Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Magic Detective Podcast

The Magic Detective Podcast artwork

Ep 119 The Life of Theodore Dash Hardeen

Sep 20, 202631 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Today we explore the life of Houdini's brother, Theodore, known professionally as HARDEEN. He had a very strong career, duplicating many of his famous brothers feats, but also doing many unique things of his own.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

This is episode 119 of the Magic Detective Podcast. On this episode, you'll hear about the life of Theodore "Dash" Hardeen. That and more on this episode of the Magic Detective Podcast. Hello and welcome to the Magic Detective Podcast, your podcast home for magic history. I'm your host, Dean Carnegie. I am The Magic Detective, and this is episode 119.

What must it be like to live in the shadow of an older brother? And not just a sibling, but one who is one of the most famous people in the world. You get to live in his shadow while he's alive. And in this particular instance, even after he has died, you are relegated to continue to live in his shadow. That was the case for Theodore, the younger brother to Harry Houdini. Now, I started my journey on this looking through some of the old Houdini movies, and it's interesting how many of the movies don't include a lot of the family members.

If we start with the 1953 movie, we have, of course, Bess, Houdini's wife, and we have Cecilia, Houdini's mother, but it doesn't include any other family members. The next movie is the Paul Michael Glaser movie called The Great Houdinis, and Dash does make a prominent appearance in this movie, along with his assistant Daisy White, though I don't think Daisy ever worked for Dash in real life. In this movie, he's played by Jack Carter, and a bonus in this movie, we actually get a reference to Nathan and Leopold, and this is likely due to Patrick Culliton's help in the movie.

Next, we have the TNT movie, Houdini, which stars Jonathan Scheck as Houdini, and a little-known actor, Mark Ruffalo, playing the brother Theo. This movie shows Houdini giving Dash the name, Hardeen, and saying, quote, "It would be too confusing having two Houdinis." And in this movie, Dash claims to have started Harry and Magic. They also have the timeline all wrong, as the movie portrays Houdini and Dash as starting out, and completely erases the other two Houdinis who came before Dash.

Theo appears in the 2014 Houdini miniseries for the History Channel, though I remember a precious little of that film. I am a big fan of Nicholas Meyers, the director, but in this case, I just can't get through that movie. And here's something rather interesting. Hardeen made an appearance on the HBO series Boardwalk Empire without Harry, so it's like his first big starring role. And of all the movies, you never see the full family, as Houdini and Dash had other siblings.

Of all the biographies, Dash is always a minor character. Bill Rauscher's book, "Hardeen, Monarch of Manacles," is mostly information compiled from magic periodicals, and it's a fine expose on Houdin for the magic world, but not as comprehensive as the Silverman or Kalush books on Houdini. And Bill even says as much in the course of the book. Unfortunately, that's it for "Hardeen." There are no other books on the man.

So, if you're a casual observer and you know a little about "Hardeen" other than from the sources I mentioned, well, today's episode might be rather interesting. And here we go. [MUSIC] He was born Ferenz Descho Weiss in Budapest, Hungary, March 4, 1876. The Immigration Department changed his first name to Theodore. Theo always said his birthday was February 29, which means his birthday would fall on a leap year.

In the "Hardeen" book by Bill Rauscher, he says this was a mistake apparently made by the immigration office when the family left Hungary and came to America. But Theo played it up, claiming he was only one-fourth his real age. The Weiss family settled in a sleepy Midwestern town called Appleton, Wisconsin. His parents were Mayor Samuel Weiss and Cecilia. His siblings included Armin, also known as Herman, William, Nathan, Eric, who we know as Harry, Leopold, and a sister named Gladys.

And since the last major biography was written by Bill Kalush, evidence has been discovered to add two more names to the list of siblings. A boy named Solomon and a girl named Michael Julia, both of whom either died during childbirth or at least died very young. Theo was the fifth boy, if you're counting just the siblings who lived. He was two years younger than Harry, so it's easy to see where he might follow in his older brother's footsteps. Life in Appleton was pretty good for the family.

