to protect our standing with others almost the same way that we protect our safety. So when your standing feels like it's on the line, your body treats it like a threat. So here's why that matters spiritually. If you believe God's approval is on always on the line every time that you perform, then you never leave the test. There's no moment where the evaluation is over. Your body stays braced all week long.
SPEAKER_00And friend, I want to tell you that's not a lack of faith. That's what a body does when it believes the verdict isn't in. So the answer isn't to try harder to stay calm. The answer is to tell your whole self out loud what's already true. You ready? The verdict is in. All right, it's episode three of this new season, so you should be getting used to this. Same four steps, a new lie. Do it with me.
SPEAKER_00You ready? Okay. Think about the last time that you got ready to step up, to preach, to lead, to post, whatever it was. What did you feel in the minutes right before? One word. Just say it out loud. Maybe for some of you it's nervous or pressure or tight or on trial. Okay? Why is that important? Because naming it is already turning the alarm down. We've already we've already learned this, but we're putting it into practice again.
SPEAKER_00Second thing, I want you to ask the question what is this feeling telling me about who I am? And I want you to keep going until you hit the bottom. So for most performing leaders, it sounds like this. Well, Mark, you know, I just feel like I have to prove myself. Well, friend, I want to tell you that's the lie. That's the quote unquote if in front of your name. Now, part three, now you got to answer it with what your father has already said.
SPEAKER_00So, Mark chapter one, verse 11, the father says, You are my son, whom I love, and with you I am well pleased. Spoken before the first miracle and spoken over everybody who is in Christ. So I want you to put it in first person now. I want you to say this. I don't work for the Father's approval. I work from the Father's approval. Now, number four, here's your cue, okay? The minute before you step up, right before you go to the platform, right before you walk into the meeting, right before you hit post, okay?
SPEAKER_00Every time that minute comes this week, I want you to say it out loud, even under your breath. I don't work for the Father's approval. I work from it. And if you didn't step up anywhere today, say it once, anyways. Before you open an email, just say it. And friend, it's going to feel strange to say it while your heart's pounding and you feel the pressure, but say it anyways. And I'm not teaching you how to hype yourself up. I'm helping you remind your body that the test is over.
SPEAKER_00So, friend, I made this week's renew card with all of it on it, okay? The lie, the verse, the sentence, and the cue. So I want you to put it on your lock screen on your phone or tape it inside your Bible where you can see it before you preach. It's absolutely free. You just go grab it at markcasto.co backslash renew. And if you're watching this on Facebook or Instagram, just comment renew and I'm going to send it right over to you. And I want you to hear me. This is formation, not therapy. So if this stirs something heavier in you, like persistent anxiety or depression or thoughts of not wanting to be here, please talk to someone.
SPEAKER_00We've got the focus on the families counseling line. It's 1855-771-HELP. And if you're in crisis, I want you to call or text 988. So here's what I want you to carry out of this episode. Okay. You don't perform because God is hard to please. You perform because you don't believe he already is. But the Father spoke before Jesus ever did a miracle. You are my son whom I love.
SPEAKER_00With you I am well pleased. And in Christ, that's his word over you. So, friend, the verdict is in. So this week, catch the minute before you step up and say it out loud. I don't work for the Father's approval. I work from it. And once this week, after you preach or lead, don't check the response for the rest of the day. No replay, no comments, no numbers, no reviews. Okay. Let your father's words be the only review that you read.
SPEAKER_00So let's take some time. Let's pray together. Father, I just want to thank you for the people that are watching this episode today. I lift up every leader who has been living under that if. If I'm really called, if I'm really anointed, if I'm if you're really pleased with me, Father, you see how hard they've worked to prove what you have already said. So right now, I speak over them in the mighty name of Jesus what you spoke over your son at the Jordan. Father, I pray for your spirit to go and speak over them.
SPEAKER_00You are my son, you are my daughter, whom I love, and with you I am well pleased. Father, I pray that you take the if out of their name, break the fear that drives them, and fill them with the spirit of adoption until their spirit cries out with your spirit, Abba, Father. And Father, I pray for grace for them to work from your approval, not for it. And I pray these things in the mighty name of Jesus Christ. And everybody said, Amen. Now, friend, if you want to walk this out with other leaders, I encourage you to join us every Tuesday at 10 a.m.
SPEAKER_00Eastern Standard Time for the free weekly leader call. It lives right inside the Shepherd's Tent community. Nobody performs there. It's it's I love to say it's a tent, not a stage. So if you want to join us, the links in the description below. And I just want to speak this over you, um, speak a blessing over you and send you into this week. But I want you to know that next week is the last episode of this first season, and we're going literally after the scoreboard. We're gonna be talking about attendance and giving and views and followers. Episode four is called The Metrics Are Lying to You.
SPEAKER_00Until then, I want you to hear me. This is what I'm sending with you. The verdict is in. You don't have to prove anything. Go live like a son.
Rest can feel like you’re breaking the rules. You finally stop, and instead of peace you get a rush of guilt, a scrolling thumb, and that nagging sense you’re falling behind. We go after the uncomfortable question...
Burnout can look like faithfulness on the outside and resentment on the inside. If you’re leading, serving, preaching, building, and still feel like you’ve lost your joy, I want to name what’s happening beneath the...
The church can be loud and gifted while still leaving people unhealed. That tension is where Mark sits down with Cole Burks, a pastor whose story runs from Pentecostal wildfire to ancient Christian roots, and somehow...
A low view of yourself can feel like humility, but it quietly poisons trust. We dig into Romans 8:28-30 and Hebrews 3-4 to argue that God’s “perfect plan” is not endless striving or managing shame, but a life woven with...
A firing squad execution at Fort Hood, livestreamed to your phone, sounds like the ultimate proof that “actions have consequences.” But we cannot stop at the legal question of guilt and punishment. We have to ask the...