Mayor Samuel Weiss became the rabbi for the only Jewish congregation in town. Eventually, the congregation decided they wanted someone who spoke English, as they were wanting to assimilate more into the American culture, and Rabbi Weiss and his family were now heading to Milwaukee. This trek would be a little over a hundred miles. In regards to the replacement rabbi, he didn't speak English either. But he did come from the same town as the mayor of Appleton.

Strange coincidence there. The boys attended school in Milwaukee, as they had in Appleton, but it's here that Harry and Theo get their first jobs selling papers and shining shoes. It's also here that an older Harry said that life was filled with hardships in Milwaukee, and the less said on it, the better. The least said includes, well, they moved numerous times to smaller and smaller housing. The eldest brother, Armin, also known as Herman, died of consumption.

Mayor Samuel had to take several jobs just to keep money coming in, and even then it was near impossible. No doubt why Harry and Theo took jobs too. On the plus side, Milwaukee is where Harry, and maybe even Theo, though I'm not sure, saw his first magician, Dr. Lin, though in all truth it was likely a Dr. Lin imitator. In the Silverman biography, we learn that Harry either received or purchased a box of tricks when he lived in Milwaukee.

The next move is to New York City for the family. The times were no less tough here. Despite his efforts to find a congregation, Rabbi Weiss was eventually forced to work in a necti factory. And to add insult to injury, his son, Eric, worked there too. Eric, or Harry, also had many odd jobs, and one can assume that Theo did as well. It's at the necti factory when young Harry decides he wants to pursue magic as an occupation.

A coworker and friend, Jacob Hyman, discussed with Harry the need for a magic name, a showbiz name, in other words. The name Robert Houdin is battered around. According to various histories, young Harry had a book on the great French conjurer, Jean Regime Robert Houdin, and this inspired him to want to be just like him. So they concocted this notion that by adding the letter "i" to the end of the name, it meant "like Houdin" in French. I, myself, don't speak French, but I'm fairly certain that the assumption of theirs was wrong.

However, it did make a unique name, Houdini. And now we have the first Houdini, Harry. The year is 1891, and Harry is 17 years old. He creates an act called the Brothers Houdini with his friend Jacob, and later the friend's brother. Dash, as it turns out, would get pulled into the act in 1893, when he was also 17, and become Houdini #3. More on the other Houdinis at a later date.

So Theo becomes a Houdini brother, and for a short period of time, he is Theodore Dash Houdini. And Harry and Theo tour mainly dime museums all across the country. These are grueling venues to work. They pay a very small amount, compared to the amount of work that one has to do. It's not unheard of for them to do ten shows or more in a day, but it's an excellent training ground. Thanks to Ken Silverman's book, we have a short description of the Brothers Houdini's act.

Quote, "As Dash recalled it, it opened with the sudden appearance of a flower in an empty buttonhole." Harry's buttonhole, of course, because he was the boss. The act included some card tricks and the production of a handkerchief from a candle flame, and featured the trunk trick known as the metamorphosis to close the show. Now, for my listeners unfamiliar with this trick, it consisted of a steamer trunk.

Think of it as an oversized suitcase, big enough to fit a person inside. One of the brothers, in this case Houdini, would have his hands tied, and he'd be placed inside a cloth sack, which was then also tied. The sack was then placed into the steamer trunk, and the lid closed and locked. A large curtain cabinet would be pulled around the trunk, and Theo would step inside, closed the curtain, count to three, and just then the curtain would fly open,

and Houdini would be standing there. The curtain then would be pushed back. The process reversed, in other words, the trunk then opened, the bag untied, and lo and behold, inside the bag, there was Theo in the bag with his hands still tied. Truly a remarkable illusion. Life looks pretty promising for the Houdini brothers until Harry meets a girl named Bess. Now, there are various stories about how Bess gets into the picture, and one of the stories, it's actually Theo who meets Bess first, but Harry steals her away.

Bess was also in show business, and if you like, please listen to podcast episode 115 to learn more about Bess. Suffice to say, the courtship between Harry and Bess was rather quick. They married within three weeks. There was going to be, unfortunately, no room for Theo, though, at this point. Harry and Bess now became the Houdinis, and Theo became the odd man out. So what happened to Theo after the marriage of Harry and Bess?

At first, it looks like Theo took on some odd jobs working in other shows, but then things seemed to go silent, and I believe I know why. I found, almost by accident, an article that appears in the Wilkes-Barre Times Leader, June 28, 1928. The headline reads, "Hardeen Magician Plans to Witness Title Dot Here," and then the subtitle reads, "Artists Who Fought Here as Boxer Orders Ringsides for Bout."

What? "Hardeen a Boxer?" Then, further into the article, we learn this. "Old-time Rig fans who will see Theodore Hardeen, brother of the late Harry Houdini, your premier illusionist, perform at polls this week, will recall his appearance in this city about 30 years ago. Hardeen was not a magician then, but a mighty cover boxer in the 150-pound class, and as such he answered a call to come here and fight Joe Walcott.

Walcott found a worthy rival in Hardeen. Hardeen also fought a number of bouts in New York City and in the vicinity. Hardeen today is a keen follower of sports in general, and the presence of his two sons at the University of Virginia makes him a strong booster for the Cavaliers." So, our boy Hardeen was a boxer for a period of time, and I haven't seen this listed anywhere in the Hardeen bio by Rauscher.

I don't recall it in any of the other bios, though some mention a brief interest in boxing by Houdini, but here Hardeen is fighting professionally, and when I checked with AI, it came back with "Hardeen was never a boxer." Truly a pathetic resource at times. Incidentally, the Joe Walcott he fought was not the popular Jersey Joe Walcott, as Jersey Joe wouldn't even have been born yet. But then the 1900s happen.

Houdini is in Europe and is a sensation, and he can't fill all the dates being offered to him. Managers want to know if he knows anyone else who doesn't act like his, which is kind of insulting if you think about it. But he has a grand idea. Dash could come over. We could even be pitted against each other at times. And so he sends a telegram to his brother in the States which says, "Come over, the apples are ripe." In other words, it was harvest time in Europe.

Time to make some real money. Theo hopped the first steamer to Europe and began to appear as Hardeen. A unique name, which began as Hardeen, and then later they added the E. This was used to emphasize the strength needed in escapes, no doubt. But I also think it may have been a call back to his time as a boxer. Hardeen was a hit in Europe. He basically did Houdini's act.

You see, Harry had everything duplicated for Dash. Same props, same set pieces, same trunk and curtains. The two brothers often played competing theaters. Now the question comes up, if Hardeen is billing himself as the handcuff king, and Houdini, the king of handcuffs, which is better? It would seem that though they presented mostly the same material, it was Houdini who was the greater showman. Houdini was always billed as an American, but they often billed Hardeen as an Englishman.

And I thought this kind of odd at first, as I've heard Hardeen speak. And he doesn't sound the least bit British to me. However, in Germany, for example, though he was billed as an Englishman, he actually presented his act in German, a language he would have known from his home life. The Conjurer's Magazine from July 1945, devoted entirely to Hardeen, says he learned his act in 11 different languages.

Now that may have been an exaggeration, but even if he learned it in half that many, it would still be an enormous achievement. That isn't to say Hardeen couldn't stand on his own. When Houdini began to use the straight jacket escape in his show, so did Hardeen. They both presented it the same way. They would be placed inside the jacket in full view of the audience and then retire to a cabinet to escape. Now while in Europe, Hardeen was presenting the jacket.

And one night an audience essentially booed him when he stepped inside the cabinet. They thought, and frankly it made sense, that an assistant merely unbuckled him while he was out of view. So Hardeen decided to do it again. This time he would escape in full view, which he did. It brought the house down. And he quickly sent off a telegram to his brother Harry in the States about the change in the routine,

and Harry made the change and never looked back. All in all, Hardeen spent seven years in Europe, performing in 11 countries, and even performing before royalty on numerous occasions. His return to America was no less exciting. Houdini was working the Keith and Orpheum circuit, and Hardeen went to work for the Klaw and Erlanger Vaudeville circuit for $1,000 a week for 40 weeks. The big headliner for the Klaw and Erlanger.

Much like his brother, Hardeen also accepted challenges from people in businesses, items they would offer up for him to escape from. And here's a very interesting one. From the Daily News, Bangor, Maine, December 11, 1913. Iron bars could not hold him. "Handcuff Wizard" solved "tramp chair" problem before Bijou Theater Audience Tuesday night. Between 2,500 and 2,600 people saw Hardeen, the handcuff wizard,

step from the tramp chair at the Bijou Theater Tuesday night at the first performance. After he accomplished it in 11 minutes, he made a great hit with his audience. The ability of the man to do this thing caused everybody to marvel, and the question uppermost in the minds of all was, "How is it all accomplished?" The tramp chair used in Bangor years ago for hauling tramps through the city streets was placed in the middle of the stage. A committee from the Bangor City Police Department

put shackles on Hardeen's ankles. He was then seated in the formidable appearing iron chair. The door was locked and barred after his ankles had been shackled to each other and to the chair. One of the committee said, "There, when you get out of that scrap, you'll be ready for breakfast." Hardeen smiled. The chair rolled under the canvas. While the orchestra played, the wizard worked in there in silence. The committee stood about the canvas,

and they were satisfied that Hardeen was receiving no assistance. In just 11 minutes, he came from the chair and smiles, and the audience greeted him with great applause. Afterwards, while removing his limp linen in his dressing room, Hardeen told a reporter that he had never seen such a chair as Bangor's famous tramp chair. I saw that the shackles were strong and old-fashioned, not at all unlike anything I have ever tried to get out of, and I knew I would be bothered considerably by this new sort of imprisonment,

but I found it easier than I had expected. By 1917, Hardeen leaves the glamour of show business to run one of Houdini's side businesses, the Film Development Corp. This is during the time when Houdini was making movies, and Houdini eventually starts producing and making them on his own. Fast forward to October 31, 1926, Brother Harry dies, and in his will, he leaves all his theatrical effects,

new mysteries and illusions, and accompanying paraphernalia to be burnt and destroyed upon Hardeen's death. Hardeen closes down the Film Development Corporation and goes back on the road performing, and by 1927, he's touring the country once again. Hardeen is elected president of the Society of American Magicians in 1929 and serves a single term. Now, in 1918, Houdini was a busy man,

and among his many projects was the creation of a Temple of Mystery. This was going to be a theater in New York devoted to magic. Part theater, part museum, the Houdini Temple of Mystery would employ all the latest gadgetries, I can't even say that, gadgetries and gizmos, to make the experience fun and educational for all who attended. However, it was not to be. Friends cautioned Houdini not to get involved in such an expensive project during war times.

The idea was not completely dead. Jump ahead 15 years and Houdini has long passed on. Hardeen, however, is now the busy performer. During a 1933 summer run in Atlantic City, Hardeen opens the Houdini Temple of Mystery on the steel pier. From reports of the time, the hall was very large, and his run was quite successful. Jim Collins was his chief assistant, and Mrs. Collins acted as stage manager.

Hardeen presented a full show of escapes, magic and illusions. Much of the material was Houdini stuff, but there was a lot of Hardeen magic there too. Vess Houdini visited the show once and was acknowledged by the crowd. There was more than one theater on the steel pier, and at one point Hardeen was competing with the comedy duo Amos and Andy for tickets. One Sunday afternoon, Hardeen had 67,000 people show up during his shows that day.

I don't know how many shows he did, but that's a crazy amount of people. Hardeen, who was in his late 50s at this point, was doing the underwater packing crate escape twice daily from the steel pier, this according to a blurb in the July 1935 issue of The Sphinx. The Temple of Mystery ran from at least 1933 to 1935. As I mentioned, he was doing magic and illusions, and like his brother, he was a magician.

Some say he probably did more magic than Harry did. One very popular Hardeen mystery involved a chicken named Ponzi. The chicken was named after the scandalous Ponzi scheme of the time that bilked people out of thousands of dollars. In Hardeen's case, it was a Jack Gwen-designed illusion that accomplished the feat of making the chicken disappear. Hardeen also had a Doll's House illusion that he used to produce his assistant, Dolly Spence, from.

He also presented one of Houdini's mysteries from his final tour, the Radio Illusion, if they could only see how small radios became over time. From 1938 to 1941, Hardeen performs in the Broadway production of "Hell's a Poppin," by the popular comedians Olsen and Johnson. Now, Hardeen, he died when he was only 52 years of age, but Hardeen lived another 19 years, and he kept performing pretty much right up until the end.

When he was 61, he was in Allentown, Pennsylvania for a show. The climax was his milk can escape, and keep in mind, Hardeen had been performing the milk can escape for decades at this point. On this particular night, he's locked into the can. Six padlocks are placed on the can. He's now submerged underwater in a galvanized metal can, holding his breath, preparing for the escape. The curtain is hurriedly placed around the can, and the count begins.

Jim Collins, who was Houdini's right-hand man, is now Hardeen's, and has been for years. In his hands, he holds a stopwatch. He knows exactly what's supposed to take place, second by second. One minute passes, one minute thirty, two minutes pass. Collins peers inside the cloth cabinet. The can is still locked shut, no sign of Hardeen. Something has gone wrong. The curtain is yanked out of the way, an axe slams against the side of the can,

cutting a four-inch-long gash into the metal. Water starts shooting out of the side. They unlock the locks and pull out an unconscious Hardeen from the can. A doctor revives him. According to the report from The Conjurer's magazine, Hardeen looked up at the audience and said, "Fooled you again," and then fell back unconscious again. Less than seven days later, he was back performing the milk can. That's how it's reported in the magic press. In the real world press, there are some discrepancies.

The location was the same, but listen to this. What the newspaper describes is not exactly the milk can escape, but rather the double-fold death-defying mystery. This was the milk can on steroids. The routine begins with the milk can, which is placed inside a large wooden box, then filled with water. Hardeen gets inside. The lid is secured with six padlocks. Then the wooden box has a lid of its own that goes over it,

and this too is secured with padlocks. In the newspaper story, Hardeen doesn't show at the appointed time, so Jim Collins, listening for a secret code, which was a knocking on the side of the can, rushes in with an axe and breaks the box apart, breaks the padlocks and pulls Hardeen out of the can. But wait, there's a third version of the story. This time, in the linking ring magazine, Jim Collins is waiting in the wings for Hardeen to escape,

and he doesn't. Collins listens for the signal that Hardeen's in trouble, and he hears it. He sneaks into the cabinet, and he proceeds to unlock the box and the milk can and let Hardeen out. Then they close up the can, and Collins sneaks out the back. The front curtain then opens, Hardeen is free, and no one is the wiser. So, which is the true story? In all the stories, they happen in Allentown, Pennsylvania,

but the circumstances are slightly different in each story, and my question is, is there any proof? Obviously, there is a newspaper story, so an event of some kind happened, but we know that newspapers often embellish stories, at least back then. Maybe, is there a milk can out there that has a big gash in the side, clearly made by an axe? That would be one sort of proof. We know that the double-fold box exists, and it's in the Copperfield Collection.

Does it show signs of being destroyed? Obviously, something happened because it was written up in the newspapers. It happened in front of a large contingent of fellow magicians, but the newspaper story sounds awfully exaggerated. I think this is a story we will never quite know the truth of. Hardeen was lucky. Another artist who had performed on the Houdini Tour in 1922, it was the Houdini Wonder Shows that were used to promote his movies.

The man's name was Janesta, and he did a barrel escape. However, on November 8, 1930, in Frankfort, Kentucky, Janesta was to perform the milk can escape. That was the plan, at least. The situation was much like Hardeen's at the 2 minute 30 mark, no sign of Janesta. So they used an axe to break the locks. But by the time they got Janesta out of the can, he was dead. Someone had dropped the can earlier in the day,

denting it and thus damaging it in a way that prevented the escape. Author and magician John Booth nearly died from a dropped and dented milk can. He was pulled out unconscious, but likely left escapes out of his act after that. One last thing Hardeen did before he died was develop a very clever illusion idea. It was called the Book of Life, and was featured in the memorial issue of the Conjurer's Magazine, July 1945.

I remember stumbling across this bit of information back in November 2010, and it stood out to me because I own, and still do, the Blackstone Junior's Book of Life illusion. So to learn that this was the brainchild of Hardeen came as a big surprise. And no one I knew who had one of these, who had a Book of Life, nobody knew that it was a Hardeen creation. For listeners, the Book of Life is a giant book that stands upright on a small platform. The front of the book and the back can be opened,

and a performer can walk all the way through. There are no actual pages. The doors are closed, and then when they are reopened, that's when the magic happens. A person now magically appears within the pages of the book, and walks free and takes a bow. It's a charming illusion, and quite remarkable, and a creation of Hardeen. In the last years of his life, Hardeen suffered from various health issues. In fact, he went in for what was supposed to be a routine surgery on May 30, 1945.

But sadly, due to complications of the surgery, he died a few days later on June 12, 1945. For the record, I was hoping to have a special guest with me today to add to the Hardeen story, but unfortunately they never got back with me. Perhaps another time. I hope you enjoyed today's podcast on the amazing life of the brother of Leopold Weiss. And if you liked this episode, please be sure to like it in any way your podcasting provider allows.

If you're on Apple Podcasts, where I have a bunch of five-star reviews, if you're up for it and you'd like to leave me another one, that would be great. Until next week, when we explore more fascinating facets about Houdini and the world around him, I'm Dean Carnegie, I am the Magic Detective, and that's the way it is. Wait, sorry, that's not mine. I mean, please be well and stay safe.

[MUSIC]

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Ep 121 Magic Historian - Wayne Alan

    Oct 29, 20261 hrAudio

    This episode we explore the new book, The Houdini Timeline by magic historian Wayne Alan. A book that actually had its beginning in 1977. Wayne has worked on this off and on for ages, but it is now finished. What is it?...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Ep 120 Maryka Biaggio - Author of Margery & Me

    Oct 22, 202638 minAudio

    Interview with Maryka Biaggio, the author of the new book Margery and Me. She has written a book of historical fiction all about the life of Margery the Medium and her confrontation with HOUDINI. Get your copy of the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Ep 118 Dr. Eric Colleary & Houdini's Library

    Sep 11, 202647 minAudio

    Prepare for an extremely informative podcast on Houdini's Library which resides in the Harry Ransom Center in Austin Texas. Also, Dr. Eric Colleary, the curator of the exhibit has a new book out, also called Houdini's...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Ep 117 Charles Greene Author of Exposing Houdini

    Sep 4, 202656 minAudio

    Magic historian, collector, author, Charles Green is my guest today talking about his book, Exposing Houdini. He shares some things here that you won't find on any other interview, anywhere. Copies of the book are still...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Ep 116 Houdini In Salem Mass

    Aug 29, 202629 minAudio

    Celebrating Houdini's Centennial, I begin with a brief story of Houdini when he was in Salem Mass. And then I introduce George Schwartz, the curator of the new exhibit 'Houdini In Salem' at the Peabody Essex Museum in...

    Credit the people on this episode